"Strela-10" against UAVs. The army is modernizing military air defense

39
"Strela-10" against UAVs. The army is modernizing military air defense
Camouflaged air defense system "Strela-10MN" in a combat zone


During the Special Operation to protect Donbass, the military air defense of the Russian army faced a number of characteristic challenges and threats. She managed to quickly find methods to counter new threats, as well as gain the necessary experience. Now, based on the accumulated experience, plans for the development of military air defense are being finalized. According to recent reports, its overall performance is going to be increased by improving the organizational and staffing structure and further modernizing the material part.



development Plans


The Russian ground forces have a large number of military air defense units and units equipped with various types of equipment and weapons. In particular, as part of tank and motorized rifle regiments and brigades there is at least one battery of the Strela-10 anti-aircraft missile system. Previously, it was assumed that in the medium or long term such units would receive new types of air defense systems.

During the current Special Operation, the latest modifications of the Strela-10 air defense system demonstrated their potential and ability to effectively combat various air targets. In addition, the possibility and necessity of improving the organizational structure of air defense units and subunits was shown in order to further increase overall efficiency.

On November 20, the Izvestia publication, citing its sources in the defense department, announced plans to strengthen military air defense, taking into account the experience of its work within the framework of the Special Operation. The corresponding decision has already been made, and the first steps in this direction are being taken. The publication reveals the main features of the adopted modernization plan, but cannot yet provide all the exact data.


Missile launch and target destruction

It is reported that a certain number of new batteries and divisions will be created as part of the military air defense. The exact number of such units cannot yet be named, but it will be sufficient to solve the problems at hand in any conditions. The main task of the new batteries and divisions will be the fight against unmanned aviation an enemy that poses a known danger to troops.

According to Izvestia, the new air defense units will be equipped with the Strela-10M3 and Strela-10MN complexes using the 9M333 guided missile. It was the systems of this family that showed the best results in the fight against UAVs during the Special Operation. They successfully intercept Drones all major types and classes, from commercial quadcopters to unmanned aircraft.

The process of forming new units within the ground forces has already begun. The timing of the necessary activities has not been specified. However, it is clear that the Ministry of Defense will make the necessary efforts to quickly reorganize the military air defense unit engaged in the Special Operation. Then they will probably work on improving the remaining parts and connections. All this will require effort and time, but the expected result completely justifies all the expenses.

Technical potential


From the published data it follows that the new air defense units will retain all the main functions, but special attention will be paid to the interception of unmanned aerial vehicles. At the same time, it is reported that the best results in this area were shown by the Strela-10 air defense system of the latest modifications. In general, such results of combat use are not surprising.


Launcher during combat duty

The Strela-10 family complexes have a number of important features that ensure high efficiency in the fight against air targets. At the same time, the modernization of such equipment continues through the introduction of new components and products, as a result of which the latest versions of the air defense system are distinguished by increased tactical and technical characteristics.

The Strela-10 air defense systems of all major modifications were built on the MT-LB chassis. This vehicle has sufficient load capacity and high mobility characteristics, and is also widely used in the army and is well mastered in terms of operation. An air defense system on the MT-LB chassis can accompany troops on the march, incl. on rough terrain and provide constant defense.

The Strela-10 operator searches for targets and performs preliminary guidance visually or using an optical sighting device / optical-electronic station. Radar is used only to estimate the location of the target and the possibility of launching a missile. It is possible to work on external target designation. All this ensures sufficient accuracy and speed, but at the same time reduces radiation from the combat vehicle and makes it difficult for the enemy to detect it.

All missiles of the Strela-10 family of air defense systems have a similar architecture, but in later products, due to the new element base and other solutions, it was possible to more fully realize the existing potential. The newest ammunition for Strel-10 is the 9M333 anti-aircraft guided missile. It was first presented in 2020, and subsequently it was reported that the tests were successful and the start of deliveries to the troops.

The 9M333 is a solid-fuel guided missile over 2,2 m long with a body diameter of 120 mm and a mass of 41 kg. The high-explosive fragmentation warhead has a mass of 5 kg and is significantly heavier in comparison with previous missiles of the family. An advanced infrared homing head is used. Launch range – up to 5 km.


