The black hole of Rusnano: how the state corporation became bankrupt

45
The black hole of Rusnano: how the state corporation became bankrupt

This year, Russia’s most “high-tech” state corporation, Rusnano, announced signs of insolvency, indicating that it would not be able to pay off its debts from its own funds by the end of the year. At the same time, its former leader, Anatoly Chubais, fled abroad last year.

It is worth noting that the state corporation is quite rightly called the “black hole” of the Russian budget. Created in 2007, Rusnano has to date received 152 billion rubles in direct funding and 253 billion rubles in loan guarantees from the state.



405 billion is a very considerable amount. For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each. But this money was used by Rsnano managers.

However, the result of the activities of the organization, headed by Anatoly Chubais for many years, is, at first glance, impressive. In 2011, Russia produced products in the field of nanotechnology worth 155 billion rubles, and in 2019 already 2 trillion. Moreover, by 2027 this figure was supposed to grow to 4,4 trillion.

Meanwhile, the devil, as usual, is in the details, namely in the concept of “nanotechnology”. For example, Rusnano acquired a 5% stake in TMK, where they began producing nano-coated pipes. The latter is only 8% of the total cost of the product, while the full cost of the sale of this product goes to the nanotechnology asset.

In general, in Russia 2/3 of nanoproducts are those in the production of which nanotechnology is used. As a result, the above-mentioned growth in economic indicators applies to enterprises producing these products, but not to Rusnano directly.

But what about the state corporation itself?

From 2010 to 2023, its loss amounted to 123 billion rubles. At the same time, it began to grow rapidly after the end of state support in 2018.

Meanwhile, Rusnano did not stop using borrowed funds, establishing the issue of bonds and using commercial loans. As a result, as of 2021, the corporation had outstanding loan obligations to Russian banks in the amount of about 76 billion rubles, and the debt on bond issues amounted to about 70 billion.

It is worth emphasizing that Anatoly Chubais left his post in 2020. It was this period that was marked by a record loss, which amounted to 53 billion.

Ultimately, everyone made money from the injections into Rusnano (from banks to the companies of Chubais’ friends, in which he invested the state corporation’s funds), except the Russian budget.

However, the management of Rusnano has also earned a lot over the years. In particular, the personal income of Anatoly Chubais from 2010 until his dismissal from the post of head of the state corporation amounted to 2 billion rubles.

45 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +14
    28 December 2023 17: 12
    Putin.apparently.respects Chubais.if he allowed him to leave the country with impunity.
    1. +14
      28 December 2023 17: 14
      Quote: Million
      Putin.apparently.respects Chubais.if he allowed him to leave the country with impunity.

      And the main thing is that there is SILENCE about this! None of the creditors shout, look for anyone or demand repayment of debts!
      1. +6
        28 December 2023 18: 00
        Quote: Starover_Z
        And the main thing is that there is SILENCE about this! None of the creditors shout, look for anyone or demand repayment of debts!

        Well, you and I will all pay off all debts and interest on them from our taxes. Why worry? wassat
    2. +12
      28 December 2023 17: 20
      Quote: Million
      Putin.apparently.respects Chubais

      Most likely, Chubais is one of Putin’s bosses.
      1. +6
        28 December 2023 17: 53
        Quote: Practitioner23354df
        Most likely, Chubais is one of Putin’s bosses.

        From the same litter:
        1. +2
          28 December 2023 17: 57
          Well, what are we talking about, all the same faces.
        2. +1
          28 December 2023 20: 12
          ROSS 42 (Yuri Vasilievich) Video

