From offensive to defense. The battle of Lyubachev enters a new phase

So, the advance of the strike group of the 8 Army was unsuccessful (see 8 Army strike group tragedy).

Adjutant General A. A. Brusilov for the map

A. A. Brusilov tried to shift the blame for the unsuccessful offensive of the strike group of his army and the heavy losses in its units to the poor preparation of these formations, since they arrived from another front. Moreover, the general assigns to these corps a certain share of responsibility for the premature fall of Przemysl. So, he writes in his memoirs that when 2 attacked the aforementioned corps from Lubachev to the south-west, a frontal attack of the enemy was obtained, which had many machine guns and huge artillery, while the advancing neither machine guns nor guns had enough, and even an artillery attack , which was supposed to prepare an infantry attack and support the latter, due to a lack of shells could not take place. The general writes that it could be said in advance that this untimely and insufficient fist, launched in an inappropriate place, will not produce tangible results. As noted by A. A. Brusilov, these 2 corps were of "very high fighting qualities," but, oddly enough, "poorly trained, like most of the troops that arrived to us from the north, and they made an attack not very harsh. Shortly after this attack, Przemysl fell ... ” One gets the impression that it was not the 8 Army command that was responsible for this attack, but someone else. A. A. Brusilov writes about these events as if he was only an outside observer. Let us leave this to the conscience of the honored commander.

The end of the offensive phase of the battle of Lyubachev

The attack of the strike group of the 8 Army was drowned. The offensive of the 3 Army was also unable to realize its goal - by delivering a deep blow to the enemy’s rear, to restore the situation on the river. San and help the 8 Army to stay in Przemysl.

The offensive at Lyubachev expanded the Russian bridgehead on the left bank of the lower reaches of the river. San, restored the situation from Pregendzel to the mouth of the river. Lyubachevka, but did not allow to seize the bridgehead on the right bank of the Sana'a - from the mouth of the river. Lyubachevka, between the river. R. San and Lyubachevka. The enemy managed to concentrate significant forces and firmly strengthen.

Limited tactical success during the offensive at Lubachev was achieved at a high cost - by pulling reserve corps into the battle (the 14 Army in the 3 Army and the 2 Caucasian Army in the 8 Army). The combat strength of the remaining corps was significantly reduced.

The failure of the offensive operation by Lyubachev and the abandonment of Przemysl had a disintegrating effect on the structure of the South-Western Front. Changing operational and strategic tasks and priorities, a new alignment of forces in Galicia and southeastern Poland led to the fact that the front was divided into 2 groups: one - the 4 and 3 armies - based on Lublin, the other - 8 , 11-I and 9-I Army - based on the Kiev Military District.

The operation near Lyubachev 19 - 22 in May is indicative of fierce oncoming battles, successful for the Russian troops, and the manifestation of the highest valor on the part of soldiers and officers of the Russian imperial army.

From a tactical point of view, the limited maneuverability of the formations of the South-Western Front and the poverty in the sphere of material and technical support of the Russian troops had a great influence on the unsuccessful outcome of the offensive operation. A participant in the operation wrote that Russian counterattacks and offensive operations, deprived of the support of the necessary artillery fire, develop either very slowly or not at all, encountering the enemy’s fire curtain and artificial obstacles not destroyed by artillery fire. The adversary uses this slowness to develop his strike in other directions. And by quickly achieving success in other areas, the enemy creates a new environment, in the presence of which the expediency of continuing the attack undertaken by the Russians either completely disappears or even creates the danger of a deterioration in the general situation.

From offensive to defense. The battle of Lyubachev enters a new phase

In fact, the offensive at Lyubachev is a battle for Przemysl. The idea itself - by active actions on an adjacent sector of the front to distract the enemy's attention from the assault on the fortress - was absolutely true. The fortress during the First World War could survive only thanks to the success of the field forces. But the same situation was repeated as during the battles at Radymno - the actions of the quantitatively and qualitatively weak Russian 3 Army did not lead to a significant change in the operational-strategic frontier on the South-Western Front. the setting. The effect of the blow, despite the tactical successes of the Russian troops, was minimal, and did not affect the fate of the fortress. The enemy did not begin to transfer additional troops to the offensive zone of the 3 Army, nor did he suspend the assault on Przemysl. As during the battles at Radymno, the enemy ignored the tactical defeat of one of his army (the Austro-Hungarian 4) in order to achieve a strategic goal. As a result, a small area of ​​the left bank of the river was captured. San, but due to an even greater weakening of the troops of the Southwestern Front - primarily the 3 Army. The enemy, covering herself from this army by Austrian troops, dealt the main blow to the Russian 8 Army, using its best formations for this operation - the corps of the German 11 Army. And by May 22, Russian troops left Przemysl. Having solved the strategic task, the enemy began to supplant the remaining armies of the South-Western Front - successively delivering attacks on the 3, 11, and then the 9 armies.

Lyubachev defense

During the defensive battles at Lubachev on 30 in May - 3 on June 1915, the main enemy of the Russian troops was the German 11 Army, Colonel General A. von Mackensen. By the end of May, it received significant reinforcements and included: the German Consolidated (56 and 119 I infantry divisions; commander - Major General K. von Behr); 10 Army (19 and 20 I Infantry Divisions; commander - General of Infantry O. von Emmich), 22 I (43 and 44 I Reserve, 107 I Infantry Divisions; commander - General Cavalry E G.N. von Falkengine); Guards (1 and 2 I Guards Infantry Divisions; commander - General of the Infantry K. F. von Plettenberg); 41th reserve (81th and 82th reserve divisions; commander - infantry general G. von Francois) corps; Austro-Hungarian 6th Army Corps (39th Honored Infantry and 12th Infantry Divisions; commander - Field Marshal-Lieutenant A.F. Arz von Straussenburg).