During the Special Operation, later versions of the Strela-10 complexes showed their ability to timely detect air targets of different classes, incl. the most complex ones are in the form of small UAVs. Thanks to a modern seeker with high performance, existing missiles successfully track such targets and ensure their destruction. As it turned out, such heads are capable of confidently aiming even at low-power UAV engines with limited heat generation and at small-sized visually contrasting objects.

Distant future


According to the new plans of the Ministry of Defense, in the near future additional units with self-propelled Strela-10 air defense systems will appear in the army’s military air defense. Such a change in the OHS and an increase in the size of the equipment fleet should have a positive impact on the overall capabilities of military air defense and, as a consequence, on the safety of the ground forces.

However, it should be taken into account that the Strela-10 air defense system is distinguished by its considerable age - its first version was adopted by the Soviet army half a century ago. With all the advantages of modern modernization projects, the potential of the design is almost exhausted. Accordingly, it is necessary to study the issue of further development of military air defense and re-equipment of units.

As a successor to the existing Strela-10 complexes, a new air defense system with the code Sosna was being developed. To date, prototypes of such equipment have been tested, and the air defense system has received a recommendation for adoption. The issues of mass production and the start of supplies of equipment to the army are now being resolved. In the long term, the new Sosny will have to complement and displace, and then replace, the existing Strela-10.

Such a replacement will only have positive consequences. The Sosna air defense system was created taking into account the experience of operating and using the Strela-10 and therefore has a number of important differences and features. Due to them, an increase in all basic technical, operational and combat characteristics is achieved.


Wreckage of a Ukrainian UAV shot down by the Strela-10 air defense system

Thus, “Sosna” is proposed to be built on modern common chassis of our army. For the ground forces, an option based on the BMP-3 is proposed, and the airborne forces will have to use an air defense system on the BMD-4M chassis. The complex includes an improved optical-electronic observation and detection station - like its predecessor, Sosna emits practically nothing during operation.

A completely new missile, the 9M340, has been developed. In its design, it is vaguely similar to the 9M333, but has a completely different guidance system. Instead of ICGSN, it uses control equipment for “flight along a laser beam.” The combat vehicle’s equipment is responsible for missile guidance, and high accuracy and noise immunity are achieved. The launch range is stated to be 10 km, and the altitude reach is 5 km, which exceeds the parameters of older missiles.

Answering calls


Thus, during the Special Operation to protect Donbass, the Russian army faced active opposition from enemy unmanned aircraft. However, it turned out that our troops have a completely modern and effective means of combating such a threat - later versions of the Strela-10 air defense system. In addition, other fire systems, suppression means, etc. were in service or later appeared.

In view of the persistence of the main threats, a decision was made to expand the presence of such anti-aircraft systems in the troops and improve their air defense. This will be done through the creation of new units that will staff Strela-10. At the same time, there is already a fundamental possibility of further improving such units - a next-generation land air defense system with improved characteristics has been created and tested.
39 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +21
    22 November 2023 04: 01
    There is a lot of unnecessary water in the publication; it is noticeable that the author is chasing the volume of text.
    As for this:
    They successfully intercept all major types and classes of drones, from commercial quadcopters to unmanned aircraft.
    , then the author either does not understand what he is undertaking to write about, or in a fit of “patriotism” he deliberately misinforms readers.
    The 9M333 missile defense system has a combined seeker (IR and photocontrast channels), but against drones with an electric power plant, the thermal channel is useless, and the photocontrast channel is in most cases not effective due to the small size of the aircraft.
    1. +10
      22 November 2023 08: 57
      Quote: Tucan
      Due to the small size of aircraft, photocontrast is not effective in most cases.

