"Russia in the nuclear sphere overtook the whole world, otherwise lagging behind by 30 years"

28
Problems in the Russian defense industry (defense industry), the seriousness of which can be judged by the opposition of manufacturers weapons and the Ministry of Defense, on Thursday considered during hearings in the Federation Council. Yuri Solomonov, who is the chief designer of the Moscow Thermal Engineering Institute, who has always brought a lot of trouble to the Defense Ministry with his sharp criticism, during his speech at the hearings predicted new problems related to the implementation of the state defense order for the 2012 year.

So, Solomonov noted that at the moment the efforts of defense industry enterprises are not coordinated with the actions of the Ministry of Defense. This task in the current year should be urgently solved. This question is very sensitive and sensitive.

According to the developer of Bulava, the situation is not as critical as last year, but this issue should be considered today, not tomorrow, at the forefront. Recall that it was Solomonov in July last year who first warned about the upcoming disruption of GOZ-2011.

Having stated this, he thereby set up Sergei Ivanov, the then deputy prime minister for armaments, who then had to report to Dmitry Medvedev on the measures taken to improve the situation.

Not spared and the head of the Ministry of Defense Anatoly Serdyukov, who also inherited from the president. So, at the end of a meeting dedicated to fulfilling the instructions of the head of state, Dmitry Medvedev reported that he had read about the failure of the state defense order (however, Solomonov’s name was not named, although it was obvious that the president had in mind precisely his interview, which was published in day). He demanded to immediately investigate the situation and either dismiss persons who disrupted state defense orders, or "shoot the alarmists."

After that, the Defense Ministry promised to conclude contracts more than once, however, after the July presidential instruction, 4 passed a month before the state defense order was fulfilled at 100%.

However, this time Solomon didn’t limit himself only to criticism, but also praised the strategic nuclear weapons, in which the Russian Federation is 10-15 years ahead of the whole world.

The general designer of MIT listed the tasks that were fully completed last year. He referred to the development and adoption of a ground-based strategic Topol-M missile in the 2 variants, as well as the Yars missile system, which has the first solid-fuel missile with dividing heads, and the completion of flight tests of the Bulava sea-launched missile system .

He also noted that in the 10 years of development of the nuclear weapons industry, production efficiency was achieved, which was absent in the years of the Soviet planned economy. In his report, Yuri Solomonov relied on the assessment given by the Joint Chiefs of Staff. According to him, this committee is difficult to suspect of something, including the bias.

Nevertheless, according to him, in the field of defense industry there remain problems associated with a partial lag of the production base, with a lag in some scientific and technical issues.

In this regard, Solomonov supported the proposal put forward by the chairman of the military-industrial commission to create a special fund.
The scientist summed up, saying that you can not think about tomorrow, having technology 30-year-old. In this regard, the foundation that Dmitry Rogozin spoke about creating (the vice-premier for the military-industrial complex) and which is supported by all is necessary as air.

In turn, Alexander Sukhorukov, First Deputy Minister of Defense, in his speech at the hearing stated the existence of claims of the military department to the quality of the products of the Russian military-industrial complex. According to him, over the past years there has been a stable and serious decline in product quality. Compared to 2009, the number of complaints in 2010 was 20% more, in 2011 - even more.

In addition, the main reason for the delay in the performance of the state defense order in 2011, Sukhorukov considers overvalued suppliers. He said that in accordance with the analysis conducted by the Ministry of Defense, prices for military products show an increase of 15-20% per year. As a result, the growth of prices for military products over 5 years in 2 times.

During the same hearings in the Federation Council, Deputy Prime Minister Rogozin, who defended domestic manufacturers of weapons and military equipment, promised by the 2020 year to make the defense sector more competitive. In his report, he said that the appearance will be represented by 40 by large research and production companies capable of self-development and efficient asset management, as well as being able to actively position themselves not only on the Russian market, but also internationally.

