Military Review

The scandal around the cadet school of the city of Anapa went beyond the city

50
The fifteenth anniversary of the creation of the cadet school named after Hero of the Soviet Union N. V. Starshinov in the city of Anapa is celebrated by young cadets, their parents and the teaching staff without much enthusiasm. The reason that causes openly negative emotions in the above-mentioned people is related to the fact that the head of this school, as they say, “left”. For a man who stood at the origins of the education of the cadet school, honored education worker of the Krasnodar Territory, a representative of the pedagogical dynasty known in the Kuban, a teacher with 30-year experience of Alexander Bakanov, local leaders of the educational sphere created conditions that cost the headmaster health

As usually happens in such matters, Alexander Bakanov (the director of an educational institution) seemed disagreeable to the city educational administration for the reason related to the expenditure of funds. At least, this is how the parents of those students who chose the naval path for themselves explain the situation around the unexpected change in the leadership of the Anapa cadet corps.

A letter asking you to sort out the situation with the change of leadership in the said Anapa cadet school parents of students (cadets) sent to several instances at once. Among them are not only government bodies (the Ministry of Defense, the reception office of the governor of the Krasnodar Territory, Alexander Tkachev), but also the media. At the same time, the parent committee of the cadet school argues that attempts to find out from the regional authorities an objective reason for changing the leadership of the school preparing future cadets of naval universities, in fact future naval officers, remained unanswered.



It is reported that in a letter to the local authorities, the parent committee asked not only to clarify the situation after the change of the head of the cadet school. NVSarshinova, but also to answer the question of why the school from the Cadet was actually turned into a regular general education, eliminating drill classes, making it impossible for children of several levels to wear a Cadet uniform.

From the letter of the parent committee of the cadet school. N.V. Starshinova of the city of Anapa to the Minister of Defense Sergey Shoigu and in the media (the style is preserved):

For a major contribution to the patriotic education of youth, the Anapa Maritime Border Lyceum was renamed the KADET SCHOOL NAMED AFTER HERO OF THE SOVIET UNION N.V. STARSHINOVA and enters the register of cadet corps of the Russian Federation.

During the 15 years in our city, many mayors, heads of education have changed a lot, and the good work started by him (director Alexander Bakanov - comment) developed and flourished, although 15 had been living in rented premises for years.

Bakanov A.V. built a school! It remains to equip the territory - to make a fence and concreted parade ground.

A year ago, Filofeeva N. was appointed to the post of the head of the city education department, which literally understands the authority given to her to sweep out uncomfortable employees with a sword and a hot iron. The rebellious Bakanov AV with his arsenal of merit in education.


The scandal around the cadet school of the city of Anapa went beyond the city


The following describes the situation with the money issue, which became a stumbling block between the leadership of the cadet school and local authorities:

At parents' meetings in May 2014, Bakanov A.V. personally appealed to the parents of each class of cadets with a request for help not only by physical forces and with a request to look for sponsors, since there is no money in the school account, but there must be no small amount - 7 million.

And here began filthy romp, started by Filofeyeva, harassment and a real war against Bakanov A.V. It is hard to believe that overnight the exemplary director has turned into a complete ownerless owner and slobs. On Bakanova A.V. as reprimands for construction deficiencies rained down from the horn of abundance, devastating articles were sent to him in the regional newspapers, local TV also did not stand aside. We got the impression that Filofeeva was ready Bakanova A.V. "Roll in the asphalt." From 4 July 2014 of the year N. Filofeeva removes Bakanova A.V. from the position and appoints the Acting Act as the “most experienced manager of the Anapa district”, Sivko P. As a result, A.V. Bakanova. right from work, the ambulance is taking a heart attack to intensive care.

In the middle of August, 2014, from an article in a district newspaper, we suddenly find out that 7 million rubles appeared on our school’s account from somewhere, which in May and June were not 2014, but the parent committee of our school was constantly interested in them - where they disappeared Apparently, in our opinion, this money because of the hype raised by our parents, our education department could not “skate” them.

And now Bakanov A.V. submitted to us as a complete ownerless man who has not mastered 7 million rubles. (...)