      I will add that this channel can be very easily retargeted to any more contrasting object. If there is cloudiness and the direction is close to the sun, shooting becomes extremely ineffective. At one time, I personally observed that none of the two missiles hit the target, precisely because of the clouds.
      1. +5
        22 November 2023 11: 49
        Let me add: they laughed at the Ukrainians for using expensive missiles for cheap ones, and then - a quadcopter! Is it comparable in price? It’s better to equip the arrow with a shooting rifle, even a shotgun cartridge to invent
        1. +1
          22 November 2023 18: 41
          Quote: novel xnumx
          It’s better to equip the arrow with a shooting rifle, even a shotgun cartridge to invent

          We already have the shell. And everything is as it should be.
          And simple complexes, such as Pine, must be supplemented with Derrivations. I hope that ours will finish them and the shells for them (with remote detonation) in the near future.
    2. 0
      23 November 2023 22: 53
      Quote: Tucan
      then the author either does not understand what he is undertaking to write about, or in a fit of “patriotism” he deliberately misinforms readers.

      In this case, the author writes what actually exists in the SVO.
  2. +9
    22 November 2023 04: 25
    I was pleased with the phrase -

    A completely new missile, the 9M340, has been developed. In its design, it is vaguely similar to the 9M333, but has a completely different guidance system.

    Yes, as they say, find 10 differences.

    In general, in conditions where the main goal is a cheap drone, the missile should be as cheap as possible.

    There were options for replacing Strela -10 missiles with Iglas, now it was logical to look towards Verba.
    1. +7
      22 November 2023 04: 37
      Quote: Pavel57
      A completely new missile, the 9M340, has been developed. In its design, it is vaguely similar to the 9M333, but has a completely different guidance system.

      This missile defense system has a different guidance principle (incompatible with Strela-10) for the new complex, which is not known when it will go into service with the troops.
    2. +10
      22 November 2023 08: 56
      A completely new missile, the 9M340, has been developed. In its design it is vaguely similar to 9M333,


      Most rockets vaguely resemble each other... :))
    3. -1
      22 November 2023 13: 30
      Quote: Pavel57
      There were options for replacing Strela -10 missiles with Iglas, now it was logical to look towards Verba


      And they all have infrared seekers
  3. -4
    22 November 2023 05: 00
    The main danger of a UAV attack is drone swarms. This was confirmed by the practice of the SVO. What will MANPADS offer the troops in this regard? “Peresvet”, a weapon based on new physical principles, has already proven itself:
    On October 19, 2018, military expert Igor Korotchenko stated that laser weapons, in particular the Peresvet complex, work effectively only against UAVs and only “when there is no fog, no sandstorm, no precipitation, that is, in ideal conditions.”

    Maybe it makes sense to create a mobile complex with a hundred 9M340 in its arsenal? Based on the same "Tiger". In a word, the tactic of using a swarm of drones is justified, and we will fight these swarms with the help of (???) request
    1. +4
      22 November 2023 10: 30
      Quote: ROSS 42
      Maybe it makes sense to create a mobile complex with a hundred 9M340 in its arsenal?

      The 9M340 is guided by a laser beam...With a hundred missiles, how many targeting lasers are you going to have on the Tiger? "Sosna" has a limited "channel" ... what kind of "fight against swarms of drones" is there!?
    2. 0
      22 November 2023 11: 52
      Machine guns with shot (needle) cartridges to pollute the space with damaging elements
      1. 0
        22 November 2023 13: 18
        Directed explosion grenades with ready-made generating elements.
    3. -4
      22 November 2023 13: 32
      Quote: ROSS 42
      The tactic of using a swarm of drones is justified, and we will fight these swarms with the help of (???

      By suppressing the control source.
      When shooting with small arms, no one tries to shoot down the bullet, they try to hit the shooter.
  4. +7
    22 November 2023 05: 16
    It is interesting that there is not a single news on the site about the tragedy in Starobeshevo and the death of Menshikh. They even published it in TASS. And where is the air defense?
    1. +5
      22 November 2023 05: 29
      Quote from: costa_2
      It is interesting that there is not a single news on the site about the tragedy in Starobeshevo and the death of Menshikh. They even published it in TASS. And where is the air defense?
      all repeats. either our “gathering” was closed, or the Nazis’. if there is not enough oil in some people's heads. They gather people in a heap in the front line. One call and they arrive.
  5. +4
    22 November 2023 06: 23
    Strela-10 used a photocontrast guidance system. The article describes an infrared homing head. Either I didn’t understand something, or the author!
    Colleagues! Explain to the layman what the system is on this thing.
    1. +5
      22 November 2023 06: 41
      Quote: Amateur
      Explain to an amateur what the system is on this thing.

