Military Review

Disarmed economy

106
Russia's foreign policy conflicts with production capabilities




Vectors of foreign and domestic policy of Russia are diametrically opposed. The first leads to a revival of the status and influence of Russia in the world, the second pulls in the liberal direction, depriving Russia's foreign policy initiatives of adequate material support.

The end of November and the beginning of December were extremely rich in very significant events. This is the destruction by the Turkish Air Force of our front-line bomber Su-24, followed by Ankara's stubborn refusal to recognize the illegality of aggression and apologize. Sanctions on the part of Russia and the publication of irrefutable materials testifying to the mass purchases by Turkish firms of oil from the IG, the maneuvers of the American and European elites connected with these facts. The Turkish invasion of Iraq, which provoked the indignation of Baghdad and its decision to turn to Russia with a request to extend the military operations of the air forces to the territory of the country. Iraq’s stated determination to strike at the aggressor’s troops - that is, the Turkish tank battalion deployed in the Mosul area. All this happens against the backdrop of the consequences of the terrorist attack in Paris and the death of the Russian liner over the Sinai, the beginning of the vigorous actions of the French deck and the British aviation against the Islamic State banned in Russia, the unsuccessful attempt by President Hollande to create a Russian-Western anti-terrorist coalition.

Military tensions in the regions adjacent to our borders are growing at a very high rate, and what is most unpleasant is drawing our country into a large-scale armed confrontation with powerful radical groups in the zone of the Near and Middle East, behind which stand the United States, the monarchies of the Persian Gulf and Turkey. And this is fraught with direct confrontation with NATO countries. Russia, accepting the challenge, decides to build up an air force in Syria and for this has proceeded to accelerate the creation of an additional airbase south of Homs, which will increase the combat strength of our aircraft in Syria to one hundred aircraft, and possibly more. These forces will be able to have a significant impact on the course of the war as a whole, and not only in individual, albeit very important areas. There is no doubt that the response to this step by the United States and its allies will follow in a relatively short time. And it may include reinforced supplies of weapons and military equipment to militants (of course, under the guise of equipping "moderate opposition"), as well as preparing for a direct invasion of Syrian forces by the NATO ground forces. Probably, the appearance of the Turkish tank battalion in Iraq is a kind of “reconnaissance in force”: how will Russia behave in such a situation.

The message of the President of our country to the Federal Assembly was attentively listened to by all political and military analysts, experts, and also a considerable part of compatriots. Such great attention is quite understandable: after all, the line of conduct of our country was determined at a very critical period. The success of its overcoming depends on the welfare of each of us. However, judging by the rather critical comments of experts and the very quick curtailment of the discussion of the message in the media, the hopes of the Russians were not fully justified.

If we summarize the various statements of experts and ordinary citizens, the main reason for such a reaction can be called the apparent discrepancy between the vectors of foreign and domestic policy. What it is, you need to understand.

To restore status - at the limit of opportunities


If we talk about the foreign policy of Russia, which was clearly formulated in the President’s Address, it is actually defined as an independent and very active, focused on protecting the interests of the country and its allies in all key areas of the world, including hot spots. The president warned our "partners" against reckless actions, stating that the answer could be not only in the economic sphere. The hint is quite obvious if we take into account the “leakage” of information on the Status-6 system and the demonstrative use of the Russian TFR Caliber and X-101 in Syria. It is unreasonable to hit such guerrillas with guerrilla formations - the price of the spent weapons incomparably higher than the cost of destroyed enemy targets, which means that the launches were not so much of military importance as political: show the West what weapons Russia has. However, in the modern world any more or less noticeable military efforts suggest their rather large-scale material support. This is worth a special mention. And the fighting for our air force gives enough cause for alarm.

First of all, the exceptionally high intensity of the use of aircraft of the aviation group attracts attention. According to media reports, in the first two months of hostilities in Syria, the intensity of aviation operations averages 1,8 – 2 of departure per vehicle per day. According to the experience of the wars of the second half of the last century and the first 15 years of the new when conducting air offensive operations, the average for four to five days the intensity of the use of aviation did not exceed the 1,4 departure per day. And in the course of air campaigns involving two or three air offensive operations during a month or one and a half, on average, 0,8 – 1,1 of tactical aviation. That is, our videoconferencing systems operate with extreme intensity.

A similar picture with the volume of fire problems solved by a single board. According to experience, at least a couple of aircraft are assigned to defeat a single small object. If this object is covered by an air defense system or has a good structural protection, is equipped with a fortification ratio, the number of strike aircraft increases to a level or more. That is, for the departure on one machine should fall 0,5 and less fire tasks. Russian aircraft in Syria for the departure solve two or more fire tasks. In this case, until the death of the Su-24M, our machines acted alone, which significantly increases the risk of losing cars from air defense fire and complicates their solution to the tasks of destroying the designated targets. Comparing the volume of fire tasks solved by our aviation group for the period of conducting military operations in Syria with the required strength of forces when used with normal voltage, it can be stated that our regimental grouping operated with the intensity of the division.

This indicates one thing: opportunities are not enough. What prevents to increase the number of groups? It can be assumed that there is no sufficient operational capacity of the airfield network. However, time to expand the same Hamim was enough. The tip lies in the limited use of long-range aviation. After several strikes of Tu-22m3 groups using free-fall bombs on areal targets, their use ceased. The likely reason is that you need to achieve highly accurate target destruction. And this is possible only with the WTO or with SVP-24, which allows to use free-fall bombs with exceptional accuracy. Russia does not have enough precision weapons, and airplanes with SVP-24 are already in Syria. Probably, precisely because over the past two months additional machines equipped with the subsystem appeared, it became possible to increase the number of our aviation group.

Another possible reason is the lack of trained pilots. In any case, this is the main obstacle to attracting our aircraft carrier to combat operations in Syria. Its capabilities are very limited in solving the tasks of defeating ground objects, but an additional increase in the combat capabilities of our group in 15 – 20 percent would be very useful.

However, the main contribution to the rout of the irregular formations is made by the ground forces. Accordingly, the main "tool" of fire destruction is field artillery. It is she who, suppressing or destroying the enemy, is able to provide a breakthrough of the deeply echeloned defense. The offensive operation of the Syrian army, which began on October 1, began at an unprecedented pace - 7 – 50 kilometers, and the main contribution to this was made by the field artillery that organized the “rampart”. However, the consumption of ammunition is huge. So, if the Grad installation makes only two volleys in a day, it will launch 70 shells. Self-propelled (towed) artillery installation has ammunition from 80 to 40 shells, which she is capable of releasing in 50 – 7 minutes. Accordingly, over the period of execution of fire support tasks (from 12 – 20 minutes and more), she can launch 40 – 1,5 ammunition, that is, 2 – 60 shells. Even during World War II (starting from the end of 100), artillery densities of at least 1942 – 100 guns per kilometer were created to break through the enemy’s defense, and in particularly important areas this figure reached 120 and more. That is, with an offensive in a band of about 300 kilometers, the number of artillery systems should be at least about a thousand and they will launch about 10 thousands of shells per day offensive. Is it a lot or a little? Here it is worth remembering the articles in the MIC of a major Russian expert in the production of ammunition, Yuri Shabalin, who, complaining about the sad state of affairs in this industry, said that we need to be able to produce at least a million shells a year. That is, for one day of conducting operations on the site of the entire 100 kilometers, more than a monthly rate of ammunition production will be required. But after all, 10 kilometers is only a small fragment of the strip of advance of an army group and even this kind of operation lasts at least five to seven days.

But besides field artillery, shells are needed for anti-tank weapons, tanksinfantry. That is, to conduct a more or less serious military conflict with a trained enemy, we will need millions of pieces of ammunition in a month or even shorter period of time. They need to be produced. And there is no capacity for this in Russia today, judging by the opinion of the said expert.

