The unexpected war of Nazi Germany with the USSR. Part of 20. Lvo

68


Consideration of the events on the eve of the war in the border districts we will start with the LVO, the first district in the list of addressees of Directive No. XXUMX. Since in the Directive directives are given to all five border VOs and no districts are singled out specifically, then all indications are equivalent for all districts. The words supposedly that in the General Staff everybody understood perfectly well that in relation to the LWO there would be other instructions — this is from the evil one. There is no evidence for these words, and if there is no evidence, then these words cannot be trusted.



If all the instructions of Directive No. 1 are identical for all HEs, then, therefore, orders before June 21 regarding the troops of the districts should also be identical for all districts. What happened to the troops and aviation in LVO, before receiving Directive No. 1, it should somewhat resemble similar events in the western border districts. This is a hypothesis, and we will check it in other parts devoted to the western districts, and in this part we will check in the LVO.

Help 1 Office NKGB USSR 7.5.41: "1. According to officers of the Finnish General Staff, in the event of a conflict between Germany and the Soviet Union, the Germans will do their utmost to involve Finland in the war against the USSR.

2. The German offensive will begin on Murmansk military units stationed in Northern Norway, and the German naval and air forces will support the Finnish army in southern Finland.

3. German officers said that the month of May will be a critical month in the Soviet-German relations
... »

As of June 15-18, it was not known whether Finland would take part in the war with the USSR, and if so, when. For the period of preparation of Directive No. 1 there was no clarity on this issue in the General Staff.

From the second half of 1940, the transfer of German troops and cargo for the group being created begins.

Special Post 4.10.40: "According to reports, from the 2nd half of August 1940, reinforced transfers of German troops from the Narvik region to the northern part of Norway, Finmarken, bordering Finland, began. At the same time, winter uniforms, airplanes, were transported through Sweden and Norway to Kirkenes tanks, heavy artillery, anti-aircraft artillery... »

In accordance with Considerations GSA spacecraft on a strategic deployment plan (15.5.41) states: "Probable allies of Germany can put up against the USSR: Finland - before 20 front... "About Finnish troops is clear. And how many German divisions according to the General Staff were in Finland and in Northern Norway?

In 1941, the transportation of German troops to Finland continues. As estimated by RU GSH on 20-00 22.6.41: "In the north [in Finland] the main grouping is made up of units of the German army, which in the Rovaniemi sector has up to 3-4-x divisions, and ... in the Kirkenes area, up to three more divisions... "Total to 7 German divisions.

In addition, according to intelligence data, German divisions were stationed in Northern Norway: on 5 in May 1941 - 4, on 15 in May - 5, on 1 in June - 6. By the beginning of the war, some of them could have been relocated to our border, but this did not happen.

In fact, a separate German army “Norway” and the Karelian army of the Finns were deployed on the territory of Northern Norway and Finland. This group consisted of 21 division and 3 brigades (of which to 22.6.41 - to 4 German divisions).

Special message. Ostwald 15.6.41: "Head RU GSH KA. It was precisely established: during the period of June 5-15, at least two motorized divisions following the train trains, the 12-16 pace, and marching order to the regions of Northern Finland were unloaded in the ports of Vaaza, Oulu, Kemi. Unloading in ports and transportation from the end areas of unloading in Rovaniemi continues... "

Specify destination Rovani. In the 14 part, it was said that the number of German MDs could be included 133 tank. The two focused MD could be part of a mobile group with up to 266 tanks. Until the morning of June 10, the leadership of the spacecraft was to see this information. In the future, the reaction of the Commissar of Defense and the General Staff to these RMs was to follow.

17 of June, on the instructions of the NSH LVO 1-I of the 1-m, begins the extension by rail to the Alakurtti station. Such a movement of a tank compound cannot be made without the approval of the General Staff. According to the author, this movement was carried out by order from Moscow. The figure shows the location of the concentration of German divisions, etc. of the Red Army.

The unexpected war of Nazi Germany with the USSR. Part of 20. Lvo


According to P.A. Sudoplatova: "Guide NGOs and GSH sought to prevent the creation of the enemy on our borders groups that would have overwhelming superiority over spacecraft. Achieving at least the balance of forces on the border was the most important direction of the military policy of deterring Hitler from throwing at Russia... »

If you accept the version of PA Sudoplatov, it becomes clear the meaning of the transfer of 1 th TD in Karelia. It was carried out to counter the threat of a breakthrough of a mobile German motorcycle and tank grouping to the railway connecting Murmansk and Leningrad.

In some books, this transfer is associated by the authors with the planning of a pre-emptive strike of a spacecraft on Finnish troops. It is probably beneficial for someone to show in his writings the “bestial face of the USSR”. It should be noted that in fact there was no MD in Finland, but there were only two German sections with the total number of 124 tanks.

The situation on the border of LVO with Finland before the war can hardly be called peaceful. The border guards and commanders of the LVO visually fixed the concentration of German-Finnish troops during the summer nights near the border. The decision of the head of the Navy Hanko to transfer the base to increased combat readiness confirms this. Below is a message that describes the preparatory activities for military actions or provocations by Finland.

Special Post 17.6.41: "We report English data on the concentration of German troops in the area of ​​Rovaniemi. According to the British, two German divisions are heading south from the Kirkenes area. Two divisions are being transferred by sea across the Gulf of Bothnia, and some parts of these two divisions are being transferred by sea from Oslo. It is not excluded that these transfers are indeed a holiday of a large size, as claimed by the Germans, but it is possible that they are timed to coincide with the use of maximum pressure by the Germans on the USSR... "

The Republic of Moldova once again speaks about the version connected with the use of pressure on our country by the Germans, and not about a full-scale war ...

Special message. Brand 17.6.41: "1. A general mobilization in Finland is confirmed. Everywhere there are a large number of reservists, following the destination. Mobilization started on 10 – 11 June. In Turku, in the parish of Koski, Pernio and in the villages of the Vuoksi Valley, mobilization is being carried out. 12 June in Tammisaari declared a state of siege, everything is brought to combat readiness.

2. In Helsinki, there are signs of evacuation. 16 June at the Helsinki station marked echelon with women and children, ready to be sent to Tornio.

3. In parts of the holiday discontinued, being on leave ordered to immediately appear in part
... »

Only after the beginning of the war comes information that gave hope for postponing the period of a possible conflict with the armed forces of Finland.

Intelligence service RU GSH KA 20-00 22.6.41: "According to 21.6.41 in the Finnish army are called 24 age, i.e. before 1897, which allows you to mobilize an army in 350-400 thousand people and form up to 18 front (including brigades and individual battalions). Information about the deployment of the Finnish army on 21.6 has been reported... »

K.A. Meretskov: “[21.6.41 evening] S.K.Timoshenko said then: “Attention! tomorrow the war will begin! You need to be a representative of the High Command in the LVO. You know his troops well and will be able to help the district leadership if necessary. The main thing is not to succumb to provocations. ” “What are my powers in the event of an armed attack?” I asked.

- Exposure first. To be able to distinguish a real attack from local incidents and prevent them from escalating into a war. But be on alert. In the event of an attack, you know what to do ...

Everything fell into place of its own accord when I turned on the radio and heard a speech by the People’s Commissar for Foreign Affairs V.M. Molotov about the villainous attack of fascist Germany on our country...

Arriving in Leningrad, I immediately went to the district headquarters ... Major General D.N. Nikishev and corps commissioner N.N. Klementyev
[According to the memoirs of the commander of the LVO corps commissioner N.N. Klementyev 21-22 June was with him on the train.]

Before I arrived in Leningrad, a directive was sent from the NKO to the district headquarters to bring the troops on alert in connection with the possible start of the war. During the elapsed time, the formations, units and subdivisions of the district began to pull themselves closer to the state border and take up SD, but they did it slowly, because the directive required the troops to remain dispersed and move covertly ... [there was a period of white nights and the movement of the German-Finnish troops to the border was revealed by visual observation].

Gradually adjusted air defense. In general, the district failed to fulfill all the required. Even bringing the troops on alert carried out rather timidly: did not allow the last paragraph of the directive, which was forbidden to carry out without special orders any other measures.

At about eight o'clock in the morning, the district received a second directive from Moscow. But it was practically impossible to implement it, since in fact, it concerned only those armies that had already fought with the enemy in the NWF, Polar Division and the WFB. The special directive forbade us to cross the state border where the enemy did not violate it, and it was specifically stated that our aircraft should not make air raids on Finnish territory. Again the LVO could only wait for the development of events. Taking full responsibility, I instructed to force the bringing of troops into combat readiness and request information on the situation on the flanks of the district.

The Federation Council, commanded by Rear Admiral AGGolovko, said that the sailors are on their guard, but they are calm. The Red Banner Baltic Fleet under the command of Vice-Admiral V.F. Tributs conducted military operations at sea. Disparate information came from land bases on the coast of Latvia. However, from the mouth of the Neva Leningrad so far nothing threatened.

Finally managed to contact the headquarters PribOVO. The deputy commander of the district Ye.P. Safronov approached the phone ... The commander of the okrug’s forces, Colonel-General F. I. Kuznetsov, was at the border last night and even gave additional instructions on how to conduct combat shooting. Now it is not known where he is.

Further, EPSafronov said that the fate of the families of the commanders was very worried. A few days before the start of the war, on instructions from the district command, the family commanders were taken to the rear. But 20 Jun from the NCO came a categorical order to immediately return all to the old places. And now the fate of the families of the officers is unknown. Most likely, they are captured by the enemy
... »

Calls from Moscow from spacecraft administration to the headquarters of the Leningrad Military District before the receipt of the extensive Directive No. XXUMX, decision-making related to the activities of raising the district troops "fell on their heads" to the only head of the Military Council of the Leningrad Military District - Major General DN Nikishov. At that time, the commander of the military district troops of the military district of the military and military districts was on a train to Leningrad. Deputy Commander LVO Lieutenant-General KPPyadyshev at this time was in the Baltic States, because the territory of Estonia was in the area of ​​responsibility of the LVO.

PC 00-10 22.6.41: "Tallinn, the Commander of the Red Banner Baltic Fleet. By order of the commander 22 sk I am informing that the deputy commander of the military military unit General Pyadyshev arrived at the camp Petseri in 22-40. Nashtakor 22... »

It is strange that General Pyadyshev was allowed to go to Estonia on June 21, leaving the sole head of the District Military Council, NSN D.N.Nikishev, at the district headquarters. It is strange that the commander of the district was not in a hurry to arrive at the headquarters of the LVO and he rode the train calmly for 32 hours. All this is strange, if, according to literary figures, the highest command of the spacecraft expects a war at dawn on June 22. however, it’s commonplace war does not expect...

For various reasons, the situation in all the districts turned out to be painfully the same, except for ZOVO, where the decisions were taken by the District Military Council headed by the commander of the troops.

In the LVO, the entire responsibility for making decisions fell on the shoulders of the NSH of the district of DNNikishev.

In PribOVO, for some time, during negotiations with Moscow on the night of June 22 and making decisions on Directive No. 1, there was one NShP PS Klenov at the front control point. The deputy commander of the district troops, EP Safonov, was in the headquarters in Riga. The location of the commander of the troops Kuznetsov to 2 hours of the night is unknown. After 1-30 ... 2-00, Klenov probably manages to contact the commander. At about ten o'clock in the morning Kuznetsov is seen going out of his dugout. All decisions made in PribOVO, basically, this period lay on the shoulders of the NSH, which, like in other districts, was called and given "very valuable instructions", demanded not to panic, they reassured the heads of the spacecraft. And from below, the commanders of subordinate associations demanded instructions ...

In KOVO, the commander of the forces, Kirpanos, as recalled by NS Purkaev, did not dare to give instructions to the troops after receiving fragmentary information on the content of Directive No. XXUMX. Only after the arrival of the NS KOVO did instructions be given to the troops, in which the commander also took part. Is this so, we look at the appropriate part.

In OdVO, the commander of the troops, Ya.T. Cherevichienko, called NSh M.V. Zakharov and delegated to him the powers of the Military Council of the Okrug when deciding on Directive No. XXUMX.

According to the author, the situation during this period was so ambiguous that many of the leaders (including the People's Commissar of Defense and the Chief of the General Staff) did not know what to do and probably did not dare to take responsibility. The consequences of the wrong decision for any of them at that time could lead to serious consequences both for the manager (who made the decision) and for the members of his family.

Thanks you, NSh districts, because they began to do at least something, while the leaders of the SV and the commanders of the districts turned out to be (willingly or unwittingly) aside from making extremely important decisions. It should be noted that during this period the only commanders involved in the decision-making and who personally gave orders of an operational nature, which were forbidden to transmit on HF, were the general Pavlov.

Again, a question arises, to which there is no answer backed up by facts: if the top management of the spacecraft (according to literary figures) expects the outbreak of war on the night of 18 on June 22, then why are the VO commanders far from headquarters or KP during this period ? ..

The situation is similar with the vacations of military personnel, including senior managers. We have already met with such examples in the framework of the topic “Navy"And we will see such examples when considering the memories of veterans from the border western districts. If they are waiting for a war with 18 June, then what could be the vacation? And if they do not wait, then the situation is immediately clarified: with vacations and with the absence of commanders, and with the relocation of headquarters to field control points.

