Military Review

Successful reforms in Russia in recent years from the point of view of ordinary citizens

241

The domestic policy of the Russian Federation in recent years has caused more and more questions among the population. Too many unpopular measures have been taken. What is, for example, a pension reform with an increase in the retirement age, for example? Few also favor the tax policy of the Russian state. Meanwhile, there have been certain advantages over the past ten years, and it is easy to name them.


What are the successful reforms from the point of view of ordinary citizens.

First of all, these are, of course, measures aimed at supporting demography, namely, the payment of maternity capital. Since 2020, families in which their first child was born on January 1, 2020 and later began to receive maternity capital. For families who also gave birth to a second child during this period, the amount of maternity capital is increased by 150 thousand rubles.

Recall that for many Russian families, especially in the provinces, the payment of maternity capital is one of the few chances to acquire their own home, while not giving up the birth of a child. After all, before people faced a dilemma - either we are giving birth to a child, or we are saving up to buy an apartment. For 466 thousand rubles, of course, you can't buy an apartment in the regional center, but in a small village you can already count on something. In rural areas, for that kind of money, you can find your own home ownership, albeit unprepossessing, but still better than nothing. And the state did not pay for the birth of children before.

Oddly enough, but the approval of the masses as a whole can also cause an increase in the tax on personal income for the wealthy part of the country's population. Now the rich (with an income of more than 5 million rubles) will pay not 13%, but 15%, however, in an amount exceeding the aforementioned 5 million. This kind of concession to public opinion from the authorities was caused by the desire to slightly smooth out the degree of popular discontent after the pandemic. Indeed, it was not very clear why people with a salary of 15 thousand rubles, and people with an income of, say, 1 million rubles a month are subject to income tax in the same amount. True, the authorities did not begin to reduce taxes for the "poor": after all, they, who receive from 10-15 thousand to 50 thousand rubles a month, are the main part of taxpayers among individuals.

The population perceived the introduction of a special regime for the self-employed ambiguously, but those who work for themselves were able to quickly assess the advantages of the new regime. So, it is no longer required to register as an individual entrepreneur and pay mandatory contributions to social funds, if the income is less than 200 thousand rubles per month and there are no employees, and the types of activities are suitable for self-employment.

Another question is whether this can be called full-fledged reforms, and not individual targeted measures.

On the whole, as can be seen both from the analysis of the data of opinion polls of the population, and simply in the process of communicating with practically any ordinary people, the critical perception of the social policy of the Russian state still dominates over the support of government measures.

Confidence in the authorities is declining, and this is a very serious signal. It seems that someone on the highest levels of the power hierarchy is playing against the current vertical, hoping to inflame popular discontent. Indeed, one unpopular measure replaces another, and reports on successes in Syria or on the new power of the Russian weapons can no longer reassure citizens, who will have to assess on their own experience both the prospects for raising the retirement age and the declining standard of living of the population combined with the increasing risks of unemployment.

Low salaries and pensions remain a real scourge of Russian society, especially if one considers that they have practically not grown in recent years, in contrast to prices for food and housing and communal services. So even those positive initiatives that have taken place in the policy of the Russian authorities in the last decade, if not canceled out, then greatly dim in comparison with socially unpopular measures.

I would like to hope that the reforms in our country will be more socially oriented, if such a thing can be expected at all under the capitalist model of the economy.
Author:
Photos used:
Twitter / President of Russia
241 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Svarog
    Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 21
    +74
    There are no successful reforms. Mate capital, zeroed with an increase in apartment prices.
    But it’s not even that fact that causes irritation .. it is clear that when the courtyard boys rule the country, even in the past, there is no need to wait for a result. It is annoying that everything is in its place, continuous failures, but TOP managers are so effective that they do not go to felling, but to increase.
    1. Varyag71
      Varyag71 30 November 2020 15: 26
      +32
      Yes, normal people understand that this capital is like a drop in the ocean. He will not solve financial problems. And it is calculated on all these handouts from the state, first of all, on the marginals, who, not surprisingly, breed like rabbits, when educated, intelligent families cannot even give birth to one.
      1. Svarog
        Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 28
        +27
        Quote: Varyag71
        And it is calculated on all these handouts from the state, first of all, on the marginals, who, not surprisingly, breed like rabbits when educated, intelligent families cannot even give birth to one.

        The marginals are not taken from Mars, the current form of state organization condones the emergence of an even greater number of marginals, but the share of marginals who give birth for money is negligible.
        1. Hypertension
          Hypertension 30 November 2020 15: 31
          +7
          Quote: Svarog
          the current form of state structure condones the emergence of even more marginalized

          Like to like. What's so surprising?
        2. VORON538
          VORON538 30 November 2020 15: 34
          -21%
          In exactly the same way, officials are not taken from Mars.
          And in exactly the same way, real estate prices were raised not by the Martians and the government, but by our fellow citizens who are engaged in construction
          So who is to blame for the troubles of Russia? Only our citizens themselves, who, having risen slightly above the rest, want to take even more off their own! hiHas the state raised pensions and wages for state employees? Private traders raised prices!
          1. Svarog
            Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 39
            +36
            Quote: VORON538
            So who is to blame for Russia's troubles? Only our citizens themselves!

            Are you proposing a revolution? Or what are the options, how do you think citizens can influence officials? Here is the pension reform, the vast majority are against .. so what? Did they hear us or sent by the forest? And so in everything .. where is the real opposition? Under arrest or already with criminal cases ... The Constitution was altered when they wanted and for themselves .. By the way, what's the point, that is, from this in your opinion?
            So stop .. people don't influence the Martians .. until they take the pitchfork.
            1. VORON538
              VORON538 30 November 2020 15: 40
              -27%
              Revolutions and coups are your utopian
              I am a supporter of EVOLUTION and a tougher selection in relation to those wishing to take places in the civil service! hi
              1. Svarog
                Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 41
                +35
                Quote: VORON538
                Revolutions and coups are your utopian
                I am a supporter of EVOLUTION and a tougher selection in relation to those wishing to take places in the civil service! hi

                So any normal person is a supporter of evolution .. only we get degradation, not evolution.
                tougher selection in relation to those wishing to take places in the civil service! hi

                This is a utopia, unfortunately .. in 2010, if I’m not mistaken, it was proposed to take responsibility, right up to the president .. But as we can see, the president changed the Constitution and, in general, freed himself and the rest of the elderly guard from responsibility .. Bees against honey do not exist ..
                1. VORON538
                  VORON538 30 November 2020 15: 47
                  -24%
                  Again, thanks to whom? Our fellow citizens! It is our own fault! Nepotism is there in Russia at any level, who doesn’t put his child in a good place, and who doesn’t help a friend, and who didn’t offer the traffic police officer to solve the problem on the spot? And thanks to the doctor for Do you remember how through friends-relatives they "got" the necessary thing out of turn? This is the mentality. And they justify everything by mutual assistance and supposedly "hereditary" figures of culture, science, medicine, military, etc. .. sailed ... by officials !! And this is not 20, and not 30, and not 50 but much more years!
                  1. Svarog
                    Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 51
                    +38
                    Quote: VORON538
                    Again, thanks to whom, our fellow citizens!

                    You mean Thomas, you mean Eremu .. Have citizens added their retirement age? Or did the citizens also reset the president? Citizens also imposed taxes on themselves .. It is not necessary to unite the ruling class of the bourgeoisie with the citizens.
                  2. Vinnibuh
                    Vinnibuh 30 November 2020 16: 22
                    +23
                    Eh, again the bad people went to our light-faced)
                2. Lannan Shi
                  Lannan Shi 30 November 2020 16: 35
                  +25
                  Quote: Svarog
                  So any normal person is a supporter of evolution .. only we get degradation, not evolution.

                  It is quite an expected result, given the negative selection acting in the state apparatus. When "helluva lot of smart" bureaucrats basically spread rot. So that under the very armchair it does not sway. Well, the atmosphere of total irresponsibility contributes to this. Why smart subordinates if no one cares about the results of their activities? Let's recruit stupid ones, and we'll enjoy our office forever.
                  1. paul3390
                    paul3390 30 November 2020 16: 45
                    +19
                    Yes, the selection is just quite positive, it just pursues goals that are far from people's happiness ... The most arrogant, shameless and greedy creeps through, but at the same time - smart enough to share with whomever it is necessary in time. The main task of the Putin government is to gain money by its participants. And that's all. This is what we must proceed from ..
                  2. Nazar
                    Nazar 1 December 2020 11: 47
                    +2
                    Lannan Shi - In our republic, even such a verbal "stamp" has appeared:
                    - a man comes to get an administrative position and immediately declares "I am from Uncle Bair".
                    We even had an article in the local newspaper with the headline:
                    "they were hired" from Uncle Bair, "and they ask how smart they are."
                3. Interlocutor
                  Interlocutor 30 November 2020 16: 45
                  -10%

                  So any normal person is a supporter of evolution .. only we get degradation, not evolution.

                  Any revolution brings about a deterioration in the living conditions of the ordinary citizen. The Chinese have been saying this for 5000 years.
                  1. Overlock
                    Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 24
                    +33
                    Quote: Interlocutor
                    The Chinese have been saying this for 5000 years.

                    But leaders change
                    1. Interlocutor
                      Interlocutor 30 November 2020 17: 57
                      +4
                      But leaders change

                      Very neatly changed by the way
                      1. Overlock
                        Overlock 30 November 2020 18: 04
                        +31
                        Quote: Interlocutor
                        Very neatly changed by the way

                        But change
                      2. Interlocutor
                        Interlocutor 30 November 2020 21: 06
                        +10
                        But change

                        Do not change course
                      3. Ingvar 72
                        Ingvar 72 30 November 2020 22: 59
                        +11
                        Quote: Interlocutor
                        Do not change course

                        Here he was replaced by Yeltsin's team, and Putin continues to follow Yeltsin's path. And as time shows, the course is wrong. There is only one way out - to roll back. For which the majority of those present here stand up.
                        And to continue walking towards the cliff, arguing that it is impossible to change course, is simply stupid.
                      4. Interlocutor
                        Interlocutor 30 November 2020 23: 12
                        +3
                        There is only one way out - to roll back.

                        Roll back until what time? The second question is in what way?
            2. parusnik
              parusnik 30 November 2020 17: 55
              +10
              The Chinese have been saying this for 5000 years.
              For 20 years the CPC in China fought evolutionarily for the power of workers and peasants, from 1929 to 1949. laughing Peacefully fought against the Kuomintang. Evolutionarily. laughing
              1. brat07
                brat07 1 December 2020 03: 24
                +3
                Quote: parusnik
                The Chinese have been saying this for 5000 years.
                For 20 years the CPC in China fought evolutionarily for the power of workers and peasants, from 1929 to 1949. laughing Peacefully fought against the Kuomintang. Evolutionarily. laughing

                Unfortunately, we will not be given these 20 years.
                And the United States missed
                this is the most "moment
                truth "with the Chinese.
                China was a "factory" for anything
                Western world, but not an enemy.
                How many "doughs" were they pumped into?
                Yes, now they have risen and very high.
                I do not know how the new policy will turn out
                President of the United States, but I think that it is not in China's favor.
                So I think we need to prepare for the worst times.
                Regardless of who is at the helm
                our country!
                1. Nazar
                  Nazar 1 December 2020 11: 59
                  +6
                  brat07 - Colleague, here are your words: "Unfortunately, they won't give us these 20 years." - So we already had them from 2000 to 2021. Nobody attacked us, there was (and even now) a lot of money in the country and what, how did we take advantage of this 20 year break? Have hundreds of billions of dollars been pushed offshore?
                  China is run by people acting in the interests of their country, and we have an occupation administration. And the invaders are not driven out of the country by "revolution"; the form of struggle against them is called differently. hi
                2. brat07
                  brat07 2 December 2020 02: 48
                  0
                  Quote: Nazar
                  brat07 - Colleague, here are your words: "Unfortunately, they won't give us these 20 years." - So we already had them from 2000 to 2021. Nobody attacked us, there was (and even now) a lot of money in the country and what, how did we take advantage of this 20 year break? Have hundreds of billions of dollars been pushed offshore?
                  China is run by people acting in the interests of their country, and we have an occupation administration. And the invaders are not driven out of the country by "revolution"; the form of struggle against them is called differently. :

                  You probably did not read too carefully the comment by Alexei Bogomazov, to which I answered.
                  His comment was a mix of sarcasm
                  and jokes. I answered him in the same way.
                  But my ending, it was already serious:
                  So I think we need to prepare for the worst times.
                  Regardless of who is at the helm
                  our country!
                  hi
                3. Nazar
                  Nazar 2 December 2020 03: 56
                  +1
                  brat07 - Colleague, perhaps I reacted too harshly to your "they won't give these 20 years" and this prevented me from slowly reading both your message and the message of the previous Colleague request
                  But in essence, we are writing about the same thing, only in different words. hi
        3. WIKI
          WIKI 30 November 2020 22: 34
          +5
          Quote: Interlocutor
          Any revolution brings about a deterioration in the living conditions of the ordinary citizen. The Chinese have been saying this for 5000 years.