However, it is not only in the shells. Rocket weapons produced the same inadequate pace. Judging by the interval between the first and second rocket attacks, the volume of production of such weapons in Russia is almost two orders of magnitude less than in the United States. And it is also necessary to produce in essentially large volumes the actual military equipment for the VKS, SV and Navy. Our country remains dependent on basic industrial products for the defense industry, in particular, microelectronics. The termination of deliveries from abroad will stop the release of high-tech security products. The restoration of capacities for the production of the same shells is hampered by the lack of a modern machine park of its own production, in particular, multi-spindle machines, which were produced in our country in sufficient quantities in Soviet times.

Inertia production


It can be stated that without a large-scale restoration of the industrial potential of our country at the new technological level, with the restoration of virtually whole industries from scratch, it is impossible to support the foreign policy course outlined by the president in his Message. This requires the consolidation of society on the idea of ​​restoring the country, involving people in management who are able to organize such a large-scale work and to ensure a clearly coordinated functioning of all spheres of life. That is what the patriots of Russia dreamed to hear in the Message of our President. However, the internal political part of the document was of a pronounced liberal nature.

It is unlikely to contribute to the destruction of real corruption decriminalization of the business sphere by transferring a number of economic crimes from criminal to administrative ones. And it is unlikely to save the law-abiding merchants from the prosecution of self-serving officials.

There is little hope that the “amnestied” capital will return to Russia in six months. After all, those of them, which do not hang serious criminal articles, have already returned. Others will not return for the reason that they are behind the crimes of 90's. But the doubt that our leadership is at least minimally thinking about social justice will be sown thoroughly. Because the return of such capital means: their owners are forgiven. This is unlikely to contribute to the consolidation of the people around the government, rather the opposite, especially if we consider that the very concept of “social justice” in the Message has not been heard once.

Real measures were not proposed to change the situation in the economy. Here, at a minimum, there must be a clear plan for coordinated activities of various sectors of our economy, oriented towards the revival of the above-mentioned key areas of production. But the re-creation of the state plan in any form was not discussed. Instead, the task was to promote the implementation of various projects, both public and private. This will certainly contribute to the development of the economy, but will not allow the industrial base to be restored in a reasonable time. Moreover, it was not said about the nationalization of strategic industries, without which it is impossible in principle to revive a sovereign economy, to lead the country out of raw material dependence. Especially alarming in this regard was the opinion about the advisability of further privatization measures.

The bewilderment was caused by the high assessment given in the Message to the reform of education and science, the negative consequences of which are constantly spoken by the public. There was no call to remove these areas from foreign control. After all, it is well known that the leading Russian scientific centers are often led by citizens of other states, sometimes pursuing a policy hostile to Russia.

No real measures have been proposed for replacing “effective managers” with real production organizers — specialists in the relevant areas of production activity. The emphasis on public-private partnership, on ASI as a key tool for the selection and promotion of promising projects and personnel leaves little hope for the revival of the industrial potential of the country. It is not by chance that in the past few months the subject of import substitution in industry has faded into the background, at least in the media.

As a result, the vectors of foreign and domestic policy are diametrically opposed. AT stories Russia, this situation has already been and ended very sadly.
Author:
Originator:
http://vpk-news.ru/articles/28651
106 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. The comment was deleted.
    1. Frigate
      Frigate 30 December 2015 12: 33
      20
      Quote: kostya-petrov

      In our country, the media themselves form news reports for themselves, and they are not subject to the state. Alas, this is bad.


      We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country. Otherwise, this mess will not lead to good.
      1. Vladimyrych
        Vladimyrych 30 December 2015 12: 40
        10 th
        A way-put to you than a leader? Now, as they say, Kudrin will return it - in general, the ascent will begin. laughing
        1. sa-zz
          sa-zz 30 December 2015 12: 52
          15
          Quote: Vladimir
          A way-put to you than a leader? Now, as they say, Kudrin will return - in general, the ascent will begin

          Well, judging by your flag, you and Hollande (ollie-polly in your opinion or what?) Is enough. The French are a national minority in France now, but your sexual majority is already p.d.i.k.i.
          1. 34 region
            34 region 30 December 2015 13: 06
            0
            And how do you know who they have more? Here on TV the plot was about an American aircraft carrier. So there are many doctors and ice (Yes, yes. Girls also serve there). And inside it is painted pink. It turns out the whole army on the maintenance of doctors! Perhaps that is why they threaten us for oppressing minorities.
          2. Pulya
            Pulya 30 December 2015 15: 16
            +4
            sa-zz where does the flag ????
            I have a flag for some reason, a mattress, and I chew in Norilsk ... all the roots are Kuban KOZAKI.
            The flag on the avatar is just bullshit, something like + or -
          3. sherp2015
            sherp2015 30 December 2015 20: 21
            +1
            Quote: sa-zz
            The French are a national minority in France now, but your sexual majority is already p.d.i.k.i.


            An analysis of the article is generally about poor supply and a low production base ...
        2. Blondy
          Blondy 30 December 2015 13: 14
          14
          Yes, it’s better to Shoigu than Kudrin. Kuzhuketyych the man checked, on liberal spangles will not disappear and will not be foolish.
          And what about the liberal monetarist Kudrin and his truth? Remember the conversion of the ruble: a freely convertible ruble will be like a reserve currency - wow, what a "theory". But the yuan has already become a reserve currency, without free conversion. And for some reason the opposite is true with the ruble. And they began to squeeze out everything that was possible and not possible from the people, up to impoverishment. So, with Kudrin, another Pokemon is expected with the next hanging people on the ears. The rich may become even richer, and the people, as if even poorer.
          1. afdjhbn67
            afdjhbn67 30 December 2015 13: 33
            +4
            Quote: Blondy
            Yes, it’s better to Shoigu than Kudrin

            By the way, on the Internet, stuffing has already begun about negotiations with Kudrin with the aim of returning to the government .. for now, he is willing to think .. so that we will have Pokemon and noodles. possibly with a replacement after Medvedev’s NG ... closer to the election as a sacred sacrifice
        3. Irbis77
          Irbis77 30 December 2015 13: 43
          -5
          it’s not about whom he will return or dismiss. just liberals like Kudrin, Gaidar, Chubais, while there are still people like you in the country. in place of building something useful, you pour mud on those who really do useful things for the country.
      2. vovanpain
        vovanpain 30 December 2015 12: 41
        23
        Quote: Frigate
        We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country

        I suggest.
        1. 34 region
          34 region 30 December 2015 12: 49
          +8
          The people are FOR. That's just the guarantor against. And what to do? What to do?
          1. cniza
            cniza 30 December 2015 12: 59
            +2
            Everything is too ambiguous and the article is dull without the completion of thought. There is a normal leader, we need to do internal affairs ... and we all don’t sleep.
            1. 34 region
              34 region 30 December 2015 13: 18
              32
              Well yes! The leader is normal! Only helpers are stupid! And who chose his assistants? Or who drove out can not cope? At work, if you do not arrange a manual, you will fly out quickly. And here is the stability of the team.
              1. Vadim237
                Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 20
                +1
                We mostly have problems because of those who are sitting in the localities, all over Russia and those who are "about with me."
              2. Per se.
                Per se. 30 December 2015 18: 07
                +3
                Quote: Region 34
                At work, if you do not arrange a manual, you will fly out quickly.
                Apparently, the assistants are quite satisfied, since there are people like the unsinkable Chubais and the out-of-court Serdyukov. The whole question is how monolithic our political collective in the government is, what forces influence it, except for the power of the president. Those of the "family" who actually ruled Russia under the drunkard Yeltsin have not gone anywhere. The second question is whether Putin is with them or against them. If we return to the topic of the article itself, then the author very correctly raises the problem, with such an aggravation in the world, our defense industry should work in three shifts, we need to mobilize all forces, otherwise, you see, the army will spend the entire supply of bombs and missiles with shells in Syria, with "piece" replenishment. God forbid, another war, this time for Russia, what reserves will remain ... Finally, what economic leap can be, as long as oil, gas, transport, etc., vital, affecting pricing in the country, our economy itself, is not state property while there is trading for dollars (and pegged to the dollar), while billions are flowing out of the country to offshore.
                1. Wheel
                  Wheel 30 December 2015 18: 51
                  +2
                  Quote: Per se.
                  Those of the "family" who actually ruled Russia under the drunkard Yeltsin have not gone anywhere. The second question is whether Putin is with them or against them.

