A retired general of the Armed Forces of Ukraine named the reason why Ukraine does not declare war on Russia

Ukraine will not declare war on Russia because it is not profitable for it. As ex-deputy chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine Igor Romanenko explained, Kyiv is afraid of losing Western help.

Answering a question about a possible declaration of war on Russia, the Ukrainian retired general explained that Ukraine would not do this under any circumstances, since it would immediately lose help from the West, which is actively avoiding a direct clash with Russia. And transferring military aid to Ukraine, which has declared war, means taking its side. Therefore, Romanenko urged not to grasp at definitions.

We have a large-scale war, legally this is enough for us. (...) If we went to a state of war, then assistance for weapons and equipment would cease not only from the United States, but also from most of the allies. They have this written in the law

- said the general, adding that even in the current situation there are “closed points” in assistance from the United States.

Today, Ukraine receives virtually no military assistance from the Americans, who have switched to Israel. The “right” to support the Kyiv junta has been transferred to Europe, but it cannot do it alone. And the internal problems of the European Union do not make it possible to compensate for most of the US assistance. If war is declared, Kyiv will lose even the little assistance it receives. Naturally, Zelensky and his clique do not want this option.

By the way, all actions of the TCC with total mobilization contradict the constitution of Ukraine, because they can only be carried out after the country officially enters the war. However, in Kyiv they didn’t care about it.

Comments

[Viktor Sergeev]

This is written in the 1907 Convention. I don’t understand why we don’t announce?

[Essex62]

Because illegal fragments do not fall under any Conventions. This war is civil.

[Grag Best]

What will change from such a declaration of war? Will this cause us to have a million soldiers at the front with equipment?

[private person]

What will change from such a declaration of war?

Have you served in the army? There is such an entry in the V/B for those who “excused themselves” or for health reasons: Not fit for peacetime, fit for war. Transferring the economy to a war footing and much more

[Victor Alien]

That's it. And many actions at the front would have been carried out in other ways. Although the territory of Ukraine and Belarus will always have a special status. This is not the Baltic states, the Caucasus and Central Asia. Where they didn’t wait there and it was easier to get through, but now everything is long and tedious. Even those who are local to Rabotino don’t understand why they’ve been standing there for over a year now. And then they say that they did the right thing, that the army did not remain near Kiev and beyond the Dnieper. There was something about 1940 when they were planning an attack - six months before victory or they would lose. Now the entire West and the USA are losing - the rear is not ready for long battles. Il 2 produced 4 aircraft in 30.000 years. Now the number of releases is less. It was possible to take the whole of Ukraine with impudence - much like Afghanistan - the partisans would bring more problems. Although they will still have hemorrhoids.

[kit88]

Quote: Grag Best

What will change from such a declaration of war? Will this cause us to have a million soldiers at the front with equipment?

For those at the front, nothing will change.
But for those who are on the sofas.....
Every governor, and even just a boss, will take out of the safe a thick, dusty folder with the title “Action Plan...”.
Locked borders. No naked parties. All bloggers and other parasites to work, or under martial law...
Instead of the Internet and TV, a metronome on a wired radio, by the way, phones are only TA-57 type, the rest is in the trash.
In stores - only domestic products, no Chinese nails, teapots or cars...
Mobilization to the front. Those who are not subject to mobilization must forge victory in the rear.

Otherwise we are used to the fact that war is on screens and does not concern us in any way.

[vkfriendly]

"

Instead of the Internet and TV, a metronome on a wired radio, by the way, phones are only TA-57 type, the rest is in the trash.

“- this is actually called communication in one word. And who would think of cutting off this very communication in wartime, while the economy will collapse by tens of percent. Now almost the entire production sector is tied to the Internet and it would be impossible without them. So leave your fairy tales to five-year-olds because that at seven years old children already understand a lot

[kit88]

Quote: vkfriendly

And who would think of cutting off this very communication in wartime, while the economy would collapse by tens of percent.

Enemy.
“Now almost all” Russian people are using American software. In the morning you look at notifications, updates are downloaded, a reboot is required to complete... And I didn’t even know that the computer was downloading something. And what prevents them from downloading and executing the disk formatting command, and then applying excessive voltage to the processor? Or some other bullshit. The smart programmers at Microsoft will do it right away. Both Android and Apple. 100 million computers and 200 million mobile devices will simply burn out in one day. And how to restore them? During the war.
Banks and defense enterprises, of course, provided for this scenario, but ordinary people are absolutely not protected.

