Samurai lesson

78
80 years ago, in May — September 1939, the Soviet forces defeated the Japanese army on the Khalkhin Gol River in Mongolia. The defeat of the Japanese armed forces thwarted the plans of the masters of England and the United States to incite the Japanese empire in the Soviet Union, to push the Russians and the Japanese together again, realizing their strategic plans in the Far East and in the Pacific.

Fighting on Khalkhin Gol


In May, 1939, the Japanese army invaded the territory of the Mongolian People’s Republic (Mongolia) in the Khalkhin Gol river area. Mongolia was an ally of the USSR. The Japanese invasion of Mongolia was an important part of the expansionist plans of the Japanese empire to seize China, Mongolia, the possessions of Western countries in the Asia-Pacific region, the Soviet Far East and Siberia. The Japanese military-political elite claimed the complete domination of Japan in Asia. For this, it was necessary to completely subjugate China, knock out Europeans, Americans from the Far East and defeat the Russians.



In 1931, the Japanese invaded Northeast China (Manchuria). China was defeated. In 1932, the Japanese created the puppet state of Manzhou-Guo, gaining a strategic foothold in northeastern China for further expansion against the Chinese state and against the USSR and Mongolia. The raw material base for their empire. In 1937, Japan began a war with China with the goal of dismembering it and gradually absorbing it, including its empire in the sphere of influence. By 1939, the Japanese completed the seizure of central China and began to prepare an attack on the USSR.

During this period, the Japanese headquarters was preparing two major plans for a major war: 1) northern - against Russia-the USSR; 2) southern - against the United States, Britain and other Western powers that had possessions in the Asia-Pacific region. The masters of the West pushed Japan to the north to repeat the scenario of the Russo-Japanese and the First World Wars. Bleed the Japanese with Russian, and then throw on the USSR and the Germans. Therefore, the Anglo-Saxons at this time did not limit Japan in the arms race, supplied it with strategic raw materials. The masters of the West turned a blind eye to the carnage unleashed by the Japanese in China.

Despite Moscow’s warning that the Union would defend Mongolia as its own territory (in March 1936 of the year the USSR and Mongolia signed the “Protocol of Mutual Assistance”, Soviet troops deployed in Mongolia - 57 Special Corps under the command of Feklenko), the Japanese troops in May 1939, invaded the territory of Mongolia. In May, the Japanese carried out reconnaissance in the area of ​​the r. Khalkhin Gol. May 28 Japanese troops, having a numerical superiority over the Soviet-Mongolian forces, tried to conduct an operation to encircle the enemy. However, our troops successfully retreated and the next day they launched a counter-offensive and pushed the enemy back to their initial positions.



Bayan-Tsagan slaughter


In June, 1939, there were no major battles on earth, both sides were preparing for a decisive battle. Moscow strengthened the command, Fecklenko was replaced by Zhukov, the headquarters of the 57 Special Corps was headed by the brigade commander M. Bogdanov. To coordinate the actions of the Soviet troops in the Far East and the Mongolian forces, the commander of 1-th Separate Red Banner Army commander of 2 rank G. M. Stern arrived from Chita to the Khalkhin-Gol river region. The Soviet command prepared a new plan of hostilities: active defense on the bridgehead of Khalkhin Gol and with simultaneous preparation of a counterattack on the Japanese group. For a decisive strike, the troops were pulled up: they were transferred along the Trans-Siberian Railway to Ulan-Ude, then they went a forced march for hundreds of kilometers through the territory of Mongolia.

At this time, the air was a real battle. First japanese aviation got the upper hand. However, Moscow took emergency measures. A group of aces pilots headed by the deputy chief of the Red Army Air Force Y. V. Smushkevich were transferred to the conflict area. Many of them were heroes of the USSR, fought in the skies of Spain and China. Measures were taken to train flight personnel and strengthen the system of air surveillance, warning, communications and air defense. The modernized I-16 and I-153 Chaika fighters are being flown to Mongolia. As a result, the Soviet Air Force is gaining air supremacy. In the battles of June 22-28, 90 Japanese aircraft were destroyed (our losses were 38 aircraft).

Samurai lesson

The link of Soviet fighters I-16 in the sky during the fighting at Khalkhin Gol



Japanese Nakajima Ki-27 fighter at the airfield during the fighting at Khalkhin Gol


July 2, 1939 the Japanese group, having three times superiority in power (about 40 thousand soldiers, 130 tanks and 200 aircraft), went on the offensive. The Japanese command planned to encircle and defeat the enemy forces, force the Khalkhin Gol River and break through the defenses of the Red Army. The strike group of Major General Kobayashi crossed the Khalkhin-Gol River and after a fierce battle captured Mount Bayan-Tsagan on its western bank. Here, the Japanese concentrated their main forces and began to build strength at a rapid pace, creating a layered defense. The Japanese command gathered, relying on the Bayan-Tsagan mountain dominating the area and the fortified area created here, to strike the rear of the Soviet troops defending on the eastern bank of the Khalkhin-Gol River, cut off and destroy them.

At the same time there were fierce battles on the east bank of the r. Khalkhin Gol. The Japanese, with a strong superiority in forces, 2 infantry and 2 tank regiments (130 machines), pushed the 1,5 to the river. Thousands of Red Army soldiers and 3,5 thousand. Mongolian cavalry (without the support of the Russian Mongols had no chance against the Japanese, yielding in combat training and material technical equipment). The threat of the defeat of the Soviet-Mongolian troops on the eastern bank of Khalkhin Gol appeared. However, the Japanese forces under the command of Lieutenant-General Masaomi Yasuoka could not defeat our troops, they withstood.

