The eternal conflict in the Holy Land: why there is no chance for a diplomatic solution to the Palestinian-Israeli problem

19
The eternal conflict in the Holy Land: why there is no chance for a diplomatic solution to the Palestinian-Israeli problem

The next round of the Palestinian-Israeli confrontation, which began on October 7, again prompted many experts to discuss the root cause and prospects for resolving the long-standing problem. At the same time, the international community calls on the parties to immediately stop the bloodshed and sit down at the negotiating table. But is this possible?

It is worth noting that on the territory of the Holy Land for thousands of years, bloody conflicts have occurred every now and then between Arabs and Jews, who consider it their ancestral territory, where their shrines are located.



Meanwhile, the root cause of the current confrontation can be considered the massive resettlement of Jews to Palestine, which began at the end of the XNUMXth century.

However, this phenomenon also had its own good reason, which consisted of mass pogroms against Jews and widespread anti-Semitism in many countries. At the beginning of the First World War, the situation became even worse, as the Jewish population was forcibly evicted as an “unreliable element.”

Typically, the Palestinian population under the rule of the Ottoman Empire lived in extreme poverty on lands unsuitable for fertility. In turn, Jewish refugees began to buy these lands from the Arabs for next to nothing and turn them into fertile oases. Naturally, their former owners did not like this.

Meanwhile, after the First World War and the collapse of the Ottoman Empire, the Palestinian lands essentially became a British colony. At the same time, in order to make it easier for themselves to subjugate the inhabitants of these territories, the British, in their favorite manner, used the principle of “divide and conquer,” constantly pitting Jews and Arabs against each other. It was during this period that the massacre began between the two peoples.

The situation worsened significantly after World War II, when at the UN level it was decided to allocate their own land to Jews, creating the State of Israel on the territory of Palestine in 1948.

Obviously, this decision could not satisfy the Arabs, whose opinions, by the way, were not asked. As a result, 7 countries went to war against Israel at once: Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Transjordan, Saudi Arabia, Iraq and Yemen. The confrontation ended in 1949 with the victory of Israel, which significantly expanded its territories.

Then, in 1958, the Suez Crisis began, in 1967 - the Six-Day War, in 1973 - the Yom Kippur War. As a result, in the 70s, only a small territory on the West Bank of Jordan and the Gaza Strip remained from Palestine.

Speaking of Gaza. The latter turned into a real concentration camp, in the miniature territory of which more than 2 million people lived, constantly subjected to repression by Israel.

Ultimately, this led to the formation in 1978 of the Hamas group, with which the IDF is fighting today.

Here one could sympathize with the Palestinians and take the side of the Arabs, if not for one “but”. The Palestinian group Hamas began to wage its “liberation struggle,” in most cases using terrorist methods. Actually, this time there was no killing of civilians and hostage-taking.

The IDF responds to terrorism by bombing Gaza, during which civilians are also killed, which only fuels the hatred of the parties and makes a diplomatic solution to the conflict impossible.

Based on the current situation, the confrontation can only end with the complete defeat of one of the parties. But this will not happen, since both Palestine and Israel are supported by allies who have serious weight on the world stage.

As a result, bloodshed in the Holy Land may continue for a very long time.

19 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
    2. 0
      26 October 2023 19: 35
      The conflict between Arabs and Jews is not eternal. Do not lie. For centuries they coexisted peacefully on this land under Ottoman rule. The conflict became eternal after the idiotic UN decision to create a Jewish nation-state called Israel. For 60 years, the whole world has been disentangling the results of this adventure, and no one knows how many more years it will continue to do this and how it will all end.
      1. 0
        27 October 2023 12: 44
        I don’t know about the eternal, but I don’t remember when the Jews lived in peace with any of their neighbors; they have no saint, although they pretend to be saints.
      2. +2
        27 October 2023 21: 47
        This is not a UN decision. The British decided this back in 1918. And it all started long before the UN decision. By the time of this decision, the Jews already had an army there. In essence, a Nazi state was created. By the way, no one denies this. Minus
    3. +2
      26 October 2023 19: 45
      There was the Palestinian Authority, which was led by the moderate PLO led by Arafat.
      Suddenly Hamas arose and took charge of the Gaza Strip, which dealt quite radically with Yasser’s supporters.
      Next - illegal Jewish settlements on the West Bank of the Jordan River, the transfer of the capital of Israel to Jerusalem.
      There was a virtual liquidation of the Palestinian state.
      The question is: can forced people live in peace with foreign occupiers?
      1. 0
        26 October 2023 19: 59
        Quote: knn54
        There was a virtual liquidation of the Palestinian state.

