The unexpected war of Hitler's Germany with the USSR (part 14)

71

Your attitude to the proposed series of articles:

I don’t like it a lot because the author is inclined to distort events - 46 (6.76%)
6.76%
Just don't like it - 13 (1.91%)
1.91%
There are moments that I did not previously know or did not think about - 174 (25.59%)
25.59%
Liked! I look forward to continuing - 447 (65.74%)
65.74%


We will continue consideration of the topic, which was not finished in the previous part. Another misconception is the highly overstated view of the top leadership of the Red Army about the capabilities of air defense when covering ground forces. GKZhukov (SVKS): “... To cover the anti-aircraft artillery of the strike and mobile groups with fire, you need to cover the area along the front in 30 km and in depth 30 km - 900 sq. Km. One ass can cover 160 square kilometers with fire, and 900 square meters to cover it. km will require an 6 ass ... "(The report is probably about the ass, which is armed with twelve medium-caliber anti-aircraft guns.)



During the war years, the ozadas, armed with 37- and 76-mm guns, were able to cover the troops with double-layer fire on an area of ​​2 km along the front and 2,5 km in depth (only 5 sq. Km). Even if all three batteries in the ass are armed with 76-mm guns, it is unlikely that they would cover a 160-square-foot area. km Since the spacecraft has not previously encountered massive use aviation against its parts, we see a reassessment of the capabilities of air defense to cover ground troops from enemy aircraft. And this is not strange, since Soviet aviation was the first to seize air supremacy.

In 1940, the industry supplied anti-aircraft missiles to the NKO: 37-mm - 21% of the plan, and for 85-mm - 35%. In the first half of 1941, the plan was completed on 37-mm projectiles on 81% and on 85-mm on 99%. Total for one and a half years not planned anti-aircraft projectiles were delivered: 37-mm - 99%, and 85-mm - 66%.

In accordance with the norms of consumption of ammunition for one day of intense combat, small-caliber anti-aircraft artillery allowed 100 shots per day, and for medium-caliber (76-mm and 85-mm) shots 84. The annual consumption rate of ammunition was: on 37-mm gun - 6000 shells (on average per day 6000 / 365 = 16,4 projectile), on 76 and 85-mm - 5040 shells (5040 / 365 = 13,8). The table shows data on the number of guns, on the stocks of shells and on the number of shells per gun in the border districts.

The unexpected war of Hitler's Germany with the USSR (part 14)


The draft “Strategic Deployment Plans for the Armed Forces of the Soviet Union ...” by 15.5.41 stated: “The deployment of troops and their combat operations with available reserves are provided (by anti-aircraft guns): 37-mm - for 5 days; 76-mm - for six weeks; 85-mm - on 11 days... "

Taking into account the number of days in the border districts of the anti-aircraft guns and the number of days specified in the “Plans ...” it was planned to spend the following day: 37 / 539 = 5, 108 = 76, 1291 = 45, 28 -mm - 85 / 235 = 11 pcs. Is it a lot or a little? In the memoirs of the air defense veterans it is mentioned about the consumption of medium-caliber assault shells of several thousand for one German air raid. In the author's understanding, "several thousand" is from 21 thousand shells and more. From the calculation of 3 guns in the ass, the consumption of 12 shells per raid is obtained. This amount of shells lasts just 250 minutes of continuous shooting. Now it’s clear: why the Zenap, armed with 10-mm guns, were left without shells on the 85 or 1 day and were taken away with the materiel to the rear.

The situation was similar with the 37-mm anti-aircraft guns. In PribOVO, on average, the gun accounted for 600 shells, which is more than in other districts. In ZOVOVO and KOVO there were no projectiles for these systems at all. But even in PribOVO, on the second day of the war, the 37-mm gun batteries were transferred to a “hungry” ration - there were almost no shells left. It turns out that small-caliber artillery shot off all the existing 300-600 shells for the 1-2 of the day.

Thus, if the industry in the 1940 year (the year when the 37 and 85-mm anti-aircraft guns began to enter the spacecraft) and in the first half of the 1941 year completed the anti-aircraft projectile plan, even this additional amount would hardly be enough for 2- 3 intense day war at the rate of fire, which fired anti-aircraft gunners.

Probably, anti-aircraft gunners shot too much and often. Admiral A.G. described something similar. Golovko: "Coastal anti-aircraft batteries and naval artillery continually fiercely but still uselessly fire at aircraft: at strangers and at their own... ”The author does not discuss the question: how did the artillery shoot and how should it have been fired. He only notes that the available stock of shells for 37-mm and 85-mm guns (even with regard to central warehouses) was not enough to cover the spacecraft during the first tense days of the war.

In other words, when assessing the conduct of hostilities by specialists of the General Staff, clearly underestimated consumption rates of antiaircraft ammunition were used to repel less intense enemy air raids. Again, we are faced with sluggish fighting before the transfer of industry to "war rails".

The author assumes that the commanders of anti-aircraft units and zones did not know that there were practically no ammunition stocks for their guns (with the exception of 76-mm anti-aircraft guns). They shot every last piece of iron in the hope that, along with the innumerable compounds of the spacecraft that came to their aid, they would also bring a huge amount of projectiles. In reality, in the central warehouses there was less than one BK for 37-mm guns and less than 0,5 BK for 85-mm guns. Subsequently, the release of anti-aircraft shells grew to the required volume.

In conclusion of the material presented on the reports and speeches at the SVKS, I would like to draw attention to the fact that the senior command personnel correctly understood the actions of the German tank and motorized troops, which were united in mobile (tank) groups.

P.L.Romanenko (commander 1 mk): "The German army decided the operation in the West mainly mechanized and aviation connections ... The decisive element of the operation of the German army was the mechanized army of the Reichenau group [below F.I. Golikov will clarify that such an army did not exist]. This army broke into Namur independently, north of Sedan, cut the front of the French and Belgian armies and later completed the encirclement of the army group operating in Belgium, and ultimately played a decisive role in the final defeat of France ... The Germans, having a significantly smaller number of tanks than we , they took into account that the strike force in modern warfare is composed of mechanized and air formations and all their tanks were assembled into operational units, massaged and assigned decisive independent operations to them.... »

F.I.Golikov (Deputy Head of General Staff, Head of RU): “To 10 in May, the German command concentrated 110-120 DD, 8-10 etc., to 4 md, 2-3 air fleets ... The 200 army centered on the impact direction, from the northern border of Belgium to the southern border of Luxembourg, 4 army, 60 front 3 tank groups, not united in a mechanized army, consisting of up to 8 td and 3-4 md, as well as the main forces of military aviation... »

D.G.Pavlov (commander ZOVOVO): "During the German-Polish war the Germans launched on their border 5 mobile groups on the front to 600 km, total 12 td, 7 light and 5 md. In the border battle, mobile groups operated with infantry, the average daily advance was 10-12 km. The depth of penetration 20-40 km. Only a group of Guderian, without meeting resistance, immediately went to a depth of 100 km. This leg of the day lasted for 3-4 ...

Having broken the resistance of the Poles and quickly put themselves in order, mobile groups started the pursuit. The depth of the operational maneuver reached 200-400 km, daily transitions were 50-60 km. The duration of the detachment from the infantry reached 2-5 days ... Such use of mechanical connections led to the fact that Poland was defeated in 16-17 days.

When the seizure of Holland, Belgium and Luxembourg, the Germans acted by the same methods as in Poland. Total 4 groups were deployed. total number of 9 td, several md and up to 60000 motorcyclists. If the defense was not particularly strong, then the mobile groups immediately broke into the depths; for the 3 of the day in the Netherlands, the group passed about 140 km. In the same place, where the defense was solid, as on the Wilhelm Canal, the defense was broken first by infantry, and then mobile groups were thrown into the breakthrough. The use of mechgroups allowed the Germans to seize Holland in three days, smash the Anglo-French in Belgium in 15 days.

Operation in northern France began with a breakthrough Weygan line consisting of field defensive, hastily constructed, without concrete, constructions. Moving groups, all three, acted in close cooperation with the infantry, penetrating into the depth of the French troops on 5-7 km. Total participated in the breakthrough of about 2000 tanks - or up to 50% of all tanks concentrated on the front ...

After breaking through Weygan's line mobile groups were thrown into a breakthrough and, ahead of the retreating French troops on the Seine and the Loire rivers, did not allow the French to organize a defense against them. The magnitude of daily transitions in this period was 50-60 km, reaching on some days for certain groups up to 100 km per day. For the period from 5 to 22 July, i.e. for the 18 days of the German army’s advance of mechanized units, the French army was not able to offer significant resistance
... »

It turns out senior officers knewthat mototankovye parts and compounds should be used in groups: in mobile or tank groups. Why did the author pay attention to this fact? Just because in the prewar RM 1941 of the year there is no mention of any of them at our borders - they were not found. Only tb, tp, td and md (in bulk) were noted in the RM without a single command. Quite a lot of TB and TP are combined into some conditional TD. With this we will face in the next part. It should be understood that the operational depth to which tb - tp - td - mk can advance in an offensive is different. This is ensured by their structures.

For example, if there is a group of 6-9 TB or two TP, then it is not equivalent to td. This group (even if it has more tanks) will not be able to advance to the same operational depth for several days, which TD or MK could afford. For this, it lacks the headquarters (control), numerous subunits of communications, repair and maintenance, reconnaissance, sapper, anti-aircraft artillery and infantry units. In addition, all these units and parts must be motorized.

Therefore, if there are no headquarters (parts of divisional or corps subordination), individual tp and tb can only serve to reinforce front or backfighting (or move with the pace of infantry movement) or be used to reinforce ppm (which may include tb or tp). The pace of advancement of the reinforced MD will be somewhat higher than that of the AK units, but the operational depth of the breakthrough will be determined by the infantry, i.e. such a division will be tied to the AK. The most interesting thing is that a staff member of the Regional Office PribOVO in March 1941 delivered information that TB will be included in MD. In principle, it is logical, since it was implemented in the Soviet MD. Our intelligence during this period did not know that the Germans did not have enough tanks even for manning the existing ones. The Germans will try to implement this idea only in 1942 year ...

Of course, it is possible to create a large moto-tank group of army subordination of several MD and tank units. The creation of such a group, the organization of its headquarters and the addition of necessary parts at the expense of army formations and unions (including the withdrawal of some officers from the headquarters at all levels) can be tracked by our intelligence (too much turmoil and coordination of everything and everything rises in the troops). To ensure such a group will require a huge amount of vehicles, weapons and communications equipment from the army, which is not superfluous. This was understood by the German generals and therefore they hid their tank groups. The leaders of the spacecraft understood this and waited for the appearance of large mototank groups of Germans near our borders, which did not appear (in the Republic of Moldova) before the start of the war ... Next, in several parts we will look at information provided by intelligence to the leadership of the USSR and the Spacecraft, and also talk a little about deployment of spacecraft troops.

And intelligence reported exactly. In 1 and 2 parts of this cycle, materials were presented that indicate that many of the RM contained contradictory and even fantastic information about the plans of the German leadership regarding the USSR. This misinformation was actively “flipped” by the first persons and special services of Germany, attracted by numerous officials, military and other specialists.

More or less accurate dates of the German attack on the USSR began to appear in the Republic of Moldova since the first decade of June. In parallel with the reports on more or less exact terms, the Republic of Moldova received information on postponing the start of the war to the end of June, to August, and also about refusing to attack the USSR when the country's leadership fulfills certain conditions. As an example, consider several such messages.

