The future of Russia: poverty and archaization

434
The future of Russia: poverty and archaization


Guaranteed poverty


From a January sociological survey conducted by foreign agents, it follows that only a quarter of the country’s population has savings exceeding their monthly income, the other three quarters do not have such savings, or they do not exceed their monthly income.



35% of respondents have no savings at all. Another 16% have it, but it is less than the monthly family income. Together it turns out to be a little more than half. Another 26% have savings approximately equal to their monthly family income. Less than a quarter of the population (23%) have more significant savings, which includes 5% of those who found it difficult to answer the question about their savings.

Similar results are obtained from surveys by the Public Opinion Foundation, which the Central Bank relies on in assessing inflation expectations and savings preferences of the population. The share of people without savings consistently fluctuates around 60%, but the FOM has a different methodology. In the February survey, 59% answered negatively to the question “In principle, today your family has savings, a cash reserve that will allow them to hold out for some time.” But exactly what time is unclear.

The same FOM survey shows that 8% of Russians do not have enough money even for food, 24% have enough for food, but not enough to buy clothes and shoes, and another 32% have money for this, but they cannot buy large household appliances . Total – 64% who do not have the opportunity for significant savings. At the same time, survey participants do not expect that they will have more of these opportunities.

Therefore, fairy tales that tell about the unbridled growth of incomes of the population are obvious information manipulation. As in the joke: “The rich eat meat, but I eat cabbage, on average we eat cabbage rolls.”

The collapse of the pipe economics model


When two thirds of the country cannot save money for a major purchase, a car, an apartment, a vacation or a happy old age, this is real poverty. In essence, this is the collapse of the “pipe” economic model, which still prevails in the Russian Federation.

Here's another one news to the point. "Kommersant" сообщаетthat the volume of non-resource non-energy exports from the Russian Federation decreased by 23% in 2023, from 190,4 billion US dollars to 146,3 billion in 0223. This follows from the presentation, which was timed by the Ministry of Industry and Trade to coincide with Industry Day as part of the Russia exhibition.

Total exports from Russia in 2023 amounted to 425,1 billion US dollars, the Federal Customs Service previously reported. The indicator decreased by 28,3% compared to 2022. Imports increased by 11,7%, to 285,1 billion. The positive foreign trade balance decreased by 58,5%, to 140 billion dollars.

The high-yield market of Western Europe has largely been lost. A return in the current conditions is almost impossible, or is associated with great difficulties and losses. Competitors did not sleep and occupied free niches. A quick reorientation to the markets of Asia, Africa, the Middle East and Latin America is impossible. Problems of transport infrastructure, sanctions. Volumes are falling, prices have to be reduced significantly. Cash payments with new partners are complicated, they go through intermediaries, and this means big losses. Plus problems with converting native currencies like Indian rupees.

The result is obvious: Russia's population will continue to become poorer, and the domestic market will shrink. Plutocrats and oligarchs who sell off the people's wealth, including food and agricultural raw materials, will become even richer.

The only way out is new industrialization, the restoration of basic industries (for example, civil aircraft manufacturing, shipbuilding, automotive manufacturing, engine manufacturing, etc.). Development of the domestic market. Financial autarky from the West. Take all the best that was in the USSR. It will be difficult, and we will also have to “tighten our belts,” but at least this will preserve the state and the people. There will be prospects for growth.

Archaization


Another result of the deindustrialization of Russia is the archaization of the country. State Duma Deputy Oleg Smolin read out data from Rosstat and Russian Orthodox Church. According to these statistics, schools in Russia are being replaced by church institutions. Thus, as of 2022, there were 41,9 thousand churches in Russia, and 39,9 thousand schools.

According to data cited by Smolin, the trend has been observed for almost three decades: the number of schools since post-Soviet times has decreased by more than 30 thousand - from 69 to approximately 700. 39 kindergartens have also been closed.

By the beginning of this school year, about 193 teachers had left schools in Russia. This is the maximum value since 500, according to data from the Ministry of Education. In total, 2017 million teachers work in Russia; over the past year, more than 1,4% of them quit. One of the reasons for layoffs and staff shortages in schools is poverty. The salaries of most teachers are extremely low, people work for food.

At this rate, soon there will be nothing left of the best Soviet (Russian) education in the world except the system of parochial schools. Read, write and the Law of God.

Obviously, the In such a situation, the Russian Federation and the Russian world as a whole have no future. Hence the demographic catastrophe - people do not see a future for the country, for their families and for their personal future. The people are dying out and are being replaced quite quickly by migrants.

434 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +10
    18 February 2024 05: 17
    Walking around the city, I see a lot of idle shops, workshops, and some kind of services. These are rented premises. And what’s interesting is that they haven’t been open for years. What kind of business is this? After all, there are probably hundreds of them around the city. And how many houses in which no one has lived for a long time. Is this our deep state? Or the hidden springs of financial transactions? And the more we talk about increasing productivity, the more gaps there are at the bottom.
    1. +45
      18 February 2024 05: 35
      Quote: Nikolay Malyugin
      Walking around the city, I see a lot of idle shops, workshops, and some kind of services. These are rented premises. And what’s interesting is that they haven’t been open for years

      If you drive through the countryside, you will see countless dead villages, towns, and sometimes even towns. Others are in a dying state. Small towns are not in the best condition, although there are still people. It looks simply apocalyptic.
      Russia is “shrinking”, people are shrinking into a few “centres of comfort” in which there is still life.
      Cities with a population of over a million, the Moscow region, the Krasnodar region, the Tyumen region and, until recently, the Belgorod region, and Chechnya and Tatarstan, which are in a special position.
      PS The graph in the article is, of course, impressive. An educational cross was added to the Russian cross.
      1. +19
        18 February 2024 05: 52
        Therefore, fairy tales that tell about the unbridled growth of incomes of the population are obvious information manipulation

        The wealth of Russia's richest people increased by $2023 billion in 50,012,
        I won't be on this list...
        1. +32
          18 February 2024 08: 43
          Quote from Uncle Lee
          The wealth of Russia's richest people increased by $2023 billion in 50,012,

          But it's interesting. Why is it always considered that increases in the salaries of ordinary people are in rubles, but the welfare of Russian billionaires is always in dollars? Why such a difference in approach?
          1. +39
            18 February 2024 08: 56
            If you voice their fortunes in rubles, people will grab their pitchforks at such figures.
            1. +26
              18 February 2024 08: 59
              Quote: Andrey Moskvin
              If we voice their fortunes in rubles

              The opposite is also true. If our salaries and pensions are converted into dollars, then the result will be complete crap. Especially in terms of their regular increase!
              1. +32
                18 February 2024 09: 03
                But Carlson was so pleased with our prices. It's four times cheaper than at home. Apparently, we should appreciate that we live in such a paradise.
                1. +14
                  18 February 2024 10: 45
                  Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                  But Carlson was so pleased with our prices. It's four times cheaper than at home.

                  So believe after this that Carlson is smart. It is stupid to compare prices without also comparing salaries. And even this will not give a real picture.
                  It is necessary to compare the time spent by the employee, expressed in money, to purchase a particular product.
                  1. +9
                    18 February 2024 10: 54
                    Purchasing power parity. Right? And further. I spend no more than an hour on the road to Tyumen from work to work. Is it six o’clock in Moscow? So I have five more hours to live. laughing hi
                    1. +5
                      18 February 2024 10: 59
                      Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                      Purchasing power parity.

                      Nope. This is also a deception. Only working time spent gives a real picture of the cost of living.
                    2. +2
                      19 February 2024 12: 19
                      Namesake, hi , this is true. I have from 3 to 5 hours of travel every day, depending on where you are going.
                      1. +2
                        19 February 2024 20: 57
                        Quote: Galleon
                        Namesake, hi , this is true. I have from 3 to 5 hours of travel every day, depending on where you are going.

                        From his wife - 3, from his mistress -5? wassat If anything, it's a joke.
                      2. 0
                        20 February 2024 07: 30
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        From his wife - 3, from his mistress -5? wassat If anything - such a joke.

                        Like that wink
                      3. +2
                        20 February 2024 10: 28
                        Quote: Galleon
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        From his wife - 3, from his mistress -5? wassat If anything - such a joke.

                        Like that wink

                        Comrade Stalin, and Comrade Abakumov goes after women. What do we do? - What to do, what to do, we’ll be jealous! wassat
                      4. +2
                        20 February 2024 19: 10
                        Only the conversation was about Rokossovsky.
                  2. +6
                    18 February 2024 14: 06
                    Carson is smart, he did the review for fooled Western fools.
                  3. +2
                    19 February 2024 06: 53
                    So Carlson prepared the material not for us, but for the Americans
                  4. -3
                    19 February 2024 18: 45
                    Well, that’s right, who in Russia can you force to work 6 days a week, 10-12 hours a day? And I worked like this for 23 years, and if you want to live at the “level” in the West, then be a kind farm laborer, otherwise the salary will only last until the next salary. But you won’t agree, after all, you have 5 days, 8 hours and a salary like in a fairy tale about Western luxurious life. 50% of Americans live to make ends meet, everyone has loans like lice... but in Russia they don’t think so, in Russia they know better
                    1. 0
                      19 February 2024 22: 00
                      You have to work so much that you have time to lie on the couch and speculate about the fate of Russia.
                    2. 0
                      20 February 2024 17: 47
                      I’m very sorry for you, you spent all your conscious time at work. Even slaves and serfs worked less
                2. +5
                  19 February 2024 08: 06
                  Our total income for two is approximately 1000 euros per month. For Europe and America is this a lot or a little? I think not very much. Quite a lot for Russia. We have enough for everything, even travel. And why be surprised that with our relatively low incomes compared to Europe and the USA, our prices are lower? You need to compare not only product prices.
                  1. +5
                    19 February 2024 18: 04
                    The two of you can live on an income of 1000 euros in 2024:
                    Without children
                    Without the opportunity to buy a car
                    Without purchasing real estate (mortgage)
                    With your own garden/dacha
                    Extremely low consumer demands.
                    Because owning a car takes 10-15 thousand per month
                    6-10 thousand communal apartment
                    30 totys (grocery basket)
                    1. 0
                      19 February 2024 19: 02
                      We have a car and a 4-room apartment, and we help the children. True, we bought the apartment when our income was a little higher. And everything else is for the amount I indicated. If you don't believe me, it's up to you. I won’t sign or convince.
                      1. 0
                        20 February 2024 12: 28
                        So, retired.
                        Then I agree.
                      2. +2
                        22 February 2024 11: 05
                        It looks like - but the pension for two is within 40 tr (not euro but Russian) the apartment the garage is already empty from the daughter and granddaughter memory - we are raising a great-granddaughter, we are not living very richly and sadly after communal services and medicines there is nothing to go shopping with and no one is already well that home delivery of groceries has appeared.
                      3. 0
                        20 February 2024 17: 51
                        Likewise, 4 rooms, garage, cottage, car and 2 children
                        income is also around 1000 euros
                        Not only is there enough, but there is still some left, because there are no loans or mortgages

                        Those who write that there is not enough simply work for the banks, paying off mortgages, car loans, etc.
                    2. 0
                      20 February 2024 17: 55
                      Yes, thanks to stability, housing and cars became unattainable as in the USSR, but then at least housing was provided for free
                      But I don’t agree about spending 10-15 per month on a car, not everyone uses them and lives in them
                      It takes me 8 minutes to walk to work, it takes my wife 5 minutes, we only take the car once a week to the store, and on weekends in the summer to the dacha
                      1. 0
                        21 February 2024 02: 13
                        Well, this is, one might say, life without a car.
                        It probably also makes sense to indicate the region and place of residence as a variable. I understand that in Moscow, a million-plus population, life will be much more expensive due to the difference in logistics from regional centers and small towns.
                        5 years ago I didn’t have enough income with my wife on maternity leave and two children, and now it wouldn’t be enough.
                        Of course, mortgages/rental costs matter, that's for sure.
                    3. -1
                      21 February 2024 13: 47
                      Quote: el_ninio163
                      The two of you can live on an income of 1000 euros in 2024:
                      Without children
                      Without the opportunity to buy a car
                      Without purchasing real estate (mortgage)
                      With your own garden/dacha
                      Extremely low consumer demands.
                      Because owning a car takes 10-15 thousand per month
                      6-10 thousand communal apartment
                      30 totys (grocery basket)

                      Communal apartment 3500 in winter, euro one-room apartment 42 m. My wife and I get about 90 thousand. The car costs about 4000 for gasoline and 2300 for parking. Well, repairs and maintenance a year are about 40 thousand. Somehow there is not much extra money. It is clear that most of it goes to the wife
                      1. +2
                        21 February 2024 17: 49
                        Here you go, and add here the costs of children, sections, clothing, medical expenses, leisure, vacation...
                        It turns out that everything is a compromise.
                        And this is without loans, although all young people without exception have mortgages...
                        For a family of 4 people, an income of 100 rubles is more about survival than life.
                        That is, every month you sacrifice something.
                  2. 0
                    20 February 2024 12: 27
                    For Europe and the USA, this is below the poverty line, since the unemployment benefit is one higher, and it is almost impossible to live on it (only food)
              2. +2
                19 February 2024 13: 56
                Quote: Stas157
                Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                If we voice their fortunes in rubles

                The opposite is also true. If our salaries and pensions are converted into dollars, then the result will be complete crap. Especially in terms of their regular increase!

                That’s right, if, let’s say, pensions that are periodically “indexed” are recalculated in dollars, then it turns out that they are shrinking.
            2. +15
              18 February 2024 11: 19
              Quote: Andrey Moskvin
              If you voice their fortunes in rubles, people will grab their pitchforks at such figures.

              He won't grab onto anything. The amorphous nature of the population is no longer surprising. And if we take into account that the poorer a person is, the more he loves Putin, a bleak, surreal picture emerges. The highest possible level of “rebellion” is to record an appeal to the GDP with a request to influence the situation.
              1. +9
                18 February 2024 11: 32
                Yes, you are right, you are right. I mean it in an exaggerated way. Although, communicating at work with men from villages, ardent Putinists, I notice changes in attitude towards him. The surrounding reality interrupts any stubbornness. Prices, the dominance of women, and as luck would have it, from every irony about another corrupt official with Kamaz trucks of money...
                1. +8
                  18 February 2024 11: 40
                  Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                  Yes, as luck would have it, from every irony about another corrupt official with Kamaz trucks of money...

                  And this, by the way, has a certain effect, in terms of the fact that the first time causes anger, and the second, fifth, tenth time causes addiction and acceptance as a given. The protective mechanisms of the psyche are triggered, preventing you from going crazy, as if the brain reacted to every news about another corrupt official as if it were the first time.
                  And the opinion Indians The “sheriff” men don’t care.
                  1. +11
                    18 February 2024 11: 44
                    Moreover, due to political illiteracy, this contingent will vote again, as usual, because “for who else?”
                    1. +20
                      18 February 2024 11: 51
                      So there really is no one else to support. All “opposition” that could be anything at all was cleared to zero. And “elections” are an absolute fiction. Only a certain amount of money will be thrown down the drain, but the cart will remain there even now.
                      1. +9
                        18 February 2024 11: 58
                        This means everything will remain as it is. Changes in Russia can only be for the worse. The fat years have passed. We can only wait for “Swan Lake” on all channels... Maybe that will change. I hope not to hear a confident knock on the door at night lol hi
                      2. +6
                        18 February 2024 12: 10
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        Changes in Russia can only be for the worse.

                        With great difficulty, but I would like to hope that this is not the case.
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        I hope not to hear a confident knock on the door at night

                        How is Tsoi:
                        But a strange knock calls for the road.
                        Maybe hearts, maybe a knock on the door.
                        And when I turn around on the threshold,
                        I will say only one word: “Believe!” hi
                      3. +1
                        22 February 2024 07: 46
                        Quote: Hyperion
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        Changes in Russia can only be for the worse.

                        With great difficulty, but I would like to hope that this is not the case.
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        I hope not to hear a confident knock on the door at night

                        How is Tsoi:
                        But a strange knock calls for the road.
                        Maybe hearts, maybe a knock on the door.
                        And when I turn around on the threshold,
                        I will say only one word: “Believe!” hi

                        Change, we are waiting for change!
                      4. 0
                        22 February 2024 12: 38
                        Quote from Kartograph
                        Change, we are waiting for change!

                        We're waiting, yes...
                        "And when we lit the fire,
                        Our fire was extinguished with rain.
                        We sit by broken troughs
                        And we guess on the wind rose,
                        And when it's time to get up,
                        We are sitting, we are waiting." (Cinema)
                      5. 0
                        25 February 2024 09: 18
                        Quote: Hyperion
                        Quote from Kartograph
                        Change, we are waiting for change!

                        We're waiting, yes...
                        "And when we lit the fire,
                        Our fire was extinguished with rain.
                        We sit by broken troughs
                        And we guess on the wind rose,
                        And when it's time to get up,
                        We are sitting, we are waiting." (Cinema)

                        Colonel Vasin arrived at the front
                        With his young wife
                        Colonel Vasin convened his regiment
                        And he told them: "Let's go home"
                        We've been at war for seventy years
                        We were taught that life is a fight
                        But according to new intelligence
                        We were at war with ourselves
                        I saw the generals
                        They drink and eat our death
                        Their kids are going crazy
                        Because they have nothing more to want
                        And the earth lies in rust
                        Churches mixed with ash
                        And if we want to have somewhere to return
                        Time to go home
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nothing left to reap
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nowhere else to run
                        This land was ours
                        Until we get stuck in the fight
                        She will die if there is a draw
                        It's time to regain this land
                        And torches are burning all around
                        All dead parts are being collected
                        And the people who shot our fathers
                        Making plans for our children
                        We were born to the sounds of marches
                        They scared us of prison
                        But stop crawling on your belly
                        We have already returned home
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nothing left to reap
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nowhere else to run
                        This land was ours
                        Until we get stuck in the fight
                        She will die if there is a draw
                        It's time to regain this land
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nothing left to reap
                        This train is on fire
                        And we have nowhere else to run
                        This land was ours
                        Until we get stuck in the fight
                        She will die if there is a draw
                        It's time to regain this land
                      6. 0
                        22 February 2024 11: 22
                        Yes, a lot of things crawled out of all the corners and cracks... which should have knocked on the door and on the head too!
                    2. 0
                      19 February 2024 20: 49
                      Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                      illiteracy will vote again, as usual, because “who else?”

                      And really, for whom? Your suggestions. Just don't offer me a pig in a poke. 1. If I don’t know him, I must at least have heard him. 2. He must have experience as a successful leader of at least a region or ministry. 3. Mandatory military service (officer) 4. Participation in “hot spots” is desirable 5. This candidate has behind him a fairly large team of associates capable of leading key areas in the state economy.
                      And exchanging a watch for underpants just to please the pseudo-democrats in the “change of power”, excuse me, that’s not for me.
                      1. +4
                        19 February 2024 20: 53
                        Keep in mind that I, like you, have many questions for the president. But, give me an example of a government to which the masses of the people have no and never had any complaints.
                      2. +2
                        19 February 2024 21: 25
                        The fact of the matter is that I don’t have an answer. I don't know what to think. All our lives it turns out that we are led to a choice without alternative. I voted for Putin during his first two terms. The next three - no, everything is fine without me. And admiration for him passed along with youth. But I won’t vote against it if only I could. This is such a squiggle.
                      3. 0
                        19 February 2024 21: 30
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        The fact of the matter is that I don’t have an answer.

