Small arms ammunition with sub-caliber bullets

52
During the First World War, the belligerents began to use personal armor protection for infantrymen in the form of steel helmets and cuirasses, which for a certain distance were not penetrated by low-speed bullets of small arms. weapons. Currently SIBZ composite boron carbide plates of thickness not punched 9 mm armor piercing bullets with steel core gauges 5,45h39 mm 5,56h45 mm 7,62h39 mm 7,62h51 mm and 7,62h54 mm at a distance of less 100 meters.

To overcome this obstacle in the armor-piercing bullets of small arms, the core is often made of a composite tungsten carbide alloy with cobalt of the BK8 type with grains less than 1 μm, the flexural strength of which is 2 GPa with HRA 4 units of hardness. Even more promising is a metal alloy of tungsten of the type VNZh85, by analogy with the cores of armor-piercing artillery shells. However, SIBZ plates also have a reserve for increasing durability both by increasing the percentage of boron carbide in the composite, and due to the thickness of the plates (taking into account the tendency of transition to the use of passive exoskeletons as part of infantry equipment).



In addition, the classic ogival shell bullet is a highly inefficient carrier of an armor-piercing core, since it requires the use of a lead shirt to pass along the barrel bore without destroying them upon contact with a hard alloy core. As a result, the mass of the core itself is reduced to a minimum. For example, the bullet cartridge 7H24М caliber 5,45х39 mm with bimetallic sheath, lead shirt and armor-piercing core made of alloy BK8 weighs 4,1 gram, of which the weight of the core is only 1,8 gram. In addition, when colliding with a SIBZ plate, part of the kinetic energy of the bullet is spent on collapsing the bimetallic shell, breaking through the armor-piercing core and tearing off the lead shirt

Small arms ammunition with sub-caliber bullets


A more effective method of increasing the armor penetration rate of small arms bullets is to increase their initial velocity and reduce the cross-sectional area. The first measure increases the kinetic energy of the bullet, the second increases the specific load in the contact patch of the bullet with the barrier. The speed of the bullet is limited by the maximum pressure of the powder gases in the barrel, which currently reaches 4500 atmospheres and is determined by the strength of the barrel steel. This restriction is overcome by reducing the mass and diameter of the bullet while maintaining the diameter of the barrel bore - that is, by moving to sub-caliber bullets. To drive the sub-caliber bullet in the barrel bore, developed leading belts are used on the surface of the core or a polymer pallet, the density of which is X times less than the density of brass or lead in 9-11.

The first constructive solution in this area is the German Harold Gerlich bullet, developed in the first third of the 20 century and equipped with two leading tapered tape. The bullet in flight was stabilized by rotation, the rifled barrel had a variable diameter tapering towards the end, which allowed achieving even more efficient use of the energy of powder gases. As a result, a 6,5 gram bullet accelerated to the speed of 1600 m / s and punched a steel plate with a thickness of 60 mm at the distance of 12 mm. However, a rifled barrel of variable diameter was too expensive to produce, and the accuracy of shooting with bullets with leading belts crushing during a shot left much to be desired.



The second constructive solution in the field of sub-caliber bullets is the developments of the American company AAI, led by its leader Irwin Barr, who in 1952 developed the 12-caliber rifle cartridge, equipped with 32 swept striking elements, placed in the container-type pushing pallet. Tests have shown that arrow-shaped bullets have a great destructive effect, but they have low accuracy of shooting due to the impossibility of ensuring the specified direction of the flight of bullets after their group departure from the barrel.

The initiative work was continued as part of the SALVO research program of the US Army. AAI has developed a 110x5,6 mm single-bullet cartridge with a XHUMXX53 mm caliber cartridge with a high elongation sleeve, equipped with a steel arrow-shaped subcaliber bullet with a diameter of 1,8 mm and a caliber tail. A pulling pallet of magnesium alloy, cut into pieces by a muzzle nozzle after the bullet emerged from the barrel, was used as a master device. Shooting was conducted from small arms with a smooth barrel, the stabilization of the bullet in flight was provided by the tail. Aerodynamic bevels on the plumage planes set a small angular velocity of rotation of the bullet in order to average the effects on the straightness of the flight of manufacturing defects of its manufacture.

During the experiments, an improved version of the 5,77х57В ХМ645 cartridge was developed, which included a composite four-segment pulling tray made of fiberglass with a Teflon coating that was retained on the bullet in the barrel due to friction forces and disintegrated into segments under the influence of air pressure after the bullet departed from the barrel. The length of the cartridge was 63 mm, the length of the arrow-shaped bullet - 57 mm, the weight of the bullet - 0,74 gram, of the pallet - 0,6 gram, the initial velocity of the bullet - 1400 m / s



However, in an effort to ensure the greatest elongation of the bullet, AAI had to lengthen the cartridge case, which adversely affected the reliability of the reloading mechanism due to the large friction in the chamber, and also led to an increase in the size and weight of the receiver of small arms.

Therefore, in the next program of the US Army under the name SPIW, the 5,6x44 XM144 cartridge developed by the Frankfort arsenal in the form factor of the 5,56x45 low-impulse cartridge mm became the leader. The improved version of the XM216 SFR cartridge had a standard sleeve, the cartridge length was 49,7 mm, the arrow-shaped bullet length was 45 mm, the weight of the bullet was 0,65 grams, the weight of the pallet was 0,15 grams, the initial speed of the bullet was 1400 m / s



Experimental firing using ultra-low-swept sub-caliber arrow-shaped bullets carried out under the SALVO and SPIW programs revealed unrecoverable drawbacks of such bullets - increased lateral drift due to wind and a significant deviation from the target trajectory when shooting in the rain.

