Military Review

Who needs a caliphate

44
Radical Islamism can lead the country to disaster


In May, the 2013 of the Year at the Military Academy of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation, the Club of Military Commanders of the Russian Federation will hold a scientific-practical conference “Islamism and National Security of Russia”. On the eve of this event, the President of the Club, Doctor of Economic Sciences, General of the Army Anatoly Kulikov presented his position on the stated topics.

This complex topic can not be opened in one newspaper publication, it is so multifaceted. But without studying it, it is impossible to understand what is happening today in some predominantly mono-national republics of the country and in general in its open spaces. Moreover, the problem poses a real danger to Russia, being at the junction of both external and internal threats, and directly affects the military security of the state.

Totalitarian ideology

The Russian Federation, as is known, is a multinational and multi-faith country. For more than a century, representatives of many nationalities have lived in peace and harmony in it, from which the common spiritual core of our society has only been strengthened. Over the past decades, we have together endured incredible trials, including the most bloody war of the twentieth century - the Great Patriotic War. And all this thanks to the friendship of nations. But lately there are those who want to put a landmine under this foundation.

Today, according to various estimates, there live in Russia from 25 to 30 millions of Muslims (including migrants from the Central Asian republics and the Caucasus). In a secular state, which, according to the Constitution, is our country, the analysis of society on the basis of religion could be considered irrelevant for the time being. However, at the end of the past - the beginning of this century, the religious factor, primarily the Islamic one, began to play a new role in the world process. One of the first after the collapse of the Soviet Union, Russia felt it.

The world community felt this danger 11 September 2001 of the year.

However, Islam and Islamism should be distinguished. In the encyclopaedic interpretation, Islamism is a religious-political ideology and practical activities aimed at creating conditions under which any contradictions within a state where there is a Muslim population, as well as interstate relations with its participation, will be resolved on the basis of Sharia norms. This is the fundamental difference of this ideology from others, its main essence.

In some sources Islamism is called a totalitarian ideology, offering solutions to the complex issues of modern life by medieval methods.

The distinctive features of Islamism include:

  • imperative understanding of Allah as the supreme power;
  • the requirement to return to a way of life and religion in the form that was granted by the prophet;
  • observance of active faith in the form of rituals, traditions of Salafiriya, that is, the primordial faith of ancestors, who allegedly underwent a deviation from fundamental principles in the process of the development of mankind and Islam;
  • the primacy of sharia law over all secular superstructures;
  • unrestricted use of intimidation and violence to achieve their goals, including through terror.

    In this construction, Islamism is opposed to Islam itself in its modern form, adapted to more or less secular conditions.

    Who needs a caliphate

    Today Islamism is increasing its influence in society, constantly putting forward appropriate justifications for this. From the standpoint of this ideology, there is something to improve, even in Islam itself. For example, Saudi Arabia, Kuwait and Jordan, the purest in terms of orthodoxy from the existing Islamic states, are also not without sin. For example, the Sharia does not provide for a political regime in the form of the ruling royal power. In addition, the Saudis made seemingly unacceptable - they held the first municipal elections, departing from conservative traditions. In Kuwait, women participate in elections. In Bahrain, the authorities are loyal to mass demonstrations, and in the UAE there are foundations of a free press.

    The “Arab Spring” skated around a number of countries. Only those of them, where the modernization of the state political system has not gone too far, retain, albeit tense, but still stability. Nevertheless, with all the heterogeneity of Islamic beliefs and internal divisions, the Muslim world is very cohesive. It is not by chance that many extremist forces are obsessed with the idea of ​​recreating the great Islamic caliphate and have quite a few supporters. Moreover, it is safe to predict that in the near future, the Islamic factor will become a priority when setting the agenda for many forums and international organizations.

    Paradoxically, but in the Russian Federation with its state Orthodox culture and the undoubted interdependence of ethnic characteristics and spiritual values ​​of different peoples, Islam has even stronger positions than in the countries of Central Asia. In the absence of an official ideology in Russia in a number of Muslim republics, Islam is de facto an integral part of ideology, education, and business. But Islamism, where it does not receive active resistance, for the time being refrains from outright aggression. But only for the time being.

    The example of Chechnya showed it well. Now this republic is pacified. But the sabotage and terrorist war continues, it has moved to other areas - Dagestan, Kabardino-Balkaria, Ingushetia. The population even in the adjacent Stavropol Territory found itself in a difficult situation. Each of these entities has its own national base for militants. The situation is so complicated that the federal center sometimes finds a way out of it in rather controversial decisions.

    For example, since last year, we have abandoned conscription resources in one of the North Caucasian republics. If before 2010, about 20 of thousands of guys were called out of it, then in the autumn of 2012, only 179 was called. Of these, the military units of the Ministry of Defense - 42, the rest - in the Ministry of Emergency Situations. How reasonable is that? After all, the army is a school of international education, and we, on the contrary, seem to push the Caucasian youth away from us. Not to mention the fact that unemployment is soaring in the republics mentioned above. In Ingushetia, it is 48 percent, in Chechnya - 35, about the same in Dagestan. It turns out that with such measures we replace the concept of international education, the friendship of nations.

    Allah gives?

    Much, of course, depends on the local government, which is still ineffective and places clan, tribal relations above the Constitution of the Russian Federation and federal laws. It is no secret that, unfortunately, there is still no positive return from significant budgetary injections into the North Caucasian republics. The measures for their social and economic development do not give results either.


    Thus, the state budget of the North Caucasian republics today at 50 – 90 percent is formed and exists at the expense of federal subsidies. But how is this evaluated in the Caucasus itself? More than once I had to hear: for this, they say, the will of Allah, he gives. Imagine for a moment that Allah will stop giving due to some crisis situations. What then?

    But the main thing is not even that. Social and other subsidies often simply do not reach the population due to the corruption of local officials. But with this money real estate in the Stavropol Territory, property and luxury goods in foreign countries are bought up. In my native village (Aigursky settlement of the Stavropol Territory. - Ed.), Where my parents grew up, there were no people from North Caucasian republics at all before, although in principle I don’t see anything wrong with that. It is surprising more. In some streets of the village, there are fewer natives left than visitors. Although the village is large - three and a half thousand people.

