Military Review

Council of Europe: An investigation into the tragedy in the Odessa House of Trade Unions did not meet the requirements of the European Convention

On Wednesday, an international advisory group of the Council of Europe presented a report on monitoring the investigation of events in Odessa in May last year, when, according to official figures, about 50 people died and the total number of victims exceeded 250 as a result of a fire in the House of Trade Unions.

In the published document it is noted that the investigation of the Odessa tragedy was carried out without taking into account the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), and the local MoES and the investigating authorities did not have enough “institutional independence”.

“The group found that the investigation could not meet the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights,” the extract from the RIA document “News».

It is also emphasized that the deficiencies discovered undermined the ability of the Ukrainian authorities to bring those responsible to justice.

“Although this can be partially explained by objective difficulties, the Council believes that the shortcomings pointed out in this report have undermined the ability of the authorities to establish the circumstances of the crimes related to Odessa and bring those responsible to justice,” the report says.

The head of the consulting group, Nicolas Bratza, noted during the press conference an insufficient level of independence of the investigation.

“Given the evidence that indicates the involvement of police officers in the 2 riots in May 2014 in Odessa ... (required), the investigation of the riots in general should be carried out by a body completely independent of the police officers. Similarly, given the structural links between the state emergency service and the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the investigation into the actions of the fire service cannot be considered independent, ”he said.

The report also reports insufficient public information.

“The 2 events in Odessa in May of 2014 were so important that the authorities were obliged to provide sufficient information about the investigation in order to promote effective public control. Although the authorities published a considerable amount of information, this was done in the absence of an effective communication policy, and, as a result, some of the information was incomprehensible and contradictory, and was also provided unevenly and with insufficient regularity. (...) The information that was presented to the general public was not in itself sufficient to protect the rights and legitimate interests of the victims and their relatives, ”the report says.
Photos used:
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. avvg
    avvg 5 November 2015 06: 55 New
    The investigation was led from Washington and therefore the perpetrators of the deaths are not identified.
    1. subbtin.725
      subbtin.725 5 November 2015 07: 30 New
      ""Великое"" пробуждение,твою мать.Очнулись,через полтора года...
      1. Voha_krim
        Voha_krim 5 November 2015 07: 47 New
        Риторика меняется. Президенту Попрошенко прямо указывают на его "косяки", посягая на "святое", на майдан! Конечно, последним предупреждением прозвучавшие обвинения назвать нельзя, однако отношение Европы к Украине охладевает на глазах, и чем это всё закончится — большой вопрос.
    2. brasist
      brasist 5 November 2015 07: 34 New
      What are they to take their own and all their work to smarka?
      1. oldseaman1957
        oldseaman1957 5 November 2015 08: 24 New
        What is encouraging is the great availability of videos about this massacre. Moreover, the executioners themselves also took off. So they will have to answer in every way!
        1. subbtin.725
          subbtin.725 5 November 2015 10: 47 New
          Quote: oldseaman1957
          What is encouraging is the great availability of videos about this massacre. Moreover, the executioners themselves also took off. So they will have to answer in every way!

          + Only not any Hague. The Tribunal will be in the Donbass.
      2. Dembel77
        Dembel77 5 November 2015 08: 28 New
        Although this can partially be explained by objective difficulties.
        Utter nonsense! The only reasonable explanation for what happened in Odessa is the gangster regime in Ukraine! How much they ss uki still good people in Ukraine will destroy - these poroshenkiyaytsenyukiavakov - scary to imagine! But this does not bother Europe - they have worse problems than refugees (as they see it)!
  2. olimpiada15
    olimpiada15 5 November 2015 06: 58 New
    As always, the CE statement consists of omissions and hints.
    The fact that the authorities committed a terrible crime by burning people alive, hindering their salvation, finishing off the survivors and pursuing the survivors is never voiced by these arrogant Europeans.
  3. S_Baykala
    S_Baykala 5 November 2015 07: 01 New
    We will not forget, and Odessa residents, I hope, will not forgive.
    1. kagorta
      kagorta 5 November 2015 07: 08 New
      No, in Odessa there are very few Odessa residents. There are only housekeepers and occupiers.
      1. Rezident007
        Rezident007 5 November 2015 07: 28 New
        I agree. If in Odessa at least half a city came to the barricades and protests, then there would be a result, and so ... They are at least Russian, at least Ukrainians, at least Romanians, etc. ... However, the mentality.
        1. German Titov
          German Titov 5 November 2015 08: 33 New
          После событий в Одессе, позвонил знакомому - узнать обстановку. Ответ поразил "Там не одесситы погибли. Приднестровцы и из области". Это в Одессу 25 лет назад приехало из Ровно, и в милиции работало. Донбасс тогда всколыхнуло "не по детски".
          1. kagorta
            kagorta 5 November 2015 09: 17 New
            Your friend is worthy of the great title of Odessa. wink
  4. EvgNik
    EvgNik 5 November 2015 07: 05 New

    “The Panel found that the investigation failed to satisfy the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights

    At least something more or less intelligible was squeezed out of themselves.
    1. Watchdog
      Watchdog 5 November 2015 08: 55 New
      Yeah, who would have thought ... what
  5. Maksus
    Maksus 5 November 2015 07: 10 New
    Where were they before? One and a half years have passed since the murder in Odessa. Or received an order to crush the junta?
  6. samara-58
    samara-58 5 November 2015 07: 26 New
    The EU came from a camel from an old joke! Brakesaaaa, the hare has long been eaten! fool
  7. Same lech
    Same lech 5 November 2015 07: 28 New
    Council of Europe: An investigation into the tragedy in the Odessa House of Trade Unions did not meet the requirements of the European Convention

