Military Review

Google changed the decision on "renaming" in the Crimea

83
The Google Maps service, after brief deliberation, decided to return the usual names to the localities that they had “renamed” the day before, guided by the decision of the Ukrainian Verkhovna Rada. Recall that the "renaming" Google Maps produced both in the Ukrainian and in the Russian version of its service, while in the Russian version "leaving" the peninsula as part of Russia.


It is known that the Ukrainian side demanded from the Google team to transfer “under its jurisdiction” and the Crimea itself on electronic maps in the Russian version, but instead the Google team decided to cancel the previously renamed “renaming”.

Google changed the decision on "renaming" in the Crimea


Earlier, the service changed the names of a number of settlements of the peninsula. So, Krasnogvardeyskoe on the Google electronic map became Kurman, and Krasnoperekopsk — Yany Kapu.

On the eve of the head of the Crimea Sergey Aksyonov "renamed" settlements on maps Google called the work in the "fantasy genre" and "podsovyvaniem propaganda product instead of real maps."

After returning to the electronic resource of ordinary names to the Crimean settlements, Crimeans themselves noted that "Google remembered that people need maps to navigate in geography, and not practice politics."
83 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 29 July 2016 13: 52
    +7
    Have you recovered? Or got "in the brain"?
    1. poquello
      poquello 29 July 2016 13: 58
      +14
      Quote: Mountain Shooter
      Have you recovered? Or got "in the brain"?

      received by brain, lucidly explained to them that they work with these cards in Russia, but may not work
      1. marl
        marl 29 July 2016 14: 05
        +7
        Quote: poquello
        received by brain, lucidly explained to them that they work with these cards in Russia, but may not work

        Right When I read this news for the first time, the search engine immediately went to Yandex. If they are so susceptible to any ukrobred, then they have no confidence.
        1. jjj
          jjj 29 July 2016 14: 51
          +4
          It's simple: Roskomnadzor officially announced a couple of days ago that Google is not quite able to work normally in Russia ...
        2. VOLCHOXURAL
          VOLCHOXURAL 29 July 2016 14: 56
          +3
          Quote: marna
          When I read this news for the first time, the search engine immediately went to Yandex. If they are so susceptible to any ukrobred, then they have no confidence.

          I did it a long time ago! And I found that Yandex is more convenient, more beautiful in appearance and in it you can remove all ads with one flag in the settings (don’t know how this hour, but I haven’t seen this before in Google).
      2. gray smeet
        gray smeet 29 July 2016 14: 05
        +9
        Spin around like girls on the "panel" ... ugh, shame! Chosen, epti! wassat
        One word:
        1. captain
          captain 29 July 2016 14: 15
          +3
          The guys did not think at first, they thought Ukraine would pay them off for this, and the Russians would swallow it anyway. And then our deputies took a seat and offered to expel this "googel"
        2. Navigator Basov
          Navigator Basov 31 July 2016 20: 29
          +1
          Quote: gray smeet
          One word
          Two good
    2. arnulla
      arnulla 29 July 2016 14: 38
      +1
      Yes, they didn’t find anything. For their loot they were afraid ...
      1. Monarchist
        Monarchist 29 July 2016 15: 31
        +1
        They just found themselves: to lose grandmothers due to the vagaries of Kiev? Nevermind!
    3. The comment was deleted.
    4. siberalt
      siberalt 29 July 2016 18: 28
      +2
      Geography is best taught at school, and not Google. laughing
    5. Delink
      Delink 31 July 2016 22: 28
      0
      If you prohibit and block the search engine in Russia google as such, then how quickly they will agree with the Russian version.
  2. GELEZNII_KAPUT
    GELEZNII_KAPUT 29 July 2016 13: 52
    +4
    Topographic cretinism is curable! laughing
  3. Denis Obukhov
    Denis Obukhov 29 July 2016 13: 53
    +7
    It was worth threatening with a fine and excommunication from advertising revenue, as Google crawled back. More often, more often it is necessary to use financial leverage to influence American companies that creep in front of the White House.
    1. poquello
      poquello 29 July 2016 14: 07
      +2
      Quote: Denis Obukhov
      It was worth threatening with a fine and excommunication from advertising revenue, as Google crawled back. More often, more often it is necessary to use financial leverage to influence American companies that creep in front of the White House.

      it was necessary not to threaten, but to fine, so that there were no treachery
      1. roadsmell
        roadsmell 29 July 2016 15: 00
        +2
        Quote: poquello
        Quote: Denis Obukhov
        It was worth threatening with a fine and excommunication from advertising revenue, as Google crawled back. More often, more often it is necessary to use financial leverage to influence American companies that creep in front of the White House.

        it was necessary not to threaten, but to fine, so that there were no treachery

        There are vague assumptions, Google reads Russian forums laughing
        1. iConst
          iConst 29 July 2016 15: 27
          0
          Quote: roadsmell
          There are vague assumptions, Google reads Russian forums

          “Is that such subtle humor?”