                        See my answer (Ingvar 72) below in the thread.
                      4. +1
                        19 February 2024 21: 41
                        Thank you, I read it, but it didn’t make it any easier. I'm sorry, but it's 12 in Tyumen, I have to work in the morning. hi
                      5. +1
                        20 February 2024 10: 03
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        work in the morning.

                        Good working day. hi
                      6. 0
                        22 February 2024 15: 56
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        But, give me an example of a government to which the masses of the people have no and never had any complaints.

                        The claims may be different. One government may not have enough consumer goods (USSR). Another government may wage a senseless war (Great Paraguayan War). A third government may stage a military coup (Argentina, Greece, Turkey, Chile). The common people don’t need everyone these experiments. He wants to live in peace
                      7. 0
                        22 February 2024 16: 46
                        Quote from Kartograph
                        (Argentina, Greece, Turkey, Chile). The common people don’t need all these experiments. They want to live in peace

                        No, well, who would argue, but I won’t.
                        But you agreed with me that there will always be complaints against any government. Not for me, but for you. Not with you, but with Uncle Petya. Etc. hi
                      8. 0
                        19 February 2024 21: 42
                        Why are you not satisfied with L. Ivashov’s candidacy?
                      9. 0
                        20 February 2024 02: 47
                        I have too superficial knowledge about him to form a correct judgment.
                      10. +1
                        20 February 2024 10: 19
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        I have too superficial knowledge about him to form a correct judgment.

                        Just read his interviews, of which there are plenty.
                      11. -1
                        20 February 2024 10: 11
                        Quote: mordvin xnumx
                        Why are you not satisfied with L. Ivashov’s candidacy?

                        Was he a governor, a minister? Did he run a large industrial enterprise? What did he lead? Military cooperation between the CIS countries? And what are the successes?
                      12. +2
                        20 February 2024 10: 31
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Was he a governor, a minister? Did he run a large industrial enterprise? What did he lead?

                        What did Putin lead before his presidency? FSB? And what are the successes?
                        Ivashov was given a ride by the Central Election Commission with the elections. The Central Election Commission didn’t like something about the signatures for him. This is the official reason for refusing to register him as a candidate. He is the chairman of the Union of Officers of Russia. Author of the Throw on Pristina.
                      13. -1
                        20 February 2024 10: 38
                        Quote: Mordvin 3
                        Author of the Throw on Pristina.

                        Did he make the decision and did he give the order? What is the authorship?
                      14. 0
                        20 February 2024 11: 11
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Did he make the decision and did he give the order? What is the authorship?

                        Don't you know? Well, then it turns out that you don’t know anything about him at all, just like Moskvin, but you’re starting to argue. I want to ask why he is worse than the then Putin? I have read his publications and it is difficult to argue with his arguments against SVO. But on his team there are also those who are for the SVO, Kvachkov, for example.
                      15. +3
                        20 February 2024 16: 28
                        Quote: Mordvin 3

                        Don't you know? Well, then it turns out that you don’t know anything about him at all, just like Moskvin, but you’re starting to argue.

                        Yes, maybe I don't know. And I don't argue about anything.
                        It’s just that I know first-hand what is happening in the Outskirts, starting in 2005, and therefore I completely dismiss Ivashov’s arguments against the SVO as empty chatter of a person who does not understand anything at all about the issue he is talking about.
                      16. 0
                        22 February 2024 11: 28
                        Yes, we have those who want to “steer”, for whom the main thing is not victory, but participation is always more than
                      17. 0
                        22 February 2024 16: 02
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Was he a governor, a minister? Did he run a large industrial enterprise? What did he lead? Military cooperation between the CIS countries?

                        What did Lenin and Stalin lead before the revolution? The head of state only needs to decide what he wants and assemble a team of economists and management managers for these tasks. If you can’t cope, screw you
                      18. 0
                        22 February 2024 16: 53
                        Quote from Kartograph
                        What did Lenin and Stalin lead before the revolution?

                        Oh, I beg you. Don't confuse God's gift with scrambled eggs.
                        Ivashov, with all due respect to him, is in no way a man of the caliber of Lenin or Stalin.
                      19. +1
                        22 February 2024 07: 49
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        illiteracy will vote again, as usual, because “who else?”

                        And really, for whom? Your suggestions. Just don't offer me a pig in a poke. 1. If I don’t know him, I must at least have heard him. 2. He must have experience as a successful leader of at least a region or ministry. 3. Mandatory military service (officer) 4. Participation in “hot spots” is desirable 5. This candidate has behind him a fairly large team of associates capable of leading key areas in the state economy.
                        And exchanging a watch for underpants just to please the pseudo-democrats in the “change of power”, excuse me, that’s not for me.

                        I will definitely be for the communists. It’s not relevant to me, I served, I didn’t serve, and even in hot spots. What hot spots did Putin serve in?
                      20. +1
                        22 February 2024 08: 34
                        Quote from Kartograph
                        In what hot spots did Putin serve?

                        We are not talking about him, but about the presidential candidate and how I see him.
                        By the way, about the communists, they are the only ones who have an economic program and this is a huge plus.
                        For no one has an economic program, not even the darkest ones. Or he is keeping it a secret from the liberal wing of the government.
                2. -7
                  18 February 2024 12: 59
                  Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                  Quote: Hyperion
                  And if we take into account that the poorer a person is, the more he loves Putin, a bleak, surreal picture emerges.

                  Yes, you are right, you are right.
                  It’s interesting that you openly admit that Putin is loved not by Potanin and Abramovich, but by ordinary people. You and Hyperion don’t like Putin either. Question: are you oligarchs, or are you feeding from their hand?
                  1. +11
                    18 February 2024 13: 05
                    Were there any prerequisites for such a question? I did not recognize anything for the comrades you mentioned above. I'm a simple builder. I don’t know about Hyperion, but it’s unlikely that the oligarchs have even heard of VO.
                    1. -7
                      18 February 2024 13: 13
                      Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                      Were there any prerequisites for such a question?
                      Isn't it clear? Hyperion: “the poorer a person is, the more he loves Putin”; Andrey Moskvin: “Yes, you are right, you are right.” In terms of the degree of Putin’s rejection (love - zero), you are similar to the oligarchs, but in terms of your occupation, you are more likely to be like those whom they feed. It's simple math.
                      1. +6
                        18 February 2024 13: 26
                        This was an answer about pitchforks, no need to distort it. And as for the president, how did you determine the degree? I expressed my rejection of the facts I mentioned from the social sphere, and who should I blame for this if not him?
                      2. -9
                        18 February 2024 13: 28
                        Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                        I expressed my rejection of the facts I mentioned
                        You express it every day, more than once and in different ways. Do you want proofs?
                      3. +7
                        18 February 2024 13: 32
                        Why do I need any proofs, do I really go back on my words?
                      4. 0
                        18 February 2024 13: 39
                        About every day I overdid something. hi
                      5. 0
                        19 February 2024 08: 47
                        VVP is not a girl to love. Personally, I am very satisfied with his foreign policy, but I am far from satisfied with everything in his domestic policy. I don’t see an alternative to him, but I won’t go to the polls, because the result is obvious.
                      6. +7
                        19 February 2024 08: 58
                        Quote: Ady66
                        Personally, I am very satisfied with his foreign policy,

                        How? Foresight? Count how many times he himself said that he was deceived (by Western partners)?
                      7. -1
                        19 February 2024 09: 01
                        The one who does nothing makes no mistakes. But I think that the limit of errors has been exhausted. In any case, I want to believe this.
                      8. +5
                        19 February 2024 17: 23
                        Quote: Ady66
                        The one who does nothing is not mistaken

                        An excuse for all time! good
                        But in fact, of course, every person has the right to make a mistake, but a politician who steps on the same rake is either a fool or an enemy. Gold and foreign exchange reserves located in the countries of a potential enemy, trust in the word of “partners”, de’industrialization, and many other “mistakes” for which they were simply shot in the 30s.
                      9. +1
                        19 February 2024 21: 23
                        Quote: Ingvar 72
                        there is room for error, but a politician who keeps repeating the same rake is either a fool or an enemy. Gold and foreign exchange reserves located in the countries of a potential enemy, trust in the word of “partners”, de’industrialization, and many other “mistakes” for which they were simply shot in the 30s.

                        Those. Do you think that Putin did all this? Do you think that Putin is omnipotent and that all power in the Russian Federation is concentrated in his hands? Yes, even Stalin did not have full power, with the exception of the GKO period during the Second World War.
                        We all make one mistake - we look at the actions of the authorities from, each of our own, cellars, but we need to look from the bell tower, from which we can see better. But the trouble is that we can’t climb the bell tower. But we can fully understand that there are two or three factions fighting in the power structures, one of which is headed by the president. And his group, on certain issues, is weaker than others. Especially in matters of domestic politics and economics. Liberals filled all government offices. hi
                      10. 0
                        20 February 2024 07: 38
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Liberals filled all government offices.

                        It is obvious. but the question is - how did this happen? Someone must have formed their own team, right? wink
                        It’s a difficult question about the completeness of Putin’s power, but even if you look at power as several clans, you need to understand that on fundamental issues they are not competitors. hi
                      11. 0
                        20 February 2024 10: 22
                        Quote: Ingvar 72
                        On fundamental issues they are not competitors.

                        But the “fundamental issues” are issues of economics and finance. Who's sitting there? Liberals! And try to pick them and at the same time remain alive. Because they are also power!
                        It's not as simple as you and I think. Yes, Putin is not my hero, but at the same time I don’t see an alternative to him. And not because they don’t exist, but because the authorities are doing everything so that we don’t know about them.
                      12. -1
                        20 February 2024 10: 34
                        Quote: Ingvar 72
                        It is obvious. but the question is - how did this happen?

                        And this happened before him, and with him. Did you not pay attention to his rhetoric after he replaced DAM?
                        Putin is the president before DAM and Putin is the president after DAM, these are completely different people. But the liberals have taken root. It's not easy to uproot them. At least I think so. Of course I could be wrong
                      13. +1
                        20 February 2024 10: 50
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        Putin is the president before DAM and Putin is the president after DAM, these are completely different people

                        He will mimic the situation, remaining the same person. You need to judge him not by his statements, but by his actions. This is one team with one course, with minor differences among themselves.
                      14. 0
                        20 February 2024 11: 05
                        Quote: Ingvar 72

                        He will mimic the situation, remaining the same person.

                        Maybe so. Or maybe it’s different - you want, figuratively speaking, for him to bench press a barbell of 100 kg, but he can only bench press 50 kg.
                        “So let’s drink to ensure that our desires coincide with HIS capabilities.” I suppose you don’t think that he doesn’t specifically improve our lives? So to speak - out of spite.
                      15. +1
                        20 February 2024 11: 11
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        I suppose you don’t think that he doesn’t specifically improve our lives?

                        That's exactly what I think. It seems that his task is to support the sluggish degradation of the state. In all areas there is only regression with victorious reports. This situation can arise in two cases - either complete lack of professionalism or intent. And the first option is unlikely.
                      16. 0
                        22 February 2024 16: 06
                        Quote: Krasnoyarsk
                        You want him, figuratively speaking, to bench press 100 kg, but he can only bench press 50 kg.

                        How much did Nikolai-2 squeeze out?
                      17. 0
                        22 February 2024 11: 35
                        Stop worrying about today's troubles. There will be new ones tomorrow!
                      18. 0
                        19 February 2024 21: 55
                        Most likely, with this phrase he himself is deceiving whomever he needs. Deceived? Putin?? Do not make me laugh.
                      19. 0
                        19 February 2024 09: 08
                        Quote: Ady66
                        VVP is not a girl to love.
                        It seems that neither your father nor your grandfather loved you: you are not a girl. I feel sorry for you, but the feeling of love is much broader than sexual desire: right up to the love of the Soviet people for the Communist Party. And the claims are against Hyperion; he deduced/announced the inverse relationship between welfare and love for Putin in order to paint his “surreal picture” here.
                      20. 0
                        19 February 2024 11: 24
                        Quote: Stanislav_Shishkin
                        And the claims are against Hyperion; he deduced/announced the inverse relationship between welfare and love for Putin in order to paint his “surreal picture” here.

                        What complaints can there be against me? I just described a trend that is taking place in Russian society. Not without exceptions, but generally as I wrote.
                        And it was not me who painted the “surreal picture”, but the current reality.
                      21. +1
                        19 February 2024 11: 56
                        Quote: Hyperion
                        What complaints can there be against me?
                        Quote: Ady66
                        VVP is not a girl to love.
                        Ask Arkady; he has sexual objections. I have no complaints; on the contrary, I fully accept the validity of this study. Therefore, in reality, I don’t see any “sure” to which I have objections: the low-income people feel fluctuations in purchasing power more subtly and in their own skin and do not follow stock exchange rates, unlike the rich who fall into panic or euphoria depending on the ruble exchange rate. Hence the probability. And panic, in addition, is being rocked by the 5th column. Their dislike for Putin is due to nerves, I believe.
                      22. +2
                        19 February 2024 13: 31
                        "Sur" can be expressed by the hackneyed phrase: "the king is good, the boyars are bad." This phrase contains the paradoxical and surreal nature of the thinking of those who are incapable of the simplest logical conclusions, mixed with blind faith in the good Tsar-Father.
                      23. 0
                        19 February 2024 14: 17
                        Quote: Hyperion
                        “Sur” can be expressed by the hackneyed phrase: “the king is good, the boyars are bad.”
                        You see, I give you arguments, and you respond with hackneyed phrases that you load others with, considering them idiots. You probably think so yourself, repeating the American folk saying, launched, according to unverified data, into the people by the American businessman Warren Buffett: “If you are so smart, why are you so poor?” In general, I believe that this is a convenient and ego-warming explanation of the reason for the wealth acquired by a person.
                      24. 0
                        19 February 2024 16: 07
                        Quote: Stanislav_Shishkin
                        You see, I give you arguments, and you respond with hackneyed phrases that you load others with, considering them idiots.

                        What other “arguments”? You have only conclusions that are obvious to you, sometimes contradicting themselves. You don’t need to define for me who I consider idiots and who I don’t. You're bad at it. Whatever the “argument” is, it’s a finger in the sky. Buffett, wealth, American proverb... What's what..? Some kind of stream of consciousness...
                    2. -2
                      18 February 2024 13: 23
                      Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                      oligarchs have even heard about VO
                      The question is not about them, have you heard about the inversely proportional function?
                      1. +7
                        18 February 2024 13: 29
                        No, I haven't. I'm not as educated as you might think.
                  2. 0
                    22 February 2024 11: 33
                    And what about the common people - what about those who neither steal nor watch, unlike the Potanins and Abramovichs!
                3. 0
                  19 February 2024 16: 42
                  Although, when communicating with men from villages at work, try talking to the mirror, maybe you’ll see... but don’t be scared, this is what...!
                  1. 0
                    19 February 2024 17: 27
                    I really don’t understand what you mean recourse . Somehow too veiled.
              2. +1
                19 February 2024 16: 34
                I wouldn't be so categorical about love. They just don't see any other options.
              3. 0
                22 February 2024 08: 51
                Quote: Hyperion
                Quote: Andrey Moskvin
                If you voice their fortunes in rubles, people will grab their pitchforks at such figures.

                He won't grab onto anything. The amorphous nature of the population is no longer surprising. And if we take into account that the poorer a person is, the more he loves Putin, a bleak, surreal picture emerges. The highest possible level of “rebellion” is to record an appeal to the GDP with a request to influence the situation.

                All the violent ones were slaughtered during the revolution, the civil revolution and the 37s, since then there has been nothing rebellious left in the genes of the Russian people
                1. 0
                  22 February 2024 12: 30
                  Quote from Kartograph
                  Since then, there has been nothing rebellious left in the genes of the Russian people

                  IMHO, “violence”, in the good sense of the word, lies not in genes, but in upbringing. Learned helplessness and infantilism were imposed on the people.
            3. Qas
              +4
              19 February 2024 09: 09
              Yes, people are mentally downtrodden right now. Decades of life, whether you go to the polls or not, nothing will change in your life. This killed faith in the best. In general, on the vine.
              Plus, the tsar has his head in the clouds, and believes that the average salary among the people is 70.000 rubles.
              The “washer in the toilets” has disappeared, what remains is the political Leopold Cat “Guys, let’s live together.”
              1. +9
                19 February 2024 09: 46
                YES, and he turned out to be a bad "wetman in toilets", his "wetting" turned out to be filled with money, that's all.
            4. 0
              19 February 2024 09: 42
              And even with the numbers in dollars, I also want that...
            5. 0
              19 February 2024 21: 53
              Hurry, for the stone axes.
            6. +1
              20 February 2024 22: 50
              The people will not take up their pitchforks until the moment when a quarter of them go systematically to grub in garbage dumps. And the “vilomobilizing” organization is not noticeable. Those that exist are only capable of calling for obedience, or, at best, for dissatisfied grumbling (Cut Vanka, there is no God!), which the ruling elite does not care about.
              1. 0
                21 February 2024 03: 21
                Thank you (I had already forgotten about the article). Don’t take my passage about the pitchfork seriously, I myself understand that in general it’s possible to live. But! This is while I'm still strong. And my mother-in-law has a pension of 17 thousand. belay
      2. +19
        18 February 2024 06: 34
        Cities with a population of over a million, Moscow region, Krasnodar region
        Krasnodar region, subsidized...they come to us because it’s warm, there are apples...Work is hard...Almost all the fish were caught, both in the Azov and Black Seas. They sell “fish children” in the markets, they would Still to live, yes to live. Even the migratory bird has ceased to linger on the estuaries.
        1. +13
          18 February 2024 06: 47
          Quote: parusnik
          In the markets they sell “fish children”, they should still live, but live.

          and where is the valiant FSB since environmental protection is completely corrupt.
          Judging by what is happening, the mafia completely controls the government. in particular, scrap metal continues to destroy the last vestiges of industry amid stories of industrialization.
          1. +7
            18 February 2024 06: 53
            and where is the valiant FSB
            .... Corruption... is not in the fisheries inspection, and before they are caught officially, the same children are lying in fish stores. I’m so impressed that I live in the Far East, judging by the assortment on the shelves.
          2. +15
            18 February 2024 10: 51
            "Where is the valiant FSB RA"
            the valiant FSB is fighting the riflemen, the Shevchuks, and quite successfully
        2. +13
          18 February 2024 07: 30
          Krasnodar region, subsidized... they come to us because it’s warm, there are apples... It’s hard with work

          I don’t argue, you know better. It’s just that when you drive around the Krasnodar region you can see that there is life. And not only in Krasnodar, Sochi (which has turned into some kind of monstrous Babylon). When you drive, say, in the Smolensk region, you get the full feeling of the film Stalker. Like after Batu’s ruin.
          Almost all the fish were caught in both the Azov and Black Seas

          I was at Lake Baikal last year. First of all, of course, I find out about fish. And the locals laugh and say that there have been no fish for 4 years. I was stunned, why not? Why not ? They don’t, we don’t see it ourselves. I tell them that in the Union there was more than enough of it, back in 2009 there was, although already much less (I came). And they say, that’s it, they knocked it all out, and now there’s a ban on fishing.
          But when I arrived at the airport, I saw omul being sold (though at an exorbitant price). I tell them it’s a ban, they laugh too. Some people are told a ban, some aren’t.
          1. +5
            18 February 2024 07: 53
            Undoubtedly, I live in the outback of the Krasnodar Territory. Yes, work is extremely difficult. When I moved twelve years ago, a good education and an opportunity helped - an automation specialist was needed for production. There were no locals. It helps the region look more decent compared to the rest of Russia (you move to the Rostov region, thirty kilometers, already devastated) climate, agriculture is afloat (for now), and income from holidaymakers..
            1. +5
              18 February 2024 08: 07
              Quote from: dmi.pris1
              Undoubtedly, I live in the outback of the Krasnodar region. Yes, work is extremely difficult.

              wink “If you’re visiting us in Kolyma, you’re welcome. There’s plenty of work.” (joke).
              1. +10
                18 February 2024 09: 13
                Quote: ammunition
                "You will be with us in Kolyma

                It’s better if you come to us)))
                As far as I know, there are also plenty of abandoned villages there. Like my dear Karamken((
          2. +23
            18 February 2024 08: 06
            It was not Batu who ruined the Smolensk region, my small homeland. By the way, the Horde did not ruin the principality then.. Do you know which plant in Smolensk collapsed? More precisely, a cluster? Producing computer equipment and radio electronics in the early 90s. Spark, and Diffusion. They knew, why should it be destroyed?
            1. +8
              18 February 2024 16: 32
              Quote from: dmi.pris1
              It was not Batu who ruined the Smolensk region, my small homeland. By the way, the Horde did not ruin the principality then

              Thanks I know. There was just a saying in Rus' about Batya’s ruin. Melnikov-Pechersky wrote until the 19th century.
              Producing computer equipment and radio electronics in the early 90s. Iskra, and Diffusion. They knew what to destroy.

