Putin: Russian food exports exceeded arms exports

84
Speaking at the “Russia Calling!” Business forum, the Russian president commented on the successes of the domestic agricultural industry and compared it with the arms export industry. According to Vladimir Putin, the sale of food from Russia abroad in 2016 increased almost 5% compared to the year 2015.

Vladimir Putin:
At the end of 2016, our exports of food and agricultural products increased by 4,9%, which amounted to 17,1 billion dollars. And for the whole 2016 year, we sold weapons on 15,3 billion.




Thus, as the president noted, food exports overtook arms exports.

Putin: Russian food exports exceeded arms exports


President Putin:
We will continue to remove barriers and increase export support.


It is noted that the growth of Russian food exports is taking place against the background of unprecedented economic pressure on Russia. Economic sanctions imposed by the West, have been operating for more than three years. However, as it turned out, it even helped Russia to increase the volume of exports of the same agricultural products and expand the markets for domestic products.

Armenian Finance Minister Vardan Aramyan against the background of the visit of Russian Prime Minister Dmitry Medvedev to Yerevan, said today that “sanctions have helped Russia to get off the oil needle.”
84 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +8
    24 October 2017 15: 54
    I’m glad ... that slowly we’ll slip off the ,, oil needle ,,
    Paraffin as GDP ,, pacified ,, oleharhoffff ,,
    1. +10
      24 October 2017 16: 07
      Quote: himRa
      Paraffin as GDP ,, pacified ,, oleharhoffff ,,
      - And South Korea has revenues from the export of integrated circuits of 49,3 billion dollars only. So far we still ...
      1. +7
        24 October 2017 16: 12
        Quote: oldseaman1957
        - South Korea’s income

        Try Parashenko now to squeeze the oligarchs will kill him! The GDP, with the help of patriotism and the West, blocked oxygen for them and, as it were, nothing to do with ... I do not deny there are disadvantages, but ... for example, 3% growth is planned for next year ...
        1. +3
          24 October 2017 16: 46
          Very good. And for this success it was necessary to run into sanctions .. what kind of people are we ...?)))
          1. +9
            24 October 2017 16: 52
            what kind of people are we ...?)))

            Which is, there is no other
            1. 0
              25 October 2017 08: 24
              Another is not necessary
          2. +2
            24 October 2017 20: 10
            Quote: maxim947
            what kind of people are we ...?)))


            Yes, the people are, in general, robust and not bad ... Only here, the leaders are often shaking hands ...
            Here he says: "Remove unnecessary barriers to import-export" (see above, in the article) ...
            And here the WTO is in full swing, or rather, its rules ... We are agricultural products THERE, and on our shelves at least half of agricultural products are HERE .... Oh well, if exotic mango-pineapple-avocado ... And that’s - potatoes, onions, carrots ... I’m not talking about much else ...
            And look at the sugar in the shops - most of it - where? Ugh, I don’t even want to talk ...
            Assistance to OUR agricultural producer so far mainly - only in words and also mainly - only to the largest agricultural companies ...
            This year, I went to Tula several times this year, to the regional clinical diagnostic center ... The type of fields is not very happy ... Many (I have already written and talked about this more than once) are overgrown with weeds and bushes ... But we have not SeverA, not the Vologda_Arkhangelsk_Murmansk region, but the central part of Russia with a normal climate and normal soil ...
            Of course, I’m glad that it’s not only the state’s budget that’s replenished with oil and gas ... However, you don’t need to deal with idle talk ... If you come from the point of view of a real assessment of the country's food security, then ... hmm ... not quite safe ... sorry for the pun ...
            That’s the point of view to consider victories or victories in agriculture ... Will we (our leadership) be able to feed the country in the case of REAL sanctions, when they will not allow us to breathe or swap ??? fool
            1. +3
              25 October 2017 08: 25
              Yes, the people are, in general, robust and not bad ... Only here, the leaders are often shaking hands ...[i] [/ i]
              They do not fall to us from heaven, all of the people
      2. +2
        24 October 2017 18: 44
        Quote: oldseaman1957
        - And South Korea has revenues from the export of integrated circuits of 49,3 billion dollars only.