                  The question, in fact, is rhetorical.
                  1. PHANTOM-AS
                    PHANTOM-AS 30 December 2015 20: 27
                    +5
                    Quote: Wheel

                    The question, in fact, is rhetorical.
                  2. The comment was deleted.
            2. Finntroll
              Finntroll 30 December 2015 14: 43
              14
              The article is what you need and the thought in it is complete. And the thought is as follows - Without financial order, and real reindustrialization within the country, we can shove all our geopolitical abitions into our own dupu, or, soon, our partners will shove them. The GARANT, for some reason, visible only to him, is in no hurry to conduct shock therapy inside the country .... they say, excuse the 37th year ..... Our government, rubbing its paws, on the contrary, promises that shock therapy will be, only in the role patients will not be particularly snickering representatives of the financial and political "I" litas, but as always the common people. There is no time (well, that is, it was not there before, but now it is not at all in principle. There is a stone and two or three directions. Choose and walk, wide and better not look back). And here where not throw a wedge everywhere, or 3.14dets, as you like, or to us "people" or to them "ilitam". So far, "and" litas are winning with not quite a decent score. Something like this.
              1. Wheel
                Wheel 30 December 2015 18: 54
                +4
                Quote: FinnTroll
                GUARANTOR for some reason, visible only to him, is in no hurry to conduct shock therapy within the country ....

                The guarantor is accurate and conducts shock therapy within the country in relation to its people, if Che.
                1. Finntroll
                  Finntroll 30 December 2015 21: 39
                  +2
                  Well, here I bet, specifically the GARANT himself does not carry out it, but let's just say, with his tacit consent, the "government" is engaged in this lewdness. The key point here is that the boat shakes the ENTIRE top, and poop at the end will be thrown at the captain. EVERYONE, including the closest associates of that very captain, who directly had a hand in capsizing the ship, will be thrown. And to put it bluntly, in the event of a collapse, Putin will be PERSONALLY to blame for everything, and EVERYONE (even the current government, which really aims to screw everything up), the rest will point their fingers at him and vying with each other to bawl about how white and fluffy they are, and what Putin is bad ... ICHSKh all rush to look for a new idol and still find from among the Gorlopanov naturally, but the problem here is not so much in people as in the system as a whole. Who cares who the captain is, if you have holes in your hold, the ship is doomed anyway. For the sake of interest, look at the agitation campaigns of all candidates in the elections, Golden Mountains promise, but not one, NOT a SINGLE SOUL says what exactly he will do to obtain these Golden Mountains, at best, vague wording. By the way, they are even more afraid to talk about the real reasons for such a deplorable state of Russia so far, and God forbid, God forbid, to do something real to correct the situation. PS
              2. Evgeniy667b
                Evgeniy667b 31 December 2015 21: 38
                0
                What the Guarantor is doing now is called BLUFF !!!
                A PR created him wild.
                1. svp67
                  svp67 31 December 2015 21: 54
                  0
                  Quote: Evgeniy667b
                  what the Guarantor is doing now is called BLUFF !!!

                  The ability to bluff is not given to everyone and is worth a lot.
              3. The comment was deleted.
            3. Pulya
              Pulya 30 December 2015 15: 21
              +3
              cniza yes we already sleep so little, we work hard in two jobs to feed our family !!!!
              And the article is quite ACTUAL.
              And your leader has already tired many ...
              1. Alexei
                Alexei 30 December 2015 20: 04
                -4
                Quote: Pulya
                And the article is quite ACTUAL.
                And your leader has already tired many ...

                Personally, I will tear apart any wolf with a mattress flag for my leader, like a heating pad. And I don’t need here about Norilsk, the Internet through a plate ... I was not too lazy and read all your brilliant 46 comments and came to the conclusion that you are a typical populist who offers nothing but to rebel against the Kremlin. At first it seemed to me that you are an American troll, making inept comments with childish errors calling everyone to an immediate rebellion against Putin and Co. But then, after carefully reading it, it dawned on me that you were an ordinary simple hard-working binge who, without reading a beer, philosophizes in the kitchen on how to build a state and develop the economy.
              2. svp67
                svp67 31 December 2015 21: 55
                +1
                Quote: Pulya
                And your leader has already tired many ...

                Yes? Then GIVE UP ...
        2. Frigate
          Frigate 30 December 2015 13: 16
          +8
          Quote: vovanpain
          Quote: Frigate
          We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country

          I suggest.

          I agree.
        3. beer-youk
          beer-youk 30 December 2015 13: 41
          0
          I beg your pardon, but in order to simultaneously respond to threats to the state, both inside and out, you need to be a genius equal to Stalin. With all due respect, Putin is not Stalin, and responds to threats as they threaten the country. Although, in fairness, Stalin, to some extent, was easier. In the sense that he crushed most of the internal enemies before the appearance of a clear external threat, and that which remained was not a real danger. In this regard, Putin is much more difficult.
          1. Saratoga833
            Saratoga833 30 December 2015 14: 06
            14
            Quote: beer-youk
            In this regard, Putin is much more difficult.

            It’s not more difficult, but he doesn’t have the political will to restore order in his own state. Out of place, he!
        4. Pirogov
          Pirogov 30 December 2015 18: 25
          +1
          Quote: vovanpain
          Quote: Frigate
          We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country

          I suggest.
          .................................................. ........... Yes, but where to get it?
      3. sa-zz
        sa-zz 30 December 2015 12: 45
        +6
        Quote: Frigate
        We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country.

        Who are you talking about? About Prokhorov, or Khodorkovsky-bulk-Kasparov?
        We need a normal prime minister, this wretched "talking head" is not capable of anything in such a post, and everything is fine with the Leader in Russia. There is no command, yes. All that the West is praying for now is getting rid of the GDP, what's interesting?
        And in the article there are only minuses - everything is gone, it's time to bring down, blabla. But there are pluses in the country, only the author did not see them, but preferred to say that everything is bad !!
        1. 34 region
          34 region 30 December 2015 12: 50
          +4
          What does the prime minister have to do with it? The president is satisfied with his work. Are you against the president?
          1. sa-zz
            sa-zz 30 December 2015 12: 56
            -2
            Quote: Region 34
            The president is satisfied with his work. Are you against the president?

            You know, there is such a thing as fidelity and honesty - this is prime-faithful and honest, but unfortunately these qualities are not enough in the politics-terrarium. Maybe the President is not satisfied with the work of the prime minister as prime minister, but there is no one to rely on.
            You read my comment more closely, and then ask provocative questions hi
            1. Vladimyrych
              Vladimyrych 30 December 2015 13: 03
              +7
              sa-zz I watch. You want to sit sand? Yes? I sympathize does not shine for you. Rotenbergs won't say a word for you laughing
              1. sa-zz
                sa-zz 30 December 2015 13: 06
                -2
                Quote: Vladimir
                sa-zz I watch you want to sit peskov yes? I sympathize does not shine for you.

                Yes, of course, and you do not shine, only citizens of the Russian Federation bully
                1. Vladimyrych
                  Vladimyrych 30 December 2015 13: 07
                  +7
                  And I'm not torn. I do not have anything in that bydnyat selling.
            2. asiat_61
              asiat_61 30 December 2015 13: 46
              10
              Faithful and honest, this is not a profession. But the Guarantor chose his own assistants, we can not influence this.
              1. Saratoga833
                Saratoga833 30 December 2015 14: 16
                +4
                Quote: asiat_61
                we cannot influence this.

                We can! By electing a new President. I do not believe that in our vast country there are no smart, initiative people who are not subject to a liberal dump!
                1. Ingvar 72
                  Ingvar 72 30 December 2015 14: 58
                  +5
                  Quote: Saratoga833
                  We can! Electing a new President

                  Do you seriously believe in fair elections?
            3. Saratoga833
              Saratoga833 30 December 2015 14: 13
              +8
              Quote: sa-zz
              here’s prime, true and honest,

              Maybe he is both faithful and honest, only a small mind! You will remember what he did while being in the chair of the President! And you can’t remember anything positive! EVERYTHING that he had wandered, had to be completely redone, or returned to normal! Here is all his faithfulness, honesty, intelligence and initiative! And his visit to China? Distinguished by the fact that the negotiations failed miserably!
          2. Saratoga833
            Saratoga833 30 December 2015 14: 07
            11
            Quote: Region 34
            Are you against the president?