Special message. "Senior" 09.06.41: "Next week, the tension in the Russian question will reach its highest point, and the question of war will be finally resolved. Germany will present to the USSR a demand to provide the Germans with economic leadership in Ukraine and the use of the Soviet military fleet against England... "

Special message. "X": 10.6.41: "If Stalin does not come to Berlin, then the war is inevitable. Germany made demands on the USSR: a) additional supplies of 2,5 million tons of grain; b) free transit to Persia and military occupation of Soviet grain warehouses for 4-5 million tons. The deadline for accepting offers is 23 June 1941 g... "

Special message. Ramsay 17.06.41: "The German courier told BAT ... that the war against the USSR was probably delayed until the end of June. BAT does not know there will be war or not... »

In the Soviet embassy in Berlin, in the very center of Germany, not everyone expects the start of the 22 war of June. The report of the German agent 21.6.41 about the opinion of a Soviet employee: "The situation is very serious ... We firmly believe that Hitler started a giant bluff. We do not believe that war can begin tomorrow. The process is likely to continue. It is clear that the Germans intend to put pressure on us in the hope of obtaining the benefits that Hitler needs to continue the war.... »

The author fully agrees with the opinion P.A.Sudoplatova (Deputy Head of the NKGB USSR):The most convincing data on the timing of the attack appeared in 2-3 the day before the start of the war.... »

We will begin to consider the events and arrivals of the Republic of Moldova from the spring - summer of 1940. In 1940 and in the first half of 1941. NKO intelligence (5 RKKA Directorate, 1940 since July — RU GSH) and NKVD (5 department of the NKVD GUGB) constantly exchanged information about German troops stationed or relocated both at the USSR border and in the rest of the Reich. As an example, consider several documents.

Note by the Deputy People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the BSSR in the NKVD of the USSR 14.7.40: “...According to the Belarusian Border District, with 1 to 7 July this year. seven divisions of the German troops arrived in Warsaw and its environs... »

Note by the NKVD of the USSR to the Central Committee of the CPSU (b) I.V. Stalin, USSR SNK V.Molotov and K.Ye. Voroshilov, NKO USSR S.K.Timoshenko 15.7.40: "According to the border troops of the Belarusian District, from 1 to 7 July this year. seven divisions of the German troops arrived in Warsaw and its environs... "

The RM from the border guards arrive at the central NKVD administration and from there are sent: to Stalin, to the SNK and to the NGOs. The path of materials from the border to Stalin takes about 2 day. Perhaps this time is even less, but the lack of time stamps for sending and receiving documents does not allow you to determine the time more accurately. Of course, it takes a certain time for the Republic of Moldova to arrive from commandant's offices and detachments in the border area. Probably by analogy, this time is also about a day. Thus, the Republic of Moldova very swiftly (for that time) circulate from the RO and intelligence points to the RO of the central department, from where they reach the country's leadership and other departments. For example, the aforementioned RM got into reconnaissance of the General Staff. It is possible that these materials could get to the leadership of the General Staff and RU already on July 15.

Summary of the 5 Office of the Red Army 20.07.1940 [totals on 16.7.40 city]: "...According to the NKVD, requiring verification, in the area of ​​Warsaw arrived from 1 to 7 in July to 7 front... »

Information received from the NKVD of the BSSR is used operatively by the RP GSH when compiling their RMs, which in turn are sent to the recipients. The addressees include: Stalin (2 copies), Beria, RO VO (regarding them), etc. It can be assumed that the time of passage of the above RM to the addressees is also about a day.

RO NKVD (later RO NKGB) regularly request RG GS about the assessment provided by the Republic of Moldova. The 5 department of the RU GSH regularly responds to these 7 ... 10 requests every day. The last published pre-war estimate has a date of 7.6.41.

Special message. Head of the 5 Department of the State Security Department of the NKVD of the USSR, Fitin 7.08.1940: "I am sending a rating on your materials No. 5 / 10088, 5 / 10089 and No. 10092 from 27 July 1940 g ... Information about the transfer of German troops in the eastern direction is of interest and valuable. They mostly confirm the data we have, and in some cases almost duplicate them.... "

From the presented message it is clear that the Republic of Moldova of different intelligence services confirm or duplicate each other. A situation is impossible when one intelligence service has numerous RM about a certain event and does not inform the other service about it. In addition to the monthly assessments of the Republic of Moldova, there were urgent documents for which the NKVD RO requested an extraordinary assessment.

Special message 9.7.1940: "I ask you to urgently give an assessment of the following agent data:

1. The former English king Edward, along with his wife Simson, is currently in Madrid, from which he maintains contact with Hitler. Edward conducts negotiations with Hitler on the formation of a new English government, the conclusion of peace with Germany under the condition of a military alliance against the USSR.
2. In the coming days, the Germans planned large offensive operations against England.
3. The German and Italian ATU in Bucharest stated that in the future Bessarabia, as well as Soviet Moldova, would be rejected from the USSR ... Head of 5 of the Department of State Security of the NKVD of the USSR Fitin
»

On the eve of the war, the so-called interdepartmental council of the NKVD-NKGB and the NKO will be created to coordinate intelligence work. Inside this board, there is also an exchange of RM.

Special Post RU GSH KA in the NKGB USSR 29.03.1941: "Your recent data on the transfer of German troops and military cargo to the borders of the USSR are plausible. They are confirmed by a number of our sources. Information about the transfer of two TD in Tripoli is also quite plausible... »

From the presented message it is clear that the RMs coming through the NKGB to a certain extent already exist in the RC GS. It is also known that Beria sent the RM to Stalin in the SNK. Only from published materials it is difficult to determine how often this happened.

Report of the NKVD of the USSR in the Central Committee of the CPSU (b), SNK USSR and NKO USSR 21.04.1941: " From 1 to 19 on April 1941 by border detachments of the NKVD of the USSR on the Soviet-German border, the following data was obtained on the arrival of German troops at points adjacent to the state border in East Prussia and the Governor-General Beria»

The Head of the NKGB Directorate also regularly sends RM I.Stalinu to the CPC.

The headquarters of the western border VO also prepared reports on the materials of the illegal agents of the RO district, according to the observations of the intelligence agencies of subordinate units, formations and associations. The Republic of Moldova received from the border detachments stationed in the district.

Thus, in addition to the exchange of the RM through the central departments, there is an exchange of information between neighboring districts (in terms of their relation), between the border detachments (commandant's offices) and the headquarters of divisions, corps, and armies. It turns out that the information coming from the GS GSH is partially already available in the RO VO. The information received from the border guards is also included in the intelligence reports of the district headquarters, which are sent to the RU GSH and to the headquarters of the neighboring HE. There is a duplication of intelligence information at all levels. In addition, the information received from the border guards is verified by the Regional Department of the Military District of Uzbekistan, and the Republic of Moldova received from the NKVD of the USSR is checked by the GS.

In Intelligence Headquarters SOBOVO from 20.6.41 says: "According to RO PribOVO on 16.6, 291 DD is deployed in Klaipeda, Šilutė - 161 md.... »

In turn, in the RM headquarters Pribovo from 21.6.41 is indicated: "In the area of ​​Letzen, Allenstein, Johannisburg (data RO ZOVOVO) ... According to the 105-th border detachment in Klaipeda, the headquarters of the 61 station is marked, in the forest ... - up to two battalions of tanks (data require verification). Note. The data of our intelligence headquarters 61 th PD in Klaipeda was not observed... »

Thus, due to repeatedly duplicated information, it is impossible to hide or distort the RM by any high-ranking intelligence official. Hiding or distorting the RM would lead to the arrest of this person. The only question is: how many days will this happen.

Two copies of the Republic of Uzbekistan Republican General Staff were sent to JV Stalin. What he wrote on them, dribbled, considered what notes he made for himself - we do not know. But, the presence of two copies of one document testifies that he worked painstakingly and carefully with the RM, tracking the data provided. Perhaps he knew as well as Tymoshenko and Zhukov the situation with the German factions on the border, and maybe he knew even better ...

P.A. Sudoplatov: "By distorting the real picture of the leadership of Stalin, Molotov, Beria, Voroshilov, Tymoshenko by the Soviet intelligence activity, the leaders of the KGB and GRU GSh's foreign intelligence in 1960-1980 also voluntarily and involuntarily joined ... On the eve of the war, the intelligence officers “Reported exactly”, and the dictator Stalin ... criminally ignored the authentic RM about the German attack ... We did not open misinformation actions of the enemy’s intelligence and his satellites on the eve of the outbreak of war... »

We consider the RM, which came from various intelligence structures. In other parts, we will see what the command of the spacecraft and the leadership of the country could see in the intelligence provided.

Not to be repeated in the future, we note that scouts of all levels tried, without sparing their lives, to obtain information about the German attack on our country. It is not their fault that they were confronted with the highest class of misinformation. At that time, no one could have thought about the possibility of such a large-scale opposition to our intelligence. The data obtained by intelligence included misinformation, which the Nazis skillfully slipped through many different channels. People who process the RM in the Center and get acquainted with it, considered that this information is confirmed by many sources that are not related to each other. However, it was only misinformation from many sources. This, according to the author, was one of the main reasons for wrong decisions taken by the leadership of the country and the army on the eve of the war. Later, our intelligence officers worked more efficiently than the enemy intelligence services and, in turn, repeatedly misled the Nazis.

In addition to the presence of misinformation in the Republic of Moldova, there were The second reason, which led to an incorrect assessment of the events on the eve of June 22. it incorrect estimation of the number of divisions, after redeployment of which, Germany will decide to attack the USSR. In presenting the following material, the author decided to adhere to the chronology when describing events and documents. This will make it somewhat difficult to get acquainted with the material of the article, since the RM will alternate with other NPO documents.

Even before the capitulation of France, there was a German grouping numbering around the 30 division on the Soviet-German border (hereinafter - on the border). In April-May 1940, the transfer of German troops to the west and north was recorded. The published reports refer to the movement of relatively small forces.

Summary of the Fifth Directorate of the Red Army 3.5.40: "According to a noteworthy source, April 11 from the Zamoscie district departed to the Western Front 209 PD, instead of which arrived 110, 210, 219 and 88 nn (No. of the division they are part of, is not installed). From the area of ​​Krakow, the troops are moving in an unknown direction, and instead of them arrive parts of the Gestapo ...

10 on April from the airfields near the city of Warsaw sent 400 bombers to the Norwegian front and about 2500 people of the flight crew. At the same aerodromes, there are up to 200 aircraft, including 160 bombers and 40 fighters
... »

Summary of the Fifth Directorate of the Red Army 23.05.1940: "...According to RO KOVO, the transfer of German troops stationed on the territory of the former Poland to the western front is observed from 13 in May. From 13 to 16.5 from Tarnow to Krakow proceeded to 3 infantry regiments...

In the Republic of Moldova, the number of German troops operating in the west is greatly overestimated.

Summary of the Fifth Directorate of the Red Army on events in the West 14.05.40: "The total number of the German army in the West is 8 million people - exaggerated, it must be assumed that at present there are no more than 5-6 million people. The rise of new reserves of up to 4 million people in the near future is in doubt, in general, Germany is able to put up an additional amount... "5-6 million people in the German Armed Forces during the war with the Allied forces in the West - this is an excessively high estimate. Interestingly: what size did the German group have to reach when attacking the more powerful Soviet army in the spring and summer of 1941, according to the leadership of the spacecraft?

After the capitulation of France, Germany planned to once again strengthen the grouping of troops near our border.

Memorandum Deputy Chief of the General Staff to the USSR People's Commissar of Defense on a meeting with the German ATN 9.7.1940: “General Koestring told me that on the instructions of the Chief of the General Staff he had to report that the command of the German army had decided to demobilize his army. This demobilization should be expressed in the dismissal of older ages from units located in East Prussia and in the territory of the former Poland, instead of demobilized into these units, soldiers of young ages will be transferred.

In addition, the transfer of troops to permanent locations in East Prussia and the formation of new garrisons in Poland will be made, since in the west they now do not need to keep a lot of troops. In this regard, large movements of troops will be made in East Prussia and in the territory of Poland ... The head of the General Staff of the German Army instructed him to bring this to the attention of the General Staff of the SC in advance, before the start of military traffic ... Smorodinov
"Newsletter:"NKO, Stalin, Molotov»

Summary RU GSH KA: "On the territory of V. Prussia on 15 June it was established before 7 PD and 2 qp ... On the territory of the Bolshoy Polshi on June 15 was located before 20 CD and 4 qp ...

