Kazakhstan will be "Cossack eli"?

434
Kazakhstan will be "Cossack eli"?So, on February 6, during a visit to the Atyrau City Intellectual School, President Nursultan Nazarbayev proposed to abandon the name “Kazakhstan” in favor of “Kazak Eli” (“Kazakh people”). “In the name of our country there is an ending“ camp ”, like other Central Asian states, the president said,“ At the same time, foreigners show interest in Mongolia, which has a population of only two million people, while there is no ending in its name ” mill". It may be necessary to consider, over time, the issue of transition to the name of our country "Cossack eli", but first of all it is necessary to discuss this with the people.

Offer N.A. Nazarbayeva caused a storm of emotions in the Russian-speaking segment of the Internet, triggering the appearance of a whole wave of responses and expert comments.

During the time that has passed since the collapse of the USSR, an entire tradition has developed in Kazakhstan of changing the names of various geographical objects (toponymy). The reasons for this lie in the peculiarities of its historical development.

Most of the names, especially in the Russian-inhabited northern and northeastern regions of Kazakhstan, have traditionally been Slavic. Most of the cities inherited by Kazakhstan from the USSR were also founded by Russians and received Russian names.

Thus, Uralsk was founded by the Russians in 1584, Guriev, which became independent after Atyrau, in 1640, Semipalatinsk, in 1718, Pavlodar, in 1720, Petropavlovsk, in New York, was founded the Cossack outpost of Akmola in 1752. In the northern regions of the republic, the Slavic population has been living for 1830-300 for years, and, in fact, is indigenous there. Not surprisingly, local toponymy was also predominantly Slavic.

In 1991, Kazakhstan headed for the construction of a national state. Soviet period of his stories became regarded as colonial. Slavic toponymy, reminiscent of being in the composition of another, more powerful state, was in these conditions very inappropriate. Therefore, the change of Russian names to Kazakh began in the first years after independence. In December 1993, the Supreme Council adopted the law On the Administrative-Territorial Division of the Republic of Kazakhstan, which provided for “streamlining work on naming and renaming administrative-territorial units and clarifying the transcription of their names” creation under the government of the Onomastic Commission. The right to change the names of regions, districts and cities in accordance with the law belonged to the President of Kazakhstan, who was to make these decisions based on the conclusions of the Onomastic Commission and the opinion of residents of certain territories.

Kazakhstan is embraced by a real wave of renames. In 1991-2005 three areas were renamed, 12 cities, 53 areas of areas, 7 areas of the city, 43 railway stations and junctions, as well as 957 of small settlements. The names of some cities have changed several times. So, the regional center Tselinograd was first named Akmola, and later, after moving the capital city 1997 here in December, to Astana. In addition, the transcription of the names of 3 areas, 12 cities, 14 areas, 76 railway stations and 22 small settlements has been changed.

According to the head of the onomastics and terminology department of the Committee on Languages ​​of the Ministry of Information, Culture and Sports of the Republic of Kazakhstan Yerlan Kuzekbay, by 2005, the renaming of geographical objects was completed to 55-60%, with major flaws related to the northern and north-eastern regions. According to him, “for 14 years, much work has been done in this direction in the southern regions of Kazakhstan, but only by 30% has it been done in the northern regions and in the East Kazakhstan region”. Renamed streets, organizations and institutions. According to the same E. Kuzekbai, in the period of independence, the order of 890 institutions of health care, education, culture, sports and physical-geographical objects was renamed. In May, 2000, one of the leaders of the Onomastic Commission of the Chimkent Region, K. Duseymbi, at a briefing, said that he had renamed 200 streets for his life, but 800 streets still remained in Russian.

In Alma-Ata to 1980, the Kazakhs made up the entire 1 / 10 population, and more than 80% of the street and city names were Russian. But by 2008, the picture had changed to the exact opposite - 80% of all titles became Kazakh.