          Just in case: search engines read, index and cache ALL Internet resources.
          1. roadsmell
            roadsmell 29 July 2016 17: 16
            0
            Quote: iConst
            Quote: roadsmell
            There are vague assumptions, Google reads Russian forums

            “Is that such subtle humor?”

            Just in case: search engines read, index and cache ALL Internet resources.


            Exactly...
            Engines go awry after reading the forums and adjust caches on their own .. or whatever they are, changing names are automatically called lol
  4. roadsmell
    roadsmell 29 July 2016 13: 55
    +8
    Actually, two days ago, I decided to leave Google due to this renaming as abrucadabra - our transport works in Crimea. And today - the result of a very quick wheel turn.
    A trifle, but nice)))

    Silence at the Forum of Ukrainian Truth - pan-legolecs cannot recover from such a quick transformation of Peremogi into zrad laughing
    1. Muvka
      Muvka 29 July 2016 13: 59
      +2
      Quote: roadsmell
      Actually, two days ago, I decided to leave Google due to this renaming as abrucadabra - our transport works in Crimea. And today - the result of a very quick wheel turn.
      A trifle, but nice)))

      Silence at the Forum of Ukrainian Truth - pan-legolecs cannot recover from such a quick transformation of Peremogi into zrad laughing

      And I have already changed the search engine for myself. I won’t refuse a browser, because I’m used to it.
      1. poquello
        poquello 29 July 2016 14: 10
        0
        Quote: Muvka
        Quote: roadsmell
        Actually, two days ago, I decided to leave Google due to this renaming as abrucadabra - our transport works in Crimea. And today - the result of a very quick wheel turn.
        A trifle, but nice)))

        Silence at the Forum of Ukrainian Truth - pan-legolecs cannot recover from such a quick transformation of Peremogi into zrad laughing

        And I have already changed the search engine for myself. I won’t refuse a browser, because I’m used to it.

        )))) maybe I haven’t looked at the docks of this site for a long time, there the normal operation of the site is supposed to be with chrome
    2. Alex_Tug
      Alex_Tug 29 July 2016 14: 16
      0

      pan-cureheads cannot recover from such a quick transformation


      Without the IMF tranche, Ukrainians cannot draw the GLOBE of Ukraine?
      On it, at least Antarctica will be included in Ukraine. And Canada too.
    3. Orionvit
      Orionvit 29 July 2016 15: 23
      0
      Even I do not understand how Russia can prohibit Google from working on its territory. The search engine is the little things. 80% of the population have smartphones on android, which by default determines the use of Google services with mandatory registration. By the way, Google’s browsers are a spy at your home that collects all the information about your online activity about you, just like Microsoft. What they do not hide, citing the fact that they collect statistical information for the convenience of users. Only this information is then used to carry out all kinds of color revolutions. If you carefully dig into the history of creating Google, you will see that the American intelligence agencies were at the origins of this company, and not two unfinished students. So what goals the googol pursues in its activities is very understandable, and they are far from those that they declare.
  5. maxim1987
    maxim1987 29 July 2016 13: 56
    +1
    loot is more expensive
  6. ML-334
    ML-334 29 July 2016 13: 56
    0
    It's okay - people are working on "bugs".
  7. Monos
    Monos 29 July 2016 13: 57
    +10
    They almost whipped themselves. And in Yandex, already rubbing bloodthirsty hands.

    Enough of mocking Ukrainians already. It flies to them from all sides. Kristia won’t give credit, Trump trolls them, Turks, traitors in general ...
    1. Khariton
      Khariton 29 July 2016 17: 58
      0
      Quote: Monos
      They almost whipped themselves. And in Yandex, already rubbing bloodthirsty hands.

      Enough of mocking Ukrainians already. It flies to them from all sides. Kristia won’t give credit, Trump trolls them, Turks, traitors in general ...

