Military Review

Another roadmap for normalizing Israeli-Palestinian security relations prepared

44
A group of American and Israeli experts prepared another roadmap for resolving the conflict between Israel and Palestine. The program was presented on the eve of the New American Security Center CNAS (Washington, USA). The new roadmap involves the phased building of relations between Israel and Palestine in the field of various types of interaction for the common fight against terrorism: on land, at sea, in the air, and also in terms of radio-electronic interaction.


Another roadmap for normalizing Israeli-Palestinian security relations prepared


Press office CNAS Reports that both military and civilian specialists took part in creating the roadmap program. One of the project leaders is Ilan Goldenberg, who identifies the main problem in the relationship between Israel and Palestine. According to the author of the roadmap, the Israelis will never recognize Palestine if there is a terrorist threat from it, and the Palestinians will never perceive Israel as a normal neighboring state, due to the idea of ​​permanent occupation and the invasion of Israeli soldiers.

The main directions for implementation listed in the program are as follows:
building a multi-level system in which Israel reserves the right to protect its borders and interests;

significant modernization of the security system and infrastructure;

creation of joint operational centers and data exchange mechanisms between the parties, which will increase the percentage of mutual awareness of the security situation (will increase the level of security of the Israelis and minimize the likelihood of Israeli security forces invading the Palestinian territories).


And, perhaps, the most interesting point - inviting American specialists to monitor and conduct joint operations in the Jordan River area.

According to the estimates of the developers of the roadmap, the implementation of their program will cost "less than 5 billion dollars." According to the authors of the roadmap, this is “not so much for the cost of peace.”
Photos used:
http://www.cnas.org
44 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. oldseaman1957
    oldseaman1957 1 June 2016 16: 35
    +5
    A map is a map, and a mentality is a mentality! As the Palestinians hated the Jews, they will continue to hate it. Though they are rich. So you will not envy Israel - all life is under arms ...
    1. Приговор
      Приговор 1 June 2016 16: 40
      +5
      Well, we must pay tribute to Israel, during its short existence, he made a lot of efforts to be hated by ALL neighbors and the Arab world as a whole ..;))
      1. oldseaman1957
        oldseaman1957 1 June 2016 16: 46
        +3
        Quote: Sentence
        Israel must be respected
        - Well, if you delve into history, ALL are good!
        1. Приговор
          Приговор 1 June 2016 17: 14
          -5
          I agree. But, Israel, as always turned out to be on top ..;))) Even in this matter ..;)
      2. Chisayna
        Chisayna 1 June 2016 16: 53
        +4
        But in (in) Ukraine, there were no Arabs, but the Khmelnytsky pogrom was. And in 1939, there were no Arabs in Poland and Germany then. Maybe it's not about neighbors and Arabs.
        1. marshes
          marshes 1 June 2016 16: 57
          +1
          Quote: Chisain
          But in (in) Ukraine, there were no Arabs, but the Khmelnytsky pogrom was. And in 1939, there were no Arabs in Poland and Germany then. Maybe it's not about neighbors and Arabs.

          About the Khmelnitsky pogrom, maybe write an article.
          So friendship with Khmelnitsky, if that ....
          Goblin, what is serious from western Siberia, or did the movie remember?
        2. Maki Avellevich
          Maki Avellevich 1 June 2016 18: 26
          +6
          But in (in) Ukraine, there were no Arabs, but the Khmelnitsky pogrom was


          "But" the Bartholomew night, Jews were not observed and the pogrom was
      3. 3officer
        3officer 1 June 2016 17: 05
        +2
        The normal state for the Arab world is either a dictatorship a la Saddam Hussein or the everyday life of modern Aleppo, there is no third.
      4. MACCABI-TLV
        MACCABI-TLV 1 June 2016 22: 03
        +1
        Quote: Sentence
        made a lot of efforts to be hated by ALL neighbors and the Arab world as a whole ..;))

        In total, he refused to be destroyed ... and not some kind of mass of efforts.
    2. rabbi's pais
      rabbi's pais 1 June 2016 17: 06
      -1
      Quote: oldseaman1957
      So you will not envy Israel - all life is under arms ...

