American interests in Turkmenistan: to be or not to be

Ashgabat approved the deployment of the US Air Force at the military airfield "Mary-2". It is assumed that the rental price will not exceed 200 million dollars per year (or even 100 million dollars). In a word, almost for nothing. The consistency of Turkmenistan is explained by the launch of the construction of the TAPI gas pipeline (from the Galkynysh field to India, 1735 km). Previously, construction was postponed due to the dangerous situation in Afghanistan. Now the future TAPI wanted to protect from the air the Americans.


American interests in Turkmenistan: to be or not to be


You don’t need to be surprised at the activity of Americans in Turkmenistan. Washington used to take care of Ashgabat’s security. For example, at the end of March 2015, USA agreed meet the request of the authorities of Turkmenistan for the provision of military assistance to this country. This was stated by the head of the United States Central Command, General Lloyd James Austin. An official request from the authorities of Turkmenistan entered Washington after receiving data on the presence of militants of the "Islamic State" in northern Afghanistan.

And now another help arrived. As reported October 22 "Arguments of the week", Turkmenistan gave the go-ahead to deploy the US military at the military airfield "Mary-2". The cost of rent is small: according to experts, we are talking about a relatively small amount in 100-200 million dollars per year.

The modest requests of Ashgabat "AN" are explained by the decision on the implementation of the TAPI gas pipeline project (Turkmenistan - Afghanistan - Pakistan - India) from the second in the world in terms of reserves of the Galkynysh field. The length of the pipeline will be 1735 kilometers, and most of it will pass through the territories of Afghanistan and Pakistan, which control the Taliban and IG. The Americans promised to protect the gas pipeline from the air.

An unnamed military diplomatic source told The Arguments of the Week that the main locations for the remaining NATO forces in Afghanistan coincide with the route of the gas pipeline.

Also, the publication indicates that Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu canceled the planned visit to Ashgabat.

About security TAPI previously wrote and "Independent newspaper". Victoria Panfilova’s material from October 20 states that the Galkynysh field will be the resource base for TAPI, which will be developed by Japan and China, and the United States will provide security guarantees.

Turkmenistan has begun construction of TAPI. The pipeline will pass over 30 billion cubic meters. m of gas per year. At its own expense, and on its own, Ashgabat will build 215 km of pipes on Turkmen territory. The publication notes that the construction is probably associated with increased security guarantees that Ashgabat received from Washington during the visit of the Foreign Minister of Turkmenistan Rashid Meredov to the United States.

Alexander Knyazev, an expert on Central Asia and the Middle East, does not exclude that Washington promised security both at the border and on the construction of TAPI in exchange for the deployment of air forces at the Mary-2 airfield. Quote:

“The details are not yet known. I only know that, apparently, because of this, the alleged visit of Russian Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu to Ashgabat was canceled without explanation and the status of the Turkmen-American consultations was raised, at which, in fact, everything was discussed. ”


The expert noted that the issue of extending the time frame and increasing the number of the American presence in Afghanistan after the events in Kunduz and Faryab should be considered “in the same context”.

And one more opinion, which is provided by Nezavisimaya Gazeta.

Director of the MGIMO Analytical Center, Andrei Kazantsev, said that “there is such a disposition based on preliminary agreements: Japan receives the Galkynysh deposit, and the construction of the TAPI begins, which corresponds to American interests within the framework of their Big Central Asia project.

The purpose of the project is to establish contacts between the Afghanistan-Pakistan region and post-Soviet Central Asia. The goal is to stabilize the situation in these countries with the help of energy projects of interest to both Kabul and Islamabad. The US has its own benefit. The expert noted that the United States "receives a military airfield" Mary-2 ", which was claimed for a long time, and will give security guarantees to Turkmenistan." In his opinion, the link between American geopolitical and Japanese economic interests is often found in Asia.

There are opinions and other Russian experts.

“Obviously, we are not implementing the TAPI project,” said "Free Press" Alexander Khramchikhin, Deputy Director of the Institute for Political and Military Analysis. - As for the American base, it is not at all clear why it is there? Of course, if the Americans and the Turkmen strongly want it, then, of course, you can shove it there, only this base will create problems for the States first of all - it can be instantly blocked, such as our grouping in Transnistria. Even more surprising, some politicians and experts continue to believe in some kind of American security guarantees, especially after the war in Iraq, Georgia and Ukraine. ”

“The neutrality of Turkmenistan has outlived itself,” remarks the military-economic expert Dmitry Verkhoturov. - For a long time already the question is sharp: to whom to join? Either to the CSTO (that is, to enter the channel of Russian policy), or seek help elsewhere — in this case, from the United States. The approach to politics here is typical for Central Asia: Turkmen are trying to bargain, as in the market, comparing the "prices" (benefits). I think at this stage, the relations of Turkmenistan with Russia and the United States are at such a “trading stage”. But Russia is unlikely to allow an air force base to appear near its underbelly - the Kremlin has leverage on Berdymukhamedov. ”

Andrei Grozin, head of the department of Central Asia and Kazakhstan at the Institute of CIS Countries, also doubts that Ashgabat will burn out with a gas pipeline: “... frankly, it is hard to believe in this. Taking into account the fact that now, in Afghanistan, as it is known, the Taliban movement has become more active, an “IG” appeared, it would simply be a “golden trumpet”, because you have to pay for loyalty to various field commanders, and they have been rapidly changing lately. ”

As for the former Soviet strategic airfield "Mary-2", the expert strongly doubts that the United States will get access to it. “To give the US a base means to automatically receive a lot of trouble and symmetrical answers from Russia,” he says. “No matter how neutral Turkmenistan may be, it’s still quite vulnerable ...” The expert believes that Turkmenistan is not ready to reconsider relations with Russia.

Finally, the reaction of the PRC. The appearance of Americans in Turkmenistan will cause a negative reaction from Beijing, Grozin said.

Moreover, let us add, the Chinese will be further irritated by the appearance of the Japanese, these American geopolitical allies, who are in conflict with China over the islands, near the gas pipeline. It seems that the Turkmen authorities, with their overly flexible policies, have created not a “bargaining”, but a tangle of contradictions.