Unable to withstand such harassment (health first of all) Bakanov A.V. “Voluntarily-compulsory” submits an application.


At the end of the letter, the parents of the cadets call upon Minister Shoigu and other addressees to look into the situation, to prevent the emergence of new "Kushchevsky hoes" and to promote the restoration of the former director of the cadet school Alexander Bakanov.



The letter is acute and actually reveals the problems of not just an individual educational institution, but also of the entire system of autonomous municipal educational institutions, to which the Anapa Cadet School belongs. If we take into account the fact that an autonomous educational institution is not a budget and can attract extra-budgetary funds based on the charter of an autonomous institution, then the financial relations of such organizations with municipalities look very complicated. Of course, it is possible to understand parents and cadets who are concerned about changing an experienced and professional leader to a leadership, which, in their opinion, is far from the life of a cadet school. But here, apparently, a cause intervened in the matter, which has nothing to do with the education system. It's about utilitarian things that made students hostage in school - about raising and spending money. When the educational structure begins to think more often about where to get money for needs instead of thinking about the implementation of educational programs (and this situation in our country is becoming more and more common), then it’s too early for such an educational institution (budgetary, and even more so autonomous) or later there will be problems. In this case, as you can see, problems arose in the relationship with the municipality, which, of course, has the opposite point of view on the events that occurred with the Anapa cadet corps.

And, there is an opinion that such problems will arise more and more often and not only with educational institutions claiming to be connected with the system of training future military. The cause of such problems is an attempt to cross a bulldog with a rhinoceros, namely, to combine the responsibility of the management of educational institutions inherent in the Soviet education system with the issues of “innovative” transfer of schools and other educational institutions to market self-sustainment. In such a situation, the leaders (and Aleksandr Bakanov, among others) find themselves between two fires a priori: they are required to establish the training process at the proper level, and to obtain extra-budgetary funds on their own.

Moreover, if the funds are obtained, the municipality can automatically declare that it is primarily his merit and pressure, forcing to dispose of funds at his (municipality) discretion. If the funds are not obtained, this puts the school or its current leadership on the brink of survival, since the same municipality will be extremely dissatisfied with the economic activities of the school administration.

In general, the essence of this seemingly narrow issue is actually much wider than the competence of any one department. It is unlikely that even such a powerful ministry as the Ministry of Defense is able to answer all questions of the parent committee of the Anapa Cadet School. The issue of multilateral relations of the leadership of such schools, students, representatives of parental committees and local authorities is a matter for broad discussion involving the Ministry of Education and Science and the Ministry of Justice, and a number of other agencies that determine the legal and educational standards of educational institutions in the Russian Federation. As always, it remains to be hoped that the truly valuable pedagogical staff will not be merged in favor of "effective managers" who revolve in small-town bureaucratic spheres.
Author:
50 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. severniy
    severniy 9 September 2014 09: 51
    0
    Not really, but thanks anyway ...
    1. shtanko.49
      shtanko.49 9 September 2014 11: 29
      +1
      And HUMANLY have not tried to solve the problem? Why complicate things and make the issue insoluble? But how did this school work until the appointment of a new head of district education, is it not there that the dog is buried.
      1. Alevtina K.
        Alevtina K. 10 September 2014 17: 05
        +2
        Humanly and decide.
        Namely, we turn to people.
        Appeals to the Anapa officials-dealers did not lead to anything, so I had to turn for support to people who are not indifferent to children and respecting Russian citizens.
        And local officials consider us parents to be cattle and hope that they will get away with it.
        1. Theophanes
          Theophanes 10 September 2014 21: 28
          +1
          That's right, in min formations of all levels, one hoe is sitting! Their main occupation is to snatch, and what’s wrong with the teachers and students. Nits shorter than Furtsevsky's pro furts everything and Russia will be illiterate.
    2. Zhekson
      Zhekson 9 September 2014 13: 59
      +15
      My son is studying in Tuapse. In TMKK. Since this year there have generally been tightened the screws. The teachers recruited career officers (there used to be social educators), discipline as in training. Expand the territory of the school, due to a nearby institute. The school principal is a captain of the second rank, a submariner. boys go to school all week. There they live in cockpits. Permanent items - the history of the armed forces, combat and naval training. There are a bunch of all kinds of sections. Four kinds of shape. Take the oath of the cadet. In their youth, they fight for the right to wear a vest, then guis and cockade. After the oath, they have the right to wear epaulets and ribbons on a peak. They want to go fishing on their own boats. Every day drill. Feed 5 times a day.
      In short, small soldiers. And in high school - real men! Inflated, healthy with the right attitude to life, with respect for adults and a strong lifestyle. Yes, and education is on top. In 2012, TMKK won first place in Russia. Everything is free.
      recommend. Of course there is BUT! Only for residents of the Krasnodar Territory. Maybe when they expand, they will acquire Russian significance.
      1. severniy
        severniy 9 September 2014 14: 26
        0
        I envy you for good ... if it is possible in hp coordinates more precisely ... Ours will fall apart, you look at you will come out ...
        1. St Petrov
          St Petrov 9 September 2014 18: 48
          +2
          In Monino (Moscow region, not far from Zheleznodorozhny) there is a good school with initial flight training. (summer practice in the territory where students of the Zhukovsky Academy were doing practice (now xs how, when I was there, it was like that)