        The only problem is that Russia DOES NOT export integrated circuits ... If we had just 17 billion income from exporting integrated circuits, then yes, it would be a shame, and food is a rather cheap thing, oddly enough. And then the ruble is very cheap, so the dollar amount is very small.
      3. +3
        25 October 2017 04: 54
        They made a greenhouse regime for export to the United States as opposed to the DPRK. And, yes - years through 15 it turns out that the economic miracle of South Korea is a mirage. There are such problems with demography that at the time everything is dropped and started to work in three shifts not with the head, but with completely different parts of the body. Otherwise, in a generation they themselves will surrender to the northerners - if only there would be someone to look after the old people.
      4. +4
        25 October 2017 08: 04
        He who feeds the world rules him. I don’t remember who said it.
        1. 0
          25 October 2017 23: 50
          Feed the world US dollars.
          Your fake is off topic.
          But on our salary and pension much of the products are also inaccessible, and what is there to rejoice about.
          1. 0
            26 October 2017 00: 38
            Quote: stas
            But on our salary and pension much of the products are also inaccessible, and what is there to rejoice about.

            Please list. which products are not available to you, and we will listen ...
      5. +1
        25 October 2017 08: 56
        We have already forgotten what it is.
    2. +5
      24 October 2017 16: 52
      Paraffin as GDP ,, pacified ,, oleharhoffff ,,

      Everyone wants to live and live well, it’s enough for the clever to give a chance to choose (and the oligarchs are not fools) and he will make it.
    3. +3
      24 October 2017 18: 37
      When they cease to withdraw billions from Russia into OFFshores, then it will be possible to say that GDP ,, pacified ,, olegarchoffff ,,
      1. +2
        24 October 2017 19: 38
        Quote: valton
        When they cease to withdraw billions from Russia into OFFshores, then it will be possible to say that GDP ,, pacified ,, olegarchoffff ,,

        Well, if you are realistic, then this and even on a large scale is, for example, in China ...
        1. +1
          25 October 2017 18: 38
          When you put things in order in your house, you don’t have to look, but what about your neighbor. Who knows, it may be better for Russia that they have displayed on an even larger scale. Time will tell.
        2. +1
          26 October 2017 00: 42
          Rectal thermocryptoanalysis works wonders when looking for passwords from numbered accounts. It just needs political will.
    4. 0
      25 October 2017 23: 50
      that's for sure, life is improving. but why? The Russian Grain Union explained what caused the use of wheat intended for livestock feed when baking bread. “It’s no secret that feed wheat (5th grade) is used for bread production. It is used in the so-called“ bodyguard ”: they use improvers, some amount of 4th grade wheat, they make cheaper and better receive a grinding party, "the president of the Grain Union, Arkady Zlochevsky, told reporters.

      Commenting on reports about the preparation of GOST, allowing the use of 5th grade wheat for the production of bread, he said that this initiative essentially "enshrines the current state of things in regulatory documents."
  2. +2
    24 October 2017 15: 55
    This is already nice. Only question - When will we feel it? People have no money, and the "pillars" of democracy are living.
    1. +4
      24 October 2017 16: 22
      Export of rabid wheat, peas are bought on the vine (especially chickpeas)
      We will feel when more people in this area begin to work
      1. +4
        24 October 2017 16: 26
        The same raw materials as oil. Need more processing. Then employment will be.
        1. +8
          24 October 2017 16: 59
          The same raw materials as oil

          What is it if it is renewable?
          And in general, take the grain. What kind of processing do you propose to export rolls?
          1. +2
            24 October 2017 17: 04
            Can and rolls with preservatives. Well, at least flour. For instance. But who knows what? We buy all sorts of cookies.
            1. +4
              24 October 2017 17: 48
              Quote: BerBer
              Can and rolls with preservatives. Well, at least flour. For instance. But who knows what? We buy all sorts of cookies.