      The IMF decided to hold the loan ... That is the zrada.)))) Victor, what they asked for, they got .... And this is just the beginning!
  8. Denis Obukhov
    Denis Obukhov 29 July 2016 13: 59
    +1
    In this regard, Yandex’s position is funny - in the Ukrainian domain, Crimea is Ukrainian, in Russian - Russian. Everything is good, and the business is satisfied.
  9. roman72-452
    roman72-452 29 July 2016 13: 59
    +1
    Svidomo can’t understand in any way that the one who pays and orders the music, the music is ordered by Russia, but by no means a beggar country (does not apply to normal Ukrainians and people who, by the will of fate, ended up in this territory) hi
  10. dsm100
    dsm100 29 July 2016 13: 59
    +4
    We figured horseradish to the nose and realized that Google would be closed very quickly at such a pace.
    PS I do not use Google myself. I do not like him.
    1. afdjhbn67
      afdjhbn67 29 July 2016 14: 10
      -8
      Quote: dsm100
      PS I do not use Google myself. I do not like him.

      Be a patriot to the end - give up the Internet, to spite foreign enemies ....
      1. AllXVahhaB
        AllXVahhaB 31 July 2016 16: 36
        0
        Quote: afdjhbn67
        Be a patriot to the end - give up the Internet, to spite foreign enemies ....

        And what does the Internet have to do with it? There are services beyond GoogleMap, such as YandexMaps ...
  11. HAM
    HAM 29 July 2016 13: 59
    0
    "Weathervane Google" is more accurate.
    1. poquello
      poquello 29 July 2016 14: 12
      0
      Quote: HAM
      "Weathervane Google" is more accurate.

      Fuggle
  12. Dr. Sorge
    Dr. Sorge 29 July 2016 14: 02
    +4
    I wonder how zmagars will write in the mail? Well, all of a sudden they want to write a letter ... Ask relatives on loan whose money to borrow?
  13. Cynic
    Cynic 29 July 2016 14: 02
    0
    Again Zrada ...
  14. bardadym
    bardadym 29 July 2016 14: 03
    +3
    It seems that Ukraine will be the first country to completely go into virtual space.

    And so already the country is controlled via twitter, and now they are also conquering Crimea on Google maps)
    1. Brain Yurich
      Brain Yurich 31 July 2016 16: 54
      0
      World of Ukraine)
  15. kirieeleyson
    kirieeleyson 29 July 2016 14: 04
    +5
    The choice, as it turned out, is not great: either to lose "efficiency in work on the territory of Russia" according to the Deputy Minister of Communications, or to continue to develop at a rapid pace, as Google has been saying so far. Considering the fact that google is buying up the assets of companies engaged in mobile applications, etc., as well as the fact that it has an overwhelming share of users with chrome browsers on mobile, they are not just interested in our market, but this is a klondike. Despite the fact that you don't need to fight for this klondike, just calmly enter your kpi and watch the fuck, get your money and pay taxes. And listen to the government, where the wind blows. What they are doing)) Capitalists, there them.
    1. Orionvit
      Orionvit 29 July 2016 15: 37
      +4
      Dear forum users. They wrote a lot, and everything is about the loot. Understand that money is not the main thing for Google, they earn enough money anyway. The main thing is to be a monopolist in the information sphere, which makes it possible to collect information about everyone and us, and then use it for their own purposes. Since Google is a state-owned company, think about whose interests this information will be used. The Arab Spring was pushed through the Internet, in particular through all kinds of social networks, and you still think that Google is a search engine, browser and maps. Everything is much deeper, and googol is definitely not a "friend" of Russia.
      1. Air defense SSH
        Air defense SSH 30 July 2016 10: 12
        0
        Enlighten without jokes. I have an android tablet, like everyone else is imprisoned under google. I communicate with you on this site (VO) now. Question: how can Google affect my opinion?
        1. Cynic
          Cynic 30 July 2016 11: 34
          0
          Quote: Air Defense SVSh
          how can google affect my opinion?

          As well as, for example, TV. Selection of opportunities to know. I, Yandex, have a news feed compiled according to my interests, there are approximately equal numbers of ours and euronews, do you think they are the same with a simple news feed?
          Yes, don’t look at the flag, I’ve got interesting software, and I’m using it. And so, the tricolor of the Russian Federation, while ours is everything!
        2. Alex_Tug
          Alex_Tug 30 July 2016 11: 43
          0
          can Google affect my opinion?


