Ukrainian ex-prime minister: Ignoring the Budapest Memorandum is a threat not only to Ukraine, but to the whole world

Former Prime Minister, Head of the SBU and Secretary of the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine Yevhen Marchuk spoke about the implementation of the Budapest Memorandum. Recall that this memorandum was adopted in 1994 and marked Ukraine's accession to the nuclear nonproliferation treaty. weapons.

For some time now, Ukraine has accused Russia of allegedly violating the letter of the Budapest Memorandum, since the treaty implies security guarantees for a country that has renounced nuclear weapons (and received them). At the same time, Kiev for some reason does not put forward claims against the United States and Great Britain, which also signed the documents of the memorandum.

According to Marchuk, ignoring the Budapest Memorandum is a threat not only to Ukraine, but to "the whole world."

The ex-head of the Ukrainian government said that "it is necessary to return immediately to the implementation of the clauses of the agreement." According to Marchuk, he opposed and continues to oppose the initiative coming from individual politicians to start developing nuclear weapons in the country.

Marchuk notes that in this case, "Ukraine may be among such countries as North Korea and Iran, which ignore the treaty on the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons."

Marchuk proposes to create an “analytical group” in Ukraine, which would conduct a “brainstorming” session to develop recommendations for compliance with all the requirements of the Budapest Memorandum. It is not entirely clear just who these recommendations should be addressed to.

Marchuk added that "compliance with the points of the memorandum should become the basis for the reintegration of Crimea." And here the question is - the basis for whom? .. The Crimeans made their choice long ago, and now the inhabitants of the peninsula are definitely not interested in the problems of Ukraine.

For reference: Yevgeniy Marchuk is an ex-employee of the KGB of the USSR, the Security Council of Ukraine (the first head of this special service), worked as head of government in 1995-1996.

Comments

[Crowe]

Crimeans made their choice long ago

Crimea is ours, Marchuk and everyone else. Forget it.

[soul]

Quote: Crowe

Marchuk and everyone else. Forget

They are forced to remind, otherwise they will not be fed.

[SSR]

Quote: alma

Quote: Crowe

Marchuk and everyone else. Forget

They are forced to remind, otherwise they will not be fed.

I absolutely agree.
As they can try to remind of themselves, hoarse OZE with DR congratulated China, Slovenia, Kazakhstan .. and the rest of Ukraine's partners, simply ignored the tattered and actually spent and became a rogue bantustan.
It is necessary to remind that at least they give loans.
PS.
And they themselves wanted to violate this memorandum by joining NATO and providing bases in Crimea.

[Zoldat_A]

Quote from S.S.R.

How can they try to remind themselves

Quote from S.S.R.

It is necessary to remind that at least they give loans.

And if, moreover, it is not easy to cry to the Boss in the vest that we are, they say, small and weak, they are offended - but to tell fairy tales about how "the aggressor threatens the whole world" "that" give me money before these hordes take over the whole world "- then, you see, knock out a tear and it will turn out ...
And as a small denyuzhka for old age (own) and children (his) on bread, this tear will drop into the pocket ...

[novel66]

and he was never Ukrainian, by and large ... Khrushch, bastard

[figwam]

Quote: novel xnumx

Khrushch, bastard

And Yeltsin?

[novel66]

here the convection words end

[Sergej1972]

Well, then add Malenkov and Voroshilov. They also approved the transfer. At the time of the transfer, Malenkov was still the main thing in the eyes of the people in the USSR.

[novel66]

Comrade Malenkov himself ... I'll remember ...

[SSR]

So they also imposed sanctions against China !! Zelensky licks the 5 point of the United States so hard that it will soon be erased.
Ze is a real addict.

[Filxnumx]

Ze is a real addict.

Rather, a coprophile. Although, the eggs are the same, no matter how you look.

[Mountain shooter]

Quote: Crowe

Crimea is ours, Marchuk and everyone else. Forget

Naive ... They still believe in something ... in a kind and strong uncle who will come, give a candy, pat on the head ... And he will solve all insults ... So he is ... and very close. Yes, only you did so many nasty things to this uncle and said - and you continue ... He tolerates you already through force. Not to take the belt. And the one overseas - he doesn't care about you ... He will look with pleasure at the demonstration flogging. At most, he will accuse him of child abuse ...