              Do you understand what you said? Do you know what conditions for flour storage are needed? And transportation. For the price such flour will be gold. Who will need such flour. And about the rolls - what bread do you prefer? Fresh or a week ago? Only honestly.
              1. +1
                24 October 2017 23: 23
                Quote: Muvka
                Quote: BerBer
                Can and rolls with preservatives. Well, at least flour. For instance. But who knows what? We buy all sorts of cookies.

                Do you understand what you said? Do you know what conditions for flour storage are needed? And transportation. For the price such flour will be gold. Who will need such flour. And about the rolls - what bread do you prefer? Fresh or a week ago? Only honestly.

                And so the Turkish flour. And with it there are no problems in storage and transportation
                1. +1
                  25 October 2017 08: 45
                  Thank you fellow countryman. Southerners understood each other. laughing
              2. +2
                25 October 2017 08: 43
                Go shopping. See what they sell to us. Semi-finished products of Western production, despite the sanctions are full. I prefer fresh. But there are many options. For example, if you don’t cycle on wheat, the Turks buy sunflower from us, process it and sell oil to their neighbors. Can't we do it. Pack and do the primary processing of legumes, rice, millet and so on. There are many examples to cite. It should be comprehensive - economics + politics.
            2. +7
              24 October 2017 18: 08
              Can and buns with preservatives

              How would you explain, so as not to offend?
              Cows do not eat flour, and it’s not accepted to feed them with rolls in the world.
          2. 0
            24 October 2017 22: 49
            Quote: bk316
            What is it if it is renewable?

            For the time being. It is worth screwing up the technology for a short time and the past harvests will go down the drain, as was the case with the virgin soil. Yes, and the soil after intensive use one way or another degrade.
            1. +3
              25 October 2017 10: 53
              Yes, and the soil after intensive use one way or another degrade.

              What are you all-propellers, either complaining that the lands are standing under steam, or are being used too intensively?
              How does this fit into the picture of the world?
        2. +1
          24 October 2017 23: 22
          Quote: BerBer
          The same raw materials as oil. Need more processing. Then employment will be.

          I fully and completely agree.
          1. 0
            26 October 2017 14: 36
            Quote: Krasnodar
            I fully and completely agree.

            Yeah, only it’s impossible to export bakery products - you’ll harden while you carry it, flour is also not an option — you will reduce the circle of consumers, because a buyer in the West can make everything out of grain. what he wants, but the finished flour is already a serious limitation of its use - you can’t feed cattle with flour, but you can grain)
            Etc. etc ...
    2. +3
      24 October 2017 19: 57
      Quote: BerBer
      People have no money

      And when did people have money?
      - When was oil 120 each?
      1. +3
        25 October 2017 08: 50
        For myself and others I judge. Until the age of 14, it was better. The main sanction blow was taken by the population. The oligarchs only got rich during this time. Yes, we are not starving, but purchasing power has fallen.
        1. +3
          25 October 2017 10: 58
          , we are not starving, but purchasing power has fallen.

          Of course I fell, the course has changed.
          True sanctions here in general nothing to do with, it determines all the exchange rates, but it depends on the price of oil. I will not say anything about the oligarchs, it is obvious that those who sell oil are not particularly rich.
          And in general, what do you mean when you say get rich?
          Income or wealth?
          1. +1
            25 October 2017 13: 30
            If I am not mistaken, the first five in Forbes for $ 100 billion in positive territory. Is a drop in purchasing power and an increased exchange rate good? And with sanctions.
  3. +3
    24 October 2017 16: 22
    If everything is so beautiful, why is it so expensive in stores?
    1. +10
      24 October 2017 16: 57
      Everything is expensive for a beggar, everything is cheap for a rich.
      You are probably a rogue.
      1. +4
        24 October 2017 18: 36
        About 30% are already going to the polls, even fewer people vote for your party, and you continue to beat the show-offs, which are all bad, except for you ... Madame de Pompadour was the same as you ... she ended badly
        1. +4
          24 October 2017 19: 38
          even less votes for your party

