Crimea-2022: fellow scientists will be left with no one

45
Crimea-2022: fellow scientists will be left with no one


From the history of hydrophysics


We must not forget about scientists, especially at the most crucial moment, as now. When Crimea came under Russian jurisdiction in 2014, many managers and employees of high-tech enterprises rejoiced: now, they say, we will live. However, after some time, rose-colored glasses fell off.



After all, except for the language on the signs, in fact, almost nothing has changed. The most disturbing thing is that such a statement directly concerns two strategically important institutions of Sevastopol, known throughout the world for their developments, including the military ones.

We are talking about the Marine Hydrophysical Institute and the Institute of Biology of the Southern Seas. In a difficult foreign policy environment, such indifference is at least surprising.

The Marine Hydrophysical Institute, which the locals in Sevastopol call Gidrofiz, was established in 1948. Its predecessors were some of the oldest Soviet marine research institutions: the Black Sea Hydrophysical Station and the Marine Hydrophysical Laboratory.

In 1963, he quite logically changed his deployment from Moscow to Sevastopol. From about that moment, Gidrofiz began to engage in reconnaissance functions, in particular, its advanced developments made it possible to establish from water samples which vessel sailed there and how long it had been in the area under study.

The Institute of Biology of the Southern Seas is also a strategic institution, as it studies the ecology of the Black Sea, which is important in the light of possible biological attacks. weapons. It is one of the oldest such institutions in the world. Its prototype was discovered in the form of the Sevastopol Biological Station back in 1971.


Until now, the IBSS is located in its building, in its right wing there is the Sevastopol Aquarium, one of the main tourist attractions of the city. The aquarium was the first institution in Russia where you could look at the living inhabitants of the sea in the water through glass; it was opened back in 1900.

Promise not to defend - hello raiders


When Crimea returned to Russia, the employees of these institutions had some hope for an improvement in the situation, since under Ukraine funding was done carelessly, in particular, the buildings of Gidrofiz in Karantinnaya Bay had not been repaired for 50 years, although Crimea was by no means under “independence” for all these years. .

In 2015, in the heat of widespread “optimization”, there were attempts to take over these institutions by the Institute of Natural and Technical Systems from the city of Sochi. It was planned to first attach Gidrofiz to the InBYuM, and then transfer the InBYuM itself to the Sochi residents. But the employees of both Gidrofiz and InBYuM managed to defend their rights.

The Marine Hydrophysical Institute has always been in close cooperation with the Institute of Biology of the Southern Seas. So close that visitors, not experienced in the subtleties of Sevastopol, often confused them. In 2015, it was planned to merge them, but then the Russian Academy of Sciences backed off.

To some extent, such a decision would be positive - after all, cooperation between related institutions. But in Gidrofiz itself, they saw in this the prospects for the liquidation and raider seizure of the institute, as was the case, for example, with the Mining University under the swearing minister Livanov.

In addition, the prospect of being taken over by a little-known Sochi institute did not please anyone. The refusal to take over the InBYuM led to the fact that the staff did not receive a salary for six months. Assistance was provided by scientists from other parts of Russia.

Swan Song of Hydrophysis


Be that as it may, but for some time Hydrofiz carried out new military developments. In 2015–2016 the institute announced new developments for the Russian Navy and participated in specialized exhibitions. He himself held the exhibition “Development of MHI for the needs of Russia and fleet».

In particular, drifting buoys, which measure the properties of water and transmit data to the satellite, which have no analogues in the whole world, were presented. The ice buoy, which is already at the disposal of the meteorological centers of the Northern Fleet, is used for observations under the thickness of the Arctic ice. Also Gidrofiz presented control-calibration and measuring ship equipment at the exhibition.

In 2015, Gidrofiz announced the start of construction at the Sevmorzavod of a new strategic research vessel Pioneer-M. But this is a pale, budget copy of his Soviet predecessor "Mikhail Lomonosov", who was safely sent for cutting in the 90s.


