Spring aggravation of the sense of duty. National debt

30
Spring aggravation of the sense of duty. National debt


They counted and didn’t shed tears


The collective West has not been surprised for a long time how the United States manages to live beyond its means, but now unfriendly countries seem to be much more concerned about why they cannot drive Russia into debt. It is no coincidence that the foreign press completely ignores information about our national debt that comes from us.



Moreover, a certain vow of silence extended to the so-called “unofficial” sources. Complete silence reigns, even if the information is presented by the main controllers of the country - from the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation.


But it was from the SP of the Russian Federation, which has recently clearly gone into the shadows without an approved chairman, with all due respect to the acting Galina Izotova, who recently recalled that the volume of Russia’s national debt at the end of 2023 increased by 2,7 trillion rubles and reached 25,6, 15 trillion rubles. This amounts to XNUMX% of GDP.

In comparison with the United States, where the entire country has to pay off its long-overwhelming national debt for more than a year, one might say, almost nothing. For Russia, which, according to European and American politicians and the press, “spends trillions on SVO,” which no one argues with, is a truly unique achievement.

And no manipulation of statistics, mind you. Commenting on the results of the analysis of the government debt of the Russian Federation, the office of auditor Alexei Savatyugin rightly noted that “one must be able to not only pay debts, but also delegate them.”

Who, to whom and how much?


The point, as you can understand, is that the right and obligation to “borrow” is increasingly transferred to regions, banks and companies, including those with state participation in capital. At the same time, no one is canceling the very trend of reducing, first of all, external debts.
It is not by chance that calculations by SP RF specialists from an analytical note on annual budget execution showed that the main increase in the debt burden on the Russian budget comes from internal debt. At the end of 2023, it grew by 10,8% (2,03 trillion rubles) and amounted to 20,8 trillion rubles.

At the same time, there is no need to talk about a significant reduction in the external debt burden, although Russia now owes $4,09 billion less in foreign currency. Currently, the external debt of the Russian Federation is $53,3 billion.

Nevertheless, the budget indicator of external debt still increased, and quite significantly. What this is connected with is not so difficult to explain - the devaluation of the ruble, which can already be called “another”, is to blame.

In our opinion, this is exactly the case, since the country’s financial system, like its citizens, adapted to the rise in the dollar and euro exchange rates from around 70 and 80 rubles to 90–100 without any shocks or, worse, panic.

So, in ruble equivalent, Russia’s external debt did not decrease, but increased by 743,9 billion rubles – to 4 billion rubles.

Not “parallel” export – someone else’s debt


From the point of view of manipulations with debts, from which it is necessary to rid the federal treasury whenever possible, operations with investments in the US national debt seem to us to be very indicative, although miniscule in volume. The volume of such investments fell most noticeably last fall.


In October, Russia more than halved its investment in American government bonds to $31 million. This was noted after an increase to $73 million was recorded in September due to purchases of securities by individuals and companies.
It seems that someone had insider information about the upcoming devaluation of the ruble, promptly investing in foreign exchange instruments. At the same time, the Central Bank of the Russian Federation stated with enviable regularity that the Bank of Russia does not have US government bonds. No one, not even the auditors of the RF SP, can prove the opposite due to the complete lack of open information.

At the moment, investments in long-term and short-term US government bonds remain approximately at the October level with a significant predominance of long-term ones.

Against the background of the amount of investments of $4,5 billion, which appeared in the data of the American Ministry of Finance at the beginning of 2022, it is quite possible to say that we can forget about Russian assistance in the Fed’s work with the American national debt. Seriously and for a long time.

Is it too early to rejoice?


It remains to be noted with some concern that companies, banks and regions, unlike the Ministry of Finance and the Central Bank, today cannot boast of a weakening of the debt burden. The Ministry of Finance managed to report an increase in the total public debt of Russian regions by the end of 2023 by 14%.

Not much, but given that GDP growth rates lag behind the debt indicator by more than three times, the trend is not encouraging. However, in total the regions owe significantly less than the country as a whole – 3,192 trillion rubles. But we should not forget that the regional budgets in total are also significantly, even very much smaller than the federal budget.

In this regard, the proposal of Russian President Vladimir Putin, made in his address to the Federal Assembly, to write off two-thirds of the regions’ debt on budget loans, except for infrastructure, cannot but inspire optimism.

Apparently, in parallel with this, the practice of mandatory placement of federal loan bonds will be minimized, which, in fact, due to rising rates, are becoming very attractive.

