Alexander Menshikov. The beginning of a long journey

35
Alexander Menshikov. The beginning of a long journey

Alexander Danilovich Menshikov is one of the most grandiose figures of Peter the Great’s time, rich in strong personalities. In front of his shocked contemporaries, a young man who came from nowhere and was not at all noble suddenly became the second man in the Russian Empire. It was his signature that was the first on the death sentence for the heir to the throne - Tsarevich Alexei, the son of Peter I.

He was also the only duke in the Russian Empire (Izhora, from 1707), the first cavalry general in Russia (now they would say “marshal of the military branch”) and the first Russian member of a foreign academy of sciences (Isaac Newton sent him notice of his election).



By the way, Peter I himself became a member of the foreign academy of sciences (French) three years later than Menshikov. Here is the complete “Form” that the hero of our article used in official documents:

“We, Alexander Menshikov, His Serene Highness of the Roman and Russian States, Prince and Duke of Izhera, Hereditary Lord of Araniburkh and others, His Imperial Majesty the All-Russian Supreme Commander, Felt Marshal and Governor General of the Governorate of St. Petersburg and many provinces, His Imperial Majesty Knight of the Holy Apostle Andrey and Elephant, White and Black Eagles, from fleet Russian Schoutbenacht and so on and so forth.”

"Pie" or nobleman?


The origins of Menshikov are still debated.

Many are sure that he came from the common people and as a child sold pies and pancakes in Moscow. This version became very popular after the publication of A. Tolstoy’s novel “Peter I”.


Menshikov with pies, illustration for A. Tolstoy’s novel Peter I

And Pushkin in this line in the poem “My Genealogy” speaks specifically about the hero of the article:

“My grandfather did not sell pancakes.”

In the poem “Poltava” Pushkin gave everyone the well-known coined formula:

“Happiness is a rootless darling, a semi-sovereign ruler.”

However, in the preparatory materials for the unfinished work "History Peter" he also notes:

“Menshikov came from Belarusian nobles... He was never a lackey and never sold hearth pies. This is a joke of the boyars, accepted by historians as the truth.”

Pushkin suggested looking for the family estate of the Menshikov family near Orsha.

But Prince Kurakin, who also wrote the history of the reign of Peter I (and also did not finish it) believed that Menshikov was “of the lowest breed, below the nobility.”
The royal “diplomas” say that Menshikov:

“from the family of a noble Lithuanian, whom we, for the sake of his parent’s faithful services in our guard and seeing hope from his youth in the good deeds of his own, have been honored by the grace of our Majesty to rise at our court.”

Let's see what his contemporaries wrote about the origin of Menshikov, arranging this evidence in chronological order. Here is the very first: in 1698, the secretary of the Austrian embassy, ​​Korb, in his “Diary of a Travel to Muscovy” calls the hero of the article “the tsar’s favorite Aleksashka.” He reports:

“They say that this man has been elevated to the height of enviable power from the lowest fate among people.”

In 1704, Martin Neugebauer, the tutor of Tsarevich Alexei, who fled abroad, published a brochure in which he claimed that Menshikov was a “pie maker” and a “peasant son.”

A German in Russian service, Heinrich von Huyssen, on the contrary, wrote in 1705:

“Menshikov comes from a good noble family, well known in Lithuania.”

But in the same year, the English Ambassador Whitworth reported to London that Menshikov

"a person of very low birth."

In December 1707 in Novogrudok, at the congress of the gentry of the Grand Duchy of Lithuania, a letter was sent to Alexander Danilovich, already his Serene Highness, where he was addressed as “Alexander Menzhik, our master and brother, a commoner of our kind” and recognized him as “our fatherland of the principality Lithuanian son."

However, in this document there is no mention of either the noble coat of arms of Menshikov or his family estate. And we must take into account that Menshikov was already his Serene Highness and a prominent military leader. He and his troops are in Belarus, and no one can stop him from ordering some regiment to visit the estate of a slow-witted deputy and see if there is anything interesting there, and whether this “interesting” would be suitable for the needs of the Russian army. Then complain anywhere, to anyone, and as much as you want.

Later, Menshikov, indeed, acquired estates in Belarus, but they were presented to him by Peter I. And Alexander Danilovich never had Belarusian relatives.

In 1710, the Danish ambassador Joost Jul writes in his diary:

“Menshikov was born in Moscow from very insignificant parents. As a teenager, about 16 years old, he, like many other Moscow commoners, walked the streets and sold so-called pies.”

