Underwater predators. Submarine type "Sh" ("Pike")

35
Submarines series III "Pike" became the first type of medium submarines, which were built in the Soviet Union. The construction of six different series of submarines was carried out from 1930 to 1945. In total, 86 U-type submarines were built, making them the most numerous type of Soviet submarine during the Great Patriotic War. Distinctive features of these submarines were relatively low cost in production, increased durability and maneuverability.

Boats took an active part in the hostilities during the Great Patriotic War. During the war years, these submarines sank 45 and damaged 8 of enemy warships and commercial ships - more than a third of the total number of ships sunk by all Soviet submarines. At the same time, an 44 submarine died from 31 submarines that fought. For military merits 6 submarines of type "Sh" became Guards, another 11 submarines were awarded the Order of the Red Banner.



The design of the first submarines of the III series of the Pike type was carried out in parallel with the design of the submarines of the I Dekabrist series. "Pike" was a polutorakorpuznuyu submarine, its robust hull was divided into 6 compartments. The project was developed in the design office, which was headed by B. M. Malinin. Initially, the boats were designed as small ones; they were intended for operations in the Baltic areas that were constrained by navigation. They were planned to be used in the water area of ​​the Gulf of Finland with its small depths, skerries and narrow places. In the future, according to the pre-war classification adopted in the USSR, the boats were classified as average.


Soviet submarine Shch-301 "Pike" (type "Pike", series III) goes along the coast, photo: waralbum.ru


The first series of U-type submarines, the Series III, was created by Soviet engineers in an incredible rush. The outline sketch of the boat was completed at the end of 1929 of the year. Without waiting for approval, the Baltiysky plant began to create working drawings. At the same time, at the design stage, numerous changes were made to their design. For example, the military demanded to place spare torpedoes on board the boat. Placing on board four more torpedoes demanded manifestations of ingenuity from the Pike designers.

It is interesting that the U-boat design was influenced by the raising and inspection of the British submarine L-55, which since October 1929 has been undergoing refurbishment in Kronstadt. From this boat, the Pike got contours with linear transformation and a common architectural type: one and a half hull, with Boolean tanks of the main ballast. The English boat L-55 sank in the southern part of the Gulf of Finland on June 4, 1919 during an attempt to attack the destroyers Azard and Gabriel. As a result of the demolition of the boat by an unaccounted current, it was blown up on an English mine barrier. In the summer of 1928 the boat was successfully raised to the surface, and then restored and incorporated into the Soviet fleet. When raising and examining the boat, the remains of 38 English submariners were discovered, which were transferred to the British side for burial at home.

Tactical and technical characteristics of submarines of the type "Sh" changed from series to series slightly. A total of 86 boats were built in six different series. Mainly, there was a change in the characteristics of the boats in the direction of the power of the installed diesel engines, increasing the speed of surface and underwater travel, a certain decrease in cruising range. The armament of the boats (four bow and two stern torpedo tubes and two 45-mm artillery guns) remained unchanged (except for four series III boats armed with one gun). Submarines of the Pike type had 6 compartments in a solid hull: the first and sixth compartments were torpedoes; the second one is residential (in it, under the collapsible flooring of wooden shields, there were batteries, and under them fuel tanks); the third compartment is the central post of the boat; the fourth is the diesel compartment; in the fifth compartment there were two main electric motors and separately - two electric motors of the economic course.