          They teach the guys to fly on the Yak-52 and on the Mi-2 (pilots) and techies jump with parachutes (who are lucky) 3 times - about 36 hours of flight time for pilots in helicopters or airplanes. (Grades 10 and 11)

          Everything is free - killer food. Barracks position. Weekend at home (if I didn’t mess up and grab the deuces) - the outfits are all right. The elders are officers.

          School with a mathematical bias. In addition to standard disciplines:

          In the classes they study Morse code, parachuting, piston engine devices (in the class there is a model of the Yak and the engine is separate). In general, everything is on the level

          Of course there is a parade ground, where there was more than one mazol

          Better for a kid 16 years old there is no topic!) While I was studying - we had guys even from Khabarovsk - they only left the barracks once a year :)

          They say there are discounts on admission to the Krasnodar school after that. Not offiual like, but they look kindly
        2. The comment was deleted.
      2. I am a Russian
        I am a Russian 10 September 2014 09: 12
        0
        Quote: Zhekson
        My son is studying in Tuapse.


        Tell me more.
        1. Zhekson
          Zhekson 10 September 2014 18: 24
          0
          Boys are accepted (although several girls have seen) after graduating from the 4th grade of elementary school. Must have excellent health and a high average score. It is necessary to collect documents for admission. There is a site, there it is written that. Then you come for an interview with your child. The teaching staff talks with both the parents and the child. They can ask any questions.
          then they suddenly pick up the children. the psychologist speaks separately with each and the group. And then two exams at once - Russian dictation and mathematics examples. After some time, they immediately read out who passed the tests and exams.
          The selection is very tough of the 18 people in our stream received only three.
          You can do it after any year of study. If there are places.
          Students have a teacher and a class teacher. They wear a military uniform, apparently custom-made. Its chevrons and shoulder straps. Dressy white, dressy blue, dressy blue winter, work uniform, winter pea jacket, white and blue visor, marine cap.
          Army structure - regiment, company, platoon, detachment. The squad and platoon commanders are apprentices, the rest are officers. dismissal as in the army on the proposal of the company. On Saturday, they are fired from 13 to 18 Sunday. My son goes home. Vacations are also at home. The elders already have other interests - military camps, training camps.
          Tuapse Maritime Cadet Corps - Chancellery (selection committee) +7 8616 73 21 70 (75)
          1. I am a Russian
            I am a Russian 19 September 2014 22: 06
            0
            Quote: Zhekson
            The selection is very tough of the 18 people in our stream received only three.