Literary figures offer a version to answer this question: "This is so that the Germans do not guess that we are preparing for a preemptive strike... "The European parliamentarians will applaud such figures: here it is, the despicable essence of the Russians: they do not observe any contracts and quietly violate them if they want to do some dirty trick to civilized people ...

Memories commander LVO MMO Popov, we consider at the end of, because on the eve of the war he was absent from the district headquarters.

A.A. Novikov (commander of the Air Force LVO): "In mid-June 1941g. together with a group of district executives ... I went on a field trip near Murmansk and Kandalaksha. But 20 June unexpectedly, on the orders of the People's Commissar of Defense ... was summoned to Moscow. On Saturday, I returned to Leningrad and immediately called the Commissariat. General Zlobin, who was under the People's Commissar for special assignments, said that they were transferring me to Kiev. Naturally, I immediately thought of General E. S. Ptukhin and inquired where they were transferring him. My question remained unanswered. Zlobin somehow hesitated and, after a short pause, answered that the question of Ptukhin had not yet been resolved, and I should be at the marshal’s 9 o'clock in the morning 23 Juneand hung up...

[If the question of Ptukhin is not yet resolved, then leave as unreliable a general (from the point of view of the agencies, the spacecraft leadership and the country) to leave the Air Force of the largest military unit. And why the new head of the KOVO Air Force should arrive in Moscow on 23 June, if, for example, literary figure Kozinkin claims that Tymoshenko and Zhukov are waiting for war on the night of June 22 ...]

“It's good that you came back,” said Alexey Vasilyevich. - I finished the inspection tour of the district aviation units and tomorrow I will fly to Arkhangelsk. My report is ready, it will be transferred to you. In general, things are going well for you, but I would like to verbally inform you about something, Alexander Alexandrovich. There are questions that are best addressed in a personal conversation. I wanted to tell Nikitin that I was no longer the commander of the District Air Force, but I changed my mind: it was always useful to have a thoughtful, well-informed person like Alexey Vasilyevich to talk face-to-face ... Our conversation dragged on.

At the end of the conversation, I asked Nikitin, as a more informed person, that can be heard on other parts of our western border and how there, at the highest levels, assess the situation in the border VO. In response, Alexey Vasilyevich made an indefinite gesture with his hands. “And by the way, we will try to find out,” he said, “order me a conversation with Moscow.”

A few minutes later, Nikitin talked with General PF, Chief of the Main Command of the Air Force Space Agency. Zhigarev. The conversation was short. Nikitin reported that he had finished his work in Leningrad, and asked if he should go to Arkhangelsk or return to Moscow. From the expression on the face of Alexei Vasilyevich, I realized that Zhigarev surprised by such a question. “Well,” said Nikitin, after hearing the authorities' answer, “ ordered to immediately fly to Arkhangelsk... »

Was running out the first hour of the night... We left the district headquarters ... and went off in different directions ... I did not have time to get undressed, when a telephone call rang in the corridor ... General D.N.Nikishev called NSH HE. Dmitry Nikitich ordered an urgent visit to him on a very important matter. I replied that I had already transferred my duties as Commander of the Air Force to General A.Nekrasov and on the evening 22 June train I am leaving for Moscow. “I know, I know, Alexander Alexandrovich! - impatiently interrupted Nikishev, - and yet I ask you to immediately come to headquarters. The decor is very serious. I will explain everything at the meeting. Waiting for you…"

About ten minutes later I entered Nikishev's office. Dmitry Nikitich was very excited. He immediately, without any prefaces, said that at dawn 22 June, i.e. today, the German attack on the Soviet Union is expected, and ordered to immediately bring the entire aviation of the district to full combat readiness.

- But for now, until receiving special instructions from Moscow, Aviation specific combat missions. Please give orders personally.

I again reminded that I am no longer the commander of the District Air Force.

“I’m done, I know,” Nikishev interrupted me angrily. - But there is no order to take office of General Nekrasov. Tomorrow Popov will return from Murmansk, and Zhdanov will probably arrive from Sochi, they will make the final decision about your replacement. In the meantime, the commander of aviation, I consider you.

The situation excluded any altercations, and I agreed. But I was it is not clear how to bring this aircraft into full combat readiness, and not to set specific combat tasks? After all, if there is war, then it is necessary to act as if in a war. Without clear objectives, without knowledge of the targets for which you will have to strike, aviation will not be allowed into action at once, especially the bombers. The bombers of ammunition depends on the target object: for strikes on manpower, he is one, on the fortifications - the other, on the airfields - the third. And I said that to Nikishev.

- That you, Aleksandr Aleksandrovich, explain to me the elementary truths! - angry NS. - We are ordered clearly: do not set specific combat tasks. And the order must be executed. Here, read it!

Nikishev handed me a telegram just received, signed by the People's Commissar of Defense, SKTimoshenko, and the Head of the General Staff, G.K.Zhukov. I quickly ran her eyes ... and I involuntarily looked at my watch - it was already about two in the morning.

Returning to my headquarters, I phoned the commanders of all the air connections on the phone, ordered me to immediately pick up all the units at the signal of an alarm and spread them across field airfields and added that for duty on each home base of fighter aircraft they allocated one squadron ready for departure on a missile signal, and for bombers to prepare ammunition for attacking enemy forces and airfields. Only after giving all the orders did the administration go around ...

So the war began for me. She entered the city at 3 in the morning when Leningraders were still fast asleep. V. this time high in the sky, nine fighters rushed past, led by senior lieutenant M. Gneushev. Twenty minutes later, the first air battle broke out near Leningrad.
... »

Something similar to the initiative of the commanders is again manifested after reading the incomprehensible and lengthy Directive No. XXUMX. As a result, anti-aircraft artillery attempted to fire on the territory of the LVO during the first raid of enemy aircraft, and the fighters began to patrol the airspace ... The aircraft of the LVO air force was rescued by the fact that at dawn on 1 June, enemy aircraft were not attacked ...

A.L. Shepelev (Deputy Chief Engineer, Air Force LVO): "21.6.41 we had to stay in control. The commander of the Air Force of the Leningrad Military District, Major General Aviation A.A. Novikov handed over the case to another military leader ... Gen. A.A. Novikov was not able to go to Moscow for a new appointment. As soon as he returned home, he was urgently called to the district headquarters. There he was introduced to the directive of the People's Commissar just received ...

On the night of 22.6.41, General A.A. Novikov some once he called the head of the Main Directorate of the Air Force KA General PF Zhigarev and reported that there was calm in the area of ​​the LVO both in the air and on the ground. Informing about this Moscow, he simultaneously tried to learn about the situation in other border districts, but received answers that were not very intelligible...

At dawn 22 June 1941, General A.A. Novikov phoned General to Kiev E.S.Ptuhinu. It was felt throughout that that now is not up to talk. Alexander Alexandrovich slowly put the phone down and sighed sadly: "Yes, the war still began! Ptukhin says that the fascists are bombing Kiev ... ”Then General A.A. Novikov contacted the commander of the Air Force ZAPOV, General I.I. Kopets, and found out that the Nazi troops attacked our borders, the enemy’s planes bombed airfields, / d nodes and settlements. Equally bleak news came from the commander of the Air Force PribOVO, General A.P. Ionov ...

We did not think then that this would be the last conversation with the commanders of the Air Force of neighboring border districts, that we would not meet with them anymore. Like other veterans of the LVO, I knew well from the joint work of these aviation generals, who had been promoted to leading posts in special border VO. They possessed deep military knowledge, high flying culture, and more than once they showed heroism and bravery, selfless devotion to the Soviet Motherland.

As for the miscalculations and misses, allegedly admitted by them in the first days of the war, the right word, not only they allowed them. Let historians speak about this objectively and impartially.
... ”Unfortunately, it is easier for individual literary figures, to their advantage, to declare these people traitors. If only money paid for their labors ...

P.A. Sudoplatov: "Forged charges was shot in February 1942, the Hero of the Soviet Union, the Hero of the Spanish War, the commander of the Air Force of the Southwestern Front Ptukhin. They arrested him and brought him to court on the basis of a special note by N. Khrushchev, which he handed over to Stalin, raising the question of Ptukhin’s responsibility “for the defeat of Soviet aviation”... »

B.V. Bychevsky: "By mid-June, the district headquarters had information about the concentration of the German fascist divisions in Finland, being transferred from Germany and Norway ... In the first half of June, I went with the assistant general of the district commander for Major-General PA Zaitsev to the Hanko peninsula, which after the Soviet - Finnish war turned into a naval base ... The district commander, Lieutenant-General MMPopov visited Hanko, examined the coastal fortifications and gave new instructions to the base commander, Lieutenant-General S.I. Kabanov, and 8 commander, Colonel SEC. .P.Simonyaku. After that, without waiting for the sappers to finish the long-term structures of the naval base, the Baltic and infantry sailors quickly began to create field defenses. The three-kilometer isthmus on the border with Finland has already crossed the anti-tank ditch, bunkers were created on the most dangerous areas ...

20 June
[NSHLO] urgently called me by phone from Vyborg: “Come immediately”. Three hours later I was in his office.

- The situation, brother, has become more complicated. Finns on the Karelian Isthmus are activated. We will begin combat cover of the border. Clear?

- Not really.

- Prepare the sappers for minefield installation on the border.

“But all my people are busy in concrete work, Dmitry Nikitich.”

- So take off!

- Do you have instructions from Moscow on this? I believe that the laying of concrete can not be stopped ...

Nikishev angrily interrupted: “You never know what you think! Now there is no time to wait for instructions;. Collect all the mines in the warehouses and take them to the troops. For now we will write instructions to armies.


[Again we meet with the fact of the personal initiative of the NSH of the district of DNNikishev.]

I brought a newly developed engineering border cover plan and began writing orders to the 14, 7 and 23 armies about blocking the most important areas and roads with minefields. NS prepared an order to the commander of 23 army Lieutenant-General PS Pshennikov about advancing one division from the 2-echelon to the Vyborg region. This is so far limited.

Nikishev immediately locked himself in his office with employees of the intelligence and operations departments. And I sat down at my work cards, trying to imagine what tasks might arise before the District Engineering Department in the event of a war. Just a month ago, the General Staff demanded that we focus our attention on strengthening the borders north of Leningrad.
...

21 June I left home late at night. [How did he go home if war was about to be expected? Or not expected?]

An hour later, the duty officer called and told that an alarm had been raised at the headquarters. Gathered quickly. Commanders went from room to room, trying to figure out the causes of the alarm, but no one really knew anything. Only about five o'clock in the morning, General Nikishev invited to his office the chiefs of the combat arms: “War, comrades! Fascist Germany attacked us. Everyone to start the execution of plans "... »

G.A. Veshchersky: "In the morning of 21.6.41, I went to Major General D.N.Nikishev's NSH LVO to sign my holiday ticket. I was going to rest on the southern coast of Crimea. We were well acquainted with Dmitry Nikitovich ...

Nikishev was the commander of one of the newly formed divisions. Not stopping the conversation with him, Dmitry Nikitovich took my vacation ticket, but, before signing it, he handed me a note. “It is unlikely that you will be able to leave,” I read. Then he took the slip from me, tore it up, and nevertheless signed the holiday ticket and handed it to me. I lay down early, something around ten in the evening. Just fell asleep - woke the driver of my car Sparrows. I gave the order to immediately appear to the NSh district. Half an hour later I was already in the office of General Nikishev: “The Germans moved the troops close to the border. Go to the seventieth. By morning, the division should disperse and prepare for mobilization.
... "

PC "Commander 70 sd: “The commander of the troops ordered ... 70 sd full combat readiness in 20-00 22.6 to make a campaign and to 7-00 25.6.41 concentrate in the area of ​​Mutoranta, Pien-Pego, st.

RCB 7 Army: "20.6.41 units and units of the 7 Army stationed in points and areas ... according to plans and schedules were engaged in combat and political training. The headquarters of the divisions, in its full composition, were at staff exercises conducted by the army command.

Protection battalions from the joint ventures, sapper battalions of the army units and the Sortavala SD (stationed in the border zone) also engaged in combat training and part of the forces carried out work to improve the defenses built since the Finnish campaign 39-40. somehow: finishing the clearing and rarefaction of the forest in front of the embrasures of the bunker and the bunker and doing a number of other small works, on field filling areas, between the nodes of resistance and strong points ...

In the second half of the day, 21.6.41 from Finland took part in the violation of the state border - a Finnish aircraft in the border area No. 773 flew over the state border and plunged into our territory to 100 km. In the same day, in 18-55, in the border area No. 775, the plane flew into its territory.

22.6.41 fascist Germany perfidiously, without warning and declaring war on the Soviet Union, breaking the treaty between the USSR and Germany ... crossed the state border and began a war with the USSR using insidious methods ...

Knowing and firmly remembering that long before the start of the war, German troops were allowed to enter Finland on their territory, and that Finland’s entry into war was in alliance with Nazi Germany against the Soviet Union very likely, the commander of the 22.6.41 army ordered the commanders of the formations: 54, 71 and 168 sd to withdraw the troops for the defense of the state border to the areas designated by the plan and notify 19-00 not later than this day. In addition, an order was issued - to immediately deploy defensive work on the State Border on the construction of wire and anti-tank barriers.

