"Some sufferings from that love." Wives of Russian epic heroes

55
Family life of epic warriors is usually in the shadow of the main narrative. Stories about battles with all kinds of snakes and monsters, feats of arms seem more interesting to both narrators and their listeners. The exception is, perhaps, the epic "Stavr Gordyatinovich", in which it is the wife of Stavr who finds herself in the center of the narrative. About this epic told in the article “Prince Vladimir against bogatyrs. Intrigues and scandals of the princely court of the epic Kiev ".

"Some sufferings from that love." Wives of Russian epic heroes

Vasilisa Mikulishna cuts braids before being reincarnated as the ambassador of the Golden Horde




Vasilisa Mikulichna from this epic is also loving her unworthy and boastful husband, and the finale of this stories turned out to be happy, which is rather the exception to the rule. After all, even sincerely loving her husband, a faithful and faithful spouse, in Russian epics sometimes becomes indirectly the cause of his death. The most touching and sad example is “Bylina about Danilov Lovchanin and his wife” (see article “Prince Vladimir against bogatyrs. Intrigues and scandals of the princely court of the epic Kiev ").

But the wives of many other Russian warriors are negative characters. Sometimes it seems that the desire to lime their spouse - almost the only purpose of their life.

Two hypostases of Apraks, wife of Prince Vladimir


Let's start in order, with the wife of the epic Prince Vladimir, who is invariably called Apraksa or Apraxia (Eupraxia). The narrators have a polar attitude Most often, she is an absolutely neutral character, whose function is to sit at a feast next to Vladimir and smile friendly at guests.


V. Ryabushinsky, Vladimir the Red Sun and his wife Apraksiya Korolevichna. 1895


However, in some bylins, Apraksa acts as an intercessor for the heroes before an angry prince; it is she who saves Ilya Muromets who was thrown into the cellar from starvation. Sometimes its wisdom is emphasized. So, choosing a bride, Vladimir voiced one of the requirements for his future wife: "It would be for me, the prince, with whom I would think." In the epic of Stavr, Apraks, the only one in the "Tatar after" learns a woman.


Prince Vladimir and Princess Apraksia, still from the film “Ilya Muromets”, 1956


But in other bylina Apraks willingly accepts "signs of attention" from the enemies of Russia. For example, what is said in “Bylin about Alyosha Popovich and the Snake Tugarin:

[quoteHow does Snake-Tugarin go to white-stone chambers,
Yes, it meets Sun Sunny Vladimir Kiev
With my princess with Apraksoy,
He’s our images, Serpent, does not pray,
Prince Vladimir does not hit the brow.
He sits down at the tables of oak and sugar.
Yes, she puts the princess on her knees.
Yes caresses-mercy Apraks Korolevichna.
As the princess will speak here:
- Now and feast and gazebo
With the dear friend Snake-Gorynychem! "[/ Quote]
The alien king Idol Rebellious also has his plans for Apraksu:
"I after all will burn out Kiev-grad, the church of God,
I will borrow, I will borrow chambers white-stone,
I only let Aprakseyushku into the wards,
Aprakseyushku light is royal,
And I will send Vladimir to the kitchen ”.


For some reason, this time, the princess does not immediately sit down on the knees of another invader, but bargains for two days to think for herself, but there is no talk of suicide.

The king tells her yes these are the words:
"I respect Aprakseyushka, two more days,
In two days you will not be a princess,
You will not live as a princess, but as a tsarina! ”


As a result, in some of these epic entries, Alyosha Popovich and Ilya Muromets are not shy about expressions and “call the trough a trough”, using the appropriate (non-print) word for Apraksa as it seems to them.

Note that Princess Apraks is often called royal. The fact is that this woman seems to have been of Lithuanian descent. In one of the epics, two bogatyrs - Dobrynya Nikitich and Dunay Ivanovich (sometimes Ilya of Murom) were sent by Vladimir to Lithuania in order to marry the royal daughter for the prince. The Danube began its bogatyr service in Lithuania, therefore, knows the local customs and customs, it was probably planned that he would become the main negotiator. But the negotiations did not work. The king, having seen the Danube, asks if he decided to return to the service, and, having received a negative answer, is insulted, calling him a “noblewoman slave”. And the new lord of the Danube, Prince Vladimir, he calls him “the last groom” and the “robber”. The Danube in response is bold, and for this he is thrown into the "deep cellars". The diplomatic mission failed, and Dobryna, in order to fulfill the prince’s assignment and rescue a friend, has to “beat the Lithuanian army”.