          A striking example of a revolution that is not violent, such as a change in production forces and production relations, is China. "if in 1978 the enterprises that were in the national ownership accounted for 77,6% of industrial production, and for the" collective "- 22,4%, then in 2009 the public sector provides only 26,7% of the production, 26,9 , 20,4% of total profits and 60% of employment. " Russia, with its revolution, in this respect is the antipode of China. State ownership is over 70-XNUMX%. In fact, no one controls the state-owned companies, they are not accounted for, and their existence benefits only the management, which can overestimate their salaries against the background of chronic unprofitability.
          1. your1970
            your1970 6 December 2020 16: 05
            0
            Quote: WIKI
            Russia, with its revolution, in this respect is the antipode of China. State ownership is over 60-70%

            The example you gave - oddly enough, says that nothing can be nationalized / taken from the bourgeoisie ...
            Strange, no ???? !!!
            1. WIKI
              WIKI 6 December 2020 19: 05
              0
              The example I gave just says that today's Russian state is not effective in terms of managing state property.
            2. your1970
              your1970 7 December 2020 10: 22
              0
              Quote: WIKI
              The example I gave just says that today's Russian state is not effective in terms of managing state property.

              I repeat, from your words it follows that China has little state property and it is effective
              There is a relatively large amount of state property in the Russian Federation, and its management is not particularly effective.
              In the USSR it was 100% and zero efficiency of its management, judging by the results ...
              We follow the Chinese path - we allow the privatization of everything and everything to the maximum? Since we have a shitty management of state property?
            3. WIKI
              WIKI 7 December 2020 12: 00
              0
              Quote: your1970
              China has little government ownership and is efficient

              I didn’t say it was effective. The share of the state in the economy of 35% provided the figures that I quoted. "The average return per investment unit in 2013 reached 9,1% for private and 4,6% for state-owned companies. Analysts argue that the administration model of state corporations is close to exhaustion, and they are no longer able to deliver the growth rates required to increase GDP by the planned 7% per annum Private companies have higher labor productivity, and state-owned enterprises consume a disproportionate share of resources. They receive about half of bank loans (with an efficiency of their use of 4,6% versus 9,1%) and are the main drivers of growth huge corporate debt in China. Since 2015, SOE investment has grown faster than private sector investment, a reversal of a multi-year trend, The Economist notes. "
            4. WIKI
              WIKI 7 December 2020 13: 31
              0
              Quote: your1970
              We follow the Chinese path - we allow the privatization of everything and everything to the maximum? Since we have a shitty management of state property?

              Management of state property also implies such an element as investment. The lion's share of the state's investment falls on state-owned companies.

              “According to Rosstat data, 2018 trillion rubles were invested in Russia at the end of 17,5. Nevertheless, the economy is not showing dynamic growth. In recent years, the elasticity of investment to GDP was 2, that is, two rubles invested in fixed assets gave 1 ruble of growth GDP.

              Where did this money go? If you believe the same Rosstat, more than half of these funds in Russia go to buildings and structures: residential, commercial and industrial real estate. And only a third for machines and equipment. The rest is other investments, including intellectual property. If you look at the structure of investments in China's dynamic economy, then real estate accounts for only 23%, the rest is investments in productive assets. Compared with GDP, the figures are even more eloquent: about 6% of GDP is spent on means of production in Russia, and this is disastrously small. China invests 30% of GDP in machinery and equipment. In order to reach the growth rates of China, Russia needs to invest exactly five times more in means of production than we are investing now.
            5. your1970
              your1970 7 December 2020 14: 07
              0
              Real estate costs - commonplace heating, roads somewhere near the devil, construction of objects in the same place
              The cost of an intellectual - well, we can't steal other people's ideas like China
  • saigon
    saigon 30 November 2020 16: 56
    +2
    Vladimir changed the president, well, he removed the responsibility and WHAT?
    And what is the problem, will leave the power and those who kissed their hands first will rob, wrap and betray a lot of examples in history.
  • Stas157
    Stas157 30 November 2020 16: 59
    +28
    Quote: VORON538
    I am a supporter of EVOLUTION

    You are a supporter of Putin and the current stabilizer. Because no evolution occurs during slow degradation and cannot occur by definition.

    The path of evolution and social justice is not about our power. But the road of degradation along which we are being led multiplies the possibility of revolution.
  • Overlock
    Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 23
    +36
    Quote: VORON538
    supporter of EVOLUTION

    It is possible with a consensus in society, and when the government does not want to evolve and now is not just bronze, but reinforced concrete, while well, it does not want development at all and leave, then the question of evolution disappears as an independent issue. What suggestions?
  • Free wind
    Free wind 1 December 2020 14: 05
    -1
    Cop? Prosecutor? Or just a condom?
  • Varyag71
    Varyag71 30 November 2020 15: 44
    +22
    They made preferential mortgages, made rural mortgages, and immediately inflated real estate prices.
  • Varyag71
    Varyag71 30 November 2020 15: 35
    +5
    There are both marginals and ordinary people. I know many examples when there is no job, no decent earnings, even a family may not really exist, but they multiply and multiply. And the question is for them. what are they hoping for? After all, a child is now quite difficult to raise. And when there are 5, 6 or more? And very often from them all you hear is that everyone should honor them, because they are mothers-heroines
  • Stas157
    Stas157 30 November 2020 16: 37
    +26
    . not very clear why people with a salary of 15 thousand rubles, and people with an income of, say, 1 million rubles a month, the income tax is taken in the same amount

    Inexplicably generally take taxes from this minuscule 15 thousand! For such a shame they should pay extra, not tear taxes. This is not even up to our luxurious middle class !!

    ... True, the authorities did not begin to reduce taxes for the "poor"

    This "power" (more like a bandit) does nothing but raise taxes and tighten the screws wherever possible.

    Why reduce if she is not responsible to anyone and for anything? Accordingly, she owes nothing to anyone. All the more so for some people!
    1. Overlock
      Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 27
      +36
      Quote: Stas157
      This "power" (more like a bandit)

      During the pandemic, it continues to tear money for parking, and the real bourgeoisie during this period made parking free
      1. veritas
        veritas 30 November 2020 19: 17
        +1
        Quote: Overlock
        Quote: Stas157
        This "power" (more like a bandit)

        During the pandemic, it continues to tear money for parking, and the real bourgeoisie during this period made parking free

        So we are not afraid. Do you want like in France?
        1. evgen1221
          evgen1221 30 November 2020 21: 26
          +10
          Do you want it like in France? (Quote) Dear veritas-And what's wrong with the fact that the population in the same France regularly defends with its rallies and seeks to change the decisions of the authorities in their favor? and thereby keep the authorities in good shape and make them reckon with themselves, reminding some of the stars that the government serves the population and not vice versa? There is nothing terrible in this, all the more, they demand everything in justice and nothing superfluous. I would really like to wait for the moment when our population would go to the municipalities for every fact of infringement of their rights, And in general we have a fair people, but also the authorities should clearly explain - if a restriction and prohibition were introduced, they could explain in normal language for the sake of what and in what area the population will be relaxed and helped instead of the imposed restriction. Otherwise, you can prohibit so much of everything and everyone for the sake of your powerful ambitions and wanting to forget at whose expense the banquet - only then you should not be surprised that the country will spontaneously take up the ax.
  • Megatron
    Megatron 30 November 2020 15: 39
    +13
    And it is designed for all these handouts from the state, first of all, for the marginalized, who, not surprisingly, breed like rabbits, when educated intelligent families cannot even give birth to one

    And here I will allow myself to disagree with you already. Some kind of eugenic words, on the verge of fascism. All kinds of people are important, all kinds of people are needed.

    Who do you think is a marginal? Who has 9 grades, 11, or everyone without a tower?

    Can not be so. negative
    1. Varyag71
      Varyag71 30 November 2020 15: 47
      -5
      Under the marginal, I'm an alcoholic, a drug addict. And there are a lot of them.
      1. Sergej1972
        Sergej1972 30 November 2020 15: 54
        +11
        From a sociological point of view, a marginal person is a person who hangs between different social groups. For example, a villager who has moved to the city, but has not become a real city dweller, and he also does not want to return to the village. He has never visited theaters in his life, while visiting his relatives in the village almost every week. At the same time, he can be an excellent family man, a law-abiding citizen, and earn good money.
  • Ilya-spb
    Ilya-spb 30 November 2020 15: 46
    +32
    In fact, I have only one mercantile claim to power.

    Why do I work white, the employer pays charges for me, from 30%. Some of them should go to me as a pension, it is accumulating.

    And according to the current pensioners, I know that they get a penny, minuscule. 15-20% of the salary.

    And why can't I inherit the pension savings that I have earned?

    According to statistics, men, for the most part, do not live to 65.


    I wish you all good health and long life. Don't wait!
    1. Lannan Shi
      Lannan Shi 30 November 2020 16: 42
      +20
      Quote: Ilya-spb
      And why can't I inherit the pension savings that I have earned?

      Because the current prime minister, when he was the head of the Federal Tax Service, was engaged in something incomprehensible, but not work. If I told my boss that about half of what was planned has been done, because I didn’t, I didn’t, I wouldn’t be able to do it .... I would have flown out in a month or two, such "shock" work. Well, the tax officer, calmly broadcasting that half of the economy is in the shadows, apparently because he has more important things to do than work, does not fly into the janitors, but calmly goes to the premieres. Power vertical in all its glory. yes
      1. Interlocutor
        Interlocutor 30 November 2020 23: 30
        0
        Because the current prime minister, when he was the head of the Federal Tax Service, was doing something incomprehensible,

        It became more convenient to pay taxes. And tax collection has become more and more stable.
      2. your1970
        your1970 6 December 2020 16: 18
        0
        Quote: Lannan Shi
        Mr. Tax, calmly broadcasting that half of the economy is in the shadows, apparently because he has more important things to do than work, does not fly out to the janitors, but calmly goes to the premieres. Power vertical in all its glory.

        And in order to get out of the shadows - the tax authorities need to come to my neighbor who is officially unemployed for 30 years ... He has got KamAZ all these years and he has been driving on it ... Judging by the fact that last year he bought his mother an apartment in Bulgaria, he has been successfully driving ....
        Taxes? No, you haven't heard ...
        Do you understand? Not to Potanin / Vekselberg - but to Nikolai Vasilievich ...
        And they gave him five or six years for systematic tax evasion ...
        He does not withdraw money to offshore companies - but he is exactly the same swindler .......

        Z. Y. He regularly receives subsidies as a poor ...
    2. paul3390
      paul3390 30 November 2020 16: 49
      +17
      Because the task of collecting pensions is not at all the payment of pensions from them, and not the welfare of the people, but simply the acquisition of certain sums, which can then be stupidly backed off .. Hence the whole seeming madhouse, in fact, everything is quite logical from the point of view of the beneficiaries of this mess ...
  • zenion
    zenion 30 November 2020 16: 06
    +29
    Varyag 71. Surprisingly, somehow so - the worse, the more necessary. The trouble is that those born after the Soviet era and those who were small in Soviet times during the reign of the marked devil cannot compare these two systems. One was - everything for man, for the good of man. The present system is man to man a wolf, animal feudalism. The former Soviet people were taken hostage as slaves. This is reminiscent of Moses' plan to lead the people in the wilderness until those who were born in Egypt die. And now those who remember the real Soviet power must die out.
    1. paul3390
      paul3390 30 November 2020 17: 03
      +12
      That is why - the task of all supporters of Soviet power at the moment is work with the population, mainly with the youth. So that the memory of the great Soviet Union and its achievements does not disappear with our generation ..
  • Megatron
    Megatron 30 November 2020 15: 31
    +24
    150tr - this is a house in which thread a deaf, half-dead village, in the Pskov or Novgorod regions (mb elsewhere, I'm just from St. Petersburg, I know the prices that are nearby),
    where there are no roads, no schools, no hospitals. How to live there? The Far Eastern hectare is even more ghostly. There were tidbits, but they were all snapped up, approached, as always.
    1. zenion
      zenion 30 November 2020 16: 08
      +13
      Megatron (Polite). They were snapped up by the close ones in order to rent it, as it was under the bloody king Kolka. They are waiting for fists with whips in their hands.
    2. evgen1221
      evgen1221 30 November 2020 21: 31
      +1
      No, for 150k in regional centers, you can not take a superpenthouse, but take suitable housing, in the area of ​​150 km from any city of a million. In the nearest 50 km radius, for this money, it is more likely a barn only, but only 50 km from a millionaire, it is many times easier to work, which means a lot.
      1. Aag
        Aag 1 December 2020 06: 16
        +1
        Quote: evgen1221
        No, for 150k in regional centers, you can not take a superpenthouse, but take suitable housing, in the area of ​​150 km from any city of a million. In the nearest 50 km radius, for this money, it is more likely a barn only, but only 50 km from a millionaire, it is many times easier to work, which means a lot.