Since from the very beginning of work on the project, new submarines were considered as massive, the main requirement for them was the maximum simplicity of the design. Such a requirement was also aimed at reducing production as cheaply as possible. At the same time, this did not reflect in the best way on the tactical and technical characteristics of the Schuk. The time of submersion of the boats was unacceptably long: from the cruising position - more than a minute, and the time for purging the main ballast was more than 10 minutes. The surface speed of the III series boats also turned out to be significantly lower than that contained in the specification - on the order of 12 nodes. The placement of four spare torpedoes in the residential compartment significantly worsened the habitability of the submarine. The design of the torpedo-loading device was also unsuccessful, as a result of which the total time of loading the ammunition load onto the boat took more than a day. Submarine mechanisms made a lot of noise, which unmasked them and increased the chances of being detected by the enemy. Despite all the shortcomings, the project went into production. In total, four “Pikes” of the III series were built, all four boats became part of the Baltic Fleet and carried numbers from Shch-301 to Shch-304. Three of them could not survive the Great Patriotic War, until the end of hostilities only the YS-303 “Ruff” boat survived.

In addition to the indicated shortcomings, boats of type “Sh” had obvious advantages, which were confirmed by acceptance tests. The strengths and simplicity of their design, good seaworthiness and reliability of the installed mechanisms were attributed to the advantages of the III series submarines. In terms of their tactical and technical characteristics, the new Soviet submarines did not yield to foreign boats of the same class, for example, to the French submarines of the Orion type, which were being built simultaneously with the Soviet submarines of the Schuka type.

The first boats of the third series were laid in Leningrad at the Baltic Plant No. 189 in 1930 (boats U-301, 302 and 303), the sub-boat U-304 was built at the Krasnoye Sormovo plant No. XXUMX in Gorky (Nizhny Novgorod). The first boats were part of the fleet in 112, and by the end of 1933, 1941 submarines were built, which were built and put into operation by the following series: Series III - 84 boats (4 year), Series V - 1933 boats (12-1933 years ), V-bis series - 1934 boats (13-1935 years), V-bis-1936 series - 2 boats (14-1935 years), X-series - 1936 boats (32-1936 years), X-bis series - 1939 boats entered service in 9 year, including after the start of the war, two more were transferred to the fleet in July 1941 year.


Submarines U-201 (V-bis), U-209 (X series) and U-202 (V-bis) of the Black Sea Fleet, 1943 year.


The pikes of the second modification belonged to the V series and were built in greater numbers. 12 such submarines replenished the composition of the Pacific Fleet. To the place of the boat were transported by rail in a disassembled form, their final assembly was carried out already in the Far East. They didn’t have significant changes as compared with the III series boats, except for some changes in hull structures, in particular, the ship’s bow was given an “oceanic” slope. A notable difference was the installation of the second 45-mm gun, which was then present on the "Pikes" of all subsequent series. At the same time, artillery armament was the weak point of all Schuk. For example, the German medium submarine type VII (the largest submarine type in stories) carried an 88-mm artillery gun and an 20-mm anti-aircraft gun on board. And the Soviet C-type submarines were armed with 100-mm and 45-mm guns. In many ways, numerous modernizations of the S-type boats were connected with the fact that the commissioning of medium-sized boats of the new type “C” was delayed. In total, the 41 submarine of the type “C” entered service, but by the beginning of the Great Patriotic War there were only 17.

In addition to the acute need of the fleet for new submarines, the submarines of the "Y" type, even despite all the flaws of the first series, were considered to be quite successful ships in operational and tactical terms, primarily in the combination of combat qualities and cost. For this reason, it was decided to develop this type of submarines, gradually eliminating the disadvantages identified during the operation of the boats of the first series. Moreover, smaller sizes allowed such boats to feel better in the waters of the Gulf of Finland and the Black Sea, as compared with larger boats of type “C”. It is not by chance that the latter are best manifested themselves in the Northern Fleet, and not in the Baltic.

The submarines of the V-bis and V-bis-2 series became the result of the further improvement of the Schuk. The power of the main diesel engines of the boats was increased by about 35 percent, while their weight and dimensions almost did not change. In addition, the shape of the rudders was improved, which allowed to increase the speed of the surface course of the boats on the 1,5 node. Also, according to the experience of the previous operation of the V series, improvements were made to individual mechanisms and parts of submarines. The V-bis boat series was built by the 13. Eight of them went to serve in the Pacific Fleet, three to the Black Sea and two to the Baltic. During the war years “Pikes”, the V-bis series were actively involved in solving transportation problems in the Black Sea. Boats could take on board instead of spare torpedoes up to 35 tons of fuel, or 30 tons of cargo, or up to 45 people with personal weapons.