            Quote: Zhekson
            Must be in excellent health


            I talked with a pediatric therapist ... says the bar has been raised. Where can I read more about the requirements? What could be the cause of unsuitable health?
  2. Cananecat
    Cananecat 9 September 2014 10: 00
    +8
    There is also the FSB frontier institute of maritime security, when he was his "training" for the training of junior maritime specialists ... a large territory, but could not shelter midshipmen? Regrettable ...
    1. jjj
      jjj 9 September 2014 10: 38
      +1
      There was a case, I studied there in the 112 shift, when the Committee was still under the Council of Ministers
    2. tundra
      tundra 9 September 2014 11: 36
      +1
      So before the cadet was in the territory of the school (local name) now it seems to have been transferred to another place. But in vain, disciplined being near the sailors. The son graduated from the cadet in the second issue.
      1. severniy
        severniy 9 September 2014 11: 41
        +1
        Quote: tundra
        So before the cadet was in the territory of the school (local name) now it seems to have been transferred to another place. But in vain, disciplined being near the sailors. The son graduated from the cadet in the second issue.


        Moreover, there is an opinion that removing the cadets from the CITY of MILITARY GLORY (the title which Anap recently received with respect) is a big mistake ....
  3. Mareman Vasilich
    Mareman Vasilich 9 September 2014 10: 14
    +10
    Nothing will change. In order to change, we need strong power, and so, the raven will not peck out the crow's eye. And reliable frames are lost.
  4. Belopolyak
    Belopolyak 9 September 2014 10: 16
    +4
    Unfortunately, this is the case everywhere. By kickbacks, a significant part of state funds is stolen by a couple, and it comes to complete arbitrariness. Whoever worked with state procurements is at least a little aware of all this mess, and sometimes seeing someone's state order and want to strangle the one who posted it. this "order" looks more like "calling girls of easy virtue both directly to work and at home."
    Those who oppose this always fall into such situations just a demon of noise.
  5. Dormidosha
    Dormidosha 9 September 2014 10: 17
    +2
    For this you must definitely fight! This is our future - naval officers! And I hope that the leadership of the country and in particular the Minister of Defense will carefully consider not only this case, but the problem as a whole! The sad thing is that these problems are solved only with the involvement of top officials of the state! No patriots in the field or what ?!
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 10: 39
      0
      Quote: Dormidosha
      For this you must definitely fight! This is our future - naval officers! And I hope that the leadership of the country and in particular the Minister of Defense will carefully consider not only this case, but the problem as a whole! The sad thing is that these problems are solved only with the involvement of top officials of the state! No patriots in the field or what ?!


      There are no people willing to "drive the wave", and now Sevastopol, Novorossiysk are close by, and here it is ....
    2. Alevtina K.
      Alevtina K. 10 September 2014 18: 03
      +1
      There are patriots, but the administrative resource is strong.
      This is the Krasnodar Territory, and nepotism here is the norm.
  6. super-vitek
    super-vitek 9 September 2014 10: 26
    +2
    What kind of chaos !!! So always in our country, as soon as there is a person in his place, who is glad for the cause, all sorts of people are ready to trample, slander !!! Do you really have anyone to intercede to figure it out ?!
  7. bubla5
    bubla5 9 September 2014 10: 28
    -17
    Thanks to Putin!
    1. Belopolyak
      Belopolyak 9 September 2014 10: 38
      +12
      Quote: bubla5
      Thanks to Putin!

      Yeah, how convenient it is to blame one person for everything. It is difficult to admit that this GG, like Filofeeva, is leaving the people and it is guilty that everything is stolen.
      1. dmb
        dmb 9 September 2014 15: 18
        +3
        Putin’s fault is not that Filofeeva deprived the director of the opportunity to honestly do her job. but the fact that the capitalist system created with his participation was necessary for him and Filofeeva, and not for Bakanov and his students. He is not going to change this system, for he personally suits him and his environment. To the gullible fellow citizens who believe that this is not so, I propose. give at least words, not to mention deeds, testifying to the contrary.
        1. PSih2097
          PSih2097 9 September 2014 19: 14
          +1
          Quote: dmb
          Putin’s fault is not that Filofeeva deprived the director of the opportunity to honestly do her job. but the fact that the capitalist system created with his participation was necessary for him and Filofeeva, and not for Bakanov and his students. He is not going to change this system, for he personally suits him and his environment. To the gullible fellow citizens who believe that this is not so, I propose. give at least words, not to mention deeds, testifying to the contrary.