    I repeat: all would be nothing if the process of migration of the population was carried out in the framework of international communication and education, friendship of peoples. But the settlement of native Russian territories from the Caucasus comes with the introduction of elements of Islamist ideology, medieval traditions and rituals, up to the wearing of hijabs and the tacit introduction of Sharia norms into everyday life. And this is a completely different situation.

    Community of the faithful

    In a number of regions of Central Russia, jamaats are being created - associations of the faithful. They are members of the same community, grouped around the same mosque. In Soviet times there were few mosques, and in some republics of the North Caucasus they were completely absent. In this case, Muslims gathered in communities (jamaats) and celebrated ceremonies in some premises. At the end of the last century, the concept of “jamaat” was filled with other content. This is a community, but no longer of a religious orientation, but of a politicized Islamist activity, which is based on fundamentalist principles that compete with traditional Islam in the region and traditional communities. The adherents of this trend began to create their own communities, which are also called jamaats, led by the emir - the Arab commander, endowed with power, including military.

    Now in the open spaces of Russia there are a lot of such jamaats. Muslim representatives of both internal and external migration wave find their place in them. Their existence, lifestyle is destructive and directed against the indigenous population, including fellow tribesmen, loyal to the order established in the state. See what happens in Dagestan, Tatarstan. There they are already shooting and destroying muftis, other religious leaders of traditional Islam. First of all, because they support traditional Islam, and the Islamists do not need it. They need a caliphate.

    All of us, like the leadership of the country, may still not be seriously aware of what is happening. The clergymen who were trained in Saudi Arabia came to our house, who implant their values ​​in Arabic, demand that Islamism in Russia be elevated to the rank of state policy. At the same time, they very subtly play on the internal contradictions of the country, skillfully use social and national problems, support everything that contributes to the development of Islamism, and actively form their social base in this way.

    Unfortunately, a number of objective contradictions and problems of our state work on them. Including such as corruption, which we still can not win or at least reduce to a socially tolerable level. Fresh example. Following the appointment of a new head of the law enforcement structure in one of the national republics, a certain criminal group immediately bought him a house in the capital, and the other, an armored Mercedes. After that, this law-enforcement structure began to "protect" business and crime groups, to put pressure on respectable citizens and businessmen. What was left for ordinary people to do in this situation? Not finding justice and protection in the police, the courts, citizens united to commit samozh.

    It is here that the roots of terrorism are hidden - in the social fragmentation of society, corruption, with which no one in other regions fights. But it is effectively used in its subversive work by religious radicals. For them, this is a good reason for campaigning more and more militants into their ranks, including guys who we do not take up military service for which there are no jobs. It is not surprising that after appropriate ideological treatment, they go into the forest, pick up weapon, become suicide bombers.

    Preventive action

    Are there any retaliatory measures? Of course. But they should be more effective. Ahead of the Olympic Games, and if their security is not reliable, there may be problems associated with the arrival of their participants and guests.

    Much of this was said in the President’s Address. I am convinced that now all the security forces must constantly work in the venues of the Games in order not to allow the militants to move freely not only between the subjects of the Federation, but also within the North Caucasian republics. The earth should burn under the feet of the bandits.

    If we lose, it will be a loss to all of Russia for the next 50 years. This will be a victory of terrorists over the state, which should not be allowed. Our security officials must constantly report to the political leadership of the country on the preparations for the Olympics, and keep the situation under control in their areas of work.

    There are different forms and methods of resisting radical Islamism in Russia. This is a separate topic. But one thing I can not say. Our country is the only one in the world that has so many ethnic groups in its federal structure - around 140. Why in the state there is no body that would coordinate the work in this direction, develop the methodology, recommendations for proactive conflict situations and problems of actions. We do not have the Ministry of Nationalities and Religion, and the problems in this area are just screaming. They can lead to disaster throughout Russia.

    It is said that crime has no nationality, as does terrorism. But if we share this point of view, we will pound the problem in depth and never solve it. We must finally admit that crime and terrorism, which in the Caucasus and in a number of regions of Russia are closely linked to radical Islam, have a nationality. Recognize and not hide.

    Our special services have gained rich experience and have the appropriate opportunities to obtain the necessary information, to take preventive measures. This will ensure stability both in the North Caucasus and in the Russian Federation as a whole.
  • Author:
    Originator:
    http://vpk-news.ru/
    44 comments
    Information
    Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

    I have an account? Sign in

    1. vladsolo56
      vladsolo56 April 24 2013 05: 46
      +8
      As in due time, around the 13th century, Christianity spread throughout the world. And now there is an aggressive imposition of Islam. All talk of a peaceful religion is just a screen. Any religion initially has only one purpose, it is to gain power over as many people as possible, forcing them to obey the laws that benefit only a small handful of those in power. In order not to want to oppose this ideology, the Inquisition existed in the Middle Ages. Now in Islam there are currents of crazy radicals who are ready, at the first word of their same crazy leaders, to kill anyone who dares to object or even worse to get out of a religious dope. They are trying to impress on us that there is normal moderate Islam and there is a radical fanatical one. Then let us be offered at least one example when the most famous Islamic leaders do not just scold or condemn fanatical radicals there, but curse them, excommunicate them from Islam, declare them outcasts. There was not and will not be. The reason is elementary banal, they are needed, needed in order to keep everyone else in obedience, so that no one has the thought to leave their ranks, or even break some commandments. So judging by what is happening in the world, and I note not only in the Islamic world, the desire to expand influence by any means is happening at an incredible speed.
      1. smel
        smel April 24 2013 06: 10
        +6
        Then let us be offered at least one example when the most famous Islamic leaders do not just scold or condemn fanatical radicals there, but curse them, excommunicate them from Islam, and declare them outcasts. There was not and will not be.
        Plus I agree with that. Much can be said on this topic, but real actions demonstrate the correctness of this statement. And even despite the fact that the Islamists kill the most loyal and sane servants of Islam, the excommunication of the inveterate villains does not occur
      2. V. Ushakov
        V. Ushakov April 24 2013 07: 16
        11
        No need to "tolerate". This is not the 13th century. If I'm not mistaken 21st. We must now eradicate this evil, the evil of radical Islamism. How are you going to do it? Beliefs, "curses of mullahs and / or some ayatollahs." Nonsense. They can only recognize the strength, the strength of the people, the strength of the state, which restrain or eliminate the Islamist Evil. This is so elementary that it is understood by almost everyone, except for the especially gifted highly intelligent liberotolera-stoder-democrats and the advocates of Islamic bandits. Weapons, normal, firearms, for non-Islamic population and this Evil - will immediately "shrink". They are very afraid of force, of the armed force - even more so. And the picture is interesting: for this group, but for large-caliber ones - one queue is enough.
      3. Yarbay
        Yarbay April 24 2013 09: 23
        -3
        Quote: vladsolo56
        They are trying to impress on us that there is normal moderate Islam and there is a radical fanatical one.