Submarine Shch-201 in Tuapse


On the ships of the V-bis-2 series, once again, the designers reworked the theoretical drawing and the shape of the cabin of the submarine. This made it possible to increase the surface speed at the 0,5 node, improving seaworthiness. The aft bulkhead of the second compartment received a stepped shape. This solution allowed the torpedoes to be stored assembled. In addition, the torpedo-loading device was remade. This was a very important step, since at the same time the clutter of the boat compartments decreased and the loading time of torpedoes on board decreased from 25-30 hours to 12 hours. Also, the designers changed the transmission of the electric motor of economic progress from gear to belt, which made its work silent. The electric motors of the stern and bow horizontal rudders were placed in the end compartments, leaving only manual control in the central post. An important achievement of the boats of this series was a significant reduction in the noise of the mechanisms on board the boat, which increased the combat capabilities of the ships. Thanks to all the changes to the design, the V-bis-2 series submarines have earned high marks from the Soviet submariners. In total, the X-NUMX boats of the V-bis-14 series were built. Five of them received the Baltic and Pacific Fleets and four - the Black Sea Fleet.

The most numerous series of “Schuk” steel boats X series, which was built immediately 32 jokes. 9 boats received the Pacific Fleet, 8 - the Black Sea and Northern Fleet, 7 - the Baltic Fleet. These submarines looked the most exotic due to the introduction of the so-called “limousine” type into the design of the streamlined fencing. In general, these submarines almost did not differ from the ships of the V-bis-2 series. As the main power plant, they used diesel engines 38-K-8 Kolomna plant 800 horsepower. at 600 rpm. The speed of their surface stroke increased to 14,1-14,3 nodes.

The low profile of the new cabin of the X-series boats had a negative effect on the increase in its filling capacity even at relatively low seas, which was especially critical for submarines that served in the Northern Fleet. As a result, another series of submarines of the “Sh” type appeared - the X-series. The modernization potential of Schuk was almost completely exhausted by that time, so the updates were reduced mainly to a return to the traditional fencing of the cabin, as well as to minor edits in the water pipeline and high-pressure air system. On submarines TTX is not significantly affected. Total was laid 13 submarine X-series. Of these, 11 boats were completed: two before the war, the rest during the Second World War. Four submarines participated in the battles in the Baltic, one in the Black Sea. The remaining submarines operated as part of the Pacific Fleet. From the “European” “Pike” of this series only one Baltic boat survived. In the Pacific, one "Pike" series X-bis died in an explosion at the base. Only one submarine of this type participated in combat operations against Japan.


Loading torpedoes on the submarine of the Pacific fleet of the "Pike" type (V-bis). Instead of the stern gun, a DShK machine gun was mounted on the boat. In the background you can see a submarine of the type "Pike" (X series), photo: waralbum.ru


The appearance of the Shchuk during the war years changed during various upgrades. For example, the folding parts of the gun platforms were replaced with permanent ones and equipped with railing over time. According to the accumulated experience of sailing in broken ice, the outer covers of torpedo tubes were dismantled on parts of the submarines. Instead of a second 45-mm cannon, a large-caliber 12,7-mm DShK machine gun was mounted on submarines, while in the Pacific Fleet, along with a standard tumbovic installation, homemade ones were also encountered. During the Great Patriotic War, some submarines managed to get the Asdik sonar (“Dragon-129”), as well as a special demagnetizing device with windings outside the hull at the superstructure deck level.