Danube Ivanovich and Nastasya


On the way home, it turns out that Apraksa has an older sister, Nastassja, who once had an affair with the Danube (for this reason, the Danube was arrested "for insulting the majesty" and fled from Lithuania to Kiev). And now the hero ignores his former passion. Offended by his inattention, Nastassja overtakes ambassadors in the field and engages in battle with the Danube. Perhaps, in the original version, it was about an ambush, similar to that which the wife of Yaroslav the Wise, Ingigerd, tried to organize, who wished to go to Polotsk to Norman kondotier Eymund (decided that it was too expensive for Novgorod, and would be too dangerous in Polotsk). In the epic, the personal duel of the Danube and Nastasya is described. The Danube wins, Nastasya goes with him to Kiev, where two weddings are played at once - the princely and heroic. A happy ending? Where there: soon pregnant Nastasya will die from the arrow of a drunken husband, who then commits suicide (rushes at the sword) and the Danube River will appear from his blood.


Danube Ivanovich kills his wife during a contest for accuracy


Possible prototypes of Princess Apraksa


But back to the princely palace of the epic Kiev. Some historians have tried to identify Princess Apraks with the wife of the “ancient Vladimir”, referred to in the Ioakimov chronicle:
"Vladimir ... had a wife from the Varyag Advind, Velma is beautiful and wise, about her much of the old narrated and exclaiming in the songs."


Especially valuable here is the testimony that Advinda was the heroine of many "old narrations" and "songs."

The second version is striking in its straightforward obviousness: in one version of the epic, Vladimir sent his heroes, including Dobrynya and the Danube, to woo the daughter of the Lithuanian king for him, giving such instructions:

"You really take the strength, but how much do you need,
Go for Opraksoy and royal.
And the king will give good, duck you and take good,
And it will not give good - take power. "


The king, as we have already said, does not consider Prince Vladimir to be equal to himself, he refuses to “matchmakers” on the grounds that Vladimir is “a former servant” ... Have you already thought of Polotsk and Rogned? But the fate of the unfortunate Polotsk princess is very much different from the fate of Princess Apraksa of Russian epics.

The third version was proposed by a very well-known and authoritative, but sometimes a little enthusiastic specialist - academician B.A.Rybakov. So, get acquainted, Eupraxia Vsevolodovna, sister of Vladimir Monomakh, better known in Europe as Adelgeida. She could well have become the heroine of the Gothic novel (with an erotic bias), only the action in it will be too far from Kiev.


Eupraxia-Adelgeida


At the age of 12-13, Eupraxia was married to Heinrich Long, Count Staden, before her marriage she was brought up in a Catholic monastery for three years, where she changed her faith and received a new name. The wedding with Heinrich took place in 1086, and in 1087 the husband died. Already in 1088, she became engaged to the emperor of the Holy Roman Empire, Henry IV, which caused displeasure in Kiev (this monarch had a too scandalous reputation, and the term of mourning for her husband was insufficient).


Emperor Henry IV, husband of Eupraxia-Adelgeida


In 1089, marriage between Heinrich and Adelheida was concluded in Magdeburg, and in the same year her coronation took place in Cologne. This marriage turned out to be extremely unfortunate, it all ended with the flight of the former Kiev princess to Canossa, to the famous Matilde of Tuscany, under the patronage of the worst enemy of Heinrich - Pope Urban II.


Matilda Tuscan



Pope Urban II


At the cathedral in Piacenza (1095), the fugitive empress accused Heinrich of satanism, a commitment to Nicolaitans heresy, and a penchant for various sexual perversions. The times in Europe were still “dark”, intolerant, therefore, instead of protecting Henry’s rights to freedom to blaspheme, to attend dark masses and the choice of sexual preferences he was subjected to anathema. And Eupraxia, having received complete forgiveness of sins, first moved to Hungary, but at the end of her life she returned to Kiev, where she tonsured into a monastery and died in 1109.

For some reason I like the first version of the origin of the image of Apraksa.

Strange story of Svir's marriage


The story about Svyatogar’s wife seems very unexpected: a girl should have been betrothed to him; a girl will fall near his house, stuck in a beard of golden hair, forged for him by a blacksmith. In the house near which this hair fell, there was only a sick girl whose body was covered with scabies and scabs. In one version of the epic, Svyatogor, struck her, sleeping, with a sword, in a different way - before killing, kissed (at her request). The result was the same in both cases: the opal scab and the girl recovered. In some versions of the epic, Svyatogor always carried her with him. In others, she stayed among the people and became very rich in trade with foreign countries, but she met Svyatogor several times a year when the hero came to her home.


Svyatogor with his wife


It would seem a very strange couple, but this nameless girl remained at the coffin, in which Svyatogor lay ill-advised, and turned into a rakita, from which the spring flowed from under its roots.

But this is the outer, surface layer of this epic. Proponents of a “common approach” to exploring bylinas made an interesting suggestion that a sick girl, miraculously recovered after a sword strike, symbolizes the non-black earths of Northern Russia, which remained barren until iron tools appeared. And the fact that Svyatogr's wife became rich through trade with overseas countries allowed them to conclude that the Novgorod land was meant.