Zhukov threw into battle a mobile reserve, right from the march - the 11-th tank brigade of the brigade MP Yakovlev (up to the 150 tanks) and the 8-th Mongol armored division. Soon they were supported by the 7-I motobronevy brigade (154 armored vehicles). It was a big risk, the mobile unit went into battle without the support of the infantry. Luck was on the side of Zhukov. During the bloody battle in the Bayan Tsagan mountain area (up to 400 tanks and armored vehicles, 800 guns and 300 airplanes participated in it on both sides), the Japanese strike group was destroyed. According to various sources, the Japanese lost 8 - 10 thousand people killed, almost all the tanks and most of the artillery.

Thus, the Bayan-Tsagan slaughter led to the fact that the Japanese no longer risked crossing the Khalkhin-Gol. Further events took place on the east bank of the river. But the Japanese were still standing on Mongolian land and preparing for new battles. That is, the struggle continued. There was a threat that this hotbed of conflict would grow into a full-scale war. It was necessary to restore the state border of the MPR and teach Japan a lesson so that the Japanese would abandon the idea of ​​northern expansion.


Japanese infantry in positions of two shot-up BA-10 Soviet armored cars in the Mongolian steppe (Khalkhin-Gol river region). In the right part of the photo - the calculation of the machine gun Type 92 caliber 7,7 mm. July 1939



Japanese tanks "Yi-Go" (Type 89) during the offensive in the Mongolian steppe. July 1939


Samurai lesson


In July - August 1939, both sides were preparing for a decisive offensive. The 57-th special corps was deployed in the 1-th army (front-line) group under the leadership of Stern. They strengthened it, transferred the 82 th rifle division, the 37 th tank brigade to the battle area. On the territory of the Trans-Baikal Military District conducted a partial mobilization, formed two rifle divisions. The Soviet command reinforced the defense on the bridgehead, redeployed new units there. The Japanese carried out several attacks on the eastern shore of Khalkhin Gol, but were repelled. The battle continued in the sky, the Soviet air force retained air supremacy.

By the beginning of a decisive battle, the Soviet 1 Army Grouping had about 57 thousand people, 542 guns and mortars, more than 850 tanks and armored vehicles, over 500 aircraft. The Japanese grouping - 6-I separate army under the leadership of General Ryuhei Ogisu, numbered about 75 thousand people, 500 guns, 182 tanks, 700 aircraft. That is, the Japanese maintained an advantage in manpower, and the Red Army had superiority in armored forces and air supremacy (qualitative and quantitative directly in the battle area).

The Japanese were preparing to resume the 24 August 1939 offensive of the year. Taking into account the sad experience of the Bayan-Tsagan battle, the Japanese command planned to deliver the main attack on the right wing of the Soviet group, without forcing the river. The Soviet command relied on mobile units in order to surround and destroy enemy troops in the area between the river and the Mongolian state border with sudden flank attacks. Soviet troops were divided into three groups - the Southern, Northern and Central. The main blow was delivered by the Southern Group under the command of Col. M. I. Potapov, the auxiliary blow by the Northern Group of Col. I. P. Alekseenko. The central group, under the command of the brigade commander D. E. Petrov, was to forge the Japanese forces in the center, thereby depriving them of the possibility of maneuver and escape from the blow.

The Soviet offensive was carefully prepared, all movements of troops, equipment, supplies were carefully concealed, positions were disguised. The enemy was told that the Red Army was busy only strengthening the defense and was preparing to continue the campaign in the autumn-winter period. Therefore, the offensive of the Soviet troops, which began on August 20 on 1939, and on the forerun of the 6 of the Japanese army, was unexpected for the enemy.


A group of Japanese soldiers captured during the fighting near the Khalkhin Gol River



Red Army soldiers attacking Khalkhin Gol with the support of the BT-7 tank


As a result, the Red Army conducted a classic operation to encircle and destroy the enemy army. During the stubborn 6-day battles, the 6-I Japanese army was crushed. In the center of the Japanese, who had a strong defense, kept well. On the flanks, Soviet mobile units, with strong aviation support, crushed enemy resistance and August 26 united, completing the entourage of the 6 Army. Then the fighting began to dismember and destroy the enemy army. Attempts by the Japanese command to unblock surrounded groups did not lead to success. By 31 August, the territory of Mongolia was completely cleared of the enemy. It was a complete victory. The Japanese army was destroyed. The Japanese suffered huge material losses. The remaining forces are demoralized.

In the first half of September, 1939, the Japanese forces made several attempts to cross the border of Mongolia, but were repelled and suffered serious losses. In the air, the battle was still going on, but it also ended in favor of the Soviet Air Force. The Japanese elite, convinced of the failure of their plans for expansion to the north, asked for peace. 15 September 1939 was signed an agreement between the USSR, Mongolia and Japan on the cessation of hostilities in the area of ​​the Khalkhin Gol River, which entered into force on September 16.



Japan turns south


The victory of the Red Army over the Japanese at Khalkhin Gol had important geopolitical consequences. The masters of the West in the 1930-ies again played the old scenario in a new way: they incited Germany, and with it almost all of Europe, to Russia. And in the Far East, the Soviet Union was supposed to attack Japan. The masters of the USA and England initiated a new world war, but they themselves remained as if on the sidelines. Their figures in the "big game" were Germany, Japan and Italy.