      They themselves chose such a life. So there is nothing to worry about them. And then, the non-Jewish generation of Jews is more far-sighted than those who lived 70 years ago and realized that they should rely on themselves for security and keep several passports under their mattress. case, so to speak.
      1. Maki Avellevich
        Maki Avellevich 1 June 2016 18: 28
        +5
        keep several passports under the mattress. Just in case, so to speak


        Weapons must be kept and not passports.
        1. rabbi's pais
          rabbi's pais 1 June 2016 18: 53
          -1
          Quote: Maki Avellievich
          Weapons must be kept

          in a plastic bag inside the push drain tank
        2. The comment was deleted.
      2. Chisayna
        Chisayna 1 June 2016 18: 43
        -4
        Yes, you had to live on your own land and defend your land. Instead of wandering around foreign countries and lands. And when "they" remembered that there is somewhere a piece of desert, and former relatives already live there.
        1. rabbi's pais
          rabbi's pais 1 June 2016 19: 02
          -3
          Yes, what kind of Arabs are their former relatives. One of them is a Semitic tribe. The Slavs are not too friendly with each other, however, this does not mean that common roots must be forgotten or denied.
    3. Amnestied
      Amnestied 1 June 2016 18: 23
      -4
      Quote: oldseaman1957
      So you will not envy Israel - all life is under arms ...

      Gee-s, the fact is that the word "Catastrophe" means in their West and in the BV in particular - the Holocaust. And to inherit vi still, yes, they did not care in what order - physical ASSET. the occupied, privatized from suckers, physical territory (ie the State of the Peoples ... of Palestine). By the way, subsequent attempts to put the stamp of Pestuplenie, i.e. Anti-Semitism, you can't do this, because these attempts are banal - banal))
  2. vorobey
    vorobey 1 June 2016 16: 35
    +5
    but without the Americans, well. no way ... now Israel will invite to his garden ... if the Lord wants to teach someone a lesson, he sends hurricanes and tornadoes to them, and if he wants to punish someone, he sends Americans to them ...
    1. atalef
      atalef 1 June 2016 16: 42
      +7
      Quote: vorobey
      but without the Americans, well. no way ...

      Hi, Sasha.
      The most interesting thing is that we (about the next 15001 roadmap laughing ) learn from VO.
      All bullshit. there is nothing and will not be until then. until the palms (at least 0 do not understand themselves, otherwise you can bet if Hamas (Gaza) and Fatah (West Bank) sit down to negotiate with each other --- how long will they overdo each other? In 4 minutes or 5? laughing
      1. vorobey
        vorobey 1 June 2016 17: 00
        +3
        Quote: atalef
        Hi, Sasha.



        Quote: atalef
        how much time will they overdo each other? In 4 minutes or 5?


        and will you do with the Americans in the area of ​​the Jordan River? baptize or crop?
        1. atalef
          atalef 1 June 2016 17: 23
          +3
          Quote: vorobey
          Quote: atalef
          Hi, Sasha.



          Quote: atalef
          how much time will they overdo each other? In 4 minutes or 5?


          and will you do with the Americans in the area of ​​the Jordan River? baptize or crop?

          With the Americans then? With such friends (in politics), enemies are no longer necessary
        2. Amnestied
          Amnestied 1 June 2016 18: 32
          -6
          Quote: vorobey
          and will you do with the Americans in the area of ​​the Jordan River? baptize or crop?


          When, as you put it, "many" like you ONE in particular, think of the convolutions of sciatic nerves cellulite and write their comments from the damp basements of the synagogue - it's even too late to get baptized. And where do all these descendants of the unfinished "harsh" mishling of the Third Reich go if, against the background of another noisy gevalt, specially for them the chaplains are formed in silence - a global Ethics for suckers: "While the bones of thousands of victims languish under their feet, it is our duty to speak, share and tell the victims of Zionism the truth of their Nazi past. In order to allow our children learn your history in all its glory, but also its most embarrassing moments "- gy-s))
        3. igor67
          igor67 1 June 2016 19: 26
          +2
          Quote: vorobey
          Quote: atalef
          Hi, Sasha.



          Quote: atalef
          how much time will they overdo each other? In 4 minutes or 5?


          and will you do with the Americans in the area of ​​the Jordan River? baptize or crop?