Meanwhile, the Ministry of Defense periodically "threatens the Swede" with the presence of powerful research vessels that have no analogues in the whole world. What prevents to transfer one of them to Hydrophys? After all, in 2015, Hydrophys was extremely brightly represented at the Army-2015 forum.
The Institute then demonstrated its developments in the field of instrumentation. First of all, these were automatic drifting buoys and ice micromarkers. Then they were also purchased by the United States and Canada as part of the Arctic program. In the same year, Gidrofiz participated in the VII International Maritime Defense Show "IMDS-2015" with its instruments for measuring the characteristics of sea water.

The exhibition-review "Developments of the MHI for the needs of Russia and the fleet" in the same 2015 was, apparently, the last military exhibition for Gidrofiz. On the eve of it, the leadership of the institute announced that it was transferring its specialization to a peaceful track. Again Gidrofiz presented measuring devices, in addition to them - optical and control and calibration.

"Top management reforms" in IBSYUM


Starting in 2015, the state began to appoint “effective managers” from Armyansk, Krasnoperekopsk and Feodosiya to the positions of the institute’s leadership, who had nothing to do with hydrobiology. By education, these are geographers, political scientists, - anyone, only people who are not related to marine biology and ecology.

During their “effective management”, the archive and the laboratory of ecotoxicology were abolished - a direction that is just relevant in connection with the aggravation of the military situation in the Black Sea. Deputy Director Andronchik also distinguished himself by issuing reprimands and fines for the fact that on Navy Day, a sacred holiday for any Sevastopol citizen, employees went out onto the balcony to greet the participants in the parade along Nakhimov Avenue.

Such behavior, expressed in unwillingness to know and respect urban traditions, is generally characteristic of the "Varangians" who flooded the city state structures. Director Gorbunov and his deputy Andronchik were also seen in fraud with gasoline coupons, which had expired.

This year, there were two scandals at once related to the activities of the new leadership of the InBYuM, and both ended in criminal cases. At first it turned out that a number of firms were renting the institute's property without the consent of the owner (i.e., in fact, there was a raider seizure, which already happened in stories Sochi firm lit up).

Without the consent of the owner, a small shipbuilding company operated a berth in Kamyshovaya Bay, which is, accordingly, federal property, since the institute belongs to the Russian Academy of Sciences. And K-Telecom LLC placed antennas on the roof of the building (the one where the famous Aquarium is located in the left wing).

The second scandal was that the 830 rubles earmarked for the renovation of the institute's premises were lost to the contractor in some unknown way. This has not been tolerated by law enforcement agencies. Yaroslav Andronchik now faces up to 4 (four - just something) years in prison.


Current position


The infrastructure of Gidrofiz is in ruins, despite the fact that targeted funding has made it possible to repair the upper building. The storm basin of the Hydrophysis in Katsiveli, near Simeiz, where studies of kinematic phenomena during storms were carried out, has long been closed and drained, the fans are either rusted or handed over for metal.

Once it was the only one in the world, the famous Typhoon project was carried out in it, and now there is not a single similar pool in the world - no others have been built. There is a chance to become the first in the world again, until they are ahead, it seems that the state has money, but only now, apparently, there is no desire at the top.

Of course, you can blame everything on the enemy America, which, after the annexation of the Crimea to Russia, refused to purchase research buoys from Hydrofiz. But, besides the NATO countries, there is also China, India and other friendly countries that have their own navies. The fact that NATO countries refuse to buy buoys is their problem, since foreign counterparts are of poorer quality. But the work of the state in the sphere of negotiations on deliveries to China, apparently, is simply not being carried out, otherwise there would be a result.

It would be wrong to say that the InBYuM, which the authorities chose as the devourer of Hydrofiz, also did not suffer from their disregard. In particular, there have been problems with the light in the institute's storage facility for a long time; it periodically turns off.

The ceiling is leaking, the whole room is in disrepair, even the stairs have no railings. Funding received in 2017 was insufficient to fully renovate the vault. Tens of thousands of hydrobionts from all over the world are kept there in containers with formalin.