Thus, even before the official start of World War II, the masters of London and Washington initiated and secretly encouraged the aggression of the militarist Japanese empire against China. Japan had to get stronger at the expense of the Middle Kingdom and again turn their bayonets against Russia. Germany was the western cudgel of the masters of the West, and Japan was the east. Since ancient times, the masters of the West have learned the “divide and conquer” strategy, they realized that it is better and more profitable to fight with someone else’s hands, “cannon fodder”, solving their strategic tasks and making money on the mountain of other nations and countries along the way weapons and other products.

Therefore, Japan was given the opportunity to smash China, rob it, create on its territory a springboard for the war with the USSR. According to the plans of the owners of the USA and England, after the seizure of China and simultaneously with the attack of the Third Reich on the European part of Russia, Japan had to strike with all its might the East of Russia, capture Primorye, the Far East and Siberia. The Japanese generals supported such a scenario. The Khalkhin-Gol fights were supposed to be a preparatory stage before the full-scale war of Japan against the USSR, together with Germany.

However, Russia taught a hard lesson on the Khalkhin Gol to the Japanese. The Japanese, seeing the power of the Red Army, the results of the Stalinist industrialization, the reform of the armed forces, the strength of the Soviet mechanized troops and the Air Force, turned out to be smarter than the Germans. The Japanese bid realized that they wanted to break through the road to victory, to go to Moscow for their dead bodies. The Japanese saw the plans of the owners of the West. As a result, the Japanese military-political elite began to lean toward the southern scenario of the war. Expansion to the south, further in China, Southeast Asia and the Pacific. The war against the United States and Britain, other Western countries, to oust the Westernizers from Asia and the Pacific.


Soviet cameramen are considering the Japanese wedge 94 wedge captured at Khalkhin Gol. In the background is the captured Japanese car Chevrolet Master, model 1938 of the American production. This vehicle was used as a headquarters in the 23 Japanese Infantry Division and was captured by Soviet troops 20-31 August 1939.



Soviet tankmen inspect Japanese tank X-type 95 HaGo captured on Khalkhin Gol



Soviet commander inspects Japanese 6,5-mm machine guns "Type 11 Tais", captured during the fighting on the river Khalkhin-Gol



Commander of the 1 Army Group of Soviet Forces in the Mongolian People's Republic, Commissar Georgy Zhukov at the bodies of Japanese soldiers who died during the fighting at Khalkhin Gol. Photo source: waralbum.ru
78 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +7
    14 May 2019 04: 59
    But intelligence reported accurately:
    And went, commanded by the commander,
    By native land of the Far East
    Armored percussion battalion.

    And the song is such a battle!
  2. +2
    14 May 2019 06: 12
    The lesson was good for them, they remembered for a long time.
  3. +32
    14 May 2019 06: 33
    Not Russia, but the Soviet Union, Alexander. I constantly point out this to you. And you constantly ignore it. Further about the fate of Yakovlev and his tankmen. The commander himself died and many tanks in that battle unfortunately burned down .. Thank you for the photographs, I have not seen such.
    1. +3
      14 May 2019 06: 52
      Quote: 210ox
      Not Russia, but the Soviet Union, Alexander.

      It seems everywhere about the USSR is written.
      1. +3
        14 May 2019 07: 53
        the trouble is that Zhukov’s idea of ​​a frontal strike was too well established
        1. +6
          14 May 2019 13: 28
          Quote: novel xnumx
          the trouble is that Zhukov’s idea of ​​a frontal strike was too well established

          And were there other options with that army? Zhukov tried to organize an operation on the environment - instead of breaking through the mechanized units to the meeting point and further saturating the ring with infantry, a long and tedious sequential knocking out of the enemy rearguards from the defense nodes encountered along the way turned out. 25 kilometers to the meeting point, the northern group lasted 5 days.
          1. +2
            14 May 2019 13: 41
            42 year Sychechka ... again not that army ??
            1. +2
              14 May 2019 15: 39
              Quote: novel xnumx
              42 year Sychechka ... again not that army ??

              3-4 rounds per day for a rifle on the offensive. Tanks go on the attack - the infantry lies. The tanks are burning, and the next day the infantry goes on the attack without them - no one canceled the combat mission. Great army - what really is there.
              It took almost 2 years of war to learn how to fight the Red Army.
              1. 0
                14 May 2019 17: 24
                42 years old, for a second, Stalingrad. is there another army fought?
                1. +3
                  14 May 2019 17: 53
                  Quote: novel xnumx
                  42 years old, for a second, Stalingrad. is there another army fought?

                  There another army was defending. In Sychevka there were no Romanians in the directions of the main attacks. There were no trained German battalions - Paulus near Stalingrad managed to attract even an echelon of success development to storm the city. There was no imitation by the Germans of mobile reserves from the Romanian TD and the only German TD.
        2. +2
          14 May 2019 15: 08
          Quote: novel xnumx
          the trouble is that Zhukov’s idea of ​​a frontal strike was too well established
          It has long been written the same thing that this victory played a cruel joke when, on the basis of this experience, the tanks went into battle without the support of infantry and artillery. It turned out with the Japanese, but not with the Germans.
          1. +3
            14 May 2019 16: 49
            Quote: qqqq
            It has long been written the same thing that this victory played a cruel joke when, on the basis of this experience, the tanks went into battle without the support of infantry and artillery.