        The land under the barn is more expensive within a radius of 50 km from the city of a millionaire, if, of course, you can drive to it ...
        It also depends on traffic, sometimes it takes more than two hours for 20 km, people go to work for a week.
    3. ycuce234-san
      ycuce234-san 30 November 2020 21: 33
      +2
      Hectares would rather work as a source of jobs if they were given preferential treatment for industrial activities to joint-stock companies: hundreds of hectares for new industrial zones near railways, roads or waterways, and hundreds of thousands of hectares for risky farming, projects for fish farming, fur farming, small energy, wood chemistry , forestry and forestry without significant industrial felling - in places farther from transport. In principle, it is not too late to do so.
      1. Megatron
        Megatron 30 November 2020 21: 45
        +3
        Industry is more likely to have a different problem.
        To open a PRODUCTION in our country, you need to collect so many permits and approvals (read bribes) that it is almost impossible to go through this dark forest (read very expensive).

        And then they wonder why everything is so cheap in China, so much is produced and so on. So there millions of caps on their knees rivet everything, from hammers, to microcircuits and microscopes, and no one puts a spoke in their wheels, but on the contrary helps with all their might. That's the whole answer.
        1. ycuce234-san
          ycuce234-san 30 November 2020 22: 03
          +1
          Not another, not another. Permissive procedures can always be simplified, this is not a big problem. But low-tech production is also not too necessary - it does not consume the products of other high-tech domestic industries, especially machine-tool engineering and chemistry. And it does not provide a competitive advantage with manual labor in other countries. In this regard, a small tire plant with technology purchased from foreigners under a license and located near a remote Far Eastern railway is strongly preferable to a huge assembly shop for cheap consumer goods. And with a tire factory, an apron will first grow, then a working hostel and then a small village. Leskhozes and collective farms for especially risky forestry activities will work in a similar way - a field or a grove of pharmaceutical crops or raw materials for perfumery and cosmetics is better than a grain field in such conditions, raw materials will simply be more expensive.
  • withoutreverse
    withoutreverse 30 November 2020 15: 39
    +25
    when I see old women and old people with tears begging for alms, on the streets of Russian cities. in the subway, in shops, etc. I want these "successful" reforms.
    1. Hunter 2
      Hunter 2 30 November 2020 15: 46
      -46%
      Quote: withoutreverse
      when I see old women and old people with tears begging for alms, on the streets of Russian cities. in the subway, in shops, etc. I want these "successful" reforms.

      I will tell you a terrible Secret! In the USA there are many times more Homeless and Beggars! Damned imperialists ... laughing There are a lot of declassed elements, and simply lowered marginals and simply sick people in any country of the World! yes Begging is also a Profession!
      1. Svarog
        Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 48
        +33
        Quote: Hunter 2
        I will tell you a terrible Secret! In the USA there are many times more Homeless and Beggars!

        So go there and live there .. There is a general conversation about Russia ..
        1. Hunter 2
          Hunter 2 30 November 2020 15: 55
          -36%
          Quote: Svarog

          So go there and live there .. There is a general conversation about Russia ..

          So, unlike you, I am not Noah here days and nights! Give your advice to your whiners, free of charge! laughing
          Russia is my Motherland, I Protected and Love it, unlike you. I like traveling very much, that's why I am writing what I am responsible for, too, unlike you. negative
          1. Svarog
            Svarog 30 November 2020 16: 01
            +27
            Quote: Hunter 2
            I am writing what I am responsible for, also unlike you.

            Unlike me, you only defend your soft spot .. and the soft spot of those 10% who have saddled everything in this country .. and your interests with the overwhelming number of citizens clearly diverge .. Few people are interested in how many people in the US are homeless. If only in the understanding that we have the same prospects .. Or are we fundamentally different from the United States?
            1. Hunter 2
              Hunter 2 30 November 2020 16: 17
              -28%
              Quote: Svarog

              Unlike me, you only defend your soft spot .. and the soft spot of those 10% who have saddled everything in this country .. and your interests with the overwhelming number of citizens clearly diverge .. Few people are interested in how many people in the US are homeless. If only in the understanding that we have the same prospects .. Or are we fundamentally different from the United States?

              Svarog, you're just - Funny! Leave your speculations about what I protect and for whom I Fought ... with you. This time.
              Second, having traveled a lot, I can draw one conclusion, the majority of people are the same. Everyone wants to live better and do nothing. In this we are not fundamentally different from anyone. And in All Countries of the World there are citizens who are banally strangled by the Angina pectoris, who completely forget that Envy is Bad!
              1. Svarog
                Svarog 30 November 2020 16: 21
                +21
                Quote: Hunter 2
                that Envy is Bad!

                What does envy have to do with it? We are talking about reforms .. and generally not envy, but social justice should be .. If a person earned honestly, you can only rejoice for him .. and you know many in our state, who earned honestly?
                Svarog, you're just - Funny!

                Strong argument ..
                1. Hunter 2
                  Hunter 2 30 November 2020 16: 25
                  -20%
                  Quote: Svarog
                  What does envy have to do with it? We are talking about reforms .. and generally not envy, but social justice should be .. If a person earned honestly, you can only rejoice for him .. and you know many in our state, who earned honestly?

                  Actually a lot! There are no oligarchs in my environment. And many actions of the Power - I don't like it either. But I try and I Work, and the Wife works, that's actually the whole secret.
                  Changes in the Country - I welcome them, only the ways of achieving these changes are completely different.
                  1. Aag
                    Aag 1 December 2020 06: 50
                    +5
                    Quote: Hunter 2
                    Quote: Svarog
                    What does envy have to do with it? We are talking about reforms .. and generally not envy, but social justice should be .. If a person earned honestly, you can only rejoice for him .. and you know many in our state, who earned honestly?

                    Actually a lot! There are no oligarchs in my environment. And many actions of the Power - I don't like it either. But I try and I Work, and the Wife works, that's actually the whole secret.
                    Changes in the Country - I welcome them, only the ways of achieving these changes are completely different.

                    "But I try and Work, and the Spouse works, that's actually the whole secret."
                    Is it unaware that many fellow citizens of your beloved Country, as a result of the reforms being discussed, simply cannot do this? Lack of jobs, state of health. People have already earned, deserved pensions, changed the rules of the game, robbed, calling things by their proper names, " offer "to work more. Well, then, for an additional thousand to travel ..
                2. Overlock
                  Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 45
                  +31
                  Quote: Svarog
                  Strong argument ..

                  It's good that not an agent of the Abwehr
              2. Stas157
                Stas157 30 November 2020 17: 32
                +27
                Quote: Hunter 2
                In the USA - Homeless and Beggars times more!

                Why at times, in orders! There is generally poverty all around !! Compared to Russia, then !!! It's different with us - 17 thousand and you are a luxurious middle class !! Great, isn't it?

                Quote: Hunter 2
                corny chokes Angina pectoris

                Quote: Hunter 2
                Envy is Bad!

                Mr. Okhotved proposes not to pay attention to the abnormal income gap of Russian citizens. And he offers to "treat" and deal with the moral and educational side of the issue - to shame the poor that it is very bad to envy the rich.
                How touching it is!
          2. Galleon
            Galleon 30 November 2020 16: 13
            +31
            Quote: Hunter 2
            unlike you

            Quote: Hunter 2
            also unlike you

            Yes, you generally have an excellent student, you are our 2nd hunter. Is it not lonely for you to love your Motherland - it seems that you no longer give this right to others?
            Do not be offended or if you want to - take offense - but your separation from the dissenting forum participants is your professional deformation. It's easier and more familiar to you - you think of us in the category of, if not internal enemies, then enemies who will become enemies at the command "front". And which, on command, it is possible and necessary to suppress the indicated forces and means. It would never even occur to you that behind our nicknames there are officers, conscripts who have served, engineers, ordinary normal people, after all. With a different experience and other views, which are the majority and which are not the worst part of the people, which you gloomily endure in your beloved homeland. For in your homeland you can only affably bear her power.
            1. Overlock
              Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 43
              +39
              Quote: Galleon
              that behind our nicknames are officers, conscripts who have served, engineers, ordinary normal people, in the end

              This is alien to him, because he never thought about who feeds him, dresses him, makes weapons, where the salary comes from and the apartment. The dependent is shorter
          3. Overlock
            Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 40
            +40
            Quote: Hunter 2
            Russia is my Motherland, I Protected and Love it, unlike you.

            Modesty beautifies, Ilya Muromets! They defended them with what a worker or engineer gave you. What have you created yourself? Plowed or rented, stood at the machine or at the drawing board? What surplus value have you created? What product was produced? You have consumed ready-made food, so you shouldn't be proud. A hard worker or a collective farmer fed and clothed you and you defended him. They, the workers, are the Motherland.
          4. Interlocutor
            Interlocutor 30 November 2020 23: 32
            -5

            So, unlike you, I am not Noah here days and nights! Give your advice to your whiners, free of charge! laughing
            Russia is my Motherland, I Protected and Love it, unlike you. I like traveling very much, that's why I am writing what I am responsible for, too, unlike you. negative


            I subscribe to your every word
        2. zenion
          zenion 30 November 2020 16: 10
          +14
          When this began in ancient Rome, there was no one to defend it. Rome shrank and disappeared.
          1. Alf
            Alf 30 November 2020 17: 56
            +10
            Quote: zenion
            When this began in ancient Rome, there was no one to defend it. Rome shrank and disappeared.

            1. veritas
              veritas 30 November 2020 19: 16
              +8
              Quote: Alf
              Quote: zenion
              When this began in ancient Rome, there was no one to defend it. Rome shrank and disappeared.


              The only question is, what state do our officials think about? Even if their regular propagandists have citizenship of other countries, and a mustache, in general, his family has left for unfriendly countries. The boss seems to be fighting with them, but the subordinates have everything there.
              1. Alf
                Alf 30 November 2020 19: 40
                +5
                Quote: veritas
                The boss seems to be fighting with them, but the subordinates have everything there.

                Well, now the fight against them will trample ... All top bureaucrats will suddenly become Russian citizens ...

                But what about the children of bureaucrats? Are they all "imported"?
                It's just that when I see such initiatives, I recall an old anecdote that has not lost its relevance.
                "The State Duma has received a bill consisting of two points.
                1. Do not kill.
                2. Do not steal.
                The Duma is working on amendments ... "
            2. your1970
              your1970 6 December 2020 16: 23
              -1
              I can say for sure - the Swedes will not throw themselves under tanks with grenades for their homeland ...
              And their standard of living is high .....
              1. your1970
                your1970 8 December 2020 08: 06
                0
                Minusery- can you give an example of heroism during the occupation of the Scandinavian countries in WWII ???
                To lay down his life for his friends ???
                A paperclip in the lapel is their heroism then ...
                Now it will be exactly the same ...
      2. withoutreverse
        withoutreverse 30 November 2020 15: 49
        +16
        I care .. only my old people who built this state.
        1. Svarog
          Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 53
          +21
          Quote: withoutreverse
          I care .. only my old people who built this state.

          Apparently because you are still full of strength. That's when the strength ends .. with age, you understand that after 50 you are not needed anywhere, but health is already gone .. and also, as it is necessary to raise children .. In general, old people are good, but also think about yourself need..
      3. Interlocutor
        Interlocutor 30 November 2020 16: 47
        +4
        Begging is also a Profession!


        Yes, and what.
      4. Overlock
        Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 33
        +36
        Quote: Hunter 2
        In the USA there are many times more Homeless and Beggars! Damned imperialists ...

        Well, why is it so? How to compare the standard of living, so we are compared with Africa, and if we are talking about the poor, then immediately America is cited as an example, they say, it's even worse.
    2. dzvero
      dzvero 30 November 2020 17: 05
      +8
      Of these, only a few are really in need. The rest are cogs of a well-established system. Test - offer instead of giving money, go to the store together and buy groceries for the same amount ...
      1. Mordvin 3
        Mordvin 3 30 November 2020 17: 34
        +4
        Quote: dzvero
        Test - offer instead of giving money, go to the store together and buy groceries for the same amount ...

