Germany to build largest submarines for Israel since war

41
Preliminary render of an Israeli Dakar-class submarine, ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS)

On January 20, 2022, in Tel Aviv, the Israeli Ministry of Defense signed an agreement with the German shipbuilding association ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS) to design and build three new non-nuclear submarines for the Israeli Navy.

The deal is very large in terms of money and is estimated at 3,1 billion euros, while the German government will allocate a significant amount to partially co-finance the project.



Another interesting feature of the agreement is that the German shipbuilding company will build the most advanced non-nuclear submarines for Israel.

Submarines are likely to receive a VMPL (Vertical Multi-Purpose Lock) module developed by TKMS engineers, designed to accommodate underwater vehicles, vertical missile launchers or an airlock chamber for combat swimmers.

Another interesting point is the fact that non-nuclear Dakar-class submarines for the Israeli Navy are likely to be the largest submarines built in Germany after World War II. Their underwater displacement can be more than 2 tons.

For comparison: the most advanced German diesel-electric submarines of type XXI, which had a huge impact on the entire post-war submarine shipbuilding, had an underwater displacement of approximately 2 tons.

What is known about the contract concluded in Israel


History, of course - a lady with self-irony.

Less than a century ago, Germany and German society were obsessed with ideas of anti-Semitism, which turned into a terrible tragedy for the entire Jewish population of Europe, and today German defense companies are the main partners of the Israeli navy.

The ties established between the countries are quite strong and have only been expanding in recent years. In addition to submarines, Germany is building modern corvettes for Israel.

Germany to build largest submarines for Israel since war
Israeli Dolphin-class submarine, 2010 photo, wikimedia.org

Four Sa'ar 2015 corvettes ordered in Germany in 6, along with submarines of the Dolphin and Dolphin 2 types, were built for the Israeli Navy in Germany.

And now the latest submarines for the Israeli fleet will be supplied by the German company ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems, which has become an important partner for Israel in the construction of surface and submarine warships.

The cost of the deal for the construction of three non-nuclear submarines of the Dakar project is a record for Israel. For 3,1 billion euros, the country will receive not only three of the most advanced non-nuclear submarines, but also an extensive set of related equipment, equipment and spare parts. The contract also includes the construction in Israel of a modern training complex for training submariners and a full package of logistical support.

The sale of three non-nuclear boats equipped with a modern air-independent power plant also provides for a compensation agreement between the countries in the amount of more than $850 million. This agreement provides for Germany's obligations to purchase products from the Israeli industry, including the defense industry.

Despite the acquisition of three new submarines, the Israeli Navy does not abandon the concept chosen at the end of the XNUMXth century, according to which the fleet should simultaneously have six large non-nuclear submarines. The new Dakar-class boats will replace the Dolphin-class submarines in the Israeli Navy, which will be withdrawn from the fleet after thirty years of service.

Submarine of the Dolphin 2 type with an air independent power plant, photo: thyssenkrupp-marinesystems.com

At the turn of the 2000s, the Israeli Navy received three diesel submarines from Germany, built according to a special project IKL800. The first diesel-electric submarines of this type were designated Dolphin in Israel.

The boats were built in Germany at the Nordseewerke Emden shipyard in Emden, closed in 2010. It is planned that they will be in the fleet until the early 2030s.

In 2006, Israel ordered two more submarines from Germany, this time on a different project. These were modified boats with a larger displacement, equipped with an air-independent power plant, which was not available on the first Dolphin-class boats.

The project was designated Dolphin 2. The first two boats entered the Israeli Navy in 2014-2016.

In 2011, Israel ordered another boat of the Dolphin 2 project. It was a modernized project, modified at the request of the Israeli military.

The boat, which is planned to be handed over to Israeli sailors by 2023, has a total displacement of 2 tons. This submarine could already claim the title of the largest submarine built in Germany after World War II.

Features of submarines of the Dakar type


Judging by the images published on the Internet of future Dakar-class boats, they may well have an even greater underwater displacement than all the submarines ordered by Israel so far. And, perhaps, they will surpass in this parameter the third boat of the Dolphin 2 type, which has not yet been introduced into the Israeli fleet.