The most beloved hero of Russia, Ilya of Murom, did not get a wife. But he was not a monk either, and therefore in bylinas there are occasionally indications of Ilya's love relationship with certain “bogatyrs” (for example, Savishna's plain). These stories can sometimes serve as an illustration of the thesis about the perniciousness of extramarital relations, especially if they are made in the territory of a “probable enemy”. The terrible and tragic consequences of one of these “novels” of the bogatyr (with a woman named Zlatgorka or Goryninka) were described in the article The most revered Russian hero. Ilya Muromets

Two attempts of Dobrynia Nikitich


Much more fortunate in this regard is his “cross brother” - Dobryna Nikitich. "The first pancake" he, however, also turned out "lumpy." In the not-so-well-known wide circle of readers the epic “Dobrynya and Marinka” tells about a sorceress whom many researchers consider to be the incarnation of the goddess of death Mara (let's also remember Marya Morevna of Russian fairy tales). In punishment for the crystal mirror broken by the arrow of the hero, she bewitched him, but did not want to answer reciprocate. When Dobrynya began to show perseverance and appeared to her, driving away “Snake-Gorynych's dear friend”, he turned an obsessive boyfriend into a bay tour with golden horns and silver hooves.


Dobrynya finds the Serpent in the house of the bewitched Marinka


But one day, after drinking “green wine,” Marinka let out what had turned the good youngsters into 10 tours, including Dobrynya. Dobrynia's mother, having heard that
“Hit Marinka on her white cheek, knocked her off her quick legs, started dragging the brick-built floor. Carries, and itself says: I am more cunning, wiser than you, let me not brag! Do you want to wrap you bitch long tail? Will you, Marinka, walk around the city, will you, Marinka, drive males behind you! ”


If Dobrynia's mother does not “bluff” and speaks the truth, you will have to admit that she is also a witch - and not one of the last!

Marinka agrees to return to Dobryna the former appearance, but with the condition that he marries her. But after the wedding, Dobrynya cut down Marinka's head, and burned her body.


Dobrynya cuts off Marinke's head


He met his real bogatyr wife Nastasya Mikulichna later - “in the field”.


Nastasya Mikulichna and Dobrynya Nikitich, illustration to the epic, Voronov S.


In one of the options, some force keeps him from the fight (the raised hand does not drop). But more often he suffers defeat in battle with her. Sometimes a woman “pulls off” him from the saddle with the help of a lasso (in this case, she is clearly a girl of a nomadic tribe, and she gets the name Nastassja at baptism). Sometimes - pulls off the saddle by the hair (yellow curls). In both cases, it sets the condition: "Do you take, Dobrynya, in marriage, I will let you go, Dobrynyushka, in living creatures?"

In the future, Nastasya somehow loses her heroic strength and appears as an ordinary woman and exemplary wife to the tales listeners. Another famous song (“Alesha Popovich's Unsuccessful Marriage”) tells that, going on a princely assignment to the Horde, Dobrynya asks his wife to wait for his 9 years. Nastasya is waiting for him 12, after which she agrees to marry Alyosha Popovich, who has long been in love with her. Dobrynya returns in time, but for some reason does not declare himself, but comes to their wedding disguised as buffoon. Nastasia recognizes him in this look, and the wedding breaks down.

But Dobrynya himself, as we shall see below, was not a faithful husband, alas.

Scandalous marriage Alyosha Popovich


Alyosha Popovich, so unsuccessfully wooing Nastasya Mikulichna, according to one of the epics, still got a wife, but the story of his marriage is incredibly scandalous and therefore virtually unknown to readers. This song begins with a traditional description of the feast of Prince Vladimir, where the guests (as usual) boast who is nobility, who is wealth, who is young wife. And only the brothers Zbrodovichi (sometimes Petrovichi, Borodovichi) are silent. When the prince himself addresses them, they nevertheless tell about their beloved sister - the Fawn, a modest and beautiful woman who sits in the back room, so that extra people don't see her. Alyosha Popovich laughs at them, claiming that for a long time he and his sister live “like husband and wife”. The brothers, of course, do not believe him, and then he leads everyone to the house of Zbrodovych and throws a little snow-light into the window - it opens up, a long white cloth comes down from it (sometimes Olyon goes out by itself - “improperly dressed”). The angry brothers are going to take the disgraced their sister to the field in order to cut off her head, and then she informs them that the wife of the elder brother is cheating on him with Dobrynia, and the younger spouse is with a kind of Residue. In general, family clashes in the epic went almost like a shameful evening talk show 1 of the Russian television channel. The reaction of the brothers to such news is not reported, but I think that it can be easily guessed. But it is said that Alyosha Popovich comes to the place of the alleged execution and takes Olyonushka to the church for the wedding.


Alyosha Popovich and sister Zbrodovich


Gullible Michael Potyk and treacherous Avdotya-Swan White


Other warriors with their wives were even worse. About Mikhail Potyka and his wife Avdotya-Belaya Swan were briefly told in the first article of the cycle (Ryzhov V.A. "Heroes of epics and their possible prototypes"). Add that, saved by her husband, who went to her grave (and killed the Serpent in her), she tried to kill him three times. Initially turned into stone - they saved Mikhail Ilya of Murom, Dobrynya Nikitich and the unknown wanderer of Kalika. Then she ordered him to be nailed to the wall - this time he was saved by the daughter of the Lyakhet king Nastasya (well, the narrators love this name, nothing can be done about it). For the third time, the wife is trying to poison Pety (gives the goblet with wine as a sign of reconciliation), but Nastasya, who was nearby, invited him to look at his wounded nails, and he disbelieving this time, kills Avdotia.