        In reality, there is Islam and pseudo-Islam !!
        Quote: vladsolo56
        . All talk about peaceful religion, it's just a screen

        You are deeply mistaken!
        1. baltika-18
          baltika-18 April 24 2013 15: 00
          +3
          Quote: Yarbay
          In reality, there is Islam and pseudo-Islam !!

          Alibek, so be it. But they kill with the name of Allah and in the name of Allah, but to a simple person (not a Muslim) who cares about your Islamic turmoil. You are a smart man, Alibek, and you perfectly understand that the more you say, the pseudo-Islamists will be, the it’s going to hit you harder and Islam in general. First of all, this trend threatens you (classical, secular Muslims). For us, this is understandable to the enemy and everything must be destroyed. And for you, a misguided believer who needs to be set on the right path? catch?
          Or isn’t it? If it’s also an enemy, then why is silence? Why is there no condemnation?
          And if there is, then only when he has already killed? Why do true Muslims allow the propaganda of this pseudo-Islam? Many questions, Alibek. Maybe not everything is so simple?
          Or maybe religion is not given by God?
          1. Yarbay
            Yarbay April 24 2013 15: 52
            +3
            Quote: baltika-18
            But then they kill with the name of Allah and in the name of Allah, but to a simple person (not a Muslim) nevermind before your inner Islamic vicissitudes.


            Hello dear!
            So I’m talking about this))) If you carefully read my comments in the past on this topic, then you would understand that I am convinced that there are forces that have been discrediting Islam for the first time and they are very influential, and these forces are not related to Islam! !! these forces use very effective psychological methods to recruit illiterate people!
            Quote: baltika-18
            First of all, this trend threatens you (the classical, secular Muslims). For us, this is understandable to the enemy and everything must be destroyed
            For me, there is no division into classical, secular or non-secular Islam !!
            All these terms were coined specifically by the enemies of Islam!
            Fundamentalists ..
            I consider myself a fundamentalist! the foundation is the base!
            I fundamentally know my religion !!
            For us, too, they are shaitanists and are subject to destruction !!
            Quote: baltika-18
            Catch the difference?

            I do not see the difference!
            Quote: baltika-18
            Why is there no condemnation?

            How no condemnation ???
            All famous scientists constantly expose them, but you do not print them, do not show on TV !!
            this is also part of the fight against Islam!
            Since last year, in Thailand, periodically Buddhist monks, with the support of local authorities, have been slaughtering hundreds of Muslims with impunity, who says where and where ???
            Everyone is silent, even the media * enemies * America !!
            Because the news does not fit into the script !!
            About propaganda !!!
            How can I prevent this if in Western countries in America, even millions of disks are produced with propegs of illiterate people and distributed !! ??
            And the speeches and works of famous scientists cannot be translated, not distributed!
            All for one!
            There is a struggle between good and evil!
            Atheists versus Believers (regardless of religion)
            1. baltika-18
              baltika-18 April 24 2013 16: 06
              +1
              Quote: Yarbay
              Hello dear!

              Thank you for your reply.
              1. Yarbay
                Yarbay April 24 2013 18: 38
                +1
                Quote: baltika-18
                Thank you for your reply.

                here is a small example !!
                Canadian police managed to track the alleged conspirators, who were about to blow up a New York-Toronto train, with the help of an imam from a Muslim community in a suburb of Toronto, who noticed odd behavior in one of the suspects, reports NBC News.
                “We Muslims must be the front line of defense. Our task is to stifle such manifestations in the bud and to fully cooperate with the police in order to bring criminals to justice, ”said Heft, commenting on his role in the capture of potential terrorists. At the same time, he added that he loves Canada and wishes peace to all its inhabitants, regardless of their religion
                http://www.vesti.az/news/155999

                Let's see where the news will be ??
                In many publications they will not cover, but in others they will forget in half an hour !!
      4. vadimus
        vadimus April 24 2013 10: 00
        +2
        By destroying obscurantism in the bud and raising the social level, you can partially protect Russia from this infection .. To special services and cards in hand ...
      5. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 10: 10
        +2
        Yes, there was such a "theme", forced Christianization, especially in South America in the 15th and 16th centuries, and we also "promoted" Christianity, especially among the Kazan Tatars under Ivan the Terrible.
        1. 755962
          755962 April 24 2013 12: 37
          +9
          There has already been an article about this .. About the Islamization of Europe. And most members of the forum compared this to the plague ..
          1. Maximus
            Maximus April 24 2013 12: 55
            +2
            In Australia, this question is "burning". Only hopes for adaptation are in vain.
      6. Pinochet000
        Pinochet000 April 24 2013 13: 58
        0
        Quote: vladsolo56
        As in due time, around the 13th century, Christianity spread throughout the world. And now there is an aggressive imposition of Islam. All talk of a peaceful religion is just a screen. Any religion initially has only one purpose, it is to gain power over as many people as possible, forcing them to obey the laws that benefit only a small handful of those in power.