            Actually, after HG there was a SPF. The experience of which was introduced in all parts - even in the Caucasus there were exercises on breaking the line of defenses in a wooded and swampy area.
            So, one of the main conclusions based on the results of the Special Forces is the defenselessness of tanks without infantry. During the first assault on the LM, a heavy tank brigade, acting in one person (the infantry traditionally lay down), came down to zero in less than a week.
      2. +5
        14 May 2019 08: 13
        However, Russia taught a hard lesson to the Japanese at Khalkhin Gol. The Japanese, seeing the power of the Red Army, the results of Stalin's industrialization, reform of the armed forces, the strength of the Soviet mechanized troops and the Air Force, were smarter than the Germans.
      3. +5
        14 May 2019 08: 34
        "However, Russia taught the Japanese a hard lesson on Khalkhin Gol." hi
      4. +6
        14 May 2019 16: 19
        At the beginning of the article: "During this period, the Japanese rate was preparing two main plans for a big war: 1) the northern one - against Russia-USSR", and in the last four paragraphs - so there in each one about Russia. The author is really constantly corrected and everything is useless, especially since even such a country - Russia-USSR - has never existed.
        1. +1
          14 May 2019 16: 22
          Quote: fuxila
          northern - against Russia-USSR "

          I agree, just did not read very carefully.
    2. +7
      14 May 2019 08: 00
      I fully support. remark. one BT-7 tank was found in the salt marsh during the exercises of the Soviet and Mongolian troops. it was restored and put on a pedestal on the territory of the 90th tank regiment in the city of Choibalsan. I happened to attend the opening of the monument. at the base of the pedestal was a sleeve with the ashes of tankers. 1986-1987. and in 1988 the regiment was taken out of Mongolia. I don’t know what happened to the monument.
      1. 0
        1 July 2019 18: 33
        With a high degree of probability, this BT-7 is now in the museum of Verkhnyaya Pyshma. And what's interesting on the go)))
        1. 0
          16 July 2019 15: 10
          I can’t say anything about it. in Mongolia there are a lot of monuments (tanks) of those times. we even played war games on the SU-100 (there were no goos and the gun had only horizontal guidance), but for children it was more than enough)))
    3. +1
      14 May 2019 21: 18
      Yes. all the same, it was the Soviet Union who fought and not Russia Although I admit that the main heir to the Union is Russia now
    4. xax
      0
      9 June 2019 12: 00
      Quote: 210ox
      Not Russia, but the Soviet Union

      Russia was, is and will be, regardless of the form of government.
  4. +8
    14 May 2019 07: 09
    . Luck was on the side of Zhukov.
    - well! Not a word about the planning of the operation by Zhukov and the headquarters of the operation — they simply went off to battle and here it is — luck!)))) This is all because ... Yes, because we are a generation of winners and Russians! Well, luck, damn it, a big jackpot))) Without luck, the Second World War would have lost. The commander must be lucky, there it is ...
    1. +2
      14 May 2019 13: 20
      The first time, luck, the second time, luck, it’s time, my friend, to learn how to fight. It’s good that Zhukov is so lucky. And then the corpses would flood the enemy.
  5. -1
    14 May 2019 07: 42
    There is another opinion about this conflict.
    1-the conflict was caused by the actions of the USSR and Mongolia, which unilaterally began to demarcate the border, occupying the disputed hills and border areas, 2-Soviet troops, especially the Air Force, were defeated by the Japanese for most of this armed conflict, the Air Force was never able to gain air superiority. 3- the war was won by the "cautious" Stern, who managed to organize the supply of the entire Soviet group in difficult desert conditions, the 4-Japanese group was planned to be "hammered" with artillery and aviation and squeezed over the river or destroyed by destroying the crossings, and everything was ready for this, Zhukov violated all the orders with his dashing tank attack and he was very lucky that the case ended in our favor. The 5-dashing "cavalry" attack by tanks played a cruel joke with the Soviet command convincing him that it was possible to win the battle with tanks alone, without the support of the rest of the troops, regardless of losses, which led to the creation of huge clumsy "mechanized corps" and senseless attempts With these corps alone, to reverse the initial stage of the Second World War, finally ditching all the tank power of the USSR.
    1. +6
      14 May 2019 08: 00
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      There is another opinion about this conflict.

      And where only do you manage to dig such bredyatinu? :)))))
      1. +7
        14 May 2019 11: 49
        As where? Sokolov is a type of historian and "fighter" against "Soviet myths". Sokolov is the one who stands with his eyes in a heap and his tongue thrown out during the interview. The very one whom General of the Army Gareev in 2005 gagged on the air with a couple of phrases. During the discussion of the losses of the USSR in the Second World War.
        1. +7
          14 May 2019 13: 33
          Quote: Oleg Kolsky 051
          As where? U Sokolov

          Seriously ?! :)))) Oleg, I didn't know. With the work of this "figure" I am a little familiar, one of the most odious liars in the history of WWII and WWII. Lies a lot, stupidly, verifiable, but, alas, can make an impression on an unprepared audience.
          Naturally, I did not even try to master Sokolov's "works" completely - I understand that "you need to know the enemy by sight," but this is such a cesspool ... My sincere respect to you for wasting your time on this! hi
          1. +5
            14 May 2019 16: 39
            Good evening. Sokolov B.V. not only writes nonsense, but also carries this nonsense to the masses. This delusional specializes in spitting on the entire Russian history - I saw an interview of this evil spirits on Spanish television, where he broadcasted that Ivan the Terrible cut out more people in the Novgorod campaign than were destroyed during the entire period of the Inquisition. How! The Spaniard was already glowing with joy. And the most funny - the commentary is more likely written on the book "Unknown Zhukov", and the article that we are commenting on is a slightly revised "Great commander Marshal Zhukov" I have a Roman newspaper of Soviet times. The article is straight, straight ...
            1. +3
              14 May 2019 16: 42
              Quote: Oleg Kolsky 051
              where he was saying non-depressingly that Ivan the Terrible in the Novgorod campaign had cut out more people than had been destroyed during the entire period of the Inquisition. In, how!