Observed and commented on Oleg Chuvakin
- especially for topwar.ru
Ctrl Enter

Noticed a mistake Highlight text and press. Ctrl + Enter

103 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Same lech 23 October 2015 06: 24 New
    • 19
    • 0
    +19
    It is not necessary to be surprised at the activity of Americans in Turkmenistan. Washington previously cared for the security of Ashgabat.


    Again, the new US base in the underbelly of RUSSIA ... but how many can be encircled with bases under a plausible pretext.

    Turkmens need to be made clear that they contacted Satan by concluding an agreement with him.
    1. science fiction writer 23 October 2015 06: 39 New
      • 15
      • 0
      +15
      The Americans promised to protect the gas pipeline from the air.

      The promised three years are waiting. But the most interesting thing is that from the air you can protect the gas pipeline from terrorists who are essentially located on their territory where there is no
      nor any laws and where de facto they are the government.
      It is real that USkaly will guard there so is its own drug business.
      1. Jack-b 23 October 2015 07: 21 New
        • 11
        • 0
        +11
        Quote: fiction
        But the most interesting is how you can protect the gas pipeline from terrorists from the air

        like this:
        it will be just a “golden trumpet”, as various warlords will have to pay for loyalty

        So this will be another terrorist financing project.
        1. science fiction writer 23 October 2015 07: 38 New
          • 6
          • 0
          +6
          I sen stump What will be paid, But why did they come up with a bike about air protection?
          They couldn’t cook noodles more elegantly.
          1. Eugene-Eugene 23 October 2015 08: 57 New
            • 13
            • 0
            +13
            Turkmenistan after the collapse of the Soviet Union went the beaten path of Asian despots. The daily oaths of loyalty to the people of Niyazov, the verse odes to him in the country's constitution are only minor parts of the medieval personality cult. Chauvinism typical of Central Asia, the Caucasus and the Baltic States is the extrusion of Russians from the country (333 thousand in 1989 g., 165 thousand in 2010), as a result - degradation of education, science and medicine, Islamization of the masses: the education of the Turkmen has sunk into oblivion, which The USSR led for decades, they returned to the embrace of darkness and ignorance that was comfortable for them.
            Against this background, economic growth is impressive: GDP - 3,1 billion dollars in 1990, 7,1 billion in 2013 (in constant prices 1990). At the same time, the growth of the economy, achieved through energy exports, is eaten up by population growth: 3,6 million. in 1990, 5,1 million in 2013. And here we see familiar paths: almost all southern countries develop in the same way - economic growth is accompanied by population growth, when economic problems begin and this whole house of well-being collapses and the idyllic picture gives way to civil war. For example, the population of Syria in 2000 is 16 million, in 2013, 23 million. In this regard, the question arises: in the face of falling prices for hydrocarbons, business problems in Turkmenistan have already begun?
            1. kepmor 23 October 2015 11: 42 New
              • 5
              • 0
              +5
              At all times they were BASMACHI- they remained! Nationalists in their most extreme form, vicious and greedy. Savages!
              1. 406ppm2gv 23 October 2015 17: 46 New
                • 2
                • 0
                +2
                kepmor (2) RU
                Explain what nationalists are in extreme form. Have you lived there, what do you say?
                1. Talgat 23 October 2015 21: 06 New
                  • 2
                  • 0
                  +2
                  No, this is unreal! Turkmenistan cannot go against all neighbors! From the south, Iran - which is simply allergic to the United States, is surrounded by Kazakhs and Kyrgyz, CSTO members and allies of Russia, and from the north Russia - well, why should the Turkmens be asked the base of a hostile state?

                  Moreover, for example, Turkmen recently allowed to lay on their territory a section of the new railway line Kazakhstan-Iran - and these are strategic things. They will not strain relations with all neighbors at once - this is not logical simply
            2. _Vladislav_ 23 October 2015 12: 05 New
              • 2
              • 0
              +2
              The US Air Force base itself, even if it appears an unpleasant factor, but not fatal.
              As correctly noted in the article, such a base is vulnerable, and in which case, it can be quickly neutralized. Ultimately, this is not a base with mine-based missiles, which, if used, leave little time for a decision.

              Why did Turkmenistan want to draw a target on her forehead? In principle, a country consisting predominantly (by 89%) of Sunnis does not particularly sympathize with Shiite Iran and Syria in the first place, and the second is the ability to realize itself beautifully with a gas pipeline.
              Well and ISIS, they relied on the United States and its allies. Loyal regimes are not attacked by ISIS.

              But now it doesn’t matter.
              The success of Russia in Syria, eliminates any gas pipelines and air bases in Turkmenistan. This is important.
              1. The comment was deleted.
              2. Oleg NSK 23 October 2015 12: 44 New
                • 10
                • 0
                +10
                Gas pipeline through Afghanistan and Pakistan? ... I have not heard anything more optimistic for a long time .... it seems to me that the gas pipeline, say "Turkmenistan - North Pole - Atlantic - Antarctica - Indian Ocean - India" - sounds more realistic
              3. svd-xnumx 23 October 2015 20: 33 New
                • 1
                • 0
                +1
                and the opportunity to be beautifully realized with the gas pipeline is secondly.
                Now Turkmens supply most of the gas to China. And having contacted immediately with three opponents of the PRC: India, the USA and Japan, Turkmenistan risks “import-substituting” Russian gas from the Chinese market.
            3. Spnsr 23 October 2015 18: 08 New
              • 2
              • 0
              +2
              Quote: Eugene-Eugene
              question: amid falling prices for hydrocarbons, economic problems in Turkmenistan have already begun?

              yes, otherwise why did they get pin-ups?
              and in general the article was incorrectly called:
              American interests in Turkmenistan: to be or not to be

              God forbid, of course!
            4. The comment was deleted.
            5. forwarder 24 October 2015 22: 53 New
              • 0
              • 0
              0
              Quote: Eugene-Eugene
              as a result, the degradation of education, science and medicine, the Islamization of the masses: the enlightenment of the Turkmens, which the USSR conducted for decades, has sunk into oblivion, they have returned to the comfortable embrace of darkness and ignorance.