              The first to be destroyed within the framework of an “effective market economy” were industries with high value added and everything that had no export prospects.
              Now raw materials are gradually degrading.
            2. +3
              18 February 2024 17: 13
              Do you know which plant in Smolensk collapsed? More precisely, a cluster? Producing computer equipment and radio electronics in the early 90s. Iskra, and Diffusion.
              Did the aircraft factory survive? I do not believe!
              1. +4
                18 February 2024 17: 49
                He was saved by the fact that he came under the wing of KRTV, but only partially. They made missiles there before, but you can forget about Yaks. Accordingly, the entire social system of the factory, the technical school, collapsed... Now, perhaps missile production has been expanded, I don’t know. I go to city ​​not every year, unfortunately. The graves of my parents remain there
            3. 0
              19 February 2024 16: 50
              Perhaps the MVM plant collapsed - I started there in 1969 under Matula, but the Smolensk villages were empty in 1965 and there was no one to work with.
              1. 0
                19 February 2024 17: 12
                The Iskra software was virtually destroyed in 1992. It’s a shame for the former plant of small-sized computers. I didn’t work at it, but as a kid I went to their pioneer camp “Timurovets”
      3. +11
        18 February 2024 13: 12
        If you drive through the countryside, you will see countless dead villages, towns, and sometimes even towns. Others are in a dying state. Small towns are not in the best condition, although there are still people. It looks simply apocalyptic.

        Just don’t tell Ellochka from the election commission this. Even Rosstat, in its population statistics, indicates that as of January 1, 2022, it was 146 people, and as of January 980, 061, it was already 1. That is. even taking into account the population of the new “annexed” regions, the population decreased by more than 2023 thousand people in just one year. But since we are talking about the election process, it is “more correct”, of course, to compare current or approximately current population indicators (since Rosstat does not yet publish information as of January 146, 447) with similar data from the period of the previous electoral cycle in 424, when the population of Russia according to Rosstat data, it was 500. The difference in this case, however, will not be so “impressive,” but even it will be minus 1 thousand people.

        However, Ellochka’s demographic situation is diametrically opposite. According to its data, as of January 1, 2024, 112 voters were registered in the Russian Federation, another 309 voters live outside the country, while on January 947, 1 (at the time of the last presidential elections) there were 890 voters in the country . and 863 outside of it.

        An interesting picture emerges: the number of citizens in the country is steadily declining, while the number of voters is growing uncontrollably, increasing by as much as 3 million. At the same time, the number of voters abroad, despite the flight of dissent and potential mobilization, on the contrary, decreased by 15 thousand people. This “wonderful picture” is explained by its own “special” calculation method. However, considering that at one time I received approximately the same wording from the local election commission: that electoral legislation is a special branch of law, which is not subject to the norms characteristic of the rest of the legal system, one should not be surprised. It has its own “special” calculation method, its own “special” legislation, its own “special” country.

        And here you are remembering some kind of reality...
        1. +16
          18 February 2024 16: 41
          Quote: Dante
          An interesting picture emerges: the number of citizens in the country is steadily declining, while the number of voters is growing uncontrollably, increasing by as much as 3 million.

          The Russian Federation is gradually becoming a full-fledged country of the 3rd capital of the world. Only a thin thread of remnants of political legitimacy and nuclear weapons separates it from this brink.
          And in such countries, statistics and sociology do not serve the purposes of management, as in the countries of the first capital of the world and socialism (although there are also additions, manipulations, and mistakes), but the purposes of hiding reality and maintaining power. There is nothing more behind statistics in the Russian Federation. It can be analyzed because there is nothing else, but in general it is meaningless.
          PS For example, the 2021 “census” determined that 90% of Russians live in Moscow, with 29 thousand Uzbeks, 22 thousand Tajiks and 16 thousand Kyrgyz. When I read these “statistics” I laughed nonstop for half an hour.
        2. +3
          19 February 2024 18: 09
          Well, there’s nothing surprising about the first indicator: the aging population, yesterday’s 4 million children who were not part of the 108 million turned 18, but no new ones were born,
      4. +2
        18 February 2024 16: 40
        Well, people don’t flock to Chechnya if they really approach it. Quite the contrary...
        1. +8
          18 February 2024 16: 47
          Quote from: dmi.pris1
          Well, people don’t flock to Chechnya if they really approach it. Quite the contrary...

          Right. Chechnya and Tatarstan are in a special position. There is also Dagestan, but there is an atmosphere there that is different from Chechnya.
          And in Chechnya, under our “democratic-patriotic” authorities, all Russians were genocided, now an autonomous national state with its own laws.
          But there is life there on payments from the federal budget.
      5. BAI
        -4
        18 February 2024 20: 09
        The disappearance of villages, hamlets, and small towns is an inevitable price to pay for the industrialization of the country. Everyone wants an 8-hour working day, medicine, education for children, shops, the opportunity to spend leisure time, and even just the opportunity to walk on the asphalt in fashionable, comfortable shoes. I'm not even talking about hot water and warm toilets.
        Why do those living in the city take the pose of a righteous man, lamenting about the dying village, but categorically do not want to pick through the manure with a toilet on the street at minus 30 and the nearest paramedic station is 20 km away?
        1. +11
          18 February 2024 21: 55
          Quote: BAI
          The disappearance of villages, hamlets, and small towns is an inevitable price to pay for the industrialization of the country.

          Excuse me, is this some kind of joke? This disappearance occurred in the last 35 years, and the underlying cause was deindustrialization happened in Russia. Industrialization took place in the 30s of the 20th century, and then villages, towns, and cities were being built I have been to many villages and towns where several thousand people lived during the union. There was school, production. Now there is nothing and no one, just the abomination of desolation. In the north and in the Far East there are such cities (I haven’t been personally, but I’ve seen atmospheric videos from there).
          The process of deindustrialization is the same throughout Russia (in the area where I live there were 4 medium and large industries - now there are none), it’s just that for a conditional urban settlement, the liquidation of one’s production is death, and through large cities the native leaders pump part of the money for raw materials allowing the “dependents” “(and the authorities perceive the majority of the population as their servants or dependents, since they do not create any “surplus value”) somehow to live.
          1. -9
            18 February 2024 22: 38
            The process of deindustrialization could have been easily stopped - simply not opening the door to imports and continuing to live with what we were sitting with in the 80s. The state-military-industrial complex, instead of a car, here’s a red flag, and instead of the word “buy”, go with the words “get” to the queue for a couple of days.
            Without normal commodity-money relations and competition, it is impossible to create normal production with normal solutions, adequate prices, affordable and high-quality service. A planned directive economy that obeys Marxist dogmas is not a normal economy. Such an economy has never been successful anywhere. In “communist” China, ~70% of GDP is generated by private businesses with private ownership of the means of production.
      6. -9
        18 February 2024 22: 32
        There were countless living villages and hamlets in the Russian Empire. And then collectivization and forced industrialization broke out, in the furnace of which the peasantry and one-story Russia were burned, respectively. And subsequent urbanization with dense standard buildings completed this process.
        Stop engaging in neo-Bolshevik anti-state propaganda on the Internet; you won’t be able to pull off 1917 cosplay.
        1. +1
          21 February 2024 09: 35
          Quote: Shuridze
          There were countless living villages and hamlets in the Russian Empire.

          How much cast iron did these “countless villages” produce? what about steel? and the machines? and the guns?
          or did they only give bread, which they drove over the hill? (reminds me of nothing?)
          RI showed what it came to during the Japanese and First World Wars
        2. +1
          21 February 2024 09: 43
          and yes, one more remark about “Countless number of living villages in the Russian Empire”
          Haven’t you read the Russian classics about poverty and savagery in the countryside? about her lack of education? about the lack of medicine in the village?
          Have you also heard nothing about the constant peasant unrest, which was crushed by troops? from 1801 to 1861 - 1448 registered peasant unrest, and after 1861 there are still more frequent

          yes, a wonderful wonderful world that we have lost, yeah
    2. +1
      18 February 2024 20: 55
      The impression is that the material was not written by Samsonov, but by a liberal amateur under his name. I have not seen such a gathering of outright stupidity, distortion and emptiness for a long time. Samsonov, is that really you?
      1. -1
        19 February 2024 10: 08
        I’ll say more, how can you compare the number of churches that do not belong to educational institutions and the number of schools? I found out that there are about 13 Sunday schools in the Russian Federation and 000 higher theological schools, and this is no more than 41 ordinary schools, and especially other universities and technical schools...
  2. +21
    18 February 2024 06: 17
    About 193 teachers quit schools in Russia
    Someone higher up said: “Don’t like it? Go into... business.” (c) They left. And as a result, Russia is the fifth economy in the world, exchange rate $ 92,55 smile
    1. +20
      18 February 2024 06: 59
      They left. And as a result, Russia is the fifth largest economy in the world, the exchange rate is $ 92,55 smile

      And you believe in this nonsense?
      Relative to what base was it calculated?

      It’s sad, but SVO has a catastrophic effect on the population. Poverty has come to the homes of many citizens.
      The problems are trivial - everything is becoming more expensive! Citizens are increasingly working for food.
      The NWF's liquid assets remain for 1,5 years.

      Sakhivzadovna and the rest of the liberal bureaucrats are sitting in their places
      Quality education is becoming inaccessible. Of course, there is hope that your child will have some special aptitude for science and Sirius will take him away from the family, and if not, then you will work for tutors.
      As the guarantor of the constitution said, Russian industry will produce 1000 aircraft by 2030, but in reality there will be (if any) 35. This is how we live. There is one thing on TV, but in life something is not even close.
      The picture is similar in the machine tool industry. The Kalashnikov concern is indicative. All CNC machines are on Fanuc, Siemens, Yaskava stands. As far as I know, CNC machining centers were made on Elbrus, while Taiwanese TSMC was still producing them for Russia. But the last batches of processors ordered and paid for were never delivered to us after the start of the SVO.
      And no one yet considers how much money will be needed (and whether there will be any at all) for the treatment of bojtsoa after SVO. But new rehabilitation centers are not being built, doctors are not being trained, and the deputies rejected the program to provide psychological assistance to boys from PTSD.
      Has anyone seen the newly built centers for the production of modern bthonic prostheses for North Military District soldiers who have lost limbs?
      Where can fighters work, well, besides life safety at school for 18 thousand rubles?

      I don’t really see any prospects, what about you?
      1. +3
        18 February 2024 07: 02
        I put a smiley after the comment, look carefully. Or I can tell you what the smiley means after the comment.
        1. +3
          18 February 2024 07: 06
          I put a smiley after the comment, look carefully. Or I can tell you what the smiley means after the comment.

          Reminds me of the late period of the USSR, where everyone understood everything, but said that they were thinking quietly in their kitchen.
          Now let's put emoticons
          1. +4
            18 February 2024 07: 10
            I put it for you. You are not familiar with the law of contradiction. hi
          2. -8
            18 February 2024 14: 07
            Quote: Sergey_Bely
            Now let's put emoticons
            Would you like to bring back Shenderovich, “Dolls”...
      2. +1
        18 February 2024 07: 16
        if there is a Stalinist example of solving this issue
        1. Qas
          +1
          19 February 2024 09: 24
          Only Stalin himself is missing...
      3. +10
        18 February 2024 07: 55
        So that’s what it’s designed for. The prospect is to go to war. There’s income there. But it’s not a fact that it will be useful in the future
        1. +2
          18 February 2024 12: 02
          As Timur Shaov sings: “So this means: Life is crap! But the prospects are sooooo GOOD!”
          1. 0
            25 February 2024 09: 28
            Quote: comradChe
            As Timur Shaov sings: “So this means: Life is crap! But the prospects are sooooo GOOD!”

            Two dogs sit and argue that there is absolutely nothing to eat and it’s time to get out of here.
            One says, just wait a little, I have a new perspective - I overheard the owners talking here.
            They say soon... ours will be sucked
      4. +13
        18 February 2024 08: 17
        I don’t really see any prospects, what about you?

        What, no prospects? Yes you, what? We only have “prospects” left....- “somewhere out there”, “it’s unknown when” and “it’s not clear what”.... Well, these are the prospects like “here, as soon as” then we’ll live.”... the main thing is to believe in the “prospects”, not ask questions and “don’t rock the boat.” winked
        1. +3
          18 February 2024 23: 23
          Quote: Monster_Fat
          I don’t really see any prospects, what about you?

          What, no prospects? Yes you, what? We only have “prospects” left....- “somewhere out there”, “it’s unknown when” and “it’s not clear what”.... Well, these are the prospects like “here, as soon as” then we’ll live.”... the main thing is to believe in the “prospects”, not ask questions and “don’t rock the boat.” winked


          Is this how you speak from America about local prospects?
      5. +5
        18 February 2024 08: 36
        Quote: Sergey_Bely
        doctors are not trained

        Doctors are trained, in “commercial volumes”, only... they are in no hurry to go into medicine, that is, some go, but in certain areas: plastic surgery, cosmetology, sit at the echo chamber, but no one “in the field” you will drag, you will not lure. And they are offered houses, and cars, the damned ones don’t go...
        1. +13
          18 February 2024 10: 19
          Now the shortage of doctors is being filled by immigrants from Central Asia and Africa, in our city there are already 30 percent of them, they speak Russian very poorly. In Tyumen, a neurologist is a black doctor, recently they showed this on TV as an achievement, his wife’s sister got an appointment with him, neither he understood her nor she him, so she went to a paid one. So soon the only thing left from medicine will be dental prosthetics and cosmetology, they will be toothily beautiful laughing
          1. +4
            18 February 2024 10: 58
            “Now the shortage of doctors is being filled by people from Central Asia and Africa, in our city there are already 30 percent of them, they speak Russian very poorly. In Tyumen, the neurologist is a black doctor, recently they showed this on TV as an achievement.”
            So the guarantor raises their salaries by 50%, and then he also threatened. caring about the health of the electorate, oh how!
            1. +3
              18 February 2024 11: 17
              Quote: ZloyKot
              Here is a guarantor of their salary and raises it by 50%

              For whom is this request
              Can you tell me about the latest provision on additional payments in settlements of less than 50 thousand people? So it's unlikely that this will change anything fundamentally...
              1. +1
                18 February 2024 11: 19
                "about additional payments in settlements of less than 50 thousand people? "
                exactly. It’s unlikely that blacks and Tajiks treat people in Moscow, it’s more in the regional centers
          2. +9
            18 February 2024 11: 12
            Quote: Alexey 1970
            Currently, the shortage of doctors is being filled by immigrants from Central Asia.

            It happened, but they didn’t last long; the hardiest ones lasted about a year and fled in an unknown direction...
            Quote: Alexey 1970
            went to the paid one

            This is the course we are all following...
            Quote: Alexey 1970
            So soon there will be no medicine left

            Several very expensive clinics for “not everyone”, the rest - spells/herbs/midwives...
          3. +3
            19 February 2024 09: 04
            And not only in Tyumen. At the same time, getting an appointment even with a local therapist is a problem.
      6. +6
        18 February 2024 09: 19
        Quote: Sergey_Bely
        SVO has a catastrophic effect on the population. Poverty has come to the homes of many citizens.
        The problems are trivial - everything is becoming more expensive!

        Here's an interesting story for you. I have an employee in my department. Recently, about a month ago, she asked me to take leave for a few days to go to the funeral of her closest friend’s husband. His head was torn off during the war and he was buried in a closed coffin.
        In short, this guy drank like a beast. His wife left him a long time ago; they didn’t live together, but were married. They have a daughter, about 7 years old. They are from Izhevsk. She completed all the paperwork and her homeland paid her 8 million in compensation for the death of her husband. And until the age of 18, my daughter will be paid 30 thousand from the local budget and 50 thousand from the federal budget.
        Moreover, I don’t know why, but this guy’s mother was also paid 8 million. And they all live together, 3 women.
        As a result, the family is very happy, because they killed a worthless drunk, and the women were given 16 million at a time + 80K a month they will pay for another 10 years. It's a lot of money for Izhevsk. His wife writes to this Tanya of mine that she plans to buy a new apartment, they want to travel around all sorts of Thailand and Turkey, in principle, you don’t have to work anymore, a million happy emoticons, etc.
        To be honest, on the one hand I understand her. On the other hand, it’s kind of disgusting...
        But that’s what I’m talking about.
        If, according to reports from our Defense Ministry, we killed 500K dill, and according to Putin, the losses were 1:7, then this comes out to 70+ thousand people. These are only those killed. 70 * 000 = 16 trillion 000 billion of live, freshly printed money thrown into cash circulation in the country. And they also give 000 lemmas to the wounded, of whom there are hundreds of thousands in such situations... And another 1K each monthly, whereas before they received 120-3.
        What the hell is 7% inflation? According to my feelings, 20% is at least. Rather more..
        The same notorious “helicopter” money.
        1. +12
          18 February 2024 09: 27
          She completed all the paperwork and her homeland paid her 8 million in compensation for the death of her husband. And until the age of 18, my daughter will be paid 30 thousand from the local budget and 50 thousand from the federal budget.

          I don’t know... I heard completely different numbers from the wounded mobilized. In our region, 3 million, if he died and was declared dead.
          But there are missing persons. And no payments are due. And now at work we chip in so that the woman and her 2 children don’t die of hunger. So different situations in different places.
          Another 2 acquaintances of the family have disappeared in the Northern Military District. No payments either.
          1. -1
            18 February 2024 10: 32
            As in a joke:
            Patient: And the neighbor, the old man, says that twice a night.
            Doctor: That's what you say!
            -
          2. 0
            22 February 2024 09: 04
            Quote: Sergey_Bely
            She completed all the paperwork and her homeland paid her 8 million in compensation for the death of her husband. And until the age of 18, my daughter will be paid 30 thousand from the local budget and 50 thousand from the federal budget.

            I don’t know... I heard completely different numbers from the wounded mobilized. In our region, 3 million, if he died and was declared dead.
            But there are missing persons. And no payments are due. And now at work we chip in so that the woman and her 2 children don’t die of hunger. So different situations in different places.
            Another 2 acquaintances of the family have disappeared in the Northern Military District. No payments either.