          I DO NOT HAVE MY OWN PARTY.
          I did not say anything that everything is BAD around.
          You understand what’s the matter, you don’t see a lot of things around you and even make unfounded assumptions. This is a sign of a serious disorder, by the way I'm not surprised, your NIK says about it, to be called the name of a goddess, and even the goddess of retaliation is not very healthy.
          1. +2
            24 October 2017 20: 12
            You think that all around are losers, of course, except you and other parishioners of the drunkard. Retribution is a good thing, this dish is served cold, and those who feel sins are afraid of it. People like you put a guard at the monument to the drunk, but the people do not like this monument and it will fall, together with the authorities who have erected it and you know this no worse than me, this is only a matter of time ...
            1. +3
              25 October 2017 10: 39
              You think that all around are losers, of course, except you and other parishioners of the drunkard. Such as you have guarded the monument to the wino, but

              If you had bothered to read my comments, you would have known my attitude towards EBN and its center, but you don’t need this, people with mental disorders do not care about the world around them. This is called nonsense.
              So consult a specialist before it’s too late; your nonsense is of no interest to anyone except him.
              1. +1
                25 October 2017 21: 28
                But I’m not interested in reading all your correspondence ... I don’t understand the meaning of what you wrote to me, apparently you have no contact with anyone and you haven’t been taught courtesy on the street for a long time ... Do not write me more.
      2. 0
        24 October 2017 23: 30
        Quote: bk316
        Everything is expensive for a beggar, everything is cheap for a rich.
        You are probably a rogue.

        In fact, the rich and the rich because the loot is considered.
        I can afford to buy a Swiss watch in Moscow, but I will lose 6 thousand euros on this. If I buy in Switzerland, it will be cheaper, but if I buy in the branded boutique of this brand in Vienna (oddly enough), then, taking into account the VAT refund for foreigners (tax free), I will save these 6000 euros. But ... only if I'm going to Vienna. And I won’t buy this watch at all.
        1. +3
          25 October 2017 10: 41
          In fact, the rich and the rich because the loot is considered.

          They think - yes save - no.
          The correct proverb is this: the rich is not the one who spends a little, the rich is the one who earns a lot.
    2. +6
      24 October 2017 17: 51
      Did not notice that expensive. Pork is not frozen minced meat as a table 4 years ago about 250 rubles, and now it costs. And the chicken. And the eggs. And buckwheat ... well, I'll go to the wilds. In short, if anything has risen in price, these are some fruits and vegetables. And that’s not all. We can find a kilo of potatoes for 9 rubles - it's a penny.
      1. +7
        24 October 2017 18: 09
        Didn't notice that expensive

        So you are not a rogue. bully
      2. +1
        24 October 2017 20: 18
        In the summer, potatoes cost 50 rubles, now 12 and then at the wholesale ... Tell your tales to those who do not go shopping.
        1. +1
          24 October 2017 22: 39
          Is 12 expensive?
          1. +1
            25 October 2017 21: 30
            12 is not expensive, but 50-70, as it was in the summer, is not cheap ...
      3. 0
        24 October 2017 23: 33
        Quote: Muvka
        Did not notice that expensive. Pork is not frozen minced meat as a table 4 years ago about 250 rubles, and now it costs. And the chicken. And the eggs. And buckwheat ... well, I'll go to the wilds. In short, if anything has risen in price, these are some fruits and vegetables. And that’s not all. We can find a kilo of potatoes for 9 rubles - it's a penny.

        If in 2013 I left Tabris (Krasnodar Alphabet of Taste type) with 6 - 7 thousand loss (family products for a week), now I go out from 10-12. Here is the arithmetic.
        1. 0
          26 October 2017 14: 41
          Hmm ... And here I am, in the Moscow region for a minute I feel a maximum of 1000 rubles of growth over all the years - that is, in the 14th I gave 5000 rubles for a certain average package of products, now about 6000 rubles.