            I am against his liberal domestic policy.
            1. asiat_61
              asiat_61 31 December 2015 23: 54
              0
              You might think, I am delighted with LADIES? People are smart, it’s not even discussed.
        2. Ingvar 72
          Ingvar 72 30 December 2015 12: 56
          +8
          Quote: sa-zz
          But there are pluses in the country, only the author did not see them, but preferred to say that everything is bad !!

          Who is to blame for the more cons? (I'm about economics)
          Quote: sa-zz
          and with the Leader in Russia, everything is fine. No team, yes

          Still believe in a fairy tale about a good and fair king and evil boyars? Do not build illusions, they are one well-coordinated team, and the positive in the country (foreign policy) is explained only by the fact that the interests of the country and the ruling elite coincided. hi
          1. sa-zz
            sa-zz 30 December 2015 13: 03
            -5
            Quote: Ingvar 72
            Who is to blame for the more cons? (I'm about economics)

            There are no minuses without pluses, but only minuses are mentioned.
            Who is to blame and what to do is a rhetorical question in Russia. It is necessary to move, not to hope that they will bring home money, but to work and feed the family, you look, and there will be more pluses. Well, do not let the authorities relax, but how pregnant cows move.hi
            1. PHANTOM-AS
              PHANTOM-AS 30 December 2015 14: 40
              +7
              Quote: sa-zz
              There are no minuses without pluses, but only minuses are mentioned.

              And where are the pluses?
              In addition to PR, I would like to look at real achievements.
            2. Ingvar 72
              Ingvar 72 30 December 2015 14: 54
              +2
              Quote: sa-zz
              There are no minuses without pluses, but only minuses are mentioned.

              Well, someone even in the Yeltsin board sees advantages. If we compare the GDP with Yeltsin, then he is certainly the guru of the economy. But if you compare with Stalin?
              Quote: sa-zz
              You need to move, do not hope that they will bring home money, but to work and feed your family, you will see more advantages

              Yah!? belay Damn, I thought how Emelya lay on the stove! laughing
          2. vovanpain
            vovanpain 30 December 2015 13: 10
            +7
            Still believe in a fairy tale about a good and fair king and evil boyars?

            Now, I’ll ask you dear forum users, what kind of king, president, general secretary do you need? Whoever you ask, all for a good people, a fan of the people, and so on, well, you’ll name your surname in the end. that would be led by I.V. Stalin, but he won’t be returned, and except for V.V. Putin, I don’t see anyone now and I won’t pour water on the mattress mill. With respect to you. hiOf course, I apologize, but now I have to go to the ruined, torn to shreds and in general nothing works for us, but for some reason we have all the machines and we live, work. Once again, with respect and all Happy New Year, dear forum users. hi drinks love
            1. PHANTOM-AS
              PHANTOM-AS 30 December 2015 13: 43
              14
              Quote: vovanpain
              and apart from Vladimir Putin, I don’t see anyone now

              and this is in a huge country request
              what happened to us?
        3. Frigate
          Frigate 30 December 2015 13: 11
          14
          Quote: sa-zz
          Quote: Frigate
          We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country.

          Who are you talking about? About Prokhorov, or Khodorkovsky-bulk-Kasparov?
          We need a normal prime minister, this wretched "talking head" is not capable of anything in such a post, and everything is fine with the Leader in Russia. There is no command, yes. All that the West is praying for now is getting rid of the GDP, what's interesting?
          And in the article there are only minuses - everything is gone, it's time to bring down, blabla. But there are pluses in the country, only the author did not see them, but preferred to say that everything is bad !!

          If a leader is not able to assemble his team, then what kind of leader is he?
          Like it or not, but Putin is a protege of the Yeltsin clan. He is the manager of certain oligarchic circles.
          And the West is stupid, since it is praying for a change of Putin, because God can send Russia such a leader who really sweeps away all this Western husk.
          We need a smart, strong and decisive leader. Like Stalin.
          1. sa-zz
            sa-zz 30 December 2015 13: 22
            -5
            Quote: Frigate
            We need a smart, strong and decisive leader. Like Stalin.

            I hope that Putin, as a good intelligence officer, is preparing to become one, preparing the ground, so to speak.
            Stalin’s topic can be discussed separately all day, no matter how good it sounds, I’m sure that young people so zealously advertising it (Stalin) do not particularly like this, not at that time. Our leader, with all the rigidity of Stalin, must possess even greater qualities, the world is not the same.
            1. Wheel
              Wheel 30 December 2015 15: 40
              +6
              Quote: sa-zz
              I hope that Putin, as a good intelligence officer, is preparing to become one, preparing the ground, so to speak.

              And who said that he is a good scout?
              And who said that he is preparing to become someone?
          2. PHANTOM-AS
            PHANTOM-AS 30 December 2015 16: 12
            +1
            Quote: Frigate
            If a leader is not able to assemble his team, then what kind of leader is he?

            and the "lake" is not a team? and personalities are all in sight.
        4. dauria
          dauria 30 December 2015 13: 20
          +2
          But there are pluses in the country, only the author did not see them, but preferred to say that everything is bad !!


          Not only this. He is sly. It turns out that everything is "bad" in Syria. wink There are no shells, the density of fire, as in Kurskaya, we can’t do (but should it be?) 2 sorties per day per car is for wear laughing . But he concealed the Soviet times, and he didn’t say why there were more pilots than machines in the staff of pilots.
          1. sa-zz
            sa-zz 30 December 2015 13: 25
            +2
            Quote: dauria
            But he concealed the Soviet times, and he didn’t say why there were more pilots than machines in the staff of pilots.

            Here I am about the same.
        5. trantor
          trantor 30 December 2015 16: 59
          +4
          Quote: sa-zz
          We need a normal prime minister, this wretched "talking head" is not capable of anything in such a post, and everything is fine with the Leader in Russia. There is no command, yes.

          It's hard to disagree. But the prime minister must also be an authoritative, charismatic and literate leader. Ours is clearly out of place. In this regard, Kiriyenko, better known as "kinder surprise", comes to my mind. There was no prime minister, but he got to his place and the industry started working. So it is with the LADY - there is more authority in his iPhone than in himself.

          And they all lie on trifles, and on a large scale. Obviously, the same figures can be presented in completely different ways ... Intelligence is needed inside - illegal and deeply conspiracy. One that provides information only to the head of state.
      4. Pulya
        Pulya 30 December 2015 15: 10
        +3
        [/ Quote]

        We need a leader who will finally restore order in the country. Otherwise, this mess will not lead to good. [/ Quote]

        Need more as needed !!!!!!
        But the trouble is that - who will admit him to power ...
        These leaders clung tenaciously ... just like that, without a fight they won’t give up their positions
      5. Platonich
        Platonich 30 December 2015 18: 49
        0
        And Putin-who ???
  2. Woodman
    Woodman 30 December 2015 12: 30
    +8
    No one promised that it would be easy ... And we, in fact, have nowhere to retreat.
    1. vovanpain
      vovanpain 30 December 2015 12: 36
      10
      Whining nothing to do with, just the facts

      Yes, this is not nagging, the author only read the comments on VO for the last six months and wrote an article. laughing fellow laughing
  3. fzr1000
    fzr1000 30 December 2015 12: 31
    25
    If rumors of Kudrin’s return to the government are confirmed, then the wretchedness and limitedness of the Government, including and the Chief, will be denied only by the most stubborn. Whining nothing to do with, just the facts.
    1. horoh
      horoh 30 December 2015 12: 36
      +8
      The return of Kudrin is essentially a suicide for the authorities, it is unlikely that the GDP will allow this. Although the devil knows him ....
    2. Vadim237
      Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 24
      0
      Kudrin has already been dropped and no one will give up such a stunned place.
  4. pts-m
    pts-m 30 December 2015 12: 36
    -5
    the decadent mood of the author of the article does not fit with the spirit of Russian man. The beginning of the Second World War took place with the same pluses and minuses. Result: Russia is not under the boot of the occupier, but a geyropa under the boot of the FSH.
    1. lis-ik
      lis-ik 30 December 2015 12: 51
      22
      The author’s mood is not decadent, only the blind can not see that there is simply no domestic policy, and the economic bloc of the government is no longer criticizing, elementary shame.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. 34 region
      34 region 30 December 2015 12: 54
      10
      And what does the author of the decadent have? The author pointed out bottlenecks. Is identifying problems is decadence? If I don’t know about the problems, then everything is fine with me !? Oh well! Blessed is he who believes.
    4. Zeppelin ml.
      Zeppelin ml. 30 December 2015 13: 03
      +5
      Quote: PTS-m
      the decadent mood of the author of the article does not fit with the spirit of Russian people.