According to Rogozin, the pace of economic growth in the military-industrial complex is much higher than the pace of development of civilian industry. Thus, the volume of industrial production in the 2009-2011 years in the field of defense industry has increased 1,3 times, labor productivity over the same time - 1,6 times.

The Deputy Prime Minister stressed that many defense organizations have a serious development resource.

He also opposed using the media as a platform for disputes between the Ministry of Defense and the defense industry. He said that discussions on the quality of domestic weapons should take place only within the framework of a professional workshop.

According to Rogozin, all claims from the Ministry of Defense about the quality of domestic products should be discussed and expressed only at relevant meetings. He clarified that such meetings are held only with the participation of design teams of defense enterprises.

Earlier, Rogozin challenged a fairly tough criticism, addressed to the industrialists by General Nikolai Makarov, the head of the General Staff. He said that the Ground Forces were unhappy with any of the proposed models, ranging from small arms and ending with armored vehicles, and that in some of its characteristics, Russian products are seriously inferior to their Western competitors.

In this regard, according to Makarov, the Russian army will not purchase armored vehicles over the next 5 years. This deadline was given to developers with the goal of creating a completely new and undeniably high quality. Rogozin, commenting on this speech on Twitter, said that the rearmament of the army and fleet will be held as planned, and hinted that the General Staff is not the only agency making a decision on the procurement of weapons and military equipment.

Last Wednesday, there were reports that the Russian government is ready to give the GOZ under the control of Rogozin and the government. Some publications wrote that the federal service Rosoboronzakaz would be left out of the Ministry of Defense, and the functions of the state customer would be divided between the departments of the industrial unit. Their work will be carried out under the scrutiny of the military-industrial commission under the government.
In the opinion of the same print media, the changes will most likely be approved not earlier than mid-June, after the inauguration of the new president has passed and the State Duma will approve the new prime minister.

However, Rogozin denied such rumors. He said that the decision of this issue is the responsibility of the government of the Russian Federation, and the Russian president will think about it. All the talk on this topic is only speculation.

According to a high-ranking source in the Kremlin, no decisions were made on this issue. He recommended that some members of the Russian government "stop the fuss about this issue." He also added that only the new president, on the proposal of the new chairman of the government, will decide who will be responsible for executing the state defense order.
28 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. predator
    +11
    20 February 2012 09: 19
    The Russian army first needs to get rid of two brakes - Serdyukov and Makarov.
    1. +6
      20 February 2012 10: 43
      No need to get rid of anyone ... Serdyukov is already living out his last days .. The Moor has done his job, the Moor must leave ... Seryukov’s fate is exactly the same as Zurabov’s or Chubais’s scarecrow ... There are people who are set to break , but there is one to build ... All sappers, only one mine and blow up, while others restore ... Money went into the military-industrial complex, so it will take another MO ...
      1. +2
        20 February 2012 12: 35
        I'm not sure that Serdyukov will be removed ...
    2. +5
      20 February 2012 20: 01
      A true remark, it would not hurt to drive out lobbyists of foreign military equipment, especially Israeli UAVs. Serdyukov will leave this way, so it’s not Senka’s hat, but let Makarov do military planning according to his official duties and draw less before the press. Headquarters is the brain of the army! should work quietly and quietly
    3. +2
      21 February 2012 00: 42
      Not just get rid, but also investigate their activities!

      The article contains the correct words "stop the fuss around this issue" ... The fact of the matter is that there is no normal one-man management and responsibility, but there is "fuss" in which you cannot find who is responsible for what!

      As for the title of the article, I partially agree ... It was Kiriyenko's department that fully complied with the state defense order! The warheads were delivered and accepted ... but the problem with the carriers ... A legitimate question to Solomonov. Leading the way in the "nuclear sphere" is also true. Developments in Sarov and other centers are underway, incl. and on the so-called. "other physical principles" of nuclear weapons.

      But 30 years behind development conventional weapons, never agree!
      In aviation, a maximum of 3-5 years, and that is debatable ... In artillery, including MLRS, we are not far behind. On tanks, also a moot point ... According to the latest models of small arms, I also don’t see a 30-year backlog!
      The biggest lag in the fleet ... but then we need to make an amendment for the defense line of our military doctrine.