One of the last major renaming took place in 2007 on June 16 at a meeting held in Semipalatinsk, President N. Nazarbayev proposed to rename the city Semey, citing negative associations with the move with the 1949-1989 operating here. Semipalatinsk nuclear test site, which scare away foreign investors and potential tourists. According to him, the new name should also enhance the role of the Kazakh language and statehood. The proposal was favorably received by the onomastic commission, as well as by the majority of the population of the city, among whose residents the share of Kazakhs increased to 60% over the years of independence. The city council voted unanimously to rename, and 21 of June 2007 issued a presidential decree, according to which Semipalatinsk received a new name Semey.

Constant reproaches of the Kazakh intelligentsia against the authorities, who do not want to change the remaining Russian toponyms to Kazakh, suggest that the renaming policy will continue. According to the deputy of the parliament, the chairman of the party of the national association “Kazak eli” E. Abylkasymova, the modern youth “do not need a constant reminder of the sufferings of the Kazakh people in the past, that we have been under the heel of another, more powerful people for almost three centuries”. Therefore, it is necessary to rename the “inherited from the past” cities of Petropavlovsk, Pavlodar, Ust-Kamenogorsk, Kyzylorda, as well as such “meaningless names as Novorybinka, Elizavetinka, Sosnovka, Peterfeld, etc.”.

The Kazakh press repeatedly discussed the issue of renaming Pavlodar and Petropavlovsk. The newspaper “Zhas Kazak” in the article “To whom are the roads - Pavlov's“ gifts ”?”, Justifying the need for renaming, referred to the statement of President N.A. Nazarbayev, who told 10 years ago at a meeting with representatives of the Kazakh intelligentsia, that “onomastic issues will always be in the center of attention of the country's leadership. And there is nothing to look around timidly around. The names inherited from the colonial times, affecting directly the honor and dignity of our people, inappropriate to the old historical names of the area, sounding discordant ear, must be changed. ”

For the time being, the fear of increasing the emigration of the Slavic population, which still accounts for about a quarter of the population of the republic, but keeps at the same time the backbone of skilled workers and engineering and technical personnel, is keeping the mass change of Russian names to Kazakh Kazakhstan. A complete rejection of Russian-language names, justified by the need to combat the colonial heritage, will further enhance the alienation of Russians from the Kazakh state and the title ethnic group. To enhance migration attitudes among the Slavic population, the change of toponymy will create a more “favorable" psychological background.

Why did it take to voice the idea of ​​renaming Kazakhstan into “Kazak el?”

The main reason, apparently, is the desire to distance itself from other “stans” - the republics of Central Asia, which gained independence in 1991, as well as Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Most of them combine political and economic instability, creating a negative image of the entire region in the eyes of the global expert and political community. Kazakhstan, which has achieved some success on the path of social and economic development, with the help of a name change wants to emphasize that it does not belong to this “belt of instability”. In addition, the change of name will be a kind of summing up the results of the reign of N.A. Nazarbayev, emphasizing his achievements on the way to building the Kazakh national state.
434 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. fall
    -2
    18 February 2014 16: 35
    Better return the historical name of the capital of East Prussia - Koenegsberg, otherwise now there are more drinking glasses than churches!!!!!!!!!!!!
  2. fall
    -1
    18 February 2014 16: 37
    We have only one path: integration................with the West, in any case. there planes don't crash from drunk pilots!!!!!!!!!!!!
  3. Refugee from Kazakhstan
    +1
    18 February 2014 16: 37
    Well, 6222 thousand minus 3797 thousand and it comes out to less than 3 million. Didn’t I write it correctly? Further: the saying “where did you learn to lie, I already taught there” is purely popular and means that there is no need to bullshit me! You shamefully cling to words like I don’t know who. I agree with the rest of the article, and you will also agree that the majority of Kazakhs on the branch are not enthusiastic about the idea of ​​the NAS. From the outside it looks like this: Kazakhs are forced to justify themselves by saying that you are primarily to blame. Further: The Kazakhs (like Vasilenko) did not specifically record stories about the manifestation of Russian nationalism, did not collect them in shorthand by regions and villages. I’ll tell you one story: three railway workers gathered to have lunch at a distance, 1978 Kazakhstan, two Kazakhs and one Russian. They're having lunch and talking, here the Kazakhs talk to each other in Kazakh "last year, a neighbor sold a thin sogym (horse), he deceived me that it was fattening, and there wasn't even enough fat left for a finger, this year I'll take it from Utegen for two with his son, etc. .d." In short, they spoke Kazakh for a long time. Lunch was over and we went to work. The next day, railway workers who spoke Kazakh were dealt with at the trade union committee based on a complaint from a third party. If there were party members they would have been expelled, but otherwise they were deprived of the bonus. Since then, those railway workers spoke Kazakh in their native land only at home. WOULD THIS BE POSSIBLE IN ANY OTHER UNION REPUBLIC? NO! ONLY IN KAZAKHSTAN. By the way, only Russians sat on the trade union committee. This is how interethnic hostility was nurtured and fueled not only at the everyday level, but also at the level of state policy. The dissatisfaction was simply hushed up. Therefore, not you personally, but with the participation of your Russians, the root cause of such hostility arose, which in many ways negated all the good that the Russians had done!
  4. fall
    -1
    18 February 2014 16: 42
    Yes, we are stupid, and you are smart! That's why stupid people don't want smart weapons from .........smart ones!!!!!!!!!!!:
    Unexpectedly, the planned signing of the protocol on the supply of Russian Yak-130 training aircraft for the needs of this country's air force ended in Kazakhstan. More precisely, it did not end with anything, as it simply did not take place. The Kazakhstan side, one hour before the appointed event, announced its rejection of the planned transaction. This was a complete surprise for the Russian side.