        I completely agree, I just wanted to add that both religions are Jewish, only the bearers of these religions do not understand this ... in general, the fact that we live in Jewish civilization is obvious .. IMHO We can continue to convince ourselves that this is not so. ..just you need to look at modern civilization as a whole, discard the details (they only complicate, the root is a lie) and present the general picture of the world. Who needs a caliphate? I wonder why the comrades from the Palestinian people, so vehemently support the Syrian opposition, in many forums of Runet, Courage, Air Base?
        1. Pinochet000
          Pinochet000 April 24 2013 14: 29
          0
          Well or here:
          Syrian opposition calls on Obama to heed Israeli general Link
          Representatives of the Syrian opposition called on US President Barack Obama to fulfill his promise and intervene in the civil war in Syria. They recall that a few weeks ago, the American leader said that the use of weapons of mass destruction by the Bashar al-Assad regime would have the most serious consequences.
          The appeal was based on a statement by the head of the analytical department of the Israeli military intelligence, Brigadier General Itai Brun. Speaking at a conference of the National Security Research Center, he said that Assad used WMD against the opposition, most likely sarin.
          Earlier, British experts who studied soil samples came to a similar conclusion. But the opinion of the Israeli general seems more authoritative to the Syrians. The opposition, which has almost lost hope for military assistance from the West, hopes that in this case Obama will fulfill his obligations.
          Representatives of the American administration hastened to dissociate themselves from the words of Brun. Secretary of State John Kerry noted that in a telephone conversation with him, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was unable to confirm the words of the head of the analytical department of military intelligence.
          The Maariv newspaper cites anonymous sources in Jerusalem who say the general’s speech caught the political leadership by surprise. They noted that Israel was not going to put the United States in an uncomfortable position, and Brun should have shown restraint in his statements.

          already engaged
      7. radio operator
        radio operator April 24 2013 14: 29
        +2
        Quote: vladsolo56
        All talk of a peaceful religion is just a screen.

        This is what Western liberals are calling for. Atheism and liberal freedom are the weapons of the West.
        1. vladsolo56
          vladsolo56 April 24 2013 18: 40
          -1
          Atheism is not a weapon; it brings you up. Atheism is a worldview based on the knowledge of the world. Absolutely not having an ideology.
          1. radio operator
            radio operator April 25 2013 07: 50
            +1
            Quote: vladsolo56
            Atheism is a worldview based on the knowledge of the world

            Excuse me, but what kind of knowledge of the world are we talking about?
            Atheists are the only ones who believe "IN ANYTHING." Atheism is inherently anti-scientific.
    2. V. Ushakov
      V. Ushakov April 24 2013 06: 10
      +8
      Everybody knows that crime and terrorism have a nationality, as a rule, Caucasian, there is also a religion - radical Islamism. And everyone knows this. That is, absolutely everyone. Well, this is the way to work, it is clear how and where - with an anti-Caucasian, anti-extremist orientation, in the Caucasus and in other places where there are corresponding "jaamats" of radical Islamism. Such "Mosques of terrorists" should simply blow up, disperse the "parishioners" and, by any means, destroy the "preachers", whether they are local residents, or the Arabs who have come in large numbers. The tougher the response of the state and non-Muslim part of the population to extremist "Islam", the sooner we get rid of this Islamic Evil. And besides, the non-Islamic population should be well armed, so that there are as few inclinations as possible on our usual way of life on the part of these bastards.
      1. Nesvet Nezar
        Nesvet Nezar April 24 2013 07: 26
        11
        You know the story very poorly. The crusades brought death to all who lived on the path of advancement of the crusaders. Even in Jerusalem, after its capture by the crusaders, EVERYTHING was killed - Muslims, Christians, and Jews. Beggar knights from impoverished Europe went to the rich Middle East for money and land, hiding behind God. So now, poor people from the Middle East, like the crusaders, have redefined the meaning of Jihad and become in the ranks of thieves, robbers and murderers. Why aren't they cursed? Yes, because they create grief outside the house. They don’t have anything at home, except for the poor mom and dad. Someone foolishly goes for fame. The engine and resource of these movements is demography ..... Muslims of Russia, considering it (Russia) their home, cannot and do not share the aspirations of the Islamists. People like you, I’m sure, even consider the Tatars to be enemies. But the Tatars, for example, second after the Russians defended our (read yours) our homeland in the Second World War ... Such a concept as Jihad of Allah is literally translated into Russian - the path of a preacher, monk, ascetic, humble, single god. Magomed did not say that jihad is the way of war. The Arabs misinterpreted Magomed, may God bless and greet him, and recite that Arabic is the only language in which one can believe in the One God. This dogma holds the Islamists together. She leaves them unaware of truly orthodox Islam .... Faith can be defeated only by faith and procreation, as all the gods of the earth teach. Do you have faith? Do you have three children? If the answer is no to both questions, then the weapon you are calling for will not save you.
        1. Kaa
          Kaa April 24 2013 07: 50
          +6
          Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
          Arabs misinterpreted Magomed, may God bless and greet him, and recite that Arabic is the only language in which you can believe in the One God
          " In general, Islamists cite three key reasons: Israel’s non-recognition of Palestinian rights, Islamophobia and Western intervention in Muslim countries. It was these points that were touched last week by one of the Muslims who wrote a letter to the newspaper The Independent.
          Religion is another fig leaf used by millions of followers of the Prophet Muhammad. Islam, they rightly observe, does not authorize the killing of civilians by ordinary believers or leaders. However, focusing on good texts, Muslims do not notice the real actions of the Muslims themselves. I doubt that even the most virtuous imam can point this out and not get a threat in his address.And some organizations, always ready to give an alarm about Islamophobia, including the British Muslim Council, avoid looking at intentional ignorance and barbarism in Muslim communities around the world under Muslim control.
          Remember what happened last week, when an explosion of indignation occurred in Bangladesh and the protests competing among themselves caused the death of five people. Supporters of secularization demand punishment for those Bangladeshi who committed atrocities in 1971 during the war for independence from Pakistan. Some of the perpetrators were active members of the Muslim police, and now they are protected by an alliance of influential Islamist parties. In Egypt, human rights organizations have reported that children are thrown into prisons and tortured. The government spent £ 1,7 million on tear gas. In Tunisia, after the assassination of the popular anti-religious leader Chokri Belaida, the radical Islamic party Ennahda is gaining more influence. More than 50 people died during the explosion in Syria, where over two thousand people were killed in two years. Islamic rebels in Mali, Nigeria and elsewhere continue their wicked and destabilizing activities. 70 Shiites were killed in Pakistan, whose first leader Muhammad Jinn was a Shiite, like me. They also want to destroy us in Afghanistan, in Kashmir, in Bahrain and in Iraq, where bombs regularly explode and kill these believers. Another Muslim minority group is targeted and its supporters often die. Internal and external intolerance is the brand of Islam at present. The great past of Muslim civilizations, known for their diversity, humanity, science and extraordinary achievements, perished. Education, various arts, photography, television, sports and even work are condemned by insane imams online, as well as in mosques around the world, including in the United Kingdom.
          Thinking and honest Muslims are silent, as they are afraid to be ostracized or to increase racist manifestations against Muslims - and these are real threats. However, to be silent today is to show cowardice and conspire with the destroyers of our faith. True believers must actively oppose this kind of destruction..
          Original publication: How did modern Islam become so intolerant?
          Опубликовано: 24/02/2013 17:42 http://www.inosmi.ru/world/20130226/206326714.html#ixzz2RLhT8CNn
        2. Yarbay
          Yarbay April 24 2013 13: 35
          0
          Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
          and recite that Arabic is the only language in which you can believe in the One God

          You are a little wrong or misled !!
          God can be trusted and glorified in any language!
          But the prayer must be done in Arabic !!
        3. baltika-18
          baltika-18 April 24 2013 14: 41
          0
          Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
          Faith can be defeated only by faith and procreation, as all the gods of the earth teach.