In the current situation on the Black Sea, stability of scientific research in the field of ecology and military security is important for Russia (and for other Black Sea countries as well). Once the InBYuM had already saved the Black Sea from an ecological catastrophe, then the United States tried to prove the possibility of burial in the lower layer, saturated with hydrogen sulfide, of radioactive waste, they say, there is still no life there, and the Black Sea deep waters do not pass through the Bosphorus into the World Ocean.

But the institute's specialists proved the opposite: that radiation would penetrate into the Mediterranean Sea. Now the same stage has come as it was then: the second coming of the Cold War. The developments of both institutions are needed throughout the Black Sea region for the sake of military and environmental stability in the region, and it is not clear why the Russian leadership does not understand this.
45 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +35
    10 December 2022 04: 39
    As a person who has worked in Russian science for a long time, I dare say that ordinary academicians and corresponding members are no better than effective managers. Their number is constantly growing, in contrast to the number of scientists, they do almost whatever they want in their institutions, distribute grants in their favor, buy cars at the price of a Moscow kopeck piece. I knew one academician, whose signature was worth half a million. I knew one dean, to whom, for intercession, one had to come with an envelope with an amount of 5000 bucks. I heard stories about how in the 90s the rector's office with deans simply stole the salaries of employees in one very important university. I did not know only the academicians who were imprisoned, at most they asked from the director of the institute to move to a special position of scientific director of the institute for obviously illegal commerce with a considerable turnover in this very institute. And therefore I am not very surprised that with such representatives the state is not too eager to communicate with Russian science and is limited to handouts so that they do not die of hunger
    1. +11
      10 December 2022 05: 18
      There is no prophet in the Motherland, and the principle of Synergy is unknown to the grabbers. In the pursuit of personal success and wealth, the basic human virtues are forgotten, but you can’t sew pockets to a coffin. hi
      1. +12
        10 December 2022 07: 21
        Quote: Angry 55
        But you can't sew pockets to a coffin.

        The eternal right to inherit not only property, but also warm high chairs - this is their greatest urgent task.

        Quote: Angry 55
        In the pursuit of personal success and wealth, the basic human virtues are forgotten.

        In this short sentence, the whole reality of capitalism.
        1. +2
          11 December 2022 22: 55
          Knew in the USSR institutes - the directors of which were sons.
          Dads left them institutions as a legacy in the 1970s ..
          Moreover, both research institutes and universities ...
      2. +3
        11 December 2022 10: 13
        But you can leave it to the kids hi "" "
    2. +7
      10 December 2022 09: 07
      I did not know only the academicians who were imprisoned
      I don't know any of them either, although Alyoshin, the well-known reformer of AvtoVAZ, is now an academician.
      1. +4
        10 December 2022 15: 00
        Science gives indulgence, plant directors can be imprisoned, but an academician - what are you, encroaching on the sacred! There were two articles in "Izvestia" about the rector of the second honey, who employed all his acquaintances from his previous place of work, and bought hundreds of millions from a company he had created himself, so what? And nothing, forgot
    3. +6
      10 December 2022 16: 47
      As a person who has worked in Russian science for a long time, I dare say that ordinary academicians and corresponding members are no better than effective managers.


      In Russia, in general, there is an amazing paradox, every more or less “self-respecting” official tries to get a scientific degree, where all candidates and doctors of science do not spit.

      Only offhand from the higher apparatus, well, solid “scientists”
      Putin Candidate of Economic Sciences
      Medvedev PhD in Law
      the late Zhirinovsky Doctor of Philosophy
      Shoigu Candidate of Economic Sciences
      Zyuganov Doctor of Philosophy
      Mishustin Doctor of Economics.
      1. +3
        10 December 2022 17: 08
        Honor to scientists, and that almost all modern academicians became academicians after 1991, and to become a professor of the Russian Academy of Sciences it is enough to have a doctoral degree and acquaintances, nothing will be told to the society about this. The officials are bad, the Academy of Sciences is good, but what if the official average salary of the leadership of the Russian Academy of Sciences is ten times higher than the salary of a researcher (and at Moscow State University, in some faculties, the salary of a laboratory assistant is less than the minimum wage) no one will talk about this.
        1. 0
          11 December 2022 23: 05
          Quote from alexoff
          (and at Moscow State University, at some faculties, the salary of a laboratory assistant is less than the minimum wage) no one will talk about this.