              Well, let's compare the "ignorant Turkmens" with residents of other states of the former USSR. According to Credit Suisse 2015 (2014), the welfare of an average Turkmen over 20 was welfare:
              1,27 residents of Estonia
              1,98 residents of Lithuania
              2,14 inhabitants of Latvia
              2,41 residents of Georgia
              2,52 residents of Azerbaijan
              3,83 residents of Russia
              8,03 residents of Kazakhstan
              8,41 Armenian residents
              9,17 Kyrgyz
              14,47 Moldovans
              16,69 residents of Tajikistan
              28,96 Belarusians
              31,26 residents of Ukraine
              At the same time, the average Turkmen is poorer than the richest of the Eastern Europeans (the average Slovenian is 0,80), but richer than the Czech following the word (1,08). By the way, Estonians in this conditional ranking immediately follow the Czechs.
              Quote: Eugene-Eugene
              In this regard, the question arises: in the face of falling hydrocarbon prices, have economic problems already begun in Turkmenistan?

              Prices began to fall not yesterday. Here it will be appropriate to see the dynamics for 2014. What happened to the well-being of residents of the countries of the former USSR over 20 years old in 2014, compare the data of Credit Suisse 2015 and Credit Suisse 2014 (+ this increase, became richer; - this decrease, became poorer).
              resident of Turkmenistan + 10,6%
              Latvian resident + 0,2%
              resident of Lithuania -0,3%
              resident of Kazakhstan -4,5%
              a resident of Kyrgyzstan -9,5%
              resident of Armenia -10,2%
              resident of Estonia -13,1%
              resident of Georgia -14,7%
              resident of Tajikistan and Azerbaijan -15,7%
              resident of Moldova -16,9%
              resident of Belarus -28,8%
              resident of Ukraine -39,5%
              resident of Russia -40,1%
        2. Ramzaj99 23 October 2015 20: 24 New
          • 0
          • 0
          0
          It seems that Turkmen history does not teach .....
          Since the Yankees came, we are waiting for another maidan soon .....
      2. Tktyfern 23 October 2015 09: 23 New
        • 9
        • 0
        +9
        Turkmens understand everything perfectly. Do not be surprised. Russia has been betrayed in all ages. A little bit again they will lean against Russia. And we are kind, forgive.
        1. Karabanov 23 October 2015 14: 31 New
          • 1
          • 0
          +1
          Yes, and I am not at all surprised at the flexibility of the spine in Turkmen. They were geographically lucky for natural resources, and therefore they sway and build important people out of themselves. Razomlev from laziness invent idols for themselves, which alone is worth Turkmenbashi-Niyazov ...
          In general, nothing surprising and their position to bend is quite natural.
      3. yushch 23 October 2015 10: 22 New
        • 8
        • 0
        +8
        From the air they will easily guard it. Look, analysts talk about the coincidence of the gas pipeline route and the locations of the US Army units that will remain in Afghanistan. Aviation will not be used for air protection; attack and reconnaissance drones will be used. These units will ensure their round-the-clock presence in the air. In fact, any objects present in the area of ​​the pipeline and the pit and perfume will be destroyed.
        It amazes me that not one expert indicated a very important reason for the presence of the US base in Turkmenistan - this is access to the Caspian Sea and control of deposits owned by the Turkmen. After all, the Americans called the Caspian a zone of their interests. I think this is the main reason.
      4. Karlovar 23 October 2015 12: 15 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        The effect of protecting the future gas pipeline from the air in Afghanistan (!) Will be the same as from the “struggle” of the coalition (62 countries) from the air against the Islamic State .... Actually, both the Turkmens and the Indians are well aware of this! It looks like just an air shock ... Well, the main Wishlist for the United States is the Air Force base in Mary-2, the gas pipeline on its side, moreover, is unprofitable, as it will bring peace (relative) to Afghanistan, Pakistan, spur the economy of India ... In the course of a tricky plan the State Department is this: the base in Mary-2 was put under this noise, but what about the protection of the gas pipeline? -Well, I couldn’t, I couldn’t !!! that phrase wring their hands, for greater credibility) ... In an extreme case, the position of a gas pipeline security guard in the possible future promises tremendous opportunities for blackmailing India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Turkmenistan !!!
      5. Cossack Ermak 24 October 2015 01: 14 New
        • 1
        • 0
        +1
        That is, the Turkmens will pay the leaders of the groups that will currently control the pipeline. If they don’t, then no USA will help them.
        And that means direct financing of terrorists.

        About the base.
        It turns out on the Caspian Sea Tang planes will be able to fly up to Astrakhan?
    2. Aleksandr72 23 October 2015 07: 33 New
      • 27
      • 0
      +27
      I believe that the Americans, fleeing from Iraq, forced to curtail their air base in the Kyrgyz Manas, realizing that their military mission in Afghanistan, despite the growing military presence, is also stalling, are trying to get to the territory of their geopolitical rival and have long been no potential enemy (war The USA has been going against Russia for a long time, even if not in the form of direct clashes) from the most unprotected side. The presence of an air base in Turkmenistan will allow, apparently, the Americans believe, to control the airspace over Central Asia and the Caspian, to counteract the Russian fleet in the Caspian (which became relevant after missile attacks on ISIS militants from ships of the Caspian flotilla), as well as provide an air bridge to Afghanistan , independent of the position of Russia and its allies in this matter, unless they ask for an air corridor for their transporters.
      Ashgabat's security issues in this regard are not in the first, and not in the second, and most likely not even in tenth place, if at all, at least somehow interest the Americans. And the Turkmens grab themselves problems for the most do not indulge. Apparently, the examples of Japanese Okinawa, the neighboring Kyrgyz Manas (where the US presence eventually degenerated into a sway in the political and economic situation in the country, didn’t even get to the Ukrainian version), the Turkmen side does not teach anything.
      I have the honor.
      1. Apsit 23 October 2015 11: 11 New
        • 2
        • 0
        +2
        "some politicians and experts continue to believe in some sort of American security guarantee, especially after the war in Iraq, Georgia and Ukraine."
        Yeah, this is the first thing that comes to mind.
    3. Uzzy 23 October 2015 08: 25 New
      • 5
      • 0
      +5
      Turkmens need to be made clear that they contacted Satan by concluding an agreement with him.