In the Soviet Union, the first 7,62 / 3х54 mm cartridge with a subcaliber arrow-shaped bullet was developed under the direction of Dmitry Shiryaev at the beginning of the 1960-s at the Scientific Research Institute-61 (future Central Research Institute of Musical Instrument Engineering). The arrow-shaped bullet differed from its American counterparts in its greater mass, lesser elongation (3x51 mm), the absence of a narrowing in the area of ​​the tail unit and, most importantly, the method of connecting the pallet and the bullet using a comb applied to the boom shaft. This solution made it possible to provide the necessary grip with a greater pulling force from the side of the pallet for driving the bullets of a multiple greater mass than that of the American counterparts.



The two-piece pallet was made of aluminum alloy, so when expanding after leaving the barrel, it was a certain danger to the neighboring shooters. In addition, aluminum intensively adhered to the surface of the bore, which required dry cleaning of the barrel every 100-200 shots. But the most negative property of arrow-shaped bullets turned out to be their low killing effect in manpower — high-speed bullets pierced armor perfectly and, like needles, passed through soft tissues without causing shock shock and without forming a large-diameter wound channel.

In connection with these circumstances, in the year 1965, under the leadership of Vladislav Dvoryaninov, the development of a new 10 / 4,5x54 mm caliber cartridge with an arrow shaped bullet of a modified design with a weight increased to 4,5 was started. During the development, a polymeric material was used to manufacture the pallet, which did not contaminate the bore during the shot, tailing of the shaft was used (as in the American counterparts) to increase the ballistic coefficient, and transverse propyl of the shaft was formed in the area of ​​the comb and flat on the tip of the bullet. according to constructive weakening of the bullet for breaking into two parts and tipping the bullet in the process of breaking through the soft tissues



These technical solutions allowed to increase the slaughter effect of arrow-shaped bullets, but at the same time reduced the degree of penetration of infantrymen’s individual armor protection means, since the bullet undergoing a solid obstacle is experiencing including flexural stresses (increasing with an increase in the angle of the bullet meeting the obstacle), which lead to the destruction of the bullet shaft , twice weakened (comb and propyl) in the most critical section, directly adjacent to the tip. The gain in the slaughter action and the loss in the breakdown action did not allow the articulate arrowhead bullets of the Dvoryaninov and co-authors construction to be adopted.

The study of the flow around various bodies in a wind tunnel with supersonic air flow revealed that swept bullets of any design have a non-optimal aerodynamic shape - they generate five shock wave fronts at once:
- head front;
- front at the point of transition of the point into the shaft;
- front on the front edges of the tail;
- front on the rear edges of the tail;
- the front at the place of the tail narrowing of the shaft.
For comparison, the caliber bullet of ogival shape at supersonic speed generates only three shock wave fronts:
- head front;
- front at the point of transition of the tip into the cylindrical part;
- tail front.

The most optimal from the point of view of supersonic flight aerodynamics is the conical shape of a bullet without a fracture of the generatrix surface and without tail unit, which generates only two shock wave fronts: the head and tail. In this case, the opening angle of the head front of a conical bullet is a multiple of the opening angle of the head front of the swept bullet due to the smaller opening angle of the tip of the first compared to the opening angle of the second cone. In addition, an arrow-shaped bullet fired from a smooth bore and unwound in flight (in order to compensate for manufacturing defects) at the expense of tail tails, is also distinguished by increased braking due to the selection of part of the kinetic energy for unwinding a bullet.

In connection with the indicated disadvantages of arrow-shaped bullets, an innovative cartridge under the title “Spear” / SPEAR, equipped with a sabotted conical bullet with a pushing pallet that does not require the application of a comb to the body of the bullet, is offered to the attention. The cartridge is made in a telescopic form factor in order to minimize the packing volume, which is determined only by the length and the largest diameter of its sleeve. The cartridge is intended as an ammunition for small arms equipped with a barrel with an oval-screw drill for Lancaster-type drill for the purpose of spinning a bullet in the process of passing the barrel bore. A bullet in flight maintains stability due both to the gyroscopic moment and to the forward displacement of the center of gravity relative to the center of aerodynamic pressure by forming an internal cavity in the tail portion of the bullet.



A conical bullet fired from a Lancaster barrel has an improved ballistic coefficient compared to both lively and swept bullets for the following reasons:
- The smallest number of shock wave fronts generated during supersonic flight;
- no loss of kinetic energy for the promotion of a bullet due to the oncoming air flow.

A conical bullet with an internal cavity in the tail section also has an increased penetration ability — during the passage of a solid barrier, the tail section is crushed inwards and the diameter of the base of the cone decreases to the diameter of the bullet at the cross section of the beginning of the cavity. The transverse load of the bullet almost doubles. At the same time, the sharpness of the preserved conical surface of the bullet remains larger than that of an ogival or arrow shaped bullet of equal length. The absence of a comb and transverse cuts on the surface of a conical bullet additionally increases its penetrability in comparison with the arrow-shaped bullet of the Dvoryaninov and co-authors design.

At the same time, a conical bullet with an internal cavity in the tail section has a high lethal effect, since:
- it is on the verge of stability due to the gentle pitch of the screw cutting of the bore of Lancaster;
- after penetration of the armored obstacle, its stability decreases due to creasing of the tail section and displacement of the center of pressure beyond the center of gravity.

The loss of kinetic energy to penetrate the armored obstacle at a conical bullet with an internal cavity is at the level of arrow-shaped and ogival bullets: at the first energy is spent on the body crushing in the cavity, at the second - on the tail section, on the third core.

The body of the conical bullet functionally corresponds to the core of the shell bullet, the lead shirt is absent, instead of a shell made of heavy and expensive brass, a pallet of lightweight and cheap plastic is used. On the other hand, the conical bullet makes the most rational use of the strength characteristics of its structural material in comparison with the arrow-shaped bullet, which is artificially weakened in the place of the comb and transverse cutting. Therefore, the mass of a conical bullet can be significantly minimized compared to an ogival and swept bullet with equal penetrability. This makes it possible to make an economically reasonable choice of the construction material of a conical bullet in favor of a metal tungsten alloy with the highest density.