          And who else to say - that 30% of civil servants have a salary equal to the minimum wage (all discharge secretaries), and another 50% of civil servants (specialists - experts and positions equal to them) have a salary floating at the level of 2 minimum wages?
          Yep, gee....
          "All civil servants are crooks / thieves / corrupt officials" (c) folk
          1. 0
            11 December 2022 23: 47
            It is unlikely that someone will point a finger at an aunt in the social security and call her a swindler and a thief. But here’s what’s characteristic - a crowd of dull active students from all sorts of kvns and student councils, all as one for the opposition and the change of power, but on the anniversary of Sadovnichy, who has been the rector since 1992, they licked his fifth point so that I suppose surgeons were called in to give him back the opportunity to go to the toilet . And employees at the rate of 10 thousand will stubbornly endure ...
      2. +5
        10 December 2022 17: 16
        “self-respecting” official tries to get a scientific degree

        Well, what are you ... Forgivable petty ambition. Doctor of Science, Hero of Russia ... In ancient Greece in general
        out in the descendants of the gods seriously recorded. The gods descended to earth from Olympus, slept with ordinary aunts. And officials were already born from them .... wassat
        So we are waiting for the conclusion of a genetic examination about the relatives of Yaroslav the Wise and Alexander Nevsky ....
        1. 0
          11 December 2022 23: 15
          Quote: dauria
          Well, what are you ... Forgivable petty ambition. Doctor of Sciences, Hero of Russia ..

          Order of Victory and a pair of GSS ....
    4. +3
      10 December 2022 18: 41
      Quote from alexoff
      And therefore I am not very surprised that with such representatives the state is not too eager to communicate with Russian science and is limited to handouts so that they do not die of hunger

      Those who govern the state are the same "academicians" themselves. Could have supported the brothers in mind. Classic from classic:
      "At the Academy of Sciences
      Prince Dunduk is in session..."
      1. +4
        10 December 2022 18: 50
        As I already wrote here - scientists will completely give odds to any official in the case of cuts. Do the examples of Berezovsky and Nemtsov mean nothing to you? Well, they started just as scientists, and not as children of officials
    5. +1
      11 December 2022 08: 21
      that's because we, knowing a lot of facts, each in our own field, indifferently look at this similar thing happening all the time for many years ... Actually, why there are no "breakthroughs".
    6. 0
      13 December 2022 09: 31
      Quote from alexoff
      As a person who has worked in Russian science for a long time, I dare say that ordinary academicians and corresponding members are no better than effective managers. Their number is constantly growing, in contrast to the number of scientists, they do almost whatever they want in their institutions, distribute grants in their favor, buy cars at the price of a Moscow kopeck piece. I knew one academician, whose signature was worth half a million. I knew one dean, to whom, for intercession, one had to come with an envelope with an amount of 5000 bucks. I heard stories about how in the 90s the rector's office with deans simply stole the salaries of employees in one very important university. I did not know only the academicians who were imprisoned, at most they asked from the director of the institute to move to a special position of scientific director of the institute for obviously illegal commerce with a considerable turnover in this very institute. And therefore I am not very surprised that with such representatives the state is not too eager to communicate with Russian science and is limited to handouts so that they do not die of hunger