    It was not only a formal protocol on cooperation and intentions to purchase UTB that was prepared. All the necessary technical and legal documents were prepared, including a specific quotation. However, they were not needed.

    The representative of the Ministry of Defense of Kazakhstan explained this behavior by the fact that the proposal of the Russian side, and then the execution of contract documents were completed in a fairly short time. The representatives of Kazakhstan simply could not thoroughly study and make an informed decision.

    Secondly, Kazakhstan only a year and a half ago carried out a series of works on the deep modernization of the entire fleet of the UTS on the basis of the L-39. It would be irrational now to begin their decommissioning, not allowing to fully exhaust the resource. And while there is no experience in operating the Yak-130 in the Russian Air Force. In any case, Kazakhstan does not completely deny the possibility of purchasing the Yak-130, but it will wait.

    I am very glad when I heard this news!
    1. +2
      19 February 2014 11: 06
      Quote: beifall
      Yes we are stupid

      well you are right
  5. fall
    0
    18 February 2014 16: 45
    It still won’t be your way, but it will be like this:
    The Ministry of Defense of Kazakhstan has begun the selection of candidates for training in military universities of the USA since 2014. Next year, the defense ministry of Kazakhstan will send four Kazakhstanis to study in the United States, the press service of the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Kazakhstan said.

    Each candidate will study at a prestigious military university, including the West Point Military Academy of the Ground Forces, the Academy of the Naval Forces, the Academy of the Air Force and the US Coast Guard Academy. Duration of training 4 year.

    Information about candidates admitted to military universities of the United States will be known tentatively at the beginning of May 2014.




    Departure to the United States for training is expected in mid-June 2014, after taking the Military oath. Before being sent, the cadets will sign a contract on military service in the Armed Forces of the Republic of Kazakhstan. Upon return, graduates of US military schools will have to continue serving in the Kazakh army for at least 10 years.

    Last year, two Kazakhs received a certificate for training in the United States. Abylai Akhmetov entered the West Point Military Academy of the Army, Ilyas Kameledinov became a cadet of the Naval Academy of the US Armed Forces, the press service of the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Kazakhstan said.
    1. +2
      19 February 2014 11: 07
      Quote: beifall
      The Ministry of Defense of Kazakhstan began the selection of candidates for training in military schools of the United States since 2014.

      and you will have not tankmen, artillerymen, etc., but officers of the ground forces, forward and with a song
  6. Refugee from Kazakhstan
    0
    18 February 2014 16: 51
    It is also interesting that stupid Kazakhs at the Sochi Olympics cheer for smart Russians as if they were their own (stupid and lazy)!
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. +1
      19 February 2014 11: 08
      Quote: RK refugee
      It is also interesting that stupid Kazakhs at the Sochi Olympics cheer for smart Russians as if they were their own (stupid and lazy)!