              wassat
              "I recognize my brother Fedya!" (c) Yeah, Sokolov in his repertoire :))))
    2. +9
      14 May 2019 08: 26
      1. If there was a demarcation, then it was a demarcation of the Sino-Mongolian border and Japan is no side here.
      2. Yes, at the beginning of the hostilities of the Red Army Air Force they were defeated, but then they came out on an equal footing, and managed to achieve superiority in important sectors.
      3. Yes, expeditionary logistics is key to success.
      4. No, under the Bain-Tsagan, the Japanese took a foothold and if they had consolidated themselves, then the outcome of the conflict could be different. So Zhukov had no other options - only the destruction of the bridgehead could give (and gave) chances for the success of the entire operation. There was no time to regroup and tank counterattack was the only way to overcome the crisis.
      5. Here maybe you are right. There was a cycle about the pre-war development of tank troops. The actions of tank units in Mongolia were undoubtedly analyzed and, possibly, were taken into account in the early concept of mechanized corps. But this is hardly the main reason for their defeat in the 41st. Then a lot of different factors were superimposed.
      1. -5
        14 May 2019 10: 46
        This ill-fated conflict at Khalkhin Gol became the "evil genius" of the USSR. Having "defeated" the Japanese troops and hiding the losses of their forces, as well as shortcomings in practically all the structures of the troops that took part in the conflict, on the wave of dizziness from "success", the USSR leadership did not make a deep analysis of the actions of its armed forces in this conflict. Moreover, Zhukov's entourage as a "winner" by "offensive actions" destroyed the far from stupid and good organizer Stern and other "defenders and staff officers" and led to the final approval of the concept of waging war - "only offensive actions." The leadership of the Red Army did not bother to analyze why the Air Force was actually defeated by Japanese aviation, and a smaller one. Likewise, no one bothered to draw conclusions about the virtually complete absence of interaction between the combat arms in this conflict, about the disgusting organization of intelligence, communications, etc. In the wake of the euphoria of this "victory", a decision was made to unleash the Soviet-Finnish war, which cost simply monstrous blood on the Soviet side and took a certain amount of time, which could be used to correct mistakes and imbalances both in the organization of its armed forces and in armament - if only an honest and truthful analysis of this Khalkhin-Golsk "victory" had been made. But that did not happen. As a result, the USSR received the Finnish shame, and the hasty rearmament and reorganization and 1941 ... IMHO, of course.
        1. +5
          14 May 2019 15: 31
          Khalkhin-Gol had no influence on the reformation of the BTV structure, the TCs were disbanded following the results of the Polish campaign, switched to separate motorized divisions, they came to MK copying someone else's, German, experience.
        2. +2
          14 May 2019 15: 34
          Quote: Monster_Fat
          This ill-fated conflict at Khalkhin Gol became the "evil genius" of the USSR. Having "defeated" the Japanese troops and hiding the losses of their forces, as well as shortcomings in practically all the structures of the troops that took part in the conflict, on the wave of dizziness from "success", the USSR leadership did not make a deep analysis of the actions of its armed forces in this conflict.

          Oh ho ho ... it’s not just Khalkhin Gol. The point is the systematic practice of fraud, which flourished in the Red Army, and the unwillingness of the leadership of the Red Army to substitute for bossy anger, starting reforms and revealing the true picture of what is happening in the army. What, according to the results of the Great Maneuvers, was it not clear that the training of fighters, units and formations was insufficient even to play the window dress normally according to the scenario brought to all sides? Or maybe Hassan did not show - what is really worth the mighty OKDVA? Or the Polish campaign, when, in the absence of opposition, the mechanized corps managed to stand on the march, having scored all army rear units with equipment? Nobody needed an analysis - they won, and glory to god omnipotent teaching.
          No one analyzes victory. So the Red Army needed the Finnish campaign, so that the leadership actually saw what a gaping chasm is balanced by the country's defense in the context of the great war in Europe.
    3. +5
      14 May 2019 14: 48
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      1-conflict is caused by the actions of the USSR and Mongolia which unilaterally began to demarcate the border, occupying the disputed hills and border areas

      It was on Hassan, not Khalkhin Gol. In the HG, it was the Japanese who began by force to move the actually existing border - to protect the Halun-Arshan-Ganzhur road under construction. And along the way, ongoing negotiations on demarcation froze.
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      The 2nd troops of the USSR, especially the Air Force, were defeated by the Japanese for most of this armed conflict, the Air Force could not gain air superiority until the end of the war

      The Red Army Air Force merged exactly before the arrival of a group of aces with the experience of Spain. After this role began to change - our Air Force was finally able to concentrate and massage forces. On the same Bain-Tsagan, the Air Force actually replaced the lagging artillery: instead of artillery preparation, they raided 73 SB bombers, instead of direct support artillery, I-15bis assault strikes against enemy infantry and artillery positions.
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      It was planned to "hammer" the 4-Japanese grouping with artillery and aviation and push it over the river or destroy it by destroying the crossings, and everything was ready for that, Zhukov violated all orders with his dashing tank attack and he was very lucky that the case ended in our favor ...