Soloman and Solomanida


The hero of Solomon’s wife (in the epic, based on the apocryphal Tale of Solomon and His Unfaithful Wife) proved no better. In the absence of the protagonist, the servant of Tsar Vasily Okulievich Ivashka Povarenin (and sometimes the overseas merchant Tarakashka) seduces his wife Solomanid with rich gifts and takes them away on a ship. Soloman, along with the retinue, goes on a search for her, but goes to the discovered wife alone - and, given to her, is captured by Tsar Vasily. Soloman asks to execute him in the open field by hanging two silk loops on the bar (the insidious wife, just in case, adds a third one, saying that her husband passes the first loop with cunning, the second with wisdom, but the third will not pass). As a last wish, Soloman asks to let him blow on the horn of Turii - the squad comes to the rescue and a treacherous wife, Tsar Vasily and his servant Ivashka are hanged on the gallows prepared for him.

Unsuccessful attempt of Ivan Godinovich


Another hero, devoted to his wife - Ivan Godinovich, nephew of Prince Vladimir. However, given that he forcibly married another bride, this is not surprising. This girl, the daughter of a certain merchant Mitrei, was wooed for “the king of Vahramishcha, Koshchey the Immortal” (“Koschey the Immortal” in this case sounds like a title). In other variants, the fiance's tales are called Odolische Koshchevich or Fyodor Ivanovich with Lithuanian choorobuses. Chernigov, the Liakhovinsky kingdom, the Golden Horde and even India are called the place of residence of the bride by the tales.


Koschei Tripetovich, his bride Nastasya and Ivan Godinovich


The father of the girl, who (again!) Is called Nastasya, is categorically against the wedding with Ivan:

"For the king to give - to her queen be called,
For you, Ivan give - slave to slave,
Of course revenge, scrape calls.
I have a spliced ​​dog in my yard -
Give for you, Ivanushko Godinovich. ”


But Ivan is smashing his house, rushes into Nastasya Mitreyanovna’s room, which at this time is embroidering a towel for her real groom, and forcibly takes her away, not forgetting to demand a dowry from her parents. On the way to Kiev, they are caught up by Nastasya's fiancé, who calls Ivan to a duel. Ivan wins, but Koschei, who fell to the ground, turns to Nastasya, inviting her to make a choice:

"For Ivan to be a peasant woman to you,
Portomashchitsey Prince Vladimir,
And for me to be you - the queen be. "


Nastasya comes to the aid of Koschey, together they tie Ivan to the oak, and they themselves enter the tent - “amuse”.


Ivan Godinovich


But Koshchei is hindered by two pigeons (two crows in another version) sitting on an oak tree — they, you see, comment on what is happening, claiming that “not to own Nastasya Koschey, to own Ivan Godinovich”. He comes out and shoots them with a bow - the arrow hits the oak, rebounds, and strikes Koshchei himself, who for some reason dies, although he is called immortal. Nastasya allegedly tried to kill Ivan, but her hand trembled and the sword cut the cords. In my opinion, more than a dubious option: the girl probably freed Ivan, having decided that the living nephew of the Kiev prince as a groom was better than a dead king. The liberated “hero” savagely executes his failed wife: she cuts off her hands first, then her legs, lips, and only then her head.

These are the serious passions seething in the married couples of the heroes of the epic Kiev. However, if you look through the pages of the “yellow press” in search of the criminal chronicles, even today, you can probably find something similar.
55 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +7
    29 June 2019 05: 25
    Unusual, interesting, great!
  2. +4
    29 June 2019 05: 58
    If it's a joke, then in vain the primitive patriots come to the "soulless shows of the first channel." As you can see, they have deep roots in the cultural memory of the people)
  3. +6
    29 June 2019 06: 18
    Mdya ... And about the little dog someday add up ....
    1. +3
      29 June 2019 07: 30
      Alas, the age of informatization and technology! So the maximum that “Doggie” will leave behind, apparently you have K. Sobchak - this is a couple of three memoirs printed or written by order of your own, and also maybe one or two songs of the REP genre! Well, another obituary in the newspaper!
      Sadly, on the traditions of an epic epic and an oral fairy-tale legend, they could live with torches, with the advent of electricity they began to die, with the advent of televisions they had already died.
      Now our youth lives "candy wrappers", what do not ask. To be honest, I don’t understand the meaning of hanging a fictional story on a real “idol”? But the fact remains!
      Regards, Vlad!
      1. +1
        29 June 2019 18: 06
        Do not be a pessimist buddy ... Yes, given the current opportunities, you can order a reprint of any book .. Which is what I do .. Now for me they are printing a reprint called "Alexandria" about Alexander the Great .. But not a single textbook says about the connection between the Slavs and the Macedonians ... But this comes out one people ..
        1. +1
          29 June 2019 19: 40
          Quote: Nathanael
          ........ Right now a reprint is being printed for me under the name "Alexandria" about Alexander the Great ... But not a single textbook speaks of the connection between the Slavs and the Macedonians ... But this is one nation ...