            A friend’s husband was imprisoned in the village, they took him to Wagners. He died just before the end of the contract. His wife was paid about 2 million
        2. +4
          18 February 2024 10: 13
          killed a worthless drunk
          Soldier died, and the worthless drunk is indignant. that they helped his loved ones with money.
        3. +3
          18 February 2024 12: 38
          Quote: Mishka78
          I have an employee in my department. Recently, about a month ago, she asked me to take leave for a few days to go to the funeral of her closest friend’s husband. His head was torn off during the war, they buried him in a closed coffin........In the end, the family is very happy, because they killed a worthless drunk, and the women were given 16 million at a time........in principle, you don’t have to work anymore , a million happy emoticons, etc. To be honest, on the one hand I understand her. On the other hand, it’s kind of disgusting.
          The warrior died, not the drunk. He might be the only one in battle, like you, he was worth five. What are you hanging? Why are you jealous? Are other people's grave money passing through your pocket? And you, Mishanya, are a rare bastard and there is nothing more to add to this. For such stories, if it were up to me, I would transport you to Kharp, where a place was freed up for you after Navalny. You can complain to the moderator.
      7. The comment was deleted.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
            1. The comment was deleted.
              1. The comment was deleted.
                1. The comment was deleted.
        2. +2
          18 February 2024 13: 23
          I wonder if he was lying, honestly looking into the eyes of the people, or simply does not know what is happening in the country that he supposedly rules?

          Reminds me of a scene from Comedy Club
    2. +4
      18 February 2024 07: 21
      Quote: parusnik
      Someone said from superiors: “Don’t like it? Go to... business.”

      You need to know the classics... feel (iPhone, if nothing else request )
  3. +8
    18 February 2024 06: 29
    We need a debate between Samsonov and Shpakovsky.
    For example, in the article "New Schools".
    1. +13
      18 February 2024 08: 56
      Quote: ivan2022
      We need a debate between Samsonov and Shpakovsky.

      Shpakovsky will lose with a bang. And if it is possible to place bets, then even his supporters will not bet on Shpakovsky. Otherwise, you will be left at a loss!
  4. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. The comment was deleted.
      1. The comment was deleted.
        1. +3
          18 February 2024 09: 09
          Of course, but who wants it, only thieves in law - Usmanov, Muller, Gref, Peskov, etc. and at the critical hour they will all fly away from here, maybe they’ll grab Putin too
          1. Alf
            +3
            18 February 2024 21: 05
            Quote: g0ryachevnn
            and at the critical hour they will all fly away from here, maybe they’ll grab Putin too

            Why do they need him there? He fulfilled his task here, he filled his pockets with them. They will say, Sorry, bro, there is no extra space for you on the plane.
            1. +1
              19 February 2024 09: 56
              Well, yes, - “sorry genotsvale, but a violinist is not needed.”
    4. +10
      18 February 2024 09: 37
      Quote: Serg 122
      Bury your oval one, kiss Nadezhdin’s ass.

      Why were they dragged in? After all, for any criticism of the authorities you are immediately declared a navalist! What if you figure it out? Both Nadezhdin and Navalny are pure liberals. Therefore, they are clearly closer in their ideology to the ruling United Russia and to our main liberal and his supporters.

      And it’s generally interesting about Navalny. The guy fought against corruption, but he was persecuted and put behind bars. Moreover, when he went to jail, he was not yet a traitor (they didn’t shout about him like that then). Hence the question. How did he suddenly turn out to be a traitor in prison? Who did he betray there, his warden or what? And if Navalny is still a traitor, as everyone is shouting at the same time, then why wasn’t he convicted for this?
      1. +6
        18 February 2024 12: 39
        How did he suddenly turn out to be a traitor in prison?
        Probably when, with the help of something carried in a gypsy's pocket smile telephone called to capitulate to Ukraine and pay them reparations?
    5. +3
      18 February 2024 12: 36
      It's disgusting to read such old mental people as you. Your level is to go to church every Sunday and light a candle for the health of the Tsar-Father and for the Owner of the enterprise for which you work. You need a Master. To do it properly, with rods and shackles. As you like.
    6. +2
      18 February 2024 13: 38
      I think everyone who read this article, including me, should publicly apologize for what they read and their ability to read in general wassat
  5. +18
    18 February 2024 06: 45
    On March 17, again, like a flock of sheep, they will go to vote for the continuation of the path that is destructive for the people.
    1. +11
      18 February 2024 08: 39
      Quote: VZEM100
      On March 17, again, like a flock of sheep, they will go to vote for the continuation of the path that is destructive for the people.

      Just don't! The people vote, and they count. “They’ll draw” a nice figure—it’s not in vain that they spent 25 years building the “vertical of power,” not in order to lose all the goodies. laughing bully
      1. +8
        18 February 2024 08: 56
        When reason leaves the skull, faith takes over...
        In Russia, the “blessed” are stored up for hundreds of years... faith in a good king based on servility and infantilism among the majority of the population will be worse than any election propaganda.
        So there’s no need to cheat too much with votes... well, if only the turnout with approvals is increased to the coveted 146% for the delight of nature...
        1. +7
          18 February 2024 09: 22
          When reason leaves the skull, faith takes over...
          In Russia, the “blessed” are stored up for hundreds of years... faith in a good king based on servility and infantilism among the majority of the population will be worse than any election propaganda.

          Let's not touch our faith.
          There are enough problems with the economy. And without the economy, at least there will be faith, at least there won’t be, but the state will not exist.
          So I have only one complaint to the ruling elite, why... they haven’t developed production in 24 years. Young engineers come and ask where they should go to become competent specialists. What should I answer them...
          I honestly tell them that they don’t need literate people at enterprises like ours. And where they are needed, you won’t be able to get a job there, since the level of demand for entry-level specialists is much higher than what is prepared by Russian universities in the regions.
          This is the reality
          1. +19
            18 February 2024 10: 49
            Quote: Sergey_Bely
            Let's not touch our faith. There are enough problems with the economy.

            Let's not touch the economy, just say that its growth (GDP growth) ensures a steady increase in prices and tariffs. Enough problems with healthcare.
            Let's not touch healthcare, just say that in Russia there are 150 teeth per 000 inhabitants, and we have surpassed the whole world in terms of paid SMS messages for sick children. There are enough problems with education.
            Let’s not touch education, otherwise the last teachers will run away and then we’ll have to send our children away from an early age. There are enough problems with employment.
            Let's not touch on employment, just remember that the Brezhnev Constitution of 1977 offered a choice of profession, and today a choice of salaries is offered. There are enough problems with housing and communal services.
            Let's not touch housing and communal services, otherwise it will turn out that we are paying for services for those who do not want to pay, and it is unclear who and with what stitches sewed 20% (VAT) onto the payment for housing. There are enough problems with elections.
            Let’s not touch the elections, because this is a complete profanation, a choice without a choice, a choice without the “Against all” column, a choice without reports for the past election period, a choice without discussion, without questions from voters and answers from those elected, elections at the choice of the Central Election Commission. There are enough problems in sports.
            Let's not touch sports, which have been turned into betting, which does not determine the nationality of the athlete and his right to perform in international arenas. There are enough problems in TV.
            Let's not touch TV, which has been turned into endless advertising with alternating talking heads, otherwise it will turn out that more people work in this industry than are employed in the SVO or in production in the military-industrial complex. Enough problems with finances.
            Let’s not touch finances, otherwise it will turn out that the head of the Central Bank, whose candidacy was proposed by the “guarantor,” devoted her entire tenure to weakening the ruble (more than three times) and transferring gold and foreign currency reserves to the banks of NATO countries, without being a foreign agent. There are enough problems with demographics.
            Let's not touch demographics, because the “guarantor” cannot answer for it; those who can improve demographics are not citizens of the Russian Federation, and citizens of the Russian Federation have forgotten how this is done. Actually, they still remember the process itself, but they don’t know the rest, because grandmothers earn their pensions, and grandfathers also have to live to live.
            * * *
            We won’t touch anything, we’ll leave it as it is, because we can’t change anything and don’t want to. Let them continue to rule - they have already stolen.
            1. +2
              18 February 2024 11: 15
              “We won’t touch anything, we’ll leave it as it is, because we can’t change anything and don’t want to” hi
              1. 0
                18 February 2024 11: 43
                I wrote about this. Options? Revolution - well, here I will believe Putin, “Russia has already exhausted its limit of revolutions.” Revolution is a turmoil, and they will devour us there. Evolution - this is how the system cannot reform itself, examples are Serdyukov and Rogozin. Yes, their results are ambiguous, but without them there would be a swamp. Are there any other options, well, besides the arrival of aliens who will do everything for us?
                1. +7
                  18 February 2024 11: 52
                  Quote: Not the fighter
                  Are there any other options, well, besides the arrival of aliens who will do everything for us?

                  Instead of Serdyukov, any regiment commander from the reserve could be appointed. It couldn't get any worse.
                  As for Rogozin, why not him? In our country the only men are Putin, Rogozin and Dzhigurda...
                2. 0
                  20 February 2024 04: 12
                  Believe Putin and you will make a mistake
              2. +2
                19 February 2024 11: 59
                And how we will change it. After the pension reform, the Eat Russia party won the elections. Do you believe that the people unanimously went and voted for this party. Then they rewrote the Constitution to suit Putin and again went to vote together. And now whether you go or go to vote, everything is decided.
            2. -3
              19 February 2024 01: 16
              Try taking antidepressants, or at least cognac. Otherwise, everything is true, well, almost, well, not everything, well, a lot of it is complete crap. But, in general, you’re doing great.
      2. +11
        18 February 2024 12: 40
        At my work, 90% of the men, scolding and criticizing the current state of medicine, the retirement age, rising prices, etc., still try to vote for GDP and United Russia. Their real position. And okay GDP. But EdRo!!! If only not for the communists! They are worse than Hitler! Schizophrenia.
        1. +1
          20 February 2024 04: 22
          The people deserve to live the way they live now. But when he realizes that he doesn’t deserve it, then the situation will change.
    2. +10
      18 February 2024 09: 33
      And he even stopped making election promises.
      1. +1
        18 February 2024 10: 09
        Vlad, most likely he himself understood why give if they are not fulfilled, dear comrades, everything is for Putin’s elections
      2. +6
        18 February 2024 10: 29
        Well, there isn’t even an election program request
        1. +6
          18 February 2024 11: 05
          “So there isn’t even an election program”
          he had promised enough in previous years. use this for now
        2. +5
          18 February 2024 12: 46
          What the heck is the program? And so everything is PERFECT!!!
    3. -5
      19 February 2024 10: 26
      Exactly, let's raise our hands together, bow to the Anglo-Saxons and their sixes, they will bring us brand new Skodas and Volkswagens again, and we will be happy with life and watch as the neighbors begin to nightmare those who disagree with a vengeance... will this path suit you? Where do you come from, ippanushki ?
      1. +1
        19 February 2024 12: 20
        And that there are no Anglo-Saxons in the leadership of the country, the State Duma and the Federation Council. Where do all rich citizens keep their money? Who does the Central Bank work for? Here China is the world's main producer of goods and they worship the West. When the VAZ plant starts producing cars at the level of Skoda or Merc, then we will buy our cars. You probably have a computer or smartphone made in Russia and you vehemently dislike watching TV made in the countryside.
        1. +2
          19 February 2024 12: 27
          We need to think globally, who and when got us hooked on imported planes, cars and electronics, until 14, half of the food in stores was imported, agriculture was dying, the West pumped up our resources and overwhelmed us with its goodies, and everyone liked it. And suddenly bam , we were deprived of everything, but we don’t have anything of our own, it turned out that we are a colony with a consumer society, and now everyone is whining about where ours is, but no one wants to look in the mirror, it’s a shame....
          1. 0
            19 February 2024 21: 19
            Well, ordinary citizens care about global problems.
  6. +6
    18 February 2024 06: 55
    As long as Russia is ruled by Sharikovs with billions of dollars in money, nothing good awaits us
    1. +5
      18 February 2024 09: 10
      It’s okay...we’ll survive, but not everything...
      Moses led the Jews through the desert for 40 years... we have been on a rake since 91... until the age of 40 we have a little to endure...
      1. +7
        18 February 2024 12: 48
        Every 10 years, the bourgeoisie asks the Russian people to be patient for another 10 years. And so on ad infinitum.
  7. +8
    18 February 2024 07: 01
    Unfortunately, in today's Russia there is no most important thing - no patriotism and no pro-Russian ideology.
    On the one hand, there are volunteers collecting money for quads and winter clothes for our soldiers in the Northern Military District, on the other hand, Ksyusha the “horse” and the “unfortunate lolita”, who they are trying to remove from the feeding trough because of her bare ass. “Bunny Phil,” who once gave a concert in the Donbass, is almost a patriot and is being put on TV again. For what?
    The swindler and traitor Navalny suddenly becomes a symbol with the phrase “fight against corruption” (it’s not clear what, but a symbol)
    When will the Kremlin finally understand that it is necessary to fight not against “bulk”, but against corruption and corrupt officials.
    "A thief should sit in jail". And while they are sitting in the State Duma, in the government, governors and regional deputies, there will definitely be another “lily” who, under the pretext of fighting corruption, will ruin the country from the inside.
    Of course we will choose Putin. But he will finally have to clear at least the country's leadership of compromised people, talkers and losers.
    I won’t tell you for all of Russia
    All of Russia is very big...
    (Almost L. Utesov)
    1. +20
      18 February 2024 07: 08
      I haven’t cleaned it four times, you’re hoping for a fifth...how they took it for cleaning
    2. +18
      18 February 2024 07: 20
      When will the Kremlin finally understand that it is necessary to fight not against “bulk”, but against corruption and corrupt officials.
      "A thief should sit in jail". And while they are sitting in the State Duma, in the government, governors and regional deputies, there will definitely be another “lily” who, under the pretext of fighting corruption, will ruin the country from the inside.

      What should change? What prevented you from changing for the better in 24 years? Who will change? Can you name them by last name?
      1. -16
        18 February 2024 07: 29
        What prevented me from changing for the better in 24 years?

        Do you think that after the alcoholism nothing has changed? I don't agree. It has changed and changed for the better. But not all. The process must be completed. In 2014, Putin, despite the peak of his popularity, chickened out and did not disperse his “accomplices.” I hope he corrects this mistake in 2024. He probably wants to remain in people’s memory as one of the greatest rulers of Russia, and not as a “protector” of the dogs, Chubais and other Golikov-stools.
        1. +15
          18 February 2024 07: 35
          Do you think that after the alcoholism nothing has changed? I don't agree.

          What's the point of comparing with Yeltsin?
          Let's compare with 1980. How many enterprises were there in the RSFSR and how many are left now in Russia?
          In whose favor do you think the result will be?

          I am familiar with the manipulation of the low base effect.
          But Yeltsin is the center and does not interfere with anyone in the upper echelons of power.
          1. -9
            18 February 2024 07: 51
            Let's compare with 1980.

            Why since 1980 and not 1913? No need for demagoguery. It was not Lieutenant Colonel Putin who destroyed the USSR.
            He must be held accountable for his deeds and actions since 2000.
            1. +12
              18 February 2024 08: 56
              Quote: Amateur
              Let's compare with 1980.

              Why since 1980 and not 1913? No need for demagoguery. It was not Lieutenant Colonel Putin who destroyed the USSR.
              He must be held accountable for his deeds and actions since 2000.

              do not
              It was the colonels and generals of this service that destroyed the USSR
              and the lieutenant colonels carried their briefcases am
              1. -6
                19 February 2024 01: 22
                You are lying and lying deliberately and cynically. Moreover, blaming one person for all problems is stupid, and blaming those around him for plundering the country smacks of quiet envy of other people’s money and successes.
            2. +7
              18 February 2024 09: 36
              Quote: Amateur
              He must be held accountable for his deeds and actions since 2000

              Undoubtedly, we have been walking the right road for 24 years, Mr. Gaidar
              “Who needs your machines?! And if you need it, we will buy everything abroad!”
              The earth may be glassy to him, but his work lives on.
            3. +4
              19 February 2024 18: 31
              . He must be held accountable for his deeds and actions since 2000.


              Come on! Will he answer?
              Well, here's an example: 92 gasoline on January 01, 2000 cost 6-50. (On Nesta 6-70). Now 51 rupees per liter. This is 685%. We divide by 24 years of happiness and we get... we get... 28.55% on average for each (!) year. For every! By a quarter (no less!)! Every year. How many times did He say that He would not allow the price of gasoline to rise sharply? So, by a quarter on average per year, isn’t that drastic? Oh! This is stability!
              Hey! Whose salaries/pensions are growing so much? There are such?
        2. +1
          18 February 2024 12: 07
          Do you think that after the alcoholism nothing has changed? I don't agree. It has changed and changed for the better.


          What has changed for the better?

          For whom has it changed for the better?

          For 10% of the Russian population?

          According to Credit Suisse estimates, the top 10% of Russians own 83% of the total wealth of all Russian households...
          https://www.vedomosti.ru/economics/articles/2019/10/21/814324-rossii-uvelichilos-neravenstvo


          After “...Russia voluntarily and proactively went to the collapse of the USSR, believing that after this it would begin to form allied relations with Western countries..”, what changed?

          The social and political system has changed.
          During the years of V. Putin's rule, radical socio-economic reforms were carried out, which recorded the victory of capitalism in Russia.

          "In the 2000s, a number of socio-economic reforms were carried out in Russia: tax, land, pension (2002, 2019), banking (2001-2004), monetization of benefits (2005), reforms of labor relations, electricity and railway transport." (ts)

          P.S..
          Let me remind you that in 2024 the retirement age for women is 58 years, and for men - 63 years.
          1. -3
            19 February 2024 01: 25
            And you are a Decembrist and a silver-free person, are you concerned about the fate of Russia or each individual citizen who is destitute by the darkest?
            How did he personally offend you?
        3. +5
          18 February 2024 12: 09
          Quote: Amateur
          I hope he corrects this mistake in 2024.

          Your nickname matches the content of the post.
          Do you think that Mavrodi did not please anyone?
          Just don’t remember EBN again. The best side of his activity is his political clownery outside and inside.
          Changed prime ministers, tiri-tiriyam, like gloves
          And he didn’t wear, tiri-tiriyam-ta, a hat.
          He distributed the country like a foreman according to orders,
          And he drank three stars, tiryam-tiryam, cognac.
          1. -1
            19 February 2024 01: 27
            In this case, Nicholas 2 did not have the right to be the Tsar of All Rus'.
            The leader in himself is weak; what makes a king is his retinue and the faith of his people in him.
        4. +3
          18 February 2024 12: 54
          These are you who have been voting for bourgeois capitalists for 35 years in a row in the hope of social justice and equality for your children and grandchildren. This is schizophrenia. I congratulate you.
          1. Alf
            +4
            18 February 2024 21: 18
            Quote: cast iron
            These are you who have been voting for bourgeois capitalists for 35 years in a row in the hope of social justice and equality for your children and grandchildren. This is schizophrenia. I congratulate you.

            Absolutely agree with you.
      2. +1
        18 February 2024 07: 51
        There are no others, but those farther
        As Sadie once said.
    3. +8
      18 February 2024 07: 30
      "Unfortunately, in today's Russia there is no most important thing - no patriotism and no pro-Russian ideology."
      Where will it come from? If, according to the opinion and statements of our authorities, as well as the official media, “all good things” in this territory ended with Nicholas II.
      1. +2
        18 February 2024 12: 13
        Quote: Vladimir-TTT
        Where will it come from? If, according to the opinion and statements of our authorities, as well as the official media, “all good things” in this territory ended with Nicholas II.