The Tsar's turner Andrei Nartov reports that one day, angry with Menshikov, Peter began to threaten him to “turn him back to his previous state at once.” Menshikov ran out into the street, took the body from some pie maker and, hanging it on himself, returned to the palace, making the Tsar laugh and thereby achieving forgiveness.

A Frenchman in the Russian service, Vilboa, adjutant of Peter I, then vice admiral, claimed that Menshikov’s father

“there was a peasant who received his livelihood from selling pies at the Kremlin gates, where he opened a small cake shop.”

Burchard Minich considered Menshikov’s origins “from commoners” to be an indisputable and well-known fact. His adjutant Manstein also writes:

“It is undoubtedly true that Menshikov is of low birth; he began as a servant, after which the king took him as a soldier in the first regular company, which he called amusement. From here the king took him to himself and showed him complete trust.”

After the death of the first emperor, in July 1727, a certain artisan of the city chancellery, Daniil Kolosov, brought the authorities an anonymous letter directed against Menshikov, in which the anonymous author wrote that the temporary worker

“he forced a twelve-year-old boy (Emperor Peter II) to get engaged to his daughter, the grandson of Marktan, unworthy of that marriage.”

That is, Menshikov’s father is called a sutler – a seller of food for soldiers.

What about the Menshikov estate near Orsha?

It probably never existed. And there is reason to believe that, despite the document from the delegates of the gentry congress of 1707, in fact no one had heard of the Menshikov nobles in Belarus. For example, Yuri Trubnitsky, one of the members of the Mogilev magistrate, having received the news of Menshikov’s death, wrote that Peter’s favorite

“he was of low class, supposedly the son of a baker, his father baked pancakes, and he was known for delivering them around Moscow on a tray.”

That is, the circle is closed, and we again find ourselves in Moscow, where young Aleksashka Menshikov sells either pies or pancakes.

Parents of Alexander Menshikov


The earliest document containing information about A. Menshikov’s father is dated October 13, 1689: in the “Notebook of the Streletsky Order” you can find an entry about

“the verbal petition of the amusing groom Danil Menshikov of the Novodevichy Convent against the quitrent peasant Kiryushka Ivanov in the beating of his nephew Danilov, the tradesman Kalinka Pavlov.”

Born on November 6 (16), 1673, Alexander was 16 years old at that time. It is known that Menshikov’s father later served in the Semenovsky regiment and died during the first siege of Azov.

The hero's mother, Anna Ignatievna, came from a merchant family. In 1695, Menshikov even inherited from one of his relatives shops in the Zhelezny and Syreiny rows. That is, the hero of the article cannot be called completely poor.

To summarize, we can say that Menshikov was a very dubious nobleman, and the possibility of assigning him this title cannot be ruled out. Peter I, of course, did not interfere with this, since it was somehow inconvenient for the tsar to bring a person of peasant origin closer to him.

The early life of Alexander Menshikov


So, the first documentary evidence about A.D. Menshikov dates back to the late 1690s, and from that time the “semi-legendary” period of his life ends, and the well-known “historical” period begins.

According to the most common version, young Peter first saw Menshikov in Lefort’s house, where he was in service. A tall and cheerful teenager, almost the same age as the Tsar (a year younger than him), apparently by that time he had already “cut his teeth” in the German Settlement, knew some foreign words, and learned some “polites.”

But François Guillaume Villebois, mentioned above, also gives a version of Menshikov’s acquaintance with Peter:

“Once, when he was screaming loudly because some archer had torn his ears, no longer joking, Peter sent to tell the archer to stop offending the poor boy, and at the same time ordered him to be brought to him.”

By the way, this is exactly how Mark Twain’s novel “The Prince and the Pauper” begins.

Soon Peter and Alexander became friends and, as they say, sometimes even slept in the same bed (“hussars, keep quiet”!).

Ivan Golikov, the author of a 30-volume work about Peter I written in the XNUMXth century, tried to combine all versions:

“It is accepted as the most reliable of the legends regarding the glorious Prince Menshikov that he was born in Moscow in 1674 from a poor Polish nobleman who served in the royal stable as a stirrup, and that, having left behind his father, in childhood, he lost his last small property and was forced to look for get your food from one of the Moscow pirozhniks.”