      you will be surprised, but we also root for Belarusians, Kazakhs and Ukrainians
  7. Ermek
    0
    18 February 2014 21: 09
    hi all. I haven’t written for a long time, but I couldn’t resist. I look at this family squabble, and I want to praise the boys of my fellow tribesmen - you don’t put your money where your mouth is. But I suggest you stop throwing pearls in front of some. You see, this is the contingent that eats crap, they get high from it. Look at how they instantly respond to your comments, how selflessly they write their semi-literate comments. Smart Russian brothers do not participate in this nonsense. True, for some reason they don’t stop these vampires, who, in full accordance with the biochemistry of betrayal, work for those. I think that many of these vampires even look like that bad guy nerd blogger who probably sweats a lot in the warm season.
    Well, a summary - we have democracy in Kazakhstan (please do not be ironic), what we call ourselves is our internal matter and, if it comes to that, it will be determined in a referendum. Russia is also a democratic country (no irony); it respects the democratic choice of its, by the way, closest ally. And therefore I propose to stop pouring water into the enemy’s mills.
  8. ekzorsist
    -1
    18 February 2014 21: 53
    Quote: Yeraz
    And what ??? But these lands are Cossack.

    You're lying, however - THESE LANDS WERE NEVER KAZAKH!
    ...I didn’t teach history well...although in the recent history of the greatest Kazakhstan of all the greatest Kazakhstans...they probably dug up something new...
    What kind of money do the Kazakhs give in just to prove how great they are? Either the descendants of Genghis Khan, then completely the descendants of Temirkhan, then suddenly every second direct heir of Aldarakose (who with a scythe is like death - or what?) ...
    1. Refugee from Kazakhstan
      -2
      21 February 2014 08: 52
      DO NOT LIKE? Good riddance, YOU CHOOSE YOURSELF THE FATE OF ROADSIDE TRASH, OUTcastS!
  9. ekzorsist
    -2
    18 February 2014 22: 03
    ...Yes, about the so-called "defense" of Kazakhstan...and laughter and sin...BUT!!! Deputy Minister of Defense with two million dollars in his pocket... it seems like they got it in Kazakhstan? And not in Mogolia or Kyrgyzstan? I'm not wrong ?
    That's the whole essence of the entire "titular nation" ... all the "defense"
    1. +1
      19 February 2014 10: 49
      But I haven’t forgotten Serdyukov, he will have more sins.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  10. rezident
    -1
    19 February 2014 22: 42
    The Kazakhs were very lucky; they were able to leave with most of their lands, and even virtually without bloodshed. Not many nations are so lucky. And it’s time for military fighters to understand that this is an independent country with its own interests that do not always coincide with Russian ones. And yelling that everything around is Russian, everything around is mine, counting money in the pocket of someone else’s defense minister does not contribute to good relations.
  11. The comment was deleted.
  12. +1
    20 February 2014 15: 01
    And all the fuss is because the Kazakhs ate and not drank...
  13. Refugee from Kazakhstan
    -3
    21 February 2014 09: 01
    DEAR RACIANS! THERE WILL BE AS MANY RUSSIANS IN KAZAKHSTAN AS THERE WERE KAZAKH IN THE KAZAKH ASSR AND SAY THANKS TO NA! SO IN THE QUEUE TO THE OCULIST FOR LOG STEP MARCH!
    1. ekzorsist
      0
      21 February 2014 22: 44
      Quote: Refugee from RK
      DEAR RACIANS! THERE WILL BE AS MANY RUSSIANS IN KAZAKHSTAN AS THERE WERE KAZAKH IN THE KAZAKH ASSR AND SAY THANKS TO NA! SO IN THE QUEUE TO THE OCULIST FOR LOG STEP MARCH!

      Won't you fart?
  14. +1
    21 February 2014 11: 42
    Quote: ekzorsist
    The majority of Kazakhs are lazy, do not want to work and will not. Let them forgive me, but it is a fact.