In total in the USSR 86 of medium submarines of the “Pike” type of different series was built. Of these, the 31 submarine died during the Great Patriotic War, which is 36 percent of their total number or 69 percent of the number of submarines that fought in the European theater of operations. Losses were very substantial. To some extent this was due to the active use of these submarines in the battles, as well as the most difficult conditions for submariners in the waters of the Gulf of Finland, where many Soviet boats became victims of enemy minefields.

At the same time, in spite of not the highest tactical and technical characteristics, the submarines of the "Sh" type proved to be a formidable and efficient weapon. In the North, they managed to sink 6 warships and enemy transports with torpedo weapons, as well as damage one transport (the torpedo did not explode). On the Baltic Sea, Pikes were able to sink one enemy submarine, as well as 17 transport and combat ships, with torpedoes. Five more ships were seriously damaged. On the Black Sea, boats of type “Sh” recorded 12 transports and enemy warships on their torpedo account, two more ships were seriously damaged. At the same time 9 transports they managed to sink their artillery weapons.

Tactical and technical characteristics of the boat type "Pike" X series (the most numerous):
Displacement: surface - 584 tons, scuba - 707,8 tons.
Overall dimensions: length - 58,8 m, width - 6,2 m, draft - 4 m.
The power plant - two diesel 38-K-8 power 2х800 hp and two main rowing electric motors with power 2х400 hp
Speed: surface - node 14,3, submerged - node 8,1-8,3.
Economic speed: surface - node 7,9, submerged - node 2,6.
Cruising range (normal fuel capacity) - up to 2580 miles (surface run), to 105 miles (underwater run).
Immersion depth: working - 75 m, limit - 90 m.
Artillery weapons: 2x45-mm guns 21-K and 2x7,62-mm machine gun.
Torpedo armament: 4х533-mm nasal torpedo tubes and 2x533-mm stern torpedo tubes, total torpedo stock - 10 pieces.
The autonomy of swimming is 20 days.
Crew - 37-38 people.

Information sources:
https://vpk-news.ru/articles/45193
http://deepstorm.ru/DeepStorm.files/17-45/sh%20X/list.htm
http://techno-story.ru/articles/fleet/618-shatype
Open source materials
35 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +6
    12 January 2019 08: 12
    Thanks for the work, Author ,! hi Very interesting, I read it in one breath, the topic is close, we are anti-submariners .. feel
  2. +5
    12 January 2019 11: 30
    On the Baltic Sea "Pikes" torpedoes were able to sink one enemy submarine,

    ,,,The Irony of Fate,, winked

    10 August 1941 d. U-144 (which was the first in World War II to sink the Soviet submarine 23 June 1941 of the year M-78),

    U-144

    was sunk by the Soviet medium diesel submarine W-307 "Treska" (commanded by Lieutenant-Commander N. Petrov). The first submarine drowned by Soviet submariners in the Second World War.

    1. +2
      12 January 2019 11: 47
      ,, the fate of Lieutenant N. Petrov was tragic:
      Excerpt from "Decision of the Military Council of the Red Banner Baltic Fleet No. 0089 28 September 1941
      ".... The former brigade commander of Captain 1st Rank Comrade Egyptko and the Military Commissar Brigade Commissar Comrade Obushenkov, instead of stepping up hostilities, the widespread use of submarines in the current conditions of war in the theater and decisive struggle against carriers of decadent and defeatist sentiments, connived and liberal open statements about the fear of going to sea, did not take action against those who criticized the orders of the higher command, ignored the facts of drunkenness and corruption of individual commanders (Lieutenant Commander Petrov and Senior Lieutenant Gladilin) ​​[In the draft document, this phrase originally sounded like "Among the personnel drunkenness is flourishing in the brigade. The commanders set the tone for drunkenness (Senior Lieutenant Gladilin and Lieutenant Commander Petrov)]

      6) The commanders of the PLPL "M" 102 - Senior Lieutenant Gladilin, "Sh" 307 - Lieutenant-Commander Petrov for decadent and defeatist sentiments, criticism of the actions of the higher command and drunkenness - to be removed from their posts and brought to justice by the Military Tribunal "