          Sanya in the area of ​​the Jordan River You can be baptized to fish, plump, swim, nothing more
          1. MACCABI-TLV
            MACCABI-TLV 1 June 2016 22: 07
            +1
            Quote: igor67
            Sanya in the area of ​​the Jordan River You can be baptized to fish, plump, swim, nothing more

            Almost perfect sequence. yes
      2. svp67
        svp67 1 June 2016 17: 36
        0
        Quote: atalef
        All bullshit. there is nothing and will not be until then. while the palaces (at least 0 can’t figure it out on their own, otherwise you can bet if Hamas (Gaza) and Fatah (West Bank) sit down to negotiate with each other --- how long will they overdo each other? In 4 minutes or 5 ?

        Right, otherwise
        Group American and Israeli experts prepared another roadmap for resolving the conflict between Israel and Palestine.
        Until Israel and Palestine begin to agree among themselves, as long as it is hard to believe, NOTHING will happen
      3. Kyrgyz
        Kyrgyz 1 June 2016 19: 04
        +2
        Quote: atalef
        All bullshit. there is nothing and will not be until then. while the palaces (at least 0 do not deal with themselves

        Which means no, judging by the article a minimum of 5 yards per world))) with such investments, the further the world the fuller the pockets)))
  3. Coconut
    Coconut 1 June 2016 16: 35
    +2
    while rats dig tunnels there will be no normalization lol
  4. Приговор
    Приговор 1 June 2016 16: 37
    0
    Good luck. I will be glad if it is possible to resolve the "conflict". But, something tells me that for the success of such projects it is necessary to participate in its development of another "side". Palestine ...;)))) And most importantly: Israel's recognition of an independent Palestinian state is not heard. Everything else - the usual blah blah blah about nothing ..;))
    1. atalef
      atalef 1 June 2016 16: 46
      +5
      Quote: Sentence
      cottages. I will be glad if it is possible to resolve the "conflict"

      fail and no initiative plays any role.
      Quote: Sentence
      But, something tells me that for the success of such projects it is necessary to participate in its development of one more "side". Palestine

      Palestine? And who do you mean? Fatah or Hamas?
      1. Приговор
        Приговор 1 June 2016 17: 10
        +1
        I mean the representatives of Mahmoud Abbas, as the head of the Palestinian state. And whom exactly he considers it necessary to send for the development of such important initiatives, you must admit that it is not our business with you. Let them understand within themselves. Without our advice ..;))))
        1. atalef
          atalef 1 June 2016 17: 25
          +1
          Quote: Sentence
          I mean the representatives of Mahmoud Abbas, as the head of the Palestinian state. And whom exactly he considers it necessary to send for the development of such important initiatives, you must admit that it is not our business with you. Let them understand within themselves. Without our advice ..;))))

          The powers of the Abbas (as the head) have long been over, but he isn’t going to the polls, and how? He will come to Gaza, he will not have time to take a couple of steps, he will cut off his Hamas eggs there
          1. Приговор
            Приговор 1 June 2016 17: 39
            -1
            Again, it’s not for us to organize the elections for the Palestinians. We have enough of our costs and worries ...;)) If they consider him their head, then health. They must clean up their territories, including Gaza. Even if it will be a civil war and someone will be cut off something. I do not intend to worry about the health of a single Mahmoud, and especially Abbas ..;))) All that a normal person can be interested in is:
            1. That the people had their own country.
            2. No threat came from this country.
            3. That the country be completely self-sufficient and independent (I do not want to send humanitarian aid to anyone). laughing
    2. Amnestied
      Amnestied 1 June 2016 18: 37
      -2
      Quote: Sentence
      Palestine ...;)))) And most importantly: Israel does not hear the recognition of an independent Palestinian state. Everything else - the usual blah blah blah blah about anything ..;))

      Since the final decision in favor of the "Yemenis mother" of the Palestinian issue is clearly delaying, and their hopes for a peaceful settlement or at least a return to a relatively normal situation at the expense of suckers in the process of milking the countries of the BV are pushed back into the indefinitely distant future, cat gnomes are beginning to suspect that and Judas himself may soon fall into the crosshairs of the Anglo-American scope. Recently, with a swift jack, there have been signs that this is exactly how it is "- oops, like wow! Nanai boys of Judah are starting to shoot dgug dguzhka, - like aristocratic members of the Club of Rogue Suicides, today the duelists will win, definitely!
  5. 3officer
    3officer 1 June 2016 16: 38
    +1
    "Brothers, don't shoot each other ..
    1. Pinkie F.
      Pinkie F. 1 June 2016 17: 11
      +1
      Quote: 3officer
      Brothers do not shoot at each other ..