        For 5-10 rubles? Estessno, you will be sent to hell.
        1. dzvero
          dzvero 30 November 2020 18: 30
          +5
          So offer them a purchase for 300r. - the effect will be the same ... "give me money, I myself know how to spend it."
          In the nineties, it happened ... but when I saw which cars they were transported "to the points" ...
          1. Mordvin 3
            Mordvin 3 30 November 2020 19: 31
            -2
            Quote: dzvero
            So offer them a purchase for 300r

            They will say, buy a bottle of vodka and cheese, buy it?
            1. Bolt cutter
              Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 20: 44
              +5
              a bottle of vodka and cheese
              So as not to stretch my legs out of hunger wassat
              But seriously, in Latvia I saw beggars who hunted in the store, and bought in the same store ... Gourmets, however. They just didn't take black caviar smile And in England, I saw a tired beggar round the corner throwing off his "overalls" - dirty rags and leaving "work" in his car. It seems that he had a Toyota. And young people whose leg is amputated at the very base - stabbed a "crocodile" in the groin (other veins are burned). With real injuries, the leg (one) is not amputated, because from the other, when exposed to weapons, nothing will remain, and blood loss will kill in a minute. Please note that the leg is questionable, it is always the left one, it is more convenient to prick there.
              1. Mordvin 3
                Mordvin 3 30 November 2020 21: 49
                0
                Quote: Bolt Cutter
                So as not to stretch my legs out of hunger

                Uh-huh. I wonder how much a person is willing to fork out and what exactly to buy a beggar. I knew one really beggar (he died this year), so he only collected a drink and a snack.
                P.S. Does everyone's site blink when changing ads, or do I have one? He hesitated.
                1. dzvero
                  dzvero 1 December 2020 09: 50
                  +2
                  Just like that, I would fork out for 50, max. 100 rub. If "familiar", i.e. really in need, then, probably, and more. Fortunately or not, I have no such "acquaintances".
            2. dzvero
              dzvero 1 December 2020 09: 43
              +1
              Of course not smile And I don’t talk to them. Sometimes they drive up at traffic lights, but when they see a gesture (not the one they usually think about; just "no") they immediately fall behind.
  • The leader of the Redskins
    The leader of the Redskins 30 November 2020 16: 06
    -1
    So the first part of the article (optimistic) somehow did not come to me. I knew a number of dysfunctional families who simply spent their children's money on drink ...
  • Sling cutter
    Sling cutter 30 November 2020 16: 09
    +17
    Quote: Svarog
    No successful reforms

    Colleague, if we talk about the anti-people reforms, then they are all successful, starting with the reform of RAO UES and can be continued indefinitely.
    1. Svarog
      Svarog 30 November 2020 16: 15
      +11
      Quote: Stroporez
      Quote: Svarog
      No successful reforms

      Colleague, if we talk about the anti-people reforms, then they are all successful, starting with the reform of RAO UES and can be continued indefinitely.

      If reforms are replaced by robbery, then yes, complete success hi
      1. Interlocutor
        Interlocutor 30 November 2020 23: 37
        -4

        If reforms are replaced by robbery, then yes, complete success

        Have you been robbed?
        1. Essex62
          Essex62 1 December 2020 08: 28
          +6
          I don’t know how comrade Svarog is, but they just robbed me. Toka, I unraveled my lips, get my earnings, in 40 years of continuous plowing, and rush to the bosom of nature to fish and dig in the garden, as a grandiose bummer happened and I was asked to enter the position. They, you see, stole all the money earned by the Soviet and non-Soviet people, and therefore I still have to work hard. Five years, and maybe more in the future. Well, until I'm bent, in general. And if the withdrawal from the service in the Armed Forces and study rolls out, then there will be no hope for an early start, in general there will be no hope for a normal (scanty in comparison with the USSR). This is not a robbery in your opinion?
  • bandabas
    bandabas 30 November 2020 16: 25
    +6
    The oligarchs' minions never had confidence in the authorities. "They say the king is not real!"
  • Mishka78
    Mishka78 30 November 2020 16: 51
    +10
    Oh yeah. For example, there is such an extremely effective manager Kostin-zade with a salary of 5 million rubles. in a day.
    He manages VTB Bank with assets of 16 trillion rubles.
    Judging by the reports posted by the bank, in September 2020 the bank earned as much as 90 million rubles. In October - 155 million. Effective? :)
    1. Sling cutter
      Sling cutter 30 November 2020 16: 59
      +10
      Quote: Mishka78
      Oh yeah. For example, there is such an extremely effective manager Kostin-zade with a salary of 5 million rubles a day.
      He manages VTB Bank with assets of 16 trillion rubles.
      Judging by the reports posted by the bank, in September 2020 the bank earned as much as 90 million rubles. In October - 155 million. Effective? :)

      They have a lot of such devils, Gazprom also shows losses
      1. Mishka78
        Mishka78 30 November 2020 17: 08
        +10
        With Gazprom, everything is both simpler and more complicated at the same time. It's still a living company that invests in various projects, investments, etc. It can be successful, it can be unsuccessful, it happens that you have invested now, but the return is only in 5-10 years, etc.

        With the Bank, everything is on the surface. Raised money from the population at 4%, placed in loans at 10%. You live on the difference. You can have losses only in one case - you issue bad loans to lawyers.
        In the modern world, such loans in 9 cases out of 10 are issued to those who need it, and who drives these loans to the right place ...
      2. veritas
        veritas 30 November 2020 19: 11
        +7
        Quote: Stroporez
        Quote: Mishka78
        Oh yeah. For example, there is such an extremely effective manager Kostin-zade with a salary of 5 million rubles a day.
        He manages VTB Bank with assets of 16 trillion rubles.
        Judging by the reports posted by the bank, in September 2020 the bank earned as much as 90 million rubles. In October - 155 million. Effective? :)

        They have a lot of such devils, Gazprom also shows losses

        Gazprom has losses, Rosneft has losses, and managers receive bonuses, and even taking into account inflation.
  • tochila
    tochila 30 November 2020 16: 52
    +7
    The nobles in the seventh generation ruled the country even worse and brought it to the handle by 1917!
    1. Overlock
      Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 49
      +39
      Quote: tochila
      ruled the country even worse and brought it to the handle by 1917!

      The country was brought to the handle by the extremely ineffective manager Nicholas II. His personnel policy, as now, was based on nepotism, cronyism, money. Therefore, we are slowly stomping towards the same ending. Bad king, as it turned out
      1. Essex62
        Essex62 1 December 2020 08: 34
        -2
        Don't touch the martyr king. He is our man, he did everything right. (Sarcasm, who did not understand). And how else could it be to break the servile psychology that had been implanted by the priests for a thousand years? Only through thorns to the stars is it possible to break through.
  • polar fox
    polar fox 30 November 2020 16: 57
    -2
    Quote: Svarog
    it is clear that when the courtyard boys rule the country, even in the past, there is no need to wait for the result.

    I disagree fundamentally. "courtyard boys" from the 90s, they were not even sickly resolving many topics. And they taught their children in ordinary schools, where the children went on foot, with everyone else they got to ... the dashing 90s, if anything. Tolyatti.
    1. Overlock
      Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 50
      +28
      Quote: polar fox
      courtyard boys "from the 90s, they were not even sickly resolved many topics

      It was even possible to find the truth, unlike the police
      1. Essex62
        Essex62 1 December 2020 08: 37
        +2
        Long live the bandit Russia! ? Do you understand what you are writing?
  • Roman070280
    Roman070280 30 November 2020 15: 22
    +14
    Mat.kapital .. Are all the successful reforms ??)
    1. Snail N9
      Snail N9 30 November 2020 15: 44
      +27
      In fact, the only thing that really helps citizens in real life is the creation of MFC-single document circulation centers. But all this is leveled by the number of documents that need to be constantly updated, received, confirmed, and so on. In Soviet times, I kept my passport on the shelf for years, because it was extremely rarely needed. Now, without a passport, I do not leave the house, because it may be required at any time. As for the notorious "maternity capital", they are especially grateful to him in the Caucasus ... wink But these are not reforms - they are just "changes" and "innovations". Reforms were carried out in: 1-education (Baba Unified State Exam), 2-in health care (optimization), 3-in pensions (we smile and wave), 3-in wages and labor protection (new TC protecting the employer), 4-in the political system (the notorious amendment of the Constitution), 5-in subsoil use (Western and private companies allowed our gold, etc.), 6-in the energy sector (let's say thanks to Chubais), 7-in the financial sphere (thanks to Nabiulina and look at the exchange rates of the ruble ), 8- in territorial entities (the creation of TORs, in fact, private latifundia), etc. And which of all of the above can be called “done for the good of the population”? But this is all true - "flowers" - berries are being prepared for us - "creating a digital concentration camp" ...
      1. Alex66
        Alex66 1 December 2020 07: 04
        0
        But this is all true - "flowers" - berries are being prepared for us - "creating a digital concentration camp" ... You are right and it looks like they will start with a vaccination passport without which they will neither work nor from home, but then they will supplement it. And everything is voluntary.
    2. Fan-fan
      Fan-fan 30 November 2020 23: 57
      +8
      Did this mate capital raise the birth rate? No, the death rate is now higher than the birth rate. Here's what I found on the network: "155 rubles will be paid to parents for their second child in case the family received maternity capital for the first child in 550." Even Poland pays more, they pay 2020 zlotys per month for any child under 18 years old, this is a little more than 500 million of our rubles for 18 years.
      Putin should be ashamed for such a meager payment.
      1. Yaroslavl
        Yaroslavl 1 December 2020 11: 02
        +4
        and in Finland, a country without resources at all, they pay 18 euros from birth to 150 years old, monthly ..... teach and feed children in schools for free ... and no one is promoting this ... this is the sacred honorable duty of the state ... . and our mat. capital is a handout, dust in the eyes and fiction
  • Stirbjorn
    Stirbjorn 30 November 2020 15: 27
    +18
    Everything that the author listed on the word "reforms" somehow does not pull
    1. Svarog
      Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 31
      +16
      Quote: Stirbjorn
      Everything that the author listed on the word "reforms" somehow does not pull

      Imitation of hectic activity, rather, hanging noodles to the electorate.
    2. Uncle lee
      Uncle lee 30 November 2020 15: 37
      +16
      Quote: Stirbjorn
      "reforms"

      Pension reform + updated Constitution! Successfully completed! (for those in power!)
      1. Overlock
        Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 54
        +37
        Quote: Uncle Lee
        Pension reform + updated Constitution! Successfully completed!

        And how are the May decrees doing there? At least one completed? Where are the 25 million new jobs? - Drowned?
        1. veritas
          veritas 30 November 2020 19: 08
          +5
          Quote: Overlock
          Quote: Uncle Lee
          Pension reform + updated Constitution! Successfully completed!

          And how are the May decrees doing there? At least one completed? Where are the 25 million new jobs? - Drowned?

          Everyone has already forgotten about them. In December, the storyteller will tell about the new decrees.
  • sleeve
    sleeve 30 November 2020 15: 31
    +14
    I did not understand the article. Mat.capital? Well, the author would also write that there was nothing successful. Why fence a vegetable garden with the adjective "successful"? And if you want to, you have to sit down to the periodicals and read the story. Compare the state of affairs in 1999 and now. Conduct an analysis of what was done and already there go to the proposed title. Otherwise, don't understand what happened ... And be careful with the "point of view of ordinary citizens." Just be careful with the unfamiliar and unknown.
  • Deniska999
    Deniska999 30 November 2020 15: 32
    +11
    I did not see real reforms in the article. Just don't talk about reducing development institutions from 40 to 20)
    1. Svarog
      Svarog 30 November 2020 15: 35
      +6
      Quote: Deniska999
      I did not see real reforms in the article. Just don't talk about reducing development institutions from 40 to 20)

      40 institutes worked on development, and as a result - degradation .. and everything is normal .. everyone is in business, they continue to work ..
      1. veritas
        veritas 30 November 2020 19: 07
        0
        Quote: Svarog
        Quote: Deniska999
        I did not see real reforms in the article. Just don't talk about reducing development institutions from 40 to 20)

        40 institutes worked on development, and as a result - degradation .. and everything is normal .. everyone is in business, they continue to work ..

        They are going to be promoted.
  • Alien From
    Alien From 30 November 2020 15: 33
    +18
    Unfortunately, from the point of view of an ordinary citizen, there are none (((
  • U-58
    U-58 30 November 2020 15: 36
    +28
    Reduction of hospital beds - hiccup with coronavirus. The merger of polyclinics, the enlargement of the sections - the queues to see the doctor for 4-5 hours in spite of any electronic records (and after all, they entered and reported!).
    The middle class with 17000 incomes is a gem that has no analogues in history.
    Retiring all and all the president is also a kind of reform.
    Complete distrust of the people in the official election results. And the people "eat". Also a successful reform.
    Power is now power itself, but not power from the people.
  • ximkim
    ximkim 30 November 2020 15: 38
    +6
    Domestic policy is not very happy. The main reforms are taking place in the tax sector, and they are not ↓, but ↑. Maternity capital does not raise demographics, or rather, mat capital has scanty motivation to increase the birth rate.
  • Daniil Konovalenko
    Daniil Konovalenko 30 November 2020 15: 39
    +9
    There is actually nothing to remember. If only in technical terms, there are many icebreakers, our weapons at hypersonic speed will carry nuclear warheads or shoot down their weapons with nuclear warheads, but icebreakers cannot be smeared on bread, super missiles cannot be put in a saucepan instead of sausages. say, it became available, the money was paid, and both are specialists with secondary technical in any profession.
    1. ANB
      ANB 30 November 2020 16: 06
      +6
      ... but you can't put icebreakers on bread,

      Well, you can't put a CNC machine on bread either. But without him there will be no bread.
      As well as without a combine and a bunch of other equipment.
      And without the missiles, someone else will eat bread and spread.
      1. Daniil Konovalenko
        Daniil Konovalenko 30 November 2020 16: 16
        +3
        Literally, you are right ... but literally ..
  • Chervonny
    Chervonny 30 November 2020 15: 42
    +38
    Successful reforms in Russia in recent years from the point of view of ordinary citizens

    I don't see any successful reforms. There were none.
    1. Chervonny
      Chervonny 30 November 2020 15: 45
      +35
      Quote: Red
      I don't see any successful reforms. There were none.