      Quote from JSC TsVMAb f. 29, d. 38536, l. 85-89 (the document was published in the collection of documents "The Fate of the Forgotten Hero" in the magazine Flotomaster No. 1. 2007. compiled by M.E. Morozov, K.B. Strelbitsky)

      ,,, Petrov was convicted in early October and sentenced to forced labor camps by 10.
      1. +4
        12 January 2019 12: 10
        As for Petrov, the grandfather said that he simply washed down after coming to Leningrad. So he was removed.
    2. +10
      12 January 2019 12: 09
      This is my grandfather’s boat. From it fought the whole war.
      They were lucky to be among the few remaining boats in the ranks of Shch.
      As a child, I remember how submariners gathered at the Bronze Horseman on Victory Day.
      1. +13
        12 January 2019 12: 56
        Add some pictures with my grandfather:




  3. WW2
    -4
    12 January 2019 12: 25
    Curious is the fact that the U-boat design was influenced by the raising and inspection of the British submarine L-55, which since October 1929 has been undergoing refurbishment in Kronstadt.

    The "Sh" submarines were just a copy of the western submarines of WW1.
    Shame that Soviet sailors had to fight on such troughs.
    During the Great Patriotic War, some submarines managed to get the Asdik sonar (“Dragon-129”)

    This was not the case during the war years for boats of combat personnel.
    Instead of the second 45-mm gun, a large-caliber 12,7-mm DShK machine gun was installed on the submarine’s part

    Both had to be cut. According to the TTX, the marine magpie was not much different from the layout of the gun. Only, unlike the layout, she also made the sounds of shots.
    1. +3
      12 January 2019 13: 47
      Do you think that the submarines of the First World War in the Imperial Navy were the most progressive in all of their technical parameters?
      Before the First World War, in order to attract volunteers to the submarine fleet, a petition was raised to increase the salary of submarine officers.
      The reaction of the ranks of the Admiralty turned out to be positive, but very peculiar: "It can be added, they will still overflow!"

      The main weapon of submarines - torpedoes, as it should not be checked and it turned out that they can not withstand diving to great depths. As a result, until the end of 1915, not one of the torpedo attacks of the Baltic Fleet submarines was successful, and the submarines could only boast of capturing 2 German ships.
      1. WW2
        -4
        12 January 2019 13: 54
        Quote: hohol95
        that the First World submarines in the Imperial Navy were the most progressive in all their technical parameters?

        Not at all. There was also a link to the British L-55.
        Quote: hohol95
        The reaction of the ranks of the Admiralty turned out to be positive, but very peculiar: "It can be added, they will still overflow!"

        There are enough fools everywhere. And enough.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. WW2
            -1
            13 January 2019 01: 22
            Quote: hohol95
            And at the same time, not ............. on batteries without SERIOUS DOCUMENTS ...

            What other batteries?
            1. 0
              13 January 2019 01: 29
              I apologize!
              Confused you with another "LORD"!
              He hinted that all the batteries in the USSR were on IMPORTED components.
            2. +1
              13 January 2019 01: 32
              And YOU are able to compare "Pike" with foreign boats of similar displacement?
              1. WW2
                -2
                13 January 2019 02: 01
                Quote: hohol95
                Can YOU compare "Pikes"?

                Something capable, but I will not. This is not quite my topic, and not in my topics I prefer to read more and write less.
                1. 0
                  13 January 2019 02: 11
                  The "Sh" submarines were just a copy of the western submarines of WW1.
                  Shame that Soviet sailors had to fight on such troughs.

                  Something capable, but I will not. This is not quite my topic, and not in my topics I prefer to read more and write less.

                  Then do not P ............. HAYT what you do not understand until the last rivets ...
                  1. WW2
                    -1
                    13 January 2019 02: 14
                    Quote: hohol95
                    Then do not P ............. HAYT what you do not understand until the last rivets ...