      But the Japanese for some reason did not want to fight according to our plans. Zhukov's dashing attack is Bain-Tsagan. Then, even before the concentration of our forces, the Japanese decided to do with us what we planned to do with them - to surround (cut off from the crossings) and defeat. And the Red Army command had a choice - either hastily withdraw troops from the bridgehead, abandoning equipment and weapons, or somehow fend off the Japanese offensive. Zhukov chose the second and attacked tank brigades with the support of aviation. Alas, there was no motorized artillery and motorized infantry in the infantry battalion - and bare tanks suffered heavy losses in the Japanese anti-tank missile. But the task was completed.
    4. 0
      15 May 2019 09: 02
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      the war was won by the "cautious" Stern, who managed to organize the supply of the entire Soviet group in the difficult conditions of the desert


      In planning the supply of the General Staff, a gross logistical error was made. All troops sent to Mongolia were to be unloaded at the Olovyannaya station, which could not miss so many troops and cargo. Unlike the tsarist administration, for the same reasons, Stalin, who had completely lost the Russo-Japanese war, forced the representatives of the Ministry of Railways to leave for the place, who were able to correct the logistic mistakes made there. The group was headed by Kovalev, the future minister of railway transport during the Second World War. Kovalev was also instructed to control the work of the railways during the liberation of the Far East from Japan and to help restore railway transport. .in China after the removal of the Kuomintang from power. So the military could not solve the transport problems on their own, which casts a shadow on your other judgments.
      Quote: Monster_Fat
      caused by the actions of the USSR and Mongolia which unilaterally began to demarcate the border,

      For 30 years, Japan captured Korea and Manchuria with fire and sword, creating unheard-of atrocities. You can blame Stalin that he did not dare to enter the war in alliance with China, but not that he refused to indulge the aggressor in Mongolia.
  6. +2
    14 May 2019 07: 44
    [quote] The Japanese bid realized that they want to pave the way to victory, go to Moscow along their corpses. The Japanese saw through the plans of the owners of the West. As a result, the Japanese military-political elite began to lean toward the southern scenario of the war. [/ quote
    It was just that the ground forces received a chomp, so the Emperor's favorites were the Moremans and "crawled" across the Pacific Ocean.
  7. +9
    14 May 2019 07: 45
    I saw in the very first paragraph a phrase about "the masters of the West who want to destroy the USSR," and immediately realized who the author was. I didn't read further. How much can this nonsense be woven into any event?
  8. +3
    14 May 2019 08: 40
    If the masters of the West so want to destroy Russia, then why did England and the USA not attack the USSR together with Germany and Japan? Why did they fight against them?
    1. +13
      14 May 2019 10: 35
      So I, too, no matter how much I strain my poor brain, I just can not understand: who are these notorious "masters of the West" (or abbreviated "xs") and in which country or countries they live. First xs set Japan against the USSR. So the xs are not from these countries. Then xs set Germany against France. Therefore, xs have nothing to do with these countries. Then xs pitting Germany against England. So England also has nothing to do with xs. The fact that neither Germany nor the USSR are related to xs is clear from previous events. Remains like the United States. But no, xs is setting Japan against the United States, so the United States is also not a habitat for xs. Where did they come from these mysterious xs? Where do they live? It can be assumed that in a country that did not participate in the world war and was not under occupation. Is this really Switzerland? Or Liechtenstein? Or some South American country like Uruguay or Paraguay? Riddle.
      1. +7
        14 May 2019 10: 57
        These are reptilians from the planet Nibiru! On RenTV they have been watching them for a long time ...
      2. +1
        15 May 2019 15: 20
        Take it higher - Vatican)))
    2. -4
      14 May 2019 11: 11
      I explain: both the Japanese and the Naglosak people in this region had one goal - to capture the APR and the Far East of the USSR. Therefore, they are rivals to each other and not allies. It’s the arrogant people who decided to give the Japanese an opportunity to fight in China and provoke them to attack the USSR. Well, then it was expected that Japan and the USSR would bleed each other and then the Yankees would come and restore their order.
      Exactly the same story was in the west (i.e. in Europe) - only there was Hitler instead of Japan, read the rest above. But when they saw that the USSR was winning, they rather rushed to grab their piece from Hitler.
      Well, why did the Japanese attack the United States - they were just smarter than Hitler, they realized that they were trying to use them.
      Exactly the same story is happening now - the Naglosaks are trying to bleed Russia with the wrong hands - they incite their satellites (for example, the Baltic states, Poles, etc.), and if they aren’t created they (hohlopiteks and other igilas) .. Ideally dream of a war between Russia and Europe (for them it would be a double benefit. Why? - it's simple, but think for yourself ...)
      Those. the principle is simple - to knock two strong rivals with their heads together and when they break each other's ribs, arms, calmly approach, finish off both and become the owner of the property of one and the other. This is what the Naglosak people call "Divide and Conquer".
      And one more thing - they are arrogant traders by nature, so they sold weapons to both sides of the conflict. And on this fabulously enriched. For example, the USSR paid for all supplies of food and weapons with gold, and at a very good price. So that...
    3. 0
      14 May 2019 15: 35
      Because the abstract "West" has never been one, in that pack everyone kept their own interest. The British needed a counterbalance to French influence in Europe, the Americans needed a new big war that would sweep away the continental powers, even the French had their own interest, more precisely the so-called financially active capital, it was profitable to invest in German industry. The USSR was a whipping boy, not a major enemy.
      1. +1
        14 May 2019 17: 24
        Quote: strannik1985
        Because the abstract "West" has never been one, in that pack everyone kept their own interest. The British needed a counterbalance to French influence in Europe, the Americans needed a new big war that would sweep away the continental powers, even the French had their own interest, more precisely the so-called financially active capital, it was profitable to invest in German industry. The USSR was a whipping boy, not a major enemy.