      Although as it was, there were no successful reforms. For example, they successfully carried out a reform of the pension legislation by raising the retirement age.
    2. Daniil Konovalenko
      Daniil Konovalenko 30 November 2020 15: 55
      +9
      I don't see any successful reforms. There were none.
      ... For the ruling class, they are successful .. The rich are getting richer, the poor, poorer. It is trite and sore on edge, but this is so.
  • ALARI
    ALARI 30 November 2020 15: 46
    +15
    Yes, interestingly, you pay 15% from the amount that is MORE than 5 million, and those who receive 10 thousand 13%. Why can't you set a minimum wage bar when you don't have to pay taxes? The percentage of income on securities is not touched is sacred.
    1. ANB
      ANB 30 November 2020 16: 13
      +3
      ... Why can't you set a minimum wage bar when you don't have to pay taxes?

      Previously there was a deduction per employee. Now only benefit recipients and a deduction for children.
    2. veritas
      veritas 30 November 2020 19: 06
      -3
      Quote: ALARI
      Why can't you set a minimum wage bar when you don't have to pay taxes?

      Sound initiative and socially necessary. Only the budget already lacks enough for tasty projects.
  • Sergej1972
    Sergej1972 30 November 2020 15: 57
    +6
    The site of "Gosuslugi" and the MFC are really convenient things.
    1. ANB
      ANB 30 November 2020 17: 37
      +4
      ... "State Services" website

      Awfully done.
      1. Sergej1972
        Sergej1972 30 November 2020 20: 51
        +4
        It suits me perfectly.
  • AB
    AB 30 November 2020 15: 58
    +14
    reports of successes in Syria or the new power of Russian weapons can no longer reassure citizens

    Well, the author wrote crap. The successes in Syria, yes they are, are military, and no one denies them. But, they are at the expense of our population. Russia pays for every Syrian sneeze. Hence the increase in the retirement age, and higher taxes, and beggarly pensions with no less beggarly salaries. And then there is Karabakh ... Well, they lit up the howling freaks - well done. But why, at the expense of Russia, restore something that was not destroyed by us? The Armenians are happy to shit, once again threw Russia for loot. What enthusiasm about the power of Russian weapons? Where can they come from? 90% of the population watches how they fly higher and higher, and higher prices for EVERYTHING, not Zircons.
    1. Interlocutor
      Interlocutor 30 November 2020 16: 50
      -13%
      Russia pays for every Syrian sneeze. Hence the increase in the retirement age, and higher taxes, and beggarly pensions with no less beggarly salaries.


      Sounds like panic
      1. Overlock
        Overlock 30 November 2020 17: 59
        +35
        Quote: Interlocutor

        Sounds like panic

        And if you count? Once they called the sum of $ 5 million, it cost 1 day of war in Syria. Multiply by the number of days and a very considerable amount comes out. Where do these dollars come from? Maybe a copier?
        1. veritas
          veritas 30 November 2020 19: 05
          +2
          Quote: Overlock
          Where do these dollars come from? Copier can

          Well, it's not the oligarchs who sponsor. It’s a well-known business of our taxes.
          1. Sergej1972
            Sergej1972 30 November 2020 20: 53
            +4
            Taxes on large companies are much higher compared to income taxes on salaries.
        2. Interlocutor
          Interlocutor 30 November 2020 21: 05
          +1
          And if you count? Once they called the sum of $ 5 million, it cost 1 day of war in Syria. Multiply by the number of days and a very considerable amount comes out. Where do these dollars come from? Maybe a copier?


          This amount is included in the military budget and compensated during the next year.
          1. AB
            AB 1 December 2020 15: 30
            0
            This amount is included in the military budget and compensated during the next year.

            Sounds like panic

            And what kind of money does the budget come from? Are they falling from the sky or from taxes? References to Gazprom and Rosneft as the main taxpayers are relevant, but not so much. In 2021, oil and gas revenues are projected to amount to 6 trillion rubles, non-oil and gas revenues - 12,8 trillion rubles. That is, in the total volume of revenues, oil and gas revenues will take 31,9%. About another 20% -30% (plus, minus) are taxes from banks and other commercial structures. Everything else is from the people. So there is no panic at all, there are fair questions to the State.
            1. Interlocutor
              Interlocutor 1 December 2020 15: 40
              -1
              Are they falling from the sky or from taxes?

              The military is definitely not with the taxes of citizens.
              Citizens' taxes are grains.
              Organizational taxes in one form or another are the bulk of the budget.
            2. Interlocutor
              Interlocutor 1 December 2020 15: 53
              +1
              Everything else is from the people.

              This year I paid 9000 in tax. We take 150 million (together with the babies), they don't want to shirk them ... Suppose, on average, everyone paid that way, who is not at all. It turned out thirteen billion five hundred million rubles.
              1. AB
                AB 1 December 2020 20: 01
                0
                The military is definitely not with the taxes of citizens.

                The military budget is part of the federal budget and nothing else
                I paid 9000 tax this year

                If you are an individual entrepreneur, but the employer pays taxes for 99% of working citizens
                Personal income tax - 13% Salary of employees-residents of the Russian Federation
                Pension fund - up to 1.292.000 rubles. per year 22%
                Pension fund - over 1.292.000 rubles. per year 10%
                FSS - up to 912 rubles. 000%
                MHIF - 5,1%
                Owners must pay taxes on property annually - houses, summer cottages, apartments, rooms, cars, boats and other vehicles, as well as land plots.
                VAT - 0,10,20% on any purchase
                Excise taxes on gasoline, cigarettes, alcohol are also from you
                If you have a loan, then the State has 6% from it (refinancing rate)
              2. your1970
                your1970 8 December 2020 08: 13
                0
                Quote: Interlocutor
                Everything else is from the people.

                This year I paid 9000 in tax. We take 150 million (together with babies) nefig them to shirk ... Suppose, on average, everyone paid so, who is more than who not at all. It turned out thirteen billion five hundred million rubles.

                It takes 20 (!!!!) billion to pay pensions daily.
                Regardless of babies ...
  • Galleon
    Galleon 30 November 2020 16: 01
    +13
    All these articles on domestic or foreign policy topics on VO are, forgive me, like knocking dogs on someone else's fence with a stick while passing by. The barking will stand for a long time, they will pick it up until the outskirts. So it is with the articles: they wrote once again hackneyed theses without any analysis, without polling people, without any objective assessment of the effectiveness of the measures taken - and my soul rushed to collect comments!
    Tired of this banality and lack of professionalism. negative
    1. ALARI
      ALARI 30 November 2020 16: 15
      +4
      You need to write at least something so that they don't forget, and a small denyuzhka is always useful.
  • fuel oil
    fuel oil 30 November 2020 16: 07
    +4
    In general, from the pros, some minuses ... Pathetic fuss at the bottom of the standings.
  • O. Bender
    O. Bender 30 November 2020 16: 15
    +8
    Matkapital, of course, was partially able to assist in the acquisition of housing, but its size is such that it is impossible to buy decent housing with this money. Only take a mortgage and pay off a part of the mortgage. Mortgage is a bank that takes interest by driving into bondage. As a result, we have an overflow of mat capital from the treasury into the hands of citizens, and then into the bags of bankers and home sellers with a margin in the form of interest on the loan. So, in my opinion, materkapital is just bait for catching fish. Banks have a margin, the developer sells housing, the happy owners of square meters on a leash .Curtain In a socially oriented state, housing should be free of charge.
    1. Bolt cutter
      Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 16: 33
      0
      .
      In a socially oriented state, housing should be free of charge.
      What is given for free is not appreciated. And it is always not enough. So this is a utopia.
      1. O. Bender
        O. Bender 30 November 2020 18: 04
        0
        This was, and I remember this well hi
        1. Bolt cutter
          Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 18: 07
          +1
          I also remember. And how did this "such" end?
          1. Bolt cutter
            Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 18: 35
            +6
            We need a stable currency system so that loans can be issued at 3,5% per annum. Then there will be fewer problems with housing. And restrictions on the construction of high-rise buildings, which are appropriate only in Hong Kong, but not in the largest country in the world, then housing will be of better quality.
            1. Essex62
              Essex62 1 December 2020 08: 56
              -1
              There shouldn't be any monetary system at all. The only payment unit is the ruble and only the ruble. And only as a means of mutual settlements, and not as a product
              Usury to put pressure on the root, salaries, pensions, royalties and other legal payments ensure a dignified, equal existence, for everyone, for ALL citizens of the state. This is how a just society works. And restore the sign so that all this obscenity does not come from there to us.
              1. Arpad
                Arpad 1 December 2020 09: 01
                +2
                Quote: Essex62
                There should be no monetary system at all.

                What is it like ?
                Prevent other countries from using their money?
                Quote: Essex62
                The only payment unit is the ruble and only the ruble.

                Worldwide ?
                Quote: Essex62
                And only as a means of mutual settlements, but not as a commodity
                Usury to press on the vine
                ,

                that is, you can forget about loans?
                Quote: Essex62
                pensions, royalties and other legal benefits provide decent,equal existence, everyone,

                moral - is it in the DPRK or Cuba --- but for some reason no one can call him worthy

                Quote: Essex62
                This is how a just society works.

                and where is it so arranged?
                in which country ?
                Quote: Essex62
                And restore the signso that all this lewdness does not come to us from there.

                good
                on what then will you sprinkle your deep thoughts and how to spread it into the * world *?
                On this ?
                1. Essex62
                  Essex62 1 December 2020 09: 20
                  +1
                  And where does the whole world have to do with the poor Cuba and North Korea? I'm writing about Russia. And this was how it was arranged in the Union and worked perfectly until the hucksters with sticky paws reached the power, with the help of traitors. And we, I admit, missed this moment. As for technical progress, one should not deny the citizens of Russia the ability to create in themselves everything that the bourgeois have. Including using their achievements. The loaf is strong and the carrier to it, as an example. Moreover, they have already given us everything, to master it, it will work.
                  And you can bring your thoughts to people in different ways.
                  1. Arpad
                    Arpad 1 December 2020 11: 16
                    +2
                    Quote: Essex62
                    And what has the whole world to do with it, what has the poor Cuba and North Korea got to do with it?

                    everyone is equal there
                    Quote: Essex62
                    ... And it was arranged this way in the Union and worked perfectly

                    I lived enough in the USSR and there was no equality in the USSR
                    Quote: Essex62
                    And we, I admit, missed this moment.

                    no . you were sitting on the couch. but it was necessary to climb the barricades.
                    But crying is always easier than lifting your ass
                    Quote: Essex62
                    As for technical progress, one should not deny the citizens of Russia the ability to create in themselves everything that the bourgeois have

                    but whoever refuses, they themselves do not take.
                    It's like an old joke
                    The West all the time tried to bring Russia to its knees, but it remained lying

                    Quote: Essex62
                    And you can bring your thoughts to people in different ways.

                    pigeon mail?

                    1. Essex62
                      Essex62 1 December 2020 15: 26
                      0
                      In the USSR I felt myself completely equal and even made some people who decided that he felt it "more evenly". On the party line, catching the tail of the presumptuous bureaucrat. Well it is, lyrics.
                      Here's a father-in-law, for example, an ordinary driver on a state farm, he received a thousand for his suffering. My brother, on the "box" 350 a month, and the minister under a thousand. Plus drove with the Volga, the dacha and the hut are more spacious. Oh, and the soldering is also on this mustache. And I didn’t care about any boss, because I didn’t sculpt my career, I didn’t go over my head. I was calmly doing my job. And my Country was on my side. She could not stand the thief hucksters and periodically caught them, in especially large ones, leaned against the wall. And if the admin resource even squeezed someone out, creating difficult working conditions at a given place, so he crossed the road, and there is the same plant. And required, required, required.
                      "Dear Leonid Ilyich" paid party dues from 800 rubles. Where is not equality here? Want more? You are welcome.
                      Our director, entering the smoking room, greeted each worker by the hand, and he was no less than a deputy of the RSFSR Supreme Soviet and a member of the district committee bureau
                      Not everyone got up like that.
                      No need to lie, there was equality in the Union.
                      At the expense of the barricades, this is not for me. We started fiddling with the district committee in 88, when it came to where everything was heading, but in 93 we had to seriously clash with counter. Well, as it was, you yourself know, without a chance.
                      1. Arpad
                        Arpad 1 December 2020 21: 33
                        +1
                        Equality - well, well, if everything changes with money - my mother, a teacher of Russian and literature with a university education, earned 220 rubles a month at one and a half rates.
                        All your other tales about Leonid Ilyich who paid contributions from 800 rubles. Ridiculous maybe he did not generally give a damn, as if he would live on a salary.
                        The wife of my father’s brother, a responsible employee of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, the foreign trade department, I don’t think she earned millions, but they lived like the first time from .... I don’t think that many were equal to them and where the money came from, we all knew.
                        Do not tell fairy tales, I saw also the Central Committee's hospitals and sanatoriums and special distribution centers with practically any products at ridiculous prices.
                        Equals - residents of regional cities and collective farms - were equal?
                        Tell your grandchildren stories.
                      2. Essex62
                        Essex62 2 December 2020 08: 08
                        -1
                        The difference is only three times, with a thousandfold difference in responsibility, this is equality. It is not for nothing that I gave you an example with the RF Minister and the Milling Machine operator, on the PYa. The indicator is characteristic. Specialist hospitals and distribution centers took place, the bureaucracy, under any regime, tries to create the CONDITIONS for itself, such is it - it is a nettle tribe. But this, as it were, cannot be called inequality.
                        And where does the responsible employee of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs get the money from? Why didn't you ask? Didn't involve the competent authorities? If a person lives beyond his means, it should be a lively question to give rise to someone who honestly lives on salary and extra earnings. This tacit agreement, with the disgusting idylogism that arose, "if you want to live, be able to spin," and brought the huckster to our neck. We had to fight, as our fathers did. In the 50-60s, such phenomena were caught in the bud, first of all by Soviet citizens. The speculators and money-grubbers had a hard time.
                        About Brezhnev, nothing at all. This is an example of the size of the RFP. Of course he did not need anything, so he is, forgive the General Secretary, read the emperor.
                        And I will definitely tell my grandchildren, let them draw conclusions. Indeed, the fabulous life was in the Union.
            2. your1970
              your1970 8 December 2020 08: 16
              -1
              Quote: Essex62
              salaries, pensions, royalties and other legal payments provide a decent,equal Existence
              - that is, it will be possible not to tear the veins, but to live a fool (less demand) ??
              Such a state will die out in six months, no more ...
              Even the USSR, where there was no equality, lasted longer ...
              1. Essex62
                Essex62 9 December 2020 14: 17
                -1
                Where did I write this? Quite the opposite, it was necessary to work hard to live a little better. Someone went to BAM, to raise Tyumen, etc. But only not much better than the others working on the assembly line of ZiL and AZLK, for example. And for the state, the working man was a priority, he created all the conditions for him. And yet equality flourished in the USSR, and the hucksters were in persecution, until a certain period. The absence of financial inequality removes huge contradictions in society and creates the basis for good-neighborly relations between people. They do not gnaw each other, but rather show participation and help. In this regard, the Union is the most unique society in the history of extreme humanity. The desire to row under oneself must be crushed by the most stringent measures. The money-grubber is the enemy of the People.
                1. your1970
                  your1970 10 December 2020 08: 42
                  -1
                  Quote: Essex62
                  The absence of financial inequality removes huge contradictions in society and creates the basis for good-neighborly relations between people. They do not gnaw each other, but on the contrary show participation and help. In this regard, the Union is the most unique society in the history of extreme humanity.