      If the author had your pathos, the article, of course, would have turned out to be completely different - a patriotic splint with rosy-cheeked heroes and not a word about the economy. What does the Second World War have to do with it? The present society cannot be compared with the then. The modern man in the street does not want to compromise on consumer goodies, but he is ready to applaud the success in "getting up from his knees" and strengthening the authority of the Russian Federation on the world stage. As Buffett said - low tide will show who swam without panties. Let's wait for low tide, a little left)
      And the imbalance that the author speaks about is quite obvious, alas. As the colleague rightly noted below:
      Quote: lis-ik
      only the blind cannot see
    5. cap
      cap 30 December 2015 14: 01
      +3
      Quote: PTS-m
      the decadent mood of the author of the article does not fit with the spirit of Russian man. The beginning of the Second World War took place with the same pluses and minuses. Result: Russia is not under the boot of the occupier, but a geyropa under the boot of the FSH.


      Disarmament Economy
      Ready to reason with the author
      “The vectors of Russia's foreign and domestic policy are diametrically opposed. The first leads to a revival of the status and influence of Russia in the world, the second pulls in the liberal direction.
      The military tension in the regions adjacent to our borders is growing at a very high pace and, what is most unpleasant, is drawing our country into a large-scale armed confrontation with powerful radical groups in the Near and Middle East, behind which are the United States, the Persian Gulf monarchies and Turkey. ”
      In general, a large-scale armed confrontation with powerful radical groups behind which the United States stands was and will be. The centers of power are shifting east against the will of the United States.
      It’s not Russia’s fault behind the unleashing of the large-scale “work” that was conducted by the USA and NATO
      in all regions of the world without exception, in fanning the fire of the color revolutions, and the “tsunami of refugees” that followed in Europe.
      “If we talk about the foreign policy of Russia, which was clearly articulated in the President’s Address, it is actually defined as independent and very active, focused on protecting the interests of the country and its allies in all key areas of the world, including in hot spots. The President warned our “partners” against reckless actions, saying that the answer could be not only in the economic sphere. The hint is quite obvious, given the "leakage" of information on the Status-6 system and the demonstrative use of the Russian Caliber and X-101 TFRs in Syria. ”
      There is no objection.
      Only this can probably explain the desire of everyone who was a member of the US coalition to quickly join the fight against terrorism. Just for some reason, forgetting to ask the authorities of the country (Syria in this case) about their intentions. For some reason, having forgotten about the leadership of Russia and the Russian air forces, they have successfully begun to do their part, despite the “world leader”, but having secured the decision of the government of H. Assad.
      Regarding the purely military and military-technical aspects of the use of weapons, I would not want to argue with the author. Not because I can’t. I do not have data on strategic stocks of weapons and ammunition for the current date, which in fact will put our discussion in the category of a simple talking room. I will take the author’s arguments in this aspect to them, leaving behind him conclusions that are dubious from my point of view.
      As for the “large-scale restoration at the new technological level of the industrial potential of our country with the reconstruction of entire industries from scratch,” we can recall the USSR and the conditions that had to be encountered in 41 when entering the war against Nazi Germany, in the complete absence of assistance from the then and current “partners”, at the first stage of the war and the transformation of the winners into interventionists after 70 years.
      I think that in such a complex and controversial situation on the eve of 2016, power, whatever it seems to us, is one liberal and totalitarian one. Faced with circumstances characterized as “we are them, or they are us”, we will simply have to follow the historically proven motto “THE ENEMY WILL BE BROKEN-THE VICTORY WILL BE AFTER US”
      1. Wheel
        Wheel 30 December 2015 18: 15
        +1
        Quote: cap
        As for the “large-scale restoration at the new technological level of the industrial potential of our country with the reconstruction of entire industries from scratch,” we can recall the USSR and the conditions that had to be encountered in 41 when entering the war against Nazi Germany, in the complete absence of assistance from then and current “partners”, at the first stage of the war

        Well, yes, it is easy to remember that up to June 22, 41, 2 enterprises per day were introduced in the country. Two businesses a day, Karl!
        Exactly for the prewar five-year plans were created from scratch industry, which had not existed before.
        An education system was created (including vocational education), which made it possible to quickly and almost painlessly replace men who had gone to the front in production.
        A medical care system was created that allowed the return of 72% of the wounded (55% in Germany) and 92% of patients.
        There was food security. The country dressed itself and put on shoes.
        There was something to re-profile in case of war (I wonder what can be re-profiled into the thuja heap of shopping and business centers?).
      2. Army soldier2
        Army soldier2 30 December 2015 18: 45
        0
        And I was touched by the author’s calculations for the needs of artillery. True, he forgot (or maybe didn’t know) that since 1945, artillery has improved somewhat, the power of ammunition has increased, and the caliber has increased. In addition, in the Second World War, the offensive, as a rule, was carried out on a previously prepared defense, but in Syria there is no continuous front.
        1. Wheel
          Wheel 30 December 2015 20: 10
          0
          Quote: Army 2
          And I was touched by the author’s calculations for the needs of artillery. True, he forgot (or maybe didn’t know) that since 1945, artillery has improved somewhat, the power of ammunition has increased, and the caliber has increased. In addition, in the Second World War, the offensive, as a rule, was carried out on a previously prepared defense, but in Syria there is no continuous front.
          I will tell you a terrible secret: in spite of the increased calibers, power and other buns, the calculation of the consumption of ammunition remained the same.
  5. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 December 2015 12: 41
    13
    The need for domestic reform is overripe. It is impossible to delay further. If nothing is done in the next month or two, everything will be very bad.
    1. GELEZNII_KAPUT
      GELEZNII_KAPUT 30 December 2015 14: 27
      +5
      Quote: vladimirvn
      The need for domestic reform is overripe. It is impossible to delay further. If nothing is done in the next month or two, everything will be very bad.