Then, according to Golikov, in 1686 he became a servant in Lefort’s house, and from him went to Peter.


Lefort and Menshikov, illustration by I. Bilibin for A. Tolstoy’s novel “Peter I”

And here is the opinion of S. M. Solovyov:

“Foreign contemporaries unanimously say that Menshikov was of very humble origin; according to Russian news he born near Vladimir and was the son of a court groom."

Appearance of Alexander Menshikov


Dmitry Bantysh-Kamensky in “Biography of Russian Generalissimos and Field Marshals” (1840) gives the following description of the appearance of the hero of the article:

“Prince Alexander Danilovich Menshikov was two arshins twelve inches tall (196 cm), two inches shorter than Peter the Great; slender in appearance... Intelligence and ambition were depicted in bright colors on his face. He had a sarcastic smile; distinguished by its sharpness; usually got up at six o'clock or earlier, had dinner at nine, and went to bed at ten o'clock; I didn’t put off any work until another day; loved to give sumptuous dinners; decorated himself with orders."


His Serene Highness Prince A. D. Menshikov in a portrait by an unknown artist

And here is what S. M. Solovyov writes about Menshikov:

“The favorite’s appearance was very remarkable: he was tall, well-built, thin, with pleasant facial features, with very lively eyes; he loved to dress superbly and, most importantly, what especially amazed foreigners, he was very neat, a quality rare even then among Russians.”

Beginning of the royal service


Since 1693, Menshikov served in the bombardment company of the Preobrazhensky Regiment, whose captain was Peter, in 1699 he became its sergeant, in 1700 - lieutenant. He took part in the Azov campaigns of 1695–1696, then Peter I included him in the Great Embassy of 1697–1698.


M. van Musscher. Portrait of A. Menshikov, painted in Holland during the Great Embassy (1698).

Together with the tsar he worked in shipyards, studied artillery, and learned German and Dutch. In addition, he was in charge of the economic affairs of the Embassy. Upon returning to Russia, he became one of the tsar’s most active assistants, taking an active part both in the “Assemblies” and in the very dubious and obscene entertainment events of this tsar.

North War


One of the results of the Great Embassy was the creation of an anti-Swedish alliance between Russia and the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth (the Polish king Augustus III was also the Elector of Saxony). The Kingdom of Denmark and Norway also joined this union.

Russia's goal in the coming war was to regain control of the eastern coast of the Baltic Sea, which had fallen under Swedish rule during the Livonian War. In 1583, Russia was forced to conclude the Truce of Plus, according to which it lost, in addition to Narva, three border fortresses (Ivangorod, Koporye, Yam), retaining only Oreshek and a narrow “corridor” along the Neva to its mouth, a little more than 30 km long.

In 1590, the government of Boris Godunov (under the nominal Tsar Fyodor Ioannovich) attempted to regain the lost territories. The war ended in 1595 with the signing of the Tyavzin Peace, according to which Russia regained Yam, Ivangorod and Koporye.

Russo-Swedish War 1610–1617 ended with the signing of the Stolbovo Peace Treaty, under the terms of which the Swedes returned Novgorod, Porkhov, Staraya Russa, Ladoga, Gdov and Sumerskaya volost to Russia, but received Ivangorod, Yam, Koporye, Oreshek and Korela. Under Alexei Mikhailovich, Russia tried to recapture these lands, but was unsuccessful.

The Kingdom of Sweden at the beginning of the 18th century was a large European country. In addition to Sweden itself, this state also included Finland, Livonia, Karelia, Ingria, the cities of Wismar, Vyborg, the islands of Rügen and Ezel, part of Pomerania, the duchies of Bremen and Verden.


Kingdom of Sweden on the map

The military reputation of the Swedes, starting from the Thirty Years' War, was very great, the army was famous for its discipline and high fighting spirit. Swedish historian Peter Englund in his work “Poltava. The Story of the Death of an Army" gives the following assessment of the army at the disposal of Charles XII:

“Never before in its history has the country been more combat-ready. Charles XI's persistent reforms resulted in the country having a large, well-trained and armed army, an impressive navy, and a new system of military financing that could withstand enormous initial outlays."