        Hrenase whipping boy! laughing I'm not talking about the war, remember how our missiles in Cuba made them moderate their appetites and move theirs away from us, how our ships entered the port of Tripoli during their "run over" to Gaddafi - they did not dare to mess with the "whipping boy" and got out. And with the forces of the Groups of Forces, the Union could simply roll out the whole of Europe, if they provided an excuse for this - there was a case when, by mistake of OsNaza, ours "lost" several brigades of the American Airborne Forces, transferred from America to Germany, so the GSVG immediately really prepared for war , even started the evacuation of families, there was one "crooked" word or a delay in answering the request, and - "hello" to Europe would be, because our "sharpened" were for a preemptive strike. Wouldn't wish anyone such a "whipping boy"!
        1. +2
          14 May 2019 18: 13
          You "slightly" mixed up the periods, in the 30s the USSR's opinion on Czechoslovakia was simply not noticed, you gave it to the Reich and that's it. In the mid-30s, the General Staff considered Poland a strong adversary for the Red Army (the estimated period of a b / d up to 6 months). The USSR of the 30s and 60s, two big differences.
          1. 0
            14 May 2019 18: 22
            Quote: strannik1985
            You "slightly" mixed up the periods, in the 30s the USSR's opinion on Czechoslovakia was simply not noticed, you gave it to the Reich and that's it. In the mid-30s, the General Staff considered Poland a strong adversary for the Red Army (the estimated period of a b / d up to 6 months). The USSR of the 30s and 60s, two big differences.

            Yeah, I didn’t mean the 30s. Although it was then, in fact, that a completely modern army began to be created in the Union.
            1. 0
              14 May 2019 18: 38
              In 1939, when the "troichi" were deployed in a single deployment division.
              1. 0
                15 May 2019 19: 50
                Quote: strannik1985
                In 1939, when the "troichi" were deployed in a single deployment division.

                Rather, in 1940, when the leadership was unpleasantly surprised by the results of the war with Finland, after which it was thrown out first red officer, an audit of the NPO was carried out, and training in the field began in practice, and not in class in theory. And the results were summarized for the unit as a whole, and not for the best group.
        2. 0
          14 July 2019 04: 16
          "Wouldn't wish such a" whipping boy "on anyone!"
          And when it was that, the feather grass has long been overgrown ...
  9. +10
    14 May 2019 08: 51
    Quite a superficial description. In the Bain-Tsagan battle, on the western bank, where the main part of the battle took place, the Japanese had no tanks at all. There were anti-tank guns, several armored vehicles, but there were no tanks - the crossing was not suitable for them. The crossing of the Japanese to the western coast was unopened, at dawn and in the morning they were accidentally stumbled upon by Mongolian and then Soviet units. Zhukov first sent part of his forces, the 2nd tank battalion conducted 2 attacks, the first involved 8 BT5 tanks (2 destroyed, 6 knocked out), in the second 15 BT5 and 5 HT26 (7 BT5 and 5 HT26 destroyed, 2 BT5 knocked out), the advance of the Japanese to the crossing the Red Army was stopped. After that, Zhukov decided to surround the Japanese troops that had crossed, sending all his forces for this. The exact location of the Japanese was not known; the troops entered the battle at a time, separately, as they approached. As a result, about five attacks took place, more than 50% of tanks were lost (11 TB out of 133, 77 tanks were lost), 37 armored vehicles out of 59. Air strikes against ground forces were spontaneous, but the Japanese twice "scattered" the 15th cavalry regiment of the Mongolian army from the air. As a result, it was not possible to surround the Japanese, but the next day they began the crossing back, the actions of the Soviet aviation and artillery did not succeed in destroying the crossing, although the Japanese suffered losses. The Japanese themselves blew up the crossing when they crossed. There was a battle on the eastern coast, but the Japanese attacked there and they had tanks there, out of 73 they lost 41 (irrevocably 13).
    The Bain-Tsagan battle ultimately proved to be a victory for the Red Army, it is. Wore the character of such a somewhat chaotic oncoming battle. The Red Army suffered more significant losses in tanks, losses in manpower seem to be equivalent. At least not at all 8-10 thousand among the Japanese. Victory, with sweat and blood, not painted with an epic brush.
    1. +3
      14 May 2019 09: 10
      At least not the Japanese 8-10 thousand.
      ,, Can this data for the entire period of the fighting?

      ,,Soviet and Mongolian troops in Khalkhin Gol from May to September 1939 lost a man killed by 6831,
      missing - 1143,
      wounded - 15 251
      and sick - 2225 people.
      89 Soviet and 1 Mongolian servicemen got into Japanese captivity.
      Thus, the total Soviet and Mongolian casualties of the dead amounted to, in the light of approximately 1, thousands of deaths from injuries, about 9 thousands. In total, about 5 thousands of Mongol and about 120 thousands of Soviet soldiers took part in the battles.
      They were opposed by 76 of thousands of Japanese and Manchus.
      The ground forces of Japan and Manzhou-Guo have lost 8629 people killed,
      9087 wounded and 2350 sick.
      Japanese aviation personnel losses reached, according to some sources, 141 killed and 89 injured, according to others - 116 killed, 65 missing and 19 injured. Since only a Japanese pilot 2 returned from captivity, the total number of people killed in the Japanese Air Force is likely to be 179 people.
      1. 0
        14 May 2019 15: 52
        Quote: bubalik
        ,, Can this data for the entire period of the fighting?