However, a flexible policy of floating rates, tied not to the rate of the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, but to real inflation indicators, can bring down any demand, even close to the rush. And again, despite the fact that big problems with debts, as well as with finances in general, are not visible even on the horizon, the idea of ​​new “Stalinist” bonds or a large war loan literally suggests itself.
30 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. -1
    April 10 2024 06: 19
    We need another bank. That part of the economy that belongs to the state needs its own bank. The Central Bank does not fulfill this mission. Then it was possible to introduce a non-cash form of payment. “There are lies, there are big lies, and then there are statistics.”
    1. -2
      April 10 2024 09: 44
      The Central Bank is not a state bank. He reports directly to the Fed. Our president only approves the chairman of the Central Bank, and does not appoint. And Mr. a bank with the required function - VTB. There is a law that stipulates the Central Bank.
      1. -1
        April 10 2024 21: 23
        He reports directly to the Fed.

        Well, why are you so scared that he submits directly? No need to lie.
        1. -2
          April 11 2024 11: 22
          Read the law on the Central Bank. If you have enough understanding, then analyze where money comes from in the Russian economy and who controls it. And put your complaints about lies in your wallet. The Central Bank of the Russian Federation is not subordinate to the state.
          1. -1
            April 11 2024 14: 17
            You better read it yourself, otherwise it looks like you haven’t read it. And I know the law perfectly. At one time, he graduated from the Faculty of Finance and Credit and worked for 20 years at the Central Bank and also at the State Bank of the USSR and + in a commercial bank. By the way, the Chairman of the Central Bank, according to the law, is approved by the State Duma. The annual report of the Central Bank is also submitted there. The State Duma has the right to check the Central Bank through the Accounts Chamber.
            1. 0
              April 12 2024 14: 41
              Since you are an expert, please explain why the number of rubles is equal to the number of gold and foreign currency reserves? On what basis? After all, rubles are the internal currency, and gold and foreign currency reserves are used for external payments? We do not produce anything internally and are completely dependent on the Western financial system?
              1. -2
                April 12 2024 15: 15
                We do not produce anything internally and are completely dependent on the Western financial system?

                Well ! Are we really not producing anything? How are we fighting with NATO? We don’t go hungry and even export food.
                What kind of complete dependence do we have on the Western financial system? Maybe you can explain.
                1. -1
                  April 12 2024 15: 30
                  It’s clear what kind of specialist you are; you still haven’t answered the question. But it’s simple and the conclusion is also simple.
                  1. 0
                    April 12 2024 15: 37
                    Yes, he really didn’t answer about rubles and gold and foreign currency reserves. And the answer is simple: rubles and gold reserves in practice are not equated to each other. They are equated only by incompetent journalists and economists who do not have a proper understanding of monetary circulation and have forgotten the political economy of Karl Marx. And gold and currency reserves serve mainly only to balance international payments, to avoid sharp fluctuations in the ruble exchange rate on the stock exchange.
                    1. -1
                      April 12 2024 15: 49
                      So why are there not enough rubles in the economy if they are not tied to gold and foreign currency reserves? If they are not tied, then why is the dollar exchange rate growing all the time?
                      1. -2
                        April 12 2024 16: 01
                        Where did you get the idea that there are not enough rubles in the economy? Lazy people, unprofitable enterprises that no one wants to lend to have enough. The rest of the normal profitable enterprises are credited and there is a struggle between the banks for them. Why is the dollar rising? Because the demand for dollars on the stock exchange is not satisfied by the amount of incoming revenue. Everything according to Marx, price depends on supply and demand.
                      2. -1
                        April 12 2024 16: 06
                        Strange. If the state wants to boost the economy, it lends at a low interest rate, otherwise it simply won’t grow. So, if, in your opinion, the Central Bank is subordinate to the state, then why such a high rate? If there is no circulation of dollars within the country and they work only outside, then why, having earned dollars, convert them into rubles, and then back? To bring profit to whom? Which enterprises are profitable: raw materials extraction or consumer goods production? I mean private, not public.
                      3. -1
                        April 16 2024 13: 06
                        Quote: AKuzenka
                        Strange.

                        No one at VO will raise your zero economic level. Learn the materiel yourself. hi
                      4. -1
                        April 16 2024 13: 10
                        Increase your zero economic level
                        Of course it won't. That’s why I ask “stupid” “questions” to a recognized “expert”.
                      5. -1
                        April 16 2024 13: 03
                        Quote: Alexey Lantukh
                        Why is the dollar rising? Because the demand for dollars on the stock exchange is not satisfied by the amount of incoming revenue. Everything according to Marx, price depends on supply and demand.