          So, after all, Allah is not in a single copy, do you think? Are there many gods or what?
        4. radio operator
          radio operator April 24 2013 16: 15
          +1
          Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
          Faith can be defeated only by faith and procreation, as all the gods of the earth teach. Do you have faith? Do you have three children? If the answer is no for both questions, then the weapon you are calling for will not save you.

          Very correct words!
          It is a pity that we still do not want to understand this.
      2. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 10: 14
        +8
        Radical Islam, in most cases it is Wahhabism, and Wahhabism is a sect based on Islam. Wahhabists are considered Muslims, the same as Jehovah's Witnesses or Marmons, Christians.
    3. Ivan Tarasov
      Ivan Tarasov April 24 2013 06: 42
      +8
      In this design, Islamism is opposed to Islam itself in its modern form

      So you need to call a spade a spade.
      There is Satanism.
      Let this word be designated on the agenda.
      Otherwise, there will be errors and speculations, in the end, everyone will get confused ...
      If we denote that there is a war with the worshipers of Satan, then all concessions will unite.
      Against ideology, ideology is needed.
      If there is a war on priority 3, then jumping to 6 in the hope of winning the third is pointless!
      1. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 10: 18
        +4
        Many true Muslims call radicals from Islam and especially terrorists shaitans, which means devils or demons, in general satanists in their pure form.
        1. Uncle
          Uncle April 24 2013 13: 32
          +1
          Quote: Maximus
          Many true Muslims

          And where do they live?
          1. fzr1000
            fzr1000 April 24 2013 14: 33
            +1
            In Syria, for example, in Libya, they were ...
          2. Maximus
            Maximus April 24 2013 15: 02
            0
            They still live .... while they live ... but I hope the Islamists who distort Islam survive together with their overseas friends!
            1. Yarbay
              Yarbay April 24 2013 16: 19
              0
              Quote: Maximus
              They still live .... while they live ...

              Inshallah victory is ours!
              The Almighty gives us tests and inshals and will give us victory, for firmness, for our kinship and for the fact that we will not bow to the shaitanists !!
              1. Anti
                Anti April 24 2013 18: 49
                +1
                Quote: Yarbay
                Inshallah victory is ours!
                The Almighty gives us tests and inshals and will give us victory, for firmness, for our kinship and for the fact that we will not bow to the shaitanists !!


                NATO and Azerbaijan are actively cooperating in the field of democratic and institutional reforms, military reform, and are also engaged in practical cooperation in many areas. The program of cooperation between Azerbaijan and NATO is set forth in the Individual Partnership Action Plan (IPAP) of Azerbaijan.

                By the way, NATO refers to the Shaitanists?
          3. Yarbay
            Yarbay April 24 2013 16: 16
            0
            Quote: Uncle
            And where do they live?

            Worldwide!
        2. Yarbay
          Yarbay April 24 2013 16: 15
          0
          Quote: Maximus
          especially terrorists shaitans, which means devils or demons, in general satanists in its purest form.

          That's right !!
      2. Yarbay
        Yarbay April 24 2013 16: 14
        0
        Quote: Ivan Tarasov
        So you need to call a spade a spade.
        There is Satanism.
        Let this word be designated on the agenda.

        All right!
        You are absolutely right!
        Quote: Ivan Tarasov
        Against ideology, ideology is needed.

        Against dirty ideology, pure ideals must be countered !!
    4. Nesvet Nezar
      Nesvet Nezar April 24 2013 06: 48
      +3
      - the supremacy of Sharia law over all secular superstructures;
      - unlimited use of intimidation and violence to achieve their goals, including through terror.