[vkfriendly]

Yes, it will be stressful for Microsoft to search among billions of addresses for Russian ones and carry out an attack. Moreover, for a simple user this is from the realm of fantasy. Production and Russian companies with state participation have long switched to their own software and already have about a dozen operating systems.
"Alt Education", "Alt Virtualization Server"
"Phantom"
Elbrus
Astra Linux Special Edition
"ROSA Barium"
"AlterOS Desktop Education", AlterOS Desktop MO.2Х
"Aramid"
"Synergy"
Kraftway Terminal Linux
"SintezM"
KasperskyOS
"Aurora"
And besides everything else, there is the Internet and there is RuNet. In the event of hostilities with the West, they will simply pull the so-called “switch” and all that remains is RuNet.
And who else is stopping you from disabling all updates? This can be done in a couple of mouse clicks under the admin.

[kit88]

Why are you telling me everything about state companies? Tell me about an ordinary person.

[kaa]

How long have you been to the store? Did you pay with a card, sticker, smartphone or through your favorite TA-57?

[kit88]

What planet did you fall from? Have we started a war?

[kaa]

You seem to be an alien yourself. Today, without a network, you can’t get a salary or pay taxes, but he’s dreaming about the TA-57..

[kit88]

Are you really stupid?
They tell you there is a war going on now? Or peacetime?

[kaa]

OU. That is, are you really sure that in non-peaceful times the connection will be set back a hundred years?

[Thumbs]

What will change from such a declaration of war?

the article directly states that the country speaking on one side
conflict, transferring military aid, become a participant in the war.

[Thumbs]

What will change from such a declaration of war?

For “our” (conditionally) oligarchic kaganate, to whom is war, and to whom mother is dear.

[Igor Viktorovich]

Have you forgotten that conscripts are in barracks?

[Frank Muller]

An officially declared war is a serious matter. Then the Russian oligarchs will not get off with the current sanctions, but they may even take off their last pants. More precisely, they will take it off themselves without any demand.

[Zamira]

Quote: Frank Muller

An officially declared war is a serious matter. Then the Russian oligarchs will not get off with the current sanctions, but they may even take off their last pants. More precisely, they will take it off themselves without any demand.

Oh yeah, it's very possible... And it would be very correct, however...)
I see you have received some cons.) And who could it be? Are the oligarchs really looking into VO?

[Aken]

This is written in the 1907 Convention. I don’t understand why we don’t announce?

To do this, you need to be a complete and hopeless idiot.
Tricky question.
What is the last country to declare war?:

[solar]

There is nothing like that in the 1907 convention. Moreover, there is nothing in any international agreement about declaring war.

[bandabas]

And you ask the lady. It has been virtually “at war” online for a long time.

[Mikhail Ivanov]

What is there to understand? We (Gazprom) sell gas not only to the EU, but also to the Ukrainians, who are our opponents. We (Lukoil) sell petroleum products from Novorossiysk to Romania, where they are resold to Ukrainians. The list goes on...

[Vend]

Quote: Victor Sergeev

This is written in the 1907 Convention. I don’t understand why we don’t announce?

Well, now we are fighting for our territories.

[dnestr74]

The world has gone crazy, countries are killing each other in every possible way, but they are not fighting... Business will suffer...

[Frank Muller]

Leap year, what do you want! Yes, and the Sun was raging, we live during the maximum of its activity: spots - flares, spots - flares, and behind them magnetic storms. And this is already serious and this is science, not belief.

[dmi.pris1]

What kind of consecutive leap year is this already?

[Frank Muller]

The first one during the Northern Military District. Didn't you know this?

[dmi.pris1]

And it seems to me that during the SVO-third. And if you count from 2014, then.... Since May 2, 2014..

[Aleksandr_85]

For Russia, every year is a leap year.

[1erWahrheitsMinister_1984]

Ich erschiesse Dich, aber ich ziehe Dir (noch) nicht die Schuhe aus, weil wir sind ja noch nicht im Krieg...!!?
Die teilweise idiotischen bis schon fast lächerlichen "Regeln" des Krieges muten oft sehr seltsam an...!!!

[expert]

Genau richtig! Einverstanden

[Fatalist]

By the way, I read it recently. It turns out that until now, citizens of a country of Jewish nationality and employees of the Greco-Roman Catholic Church were absolutely inviolable for tzkashniks. And, suddenly, they began to be dragged to the front.)

[Scientist_]

Quote: Essex62

Because illegal fragments do not fall under any Conventions. This war is civil.

Has the Russian Federation officially annulled the Belovezhskaya Conspiracy?

[Pavel_Sveshnikov]

It turns out that all of Europe is violating its own laws. After all, it’s a no brainer that there is a war going on. Because it was not formally declared, large-scale hostilities are taking place. Not to consider them a war is obvious deceit.

[dmi.pris1]

Yes, all social relations, here and there, are sheer deceit, that is, a hypocrite. By the way. This article has already been on the site a couple of times.