[Nyrobsky]

Quote: Mountain Shooter

Naive ... They still believe in something ... in a kind and strong uncle who will come, give a candy, pat on the head ... And he will solve all insults ... So he is ... and very close. Yes, only you have done so many nasty things to this uncle and said - and continue ... He tolerates you already through force. Not to take the belt. And the one overseas - he doesn't care about you ... He will look with pleasure at the demonstrative flogging. Maximum - accused of child abuse.

That's all right. They screwed up themselves, now they whine at all corners. They decided to join NATO, which possesses nuclear weapons and broke its promise not to move to the borders of Russia, that is, the official position of Kuev led to the fact that a nuclear NATO would be located on the territory of Ukraine, which changes the status of this territory stipulated in the Budapest Memorandum. Let them now walk in the forest and smoke dungs ​​wrapped in a memorandum.

[Mykhalych]

A memorandum is just a document of intent, which sets out in detail the factual side of an international issue, provides an analysis of certain provisions, provides a justification for the state's position. And that Russia is threatening the outskirts with the use of nuclear weapons? ...

[mitroha]

Quote: Mykhalych

And that Russia is threatening the outskirts with the use of nuclear weapons? ...

And that Russia in general is threatening the outskirts with something?
Every day they have so the statement of another frostbitten Russophobe or one who wants to become famous for this degenerate. So writing "news" about these pearls is just feeding the trolls. It's time to tie

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Mitroha

And that Russia in general is threatening the outskirts with something?

Well, the Tribaltika has been feeding on tales for how many years that we are about to capture it. And what are these - are they worse? They also want ...

[novel66]

The outskirts would like to threaten ... but nothing

[nnm]

1. Ukrainian politicians are very similar to pop stars, released in circulation - well, at least somehow, but remind about yourself.
No matter what, just to appear in the media. They strongly resemble Volochkova in her eternal twine.
2. I will not say 100%, but at the time of signing the documents, in fact, there was no poison weapon in any republic. Exported simultaneously from all the republics in just 1 night. A kind of last greetings from the GRU General Staff of the USSR. Two sources have independently confirmed. But how it really happened - I don't know. But all the talk now about nuclear weapons for Ukraine is the cheapest, but deadly populism for them. The United States will be the first to take down these monkeys with a poisonous grenade at their very first steps.
3. The memorandum is only a protocol of intent, it does not impose any legally significant obligations. Therefore, it is absolutely pointless to wake up this topic. Or a beggar country wants to seriously present something to the strongest countries in the world? Well, apparently, a few more areas in the west and east are pressing ...

[Thrifty]

Well, it worked out its 30 hryvnias, read the text memorized by heart, so that the Natsiks would not rip their heads off, spat in the direction of Russia, and what ??? There, there are ten dozen such entities! Many will still grunt inappropriately towards our country, showing their true - rotten from the inside - essence! !!

[Pavel73]

Alas, Soviet Ukraine in this regard was no better than Bandera's. Ukrainian communists viewed the Great October Socialist Revolution only as a means to "free themselves from the imperial oppression of Moscow." Hiding behind this their own imperial ambitions to create "Rus-Ukraine", in which the leading role would belong not to Moscow, but to Kiev. That is why they instantly repainted in rabid Bandera as soon as the USSR collapsed.

[Pavel73]

Nuclear weapons - THIS ?! There are no fools!

[Vadim Golubkov]

And it never belonged to them.

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Pavel73

Nuclear weapons - THIS ?! There are no fools!

For some reason, I have a stable feeling that if they had at least a couple, at least tactical charges, they would have shied them long ago in Donbas. The "cynical Banders" have no boundaries of cynicism ... And the hunt to be at least something like the Master. Those didn’t take a lot of steam when Hiroshima and Nagasaki were burned - on the contrary, they take credit for it. Well, THESE there too ... Would ...

[Pavel73]

No, a little bit wrong. If they had nuclear weapons, then not a single canal would have dared to arrange a "Maidan" there. For this, they signed the Budapest memorandum, and the nuclear weapons were removed from Ukraine. So that you can fearlessly arrange all this bedlam there and turn into an enemy of Russia, without fear that the situation will get out of control, and someone will fly with a vigorous loaf.

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Pavel73

If they had nuclear weapons, then not a single canal would have dared to arrange a "Maidan" there.