Due to the limited internal volume of the telescopic cartridge, it is proposed to use a propellant charge in the form of pressed gunpowder with the addition of HMX (which is smaller than the critical detonation diameter of the explosive) to its composition in order to provide the calculated charge burning rate for the selected barrel length of the small arms. In order to reduce the total weight of the cartridge as a structural material of its sleeve, it is proposed to use a composite alloy of aluminum and dispersed aluminum oxide fiber, protected by a brass electroplated coating and an antifriction polymeric coating with graphite filler, described in the article "Promising cartridges for rifled weapons" ("Military review "From December 9 2017 of the year).

The following table provides a comparative assessment of various types of small arms ammunition and bullets:


As can be seen from the table, the “Spear” / SPEAR cartridge is leading in terms of minimum packing volume, length and weight, as well as in transverse load of the bullet. The total recoil impulse of its bullet, pallet and powder gases by approximately 1 / 3 exceeds the total recoil impulse of the bullet and powder gases of the cartridge 5,45х39 mm while the muzzle energy of the first one exceeds the second one by 1 / 7.

In addition, when shooting with a bullet in a polymer tray from a barrel with an oval-helical drill, there is practically no thermoplastic wear of the bore due to the lack of rifling. In this regard, increasing more than 1,5 times the initial speed of the bullet will not affect the resource of small arms. Moreover, a shotless shot creates a reserve for increasing the rate of firing with fixed bursts to the level of 2000-3000 rounds per minute, which was recommended by the commission of the Main Directorate of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation according to the results of the Abakan competition in order to increase the accuracy of automatic shooting from uncomfortable positions.

In addition to small arms ammunition, the Spear / SPEAR cartridge can be used as a hunting weapon ammunition with Lancaster IZH-27 trunks using standard plastic shells equipped with turned conical steel or brass bullets in a thermolayer molded pallet. If the recoil of the weapon is maintained at the level of firing, the 12 caliber’s standard shotgun sub-caliber bullet weighing 9 grams will accelerate in the barrel with a length of 70 cm to a speed of 900 m / s, which corresponds to the characteristics of the Mosin three-line rifle.

Geometric characteristics of various types of conical bullets (length, angle of opening of the cone, degree of roundness / biconality of the tip, presence of a contact pad for crushing an armored barrier or expansive cavity for slaughter of a large beast, depth and wall thickness of the tail cavity) taking into account specified flight speeds and target targets can be determined on the basis of modeling the passage of bullets of air, gel or solid media using the domestic software product FlowVi sion.
52 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +2
    April 16 2018 16: 18
    I don’t understand what about shooting from lacaster ... the core of the bullet seems to be 3 mm, it seems like the striking part ... whom to shoot with such a diameter.
    sleeve material (why?) cermet for izh-27 cermet sleeve - I don’t understand ...
    As far as I know, in the hunting weapons only the “accelerator” cartridge, 5,6 bullets in a plastic container of 308 wines, was released, they quickly refused because of the low stability of shooting ...
    1. +4
      April 16 2018 19: 48
      The table shows the characteristics of the "Spear" cartridge in the form of ammunition for handguns equipped with a sub-caliber conical bullet of large elongation, low weight and high initial speed (accordingly, an aluminum-based sleeve is proposed to reduce the weight of the carrying ammunition).

      The text mentions the possibility of equipping standard cartridges (plastic and brass) of hunting rifles (both smooth-bore and with an oval-screw drill of the Lancaster type) with sub-caliber conical bullets of less elongation, greater weight and lower initial speed (but at the level of rifle caliber bullets). The 12 caliber sub-caliber bullet will have a cone base diameter of 9 mm, a length of the order of 70 mm and a weight of 9-10 grams at an initial speed of about 900 m / s.

      The accuracy and accuracy of firing with sub-caliber bullets is determined by the stability of the characteristics of plastic pallets - repeatability of geometric dimensions during casting and structural rigidity. At the moment, the most optimal material for casting pallets is polyamide of special grades - the one used for bulk printing on 3D printers (Nylon trademark).
  2. CRP
    +3
    April 16 2018 17: 03
    The article is interesting, but the final characteristics do not look very convincing: increasing the energy to the level of .223 at the cost of increasing the recoil momentum by a third.
    And when did we have brass sleeves? Steel, yes varnish.
    1. +2
      April 16 2018 19: 58
      Penetration is determined by the transverse load - in the spear cartridge sub-caliber bullet this figure is four times higher than in the 7H24M cartridge bullet core core (with an increase in the recoil momentum by only a third).

      According to my information, the cartridges 7Н24М are equipped with a brass sleeve.
      1. CRP
        +1
        April 17 2018 10: 08
        Penetration is good, but what will be the speed (but in fact we are interested in energy) of such a bullet at a distance of 300-400 meters? Indeed, as far as I know, a low-pulse NATO cartridge fired from an M4 carbine has an energy of about 500 J at a given distance with a mass of 4 grams.

        If we talk about the 9mm Lance, then there the bullet weighs 1,8 grams. It would be nice to have information about the speed of a bullet at a distance of at least 300 meters. But I'm afraid the penetrating properties of such a light bullet will end at 100 meters.
        1. +3
          April 17 2018 11: 37
          Correctly ask the question - at my request, programmers at FlowVision are now simulating the external ballistics of two types of sub-caliber conical bullets - pointed and blunt (analogous expansive) - according to several design options (different location of the center of gravity, different pitch of the oval-screw drilling of the bore).

          Simulation includes determining the speed of bullets at various firing distances and the stability of bullets on the trajectory during supersonic and subsonic flight.