      Do not need anything. They will soon understand themselves ... In Iraq, the Americans fought against ISIS and guaranteed security so that the Iraqi government wanted to consider the possibility of assistance from Russia.
      Well, and so ... how many post-Soviet territories have crossed over to the USA?
    4. bornikrub 23 October 2015 08: 32 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      Not surprisingly, among the five Soviet Central Asian republics, it was the Turkmen Republic that was considered the most backward.
      1. SRC P-15 23 October 2015 08: 57 New
        • 1
        • 0
        +1
        After the "appearance" of the Caspian flotilla, the United States sleeps and sees its own base near the Caspian. And thanks to the promises of the Turkmen leadership, the Americans succeed. They need an air base there, and the gas pipeline is just a cover. We need to make every effort to prevent the United States from entering this region.
    5. Rus2012 23 October 2015 09: 28 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      The appearance of Americans in Turkmenistan will cause a negative reaction

      ...by itself!
      So a reaction will follow. In what form, let's see.
      It is likely using one of the options from the "rich Yankees arsenal":
      - color revolutions
      - "Bermuhamed fell from a horse"
      .
    6. marlin1203 23 October 2015 11: 37 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      And now, then, for TAPI the most suitable situation in Afghanistan! laughing here are naive - this gas pipeline is simply a “gift of heaven” for the Taliban, if you want to milk, you want to blow it up ...
    7. Pcorda38 23 October 2015 15: 51 New
      • 4
      • 0
      +4
      An alliance with the United States is how to sell your soul to the devil ... when you realize the danger is too late!

      The USA corrupts everything and everyone ... are the bubonic plague !!!
    8. mr.vasilievich 23 October 2015 17: 24 New
      • 5
      • 0
      +5
      Turkmens themselves do not decide anything. Pasha decides. who gets the money.
    9. Asadullah 23 October 2015 19: 34 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Turkmens need to be made clear that they contacted Satan by concluding an agreement with him.


      Turkmen thinks and decides for Turkmenbashi. And for Turkmenbashi the leadership of Turkey decides. So the Americans began to agree on this with Turkey. This base, convenient for DA, was actively used during the Afghan war. As for possible aggression against the Russian Federation, it is useless, because it will be destroyed at a time, since any base requires layered protection. Yes, let them sit in Afghanistan, the longer they get stuck there, the more they will receive in the face.
      1. Karlovar 24 October 2015 14: 11 New
        • 1
        • 0
        +1
        Moreover, the Ottoman dynasty came to Asia Minor from Turkmenistan ... Like relatives with the Turks ...
  2. avvg 23 October 2015 06: 31 New
    • 7
    • 0
    +7
    Does history with Ukraine not teach Turkmen? All republics of the former USSR attack the same rake.
    1. blizart 23 October 2015 07: 18 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      Quote: avvg
      Does history with Ukraine not teach Turkmen? All republics of the former USSR attack the same rake.

      Mayakovsky-Passing.
      All Republics are Bargainable.
      My grandmother: For busting and to hell in the yard.
    2. Zymran 23 October 2015 08: 48 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      Quote: avvg
      Does history with Ukraine not teach Turkmen? All republics of the former USSR attack the same rake.


      The difference from Ukraine is that it will not work to threaten the Turkmens with military force or “invasion of aliens”.
      1. Karlovar 23 October 2015 12: 38 New
        • 2
        • 0
        +2
        Already threatening the Turkmens "invasion" of the Chinese hordes! Here, I inadvertently thought about how they (the Turkmen) gathered to sell gas to the Indians when the Chinese bought up all the Turkmen gas (contracted) for twenty years ahead ????? Only right now I remembered such an obstacle ... to the American Wishlist ... Nevertheless, all these conversations around the TAPI gas pipeline are like empty bullshit ...
    3. Karlovar 23 October 2015 12: 32 New
      • 4
      • 0
      +4
      Here it is worth recalling the story with Kyrgyzstan yet, with Uzbekistan, there American bases and "popular unrest" and revolution went hand in hand! As a result, the Uzbeks and Kyrgyzs had no choice but to drive out the Yankees with their bases! Yes, and in North America, the Yankees at first gifted the Indians with glass beads .... and then cleaned them under the root (they shot them, starved them, they killed all the bison, the Indians feed base, they threw diseases with lice in donated blankets, etc., etc. .) ... Byrd do not like reading historical books along the way !!!
    4. ostrovS2003 23 October 2015 13: 51 New
      • -8
      • 0
      -8
      Why are YOU constantly threatening your neighbors. All former Soviet Republics are sovereign countries. They seek protection where it benefits them. Why should all of them be dependent on Russia?
      1. psg72 23 October 2015 14: 23 New
        • 4
        • 0
        +4
        Firstly, there are no threats to Turkmenistan from Russia. And why does the US have geopolitical interests around the world, and Russia should not have them even in its underbelly?
      2. Bayun 23 October 2015 20: 39 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        Sovereignty is an invention of professors. Kakstrany seriously believe that the United States will fight for their interests. Fools! They will die, fighting for the interests of the United States.
  3. parusnik 23 October 2015 06: 31 New
    • 10
    • 0
    +10
    Ashgabat approved the deployment of the US Air Force at the Mary-2 military airfield. ..But there is such an omen for Central Asia ... In the country where the American base is located, Islamic militants are starting to pull themselves up to the borders of this country and the situation in the country is becoming unstable .. Examples, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan .. Peacefully tired of Turkmenistan ..
  4. Humpty 23 October 2015 06: 35 New
    • 4
    • 0
    +4
    Now let the Turkmen wait for the bearded.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. Mera joota 23 October 2015 06: 47 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      Quote: Humpty
      Now let the Turkmen wait for the bearded.