          So, stop Dear! Here we must be careful, our very wide Slavic soul loves to play in categories and spaces, while not noticing time!
          Question one! Who are the Macedonians? In the 4th century BC, it is one of the Greco-Thracian tribes from the Indo-European language group. Which, incidentally, belonged to the Scythians, and the Greeks themselves, and ..... no wonder the Persians !!!
          The second question! Who are the Slavs! A tribal union that arose after the collapse of one of the Indo-European language groups of eastern Europe. And they broke up into Germanic, Baltic and Slavic language groups! And it happened as the earliest at the end of the 2nd century AD!
          The third question! What connects the ancient Macedonians and Slavs? A common language group and possibly common ancestors - arias! In fact, the Macedonians, like the Greeks, were integrated into the Roman Empire, and then came the wild southern Slavs, who in turn were assimilated into the Byzantine Empire! However, at the beginning of the last century, the Greeks of modern Macedonia answered the question of who are you? Romei !!!
          Well, somewhere like that!
          Regards, Vlad!
          1. 0
            2 July 2019 22: 06
            Powerful !! About the breadth of the Slavic soul. Especially in isolation from time .. I will remember .. Question one In the 4th century, the Greeks knew that they were Greeks. They kind of called themselves the Hellenes. Well, they write in the annals .. And why do you write-Greco-Thracian tribes .. The autochthonous population of Hellas is classified as belonging to the Semitic group of languages. New Greek Newspeak is not even close to the so-called Ancient GreekSo like Morozov claims .. And I believe him more .. Who are the Slavs? Yes, the descendants of those tribes that lived in this territory before them .. That is, the Scythians of the Sarmatians and others. I do not believe in the mass migration of peoples. As well as in the sudden disappearance. of them. What connects the Macedonians and the Slavs.? Yes, a common history and culture. If we take our "enlighteners" - as if the Slavs did not know how to read before them, then we read: for the Macedonian The Slavs - I emphasize - the Macedonian Slavs, a disciple of Cyril Clement, created letters that are more convenient than the letters of Constantine. Here's a question for me. They called the writing Cyrillic. Well, okay ... The inhabitants of Byzantium also called themselves Romei ... ..
  4. +3
    29 June 2019 06: 19
    Mdya, we had fun ... by the concepts belay That's terrible !
    By the way, there is an answer to my question about the literature brought by Christianity to Russia, and borrowed stories
  5. +8
    29 June 2019 06: 32
    And so it turns out that the "winged" expression "Shakespearean passions" is somewhat far-fetched ...
    Great stuff, like the whole cycle! Thank you Valery!
    1. +5
      29 June 2019 07: 17
      I support Anton !!!
      Valery - Your today's work is the highlight of the cycle about the epics of ancient Russia. If it’s not a secret, share your plans for tomorrow, otherwise I noticed that in order to discuss the topics of your work, you need to prepare !!! Always unexpected, always aback .......
      Regards, Vlad!
      1. VLR
        +7
        29 June 2019 08: 59
        Good morning! Perhaps I will write another article about Snakes and Russian Tale Monsters, but for now I'll take a break. The next article will be about one of the Allied operations during World War I, which was ready for a long time (it should have outstripped the materials on this topic published here), but was put aside because of the work on articles about epics.
        1. +2
          29 June 2019 09: 17
          Thank you Valery for the answer!
  6. +6
    29 June 2019 06: 55
    Bravo author! Keep going
  7. +3
    29 June 2019 08: 00
    I propose in the next article to consider the horses of the heroes of epics - this is also not an unimportant part of the epic ... But Miracle-Yud (maybe a separate article) also had a cursed dog (Prince Ryazan!)
    1. +4
      29 June 2019 12: 15
      How's that joke?
      Miracle Yudo wakes up after 600 years of hibernation, sees - eccentrics go through the forest in helmets with strange sticks. I decided to shug them out of habit
      - I am the Miracle of Yudo!
      - Hans, yude, faye!
      1. +3
        29 June 2019 12: 16
        Quote: Krasnodar
        How's that joke?