          I fully support if he didn’t say that a rigid vertical of power was built, but in reality it was a show, how the local authorities did what they wanted, they are doing it ... That’s the same vertical.
  8. Archikah
    Archikah 9 September 2014 10: 37
    +8
    Where the name of Governor Tkachev flickers, there are always some kind of dark stories. Not so long ago, he stood in line with the Kushchevsky bandits and shook their hands. Now he is distancing himself from that relationship. But they were and this affects his image. In the south of Russia, not everything is safe. And Putin alone cannot manually control the entire country. This is not real. fool
  9. sso-xnumx
    sso-xnumx 9 September 2014 10: 39
    +3
    Reassign the cadet corps of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation. Select competent teachers and educators from among the officers and train cadets at the rate of department commanders. They will finish the corps themselves and decide where to go next, but we will have more or less trained sergeants.
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 10: 44
      +1
      Quote: sso-250659
      Reassign the cadet corps of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation. Select competent teachers and educators from among the officers and train cadets at the rate of department commanders. They will finish the corps themselves and decide where to go next, but we will have more or less trained sergeants.


      It was almost like that, and over the past week two naval officers who worked there ... quit Captri and Capras ...
  10. starshina wmf
    starshina wmf 9 September 2014 10: 43
    +10
    This Krasnodar Territory is a hotbed of corruption and gangster lawlessness. Maybe it’s time for the governor to plant him together with all the officials.
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 10: 49
      +1
      Х
      Quote: Starshina wmf
      This Krasnodar Territory is a hotbed of corruption and gangster lawlessness. Maybe it’s time for the governor to plant him together with all the officials.


      Well, if you know half ... Very much neither on TV nor in the press was ... Olympics, the image you know sad
    2. tundra
      tundra 9 September 2014 11: 49
      +8
      Oh ho, how right you are. Anapa is a town, though not federal, well-known enough. It's all about cronyism, matchmaking, brother, godfather. There is no question of the business qualities of the appointed officials, but damn drunks are drunken thieves. After each mayor’s appointment, a middle section from the vineyard is cut down and trading in plots begins, with huge banners visible throughout the entire district. Well, all the plots are legally preliminarily withdrawn from agricultural circulation. Just the mayor must bring up. Well, he simply hates Tkachev in his native village, small farmers and former collective farmers. They work for him as slavery for stew, he cleaned all the lands in the district for himself and his relatives.
  11. Evkur
    Evkur 9 September 2014 10: 54
    0
    all the delights of the capitalist management model!
  12. Baron Wrangell
    Baron Wrangell 9 September 2014 11: 15
    +1
    And I would like the comment of an eyewitness who knows about this situation not by hearsay.
    And so indiscriminately to blame everyone! Ugly.
    A article on the topic, because affects directly, parenting.
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 11: 35
      +4
      Quote: Baron Wrangell
      And I would like the comment of an eyewitness who knows about this situation not by hearsay.
      And so indiscriminately to blame everyone! Ugly.
      A article on the topic, because affects directly, parenting.


      I’m an eyewitness, moreover, the article appeared on my request .. III eee, karoch corners the author pretty much curved rounds ...
      1. Baron Wrangell
        Baron Wrangell 9 September 2014 12: 57
        0
        Quote: severniy
        I’m an eyewitness, moreover, the article appeared on my request .. III eee, karoch corners the author pretty much curved rounds ...

        Duck, let’s describe the problem more fully !, otherwise it’s not clear from the article
        1. severniy
          severniy 9 September 2014 13: 05
          0
          Quote: Baron Wrangell
          Quote: severniy
          I’m an eyewitness, moreover, the article appeared on my request .. III eee, karoch corners the author pretty much curved rounds ...