Under the existing plans in 6-00 - 7-00 22.6.41, the battalions covering the army units located in the border zone took their positions by order of the commanders of the troops and, after monitoring the adjacent side, covered the collection and exit of units and formations to the state border
... »

From the CCD it is clear that immediately after the alarm was announced, the covering battalions advanced to the border and by the morning of the morning took defensive positions.

RCB 81 cn (54 cd): "22.6.41. In 12-00, t.Molotov announced on the radio a treacherous German attack on the USSR. After the end of the speech of t.Molotov, NSH Captain Titov (stayed for the regiment commander, because the regiment commander was in the Voynitsa area with the 2 battalion), were called for instructions ... In 16-00 a copy was received an order of NGOs and mobilization was announced... »

RCB 337 cn (54 cd): "22.6.41 to 13-00 on the basis of the oral order of the 54 cd 337 cn, the company switched to the combat position and occupied the field UR No. 1, 2, 3, 4 for defense... »

RCB 462 cn (168 sd): “22.6.41. In 4-00, fascist Germany, without a declaration of war, treacherously attacked our homeland, .. In 8-00 the regiment was declared combat alarm. The regiment in full military armament lined up at the hippodrome on the highway, heading the column to the north. AT 13-00 a regiment composed of ... marched to the border... »

RCB 14 Army: "22.6.41. The fascist German forces are concentrated at our state border. Enemy aircraft make reconnaissance flights over our territory. At the ZF began major military operations. Not declaring war, Hitler's gangs invaded our country. Army units have put in place a "Covering Directive for 1941 of the Year."

22.6.41 by the end of the day parts of 14 sd are on alert ... Parts of 52 sd complete loading onto the Spartak steamer for crossing to Mishukov subway ... ... parts of 122 td also began to focus
... »

D.O. Leichik (head of the engineering troops 14 A): "Against 14 And ​​the German command launched two mountain corps ... The first instruction on bringing the troops on alert and preparing for combat was given to the army commander early morning xnumx... »

RCB 420 cn (122 sd, 42 ck): "22.6.41 on the orders of the regiment took defense at the state border... »

CDB 104 sd (42 sc): "12-15 22.6.41. Government report about the beginning of 4-00 22.6 of the military actions of Germany against the Soviet Union.

13-18 22.6. An order was received by the People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR on the destruction of the enemy forces that had crossed the Soviet borders.

14-00 22.6. 104 cd (without 242 cn, 2 and 3 / 273 cn, 2 / cnNXX cn, 502 sapbat, without 276 and 1 / 2 ptd) made a route Kandalaksha, Alakurtti, leaving a cover, KS, XAUMX / 161, 3, 359 / 502 cn. Xnumx gap. An order of 242 cn was given from 2 / 502 gap to immediately take up the line prepared for the defense along the east bank of the river Sophianga. 2 and 3 / 273 order were given, 276 Sapbat returned from Kokosalm to Kandalaksha
... »

RCB 217 cn (104 cd): "22.6.41. 15-00. Received the combat order No. 1 stadium 104 from 22.6.41 217 cn with 290 up to the end of 22.6 concentrate in the district of Baraki (35 km)... »

I.M. Pyadusov (chief of artillery 19 ck 23 A): "A few days before the war, the district headquarters conducted an inspection of parts of 19 and 50 c ... The teaching was to continue for five days. And suddenly, on the third day, I was backed off ... Upon arrival at Kexholm, I reported to the corps commander about the end of my work and asked Is there anything new? Corps Commander He looked at me in surprise and answered - there is nothing new. At night, all the corps headquarters officers were summoned to headquarters, where the start of the war with the Finns was announced.... »

RCB 19 ck: "В 2-00 22.6.41 K-rom Corps received personally from the NSH LVO order to call the commanders and declare a combat alarm ...

The 2-12 K-rum corps declared a combat alarm.

4-15 - 4-25 received an order from the LVO headquarters (in cipher) to exit the corps parts to the state border.

In the 4-30 parts of the 115 and 142 sd to the corps, the order was issued to exit the parts to the state border. The same cipher order is completed by transfer to 17-30 22.6.41.

In 7-07 a telegram was received about violation of the state border by the Germans ...

Parts of 142 sd and 115 sd delivered to the state border: 142 sd - advanced parts in 6-40 22.6; 1 echelon in 7-40 22.6; 115 sd 1 Echelon to 7-30
... »

Telegram. «Headquarters LVO. Parts of the body made to the border: 115 cd - in 7 h 30 m142 sd - in 7 h 40 m... »

CDB 142 sd: "22.6.41. The division in 6-00 on the basis of the government message and the order of the commander of 19 ck was raised on alert with the occupation of defensive areas - according to the plan to cover the state border... »

PC: "NSH 19 SC. Parts of 142 sd delivered to their area 8-00 22.6.41... "

PC 7-50 ... 8-30: "Commanders 142 and 115 sd. I hand over the order of the Military Council of the LVO. At dawn 22.6.41 the Germans launched the bombing of Sevastopol, Lubava, Vandava. The fighting began in the Kiev and Baltic VO. There were border violations by Finnish and German aircraft in the direction of Vyborg, Kronstadt, Leningrad.

The People's Commissar ordered all troops, headquarters and air defense systems to be brought to combat readiness, to prepare all the conditions for receiving the mobilized. The border with Finland does not cross and do not fly. Violators to destroy on its territory. Bring the units immediately to the state border and take up defense areas.

The corps commander ordered to immediately report on the withdrawal of troops to the border and to report on the occupation of the defense areas according to the cover plan, in the form of opera reports indicating the battalion (division)
... "

Supplement to the exploitation number 1 (to the headquarters of LVO). 42 ck 18-00 22.6.41 ... "Parts of 122 sd focus the occupied op and re-equip areas. 285 ap 17-30 passed by Kairal... »

V.F.Konkov (commander of the 115th division): "In May 1941, the division made a transition from Kingisepp region, through Leningrad, to the Karelian Isthmus, to the Vanhala, Enso, and Kirvo areas with the solution of training issues, with the development of actions with aviation, etc. ... state border in the occupied area ...

In the evening, 21.6.41 and I, the deputy for political affairs, V.O. Ovcharenko, were invited by Red Army soldiers and 638 commanders to a concert of amateur performances ... Vladimir Andreevich and I, without saying a word, went along the edge of the forest towards the location of one of our parts ... discussing a friendly meeting with battle friends. It was past midnight. But I didn’t want to sleep ... We parted ways with Vladimir Andreevich, when the sun's rays began to play with colorful sparkles of dew on the grass. In the house did not want to go. He sat down on the porch fits. And, it seems, dozed off. The agitated voice of the coherent brought me out of this drowsy state: "Comrade general, you are urgently called to headquarters."

In the headquarters I had a telephone conversation with the army commander 23, Lieutenant-General PS Pshennikov. From him I learned about the treacherous attack of fascist Germany on our country. I was ordered by the forces of 115 sd to provide a solid defense of the USSR State Border
... »

V.I. Scherbakov (commander 50 ck): " The plan of covering the border provided for tasks and variants of the action of the troops in case of war, the same plan defined the defense lines of the cd and the regiments inclusive of company defense areas. OP were identified as ground and anti-aircraft artillery to the battery, inclusive ... The cover plan provided for the order of withdrawal of troops from the RPD to the border in their lanes and areas of defense ...

The trained lines and defense areas were not constantly occupied by the troops, but the troops were withdrawn by units from time to time to their areas for their equipment. Parts were withdrawn to their defense areas, as a rule, on alert.

43 and 123 sd, as well as corps units, began to advance to the border according to my signal, which was provided for by the cover plan on the basis of the received directive of the People's Commissar of Defense. The directive was passed from the headquarters of the LVO around June 4's 22 hours ... The departure of the troops to the border began on June 6-30 June 22
... »

RCB 147 cn (43 cd): "22.6.41 12-00. The regiment with the attached units in accordance with the order of the stadium 43 advanced to the front line of the state border and began defensive work to strengthen the state border.... »

CDB 123 sd: "By the verbal order of the corps commander, units of the division began their advancement by separate subunits to the border in their areas of cover. 255 cn and 272 cn in 8-30 22.6.41. went to their sites. 245 cn - reserve KSK [commander sk]. Parts began reconnaissance and defense work on their sites. During the advancement of units to their areas as a result of insufficient camouflage, there were cases of raids of planes on the advancing columns.... »

RCB 272 cn (123 cd): "22.6.41 5-00. 272 cn pursuant to the order of the commander 123 of the Order of Lenin sd from the area of ​​concentration ... acted in the direction of the state border with the task of covering it and to 8-00 took up defense according to the cover plan... »

ZhBD 24 cap (50 sc): "At 6 o'clock in the morning 22 June 1941g. throughout the Vyborsk Garrison, an alarm was declared and by the 12 watch the 24 cape was already on full alert, with the exception of the 2 Division, which at that time was at the border equipping its battle formation ... B 12-30 the regiment began its movement to the borders of Finland... »

ZhBD 21 td (10 microns): "17.6.41. In full composition, Shtadiv performed a corps staff exercise conducted on the Karelian Isthmus. The teaching was designed for five days, i.e. to 22.6.41 inclusive. But 21.6 to 9-00 the exercise was given a retreat and the entire commanding staff was sent to Vyborg to analyze the exercises, which took place in DKA [House of the Red Army]. After parsing, it was ordered to immediately depart to their units.

It was clearly felt that the situation has changed dramatically and the teachings were minimized. By the end of the day 21.6 shtav arrived at Black River and the command staff disbanded to rest on vacation with a warning - do not leave the area of ​​the military town.

In 2-00 22.6.41, the commander of the 23 Army arrived in the roundabout and warned about the division’s readiness for action. It was about 11-00 22.6 that the speech of Comrade Molotov was broadcast by radio that Nazi Germany attacked our Homeland without a declaration of war. AT 12-00 divisions declared combat alarm with the release of parts in their areas of the collection of anxiety. By 18-00, all parts in full readiness went to the areas of collection for alarm
... »

RCB 1 micron: "17.6.41. By personal order NSH LVO of Major General Nikishov, 1, etc. was taken from the corps and sent to perform a special task where I went plunging at Berezka station ...

22.6.41. PCS of LVO headquarters No.1 / 39 1 mechkorpusu (without 1 etc.) was tasked to follow its own course from the areas: 3 etc. - Strugi Red; Office Corps, 202 obs, 5 Motts.polk, from Pskov; 163 MSD from Cherekh - to the area of ​​cities - Slutsk, Pushkin
... »

RCB 1 reconnaissance battalion 1 MK: "The 7889 military unit being in the Strugi Krasnye camps, the Vladimir 22.6.41 camp in 9-00 was raised for combat alert and as part of a tank company, bronerot, motorota, park platoon and platoon control, went to the collection point for alert, 2 km south. camps... »

RCB 3 td 1 micron: "22.6. In 7-30 according to the 7373 telegram, parts are on alert and for 11-00 are concentrated in the collection area, 3 km. South. ammunition tanks... "

PC. 23-25 22.6.41: «Commander 16 sd. The commander of the military military district ordered: 1. To occupy a division for the defense of the division from Tallinn to Hapsalu and Dago Island, where there is at least 4 cn.

2. Parts of the division must have a standard supply of food, ammunition and fuel.

3. Take all air defense measures in parts of the division.

4. On the occupation of the defense to convey ..
. "

RCB 2 Garden: "3-00 22.6. Parts of the 2 Air Division are on alert. The materiel is dispersed and disguised at the dislocation aerodrome ... The defense of the airfields is organized. Background: Telegram of the Commander of the Air Force LVO from 21.6... »

Here, too, did not seek to execute the order of the People's Commissar of Defense from 19.6.41 by dispersing aircraft to 22 June. As part of the activities carried out in accordance with Directive No. XXUMX, measures to disguise and disperse are accelerated in accordance with the order of the People's Commissar of Defense, which has not yet entered the formations. The date of the June 1 telegram is probably a typo. Such typos were repeatedly encountered by the author when viewing documents on the Memory of the People website.

N.F. Kuznetsov (Deputy 436 iap): “I and several of my comrades received an appointment in the Air Defense IAP ... On Saturday, we could not sleep for a long time. Silent, warm June night ... A siren that screamed fiercely woke us. Her howl seemed to fill everything — the tent ...

“Great neighbors excite!” Shouted Savchenkov. “Soon we will be alarmed on flights,” he rolled over, yawned sweetly and hid his head under the pillow ...