    Well, still .. one of the ODESSA police officers Dmitry Fuchegi is in Russia and gives testimony (sings like a nightingale) .... although at the time of the tragedy he did nothing to stop the crime.
    1. builder
      builder 5 November 2015 08: 37 New
      He is in Transnistria.
  8. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 5 November 2015 07: 41 New
    the investigation failed to meet the requirements of the European Convention on Human Rights

    Woke up or what? Better tell me what actions, and even more so the investigations of the Kiev authorities correspond to this convection? What was visible to everyone and Europeans in particular was quietly ignored, distorted, falsified under the tacit consent of Europe. What they have sown, so reap.
  9. cniza
    cniza 5 November 2015 08: 02 New
    Quote: avvg
    The investigation was led from Washington and therefore the perpetrators of the deaths are not identified.

    Oh, how all the USA got tired, all of them will be rewarded with interest.
  10. APASUS
    APASUS 5 November 2015 08: 02 New
    How to recognize when power is involved in a crime, but reluctance?
    There are all sorts of OSCE, human rights defenders ............... But when they are hunting, F-16 and Tomahawk immediately fly to the scene of the crime !!!
  11. Vladimir71
    Vladimir71 5 November 2015 08: 04 New
    If you have already killed the blogger for the wild joy about the crashed airbus (I hope that’s exactly why), then not everything is lost in Ukraine and the line at the cemetery is slowly moving, and each participant in the May events is already waiting for his turn with a number. To everyone according to his deserts ...
  12. mr.vasilievich
    mr.vasilievich 5 November 2015 08: 10 New
    I can imagine with what torment the Council of Europe issued this conclusion, how they selected words in a more affectionate way to Kiev. After all, Europe recognizes this as its direct complicity in the development of Ukrainian fascism, and to some extent it is even, perhaps, ashamed.
  13. maikl50jrij
    maikl50jrij 5 November 2015 08: 14 New
    Yeah! You will envy such speed! When people burned, they finished off all the media about it Taldychili ... And here, on you! The investigation is useless! Where did you look?
  14. jPilot
    jPilot 5 November 2015 08: 15 New
    Ну так таки скоро и до расследования майдана дойдём, а там и трибунал глядишь к украинской хунте подкрадётся. Не иначе как еуропа старушка, "просыпаться" собралась. belay No. Вот что, "бомбардировки животворящие" по ИГИЛ делают, сразу призадумались (дай-то Бог) о своём поведении.
    1. WOLF 107
      WOLF 107 5 November 2015 09: 00 New
      With such speed, not earlier than in 15 years, or even more
    2. Karlovar
      Karlovar 5 November 2015 22: 24 New
      Старушка не "проснулась",её разбудили!!! Думаю,риторика и движения запада изменились после опубликования данных эксперимента Алмаз-Антея.Скорее всего,этот эксперимент ни что иное,как воспроизведение истинной картинки произошедшего,имея перед глазами спутниковые снимки...Таким боком дядя Вова дал "партнёрам" понять,что он знает(как и они-"партнёры"),как всё было,соответственно имеет неопровержимые доказательства!!! А чем объяснить такие перемены?:"умеренная" опозиция изъявила желание сотрудничать с Асадом,начала реально мочить ИГ,американские ВВС начали хоть как-то молотить по ИГ,Турция объявила,что ща будет молотить по ИГ,Асада оставили в покое с немедленной отставкой,это заявление европейской комиссии по одесским событиям,принуждение хунты к миру,бриты заткнулись с участием своих ВВС в Сирии,Канада соскочила с коалиции,да много ещё чего,всего не упомнишь даже...
  15. leo3972
    leo3972 5 November 2015 08: 17 New
    Europe woke up all in shit, and now do not wash.
  16. slizhov
    slizhov 5 November 2015 09: 49 New
    International Criminals TO ANSWER !!!

    Well, that’s it ... Doubts are over
    Our callsign is “Odessa will not be forgiven ...”!
    It’s not for us to pray with God for luck,
    Cathedrals in the souls of each grow.
    And the hour will strike, and the mobile of midnight will perish
    Stripes of tape will lie on the sleeve ...
    And all the fragments will be collected
    For obelisks among succulent herbs.
  17. mamont5
    mamont5 5 November 2015 11: 34 New
    Quote: subbtin.725
    ""Великое"" пробуждение,твою мать.Очнулись,через полтора года...

    No, they woke up, but not about the crimes on the Ruin. Everything affects here, and the tiredness of the sanctions-counter-sanctions, refugees, the war in Syria, and Europe (not all) begins to understand that there is no way without Russia, which means that it is necessary to establish contacts and dampen the squeals of dill.
  18. Shuttle
    Shuttle 5 November 2015 16: 54 New

    The by-television population sees absolutely nothing and does not want to know.
    The hardest thing to wake up is not the one who is sleeping, but the one who pretends to be sleeping.

    What the hell is such an investigation? To merge all the facts into one toilet and forget it completely! Wolves are rag!

    Poroshenko, Turchinov, Yatsenyuk, etc. to the Hague in court!