                    Well, such things as "what are Soviet submarines of WW2" I can easily tell.
                    1. 0
                      13 January 2019 02: 19
                      Well, such things as "what are Soviet submarines of WW2" I can easily tell.

                      YOU DON'T TELL - YOU COMPARE with similar SUBMARINS!
                      And I tell stories myself MUCH ... (it’s beautiful not to lie - don’t tell stories)!
                      1. WW2
                        -1
                        13 January 2019 02: 24
                        Quote: hohol95
                        YOU DON'T TELL - YOU COMPARE with similar SUBMARINS!

                        And what is there to compare? They are just with the museum at that time L-55 and must be compared.
                        Well, offhand - did you see pike artillery? How were they opposed by the enemy in the opposite way?
                        Nothing. Just dive. But they sank slowly.
                        Etc.
                      2. +1
                        13 January 2019 02: 28
                        This is not the first time I ask you to COMPARE "PIKES" with boats of similar displacement! Those who fought in World War II!
                        And do not "wag the fifth point"!
                        You can not - SO WRITE!
                        And then we won’t clog ETHER!
    2. 0
      12 January 2019 21: 32
      The Germans, by the way, also, after the 42nd, it seems they began to take off their 88 .. but reinforced with small defense
      1. WW2
        -2
        12 January 2019 22: 16
        Quote: Region-25.rus
        The Germans, by the way, also, after the 42nd, it seems they began to take off their 88 .. but reinforced with small defense

        Maybe. The fact is that merchant ships did not go alone then. And against aviation, the average caliber for p / l is useless.
  4. +3
    12 January 2019 13: 50
    During the Great Patriotic War, some submarines managed to get the Asdik sonar (“Dragon-129”)
    ,, Lend-Leased, ,,, 70 sets of such sonars from the 96 ordered.

    Equipment of the Soviet submarines of the “Dragon-129” GLS in 1942-1945:
    1942 year - U-403, K-3, K-22.

    1943 year- “L-20”, “L-22”, “L-15”, “C-54”, “C-55”, “U-404”, “C-102”, “L-3” , “U-318”, “U-407”.

    1944 year- “C-56”, “U-402”, “C-101”, “C-19” “L-21”, “C-4”, “C-13”, “U-303” " U-202 ”,“ U-205 ”L-8”, “L-11”, “L-12”, “L-14”, “L-17”, “L-19”.

    1945 year- "C-17", "D-2", "U-310", "C-18", "L-7", "L-9", "L-18", "U-107" , “Shch-108”, “Shch-109”, “Shch-110”, “Shch-111”, “Shch-112”, “Shch-113”, “Shch-114”, “Shch-115”, “ U-121 "," U-124 "," U-136 "
    1. WW2
      -3
      12 January 2019 16: 15
      Quote: bubalik
      Equipment of the Soviet submarines of the “Dragon-129” GLS in 1942-1945:
      1942 year - U-403, K-3, K-22.

      1943 year- “L-20”, “L-22”, “L-15”, “C-54”, “C-55”, “U-404”, “C-102”, “L-3” , “U-318”, “U-407”.

      1944 year- “C-56”, “U-402”, “C-101”, “C-19” “L-21”, “C-4”, “C-13”, “U-303” " U-202 ”,“ U-205 ”L-8”, “L-11”, “L-12”, “L-14”, “L-17”, “L-19”.

      1945 year- "C-17", "D-2", "U-310", "C-18", "L-7", "L-9", "L-18", "U-107" , “Shch-108”, “Shch-109”, “Shch-110”, “Shch-111”, “Shch-112”, “Shch-113”, “Shch-114”, “Shch-115”, “ U-121 "," U-124 "," U-136 "

      Never in any memoirs have I encountered references to radars on Soviet submarines. I met only complaints that they are not there. And, like, on series B boats (British, Lend-Lease) they are.
      1. +3
        12 January 2019 16: 20
        Never in any memoirs did I encounter any mention of radars on Soviet submarines. Met only complaints that they are not.