          Based on the results of the simulation, I plan to publish a report on VO.

          If anyone is interested, in Flowvision you can simulate not only a bullet flying in the air, but also breaking through an armor barrier and passing a ballistic gel, but this requires appropriate experience.
      2. 0
        18 December 2020 17: 00
        Quote: Operator
        Armor penetration is determined by the lateral load

        Not true. At the beginning of the article, you indicated the required indicator, but then you forgot about it and it is not calculated in the table of characteristics. And in the commentary again - "determined by the lateral load ..." Not true.
        1. -1
          18 December 2020 18: 53
          In addition to the lateral load, the bullet / core material (lead, brass, steel, tungsten carbide, tungsten) is important, as well as the mass and velocity of the bullet (muzzle energy). But with equal muzzle energy, the comparative penetration is greater for the bullet with a higher lateral load (g / cm XNUMX).

          Plus the presence / absence of a shell in front of the core, since in the process of penetration, the shell is pulled into the hole in the pierced obstacle or energy is spent to break the shell from the bullet, which reduces the penetration. In this sense, sub-caliber bullets with a pallet dropped immediately after departure from the barrel have the best armor penetration rates - all other things being equal, with caliber shell and semi-shell bullets (speed, muzzle energy, lateral load, mass and material of the bullet core).
          1. 0
            18 December 2020 18: 59
            Quote: Operator
            In addition to lateral loading, material is important

            Not that. Here's what:
            A more effective method of increasing the armor penetration of small arms bullets is to increase their initial velocity and reduce the cross-sectional area. The first measure increases kinetic energy bullets, the second raises specific load at the contact patch bullets with an obstacle.

            Only your "specific load" has a different, correct name. Any textbook on cartridges is given.
  3. +3
    April 16 2018 21: 50
    Since he was interested in this topic for a long time, such impressive data were never encountered. Potentially “sewing” characteristics may well be unattainable, as well as the ability to maintain speed on the trajectory, but as with shooting accuracy and repeatability of results from batch to batch of pallets, since, as I understand it, it was pallets for sub-caliber bullets that always caused so many complaints ?
    The recoil momentum, of course, is rather large compared to that of 5,45, but this is the price paid for the large actual caliber. How to deal with it? Indeed, at a rate of fire of fixed bursts with a rate of 2-3 thousand rounds per minute, the spread will be greater than that of the AN-94 with its “deuces” with such an impulse.
    1. 0
      April 16 2018 22: 20
      Regarding pallets, you rightly raise concerns - the solution is to use modern polymers, which with a thickness of products up to 0,1 mm are poured into a ceramic mold with an accuracy of 0,01 mm and keep their shape up to 240 degrees Celsius.

      As for the rate of fire in order to increase accuracy, the GRAU of the RF Ministry of Defense, based on the results of the Abakan contest, on the basis of the experience gained, recommended increasing the rate of fire from 2000 (AN-94) to 3000 rounds per minute - but only with a fixed burst. The muscles of the human hands do not have time in 0,01 second (the length of the queue of 3 shots) to work out the recoil momentum and change the position of the weapon.
      1. 0
        April 17 2018 05: 23
        Let me clarify one point. The AN-94 has a recoil impulse design when firing a fixed burst. With this approach, the rate of fire does not affect the accuracy of the fire at all, regardless of the magnitude of the recoil momentum of each individual shot. The shooter receives this momentum already doubled when both bullets are already in flight. Another question is, will there be a new weapon under the telescopic cartridge based on the same principle? And is it possible to realize 3 shots at a rate of 3000 rounds per minute with an accumulation of recoil momentum, despite the fact that Abakan managed to achieve working capacity only with 2 shots at a rate of 2000? If yes, then it doesn’t matter what the momentum of one shot is, the dispersion in the top three will depend on other characteristics: the design of the system, manufacturing accuracy, rigidity in general, the mass of the weapon and the barrel in particular, contamination and the presence of lubricant, and, of course, quality of container pallets.
        As for pallets, the accuracy of 0,01 mm is unacceptably low for such a responsible business. For example, the accuracy of casting Lego parts even 20 years ago was 0,0001 mm. I understand that the polymer there is completely different, but still.
        1. +1
          April 17 2018 11: 49
          The conclusions of the GRAU of the RF Ministry of Defense were based on testing multi-barrel small arms without an recoil momentum, which nonetheless provided the best accuracy of fire in fixed bursts (in terms of the number of gun barrels) from uncomfortable positions with a rate of fire of 3000 rounds of a minute.

          The same rate of fire was also possessed by a single-barrel machine gun of the Yurchenko YuAS Shkval system of the 1938 model of the year with a crank reloading mechanism.

          That's right - for the manufacture of pallets for caliber bullets, you can try to use the plastic "Lego", consisting of copolymers of acrylonitrile, butadiene and styrene.
      2. 0
        18 December 2020 17: 04
        Quote: Operator
        keep their shape up to 240 degrees Celsius.

        And the barrel can get hotter when firing in bursts.
        And will your pallet withstand the load from the bullet during its acceleration? Is there a calculation?
        By the way, the pallet drawn on the animation will not work. The longitudinal power member is not in place.
        1. -1
          18 December 2020 18: 40
          In the 20th century, American and Soviet designers used glass-filled cured epoxy resin with an operating temperature of 180 degrees Celsius as a material for pallets of sub-caliber bullets. Now, polycarbonate with an operating temperature of 200 degrees is used as the material for the leading belts of artillery shells.

          When passing the barrel bore, the surface of the pallet of the sub-caliber bullet and the leading belt of the artillery projectile is partially gasified (sublimates along the aviation), due to this friction heat is dissipated. The time for a bullet to travel through the bore is about 0,002 seconds, so the main part of the pallet array remains intact.