      If you believe those. characteristics, then both systems operate in parallel in guidance mode...
    2. +4
      22 November 2023 07: 06
      Quote: Amateur
      Strela-10 used a photocontrast guidance system. The article describes an infrared homing head. Either I didn’t understand something, or the author!
      Colleagues! Explain to the layman what the system is on this thing.

      The first mobile military air defense system "Strela-1" used missiles only with a photocontrast seeker, while the missiles of the "Strela-10" complex switched to a combined guidance method, which increased noise immunity and significantly increased the probability of destruction.
    3. +6
      22 November 2023 09: 00
      Quote: Amateur
      Strela-10 used a photocontrast guidance system. Explain to the layman what the system is on this thing.

      Combined. Photocontrast, but IR guidance is also possible. Before launch, the seeker is cooled with liquid nitrogen and becomes quite sensitive to this type of radiation. But in fairness, there is practically no noise immunity.
      1. 0
        23 November 2023 22: 55
        Quote: qqqq
        But in fairness, there is practically no noise immunity.

        And what?
  6. 0
    22 November 2023 08: 08
    I wonder, where is the Strela-10 on the Brdm2? Somehow they are not visible at all
    1. +5
      22 November 2023 08: 42
      Quote: Vadim S
      I wonder, where is the Strela-10 on the Brdm2? Somehow they are not visible at all

      All complexes of the Srela-10 family were produced only on the basis of MT-LB.
    2. +6
      22 November 2023 09: 01
      Quote: Vadim S
      I wonder, where is the Strela-10 on the Brdm2? Somehow they are not visible at all

      This is Strela-1. The missiles are probably completely rotten by now.
      1. +3
        22 November 2023 10: 41
        Quote: qqqq
        This is Strela-1. The missiles are probably completely rotten by now.

        About 15 years ago, Strela-1 was available in the Pacific Fleet Marine Brigade. But at the same time, the Marines had a tank battalion with T-55s.
        1. -3
          22 November 2023 14: 18
          Quote: Tucan
          15 years ago, Strela-1 was in the Pacific Fleet Marine Brigade. But at the same time, the Marines had a tank battalion with T-55s.

          The rocket has a shelf life of 7 years.
  7. +3
    22 November 2023 14: 25
    According to the new plans of the Ministry of Defense, in the near future additional units with self-propelled Strela-10 air defense systems will appear in the army’s military air defense. Such a change in the OShS and an increase in the size of the equipment fleet should have a positive impact on the overall capabilities of military air defense