        On August 28, our submarine maneuvered in 7 – 8 miles from the coast in a submerged position at the speed of an 3 node. In 10: 18 GAS "Dragon-129" (hydroacoustical sailor IV Larin) recorded the noise of the propellers, but the commander did not detect the target due to the snow charge. With the next rise of the periscope, Egorov was watching. He discovered in 10 – 12 cable cabins of a submarine, following the course of 350 °. Egorov immediately began maneuvering to enter the attack [160]. In 10: 50, when the distance was reduced to 6 kb, a three torpedo salvo was produced. Two of the three torpedoes fired by the boat had NAF fuses. After 45 seconds, one of them hit the enemy. In 10: 52 "C-101" surfaced, the commanders climbed the bridge. In place of the death of the German ship there was an oil stain left, a large cloud of smoke from the explosion was carried away into the distance. This picture was taken with the FED camera from 3 cable distance, after which the boat sank again. On C-101, the motors were stopped and 6 was listening to the horizon for minutes. Making sure that there is no danger, the commander in 11: 08 gave the command to ascend. Now the boat was at the place of the death of the enemy. An oil stain grew on the surface, wooden fragments, torn bodies of German submariners and various objects floated. Some documents and things were picked up.

        Destroyed the submarine was "U639" (Oberleutenant tsurze Walter Wihman). She was returning after Operation Seehund - 24 production of TMB bottom mines in the Ob Bay (OMU-98 barrier). This was her fourth and farthest battle campaign.



        S.P. Makhov, N.N. Bazhenov, V.A. Nagirnyak, M.E. Morozov, A.Ya. Kuznetsov

        Secrets of the underwater war. 1914 — 1945
        1. WW2
          0
          13 January 2019 01: 29
          Quote: bubalik
          S.P. Makhov, N.N. Bazhenov, V.A. Nagirnyak, M.E. Morozov, A.Ya. Kuznetsov

          Secrets of the underwater war. 1914 — 1945

          The brigade commander of the submarine Kolyshkin has nothing like this about GAS "Dragon" in "Secrets of the Polar Seas". But about the destruction of Vikhman's boat, just there. There is even that a portrait of Hitler floated unscathed. But not a word about GAS "Dragon".
          By the way, he also complains about the lack of radar on Soviet boats.
          I somehow trust the brigade commander more than S.P. Makhov, N.N. Bazhenov, V.A. Nagirnyak, M.E. Morozov, A.Ya. Kuznetsov combined.
          1. +2
            14 January 2019 20: 47
            Do you even understand that during the Soviet era military memoirs were strictly censored. And the theme of Lend-Lease was banned! It was impossible to write about technical details and very much. Your technical ignorance is a consequence of reading the emasculated Meroir.
            From the beginning of the 1990s, numerous technical literature on the fleet and shipbuilding began to appear, the authors of which are naval sailors, shipbuilding engineers and other highly educated people who were no longer constrained by the Soviet era with restrictions on the flow of information.
            By their level, the boats of the "Sh" type corresponded, by the way, to the aforementioned small British boats of the "B" type. And for the early 1930s, Pikes were quite suitable boats. By the beginning of the Second World War, against the background of the entry of boats C 9 series, L 13 series, even 10 series of pikes was outdated.
            By the way, they were delivered not by Lend-Lease, but on account of the division of the Italian fleet.
      2. 0
        14 January 2019 19: 15
        And you do not read memoirs, but technical literature on the history of shipbuilding and the fleet. And then an amazing detail will open - in addition to the equipment installed on the Lend-Lease ships, the USSR received 1196 radar and 329 sets of English ASDIK GAS. And you need to understand that the radar is precisely the radar, and the ASDIK is the sonar, GAS.
  5. 0
    12 January 2019 14: 03
    the design of the English type L submarine was taken into account when constructing type D boats, well, and the u boats, despite numerous attempts to improve their performance characteristics, were rather weak, the best Soviet submarines during the war were
  6. +1
    12 January 2019 15: 53
    Once upon a time I read that the destroyer Gabriel sank the L-55 with artillery fire.
  7. -4
    12 January 2019 22: 57
    For some reason, the author does not give the tonnage of the sunk "warships". Probably because they were worthless trawlers and barges. And not all "victories" are confirmed. In addition, the author forgot to mention that in the USSR at that time they did not know how to produce batteries for submarines, everything was imported. And without Lend-Lease, the boats would have been idle for the entire war. She's half-true ...
    1. +1
      13 January 2019 00: 51
      Well, there were no Atlantic convoys for our submarines. One of my patients was a submariner in the Baltic. He told me how first they drowned everyone in a row, then they sorted it out. They drowned the Swede, but he’s kind of neutral. And figs on a scandal is needed? Nobody at work. What if this Swede brought iron ore to Germany?
      1. 0
        13 January 2019 01: 12
        And from AMERICA, your patient did not drive boats through the PANAMA channel to MURMANSK?
    2. +1
      13 January 2019 01: 31
      In addition, the author forgot to mention that in the USSR of that time they did not know how to produce storage batteries for submarines, everything was imported. And without Lend-Lease, the boats would be fun throughout the war. She is so half-truth ...