          Duck, let’s describe the problem more fully !, otherwise it’s not clear from the article


          L.S. With uv.
    2. tundra
      tundra 9 September 2014 11: 54
      +1
      Now he called his wife, she doesn’t know anything yet, by the evening she’ll find out, I’ll write it off. Well, most likely it is, you just have to live here, everything is possible in Anapa laughing He who does not bring up does not sit in his place for a long time.
    3. Alevtina K.
      Alevtina K. 10 September 2014 17: 11
      +1
      Yes, in fact - just everything.
      Director Bakanov created a prestigious educational institution in our city, pulled out the repair / restoration of the building for the cadet school, and now it can be drained.
      And to bring ready-made "obedient" manual director.
      Nothing personal - just anapa business.
  13. Kengo
    Kengo 9 September 2014 11: 54
    +1
    The question is: What should be done to help N.V. Starshinov's cadet school named after the Hero of the Soviet Union?
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 12: 04
      +1
      My personal opinion is: to restore the director, try to return the teachers who left the officers (laughter, in a purely male institution physical training is conducted by a woman), return the drill uniform, uniform for all students (if you could only see the boys in their uniforms!) .... And finally Bakanov back to he’ll return the rails, he’d have to remove the sticks from the wheels ... By the way, the cadet corps is still in the state. the registry ...
      1. Kengo
        Kengo 9 September 2014 12: 12
        +3
        What can we do at the moment? An account opened with a lawyer director?
        Can we sign a petition for the restoration of the director? Maybe someone next to the readers of "Military Review" will come to the rally? We will write letters to various deputies, PR to them, but we benefit.
        Actions are necessary that the layman can do.
        1. severniy
          severniy 9 September 2014 12: 27
          0
          Malakhov has a letter published on the site "Let Them Talk", they seem to be preparing for the deputies, but you still need a stupid instruction - leave the establishment, but who can give this instruction is not yet clear ...
          Everyone thought that the matter was in the director, or position, but after his departure the collapse continues ...
          1. Kengo
            Kengo 9 September 2014 12: 31
            0
            Well, since they’re cooking, let them put the text here, send them with the whole crowd, you see, they won’t wave it off.
      2. severniy
        severniy 9 September 2014 12: 16
        +1
        September 1 (without founding director) ..
      3. severniy
        severniy 9 September 2014 12: 20
        +1
        For fourteen years he was a fine fellow, and for the fifteenth - once and for all, an ownerless ...
      4. severniy
        severniy 9 September 2014 21: 20
        0
        Quote: severniy
        My personal opinion: to restore the director, try to return the teachers who left the officers (laughter, in a purely male institution physical training is conducted by a woman)

        senior classes need to be loaded with iron and crosses, and if not a strong word, then they certainly need a strong hand, how a woman can work physically with a crowd of adult guys ...
  14. MAXUZZZ
    MAXUZZZ 9 September 2014 11: 57
    +2
    And why not equalize the status with Suvorov schools? The military leadership seems to me more appropriate in such educational institutions, and even with the abolition of uniforms, drill and special training, the basic military-oriented sense of the cadet school itself disappears
    1. severniy
      severniy 9 September 2014 12: 11
      0
      Quote: MAXUZZZ
      And why not equalize the status with Suvorov schools? The military leadership seems to me more appropriate in such educational institutions, and even with the abolition of uniforms, drill and special training, the basic military-oriented sense of the cadet school itself disappears


      That's what it is, but there is a good building there, the current after thorough repairs (draw conclusions) ... and the children, yes, maybe they will learn in simple schools
      1. Zabvo
        Zabvo 9 September 2014 21: 22
        0
        I welcome you, so haven't you finished the construction now (from Ivan Golubets St. 40 years of Victory towards the sea)? If not very sorry.
  15. parafoiler
    parafoiler 9 September 2014 12: 21
    +1
    As long as this happens on the ground, Russia will remain at the margins of democracy. In the correct sense of this household word.
  16. special
    special 9 September 2014 15: 52
    +1
    Looks like the administration of hail has spread to an extra-budget .. And they were sent to the garden ...
    1. Alevtina K.
      Alevtina K. 10 September 2014 17: 29
      +1
      You are a shrewd person.
  17. s30461
    s30461 9 September 2014 22: 40
    +2
    Can you be more specific? How can I help you???
  18. grisha777
    grisha777 5 February 2015 13: 48
    0
    This is the best director, the Cadet School is not the same without its FOUNDER! Yes, maybe he was strict, but every cadet respected his decision and himself, as a person. I do not believe that this person could steal money, he put his soul into this institution. Regards, Grape Grigory, graduate of the 2013-2014 academic year!