    4. +6
      18 February 2024 11: 31
      Quote: Amateur
      When will the Kremlin finally understand that it is necessary to fight not against “bulk”, but against corruption and corrupt officials.

      When will the bees finally give up honey?
      1. +4
        18 February 2024 12: 15
        Quote: Hyperion
        When will the bees finally give up honey?

        Drones will not give up honey until their bees throw out their hives.
    5. 0
      18 February 2024 12: 53
      You fully justify your nickname. Is there not enough patriotism? And there were more than enough of Hitler’s henchmen of patriotism. The minions of Pinochet, Franco and Mussolini are also all patriots. The White movement, which fought against the Russian people together with the interventionists in 1917-1922, was also full of patriots. Proletarians can have only one ideology - communist. Any other way is gradual impoverishment, dullness and enslavement.
      1. +3
        18 February 2024 12: 57
        You fully justify your nickname. Is there not enough patriotism?

        And you are a boor and a demagogue. They remembered about Hitler and other henchmen, but for some reason they didn’t remember about the Soviet soldiers who threw themselves under German tanks shouting: “For the Motherland, for Stalin.” Do you think they are not patriots?
        1. +5
          18 February 2024 13: 31
          Yes, I'm rude. A simple proletarian. Who knows quite a bit of history. Unlike such a non-rude person like you. You won't get far on patriotism alone. You might not even go there at all. Examples in history include a carriage and a small cart. You especially can’t get away with patriotism, brought up by the bourgeoisie to solve their financial affairs. Vaughn, Ivanovets in Ukraine, every second Nazi is a patriot to the core.
        2. 0
          19 February 2024 01: 30
          I'll upset you - everyone is patriotic, it's just that true patriots end up only on the side of e
          winners. For the “correct” history is always written by the winners. But over time, victories are forgotten and the vanquished hire lawyers and Jesuits to rewrite history.
    6. Alf
      +3
      18 February 2024 21: 10
      Quote: Amateur
      When will the Kremlin finally understand that it is necessary to fight not against “bulk”, but against corruption and corrupt officials.

      By yourself, or what?
      Quote: Amateur
      Of course we will choose Putin.

      Well, yes, the king is good, the boyars are bad.
      Quote: Amateur
      But he will finally have to clear at least the country's leadership of compromised people, talkers and losers.

      From those whom you appointed and whose work you are satisfied with?
    7. 0
      19 February 2024 15: 30
      Victor, do you live on the moon? corruption is our form of governing the country, the fight against it is a coup d'etat
  8. -1
    18 February 2024 07: 13
    From the January sociological surveycarried out by foreign agents, it follows that only a quarter of the country's population has savings exceeding their monthly income, all the other three quarters do not have such savings, or they do not exceed their monthly income.
    Samsonov Alexander - are you registered as a foreign agent? And why?
  9. -5
    18 February 2024 07: 31
    The photo attached is good - I’m dying of laughter right now!
    Just 5 days ago I saw people vomiting on the Munich metro...
    White-skinned people are already afraid to go down there.
    I was traveling home to St. Petersburg in transit through Moscow - I breathed through my mouth and was not afraid...
    PS
    Yes, I don’t know - maybe in some Krivohrenoovka it’s like this, as in the photo...
    1. +4
      18 February 2024 10: 19
      I saw people vomiting on the Munich metro
      That is, in comparison with the splattering of the foreign metro, the collapse of the state is a trifle? Everything is fine, here in Munich the barn is full, the cow has died. Do you want it like in Munich?
      White-skinned people are already afraid to go down there.
      Are there signs in Uzbek and Tajik in Munich? If not, it's a mess.
      1. Alf
        +5
        18 February 2024 21: 27
        Quote: Bolt Cutter
        If not, it's a mess.

        But there is already one in Moscow.
  10. -29
    18 February 2024 07: 32
    The tone of the article is simply defeatist. How did she get here? "Everything is gone, the plaster is being removed, the client is leaving, grab the bags - the station is leaving, AAAA! We are all going to die!!!!" Aren't you tired of whining? All countries have their own problems, there is no heaven on earth! If Russia didn’t perish under Yeltsin, then it won’t perish now!
    1. +26
      18 February 2024 07: 43
      the population continues to become poorer and shrink. This is not whining but reality.
      1. -29
        18 February 2024 07: 44
        I'll believe you when you sell your computer.
        1. +11
          18 February 2024 07: 47
          like when everyone becomes homeless
          1. +9
            18 February 2024 12: 59
            He will check when his children are thrown out onto the street as a whole family due to arrears on their mortgage. Then he will believe in something. In the meantime, he’s sitting in his grandmother’s house and everything is fine for him.
        2. +12
          18 February 2024 07: 49
          Maybe you’ve settled down somewhere and that’s why your tail is a pipe, but from the point of view of a working peasant, a small entrepreneur, an employee, the situation is difficult and continues to get worse.
          1. -28
            18 February 2024 07: 54
            Well, okay, I agree - we're all going to die. Everything is bad, as usual.
    2. +8
      18 February 2024 07: 59
      Quote: Tail pipe
      If Russia didn’t perish under Yeltsin, then it won’t perish now!

      That’s how we are now under Yeltsin... Right according to the Soviet slogan: “Stalin is Lenin today.” Just rearrange the names, but the essence has always been the same....

      Yes! There are people who, just like in Soviet times, firmly believe that everything is done for their benefit. Even when the population is declining and business is thriving, only funeral services... My relative got a job as an orderly at a morgue. He says, “The money is terribly high! You can start building a cottage in an elite village.” laughing
    3. 0
      18 February 2024 12: 58
      That's right! Don't whine, but take the children to church to see the priest. Not to school, but to the priest. There are still fewer schools than churches! So let's win!
    4. -1
      19 February 2024 01: 36
      "tail pipe" They kick you for not being hysterical. People live by faith in the West and "everything is lost", throwing mud at their country and insulting their opponents.
  11. -31
    18 February 2024 07: 52
    I am amazed at how inadequate people can be! The question is, what are you missing? Remember how there were queues for cars, televisions for distribution, the most “rich” decoration - a carpet on the wall! Is anyone starving now? Well, go to Europe or India, there is probably heaven on earth! We are just getting out of Yeltsin’s “democracy”! Apparently, it’s hard to hammer the keyboard, not to carry the bags...
    1. +14
      18 February 2024 07: 56
      India, despite all the difficulties, is developing and not degrading; this is a fundamental difference, I’m sure you can feel it yourself.
    2. +12
      18 February 2024 08: 17
      Is anyone starving now?

      They are starving. Pensioners. You either pay for housing and communal services or buy food.
      You probably don’t know, but the Russian Federation is 1/8 of the land area. We have all the resources we need in our depths. And the economy is 1.5% of the world.
      How to deal with this?
      We cannot produce the machines and cars required for precision. By the way, the average income of a citizen is 48 thousand. rubles, and the cheapest car, even without airbags (in 2024), costs about 1.5 million rubles. Loan from 18%, because the Central Bank rate is 16%.
      So if this is happiness in your opinion, then in the opinion of the common man, this is a sure move towards disaster. Simply because there is complete mismanagement represented by the state and a lack of understanding of the internal economic situation within the country.
      1. -24
        18 February 2024 08: 23
        The pension, yes, is not enough. And the pension reform itself is some kind of creepy Frankenstein. We all want changes for the better to happen every day throughout our lives, but it doesn’t happen that way! It can be destroyed in an instant, but it takes a lot of work and time to build. However, constantly frustrating is not the solution!
        1. +8
          18 February 2024 08: 28
          It can be destroyed in an instant, but it takes a lot of work and time to build.

          It couldn’t be destroyed in an instant, it took 33 years. But the ruling elite of the Russian Federation is already close to this.
          Please tell me by what percentage the housing and communal services funds are worn out? During your life in the Russian Federation, have you seen large-scale modernization (relaying of pipes) of housing and communal services?
          1. +3
            19 February 2024 09: 44
            Quote: Sergey_Bely
            But the ruling elite of the Russian Federation is already close to this.

            By the way, yes. For the first time in Russia, KamAZ lost its leadership to the Chinese Sitrak truck. Over the year, sales of KamAZ fell by 22%, and sales of Sitrak trucks, on the contrary, soared by 49%, Autostat found out. Chinese brands now control more than 60% of the country's truck market.
            Quote: Sergey_Bely
            Please tell me by what percentage the housing and communal services funds are worn out?

            PJSC T+, owned by Vekselberg, still transfers profits offshore. Production facilities are not just deteriorating - they are crumbling from old age.
        2. +11
          18 February 2024 09: 33
          laughing wassat what Yeltsin was in power for less than ten years. And your Putin is already over twenty. However, for some reason, now after the elections he promised to bring in more migrants and carry out privatization. He didn’t say anything about the people.
        3. +2
          18 February 2024 11: 42
          “However, constant frustration is not the solution!”
          well, yes, we live for a thousand years, why not wait, 50-70 years, maybe it will be better?
      2. -2
        19 February 2024 01: 41
        Oh, don’t be a jerk, my parents are pensioners, they pay their utilities well, they eat and manage to save a little. In other matters, maybe you have some special poor pensioners, so give me the coordinates, I’ll personally go and help.
        Oh, these storytellers with their fabulous tales.
    3. +10
      18 February 2024 08: 59
      Quote: Tail pipe
      I'm amazed at how inadequate... The question is, what are you missing? Remember how they stood in lines for cars, TVs were distributed, the most "

      There are no “inadequate” people at all. You can only be adequate or inadequate to something. You should remember the Stone Age....
      In the USSR under Khrushchev, it was funny to compare with 1913. And now it’s normal to compare with Brezhnev’s stagnation. Although both are 50 years apart. In addition, the Yeltsin peace period is similar to the war.

      If we compare correctly, the international rating of quality of life has decreased. From 1989 in the USSR (place 26) to today in the Russian Federation (place 60+)...
    4. +5
      18 February 2024 10: 21
      Well, go to Europe,
      They don’t let me in, it would hurt more in percentage than from Lithuania and Latvia. Half of VO would have a geyropa while sitting in Dublin or Hamburg laughing .
    5. 0
      18 February 2024 10: 42
      “I don’t take bribes, I feel bad for the state!” - customs officer Vereshchagin.

      It's not lacking, but it could be better.
      The question is how to do this?
    6. +3
      18 February 2024 11: 40
      “Remember how in the queues for cars there were TVs for distribution, the most “rich” decoration - a carpet on the wall! Is someone starving now?
      As I understand it, the main thing for you is to fill your stomach, and it doesn’t matter in what country and under what system. but besides eating, as now, people built Dnieper hydroelectric power stations, magnetic stations, and the same VAZ and KAMAZ. it's left for decades, and you're the one finishing it now. What are they building now, besides human health centers, shopping centers and pedicure rooms? what have you personally built, and what have you personally done for the country?
    7. +2
      18 February 2024 18: 36
      Don't drive nonsense. I calmly went to the store and bought the TV.
  12. +3
    18 February 2024 07: 55
    Several years ago, Dmitry Vasyukov made four documentaries "Happy people. Yenisei. Spring. Summer. Winter. Autumn." Everything there is without embellishment, but also without “everything is lost.” I recommend watching it. What I mean is that people there themselves, and immediately after the Soviet regime, they realized that you can’t get everyone into business. By the way, not all engineers or other “intellectuals” were very sad when Soviet power collapsed and factories began to exist. Many of them were even secretly waiting for this, they say, well, now we are all these workers from our plant who receive the same salary, well, we will show them who is who... and they rushed into business. Some enjoy selling junk at bazaars, some carry clothes from Turkey, some opened shops with icons for sale and then ended up with a “long nose.” So I repeat once again that you cannot drive everyone into business. And whoever understands this is no longer unhappy. By the way, if those from the banks of the Yenisei are resettled in the article by advertising “awarded” rich people to St. Petersburg, Moscow, Krasnodar, or even to Krasnoyarsk, then in half a year they will die without this archaization indicated in the title of the article. They will not die from it, but without it.
    Of course, the influx of migrants from the “sunny republics” may, if this happens, “remake” the happy people on the Yenisei into unhappy ones...
    1. -2
      19 February 2024 08: 24
      not a few years, but a decade and a half or two ago... and then there wasn’t much skepticism here on topvar either... and then there was a series 10 years later - and in it there were already remnants of those people who lived differently and saw the world differently .
  13. -27
    18 February 2024 08: 02
    The main sign of a Russophobe is his anti-churchism. The conciliarism and Orthodoxy of the Russophobe burns from the inside. For example, this article definitely included something about churches! And it doesn’t matter that not a single church has opened on the site of the school, it doesn’t matter that not a penny from the budget has been spent on this - we need to cry! “Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravenous wolves. By their deeds you will know them.”
    1. +14
      18 February 2024 08: 08
      the main sign of a narrow-minded person is his churchliness
      1. -19
        18 February 2024 08: 14
        The main sign of a narrow-minded person is labeling without reasoning. Getting personal due to lack of arguments. Intolerance to other people's opinions. Poor erudition.
        1. +7
          18 February 2024 09: 38
          Quote: Tail pipe
          The main sign of a narrow-minded person is labeling without reasoning. Getting personal due to lack of arguments. Intolerance to other people's opinions. Poor erudition.

          Are you “distant”? Take, for example, the trumping of cars.... Nowadays there is a lot of all kinds of auto junk, even in Africa.
          In the USSR, from 1960 to 1980, car production doubled every 10 years. And passenger car production grew even faster because AvtoVAZ was launched in the early 70s. Now he gives the same 400 thousand a year as under Brezhnev laughing
    2. -16
      18 February 2024 08: 21
      I completely agree with you. The Orthodox Church is a bone in the throat for all Russophobes. By the way, there are not so many beautiful palaces in Russia, but there are thousands of beautiful monasteries and beautiful churches.
      You can’t stop looking at the Golden Ring alone. And how many are there throughout Russia? This is why conciliarity, collectivism, and communalism infuriate the Russophobe so much. There is a fist in them, and all he needs is spread fingers... By the way, the fact that in today's Russia they have begun to drink much less alcohol is also a merit of today's Orthodox Church...
      1. +3
        18 February 2024 09: 23
        Quote: North 2
        .. By the way, the fact that in today’s Russia they have begun to drink alcohol much less is also the merit of today’s Orthodox Church...

        It is difficult to say whose merit lies. If the “Soviet” praises the USSR, it is supposedly because “the girls were young back then,” and if the “Anti-Soviet” scolds the USSR, this means that the official data cannot be trusted...

        Nevertheless, according to official data, which is not disputed today, alcohol consumption in the USSR before the start of the Second World War and until 1950 was 2-3 liters per person per year. In 1970 - 8 liters, in 2000 16-18 liters, and now it is declining. And explain what is the merit of the Russian Orthodox Church here?
      2. +5
        18 February 2024 09: 38
        Have you lovers of Orthodoxy noticed how many mosques are being built?
        1. +1
          19 February 2024 12: 58
          Why your question, Gardamir? To the fact that Orthodox Christians should show intolerance towards other people's faith, or to the fact that other people's churches are being built on Christian soil?
          If the first, then I don’t want to answer. And if the latter, then we both understand the reason for these buildings - the indigenous people are betrayed by the authorities, betrayed and spat upon, without rights, poor and powerless. So now, should we also worry about mosques? Let them build: maybe there they will teach the animals that have come in large numbers something good.
          1. +1
            19 February 2024 13: 59
            Second. Alas, they are taught there to unite against the Russians.
            1. 0
              19 February 2024 15: 27
              They have it written in the Koran: “Do not make your friend either a Jew or a Christian.” I read it myself. request
      3. +4
        18 February 2024 09: 53
        What don't you like about the modern Russian Orthodox Church? The fact that under the modern “power from God” the number of Russians is decreasing, but under the “God-fighting government” it has been growing. And what happens? That after 1991 God got down to business because no one bothered Him, and began to put pressure on the Russians? So what?
        1. -8
          18 February 2024 20: 00
          The power from God was under the king. Then the population grew by leaps and bounds. Under the Soviets, the population grew very little (not comparable to tsarist times) only in the last Soviet times. There is no need to call modern government the power of God. Democracy is not from God. “Democracy is in hell, but the kingdom is in heaven” is a well-known phrase of the rights. John of Kronstadt. Do not be deceived by the loyalty of the clergy to modern rulers. The clergy are always loyal to any authority, whether from God or from people. For politics is not the business of the church.
          1. +1
            18 February 2024 21: 44
            I think that the clergy are not loyal to any authority, as you write, but they take the position that all authority is from God. However, sometimes the Lord allows such power to punish the people that the people become bitter, for the people have forgotten God. The Old Testament says a lot about this.
          2. 0
            19 February 2024 07: 49
            Under the tsarist “power from God” - the Republic of Ingushetia fought through three wars in a row, from the consequences of the third and collapsed (well, and from the “divine” power that brought the country to ruin).
            The population lived in the majority either in poverty or in poverty, the average life expectancy of adults was 4-45 years, the country was a leader in infant mortality, in mortality from infectious diseases, but at the same time extremely backward technologically, but one of the leaders in the economy thanks to sales resources and low value-added goods - raw materials, grain, cast iron, timber, and so on. Well, at that time, many peoples and states, not only the Republic of Ingushetia, were rapidly increasing their numbers. However, it was under the USSR that not only the total number of Russians increased, but also the duration and quality of life of ordinary people.
          3. +1
            19 February 2024 11: 46
            Quote: Shchelokov Yura
            Power from God was under the king

            Did you have a revelation from God about when what power? I see...
            Only there is a synodal translation of the Bible from Greek into Russian, made in the 19th century. And it says that any power is from God. I somehow trust the MDA professors of the 19th century more than the current “wise men” of the 21st century.
        2. 0
          19 February 2024 10: 23
          Extinction began in 1964, when the TFR fell below replacement level at 2,2.
          So even under the USSR, 27 years before the collapse, they could not do anything.
          1. +1
            19 February 2024 11: 48
            Quote: Petya Kuzmin
            Extinction began in 1964

            There was no extinction, and in the 80s the birth rate increased. You should at least look at modern charts. There is a clear turning point in 1991.
      4. +1
        18 February 2024 18: 54
        Quote: north 2
        By the way, the fact that in today's Russia they are drinking much less alcohol is also a merit of today's Orthodox Church...

        Heh, is it because they stopped selling wine? Like the Monastic Hut?
    3. +7
      18 February 2024 09: 03
      The main sign of a Russophobe is anti-Soviet in the spirit of Hitler's leaflets.

      By the way, Russians existed even before the adoption of Christianity, although I am not against Christianity.
    4. +12
      18 February 2024 09: 14
      You are deeply mistaken about the fact that not a penny comes from the budget! A huge number of grants come from both the budget and joint programs from government organizations! Most of the churches and monasteries are owned by the state and a significant part of the maintenance burden is borne by the state! And the buildings themselves are in perpetual use by the Russian Orthodox Church!
    5. +9
      18 February 2024 09: 22
      The city of Minusinsk is an example for you. For the bicentenary, the restoration of the Spassky Cathedral was financed from the budget! And the restoration of the Church of the Ascension! Regarding the last church, here is the previously officially announced information - **An electronic auction for repair and restoration work has been announced, applications for participation are accepted until November 9. A contract for 119 million rubles will be concluded with the contractor, the source of financing will be funds from the regional budget. The work will be completed in the spring of 2023.****
      1. -2
        18 February 2024 20: 02
        Yes, the state pays for the restoration of architectural monuments and this is normal. But the state does not build new churches; they are built by rich people who have nowhere to put their money. And this has been the case throughout all centuries in all countries. Ordinary people cannot afford such construction projects.
        1. +3
          18 February 2024 20: 09
          Transneft is an example for you! 100 percent state owned! So why is he building churches in Moscow and not only???? Let me ask again: why is a state company doing this???
    6. -4
      18 February 2024 11: 02
      According to these statistics, schools in Russia are being replaced by church institutions. Thus, as of 2022, there were 41,9 thousand churches in Russia, and 39,9 thousand schools.