Someone jerked open the tarpaulin valve of our tent, and at that very moment I saw the head of the NS: “What the hell are you waiting for ?! Anxiety does not concern you, is it ?! ”A minute later, all those who were in tents and in the whole forest camp ... ran to the airfield ... When the planes were put on alert, we were built not far from the parking lot. The captain of the Banshchik with the unfamiliar major came: "War, comrades .. Fascist Germany attacked our Homeland
... »

N.I. Gapeenok (pilot 202 bap): "The pre-day of June 21 ended, which did not foreshadow anxiety. All the family officers were leaving for their families ... Early on Sunday morning 22 June 1941, the alarm alert sounded in the camp. On alarm, all those remaining in the camp gathered at the designated place. On the first team we were sent to the parking of the aircraft. And here we are in the parking lot, where, like a parade, white-winged bombers are lined up [Sat]. All planes are sheathed and sealed ... Soon from the camp officer Received a team to mask the aircraft branches of trees and nearby shrubs. Two trips to the forest behind the branches ... No one, of course, did not assume that the alarm is realfighting until arriving from winter flats [pilots] ... "

A.A. Kukin: "Before the war we organized courses for flight commanders at the airfield Gorelovo. The head of the course was I.P. Neusturuev, I was the deputy ... At 3 in the morning, 22 in June and 1941, we arrived at the airport in alarm, and in 3-30, in three links, leading: Neustruev, I and Chuguev flew to the cover of Leningrad with photo machine guns, since expected the beginning of the exercise, not war. During the patrol they did not meet anyone in the air and returned to their airfield. After landing, Neustruev reported to the division commander about the task, and he learned about the beginning of the war ... It was at four in the morning... "

I.D.Gaidaenko (flight commander rap): "21 June I and several other pilots were sent on vacation. I decided to go to Kexholm ... and then home, to Ukraine. While going - anxiety. We went out in alarm on the airfield, uncovered our whites, like swans, SB planes, warmed up the engines, prepared for departure. We do everything as usual in terms of training. No one knew that the alarm is a battle one! Only hours in 9-10 morning announced the end of the training alarm - combat alarm. So the war began for me... »

RCB 63 Obap 22 of the Karelian SD: "22.6.41 7-30. Exit and training for anxiety strongholds - Lembolovo, Elizavetinka, Agolatovo. In 7-30 b-well, declared combat alarm. The companies quickly occupied their company strong points ... "

It is clear from the FBD that the long-term facilities of 63-m obap to 22.6.41 were not occupied.

A.M. Andreev (chief of 5 frontier detachment): "In the middle of June, 1941 from the border towers in the area of ​​the city of Enso, Finnish troops were seen advancing to the border. Artillery and tanks occupied firing and initial positions ... On June XN one of the trespassers was delivered to the squad headquarters. He refused to answer questions. Only two words hissed through his teeth: "Tomorrow is war."

21.6.41 after the meeting ... with the deputy chief of the detachment for political affairs, the regimental commissioner Zyablikov and the NSH of the detachment, Major Okunevich, we evaluated the situation and came to this conclusion:

a) the German-Finnish troops complete the concentration of the operational offensive group ...;

b) the enemy is most likely to attack in the coming hours;

c) ... according to the cover plan ... it is envisaged to nominate units of 115 sd of Major General V.F. Konkov from the 23 army.

On the morning of June 21, 1941, the command of 115 sd informed us: “We are instructed to be on full alert in places of permanent deployment”.

Based on this assessment of the situation, I gave the following order for the detachment:

“1. Continue to strengthen the protection and defense of the State Border ...

2. The personnel of the outpost, free from direct service on the state border line, on the night of 22.6.41, take up and defend combat positions in the outpost area.

3. The commandant's office and the maneuvering group should occupy spare command posts and areas, paying particular attention to reliable, stable communication and control with outposts and border patrols along the front and bypass connection with the depth.

4. The headquarters of the border detachment ... from Enso on the night of 22 June 1941 moved to the area of ​​the emergency command post ... to 24-00 21 June 1941 of the year to organize communication and control with commandant's offices, outposts and units of the SV, deployed in the border detachment band, as well as with district and center.

5. I and the regimental commissar Zyablikov with the task force, with the means of communication with the troops, district and center remain at the same place of deployment of the headquarters of the border detachment of Enso.

6. On the night of June 22 1941 military families (children, old people) to lead to the rear, highlighting for this the appropriate vehicles
».

Again we see private decision and initiative of the border guard command. Light memory of them ...

As we remember from the 9 part, a similar request to Beria was addressed by the head of the border troops of the NKVD of the USSR: “The commander of the border troops of the NKVD BSSR, Lieutenant-General T. Bogdanov informed that, by order of the commander of the Baltic border district, the families of the commanding personnel of the CA units of the Taurogren direction are being prepared for evacuation. T. Bogdanov asks for instructions on the evacuation of families of the commanders of the Sakiai border detachment, on the preparation for which the order was given to them ... I ask for your instructions. Lieutenant-General Maslennikov"According to the memory of the surviving border guards, the families remained at the outposts ...

A.M. Andreev: "During the night on 22 June 1941 of the year, carrying out the order received, border outposts with outfits of at least 3-5 border guards covered the main potential enemy offensive directions ..., the gaps were blocked by mobile sentinel posts. After three o'clock in the morning, 22 June began receiving reports from 9 and 12 of numerous outbreaks by German aircraft of our border. Finnish border guards left the cordons ... and retreated to the rear. On the area of ​​the border detachment appeared divisions of the Finnish and German regular troops, who began to equip the initial area for the offensive... »

A.P.Kozlov (Head of the 3 frontier post): "Sports competitions between 22 and 1 outposts were scheduled for the morning of June 3. Our island was chosen as a meeting place ... A messenger arrived and handed me a package ... Captain MS Small ordered no one to leave the island, strengthen his outfits, keep his eyes on the adjacent shore, check again the condition of the bunkers, trenches, slots and trenches ... Border guards took their places according to combat crew ...

He passed hour after hour ... That night fell on the island ... "Well, that's all! - I thought with relief. - In vain the commandant was worried". And just at that moment there was an unfamiliar bass sound ... I looked up and was numb - planes with black crosses on the wings were going to Leningrad. Suddenly, one of the close-in armada of aircraft broke away from the line and dived onto the island ... Senior Lieutenant Ryatskov's anti-aircraft battery opened fire
... "

E.I. Vodopyanov (border guards of the NKVD): "After the Finnish War, I remained at the first frontier post ... We had no idea whether there would be a war. Were, as usual, guard the state border... "

Post-telegram: "NSH LVO. 20-00 22.6.41 in the area [entrusted] my division without changes. The camps are collapsed, the units of the units should be winter apartments. Major General Ivanov, commander of the 2 division of the NKVD Troops for the protection of railways.»

In the documents and memoirs of the veterans, there is no data on the preparation of LVO troops to repel a possible attack in accordance with the mythical directive of the General Staff, according to which they allegedly began to conduct activities in Western HE, including and in PribOVO.

Probably, on the night of 20 on June 21, on the instructions of an unknown person, some units and formations of the cover of the 1 train are in full alert, remaining in the RPM.

All activities for the promotion of compounds to the defensive line at the border, the dispersal of aviation begin only at dawn, the day of June 22. The actions of saboteurs until 22 June are not expected, since The division of the NKVD moves out of the camps in the PPD only on the evening of June 22.

Let's try to determine who is the above-mentioned person who made the decision to increase the combat readiness of parts of the 1-echelon of the cover of the Leningrad Military District. I will preliminarily say that these are not instructions from Moscow ...

Consider the memories Commander LVO M.M. Popova: "At the beginning of May, we were summoned to the General Staff with the chief of the operational department of the district headquarters, General PG Tikhomirov, where for several days we were working on the option of covering and defending the district’s borders in case of war. Preliminary outlines of this plan have already been made in the General Staff, and Tikhomirov and I were asked to study them carefully and make our own specific proposals. Since these issues were not once comprehensively discussed at narrow operational meetings of the district command, it was not difficult for us to delve into the General Staff’s proposals and to make the necessary, in our opinion, amendments and clarifications ...

In the tenths of June, the directive of the People's Commissar of Defense was received, which appointed ... a commission chaired by the commander of the LVO with entrusting it with the tasks of selecting sites for building airfields to base fighter and bomber aviation on the shores of the Barents Sea
...

[A completely unnecessary question for the district commander if everything is supposedly waiting for war.]

Such an assignment did not suit me as a commander who had not yet had time to properly study the troops and the border territory of the district. Therefore, before the commission’s work, it was necessary to carry out a field trip planned by the operational preparation plan for a part of the 14 Army to study the issues and conditions for covering and defending the Murmansk and Kandalaksha areas, on which, according to intelligence data, German forces had already begun to concentrate in Finland.

Stay at the border once again convinced me how frankly the Germans and the Finns bring their troops to our borders and prepare a bridgehead for offensive. For example, when familiarizing with the border area in the area of ​​Kuolajärvi (Kandalaksha direction) according to the reports of the commander 122 st and the head of the border detachment was found that in the immediate vicinity of the state border against Kuolajärvi a few days ago began the concentration and deployment of German troops, and a little south of the Finnish units. The white nights did not allow to hold these events covertly, and they were well observed by the border posts, especially from the towers and the NP, equipped on tall trees ...

Yes, we personally observed, climbing some of the towers of the border guards, clearly visible groups of German officers moving directly along the state border with binoculars and maps, groups of soldiers moving in equal directions, cars running along the roads, and a lot of smoke — obviously field kitchens, as on a hot June day hardly anyone made a fire ...

It was something to ponder under the fresh impression of everything seen and heard during these days. An experienced and combat commander of the division, taking this opportunity, remarked: "Here the matter is absolutely clear and not subject to doubt. They will come for sure. How good it would be for us to sit on the defensive, gain a foothold and prepare for the meeting of the enemy».

Frankly, I myself thought about it, weighing everything in my mind "behind" and "против". "According"- clear need and appropriateness of training and defense preparation. "Против"- the absence of firm directives to this effect and the fear that the measures we have taken may be used by the opposing party for all sorts of provocations.

However, prudence prevailed, and After consulting with the commander of the 14 Army, Lieutenant-General V.A. Frolov, I ordered the 122 Division to immediately go on the defensive, firmly and well to gain a foothold, but to do it skillfully, without repeating the mistakes of the Germans and Finns, who created their groupings very frankly. White nights and we did not guarantee the secrecy of the deployment and conduct of defensive work.

The division commander assured that he perfectly understands and will accept all measures to ensure that their events as much as possible to hide from the German observation. I ordered the division commander occupy defenses, barricade, put barriers and mines. On the way to Murmansk, we and the army commander discussed in detail the situation in the Murmansk sector ...

The field trip confirmed our fears that were born at the district headquarters that the Murmansk and Kandalaksha directions are aimed approximately at the German forces corps, reinforced by the Finns, with the obvious task of capturing very important points for us - Murmansk, the main base of our Federation Council and the only non-freezing port in the area , and Kandalaksha, as a result of which the enemy would have been able to cut the Kirov railway, along which all supplies of the Northern Fleet, the 14 army and a relatively large population of the Polar region go ...

In Murmansk, we summed up our field trip, made some adjustments to the cover plans developed earlier, without changing their basic essence, - Murmansk direction - two sd, Kandalaksha - two sd and one etc. and, finally, on the Kestengsky direction - one unit
... »

District Commander writes about the decision without solid directives from Moscow about the expediency of supplying units to the border and occupying the line of defense. The events described occur 20 th June. After visiting 122, the commanders of the military detachment of the Leningrad Military District and the 14 army leave for Murmansk. And now we will consider negotiations of two chiefs of associations.

Blank record: "Who negotiates Skvirsky [NSH 14 army]

Who are the negotiations with Panin [Commander 42 sc Lvo].

В 21-30 Shevchenko [commander 122 sd] reported that the farm reconnaissance new apartment.

[Shevchenko reported after the departure of both commanders: the LVO and the 14 Army.]

Skvirsky: Waiting for action tomorrow, after tomorrow 22.23.6. [The above phrase indicates that negotiations are underway on June 21.]

Economic movement immediately. Warn about it Shevchenko. Applying full measures of disguise, let him take what he is supposed to take.

Move in small batches to remember the air. Take ... measures readiness at any moment of Morozov
[commander 104 sd].

Ensure by all means [Kirov Railway] ...

More detail after receiving data from Popova [commander LVO], whom we wait in an hour...

[Popov must leave Murmansk by train to 7 in the morning on 21.6.41.]

Panin: how to understand 22.23.6.

Skvyra - wait for 22 or 23.6.41 action. Is it clear.

Panin: I will push tonight 715
[715 sp xnumx cd] into place. Shevchenko hurry with the promotion of a convoy. Morozov plunges two kul 273 cn [104 sd] 25 in Kesteng. I have everything for now.

Skvirsky: Are there any questions for me.

Panin: no questions
... »

According to the results of the inspection of the adjacent territory, the commander of the military-military detachment and the commander of the 14 Army came to the conclusion that the enemy’s 22-23 could begin hostilities in June 1941 in this direction! The 122-I division was supposed to occupy defenses on the border west of Alakurtti and up to the Arctic Circle. It took several more days to concentrate the 1 th ... Opponent began concentrating earlier.

The commander of the LVO was obliged to inform the district's NSN of its decision on the gradual advancement of 122 units to the border and on the expected (in their opinion) deadline for the 22-23 attack on June 1941. It is likely that after this conversation, other troops of the district 1-echelon of the district were instructed to switch to increased readiness on the morning of June 21 while in the PDP. Does not have the top management of the spacecraft to this relationship ...

M.M.Popov: "Then there was an acquaintance and the first meeting with the commander of the Federation Council, Vice-Admiral AG Golovko, with whom a true friendship was subsequently established, which lasted until the last days of his life. The Federation Council on land defense issues quickly obeyed the LVO, and both of us had something to talk about ... Naturally, the questions to me first of all came down, and issues related to the assessment of the overall political and military situationbecause under the conditions of that time, any additional information on exciting questions was of vital interest.

By the end of our meeting, AGGolovko reported that the destroyer allocated for the commission on the choice of airfields, where I was supposed to go, was ready to go to sea, and suggested clarifying the time of this exit. The soul did not lay, as they say, to this parting from the land almost a month. However, the directive of the Commissar did not
».