During the period from 19.6 to 14.7, the 5 Directorate and the ZOVOVO and KOVO RO were marked up by 860 military echelons, proceeding from the west in the east and southeast directions. As a result, it can be assumed that during this period, Prussia was transferred from the West to 6 PD (and in them up to two MD ...), 5 CP, over two TBR (TBR and six TB) ...

To territory b. In Poland over the same period, the following number of units and connections arrived: ... Against CECO - before 3 front-door and tp; ... Against KOVO - before 5 PD, CP and tank units of unspecified numbers ...

In Austria - on the Slovak-Hungarian-Yugoslav border 12 – 13 divisions, of which 2 etc. In addition, in the region of Zvolen (Slovakia), a tank part of an unspecified number and numbering is noted.
... "

In fact, at that time, in the specified areas there were about 31 of the German division. The divisions noted in the report were deployed at a distance from 20 ... 30 to 50 ... 150 km from the border. In the summary against PribOVO, tbr and six tb are noted, which are conventionally combined into another tbr. Intelligence did not establish the belonging of this brigade and battalions to specific tank units or formations. The published information from the Republic of Moldova on whether there were any tank units near the border of the USSR at the current time. Upon request, the RU GSH intelligence of the NKVD received information about the availability of equipment in TB.

Special message. Head RU GSH KA 2.8.40: "At your request ... I inform you that according to the intelligence information obtained in recent days from various sources, it has been established: ... in TB located in the territory of V. Prussia and b.Polshi, there are 133 light and medium tanks... »

The figure shows the data on the number of German divisions in accordance with the RM RU GSH and their actual number. The difference between the actual number and the "discovered" intelligence shows once again testifies to the excellent work of the German intelligence and military command.

It should be noted that in the figure, the dependences are plotted according to control points related to the dates of arrival of the Republic of Moldova, which do not coincide with the dates of the presence of the actual number of German divisions at the border during this period. On the sections of the curves between the control points, the number of connections may be distorted, since unknown speed of movement of connections between control points. Therefore, the data in the figure are reliable only at control points, and between them they create a conjectural picture (given for data visualization).

In the Republic of Uzbekistan RU GSH in certain areas presents the range of existing divisions at the border. For the minimum values ​​of this range, the dependence of the minimum number of divisions is constructed, and for the maximum values ​​- the maximum.



According to RU GSH from 11.5.40 to 1.9.40, the number of divisions near the border increases from 31 to 90. 90 divisions are 73% groupingwhich will invade our territory 22.6.41. In fact, on the 1.11.40 near the border (against the troops of PribOVO, ZOVOVO and KOVO, including the territory of Austria) there is only 32 division.
It turns out that by the end of August 1940, our intelligence counted near the border almost 3 / 4 of an assault force, which 22.6.41 would invade the territory of the USSR. At the same time, almost all the same areas were considered, which will be considered in the future from April to June 1941. Only the territory of Romania, which at that time did not have German connections, did not enter.

NKVD intelligence 24.8.40 reports an even more fantastic number of German troops: "The German ambassador in Belgrade told the military minister of Yugoslavia that the Germans had concentrated 75 divisions in Poland, of which 18 md. According to the plan, the 120 divisions should be concentrated on the Soviet-German border. Please rate the reported material.... "Number of divisions overestimated on 28 compared to the already overestimated data of the RU GSH.
The large gap between the “discovered” reconnaissance compounds and their actual number leads the author to the idea that coincidence of the number of divisions to 22.6.41 is a random factor.. Having a different angle of inclination, the dependencies shown in the figure should have crossed somewhere ...

Is 90 "discovered" German divisions a lot or a little? These divisions are deployed against the troops of Pribovo, Zapovo and part of the forces of KOVO. In early September, 40-th is not yet German troops in Romania. On 17.6.41, intelligence will “locate” in Romania (near our border) to 18 German divisions. It is well known that according to 22.6.41 intelligence, the German group at our border (including the territory of Romania) consisted of 129 divisions (in fact, they were 124). If you add German divisions in Romania to 90 connections, you get the number 108. 108 divisions are 87% of the invasion grouping. Thus, in the territory where the 90 divisions are allegedly deployed, the entire 16 is not enough to the number that will be concentrated in this territory by 22.6.41.

Some writers are confident that they say that the command of the spacecraft was very confident at the beginning of the war, namely 22.6.41. So why aren't they preparing for the September 1940 war? To transfer the remaining 16 divisions for the German command is a matter of a few days.

Many documents from that period provide data on the number of German trains per day in different directions.

For example, "Lublin grouping ... railway capacity, leading to the Visla river - 72 pairs ..., i.e. per day is possible to bring one division... »

«Krakow grouping ... railway capacity up to the Visla river line 126 par ..., i.e. gives you the opportunity to bring up to 2 divisions every day... »

«Hungarian grouping ... The capacity of the 126 railway pairs ... You can bring up two divisions per day... »

«East Prussia ... the railway network with a total capacity of up to 300 pairs of trains per day, of which up to 200 can be used for operational traffic, ensures that, on the 12-th day of mobilization, concentration up to 40 enhanced traffic... "If we carry out the simplest calculation, we get that the speed of concentration in the direction of East Prussia is more than three divisions per day.

There is no data on the assessment of rail transportation in the direction of Warsaw - Zapovo border, but it can be assumed that in this direction it is possible to transport up to 2 divisions per day. In this way, within two days the missing 16 divisions could be at the border.

So why not particularly prepared for the attack of Germany in the month of September? After all, there was a sharp increase in the grouping since May 1940, almost 3 times, and no one could guarantee that there would not be a further increase in one week (during this time you can transfer more than 50 ... 60 divisions). But they did not prepare because they were sure: Germans are required much more divisions than available 90 (Of these, 9 TD and 4 MD) and also require much more motorcycle-tank connections.

From Notes of the People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR and the Chief of the General Staff of the Spacecraft in the Central Committee of the CPSU (b) - I.V. Stalin and V.M.Molotov about the basics of deploying the 18.09.40 aircraft:Currently, Germany has deployed 205-226 DD (including up to 8 md) and 15-17 etc., and only to 243 divisions ... Of the above 243 divisions before 173 divisions, - of them up to 140 PD, 15-17 td, 8 md, 5 light and 3 airborne ... will be directed against our borders..."According to the GSH against the USSR, up to 71% of German armed forces can be set. According to the memoirs of A.M. Vasilevsky, this document was twice brought into Stalin's office. Consequently, the leader should have read this document.

Prior to September 1940 of the number of divisions concentrated against the western border VO, indicated in the Note 48% of connections missing: 69-ti and to 14, etc. and md. Therefore, the country's leadership and the Red Army were not afraid of a sharp increase in the grouping of German troops on the Soviet-German border during this period.

The projects of the “Cover Plans ...” are being worked out. A.M. Vasilevsky: "Troop commanders, members of the Military Councils, NSH and operational departments of the LVO, PribOVO, ZOVOVO and KOVO in the second half of 1940 and at the beginning of 1941 were summoned in the General Staff, where, on the basis of the operational plan, the General Staff worked on their district plans for weeks. Working out, as a rule, began with a decision to allocate the necessary forces for cover echelons and the order of their use. In order to work out certain special issues that arose during the development of the plan, the commanders of the troops were allowed to call up the respective commanders of the arms of service and the chiefs of services of their district. All principal decisions taken by the district command in accordance with the plan being developed were immediately reported by them to the Chief of the General Staff, and then to the Commissar of Defense.... »

Let's go back to intelligence reports, Special message RU GSH KA 28.09.1940: "In the near future, it is planned to hold a new appeal, from which 40 of new divisions intended for the east should be formed, and this refers to the call of people with technical knowledge, in particular for service in motorized units.... "Newsletter:"Stalin, Molotov, Voroshilov, Beria, Kuznetsov, Vatutin, Kornev»

Intelligence reports that new divisions will be formed. For their formation and preparation requires a lot of time. Consequently, the beginning of the war is postponed. Ahead is a thaw on the territory of the USSR, a winter with drifts and, perhaps, there will be no war until the spring of 1941. Two days later, a new message of a more threatened nature comes in, which included misinformation.

Special message 30.9.40: "NKVD USSR reports the following agent data ... During September of this year. about 20 of German divisions, which were being transferred from the western front to the territory of the eastern regions of Germany to the borders of Romania and the Soviet Union, proceeded through Paris ... During September of this year. through Vienna, went east around 10 German td ... "

In early October, 1940, the leadership of the NPO was also preoccupied with the formation of new tank units. From the document "On increasing the number of tank units and formations'"The creation of the missile forces forced us to temporarily reduce the tanks intended for direct support of infantry ... I consider it necessary to increase the number of infantry support troops at the rate of providing each missile with one tactical ... People’s Defense Commissar S.Timoshenko Head of the General Staff KA K.Meretskov»

Guderian: "In October, 1940. Hitler was busy negotiating with the French and Franco to continue the war. At the end of the talks, he met in Florence with his friend Mussolini. On the way to Florence, at the Bologna station, Hitler unexpectedly learned that his ally, without notifying him, Hitler, and even without his consent, started a war with Greece. Thereby the Balkan problem was again affected, and the war went in a direction extremely undesirable for Germany.

The first consequence of the unauthorized step of Mussolini was, as Hitler told me, the refusal of Franco from any actions with the Axis. He clearly did not want to pursue a joint policy with such partners, from whom one could expect any surprises.

The second consequence was the growing tension in relations between Germany and the Soviet Union. This tension has been exacerbated by a number of incidents of recent months, and especially by German policy in Romania and on the Danube ... From the Molotov visit
[13-14.11.40 g.] and the course of negotiations Hitler concluded that the war with the Soviet Union can not be avoided... »

From KOVO's Note on the Deployment Plan for 1940 Year [before 8.11.40]: "Estimating the modern grouping of the German army with the most rigorous assessment of its temporary nature, arising from current aspirations, we must understand that for the near term the group against the USSR will be created from the existing, characteristic presence of large forces in the Balkans and in southern Germany.
Germany has: 230 – 240 PD, 8-10 MK ... Currently, these forces are grouped:

... in East Prussia and Poznan 18 PD, 2 TD, 1 MD;
against ZOVOVO 19 PD, 3 TD, 1 MD;
against KOVO 23 – 25 DD, 3 gds, 3 - 4 etc., 4 md;
group of gen.Blaskowitz (most of it is already in Romania) 20 – 25 pd, 1 td, 1 md ... NSH KOVO Purkaev
»

This Note states that it was released no later than December 1941 of the year. You can specify the time of its release. The note also states: "...group gen.blaskowitz (most of it is already in Romania)... ", i.e. General Blaskowitz’s group has not yet completed its concentration.

In a special report RU GSH KA from 9.11.40 is indicated: "According to new data from our sources from Romania and Bulgaria, the army of Colonel-General Blaskowitz, who previously occupied the region of Moravia and Galicia, finished my concentration in romania... "Therefore, the term of the Note - no later than 8.11.40 - the time of sending the message.

In the beginning of the part it was said that before the war, intelligence did not find a single tank group of Germans. The presented fragment of the Note is interesting in that it mentions about German micron.

Consequently, our intelligence and senior officers knew about MK, but intelligence to 22.6.41 near our border found neither their headquarters nor these associations themselves. Just as she did not find a single tank group of the enemy before the start of the war. And if there are no tank (mobile) groups and even no MK, then how can the Germans apply their favorite blitzkrieg tactics? For our military and intelligence, these unions became the same mythical troops as the amphibious divisions and divisions of heavy tanks. The difference is that tank groups and microns were, but they could not be found ...