      How can you write such nonsense? ....Where and how did children start going to “church institutions” instead of schools? What kind of institutions are these - does anyone know? And what city has more churches than schools? Please name it. Are mosques counted separately or together with churches? .....Nonsense.
    7. +5
      18 February 2024 13: 03
      Well, the obscurantists have appeared in VO. Soon everyone will be judged by a church court :)
    8. +7
      18 February 2024 17: 32
      not a single church was opened on the site of the school, no matter that not a penny from the budget was spent on it
      Oh really? Are churches “within walking distance” built solely on donations from believers? The Russian Orthodox Church entered the budget with both feet, just as it did more than 100 years ago. But this is what it turned OVVAUL (Orenburg Flight School), which Gagarin graduated from, into. Now there is a seminary there.
      1. Alf
        +3
        18 February 2024 21: 51
        Quote: Aviator_
        But this is what it turned OVVAUL (Orenburg Flight School), which Gagarin graduated from, into. Now there is a seminary there.

        Not only.
        1. +2
          18 February 2024 23: 00
          I might also add how they use famous photos.
  14. +5
    18 February 2024 08: 16
    In modern Russia it has always been like this, in the 20s it was a little better, now it’s worse. The so-called “damned liberals” have been talking about this for 10 years. I don’t share their views, but it’s stupid to argue with reality. Now the refrigerator is starting to win over the TV. Do you know how the West can win this confrontation? Just wait. In 15-XNUMX years, our country will become uncompetitive simply because there will be practically no people left here.
    1. +5
      18 February 2024 08: 20
      In 10-15 years, our country will become uncompetitive simply because there will be practically no people left here.

      Yes, you are still an optimist. At this rate of degradation, we have about 7 years.
  15. -2
    18 February 2024 08: 24
    The only way out is new industrialization, the restoration of basic industries (for example, civil aircraft manufacturing, shipbuilding, automotive manufacturing, engine manufacturing, etc.). Development of the domestic market. Financial autarky from the West. Take all the best that was in the USSR. It will be difficult, and we will also have to “tighten our belts,” but at least this will preserve the state and the people. There will be prospects for growth.

    Well, the author is right to some extent. There is poverty, but where is it not? Even in the USSR there were poor people. Lonely pensioners with small pensions often live in poverty. Of course, they are given some kind of benefits for which they still need to go to institutions. On the other hand, people somewhere were sitting on a small salary or did not work at all and did not think that they would be pensioners.
    Yes, the village is almost dead. Those who remained were mostly pensioners. However, the process of villages dying is typical for all countries with the transition to industrial development, including the example of the US capital showcase. Accordingly, rural schools, of which there were many, are dying.
    And the fact that we will have to tighten our belts is certain: the war, the upcoming and already real industrialization. What do you want? It’s time to stop using petrodollars in Turkey and the UAE. And we need to introduce higher taxes on higher salaries. For example, with salaries of more than 100 thousand. How to finance the war?
    1. +12
      18 February 2024 09: 01
      Well, the author is right to some extent. There is poverty, but where is it not? Even in the USSR there were poor people.

      There were no working poor in the USSR. and now if you work at an enterprise and have 2 children, then you are 99% poor, and maybe even a beggar.
      1. -4
        18 February 2024 09: 56
        There were no working poor in the USSR.

        Well, in the USSR everyone was working, except for pensioners, of course, some single people had a pension of 54 rubles, which was not even a lot. There were also single women with children who lived in poverty. Our trade union department annually allocated significant financial assistance to such people. So, no need to blah-blah about poverty in the USSR. Now, of course, there are poor people, especially those with children. I do not argue. But there’s another question: the poor don’t have enough for food or the poor don’t have enough for a child to buy a fairly expensive smartphone.
        1. +4
          18 February 2024 10: 00
          There were also single women with children who lived in poverty. Our trade union department annually allocated significant financial assistance to such people. So, no need to blah-blah about poverty in the USSR. Now, of course, there are poor people, especially those with children. I do not argue.

          I wrote about two-parent families with two working parents.
          And it is precisely this kind of poverty that confuses me.
    2. +3
      18 February 2024 10: 14
      Quote: Alexey Lantukh
      For example, for salaries of more than 100 thousand.

      This is nothing, since this is the salary of just a qualified specialist or a more or less successful small businessman. It should be introduced for the export of raw materials in order to make the export of high-tech goods profitable, it should be introduced for money transfers abroad, business benefits should be tied to investments in domestic patent developments - the more a business has invested in domestic patents, the more tax benefits it can receive.
      It is necessary to stimulate the high-tech private military-industrial complex from small firms, medicine and rehabilitation, through measures of tax-free production and import abroad for those things that are used in the Northern Military District.
      1. -8
        18 February 2024 10: 22
        Based on the results of 2022, the average salary in Moscow is 122
        [Quote] [/ quote]
        This is average, and for many it is much higher. And overall this is a lot of money. And there are already high duties on raw material exports.
        1. +3
          18 February 2024 12: 39
          “This is average, but for many it is much higher.”
          ok then how laughing !
          But for the majority, even in Moscow, it is much less. unless, of course, their last name is Volodin, and not Volodin’s mother
        2. +7
          18 February 2024 13: 43
          This is very funny. It’s just as funny when Rosstat seriously states that the average salary nationwide 77 rub. I laughed for a long time when I found out this information.
          1. +3
            19 February 2024 01: 55
            I looked at my income for the last 3 years, the average is 77, for 22 it was 85, for 23 -80.
            Although I know people with a salary of 35 who have apartments, garages, and a couple of cars.
            I remember an old joke - I get 200, my wife gets 150, every month we save 400, and we live on the rest.
        3. +2
          18 February 2024 14: 06
          Quote: Alexey Lantukh
          And overall this is a lot of money.

          Labor (wages), even in labor-intensive industries, occupies an insignificant place in the cost structure.
          But it is possible to create an artificial demand for intellectual technical property - tie all sorts of government subsidies to the purchase of domestic patents and technologies and such property, introduce threshold minimums for the ownership of domestic patents, especially for non-productive sectors, such as banking. Introduce incentives for collective ownership of such property for economic and tax agents to ease their burden. At first, in the first years, such demand will be artificial, but then a market will form. - and this is much better than boiling cast iron for every household according to the well-known Chinese recipe for industrialization.
          It is advisable to limit the possibility of patenting foreign owners of such property - only if it is joint in a significant proportion with us and there are domestic centers for its scientific development.
          1. 0
            19 February 2024 13: 45
            tie any government subsidies to the purchase of domestic patents

            The main thing for our patent office is to receive the fee. Sometimes you come across such patents that your hair stands on end.
            cook cast iron for every yard

            “In every yard” you can’t smelt cast iron; at best, you can’t smelt cast iron.
    3. +3
      18 February 2024 13: 45
      Increased taxes per hundred square meters? Are you laughing? 1000 dollars. There shouldn’t be such a salary at all, it’s a stipend at best.
  16. +6
    18 February 2024 08: 26
    Here in the comments they write about fish, I’ll add it myself. In Chukotka, red fish is also running out. The people of Sakhalin and Kamchatka caught their fish and now their seiners and trawlers are fishing the shores of Chukotka.
    1. +6
      18 February 2024 12: 09
      Quote: AlexisT
      Sakhalin and Kamchatka residents caught their fish

      It was not we who caught it, but the Muscovites who cut out all the spawning rivers... Last year I drove along the east coast - all the rivers were blocked and the crane was standing scooping fish... There are no more fish on the west coast...
      1. 0
        20 February 2024 00: 31
        You caught it from yourself, now you’ve got your hands on us. The home port is visible on the Internet map of sea vessels. Muscovites don’t know how to fish, they just pinch off fish.
        1. +2
          20 February 2024 02: 35
          Quote: AlexisT
          Muscovites don’t know how to fish,

          They even know how to do it - in troubled waters!
  17. +4
    18 February 2024 08: 31
    . The share of people without savings fluctuates consistently around 60%,

    It would be fine without savings. They are also accredited!

    . Plus problems with converting native currencies like Indian rupees.

    And some consider calculations in local currencies to be a breakthrough. They say that the dollar has already been won!
  18. +3
    18 February 2024 10: 29
    Yeah... Based on the comments to the article, you can open a bunch of criminal cases for libel of something or other.
    Especially if someone compassionate from the forum members sends it to the right place
    1. +3
      18 February 2024 11: 01
      Heh.... heh.... according to a long-standing tradition, there is nothing more pleasant for a Russian person than to imprison another Russian under some “Russian article”..... I was once threatened with prosecution under the Criminal Code by one.... So I later guessed from indirect evidence that he was a monk in a monastery and carried out educational work on the forum.
      The Kingdom of Heaven is earned..... laughing
    2. +7
      18 February 2024 11: 08
      Covering the shit on the carpet with a nice tablecloth doesn't change the fact that the shit is still there and it stinks. Let's continue to pretend that there is no crap and no problems. On March 17, 120% of the votes for a famous person and all our worries and problems will disappear.
      1. -1
        19 February 2024 02: 01
        I would gladly vote for another strong candidate with support, a program and hope for its implementation. But, let’s be honest, there are no options. Supporters of the “honest” Navalny and Nemtsov, leave the dead alone, there are no leaders of the level of Trotsky, Stalin, early Brezhnev. The Darkest and for me personally, the irreplaceable best option with a guarantee of victory in the SVO, then we will look at the receiver.
      2. +2
        19 February 2024 10: 13
        Don't lie, not 120%, but 146%. Why the hell did he think of lowering the percentage of trust?
  19. 0
    18 February 2024 12: 09
    It's always like this with us. As soon as a lot of money accumulates in a country, it immediately begins to stir up some kind of adventure. It’s true, it’s better if oil is at 50. Everyone calm down. wink
  20. -8
    18 February 2024 12: 10
    Holy shit! I read the comments here on this dung article, who offended you so much. the poor fellows have already eaten the last one without salt, they only have money left for the Internet winked
    The country is in such a “hellish” state that people for the most part don’t even notice that the country is at war, they continue to live for their own pleasure, shake the cloud from your eyes, although it is useless for you instead of a brain.
    1. +4
      18 February 2024 13: 27
      Here's another man without a brain. I understand that you don’t feel sorry for yourself and your children. At least have pity on strangers.
    2. +3
      18 February 2024 17: 26
      Quote: core
      The country is in such a “hellish” state that people for the most part don’t even notice that the country is at war, they continue to live for their own pleasure, with

      Question How much do you earn?
    3. -5
      19 February 2024 02: 02
      Bravo, first sober comment.
    4. 0
      21 February 2024 18: 13
      These comments are most likely either from the “bortsuns” or from the “Zaluzhinskys” with TsIPSO in the mix. We sang in a friendly choir. In Soviet times, most engineers knew “Parkinson’s laws” and were familiar with the research of Peter and others. Gradations of lies in accordance with these works: lies, big lies and statistics! You have to disrespect yourself to believe statistics with an unknown method of data collection, an unknown array of subscribers, an unknown or little-known company that published the “statistics.” And “foreign agents” generally have little faith: they are enemies not only of the Russian state, but also of Russian society, as well as the Russian everyday way of life. We must trust our own common sense, the surrounding reality, our “peasant logic.”
  21. +4
    18 February 2024 12: 20
    The enormous stratification of the population is a consequence of Yeltsin’s coup d’etat, the restoration of capitalism and Chubais’s privatization.
    Despite the increase in the standard of living of serfs associated with scientific and technological progress, income stratification will only increase, and class contradictions will intensify. This is the fundamental contradiction of capitalism between the social nature of production and the private capitalist form of appropriation, which cannot be smoothed out by any handouts from the master’s table.

    As long as the Russian Federation possesses all the resources existing in nature in an almost unlimited amount, the collapse of the so-called. There will never be a raw materials model of the economy, because large capital always flows into the least expensive industries with the greatest profits, and it is always easier to take something ready than to create something.

    Religion is one of the pillars of the ruling class and, in a way, is itself a co-ruler of the ruling class, and therefore there is nothing surprising in the penetration of religion into all spheres of public life.

    “It is obvious that in such a situation the Russian Federation and the Russian world as a whole have no future”

    The Russian Federation includes Republics that have national characteristics and language, their own constitution, elected and executive authorities, territorial power structures, military and other insignia - practically the Russian Federation is a union state formation similar to the USSR.
    In contrast to the Constitution of the USSR, which back in 1936 and until its collapse provided for the possibility of the Republics separating from the USSR.
    As J.V. Stalin once said, the USSR is a Voluntary Union of Equal Republics. To exclude from the Constitution the article on the right of free secession from the USSR means to violate the voluntary nature of this union.
    Law is the will of the ruling class, elevated to law. By the will of the ruling class in the New Constitution of the Russian Federation, the right of republics to secede from the Russian Federation is excluded
    Based on a hypothetical assumption, if there were a coup in the Russian Federation similar to 1991, there would be no peaceful outcome - the Constitution prohibits it.
    1. 0
      20 February 2024 21: 55
      Territorial power structures in the republics of the Russian Federation are under federal subordination; in most republics, the leaders of these structures are not their residents or natives. You should also keep in mind that only about 18 percent of the population of the Russian Federation lives in the republics. And more than half of them are multinational and (or) with a predominance of Russians.
  22. +7
    18 February 2024 12: 48
    Quote: Sergey_Bely
    The NWF's liquid assets remain for 1,5 years.

    In 2024, it is planned to spend 800 billion rubles from the National Welfare Fund. Of this, 400 billion rubles are for the construction of an LNG production plant in Ust-Luga for Gazprom. Those. National Welfare Fund funds are spent to increase the export of minerals. This is all you need to know about using NWF funds. Although, if you consider that, as the advertisement assures, Gazprom is a national treasure, then where else to spend money from the NATIONAL WELFARE FUND.
    1. -4
      19 February 2024 02: 07
      The state spends the money of the National Welfare Fund exclusively in its own interests. And the investment, being an asset, will bring profit, load the gas transportation system, provide work for thousands of people. Will the plant be built or are you against the construction?
  23. +1
    18 February 2024 12: 53
    Dear author, in 30 years our population will end
  24. +8
    18 February 2024 13: 01
    During Brezhnev’s time, few people were happy... Even Makarevich and Pugacheva, as it later turned out in hindsight, protested “against the regime”...
    But if Leonid Ilyich had lived another 10 years in some more or less capable state, at least without changing much, the SGA and its allies would have quite realistically gotten into trouble.
    These were the trends of the economy.
    But zealous reformers came and quickly brought about such a situation that the USSR and the Eastern European socialist camp collapsed, and the West received another 20 years due to expansion, robbery and absorption.
    So now the situation is even more acute both for the West and for us, and all processes have run an order of magnitude faster.
    And for them a lot depends on the top officials, but with us everything depends on them!
    And I wouldn’t want a repeat of the Andropov-Chernenko-Gorbachev-Yeltsin chain, only compressed from eight years then to two or three now.
    It doesn’t mean that everything is good and correct with us, we’ve made mistakes - it’s up to generations to sort things out.
    But now the war, who will win, is much wider than Ukraine, the Middle or Far East, the Arctic or outer space.
    It is almost species-specific - Neonderthals or Cro-Magnons, with the disappearance and absorption of the losers.
    Let's not allow ourselves to be devoured - the enemy will die of hunger, or grind on a meager diet, become a herbivore and peaceful with a separate intestinal section for digesting grass.
  25. -7
    18 February 2024 13: 14
    The future of Russia: poverty and archaization

    TsIPSO also writes articles here.
  26. -1
    18 February 2024 13: 24
    Or maybe there are more churches and schools? All our schools are open, not a single one has closed. The rural ones are closed, but it’s not profitable; it’s easier to bring the children to the city by bus.
  27. +1
    18 February 2024 13: 29
    In most countries of the world, not among the richest (Norway, Switzerland, Sweden, etc.) and the poorest (Somalia, Bangladesh, etc.), people basically live like this - from paycheck to paycheck. For example, in prosperous Spain, with an average salary of 2000 euros per month, you have to pay 20% for taxes, many pay off their mortgage, this is still about the same, if so, that leaves 1200 euros per month or 120 thousand rubles in our hands. Products in Spain are cheap, but fuel, energy, and utilities are not at all. Even for the Internet you pay 60 euros per month. Nothing much remains. They are saving up for a vacation, although Spain itself is a huge resort. Of course, if you are a university professor or a dentist or an army officer, your salaries will be higher. But many Spaniards work for 1,5 thousand and hold on to their jobs. In the richest countries the situation is more interesting, but how many countries are there? But the poor are silent, and so everything is clear. Russia is somewhere in the middle, of course things could be better, but compared to the USSR - if you are over 40 and honest - in the USSR the vast majority also lived from paycheck to paycheck, there is no need to force it, you need to work.
    1. +4
      18 February 2024 13: 45
      In the richest countries the situation is more interesting
      In England the minimum wage is 1700 pounds per hand.
      1. +4
        18 February 2024 18: 08
        And our president said that 17 thousand is correct.
      2. -2
        19 February 2024 02: 11
        Yeah, but the rent for an apartment is 1000, and it’s far from the center. Plus a communal apartment. Don’t transfer THEIR money into rubles, they receive and spend without converting into rubles.
        1. +4
          19 February 2024 09: 29
          apartment rental 1000
          if not in London, keep it to 700. And this is the minimum wage - no one is stopping you from earning more.
      3. -3
        19 February 2024 07: 43
        Quote: Bolt Cutter
        In the richest countries the situation is more interesting
        In England the minimum wage is 1700 pounds per hand.

        Well, there are all sorts of corresponding expenses. In general, I don’t know a single country where the population would have large savings; this is generally not good for the economy; it results in a “non-working” money supply, the size of which is unknown.
        1. 0
          19 February 2024 09: 44
          Well, there are all sorts of corresponding expenses.
          If not in London, then it’s enough for housing, food and Spain once a year.
    2. +11
      18 February 2024 13: 51
      Be honest, in 1991, half of the citizens of the USSR had their savings in their savings books reset to zero. And the savings amounted to several thousand per person. My grandparents, being simple workers and employees, each accumulated from 3 to 10 thousand rubles in savings books. And all this was reset in one day. So there is no need to tell fairy tales here about how some drunks lived from behind to behind and extrapolate this nonsense to the rest of the working Soviet people.
  28. +6
    18 February 2024 13: 32
    Dear author, over the past 30 years, as a result of liberal-bourgeois “reforms,” our population has finally become divided in relation to privatized property and the bulk of OUR citizens do not own any market-valuable small and medium-sized production, engineering, infrastructure and agricultural property. That is, in fact, in addition to old wallpaper, a rusty car under the window, a garage and a house in the village, it received a “donut hole”! People, simply, are poor or beggars who do not have ANY economic, and therefore political, interests. Since there is NOTHING to protect or develop and there is NOTHING to cooperate with and NOTHING WITH ANYONE. The financial policy of the regime of the dominance of private property is strictly aimed at protecting and promoting the interests of large commercial capital, financial usurers and commercial speculators. What kind of “autarky” are you writing about? Where does it come from? Who will be the subject of such a social production revolution today? When, over the course of these 30 years, science-intensive and high-tech industrial production, scientific, technological and design schools, and support and service infrastructure were SYSTEMICALLY destroyed. Which of those bastards of the party, economic and Komsomol nomenklatura, who in the 90s stole the country, property, savings, and mineral resources from their own population, is capable of such radical SYSTEMIC actions to revolutionize the legal relations between the forms of private property and the state? Do you really think that they will raise their own enemies THEMSELVES? And even if today, among them, there is such a group of people, don’t they understand that for 30 years of robbery and theft of the country, and a conveyor belt of crimes against their own population, they will bear serious responsibility? So what incentives and reasons do they have to revolutionize this situation?
    There was a period in my life when I worked in Moscow. And one “old” Soviet specialist once told me in a conversation that thieves, swindlers and bandits will NEVER become responsible owners.
    1. -4
      18 February 2024 20: 44
      Quote: Oleg Plenkin
      That is, in fact, in addition to old wallpaper, a rusty car under the window, a garage and a house in the village, it received a “donut hole”!