Now the Nazis are shouting there that, in the event of Russian aggression, they have 15 nuclear charges with which they will meet the "aggressor." By the number of operating power units at their 4 NPPs ...

15 Chernobyls - what kind of brains do you need to have? Rather, how much one should not have them ...

[sergo1914]

For reference: Yevgeniy Marchuk is an ex-employee of the KGB of the USSR, the Security Council of Ukraine (the first head of this special service), worked as head of government in 1995-1996.

In the late 80s - early 90s, the KGB became a forge for the release of some kind of mutants.

[Kot_Kuzya]

Quote: sergo1914

In the late 80s - early 90s, the KGB became a forge for the release of some kind of mutants.

This is the "merit" of Andropov, who was the head of the KGB, and then, becoming secretary general, promoted Gorbachev.

[hagen]

Quote: sergo1914

In the late 80s - early 90s, the KGB became a forge for the release of some kind of mutants.

All our successes in overcoming the united Caucasus-Arab terrorism have been achieved, together with others, these, as you have deigned to say, "mutants". Maybe you know who is capable of more? Maybe there are areas of nationalist politics in Ukraine that are not occupied by graduates of the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Ministry of Defense, the entire spectrum of civil institutions of the former USSR? Maybe Klimkin was not brought up in Moscow? Maybe Naev is not a Kremlin man? No need to throw manure on a decent organization. Ask yourself better, what would have happened to the country if it were not for the work of the overwhelming majority of those fighters of the invisible front ?! Who would have prevented terrorist attacks in the country today if it were not for the pupils of those who previously bore the title of this Structure? No need to say nonsense ...

[mark1]

Is it important for us to know what Marchuk thinks? Let the thought grow richer.

[Vadim Golubkov]

And if there were mines with nuclear missiles in Estonia or Georgia and some components for nuclear missiles were assembled there ... would it also be considered that Estonia and Georgia possessed and had their own nuclear weapons, but they had to abandon it?

[letinant]

The Budapest Memorandum has not been ratified by two parties, the United States and the Russian Federation. Therefore, it is not considered effective, POINT!

[7,62x54]

As soon as the raguli begin to push their brains, the percentage of methane in the atmosphere immediately increases.

[aszzz888]

Marchuk notes that in this case, "Ukraine may be among such countries as North Korea and Iran, which ignore the treaty on the non-proliferation of nuclear weapons."

You were clearly told - then forget about your statehood. Although what kind of statehood is there !, thrown rubbish and not raised by anyone.

[rocket757]

According to Marchuk, ignoring the Budapest Memorandum is a threat not only to Ukraine, but to "the whole world."

This is understandable, a vigorous grenade, in the hands of the Skakuas, it is a threat and some other.

[Thompson]

How many parasites lived in the USSR and pretended to be both communists and defenders

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Thompson

How many parasites lived in the USSR and pretended to be both communists and defenders

General Vlasov, it turns out, all his adult life only dreamed about the overthrow of the communist regime, about the liberation of the Russian people from the bloody oppression of the Bolsheviks. True, he began to do something for this only when he was captured and wanted to live at ANY PRICE. Even at the cost of the most disgusting betrayal ...

No, well, it is understandable - there was no democracy in Soviet Russia in the 20s and 30s, and no one knew about Western liberal values ​​... ". Or at least a single picket on Red Square. So the Soviet power had to secretly hate and suffer under its yoke alone, under a blanket ...

And all of them, bastards, are such ...

[steelmaker]

"The bewilderment of adults - shooting for children."
So it is in politics!

[Dzafdet]

This memorandum has not been ratified by the State Duma. So it's just a piece of paper. Rest, uncle!

[Dzafdet]

Quote: nnm

1. Ukrainian politicians are very similar to pop stars, released in circulation - well, at least somehow, but remind about yourself.
No matter what, just to appear in the media. They strongly resemble Volochkova in her eternal twine.
2. I will not say 100%, but at the time of signing the documents, in fact, there was no poison weapon in any republic. Exported simultaneously from all the republics in just 1 night. A kind of last greetings from the GRU General Staff of the USSR. Two sources have independently confirmed. But how it really happened - I don't know. But all the talk now about nuclear weapons for Ukraine is the cheapest, but deadly populism for them. The United States will be the first to take down these monkeys with a poisonous grenade at their very first steps.
3. The memorandum is only a protocol of intent, it does not impose any legally significant obligations. Therefore, it is absolutely pointless to wake up this topic. Or a beggar country wants to seriously present something to the strongest countries in the world? Well, apparently, a few more areas in the west and east are pressing ...