      The Koran is not written about such things. And whoever does this is abandoned by Allah.
      1. Uncle
        Uncle April 24 2013 13: 34
        +1
        Nesar nezarya, are you Muslim? The name is Russian, sort of. or are you an orientalist? Just wondering...
    5. Sirocco
      Sirocco April 24 2013 06: 50
      +5
      As K. Marx once said, Religion is opium for the people. And this in the light of modern events is confirmed as two fingers on the asphalt. Who now consists of these gangs, Syria, the North Caucasus? semi-literate, uneducated young people. With which the brain was washed (with new views on Religion, the Koran.) The main ideologists of Western democracy. After all, a fool doesn’t need a knife, you’re lying to him from three boxes, and do whatever you like with him !!! One word, cannon fodder in the hands of ideologists, in the redistribution of spheres of influence. Organized crime groups in one word. Only on a national scale. And I want to note such a peculiarity, because all this infection was not in the days of the USSR (at least a few were identified and punished) as soon as the borders were opened, and all this infection poured into our territory. Can close the borders of the castle? or how else to fight? If our sovereigns do not want to, fight with those who deliver this infection to us (UAE, Qatar and others.).
      1. Captain Vrungel
        Captain Vrungel April 24 2013 07: 51
        +4
        The main mistake is that the clergy are allowed to rule the state and lobby their interests in power. We do not have the Middle Ages. On the street is the 21st century. Libraries, cinemas, houses of creativity are dying, stadium players and gyms are being destroyed (clubs and fitness centers for money bags do not count).
        Look at how fast and in what quantity churches and churches, mosques and minarets, synagogues and churches, churches and shamanistic yurts are being erected. We are not moving forward. We roll back to paganism. It is not pleasant to observe when a high-ranking arrogant person, yesterday’s atheist-communist, not a Christian by blood, puts a pen for a priest’s kiss in the Orthodox church, or kisses a priest of a higher rank. In captivity, I agree with the Bolsheviks (not to be confused with the Communists. The Bolsheviks saw Lenin alive, the Communists in the grave) Religion is opium for the people.
        1. Kaa
          Kaa April 24 2013 08: 00
          +6
          Quote: Captain Vrungel
          The main mistake is that the clergy are allowed to rule the state and lobby their interests in power.
          "In Western countries, there is a clear desire - based on inhuman fear and hatred, to spread an anti-Islamic concept. This campaign of desecration brings humanity to hatred, enmity and, ultimately, war. Biased news and commentary that has no end in sight today connects every counterattack made by the group with religion, and images of those who commit murders or mutilate with the call of Allah Akbar continue to be broadcast in all information and communication spaces. Mentioning the name of Allah when making a counterattack contains the message: “I am carrying out this act in the name of Allah and the motherland”, it represents human murder as part of Islam, and these people, who are supposed to support their country, essentially prepare favorable ground for the campaign for the desecration of Islam. We often see religion trying to justify behavior toward women. It remains a mystery on which ayah they rely in the case when they make efforts to force Islam to be perceived as a religion hostile to women, although the protection of women's rights was first consolidated in Islam. Another controversial pattern of behavior are acts directed against the occupying forces. The soldier you caught is a prisoner of war, his life is now in your hands, and it is not a matter of religion, man or soldier. A deliberate prescription of the illusory actions of Islam by those who seek to defend their country uncontrollably must be regarded as efforts to arouse imaginary fear, designed to mislead the opposite side and world public opinion. However, the whole world should ask the following questions: why are most of these soldiers foreigners, what did they do in this country, and what would we do with these soldiers if they captured our country? The main problem is hidden precisely in this: the troops of one country are occupying another, and the citizens of the captured country are defending their homeland, while they are not limited to terrorism, they are attacking the religion of the people defending their country. The West’s production of its own identity on the basis of an understanding of “one’s own and another’s” and an idea of ​​the phenomenon of Western civilization constructed on this basis. - not a new phenomenon. Based on the feud with Islam, which was defined as “alien,” the spirit of the crusaders is an idea that was built on memories and stories spanning the Middle Ages and served to fuel enmity. The preconceived position that this understanding has produced in relation to the Islamic world has survived to this day on the basis of “Islamophobia”. This can be clearly seen in the foreign policy of Western states in the framework of sabotage events. From the point of view of terminology, it becomes obvious that Islamophobia means “fear of Islam,” a phobia. As for the meaning of this term, it implies an instinct of fear and horror caused by Islam and Muslims. It can be argued that in order to prevent the spread of Islam in the West, cultural, theological, military and political threats are created, which today, turning into a desecration of the Islamic religion, lead to an increase in Islamophobia. Now the world knows that provocations are committed to ensure the growth of Islamophobia in the West. And we, knowing this, should not become part of a certain game. Original publication: Batıdaki İslam fobisi sanal mı?
          Опубликовано: 06/02/2013 13:50
          : http://inosmi.ru/world/20130208/205596919.html#ixzz2RLkH7RI1
        2. Sirocco
          Sirocco April 24 2013 08: 05
          +4
          The fact that religion sometimes plays a negative role, I agree with you, and there are a lot of examples from the Middle Ages, this is sometimes not a step, but dozens of steps back, in science, medicine and so on. The golden mean must be observed in religion. So I say, God is godly, and Caesar Caesarean. Without faith and religion, the end will come to us, and quite quickly. Not in vain in the 40s, the Dalessa doctrine was developed, and now it is being introduced.
          1. Nesvet Nezar
            Nesvet Nezar April 24 2013 08: 54
            -3
            Quote: Sirocco
            Not in vain in the 40s, the Dalessa doctrine was developed, and now it is being introduced.


            You have too good opinions about the Americans)))) and this doctrine was invented after the USSR collapsed with the hands of Gorbachev. And this doctrine was invented by citizens such as rezun.
            1. Egoza
              Egoza April 24 2013 10: 22
              +5
              Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
              and this doctrine was invented after the USSR collapsed with the hands of Gorbachev. And this doctrine was invented by citizens such as rezun.

              You are not right. I heard about this doctrine in the 60 years in the classroom of the school of international lecturers. Moreover, very famous and respected Valentin Zorin spoke about her.
            2. Sirocco
              Sirocco April 24 2013 10: 39
              +2
              I do not want to delve into the jungle of this doctrine. But the fact that it has been operating since the perestroika suggests that they wrote it without sitting on its knee. Doctrine of Alain Dulles. CIA Directors
              US CIA Directive 1945
              We will throw everything that we have, all gold, all material power and resources into fooling, and fooling people.
              The human brain, the minds of people are capable of change. Having sowed chaos in Russia, we will quietly replace their values ​​with false ones and make them believe in these false values ​​... We will find our like-minded people, our assistants and allies in (Russia) itself. Episode by episode will be played out with a grandiose scale tragedy of the death of the most rebellious people on earth, the final irreversible fading of his self-consciousness ...
              For example, we will gradually erase their social essence from literature and art, alienate artists, discourage them from engaging in image, investigation (research), or something, of the processes that occur in the depths of the masses.
              Literature, theaters, cinema, the press - everything will depict and glorify the most base human feelings, we will in every way support and raise the so-called artists who will plant and hammer into the human mind the cult of sex, violence, sadism, betrayal - in a word, all immorality.
      2. Uncle
        Uncle April 24 2013 13: 37
        +2
        Quote: Sirocco
        as soon as the borders were opened, and all this infection poured into our territory. Can close the borders of the castle?