      Yes, the economy is on the verge of collapse, many are one step away from ruin!
  6. fzr1000
    fzr1000 30 December 2015 12: 45
    +2
    Construction is in progress throughout Russia. That's just oil refining. There are 20 factories in total. Fully on ruxpert.ru.
    Complex "ZapSibNefteKhim", the city of Tobolsk
    One of the largest enterprises in Eurasia for the deep processing of hydrocarbons has been under construction since February 17, 2015 in Tobolsk. Pyrolysis plants with a capacity of 1,5 million tons of ethylene, about 500 thousand tons of propylene and 100 thousand tons of butane-butylene fraction (BBF) per year, as well as plants for the production of polyethylene of various grades with a total capacity of 1,5 million tons, will be built at the plant per year and polypropylene production facilities with a capacity of 500 thousand tons per year. The total cost of the project is 9,5 billion dollars. [543] [544] See photo of the model of the plant and construction.
    [edit] Novy Urengoy gas chemical complex
    The largest polyethylene production plant in Russia has been under construction in the Yamalo-Nenets Autonomous Okrug with interruptions since 1993. The plant will produce per year: 400 thousand tons (with the possibility of increasing to 1,2 million tons), 400 thousand tons of a wide fraction of light hydrocarbons and 1,48 billion m³ of methane fraction. At the beginning of 2013 it continues to be built. [545] The project cost is 54 billion rubles. [546]
    [edit] Budennovsky gas chemical complex
    The gas chemical complex in the city of Budennovsk, Stavropol Territory, has been under construction since 2011 by Lukoil on the basis of the Stavrolen enterprise. The complex will process raw materials from the Northern Caspian - up to 5 billion m³ of gas per year. The project cost is 140 billion rubles., The start of production is planned for 2015—2016. [547] [548] Three gas pipelines with a total length of 583 kilometers will be built for the complex. [549] In June 2015, the Budyonnovskaya TPP with a capacity of 135 megawatts was opened in the Stavropol Territory, the last stage of the Lukoil program to build 4 power plants in different regions with a total capacity of about 1 gigawatt (the cost of the program is 50 billion rubles). At the same time, the Budennovskaya TPP is the first stage of the implementation of the program for the construction of a gas processing complex in the Northern Caspian on the basis of the Stavrolen enterprise. [550]
    [edit] Complex for the production of liquefied natural gas in the Smolensk region
    The largest LNG production facility in the European part of Russia is being built by Sadhana-Yar in the Kholm-Zhirkovsky District of the Smolensk Region. The complex’s products will ensure gas supply to remote settlements without laying expensive gas distribution networks to them. Productivity will be 21 tons per hour or more than 150 thousand tons per year, the commissioning period is 2016. The project cost about 10 billion rubles. [551] [552]
    [edit] Yamal LNG
    See Port of Sabetta.
    [edit] Complex of oil refineries and petrochemical plants "TANECO", Nizhnekamsk, Republic of Tatarstan (launch complex 1b)
    A large oil refining and petrochemical complex with a capacity of 7 million tons of oil per year (after the launch of the second stage - 14 million tons per year). The project is important for the oil industry as a whole, as it should provide an increase in the quality and, accordingly, the price of Russian exported Urals brand oil. The refinery processes oil from the fields of Tatarstan (containing impurities that reduce the quality), which reduces the share of this oil in export volumes, and, thus, the quality of oil exported increases. The project of the complex has been developed since 2005, the construction began in 2008, the launch complex 1a was commissioned in 2011 [553] Construction of the plant continues [554], the total expected volume of investments is 235 billion rubles [555], of which As of 2013, 170 billion was invested in already commissioned facilities. In March 2014, TANECO OJSC commissioned a new combined hydrocracking unit for raw materials with an annual capacity of 2,9 million tons and a cost of 40 billion rubles. [556] The cost of the main facility of complex 1b is 24 billion rubles, the total amount of investments already made in the plant at the end of 2012 amounted to 223 billion rubles.
    1. 34 region
      34 region 30 December 2015 12: 56
      15
      Well, that’s it! Gasoline will now be three rubles per liter! Or three euros?
      1. Zeppelin ml.
        Zeppelin ml. 30 December 2015 13: 14
        +1
        Quote: Region 34
        Or three euros?

        more expensive than in Europe? )))
      2. Vadim237
        Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 30
        0
        We have a tax on the state treasury with a liter of gasoline of 18 rubles - half the cost.
    2. sa-zz
      sa-zz 30 December 2015 13: 16
      -4
      Quote: fzr1000
      Construction is in progress throughout Russia. That's just oil refining. There are 20 factories in total. Fully on ruxpert.ru.

      Definitely +100500, you can still see http://www.sdelanounas.ru/, a review of production, a lot of which are already working, there will be more.
      And if, as some commentators of a nurse dismiss, you will get used to it (not for nothing they say - repeated a hundred times becomes real)
    3. unfriendly
      unfriendly 30 December 2015 13: 24
      10
      fzr1000, in response to your comment I want to ask for whom is this construction site? For our aligarchs, who sell our property to everyone (including the enemies of the Russian Federation), or just for the enemies of the Russian Federation, who sleep and see how they will use it after they make their colony of us?
      You can at least award me with minuses from head to toe, but the author is right: WE NEED Shells, ROCKETS, WARShips, SUBMARINS AND AIRCRAFT! And Another very important point: we need more military specialists: pilots, gunners, operators.
      PS. If everything is correct, then we will put all the enemies face in the mud and stand with their boots on the back of the head. If not, then Comrade Comrade will meet us at the gates of Paradise. Stalin, and will say that we were mistaken with a door and hell on another floor ...
      1. fzr1000
        fzr1000 30 December 2015 14: 28
        +1
        Go to the site. ALL INDUSTRIES of economics are listed there, I have to post a thousand construction projects here. Balm on the heart.
      2. Vadim237
        Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 40
        +1
        This construction site is for people who will work there, among other things, taxes are allocated to the budget from the sale of our assets to the budget - the enemies also sell a lot of things to us - there are also equipment for the production of weapons and ammunition and there are no more colonies and never will be - we are all in a market economy.
      3. epsilon571
        epsilon571 30 December 2015 16: 48
        +1
        A government that sees our country as a "world gas station" industrialization is unnecessary. In order to raise the industry from ruins, it is necessary to change not only priorities, but also the government itself, and this is impossible today. We all hope for the common sense of the president, but hopes are melting before our eyes, and now people are talking about Kudrin as a new messiah and savior of the economy. Sources familiar with the negotiations say that the return of the ex-minister is actively lobbied by large Russian entrepreneurs, from whom he has earned respect as a guardian of budget discipline and an adherent of market reforms. What is not a new Premier for you, the only thing left is to change the "awl for soap."
        Let’s remember for what reason Kudrin left his post in 2011, and after the conflict with Dmitry Medvedev, is it really possible for Dima to have little hands and a kick in the ass ...?
        All this resembles dancing with tambourines, and this is the time to talk about forecasts for the future:

        Predictions from the Shaman Dondukov
        (material taken from the newspaper "Morning")

        ".. According to the Slavic tradition, 2016 will not be an easy year," says Dondukov. "A leap year is a year of retribution for sins, a year of atonement. The previous three years are like spring, summer and autumn. And a leap year is winter. Who could save what for the previous three years, that is how a leap year will be spent, "the shaman recalled.
        Those who were able to make supplies "for the winter" and put something aside in a bank account will consume this money during the year. And whoever has not postponed anything, and even got into loans, will be in a disastrous situation.
        According to legend, the shaman said that Saint Kasyan, already be a saint, revealed the plans of God to the Devil. And for this, once every four years, on February 29, he is taken from paradise and hit with a hammer on his forehead. This bears a negative imprint for the whole year.
        Therefore, in a leap year, Dondukov warned, one must be careful - there is a high probability of getting into an accident, getting injured. It is best to stay at home under a blanket until 2018 and slowly multiply: the stars say that in 2015 - 2016 this is the only thing that will work out well ... "

        ... Do not be offended by the old man, hope only for the best and everything will be fine - Happy New Year 2016 wink !
        1. voyaka uh
          voyaka uh 30 December 2015 18: 52
          +1
          "PREDICTIONS FROM SHAMAN DONDUKOV" ////

          I recalled a joke smile :
          The Chukchi come to the shaman: "what will be the winter?"
          He thinks - it is better to play it safe ..: "the winter will be very cold."
          They ask the head of the HydroMetCenter in Moscow: "What winter will it be?"
          He replies: "of course cold - the Chukchi have been storing firewood since summer"
    4. Asadullah
      Asadullah 30 December 2015 13: 31
      -6
      Construction goes on all over the Russian Federation


      Respected! Why are you team funeral patriots interfere with a round dance !? Take a look, their wreaths are prepared, spades, a portrait with a black border, mournful voices are trained and speech is learned. And you are so soullessly breaking off all the buzz to people! Oh no no no. Softer, softer, slaughter lively.
    5. Saratoga833
      Saratoga833 30 December 2015 14: 34
      +3
      Construction of refineries and their modernization is, of course, good, but it does not reflect in any way on the internal FAILURE policy. Nothing will get into your pocket from the improvement and construction of these factories! This "National Heritage" will not go to us, but will go to anything, just not to our welfare, for example, to buy new yachts or foreign estates (not for us). Soon, very soon we will see a rise in prices for gasoline and diesel fuel! And we will clap our hands to this, and ears at the same time!
      1. Asadullah
        Asadullah 30 December 2015 15: 48
        0
        The construction of oil refineries and their modernization is, of course, good, but this does not in any way affect the internal FAILURE policy.