    In the USSR, the military air defense system was constantly being improved - at the peak, each regiment (small or TP) had a division consisting of 3 batteries (Strela-10, Tunguska, Igla man-portable air defense missile system), when before the SVO the divisions were revived in the regiments there was only a battery (4 Strela-10 and 4 Tunguska/Shilka).
    Those. First, the Soviet military air defense system was destroyed, and now WE OBJECT!
  8. +3
    22 November 2023 17: 19
    all these arrows, wasps, needles can do little to help our military sitting in the trenches and dugouts at the LBS. Firstly, the carriers of their missiles, except for the needles, cannot get close to the LBS due to the high risk of being hit by artillery fire. Secondly, these missiles with infrared and photocontrast seekers are not effective in the fight against UAVs that are very small in size and have an electric motor powered by batteries. And for the most part, the drones working on our front lines are exactly like this. To protect against such drones, our trenchmen and attack aircraft need modern anti-drone guns and portable portable electronic warfare devices capable of suppressing their communication, control and navigation channels. Moreover, such devices should be in every company, reconnaissance group and DRG. And also for the crews of tanks, self-propelled guns, infantry fighting vehicles and towed artillery crews. Then it will be possible to talk about the real neutralization of enemy UAVs. Arrows, wasps, pine trees can protect columns of armored vehicles, stationary objects from aircraft attacks, large attack drones, but nothing more.
    1. +1
      22 November 2023 18: 36
      Anti-drone guns are far from the best tool. If you are interested, look at the tests of anti-drone guns from the 911 laboratory. It is long, difficult, and the main thing, again, is to determine and detect the UAV. We need a comprehensive solution and simple, cheap methods of combating. There are and use UAV hunters, there are detectors detection of UAVs, there is RB, RTR, but everything is not massive in itself, and often not combined. Everything needs to be united and unified. An extensive network with fast data transfers must work, so that it becomes possible to leave, take cover or destroy the UAV.
      1. +3
        23 November 2023 14: 36
        What’s so complicated, time-consuming and expensive about an anti-drone gun? The main thing is that it contains a UAV operating frequency detector and a generator with an automatically tuning and changing frequency band. All these blocks are made by the Chinese and sold on Aliexpress. If a group of our journalists or the military accompanying them had such a gun, the Maskhud correspondent could have remained alive. A drone, apparently a Mavic, attacked them, dropping grenades from 50-100 meters, where it was already visible and clearly audible, but the attacked could not do anything about it, just run in different directions and hide. Complete defenselessness and helplessness. If they had this gun or portable portable electronic warfare in their hands, journalists could timely detect an enemy drone and prevent him from dropping grenades on them. Enemy UAVs have become a big problem for our military and civilians, and in order to solve it, the state must set a task for our military-industrial complex and business to establish mass production of these portable field devices. To do this, it must place a government order for this, with appropriate funding. Then things will move forward and real protection against drones will appear in the army.
  9. 0
    22 November 2023 18: 28
    Why is “Komar” not being considered? An installation with “Verba or Igla” missiles in combination with ATGM missiles of the “Sturm” complex. A completely suitable development considering the location of at least “Strela, Sosny” to the combat line or as protection against DRGs.
    1. 0
      23 November 2023 23: 04
      Quote: Mikhail Maslov
      Why is “Komar” not being considered? Installation with “Verba or Igla” missiles

      Because if you do not produce and use 9M333, then the total number of short-range missiles will be less.
  10. +1
    22 November 2023 21: 48
    It is advisable for the developer to introduce both missiles into the BC. Since Stray-Streak often missed the target due to the disadvantages of laser guidance. The target managed to hide behind trees or other obstacles. Plus, poor visibility reduces the efficiency of the laser illumination.
  11. +1
    23 November 2023 00: 08
    Against drones it would be nice to have something economical, for example derivation, by the way, the least is heard about it, or rather, nothing is heard at all, I hope it is being finalized, because air defense of this type may well become the basis in the near future
    1. +3
      23 November 2023 16: 23
      The problem is that there is no coordination between the design bureau, enterprises and the military. In the summer, at an exhibition in Abu Dhabi (I could be wrong, it looks like it was there), one of our design bureaus boasted of a 30 mm programmable projectile. That is, there is already a 30mm projectile capable of effectively and economically fighting UAVs. The question is, who in the Moscow Region knows about this? Has a 57mm projectile for Derivation been developed? There is at least some kind of cooperation between enterprises. It seems that everything rests on the private initiative of individual designers and engineers.
      1. 0
        23 November 2023 22: 51
        Quote: Timur_kz
        That is, there is already a 30mm projectile capable of effectively and economically fighting UAVs.

        Why did you decide that it was “effective and economical”?
  12. 0
    24 November 2023 01: 24
    The high-quality operation of the Strela-10 air defense system primarily depends on its location on the ground, taking into account dangerous directions and close interaction with reconnaissance equipment at other levels. Overall the text is informative. Star good drinks
  13. +1
    3 December 2023 08: 43
    Ryabov writes according to a standard template, you don’t have to read it
  14. 0
    4 January 2024 19: 55
    So there is a newer Sosna air defense system, why isn’t it being tested where?