          Bah, all the faces are familiar! winked
    3. +7
      28 December 2023 17: 33
      Does he respect a million? They have been saying here for a long time that the voucherello is the “eminence grise” of the authorities from the Jewish banks. That is, a kind of independent master of the country. Let's say the voucherello ran away - why won't they dump him in Europe? And what about the rest of the management, what about these billions of debts - will they be forgiven and written off? There are a million questions, but we will NEVER hear one honest answer from the Kremlin!
      1. +2
        28 December 2023 17: 41
        Not gray, but red, and not a cardinal, but a manager
    4. 0
      28 December 2023 17: 37
      If not all, then the majority understand everything perfectly. There are many in Russia who breathed a sigh of relief after his departure.
      1. +7
        28 December 2023 17: 58
        And what changed in the end was that Yeltsin died, Chubais left, but what’s the point?
    5. +1
      28 December 2023 18: 58
      Quote: Million
      The black hole of Rusnano: how the state corporation became bankrupt
      no...no respect, just had to.
  2. +5
    28 December 2023 17: 12
    And where do the public funds invested in RosNano come from, not from banks?! And the banks that gave money to anyone “for their skin” don’t take this money and don’t send collectors?! This is how and why?!
    1. +7
      28 December 2023 17: 21
      "Who will imprison him? He's a monument!" The monument to the current government is by definition inviolable.
      1. +9
        28 December 2023 17: 42
        Should we wait for the Chubais Center?
        1. +3
          28 December 2023 19: 00
          Quote: novel xnumx
          Should we wait for the Chubais Center?

          Elections are coming soon...again. and again as always.
  3. +5
    28 December 2023 17: 15
    How could a top-category secret carrier go abroad? But it turns out that people have already thought of everything
  4. +1
    28 December 2023 17: 21
    Gentlemen, not comrades, and what you don’t understand Nanotechnology is not visible to the naked eye, nor can it be felt by the hands. Here is God - no one (except for the holy ones, the saints and a couple of Eugeians) has seen or touched him, BUT he exists. So Chubais the red-haired dog created and implemented everything! That’s right, the money was lying around unneeded and he grabbed it, but everything else was like in a book about a naked king. There are nanotechnologies in Russia and ours king those. The guarantor cannot say otherwise...
  5. +6
    28 December 2023 17: 21
    Inspection, audit and all “companions” are sent to their bunks with confiscation. Chubas - ice axe. Dreams Dreams...
  6. Des
    +2
    28 December 2023 17: 24
    Closer to our last breath, we all begin to see the light. I assume that Chubais already has one foot there. But the indulgence does not prolong its existence for long. And now he, realizing the futility of efforts and dough, is trying to taxi out. And he himself knows - there is no forgiveness.
    Unfortunately the ice axes have been cancelled.
    We will live without Chubais.
  7. +2
    28 December 2023 17: 33
    And who got rich from this?
  8. +4
    28 December 2023 17: 38
    Every nation deserves not only its own government, but also generally receives what it deserves.
    1. 0
      29 December 2023 07: 27
      Quote: ivan2022
      Every nation deserves not only its own government, but also generally receives what it deserves.

      Does the Lord lead his flock through appointed managers?
  9. 0
    28 December 2023 17: 47
    Concerned...

    You need to ask Putin why Chubais captivated him so much...
    405 billion is a very considerable amount. For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each.

    Yes, the total fortune of 25 (out of 110) Russian billionaires (stolen and stolen by appropriating the products of labor of those poor workers who made ends meet), included in the list of the 500 richest people on the planet, is 309 dollars, which in rubles will be equal to almost 300 trillion rubles - the amount is orders of magnitude higher than indicated...
    1. +3
      28 December 2023 18: 00
      Quote: ROSS 42
      Concerned...
      [media=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YJXjZCcrceU]
      You need to ask Putin why Chubais captivated him so much...
      405 billion is a very considerable amount. For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each.

      Yes, the total fortune of 25 (out of 110) Russian billionaires (stolen and stolen by appropriating the products of labor of those poor workers who made ends meet), included in the list of the 500 richest people on the planet, is 309 dollars, which in rubles will be equal to almost 300 trillion rubles - the amount is orders of magnitude higher than indicated...

      “Appropriation of the labor of poor workers” occurs when these workers sign a voluntary agreement to sell their labor. But Rusnano is raking taxpayers’ money from the budget without any consent of these same taxpayers. The difference is obvious.
      1. +2
        28 December 2023 18: 29
        Quote from Escariot
        “Appropriation of the labor of poor workers” occurs when these workers sign a voluntary agreement to sell their labor.