In the ranks of the enemy are the 1th Guards Field Artillery Regiment, the Guards Corps of the German 11th Army. 1915 Propulsion The Parade of the Guards Corps, infantry general K.F. von Plettenberg and the chief of the 1th Guards Infantry Division, Major General Prince Eithel Friedrich of Prussia, take the parade. New York Public Library

From May 23 to May 29, the adversary remained passive and improved his position.

But on 7 hours of the 30 on May, he opened a strong artillery fire on the right flank of the 24 Army (48 I Infantry Division) and the left flank of the 3 Caucasian Army (52 I Infantry Division) corps. At 9 o'clock in the morning the enemy launched an offensive, especially actively - at Monasterzh, Melnik and between Zaponts and Shmule.

After fierce battles, in the evening of May 30, the 52th Infantry Division moved north, occupying the Senyava-Tsedyly front, and the 48th Infantry Division was pushed north from the river. Lyubachevka - on the Tsedyly line - 189 height. With the support of the reserves of the 48 Infantry Division, it was again possible to occupy the Tsedyly-Veremetsk front.

To be continued ...
Our news channels

Subscribe and stay up to date with the latest news and the most important events of the day.

Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +11
    October 18 2019
    The transition from offensive to defense is fraught with the fact that the initiative passes to the enemy, but the situation is ripe
    1. +11
      October 18 2019
      What can you do?
  2. +10
    October 18 2019
    Combined operation, very interesting
  3. +3
    October 18 2019
    One gets the impression that it was not the 8th Army command that was responsible for this attack, but someone else. A. A. Brusilov writes about these events as if he was only an outside observer. Let us leave this to the conscience of the honored commander.

    His usual practice: victory is his merit (although he only voiced the ideas developed by his headquarters), like defeat, anyone is to blame, but not him. Deserved? No.
    1. +9
      October 18 2019
      Be that as it may, this episode is a dark spot in the general’s career. However, in fairness, such spots can be found in most generals
      1. +4
        October 18 2019
        Quote: Hunghouse
        dark spot in the career of a general

        A senseless disastrous "Kovel meat grinder" - whose merit? Also his.
        1. +11
          October 18 2019
          Yes, and a quick departure to the Gorodok position with the surrender of Przemysl, also his
    2. -1
      October 18 2019
      Etozh your tactic Olgovich as everything good is so in the Russian Empire and anyone is to blame for its shortcomings only it is not all bad as it is the USSR
  4. +11
    October 18 2019
    Now the Germans are banking with the Austrians
  5. +11
    October 18 2019
    With unflagging attention, I am following the development of this important operation. Thanks to the author.
    1. +4
      October 19 2019
      Quote: Migrant
      With unflagging attention, I am following the development of this important operation. Thanks to the author.

      From the bottom of my heart I join these words. hi
  6. +1
    October 18 2019
    The more I learn about Brusilov, the worse the opinion of him becomes.
    1. +10
      October 18 2019
      The esteemed Dmitry probably does not know the ideal commanders.
      But yes, I personally set such generals as P. A. Pleve and N. N. Yudenich to put him higher
  7. +10
    October 18 2019
    Great-grandfather fought in the year 15 Poland
    Bright memory
    Eternal memory to all who fell for their homeland !!
  8. +8
    October 19 2019
    As one lady rightly wrote, such courses need to be introduced to the history textbook at school!
  9. +9
    October 20 2019
    In truth, victories have many fathers, and only defeats are always orphans. It is a pity that Brusilova does not paint this act. Could fail to blame on the Germans, such as there are more and they are stronger ...
    1. +8
      October 20 2019
      And even better - on the Germans with the Austrians))
  10. +4
    October 21 2019
    Always for surgery, a fracture is very important and dangerous. We look forward to continuing.
  11. +4
    October 22 2019
    Though not the topic, but here is such an interesting nuance

    That is, during these years, all five allegedly visited (or stayed) in Vienna, visiting their favorite cafes (indicated on the map). Everyone’s favorite cafes are different, but theoretically there was an opportunity to meet.
    They knew the canals where to walk wink ))
  12. The comment was deleted.

"Right Sector" (banned in Russia), "Ukrainian Insurgent Army" (UPA) (banned in Russia), ISIS (banned in Russia), "Jabhat Fatah al-Sham" formerly "Jabhat al-Nusra" (banned in Russia) , Taliban (banned in Russia), Al-Qaeda (banned in Russia), Anti-Corruption Foundation (banned in Russia), Navalny Headquarters (banned in Russia), Facebook (banned in Russia), Instagram (banned in Russia), Meta (banned in Russia), Misanthropic Division (banned in Russia), Azov (banned in Russia), Muslim Brotherhood (banned in Russia), Aum Shinrikyo (banned in Russia), AUE (banned in Russia), UNA-UNSO (banned in Russia), Mejlis of the Crimean Tatar People (banned in Russia), Legion “Freedom of Russia” (armed formation, recognized as terrorist in the Russian Federation and banned)

“Non-profit organizations, unregistered public associations or individuals performing the functions of a foreign agent,” as well as media outlets performing the functions of a foreign agent: “Medusa”; "Voice of America"; "Realities"; "Present time"; "Radio Freedom"; Ponomarev; Savitskaya; Markelov; Kamalyagin; Apakhonchich; Makarevich; Dud; Gordon; Zhdanov; Medvedev; Fedorov; "Owl"; "Alliance of Doctors"; "RKK" "Levada Center"; "Memorial"; "Voice"; "Person and law"; "Rain"; "Mediazone"; "Deutsche Welle"; QMS "Caucasian Knot"; "Insider"; "New Newspaper"