                  My father, being the head of the PMK and responsible for a hundred people and a bunch of equipment / objects, received 205 rubles and a bonus for these objects - another 15 ...
                  His tractor drivers could earn up to 400 ... I don't even want to remember about the north from their 500-1000 per month ..
                  Is this equality ???! Did it make him work better ??!
                  His same hard worker told him in front of me - "And why are you tearing your veins, my salary is still twice as much !!"
                  Apparently this form of "participation and assistance" was, yeah ....
                  Quote: your1970
                  live a fool (less demand) ??

                  It was many times easier for the tractor driver - they did not remove the shavings from him for the plan in the district committee, and the head for the tractors who got drunk and drowned (on the dispute, "Who will go further into the river ??!") Did not hurt ....
                  1. Essex62
                    Essex62 10 December 2020 08: 53
                    0
                    Obsalyutly correct approach, you want to sit in a clean blue robe, in a warm change house and sort out the pieces of paper, your right. If you want to earn more, go in the cold, head over heels in oil and diesel fuel to turn the levers. The working class is the hegemon, it has all the priorities.
                    1. your1970
                      your1970 10 December 2020 11: 27
                      0
                      Quote: Essex62
                      The outright correct approach

                      Quote: Essex62
                      The working class is the hegemon, it has all the priorities.

                      And then this hegemon was very surprised - where did the USSR go ???? !!!!!
                      And it's just that bosses of all levels are fed up with being the on-duty ass for everything and everyone, including the hegemon ...
                      Smart and conscientious, they threw everything to hell and stopped floundering and struggling ... they all fell deep on the drum ..
                      In their place came the boss, cunning and thieves ... who stole the USSR ...

                      Quote: Essex62
                      If you want to earn more, go in the cold, head over heels in oil and diesel fuel to turn the levers.

                      Only here troubles - in such a scenario, those who want to go to engineers become zero point fucking tenths ...
                    2. Essex62
                      Essex62 11 December 2020 11: 49
                      0
                      Why, then. I, for example, tried both. I liked the engineer more. Losses in wages took it for granted. I had enough, with scanty prices for everything in the Union. But the work itself is more interesting.
                      The problem is not that the engineers were hammered into work, the grandfathers from the Politburo missed the moment of turning in the minds of people. It was necessary to reduce the stamping of "armor" and focus on consumer goods, while maintaining the main criteria of socialism. Prohibition of personal enrichment and private property.
                    3. your1970
                      your1970 11 December 2020 14: 35
                      0
                      My father had two tractor drivers with higher education - an electronics engineer and a lawyer ...
                      My father had a techie behind the ear and that's it ..
                      Quote: Essex62
                      No personal enrichment

                      And how are you going to accomplish this with such a salary difference?

                      A tangerine garden near a house in Abkhazia cost 100 000 ( in the 70s) and fought off in five years easily ...

                      Cut down the gardens and strawberries (a neighbor's grandmother built her daughter's cooperative in Saratov) to zero?
                      And if we leave the dealers, no one canceled .... See "Station for two" - there is a lot about it ..
                      Taking into account current realities, it is impossible even if we cut our hand
                    4. Essex62
                      Essex62 11 December 2020 22: 18
                      0
                      Doable. That state ceased to be proletarian and gave up on the class struggle. All these tangerines, fartsa and other elites of capitalism had to be squeezed at the root and mercilessly. Unfortunately, with the aged leadership, only slogans and a minimum of work remained. And young people were beaten on the hands and slowed down the initiative. I personally got into such a situation, under Andropov.
                      They had neither the strength nor the desire to defend the postulates of socialism, especially in the outskirts. Where there was very little Soviet power, to put it mildly.
                      You yourself have identified the cause of the death of the USSR. The indifference of the people. The indifference grew out of the indifference of those who had to move and direct.
                      There is no capitalism with a human face. Utopia, material inequality leads to suppression. Freedom and equality is based on the absence of contradictions in mat. providing for all, without exception, citizens of the country. Everyone should have a piece of the public pie based on the fact that he was born a citizen of the country. Strive further on your own, in accordance with your abilities and talents. But within the framework established by society, otherwise "to the very hat." And money-grubbing is generally out of morality.
                    5. your1970
                      your1970 12 December 2020 13: 25
                      0
                      unfortunately, what you propose is also a utopia like capitalism with a human face ...
                      Quote: Essex62
                      Freedom and equality is based on the absence of contradictions in mat. providing for all, without exception, the citizens of the country.
                      -I will repeat
                      the father had to organize this crowd into a team, make them work and overfulfill the plan, bear responsibility for all of them - including criminal ones, knock out funds and equipment ...
                      and receive half the salary ...
                      You will find a lot in the Russian Federation who are willing to be bosses under such conditions ???!
                      I guarantee you 100% - that even you yourself will not agree to go to jail for that drunken rascal who pee in a transformer booth on a pumping station in the steppe and was badly burned ...
                      Father was almost imprisoned for this - well, all the papers were signed / the magazines were filled ... Well, about the fact that it was impossible to just kick out for a booze - hegemon Ms. ... how can you, the colleftive vouched and took bail ...
                      Now he would not have reached the gate of work - they would have already calculated - but then his father fought with him for 6 years ...
                      once again - the salary is exactly 2 (TWO !!!) times less than that of the hegemon ...
                    6. Essex62
                      Essex62 14 December 2020 07: 31
                      0
                      In normal teams, they kicked out for kicks without any obstacles. The very same hegemon and bouncer. I faced such situations more than once. I won't argue that "they let go". Labor discipline of Stalin's and Brezhnev's socialism, as they say in Odessa ... But this can be solved, education and strict control. What has lost the society of "developed socialism" and led to its disintegration. And for other people's sins on the official grub it is possible to thunder at all times and under any power. The scummy nature of individual individuals breaks through, how not to educate. This is only surgically.
                    7. your1970
                      your1970 14 December 2020 08: 26
                      +1
                      And the hegemon went to the district committee of the party and tore the shirt on his chest "The proletarian was devoured by the enemies !!!! Yes, he had a drink once in the morning, before work, he was nervous, but the boss has long been a grudge ..."
                      I've seen this ...
                      "To sit down for other people's sins" - often you see this among the authorities? Yes, even with a salary, half the number of subordinates?
                      In my opinion, an honest deputy is more realistic than such a twist ...
                    8. Essex62
                      Essex62 14 December 2020 08: 50
                      0
                      You are stuck in a local situation. And you are considering the issue from the perspective of one group. From this position, but now the manager is fat and sweet, everyone else is sour. It is not good. The balance is upset, the predator reigns supreme and sets the standard for behavior. It ends with big and small troubles for normal citizens, whom it is against nature to shove over their heads. Socialism is for everyone, capitalism is for the shameless and toothy. This is especially evident in relation to old people who have lost the ability to work effectively. The jungles of capitalism simply kick them out of life. This is nothing more than a local example, like yours, with your father as your boss. Everyone has their own truth, ours will be bigger.
                    9. your1970
                      your1970 14 December 2020 12: 54
                      0
                      This is what you sample in 170 person - local ???? This is just a very common situation was ...

                      But this is generally all the same ...

                      Your idea of ​​the dominance of the hegemon over all the others is possible in one single case - following the results of the Civil War ...
                      No other way....
                      Any peaceful transfer of power to the proletariat will not give anything, except for the redistribution of property between the winners and the new owners ... All revolutions / coups after the death of the USSR - since 1991 ...
                      Only when there is absolutely nothing to eat, human life will not cost anything - only then ...
                      Exactly because for this it will not be necessary to plant an abstract Chubais, but to put your neighbor, a farmer or a trader, against the wall "Guided by the revolutionary sense of justice ..." ... and a lot ...
                      Otherwise, no way, all the coming to power of the proletariat throughout the world-only as a result of a lot of blood ...

                      You look at the VO - after 100 years, people are still arguing about the Revolution and there is no consensus ... Moreover, they argue to hysterics and scandals.

                      lol taking into account the amount of money among the population, the first CheKists (new ones !!) will have to be shot in a month, no later ...
                      Which, in general, happened in the real 1918-19 ...
                    10. Essex62
                      Essex62 14 December 2020 22: 22
                      0
                      You got the point very accurately hi The situation is disastrous. No one wants a lot of blood, and there are not many prerequisites for this. But there is no solution to the problem and cannot be. Dead end. You can shake the air as much as you like, but what has matured in the post-Soviet space, taking into account local quirks such as square, is a hellish mixture with a taste of cyanide. The state machine, built on the Byzantine principle, uncontrolled bureaucrats and motley "businessmen" are yesterday's gangsters and relatively honest, in some ways similar to unreasonable children, floundering bakers and hairdressers. And it will claim millions of lives, more and more every year, distort the consciousness of young people deeper and deeper, up to a massive refusal to support their old people and even children. We are stuck between two systems and it's scary.
                      And Chekistov in 18-19ggs, very often, mind you, and not in large numbers, were leaned against the wall not for "economic reasons". Political. The backbone lived up to the Yezhov purges, the first attempt at counter to knock off the already "settled" Soviet power and fulfilled its task. Although everyone ended up in the Office at that time, a difficult time - "To the ground, and then ..."
                      But citizens will not have cash in the transition period, in the form that it currently exists. But these are nuances.
                      I admit honestly, superimposing on the present moment the "state of mind" in the country, I do not see the creation of a proletarian state, right now, even theoretically. There are no prerequisites. The bourgeoisie learned the lessons, once, Stalin is not on the horizon, two, the working class is scattered and not ready to fight, the main thing is three. As a sentence.
                    11. your1970
                      your1970 15 December 2020 00: 01
                      0
                      Quote: Essex62
                      And Chekistov in 18-19ggs, one thing, mind you and not en masse, were leaned against the wall not for "economic reasons".
                      - in our region, by 1925, 3 chiefs of the district Cheka, 2 army chiefs of the Revolutionary Tribunals in the territory of the district, and about 10 small Chekists were shot ...
                      1 county with a floating number of departments up to 10-12 people ...
                      1 - for politics, the rest are purely for - "during the search he concealed part of the values ​​from being included in the inventory" ......

                      You will read about the sales representatives of the RSFSR abroad - up to 1500 people did not return in the period before 1935 ...
                      Do you know why? And everything is simple - all over the world it was customary to pay commission to an agent for a successful deal. Our buzz for kickbacks bought at exorbitant prices - something that cost much cheaper. Well, rollback money in your pocket ...
                      All those who traveled abroad then - all were noted in inappropriate spending of foreign exchange funds. Everyone, polls ...
                      Starting from living in the most expensive hotels and ending with buying a car for a few days
                      two brochures from the 1930s about this published in Moscow are surfing the net ..

                      Well, and my favorite - "The fight against embezzlement in communication agencies (Meeting of the People's Commissariat of Communication with the Prosecutor's Office)" in 1935 you can read ...