      Well, why lie and twist like that? What does old wallpaper hold on to? That's right - on the walls of the apartment. Quite comfortable. (A friend of mine in Holland has single-strand glass, a friend in Paris has a winter temperature of 19 degrees). How many people have a house in a village (dacha) in England, France or even the States? What about the garage? Who has? The old car has long been replaced by a foreign car or the same Chinese one. Stop whining! No one has been building houses of less than two floors for a long time. And not from plywood, shit and sticks as in the USA, but more and more they strive to build from brick and timber. Maybe they live better in Israel?
      1. +4
        18 February 2024 21: 38
        No one has been building houses of less than two floors for a long time.
        The average Russian has 28.2 square meters of living space, while the Briton has 39.7 square meters.
        The old car has long been replaced
        The average age of a car in Russia is 14.7 years, and in England it is 10 years. In Britain, by the way, there are 1000 cars per 600 people, and in Russia there are 396.
        a friend in Paris, the temperature in winter is 19 degrees
        He who doesn't work doesn't get warm.
        1. -3
          19 February 2024 02: 15
          Do not confuse “at disposal” and “in ownership”, these are very different concepts.
          1. +2
            19 February 2024 09: 32
            , these are very different concepts.
            Both cost money. But I cited this fact to clearly show that not everyone has two-story houses in Russia as a whole.
      2. +8
        19 February 2024 02: 23
        Is your comment for idiots?(((The property I listed for the vast majority of the population of Russia is a SOURCE OF COSTS, and not a SOURCE OF INCOME! Even if you, for example, rent out an apartment, drive a “rusty car”, and live in a “house” in the village", under the conditions of the dominance of large private commercial property, you will not get out of poverty. Yes, you will not be a beggar, but you will never be able to become a petty-bourgeois political middle class influencing the economy, and especially politics, in a direction favorable to you !THE POPULATION WHO DOES NOT HAVE MARKET VALUABLE COLLECTIVE PRODUCTION, ENGINEERING, INFRASTRUCTURE AND AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY, HAS NO INTERESTS AND INCENTIVES TO PROTECT IT, HAS NO DEVELOPMENT PROSPECTS, THAT IS, AS A POLY THE ECONOMIC SUBJECT HAS NO FUTURE!Look around and don't talk nonsense!
  29. -9
    18 February 2024 13: 51
    Well, I don’t know, but I’m happy when former shopping centers are converted into new production facilities. Haven't you tried to work about becoming poor? There are not enough workers. Aren’t you tired of the mantras about the Western market yet? Western Europe has all blown away, following Germany and France into recession.
    1. +5
      18 February 2024 13: 55
      Western Europe is all blown away
      Oh Shlomo, yes, yours was just like hiss. tongue .
      1. -7
        18 February 2024 16: 15
        I understand there is nothing to object to wink
        1. +5
          18 February 2024 16: 17
          to object
          Eat. Europe and Europeans live quite well, the horrors from the Russian media are exaggerated, and no one is going to switch to bread and water with splinters. To believe otherwise is, at the very least, stupid.
    2. +9
      18 February 2024 14: 33
      They really tried to work. Housing prices are flying so fast that even if you work hard, you’ll be able to put a credit noose around your neck... So there’s no need for us to tell bourgeois fairy tales for idiots about “working more.”
      1. -10
        18 February 2024 16: 14
        housing suddenly unexpectedly even now can be obtained from the employer
        1. +7
          18 February 2024 16: 18
          receive from the employer
          When signing a general regime contract?
          1. +8
            18 February 2024 19: 07
            Quote: Bolt Cutter
            When signing a general regime contract?

            But why? Strictly it is also possible.
        2. +2
          18 February 2024 20: 58
          We've had capitalism for 34 years now. The issuance of apartments remained in the USSR. Well, and perhaps in your inflamed mind.
  30. +2
    18 February 2024 14: 14
    We are already confidently surpassing America. New regions will give an unprecedented new impetus to development. And it’s not far off and Europe will work for us!
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 02: 17
      Your irony will not be appreciated. But what if you are right?
  31. +3
    18 February 2024 14: 47
    Everything is lousy. And nothing will change, because the poorer the people, the more actively they support the government. Paradoxical but true.
    1. +5
      18 February 2024 14: 52
      The poorer the people, the more actively they support the government.
      That's not the point. It has been explained to me more than once during serious cabbage soup that the standard of living in Russia is above than in the USA and Western Europe. So people are just sure that everything is fine.
      1. -6
        18 February 2024 16: 17
        not higher yet, but excuse me how the situation is deteriorating there, how the middle white class is being killed there for the sake of LGBT leftists. There won't be enough fat for a long time. San Francisco and beyond have turned into open-air drug dens. Do you not have this or will you argue?
        1. +4
          18 February 2024 16: 20
          San Francisco and beyond have turned into drug dens
          My wife's relative lives there. Doesn't complain. The fact that there are drugs on a couple of streets in the local ghetto is a problem, but not the end of the world.
          There won't be enough fat for a long time
          How long has imperialism been rotting and the dollar collapsing?
          killing the white middle class.
          Was he at least given the opportunity to appear in Russia?
          1. -6
            18 February 2024 16: 27
            They could at least change the manual. Well, yes, communism, after all, blacks can come in and take what they want wink
            1. +2
              18 February 2024 16: 29
              and blacks can come in and take it
              You clearly get your information exclusively from Russian media.
              1. -2
                18 February 2024 17: 06
                Yeah, you don't happen to be that officer's daughter. And by any chance, your wife’s relatives are not in Los Angeles, for example? Or in Paris? And so there is such a YouTube and there in the English segment there are videos about how everything is beautiful, a beautiful marquise in AI and even chew your butt
                1. +3
                  18 February 2024 17: 10
                  Quote: Maxim
                  Yeah, you don't happen to be that officer's daughter.

                  Are you by any chance the daughter of that officer?
                  1. -6
                    18 February 2024 17: 16
                    Well, judging by everything, it’s so ambiguous it’s hard not to recognize. So they accepted the budget and didn’t ask the wife’s friends? How did they find smart builders with the construction of the STM plant? Did you defeat all the bugs in Paris? Is GDP growing in Russia despite the sanctions, or are you going to argue? Russia has overtaken the USSR in nuclear reactor production
                    1. +8
                      18 February 2024 17: 18
                      Quote: Maxim
                      Well, judging by everything, it’s so ambiguous it’s hard not to recognize. So they accepted the budget and didn’t ask the wife’s friends? How did they find smart builders with the construction of the STM plant? Did you defeat all the bugs in Paris? Is GDP growing in Russia despite the sanctions, or are you going to argue? Russia has overtaken the USSR in nuclear reactor production

                      I didn't understand a damn thing.
                2. +3
                  18 February 2024 21: 27
                  Or in Paris?
                  My wife was born and raised in Paris. And since I lived in London for quite a long time, I worked in a travel agency, I have friends and acquaintances of 30-odd nationalities, and - thanks to Mordoknigems - we are in touch.
  32. +2
    18 February 2024 15: 11
    The only way out is new industrialization, the restoration of basic industries (for example, civil aircraft manufacturing, shipbuilding, automotive manufacturing, engine manufacturing, etc.). Development of the domestic market. Financial autarky from the West. Take all the best that was in the USSR. It will be difficult, and we will also have to “tighten our belts,” but at least this will preserve the state and the people. There will be growth prospects

    It seems like the author described everything beautifully. Pathetic. I drew a bold letter “E”. Only he didn’t put an end to it - he didn’t describe how to carry out this very “new industrialization” and other proposed great achievements and who will lead this process! Who will tighten whose belts and build financial autarky? That is, there is a proposal, but there is no mechanism for implementation.
    1. -2
      19 February 2024 02: 24
      Change is only possible when 80 percent of the population wants to work for bread, warmth and clothing, plus some money for entertainment. There is no other way. The history of industrialization of the USSR, the pre-war rise of Germany, China with its “economic miracle”. While you are riding a crossover , you go to a barbershop and are interested in the dollar-ruble exchange rate, it is impossible to force you to work for the benefit of society, and not for your own.
  33. +2
    18 February 2024 15: 31
    Quote: Nikolay Malyugin
    Walking around the city, I see a lot of idle shops, workshops, and some kind of services. These are rented premises. And what’s interesting is that they haven’t been open for years. What kind of business is this? After all, there are probably hundreds of them around the city. And how many houses in which no one has lived for a long time?

    There is a REVOLUTIONARY situation in the country. And this, let me tell you, is not irony or sarcasm!
    1. -3
      18 February 2024 20: 49
      Quote: Vlad Baryatinsky
      There is a REVOLUTIONARY situation in the country

      On whose face?......literate, you, ours.
      Quote: Vlad Baryatinsky
      And this, let me tell you, is not irony or sarcasm!

      Really. I confirm. That's bullshit.
    2. -2
      19 February 2024 02: 27
      When there are crowds of hungry and homeless people on the streets, then there will be a revolutionary situation, and when you talk about investing in crypto, plan a vacation to Turkey and complain that your car will soon be 10 years old, a revolution is impossible in principle. While the majority of the bourgeoisie is the proletariat or the underground has left or become bourgeois.
  34. 0
    18 February 2024 15: 35
    Quote: Andrey Moskvin
    If you voice their fortunes in rubles, people will grab their pitchforks at such figures.

    It is high time !!!
    1. -1
      19 February 2024 02: 30
      I support, tomorrow I suggest you buy pitchforks in Leroy. Or is it better to order delivery?
      Until you howl from hunger and powerlessness, looking at your hungry, grimy children, you only remember the pitchforks.
  35. +2
    18 February 2024 16: 36
    If we take into account that the form of government in our country is autocracy, then everything falls into place. One of the conditions for the stability of autocracy is the partial isolation of society to concentrate power, but there is one BUT - the economy is developing poorly. The Soviet Union is proof of this. Therefore, we have what we have.
    1. -9
      18 February 2024 17: 03
      Yeah, Russia's GDP in terms of PPP has overtaken countries 7. There is a recession in Germany, and then in France. Would you at least change the manual, it’s pathetic, it’s pathetic
      1. +6
        18 February 2024 17: 34
        The presence of a recession in European countries does not in any way deny stable GDP in the Russian Federation. Our sustainability rests on the resources the country trades. More expensive oil means more GDP. Other sectors of the economy do not develop at the same time. except perhaps those related to the military-industrial complex. There is probably no need to discuss investments anymore.
        An interesting article on this topic from 2015 in Forbes
        https://www.forbes.ru/forbes/issue/2015-10/300433-kak-vyzhivayut-avtokraty
        1. -11
          18 February 2024 17: 45
          They forgot to change the manual again. In Russia, GDP growth is not due to raw materials, but production, if that. How do you respond to the fact that Russia produced more nuclear reactors than the USSR?
          Rosatom's mechanical engineers built five sets of reactors in a "conveyor" mode: this is almost twice the USSR record. But this is just the tip of the iceberg of achievements. “KP” reveals what other victories are hidden in the most technologically advanced (and secret) industry in the country.

          Read on WWW.KP.RU: https://www.kp.ru/daily/27597/4869663/
        2. +5
          18 February 2024 20: 44
          Don't trust Forbes, Bloomberg, etc. They write to order
  36. -8
    18 February 2024 17: 02
    Katz suggests surrendering? If you criticize, suggest we listen to the author’s suggestions. But there is no peace in the whole world. But I think the author has nothing to offer because they immediately stuff him with a Panama hat
    1. +4
      18 February 2024 17: 45
      I don’t know how it is in developed countries, but when you look at the size of the minimum wage, questions inevitably arise.
      1 if the wage is minimal obviously and the work corresponding to it should also be minimal or what?
      2 is there a connection between the minimum wage and poverty?
      and if legislators mean something else by minimum wage, then where does wages come from?
  37. +1
    18 February 2024 17: 50
    I don’t know who interviewed whom, but among my friends and acquaintances everyone has savings, accumulations, nest eggs.
    “Everything is lost, Russia is dying” - this reminds me of something.
    There are millions of idiots who grabbed loans and are now hiding from creditors or giving everything they earn to banks, there are many lumpen people who have never worked anywhere, but successfully take money from microfinance organizations and banks, there are many single mothers living on child benefits. And all this people who don’t have savings. Statistics are a tricky thing, how and who you count, that’s what will come out.
    1. +2
      18 February 2024 18: 41
      This is a class .... it turns out that more Russians are born than die and the number of people has been growing for three decades? Or does having a nest egg and savings change this conclusion?
    2. 0
      19 February 2024 23: 55
      Should we focus our statistics on your less wealthy 25-30 acquaintances and friends? Powerful! But I have examples before my eyes when a pensioner, who has worked honestly all his life, after paying bills, housing and communal services, tariffs and pills, somehow scrapes together a rather simple grocery basket. You have to save up for clothes and shoes... I’m talking about those who have no relatives. There are many of those.
  38. -1
    18 February 2024 20: 04
    The author mentioned the church clearly out of place.
  39. +2
    18 February 2024 20: 12
    If you think that everything is bad here, but everything is good there (in the West), this is a mistake. I will give two examples. A friend of mine went to Greece for permanent residence in 2009 and was happy at first. And the business opened, and the weather is fabulous, and this and that. As of now, the business has closed because it has become unable to pay bills. He had two shops, and when the electricity bill exceeded 900 Euros, he quit. This is in addition to taxes, etc. The second example is Portugal. A retired lieutenant colonel (I know him from his service in the UN mission) wrote that he survives at the expense of his summer cottage. The plot is large, he grows a lot of things and saves money. Otherwise, kaput! This is Portugal, which we threatened to almost overtake. He almost burst into tears when I brought him a jar of caviar as a gift...
    1. -3
      18 February 2024 22: 44
      Unfortunately, such information is apparently not listed on VO. But neo-Bolshevik anti-state propaganda is quite appreciated. Even during the most difficult and dangerous (for the country) military operation. It's like a "naked party", only Marxist. Apparently fantasies about the USSR 2.0 are necessarily associated with 1917 2.0, which is why they are pouring grist into the enemy’s mill, trying to cosplay the Bolsheviks into the First World War, criticize the only horse and do this precisely at the crossing.
      1. +1
        19 February 2024 23: 52
        Communist propaganda has not changed during all 34 years of “blessed capitalism” in Russia. If there were no black marketeers and speculators at the helm, then such a situation with Ukraine might not have happened at all.
      2. 0
        21 February 2024 11: 06
        Quote: Shuridze
        Even during the most difficult and dangerous (for the country) military operation.

        Are you kidding me? Vladimir Vladimirov said that we haven’t started anything yet.
    2. +5
      19 February 2024 00: 25
      You chose the poor countries of Europe. But if the facts stated in this article are true, then Russia is on another level. The West has also become poorer. But for them, this often means they will only go on vacation to the Caribbean once this year. Of course, on a global scale, the situation of rich countries has worsened. But their standard of living began at a completely different level than the Russian one. NATO countries are arguing about whether to spend 2-3% of GDP on weapons. Russia will give away 40% of its budget this year!!! Are you really sure that the money will not be lost? And most importantly, all the positive growth indicators of the Russian economy stem from the production of weapons. This industry will employ the majority of workers. How will their return even happen? And will there be somewhere to return? And besides, those contracts of army companies are paid from money that should go to health care, schools, infrastructure. I am sure that in Greece there are no such problems.
  40. +5
    18 February 2024 21: 12
    Alarming article. Although there are no conclusions. What should I do? This is the notorious domestic market - when will it be? And where does it come from, if the author himself writes that most people have no money?
    The author kept silent about one more problem. People still need money. And if they are not there, then what happens? People are starting to take out loans. And in order to pay off one loan and buy something else, they take out another. Once the limit comes, there is nothing to pay. No matter how much you scold banks for robbing the population, they, too, will someday accumulate a critical mass of “rotten assets”, and they will crumble. And this is a financial crisis.
    Okay, they take it from banks, but banks don’t give it to everyone. The gray and black market for “quick money” is flourishing, and this is already a crime.
    Regarding industrialization. When will it be? Especially in conditions when they do it not so that it is “good”, but so that it is “beautiful”?
    Further. Considerable funds are being poured into the restoration of new territories. But if the money goes there, does that mean it doesn’t go to other projects?
    And no one is talking about “pinching the oligarchs,” cutting salaries and entertainment expenses. Where will the money come from? What should I do?
    1. 0
      19 February 2024 23: 49
      What to do? Print rubles in trillions and collapse the ruble exchange rate against international currencies
  41. -3
    18 February 2024 21: 17
    By the way, a question about churches. Why do they grow? Does the state give money for them?
    They collect it themselves. So people bring them money? The latter will certainly not be tolerated.
    So, after all, people’s money isn’t so bad?
    Let's stop carrying money to church! There will immediately be fewer of them
  42. 0
    18 February 2024 22: 52
    Quote: Silhouette
    On whose face?

    Not yours.
    After all, on the sole...
  43. +1
    18 February 2024 23: 16
    reform: education, health care. Industry optimization. University graduates: managers, lawyers, economists. 1991, to turn a bolt with a non-standard thread, at the “neighbor’s garage”, now there is a lot of searching where and how, on CNC the hundredth time it may work... to restore something to working condition is still a “quest”. consumables for operating equipment are a problem. “managers” simply don’t understand what is needed, “they thought” they bought it and then you can work with it as you want. and the fact that the “purchase” did not bring any benefit other than a kickback into their pockets is not their problem. It's you who don't know how to work and think creatively =(
  44. The comment was deleted.
  45. The comment was deleted.
  46. 0
    19 February 2024 00: 03
    There will also be enough tanks and missiles. The GDP growth curve is doing well. A classic way to solve everyday problems that we cannot solve. The enemy is found and named as the culprit, and suddenly a bigger problem than poverty arises.
  47. +1
    19 February 2024 00: 16
    Question for the audience, in which countries is such an effect observed, such as the opening of more and more schools, with a general decrease in the birth rate, taking into account the fact that the need for them was satisfied 30 years ago?
    And now I’m not talking in general about individual growing areas and cities where such a thing can happen, but about the country as a whole?
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 23: 46
      Attention question. How does the increase in the number of churches correlate with the overall decrease in population in the country? Fewer people mean more churches? I don't see the logic.
  48. 0
    19 February 2024 05: 29
    It is obvious that in such a situation, the Russian Federation and the Russian world as a whole have no future. Hence the demographic catastrophe - people do not see a future for the country, for their families and for their personal future. The people are dying out and are being replaced quite quickly by migrants.