But on April 14, 1697, a new king, Charles XII, ascended to the Swedish throne. At this time he was 14 years 10 months old, he had a well-deserved reputation as a good-for-nothing scoundrel, and therefore no one expected any feats from him. However, the Northern War awakened in this young man not even a Viking, but a berserker; his contemporaries compared him to Alexander the Great. The Holy Roman Emperor of the German Nation, Joseph I, in 1707, in response to the reproaches of the papal nuncio for concessions to the Protestants of Silesia, said:

"You must be very happy that the Swedish king did not offer me to accept Lutheranism, for if he wanted to ... I don’t know what I would do."

The first battle of the Russian army in the Northern War was the unfortunate Battle of Narva, which took place on November 19 (30), 1700. Menshikov did not take part in this battle, since Peter I, who left for Novgorod, took him with him.

This victory for Charles XII turned out to be truly fatal, since as a result he made an absolutely logical, but completely wrong conclusion about the weakness of Russia and the need to focus his attention on more worthy and powerful opponents in Europe. But Russia was not defeated and received its most valuable resource at that time - time.

Already 2 weeks after the Battle of Narva, Sheremetev at Marienburg dared to attack (albeit not very successfully) the Swedish detachment of General Schlippenbach. A year later (December 29, 1701), at Erestfer, Sheremetev’s troops inflicted the first defeat on Schlippenbach’s corps, for which the Russian commander received the rank of Field Marshal and the Order of St. Andrew the First-Called. Schlippenbach was then defeated twice in 1702.

In the fall of 1702, Menshikov distinguished himself during the assault on the Noteburg (Oreshek) fortress: he ordered the collection of boats and used them to deliver reinforcements to the walls of the fortress. The Russian troops were then led by Peter himself.


A.E. Kotzebue. "Storm of the Noteburg fortress on October 11, 1702"

This fortress was renamed Shlisselburg, and the hero of the article became its commandant.
In the spring of 1703, Russian troops occupied Izhora land. Menshikov participated in the capture of Nyenskans, which was renamed Schlottburg. The Swedes, who did not know about the fall of this fortress, placed two ships near it - the 10-gun bot "Gedan" ("Pike") and the 8-gun shnyava "Astrild" ("Star"). On May 7 (18), Peter and Menshikov on boats led an attack on these ships, “Gedan” was captured by the team of Menshikov, who, at the same time as Peter I, then received the Order of St. Andrew the First-Called.


L. Blinov. Capture of the boat "Gedan" and the shnyava "Astrild" at the mouth of the Neva. Central Naval Museum

Already on May 16, the first bastion of the Peter and Paul Fortress was founded on Hare Island, Menshikov became the first governor of St. Petersburg, supervised the construction of this city and Kronstadt, founded shipyards on the Neva and the Svir River, and two cannon factories.


Menshikov and Peter I at the foundation of St. Petersburg

In July, by order of the tsar, he formed a new regiment, later called Ingria.

In May 1704, near the besieged Narva, at the suggestion of Menshikov, they managed to provoke the Swedes into a sortie. Soldiers from 4 regiments, dressed in blue uniforms similar to Swedish ones, approached the fortress. Part of the troops of the Swedish garrison came to the aid of their compatriots, losing up to 300 people. However, it was possible to take Narva by storm only in August.

On November 30, 1705, Menshikov became a cavalry general. In the same year, he was awarded the Polish Order of the White Eagle and received the title of Prince of the Holy Roman Empire (he became a count back in 1702).


Jan Hendrik Beering. Portrait of A. Menshikov, 1705

On October 18, 1706, Menshikov played a big role in the victory of the allied army near Kalisz: he personally led the decisive attack of the Russian dragoons and was wounded. The surrounded Swedes surrendered - along with the commander-in-chief Arvid Mardefelt.


Peter Pickart. Prince A.D. Menshikov against the backdrop of the Battle of Kalisz. 1707–1708

The battle of Kalisz is called the first “proper battle”, in which the Russian army won. The next day, Kalisz also capitulated. As a reward, Menshikov received the rank of lieutenant colonel of the Preobrazhensky regiment. In August of the same 1706, the hero of the article married Daria Mikhailovna Arsenyeva, who was the daughter of a Yakut governor. It is curious that this woman signed her letters to her husband “Daria Stupid.”


Daria Mikhailovna Menshikova in a portrait by an unknown artist

This marriage produced 7 children, but four of them died at an early age. The fate of the rest will be discussed later.