You're right. Instead of warheads, they were left with dummies with waste inside ...

[kit88]

in Ukraine, Russia is accused of allegedly violating the letter of the Budapest Memorandum, since the treaty implies security guarantees for a country that has renounced nuclear weapons

Guarantees are guarantees, but the banks should not be confused.
There is no need to pull the tiger by the mustache; no guarantees will help here.

[sergo1914]

Quote: Hagen

Ask yourself better, what would have happened to the country if it were not for the work of the overwhelming majority of those fighters of the invisible front ?!

The country fell apart. Including, thanks to such "fighters". And all the consequences are the result of the fact that all the "fighters" wanted to become kings, to eat in three throats together with their retinue, to do winemaking on weekends.

[prior]

Today, the sense of the Budapest Memorandum is like a textbook on the History of the CPSU, handed over to a waste paper collection point.

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: prior

Today, the sense of the Budapest Memorandum is like a textbook on the History of the CPSU, handed over to a waste paper collection point.

There is more sense from the history textbook of the CPSU - it is heavier. ...
I remember - the Talmud is three fingers thick ...

[nov_tech.vrn]

The dog barks in the wind. For what purpose are the chatter of this "nobody", which has long been called "no way", is relayed?

[rotmistr60]

Yevhen Marchuk is a former employee of the KGB of the USSR, the Security Council of Ukraine (the first head of this special service), worked as head of government in 1995-1996.

From the second position (SBU), the transformation of a Soviet man into a Ukrainian nationalist, obsessed with the "greatness" of Ukraine and the integration of Crimea (where?), Began. They have already buzzed their ears with this Budapest Memorandum. And the red line is that if we (Ukraine) had not given up nuclear weapons, then today Russia would already be on its knees before us. In a word, nonsense in a head without brains. The only positive thing is that Marchuk recognizes that there are people in the country who are eager to get nuclear weapons.

[Reviews]

Marchuk proposes to create an “analytical group” in Ukraine, which would conduct a “brainstorming” session to develop recommendations for compliance with all the requirements of the Budapest Memorandum.

would brainstorm

Brainstorm - operational a method of solving problems, in which the participants in the discussion generate the maximum number of solutions to the problem, including the most fantastic and stupid.

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Avis

Brainstorming is an operational method for solving problems, in which the participants in the discussion generate the maximum number of solutions to the problem, including the most fantastic and stupid.

That's why normal people have a special person who rejects "the most fantastic and stupid".

On the outskirts of this to do something. And since "the most fantastic and stupid", as a rule, seem to be the most interesting - that is why we have on the outskirts what has ...

[Bare]

The memorandum is just a treaty on the non-use of nuclear weapons on the territory of Ukraine, I just emphasize the treaty. Marchuk is a bastard who at one time took an active part in the sawing of Ukraine, squeezing out private business while in leadership positions.

[Andrei Nikolaevich]

First, a memo is not a contract. The rights and obligations of the parties are not implied. You cannot "violate" something that is not. By and large, Ukraine gave up nuclear weapons in exchange for an empty piece of paper. The Ukrainian authorities acting at that time could not but know this. Ukraine, now sit and keep quiet about the fact that someone other than Russia "violated" something there. Otherwise, the forelocks will lose all support, from political to military. Even a child can understand what Pan Marchuk said. But the train is gone ...

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Andrey Nikolaevich

First, a memo is not a contract. The rights and obligations of the parties are not implied. You cannot "violate" something that is not.

That would be enough. Then you can not say anything - everything is said.

My mother-philologist taught me, in case of doubt, to turn to this book - everything is written there.

There it is said in Russian in white that

MEMORANDUM, memorandum, husband. (lat. memorandum - "what must be remembered") (official).
1. A diplomatic note outlining the government's views on an issue. [...]

I, Andrei Nikolayevich, somehow do not see that in the interpretation of the word "memorandum" there is something about obligations. I don't think you see either. And the Okraintsy have forgotten the Russian language so much that they see the word "obligations" in the "statement of the government's views"?

Panopticon, damn it ... "Field of Miracles" ...