      Another thing is that there is a lag in the real equipment of the army with new equipment! But this is where the "time-money" formula works. There will be a budget, there will be equipment! ... And if there is a budget, but there is no equipment, then this is a reason to ask Serdyukov and Makarov!

      But talking about technological lag is stupid!
  2. +6
    20 February 2012 09: 44
    In general, the article is not hurt request The enumeration of all the vicissitudes of the squabble between the Moscow Region and the military-industrial complex is not grateful ... Much of the above is known from scattered articles and programs. requestthe most important thing for the country is that all these smart uncles do not substitute a leg for each other, do not lurk their bosoms for hurt professional pride, but strive and find a common language and provide Russia with a qualitative leap in all areas. In short - they would blow in one tune!
    1. +2
      20 February 2012 10: 45
      I agree ... Probably for this Rogozin received such almost dictatorial powers ... The corrector and breaker of horns is too zealous ...
    2. +2
      20 February 2012 11: 15
      Once again, I suggest that journalist Vadim Sobin kill himself against the wall. So brazenly distorting words, making loud puffy headlines is already the limit of everything.
      1. recitatorus
        +1
        20 February 2012 15: 14
        Upon reading, the impression is complete mess and bacchanalia! They say that no one does and is not going to do anything! Everyone sits at press conferences and makes statements that others then refute, and others refute the refutation! .. Then all this verbal bunch is processed by journalists and then everyone interprets already under his favorite sauce ...
        Saltykov-Shchedrin some! ...
        1. -1
          20 February 2012 17: 01
          blablablabla.
  3. +4
    20 February 2012 09: 53
    "Solomonov did not confine himself only to criticism, but also praised strategic nuclear weapons, in which the Russian Federation is 10-15 years ahead of the whole world."
    Reading and understanding is very nice. The main thing now is not to slow down.

    "So, Solomonov noted that at the moment the efforts of the enterprises of the military-industrial complex are not coordinated with the actions of the Ministry of Defense. This task should be urgently resolved this year. This issue is very acute and sensitive."
    Rather, you will not say. Sometimes it seems that everyone is talking to himself.
    "According to Rogozin, all claims from the Defense Ministry to the quality of domestic products should be discussed and expressed only at specialized meetings. He clarified that such meetings are held only with the participation of design teams of defense enterprises."
    This is the first step in this direction.
    In general, the article left a good impression. The fact that the defense has problems is not secret, obvious improvements are already visible. Problems are identified, solutions are identified. Now only work.
  4. +1
    20 February 2012 09: 57
    The title of the article does not match the content.
    In addition, the main reason for the delay in the implementation of the state defense order in 2011, Sukhorukov considers the excessive prices of suppliers