In 1707, Menshikov fought in Poland. But the main battles were ahead. We will talk about this and much more in the next article.
35 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +4
    20 January 2024 06: 18
    I am writing my traditional thanks to Valery!
    I’ll finish reading the article on the subway, and after work I’ll find time to write a few comments, the hero of the article is a very extraordinary person!
  2. +1
    20 January 2024 06: 51
    Alexander Menshikov. The beginning of a long journey

    So is he still Menshchikov or Menshchikov?
    1. VLR
      +6
      20 January 2024 07: 30
      According to the rules of the Russian language, one should write with a soft sign, but these rules do not apply to surnames. Yeltsin, for example, in this case would be Yeltsyn. There are both variants of spelling the surname Menshikov, but when applied to the hero of the article, most often without a soft sign.
      1. 0
        20 January 2024 07: 37
        Yeltsin, for example, in this case would be Yeltsyn.

        It was not in vain that I asked a question about the name of Alexander Danilovich. Its correct spelling is a historical mystery, and you ignored it in your article about its origin.
        As for the endings “Yn” and “In” in Russian surnames, for Russians they are “Yn”, and for “crosses” they are “In” (previously it was Ind)
        Malkin, Palkin and Zalkind
        (I. Ilf, E. Petrov 12 chairs)
        1. +5
          20 January 2024 08: 17
          [quote=Amateur][quote] Yeltsin, for example
          [quote]Malkin, Palkin and Zalkind
          (I. Ilf, E. Petrov 12 chairs)[/quote] Forgot Kukushkind
          1. +3
            20 January 2024 09: 30
            You're right! It’s just that for a very long time at our institute, Colonels Malkin and Zalkind, as well as Major Goryunov, who was called “Palkin” behind his back, taught in the military department at our institute. drinks
            p.s. but actually there were 5 of them: Galkin, Palkin, Malkin, Chalkin and Zalkind
        2. +3
          20 January 2024 08: 30
          Quote: Amateur
          As for the endings “Yn” and “In” in Russian surnames, for Russians they are “Yn”, and for “crosses” they are “In” (previously it was Ind)

          According to Russian grammar, Alkasha's last name should be written YeltsYn, but Russian last names are usually written with the ending IN. And the endings IND are among European Jews, remember the British Minister of Defense in the 90s named RiskIND
        3. +10
          20 January 2024 09: 17
          As for the endings “Yn” and “In” in Russian surnames, for Russians they are “Yn”, and for “crosses” they are “In” (previously it was Ind)
          Malkin, Palkin and Zalkind
          (I. Ilf, E. Petrov 12 chairs)

          You have done something clever: you just can’t turn your hand to write Malkin and Palkin with “Y”.
        4. +8
          20 January 2024 22: 24
          Somehow you classified Pushkin, Minin and many others as “crosses”.
          1. +3
            21 January 2024 01: 28
            Quote from shikin
            according to Russian news, he was born near Vladimir and was the son of a court groom

            And Peter’s mother’s name was Natalya Kirillovna Naryshkind.
        5. +1
          20 January 2024 22: 24
          Somehow you classified Pushkin, Minin and many others as “crosses”.
  3. +11
    20 January 2024 07: 16
    An intriguer, a joker, a mass entertainer, a sly, a rogue, a lover of getting his hands on good things and took quite a lot of them, not educated, but had a fairly high intellect, brave, sometimes courage was part of showing off in front of the king, very fond of expensive gifts and awards, quick-tempered, cruel, reckless in anger, an unusual and contradictory personality, yet, to be honest, Pyotr Alekseevich became close to Menshikov only because he saw a reflection of himself in him.
    1. +1
      20 January 2024 09: 26
      With his Palace he turned around properly.
  4. +2
    20 January 2024 08: 34
    Many are sure that he came from the common people
    Well, even if Menshikov comes from the people? What? The main thing is the breed? smile A phrase from the film Silva of the early 80s, where Colonel Edwin's father reflects on this, that the main thing is the breed, examines his head during a conversation, and explains who it came from, stumbles upon a lump, tries to attribute it to some ancestor, and then remembers, that as a child I hit my head on a doorframe smile
    1. VLR
      +12
      20 January 2024 08: 46
      "Social elevators" have not harmed any state. That's when they stop working - this is a sign of impending trouble and disaster.
      1. 0
        20 January 2024 09: 26
        What does this have to do with social elevators? My comment is not about them. Roughly, saying that we have one ancestor - “Adamyan”, who was not purebred, without bumps and grooves .. laughing And he doesn’t play the piano, whether Menshikov was one of the “thoroughbreds” or not... His deeds speak for him of what he was like, bad or good.. “Am I explaining clearly?” (c) smile
        1. +10
          20 January 2024 10: 56
          Quote: parusnik
          we have one ancestor - "Adamyan"