      And therefore, the most effective way to work with scientists in our country is "sharashki"!!!!!! Full control over the personnel, demand for the assigned tasks!! And most importantly - do not steal anything! A smart man was I.V. Stalin.
      1. +1
        13 December 2022 21: 34
        Better normal sharashki, where not starving. The problem is that the government itself does not know what to ask of these sharashkas. Now scientists are asked for articles in scientific journals, like medals from athletes. So actually in the West in 95%. But there is no sense in such a science for the country, because one scientist will develop what, and then you will build a plant chtol? It is difficult and expensive, but everything needs to be changed! But the production of articles in the Russian Federation has grown three times over 10 years, even grannies have learned to write in foreign magazines.
  2. +12
    10 December 2022 05: 58
    There were many such scientific institutes that were closed. And scientists scattered all over the world. There is capitalism, there is nightmarish capitalism. Since it became cool at home, I began to search the Internet for a battery to change in the summer. I came across an interesting detail that refreshed my thoughts. Advertising - a cast-iron battery, painted antique, is served as a luxury item. And we were entirely cast-iron batteries. So it turns out that what was the subject of everyone became the subject of the elect. And what was the lot of narrow-minded people became public. Yesterday, after listening to Devyatov, I decided to see what stratagems are. It turned out to be more difficult than I expected. But one sense nevertheless caught. Before starting military operations, it is necessary to have complete information about the enemy. I will study further. Until I finally go crazy.
    1. +3
      10 December 2022 08: 39
      Quote: Nikolay Malyugin
      I will study further.

      The democrats also studied them intensively, mastered at least two to perfection.
    2. Eug
      +2
      11 December 2022 21: 21
      Complete information about the enemy is fantastic. There is always a "fog of war" (according to Clausewitz), and how the command and staff deal with this "fog" is the essence of military art.
  3. +11
    10 December 2022 06: 31
    it is not clear why the Russian leadership does not understand this
    And then he claims that Russia depends on foreign technology.
  4. +1
    10 December 2022 06: 43
    In fact, for such articles there is a specialized site compromat.ru
    Why "take away bread" from specialists in pouring mud on each other.
    Well, the "icing on the cake" is at least the double use of the ambiguous expression "having no analogues in the world."
    1. +4
      10 December 2022 06: 58
      Quote: Amateur
      Why "take away bread" from specialists in pouring mud on each other.