          But here’s what I noticed - about how everything “went up, there is no money, nothing to eat” shout in 90% of cases, those who, as it turns out, bought a new iPhone, a new car, etc., and did it exactly in the midst of a crisis ... Don't you find a strange pattern?
    3. +1
      24 October 2017 20: 11
      Quote: Nemesis
      why is it so expensive in stores?

      You just have to jump, and forget about the high cost.
      1. +1
        24 October 2017 20: 14
        Someone else is jumping at this pace ...
  4. 0
    24 October 2017 16: 30
    Quote: Nemesis
    If everything is so beautiful, why is it so expensive in stores?

    This is our strategy!
    1. 0
      24 October 2017 16: 43
      Strategy to achieve Maidan?
      1. +2
        24 October 2017 17: 01
        Quote: groks
        Strategy to achieve Maidan?

        Maidan and madhouse words synonyms ...
        Will you go wassat
        1. 0
          24 October 2017 18: 26
          Today they said that they could drive out in the BS. If such successes continue, then I may not go right away, since the Maidan will probably organize some kind of dirty trick. But when there is nothing to eat - I will go. And I will choose the Maidan people frostbite - so that they pay attention. But for many, patience will end sooner.
          The reason for the alleged BS? But it’s very simple - now you can’t take an advance payment under state defense orders. Not at all. And why the hell are we buying materials for that GOZ?
          1. +2
            24 October 2017 18: 54
            BS, as I understand it, is lack of maintenance on vacation ... and this means that it is not a matter of materials or money for them, but that you are ahead of schedule!
            You can be envied; you have GOZ!
            Many enterprises are spinning as they can (I have never been an economist)
            I’m sure you won’t go anywhere because economists have learned how to, adjust, the average salary in the city ... and everywhere it is the same, even in private business ...
            With ,, hunger ,, do not die, do not worry, but there will be time for ,, economy ,, hi
            Quote: groks
            Today they said that they could drive out in the BS. If such successes continue, then I may not go right away, since the Maidan will probably organize some kind of dirty trick. But when there is nothing to eat - I will go. And I will choose the Maidan people frostbite - so that they pay attention. But for many, patience will end sooner.
            The reason for the alleged BS? But it’s very simple - now you can’t take an advance payment under state defense orders. Not at all. And why the hell are we buying materials for that GOZ?
            1. 0
              24 October 2017 18: 58
              but the fact that you are ahead of the schedule!
              Yes? If we cannot start to do something, because we have not bought materials, then we are clearly ahead of schedule!
              but there will be time for
              Ehhhh ... I mean? Scratch?
              1. +2
                24 October 2017 19: 20
                Quote: groks
                Ehhhh ... I mean? Scratch?

                Pretend to be a fool?
                or want to say that you live on the same salary and want stars from heaven .... want more ... you can jump for a change
                1. +1
                  24 October 2017 19: 34
                  Pretend to be a fool?
                  What remains? In response to "get ahead."
                  Yes - I live on one salary of an engineer in the defense industry. The extra income directly depends on the welfare of the people around me. If everyone puts their teeth on the shelf, then taking money from the same beggars will be just a shit. Is such a term familiar? I try not to take it now, I just maintain the level.
                  1. +2
                    24 October 2017 19: 53
                    *********
                    started with hunger cumshot ,, for the state offensively ,,
                    *******************
                    come on, bye ..
                    1. 0
                      25 October 2017 08: 27
                      Type offended.
                      Dear Sirs, I want to give advice - get back to reality as soon as possible. And then soon they will begin to beat for your enthusiasm. As reality is increasingly detached from this enthusiasm.
                    2. +1
                      25 October 2017 23: 55
                      well-fed not hungry, but to teach life, master
    2. The comment was deleted.
  5. +4
    24 October 2017 17: 34
    Honestly, I go to the store every other day and I don’t understand in any way where this super success in agriculture is!
    1. +1
      24 October 2017 18: 18
      I myself rarely go to the store. But from my mother I hear that, here, the end of October, there are a lot of seasonal products and that there are a lot of promotions. She has her favorite shops in St. Petersburg. There are products in bright packaging, they are more expensive than in simple.
      I read once a long time ago a newspaper that earlier in the USSR there was such a thing as a mobilization economy. That the Russian Federation is not able to do it right now. Well, it would have worked out.
  6. +1
    24 October 2017 18: 38
    "At the end of 2016 <...> the export of food and agricultural products increased by 4,9%, which amounted to $ 17,1 billion. For the entire 2016, we sold weapons for $ 15,3 billion," he said.