          When Adam plowed and Eve spun, who was the nobleman then?
          wink
          1. +2
            20 January 2024 15: 36
            When Adam was plowing
            Glory to reason, there was someone who understood.. smile To me, the film reminds me of Carnival night, when Ogurtsov, the comedians perform. smile Or the Noble Assembly, where nobility gather... wink
    2. +7
      20 January 2024 11: 05
      “Breed” is not about skulls and bumps, it’s about Spirit and education. The breed tends to degenerate under the influence of time and circumstances. Children of the glorious and strong are almost always weaker, exceptions are very rare.
      Therefore, social elevators are of decisive importance in the development of society and civilization.
  5. +7
    20 January 2024 08: 59
    The same Minich, also from the same “administration of the affairs of the Tsar” in which Menshikov was a member, periodically admired Menshikov that he, not even knowing how to read or write, enjoyed such trust from Peter, which allowed Menshikov to participate in the management of the vast Kingdom for many years .
    But since Menshikov, at the end of his power, having fallen into disgrace and having lost virtually everything, endured exile steadfastly and even jokingly and did not make or bother with requests for pardon, this indicates that Menshikov himself, at the end of his life, could have been surprised - how From being a commoner, his life was successful.
    Well, he took an ax and cut down the village church. The offspring of the “grafevs” and the boyars somehow did not know how to work with an ax.
    Well, with the exception of Tsar Peter himself.
  6. +9
    20 January 2024 09: 31
    Quote: Amateur
    and for the “crosses” - “In” (previously it was Indus)

    Who are you referring to? A ?
  7. +10
    20 January 2024 10: 10
    To begin with, I would like to express my gratitude to the respected author for the work done.
    All (or almost all) versions of Danilych’s origin are given, as well as sources.
    But some things can be clarified)
    Menshikov was a very dubious nobleman

    Let's start with the fact that the ruling class began to be called “nobility” only under Catherine the Great. And when young Aleksashka entered the service of the equally young Peter, this was a rank, and one of the lowest. So, if they called a steward that way, he would probably be offended. Yes, there were still “duma nobles,” but very few.
    And the ruling class in Rus' was called “serving people of the fatherland,” but by the end of the 17th century, the term borrowed from its closest neighbors was increasingly used—the gentry! And even the first cadet corps was called “Nobility”!
    One more moment. In addition to the gentry themselves, there was a fairly significant layer between them and the common people. In Russia they were most often called odnodvortsy, and in Lithuania “good” or “armored boyars”, “closed gentry” and so on. And, in general, it happened that even representatives of princely families fell into this category.
    Since they had no serfs, they had to plow on their own. And if there was no land at all, then they were often and heavily hired into service and even... sold pies.
    By the way, this is not the worst option. EMNIP, even under Mikhail Fedorovich, there was a decree prohibiting the sons of servicemen from selling themselves as slaves!
    was the son of a court groom."

    That's it!
    The key word in this case is “courtier”. People from the street were not hired for such a position. So this is also evidence that Menshikov Sr. was of the service class, even of the very last eighth category.
    By the way. We often think that young Peter’s “Amusing Regiments” were staffed almost by peasant children. Well, this is not even close to the case. These boys were the offspring of servants of the Moscow orders. Mostly “Amusing” - that is, engaged in royal fun - hunting.
    For them, fulfilling the royal whims, no matter how strange they may seem, was an ordinary service.
  8. +6
    20 January 2024 10: 43
    He was also the only duke in the Russian Empire

    There were quite a lot of dukes in the Russian Empire. The last one, Vasily Alekseevich Durasov, who bore the title “Prince of Anjou, Duke of Durazzo,” died in 1971.
    But there are formally three dukes elevated to ducal dignity by the Russian authorities. The first was Alexander Danilovich Menshikov, to whom the title of duke was granted by Tsar Peter I (at the same time as the title of prince).
    With the other two, the question is somewhat more complicated. By decree of Alexander III in 1890, the right to use the title of Dukes of Leuchtenberg with inclusion in the genealogical books was granted to the sons of His Imperial Highness Prince Nikolai Maximilianovich Romanovsky, Duke of Leuchtenberg from the morganatic wife N. A. Akinfova, Nikolai and George.
  9. -2
    20 January 2024 10: 49
    So I look at the portrait by van Musscher and think that this guy in the picture doesn’t look like a Russian at all... His butt is wider than his shoulders, his hair, his eyes... I don’t know which part of the Semitic people he belonged to, but there’s no way he could be Russian I couldn’t... An extra plus in favor of the theory of Peter’s substitution.
  10. BAI
    +2
    20 January 2024 11: 42