Help 5 Department of the State Security Department of the NKVD 6.11.1940: "From the first half of October begins the gradual weakening of the concentration of German troops on our borders by transferring them to the Balkans (to Romania), as well as to Hungary and Slovakia due to the beginning of the implementation of the plans of the German command to occupy Romania and further advance deep into the Balkan Peninsula... "These transfers explain the decrease in the number of divisions in the figure above.

In the certificate below on the number of German compounds in the spring of 1940, the years are quite close to the actual number. Since July intelligence NKVD, as well as intelligence and spacecraft, begins to inflate the number of German troops on the border. This is probably due to the onset of misinformation by the German command.

Help 5 Department of the State Security Department of the NKVD 6.11.1940: "During the period of operations in France, the German command held in East Prussia and the former Poland to 27 PD and 6 CP.

After the capitulation of France, the German command began in early July 1940 to massively redeploy its troops from west to east and southeast, with the result that in East Prussia and the former Poland it was concentrated: on 16 July - up to 40 nd and over 2 etc; on 23 July - up to 50 PD and above 4 TD; on 8 August - up to 54 PD and up to 6 etc ...

On 1 in October in East Prussia and in the territory of the former Poland are concentrated 70 pd, 5 md, 7-8 etc. and 19 kn
... »

When we are told that the NKVD (including the border guards) on the eve of the war had accurate information about the German troops to a depth of 400 km - this is a hoax to reinforce fantastic nonsense. At the same time, except for words, they do not impose anything on us. Yes, they can publish an exact list of weapons, for example, the guard battalion. But by the number of troops - nothing to show. It does not happen like this: they reported, they reported overestimated data about the troops, and suddenly “saw the light” before 22.6.41 ...

Pauls: "Decisive in the further preparatory work on the Barbarossa plan was that the OKN directive from 18.12.40 set the beginning of the offensive around mid-May 1941. The appointed time was explained by the Russian climatic conditions ... The attack on Yugoslavia led to a change in the directive on the strategic deployment of forces under the Barbarossa plan, since for the attack from Romania [on the USSR] there was not enough troops that were connected in the Balkans... »

Below again in the Republic of Moldova, we will see the flow of dezu. Special message. "Harry" 11.12.40: "Head RU GSH KA. 4/5 Germany's motorized forces transferred to Poland... »

Special message RU GSH KA 14.2.41: "Starting from October, 1940 should be additionally mobilized around 1,5 million people, including 750 thousand people in the army, the rest for the military industry. In January, 1941 was called up in Germany proper, ranging in age from 40 to 45 years, as well as those who recovered after injury. There is information about the additional formation of 25-td, five td and five md, the final formation of which must be completed by March 1, in addition, expeditionary corps (number unknown) are formed from persons who participated in the war in Spain and fit for military service in African conditions ...»

Special message of the NKVD 25.2.41 ("Dora" 21.2.41): "Head RU GSH KA. According to the intelligence officer of the Swiss General Staff, Germany now has 150 divisions in the east. In his opinion, the performance of Germany will begin in late May.. "There are litters:"BUT-1. This is probably ... desa. It is necessary to specify "Dora". Golikov»

RU GSH KA asks intelligence NKVD on clarification provided by RM: “[1.2.41] The information material received from you on the deployment of troops, on defensive construction and the military industry in the territory of the former Poland, which ceded to Germany, is of interest to the Republic of Uzbekistan. Particularly valuable information about the construction of fortifications in the areas of Biala Podlaska, Radzimin and Belzhets, new airfields and dislocation of parts.
I ask you to give instructions to the source to additionally check and supplement individual information on the following points:

... 4. Check the quartering message for 3 and 14 divisions 67, 68, 107, 108, 109. 214, 215 and 216 paras.
5. To clarify the grouping and numbering of parts in the areas: a) Warsaw-Modlin-Minsk-Mazowiecki; b) Krakow-Tarnow-Jaslo; c) Biala Podlaska Lukov Mezhirechye
... »

We see that in the GS GSH “stupidly” does not use the information provided, but tries to clarify it from the intelligence that obtained these RMs. Probably, along its line RU GSH will also recheck this information.

The flow of misinformation does not stop. It continues in the spring in the reports of the agency of the GSH, NKVD and border guards, It also comes from future allies.

Note Commissar of State Security JVStalin, V.M.Molotov 11.3.41: “A source from the USSR NKGB, close to the British Embassy in Moscow, reported that 6 in March of this year. British Ambassador Kripps held a press conference, which was attended by British and American correspondents ...

Currently, the Turks are trying to improve their relations with the USSR, and if they manage to get a certain guarantee that the USSR will not attack Turkey and in the event of a German attack on Turkey will provide the latter with material assistance, then the Turks will definitely go to war with Germany ...

On the other hand, if Hitler is convinced that he will not be able to defeat England before America can help her, he will try to make peace with England on the following conditions: the restoration of France, Belgium and Holland and the seizure of the USSR. These conditions of peace have good chances for them to be accepted by England, because both in England and America there are influential groups who want to see the USSR destroyed, and if England’s position deteriorates, they will be able to force the government to accept Hitler’s peace conditions . In this case, Hitler will very quickly attack the USSR
... »

We see how the British throw up information about a possible alliance with Germany - this is what the leadership of our country feared. German intelligence officers could also receive this information and deliver it to the leaders of Germany. Wasn’t Hess’s flight to England a step by the German government towards making peace with England?

Information about the steps of British intelligence aimed at provoking a collision between Germany and the USSR also came to Moscow earlier. In an effort to divert the threat of invasion from England, her intelligence spread rumors that "The Soviet Union intends to immediately take further aggressive military actions as soon as Germany is involved in major operations.". According to K.Filby, the British leadership by all means sought to escalate the fear of Soviet military preparations among the German leadership in order to stimulate tension and conflicts in Soviet-German relations. In the United States, British agents spread rumors about the inevitability of the Soviet-German war on the initiative of the Soviet Union, which would strike at southern Poland. We do not know what information they threw at the German intelligence services for the same purpose ...

Special message RU GSH KA 11.3.41: "The total number of the German army by September 1940 was about 228 divisions, including 15-17 etc. and 8-10 md. According to reports, over the past winter period, the German command has additionally formed 25 front, 5 etc., 5 md. In addition, due to the PD formed, apparently, to 5 MD. Thus, the total number of divisions of the German army on 1.3.41 is about 263 divisions, of which: 221 pd, 22 etc and 20 md... »

In reconnaissance, a change was also noted in the grouping of the German army: in the south-east direction: the number of divisions increased from 22 (by 1.9.40) to 62 (1.3.41). Again, we are faced with an estimate of the RP, which provides overestimated data on the number of German connections.

From the Plan of the General Staff of the Spacecraft for Strategic Aircraft Deployment 11.3.41: "Germany currently has deployed 225 radar, 20 td and 15 md, and a total of up to 260 divisions, 20000 field guns of all calibres, 10000 tanks and up to 15000 aircraft, of which up to 9000 – 9500 combat.

Of the specified number of divisions, 76 divisions, of which up to 6 td and 7 md, are currently focused on our borders and before 35 divisions in Romania and Bulgaria.

If the war with England ends, it can be presumed that of the existing 260 divisions, Germany will leave at least 35 divisions in the occupied and bordering countries and up to the 25 divisions in the depths of the country.

In this way, before 200 divisions, of which up to 165 DD, 20 TD and 15 MD, will be directed against our borders
... »

The Plan ... also states that the main forces of the German army can be deployed in the south or in the north. On 11.3.41 - for GSH it is not yet clear where the main attack is possible. At the SVKS, it was said that the Germans concentrated on the main line during the war in the West up to 100-130 divisions. The same leadership of the spacecraft is also waiting for it: it is considering grouping divisions in the southern or northern directions in 100-130. The concentration of such a huge grouping at the border is hard to miss intelligence ...

The draft Directive of the People's Commissar of Defense of the USSR and the Chief of the General Staff of the Spacecraft Commander, ZOVOVO, prepared in April 1941, also mentions the same number of troops: “In the event of a war with us, Germany, out of its existing 225 PD ... will be able to send against our borders before 200 divisions, of which up to 165 PD, 20 etc. and 15 md... »

From both documents it can be seen that, according to the GS (in March-April), the USSR can be concentrated on the border of the 200 divisions, which is 77% of the existing formations in the German Armed Forces. Attention should be paid to the distribution of German troops near the USSR border. In some books, the redistribution of spacecraft forces is explained to counteract a possible German strike in the southern direction by the fact that Zhukov brought along with him in the GSH many people from QUO (KOVO). According to the author - this is not a correct explanation. The author agrees that the leadership of the spacecraft was probably secretly willing to launch a counterstrike in the direction of southern Poland. But to desire is not to fulfill your wish ...

On 25.4.41 against troops, PribOVO and ZAPOVO are estimated by the RU GSH concentrating on 49-50 divisions (including 9, etc. and md), against KOVO and OdVO - 40-44 (including 7 etc. and md).

5.5.41-52 divisions are listed on 53 against PribOVO and ZOVOVO, against KOVO and OdVO are 45-49.

15.5.41-53 divisions (including 54 td and md) are listed as 10-55 against 59 vs PribOVO and ZOVOVO, 15-XNUMX are against KOVO and OdVO. (including XNUMX td and md).

1.6.41 vs. PribOVO and ZAPOVO have the same 53-54 divisions (including 10 etc. and md), and against KOVO and OdVO rises to 61-62. (including 17 td and md).

In addition, according to intelligence data in Bulgaria, there were: on 25.4.41 - 25-27 German divisions, on 15.5.41 - 15-16 divisions, on 1.6.41 - up to 11 divisions. Do not forget about the other German divisions that could be sent to the southern border of the USSR. According to intelligence data, 1.6.41 had German connections in the central part of Romania - 11, in the Protectorate - 6-8, in Greece - 12.

Thus, a powerful grouping (eg, for 10.6) consisting of up to 87 divisions could be created against the KOVO and OdVO troops. Taking into account the further concentration of troops, theoretically, a much more powerful grouping could be created in this direction.

In the 13 part, you were presented with data on the significant difference at our border between the actual number of divisions and the number presented in the Republic of Moldova. Consider the assessment of the German intelligence forces border guards and RU GSH.

Note by People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSR L.P. Beria JVStalin, V.M.Molotov and the People's Commissar of Defense S.K.Timoshenko 21.4.41: “From 1 to 19 on April 1941 by the border detachments of the NKVD of the USSR on the Soviet-German border, the following data was obtained on the arrival of German troops at points adjacent to the state border

In East Prussia and the General Government:

In the border strip of the Klaipeda region: profits 2 PD, PP, kavskadron, hell, TB and a company of scooters.

In the area of ​​Suwalki - Lyk: profits before 2 md, 4 nn and 2 kp, tb and sat.

In the area Myszyniec - Ostroleka: arrived up to 4 pp and an, TB and a battalion of motorcyclists.

In the Ostrov-Mazowiecki-Malkinia-Gurna area: arrived at PP and CP, before 2 hell and a company of tanks.

In the area of ​​Biala Podlaska: arrived pp, 2 sat, kavskadron, company scooters and artillery battery.

In the area of ​​Vlodawa - Orkhovok: arrived before 3 pp, kp and 2 an.

In the area of ​​the town of Kholm: arrived before 3 PP, 4 an, MP, CP, TB and sat. There is also concentrated over 500 cars.

In the area of ​​Hrubieshov: arrived before 4 nn, an and mp and kavskadron.

In the Tomashov district: the compound headquarters arrived, up to 3, and up to three hundred tanks.

To the Przheorsk-Yaroslav district: arrived before the first, above an, and up to two cavalry regiments.