          In order to further reduce the load on the pallet in the considered concept, it is proposed to use a barrel with the so-called. a flat Lancaster drill - a helical surface of an oval cross-section without sharp edges of the grooves (a slight twist of a sub-caliber bullet is needed to average the aerodynamic resistance of its factory-made defects).
          1. 0
            18 December 2020 19: 10
            Quote: Operator
            The time for a bullet to travel through the bore is about 0,002 seconds, so the main part of the pallet array remains intact.

            I am not talking about that. If you fired a burst and heated the barrel to 250 degrees, and then wait a few seconds or minutes for the next target, then the next cartridge in your chamber warmed up to 220 degrees. I'm wondering if the bottom of the pan so heated can withstand the inertia of the bullet when fired?
            Quote: Operator
            Soviet designers in the 20th century used glass-filled cured epoxy with an operating temperature of 180 degrees Celsius.

            And these pallets were constantly buggy. Dvoryaninov's 3-mm arrows were removed from the final tests because they did not pierce 1 board. And they didn’t puncture because when making a batch for FINAL tests, the pallets began to crack at minus 50 degrees. And so that they can withstand a shot (tests were carried out at subzero temperatures) TsNIITOCHMASH reduced the amount of gunpowder in cartridges.
            This is how plastic flushed down the toilet for 20 years of work on arrow-shaped bullets.
            1. -1
              18 December 2020 19: 36
              The concept proposes to use telescopic cartridges with a bullet pan completely recessed in the sleeve, which normally acts as a heat accumulator, accumulating the heat of the barrel chamber and reducing the temperature of the remaining elements of the cartridge to +170 degrees - otherwise the powder charge will self-ignite. The upper limit of the operating temperature of the polyarylate is 30 degrees higher.
              Those. in the case of intense firing, the pallet will simply not melt due to the transition of the weapon to self-firing mode laughing

              Not a single problem (including collapse in the barrel when fired) with fiberglass pallets was noted in the test reports available on the Internet - with the exception of increased dispersion of pallet segments after exiting the barrel.
              However, it is more than likely that the thermosetting epoxy cracked at -50 degrees (what else would you expect from a brittle epoxy). Therefore, it is proposed to use a modern thermoplastic plastic as a material for the pallet of the concept - polyarylate with a lower operating temperature limit of -60 degrees (when fragility has not yet arisen in it).
              1. 0
                18 December 2020 20: 27
                Quote: Operator
                in the sleeve, which normally acts as a heat accumulator, accumulating heat from the barrel chamber and reducing the temperature of the remaining elements of the cartridge to +170 degrees

                The cartridge case will absolutely not be able to accumulate the heat of the chamber. Mass difference. Therefore, the "crossbow" is provided. The plastic has been rehabilitated.
                Quote: Operator
                available on the Internet,

                Buy Dvoryaninov's book. I bought. A lot of interesting things come up.
                Quote: Operator
                it is proposed to use modern thermoplastic plastic

                Test, test and test again. Noblemen tested his plastic for 10 years and got burnt in the final tests anyway.
                1. -1
                  18 December 2020 20: 55
                  You can test, or you can read a modern guide to engineering plastics.
        2. -1
          18 December 2020 19: 05
          Quote: Svateev
          Longitudinal power spar is not in place

          The pallet is applied with a pulling structure - an obturator is located in the head part, then there are longitudinal stiffeners (they are the side walls of four segments), between the ribs there is a conical shell, which in the tail part is bent into the end cavity of the bullet.

          The longitudinal stiffening ribs of the segments form in pairs four radial "skis", which perceive lateral loads during the movement of the pallet in the trunk.
          1. 0
            18 December 2020 20: 31
            Quote: Operator
            longitudinal stiffeners (they are the side walls of four segments)

            Does each segment have 2 stiffeners? At the edges? Then maybe. And this is not visible in the animation.
            Quote: Operator
            bends into the end cavity of the bullet.

            In my opinion, we have already talked about how the pallet will come out of the cavity? Even a smooth bottom will come off with problems, let alone a "bent into a cavity" ...
            1. -1
              18 December 2020 21: 02
              The segments are not connected to each other (except by inserting their shanks into the end cavity of the bullet), therefore, after the pallet with the bullet leaves the barrel, the segments begin to diverge under the action of air pressure and decelerate aerodynamically. A conical bullet with a multiple of lower aerodynamic resistance retains its velocity and its hollow end moves forward relative to the braking pallet segments, which freely fly apart.
              1. 0
                24 December 2020 18: 41
                Quote: Operator
                start to disperse

                How will they disperse if they are brought into the end cavity ?! They will not disperse until they brake and leave the cavity. Difficult, "will not take off".
                Once again: read Dvoryaninov with their troubles. Informative. Burrs prevent the pallet from separating, and your pallet is deliberately inserted into the bullet cavity.
  4. +1
    April 16 2018 21: 54
    It’s very interesting, although it’s a pity that it’s technically not savvy to understand - this is the breakthrough that was dreamed of: a sub-caliber lightweight ammunition that will simultaneously increase penetration and kill capacity while increasing ammunition (or at least reducing the weight of the existing one) or is it another interesting thought, which, however, will not work and will not make a coup.
    Need a techie who is likely to find bottlenecks. For example, wouldn't a conical sub-caliber bullet flip over in flight? And the smooth, not rifled barrel of a personal firearm is somehow unusual (although tank guns are smooth-bore, but it’s still unusual).
    But one thing is clear: they try to search for a sub-caliber bullet along the way, everyone here feels great success. Maybe the smoothbore is the boat that will transport the sub-caliber bullet through all the technical thorns, why not.
    1. 0
      April 16 2018 22: 08
      It is more difficult to tip the conical bullet cap in flight than the classical one; pay attention to the lateral load and the shift of the center of gravity to the tip due to the design. There are grooves in the trunk, but not classic, but oval-smoothed, two of them, first used by the Lancaster gunsmith, it seems, back in the 19th century. Even our industry has mastered this cutting for hunting rifles. Feature: it is good to shoot a bullet, with almost no change in shots. Oval cuts do not retain carbon deposits less and do not clog material from a bullet / container / pallet.
    2. 0
      April 16 2018 22: 29
      I think that every owner of a smoothbore gun or shotgun with a barrel bore Lancaster (legally equivalent to a smoothbore in Russia) can equip standard 12-caliber cartridges with a similar sub-caliber bullet machined from steel or brass on a lathe or made by pouring lead into a cone cap-shell (in the latter case, the bullet can be made expansive by cutting off the top of the cap and applying longitudinal cuts to its surface).