        Right! The ideological border must be restored! And for the flows of religious evil spirits (Amersky preachers, sectarians) I must say thanks to Gorbachev. His mother is so ...
    6. SEM
      SEM April 24 2013 07: 30
      +6
      There can be any amount of discussion here. Militant radical Islam must be burned out with a "hot iron" And the time is running out every day since the adherents of this movement are active all over the world. Enough on TV and any news release points to this problem directly or indirectly not with what foundations of life? 80% of them are from the Caucasus. (I myself have a lot of Muslim friends who talk about this problem in concern and anxiety). And again, we do not have enough firmness and decisive measures in the country to protect the peaceful and understanding population of the country from this infection.
    7. Igarr
      Igarr April 24 2013 08: 32
      +7
      Hello to all...
      Here is a quote - "..Unfortunately, a whole range of objective contradictions and problems of our state are working for them. Including such as corruption, which we still cannot defeat or even reduce to a socially tolerant level. "
      In ordinary human language, it is a bribe.
      That's all, nothing else is needed. If the official can buy- they will definitely buy it.
      And then "Polovtsian dances" will go.
      Islam, indeed, does not have a single governing center. Imams interpret the Qur'an as to whom it is FAVORABLE.
      But not to take away the huge organizing impact of a particular jamaat on specific people.
      It’s one thing, if somewhere far away, someone scolded you (Pope, let’s say). And quite another - when your fellow villagers, fellow soldiers - turned their backs on you and your family. This is the impact of the Ummah, a community of believers.
      And here, well, in the hand - corrupt creatures in government organizations.
      Whether you are a Muslim, a Buddhist, a Jew, a Christian - well, whoever has the idea that such a corrupt person is a man of the state. What kind of state is this in which its functionaries - are sold - like whores?
      ...
      The sleep of reason gives rise to monsters.
      The dream of the state will cause chaos.
      Which we are observing.
      .
      ".. Burn the filth with a red hot iron .." With a red hot iron. Iron.
    8. igor36
      igor36 April 24 2013 08: 40
      +8
      Dear !!! Your posts are of one one-sided orientation - the Caucasus, the Caucasus. Take a look around. Tataria, Bashkiria - there they almost recruit people into jamaats openly. Further: Wahhabis, Salafists, etc., crawl around Russia along with guest workers. Wahhabism is the official religion of Saudi Arabia, all the leaders of gangs, clans, jamaats or Saudis or studied there. The whole series of colored Islamic revolutions is nonsense compared to what could be in Russia. There is a deliberate policy of weakening and destroying Russia because we have centuries of experience in the peaceful coexistence of various faiths, which prevents the world's gendarmes from dividing and dominating.
    9. UFO
      UFO April 24 2013 08: 43
      +6
      The bad news is that the radicalization of Islam in Russia is also beneficial for our Western "friends." Here the interests of both Muslims, dreaming of a caliphate, and European puppeteers, who believe that they are in control of world processes, converged. At the present stage, it is believed that Russia is a weak link in Eurocivilization, a sick colossus, a kind of "plasticine" from which a self-destructive society can be molded. They achieved some results, not without the help of our "reformers", and radical Islam for them is another means of sinking a ship named "Russia". hi
      1. hrych
        hrych April 25 2013 03: 51
        +2
        The radicalization of Islam is needed by "puppeteers" to control oil wells, the Salafis are destroying states from the inside, turning them into a territory with an illiterate, backward population and small mobile forces of punishers like the Frankish foreign legion can easily control vast territories with their resources. In the case of Russia, rather thanks to these monsters, it has survived. If there were no war in the Caucasus and terrorist attacks, the liberals would have taken away Mother Rosseya to the Ural and Siberian republics without a fight, and then after a while the best pieces of NATO, Turks and Chinese would be privatized. Many do not understand, but it was in Chechnya that New Russia was born.
    10. dc120mm
      dc120mm April 24 2013 10: 04
      12
      Very interesting article.

      Islamism is a serous threat.

      That is why the sending of the Georgian and the Russians together must be beaten. And we shoot each other. But Nadeus will get along and together wake the enemy’s community out.
      1. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 10: 27
        +5
        I don’t have anything against Orthodox Georgia, but regarding the unity of Christians around the world, here I believe that the Orthodox have more in common with Muslims of a traditional sense than with Catholics.
        1. Uncle
          Uncle April 24 2013 13: 45
          +2
          Quote: Maximus
          that the Orthodox have more in common with traditional Muslims than with Catholics.

          Well you give! For Christians, God is Christ, and Muslims do not recognize him as God. And with regard to Catholics, so they came to the point that they consider Christianity the younger brother of Judaism. Rather, the Orthodox have nothing to do with anyone. The exception will be God-seeking natures, even if they are unbelievers.
          1. Maximus
            Maximus April 24 2013 15: 07
            0
            For Orthodox Christians, God is triune - "God the Father, the Holy Spirit, and the Son of God Christ"! And by the way, Muslims revere Jesus Christ, he is just their preacher Saint Issa.
    11. Opera
      Opera April 24 2013 10: 22
      0
      Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
      Muslims of Russia, considering it (Russia) their home, cannot and do not share the aspirations of the Islamists. People like you, I’m sure, even consider the Tatars to be enemies. And Tatars, for example, second after the Russians defended our (read yours) our homeland in the Second World ..

      Quote: Kaa
      In Western countries, there is a clear desire - based on inhuman fear and hatred, to spread an anti-Islamic concept

      Quote: Nesvet Nezarya
      You are too good opinion about the Americans))))

      One cannot but agree with this! I would only like to add that one should not forget where it is financed, at whose orders it is sent, supported by information, dresses, puts on shoes and arms this very movement of "fighters for the faith"! Imagine for a moment that this support is not there! What then ?!
      Some particularly zealous authors here who actually see enemies in all Muslims would like to ask - so who is fighting with whom in Syria and with whom? Who supports and finances this war?
      We must fight the cause, not the consequence! Fight with real enemies and their accomplices in the Muslim world, and not seek and create new ones in the same Muslim world!
      Quote: Ivan Tarasov
      So you need to call a spade a spade. There is Satanism

      And I certainly agree with this too! The road to hell is paved with "good" intentions!
    12. Opera
      Opera April 24 2013 10: 28
      +3
      Quote: dc120mm
      That is why the sending of the Georgian and the Russians together must be beaten. And we shoot each other. But Nadeus will get along and together wake the enemy’s community out.
      smile Of course it will be so. Everything will work out as you say!
    13. Yeraz
      Yeraz April 24 2013 10: 45
      +1
      The nourishment of Islamism of social problems. Resolve social injustice, if you do not eradicate it, then lower this level many times and bring it to a minimum. Well, you should not forget about the traditions of certain peoples, the imposition of alien Western values ​​also leads to radicalization.
    14. newcomer
      newcomer April 24 2013 11: 06
      +1
      Quote: V. Ushakov
      Weapons, normal, firearms, for non-Islamic population and this Evil - will immediately "shrink". They are very afraid of force, of the armed force - even more so. And the picture is interesting: for this group, but large-caliber -

      absolutely correct offer !!! since our authorities and the police cannot and do not want to protect the local civilian population from come in large numbers of Basurmans (they themselves feed from them). and the Gundyaevskaya Orthodox activists are cowardly mummers, capable only of fighting with the "pussies" and slapping a lesbian in the face ... pretending that nothing "noticed" ...
    15. Rrv
      Rrv April 24 2013 11: 18
      -1
      Humanity has too many problems because of religions. In my opinion, religions based on Judaism cannot be peaceful in principle.
      1. Uncle
        Uncle April 24 2013 13: 47
        0
        Quote: RRV
        In my opinion, religions based on Judaism cannot be peaceful in principle.