      It was for the sake of protection against what you put “bearded” Turkmens invited (in fact) Americans. Turkmens are completely independent of Russia and there is nothing to threaten them, but what will be the reaction of China ... Turkmenistan is the main supplier of gas to China.
      1. Humpty 23 October 2015 07: 21 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        Knowing not by hearsay about the consequences of the American military presence, I imagine American help so, do you have bearded ones? What not !? So it will be.
      2. parusnik 23 October 2015 08: 15 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        It was for the sake of protection against what you put “bearded” Turkmens invited (in fact) Americans...Oh yeah! In Iraq, so Americans from the bearded, defend that Iraq, do not know what evil is worse than the "defenders" or bearded
      3. viktorrymar 23 October 2015 08: 26 New
        • 5
        • 0
        +5
        Mera Joota: It was for the sake of protection against what you put “bearded” Turkmens invited (in fact) Americans.


        It’s a very convenient ignition point, you can annoy both Iran and Russia at once - the Americans will not miss their chance, no one is going to defend the Turkmens. The government of Turkmenistan seems to have isolated its brains in the same way as the country.

        Turkmens are completely independent of Russia and there is nothing to threaten them


        Do you think Russia is threatening Turkmenistan? I wonder what?
        1. Karlovar 23 October 2015 12: 45 New
          • 2
          • 0
          +2
          The main goal of the Yankees is to threaten China! Also, Russia, Iran, Kazakhstan, Azerbaijan-Caspian littoral. Yes, and the New Silk Road should go into Iran through .... Turkmenistan (such a geography) ...
      4. Karlovar 23 October 2015 12: 42 New
        • 3
        • 0
        +3
        Iraq, too, "invited" the Americans to protect against bearded IG! And what are the results ????
  5. LeftPers 23 October 2015 06: 38 New
    • 6
    • 0
    +6
    The loot decides everything, they threw money to the Turkmen cultivators, but most likely, they bought it with giblets and here is the result.
  6. Glot 23 October 2015 06: 39 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Another test of our strength and attempts to introduce an imbalance in the relations between us, Turkmens and other Asian players.
    They are going to protect someone, yeah. They, the Americans, already around the world "defended" all the hell to what.
  7. Babai Balkan 23 October 2015 06: 41 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    and we have silence - only the OBS reports what and how .... the condom does not take into account that the Balkan and Akhal regions are 80% pro-Russian. And the Oriental will not be happy amers.
  8. Junior, I 23 October 2015 06: 49 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    A convenient strategy for the Americans. First, a hotbed of Islamists is created, then they are sent to the right place. Then they “fight” them, creating new and new military bases around Russia, in order to later turn around and, together with ISIS, head into the depths of our country.
  9. Mountain shooter 23 October 2015 06: 56 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    The Turkmens decided to have lunch with the devil. Did they stock up on a long spoon? The gas pipeline through Afghanistan is cool! And how is his mattress going to protect him? A soldier every 100 meters is about nothing, but already more than 10 thousand in one shift! And enough of a grenade launcher to arrange a little trouble, and the truck with explosives, so beloved in those places? No, this is some kind of gamble like American football. Throw a ball behind the opponent’s back, and there he will run away - he will not run away, or he will be damaged in the body - for luck! Only the rival - the Russian bear - breaks his legs.
  10. Nymp 23 October 2015 06: 57 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    Of course, protection from Merikasos Turkmenistan will not wait! Hedgehog it is clear that mattresses want to control the flight space from one side to China, and from the other to Russia. And Turkmenistan itself, as a gas producer (economically independent for mattresses), will be under military supervision. It’s not for nothing that the puck flies there, I hope he will tell them what kind of game they try on their ass.
    1. Vladimir 1964 23 October 2015 07: 48 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      Quote: Nymp
      It’s not for nothing that the puck flies there, I hope he will tell them what kind of game they try on their ass.


      Boris, you are wrong!

      Also, the publication indicates that Defense Minister Sergei Shoigu canceled the planned visit to Ashgabat.


      Something like this, Dear, this is a phrase from an article. hi
      1. Nymp 23 October 2015 21: 51 New
        • 0
        • 0
        0
        Quote: Vladimir 1964
        Boris, you are wrong!

        Sorry Vladimir, read in the morning at tea, getting ready for work. I read it in the evening, made a mistake. But in general, I'm not mistaken about the intentions of the mattresses! request
  11. paxil 23 October 2015 07: 02 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Oh, Gurbanguly Myalikgulyevich Berdimuhamedov will wait for the cotton revolution laughing
    1. Lindon 23 October 2015 13: 39 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Cotton in Uzbekistan at Karimov Islam Abduganievich.
      The Turkmen have gas and deserts.
      1. paxil 23 October 2015 19: 12 New
        • 0
        • 0
        0
        Quote: Lindon
        Cotton in Uzbekistan at Karimov Islam Abduganievich.
        The Turkmen have gas and deserts.

        Yes, do not care anyway laughing
  12. Taygerus 23 October 2015 07: 03 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    such friends of enemies are not necessary
  13. natakor1949 23 October 2015 07: 04 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Hmm ... One already tried to sit on 2 chairs, now in Rostov, resting from the cares of the sick. What kind of magnet is this - a rake, because all 15 republics attacked it, some even several times, and again I want to smash my face in the blood. The poor peoples of the republics ...
  14. Wise Kaa 23 October 2015 07: 08 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    US strategy is clear! So they want to control our Caspian flotilla, and don’t go to the grandmother here !!! But Turkmenistan probably hinted that if they do not agree, you will find the fate of Syria. It is unlikely that they would have agreed otherwise; they are living quite well anyway.
  15. Shiva83483 23 October 2015 07: 09 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    It’s interesting that it happened from the Turkmen-Bashi that he requested help from 3,14 ... wasps requested?
    1. Humpty 23 October 2015 07: 31 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      Nothing happened to him. The gas is on sale, the people are packed with opium, the salt is free. The word is quiet and the surface is tired.
  16. VadimSt 23 October 2015 07: 10 New
    • -5
    • 0
    -5
    I am outraged by the Uzbeks, like everyone else - the Kyrgyz only escorted "our partners", so these were tied up. But at the same time I am outraged by the fact that you can’t follow the principle - "we have scouts, and they have spies."
    What am I talking about here
    The rental price is low: according to experts, we are talking about a relatively small amount of 100-200 million dollars per year,
    and in the title, so generally
    In a word, almost for nothing
    Why give food to raise "last year's dust"? Tomorrow, all ill-wishers will poke their faces - “For the Black Sea Fleet base in Crimea, Russia paid $ 90 lemons per year, and stupid Uzbekistan, for renting an airfield in Mary, will receive only $ 100 to $ 200 lemons. Stupid!
    1. Mart 23 October 2015 07: 21 New
      • 3
      • 0
      +3
      Quote: VadimSt
      Indignant at uzbeks