        II !!
        1. +2
          29 June 2019 12: 17
          “Did you blow the rails under the train?”
          - I!
          - So this is ours, the Soviet train!
          - II !!
          1. +2
            29 June 2019 16: 25
            Hi Albert! It is felt that you have taken to heart the law on insulting power. Initially, the joke was about Vovochka ... laughing drinks
            1. +2
              29 June 2019 16: 31
              Hello! )))
              About Vovochka I know only Gut, Waldemar, Gut!
              Like, what did the soldiers say?
              1. +1
                29 June 2019 18: 41
                "Erholen nicht shpatsiren,
                Erholen, dansen, dansen "- said the soldiers.
                In general, it makes sense to read "Young Lions" by Irwin Shaw. Oddly enough, the American reflected the essence, the way of thinking of a German soldier, during WWII
                1. 0
                  29 June 2019 18: 45
                  I read, thanks!
                  Remarque had a couple about WWII, but they were not impressed. He’s somewhat touching about the First, as well as about the Weimar Republic. I didn’t survive it myself - I could not convey it on paper.
                  1. 0
                    29 June 2019 19: 08
                    You know, with Remarque I was impressed only by "Arc de Triomphe" and a novel about a concentration camp, alas, memory, I do not remember the name, I read it for a long time.
                    Irwin Shaw, in defiance of his English namesake, the most powerful American writer of the twentieth century! Back in the USSR, filmed series on his novels!
                    1. -1
                      29 June 2019 19: 34
                      Bernard did not read anything except Pygmalion, to be honest. )))
                      1. +1
                        29 June 2019 19: 43
                        This is Bernard Shaw, and I'm talking about Irwin.
                        "Young Lions"
                        "Rich man, poor man"
                        "Night porter"
                        So, offhand, I read more, but these are the most memorable.
                      2. +1
                        29 June 2019 19: 49
                        I understood. )))
                        Read - see. Poor rich man - I remember the Soviet film. Abdulov seemed to be playing there.
                      3. +1
                        29 June 2019 20: 36
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        I understood. )))
                        Read - see. Poor rich man - I remember the Soviet film. Abdulov seemed to be playing there.

                        Dear Krasnodar, I welcome you! You were mistaken, the cool film * Rich, poor * was shot at a Lithuanian film studio. In the second part of the film from our famous actors G. Taratorkin was involved. Excuse me, but Abdulov wasn’t there at all. And the film is really magnificent, and the book .... !!! I admire and reread it since adolescence. With respect (you know who you are).
                      4. +2
                        29 June 2019 21: 37
                        Immortal phrase: "Kiss me, honey! I defeated Japan!"
                      5. +2
                        29 June 2019 21: 00
                        I greet you Anton! By the way, at the Show (American) Pts. an interesting real name is Shamforoff. But by the name, after all, is Irwin. Well, from the emigrants, he understand.
                      6. +2
                        29 June 2019 21: 34
                        Hello Sergey! This is a question from the category: "Whose writer is Nabokov?" Well, or Rubin.
                      7. +1
                        30 June 2019 08: 30
                        Quote: 3x3zsave
                        Hello Sergey! This is a question from the category: "Whose writer is Nabokov?" Well, or Rubin.

                        Good morning Anton! Yesterday I didn’t answer, they distracted me. Yes, God bless her with her surname, etc., the main thing was just fine! And I remember Thomas’s dialogue with his son: * Stop calling me sir, I’m your father, understand? Yes, sir . * This is the episode when he took him out of military school.
                      8. +1
                        30 June 2019 08: 36
                        I have, the final scene of the novel, the funeral of Thomas.
                    2. +2
                      30 June 2019 11: 52
                      "Spark of life," as I understand it.

                      At first, Three Comrades liked it better.

                      But later I’m returning to the “Arc de Triomphe”.
                      1. +1
                        30 June 2019 18: 04
                        Thank you, Sergey! Absolutely memory became full of holes ... crying
      2. +3
        29 June 2019 16: 18
        Feuer only
        1. 0
          29 June 2019 16: 29
          Heard as faye (foyer)
          In general, German is spoken differently - the Swabians (Stuttgart) have their own dialect, in southern Bavaria and Austria the language is more like Yiddish, etc.
          1. 0
            29 June 2019 16: 44
            Oh sure. Each hut has its own rattles. My father once said that, for example, the Altai Germans (expelled from the Volga region) adapted their vocabulary to Russian. Another example: a couple of years ago, a girl I knew who had been studying modern German for three years, could not explain herself to the seller of the Berlin Lebenmittelgescheft, and had to switch to English.
            But I taught the classic "Deutsch", that's why Anglicisms hurt the eyes.
  8. +5
    29 June 2019 09: 35
    Hello everyone, dear friends, and the author a special thanks! hi