      funny about "lads"
      1. 3officer
        3officer 1 June 2016 17: 22
        +1
        Brothers are not brothers, but neighbors after all, and they say they don’t choose neighbors (here either by moving themselves or moving neighbors wassat
        1. Pinkie F.
          Pinkie F. 1 June 2016 21: 02
          +2
          Quote: 3officer
          Brothers are not brothers, but neighbors after all

          no way) Palaces of Jews consider squatters. Neighborhood is not and never will be. Yes, the Arabs are not particularly keen on him - sponsors will lose interest.
          1. 3officer
            3officer 1 June 2016 21: 30
            0
            Squatters usually "live" in abandoned or "no-man's" housing, so the Arabs should have better look after their property if they think it is request
  6. marshes
    marshes 1 June 2016 16: 43
    0
    It will be good if I’m in Ashdod, the sea, I won’t look around. I’m fucking, I’m already in touch with the pictures from the sea, even though I don’t like seal rest. For me everything would die out laughing
  7. ALABAY45
    ALABAY45 1 June 2016 16: 45
    +2
    "... inviting American specialists ..."
    All! Key phrase ... The article can be canceled, sense-zero! Although, what was there, after all, about "5 billion" ?!
    1. atalef
      atalef 1 June 2016 16: 48
      +2
      Quote: ALABAY45
      "... inviting American specialists ..."
      All! Key phrase ... The article can be canceled, sense-zero! Although, what was there, after all, about "5 billion" ?!

      In this I agree
      Well, let's start with the question. who invited them 7
      well. and the most important anecdote is AMERICAN SPECIALISTS laughing
      experts on arranging a mess in BV ,. If only.
      1. APASUS
        APASUS 1 June 2016 18: 01
        0
        Quote: atalef
        experts on arranging a mess in BV ,. If only

        Good evening.
        You will not share your thoughts on how to solve problems with Palestine, how do you see this solution and if the general mood in the country is possible to solve the problem
        1. Maki Avellevich
          Maki Avellevich 1 June 2016 18: 36
          +3
          You will not share your thoughts on how to solve problems with Palestine, how do you see this solution and if the general mood in the country is possible to solve the problem


          with your permission I’ll insert my one and a half penny


          We have an Antagonistic game everywhere on BV, that is, a zero-sum game. in all conflicts, only one player must remain.

          Claims for a compromise is not a problem. not in Syria, not in Iraq, Saudi Arabia, Lebanon, Israel, etc. etc.
          such a carrot.
          1. APASUS
            APASUS 1 June 2016 18: 56
            +1
            Quote: Maki Avellievich
            We have an Antagonistic game everywhere on BV, that is, a zero-sum game. in all conflicts, only one player must remain.

            If I understand your point correctly, you are the only way out. Only then do the participating countries find consensus
            1. atalef
              atalef 1 June 2016 19: 37
              +2
              Quote: APASUS
              If I understood your point correctly, you are the only way out

              War is the easiest way out
              Quote: APASUS
              Only then do participating countries find consensus

              Actually, I think (in fact) exit 2
              1. War
              2. The UN Security Council develops a proct and forces both sides to accept them.
              It will not be possible to agree all the same and, first of all, because of the palaces of the shopping mall, sitting on the neck of the whole world and screaming how poor they are is much easier than removing garbage on the territory and building industry.
              1. Pinkie F.
                Pinkie F. 1 June 2016 21: 06
                +1
                Quote: atalef
                The UN is developing a proct and forcing both sides to accept them.