Total in these areas arrived: compound headquarters 3 md, 6 PD, up to 21 PP, 2 mp, 7 kn and 9-10 an, up to 7 TB and 4 sat, motorcycle battalion, 2 companies of scooters and more than 500 cars ... People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSR Beria
»

It should be noted that the regiments listed in the Note are not included in the divisions indicated in the same document. The RM indicates the arrival of 9 divisions (6 front and 3 md). Let's try to combine the remaining parts (21 PP, 9-10 an, 2 mp and 7 TB) into conditional divisions. We will not consider smaller parts and divisions.

We will conduct a calculated estimate: 21 PP / 3 + 1 an ~ 7 front; 1 mp + 1 an + 4 TB ~ 1 TD.

It remains with us: 1 mp, 2 an, 3 TB - let's conditionally evaluate them in the 0,5 division.

So that in the period from 1.4.41 on 19.4.41 (for 19 days) frontier guards "discovered" the arrival of German divisions before 17,5 in the area from Klaipeda to the area of ​​Hrubieszhov-Tomashev-Przhevorsk-Yaroslav. From the city of Yaroslav to the border with Slovakia, 92,5 km was still there, and German troops could also concentrate there, which were not included in the above Note.



And what did the RU GSH report? Intelligence services of the RU GSH completely coinciding with the dates specified in the RM of the NKVD could not be found. But there is, for example, Intelligence RU GSH from 4.4.41.

Intelligence: "Throughout March the German command carried out reinforced troop movements to the border strip with the USSR. They began as early as the end of January 1941 ... As a result of analyzing all the data received, the overall reinforcement of the Eastern German front against the USSR from the Baltic Sea to Slovakia for February and March is six per day and three, etc., the total number of German troops on the border with the USSR to Slovakia ... 72-73 divisions... »

We see a summary of the total number of divisions, taking into account their transportation from January to March, i.e. as of on 31 March. We can say that the initial period of further observation 1.4.41 the border guards of the NKVD and the RU GSH coincides.

In the next published Intelligence RU of the GSH German group at our border on 25.4.41 estimated in 84-88 divisions. For 25 bottomth there was an increase in grouping on 12-15 divisions. The intelligence data of the NKVD for a shorter period speak of a greater number of arrived divisions (17,5), compared with the information of the RU GSH. And we know that according to the estimates of the GS GS overestimated the number of German troops at our border.

And how many divisions were actually redeployed? Accurate information on 19 or 25 April is missing. It is only known that April 4 to May 15 1941 of the year has been relocated 24 divisions. Therefore, it can be said that the RM from the border troops of the NKVD also included misinformation thrown by the Germans and on a scale larger than in the Republic of Uzbekistan RU GSH KA.

At the end of April, the question of the redeployment of the 16 army (5 MK (1070 tanks) and 32 ck) from Transbaikalia to Transcaucasia is being considered. The army also includes 57 td (more than 300 tanks), which had previously been stationed in Mongolia. The structure ZakVO includes 28 MK, 3 and 40 ck, two cd, two cd and 6 gsd. The 1.4.41 has an 151 armored car, a 892 tank and a wedge.

Why in the Caucasus, and not on the western border? Probably because the western border at that time was less disturbing than, for example, the invasion of German troops through Turkey or Iran ...

Special message. "Senior" 17.4.41: "The source notes that in connection with the successful advance of the German troops in Denmark, the sentiments of the circles advocating for action against the Soviet Union have somewhat subsided, because now hope to win the war with England by striking its vital communications and oil sources in the middle east... »

Special message. "Senior" 24.4.41: "At present, the Aviation General Staff has almost completely ceased the development of Russian facilities and is intensively preparing for an action against Turkey, Syria and Iraq in the first place. The rally against the USSR seems to be relegated to the background... »

Special message RU GSH KA «On the distribution of German armed forces in theaters and fronts of military operations as of 25.04.41 ”:“ The mass transfer of German troops from the interior regions of Germany and the occupied countries of Western Europe continues uninterruptedly. The main transfer flows follow in two directions: to our western border and to the Balkans ... Due to the reserves brought to Bulgaria and the liberation of the German parts in Yugoslavia an army is being created against Turkey... »

BAT Note in Germany To Chief of the General Staff of the 25 / 26.4.41 SC: "The next coming German events seem to me like this:

a) Settling Turkey with a pact of three or some similar to it ...

d) Whether the Germans are planning extensive operations in the Middle East and Africa with such a number of troops that would weaken their European grouping is difficult to say, although such goals as Suez, Mossul, the defeat of the British in Abyssinia are officially proclaimed.
... »

Special message. "Zeus" 27.4.41: "Germany will not allow the conclusion of a treaty of the USSR with Turkey... »

Note NKGB USSR Stalin, Molotov, Beria 30.04.41: "Message "Corsican" from 28.4.41 g. Source reports: 1. The referent of the Ministry of Economy told ... that the Germans are taking all measures to include Turkey in the fairway of German policy. The Germans promised Turkey a part of Thrace, as well as the accession of other territories ... The German proposal also included the rejection of some Soviet areas in the Caucasus in favor of Turkey... »

Special message. "Mars" 29.4.41: "Part of the German troops operating against Yugoslavia with Hungary ..., are returning by car through Budapest to Vienna. German soldiers say they will get a few days of rest, then they will be sent to Poland to the border of the USSR. Another part of the German troops from Yugoslavia is sent to Romania. In Budapest and Bucharest, there are many rumors about the upcoming war between Germany and the USSR... "There are litters:"It is especially important to trace where the German forces from Yugoslavia are being transferred.. Golikov 29.04.41»

Special message. "Mars" 1.5.41: "Intensive air operations of the German army and the war in the Balkans extremely depleted stocks of gasoline. The situation with gasoline is so complicated that the Germans intend to by all means force an offensive against Iraq to occupy oil sources. For this purpose, the reinforced transfer of German troops to Libya through Italy and the concentration of troops in the Balkans is currently underway.

The assault on Iraq is planned to be carried out from Egypt and through Turkey, or by transferring troops through the Dodekanevskie Islands and then by sea along the Turkish coast. Rumors are circulating in the high command circles that in the event of a successful attack on Iraq, an attack will be launched on the USSR, on the Caucasus from Turkey and on Ukraine from the west
... »

Note NKGB USSR in the Central Committee of the CPSU (b) I.V. Stalin, the SNK of the USSR V.Molotov and the NKVD of the USSR L.P. Beria with the transmission of telegrams from the British Ambassador to the USSR S.Kripps 5.5.41: “A likely and effective counterweight to German pressure can be: a) the fear that Turkey will join the powers of the “axis”... »

We see that misinformation has also touched upon a new strategic direction for striking the USSR from the Transcaucasus. It is possible that 16 A was thrown to counter this threat. Parry threat could occur due to the rapid advance of mechanized troops, which were represented by two microns, one etc. and two cd. Only one thing is not entirely clear: why is the 32 ck being transferred from Transbaikalia, and not a similar case being relocated from the North Caucasian Military District? Perhaps, according to the General Staff, a separate army group was needed in this direction, which went through internal coordination ... In any case, the North Caucasus Military District troops began to be transferred to KOVO from May ...

Whether this movement of troops was connected with the fear of the military-political leadership of the country in connection with the possible actions of Germany in the Middle East, the author cannot say for sure: not enough information. Could such a move be a legend to cover the redeployment of troops allegedly in the direction of Transcaucasia, and then towards Ukraine? According to the author, this is unlikely.

Memo Deputy Commissar of the USSR State Security B.Z. Kobulova I.V. Stalin, V.M.Molotov and L.P. Beria with the text of the conversation, obtained by the agent's 6.6.41: "The Germans are extremely indignant at Turkey’s intractability in the issue of passing German troops through Turkish territory. Filov concluded that Moscow prevented the German-Turkish agreement on the passage of troops... »
71 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. VS
    -3
    17 July 2018 07: 18
    "" Another misconception - this is a very overestimated view of the top leadership of the Red Army about the air defense capabilities in the cover of ground forces. "


    - and that means - the attack on the summer of the 41st did not wait)))
    1. 0
      17 July 2018 08: 57
      V.S. (Basil)
      Since 1927, And In Stalin, in his reports to party congresses, she talks about preparing a war of the countries of the capitalist world against the young socialist republic. Everything is openly in print.
      -XV CONGRESS OF THE CPSU (B.)

      2-19 December 1927

      POLITICAL REPORT OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE

      3 December

      I

      THE GROWING CRISIS OF WORLD CAPITALISM AND THE EXTERNAL SITUATION OF THE USSR
      http://www.hrono.ru/libris/stalin/10-13.html
      POLICY REPORT OF THE CENTRAL COMMITTEE

      XVI CONGRESS OF THE CPSU (B.)

      27th of June 1930

      3. RELATIONS BETWEEN THE USSR AND CAPITALIST STATES
      http://www.hrono.info/libris/stalin/16s13.php
      --STALIN I.V. REPORTING REPORT TO THE XVII CONGRESS OF THE PARTY ON THE WORK OF THE CPSU CPSU (B.)

      January 26, 1934, evening meeting. == Pay particular attention to this speech of Comrade IV Stalin ++
      http://hrono.ru/dokum/1934vkpb17/1_2_1.php
      "As you see, the matter is moving towards a new imperialist war, as a way out of the current situation.

      Of course, there is no reason to believe that war can provide a real way out. "
      --- REPORTING REPORT AT THE XVIII CONGRESS OF THE PARTY

      About the work of the Central Committee of the CPSU (B)

      10 March 1939 year

      I

      The international situation of the Soviet Union
      https://petroleks.ru/stalin/14-27.php
      “Some politicians and press figures in Europe and the USA, having lost their patience in anticipation of a“ march on Soviet Ukraine, ”themselves begin to expose the real motive of the policy of non-intervention. They directly say and write in black and white that the Germans cruelly“ disappointed ”them, because instead to move further east, against the Soviet Union, you see, they turned west and demand colonies.You might think that the Germans were given parts of Czechoslovakia as a price for the obligation to start a war with the Soviet Union, and the Germans now refuse to pay the bill, sending them somewhere far away .....
      Tasks of the party in the field of foreign policy:

      1. Continue pursuing a policy of peace and strengthening business ties with all countries;

      2. To be careful and not to let our provocateurs of war, accustomed to rake the heat with the wrong hands, draw our country into conflicts;

      3. To strengthen in every way the combat power of our Red Army and Navy Red Navy;

      4. To strengthen international relations of friendship with workers of all countries interested in peace and friendship between peoples. "" ""
      1. VS
        -5
        17 July 2018 11: 00
        You’re right - cockroaches in the head of some authors are a terrible thing))) I sat a girl .. I embroidered a cross .. I didn’t touch anyone .. and then she slipped some “bulletins” into the letters “m” and it started - inflate OPENING WORLD - Stalin and the military did not wait for the attack on June 41st !! BECAUSE the Germans drove the desu and her tyrant believed sacredly for he believed Hitler and German intelligence naturally and not his intelligence or military))) And if someone did something, contrary to the tyrant, despite his tyranny and on his own initiative))) For such bold and good people and shot the Stalin executioners killers)))
    2. -1
      17 July 2018 20: 14
      Again the inflated performance ...
      On the defensive side, a 6-point defense of 85 mm ZP of the 39th year was enough for 30 km along the front. Spaced after 5 km, in height it hits 10 km, slanted further, in between small caliber. Che said something wrong Zhukov?
      1. +5
        17 July 2018 20: 44
        The article determines the shortage of many supply points of the Red Army. Only in reality it turned out even worse, and those available resources in the first weeks of the Second World War were not used for their intended purpose, were destroyed or got to the Germans ... Interesting statistics on non-combat losses (losses) in ammunition, military equipment, fuel and lubricants, and how much Germans got into the form of trophies ... Interesting statistics, classified and there is no desire to inform, it is understandable why, because these losses are the culprits, and the "Marshal of Victory" in the main .....
      2. +12
        18 July 2018 09: 03
        these guns were only enough to indicate the presence or shoot at a hovering airship
        there was no question of any density of fire to stop the raid.
        add to this the low experience of air defense personnel and the lack of high-quality equipment, for example, to accurately determine the height, speed of a target or remote fuses,
        as well as the deficit of shells mentioned in the article
        I will say more, experienced u-87 pilots usually successfully fought even alone against a whole battery, disrupting precise guidance with a maneuver. There are German video chronicles that show the actions of pieces on the attack.
  2. VS
    -3
    17 July 2018 07: 20
    "" In conclusion of the material presented on reports and speeches at the SVKS, I would like to draw attention to the fact that the highest command correctly understood the actions of the German armored and motorized forces, which were combined into mobile (tank) groups. ""