        A "failed" policy affects only those who fail there. And in steel one must be able to count. Can you count? How many yachts and foreign estates do you need, what would all this be reflected at least on the country's budget? The only question is that foreign wealth, if it is not on which Isle of Man, is taxed somewhat more than in Russia. From that, any property, foreign or domestic, requires a constant income. If this income is abroad, then the plot of the question disappears, and if the income is in Russia, then these are taxes on this income. VAT, income tax, excise taxes. Failure to pay for such is a criminal offense. Do you know about these? Then you should report it. Otherwise, failure to report a crime is also a crime. Do not know? So this is your position - I don’t know and I’m talking. Because of personal troubles in life.

        Why is the last, in my opinion the most true. Personal insults to life always give rise to bias of consciousness and hypertrophied sensitivity.
      2. Vadim237
        Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 50
        +1
        The money will come from this construction, to those who are engaged in this construction - workers, allied workers, factory owners, workers at these plants, shareholders, the treasury will receive additional taxes from production, these funds will be redirected to other industries, including defense, the chain is long - we are in a market economy.
    6. Wheel
      Wheel 30 December 2015 18: 20
      +1
      Quote: fzr1000
      Construction is in progress throughout Russia.

      Yeah, especially touched: "under construction in the Yamal-Nenets Autonomous Okrug with interruptions with 1993 g".
  7. 34 region
    34 region 30 December 2015 12: 47
    15
    Effective analysis. And it is not a matter of urapatriotism or it is all gone. The look is really real. We won’t have any army without industry. What we produce can be disabled. And then the question will be how to make up for the loss? And in a short time. Nobody will give us 20 years.
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 30 December 2015 15: 53
      -2
      Russia has "Rosrezerv" everything is there - for several years of war, including industrial equipment, materials from which you can make weapons and everything else.
      1. Wheel
        Wheel 30 December 2015 21: 20
        +2
        Quote: Vadim237
        Russia has "Rosrezerv" everything is there - for several years of war, including industrial equipment, materials from which you can make weapons and everything else.

        You have been deceived in large part.
        Everything has been optimized for a long time.
  8. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 30 December 2015 12: 51
    +1
    Sneakers will fly now, but I'll tell you my opinion. The myth about Kudrin that he tried to harm the economy is a myth. If you read his articles, and not compilations, then there in black and white - dependence on oil destroys the country's economy. It is necessary to "sterilize" the excess profits from oil in any way. And, as we see, he was right!
    1. Asadullah
      Asadullah 30 December 2015 13: 23
      +3
      And, as we see, he was right!


      He was right in many ways. But. Kudrin was not the only one who understood elementary things; the excess profit from oil was needed to restore the country's defense capability in the first place. Thanks to these excess returns, the military-industrial complex rose. Kudrin opposed the military-industrial complex, as well as for tightening social policy. From the point of view of the Oxford economy, this is also correct. High credit validity of the country and the movement of investments, though in the Russian version in the form of exclusively speculative transactions. If you exaggerate to the level of psychology of the moneylender, all of Kudrin’s wisdom came down to one thing, to build the country's economy, borrowing for small percentages, and borrowing for large ones. Revenues are placed in US assets. This is how all countries of the world behave. It is for departing from such a model of the economy that we are punished. Only in the world there are only two countries that have received indisputable benefits from such a model, these are Great Britain and China. The first itself is a share of this scheme, the second managed to break the credit yoke with the investment pyramid, and now the domestic assets of the Celestial Empire in US dollars are comparable to the value of assets in the US itself. So, with all your rightness and the rightness of Kudrin, there is one more rightness, the rightness of Russia, which didn’t want to find a job in a brothel, either by deception, by high salaries, or by the force that is happening today.
  9. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 December 2015 12: 57
    +9
    Kudrin, this is the lack of money in real sectors of the economy. This is not an increase in salaries and pensions. These are the gold and foreign exchange reserves of the Russian Federation in US securities and dollars. These are happy bankers and a poor population. This is Kudrin!
    1. Asadullah
      Asadullah 30 December 2015 15: 55
      +1
      These are happy bankers and a poor population.


      The title "banker" is already one of the names for happiness. smile As for the poor, this concept goes far beyond the competence of citizen Kudrin, any official, and the state in general. The issue of wealth of the population is a personal question of each individual individually. The issue of his education, competence, will and luck. If you provide me with an example of a state that has made its citizens rich, I undertake to play the violin for an entire week in the underpass in your honor.
  10. Rakti-kali
    Rakti-kali 30 December 2015 12: 59
    +7
    Quote: Mountain Shooter
    It is necessary to "sterilize" the excess profits from oil in any way. And, as we see, he was right!

    Yes, it was not necessary to sterilize them, but to invest in YOUR own economy - to build capital facilities, open new necessary production facilities, and use it for lending to agriculture at low interest rates or without them at all.
  11. Panabebis
    Panabebis 30 December 2015 13: 02
    +9
    This corrupt bastard sold our interests in Libya, destroying this country!
    1. Platonich
      Platonich 30 December 2015 19: 01
      +1
      Yeah, this .var is worse than everyone, and also at the helm !!!
  12. Yugra
    Yugra 30 December 2015 13: 08
    -9
    Sivkov, apparently, for two days continuously listened to the treacherous channels of liberalism "rain" and "echo", and the liberated woodpecker bumped him to write such a mess ...
    1. Zeppelin ml.
      Zeppelin ml. 30 December 2015 13: 16
      11
      Quote: Ugra
      Sivkov, apparently, for two days continuously listened to the treacherous channels of liberalism "rain" and "echo", and the liberated woodpecker bumped him to write such a mess ...

      and you, therefore, all is well? I am sincerely happy for you. Share optimism with others. Just do not quote the GDP press conference, no.
      1. Asadullah
        Asadullah 30 December 2015 15: 59
        -2
        and you, therefore, all is well?


        Is everything bad with you? So why the hell are you wiping your pants on the forum, pick in your hands and march to the clearing to uproot the stumps. Look, you'll make money on "all is well." Or is the German social a full cup?
        1. alicante11
          alicante11 30 December 2015 16: 36
          +7
          Is everything bad with you? So why the hell are you wiping your pants on the forum, pick in your hands and march to the clearing to uproot the stumps. Look, you'll make money on "all is well." Or is the German social a full cup?


          And what, apart from work in life, we should not have anything else? What for you need "everything" if you don't use this "all", because you spend 25 hours a day at work. I worked like that in due time, slept one night out of three, with all the working days. Yes, you get good money (although you won't earn so much on uprooting), but for a long time to work like this, firstly, your health will not be enough, and secondly, you are psychologically exhausted and problems arise in the family. Not life for work, but work for life!
        2. Zeppelin ml.
          Zeppelin ml. 30 December 2015 17: 20
          +1
          Quote: Asadullah
          Kyle in hand and march to the clearing stump uproot.

          You are not the case from the retirees will be retired, my dear? The manner of giving out to everyone is very reminiscent of. As my grandmother used to say, not the one who has a lot of money is happy, but the one who has enough. I’m from the second category, if you really asked.
          1. Asadullah
            Asadullah 31 December 2015 17: 15
            0
            You are not the case from the retirees will be retired, my dear?