    It’s good that I didn’t read it for the night, otherwise the image of the "insidious wife" with an ax in her hands would have been imagining all night. smile
    All this is terribly interesting, I mean the family entertainment of our distant ancestors, but somehow it is more pleasant for me to remember them, watching, for which time, a series of magnificent cartoons "Bogatyrs". good
    1. +3
      29 June 2019 12: 17
      Konstantin, good day!
      I agree with you completely on the popularization of our epic epic through animation !!!
      By the way, you can long and tedious compare the series about the “heroes” of the publication to catch Mills’s cold with real epics, reproach for the “hollywoodization” of the Russian hand-drawn meter, but for children to understand and recognize the key figures of the epic as defenders of the Russian land made The authors are an order of magnitude more than historians and teachers ...
      Simple, affordable and funny !!! I especially rejoice when the children play “heroes”, I didn’t notice “yes war” behind me, the Germans are ours, the whites are reds, knights, Vikings! But based on the epic epic of Russia, they didn’t make weapons in childhood, they didn’t play Ilya Muromets !!! And today, more than once or twice, I watched the fry (lynuses - slang of my daughter) play "heroes" !!! They argue who will be Ilya Muromets, etc.
      The only thing we get is a solid series about the epic epic. It is epic, albeit with a fabulous element, but without sweeping fiction! "Last hero" does not count, just soap ...
      Regards, Vlad!
      1. +4
        29 June 2019 12: 26
        Good day, Vladislav!

        It is difficult for the present to film something worthwhile after the good old "Ilya Muromets", and where such an artist as Andreev can be found for the main role. Everything became smaller, I stopped watching our films so as not to get upset. But these cartoons delight from the heart. drinks
  9. +3
    29 June 2019 09: 39
    Yeah ... the idea that all the troubles from women, litter, from women, obviously not born today.
    1. +3
      29 June 2019 12: 29
      So, colleague, women, they, too, were not born yesterday. Hand flowed, go hand in hand and walk. request
      1. +1
        29 June 2019 16: 30
        "Wherever they say
        All one, will reduce to women! " laughing
        Hello, Konstantin! drinks
        1. +1
          30 June 2019 04: 33
          Hello Anton! drinks
          He just came back to life and immediately remembered:

          "A good horse is more important to the Cossack,
          To the steppe under the hooves sang,
          Hot blade and accordion
          And women are the last thing !!! laughing

          (C) feature film "When the Cossacks cry".
  10. +5
    29 June 2019 10: 11
    Yes, the cycle is interesting. Thank!
    We read quietly aloud (it’s easier to discuss this way), but in the train the passengers listened, their necks were pulled out.
  11. +4
    29 June 2019 16: 37
    Great article, great cycle.
    From the article one gets the impression that the wives of the heroes were somehow not very faithful and virtuous. It was probably not interesting to hear about faithful and loving wives. I urge readers to judge by the "heroic wives" about the morals in Russia as a whole. At one time I wanted to write material about adultery among the upper class of medieval Russia, but I simply did not find enough relevant material to make generalizations, while in Europe there is enough such material.
    By the way, it is interesting - is it our tradition of chronicling, or did we really have such strict morals?
    1. +2
      29 June 2019 17: 28
      Quote: Trilobite Master
      I urge readers to judge by the "heroic wives" about the morals in Russia as a whole.

      Do not judge, of course. I apologize. request
    2. 0
      29 June 2019 17: 48
      Oh, well, at the end! Hello Michael!
      Everyone was waiting for you to come "from the fields" and say your weighty word! (By the way, "weighty" from the word "weight" or "all")
      My opinion, the Russian chronicles, in general, are scarce in details
      1. +2
        29 June 2019 20: 03
        Greetings, Anton.
        Quote: 3x3zsave
        My opinion, the Russian chronicles, in general, are scarce in details

        The European chronicles are not very detailed either, but when the matrimonial whims of the rulers influence political decision-making, this cannot but affect the events that these chronicles or chronicles record.
        If we take precisely women adultes in royal families, then in Europe such examples can be found, in any case, hints on them are sufficient. For example, Eleanor of Aquitaine or the wife of Louis X of France, or Edward II of England, can be recalled to Margaret of Anjou, wife of Henry VI or Cecilia Neville, Proud of Cis, this is just offhand. It is possible that someone was falsely accused (for example, I don’t really believe in betrayal of Pride Cis, although, on the other hand, where G2 from Plantagenets comes from, anything can happen), but the fact of operating in political struggle with such arguments is very telling - it means believed.
        1. +1
          29 June 2019 20: 11
          Perhaps only women from the Boleyn clan were not remembered! laughing
  12. 0
    2 July 2019 10: 22
    I read articles about epic heroes with interest. It would be interesting to read about the weapons of the epic heroes, about their equipment and from whom (where) it appeared from them.
  13. 0
    13 August 2019 10: 17
    The usual thing. Most women are just that. And before, ordinary women could not behave this way, because a man was needed for a living. Now a woman is able to earn, plus an alpha male shakes child support to help a woman. Because of the initiatives of divorce on the part of women already 70%. A divorce in the Russian regions in places 104%.
  14. 0
    16 August 2019 11: 27
    "Dobrynya, don't you dare. Mind you, you will come back, and I will go to my mother" (From the cartoon "Dobrynya Nikitich and the Serpent Gorynych")
  15. 0
    30 August 2019 19: 54
    Quote: Nathanael
    Do not be a pessimist buddy ... Yes, given the current opportunities, you can order a reprint of any book .. Which is what I do .. Now for me they are printing a reprint called "Alexandria" about Alexander the Great .. But not a single textbook says about the connection between the Slavs and the Macedonians ... But this comes out one people ..

    at the time of Sani it was even relatives, but not the same. Then - yes, the Slavs assimilated the locals and now yes.
  16. 0
    30 August 2019 20: 01
    Quote: Kote Pan Kokhanka
    Quote: Nathanael
    ........ Right now a reprint is being printed for me under the name "Alexandria" about Alexander the Great ... But not a single textbook speaks of the connection between the Slavs and the Macedonians ... But this is one nation ...