    The rapid increase in food exports, exceeding the export of weapons and good and bad.
    By armament
    Nevertheless, this segment in the general structure of domestic exports is still small: 2,5-3 percent before the devaluation of the ruble and up to 4 percent — now
    .
    For me, the weapons market is much better in terms of high value-added products and services. than just exporting primary raw materials (for example, 3 grains and lower grades).
    The main balance. But prices in the country are reflected in the increase (food prices) for the balance with export prices. A system of subsidies and preferences is needed, but it will be sent to corporations. But they prefer profit-than price stabilization in the domestic market ...
    1. 0
      26 October 2017 14: 45
      Quote: Catherine II
      But on domestic prices reflected in the increase

      Respected. Nobody has been working in Russia for a long time on the principle of “we’ll not eat, but we’ll take out”, and prices are rising annually due to ruble inflation, the reasons for which are a completely different story.
  7. 0
    24 October 2017 19: 28
    Thus, as the president noted, food exports overtook arms exports. Why rub the glasses? Yes, even on the forum. If the numbers are not invented, then we consider the column - 17,1 yards - 5% = 16, with copecks in 2015 ...... i.e. it turns out we were ahead of last year's figures for agricultural exports, we just sold less weapons in 2016. And this is not surprising, the market with all the wars oversaturated weapons. In other words, we can’t sell anymore, we don’t have anything new yet that could .... helicopters, Terminators a couple of, and the S-400 are our shock contracts. But not all NATO members will buy the S-400, Indians and Chinese will rather confine themselves to the samples, or they will build it under their own license, are there several more Arab state-owned TVs and everything? What else can we offer to the foreign market, which is so crowded? Armata? But she is raw. So that?

    Our 15 yards is the ceiling, then as forums do not call and who do not invite, they will still wait for serious discounts.

    We sold out heavily on these sanctions, poured the market for guns and tanks ...... the further we will plug the budget gaps? There is still this trick for the elections should be so that the Papuans correctly vote, so what to raise pensions? or index?

    Everything goes out of stagnation for the president of Russia, but he doesn’t specify which Kremlin corridor it creeps into and into which pocket the Karigan oligarch? like Rotenberg, the bridge is completed ..... I can imagine what a breakthrough Russia will make after the construction of the bridge. Oh yes - there Sakhalin is outlined, again unlucky with a way out of stagnation. bully
  8. +2
    24 October 2017 19: 51
    Quote: oldseaman1957
    And South Korea has revenues from the export of integrated circuits of 49,3 billion dollars. So far we still ...

    GOING will master the road !!!
  9. +1
    25 October 2017 09: 34
    It is strange that food prices are rising inside Russia, despite all the mantras about increasing its production and lowering inflation! Something is wrong in the Danish kingdom!
    1. 0
      26 October 2017 14: 50
      Do the words "inflation", "cartel conspiracy", "monopoly" not say anything to you? The problem is. that we have huge ruble inflation in our country (there are many reasons and they are very diverse), plus we simply do NOT have antitrust laws, and when we have different, at first glance, retail chains, for example, Pyaterochka, Victoria and Perekrestok "one owner, then prices in all stores will rise simultaneously and regularly.
      1. 0
        26 October 2017 16: 31
        And why the antitrust laws do not work, do not tell me? And please tell me how much do you think the margin on products in the networks? And are retail chains lobbying their business in the State Duma and the Government?
        1. 0
          26 October 2017 16: 52
          Quote: andrej-shironov
          And why the antitrust laws do not work, do not tell me?