        Do you know what a collective agreement is and how an individual agreement is signed?
        Today we do not have an article in the Constitution:
        Article 38. Citizens of the RSFSR have the right to work, that is, to receive guaranteed
        work with remuneration in accordance with its quantity and quality and not less
        minimum size established by the state
        , - including right to choose
        profession, occupation and work in accordance with vocation, abilities,
        vocational training, education
        and taking into account social needs.
        This right is ensured by the socialist economic system, the steady growth
        productive forces, free vocational training, increased
        labor qualifications and training in new specialties, development of systems
        professional organization and employment.
        1. -1
          28 December 2023 19: 55
          Quote: ROSS 42
          Quote from Escariot
          “Appropriation of the labor of poor workers” occurs when these workers sign a voluntary agreement to sell their labor.

          Do you know what a collective agreement is and how an individual agreement is signed?
          Today we do not have an article in the Constitution:
          Article 38. Citizens of the RSFSR have the right to work, that is, to receive guaranteed
          work with remuneration in accordance with its quantity and quality and not less
          minimum size established by the state
          , - including right to choose
          profession, occupation and work in accordance with vocation, abilities,
          vocational training, education
          and taking into account social needs.
          This right is ensured by the socialist economic system, the steady growth
          productive forces, free vocational training, increased
          labor qualifications and training in new specialties, development of systems
          professional organization and employment.

          I know what a collective agreement is. Signed several times.
          And of course, how can an article from the Constitution of the Russian Federation contain an article from the Constitution of the RSFSR? There is Article 37 in the Constitution of the Russian Federation.
          Article 37

          1. Labor is free. Everyone has the right to freely dispose of his abilities to work, to choose the kind of activity and profession.

          2. Forced labor is prohibited.

          3. Everyone has the right to work in conditions meeting the requirements of safety and hygiene, to remuneration for work without any discrimination and not below the minimum wage established by federal law, and the right to protection against unemployment.

          4. The right to individual and collective labor disputes is recognized with the use of the methods established by federal law for their resolution, including the right to strike.

          5. Everyone has the right to rest. Workers under the employment contract are guaranteed the length of working hours, days off and holidays, paid annual leave established by the federal law.

          Minus the passage about the long-dead “socialist system”, it’s basically the same thing. Even separately, “forced labor” was prohibited, which was not in the constitution of the RSFSR.
  10. +2
    28 December 2023 18: 01
    Once again, officials showed how effective the state is in spending taxpayers' money.
  11. +3
    28 December 2023 18: 04
    So Yumashev (not 2 years since he left the VVP advisers) told everything..
    "Yumashev: Chubais suggested taking Putin to the Kremlin"
    https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/4170225
  12. +3
    28 December 2023 18: 24
    His accomplice must answer for the crimes of the “escaped” Chubais.
  13. +3
    28 December 2023 18: 24
    For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each.

    All that remains is to find out where in the country you can just get 60 teachers (teachers, pedagogues...) Today there are no personnel for existing schools...
    1. +2
      28 December 2023 19: 04
      Quote: ROSS 42
      For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each.

      All that remains is to find out where in the country you can just get 60 teachers (teachers, pedagogues...) Today there are no personnel for existing schools...

      return to the Soviet system of distribution of university graduates upon graduation. that's all. There will be more teachers than schools.
      1. -1
        28 December 2023 20: 28
        Quote: Aerodrome
        return to the Soviet graduate distribution system universities upon graduation. that's all. There will be more teachers than schools.

        And free education...
        Teaching is not a profession. This is a calling.
        1. +1
          5 January 2024 15: 46
          With the current salaries of a teacher in Russia, this is a hobby. don’t mix Moscow into this, this is not Russia
      2. +1
        29 December 2023 07: 34
        Quote: Aerodrome
        Quote: ROSS 42
        For example, with this money in Russia it was possible to build 1200 schools, in which 550 children could study in each.

        All that remains is to find out where in the country you can just get 60 teachers (teachers, pedagogues...) Today there are no personnel for existing schools...

        return to the Soviet system of distribution of university graduates upon graduation. that's all. There will be more teachers than schools.