    Yes, our defense industry has not seen such infusions of state funds for a long time, therefore, and bending prices in order to "gain fat" so to speak, while there is an opportunity, because we do not have a civilian arms market as such, which is sad.
  5. Dimitrxnumx
    -1
    20 February 2012 09: 58
    Of course, it’s good that there is constructive criticism, I would like it to be perceived normally, and most importantly, draw the right conclusions and the right actions to eliminate it. It’s good that they began to raise such questions and draw correct conclusions, because before that nobody needed it and there was a complete mess. I want to believe that in the near future we will catch up. And most importantly, new equipment will be regularly updated and appear in the army, as well as overtaking world standards as in the nuclear sphere.
  6. +1
    20 February 2012 10: 58
    That's right ..... and now we need to draw conclusions and go the 30-year journey in 5-7 years ...... there is experience in our country in overcoming difficult situations, (the country's recovery after the Second World War, Western analysts predicted 50 -70- years, and a few years later we were already the first in space).
    1. recitatorus
      +5
      20 February 2012 15: 18
      For this we need passionarity, the burning of the people with a common noble goal!
      The slogan "chop the loot - and you're in chocolate! .." it's time to rip off!
      1. black_eagle
        0
        20 February 2012 19: 38
        Hmm ... people without a common idea - there is very bad! Look at Cuba in North Korea, how much worse they live, economically, and how devoted to the state. Today, one of the leaders will die, what shall we say? - Thank God, there is a way for him! also count how much dough spent on wreaths !!!
  7. 755962
    +3
    20 February 2012 11: 07
    So, Solomonov noted that at the moment the efforts of defense industry enterprises are not coordinated with the actions of the Ministry of Defense. This task in the current year should be urgently solved. This question is very sensitive and sensitive.
    I would say in Russian .... AS a sickle in the balls. Forgive me, I got sick ..
    1. +2
      20 February 2012 12: 53
      This problem is not easy to solve because many defense industry enterprises are virtually no longer owned by the state. And administrative measures are indispensable here ...
  8. +2
    20 February 2012 15: 10
    Solomon is a smart man. It's a pity to listen to him only now.
  9. +2
    20 February 2012 15: 21
    For the money that weapons designers receive, few will go to work ... At Solomonov's institute, the average age of specialists is 50 ...
    1. 0
      20 February 2012 17: 04
      Well, what is your salary, knowing ours?
      Personally, I have a very good salary for our city, however, I dare to assure you that if you pay me 2 times as much, I would not change my interesting and fascinating work, which throws new challenges to my professionalism every day, to another.
  10. +4
    20 February 2012 15: 31
    recitatorus This requires passionarity, the burning of the people with a common noble goal!
    The slogan "chop the loot - and you're in chocolate! .." it's time to rip off!
    I completely agree. People do, and not poured, then plundered funds. And esaul is right - to blow everyone into one dudu. There you have the coordination.
  11. suharev-52
    +3
    20 February 2012 18: 55
    They gave as an example that the defense industry inflates prices by 15-20% per year. And who, if not the native state, winds up energy prices, who increases various deductions and taxes? Martians? So, before attacking the same "parquet general", I would get out of my Moscow den and see how people live in Zamkadye. The military-industrial complex is forced to raise the price, as the prices for electricity - "market", raw materials - are becoming more expensive from private suppliers. Eh ... yes, what can I say. Oh ... this Moscow has left, that's the whole conversation. It is high time to introduce, if not execution, then life imprisonment with full confiscation for budget robbery. But it is our money that is being stolen, and we are silent. Give a referendum on corruption !!!!
    1. 0
      20 February 2012 19: 15
      suharev - 52,
      referendum on corruption is how? Question are you for or against corruption? the referendum will be quite funny
  12. 0
    20 February 2012 19: 13
    Well, how can we not argue in public about the quality of technology on the other hand, then we won’t find out anything, and they will again say what is progressive and in reality everything will pour in, a certain transparency and objectivity of the assessments should be discussed on a wide platform
  13. SL.Kocegar
    0
    21 February 2012 06: 43
    According to Rogozin, the pace of economic growth in the military-industrial complex is much higher than the pace of development of civilian industry. Thus, the volume of industrial production in the 2009-2011 years in the field of defense industry has increased 1,3 times, labor productivity over the same time - 1,6 times.
    I understand this, and on one hand for one. Just answer me as a technician why we buy machines in Italy (U-UAZ) and why our light industry is bent over, I remember the shots from "Peter 1" when Petr Alekseevich Menshikov for cloth kalashmatil
  14. DEATH UWB
    0
    22 February 2012 16: 17
    by the way, we now have an anarchist system in this, we have moved to the penultimate stage of development. the last step is absolute anarchy from above, and the power of all people - that is, everything that the country has earned to divide evenly into all citizens of the country, and the defense of the country directly depends on everyone, each has its place on the battlefield and in life even before his birth, but he has the right to choose if he proves that he deserves more ...
  15. 0
    17 January 2015 12: 43
    The Solomon Institute is also not an ideal of quality work. One Mace is worth it. Of course, criticizing others is easier, but as they say, a log in one’s eye should also be seen.