      And at the same time, not ............. on batteries without SERIOUS DOCUMENTS ...
      1. 0
        29 January 2019 21: 43
        Fu how rude ... Refute with documents. I have not seen any references to "SERIOUS DOCUMENTS" here.
        1. 0
          29 January 2019 23: 51
          Morozov M.E. Soviet submarine fleet 1922-1945: About submarines and submariners / M.E. Morozov, K.L. Kulagin. - M .: AST: AST MOSCOW: Transitbook, 2006.
          Morozov M. E., Kulagin K. L. The first submarines of the USSR. “Decembrists” and “Leninists” - M .: Collection, Yauza, EKSMO, 2010
          Before the war, batteries were produced at 2 plants -
          Battery Plant No. 2 named after Lieutenant P.P. Schmidt (Leningrad) and the Saratov Plant of Lead Batteries!
          During the war, began to import batteries for submarines from the second half of 1942. It received 42 British and 40 American battery kits.
    3. 0
      16 January 2019 15: 28
      Quote: ded_mazai
      In addition, the author forgot to mention that in the USSR of that time they did not know how to produce batteries for submarines

      What are you? They didn't know! And you know that the batteries for the submarines were produced by the Leningrad Battery Plant and that the KBF did not feel the need for batteries, and the reason is banal, the batteries for the submarines simply remained in besieged Leningrad, as V.E. Korzh To repair ships, one or the other is required. Some boats need to change the batteries. Where can I get them? We learned that in the fall several carriages with batteries were to be sent to the rear. Did they manage to slip into the mainland? Nobody knew that ..... The local authorities allowed us to inspect the remaining unsent trains. Midshipman Moskovkin, our battery specialist, was sent to the railway administration. There he was “delighted”: there were 17 loaded wagons left on [2177] tracks. The railwaymen do not know what is in them: the documentation has been lost. The representative of the submarine department of the headquarters of the fleet, engineer-captain 3rd rank A.K. Vasiliev, pomflagmech engineer-captain 3rd rank N.I. Golenbakov and A.O. Moskovkin climbed the tracks littered with snowdrifts in frost and blizzard, opened the cars, examined them and they were sealed again, putting a conventional sign in chalk, so as not to meddle here a second time. We worked for many days. Sometimes they fell from exhaustion. And yet they found it. There were six new storage batteries in the cars for different types of submarines. We were not able to carry 360 tons of this fragile and bulky cargo through the rails and drifts. We put it off until spring. This is just what they found !!! And how many did not find ?????