Markian Mikhailovich Popov hesitated for a long time before he decided to call Marshal Timoshenko.

«And the Commissar on the wire. A short report on the situation at the land border, at sea and in the air, and a frank statement that in these conditions going to sea is impractical.

“It's good that I called,” said the people's commissar's voice. - Putting to sea for the time being. Immediately return to Leningrad. ” Those present during the conversation with the People's Commissar - the komflot and the commander - saw in the cancellation of going to sea some confirmation of our fears.
...

[In the morning of June 21, M.M.Popov left Murmansk for Leningrad by the express train “Polar Arrow” (travel time 32 h 40 min). If his presence at the district headquarters was required immediately, he would have been ordered to take off by plane. According to the author, at that time, the People's Commissar of Defense did not expect a war in the morning of June 22. In addition, the commander of the LVO himself did not expect full-scale military operations on the entire border of his district, since was forced to break away from communication for more than 32 hours. He was probably expecting a provocative attack on 122 sd positions ...]

June 21 day, spent in the car, passed quietly. At large stations, the military commandants who were on duty to the car could not report anything alarming. In Petrozavodsk, where we arrived around 4 o'clock in the morning 22 June, in addition to the commander-in-chief, Lieutenant-General FD Gorelenko, who was waiting for us, we also met the secretary of the Central Committee of the Karelo-Finnish SSR and the head of the Kirov railway. First of all, they reported on the received order from Moscow: to unhook the wagon of the commander from the train and to deliver him to Leningrad outside the schedule, for which purpose a separate steam locomotive...

[Only after the bombing of a number of Soviet cities from Moscow is an order to speed up the arrival of the commander to his district headquarters.]

We are with WWW N.N. Klementyev puzzled at the guesswork, which means this order about urgent delivery of us to Leningrad... [The People's Commissar of Defense on the phone did not tell Popov anything about waiting for an imminent war with Germany. Maybe he didn’t know about it yet?]

At around 7 in the morning, our ... line-up made its first stop. The commandant who appeared in the carriage ... reported that the stop was due to the need to check the axle boxes and it would be very short ... About an hour ago, the selector from Leningrad sent a message only for the attention of the station head and the commandant that the Germans bombed a number of our cities in the west around 4 railway nodes and after a strong artillery shelling crossed the border and invaded our territory. Both of them were ordered to start holding events according to the mobilization plan ... In the morning of June 22 we returned to Leningrad... »

Finally, we will consider the talks of Colonel Kurasov [deputy head of the operational management of the General Staff] with the headquarters of the LVO.

«At the unit, Colonel Kurasov = Passing instructions to General Lieutenant Vatutin = At ​​dawn on June 22, the bombing of Sevastopol by Libau Vindava began. The fighting began in Krystynopil in the Kiev Military District and on the borders of PribOVO the Germans began the fighting

It has been ordered to bring the troops of the Leningrad district into a state of combat air defense and prepare all the conditions in case of a rise of troops = While all

Please repeat the points of trespassing. At which points are the borders violated.
»

Negotiations between the General Staff and the headquarters of the Leningrad Military District are under way even before Directive No. XXUMX arrived at the General Staff. Not a word about the beginning of the war. Only about the bombing of cities and the fighting in one direction in KOVO and about PribOVO. In ZOVOVO - calm. During negotiations, the requirement of Directive No. XXUMX on bringing troops and air defense into a combat state is duplicated. According to the author, at the time of the negotiations at the beginning of a full-scale war, neither Vatutin nor Kurasov were yet sure of the start of the war.

Below are the later negotiations in the LVO, which are already a reflection of Directive No. 2 received from Moscow: “I convey the order of the military council = First = Dawn 22 June the Germans began the bombing of Sevastopol, Libau, Vindava. Fighting began in the Kiev military district of the district of Hristanopol and on the borders of PribOVO. The fighting began the Germans. Violations of the Finnish and German planes Tisovka, Vyborg, Kronstadt and Leningrad took place at the borders with Finland 22 June. The People's Commissar ordered to bring all the troops, headquarters and air defense into a combat condition and prepare the conditions for receiving the mobilized. The border with Finland does not cross and do not fly. Violators destroy everything on their territory ... = Everything is clear= "

According to the results of the presented material, it can be seen that the instructions from the NKO and the General Staff regarding the dispersal of the Air Force and on the transfer of the units to increased combat readiness did not arrive at the Leningrad Military District before the receipt of Directive No. XXUMX. There are no traces of the mythical directive (or directives, as it is already customary to say) ...
68 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +14
    16 September 2018 06: 03
    Thanks aKtoR for the article! As always, I read this part with great interest. Do not pay attention to the comments of counterfeiters from the literature. For them, the main thing for obtaining their profits is to follow their versions, set out already in NINE books. It is clear that any other ideas should be drowned by any means. Business is only business. No ethics for money.
    1. VS
      -9
      16 September 2018 09: 48
      Quote: Ales
      For them, the main thing for obtaining their profits is to follow their versions, set out already in NINE books. It is clear that any other ideas should be drowned by any means. Business is only business. No ethics for money.

      Have you read MY books ??))
      Yulia’s ideas are not new - she’s trying to prove that if cho was done in the pre-war days, it was done on the personal initiative of the fearless tyrant of the military whom they later shot)))

      And this is nonsense - the troops led to B .. g and led out according to the BCP and this was done in connection with the expectation of an attack - And at the same time on different dates in different districts - and at the command of MOSCOW, this was done because it would be taken to the border zone, in the UR without Stalin’s permission, no one could, and this has been done since June 11)))

      The words of the person who ordered it to be done, I quoted more than once))

      He did not fall into his official memoirs, but then he told the truth))

      "" The commanders of the border military districts were ordered to withdraw the troops of the districts - designated as part of the covering forces, closer to the state border and the lines that they had to occupy in an emergency, by special order.

      At the same time, the advanced units were ordered to be advanced to the zone of border units. Other equally important events were held. All this obliged the commanders of the districts and armies to increase their combat readiness. ""))

      I do not like these words - not my problems)))
      1. +1
        16 September 2018 10: 20
        Kozinkin came in and again began to show his many cheekiness, arrogance of twisting facts and a clear lack of facts. Read smarties from falsifier-rezunist Kozinkina, a follower of the English
  2. +15
    16 September 2018 06: 23
    Thoroughly. Thank you ....
    1. +7
      16 September 2018 06: 27
      I join the answer. Specially came to the site that track this topic.
      Hold on aKtoR!
      1. VS
        -6
        16 September 2018 09: 49
        did not try echo cho to read a thread on a subject ??))
    2. -3
      18 September 2018 13: 40
      + made to continue the void AND Actor and V.O .-- MIRACLES.
      for understanding - how they waited and overslept the attack - DO NOT WATCH THE RAILWAYS AND MEMOIRS --- AND THE STRUCTURE OF THE HANDS AND MANAGEMENT OF THE USSR
      it is laid down - the peasant class (its mentality) would not allow it to stop the households and prepare for death BEFORE THE ATTACK (until the thunder strikes ...)
      NOW LIKE THE SAME: they are modestly chewing on the Il20 theme and waiting for instructions from the Kremlin - and a literal debriefing, but there are "instructions" and "instructions" and regulations and other rubbish ..

      which of you (us) has now distinguished provocation from TrMV announcement ???
      1. VS
        -3
        19 September 2018 06: 27
        Prefer to study the mentality of history rather than facts and documents?))

        By mentality, you will understand HOW a person or nation behaves in some situation - like a psychotype, but LEARNING WHAT YOU HAVE DONE, what actions and actions were done - specific people - you can talk about facts and docs)))

        And - my "initials" are "V.S.")) and not V.O.)))
        1. -1
          19 September 2018 08: 30
          I want to understand, and not distort the facts, how do you go around with a "lady" --- it was — it wasn’t so, they wrote another, then a third.
          in 89, Alksnis was waiting for the declassification of the British archives (is there recognition of the Soviet Baltic?) - and those archives are not available for us, and ours also only understand the motivating reasons and suggest (God has it)
  3. VS
    -9
    16 September 2018 09: 40
    "" The words allegedly that everyone in the General Staff understood perfectly well that in relation to the LPO there would be other instructions - this is from the evil one. There is no evidence for these words, and if there is no evidence, then these words cannot be trusted.

    If all the instructions of Directive No. 1 are identical for all VOs, then, therefore, the orders before June 21 regarding the troops of the districts should also be identical for all districts. What happened to the troops and aviation in the LMO prior to the receipt of Directive No. 1 should somehow resemble similar events in the western border districts. This is the hypothesis ""

    This is DEMAGOGY)))

    YOU DO NOT HAVE PRELIMINARY directives - because they are not in the TsAMO and your assistants will NEVER get into the archive of the General Staff)) And even more so you yourself))) So, guess any further, but better without demagogic "logical" twists of a yulechka)))
  4. +9
    16 September 2018 10: 14
    Thank you, NSh counties, for the fact that they began to undertake at least something, while the leaders of the spacecraft and the commanders of the troops of the districts were (voluntarily or involuntarily) aloof from making extremely important decisions.

    A few days before the start of the war, on the instructions of the district command, the families of the command personnel were taken to the rear. But on June 20, a categorical order came from NGOs to immediately return everyone to their old places.

    how can this air force be brought into full combat readiness, but not set specific combat missions?

    The farther I read the author’s articles, the more clearly it is evident what a mess was created upstairs before the start of the war! Everyone is afraid to make decisions, run away from responsibility, no one knows what to do, where to run .... Someone, on personal initiative, does something to us at his own risk, someone does nothing ....
    The mess is the main cause of the disaster on June 22 and the whole of the 41st year and unimaginable losses.
    As for the political leadership, its inaction is simply amazing: on the border of the country there is a long-mobilized, victorious belligerent army of an aggressive state that treacherously captured almost all of Europe, but this no reason for him not only to carry out the same mobilization, but even to bring the troops into combat readiness. They were afraid to "provoke", you know.
    A mobilized Nazi army on the border is, for some reason, NOT a provocation of Germany, nea ...
    And the fact that the sky-ready Red Army is the best seductive provocation for the aggressor did not even enter my head ... belay

    I read the author’s articles with pleasure, thanks to him for his work! hi
    1. +7
      16 September 2018 10: 23
      I subscribe for your every word, dear Olgovich! I myself can’t put it so beautifully. By copying one of your phrases for the author, no offense, okay?)))
      I read the author’s articles with pleasure, thank you for his work !!!
      1. +2
        18 September 2018 13: 42
        there was no mess - there was excessive caution of the weak before a strong Europe

        everyone understood everything 41g - see right now the reaction to il20
        1. 0
          18 September 2018 19: 33
          Quote: antivirus
          there was no mess - there was excessive caution of the weak before a strong Europe

          I agree with this assessment. That is precisely why they did not take drastic actions in the hope that they would somehow manage to postpone the war for at least a year or two.
          1. +1
            18 September 2018 19: 44
            I wrote about the mentality of the peasants (everyone in the country was like that, even workers who came from the countryside in the first generation) - according to Bismarck - "two rains in May and Russia is invincible" - oats have risen - cavalry will provide a breakthrough and victory (in pm and Zhukov, and Timoshenko with Budyonny (and Tukhachevsky?))
            after May, everything is not clear for the economy of the peasants - WEIGHT WILL GIVE POWER FOR VICTORY OVER THE SUPPOST
            and most importantly - the vast majority of the authorities (and the young Khrushchev too?) thought so-- to pull a small one to a week, 2 weeks, 3 .... 7 weeks and the haymaking passed --- Hurray, WE ARE UNBEATABLE! won the whole year
            1. VS
              -3
              19 September 2018 06: 35
              But at the same time, in anticipation of the attack, they were withdrawn according to the Cover Plans for the troops - in 10 days, they were brought in the battlefield. and other measures necessary for the army to more or less normal entry into the war were carried out ..
              1. +1
                30 September 2018 08: 23
                Facts where the liar Kozinkin. Facts are extracts from documents, memoirs. The facts are not the words of you Botan !!!
            2. -2
              19 September 2018 12: 41
              Quote: antivirus
              so they thought-- to pull back a little until a week, 2 weeks, 3 .... 7 weeks and the haying passed --- Hurray, WE ARE UNBEATABLE! won the whole year

              It is not a matter of haymaking, but the fact that any military company against Russia and the USSR in the non-nuclear period required at least several months to capture the main part of the country and destroy its military potential. So even a delay of a couple of months in June 1941 would make it impossible to start a war, if only because our frosts started already at the end of September, and our opponent knew this very well. So an attempt to delay the war by any means is the sanity of our leadership, and this is an indisputable fact.
              1. +2
                19 September 2018 14: 12
                everyone is always right, except me - in 42-43 the Germans fought and in cold weather - in 41 they deliberately prepared themselves in the "European" weather for a walk in Russia

                THE ARCHIVES WILL BE OPENED (???) BY 2041 - AND THE SUN AND AUTHOR AND ME WILL NOT BE - THERE ARE THE CALCULATIONS OF THE USA, BRITS, YAP. DR PLAYERS-- launch a plane into a series, air defense, mob reserves have grown, kanechna - OVES has gone, oilfields = railway roads have been modernized for a big war