Project 212CD submarine render for the German and Norwegian navies, ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS)

The new boats got their name Dakar in honor of the Israeli submarine of the same name that mysteriously died in 1968.

The submarine was bought in the UK and sank while crossing to Israel on January 25, 1968 under unclear circumstances. The submarine was discovered only in 1999.

The new Dakar-class submarines will be the largest in the Israeli fleet. In terms of underwater displacement, they will be comparable to the fourth-generation Russian diesel-electric submarines of Project 677 Lada.

At the same time, unlike Russian boats, Israeli submarines will almost certainly receive a German-made air-independent power plant based on hydrogen fuel cells.

Such an installation is used on all three Israeli Navy Dolphin 2 boats and on modern project 212CD boats, which were ordered by the German and Norwegian navies and will be commissioned at the turn of the 2030s.

This technology allows the submarine to make trips without having to rise to the surface. True, the range of diving in this mode is seriously limited.

Judging by the submitted renderings, Israeli Dakar-class submarines will receive hull lines comparable to the new German Project 212CD boats, which are also planned to enter the German fleet in the early 2030s.

A distinctive feature of the boats, apparently, will be a special diamond-shaped hull. This form was chosen by ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems engineers as part of the implementation of stealth technology.

At the same time, according to previously published renders, which may be preliminary, we can talk about the presence of an elongated cabin on a Dakar-type boat, the dimensions of which allow us to judge the placement of various additional equipment in it. Such a solution, apparently, can increase the length of the boat up to four meters.

Preliminary render of an Israeli Dakar-class submarine, ThyssenKrupp Marine Systems (TKMS)

Experts believe that the presence of such an elongated strong felling may be dictated by the specifics of the use of Israeli boats, which will be involved in special operations.

In this case, the extra space will come in handy to accommodate the special forces soldiers with all the necessary gear and equipment.

It is also possible that the Israelis needed the increased size of the cabin to accommodate missiles of increased size and power on the boat. Probably, we are talking about ballistic missiles. There have been examples in history when missile silos were located in an elongated felling fence.

Such a solution, in particular, was used on the first Soviet submarines, which were equipped with ballistic missiles. For example, on boats of project 658M.

The transfer of three new submarines to the Israeli Navy should take place in the early 2030s, it was previously reported that the first submarine could be ready as early as 2027.

As part of the Israeli fleet, they will replace Dolphin-class boats, which are distinguished by a much more modest displacement and do not have an air-independent power plant.
41 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +3
    31 January 2022 04: 35
    Such a solution is likely to increase the length of the boat to four meters.
    And in Russian, poorly? "...by four meters..."
  2. +5
    31 January 2022 05: 14
    When will our designers give birth to VNEU? Or, due to failures, they considered it unjustified?
    1. +15
      31 January 2022 07: 30
      When they stop paying the designers a salary in the amount of a beggarly handout, they will immediately give birth, no questions at all ...

      Vacancies P.I. Baranova":

      Leading design engineer in the department of the chief designer - from 30 rubles. on hand, https://hh.ru/vacancy/000
      Engineer - technologist in the department of the chief technologist - from 20 rubles. on hand, https://hh.ru/vacancy/000

      You need to clearly understand that stagnation in development and production is the conscious position of the current Russian plutocratic leadership.
      All of it, from the very top to the effective lower-level manager, is riddled with betrayal.

      Where does the current president's daughter live?
      In the Netherlands!

      Management needs PR visibilitybut not real products.
      They will not go into a real conflict with the West, their home, families, assets are there ...
      Ukraine - yes, it is possible.
      But not more.
      1. +3
        31 January 2022 09: 57
        Quote: Sergey BM

        Ukraine - yes, it is possible.

        The war with Ukraine is part of the plan to destroy Russia. A long, exhausting, senseless war.
        Divide et impera - Divide and conquer

        Everything else is correct. The real enemies of Russia are in power.
      2. -3
        31 January 2022 10: 19
        Quote: Sergey BM
        Where does the current president's daughter live?
        In the Netherlands!