          Because the real owners are sitting / have ties in the country's leadership - the work of antitrust legislation is trite disadvantage to very many influential figures.

          Quote: andrej-shironov
          And please tell me how much do you think the margin on products in the networks?

          It depends on the type of product - the margin can reach 200% and 300%, and not necessarily in the networks - our domestic trade, in principle, gives huge margins on goods. The reason is still the same - hidden monopolies and cartel conspiracies in this area, plus a huge number of resellers.

          Quote: andrej-shironov
          And are retail chains lobbying their business in the State Duma and the Government?

          Of course lobby! Actually, many of their owners / co-owners live there. A very clear example is the war of Sobyanin against "small" trade in favor of large trading networks.
          1. 0
            26 October 2017 17: 50
            And it remains to ask; who is to blame?
            1. 0
              26 October 2017 22: 33
              Well, you’re just asking the original “Russian questions” - you just have to ask “what to do?”))))
              This is to blame for so many random and regular factors, and so many people, too, both random and extremely interested, that a one-year course of lectures is required to describe all this.
              In short, the current situation in the country is a logical result of the incompetent activities of first citizen Gorbachev and then frankly criminal activity of citizen Yeltsin ... And we will, alas, be the fruits of their activity. reap a long time.
              On the other hand, all these Western "sanctions" are somewhat sobering on some of our "leaders" ...
              1. 0
                27 October 2017 07: 39
                Those. Do you think that the activities of citizen Putin, coupled with a mediocre government and neoliberals, are good?
                1. The comment was deleted.
                  1. 0
                    27 October 2017 17: 45
                    :-) Speak well! And I would even agree with you. But I do not agree. At the moment, I consider the activities of citizen Putin and the Government of the Russian Federation to be criminal, relative to Russia.
                    1. 0
                      27 October 2017 18: 09
                      Quote: andrej-shironov
                      At the moment, I consider the activities of citizen Putin and the Government of the Russian Federation to be criminal, relative to Russia.

                      In this case, I ask you to argue your position.
                      1. 0
                        28 October 2017 09: 43
                        And you do not know these arguments? Maybe our industry is growing? Is the demographic situation improving? High level education? There are still a lot of all kinds of arguments, but I think you yourself know them.
  10. 0
    4 November 2017 14: 36
    andrej-shironov,
    Quote: andrej-shironov
    And you do not know these arguments? Maybe our industry is growing? Is the demographic situation improving? High level education? There are still a lot of all kinds of arguments, but I think you yourself know them.

    I'm sorry that I didn’t answer for so long - I was sitting in the bathhouse. Regarding the "arguments" - I will give you a short example from personal experience - my father is an engineer and most of his friends are also engineers, they mostly work at enterprises of different directions in different regions of Russia - who is in the Moscow region (like my dad), some in St. Petersburg, some in Magnitogorsk. So now they all unanimously say that the intensity of the work of factories has increased dramatically, new jobs began to appear and new young cadres appeared gradually. Of course there are problems with a cart and a small cart, but the work has gone and it pleases.
    Regarding demography, yes. everything is difficult, but as an example, most of my former classmates, with whom I still keep in touch, and those who are married (and most of them) give birth to their second child. One, I still can’t sway all))) At the same time, everyone lives in Russia, note that there are no "millionaires" among them.
    Regarding education, I myself am currently working in this area, I know what horror there is. but there are also positive trends - for example, throughout the hated USE, tests for tasks with a detailed answer are being actively replaced, while timid rumors are leaking from the ministry that everyone who is disgusted will be seriously reformed to our needs. In schools, they have actively resumed such a useful thing as Design and Research Activities, for all classes from 5th to 10th ...
    So my advice to you is to try to collect as much information as possible, analyze and draw conclusions ... hi