Military Review

The most scandalous film about the war

7
In Russia, most citizens with great reverence belong to the art associated with the military history. People enjoy watching the military movie on tv. Recognized masterpieces: "Seventeen Moments of Spring", "State Border", "They Fought for the Motherland", "And the Dawns Here are Quiet" and many other Soviet film legends.


Recently, films with claims to cover military history began to appear, with obvious hints of attempts to rewrite people's attitudes toward the Great Patriotic War. One of these films, which can be attributed to the category of kinozhi, can be called the film "Swine". This is a story by Vladimir Atanesyan by Vladimir Feinberg (Kunin). The film was released in 2006 year, and immediately received the most negative reviews from veterans and historians. It was stated that the film contains a real lie, which is aimed at denigrating the struggle of the Soviet people against fascism. After making claims not only to the director, but also to the author of the story, the latter (Vladimir Kunin) stated that the events that he once described are fictional and have nothing to do with the real history of the war. In addition, Kunin noted that in addition the filmmakers had distorted his very word, adding to the film what was not indicated in the work.

The scandal, as is known, led to the fact that Vladimir Menshov refused to hand over the award to the film “Bastards”. It was in 2007, at the MTV award ceremony. Then Menshov defiantly announced that he was going to hand over the award, since the film “Shames My Country”. It was a bold act of a famous director and an honest person, and it is this act that shows how to relate to the facts of the distortion of history, which today, unfortunately, are not uncommon.

The events that were described in the movie “Bastards” and the stories of Kunin attracted the attention of even the FSB. This is a special case in recent history, when an investigation of the special services is arranged on a film. In the end, the FSB presented materials according to which there was no school for training child saboteurs in the place described by Kunin (and indeed in general). This suggests that the script of the film was a priori provocative in nature in order to attract the attention of the liberal audience, which turned out in the end.
7 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. sergey72
    sergey72 1 July 2013 11: 33
    +1
    Morning has begun on the collective farm! Citizens, today is Monday, the day is already hard, and you remember all the filth! Menshov, respect, Panin and Krasko frankly feel sorry for Bo deceased either well, or nothing. But the wolf cub Golovin and K. were remembered at the awarding ceremony. To my great regret, this is not the last tub of dirt on our history ... Go to the site "Militarists" there in the section "Kino" will find reviews with photos for similar products. I understand those who vomit and sympathize with those who are not.
  2. The comment was deleted.
  3. vladimirZ
    vladimirZ 1 July 2013 17: 03
    0
    Unfortunately, the liberoid intelligentsia is in the forefront of the detractors and traitors to the Motherland. No wonder Lenin, in his hearts, called the intelligentsia "shit of the nation" or something like that. Not everything, of course, but liberal for sure.
  4. Hleb
    Hleb 1 July 2013 17: 16
    0
    and who watched the film "POP" V. Khotinenko? have an opinion about it?
    1. lilit.193
      lilit.193 2 July 2013 11: 02
      +2
      Quote: Gleb
      and who watched the film "POP" by V. Khotinenko?

      Honestly, I haven't watched this film. But before I saw a film by the same director called "Muslim".
      So I think the film is not intended.
      1. Hleb
        Hleb 2 July 2013 23: 06
        0
        exactly. ambiguous emotions remained
  5. Alf
    Alf 1 July 2013 20: 54
    0
    Quote: vladimirZ
    Unfortunately, the liberoid intelligentsia is in the forefront of the detractors and traitors to the Motherland. No wonder Lenin, in his hearts, called the intelligentsia "shit of the nation" or something like that. Not everything, of course, but liberal for sure.

    The intelligentsia is not a class, but a layer living in Russia, not being, de facto, part of Russia and occupying the position of spitting on the whole of Russia and praising and exalting the West.
  6. Mikhail
    Mikhail 3 July 2013 00: 25
    0
    Quote: Alf
    Quote: vladimirZ
    Unfortunately, the liberoid intelligentsia is in the forefront of the detractors and traitors to the Motherland. No wonder Lenin, in his hearts, called the intelligentsia "shit of the nation" or something like that. Not everything, of course, but liberal for sure.

    The intelligentsia is not a class, but a layer living in Russia, not being, de facto, part of Russia and occupying the position of spitting on the whole of Russia and praising and exalting the West.


    What you mean by the intelligentsia, in fact, is not such - it is just the self-designation of people who are not always brilliant in their minds, negatively disposed towards Russia and everything Russian. For them, a diploma of higher education and dislike for "this country" are a pass to a "cultural" society. They are material that plays a far from last role in various public shocks. From them cadres of the fifth column are recruited.
    Genuine intellectuals are people like, for example, Lomonosov and Mendelѣev. Their scholarship was combined with the love of Russia.
  7. tomket
    tomket 3 July 2013 23: 13
    0
    went to the war of the worlds z, saw a trailer for Bondarchuk's upcoming "masterpiece" - "Stalingrad" with a soundtrack in English, in short, I advise you to save your nerves until autumn, so that you can throw out the boiling water))))
  8. Doctor71
    Doctor71 14 October 2013 00: 46
    0
    Good day. I have not seen the film itself, I know about it from advertising. But it's not that. This "creation" of art is nothing more than a remake of our own film. Just the opposite. About 10 years ago, a film was shown on TV (unfortunately I do not remember the name) about children-saboteurs. They were prepared by the GERMANS !!! Of the children of political convicts. Although the NKVD also committed atrocities in it. In short, everyone died ...