                        laughing fool A fictional rule: the money supply must be equal to the commodity supply. As it is regulated, the excess money supply causes the price of the commodity to rise. Currency is the same commodity as oil. Therefore, everything that the mass of goods cannot cover is covered by rising currency prices. For example, let's take Ukraine, even if the commodity mass of GDP covers only 10% of budget expenses, the rest will be covered by foreign currency, and the more of it, the cheaper it will be in hryvnia. hi
                2. -2
                  April 12 2024 15: 33
                  Are you not a “native Crimean, daughter of an officer”?
      2. +1
        April 12 2024 13: 46
        Yes, but VTB did not pay coupons on sub-bords for a year, leaving investors high and dry. Here's the state bank for you! Well, how they bought Otkritie - there are also tens of billions of losses for investors.
    2. +8
      April 10 2024 09: 56
      Quote: Nikolay Malyugin
      We need another bank. That part of the economy that belongs to the state needs its own bank. The Central Bank does not fulfill this mission. Then it was possible to introduce a non-cash form of payment. “There are lies, there are big lies, and then there are statistics.”

      Wild, simply the wildest game...
      1. Top 10 banks by assets:
      Sberbank, VTB, Gazprom, Alfa, MKB, NCC, Roskolkhoz, Sovcom, Otkritie, Dom.rf
      Of these, only Sovcombank is not state-owned (quasi-state).
      More than 80% of the banking sector is under the control (direct or indirect) of the state.
      In business the situation is similar. The state's share in the country's economy is about 60%.
      2. What non-cash form of payment are you talking about? Now, are trucks of money rolling around between government offices?
      3. The Central Bank is not a bank at all. This is a regulator. With MEGA prefix.

      To understand, I have been working in the banking industry for more than 20 years and know a little about this kitchen.
      1. 0
        April 10 2024 15: 37
        and what did the boss do with Tinkoff?))
        1. +1
          April 10 2024 18: 40
          And he is in 11th)
          There are, of course, many more banks lower in the ranking, but they are relatively small. And, I repeat, 80% of the banking system is under state control.
      2. 0
        April 10 2024 22: 10
        We have only the Russian Agricultural Bank, a purely state-owned commercial bank, and the rest with state participation. And, for example, Alpha is purely private. And the Central Bank is, of course, a state bank. It holds commercial bank accounts on its balance sheet, organizes and carries out settlements between banks.
      3. 0
        April 12 2024 13: 49
        I'll bet: Alfa and MKB are private banks, so no need to cry.
  2. +6
    April 10 2024 08: 28
    The idea of ​​new “Stalinist” bonds or a large war loan literally suggests itself.
    Well, let the state borrow from Russian billionaires and millionaires
  3. 0
    April 10 2024 09: 15
    Military review - a sense of duty. Spring aggravation of feelings.
  4. 0
    April 10 2024 10: 18
    In October, Russia more than halved its investment in American government bonds to $31 million.

    Another proof that we are not controlled by Putin. We were cheated out of money and again we are taking our money to the Americans
  5. +2
    April 10 2024 13: 24
    During a war, the national debt grows for all warring parties, and US debts grow for decades in peacetime - the differences are fundamental!
    Regional debts are the debt burden of regions, enterprises and the population.
    Evaluation of the activities of regional leaders depends on the implementation of planned targets, projects, national plans and other obligations, and in order to fulfill them you need to spin like a frying pan, carry out import substitution, modernization, optimization of productivity growth, etc. activities through updating production and technology. No one will do anything at a loss - the costs are recouped by increased prices, and this is monitored by the antimonopoly agency and many other fiscal structures.
    Pricing depends on monetary and tax policies, which, in addition to external factors, are superimposed by many internal ones - key rate, inflation, winter-summer, sowing and harvesting, cost of kWh, transport, etc.
    Russian President Vladimir Putin’s proposal to write off two-thirds of the regions’ bad debts on budget loans is not a good life, the question is how to compensate for the written-off debts - by selling off state property, 100% selling export foreign currency earnings, increasing voluntary contributions by RSPP singers, paying labor with government loan bonds, inventing new taxes or what?
  6. VB
    0
    April 10 2024 15: 40
    And the West freed Putin’s close friends, Aven and Fridman, from responsibility. Maybe now Aven will be able to take out of Latvia the art gallery that Putin’s security forces allowed to be stolen from Russia (steal, smuggle)?
    1. +1
      April 10 2024 20: 17
      A rhetorical question: if one side systematically comes up with and imposes sanctions, then should the other side repay debts, and then impose sanctions and at the same time demand repayment of debts in full? Maybe some offset should be made.
  7. -1
    April 11 2024 08: 55
    This is all very cool of course! But with such a rate, the Central Bank does not need debts to suppress the dead shoots of the industrial economy...
    1. +1
      April 11 2024 18: 59
      The Central Bank doesn’t really have a choice; now the Ministry of Finance, due to the Central Bank, is closing the hole in the budget by printing a bunch of new money, and if the rate is lowered, inflation will soar by double digits.