        Contradicts Article 37 of the Constitution, paragraphs 1 and 2.
        To bring back teachers and doctors, it is necessary to provide a decent salary. In general, this applies to all professions.
      3. The comment was deleted.
  14. 0
    28 December 2023 18: 39
    Until the property, property and heads (in the light version - property and property, but it’s better this way) of all relatives up to the 16th generation are a guarantee that the boss does not steal from the state, this will not end.
  15. +3
    28 December 2023 19: 08
    As I understand it, there are no cases against the main one, apparently there are no questions for him.
    They talked about Rusnano almost from its inception as a devourer of finances, but we were told that these were all slander from liberals, and that nanotechnology would soon be trampled underfoot in the country.
  16. +4
    28 December 2023 20: 10
    The black hole of Rusnano: how the state corporation became bankrupt
    And who did all this?! winked
  17. +1
    29 December 2023 10: 55
    Nobody will forgive me a 100-ruble loan, but Chubais was forgiven 405 billion rubles and was also allowed to enjoy a comfortable retirement so he could spend the stolen money.
    This is how our official lives
  18. +2
    29 December 2023 14: 30
    The main problem for Rusnano is that most of the financing came through loans from commercial banks and by issuing bonds. On average at 10 - 15% per annum. Those who lent to Rusnano and bought their bonds made money. And the corporation itself paid dearly for these funds. At the same time, only part of the purchases of startups and their own work leads to results; this is a new area of ​​​​activity and the presence of failures in this matter is inevitable. The second reason is that the corporation spends too much on itself. Salaries, vehicle fleet, business class travel, etc. - this cost billions annually. To beat all this, you need to have high-margin and high-volume topics...
    Well, Chubais - a lot has been said about him, but the fact that he escaped in the spring of 2022 is a fact that cannot be disputed.
  19. -1
    30 December 2023 07: 26
    This year, Russia’s most “high-tech” state corporation, Rusnano, announced signs of insolvency, indicating that it would not be able to pay off its debts from its own funds by the end of the year. At the same time, its former leader, Anatoly Chubais, fled abroad last year.

    But in March we will support the one who supported Rusnano?
    Anyone can make a mistake. Sometimes twice. But we need support. There are many applicants, but there is no one to choose from except the one everyone already knows.
  20. 0
    31 December 2023 19: 26
    And who profited from this? I would like to know specifically
  21. 0
    3 January 2024 15: 47
    It clearly looks like “Putin and his team”.... “To live with wolves, howl like a wolf...”
    But!!!! We have an even larger “Organized Group” represented by deputies, senators and others. And any of them has the legal Right to make an official Request to the prosecutor’s office (to the brilliant prosecutor’s office) with a Demand to consider the actions of the “Great Combinator” nicknamed Red (and his organized crime group) regarding the corpus delicti of a CRIME.
    “You shouldn’t waste the Word in vain, where you need to use Power!!!!!...”
  22. 0
    4 January 2024 23: 53
    Quote: Million
    Putin.apparently.respects Chubais

    Not Chubais (that’s his call sign) but Sagal (according to Teudat Zeut, that’s what they call him now in his homeland).
  23. 0
    5 January 2024 00: 39
    Quote: Million
    Putin.apparently.respects Chubais

    Not Chubais (that’s his call sign) but Sagal (according to Teudat Zeut, that’s what they call him now in his homeland).

    Now, his (Sagal’s) accomplices occupy cushy positions in large state corporations, continuing to collapse and bankrupt other large enterprises and entire industries.

    Nothing will happen to them for such sabotage!
    It is enough to recall only the destruction of national civil aviation.
    https://cyberleninka.ru/article/n/spad-proizvodstva-samolyotov-v-sssr-v-1980-h-godah-statisticheskiy-analiz-bazy-dannyh
    USSR, 1982, produced 511 aircraft, including in the RSFSR 326!
    If we add to this data 47 transport IL76, produced at the Tashkent aircraft plant (what are they assembling there now?), the figure turns out to be completely shameful for “effective managers”.

    In modern Russia, per year production, or rather assembly (the same for 85-90% French SuperJet) did not reach and 7% from the volume of the USSR!

    And if we judge by the Hamburg account (correlating our and imported parts in domestic aircraft), then perhaps no more 3% from USSR production!

    But we all know who (whose son-in-law, brother or brother-in-law) headed the largest airline for a long time, and with drool, bought hundreds of Boeings and Barsiks abroad!

    And such horror is happening everywhere!