        The author of the article indicated these losses for the Bain - Tsagan battle.
  10. +2
    14 May 2019 09: 44
    My grandfather told me: "In the battles on Lake Khasan, the Japanese received their primary military education. At Khalkhin Gol they did not want to continue their studies and receive a higher military education." lol
    A joke of course, but as you know in every joke, only a fraction of the joke.
    1. +8
      14 May 2019 10: 45
      My grandfather told me: "In the battles on Lake Khasan, the Japanese received their primary military education. At Khalkhin Gol they did not want to continue their studies and receive a higher military education."
      Your grandfather is not Prince Fushima laughing ? (Chief of Naval Staff, Prince Fushima, August 10, 1940 “We received elementary education in Hassan, secondary in Khalkhin Gol, as Asian people can wait to get higher, let Hitler get it”)
      1. +3
        14 May 2019 13: 58
        Well then, grandfather quoted Prince Fushima laughing
  11. +1
    14 May 2019 10: 14
    The author, more attentively, has a lot of syntax errors.
  12. +5
    14 May 2019 11: 23
    Quote: radiootdel4
    And on this fabulously enriched. So, for example, the USSR paid for all supplies of food and weapons with gold,

    What an ignorance. At VO, how many times they wrote about it, wrote, but ... it is visible to the blind.
  13. +3
    14 May 2019 11: 53
    Even with such an interesting topic, the author was able to create an agitprop, richly flavored with mantras about the masters of the West .. The only thing that can be noted positively is photographs.
    In this regard, I would like to add photographic materials "from the other side", Khalkhin-Gol through the eyes of Japanese press photographers.

    June 1939 Japanese soldiers are fighting.
    1. +2
      14 May 2019 12: 00

      July 1939. Hulun Buir, Inner Mongolia. Japanese soldiers on the background of captured Soviet tanks.
      1. +3
        14 May 2019 12: 09

        The valiant Japanese warrior captured a gopher. July 1939
        1. +2
          14 May 2019 12: 14

          The conflict did not particularly affect the life of local nomads. They just migrated on.
          1. +3
            14 May 2019 12: 17

            July 1939. A Japanese doctor assists a Soviet prisoner of war.
            1. +7
              14 May 2019 12: 25

              And today in the Mongolian steppes you can find traces of those battles. But almost a hundred years have passed.
              1. +5
                14 May 2019 12: 28

                Rusty tank. A welcome object for Chinese tourists.
        2. +1
          14 May 2019 12: 20
          Judging by the epaulettes - the second lieutenant.
          1. 0
            14 May 2019 12: 23
            Buttonholes?
            1. +1
              14 May 2019 13: 13
              In my opinion, these are still epaulets.
        3. 0
          23 May 2019 10: 19
          Jap with a strangled gopher in the photo is clearly not a Buddhist.
    2. +3
      14 May 2019 13: 24
      In this regard, I would like to add photographic materials "from the other side", Khalkhin-Gol through the eyes of Japanese press photographers.
      ,, this and stop-same series?




      1. 0
        23 May 2019 10: 25
        Soldiers in caps and windings with boots are most likely ordinary soldiers of the border guards.
  14. +8
    14 May 2019 13: 18
    And now let's return to the ground from the mountain heights of Soviet agitprop and see how the Soviet military leadership evaluated the results of Khalkhin Gol in the "not for the press" regime:
    Tov. Stalin
    I am sending the report just received to Comrade Zhukov and Kalugin. As expected, there were no divisions in the encirclement, the enemy either managed to withdraw the main forces, or rather, there were no large forces in this area for a long time, and a specially trained garrison was sitting, which is now completely destroyed.
    © Voroshilov

    However, such a result was expected: the northern group of the Red Army, instead of a dash and quick connection with the southern group, was stuck for three days in front of the "Finger" height, which was defended by the Japanese rearguard. Moreover, it was not the infantry that got bogged down in the battles, but the mechanical units, including the reserve - 9 MBBR. During this time, the Japanese managed to withdraw the main forces from the emerging boiler.
  15. +3
    14 May 2019 13: 26
    Zhukov is to blame for the attack on Pearl Harbor. Samurai decided to try their luck elsewhere.
  16. +1
    14 May 2019 15: 22
    One of the main advantages of this operation is a well-supplied supply to a remote continent. Also revealed some of the weaknesses of technology. As an example, a fuel tank located above the driver’s head and armored vehicle. And other...
  17. 0
    15 May 2019 15: 16
    Judging by the text of the article, Japan was a very peace-loving and Russophile power, and the Japanese were nice, but not-so-distant guys whom the evil Anglo-Saxons fooled and set against Russians.
    The author himself is not funny ??
    The Japanese elite, without any West, has been carrying out aggressive plans against China, against Mongolia, and against Russia / the USSR since the beginning of the 20th century.
    1. +1
      15 May 2019 19: 43
      Quote: Sergey Oreshin
      Judging by the text of the article, Japan was a very peace-loving and Russophile power, and the Japanese were nice, but not-so-distant guys whom the evil Anglo-Saxons fooled and set against Russians.

      Hehe hehe ... if only the Japanese. They regularly write that the Germans were also the sweetest guys whom the very same Anglo-Squires insidiously set on the USSR. For Englishwoman crap...
  18. 0
    23 May 2019 10: 16
    And what happened to the Japanese prisoners and our prisoners after Hassan and Khalkhin Gol?
  19. 0
    4 June 2019 00: 23
    Quote: Uncle Lee
    But intelligence reported accurately:
    And went, commanded by the commander,
    By native land of the Far East
    Armored percussion battalion.

    And the song is such a battle!

    And Kirkorov sings the nostalgic Japanese imperial song "Oh, Mom, Shikotan!"
  20. 0
    14 July 2019 16: 12
    Quote: Ehanatone
    "Wouldn't wish such a" whipping boy "on anyone!"
    And when it was that, the feather grass has long been overgrown ...

    If something happened once, the probability that it will happen again is much higher than zero, however.