    Peter Pickart. Prince A.D. Menshikov against the backdrop of the Battle of Kalisz. 1707–1708


    Are the shields still there?
  11. +5
    20 January 2024 13: 51
    Smart, brave and thieving lucky guy. He was devoted to his master, but could not survive without him. It would be interesting to have a heart-to-heart with him in the open air in Berezovo, when life has already been rethought (it was not in vain that he cut down a church for the soul)
  12. +4
    20 January 2024 15: 49
    I read it with great interest.
    A surprise for me was the information about the height (196 cm) of Alexander Danilovich Menshikov. It was in our cinema in the films “Peter the Great” and “The Demidovs” that the selection of actors for the role of Menshikov did not correspond to the actual nature and was presented as such a cunning scoundrel, not devoid (however) of courage (bravery).
    There was also a painting by Surikov:
    Now it’s completely clear why Alexander Danilovich contrasts with the size of the hut...
  13. +1
    20 January 2024 18: 47
    “Menshikov participated in the capture of Nyenskans, renamed Schlottburg. The Swedes, who did not know about the fall of this fortress, placed two ships near it - the 10-gun boat “Gedan” (“Pike”) and the 8-gun boat “Astrild” (“Star”). "Dear author! I have to correct you a little. From the location of the Nyenschantz fortress at the mouth of the Okhta River to the memorial sign “Russia’s First Naval Victory in the Northern War”, which was installed in St. Petersburg on the bank of the Neva channel Ekateringofka in Ekateringof Park, approximately 12 -12,3 km by water along the Neva and Ekateringofka. Two Swedish ships that were sent on reconnaissance stopped at night, with a headwind, south of the confluence of the Tarakanovka channel into Yekateringofka, that is, we need to add another 500 meters, at least. Directly, through meadows, swamps and forests, from the fortress to the battle site is about 10 km... Although, to be precise, in the Northern War, the first Swedish corral was destroyed by Russian troops and one was taken as a trophy in 1701 in a battle near the Novodvinsk fortress ( Linsky Priluk island in the Northern Dvina delta). From the center of Arkhangelsk to the Novodvinsk fortress is 20 km by water. It’s good that earthen batteries had already been built on both banks of the Korabelny branch of the Dvina. Bypassing the Swedes' ships in boats, as at the mouth of the Neva, on the Northern Dvina would not have been possible. In the Neva in summer the average tide height is 10 cm, in the Northern Dvina at the Novodvinsk fortress - 85 cm.
  14. 0
    20 January 2024 21: 58
    How right?
    Russian army and state or Russian army and state?
    What about the 16th century, what about the 17th and 18th in the texts this way and that.
  15. +1
    20 January 2024 22: 08
    And thanks for the article! It's interesting to read and the writing is good.
    Has anyone used the analysis of documents written by or signed by a historical figure?
    After all, from the texts, it is probably possible to determine when the “sharp increase in the level of education” occurred. But this is speculation.
  16. +2
    20 January 2024 22: 14
    Quote: yuliatreb
    An intriguer, a joker, a mass entertainer, a sly, a rogue, a lover of getting his hands on good things and took quite a lot of them, not educated, but had a fairly high intellect, brave, sometimes courage was part of showing off in front of the king, very fond of expensive gifts and awards, quick-tempered, cruel, reckless in anger, an unusual and contradictory personality, yet, to be honest, Pyotr Alekseevich became close to Menshikov only because he saw a reflection of himself in him.


    You were lucky to see everything with your own eyes, and to write about it so many centuries later.
  17. 0
    20 January 2024 22: 18
    Quote: Amateur
    Yeltsin, for example, in this case would be Yeltsyn.