      The only difficulty is to make a segmented pallet from a suitable thermoplastic.

      On rifle cartridges with sub-caliber conical bullets, it will be possible to work out the manufacturing technology of the corresponding small arms cartridges.
  5. 0
    April 16 2018 22: 30
    The article and the question itself are interesting, to the author +. There are a few points.
    "The second constructive solution in the field of sub-caliber bullets is the work of the American company AAI, headed by its leader Irwin Barr, who in 1952 developed a 12-caliber rifle cartridge equipped with 32 arrow-shaped striking elements placed in a container-type pushing pallet."

    Still, a large number of damaging elements in one cartridge can hardly be attributed to the issue of sub-caliber ammunition.

    "While maintaining the recoil of the weapon at the level of firing with a standard shot of 12-gauge shotgun, a 9-gram subcaliber bullet will be accelerated in a barrel 70 cm long to a speed of 900 m / s, which corresponds to the characteristics of the Mosin three-line rifle."

    This raises the question: why? request This cartridge and this weapon simply do not need such speed. The accuracy of 12-caliber smooth-bore weapons comparable to rifled weapons will still not be achieved. The stopping power and characteristics of damage to the soft, and hard, tissues of the same large animal at a closer distance will be clearly less than the corresponding 12-caliber bullet weighing 32-40 g.

    "In order to reduce the total weight of the cartridge as a structural material of its sleeve, it is proposed to use a composite alloy of aluminum and dispersed aluminum oxide fiber, protected by a brass galvanic coating and an antifriction polymer coating with graphite filler"


    How much will the organization of production of such cartridges and the final price for the consumer cost? Given the fact that hunters do not carry bullet cartridges in bags and the weight of the finished cartridges is not very critical? what
    1. 0
      April 17 2018 12: 05
      The equipment of bullet cartridges for smooth-bore hunting weapons is intended to expand its functionality - firing shotgun and buckshot at short range, shooting with caliber bullets at medium range and firing with sub-caliber bullets at long range.

      Hunting cartridges with sub-caliber bullets must be equipped in standard plastic or brass shells, of course. A composite of aluminum and aluminum oxide is offered exclusively for cartridges of small arms army cartridges.
  6. +2
    April 17 2018 03: 22
    At the end of the 20 century, experimented with reactive (self-destructing ....) arrow-shaped bullets ..... with arrow-shaped lethal elements from depleted uranium ...
    1. 0
      April 17 2018 12: 00
      Unguided rockets and projectiles have low accuracy.

      In addition, a bullet with a jet engine in the tail can only be shot with goggles, while there is a risk of damage to the skin of the face by the products of incomplete combustion of solid fuel of the jet engine thrown back.
      1. +2
        April 17 2018 13: 18
        Quote: Operator
        Unguided rockets and projectiles have low accuracy.

        However, NURSs have long been in service, are used in battles and .... "develop" (improve)! wink
        And why for jet bullets do not "come on holiday" after some time? request
        Quote: Operator
        You can shoot a bullet with a jet engine in the tail only with goggles, while there is a risk of damage to the skin of the face by the products of incomplete combustion of solid fuel of the jet engine thrown back.

        What the ooh belay Yoksel-moxel! Excuse me, but I can’t continue the conversation on this topic .... it makes no sense, because you do not know this topic ...
      2. +2
        April 17 2018 14: 35
        PS excuse me! I should not answer you like that! It's just that you are “out of luck” ... unfortunately, I answered you at the “moment” of the unfortunate mood. I didn’t have to take on the answer at that moment.
        In the meantime, I’m posting some pictures ...



        Gun, carbine, Gyrojet bullets (jet)

        Holecek (Czech). Czechoslovakia. (Reactive)
  7. 0
    April 17 2018 08: 40
    I wonder if this solution can be implemented in the new 9,6 / 53 Lancaster cartridge. It is designed specifically for weapons with a Lancaster drill, it has rather large dimensions and, formally, in Russia it can be reloaded, because It is designed for smooth-bore weapons.

    http://techcrim.ru/?page_id=10550
    1. 0
      April 17 2018 11: 57
      Of course it is possible - a sub-caliber bullet is sharpened on any lathe or made of a conical metal shell filled with lead.

      The only problem is the correct manufacture of a plastic pallet.
      1. 0
        April 17 2018 15: 53
        If the author introduces the 9,6 / 53 manufacturer to this topic, it might be of interest to them. Of course, not with a carbide core, but simply with a steel one is quite possible. 12 caliber cartridges with steel bullet and steel ball in a lead bullet are produced and sold.
        1. 0
          April 17 2018 17: 26
          Cartridge 9,6 / 5,3x53 mm Lancaster manufactured by Tekhkrim CJSC will not work, as it is manufactured in a “bottle” form rather than in a telescopic (standard gun sleeve) form factor.