      Quote: VadimSt
      "stupid" Uzbekistan, for renting an airfield in Mary, will receive only from $ 100 to $ 200 lemons

      Sorry, but in the review there is not a word about Uzbeks and Uzbekistan. The definition of "stupid" also does not paint you.
      PS I did not put minuses to you.
      1. VadimSt 23 October 2015 08: 27 New
        • 1
        • 0
        +1
        Hi!
        1. No one was going to insult Uzbekistan or Turkmenistan. I have enough friends and good acquaintances both there and there. This is a figurative expression, since Uzbekistan does not give anything to anyone at all!
        2. In the review, "no", but I just showed
        Tomorrow, all ill-wishers will "poke their faces" -
        why such assessments are dangerous and how easy it is to turn them into an anti-Russian attack, in interested media.
        3. On the pros and cons, I do not pay attention from the first day on the site. I express my opinion, and do not bet!
        1. Apsit 23 October 2015 11: 33 New
          • 0
          • 0
          0
          Quote: VadimSt
          No one was going to insult Uzbekistan or Turkmenistan

          Not going to, but still insulted calling the Turkmens Uzbeks.
          Quote: VadimSt
          and "stupid" Uzbekistan, for renting an airfield in Mary,

          Where is Uzbekistan, and where is Mary? Question for the 4th grader.
          Quote: VadimSt
          I have enough friends and good acquaintances both there and there.

          And they all look the same to you.
        2. Alibekulu 23 October 2015 16: 17 New
          • 0
          • 0
          0
          Quote: VadimSt
          What am I talking about here
          The rental price is low: according to experts, we are talking about a relatively small amount of 100-200 million dollars per year,

          and in the title, so generally

          In a word, almost for nothing
          By the way, yes wink I also noticed, through the prism of Baikonur for which, together with the polygons pay approx. 90 million dollars According to the logic of Oleg Chuvakin, it turns out for nothing request ?!
          Where are these Mikhanes with a campaign that are outraged with and without cause about it .. repeat
          Quote: Stoler
          To hold a referendum in Turkmenistan on joining Russia - and all issues have been resolved!
          Yeah yes - they will turn up. Here we just tried one day to hold a vote "in contact" on a referendum in East Kazakhstan.
          In the East Kazakhstan region, a user of the VKontakte social network will appear before a court on charges of separatism. The reason for the trial was a survey posted in one of the groups, the "31 channel" reports.

          Igor Sychev, a resident of the city of Ridder, was the administrator of the "Overheard in Ridder" public. This spring, a poll appeared in which readers were asked to vote “for” or “against” the entry of the East Kazakhstan region into the Russian Federation.

          How this action ended is not known. It was later naturally removed. However, such calls on the Internet today are not uncommon. As Sychev himself assures, he did not create this poll, but only allowed it to be published. However, ignorance of the law does not save from liability.

          As a result, employees of the National Security Committee became interested in this vote. A criminal case was opened against the administrator of the group under the article "Separatist activity".

          It provides for punishment up to 10 years in prison. The process will take place in Ridder. Igor Sychev himself, pending trial, has been held in pre-trial detention for several months.
  17. Babai Balkan 23 October 2015 07: 23 New
    • 8
    • 0
    +8
    .... well, what does the TURKMEN have to do with ???? Turkmens perceive all the joys and sorrows of Russia as theirs! All have parabola plates and watch Rostv, women love Turkish TV shows, and several local channels are 25 years old analogue of the Russian “swan lake” putschists. Turkmens honor traditions and ancestors, remember the genealogy .... but a layer of "Altynasyrovskaya" youth appears (an analogue of yours), the main thing for them is loot! And with that, they begin to shave off traditions. That's who for 35 of them and put in place ... for now.
    Well, as for the condiment .. In the past prezik in almost every house, hucksters were selling drugs. The cemeteries in a terrible progression were filled with youth, a shoe rag was stolen and managed to breathe in. But for half a year Berdymukhammedov put things in order, and incurable drug addicts turned into chronic drunks, and most of them pulled themselves together! And a bit later than these events, rumors began to spread about the "tricks" of the Prezik tribe, daughters, himself ... and in response - all Turkish schools in the country were closed - and everything stopped !!!
    Well, and in agreements with mattresses - that I strongly doubt ...
    1. Humpty 23 October 2015 07: 36 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      I am surprised if there are really fewer drug addicts in Turkmenistan.
    2. Xergey 23 October 2015 08: 33 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Are you sure that this is exactly how everything is in Turkmenistan, maybe you want it so much, but of course you wanted it to be true.
    3. Was mammoth 23 October 2015 09: 31 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      Quote: Babai Balkan
      .... well, what does the TURKMEN have to do with ????

      Just look at the map to understand in Turkmenistan "the sphere of vital interests of the United States." I will not say anything about oil and gas. No wonder in the USSR there was a separate TurKVO.
      Modern Turkmenistan somehow reminds me of medieval Japan, an attempt to fence itself off from outside influences. Even sailors are not allowed out of the port. However, we live in the XXI century, it will not work. You are in the "sphere of vital US interests." wink
      Quote: Babai Balkan
      Well, and in agreements with mattresses - that I strongly doubt ...

      Wait and see. I also have doubts.
      They really know what is happening in Turkmenistan only by special services. You rarely see Turkmen on the Internet.
      PS Part of his childhood was spent in Kizyl-Arvat. Our pilots were there too. And motorized arrows.
      Funny case. They brought concrete on the platform. Filmed with one brick. One tank held the platform, the other concrete.
      I would never have believed it if I hadn’t seen it with my own eyes. In the desert in the spring between the dunes in places, tulips are solid. The beauty!!!