[Arch]

Well, what did you want from the Europeans? Casuistry is the basis of their actions.
“Come on, holy father, christen these birds Trout and Macrelia” (c) P. Merimee

[solar]

There are no laws or agreements in the world regarding the declaration of war.

[Piramidon]

Have you studied the laws of all countries?

[solar]

International on this issue - yes, I have studied it.
I also studied Russian and Ukrainian ones.

[Piramidon]

Each country also has internal laws. These are referred to in terms of the order of declaration of war and the consequences of such an action.

[solar]

Try to find such laws if you can. I'm sure nothing will come of it.

[Electrical]

What happens is that since Ukraine does not declare war, all participants in the database are not combatants. Therefore, we, all their prisoners, can safely be used up. The Geneva Convention does not apply to them. There is nothing to feed these parasites.

[Al manah]

contradict the constitution of Ukraine,

which the hikhly wiped out, even when they were chasing Yanukovych, that hare...

[Andrei Nikolaevich]

And so - 300 years - “profitable”, “unprofitable”. Brotherly people, e-may....

[Novonur]

It is necessary to officially declare war on Ukraine with all the ensuing consequences, otherwise this SVO can only be done in different ways, which is beneficial to the fifth column within the country. We need to call a spade a spade and not dance around or around who knows what.

[Igor1915]

I would like to know why the Russian Federation does not announce

[opposite28]

We have a large-scale war, legally this is enough for us. (...) If we went to a state of war, then assistance for weapons and equipment would cease not only from the United States, but also from most of the allies. They have this written in their law, the general said, adding that even in the current situation there are “closed points” in assistance from the United States.

In the event of an official declaration of war, the Ukrainian national idea would lose its validity, so to speak, the “cherry on the cake” because of which the conflict in the Donbass region actually began. And the fascist elements of Ukrainian nationality were viewed from a slightly different mental and psychological perspective, not to mention the European “partners” in the “Ukrainian struggle.”

[opuonmed]

We have a large-scale war, legally this is enough for us. (...) If we went to a state of war, then assistance for weapons and equipment would cease not only from the United States, but also from most of the allies. They have this written in the law

Of course, they will automatically become participants in the conflict if they supply weapons. They can be bombed, just like the side in the conflict. It's not profitable for them.

[solar]

A retired general of the Armed Forces of Ukraine named the reason why Ukraine does not declare war on Russia

Someone invented this nonsense and it is circulating in the media.
In fact, there is no international agreement that addresses the declaration of war.
From a legal point of view, it makes no difference whether someone declared war or not.

[Two]

The interviews of Chinese Ambassador Liu Shaye, made during an interview with the French television channel La Chaine Info, caused a storm of indignation in Europe. His words that Crimea was originally part of Russia and was transferred to Ukraine during the Soviet Union caused resonance. And the Baltic countries were outraged by the statement of the Chinese diplomat that “the countries of the former USSR do not have actual status within the framework of international law, because there is no international treaty that would specify their status as sovereign states.” Now it is clear why war is not declared. In essence, the USSR was as it was and is, and all that is happening is the internal conflicts of the USSR legally.

[AC130 Gunship]

Neither side declared war on the other. Business continues. Russia pays Ukraine a billion dollars annually for gas transit to Europe. As one song says, “Father’s fat is on the table. It’s good for both her and me.”

[AC130 Gunship]

Quote from solar

A retired general of the Armed Forces of Ukraine named the reason why Ukraine does not declare war on Russia

Someone invented this nonsense and it is circulating in the media.
In fact, there is no international agreement that addresses the declaration of war.
From a legal point of view, it makes no difference whether someone declared war or not.

There is a difference. And very big. Businesses will have to be closed. And no one wants to do this

[pavel.typingmail.com]

Russia is now the legal successor of the USSR, while at the same time the border between Ukraine and Russia is not formalized. Hence the conclusion: the territory of Ukraine is Russian territory.

[Aviator]

Quote: kit88

Why are you telling me everything about state companies?

Yes, the same Alt Linux, even before any import substitution they offered their system for home use. It’s enough for leaving comments on this site :) In fact, there’s a lot more for that. Here the question is more about inertia of thinking, people sit on Windows and believe that this is the only way computers work.

[Azzzwer]

The absence of a wartime situation also did not prevent some from declaring mobilization. And nothing, no one is tormented by their conscience because they break the laws.

[Azzzwer]

Quote from pavel.tipingmail.com

Russia is now the legal successor of the USSR, while at the same time the border between Ukraine and Russia is not formalized. Hence the conclusion: the territory of Ukraine is Russian territory.

Why did you decide that the borders are not formalized?