            What of the retired, dear! Only a slightly different level of the function of higher mathematics.
  13. Back in USSR
    Back in USSR 30 December 2015 13: 17
    +4
    Well, that means we’ll soon be blown away ... alas, sad as it may be. Still, our president is weak in some ways, and does not reach the level that the country needs.
    And the wolves that are around us will not miss their moment.
    Harvesting salt / matches?
  14. chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 30 December 2015 13: 23
    +2
    Well, yes, the production of ammunition, especially high-precision ones, is very low here. More or less, only the manufacture of missiles for air defense works. And guided air-to-ground ammunition is practically not produced, just look at any last conflict. Managed munitions from Soviet stocks were used up during the Chechen wars. In the second they were used less than in the first, during the Georgian war they were hardly used. The current production is probably much smaller than with the union.
    As for me, this is all nonsense, there is no way to bomb with high-precision ones, you have to bomb with simple ones. I would try the Yak-130 as a light bomber, just its niche - the war with the "partisans".
  15. individual
    individual 30 December 2015 13: 25
    0
    Yes, there are many problems in the Russian economy.
    You need to start with something.
    We started with the fact that we are doing better - the revival of the military-industrial complex.
    Western sanctions pushed Russia to revive the agricultural sector.
    This is still better than lousy games in macroeconomics.
  16. fa2998
    fa2998 30 December 2015 13: 37
    +6
    Quote: sa-zz
    this wretched "talking head" is not capable of anything in such a post, but everything is fine with the Leader in Russia. There is no command, yes.

    Yes, in my opinion, the first task of the LEADER is to find a normal prime minister and members of the government. Because he approves them. And works with them! And this leader is satisfied with the government and the prime minister, he is not going to change anything, who is to blame! I think so from such a government and " talking head "at the head we will lose TOGETHER with the GUARANTEE, it's like a needle and thread. hi RS, of course, Yeltsin also had "favorites", but in a critical situation, on the verge of popular unrest, he changed both the prime minister and members of the government and shifted his failures to the "former". Probably now is not the time - the government is like a lightning rod for the president. yes hi
  17. Tra-ta-ta
    Tra-ta-ta 30 December 2015 13: 40
    +3
    No direction and no production will have development in our country without the support of the Fed ...
    And they will support only that which meets their plans or has demand in the foreign market.
    Hence the active military construction in the country in recent years against the backdrop of a catastrophic lack of money for social programs and other programs ...
    We are being systematically prepared for war, along the way advertising our new weapons, orders for which have risen sharply since its use in the ATS.
    Those who play this game across the ocean will not allow a shortage of means to kill .. calm down.
  18. Sars
    Sars 30 December 2015 13: 41
    11
    Quote: sa-zz
    here’s prime, true and honest,


    With friends, you need to drink vodka and go hunting, and the prime minister should be a professional in the first place.
  19. marat-73
    marat-73 30 December 2015 14: 26
    +2
    Foreign policy is a continuation of domestic policy. And our domestic policy is aimed at redistributing values ​​from the overwhelming majority of Russian citizens to some citizens of the USA, England, Europe. And although we felt a bit like citizens of a free state, such as the USSR, it is better in any case, neither in the short-term nor in the long-term only bankers-money changers from the USA, England, Europe will live on this.
    1. Zeppelin ml.
      Zeppelin ml. 30 December 2015 14: 48
      +3
      Quote: marat-73
      Foreign policy is a continuation of domestic policy.

      very doubtful. They have different vectors.
  20. alicante11
    alicante11 30 December 2015 14: 49
    +3
    Strange article and even stranger discussion. Well, let's be critical of what has been written. The article does not indicate the main thing. HOW! How many shells are produced in Russia, how many are in warehouses, how many must be written off due to obsolescence. In fact, . And this is not the first time lately. They can tell me, they say, who will give such data! Well, if there is no data, then maybe it's worth keeping quiet? Moreover, even if it is impossible to create a normal illustration even on indirect data. What are the reasons given by the author? That we haven't deployed more planes in Syria? Well, no one canceled the problem of SUPPLY. The power of the group depends on the carrying capacity of the "Syrian Express". And it is too expensive to carry supplies by air. The increase in the aviation group has been talked about for several weeks. But things are still there. Maybe this increase will not happen, the Assadis are normally coping with the existing support. They have their own aircraft on the wing again rose. Or, perhaps, they are awaiting the arrival of supplies along the circular European route. We have no information, but to say that if more planes have not been deployed, then there are no pilots and cars, this is not true.
    The intensity of aviation. I can't say anything, I'm not a specialist. But the fact that planes destroy 2 or more targets does not mean that there are not enough planes, but that they are doing their job. If they did not cope, the outfit would be increased. At first the outfit was higher, but after the most defended and fortified positions of the terrorists were crushed, it became possible to start a "free hunt". True, the Turks punished us for this. But the fact remains. It's not because of poverty.
    About artillery, of course, an interesting question. I always heard that at the beginning of the offensive, the Asadites stagnated and suffered losses. Yaroslavna’s crying on this occasion has repeatedly arisen at the VO. Now, it turns out, the Syrians at the beginning broke through tens of kilometers per day. Did the author even measure the map of Syria with a ruler? Also, the outfit in the 100-300 guns on the front km was set to overcome the defense of an enemy comparable in equipment and forces. Why throw millions of shells into dozens of terrorists? They must be knocked out by special forces, and artillery to suppress firing points, and not to level everything around, especially in a residential area where civilians remain.

    In general, let's think with our heads, and not take articles for granted, sinking in the comments to discuss the "second coming of Kudrin."
  21. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 December 2015 16: 17
    +2
    When the furry northern animal comes, there will be nothing to discuss
    1. Wheel
      Wheel 30 December 2015 21: 23
      +1
      Quote: vladimirvn
      When the furry northern animal comes, there will be nothing to discuss
      The funny thing is that the animal is homegrown, well-groomed and cherished ... recourse
  22. Lexus
    Lexus 30 December 2015 22: 47
    +1
    Quote: beer-youk
    I beg your pardon, but in order to simultaneously respond to threats to the state, both inside and out, you need to be a genius equal to Stalin. With all due respect, Putin is not Stalin, and responds to threats as they threaten the country. Although, in fairness, Stalin, to some extent, was easier. In the sense that he crushed most of the internal enemies before the appearance of a clear external threat, and that which remained was not a real danger. In this regard, Putin is much more difficult.

    Stalin at least was not easier. Stalin was a genius. And in the environment he selected people to match himself.

    And Putin chooses morons like DAM and covers Chubais.
  23. Lexus
    Lexus 30 December 2015 22: 51
    0
    Quote: Zeppelin ml.
    Quote: marat-73
    Foreign policy is a continuation of domestic policy.

    very doubtful. They have different vectors.

    But the module is the same. Such a little scarlet, like DAM.
  24. Lexus
    Lexus 30 December 2015 23: 19
    +2
    The article and the author are a huge fat plus! Without a strong economy, all attempts to superpower how to push in constipation. Take a look around - where are the plants? Where is at least one machine made in Russia? We buy the tool in China. We can’t even make molds for plastic molding ourselves (Just twenty years ago, an acquaintance walked over and built a mold and made the cover of a distributor for a foreign car, without thinking about its cost. Now they say that it costs millions and there are no specialists)
    Fifteen years ago, ptu-shnikov thought he was a slab, now they are a faceted diamond. Not found in wildlife.
    Nowadays, only the dolt does not understand how weak we are. And we are waiting for action. And they are not. And we still have a "good" working government and fattening Chubais. And everyone is still watching the barrell quotes.
    I do not call for revolution. Only the election. Putin has outlived itself.
    1. Wheel
      Wheel 31 December 2015 01: 38
      +1
      Quote: Lexus
      I do not call for revolution. Only the election. Putin has outlived itself.
      Do you think you can really choose someone?
      The system skips only its henchmen, if Che.
  25. Severok
    Severok 30 December 2015 23: 40
    +3
    The article is serious and barely reveals the serious problems of our army aviation. If you think about it and figure it out more broadly than stated in the article, it is quite clear that in the current economic domestic policy of the Government of the Russian Federation we are like a king from the aforementioned fairy tale: there is a club, but there are no pants and forces to hold a club.

    Until radical decisions are made on speculations in the commodity, currency, banking sectors, in the field of lending to real industries, in the sphere of personal extremely brutal responsibility of ALL level managers for misconduct and grossly senseless spending of public funds - we will take a penny to paycheck, we will hoping to wait for a real import substitution, we will sigh with recall the factories and enterprises that were before the theft of the 90s (which was called privatization), we will recall how the whole family could get by plane with our whole family from Murmansk to Sochi ....