          Calm down, can not. Only advertising can slip under you. On the analysis of sites where you go and on your searches.
          1. Cynic
            Cynic 30 July 2016 12: 33
            0
            Quote: Alex_Tug
            Calm down, can not.

            Nope, maybe.
            At least: If a person is constantly told that he is bad, he will never become good.
  16. sgr291158
    sgr291158 29 July 2016 14: 15
    0
    Google is the enemy of Ukraine.
  17. Signore Tomato
    Signore Tomato 29 July 2016 14: 17
    +4
    Google is generally an anti-Russian product and it feels like the CIA has launched a very strong claw there.
    Examples: I systematically look through the car accident channel on YouTube (owned by Google) (purely to keep myself in good shape) - and there often pop up mad jumps with comments like "Rashka - Ashka, zombies, etc."
    So after I wrote in the comments to several videos "a recipe for how to ban a mad jump for an ordinary user", they immediately changed the wording "insult or manifestation of hatred" to something obscure.
    Another example: in 2014, when there was a rumor about a bay on the Black Sea coast, where the Skaklyatsky fleet was rotting near the piers, in Google maps for several days it was possible to search for the name of the bay and admire the rusting remains of the Skaklyatsky fleet. After this bay became very popular, the search for the name of the bay "suddenly" stopped finding anything.

    And this is just what is recalled with a run.
  18. AlexTires
    AlexTires 29 July 2016 14: 17
    +6
    Google is required to comply with the laws of the country in which it operates. Therefore, they will most likely begin to analyze ip and show names in accordance with the laws of states. In the states that recognized Crimea as part of Russia, it will be shown as Russian, in those which did not recognize as Ukrainian. And no problem. I care about the other as a Russian. Why are our Russian companies (mobile communications, banks) in no hurry to recognize Crimea? Why does the prosecutor’s office not shake them, because they encroach on the integrity of the motherland ?!
    1. Alex_Tug
      Alex_Tug 29 July 2016 14: 23
      +2
      AlexTires
      Why are our Russian companies (mobile communications, banks) in no hurry to recognize Crimea?


      They were afraid of personal sanctions, but now they are not required. Since yesterday, Crimea has become a subject of the Southern Federal District.
    2. Mista_dj
      Mista_dj 1 August 2016 22: 53
      +1
      But because they are only in words such as Software Tsreota!
      And as it comes to denezhek, so his shirt ...
      We still have not a single decent bank, not a single supermarket with normal prices. Not a single refueling.
      There is only thieves - selling (letter G) avnom and wild prices for everything, from which already Muscovites shy away ...
      In Crimea, there were only outsiders who had nothing to lose on the mainland (read any shelupon).
      1. Chief Officer
        Chief Officer 8 August 2016 10: 16
        +1
        "But you hold on! .." (c)
        hi
  19. Engineer
    Engineer 29 July 2016 14: 29
    +1
    _____________________________
  20. Vitas
    Vitas 29 July 2016 14: 29
    0
    Let Google rename itself. Not google maps, but google maps!
  21. Retvizan 8
    Retvizan 8 29 July 2016 14: 29
    0
    Yeah! Such a buzz to people broke off! After all, how well it began!
  22. trophy
    trophy 29 July 2016 15: 05
    0
    Normally, so Svidomo muzzle on the battery dragged. Another magical transformation peremogi in zrada. It is interesting to observe the reaction of the cephalopods to such a trendline.
  23. Alex_Tug
    Alex_Tug 29 July 2016 15: 11
    +2
    I looked at the map of Crimea (in Google). Google bothers, renamed the city. But ... latin transcription of cities Ukrainian. Horonje - Garden. Wonder yet.
    1. EvgNik
      EvgNik 29 July 2016 16: 58
      0
      Quote: Alex_Tug
      Wonder yet.

      So what happens: both yours and ours?
      1. Alex_Tug
        Alex_Tug 29 July 2016 17: 13
        0

        So what happens: both yours and ours?