    - oh how))) it already turns out EVERYONE knew perfectly HOW the Germans would advance)))
  3. VS
    -1
    17 July 2018 07: 24
    "" It turns out that the top command knew that motorized tank units and formations should be used in groups: in mobile or tank groups. Why did the author pay attention to this fact? Just because in the pre-war RM of 1941 there is no mention of any of them at our borders - they were not found. In the Republic of Moldova, only TB, TP, TD and MD (in bulk) were noted without a single command. ""

    - Madame - they already explained to you on a miller - the group is not the regular structure of the army)) I don’t need to know it - and HOW the tanks are grouped in the language will be clear AFTER the outbreak of hostilities))) The reconnaissance task is to show ALL that is on the other side and how anyone is grouped into what - it will be seen there - military geography to help)))
    1. +8
      17 July 2018 18: 24
      I carefully read these messages on the site specified by Kozinkin. He lies again - only there he wrote about it. Why read man’s books that easily deceive people here.
      Give an excerpt, liar, except you and your friend there are no messages against this author’s thought
  4. VS
    -5
    17 July 2018 07: 28
    "" It is not their fault that they were faced with misinformation of the highest class. At that time, no one could have thought of the possibility of such a massive counteraction to our intelligence. The data obtained by intelligence included disinformation, which the Nazis skillfully palm off on many different channels. People who process RM at the Center and get acquainted with it, felt that this information is confirmed by many sources that are not interconnected. ""

    madam - you are not tired of writing that there who "thought" - according to intelligence ??)))

    Why don’t you show how the intelligence of DEZU opened - with the same movements of the Germans along the border in order to confuse us ??)))
    I’m not tired of falsification, then deal with topics - are you our anonymous ??)))

    It’s interesting - that it’s not an anti-Soviet face - what kind of reason - is it always hiding behind a click who is ALWAYS ??)) Just like our madame - it is stubbornly hiding behind a click)))
  5. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 32
    "" Many of the RMs contained contradictory and even fantastic information about the plans of the German leadership regarding the USSR. The first persons and special services of Germany actively attracted this misinformation, they were attracted by numerous officials, military and other specialists. ""


    - and cho ??)) Type - all this crap in the Kremlin was sacredly believed or what ??)))
  6. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 39
    "" the second reason leading to an incorrect assessment of events on the eve of June 22. This is an incorrect estimate of the number of divisions, after the redeployment of which Germany decides to attack the USSR. "

    - what a lady is not a strategist)))

    Since it is written in Considerations that the Germans MAY set up to 200 divisions against the Soviet Socialist Republic and they are not there by June 20, they didn’t wait for the attack)))

    MADAM see KShI in May - THERE IS NOT FOR 200 double-skinned creatures that the Germans threw into the Soviet Socialist Republic)))
  7. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 48
    "" Some writers are confidently telling us that the command of the spacecraft was very confident at the outbreak of the war on 22.6.41. So why aren't they preparing for war in September 1940? To transfer the remaining 16 divisions for the German command is a matter of several days. ""

    Yes, BECAUSE the REALITY and likelihood of an attack is determined not by the number of divisions on the border with you, but by OTHER factors, including)))

    UNDERSTAND these simple Vecchi - you will cease to carry nonsense that they did not wait for the attack on the Soviet Socialist Republic in the summer of 41 in May)))

    Madame - yes, finally begin to study the facts of the pre-war days yourself))) SEE WHAT MAY = according to the decisions adopted in APRIL - the armies of the inner districts began to withdraw to the West. Look at WHAT numbers in URs the BORDER divisions according to Cover Plans began to withdraw ...

    You have already been told more than once - NOT BY THE SUMMARY OF RU you have to look who cho was thinking there - cho was waiting or not waiting and how the Germans were taken on faith))) - but according to the decisions that were taken and the MEASURES and measures taken - in the pre-war days ..

    READ Madam's lessons and conclusions - THERE IS NOT THIS Nonsense - who is there who "thought" on the basis of ONLY RU reports that you HERE RUBED for half a year now)))
  8. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 50
    "" Two days later, a new message of a more threatened nature arrives, which included misinformation. ""

    - and like ALL fell into depression))) believed (((
  9. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 53
    "" The large gap between the units "discovered" by intelligence and their actual number leads the author to the idea that the coincidence of the number of divisions by 22.6.41 is a random factor ""

    - Well, kaneshnaya Ms. - it’s in YOUR bullshit - that the attack did not wait does not fit)))

    MADAM - or maybe you will try to compare with the TEM that the intelligence themselves reported in RU and not just slander what Golikov wrote to ZhUKOV in the end ??)))
    1. +3
      17 July 2018 18: 39
      blah blah blah and nothing smart and not any evidence .... When God wants to punish someone - it takes away the mind
  10. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 07: 58
    "" up to 173 divisions, of which up to 140 pd, 15-17 td, 8 md, 5 light and 3 airborne divisions ... will be sent against our borders ... ”According to the General Staff, up to 71% of German armed forces can be deployed . According to the memoirs of A.M. Vasilevsky, this document was twice brought into Stalin's office. Therefore, the leader should have familiarized himself with this document.
    Up to the number of divisions indicated in the Note, concentrated against the western border military forces, by September 1940, 48% of the units were missing: "

    - Madame - THIS DOESN'T MEAN THAT SO MUCH - until 173 WAITED for the duration of the attack.))
    SEE the May KSHI - THERE ARE NO 173 divisions that attacked the USSR)))

    MISCELLANEOUS were calculations - MISCELLANEOUS))

    And now take a look at the March "considerations")) THERE IS US - the line what forces were invented to repel the German attack))))

    And WHAT does this say?)) YES ABOUT WHAT)))

    See the lessons and conclusions))) and do not invent any crap - who was waiting there, thinking, etc. nonsense)))
    1. +11
      17 July 2018 18: 38
      If there is no mind, then a cripple. How can I read his books? God help
      Even I can figure it out though old
      173 divisions are without parts in Romania, and in March already with Romania
      Look at the map - there is such a big country. If you think poorly, read the syllables (you have already been advised))))
      1. VS
        -3
        18 July 2018 07: 30
        you are already old - so maybe it’s not worth reading anything? Moreover, as I understand it, except Madame Anonymous, didn’t you read anything on the PRELIMINARY days ??))
  11. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 00
    "" by September 1940 there was not enough 48% of the connections: 69 pd and up to 14 td and md. Therefore, the leadership of the country and the Red Army were not afraid of a sharp increase in the grouping of German troops on the Soviet-German border during this period. ""

    Yes, NOT ONLY the number of divisions on the border is estimated - when they "think" - the neighbor will attack or not)))
    1. +3
      17 July 2018 18: 36
      Like I'm smart, I know most of all. look in the mirror writer Kozinkin
      1. VS
        0
        18 July 2018 07: 31
        I’m not a writer)) And - maybe YOUR last name - so that the conversation was on equal terms ??))
  12. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 04
    "" Our intelligence and the highest command were aware of MK, but intelligence until 22.6.41 at our border did not find either their headquarters or these associations themselves. In the same way, as I did not find a single tank group of the enemy before the start of the war. And if there are no tank (mobile) groups and even no MK, then how can the Germans use their favorite blitzkrieg tactics? For our military and intelligence, these associations became the same mythical troops as the landing divisions and heavy tank divisions. The difference is that there were tank groups and mk, but they could not be found ... ""

    - and so the attack did not wait ((((
    1. +3
      17 July 2018 18: 27
      It turns out that they did not expect grief scribbler
      Prove that I'm a liar. Give two examples of documents that heavy tank divisions were not looking for and parachute divisions too. Just not your stupid speculation
      1. VS
        -2
        18 July 2018 07: 32
        calm down - you old man is our anonymous regular - they were waiting))) Learn what REALLY was done in the pre-war days and not what the ladies compose anonymous there)))
  13. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 07
    "" Some books explain the redistribution of spacecraft forces to counter a possible southward strike by Germany by the fact that Zhukov brought with him to the General Staff many people from the KVO (KVO). According to the author, this is not a correct explanation. The author agrees that the SC leadership probably secretly wanted to launch a counterattack in the direction of southern Poland. But to desire is not to fulfill your desire ... ""

    Well, kaneshnaya Ms. - our anonymous Madame MASHAL Zakharov or officers of the VNU OGS that wrote the lessons and conclusions KNOWS there was in reality - FOR WHICH Zhukov drove the troops into KOVO)))

    that's what Marshal M.V. wrote about this Zakharov in the work "On the Eve of the Great Tests" in 1969 - printed in the printing house of the General Staff Academy and classified for 20 years:
    “From time immemorial, since the Napoleonic attack on Russia, it was believed that the main direction for the enemy’s actions against us in the west will be the Smolensk-Moscow direction, north of the Pripyat and San rivers. (That is, from Brest, through Belarus - K.O.) So it was evaluated in the notes of the General Staff of the Red Army signed by B.M. Shaposhnikov. At the same time, it was proposed to set our main forces against the main forces of the enemy.
    But with the advent of Comrade Defense Comrade CK Tymoshenko and Chief of General Staff Comrade KA Meretskov’s views on strategic concentration and deployment are changing dramatically, although there were no differences in assessing the enemy’s possible actions. The main grouping of Soviet troops is created south of Pripyat to carry out the following strategic task: “With a powerful blow in the direction of Breslau, in the first stage of the war, cut off Germany from the Balkan countries, deprive it of its most important economic bases and decisively influence the Balkan countries in questions of their participation in the war.” (Archive of GOU GSH, op. 240-48, d. 528-V)
    In terms of strategic deployment, it was stated: “The blow of our forces in the direction of Krakow and Breslau, cutting Germany off the Balkan countries, acquires exclusively political significance. In addition, a blow in this direction will take place on the territory of the former Poland, which is still poorly prepared for defense. ” (Ibid.) "
    And further, Zakharov claims that:
    “According to this option, the Red Army was deployed by the beginning of World War II.” (M.V. Zakharov, Ch. On the eve of the great trials (M. 1968), General Staff in the prewar years. M. 2005, p.421)

    As you see, Zakharov is not so much Zhukov as Meretskov’s who accuses him of already pushing the idea of ​​a powerful retaliatory strike from KOVO in September 1940, even though the main German forces were expected just north of Pripyat - “there are no differences was ”with Meretskov and Shaposhnikov. The main forces of the Germans waited only and just north of Polesie.