        Where did you get it from? Just nonsense. But you believe, believe.
        1. +4
          31 January 2022 10: 47
          Likewise - where did you get that nonsense from?
          Peskov said?
          So he is a well-known liar (offshore, watch, caught lying more than once)
          And in support of my statement there is a body of information from a variety of sources.
          Believe me - this is for you.
          I do not believe, but I estimate the probability at 99,99%
          1. -3
            31 January 2022 12: 01
            Quote: Sergey BM
            I do not believe, but I estimate the probability at 99,99%

            It's absolutely incredible. Since such a lever of influence is impossible to leave. Nobody left. And fakes about Putin's daughters abroad... You can compose. And what, they won’t ask for it. For spreading rumors and gossip...
            1. +3
              31 January 2022 12: 13
              How many do not say halva - it will not become sweeter in the mouth.
              How many do not yell "fake" - they will not believe.
              And the levers of influence are so obvious that only a clearly dishonest propagandist who is following the instructions can not notice them.
              The full name of the new head coach of the St. Petersburg hockey SKA is Roman Michael Oliver Borisovich Rotenberg. He is a citizen of Russia, Great Britain and Finland, but he is not a foreign agent, but the head of the headquarters of the Russian national hockey team.
              - also fake?
              Like 10 thousand similar facts?
              Oh, nurse, it's you who can screw the churbans ...
              Here is Jorrit Faassen, the real reliable truth.
              It's 99,99% likely
              And even if you get out of it - there will be no sense from that.
              We see, we hear, we know.
              Something other than the screams of hired screamers.

              PS: that's all, I have no desire to "discuss" with marketers, liars, propagandists.
      3. 0
        31 January 2022 19: 51
        Is this accurate information? Or free speculation?
      4. -2
        31 January 2022 20: 06
        And what is the relationship between salary and funding for the development of something? Salaries just correspond to the level of knowledge of those who go to work for such enterprises, there is simply nothing more to pay for. Those who want money and know how to look in the direction of poorly financed state-owned companies do not look, and only pensions can afford to sit and wait by the sea for the weather - they don’t care anymore.
    2. -2
      31 January 2022 13: 02
      When will our designers give birth to VNEU?

      the question is expediency and principle, apparently
      VNEU - in the form that we have, this is NOT VNEU - this is why there is a misunderstanding
      different installation principle
      it's like a massive and cheap T-34 and an expensive and small series of the Royal Tiger
  3. +12
    31 January 2022 06: 09
    It feels like I read 3 different texts from XNUMX different authors....
    1. AUL
      +5
      31 January 2022 08: 50
      So the article is compiled from three different translations on this topic. For the first time, right?
  4. -1
    31 January 2022 06: 42
    For such a small country, a very large fleet. Is that expensive? :)
  5. +1
    31 January 2022 07: 41
    I have a question for those who know. What is the total energy consumption of an air-independent installation at one gas station in kWh., what is the weight of this installation and what capacity batteries are commensurate with this weight.?
    1. +5
      31 January 2022 09: 31
      There is no single answer here, it is technically possible to create about a dozen options, VNEU, but today only a few are used and mainly with a Stirling engine, no details are disclosed. , however, it must be borne in mind that this option seriously complicates the submarine, if in the usual simplified version there is a diesel engine with diesel fuel, an electric generator, an electric propulsion engine and a battery, then here it is added, a container with liquid oxygen, the stirling itself, (ideally a special fuel for heating it) and a chemical absorber of combustion products. To reduce the dimensions of the absorber, it is desirable to use the removal of water and the liquefaction of carbon dioxide released during combustion, that is, you will also need a compressor or a turbo expander plus cylinders for storing carbon dioxide. therefore, weight characteristics and energy consumption must be considered taking into account all this additional equipment.
      1. -2
        31 January 2022 09: 39
        carbon dioxide storage tanks
        Why not let her go overboard?
        1. +4
          31 January 2022 09: 52
          Why not, it is possible, but it is better to do it periodically, and then the carbon dioxide formed during the operation (heating) of the stirling can be usefully used in certain situations, to fill the compartment in case of fire or when purging ballast tanks during an emergency ascent,
      2. -1
        1 February 2022 08: 26
        today only a few are used and mainly with a Stirling engine