        Something like that. It would be interesting to see from the Ukrainian IP address. Maybe there are other eccentricities.
  24. cheburator
    cheburator 29 July 2016 15: 29
    +2
    Clowns and deb ... bl! .. negative
  25. sergeyzzz
    sergeyzzz 29 July 2016 15: 38
    +1
    I basically don’t use Google like Google - Yandex replaces it quite digestibly; it has almost all the functions that Google does and it works just as fast. Any program that is imposed for free and by force - this is cheese in a mousetrap - this is for you, google lovers. By the way, on many Microsoft smartphones sold in Russia, Yandex is preinstalled, and not Google (on my lumia it is not at all!).
  26. atamankko
    atamankko 29 July 2016 17: 05
    0
    And everywhere the state dullness.
  27. vasilev
    vasilev 29 July 2016 20: 36
    +1
    They put Google in their pants out of fear of losing the Russian market, but it's too late, for example, I "de-Google" my smartphone and use Yandex.
  28. Retvizan
    Retvizan 30 July 2016 12: 48
    +1
    HERE is an interesting life - out of trifles, both sides have made themselves "zrady-peremogi" and are buzzing.
    What is strange, nothing changed at all. Even now, Google shows all the usual names in Crimea in Russian (and in mainland Ukraine, in Ukrainian). No renaming syudy.
    Google in general is always controversial points "both ours and yours" depending on the country.
    By the way, the law on the change of names should come into force after the Crimea changes its jurisdiction to Ukrainian. That is, now the new names have not entered into force.
    In general, the zrado-peremogi bubble was inflated
  29. Mentat
    Mentat 31 July 2016 14: 58
    0
    Quote: Cynic
    Quote: DrZed
    Well, banned in Russia, so what?

    Well, let the person come off, pretend to be inadequate: to ban, not to allow, it remains to mention, to punish for using ...

    If you yourself were adequate. Everyone is thinking about how you, the navel of the Universe, will rush to forbid something. Who needs you? We are talking about Google’s reputation as a provider of accurate cartographic information and the market. of advertising in Russia. This is a lot of money and this sector continues to grow.
    1. Cynic
      Cynic 31 July 2016 15: 37
      +1
      Quote: Mentat
      If you yourself were adequate.

      My post needs to be read and, attention, THINK ...
      Sarcasm - this is a tough mockery that can be opened with a positive judgment, but in general it always contains a negative connotation and indicates a lack of judgment ...
      And so, in life, with a holiday
  30. Evil 55
    Evil 55 31 July 2016 16: 09
    0
    I still don’t understand who is “Google” - a girl or a boy .. But I believe that it is still more profitable for him to be FRIENDS with Russia ..
    1. Cynic
      Cynic 31 July 2016 16: 11
      +1
      Quote: Angry 55
      "Google" is a girl or a boy.

      According to the current European standards, "Google" IT! wink
  31. Nicola Bari
    Nicola Bari 1 August 2016 07: 50
    0
    "After the return of the usual names to the Crimean settlements on the electronic resource, the Crimeans themselves noted that" Google remembered that people need maps to navigate in geography, and not to exercise in politics. "


    Cards are needed to make money (Google). You can not continue further.
  32. tulpar
    tulpar 1 August 2016 09: 41
    +1
    circus left clowns stayed
  33. I am human
    I am human 1 August 2016 11: 22
    +2
    I suggest Google rename Washington to Fashington, New York to New Morgue, etc.
  34. elenagromova
    elenagromova 1 August 2016 12: 17
    0
    But Yandex maps insolently renamed the cities to the DPR. Now Torez is called "Chistyakovo" on them, and when I tried to find the village of Karlo-Marksovo on them, it turned out that it was not there, but there was with a different name - Sofiyivka. Although no one in the DPR renamed anything.
  35. aviamed90
    aviamed90 1 August 2016 12: 37
    0
    For clarity:

    If you go to the site "Flightradar24.com" (and this site uses their maps), then you will be sure that Google has not changed anything.

    What does it mean?
    Who is brechet?
    1. Cynic
      Cynic 1 August 2016 13: 05
      0
      Quote: aviamed90
      What does it mean?

      An interesting question, the inscriptions are double, in the aglitsky and on the mov.
    2. Alex_Tug
      Alex_Tug 1 August 2016 13: 11
      0
      If you go to the site "Flightradar24.com" (and this site uses their maps), then you will be sure that Google has not changed anything.


      On "Flightradar24.com" Krasnoperekopsk is called Krasnoperekopsk (Ukrainian transcription), not Yana Kapu. Returned the title back.
      1. aviamed90
        aviamed90 1 August 2016 14: 47
        0
        Alex_Tug


        The names were returned, but only everything is in Ukrainian.
  36. Taygerus
    Taygerus 1 August 2016 12: 57
    0
    banderlog again