          But with the “Spear” cartridge sub-caliber bullets, it is quite possible to shoot from ordinary smooth-bore guns of 12 and 16 calibers - the main thing is to balance the conical bullets so that the center of gravity is closer to the head than the center of pressure (by sampling the depth of the tail cavity).
  8. 0
    April 17 2018 17: 14
    Quote: Nikolaevich I
    Yoksel-moxel

    When a jet bullet takes off from a barrel, a jet of gas from a rocket engine in its tail beats right in m ... sorry, in the face of the shooter.
    1. +4
      April 18 2018 04: 12
      Quote: Operator
      When a jet bullet takes off from a barrel, a jet of gas from a rocket engine in its tail beats right in m ... sorry, in the face of the shooter.

      Well .... let's try to figure it out. 1. In the last century, several samples of rocket bullets and weapons "under them" were developed. The “Fatty Jet” is one (but not the only) of them, quite a well-known system. The grease jet was even produced as a "commercial" weapon, and an experimental "batch" was delivered to American officers in Vietnam. The disadvantages of such weapons are well known, but where (!) There is no mention of such a disadvantage as "powder gases .... face ... "!
      "Reasons": a), the exit point of the "bullet from the barrel is far enough from the shooter's physiognomy; b) the bullet is not a projectile ... a relatively small number of" hot "powder gases ... cool quickly ..." loop " small
      2. This "problem", if necessary, can be solved in different ways: a) an "active-reactive" bullet (small starting powder charge + rocket engine after take-off ... b) a rocket engine that completely burns out in the barrel before the bullet takes off. + scheme ,, open pipe. "
      PS At the present time, as if, a guided missile bullet is being developed (Russia). The "pluses" of the reactive bullet (RP) are realized - a) the ability to give the bullet a very high speed (kinetic energy), b) range (up to 10 km). The disadvantages are "leveled": a) by the control system; b) my assumption: it completely burns down in barrel rocket engine + "open pipe" scheme (although, I do not exclude the creation of an "2-speed" bullet ...)
      1. 0
        April 18 2018 07: 26
        In a solid propellant rocket engine, the pressure in the combustion chamber is one to two orders of magnitude greater than atmospheric pressure. The rocket engine nozzle is designed to convert pressure into gas velocity from the combustion of solid fuel.

        In order to ensure the operability of such a miniature device as a rocket engine in the pool and to minimize the dead zone during firing, the engine is started from the hot gases of the propellant propellant charge of the cartridge.

        Therefore, the gases, together with unburned particles of solid fuel, after the jet bullet takes off from the barrel, fly into the shooter's face at a speed of ~ 100 m / s. In the literature about the "Fat Jets" this momentous moment is not covered.

        The Open Tube is already a rocket launcher, not a small arms.
        1. +2
          April 18 2018 10: 21
          Quote: Operator
          In the literature about the "Fat Jets" this momentous moment is not covered.

          And this "moment" is not covered anywhere, and not just in the "Fatty Jet" ... So, did this "moment" really annoy the "reactive shooters"? wink
          PS But there were not only “Greyjets”, but also samples of the AVko company, Kolechek, French prototypes ... Much has been written about the “genetic” defects of rocket bullets, but where is it written that the powder gases burned the faces of the shooters? request .
          Quote: Operator
          The Open Tube is already a rocket launcher, not a small arms.

          Well this is how you yachts .... call "arms"! It’s like in a “discussion”: how is the bullet different from the projectile or ...: where does the bullet end and the projectile starts! We took the caliber 60-100 mm ..... = rocket-propelled (dynamo-reactive) grenade launcher; took -12-15 mm ..... = rocket-propelled machine gun! If only the "pipe" was open ... wink
          1. 0
            April 18 2018 10: 38
            This "moment" is disclosed in the phrase "prototypes."

            The size of a rocket-propelled grenade launcher is not important, the main thing is the principle of action: throwing a striking element due to a jet of propellant placed in the body of a grenade, and not due to the pressure of powder gases in the barrel (for example, under-barrel grenade launcher).

            Dynamo-reactive weapons (for example, Karl Gustav or LNG-9) are distinguished by the fact that the propellant charge is placed in a separate sleeve with a hole in the bottom - as a result, the powder gases from the combustion of the metal charge fly out straight ahead after the grenade and strictly back behind the grenade launcher .

            But in practice, a grenade launcher with a thermobaric striking element may well be called a "flamethrower" laughing
            1. +2
              April 18 2018 12: 55
              Duc and I to the garrison: "the caliber of a rocket-propelled grenade launcher is not important, the main thing is the principle of action ..."! Reduce the caliber of the grenade launcher to .... what to 13-15 mm (!) and get a jet "machine gun" .... I mean a jet gun ... with the same principle as a grenade launcher ... laughing
            2. +1
              April 18 2018 13: 06
              Quote: Operator
              But in practice, a grenade launcher with a thermobaric striking element may well be called a "flamethrower"

              And it’s called "... RPO" Bumblebee "(rocket infantry flamethrower) ... 3 in 1 (conditionally, of course ...): 1." Smoke "(smoke-generating) ammunition; 2. Incendiary ammunition (fire mixture) ; 3. Thermobaric ammunition. lol
  9. 0
    April 18 2018 14: 04
    As I understand it, the article contains purely theoretical calculations without any practical evidence. Practical implementation will take ten years, if at all, to be appropriate. For example, a Lancaster drill does not inspire optimism in terms of accuracy of fire.
    1. +1
      April 18 2018 15: 07
      The article is a reference point in the process of developing sub-caliber bullets for hunting and small arms. The next step will be the modeling of the external ballistics of sub-caliber bullets using the FlowVision program. The final stage is the development of plastic formulations and molds for casting segment pallets designed to equip gun cartridges in 12 caliber.

      Lancaster oval-screw drill in Russia is produced in the form of an interchangeable barrel block of Izh-Xnumx under the 27 caliber rifle cartridge and in the form of AK-12, AKS-366 and SKS-366 carbines under the .366 TKM rifle cartridge. These mass models of weapons have quite acceptable accuracy under gross cartridges.