        What religion is Judaism based on?
        1. Rrv
          Rrv April 24 2013 13: 52
          0
          I will answer in the best Jewish traditions: Are you familiar with the concept of "Abrahamic religions"?
    16. Krasnoyarsk
      Krasnoyarsk April 24 2013 11: 23
      +6
      The Russian Federation urgently needs to close its borders with Islamic countries, and soon Wahhabi pedrils will build Sharia in Kazan.
      1. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 11: 57
        +3
        The borders are very transparent, especially the Kazakh one; the external borders are also not that of the Union. From the same non-Muslim Georgia, how many bearded men came to us.
        1. Uncle
          Uncle April 24 2013 13: 52
          +1
          Quote: Maximus
          From the same non-Muslim Georgia, how many bearded men came to us.

          America is also a Christian country, it was, anyway. Israel is also not an Islamic state. But Syria is just Islamic. Religion has nothing to do with the foreign policy of the state.
    17. fenix57
      fenix57 April 24 2013 11: 34
      +5
      "[i] Who needs a caliphate [/ i] "One thing can be said with certainty - RUSSIA IS NOT NEEDED! AND WHY ARE THESE ALL CONFERENCES IN THE MILITARY ACADEMY of the General Staff of the Russian Federation on the topic (note!) [i] “Islamism and the national security of Russia." [/ I] - Yes, this is the same work of the FSB. Still remember this abbreviation. And what is asked to discuss ... FOR GILLS AND IN ..... Deep, deep ...
    18. knn54
      knn54 April 24 2013 12: 31
      0
      It is necessary to build a caliphate with yourself. (kill the unfaithful ... in yourself) .. then from family, then from relatives, friends, acquaintances, etc.
      The caliphate should be created by real people, and not venal puppets disguised as believers, who determine politics in the Arab world. All the absolute monarchies of the East hold on to their power, keep money in Western banks, so the Caliphate is just the least needed. There are many more contradictions between other currents of Islam than there are contradictions between Orthodoxy and Catholicism. And for the formation of the caliphate, first it is necessary that at least the Sunnis and Shiites now cease to destroy each other. It's impossible.
      And what should the builders of the "new Caliphate" take on board?
      In the Muslim world, there is no single spiritual center that would have organizational and other resources for forcing the community to unanimity.
      Classical Islam is “outlawed.” The radicals do not care who to fight for an idea, for them in this case everyone who is not with them becomes 'unfaithful' - it turns out to be an ETERNAL war.
      The project to restore the caliphate is very expensive and only the United States can finance. Western politics and finance control Muslims and their ideas. The West will not agree with the construction of the RIGHT Caliphate. In the end, the Yankees will find the last caliph and “offer” Muslims to worship him.
      PS "The Caliphate is called upon to put an end to the freedom of religious search, which is carried out within the framework of principled fidelity to the Koran and Sunnah. It will subordinate Muslims to the authority of the Caliph, who must rely in his decisions on the opinions of elected mujtahids (theologians)." –The Hizb ut-Tahrir concept. With you guys, everything is clear!
      PPS Mayor of Mogadishu correctly said "Islamists are now something of a commodity that will help the local population earn extra money." And the Somali authorities announced a reward of $ 500 for each killed Islamist. An example worthy of emulation!
    19. washi
      washi April 24 2013 13: 33
      +4
      Before the adoption of Islam, Asia was more developed (Europe - the concentration of savagery). It was not for nothing that the whole world accepted Arabic numbers - the development of mathematics, medicine was appreciated (I think many people know the name of Avicenna), Asian architecture is famous, there was a good painting. And where is ALL this? By introducing harsh Islam, we can lose ALL ALL the achievements of civilization. Many monuments in Afghanistan, Libya, and Mali have already been destroyed.
      In Kievan Rus all religions coexisted peacefully (including paganism).
      1. hrych
        hrych April 24 2013 20: 59
        +5
        A small clarification: Arabic numbers are called that, and they come from India. The culture and science of Egypt, Syria, Persia and Samarkand has nothing to do with the Arabs. The fact that the mentally retarded Arab ethnic group advanced with Islam is its merit in the degradation of civilization on these lands. A typical example is the current Arab world, which, after the colonialists left, is striving for chaos and illiteracy, and Baboon obscurantism to help it.
    20. virm
      virm April 24 2013 13: 51
      +5
      Conversations, conversations, conversations. And Evil is spreading and spreading. Under the strict guidance of the sun and the company. Millions of Asians and Caucasians come to us. Tens of thousands of some Kurds from Iraq! What for? What will all this lead to? To a lot of blood? Or to the silent disappearance of white people? How will our children live? Will we have grandchildren at all?
      If these people do not want to live in their homeland, cannot establish a normal life there, then they will turn our country into the likeness of those places where they came from. Dusty villages where Shiites kill Sunnis, Turks kill Kurds and all of them kill infidels together. Talking about correct Islam. Saying that this is all from poverty and unemployment.
      What did the Chechens lack in Boston? Someone forced them to blow up people to kill policemen?
      1. Maximus
        Maximus April 24 2013 15: 47
        +3
        A case in modern Germany; conversation on the bus of two young Turks - "there are 20 thousand of us in Cologne, 50 thousand in Berlin, etc., soon we will be the majority." Nearby sat a German old woman, who quietly told them when they got out at the bus stop - "and before the war there were thousands of Jews here" .......