    MADAM - do not be smarter than marshals in evaluating REAL events))))
  14. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 12
    "" according to the assessment of the General Staff of the General Aviation Administration, the number of German troops at our border was inflated. ""

    - and so the attack on the summer did not wait)))
    1. +2
      17 July 2018 18: 35
      yes, they were waiting for kozinkin with a friend
  15. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 17
    "" At the end of April, the question of the redeployment of 16 armies (5 mk (1070 tanks) and 32 ck) from Transbaikalia to Transcaucasia is considered. The army also includes 57 TDs (more than 300 tanks), which had previously been deployed in Mongolia. The composition of ZakVO includes 28 mk, 3 and 40 ck, two cd, two sd and 6 gsd. At 1.4.41 there are 151 armored vehicles, 892 tanks and tankettes.
    Why in the Caucasus, and not on the western border? Probably because the western border for that period of time caused less concern than, for example, the invasion of German troops through Turkey or Iran ... ""

    - here .. d ... ra)))

    The GERMANS sent notes - when OUR transport of armies began .. And formally THIS army was supposedly transferred to Georgia))) And NOW take a look at the map - onto the railway - AS IT IS AT ALL possible to get to Transcaucasia from Chita))))

    CORRECTLY - ONLY THROUGH Rostov-on-Don)))) From which the direct road to - is correct - TO UKRAINE))) to where Lukin’s army was eventually sent))) WITHOUT ANY races to Georgia)))

    AND - IN THE SAME DAYS WHEN THIS army went to Georgia from ZakVO to UKRAINE, their army decreases)))

    MADAM doesn’t come to her head — what was the misinformation in the Soviet Socialist Republic — in order to mislead the Germans — regarding the withdrawal of OUR armies ??)))
    1. +5
      17 July 2018 18: 35
      oh and durka pisaka kozinkin
  16. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 23
    "" Special message. “Petty Officer” 17.4.41: “The source notes that in connection with the successful advance of the German troops in Denmark, the mood of the circles advocating for speaking out against the Soviet Union has somewhat subsided, because now have the hope of winning the war with England through a blow to its vital communications and oil sources in the Middle East ... »" "

    - I will reveal a country secret for MADAM - Petty Officer was not considered to be the EXACT source in the Kremlin))) EVERYONE knew that his "sources" were officers of ABWERA generally))) AND it was on the denunciations of the foreman as a result - and the tyrant "wrote" obscene resolutions - as the supplier of desa))) WHICH DID NOT BELIEVE)))

    SO - Madame anonymous ours - your nonsense that they didn’t wait for the attack because the Germans were such Maladins — they drove the tyrant away and he believed her - HE HAVE in general believed Hitler more than himself and the more military men they showed in MAY - from 15 May- GERMANS can attack at any moment - Nonsense and will remain as if you were trying to prove the opposite)))
    1. +7
      17 July 2018 18: 34
      Oh fool. The story is known when, according to the foreman, Fitin was called to Stalin.
      If you didn’t believe why, on this message, distract respected people. Oh and a liar and an ignoramus
  17. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 28
    "" There are notes: "It is especially important to trace where the German troops are being transferred from Yugoslavia. Golikov 29.04.41 ""

    - yeah - to attack Hitler in Turkey (((

    Madame - well, kaneshnaya Ms. - It was NECESSARY to know WHERE the Germans would transfer their units from Yugoslavia - to the south of woodland or to the north)))
  18. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 29
    "" In the circles of the high command, rumors circulate that in the event of a successful attack on Iraq, an attack will be undertaken on the USSR, the Caucasus from Turkey and Ukraine from the west ... "" "

    and THESE HEARINGS our tyrant clearly BELIEVED !!!)))
  19. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 31
    "" "misinformation also affected a new strategic direction for attacking the USSR - from the Transcaucasus. It is possible that 16 A was being thrown to counter this threat. "

    Madame - STOP inventing all sorts of crap urging your nonsense that they did not wait for the attack for the summer -)) SEE WHAT was by DATE - REALLY))) In those days, from the ZakVO Army was decreasing to Ukraine))))
  20. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 40
    “” Only one thing is not entirely clear: why is 32 ck being transferred from Transbaikalia and not a similar corps from the North Caucasian Military District is being relocated? Maybe, according to the General Staff, a separate army group was needed in this direction, which went through internal coordination ... In any case, the North Caucasian Military District troops began to be deployed to KOVO in May ... "

    or maybe everything was simpler - NOBODY IN THE TRANSCASCO AND GATHERED TO GEORGIA troops from CHIT gnat AT ALL ??)))

    BECAUSE of Nonsense, the threats from Turkey did not believe in principle, and the attack was WAITED from Germany for the summer of 41. And - for the QUICK FOODS (but our anonymous lady is not a fool), I will tell you - THE CHIEF OF SCIENCE OF TURKEY and - was OUR agent) ) Stalin squeezed his child on his knees - being in Baku - like the son of the head of the Baku gendarmes))

    MADAME - START FINALLY NOT TO PICK UP YOUR ravings that they didn’t expect the attack in Moscow for the summer of the 41st ONLY COMFORTABLE to you and even write up on RU reports - who the hell was thinking in the Kremlin))))

    Look at the EVENTS that were held in those days)) Study the Bible on June 22 - "1941 - lessons and conclusions" and the work of Marshal Zakharov. IT ON THEM teach in military academies the history of the outbreak of war)))

    It’s not by Dumb fantasies that they are taught from anonymous ignoramuses, but by WORK plans and research of officers of the General Staff of the General Staff)))
  21. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 08: 42
    "" Could such a movement be a legend to cover the redeployment of troops supposedly in the direction of Transcaucasia, and then in the direction of Ukraine? According to the author, this is unlikely. "

    because the author is an ignoramus)) imagining herself smarter than officers of the VNU General Staff or all the more so Marshal Zakharov that in general on this topic - they do not bother with this army)))
  22. VS
    -4
    17 July 2018 10: 56
    "" Your attitude to the proposed series of articles:
    - I really do not like it, because the author is inclined to distort events - 5 (5.43%) ""

    - everything is as usual - those who are in the subject and understand that Madame is nonsense - naturally less than ordinary readers that they know ANYTHING on the topic)))
    1. +9
      17 July 2018 18: 21
      The writer Kozinkin refers himself to those who are in the subject. Unrecognized genius. Read what people on this site think of this false history.

      http://militera.borda.ru/?1-3-0-00001629-000-80-0
      1. +12
        17 July 2018 18: 26
        Oleg Kozinkin - is it Monsieur V.S. (Vasily)?

        Chu, why should Oleg mow under Vasily? laughing
        1. +6
          17 July 2018 19: 11
          I read that he was banned on the police website
          and he came there with that nickname
          Disguised as
          1. +13
            17 July 2018 19: 30
            Question to the author of the article - when do you ban Oleg-Vasiliy’s mousy on VO? laughing
            1. VS
              -3
              18 July 2018 07: 40
              This is you to the "owners" of the site please contact - another snitch))) Sorry - you are our cuckoo))) Cuckoos only do that they survive from the forums of those who they do not like - crying to administrators)))
        2. VS
          -2
          18 July 2018 07: 38
          I just put the letters - as "nickname" - V.S.)) "Armed Forces")))
          And who there ascribes the "names" in brackets is not my problem)))
      2. VS
        -5
        18 July 2018 07: 36
        Of course, it’s very important for me that there’s a couple - A PAIR - butane is carrying about me and all the more if ALL cutters are added to them but ...)))
  23. +5
    17 July 2018 11: 04
    The article says that German MKs were not discovered until June 22, although their existence was known
    but, reconnaissance planes regularly flew around the border and, at least on June 19, during the next flyby, at least one MK level connection was indirectly recorded by the accumulation of equipment advancing to the border near Brest. Also, by the sound of June 20, the leadership of the Brest garrison already knew for sure that large tank and motorized forces were concentrated near the border and deployed in attacking orders.
    I don’t know what the official rate reports say, but the leadership of the border districts 2-3 days before the start of the war knew that not just forces were deployed next to them, but fully combat-ready large mechanized groups - surviving commanders noted in the memoirs . The notorious Pavlov, too, a few days before the start of the war already knew that a large fully combat-ready mechanized force was concentrated on the border of his district, capable of striking at an operational depth of 400-600 km.
    At first I didn’t understand why he was shot, but in the light of the information he possessed, I don’t understand why his district was so unprepared to repel the attack.
    Suppose it was impossible to withdraw troops from the barracks and deploy them in order not to “provoke”, but a number of other hidden preparations were not made. For example, Pavlov sent a false report to the headquarters that on June 21 the units took up positions and were equipped. In reality, only a small part of the troops subordinate to him was at least somehow mobilized to repel a possible attack, and it turned out to be enchanting that many officers were on leave, many of which were not transferred to an increased readiness mode. Tank units (I remind you that Pavlov was a tankman) were not in fact ready for the planned scale of maneuvering - they suffered half damage already on the march. The receipt of equipment in the warehouses was not agreed with the district leadership
    1. VS
      -3
      17 July 2018 15: 37
      "" the leadership of the border districts even 2-3 days before the start of the war knew that not just forces were deployed next to them, but fully combat-ready large mechanized groups - surviving commanders noted in the memoirs ""

      - read the answers of the divisional commanders to "Pokrovsky’s questions"))) Many showed - they knew quite well what parts of the Germans were in front of them - from intelligence, which, according to statements by Madame like desu, drove)))

      "" in the light of the information he possessed, I don’t understand why his district was so unprepared to repel the attack. "

      - in all districts EXCEPT ZAPOVO, their border divisions in the area of ​​military operations, in the URs, they began to withdraw from June 8–11 and 18. And only in Belarus ALL of their frontiers stuck in the barracks ..

      At the same time, only in the ZapVO their border ones were so located on the border - that their deployment was in one place - on the border in general, but the defense line was - so 50 km - in another place .. And when in the morning of June 22 they went into their defense lines Awakened not by Pavlov but by the Germans, they walked ALONG the border - under fire ...
      Now look at the directives for the withdrawal of "deep" divisions for the ZAPOV dated June 11th. It tells Pavlov that the border should not be touched until the special order of the people's commissar. At the same time, from June 11-12, their frontier guards in the URs took them and here - Pavlov had to not touch his border ones - only some that were deployed far from the border - he began to withdraw the 2nd echelon and reserves on June 7, 00 ..
      1. +6
        17 July 2018 17: 01
        Well, do not touch - this is one thing, but he could have organized temporary field depots,
        organize additional communications, find at least some of the officers who went on vacation,
        call Uncle Vasya at the warehouse, which allows the seizure of equipment upon request of the unit commanders, deploy medical posts, requisition part of civilian vehicles, mine additional motorways or otherwise block them, strengthen control of bridges and road junctions, strengthen security of communications and headquarters, issue additional dry rations, issue additional instructions in case of alarm - so that they do not look for the commander, but immediately run where necessary, strengthen the fighter's duty links at aerodromes, set up additional observation posts, night advance to masked defense positions, force completion of technical repairs of tanks, etc. .d. Consult with the rate and specify the threatened direction and extent of the strike. In the early days Pavlov believed that 2 divisions attacked the ZVO, and there were 2 tank groups, plus several infantry reinforcement divisions. Although the aircraft that flew over its border clearly reported that there is much more.
        I don’t know how Pavlov is, but I would have found a thousand cases in his place in the last week before the war. But nothing has been done.
        And during interrogations after the retreat, Pavlov said that the Germans were objectively stronger and he could not do anything, although in winter during operational games Zhukov defeated Pavlov in a very similar scenario. No conclusions were drawn.
        Finally, it was enough for Pavlov to take under tight control only 2 roads,
        so that the German offensive would slow down 2-3 times. but instead, almost all the way along the roads of Belarus, the Germans passed light vanguards in reconnaissance vehicles and motorcycles, easily knocking out very weak guards. Pavlov did not find a couple of dozen tanks to stop this development?
        1. VS
          -4
          18 July 2018 07: 47
          On June 11, they gave such orders to the KOVO - helping to increase combat readiness .. Pavlov chose a different military path - stupidly execute and not take the initiative ...

          Stadnyuk wrote the best thin book on June 22 - "War" .. He clearly worked with the protocols and the essence of Pavlov showed that the main thing is not to be pulled - but what will be there is not important .. And then he began to demand at the first interrogation full-time Tymoshenko and Zhukov .. began to declare that he misunderstood the directives of the people's commissar .. In general, Tymoshenko’s strange behavior and muddy GS directives overlapped Pavlov’s saldophonism ..