    It was not in vain that I asked a question about the name of Alexander Danilovich. Its correct spelling is a historical mystery, and you ignored it in your article about its origin.
    As for the endings “Yn” and “In” in Russian surnames, for Russians they are “Yn”, and for “crosses” they are “In” (previously it was Ind)
    Malkin, Palkin and Zalkind
    (I. Ilf, E. Petrov 12 chairs)


    You made an interesting joke. You can take a closer look at historical figures, many of them. Are the surnames given by parents, but the accepted party ones, interpreted in the same way?
  18. +2
    20 January 2024 22: 28
    Quote: North 2
    The same Minich, also from the same “administration of the affairs of the Tsar” in which Menshikov was a member, periodically admired Menshikov that he, not even knowing how to read or write, enjoyed such trust from Peter, which allowed Menshikov to participate in the management of the vast Kingdom for many years .
    But since Menshikov, at the end of his power, having fallen into disgrace and having lost virtually everything, endured exile steadfastly and even jokingly and did not make or bother with requests for pardon, this indicates that Menshikov himself, at the end of his life, could have been surprised - how From being a commoner, his life was successful.
    Well, he took an ax and cut down the village church. The offspring of the “grafevs” and the boyars somehow did not know how to work with an ax.
    Well, with the exception of Tsar Peter himself.


    Well, with the exception of Tsar Peter himself.
    If Peter the Great could work alongside the artisans, then the children of the boyars could do the same.
    There is a desire, a given skill and stubbornness.
    1. +1
      23 January 2024 13: 41
      Quote from Fangaro
      Quote: North 2
      The same Minich, also from the same “administration of the affairs of the Tsar” in which Menshikov was a member, periodically admired Menshikov that he, not even knowing how to read or write, enjoyed such trust from Peter, which allowed Menshikov to participate in the management of the vast Kingdom for many years .
      But since Menshikov, at the end of his power, having fallen into disgrace and having lost virtually everything, endured exile steadfastly and even jokingly and did not make or bother with requests for pardon, this indicates that Menshikov himself, at the end of his life, could have been surprised - how From being a commoner, his life was successful.
      Well, he took an ax and cut down the village church. The offspring of the “grafevs” and the boyars somehow did not know how to work with an ax.
      Well, with the exception of Tsar Peter himself.


      Well, with the exception of Tsar Peter himself.
      If Peter the Great could work alongside the artisans, then the children of the boyars could do the same.
      There is a desire, a given skill and stubbornness.

      Why would a boyar work with an ax? Boyar children were sent abroad to study science and many succeeded in military and administrative affairs. You won’t demand from Putin the ability to cut down a church?
  19. +2
    20 January 2024 22: 31
    Quote: Senior Sailor
    To begin with, I would like to express my gratitude to the respected author for the work done.
    All (or almost all) versions of Danilych’s origin are given, as well as sources.
    But some things can be clarified)
    Menshikov was a very dubious nobleman

    Let's start with the fact that the ruling class began to be called “nobility” only under Catherine the Great. And when young Aleksashka entered the service of the equally young Peter, this was a rank, and one of the lowest. So, if they called a steward that way, he would probably be offended. Yes, there were still “duma nobles,” but very few.
    And the ruling class in Rus' was called “serving people of the fatherland,” but by the end of the 17th century, the term borrowed from its closest neighbors was increasingly used—the gentry! And even the first cadet corps was called “Nobility”!
    One more moment. In addition to the gentry themselves, there was a fairly significant layer between them and the common people. In Russia they were most often called odnodvortsy, and in Lithuania “good” or “armored boyars”, “closed gentry” and so on. And, in general, it happened that even representatives of princely families fell into this category.
    Since they had no serfs, they had to plow on their own. And if there was no land at all, then they were often and heavily hired into service and even... sold pies.
    By the way, this is not the worst option. EMNIP, even under Mikhail Fedorovich, there was a decree prohibiting the sons of servicemen from selling themselves as slaves!
    was the son of a court groom."

    That's it!
    The key word in this case is “courtier”. People from the street were not hired for such a position. So this is also evidence that Menshikov Sr. was of the service class, even of the very last eighth category.
    By the way. We often think that young Peter’s “Amusing Regiments” were staffed almost by peasant children. Well, this is not even close to the case. These boys were the offspring of servants of the Moscow orders. Mostly “Amusing” - that is, engaged in royal fun - hunting.
    For them, fulfilling the royal whims, no matter how strange they may seem, was an ordinary service.


    Thank you for your comment! I have never seen anything like this before. Of course, I didn't look for it.