                "Forces"? Sash, such imperatives are too much for the League of Nations-2, I think, in this particular case.
                Point 1 is more realistic.
        2. atalef
          atalef 1 June 2016 19: 34
          +1
          Quote: APASUS
          You will not share your thoughts on how to solve problems with Palestine, as you see this decision

          First of all, let them agree among themselves - without this, it’s also not worth starting.
          Then the exchange of territories - the Arabs to the Arbs. Jews to Jews.
          We give them territories - Um Elfachem, Taibe, eastern Jerusalem - we will take equivalent territory in Judea and Samaria.
          Palestinian refugees can only return within the Palestinian Authority ....
          Palestinian autonomy is a demilitarized state.
          Everything and the flag in their hands.
          1. MACCABI-TLV
            MACCABI-TLV 1 June 2016 22: 18
            +1
            Quote: atalef
            Then the exchange of territories - the Arabs to the Arbs. Jews to Jews.
            We give them territories - Um Elfachem, Taibe, eastern Jerusalem - we will take equivalent territory in Judea and Samaria.

            Of course, I am all you can FOR, but the Arabs from the triangle will be much strongly against. Depriving them of their current standard of living, and the institution of national insurance, is tantamount to the beginning of a new intifada.
      2. Beaver
        Beaver 1 June 2016 18: 25
        +1
        Quote: atalef
        experts on arranging a mess in BV ,. If only.

        good good good If only on BV ... sad
  8. Orakul2000
    Orakul2000 1 June 2016 18: 56
    +1
    And my opinion is that if you decide to introduce a new initiative, then at least along with the Americans (or better, to be honest, without them), invite Russian intermediaries. We can disagree with Russia, even sometimes bark, but you need to be blind so as not to see that the VVP administration is really trying to calm down our region. In contrast to our overseas "allies" (a damn fist itches), who create a situation of controlled chaos to solve their own political and domestic economic problems. Personally, I think that for a long time we need to cooperate more with Russia, even if I show us a fist because of an okey. Stop being politically impotent.
    1. tilix
      tilix 1 June 2016 20: 08
      +5
      You will still be surprised, but there was a time and the Russians were in Gaza, like an international patrol. So what? And nothing.
      And so, yes, another American Institute has prepared a briefing that both sides have security claims.
      No, they would be engaged in Syria or resettlement to Europe, after all, epoch-making events. So everyone climbs and climbs to us. And they forgot that because of their "breaks" Gaza lies under Hamas.
      1. marshes
        marshes 1 June 2016 20: 17
        0
        Quote: tilix
        You will still be surprised

        You are for Kazakhstan people, do without a visa. And you will be surprised. laughing You can then beat the tambourine that without a visa with a "Muslim" country. By the way, you get under 15 days.
        Former holidays in May, the nieces were great, so they left the woman ten thousand, my uncle was crazy. laughing
        1. tilix
          tilix 1 June 2016 20: 29
          +2
          You are for Kazakhstan, do without a visa
          Yalla, go ahead !!!
          1. marshes
            marshes 1 June 2016 20: 41
            0
            Quote: tilix
            Yalla, go ahead !!!

            At past holidays, girls, nieces did not take such photos, they went to a woman in Ashdod, the carcass beach was light ... laughing Here they are in niqabs, or how to dress a burqa. laughing Fillings. laughing
            They don’t want to become civilians. They must be served. In the National Assembly, dad may find a place, the eldest is already with her husband.
  9. RedBaron
    RedBaron 1 June 2016 22: 00
    +2
    Initiative Initiative Initiative
  10. A. Privalov
    A. Privalov 2 June 2016 23: 32
    +5
    I didn’t want to upset the respectable public, but I dare to remind you that Yasser Arafat still in 70 didn’t have an extra pair of underpants for replacement, and after his death in 2004, his wife already managed the amount of 14 billion green.

    At one time, the "Marshall Plan" in a fairly short period of time raised Europe destroyed by the world war from ruins. If you count the money sent by the world sponsors of the PNA, then it is easy to make sure that from the mid-90s to the present day, the FOURTH "Marshall Plan", perfectly mastered by the local elite, ends.

    In early 2000, the Daily Telegraph reported how a group of British hackers had broken into the PLO network and discovered that its management had invested a total of $ 50 billion in various foreign firms. A list of companies whose shares belonged to Arafat and his entourage were also published. Among them are Mercedes-Benz, the airlines of the Maldives and Guinea-Bissau, a Greek shipping company, banana plantations and diamond mines in Africa. So 5 billion is a ridiculous amount. Abu Mazen and K will master it as two files to send.

    Well, what about the world in our area ... What kind of world can we talk about, if the USSR, and now the Russian Federation has already 50, for years, feeds all sorts of terrorist shelups with a generous hand?