                      There are such volumes of theft - that Serdyukov and Vasilyeva are digging in the sandbox and Zakharchenko nervously smokes on the sidelines

                      “In 1931, there were so-called shortfalls in the amount of transfers identified by the Translation Control Bureau, by 10 million rubles to 10 billion rubles in turnover; in 1932 - 16-17 million rubles to 15½ billion rubles. rubles of turnover: in 1933 - 17 million rubles to 16½ billion rubles of turnover.Thus, their growth is by no means less than the growth of the turnover itself, the share of these shortages in 1933 is about 0,09% of The dynamics of embezzlement and embezzlement from these amounts is expressed in the following data: in 1933 for the entire year, embezzlement and embezzlement was 10½ million rubles., for 9 months of this year - 12 million rubles... over and over, i.e. in 9 months there were more thefts and waste than in the whole of 1933.

                      The Middle Volga Administration - 584 thousand rubles. for the whole of 1933 and
                      1. 700 thousand rubles. for 9 months of 1934 (head of the communications department, Comrade Zharkov).
                      In the East Siberian Administration in 1934, the theft and loss amounted to almost 1½ million rubles. (Head of Communications Department Comrade Kazakov).
                      Western Siberia - there, according to statistics, expenses have slightly decreased. So, according to data for 9 months. 1934 Comrade Novikov expects catch up and overtake lol November 1933, XNUMX
                      In the Sverdlovsk Communications Directorate, Comrade Sinkov has a theft of over a million in the region.
                      In Moscow, which is especially unacceptable, the head of the postal department, t. Stekhov committed theft in the amount of - 1.120 thousand... rub."

                      at that time, the T-28 cost roughly 300 - for 000 months in 9 Stekhov put money on 1934 tanks or on a rifle division a full set of small arms (rifles and machine guns) ..
                      Stalin at that moment received 600 rubles of the party maximum - against Stekhov's 1

                      Are you naive - "for political reasons", yeah, schaz ...
                      the guys sawed the loot no worse than the current ones (in reality lot more than the current ones, those millions, at any recalculation, give tens of billions of current rubles)
                    12. Essex62
                      Essex62 15 December 2020 12: 50
                      0
                      So I wrote about it. There were a certain number of people who got caught up. Enemies, however, with such and such principles of life. In the spray and went.
  • Knell wardenheart
    Knell wardenheart 30 November 2020 16: 20
    +5
    I think if you sit down and calculate - the volume of inflation "in recent years" will be absolutely incomparable with payments for the mother capital in terms of the income of an average family for the same "last years". The fact that the state has somewhat compensated from the budget is more than outweighed by its mediocre monetary policy.
    So it's hard to call it a success, unless a woman really starts giving birth as in the poorest countries of Africa.
    When I read the title of the article, I thought first of all about "Garbage Reform" - or rather, about how the attempt to accustom megacities to separate waste collection failed, and the airtime for public service announcements designed to support this undertaking was cleverly sorted out for commercial advertising.

    I will note that, in my understanding, "recent years" are ~ since 2014, and if so, then no positive moments have occurred since that time - a continuous slide. Some repayment of this slide - whether it is situational or due to some kind of efforts by the authorities - cannot be called successes. Success is when systematic growth occurs.
  • Million
    Million 30 November 2020 16: 24
    +5
    Yap on yap, yap drives ...
  • O. Bender
    O. Bender 30 November 2020 16: 27
    +7
    A successful reform, I would consider the introduction of a progressive scale of taxation, but the issue is still not resolved, the reasons are clear! its remnants) is the only true reform hi Am I Lenin? laughing
    1. Sancho_SP
      Sancho_SP 30 November 2020 17: 18
      +5
      Are you aware that the wealthiest people don't pay those taxes?
      1. O. Bender
        O. Bender 8 December 2020 11: 42
        +1
        For this there are law enforcement agencies, and yet in the United States, tax evasion is the most terrible crime. Of course, to force those who collect these taxes to work is another task. The most popular excuse that I hear from all irons is that with the introduction of a progressive scales, the rich will find a way to get away with it. So deprive this opportunity. hi
    2. your1970
      your1970 8 December 2020 08: 24
      0
      Quote: O. Bender
      I am Lenin

      No..
      Quote: O. Bender
      , nationalization of the oil and gas industry, energy, banks, industry (at least its remnants)

      China's state property declined at an accelerated rate to the current 26% ...
      This is how he became the world leader.
      We have about 67% total is in state ownership
  • Ross xnumx
    Ross xnumx 30 November 2020 16: 43
    +12
    If you take everything seriously, your head will burst! yes
    Successful reforms in Russia in recent years from the point of view of ordinary citizens

    These are just masterpiece reforms! And the adopted laws need to be knocked out in gold on the Kremlin walls ...
    What is the cost of freezing the indexation of pensions for working pensioners ...
    Only a dodgy mind could come up with a pension reform that would allow a Russian not to think about what he would do after finishing his work ...
    Nice idea to raise VAT, but why only by two percent? It is necessary to raise the level of inflation: the deputies will have something to work on, and a lot more “money” will be “easily cut down” ...
    What a great introduction - distance education, remote work. It seems to me that there is some kind of flaw in this matter. It's time to introduce distance treatment, distance selling, remote sex (and without fail) ...
    Only people familiar with mathematics could come up with an increase in salaries, pensions, utility bills, etc. Exponentially ...
    It is not clear why, after all, mortgage interest rates are higher than inflation rates ... or economic growth ... or salary increases ...
    Another question is whether this can be called full-fledged reforms, and not individual targeted measures.

    Indeed ... What are these reforms? How can you live? Here's what the people need:

    I would like to hope that the reforms in our country will be more socially oriented, if such a thing can be expected at all under the capitalist model of the economy.

    Depending on the orientation, the following events can occur:

    All the best! drinks
    1. Olfred
      Olfred 1 December 2020 14: 43
      +1
      Time to introduce remote treatment

      have already entered, it's hard to get through to the ambulance, if you are not from a big city ...
      and so, yes, treatment is prescribed by phone - Here they are, the realities of the present hi
  • Mishka78
    Mishka78 30 November 2020 16: 45
    +6
    1. Matkapital is objectively good. Only good for him?
    https://www.vedomosti.ru/society/news/2020/11/09/846203-estestvennaya-ubil-naseleniya-rossii-za-yanvar-iyul-uvelichilas-na-tret
    The natural decline in the population of Russia in January-July 2020 increased by more than 30% compared to the same period last year and amounted to 316,3 thousand people.

    300 thousand in 6 months! This is some kind of horror.

    2. + 2% tax on the rich is nothing. This is practically zero in budget revenue. This is not reform. This is some kind of populist bullshit. Here + 2% VAT on each is income, yes. But this is not a reform either.

    3. The regime of the self-employed is generally incomprehensible to me. Why is it needed - xs.

    Well, about the rest. Unfortunately, in Russia it has developed so that the state does not trust and does not like its population, believing that instead of explaining what is happening, it is better to prohibit something and for violation of this prohibition we will impose a fine, etc.
    Our state believes that the people are the source of problems for it. And accordingly, the people pay him the same. Those. we are not partners with the state, but opponents (it's good that they are not enemies yet, as in 1917) who seek to deceive and deceive each other.
    1. Svarog
      Svarog 30 November 2020 17: 10
      +12
      Quote: Mishka78
      Our state believes that people are a source of problems for it

      Rather a source of profit .. but there are fears that the source may dry up .. although they do not think too far ..
      Those. we are not partners with the state, but opponents (it's good that they are not enemies yet, as in 1917), who are trying to deceive and throw each other.

      They argue differently .. "You were not asked to give birth" .. "Eat macaros" ..
      So, the enemies are not far away ..
      1. Sancho_SP
        Sancho_SP 30 November 2020 17: 17
        -1
        Oh, do not provoke sedition)
    2. Selevc
      Selevc 30 November 2020 17: 21
      +11
      Quote: Mishka78
      Russia has developed in such a way that the state does not trust and does not like its population,

      And you mean what Russia ??? They are actually two Russia !!! Russia No. 1 is accustomed to living on a grand scale - Mercedes, villas, billion-dollar contracts, Oxfords and the Maldives ... This Russia has been accustomed to living widely and freely for decades, and at the slightest mention of economy they raise a friendly howl at all the country's media !!!
      Or are you talking about Russia # 2 ??? - who in the morning goes to shift for the machine, goes down into the mine or plows the field ... This Russia would be given a couple of days off and the opportunity to earn honestly and live with dignity in old age - and thanks for that !!! So this Russia has been quietly strangled and crushed for the past 30 years - and all the good authorities and the evil ones !!!

      Conclusion: the laws in Russia are written by Russia # 1 for themselves - therefore, Russia # 2 seems wonderful and they, for the most part, feel themselves cut off from the events taking place in the country !!! That is, in other words, Russia №1 traditionally hangs noodles on the ears of Russia №2 and then someday the next generations of suckers will probably call it Civil Society !!!

      By the way, the war clearly highlights these processes - while Russia No. 1 goes to Turkey on vacation, Russians from Russia No. 2 die in battles with the Turks-mercenaries in Syria !!! Yes, life is a very cynical thing !!! One writer said very wise words - Russia as a state is completely changing in 10 years and does not change at all in 100 years !!! How right he was !!! Direct analogies with the 1st World War - the death of some in the trenches and the fun of others in restaurants !!! Everyone perfectly remembers how it ended !!!
      1. Arpad
        Arpad 1 December 2020 09: 04
        +2
        Quote: Selevc
        By the way, the war clearly highlights these processes - while Russia No. 1 goes to Turkey on vacation

        Well, actually Russia 1 does not go to Turkey, there are more abrupt places
        Russia 2 goes to Turkey - all-inclusive and budget-friendly.
        Your theory does not work. request
        Quote: Selevc
        Direct analogies with the 1st World War - the death of some in the trenches and the fun of others in restaurants

        so it is always and everywhere.
        To whom the war - to whom the mother is dear. People just don't come up with proverbs.
    3. Snail N9
      Snail N9 30 November 2020 18: 36
      -3
      There is a sense in mother capital .... for banks. The citizen, having received the mother capital, runs to invest it in a mortgage, but it (the mother capital) is only enough for the first installment, and then a loan bond from the bank. So, whoever benefits from the mother capital is also necessary to see ... wink
      1. Bolt cutter
        Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 20: 24
        +6
        down payment, and then credit bondage
        Anyone who rents a house also often pays a mortgage for it, but only someone else's. How is it better?
  • depressant
    depressant 30 November 2020 16: 49
    +6
    Reforms?)))
    "In Novokuznetsk, angry residents went to a spontaneous rally against the unsuccessful transport reform carried out by the head of the city, Sergei Kuznetsov: the day before, some of the protesters occupied the city administration, seeking a dialogue with the authorities, and when there was no dialogue, people stayed overnight in the large administration hall."
    This is reported by Novokuznetsk.su.
    25th of November 2020.
    Let it be for now )))
  • Amur
    Amur 30 November 2020 17: 04
    +9
    The state should not give money, but an almost free opportunity to make it, help develop an intellectual business and educate people capable of running this business.
    1. depressant
      depressant 30 November 2020 17: 39
      0
      Here it is, here it is! You are right, colleague Amur. This is precisely the point of view from which it is necessary to consider and further evaluate the activities of the ruling elite. It is a pity that today I am unwell, there is no strength to comment on the topic ((
    2. veritas
      veritas 30 November 2020 19: 03
      +2
      Quote: Amur
      The state should not give money, but an almost free opportunity to make it, help develop an intellectual business and educate people capable of running this business.