    It would seem that everything is lost and there is no way out. Nevertheless, it exists!

    The only way out is new industrialization, the restoration of basic industries (for example, civil aircraft manufacturing, shipbuilding, automotive manufacturing, engine manufacturing, etc.). Development of the domestic market. Financial autarky from the West. Take all the best that was in the USSR. It will be difficult, and we will also have to “tighten our belts,” but at least this will preserve the state and the people. There will be prospects for growth.


    The way out is outlined schematically and in full accordance with the traditions of the USSR, incompletely, and therefore unrealizable. Industrialization alone is not enough. Industrialization leads to extinction, whether you like it or not. This is a fact confirmed by the industrialized countries of the West. You cannot concentrate on one thing, even if it is extremely effective, to the detriment of regional farm agriculture and local small-scale production. Only the priority preservation of local production to ensure the local market will solve the problem of depopulation. Large retail chains should be given the conditions for priority acquisition of goods and services indirectly on the local market. It's slow, it's not easy, but it's necessary and there are no options. The transformation of the Moscow region into Moscow is most likely a mistake. Instead, it was necessary to distribute the ministries among the regions, thank God the Internet exists, and create a decentralized system of government.
  49. +1
    19 February 2024 05: 38
    Quote: kepmor
    It’s okay...we’ll survive, but not everything...
    Moses led the Jews through the desert for 40 years... we have been on a rake since 91... until the age of 40 we have a little to endure...

    Well, I think Moses was with his people, and also experienced all the “delights” of the Sinai desert laughing laughing .
    For some reason, our “Moses” hid behind the Kremlin wall, in state dachas and private estates, and fenced themselves off with the FSO. So you can lead people forever! bully bully hi
  50. +2
    19 February 2024 07: 38
    What a strong smell of elections, perhaps the smell of rain, or perhaps freedom.
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 17: 29
      Subtle humor, not everyone appreciated
  51. -2
    19 February 2024 07: 41
    As for schools, I disagree. Enlargement occurs: the successful ones absorb the unsuccessful ones with the absorption of buildings and structures. From the point of view of income, people themselves are to blame, because they do not know how to work for themselves, do not know how to organize themselves and take responsibility for themselves; decades of Soviet power and appropriate education have an impact on this. It is useless to wait for a good uncle.
  52. +1
    19 February 2024 07: 41
    Quote: Weezle
    Question for the audience, in which countries is such an effect observed, such as the opening of more and more schools, with a general decrease in the birth rate, taking into account the fact that the need for them was satisfied 30 years ago?
    And now I’m not talking in general about individual growing areas and cities where such a thing can happen, but about the country as a whole?


    But for some reason, schools and kindergartens continue to open in new areas, contrary to statistics
  53. -1
    19 February 2024 07: 48
    Quote: Oleg Plenkin
    POPULATION THAT DOES NOT HAVE MARKET VALUABLE COLLECTIVE PRODUCTION, ENGINEERING, INFRASTRUCTURE AND AGRICULTURAL PROPERTY

    Theoretically, it resembles the USSR, but where is there such a thing now?
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 10: 45
      In the USSR, the above property was nationalized, and in the 90s it was privatized and corporatized. I wrote about petty-bourgeois socialization, that is, about the nationalization of property. In the Soviet Union, the structures of such petty-bourgeois socialization were “Stalinist” artels, which were later destroyed by the nomenklatura. Today, the “growth points” of nationalization are cooperatives and various forms of collective private property, in which qualified specialists THEMSELVES build “squirrel cages” of joint businesses and run them themselves, without working for the “bald guy.”
  54. -1
    19 February 2024 07: 52
    Quote: Weezle
    Question for the audience: in which countries is such an effect observed, such as the opening of more and more schools, with a general decrease in the birth rate?

    Theoretically, according to our ideas, the birth rate should increase in the rich and prosperous West, but this is not observed there either; it turns out that the cosmically high standard of living also does not contribute to the same birth rate. And countries where the birth rate is rising can hardly afford the corresponding number of schools.
    1. 0
      19 February 2024 08: 04
      PS: In our own region, schools have not been closed for a long time; mainly in our time it was in the 90s - the beginning of the XNUMXs, during the period of mass abolition of settlements that had become unpromising. Currently, existing schools are being renovated and new ones are planned.
      As for the first wave of liquidation of populated areas during the period of Khrushchev’s consolidation of farms, this was only for the better; the population gained access to full healthcare, education and, in general, the benefits of civilization. In enlarged villages, most of which have survived to this day, it became possible to create full-fledged hospitals instead of first aid stations, at best in remote areas. Infant and maternal mortality rates decreased rapidly and significantly. This generation now, which has not even seen the 90s, is “nostalgic” for life “in the lap of nature”, without leaving the warm sofa in a comfortable apartment/house.
      1. 0
        19 February 2024 08: 10
        PPS: on the topic of the article, I successfully farmed myself likes and ratings on a long-closed local portal, within a week I rose to first place in the rating by a large margin. It was closed due to the impoverishment of the population, which is now unable to afford either devices for Internet access or payment for access.
    2. -1
      20 February 2024 03: 42
      Quote: Corvair
      Theoretically, according to our ideas, the birth rate should increase in the rich and prosperous West, but this is not observed there either; it turns out that the cosmically high standard of living also does not contribute to the same birth rate.


      The "rich, prosperous Westerner" is a myth. For the sake of a cup of coffee and relaxation at a resort, people in the West are forced to work from morning to night. They do not have time for their wife and children. Caring for a child is an unaffordable expense of money and time for the vast majority. Almost all kindergartens are paid and the prices are serious. Kindergartens and schools are usually open from 9:00 to 3:00. In fact, a mother or wife in such conditions becomes permanently unemployed after childbirth, or one salary is completely spent on paying for after-school care, in kindergarten and school. There is no free food either. So a Westerner can only be envied in the movies.
  55. +1
    19 February 2024 07: 55
    Nonsense, not an article. Starting with the fact that, according to some foreign agents...
    What do schools and churches have to do with it? What the hell is this replacement? Has a church opened in at least one former school building? What does the author of the article smoke?

    Further to the point. Ok, exports have decreased. And overall GDP has increased. This is despite the SVO, sanctions and other shocks.

    The article is a big minus. And the author would like to take a walk around the country.
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 10: 37
      Quote: ButchCassidy
      What do schools and churches have to do with it?

      Moreover, it has “nothing to do with it” only if churches are built exclusively with donations from believing parishioners. According to the apostolic teaching. https://www.vedomosti.ru/politics/news/2019/01/15/791422-aven-neproduktivnimi
      Peter Aven, chairman of the board of directors of Alfa Bank, said that huge investments in sports and church are not productive compared to investments in school and science.
  56. +2
    19 February 2024 08: 22
    Quote: Mishka78
    As a result, the family is very happy, because they killed a worthless drunk

    First of all, he was a soldier. And what kind of person he was - it’s not for you to pass a verdict from the sofa.
  57. +1
    19 February 2024 08: 32
    The number of churches certainly does not affect the number of schools. The effect of a low base, with the collapse of the union. There will also be a decline further. Moreover, few people go to church, no more than 1%. Most times at baptism, other times at unction.
    1. -1
      19 February 2024 10: 30
      Quote: Petya Kuzmin
      The number of churches definitely does not affect the number of schools

      In a state where the church definitely does not receive money from the budget...... Whether he actually receives it or not - this is indicated by the position of the church authorities in relation to the state and the common sense of citizens who can estimate how much the mass construction of schools and churches costs.....
  58. +2
    19 February 2024 09: 07
    “Plutocrats and oligarchs who sell off the people’s wealth, including food and agricultural raw materials, will become even richer.

    The only way out is new industrialization, the restoration of basic industries (for example, civil aircraft manufacturing, shipbuilding, automotive manufacturing, engine manufacturing, etc.). Development of the domestic market. Financial autarky from the West. Take all the best that was in the USSR. It will be difficult, and we will also have to “tighten our belts,” but at least this will preserve the state and the people. There will be prospects for growth."

    Two consecutive paragraphs in which the second contradicts the first.

    In fact, if a system remains in which plutocrats and oligarchs sell off the people's wealth today, then why shouldn't they subsequently sell off the results of industrialization?

    If the domestic market develops successfully, then why don’t the same oligarchs appropriate all the profits of this market?

    If the oligarchs are ours, domestic, then what will independence from the West give the people?

    To take all the best from the USSR, you need funds; will the oligarchs really give them?

    The author talks about the poverty of the population, and immediately suggests tightening our belts even more. For what? To allow the oligarchs to earn even more? Or is he suggesting that the oligarchs tighten their belts? Actually, let him try, of course...
  59. -2
    19 February 2024 11: 15
    The author seems to not know the history of our country. The decline of villages and the entire province in the 60s somehow correlates with the beginning of the anti-church campaign launched by the state.
    1. +3
      19 February 2024 11: 25
      with the beginning of the anti-church campaign launched by the state.
      Rather, with an increase in labor productivity in agriculture.
  60. 0
    19 February 2024 11: 38
    An article to cheer up the depressed West. They say without us Russia will die of hunger laughing
  61. The comment was deleted.
  62. 0
    19 February 2024 14: 00
    obvious information manipulation

    There is more and more information (moreover, reliable information), but there is less and less understanding of the overall picture... We live in interesting times! ))
  63. +1
    19 February 2024 17: 17
    Here are the Canadians: Almost half (49%) of respondents said they have no savings for an emergency, with 53% relying on their next paycheck. So it’s another nonsense, all ordinary people have problems
  64. 0
    19 February 2024 17: 18
    There’s one thing I don’t understand: why the hell did they drag statistics on built churches here? Are they preventing someone from studying or taking away bricks from schools under construction? Believing citizens chipped in and built themselves a temple, what’s the problem? Should they have chipped in to build a school instead of the regional budget???
    1. -2
      19 February 2024 18: 10
      If “they chipped in for the temple,” then why didn’t they chip in for the hospital and school? Is everyone just breaking into the temple every day? Maybe it’s like that for you, but it’s not like that for us.
      Has it ever happened that they chipped in for the hospital, but didn’t chip in for the temple? What country do you live in anyway?
      1. -1
        19 February 2024 19: 09
        I live where people (suddenly) don’t have enough hospitals, but doctors. Less-than-qualified personnel fled to commercial medical centers for standard salaries.
  65. -1
    19 February 2024 17: 50
    Here are the people who have been missing out ((Everyone is so poor that they eat the last damn thing of salt, and in the courtyards you can’t crowd with new cars, the resorts are also sold out, in Thailand there are already more of ours than locals... But they keep whining and whining. Bulk in action ?
    1. +1
      19 February 2024 18: 24
      1. Read about what % of Russian citizens have a foreign passport, and then talk nonsense about how the “resorts are crowded.”
      2. Do you live in the USA? I personally live in the Moscow region, and for 5 years in a row, even official statistics literally scream that the market for new cars is heading into the abyss. And he really flies.
      3. The fact that a couple of thousand Russians are hanging out in a resort town in Thailand does not mean anything at all. Even before the Maidan, Muscovites with an apartment from their grandmother had a theme of renting out an apartment in Moscow and living in Thailand or Indonesia.
  66. -1
    19 February 2024 18: 38
    They forgot to add Islamization.

    In general, the result of Putin’s shameful policy is obvious
  67. +2
    19 February 2024 21: 30
    The Communist election campaign has begun.
    The article is an excellent example of it.

    Ukrainians will also like it; UNIAN could easily take it and post it on its portal.
  68. 0
    19 February 2024 21: 40
    Quote: ivan2022
    Moreover, it has “nothing to do with it” only if churches are built exclusively with donations from believing parishioners. According to the apostolic teaching.

    I apologize wildly, but what still confuses you?) What country are you broadcasting for? For Russia? This is how Prince Vladimir the Red Sun planted faith in Russia. And during the synodal period, who was the Synod subordinate to? To the Emperor. And in Soviet times, how many temples, built with public money, were destroyed and how many buildings and structures were built on the site of the temples? And why does it bother you that, for example, the Moscow Government subsidizes the restoration of churches? Or what?

    What about Peter Aven, maybe it’s better for him to explain for Latvian synagogues, and not for Russian churches? Because he is a citizen of Latvia, lives in London, and according to his mother, he is the most Jewish. So what do I care about his opinion about the churches?)) You won’t believe it, but no
  69. 0
    19 February 2024 22: 10
    All this religious heresy leads only to the degradation of the population. Instead of these churches and mosques, it would be better to build planetariums, schools, colleges and institutes.
  70. 0
    19 February 2024 22: 44
    Dear compatriots! A person will never be satisfied with what he has. You always want more. This is psychology and this is normal. The country is large, each region has its own characteristics that have to be taken into account. The easiest way is to blame Putin. But we must understand that he cannot personally check the work of every official. He is guided by the reports of the relevant officials. He needs to control different groups in the country that are lobbying for their interests and trying to present information from the right angle. The volume of his work is enormous; not everyone is able to withstand such a load even at a younger age. Don’t forget what kind of ass he pulled Russia out of after Yeltsin. Anyone who has managed even a small team knows what it is to work with people. There are many unresolved internal problems, but the West will definitely not solve them for us. This was clearly shown by the SVO. They see in us only a submissive raw material appendage. Their rotten ideology has deeply penetrated our society. We don’t respect ourselves, we are losing our roots. I believe that we live better every year. More and more young people live in separate apartments, have cars, and travel abroad. Our ancestors never dreamed of this. Yes, they steal during the construction of houses, roads, and sports facilities. But they are being built and people are taking advantage of it. Do you think they don’t steal in the USA or in Europe? You read various corruption stories about them. The budget is being cut with a bang. Those who want to study and work earn normally. And whoever whines in the kitchen and blames the authorities for everything lives accordingly. And the honest and all-knowing one is the one who has no opportunity to steal anything and who has not really tried to do big things. In words everything is easy, but in reality it is not. Therefore, let's love our country, starting from our entrance, our yard, our city and village. Start with yourself. Don’t give bribes, don’t steal at work, study the laws and fight boorish and thieving officials. Difficult? Yes! There is no other way. Until we begin to educate the correct majority in society, nothing will happen. Good luck and patience to everyone in building a prosperous Russia.
    1. -1
      19 February 2024 23: 15
      Dear compatriot, we live in a bourgeois-capitalist country, which in terms of industry and the number and variety of jobs lags quite far behind some large countries in the world. Comrade Putin is just serving the ruling class. And our ruling class is the bourgeoisie. The main goal of the bourgeoisie is the constant increase in capital. And it doesn’t matter at whose expense. All this ultimately leads to collapse, wars and civil war. One of the great options is fascism. You have a lot of patience. Future fascists at the helm of Russia will need very patient people.
  71. +1
    19 February 2024 23: 39
    What does this have to do with churches and education???? Well, you’re not a believer - and you didn’t touch on this topic. My child goes to a secondary school at the temple, they have one religion lesson a week. But ALL children say hello to adults and I have never heard swearing there. As for the economy, we should have thought about this in 91, Comrade Samsonov and others like him, where were they in December 1991, building barricades?? In the current realities, what he wants is North Korea, let him first live there and then advise.
    1. +2
      20 February 2024 10: 25
      And without any religious lessons, my parents taught me to greet adults and give up my seat on public transport. Paradox.
      As in North Korea, it will not work in Russia. Too different conditions. North Korea is a very small, mountainous country, where there are not as many resources and opportunities as in Russia. Therefore, they have to save on everything.
    2. +2
      21 February 2024 09: 30
      if your child “doesn’t swear” and “says hello” because he goes to Sunday school, then these are questions for you
  72. kig
    -1
    20 February 2024 05: 45
    Meanwhile, in the neighboring galaxy:

    By the end of 2023, the number of 5G base stations in China exceeded 3,37 million, and the total number of 5G communication service users reached 805 million people. China has built the world's largest fiber optic network and mobile broadband Internet access network, with 5G coverage covering 80% of the country's villages.

    There were 474 million holiday trips in China during the holidays.

    China intends to use more than 18 billion cubic meters of unconventional water resources in 2024

    During the holidays, the average daily turnover of online payments in China reached 1,25 trillion yuan

    China's C919 passenger plane made a test flight in Singapore on Sunday in preparation for the upcoming air show.


    It could be exactly the same with us. And even bigger and better. If. In the meantime:

    Sustainable development of China-Russia relations in the right direction - but which side is it correct?
  73. 0
    20 February 2024 16: 05
    The “pipeline economy” does not need educated people, but it does need an illiterate herd.
  74. -1
    20 February 2024 19: 52
    Here's a squiggle... ©
    Are we waiting for the next PMC? Because the current leadership of Russia has led the country to a dead end. The country lacks the most important thing (if you believe the Marxists-Leninists). Basics. Basis. There is no production of means of production. After all, you cannot build an industrial state on the export of energy resources and wheat. The well-being of individuals is possible. And it does not seem possible to change the leadership of Russia (I hope there are no people here who fall into sacred indignation at the mere words about it?) by a “legal” way. Because, don’t be fools, it eliminated these very “legitimate” paths. And from the “illegal” there is a 300-strong National Guard.
  75. 0
    20 February 2024 22: 38
    Given such an objective situation in Russia, questions arise: What next? Who is guilty? and What to do? These are eternal Russian questions. With the country's presidential elections just around the corner, another question arises: Who to vote for? Which way should Russia develop further? What kind of system will give the long-awaited powerful leap in economic development? What kind of system will inspire people to re-industrialize the country? Topical questions, but there is only one answer - SOCIALISM.
  76. 0
    21 February 2024 00: 02
    Why are you so, you know, a bit gloomy? If the Russian Federation in the 90s was always called a “poor country,” now the status has changed to “a country of neat poverty.” Progress, cones - Christmas trees! And “himself” once said that the “average Russian” is the one who has an income of 17 thousand rubles per month. Life, let's grow above ourselves! tongue
  77. 0
    21 February 2024 09: 28
    Thus, as of 2022, there were 41,9 thousand churches in Russia, and 39,9 thousand schools.

    very tight, everything is as it should be
    otherwise give them school
  78. 0
    21 February 2024 10: 56
    The existing oligarchic-bureaucratic system has led Russia to virtually complete collapse, economic, demographic, social...
    The upper classes cannot and do not want to change anything, and the lower classes have come to terms with the complete hopelessness of the current situation...
  79. -1
    22 February 2024 04: 27
    But on TV they show that “milk yield is increasing, the harvest is gigantic and the chickens will soon begin laying golden eggs.”
  80. 0
    22 February 2024 11: 49
    Quote: edatlt
    We take the car only once a week to the store, and in the summer on weekends to the dacha

    a taxi is much more profitable during such auto racing - a personal car is a member of the family with considerable demands and not everyone can afford it for pensioners
  81. +1
    22 February 2024 19: 01
    State standards for the minimum wage and subsistence level, their values ​​and ratios strictly document that genocide of the population is an official state policy.
  82. 0
    22 February 2024 21: 44
    Poverty is good! (WITH)
    :)
  83. The comment was deleted.
  84. +1
    2 March 2024 17: 30
    Until a state monopoly on foreign trade and a progressive tax are introduced, at least in the French style: up to 70%, then everything will be so.
  85. 0
    Yesterday, 18: 26
    Quote: Shuridze
    You won't be able to turn the 1917

    Are you going to stop history?