        German boats have an electrochemical generator
        Stirling - Swedish
    2. -1
      31 January 2022 10: 30
      Quote: man in the street
      I have a question for those who know. What is the total energy consumption of an air-independent installation at one gas station in kWh

      On the boats that the Germans build for the Turks, the VNEU power is 150 kW. And it looks like there are two. To put it mildly, not much. Sneaking up at such power is possible, lying on the ground in an ambush is also possible, running away or catching up, charging batteries ... not very much.
      The Japanese refused VNEU. They did have Stirling.
    3. 0
      31 January 2022 11: 09
      Quote: man in the street
      I have a question for those who know.

      In general terms, there is an explanation here.
      https://www.researchgate.net/publication/330899348_Analysis_of_fuel_cell_applied_for_submarine_air_independent_propulsion_AIP_system
  6. -4
    31 January 2022 10: 13
    If only Ukraine was not built!
  7. -5
    31 January 2022 17: 34
    Milking with the aid of the lochocost continues.
  8. Eug
    0
    31 January 2022 20: 43
    Looking forward to tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean between Israel and Turkey?
    1. 0
      31 January 2022 23: 09
      Why suddenly? Turkey and Israel are a NATO bloc.
      1. Eug
        0
        1 February 2022 09: 12
        Is Israel a NATO bloc? Hmm... and in the eastern part of the Mediterranean, a gas field has been discovered, which is claimed by both countries.
        1. 0
          1 February 2022 10: 25
          Well, to be more precise, the main ally outside NATO. It doesn't change the essence. The Pentagon climbs into both of these pockets. Yes, and the secret services of Israel and Turkey are actively cooperating.
          I do not think that Turkey and Israel are on the verge.
  9. +2
    31 January 2022 21: 03
    From the Germans https://www.ndr.de/nachrichten/schleswig-holstein/ and the Dutch https://marineschepen.nl/nieuws translation: "With a length of more than 80 meters, the new boats of the so-called Dakar class will become the largest submarines ever built in Germany. If all goes according to plan, the first submarine should be handed over to the Israeli Navy as early as 2029." Displacement type 212CD (German-Norwegian) on the surface is 2500 tons, underwater - 2800 tons. Underwater displacement type 212CD E (increased version for the Netherlands) is 3200 tons. Underwater displacement Dolphin 3 / Dakar can be in the range of 3400-3700 tons.
    1. 0
      1 February 2022 18: 38
      Confirmation from the TKMS management: https://www.militaeraktuell.at/drei-neue-deutsche-u-boote-fuer-israel/ "Der Trend geht jedenfalls zu größeren U-Booten wie diesen", erklärte Rolf Wirtz damals als Werftvorstand gegenüber THB (Täglicher Hafenbericht). Inzwischen seien auch Boote mit einer Verdrängung von 2.800 und mehr als 3.000 Tonnen in der Projektabteilung in Planung." ("In any case, there is a trend towards larger submarines like this," explained Rolf Wirtz, shipyard director, for THB (Daily Harbor report) In the meantime, the design department is developing submarines with a displacement of 2800 and more than 3000 tons.)
  10. +4
    31 January 2022 23: 08
    The article is empty. In general, no information. Some speculation and incomprehensible conclusions.
  11. 0
    1 February 2022 17: 44
    There is such a thing... Conscience.
  12. 0
    April 1 2022 19: 11
    Bad omen though...
    1. 0
      9 September 2023 23: 49
      Type "Dakar". All boats will be on "ד" -dalet, but not "Dakar"...
  13. 0
    April 9 2022 19: 00
    Better Russian beau monde will build palaces and yachts!