      sense from this, we are so accustomed to this that we are already distrustful of the really positive in science! If you dig on the result .... Window dressing is in our blood!
  5. +8
    10 December 2022 06: 46
    Again I will quote Timur Shaov, the song "Comrade Scientists 2".
    ... You do not complain about poverty, does science require sacrifices?
    So you are being sacrificed along with science at the same time.
    The country is atypical, the country is extraordinary,
    For us, any action is always equal to zero.
    Systems are unsystematic, standards are non-standard,
    Space is not Euclidean, who the hell knows whose it is."
    I recommend listening to it along with the song "Gods lived on Olympus" ...
  6. +2
    10 December 2022 08: 20
    the balcony was probably emergency, so they fined it out of harm's way.
    in some places there are still such islands of the past, a couple of old employees from centenarians are sitting there, surrounded by installations of the 60s and around them a bunch of younger opportunists who dream of resuming millions of injections from the budget as in the good old days of the cold war. tell journalists tales about analogues.
    in the LPR-DPR, there are also several such offices under loud signs, but judging by what has been happening here since 14g. they have no chance at all.
  7. +5
    10 December 2022 08: 22
    As a resident of Sochi, they were interested in what kind of Institute of Natural Technical Systems from Sochi wanted to absorb Hydrophys. It turned out that the material was not presented correctly, with some intent. it has a branch in Sochi. For the first time I hear that branches capture something in the city where the Institute of Natural and Technical Problems itself is located. I am far from science, but after reading the Institute's release, it seems to me that they are doing the same thing as Hydrophys. The Institute of Natural and Technical Problems is a Federal State Unitary Enterprise, so everything is fine with money, they have their own website in VK. Who is interested.
  8. +2
    10 December 2022 08: 34
    there’s also such a moment as renting out “state property”. I don’t know how it is in Crimea, but the LPR-DPR strictly monitor how they don’t rent out something at “prices lower than those set by the state” (that is, at the real market price) and these structures and remains Antediluvian equipment continued to successfully deteriorate, fall apart, rust and be plundered instead of a real market approach, especially in war conditions.
    here are the empty dead buildings of the former institutes and workshops, delighting the eyes of local repainted dill and saboteurs with devastation and silence and the absence of any additional problems.
  9. -2
    10 December 2022 12: 48
    Actually, I'm interested. If not all, then many of us are waiting for a kind uncle who would come and solve all their problems for them. I will call those ungrateful pigs who do not see the huge efforts that Russia is making to resuscitate the Crimea. Look around. Don't you see the "rich" heritage left by Bandera? Much has certainly changed after the return of the Crimea to the Russian Harbor, but the remains of ruins, the ruins of houses, broken roads, and rotten engineering communications are still preserved. Count how many hundreds of billions of rubles Russia has invested in the construction of the Crimean bridge, the Taurida highway, in the improvement of Simferopol and Sevastopol. Until now, in Simferopol, there is an endless battle for the resuscitation of the water supply, sewerage systems, and electricity supply. If anyone thinks that they will be paid millions of rubles for the creation of flightless butterflies, then they are deeply mistaken. Now Russia is in dire need of advanced developments of marine robots, flying drones, we need promising means of transport (ekranoplans, amphibious aircraft), the country needs explored deposits of natural gas and oil. The country vitally needs means of protecting military and civilian facilities from attacks by enemy drones, from rocket and artillery attacks. We need help in restoring the huge destruction from the Bandera aggression in settlements. Christ said: "Knock and it will be opened to you!" Go and knock, offer your services to help your fellow citizens, whom I mentioned here, write, offer Putin and all officials your plans in this applied R&D, training of specialists in these promising areas and you will be opened, given millions, billions for your promising plans!
    1. 0
      11 December 2022 17: 22
      What kind of resuscitation of the Crimea are you writing about? In Crimea, a complete mess, as well as throughout the country. For example, 5 years ago I bought a can of Crimean sprat in a tomato - I threw it away, it is not possible to eat. I recently bought Crimean sprats, made in Simfiropol on Karl Marx Street - I threw it away, it's impossible to eat. I decided to buy sprats from the Moscow region - I didn’t finish it, I threw it away. I would like to be a patriot, but I can't. I'd rather buy Baltic sprats.
      1. +1
        11 December 2022 23: 28
        Quote: Fan-Fan
        I'd rather buy Baltic sprats.

        And they have been doing it for a long time with liquid smoke and not smoked ...
        The last time I saw delicious ones for 210 rubles in a glass of St. Petersburg - about 3 years ago. Everything that is cheaper than 150 rubles per jar is rubbish for a long time
        1. for
          +1
          12 December 2022 01: 11
          Quote: your1970
          And they've been doing it for a long, long time Liquid smoke, not smoked...

          Tea brewing and not any smokes, not liquid, not hot, not refrigeration.
  10. +3
    10 December 2022 13: 01
    Ask Elon Musk where he got the money from. He will tell you how you can and should earn money. Everywhere and everywhere smart, competent specialists are valued!!!!
    1. +1
      10 December 2022 14: 56
      He has money from the state and unknown investors, and his smart, competent specialists from NASA and a bunch of other rocket factories, including from the FSU
  11. +2
    10 December 2022 13: 27
    modern Russia cannot be understood with the mind
  12. +1
    10 December 2022 22: 02
    In general, indeed, both in civilian and military science, we, unfortunately, have a very ambiguous situation ...
  13. +4
    10 December 2022 22: 33
    Quote from alexoff
    He has money from the state and unknown investors, and his smart, competent specialists from NASA and a bunch of other rocket factories, including from the FSU