          About KSHI in January - it was NOT SO)) Zakharov read about them - there were two games and there Pavlov Zhukov was smashing just))) on one of ...
    2. +2
      10 September 2018 22: 50
      The BTV Academy checked the presence of driver-mechanics in mechanized and tank formations, units and subunits in border districts by 22.6.41. It turned out that there were about 10 of them for about 6000 thousand tanks. Considering that about 20-25% of the tanks were not on the move and remained under bombing in the parks, then by order of a combat alert received at about 2.00 a.m. 22.6.41 ., by the beginning of the bombing and artillery raids at 4.00 no more than 5-6 thousand tanks were withdrawn from the parks. Which, of course, did not have time to leave during the planned time in the areas of concentration designated according to the plan from open secret envelopes. And on the way to these areas they saw how the places in the forests where they, fortunately, were late, were mercilessly stormed by German aircraft. A map of one German pilot shot down from the ground and taken prisoner was escorted to Moscow - it contained the exact location of our troops on 18.06.41/XNUMX/XNUMX, which was recorded on the map.
  24. +25
    17 July 2018 16: 09
    Thanks to the author for an interesting article.
    Don’t worry, the author, the false historian here as always mischief
    I am waiting for the continuation
    1. VS
      -4
      17 July 2018 16: 12
      And what are you - the next anonymous author - found out their articles by our anonymous lady?)))

      That the attack did not wait because Stalin believed the German des or - ??))
      1. +22
        17 July 2018 18: 04
        On June 14, 2018, a meeting of the Guchkov House discussion club was held, which was dedicated to the events of June 22, 1941. It was attended by writer Kozinkin O.Yu. You can read the transcript on the website http://zhistory.org.ua/nikifrov.htm
        Writer Kozinkin O. Yu. for many years "pleases" its readers and teaches others who do not belong to them. A question was asked at the club meeting: where did the 16 army go?
        Get the pleasure of how they dodge. For so many years they wrote about the beginning of the war and did not know it. The final conclusion: they allegedly forgot the leaves and simply can’t remember where the army went. And this is the basis of the beginning of the transfer of troops to the western border.
        But now he teaches the author in seven messages, supposedly he knows it.
        Look again there is no evidence as presented by the author. Some words
        A crook, not a writer. What he can natschit, just dodge and lie
        1. +11
          17 July 2018 18: 32
          There, at the meeting, when Kozinkin was given the floor, he began to show the most correct books to which he refers in his works. therefore he should be trusted.
          Only these books were read by thousands of people and no one came to the conclusions of a false history. There are many other books, but he knows only three. Previously, he wrote more about the answer of the divisors:
          the divisors all wrote about the withdrawal of divisions. the division commanders all wrote about intelligence. When the author wrote on another site that she had looked at all the messages regarding intelligence, Kozinkin stopped writing this so as not to fall for unknowing. Why read books liar)))))
          1. VS
            -2
            18 July 2018 07: 49
            and you personally WHAT book you read from mine ??))) you old man is our anonymous and restless)))

            And - am I really to blame that NO ONE ME ALL THESE YEARS - did not write about the pre-war days and plans ??)))
        2. VS
          -3
          18 July 2018 07: 58
          one fool will ask a question as he thinks smart and a hundred wise men will not be able to answer)) WITHDRAWAL OF ARMIES IN MAY - was connected with the future war with Germany)))

          And you need to ask not WHERE the army was going - all the more with Chita - specific but - WHY)))

          And look at the train cards. roads of the USSR - HOW you can get to Transcaucasia from where your own ARMY WAS DECREASING in Ukraine SAME DAYS)))
  25. +9
    17 July 2018 18: 25
    Quote: V.S.
    Why don’t you show how the DEZU intelligence revealed - with the same Germans moving along the border in order to confuse us?

    Bring the document to the liar Kozinkin. There are two queries, but no correct answers. Give the correct answer to prove that you are worth something
    1. VS
      -3
      18 July 2018 07: 50
      for anonymous people - who didn’t read my books at all - but condemned ???))) - there is nothing more to do but to look for these docks)))

      BTW - Madame herself already somehow brought this up - even Kuznetsov’s reaction to these misinformation))
      1. +6
        18 July 2018 19: 11
        Looking for docks? Well, I say a liar - he’s lying, and in order to confirm his words he still needs to look for docks!
        1. VS
          -3
          19 July 2018 08: 16
          In my books - koi you have not read - I bring everything)))
  26. +7
    17 July 2018 18: 41
    Quote: V.S.
    UNDERSTAND these simple veschs - you will cease to carry nonsense that the attack on the Soviet Socialist Republic in the summer of 41 was not expected in May

    I told you to read the syllables. There is not a single word in this message that in May they expected or did not expect a war. You calm down, drink some water and read word by word. Maybe it will come if there is something left in my head
  27. +9
    17 July 2018 19: 33
    Quote: V.S.
    IN THE SAME DAYS FROM ZAKVO THE ARMY WAS DECREASING THEM TO UKRAINE

    Vrun Kozinkin, name at least one diziviya from ZakVO, what has gone to KOVO?
    They told you: read word by word. He also says that he is a former military man.
    MY GOD! Even I German know that ZakVO and SKVO are different districts. You look at least occasionally a card when you write nonsense.
    Here are the poor people who got this morality in the book.
    1. VS
      -3
      18 July 2018 07: 51
      old man - learn about Konev’s army)))) WHERE and WHERE and WHAT days did IT advance))))
  28. +17
    18 July 2018 16: 10
    To the author, I express gratitude. For more of such articles! And then recently, one "banter"!
    About South Kavakaz. It would be a pity if the Site slides to the OK level. Write more serious articles.
  29. +12
    18 July 2018 19: 16
    Quote: V.S.
    in Transcaucasia from where its ARMY WAS DECREASING IN THE SAME DAYS


    Kozinkin, if you were a trustworthy person, I would believe you. to the word But you are a liar and therefore I do not believe.
    I wrote you look at the map: there is a Caucasian ridge and before it is the North Caucasian Military District, and beyond it is the Northern Caucasian Military District.

    Especially for a writer who is poorly versed in history I will write:
    ZakVO (this is beyond the Caucasian ridge) it had troops - 28 mechanized corps, 3 pages corps (4sd, 20gsd, 47 gsd), 23 pages corps (136sd, 138gsd), 40 pages. , 9gcd, 31gfs, 24gfs, 17gfs.

    SKVO (this is in front of the ridge, you write it down, otherwise you will forget) it had 26 mechanized corps, 34st corps (129sd, 158sd, 171sd), 64st corps (28gsd, 165sd, 175sd), 38sd

    The 19th Army included: 26 mechanized corps, 34st corps (129sd, 158sd, 171sd), 38th and 25th corps from the HVO (127sd, 134sd, 162sd).

    Take a pen and look for at least one division from ZakVO. And who reads your books, this is what kind of di you have to be
    1. VS
      -3
      19 July 2018 08: 24
      Thanks for the help))
      But - and WHAT did this change ?? In ZakVO 16th And hit or not? HOW could she even get there from Chita?))) While the 19th Konev left for these days in Ukraine))

      Poor Madame’s brains were swollen - she was surprised that on THESE days when like the 16th went to Georgia - apparently to fight with Turkey - the 19th went to Ukraine - for an unforeseen war with Germany))

      And I understand that the 16-maneuvers are no more than OUR desa for the Germans - in response to their Notti protesting the withdrawal of this army from ZabVO - Madame is not able to do this))) Like some of my youngsters ’opponents yelling at the RVIO, understand)))
  30. +14
    20 July 2018 05: 03
    Thanks to those who participated in the survey.
    Who is waiting for the continuation - in a week one more part about reconnaissance and further during the 3-4 days - one more. Then the part on air defense, LVO, OdVO, KOVO and ZOVOVO - but I don’t dare to say exactly in terms (the numbers before September 7 will all come out).
    For those who have learned something new - thanks for reading and not leaving negative feedback. I think another 3-5 new things you learn. True, it is necessary to leaf through all the material in search of the desired.
    Those who left negative feedback. Thank you for visiting the page of the article and in the future do not take the trouble to take part in the survey again. The author does not want that if you ignore his subsequent parts, other readers would form an opinion about the "genius of the author" - this is very bad.
    Thank you all, dear readers))))))))))))) And good luck in life!
  31. +10
    20 July 2018 11: 38
    All these figures, layouts, diagrams, and the pros and cons are suitable for analysis and study at the Academy of the General Staff. The general conclusion, understandable to everyone, without any numbers and diagrams, was that the Stalinist leadership was preparing for war, no one denies this fact, but they did not prepare the country for the possibility of a surprise attack from the west, this is also an absolute fact ... And the main fault lies with it on Stalin. It was he who created in the country a moral and psychological atmosphere of the complete suppression of any initiative of the commanders to increase the level of combat readiness, because in that case they questioned the "genius of the leader of all peoples" ...
    1. VS
      -4
      21 July 2018 06: 15
      Stop reading the lights of the time of Gorbi and everything will be fine ..
  32. +1
    11 October 2018 17: 34
    It would be nice to study the important graphs of Soviet reconnaissance estimates of the presence of Nazi Germany troops near the borders of the USSR more widely and more deeply in our separate departments and their sources of information, keeping the same time scan as Pts. correctly applied by the author. Wider - in geography, for example, to a depth of 400-500 km from the borders of the USSR - to the distance of the then average daily run of a military train. It would be good to sort out the information sources by departments (the Red Army, the Red Army, the NKVD, etc.) and by their locations in the bordering countries. The point is not only that over the years 39 and 40 there are striking overstatements of the assessments made to the CENTER (including Stalin personally) (this could be imposed from the Center), but also that it can reveal the failures of the USSR multi-channel intelligence service, very good. instructive.
  33. +1
    11 October 2018 21: 44
    It is worth highlighting the following FACTS noted by the author: "The draft" Strategic Deployment Plans of the Armed Forces of the Soviet Union ... "dated 15.5.41 said:" The deployment of troops and their combat operations are provided with available reserves (for anti-aircraft shots): 37-mm - for 5 days ; 76 mm - for a month and a half; 85 mm - for 11 days ... "

    Taking into account the number of days in the border districts of the anti-aircraft guns and the number of days specified in the “Plans ...” it was planned to spend the following day: 37 / 539 = 5, 108 = 76, 1291 = 45, 28 -mm - 85 / 235 = 11 pcs. Is it a lot or a little? In the memoirs of the air defense veterans it is mentioned about the consumption of medium-caliber assault shells of several thousand for one German air raid. In the author's understanding, "several thousand" is from 21 thousand shells and more. From the calculation of 3 guns in the ass, the consumption of 12 shells per raid is obtained. This amount of shells lasts just 250 minutes of continuous shooting. Now it’s clear: why the Zenap, armed with 10-mm guns, were left without shells on the 85 or 1 day and were taken away with the materiel to the rear.

    The situation was similar with the 37-mm anti-aircraft guns. In PribOVO, on average, the gun accounted for 600 shells, which is more than in other districts. In ZOVOVO and KOVO there were no projectiles for these systems at all. But even in PribOVO, on the second day of the war, the 37-mm gun batteries were transferred to a “hungry” ration - there were almost no shells left. It turns out that small-caliber artillery shot off all the existing 300-600 shells for the 1-2 of the day.

    Thus, if the industry in 1940 (the year when 37 and 85-mm anti-aircraft guns began to enter the spacecraft) and in the first half of 1941 fully fulfilled the plan for anti-aircraft shells, then even this additional amount would hardly be enough for 2- 3 tense days of war with the rate of fire with which the anti-aircraft gunners fired. "These facts were supplemented by the almost complete absence of practice shooting in air defense units and subunits, both in" special "border districts and in the rear, including Moscow, Kharkov, Orlov, etc. The air defense of the country was not ready for war, and the NPO, almost exclusively NPO, was guilty of this. Someone in NPO planned this failure from the beginning of the 30s, and someone planned in 1939-41. This treason was not fully revealed until so far.