[Andrei Nikolaevich]

Your mom is a smart woman. As far as I understand you, we had the same childhood. Unlike you, I was "directed" (when questions arise) to the Great Soviet Encyclopedia.) Such a weighty book, you know ...) I will add to you that the Outskirts have forgotten not only the Russian language, but also history and other general education sciences. Degradation, complete.
But in fact, why do they need studies and science? In order to scrub toilets around the world, science and knowledge are not required. It is enough to know exchange rates. Everything is pretty practical ... ()

[Zoldat_A]

Quote: Andrey Nikolaevich

I was "directed" (when questions arise) to the Great Soviet Encyclopedia.) Such a weighty book, you know ...)

30 weighty books ... It still stands on the shelf and is used. Third edition 1969-1978. This is approximately

Quote: Andrey Nikolaevich

that the Okraintsy have forgotten not only the Russian language, but also history and other general education sciences.

The trouble is that they have not just forgotten history, they have created a NEW history, their own, through the looking glass.
I still laugh at their "story ...

“The ancient language of the Indians, Sanskrit, is close to Ukrainian. Also, the geographical names of western and southern countries and peoples, such as Galatea, Galileans, France (Gaul), Galicia in Spain or Portugal (Porto Galia), probably indicate that the ancestors of modern French, Spaniards, Portuguese, Jews and Turks could have come to these lands from Ukrainian Galicia, ”says the Ukrainian textbook on geography for 8th grade students.

An irresistible desire for the stars is a feature of the Ukrainian character. It found its real manifestation in technical creativity in rocketry and space exploration. Ukrainians have done more in this area than all other nations of the world put together ...

The incredibly rich, diverse and beautiful nature of Ukraine gave rise to the phenomenal qualities of the Ukrainian nation, which it spread throughout the world. Everywhere on Earth, where there are black earth soils, Ukrainians live and cultivate the land - the most ancient grain-growing nation in the world. Today, genetically Ukrainian wheat, which was brought by Ukrainian settlers to the USA, Russia, Canada, Kazakhstan, Argentina, feeds the whole world ...

American scientists consider Ukrainians to be the most ancient nation in the world. They explain their assertion by the fact that the Ukrainian nation is the only one in the world, which originates from the millennial depths of matriarchy. Only among Ukrainians a human being is called a feminine word - “lyudyna”. Only among Ukrainians is a woman a man, in all other nations a man is a man (man, man, man, man, homo)

And then in the same spirit ... Poor, poor Ukrainian eighth graders ...
.
And, which has already become a traditional phrase for me when it comes to Ukraine - freak show, damn it ...

[Andrei Nikolaevich]

Amused ... thanks .... Now it's my turn.
I repeat word for word. Quote from the speech of the doctor of sciences (forgot the last name) I heard it myself. With my ears. I was speechless, for a couple of seconds.
"Hercules was born in Ukraine"

[Jaromir]

Marchuk added that “compliance with the points of the memorandum should become the basis for the reintegration of Crimea”

Invaders in Ukraine are completely crazy. Everyone dreams of returning Crimea to their occupation regime
Do not wait.

[Growlers]

A memorandum is a state's statement of intent. That's it. Now the question is why Ukraine did not RATIFY the Budapest Memorandum, since it is so interested in it? So this opinion of Marchuk is either a manifestation of senile marasmus or special cunning

[Gennady Fomkin]

Oh, I remembered the Budapest Memorandum - which Ukraine itself did not ratify

[Gennady Fomkin]

The man who cheated 43 million people in Ukraine

[georggy]

Marchuk your way: suitcase Warsaw train station!

[Prisoner]

Where is the whole world and where is Banderland? Calm down, slaughter!

[Filxnumx]

Marchuk proposes to create an “analytical group” in Ukraine, which would conduct a “brainstorming” session to develop recommendations for compliance with all the requirements of the Budapest Memorandum.

Memorandum is an informational and reference document setting out views on any issue. It can be used in diplomatic relations, business, as a memorandum or reference within the organization.
The memorandum does not imply any "requirements", it does not impose any obligations on the signatory parties, except for one: non-use (threat of use) of nuclear weapons by the signatory countries (Russia, the USA and the World Bank) against Ukraine as a state that has abandoned its nuclear weapons and signed the Treaty about its non-proliferation.