    The greatness (I'm not afraid of this word) of the Mask lies in the fact that he gathered it all together, did not let thieves take it away through the bottomless pockets and made him work. And not just, but effectively.
    Once in the USSR there were also figures of a similar specialization. Which "dragged" entire industries and scientific areas.
    And now they have Musk, and we have this ... like him ... "trampoline" rubber.
  14. +2
    10 December 2022 22: 52
    So very often here and there there is news about the diamond salaries of the authorities, about financial fraud, etc.
    Landings? So their own, who will plant their own?
    1. 0
      11 December 2022 10: 21
      Well, if there are plantings, then it turns out that the "vertical of power" built by someone turned out to be simply rotten, but there will be very plantings, then the planted people will talk, and for what, those and those also did the same and further along the chain hi
  15. 0
    11 December 2022 11: 18
    What kind of nonsense in the comments?
    The article describes the difficulties and the decadent state of two defense-scientific enterprises in the region, which are important for the state in general and the Black Sea Fleet in particular.
    And in the comments, the controversy of academic businessmen is divorced from reality, or they recall the disassembly of scientists in the struggle for funding and grants.
    ALE, so that's why it happens that domestic science has problems with funding. A dozen universities and several institutes are plowed throughout the country. And then, mainly in Moscow and St. Petersburg. And the fact that there are still universities and institutions in the country does not bother me about the current policy.
    They constantly complain about the fact that minds are leaving Russia - because for many scientific fields and industries in Russia, there are no prospects for conducting research. In a year, 1000 microbiologists conditionally graduated. And from the bottom only 400-500 will go to the specialty. The rest will either have to go to another job (and then it turns out that several years of training as a microbiologist were wasted), or go to do science in those countries where there is always a demand for scientists (and the corresponding salary).
    1. +1
      11 December 2022 23: 44
      Quote: Mustachioed Kok
      In a year, 1000 microbiologists conditionally graduated. And from the bottom only 400-500 will go to the specialty.
      - it has always been and will always be - screening out those who are not able to gnaw granite For the sake of science. And in the USSR they sat in the Ministry of Taxes and Duties on penny salaries .....
      1. +1
        12 December 2022 21: 03
        So I should have initially clarified that we are not talking about "bachelors" who, in fact, are "primary" higher education. And about the masters and those who graduated from graduate school. There are about a thousand such people. Tens/hundreds of thousands of bachelors are graduating every year. But masters and candidates are already piece specialists. And to maintain an education system that such specialists leads to the choice of a lack of places is a problem. And there is an important error in your example. Many of those who went to sit in the MNF are people who truly perform the role of advanced scientists worse. But even they have sometimes settled in the industry to, at least nothing, but fulfill the tasks that they can perform because of their education.
        Our problem is that in some areas even a HIGH-CLASS specialist may not find a job, because the current leadership needs in some area is limited to a couple of enterprises throughout the country, and even if you crack, don’t cram EVERYONE into these 2 enterprises.
        Secondly, many people leave not because they are "not able to gnaw on granite for the sake of science", but because they simply do not pay much. At the same time, they look at the same specialty in some other country, and see that they pay more there. Moreover, it is no longer in numerical terms, but in the total total. Salaries in another country are not just enough to live on, but there you don’t have to live from salary to salary. And in the Union with the payment of scientists who have proven themselves as experienced specialists and leading scientists / professors - there were no problems with the RFP most of the time.
  16. +1
    11 December 2022 17: 43
    The Russian hand does not understand a lot of things. However, if you look at those who lead the European Union, then the emotions are also negative. There is a degradation of leadership cadres. Well, Russia no longer has such pillars as Chernomyrdin, Primakov, Vyakhirev... Europe can only dream of Schroeder, Berlusconi, Chirac. Europe does not care, but our affairs are seams. From intelligence to culture and medicine, mediocrity and corrupt officials rule everywhere. The Crimeans have long lost their rose-colored glasses. Although ... In the 404th, it would still be worse. The article is correct, useful, the author is a good fellow, one cannot remain silent. Ancestors created, went to the world level, and we... Are we rolling the legacy?
    1. 0
      11 December 2022 23: 55
      Quote: Glagol1
      From intelligence to culture and medicine, mediocrity and corrupt officials rule everywhere.

      Apparently in 1941 alone literate professionals ruled, when did they reach Moscow in 5 months?
      1. 0
        12 December 2022 23: 45
        Not in 5, but in 4 months. And then there were enough stupid ones, sycophants and careerists. I still wonder how they survived. The people were like that, they didn’t bend.