                ANOTHER TIME TO SEARCH THE REASONS FOR THE ACTIONS OF THE MILITARY NEEDS IN THE PEOPLE AND THE CAPITALISTS OF THE HOUSES AND READY !!!!!!!!! BY EXPERIENCE OF PMV !!!!!!! BY THE SLAUGHTER NOT IN 3-6 MONTHS, AND YEARS
                see plans for the third five-year plan and the shipyard of the usa-britain, Ford plants, romanian-turks,
                Indians, and especially ____________ "theoretical substantiation of the production of an especially powerful bomb" and the Germans and the USSR and the Britons.
                not only to catch frost
                1. -3
                  19 September 2018 19: 03
                  Quote: antivirus
                  everyone is always right, except me - in 42-43 the Germans fought and in cold weather - in 41 they deliberately prepared themselves in the "European" weather for a walk in Russia

                  This is not entirely true, if only because the blitzkrieg had to end before a dense snow cover lay on the main European part of the USSR. And the consequence of the failure was that already in February 1943, Hitler, with the words of Goebbels, declared "total war." This means that there was a final failure of the German plans to end the war with the summer companies of 1941 and 1942.
                  1. +1
                    19 September 2018 19: 33
                    I wrote about this, they wanted to and didn’t manage to win back in caps
                    and there were many WWI veterans - they knew that to Baranavichy - one weather, and at Gorky -dr, in winter
          2. VS
            -3
            19 September 2018 06: 33
            There are no sharp ones. BUT what they did was quite possible to reduce the degree of inevitable defeats and retreats ..
        2. VS
          -2
          19 September 2018 06: 32
          the mess has always been and will be))) like betrayal sabotage and cowardice, etc. )))
          1. +2
            30 September 2018 08: 25
            Treason - yes! So simple, if something does not fit together to write about treason. Kozinkin's new nonsense is the traitor-saboteur Kirponos. Before everything reaches out - everything will be spoiled by a falsifier-liar-rezunist Kozinkin
  5. BAI
    0
    16 September 2018 10: 26
    The authors are encouraged to review and refute or confirm the following statement of Solonin: 22.06.1941/XNUMX/XNUMX the troops were in positions that were supposed to occupy the THIRD day of the UNIVERSAL mobilization.
  6. +9
    16 September 2018 10: 37
    Thanks to the author for an interesting article!
  7. VS
    -6
    16 September 2018 16: 40
    Quote: ivamoss
    Read smarties from falsifier-rezunist Kozinkina, a follower of the English

    Did I at least write in books that Stalstign was preparing the FIRST attack on Germany?)) Do you even mean the words you understand what you use ?? Rezuny, etc. - these are those who scream that Stalin was ready to attack the first but did not have time)))

    Write down the meaning of these ideas of Rezun and his fans, or so remember ??
    But here I write in rezunami and even as friends of the English - it's cool)))
    1. +1
      30 September 2018 08: 28
      You are a liar regularly on the site of Militer write about an immediate retaliatory strike. When you are tortured through how much he should have followed, if they were waiting for the war on June 22, you write a bunch of insults and text and not a single fact. You act like a bazaar trader from the times of the USSR: if you are caught on a body kit, you should scream and insult the loudest thing without letting the words be inserted. Trading - Olya Kozinkina))))
  8. VS
    -8
    16 September 2018 16: 42
    Quote: Pas7
    Hold on aKtoR!

    what lady hold on to ?? SHE IS ANONYMOUS and nothing threatens her anymore from me))) Sodlat girl or child will not offend)))
    1. 0
      30 September 2018 08: 28
      Yes, what kind of soldier are you ??? You are a warehouse clerk without a conscience
  9. VS
    -5
    16 September 2018 16: 47
    Quote: Olgovich
    how can this air force be brought into full combat readiness, but not set specific combat missions?

    The farther I read the author’s articles, the more clearly it is evident what a mess was created upstairs before the start of the war!

    the nonsense the lady wrote - STUPID about her understanding and what is the cast in b .. g - and you are delighted ??)))

    I’ll tell you for the next about the ignoramus and the batan who didn’t serve in the army - when brought to full bg. DO NOT SET COMBAT TASKS ISCO))) from the word SAPSEM)))

    A combat mission - it’s painted in red packets))))

    Madame ON THIS loops and shows her stupidity - SHE understands HOW it is being done in the army, trying to use hypotheses to compose hypotheses and it’s HERE and Vovka Rezun does something like that - they invent something about the army and then yell at that)) )

    IF ONCE - when brought to full bg even - BATTLE missions do not pose ischo)))
    1. +1
      30 September 2018 08: 32
      A comment from one of the users: "How can we bring this aviation into full combat readiness, and not assign specific combat missions to it? ..."

      Kozinkin's answer: "The lady wrote nonsense - STUPIDITY about her understanding and what is a cast in b..g"

      I clarify that we are talking about the statements of Marshal Novikov. The military marshal wrote nonsense, according to a warehouse worker who became a writer Kozinkin. So he writes not nonsense, and every word he does not require proof. This is how patients behave in a fool
      1. +1
        25 October 2018 00: 57
        Quote: RuSFr
        0
        A comment from one of the users: "How can we bring this aviation into full combat readiness, and not assign specific combat missions to it? ..."

        First of all, the DAILY 22.6.41 HOUR posts with continuous communication with the headquarters should have been FULLY deployed - and 4. they were deployed only XNUMX% of the state, and the connection was not with everyone. Secondly, in each air regiment the duty squadron should be on duty, and not the duty link, and that is not everywhere. Thirdly, all aircraft had to be fully tucked in and with full ammunition, at least machine gun. All airfield services, including anti-aircraft gunners, should have been prepared to protect the airfield, disguise it, repair it, provide power at the field airfield, communications, medicine, etc. If someone thinks that preparing a plane and a pilot for a combat mission does not require labor and time, he does not think at all.
  10. VS
    -5
    16 September 2018 16: 49
    Quote: Olgovich
    even bring troops into combat readiness

    and you read the directives of the General Staff of June or something ??)))
  11. VS
    -6
    16 September 2018 16: 51
    Quote: BAI
    The authors are encouraged to review and refute or confirm the following statement of Solonin: 22.06.1941/XNUMX/XNUMX the troops were in positions that were supposed to occupy the THIRD day of the UNIVERSAL mobilization.

    As Markushch’s current reached the documents of the pre-war days in the archives, he stopped writing books))
    Unlike Madame Yulichka anonymous from Peter, she is a fan of the lieutenant - he’s a little smarter - he realized that it’s better not to get into these docks and invented - whether Stalin wanted to attack first or DID NOT give the military anything to do, but they did it )))
  12. -7
    16 September 2018 20: 49
    Author:
    aKtoR writes:
    On the tenth of June, the directive of the People’s Commissar of Defense was received, which was appointed ... a commission chaired by the commander of the Leningrad Military District with the task of selecting sites for the construction of airfields for the base of fighter and bomber aircraft along the shores of the Barents Sea ...

    [A completely unnecessary question for the district commander if everyone is supposedly waiting for war.]

    It’s a completely stupid conclusion, because the district commander decides on the location of district airfields, which is why he was appointed chairman of the commission, because he was personally responsible for how the troops would be covered. But as a rule, the deputy is responsible for all the work. Chairman of the commission, and the participation of the commander himself is required to give instructions and approve the commission’s act.
  13. -7
    16 September 2018 21: 07
    Author:
    aKtoR writes:
    Calls from Moscow from the leadership of the spacecraft to the headquarters of the LVO until the receipt of the lengthy Directive No. 1, the adoption of decisions related to measures to raise the troops of the okrug “fell on the head” of Major General D.N. Nikishov, the only head of the Military Council of the LenVO - NS.

    What is so surprising about this? It would be surprising if the deputy. the rear commander led the district during the absence of the commander, not the chief of staff who knows best how to lead troops from the district headquarters. Another enchanting conclusion of the author of the article.

    It is strange that General Pyadyshev was allowed to leave for Estonia on June 21, leaving D.N. Nikishev, the only leader from the Military Council of the district at the district headquarters.

    This is generally a common practice, when the deputy commander of the district is sent off to the army or on a business trip (on vacation, for treatment, to study), and the NS remains in the sole person to lead the district.
    It is strange that the district commander was in no hurry to arrive at the headquarters of the LVO and he calmly rode the train for 32 hours.

    It is strange that the author did not provide documentary evidence that they rode the train for 32 hours.
    All this is strange if, according to literary figures, the high command of the spacecraft expects a war at dawn on June 22nd. however, it is commonplace if the leadership of the spacecraft does not expect war ...

    It is strange for civilians, and military experts were faced with situations where the command is not even taken by deputy commanders.

    For various reasons, the situation in all the districts turned out to be painfully the same, except for ZOVO, where the decisions were taken by the District Military Council headed by the commander of the troops.

    Complete nonsense - not all decisions of the district commander require the immediate convening of a military council, especially if it concerns the immediate execution of the order of NGOs.

    In the LVO, the entire responsibility for making decisions fell on the shoulders of the NSH of the district of DNNikishev.

    And who else should be blamed, if not on him - list the officials who will do it better than him.
  14. VS
    -6
    17 September 2018 08: 30
    "" On June 17, at the direction of the NSh LVO, the 1st TD of the 1st MK begins to move by railway transport to the Alakurtti station. Such a movement of the tank unit cannot be made without the approval of the General Staff. In the author's opinion, this movement was carried out by order from Moscow. "

    and Madame, as expected from the ladies porridge in the head, then one thing then another)))

    That’s not e troops are being withdrawn according to COVER PLANS in the districts on a personal initiative - contrary to STALIN estesseno, and they are brought to the b .. g naturally despite and on the personal initiative of brave and good people generals who are not afraid of the tyrant, THEN - it appears the troops are withdrawn from "17"! ! June - MECHCASE - by order of Moscow i.e. Stalin)))

    But Madame EXACTLY KNOWS that IN THESE DAYS from June 16, MEKKORPUSS were displayed in ALL DISTRICTS - in Pribovo, TWO of their MK, in ZAPOVO - ONE of their MK., in KOVO - THREE MK, in OdVO - one of their MK))
    CONCLUDED BY PP with a bg cast of course the most combat-ready MK
    but Madame didn’t write about IT - she just mentioned PribOV just because it wouldn’t work to ignore the conclusion of the 3rd and 12th MK but - like they themselves decided to do it - WITHOUT Moscow Stalin’s order)))
  15. VS
    -7
    17 September 2018 08: 37
    Quote: ccsr
    [A completely unnecessary question for the district commander if everyone is supposedly waiting for war.]

    It’s a completely stupid conclusion, because the district commander decides on the location of district airfields, which is why he was appointed chairman of the commission, because he was personally responsible for how the troops would be covered.

    But after all, our Julia showed anonymous Chekunov - EVEN on the night of June 22, except for the director. about b.g. - warning about the attack and about the occupation of firing points on the border, they went into the districts of TEN OTHERS - "working" directives of the General Staff NOT HAVING ANY RELATIONSHIP to the expected war)))

    It is strange that our SIE did not use Yulia as an "argument" that an attack of the type was not expected in the Kremlin and the General Staff THIS NIGHT)))
  16. VS
    -5
    17 September 2018 08: 39
    Quote: ccsr
    Calls from Moscow from the leadership of the spacecraft to the headquarters of the LVO until the receipt of the lengthy Directive No. 1, the adoption of decisions related to measures to raise the troops of the okrug “fell on the head” of Major General D.N. Nikishov, the only head of the Military Council of the LenVO - NS.

    What is so surprising about this? It would be surprising if the deputy. the rear commander led the district during the absence of the commander, not the chief of staff who knows best how to lead troops from the district headquarters. Another enchanting conclusion of the author of the article.

    and in Pribovo I drove NS Maples in the DAY)))
    and in OdVO - NSh Zakharov)))

    and even in KOVO it’s not the commander who raised his NSH ARMY ALARM that night)))
    1. -8
      17 September 2018 12: 23
      Quote: V.S.
      and in Pribovo I drove NS Maples in the DAY)))
      and in OdVO - NSh Zakharov)))

      Our madame is too far from the realities of military service, but she thinks that if she throws a bunch of materials from different sources, without understanding their essence, then everyone will believe that she understands military issues of that time if she asks stupid questions. But this does not go away with a serious analysis of her "conclusions", which is why she is afraid to discuss her articles on the militer.
  17. VS
    -7
    17 September 2018 08: 43
    Quote: ccsr
    It is strange that General Pyadyshev was allowed to leave for Estonia on June 21, leaving D.N. Nikishev, the only leader from the Military Council of the district at the district headquarters.

    This is generally a common practice, when the deputy commander of the district is sent off to the army or on a business trip (on vacation, for treatment, to study), and the NS remains in the sole person to lead the district.

    Madame, as befits a batan and a lady on THIS makes a brilliant conclusion - ONCE the commander is away and instead he steers his deputy - they do not expect war !!)))

    And tabout what in PribOVO and OdVO they also drove the NSh on that day and the clock should probably strengthen the proof of Madame - WARS and attacks did NOT WAIT !!!)) And if cho was done then Contrary to the tyrant ))
    True, she’s got MK on the orders of Stalin from the 16th but this is so - annoying nonsense doesn’t interfere with her brilliant (I almost wrote genital))) conclusions - they did NOT WAIT AN ATTACK !!)))
  18. VS
    -7
    17 September 2018 08: 47
    Quote: ccsr
    it is strange if, according to literary figures, the high command of the spacecraft expects a war at dawn on June 22nd. however, it is commonplace if the leadership of the spacecraft does not expect war ...