      They just don't like them. Too smart, still moved.
    3. Bolt cutter
      Bolt cutter 30 November 2020 20: 26
      +9
      not money, but an almost free opportunity to make it
      If everyone is going to make money, then who is going to do the rest?
    4. solzh
      solzh 30 November 2020 22: 00
      +27
      Quote: Amur
      help develop an intelligent business and educate people capable of running this business

      And to score on the rest? Can you clarify? I’m just wondering if the state will only help intellectual business, then who will help the rest to develop?
      1. Amur
        Amur 12 December 2020 04: 19
        0
        Personally, I am not a maximalist and the state should also intelligently solve social issues, on the state ... and "hammer" - such a word should not be in the lexicon of a politician and statesman.
        I don’t know how exactly to solve issues, I would sit in the thought and tell you a fairy tale about it ..
  • Sancho_SP
    Sancho_SP 30 November 2020 17: 15
    +4
    Author, are you kidding me? There can be no successful reforms for the population from above. And for herself in power a lot of successful things)
  • Alexfly
    Alexfly 30 November 2020 17: 23
    -5
    The tax should be differential, whoever earns more should pay a higher percentage of the tax, just like hello ... and you need to start not with 5 million, but with 1000000 rubles, raising gradually.
    1. ANB
      ANB 30 November 2020 18: 55
      -7
      ... Tax must be differential

      Should services from the state also be differential?
      The recipient of 10 pays 000, 1300 pays 100. Both are salaried workers. But the first did not want to study and they do not take him for another job, as he was drinking. The second was educated and plows seven days a week. He is 000 times more unfastening than a bummer. Do you think you owe even more? Can a lazy person not pay tax at all?
      1. Alexfly
        Alexfly 30 November 2020 20: 50
        -1
        This is not an argument.
        1. ANB
          ANB 30 November 2020 22: 16
          -5
          This is the argument. Earning 100 does not go to state clinics (once), does not take sick leave (unprofitable). He has no time to wander about all sorts of promotions and sit on sites. He just plows. He feeds one pensioner from his salary, and one who earns 10 feeds one-tenth of the pensioner. And their pensions will be the same. And the social security is the same.
          So why should an Earner of 100 pay even more than if he is already giving more and receiving less from the state?
          Maybe then at least the votes in the elections should be proportional to the tax paid? For example, when the owners of apartments vote at a house meeting, meters, not tenants, vote.
          1. Aag
            Aag 1 December 2020 08: 12
            0
            "... Maybe then at least the votes in the elections should be proportional to the tax paid? For example, when the owners of apartments vote at the house assembly, the meters vote, not the tenants ..."
            Is this irony? Offers to sell voices to Millers, Sechins, Grefs?
            Although, it seems, it makes no difference ...
          2. Alexfly
            Alexfly 1 December 2020 13: 15
            0
            Andrey, I hope this is not a jab at me, about the sites ... You calculated correctly who feeds whom, but in our country, there is a huge number of workers who receive a minuscule 10000 and a small number with a salary of 100000 and above. And for the most part, not because they are lazy, but because there is no abundance of production in the country ... What does the election have to do with it? Can you get by with the Board of Honor?
            1. ANB
              ANB 1 December 2020 14: 16
              -1
              ... Andrey, I hope this is not a prick in my address, about the sites ...

              No, not yours.
              Actually, I don't like the amount of switching to a new bet. The proposals from Zhirinovsky and Mironov were from 10 million per year. Accepted from 5. You offer from 1. 100 thousand per month - not that big salary.
              And for some reason, an increase in the tax on dividends and the withdrawal of capital is not considered. Everyone rested on the progressive personal income tax rate.
              My opinion: the scale should be flat. This is a reasonable compromise between a per capita tax and overburdening many workers.
              Servicemen must be exempted from personal income tax.
              Look for money in the bottom sections, which are right in sight.
              1. Alexfly
                Alexfly 1 December 2020 15: 20
                0
                Salaries in the regions of Russia, at existing enterprises, are far from 100000 per month, in Moscow this is a different story ... Therefore, over 1 million. a year you can already start progressive. Otherwise, it's a super profit tax ...
                1. ANB
                  ANB 1 December 2020 15: 36
                  0
                  ... Otherwise, it's a super profit tax ...

                  This should be the tax on super profits. Otherwise, it is fair to simply raise the tax rate.
                2. ANB
                  ANB 1 December 2020 16: 30
                  0
                  ... Salaries in the regions of Russia, at existing enterprises, are far from 100000 per month, in Moscow this is a different story.

                  Personal income tax is paid to the regional budget.
                  That is, it turns out that this will give nothing to the regions, and Sobyanin no longer knows where to spend it. Shifts tiles 5 times a year.
        2. ANB
          ANB 30 November 2020 22: 19
          +1
          My mother, in order to earn her 100 (not in Moscow), at the age of 000, being a GUI, she wandered around construction sites all over the country. And why should she pay more tax than a bummer?
        3. ANB
          ANB 30 November 2020 23: 12
          -1
          And why should a hard worker pay a tax more than a security guard in Magnet, who drives a noodle all day and catches old women, allegedly for stealing?
          Wouldn't it be better to remove from state funding the football clubs where salaries are taken from my taxes, without doing anything useful? And they can't even win.
      2. Arpad
        Arpad 1 December 2020 09: 07
        -1
        Quote: ANB
        Should services from the state also be differential?
        The recipient of 10 pays 000, 1300 pays 100. Both are salaried workers. But the first did not want to study and they do not take him for another job, as he was drinking. The second was educated and plows seven days a week. He is 000 times more unfastening than a bummer. Do you think you owe even more? Can a lazy person not pay tax at all?

        of course I should.
        The tax should be progressive, as in all countries (normal) - of course I don't like this at all. but I (as an example) - pay 47%.
        Sadly, yes, but still true.
    2. solzh
      solzh 30 November 2020 21: 55
      +24
      Quote: AlexFly
      Tax must be differential

      So you are proposing to introduce "gray" salaries again? And thereby deprive our citizens in the future of their already small pension?
      1. Alexfly
        Alexfly 1 December 2020 15: 21
        -1
        And where am I talking about gray salaries?
  • Vladimir Vladimirovich S
    Vladimir Vladimirovich S 30 November 2020 17: 28
    +7
    Article (my opinion) - "Water-water".
    Analysis in the Topic of publication - not disclosed.
    You can "minus" ...
    What "reforms" ?, The common people are already the "Purple color" of government policy.
    Survival in the current conditions of life is what is interesting to Workers ...
  • Van 16
    Van 16 30 November 2020 18: 28
    +5
    We have no successful reforms.
    However, in December, Putin will make his show "visiting a fairy tale" and tell how wonderful everything is with us.
    1. veritas
      veritas 30 November 2020 19: 02
      +2
      Quote: Van 16
      We have no successful reforms.
      However, in December, Putin will make his show "visiting a fairy tale" and tell how wonderful everything is with us.

      No .. he will say there is a problem. But there are also Pechenegs and Polovtsians who interfere. Look at Ukraine, the West is rotting.
      And then he will add that everything will be even better.
      I wonder how many people, after "visiting a fairy tale," then wash the TVs.
      1. Van 16
        Van 16 30 November 2020 19: 26
        0
        Absolutely right. There are problems, we are solving them very successfully, blah-blah-blah, and then, as you wrote ..
  • Departure
    Departure 30 November 2020 19: 08
    +1
    There were some successful undertakings. Public services and the MFC have already been named. For some reason, I did not see a single comment about reducing the service life to 1 year. This is a year, guys, you know what a year of a young life is, up to 30 years old every year counts, then you no longer feel it. Thank you for returning this year. Preferential service close to home, isn't it a bad undertaking? One more thing I remember, at some point in the police reforms of the plush, many unreliable elements were cleaned out. Unfortunately, the cleaning of the ranks mainly affected the rank and file, but the station lads, who were stripping the guards from the provinces to the bone, disappeared somewhere.
    That's all the good reforms remembered for 20 years of victories. Mat. I cannot call capital a significant undertaking, since the market always reacts to such initiatives with an instant painful compensatory increase in prices for everything from TVP to living space.
  • 16112014nk
    16112014nk 30 November 2020 19: 52
    +7
    Successful reforms in Russia

    Is this such a joke of humor?
  • faterdom
    faterdom 30 November 2020 20: 44
    +1
    It seems that someone on the highest levels of the power hierarchy is playing just against the current vertical

    Some kind of oxymoron ...
    And who is there on the uppermost levels of the hierarchy?
    I remember Korovin's 6th grade history textbook. Drawing "Feudal Staircase". Above, the king is the only one, naked, not naked, it doesn't matter: the king. Absolute monarch. Not for two terms of four and two for six, but for good! Because from God!
    True, not everyone succeeded in 8 + 12, but it happened, what was there ... From 50 to 70 years at the top.
    "The state is me!"
    By the way, the author of this pearl handed over power in a straight line to his great-grandson! The Sun King was called, in a simple way, in a popular way.
    So there was something positive then: after such a statement, to look for someone who, like, secretly runs my state - just make me laugh.
    There was such, Nicolas Fouquet, a kind of Siluanov-Gref-Nabiulina in one bottle. He finished badly. But the king, as the Sun was, and died as the Sun.
  • solzh
    solzh 30 November 2020 21: 48
    +29
    Successful reforms in Russia in recent years

    I don’t remember anything successful reforms ... Or is it such humor?
  • Alex66
    Alex66 1 December 2020 07: 07
    +1
    Meanwhile, there have been certain advantages over the past ten years, and it is easy to name them. Look about EdRo livened up for the elections began to prepare. Replace the retirement age.
  • Stalnov I.P.
    Stalnov I.P. 1 December 2020 10: 26
    +3
    I must say honestly, all domestic policy, in particular the economy, cadres, ideologists, has completely failed, and in aggregate, now foreign policy is limping on both legs. For 20 years, a financial-oligarchic, capitalist system has been created, thieving, corruption, cynical, mediocre, working only for a certain handful of people, and not to improve the welfare of the majority of the PEOPLE. Conclusion, the leaders and managers of the country have very low professionalism in terms of the development of the national economic complex, lack of political will, strategic thinking and planning. And the prospects are NOT VISIBLE, talking shop, fairy tales and promises that are simply not fulfilled.
  • Yaroslavl
    Yaroslavl 1 December 2020 10: 57
    +1
    At first I wanted to angrily oppose, but after reading to the end I saw that the author was saying everything in the case ... these are not reforms of the financial capital and even more so 15% tax for the rich, and I don't even know how to call it mildly ... power, nothing more ... and in all other respects it is even worse, everywhere there is a complete failure and collapse, instead of a breakthrough and a breakthrough ... it is going to mass demonstrations
  • 7,62h54
    7,62h54 1 December 2020 13: 14
    0
    Much nonsense has been written, but what about the reforms, what reforms have been carried out?
  • Bersaglieri
    Bersaglieri 1 December 2020 13: 38
    +2
    The most correct and successfully implemented reform is the introduction of digital document management ("State Services" and the MFC).
  • The comment was deleted.
  • hydroy
    hydroy 2 December 2020 00: 43
    0
    Honestly, there are no successful MEGA economic and social reforms. Mat capital may be a good reform, but it will not seriously solve the demographic problem. And so it is necessary to reform the labor code, to prescribe the minimum salary per hour. Protect workers, not employers. And you can also establish certain preferences for graduates of various universities and secondary specialized education, so that they can get a normal job in their specialty and the possibilities of applying their knowledge.
  • hydroy
    hydroy 2 December 2020 00: 45
    0
    And the most important thing is to set limits on prices so that they do not grow significantly, to limit price increases if wages do not grow ...
  • The comment was deleted.
  • kig
    kig 2 December 2020 04: 48
    +1
    Every increase in the mother's capital is immediately followed by an increase in the cost of housing. As a result - all at the same broken trough.
  • amr
    amr 2 December 2020 17: 55
    0
    I don’t understand conducted a survey of the population? or the Kremlin asked the author to write an article about how the people support the reforms ???

    what apartment can I buy for 450tr? even in the provinces?
    In rural areas, for that kind of money, you can find your own home ownership, albeit unpretentious, but still better than nothing.

    to the doghouse ??
  • seacap
    seacap 3 December 2020 18: 54
    +3
    Matkapital is not a help to parents, not a solution to the demographic issue, it is a banal financing of the banking system, and only, they also found me a reform, i.e. a temporary measure.
    All significant achievements have remained in the past, which they diligently want to present to us as "terrible and bloody, the prison of nations", therefore, all their failures, wretchedness and failure, their inability to solve at least some issues, cover up with liberal verbiage, slogans and constant hypocritical cries of victory 75 years ago, hiding behind portraits of their great ancestors, whose names and memories were immediately trampled into the mud with their "truthful novels and memories of gulags and nkvdshniks, stupid and always drunk commanders.
    The current generation has no victories, there is 30 years of shame and betrayal, a once great power, there is a vile betrayal of its friends and allies, squandering of all the achievements of previous generations of a great people.
    1. Yaroslavl
      Yaroslavl 4 December 2020 08: 53
      0
      More than true
    2. fif21
      fif21 5 December 2020 20: 50
      0
      Quote: seacap
      The current generation has no victories, there is 30 years of shame and betrayal, a once great power, there is a vile betrayal of its friends and allies, squandering of all the achievements of previous generations of a great people.

      good good good
  • fif21
    fif21 5 December 2020 20: 48
    +1
    Negative - prices for basic goods in 20 increased by 14%. Positive - official inflation for the year 20 4,1-4,3% tongue And what is the 3% indexation of pensions worth? And what awaits at 21 - the rise in prices for housing and communal services and goods. Most "successes" are deceitful; living standards are falling. Optimization, layoffs, layoffs, an increase in mortality, and we are being told about mother capital, an increase in the tax on the rich by as much as 2%. hi
  • tech3030
    tech3030 6 December 2020 09: 28
    0
    Some singer may not be popular, but what the authorities create ... I have no good words, what I would like to say is banned here.
  • Vladimir Balaev
    Vladimir Balaev 7 December 2020 13: 53
    0
    Do diplomats have a principle of reciprocity, but do the military and other structures of the state? I did not invent it and do not call for any kind of escalation - just - it exists and it must be strictly observed - The Turks killed our ambassador-! Why is their ambassador in Moscow running around? He wants to live - for a hundred years - home in Turkey, they shot down two of our planes and four turntables - shoot them down the same amount - killed three generals - remove the heads from three Turkish - an eye -! NTV arrested kov-arrest and Turkish journalists - everything is mirrored in relation to any country, and as ours wrote - he forced himself to respect!