    Every nation has its own shortcomings. There are both lazy and non-lazy among us. Just like among Russians. But there is no need to attach a label to the entire nation.
    1. ekzorsist
      0
      21 February 2014 22: 53
      I agree, BUT!!! The National Patriarchate's hysterics with and without cause have already gotten so bad...
      Then with this language they run around like they’ve been stung in the ass - “...whoever doesn’t know Kazakh is stupid... etc...” - why the hell did he give in to me? And as for stupidity, we still need to look at this... who has what kind of education... don’t offer the current purchased one!
      And with the territories themselves, too, let’s not get hysterical... there is a history and why bother with it??? The state itself (precisely the state!!!) Kazakhstan appeared literally 15 years ago, with a handout from a drunken Boris, so why bother showing off? What can everyone get away with because they are chosen by God?
  15. +1
    21 February 2014 11: 52
    Quote: rezident
    The Kazakhs were very lucky; they were able to leave with most of their lands, and even virtually without bloodshed. Not many nations are so lucky. And it’s time for military fighters to understand that this is an independent country with its own interests that do not always coincide with Russian ones. And yelling that everything around is Russian, everything around is mine, counting money in the pocket of someone else’s defense minister does not contribute to good relations.


    Yeah, what about the extermination in 1831-1841, 1916, the genocide of 1931-33? And December 1986? The Kazakhs paid very dearly for their independence. During the years of the USSR alone there were about 500 small and large uprisings.
    Our grandfathers also fought in the Second World War, about half a million of ours died. So there is no need to talk nonsense. Yes, the Russians were the main force, but we helped them very seriously in the Second World War (9 out of 10 bullets in the war were cast from lead in Kazakhstan)
    1. ekzorsist
      0
      21 February 2014 22: 57
      Quote: beifall
      The Ministry of Defense of Kazakhstan has begun the selection of candidates for training in military universities of the USA since 2014. Next year, the defense ministry of Kazakhstan will send four Kazakhstanis to study in the United States, the press service of the Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Kazakhstan said.

      ... So this is where the deputy minister of the so-called defense gets his money!
      And they opened a criminal case... why were you so depressed right away?
      1. Refugee from Kazakhstan
        -1
        22 February 2014 11: 30
        Quote: ekzorsist
        I agree, BUT!!! The National Patriarchate's hysterics with and without cause have already gotten so bad...
        Then with this language they run around like they’ve been stung in the ass - “...whoever doesn’t know Kazakh is stupid... etc...” - why the hell did he give in to me? And as for stupidity, we still need to look at this... who has what kind of education... don’t offer the current purchased one!
        And with the territories themselves, too, let’s not get hysterical... there is a history and why bother with it??? The state itself (precisely the state!!!) Kazakhstan appeared literally 15 years ago, with a handout from a drunken Boris, so why bother showing off? What can everyone get away with because they are chosen by God?

        Even if our state (in which you also live) is a year old, let the army limp, and show-offs and whatever else you drag in there, does not play any role in building the state model and the Kazakh society (which has no place for you for a long time)! It’s clear that you can’t shut the mouth of every outcast like you, so I advise you to occupy your mouth with something else. You, like other outcasts (LGBT, etc.), will always find a warm place away from Kazakhstan. WE REPEAT AGAIN: THE POSITION OF RUSSIANS IN KAZAKHSTAN (LANGUAGE, ROLE IN PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION, INTERNATIONAL AND INTERPERSONAL RELATIONS) WILL BE THE SAME AS TO THE KAZAKHS IN THE USSR YEARS (IE, FRIENDLY)! IF THIS DOESN'T FIT YOUR FUCKING ASS,....WELL YOU KNOW THE ANSWER!
    2. rezident
      -1
      22 February 2014 18: 19
      Believe me, others also experienced no less. In general, good luck to you there. Be careful with Moscow right now in Russia, the trend is Stalin and Revanchism. Get back, no matter what happens, what we stupidly lost in 1991.
  16. fall
    -1
    25 March 2014 15: 23
    We are taught by those who have terrorist attacks TWICE a day!!!!!! Planes crash because of drunk pilots!!!!!!!!!!!!