    It is strange for civilians, and military experts were faced with situations where the command is not even taken by deputy commanders.

    alas - our jackets and batans with rezunami believe that the army should be SO they want it to be so !!))) And since it didn’t mean it ...))) and then there are nonsense and fantasies - they didn’t wait for the attack the commanders are not in the headquarters vigil ... they wanted to attack first but in July .. well, etc. delirium of people who do not know how the army really lives and serves)))
  19. VS
    -7
    17 September 2018 08: 54
    "" ZhBD 2 garden: "3-00 22.6. Parts of the 2nd Air Division are on alert. The materiel is dispersed and disguised at the airfield of deployment ... Airfield defense organized. Reason: Telegram to the commander of the Air Force of the LVO from 21.6 ... "

    Here, too, they did not strive to fulfill the order of the People's Commissar of Defense of 19.6.41 to disperse aircraft until June 22. ""

    - Well, with WHAT Julia took it that BEFORE June 22 in THIS Okrug they did not comply with the order of NGOs from June 18-19 on the dispersal and camouflage of the Air Force ??))

    WHERE IS IT SEEN BY RECORDING IN THE RCB?)))

    In the protocol of Pavlov it is indicated - to Pavlov at 1.30 on June 22 Kopec and Tayursky were informed that the order of the NPO on the dispersal and camouflage had already been FULFILLED BY THEM)))

    So maybe THIS RCB speaks of the dispersal of the Air Force as ALREADY FULFILLED - at 3.00 event ??)))
  20. VS
    -7
    17 September 2018 12: 45
    Quote: ccsr
    she is afraid to discuss her articles on a milter.

    So that's why she hides her name here too)) Although - apparently, this is a great writer from the Hermitage - Julia K.)))

    And this is our difference - when I wrote my books, I rolled them on forums and made it available to EVERYONE who is interested and understands something in the topic - so that there are less jambs in books and I especially value the opinion of the military - who served in the army in the USSR and were interested in this topic of war))

    And our anonymous Julia rejects someone else’s opinion and the more information that breaks her fantasies))
    But this is already a visible property of the nation of this lady))) that Markushy Solonin’s site primarily decided to use for composing her pearls that they did not wait for the attack, and if something was done, contrary to the tyranny and on the personal initiative of the bold maple))
  21. VS
    -4
    19 September 2018 06: 42
    "" It is strange that General Pyadyshev was allowed to leave for Estonia on June 21, leaving in the district headquarters the only leader from the Military Council of the district - NSh DN Nikishev. It is strange that the commander of the district was not in a hurry to arrive at the headquarters of the LMO and he calmly traveled for 32 hours on the train. All this is strange if, as literary figures claim, the high command of the spacecraft expects a war at dawn on June 22nd. however, it is commonplace if the leadership of the spacecraft does not expect war ... ""

    - Madame SAMA gave a summary where indicated - the Finnish army DOES NOT DEPLOY until - on June 21)))

    Here is the leadership of the Red Army on this site and does not twitch in vain)))
  22. VS
    -4
    19 September 2018 06: 51
    "" As for the miscalculations and blunders allegedly committed by them in the first days of the war, then, rightly speaking, not only they made them. Let historians speak about this objectively and impartially ... ”Unfortunately, it is easier for individual literary figures, to their own advantage, to declare these people traitors. If only money paid for their work ...

    PA Sudoplatov: “In February 1942, Hero of the Soviet Union, Hero of the Spanish War, commander of the Air Force of the South-Western Front, Ptukhin, was shot on falsified charges. "

    - if, thanks to the activities of SUCH good people, KILL for any reason, then they shoot such heroes in ALL armies of the world ..

    And - Sudoplatov did not write his memoirs himself)) He either dictated or wrote some drafts, and his son gave the PURE option to write to two magazines from the USA)) THIS is a fact))))

    And Novikov wonders HOW this is so - to bring him to FULL YU ... but not to assign the Air Force tasks his writing was EDITED - either anti-Stalinist bastards sat in the General Staff of the General Staff or ps in the political department of the CA or in the Central Committee of the CPSU.

    But if he wrote it that way, then he is either a villain. Air Force Command CANCELED the increased B.G. and let the pilots go home on the evening of June 21. Did they have to give out cookies for IT later?

    But our anonymous author, Julia, in this case also behaves either as a d .. ra or dishonestly ..

    We read Pokrovsky QUESTIONS for PILOTS of the summer of the 41st ..


    1. Provision of an airfield network of the Air Force ____ army on the eve of the war?
    2. The manning of the aviation connections and parts of the Air Force ____ army with the material part and its quality? As far as the aircraft of the new types, which entered the arsenal of the army air force, were mastered by the flight crew. Preparedness of the personnel of the Air Force ____ army to conduct combat operations?
    3. Was the Air Force ____ Army command aware of a possible attack by Nazi Germany in the morning of June 22?
    4. When was the order to put the Air Force ____ army on alert and what was done by the command of the Air Force ____ army in pursuance of this order?
    5. To what extent by the morning of 22.6 were the Air Force ____ armies prepared to repel the sudden raids of fascist aviation?
    6. How prepared was the aviation department of the ____ army’s headquarters for managing aviation in combat conditions and to what extent did this affect its combat operations in the first days of the war?
    I ask you, as the former commander of the Air Force ____ army, to cover, as far as possible, these issues and thereby help to more fully and objectively develop a description of the Great Patriotic War.
    It is advisable to receive your answer to these questions no later than “__” ___ 1952
    COLONEL GENERAL / Pokrovsky /

    For the ladies I will explain - the question of bringing in bg stands BEFORE the issue of NIGHT events on June 22nd.

    And BEFORE this is the question of - WAS the DATE of the attack ACHIEVED?
    I will explain for batans and women - in the army DO NOT ASK about orders if they were not given ...
    1. +1
      19 September 2018 08: 37
      on "questions" - it is quite possible that it would be necessary to judge in 45 -50 years !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! too !!!!!!!!! many winners and dead (loss-pensioners) - it's easier "" to understand and grow "- according to Nasha Rasha

      only guesses are - facts as well as shaving - by 2041
  23. +1
    20 September 2018 17: 27
    Testimony of the commander of the LVO M.M. Popov's are key. By a miracle, the People's Commissar Tymoshenko did not send him to sea on a third-rate business trip literally a day before the start of the war and canceled his order already in the course of drawing up "directive number 1", and on Popov's initiative call to Moscow to HIM PERSONALLY. Had this call not happened, the LVO would have remained severely weakened on the decisive days. The main culprit in the defeat of the Red Army in June 1941 was People's Commissar Timoshenko PERSONALLY.
    1. -2
      20 September 2018 18: 39
      Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
      If this call had not happened, the LVO would have been greatly weakened on crucial days.

      It is hard to believe that the NGOs did not know that the Germans would not have the main blow to the LVO. And the chief of staff of the LWO was in place - what then do you see the problem?
      Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
      The main culprit in the defeat of the Red Army in June 1941 was the People's Commissar Tymoshenko PERSONALLY.

      A huge fault lies with him personally, no one argues with this. But to write everything off only to him would be a big simplification - apparently the state of the army, and what some commanders did before him, you do not fully take into account. Well, the general economic potential of the country also affected the fact that we started the war not in the best way.
      1. +1
        21 September 2018 10: 11
        Now we can finally talk about the "Ukrainian" pair of marshals - Tymoshenko and Kulik, who armed the Red Army in 1938-41. useless anti-tank artillery DEFINITELY CONSCIOUSLY. This despite the fact that excellent anti-tank guns - 37-mm (a Czech license was bought, but it was not launched into the series, replacing the very weak domestic 45-mm. The Germans also bought a license and fought with this gun throughout the war - they had it the most serial), as well as the magnificent 57-mm Grabin was intriguingly pushed in production "for excessive armor penetration." These two "intriguing marshals" are directly involved in the replacement of the "defensive" Border Covering Plan (Shaposhnikov's plan) with the so-called. "counterattack" (the notorious Timoshenko-Zhukov plan, dictated by Timoshenko and handwritten and signed by one Zhukov). Stalin sharply rejected this "counterattack" adventurous plan, but in fact the troops were deployed and had in sealed kaonverts this particular plan of military operations, NOT APPROVED FINALLY. Zhukov then could not go against Tymoshenko and Co. in nothing - then Tymoshenko was in the halo of glory "the winner of Poland in the 1939 campaign." He knew the intriguing power of the "Ukrainian military mafia" well and, in fact, was in it himself.
        1. VS
          -3
          21 September 2018 10: 37
          Not this way.

          Zhukov was a BIG initiator of this idea just (((

          Tymoshenko, according to German intelligence, was AGAINST the excessive strengthening of KOVO to the detriment of the rest of the districts where the Germans would trample with their main forces and he was immediately accused by the NPO of "wanting to surrender Ukraine" (((
        2. -2
          21 September 2018 18: 27
          Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
          He knew the intriguing power of the "Ukrainian military mafia" well and, in fact, was in it himself.

          Well, this is clearly overkill, especially since many of the problems inherent in our armaments were created long before Tymoshenko, while Tukhachevsky was responsible for arming the Red Army.
          1. +1
            21 September 2018 19: 33
            I completely agree that Marshal Kulik actually continued the "conspiracy of marshals", headed by Marshal Tukhachevsky, since the beginning of the 30s, Deputy People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR, responsible for arming the Red Army. But the conspiracy was exposed and Tukhachevsky was exposed in 1936-37. The purge of the top commanding staff of the Red Army was practically completed in 1938, 3-4 years before the Second World War. There was still time to correct the situation in anti-tank artillery, if the issue had not been transferred to the jurisdiction of Kulik and Tymoshenko. By June 1, 1941, the Germans had 15 thousand 37 mm anti-tank guns (their main anti-tank gun!), With a projectile completely identical in geometry, 100% interchangeable with a Soviet 37 mm projectile. Before that, they defeated the French and British armored divisions with this cannon in 1940.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  24. +1
    25 September 2018 09: 03
    Commander PribOVO on the night of 21 to 22.6.41. was with the inspection at the field headquarters 12mk, where on day 22.6. firing was scheduled at the firing range. In the field headquarters of the NWF in Panevezys there was NS Klenov, and in the evacuated headquarters of the district in Riga - Safronov. According to Timoshenko-Zhukov’s plan, the 12th MK was to counter-attack in the direction of Tilsit in the 8 A strip, which they started trying to do on 23-24.6., They were stuck and late with tanks through the forests, the Germans broke through to Libava, and the 12th MK blocked on forest roads with anti-tank barriers and aircraft. The case crushed several batteries, but lost a lot of equipment, time and impact power. The situation with the equipment was as follows: Information about the losses of materiel of the 23rd Panzer Division for the period from 22.6 to 13.7.41 years.
    Explanatory note

    Cars left in winter apartments:

    15 T-26 tanks: 3 vehicles of the 45 tank regiment and 12 vehicles of the 144 tank regiment.

    All of the above machines were awaiting average repairs, including 3 machines requiring major repairs.

    Tank repairs were started, all parts and assemblies that were available in the division were replaced, the delay was due to the lack of engines, piston group, final drive bearings, final drive oil seals, cardan joint bearings, heating chambers and a number of other details, which were not available.

    Part of the above parts and assemblies were sent from warehouse No. 942, but by the time of the performance they had not been received by the division.

    Before the occupation of Telskaya, the 12 tanks of the 144 tank regiment were concentrated on Art. Telsai to be sent for overhaul to industrial plants. It was possible to load only the 3 of the tank, as Komkov, the senior command of the military technician of the 1 rank, was ordered to finish loading and leave Telsai with the recommended representative of the District Military Council - the battalion commissar [227].

    4 tractors SKhTZ and 1 ChTZ-60 required major repairs, the district planned for July to be sent to industrial plants.

    From 12 ZiS-5 8 machines [overhaul] were required, 4 medium, overhauls were received from UABTV [228] Districts for overhaul, 4 cars required average repair, but due to lack of machine parts they were not on go in anticipation of an average repair.

    3 pontoon ZiS-5, 1 M-1 remained in winter apartments due to lack of rubber.

    3 all-terrain vehicle ZiS-5 - not on the move in anticipation of an average [repair] - change of rear axles, which the division did not have.

    16 pieces of motorcycles were waiting for repairs, the lack of parts delayed timely recovery.

    Of the total number of wheeled vehicles, 13 machines were repaired in the RBW, some had the chassis repaired, engine blocks were bored, that is, everything was prepared for the assembly of the machines, but due to the lack of a number of machine parts, they were not assembled at the time of the RBW’s performance with Quarters

    Losses of cars due to technical malfunctions, from artillery fire and aircraft:

    T-26 18 cars: 9 cars spoiling engines, 3 cars gasoline pump bodies burst, 1 spoiled, 2 spoiled chassis, 1 gas tank rupture, 1 ignition damage, 1 stuck in a cuvette during the retreat of our parts.

    Of the total number of 18 machines, 9 vehicles were sent to SPAM, some of the machines were disassembled for repair, but the threat of being cut off forced them to destroy the tanks, frequent movement of the division, the rapid advance of the enemy and the lack of evacuation facilities did not allow the tanks to be repaired or evacuated.