    4. Turkir 23 October 2015 23: 39 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      But Berdymukhammedov for half a year order led- and incurable drug addicts have turned in chronic drunks, and most pulled themselves together!

      For a long time I did not get such pleasure from the written.
      The last time he laughed like that after reading Mark Twain, you have his literary style.
  18. 1536 23 October 2015 07: 26 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    Overlooked or could not give more? It’s time to already understand that there is no “friendship” at all, there is only settlement and money. As a result, all efforts, all military victories, all victims may become in vain. Indeed, politics is not even of the 19th, but of the 18th century.
  19. Babai Balkan 23 October 2015 07: 33 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    "VadimSt (1) Today, 07: 10New I'm outraged by the Uzbeks" I feel the hand of the State Depot-Psakovskaya ..... Uzbekistan, Uzbekistan ... back in the 90s Uzbekistan tried to snatch CHARJOU, but not MARY! Therefore, the Uzbeks and the dollar for Mary 2 will not receive! )))))
  20. Babai Balkan 23 October 2015 07: 40 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    AND!! Turkmenistan is NOT Turkey, but the capital Ashgabat, previously Ashgabat, yet. earlier Askhabat, i.e. the city of Askhov, the homeland of Odin!)))))))
    1. psg72 23 October 2015 13: 54 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      And Ashgabat bore the name Poltoratsk, too, whose homeland it is. The underground lake "Kov Ata" is the entrance to the possession of Aida. Do not mix everything in a heap. Ashgabat is a beautiful city sometimes with a tragic history (1948). But to drag in this subject the ravings of modern Turkmen historians is not worth it.
      Ps I was born in Ashgabat and lived in it for 30 years. (On Gage)
  21. dojjdik 23 October 2015 07: 51 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    a worthy answer is the creation by Russia of China and Iran of a good air force-air defense base in Cuba, as long as Fidel is alive, it needs to be strengthened there well
  22. question 23 October 2015 07: 57 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    Let them drive gas to India! Fewer competitors in Europe. And it’s hard for Russia to reach India. Again, the Arabs will not be superfluous! That's just with the base, of course, not ice. But they survived Kyrgyzstan!
  23. maikl50jrij 23 October 2015 08: 19 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Some kind of nonsense ... In the zone of serious conflicts, pull and hope for the "protection" of the amers ... What kind of "defenders" are they all know, especially in relation to the IG. And the cost of "rent" is in doubt. Will they put a link for children's helicopters there? request
  24. asar 23 October 2015 08: 21 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    “Obviously, the TAPI project is not feasible,” Alexander Khramchikhin, deputy director of the Institute for Political and Military Analysis, told the Free Press.

    There were projects in the West, at one time - “Central Asia Gez Papline” and “Central Asia Oil Papline” - that is, from Central Asia through Afghanistan to the terminals on the coast of the Arabian Sea (Pakistan), it did not grow together! And this time, too, I think it won’t work!
    And it is time for the Turkmen leaders to scratch their turnips - with whom are you ?!
  25. Million 23 October 2015 08: 21 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Turkmenistan is a fairly closed country. Why should they let Americans in themselves?
  26. tlauicol 23 October 2015 08: 27 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    The next step of the Americans will be the rental of naval assets in the Caspian Sea and a controlling stake in the gas pipeline
  27. Zumich 23 October 2015 08: 38 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Turkmens, proud free people, respect their Aksakals, many legends are written about their amazing courage, dexterity, wisdom, and how many beautiful fairy tales. They always live somewhat apart and closed to their neighbors, we Russians know very little about Turkmenistan, practically nothing. They say Ashgabat is incredibly beautiful.
    Americans behave like barbarians always and everywhere, forever shitting everything, these are people without clans, without a tribe, even Abama, was at home in Kenya Nairobi, and from his relatives, as if from a plague, he shied away ... a secular man, an American.
    1. asar 24 October 2015 08: 20 New
      • 1
      • 0
      +1
      It will be right - Ashgabat
      The city is simply amazing, a kind of Abu Dhabi in the Karakum!
      There was a friend there, threw off the "pictures"
      However, I can’t answer how the rest of the Turkmen cities live.
  28. Ogogoshka 23 October 2015 08: 46 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Turkmenistan has already begun to shake, if you look at Russian-language Internet resources more and more about the most closed country, then the Belarusian went on a business trip, then they all go by Toyota, we will wait for the opposition to intensify and the arrival of democracy, I think so.
    1. Zymran 23 October 2015 08: 49 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      If infa on Russian-speaking Internet resources, then who is rocking Turkmenistan?
      1. psg72 23 October 2015 14: 01 New
        • 2
        • 0
        +2
        On Russian-language Internet resources there are a number of sites opposed to the current authorities of Turkmenistan, and they usually do not relate to Russia.
  29. F.Vastag 23 October 2015 08: 48 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    And from Whom do you need Protection and Military assistance to the Turkmens and Turkmenistan ???? (so that - for pennies - Surrender to the United States). Who today threatens Turkmenistan that it is necessary to abandon Neutrality and Climb under the wing of the States ??? Well, with the Americans, everything is clear: to them, wherever they put their military base (stick) - just to put it (and then you can not drive them out of there - even if the Turkmens very much want to). But, from whom will the Americans defend Turkmenistan ??? From Iran or Russia (so we don’t even have a border with Turkmenistan - and after 1991 and practically no ties - everything is Frozen (even there are NO Migrants from Turkmenistan in Russia). And what was bad about the neutrality of Turkmenistan under Turkmenbashi Niyazov, that Berdymukhamedov blundered to the United States and NATO (under the wing) ???????????????? Questions, Questions, Questions.
  30. Mangel olys 23 October 2015 08: 56 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    “Turkmenistan’s neutrality has outlived itself,” says military and economic expert Dmitry Verkhoturov. - For a long time now the question has been acute: to whom to join? Either to the CSTO (that is, to enter the channel of Russian politics), or to seek help elsewhere - in this case from the United States.