    So, stop Dear! Here we must be careful, our very wide Slavic soul loves to play in categories and spaces, while not noticing time!
    Question one! Who are the Macedonians? In the 4th century BC, it is one of the Greco-Thracian tribes from the Indo-European language group. Which, incidentally, belonged to the Scythians, and the Greeks themselves, and ..... no wonder the Persians !!!
    The second question! Who are the Slavs! A tribal union that arose after the collapse of one of the Indo-European language groups of eastern Europe. And they broke up into Germanic, Baltic and Slavic language groups! And it happened as the earliest at the end of the 2nd century AD!
    The third question! What connects the ancient Macedonians and Slavs? A common language group and possibly common ancestors - arias! In fact, the Macedonians, like the Greeks, were integrated into the Roman Empire, and then came the wild southern Slavs, who in turn were assimilated into the Byzantine Empire! However, at the beginning of the last century, the Greeks of modern Macedonia answered the question of who are you? Romei !!!
    Well, somewhere like that!
    Regards, Vlad!


    In order:

    1 - Indo-Europeans - a family, not a group, a group - an offshoot of the branches of the family (for example, the Slavs are a group of the Baltic-Slavic branches of the Indo-Europeans). And what is surprising about the Persians? Indo-Europeans, as it were, and Indo, that Iran and part of India are included in them. And when you start to learn a language, you see how much it is similar to ours (the Slavic languages ​​are / were a bridge between the Indo-Iranians and Europeans themselves, because in the center between the polar ends of the family).

    Further, 2 - Slavs and Germans constitute different branches and were not in the same union, the Germans stand apart. But then there were a lot of contacts between them, yes.

    3 - Aryans are not ancestors, this is just a word from Sanskrit (one of the direct heirs of the Proto-Indo-European language), meaning "noble". And that's all. It is not or was not the name of the entire conventional Proto-Indo-European people. As for the Macedonians, by the time the Romans arrived, they were no different from the Greeks, and, of course, they were conquered. The Slavs migrated there towards the end of Byzantium and assimilated all the locals, so these are such conditional Greco-Slavs, but more Slavs than Greeks. Something like this.
  17. 0
    30 August 2019 20: 12
    Quote: Nathanael
    Powerful !! About the breadth of the Slavic soul. Especially in isolation from time .. I will remember .. Question one In the 4th century, the Greeks knew that they were Greeks. They kind of called themselves the Hellenes. Well, they write in the annals .. And why do you write-Greco-Thracian tribes .. The autochthonous population of Hellas is classified as belonging to the Semitic group of languages. New Greek Newspeak is not even close to the so-called Ancient GreekSo like Morozov claims .. And I believe him more .. Who are the Slavs? Yes, the descendants of those tribes that lived in this territory before them .. That is, the Scythians of the Sarmatians and others. I do not believe in the mass migration of peoples. As well as in the sudden disappearance. of them. What connects the Macedonians and the Slavs.? Yes, a common history and culture. If we take our "enlighteners" - as if the Slavs did not know how to read before them, then we read: for the Macedonian The Slavs - I emphasize - the Macedonian Slavs, a disciple of Cyril Clement, created letters that are more convenient than the letters of Constantine. Here's a question for me. They called the writing Cyrillic. Well, okay ... The inhabitants of Byzantium also called themselves Romei ... ..

    What a mess! Horror, don’t.

    1 - the Semites never lived in Hellas, and yet yes, the Thracians, Illyrians and some other characters also belong to the Indo-Europeans (only Albanians have remained of them now). Macedonia was born as a result of the merger of alien Greeks and local Thracians. As for, modern Greek is a direct descendant of medieval Greek, it differs from the ancient, but not so very much, the modern Greek Greeks fully understand the ancient Greek texts, the pronunciation has changed more. However, all this is true in relation to any language, for that matter.

    2 - Slavs are not descendants, they are just one of the conditional ancestors of modern pasties through the Baltic-Slavic branch of the Indo-European family. It is we - their distant descendants.

    3 - Scythians, Sarmatians and others migrated from Asia, from the Iranian highlands, and by the way, they are also Indo-Europeans.

    4 - not to believe in the migration of peoples is the same as not to believe in a postman. Archeology, historical texts, all things.

    5 - yes, because by the time of the Cyrillic alphabet the Macedonians were already assimilated by the Slavs. And she is Cyrillic because of all the options for the Slavs, the alphabet turned out to be better than all, that's all.