    The rest of the 9 vehicles were left to cover the departure of our units, as a rule, tanks from the rear marching outpost remained. Lost tanks with artillery fire from unoccupied territory by the enemy, as a rule, were towed out of the battlefield, when marching, lined tanks were also towed by tanks, but when they entered the battle they were left behind and in most cases were cut off by the enemy, and especially during the march in front of the enemy’s front.

    When marching from under Madona, 15 T-26 tanks were towed in tow, which reduced the speed of the column by 2-3 times, and also led to severe overheating of the towing vehicles.

    The continuous operation of the tanks in the absence of spare parts led to the fact that most of the remaining vehicles required engine rebuilding due to falling out of the saddles of the cylinders, because of the remaining 44 12 machines were not underway, the rest worked on 2-3 cylinders, and when towing such vehicles towing tanks due to excessive overheating, they usually light up.

    If there were tractors in the towing division, all tanks that were pulled out of the battlefield and failed for technical reasons on the way would be evacuated to the rear and restored, which would reduce the total losses in the tanks by 30 – 40%.

    14 STZ-5 tractors were lost from enemy artillery fire while encircling and leaving the 3 battery and 23 park battery of howitzer artillery regiment, in the same battle 10 trucks, 1 M-1 and 14 park battery trailers were lost. The remaining transport vehicles are lost from enemy fire in the period from 22.6 to 13.7.41 of the year.

    Transferred to other parts:

    2 battalion of tanks in the number of 87 vehicles T-26, 1 "Vickers" from the 144 tank regiment, by order of the commander of the 8 army, were transferred to the 10 rifle corps. 3 of the T-26 tank transferred to the headquarters of the 12 mechanized corps. 136 trucks, 1 M-1 vehicles, 2 ZiS-5 tanks were transferred according to the order of the UABTV of the North-Western Front to form the 202 motorized rifle regiment. 45 ZiS-5 trucks were removed from the TEP in the Telshai region by order of a member of the Military Council of the North-Western Front for the transport of shells. The 1 ZiS-6 vehicle was taken on the road to the 463 infantry regiment, Colonel Zhivykh, recommended by the representative of the 8 army headquarters.

    25 trucks and 1 tractor were taken in transit under the threat of weapons, including: 5 vehicles by the NKVD detachment of Riga, 1 tractor in the Telsai area of ​​the guard detachment commanders, 2 vehicles of the artillery regiment commanders, other vehicles were picked up by various persons.

    207 trucks, 2 tractors STZ-5, 4 tractors T-20, 1 passenger M-1, workshop "A" GAZ-AAA, tank ZiS-5, radio station 5-AK GAZ-AAA, sanitary GAZ-AAA before motorized rifle regiment in the 23 infantry corps, 10 infantry division and 90 motorized infantry division.

    If we add to this picture of the state of the NWF technology almost complete lack of communication, enemy attacks from the air, armed gangs and sabotage groups on the roads, then it should be considered a miracle that the fact that the troops and staffs of the 11th and 8th armies were withdrawn from the encirclement. At the same time, the actions of the headquarters of the front 22-30.6.41. can be considered a failure - namely, the headquarters of the front, led by its chief and commander of the front, the Military Council of the front as a whole. Which was soon done by the Bet.
    1. +2
      25 September 2018 09: 20
      This sad picture can be supplemented by the fact that the district warehouse of tank, automotive and other spare parts was located by the PribOVO headquarters in Dvinsk (Daugavpils), 300 km from Libava-Siauliai, for which the district headquarters is also responsible. The Germans broke into Dvinsk as the vanguard of the "Dead Head" trade house on 28.6.41. With this vanguard for Dvinsk until 01.08. the under-formed 21 MK of General Leliushenko fought, but could not recapture the city and the crossing over the Western Dvina (Daugava). He was able to delay the enemy offensive at the most important water line only for 3-4 days.
    2. -2
      25 September 2018 11: 13
      Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
      If we add to this picture of the state of the technology of the NWP an almost complete lack of communication,

      The picture is of course depressing, and this best speaks of why the defeat of the troops took place in the summer of 1941. And here an interesting question arises - who should answer for the fact that the military infrastructure was skewed in terms of weapons and equipment, when the quantitative factor was at the expense of quality, and what our commanders thought in the mid-thirties when they adopted weapons programs. Or, as always, blame everything on Stalin?
      After all, not one Tukhachevsky quirked with weapons until he was shot - the rest of the generals did not understand that sophisticated equipment would require a completely different approach to maintenance and repair, and only uneducated people could not take this into account.
      1. +2
        28 September 2018 19: 35
        You, apparently, did not read much on the topic of the 30s in the USSR. Read about industrialization and collectivization. If this had not been carried out as soon as possible, the country would not have survived the war at all. I advise you to read the speeches of Stalin at the congresses of the CPSU (b) in the 30s. Including about Trotskyism, biases and conspiracies, purges, etc. But in the end, the country survived thanks to the generals as well. But betrayal was also, it is a fact.
        1. -2
          28 September 2018 20: 48
          Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
          0
          You, apparently, did not read much on the topic of the 30s in the USSR. Read about industrialization and collectivization.

          I think that you were too far from developing an armament program, that’s why you have no idea what kind of bias in armaments can be if the commanders begin to bend the line based on their preferences, and not understanding how this will turn out for the troops during the war.
          1. +2
            1 October 2018 21: 27
            Since 1959 I wore shoulder straps, I had a personal weapon RP-46 machine gun (in Suvorov, from the age of 13), and then studied at the Armored Academy, dear. I served with front-line officers, and my father and mother were front-line soldiers. Study the "armament imbalances" from the dozens of sources that I was taught by professors-colonels who had gone through the war.
            1. -3
              1 October 2018 22: 40
              Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
              Since 1959 I wore shoulder straps, I had a personal weapon RP-46 machine gun (in Suvorov, from the age of 13), and then studied at the Armored Academy, dear. I served with front-line officers, and my father and mother were front-line soldiers. Study the "armament imbalances" from the dozens of sources that I was taught by professors-colonels who had gone through the war.

              You are not the only one, although I did not study at Suvorovsky. Only my participants in the war not only taught, but also commanded - as they say, feel the difference. And what imbalance in armaments can be, I know from practice, and not from someone else's recollections.
  25. +2
    28 September 2018 11: 53
    It is a pity that the author does not have a higher military education and experience in commanding work in the linear units of the ground forces. If she had all this behind her shoulders, she would have seen 100% more in the picture of the pre-war month of 1941, described in the following testimony: "V.I.Shcherbakov (commander of the 50th brigade):" The plan for covering the border provided for tasks and options for the actions in case of war, the same plan defined the defense zones of the SD and regiments, including up to company defensive areas. The OPs of both ground and anti-aircraft artillery up to the battery, inclusive, were determined ... The cover plan provided for the procedure for the withdrawal of troops from the PPD to the border into their own zones and defense areas ...

    The trained lines and defense areas were not constantly occupied by the troops, but the troops were withdrawn by units from time to time to their areas for their equipment. Parts were withdrawn to their defense areas, as a rule, on alert.

    43 and 123 RD, as well as corps units began to move to the border at my signal, which was provided for by the cover plan on the basis of the received directive of the People's Commissar of Defense. The directive was transmitted from the headquarters of the LMO at about 4 o'clock on June 22 ... The withdrawal of troops to the border began at 6-30 June 22 ... "The point is that the author is not able to imagine the volume of work of the headquarters (!) On the DETAILED plan for the deployment of" troops before positions of batteries and company defensive areas. In the shortest possible time and with damage to the planned work. And can not imagine the amount of military work on these plans on the ground. ALL THE IDIOTISM OF EMPTY AND HARMFUL LOSS OF TIME. For which NOBODY answered.
  26. +2
    28 September 2018 19: 09
    Advice to the author - emphasize the most important facts. For example, the absence (vacation in Sochi) of the main person in Leningrad and the LVO - Zhdanov. This alone proves that the outbreak of war at dawn on 22.6.41. DO NOT WAIT. Even the absence at the headquarters of the LVO of the commander of the LVO and his deputy is secondary in comparison with this fact. Without a city committee and a regional committee, mobilization by military enlistment offices alone could not have been carried out — mobilization is not only an appeal to the registered military service, but mobilization of transport and industry, the entire national economy, and civil defense. Further - the evidence is given that in the north of the LVO at 7.07. 22.06.41. there was a breakthrough of German troops across the Soviet-Finnish border. This is the most important evidence of the time of the beginning of the Finland attack on the USSR. The fact is that the Finns are still trying to prove that it was the USSR that invaded Finland, launched shelling and bombing of its territory on 25.06.41. ACCENT YOUR MOST IMPORTANT FACTS.
    1. -2
      28 September 2018 20: 55
      Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
      Even the absence at the headquarters of the LVO of the commander of the LVO and his deputy is secondary in comparison with this fact.

      This is an obvious exaggeration - on the contrary, given that there was a very small group against the LVO, and given the experience of the Finnish one, we can safely say that having a commander or chief of staff of the district is much more important than the party leadership of the city. By the way, the commanders of the districts always have their own plane at hand, and they could deliver Zhdanov from Sochi within 8-12 hours.
  27. +1
    29 September 2018 09: 11
    All 20 publications "Unexpected War" are very good. useful and informative, provide new facts and documents. But the research by YET is weakened by a weak emphasis on the following points. Firstly, the fact that a fairly competent preparation for war in the LVO and almost complete absence of losses on the day of June 22 and the first week of DEFENSE hostilities, the planned deployment of troops did not save Leningrad from a 900-day blockade with a total of millions of casualties in battles at the front. under bombardment and shelling in the near and far rear. This proves that the factor of surprise in the attack by Germany and its allies (practically united Russophobes and anti-Soviet Europeans) on the USSR on 22.06.41. was not decisive. This factor stopped working after 25.06.41/100/22.07.41. by 1939%, but the avalanche retreat on all fronts continued even after 40, when a general mobilization in the country had already taken place. But Leningrad was, nevertheless, blocked and surrounded completely already in August-September (the Finns who were beaten in 9.00-22.06.41 reached Ladoga), and in October the threat of encirclement hung over Moscow, after the surrender of the capitals of the union republics - Vilnius, Minsk, Riga, Tallinn, Chisinau and Kiev, which were surrendered to the enemy almost WITHOUT DEFENSE, with huge losses for the army and the country. Secondly, from 10 on 10. not a single military unit of the Red Army could already refer to this factor of surprise, all the troops and fleets by this hour were notified of the start of a FULL-SCALE war, and not a provocation. All the troops began to carry out the notorious "counter-strike" plan to "cover the border" by Marshal Tymoshenko and his "personal headquarters" CONSCIOUS CHEERERS. Thirdly, treason also lurked in strategic military intelligence, agent and analytical, in particular, in the part of the Southern theater of operations. In Bulgaria there were up to 30 thousand Germans, less than a division, but intelligence reported 35 divisions. In Romania, there was ONE, from the strength of TWO security divisions, and intelligence and our vaunted General Staff reported on 10-11 divisions. On the Black Sea there was only ONE old Romanian submarine, and the General Staff reported on 1941-42 Italian and German ones. Our fleet scattered the sea from Odessa to Batumi with minefields, and the shores - with coastal "antiamphibious" defense divisions, starting from Odessa and Sevastopol ... Our transports began to blow up on their mines! The enemy did not land any landings in the Black Sea region! But Odessa was surrendered, and then the enemy was stupidly let into the Crimea, breaking through the isthmus defenses with just a company of captured KV tanks. What "unexpectedness" can explain this crime ?! This should be emphasized, as well as failures with the quantity and quality of weapons and ammunition. These are the main reasons for the defeats of the Red Army in XNUMX-XNUMX.
    1. -2
      29 September 2018 10: 35
      Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
      Thirdly, in strategic military intelligence, undercover and analytical, there was also treason, in particular with regard to the Southern Theater. In Bulgaria, there were up to 10 thousand Germans, less divisions, but intelligence reported 10 divisions. In Romania there was ONE, from the strength of TWO security divisions, and intelligence and our vaunted General Staff reported 30-35 divisions.

      There was no special "betrayal" there - you obviously invented that. With regard to the data on the number, in such cases, you should indicate the source of the information, for example, the intelligence report of June 15 or some other declassified document. Otherwise, you may not be able to separate the flies from the cutlets, so such accusations come up.
      1. +1
        1 October 2018 21: 44
        I read and strive to help the author with Part 1, and build on her interesting numbers in various parts of her work. And her figures are taken from declassified intelligence reports and intelligence reports. I have not accusations, but advice to a talented author, a respected connoisseur of flies and cutlets, as well as "emerging accusations." Accusations are precisely "flies", and supplementary advice to the author is, accordingly, "cutlets". Can you tell?
        1. -3
          1 October 2018 22: 44
          Quote: Mikhail Zubkov
          I read and strive to help the author with Part 1, and am based on her interesting figures in different parts of her work. And her numbers are taken from declassified intelligence reports and intelligence reports.

          The simple idea that not everything that got into intelligence was subsequently confirmed, or that what was indicated in them, was changed by the enemy after a short time, apparently did not visit you. And in vain, because the author cannot systematize them, much less determine what level of reliability is present in them.