    It seems to me that ours needs to be more flexible in acting both politically and economically. However, rowing (gas to China) is not for itself, Turkmenistan also needs to give something and interest in this sense. Then they would love to flounder in the "wake of Russian politics." And now, it seems that they are not interested. Here I see our flaw.
  31. Ogogoshka 23 October 2015 08: 58 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    The emphasis is always one, the cult of personality, corruption, the frightened population - the handwriting is always the same, our partners from across the ocean and their many friends are at our side.
  32. vladimirvn 23 October 2015 09: 05 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    Life teaches that someone else's experience teaches no one. While they themselves do not step on the rake, it does not brighten in the brain. Until a couple of revolutions shake up the top and sift it, until the people realize that something depends on it, they will have to suffer and suffer.
  33. Babai Balkan 23 October 2015 09: 11 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    "You are sure that this is how everything is in Turkmenistan, maybe you want it so much, but of course you wanted it to be true."
    Really better than it was. In the Nebitdag-Krasnovodsk Balkan. The average salary is ~ $ 250-300. For a communal apartment, I pay a 3-room apartment for $ 50 a year (in the past-$ 25). I generally keep quiet about gasoline. Shawl-telly many times cheaper than yours. Here the food and apartment prices are rising ...
    1. psg72 23 October 2015 14: 08 New
      • 2
      • 0
      +2
      And what can’t you write about the last Hulk Maslakhaty where the elders “persuaded” the president to remove everything for free. The people living well can pay. If you say, tell the whole truth.
  34. VL33 23 October 2015 09: 35 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Turkmens should be helped to make the right decision. Too many positions to close for Nato. Access to the Caspian, gas and a large number of uneducated youth. Try to swing and the result is known.
  35. Gardamir 23 October 2015 10: 45 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Love Putin because he is great in international affairs. Kremlin policy should be such that such articles do not even arise. That is, we will have an American military base close by? Or is Ashgabat stuffing its price? Or again, everything will be like with Ukraine?
  36. Performance 23 October 2015 11: 01 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    In the understanding of the Americans, there is a dictatorship in Turkmenistan, so a military base is vital for the democratization of the country. Hello to the democracies of Iraq and Libya laughing And for the "transition period" Berdymuhamed will be the best friend of the United States, and fulfill the duties of the governor, for which he will be entrusted with the honorable duty of guarding the gas valve to China and India.
  37. Grigorievich 23 October 2015 11: 24 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    And why is this base there? How will it be supplied? Only through Afghanistan, and there are already problems with the supply. A small mess in Pakistan and all.
    Who knows: Americans fly through Russia?
  38. yan 2015
    yan 2015 23 October 2015 12: 09 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    When I lived in the USSR, I took everything for granted. This is my country. And my people. And now I understand how much we still lost ... thanks to this traitor Humpbacked. damn Judah.
  39. Megatron 23 October 2015 12: 15 New
    • 2
    • 0
    +2
    I think it’s time for us to recognize the “moderate Taliban” and begin to negotiate with them, stipulating the complete destruction of poppy plantations, as they already did when they were in power, and the defeat of this TAPI itself.

    Now we will supply them with weapons and Arrows, and they will nip the Americans, as the Stingers used to be, let the aviation guarding the gas pipeline knock them down, and let the African-American soldier get wet in the toilet.
  40. Maksus 23 October 2015 13: 08 New
    • 3
    • 0
    +3
    And what a beautiful city Ashgabat was before the coming of the Sun to power. Now Turkmenistan takes an active anti-Russian position. Now the US base will appear there. Where the world is heading ...
    1. Maksus 23 October 2015 14: 11 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      And what are the cons? Or is Ashgabat (I’m so used to let Ashgabat Turkmen write) not a beautiful city?
    2. psg72 23 October 2015 14: 18 New
      • 0
      • 0
      0
      What is the minus? Man wrote the truth.
  41. Sotnik77s 23 October 2015 14: 20 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    Skobelev and our children can’t forget in any way, but remember nothing, also the guys of our time .........
  42. kirpich 23 October 2015 15: 22 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    Turkmenistan ... cotton fields .. cotton ... strategic raw materials ... God forbid we lose ...
  43. cherkas.oe 23 October 2015 15: 36 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    Well, what do you want from an illegally born dentist who became Turkmenbashi inherited from his father? His asshole is used by everyone as a condom, both ours and not ours. And he just wants to live well, it does not matter under whom, if only to live in comfort.
  44. Stoler 23 October 2015 15: 43 New
    • -1
    • 0
    -1
    To hold a referendum in Turkmenistan on joining Russia - and all issues have been resolved! angry
  45. lecturer 23 October 2015 15: 43 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    Ashgabat approved the deployment of the US Air Force ....
    ... and I’m ready to start the next (after Libya, Ukraine ... etc.) fulfillment of the duties of the sixes to lick w ... and to fulfill ... In a word, to get in line with the “Igilov” gangs!
  46. Vlad5307 23 October 2015 17: 13 New
    • -1
    • 0
    -1
    Quote: The same Lech
    Turkmens need to be made clear that they contacted Satan by concluding an agreement with him.

    So their Turkmenbashi himself is the corrupt son of Satan. He’ll sell anything for a penny, and the gas pipeline is a string with an empty wallet, there was such a rally in childhood, which greedy Turkmenbashi bought! fool
  47. pvv113 23 October 2015 19: 35 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    the main locations of the remaining NATO troops in Afghanistan coincide with the gas pipeline route

    Suddenly unexpectedly purely by accident ... An amazing coincidence. Involuntarily believe in all the devilry
  48. onix757 23 October 2015 20: 00 New
    • 1
    • 0
    +1
    The weak are always drawn to the strong, this is how the world works. And sometimes economic power turns out to be much more significant than the military. Russia itself has helped and is helping to build an “economic civilization” (partners) all along the way, in which it itself will be on 3 roles.
  49. pogis 23 October 2015 21: 34 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0

    Glory to the tankmen!
  50. maximka 23 October 2015 22: 19 New
    • 0
    • 0
    0
    1. Putin offers a compromise, moreover, profitable
    2. Negotiation partner rejects compromise
    3. The situation is deteriorating sharply for the second side of the negotiations and improving for Putin
    4. Putin offers a compromise, already on more unfavorable conditions
    .
    The procedure is repeated until a compromise is accepted or the negotiating partner has succeeded in scarfing.