      When using cartridges with a conical sub-caliber bullet, the accuracy of firing from Lancaster trunks will increase due to additional stabilization of the bullet in flight by its optimal centering - shifting the center of gravity to the head, and the center of pressure to the tail.
      1. 0
        April 19 2018 02: 39
        "Weapons with oval-screw drilling of Lancaster in Russia are produced in the form of a replaceable block of barrels Izh-27 under a 12-caliber rifle cartridge and in the form of AK-366, AKS-366 and SKS-366 carbines under a .366 TKM rifle cartridge. These mass models of weapons possess quite acceptable accuracy under gross cartridges "but cannot stand comparison with weapons with traditional polygonal rifling. And how do you plan to make bullets? By stamping or casting?
        1. +2
          April 19 2018 08: 56
          Caliber bullets for trunks with an oval-screw drill lose to caliber bullets for trunks with a screw thread by the efficiency of converting the energy of powder gases into the speed of a bullet due to its larger contact surface with the bore and, consequently, increased friction, which also affects the accuracy of fire.

          Increased friction in the barrel channel with an oval screw drill is eliminated by packing caliber and sub-caliber bullets in polymer containers, the friction coefficient of which for steel / chrome is at the level of the coefficient of friction of the metal shell of the bullets in the rifled barrel.

          The manufacture of gross sub-caliber bullets of rifle cartridges 12 caliber is supposed to be carried out in the following ways:
          - all-metal stamping from a steel billet;
          - expansive pouring of lead into a steel conical shell.
          It is advisable to produce target sub-caliber bullets of 12 caliber rifle cartridges by turning on a lathe from a brass billet.

          The manufacture of sub-caliber bullets for small arms (machine guns, rifles and machine guns) is planned to be carried out by sintering under pressure tungsten powder with nickel and iron powders.
  10. 0
    April 20 2018 09: 37
    Quote: Vladimirets
    The article and the question itself are interesting, to the author +. There are a few points.
    ...
    How much will the organization of production of such cartridges and the final price for the consumer cost? Given the fact that hunters do not carry bullet cartridges in bags and the weight of the finished cartridges is not very critical? what

    Ammo for smoothbore weapons a lot. There are both traditional and exotic ones, such as those equipped with three bullets connected by cables. The people are sophisticated, and one more species will be added, and their consumer will appear. But few cartridges can work at a distance of more than 100, especially 200+ m. This is enough for hunting. And for the militia? If in the event of military aggression any capable citizen takes up his rightful gun with a Lancaster barrel and a lance cartridge, he is already a full-fledged combat unit. And if the same spear cartridges are issued to the population from warehouses, but not with a brass but a tungsten bullet, enemy infantry and lightly armored vehicles will be consumed. An example is Switzerland. No one in your mind will attack this country as part of a classic military company.
    Of course, at first glance the idea of ​​conditional militarization of civilian weapons may seem delusional, but this does not negate the fact of the possibility of its consideration. Let people shoot at range and accuracy from their usual rifles, train. Suddenly, what happened is bad, and we have a trained militia in the field.
    What do you think? Or just nonsense?
  11. 0
    April 22 2018 15: 45
    The "spear" pallet, drawn on the diagram and in the cartoon, with this design will slow down significantly in the barrel and, most likely, will collapse there, even before departure.
  12. 0
    18 December 2020 17: 12
    The most optimal from the point of view of the aerodynamics of supersonic flight is the conical shape

    Where did you find such a statement ?!
    The number of shock waves is not everything. Otherwise, all the bullets and shells (and they are all supersonic) would have long ago become conical. But their tails are "thinned".
  13. 0
    18 December 2020 17: 31
    sub-caliber swept bullets of ultra-low mass made it possible to identify the fatal drawbacks of such bullets - increased lateral drift under the influence of wind and a significant deviation from the specified trajectory when firing in the rain.

    As for the wind drift - an obvious "duck". At this arrow speed, the flight time is half that of a caliber bullet. That is, the time of exposure to wind is half the time. And you can reduce the windage (size) of the tail of the boom.
    According to Dvoryaninov's data, all adjustments for shooting conditions for arrows are less than for caliber arrows.

    With the rain ... It looks like a duck. I remember that when the AK74 was introduced, there was a bike that condensate accumulates in the barrel of such a small caliber. If you don't want to, you will doubt: what if? because the channel is really thin ...

    Some here do not even believe in the penetrating ability of a light bullet. Meanwhile, at the proper speed, the 3mm arrow does not pierce, but breaks through the 6mm steel sheet, leaving a 2 by 2 centimeters hole.
  14. 0
    7 May 2023 12: 03
    5 years have passed, a lot has changed, incl. Lancaster is no longer a smoothbore :)

    and there was also a problem - to find a means of fire destruction of small air targets, that is, drones. Do you think arrow-shaped bullets can be a solution to this problem?

    Particularly large penetrating and lethal force is not required from them, the main thing is to hit :), and in this, kmk, _high-speed_ flashettes (that's what arrow-shaped striking elements are called?) Have an advantage - less flight time to the target, and accordingly - less impact of external parameters (wind, rain) and target maneuvers. Shooting for kilometers is not required, if there is a sufficiently high probability of hitting at 500-1000 meters, this is already an achievement.

    By the way, you can pour a tracer into the cavity at the back and then the automatic weapons will be able to track the flight of bullets and adjust the corrections on the go ... maybe ... probably ... :)

    Perhaps the usual rifle caliber will not be enough, you will have to do it with 12.7 mm, which is also not bad ... well, 30 mm guns have BOPS, why is 12.7 mm worse :)?

    PS: by the way, about equipping hunting cartridges with such bullets - there seems to be a ban on the civilian circulation of bullets with solid cores, such a bullet will not fall under this ban?