        You cannot eliminate something that did not exist and does not exist. But the erosion of the idea of ​​​​creating a Palestinian state is happening right before our eyes.
    4. The comment was deleted.
  2. -1
    26 October 2023 19: 05
    By condemning Hamas, you can slide into condemning the partisans who killed a policeman or the chairman who served the Germans somewhere in 1943.
  3. 0
    26 October 2023 19: 06
    By condemning Hamas, you can slide into condemning the partisans who killed a policeman or the chairman who served the Germans somewhere in 1943.
  4. +4
    26 October 2023 19: 06
    This conflict does not have, has not had and will not have a diplomatic solution. If only for this reason, only for the reason that the grounds for creating the state of Israel there were initially extremely mythologized. It was something from the series “my grandfather lost this.” And all this is due to the extreme inhospitability of the Jews, their belief in their own chosenness and corresponding attitude towards other peoples. This is the self-proclaimed right to bomb everyone left and right, to consider any country, any people, excuse me, as a food base. Satonovsky, Solovyov, Kedmi, Sosnovsky and so on... they filled the entire media space, privatized media mouthpieces, depriving representatives of the Russian people of the right to vote, leaving them only the opportunity to fight at the front. It’s simply disgusting and disgusting when they say everywhere “6 million people were killed by the Nazis” (Soloviev). And all the rest are not people at all? It all slips through. Enough of this private Zionist television under the federal umbrella!
  5. The comment was deleted.
    1. 0
      26 October 2023 19: 50
      I agree with every word!
  6. +3
    26 October 2023 19: 24
    The Palestinian group Hamas began to wage its “liberation struggle,” in most cases using terrorist methods.

    If the Jews have aviation, artillery, tanks, but the Palestinians do not have all this, what other methods are left for them to wage the liberation struggle? And didn’t the Jews themselves commit terrorist attacks against the same British before the creation of Israel? Have you already forgotten who the same “Irgun” was? So why is there so much indignation now?
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. 0
        27 October 2023 08: 01
        These volunteers are such dreamers, such dreamers.... They lie and believe themselves. They lie and they believe... But so far there is not a single independent investigation, not a single international commission, not a single concrete fact. They lie and believe. They lie and set themselves on fire. And they also want everyone to believe them.....Such dreamers.....
    2. 0
      31 October 2023 18: 36
      Quote: paul3390
      They have aviation, artillery, tanks, but the Palestinians don’t have all this - what other methods are left for them to wage the liberation struggle?

      Do you also justify the methods of struggle used by Basayev, Radulov, etc.? Budennovsk, Dubrovka, Beslan?
  7. 0
    26 October 2023 19: 31
    The crisis in Gaza can only be resolved politically through the creation of a Palestinian state within the 1967 borders with its capital in East Jerusalem based on UN Security Council resolutions
    1. 0
      26 October 2023 19: 42
      Jews understand well that if the state of Palestine is created, it will be anti-Israeli and therefore will never allow its creation. This means that the conflict will be eternal. And we must thank the UN, which Israel is now sending to hell.
  8. -1
    26 October 2023 19: 43
    Jews came to those places and created their own state using terrorist methods. For many years they bombed right and left. But “they want peace.” They live there only because the “reptilians” need a point of tension there.
  9. 0
    26 October 2023 19: 50
    Eternal conflict in the Holy Land: why there is no chance for a diplomatic solution to the Palestinian-Israeli problem

    Can anyone answer where, in what corner of the Earth were Jews greeted with open arms?
    What kind of neighbors did they get along with? There is no guarantee that if Israel is transferred to some US state, they will get along with the Americans...
    Most likely it's in the Jewish state itself and the basic provisions of the Torah. Probably, everything that Moses heard did not concern the rest of the nations, but was intended purely for his brothers and sisters.
    * * *
    But these are just my assumptions. Perhaps someone has other examples and information.
  10. 0
    26 October 2023 19: 59
    In fact, an entire region was organized for Jews, the size of one and a half Israel, by the way, the only Jewish administrative-territorial entity in the world, besides Israel, with official legal status. Is this where they are going to build new cities? Coincidence?))
  11. +1
    26 October 2023 20: 09
    This is not the first time, by the way, that I have heard that the Talmud is compared to Adolf Hitler’s Mein Kampf. At first glance, this is an inappropriate comparison. But, if you remember how many Jews admire the Fuhrer (writers Mikhail Weller, Dmitry Bykov; Shenderovich and many others), then why can’t I? Moreover, a lot has been written about the Jewishness of Adolf Hitler, as well as about the Jewish origin of a number of other leaders of the Third Reich (Mr. Reinhard Heydrich, for example).
    So here it is. It is naive to see an eternal victim in a people who officially consider themselves superior to all others and reserve the right to any actions in relation to other peoples. I will not open America if I emphasize that today Israel does not have a Constitution. This is wildness. At the same time, of course, no one says that this is a sign of backwardness; no one says that the absence of the Basic Law, replaced by half-primitive “concepts”, is barbaric. But barbarism does exist. In fact, Izrial is a state where Nazism is officially legalized. Therefore, it is not surprising that Zionism once created the “Third Reich” project to solve its problems.
    "The Jews are above all, and Chabad is above the Jews." The motto of this sect, responsible, in my opinion, for the carnage of World War II.
  12. 0
    27 October 2023 21: 50
    The problem cannot be solved. And it's not even about Israel. Look who is “behind” Israel. The richest people in the world
  13. The comment was deleted.
  14. 0
    30 October 2023 08: 12
    Meanwhile, the root cause of the current confrontation can be considered the massive resettlement of Jews to Palestine, which began at the end of the XNUMXth century.

    However, this phenomenon also had its own good reason, which consisted of mass pogroms against Jews and widespread anti-Semitism in many countries. At the beginning of the First World War, the situation became even worse, as the Jewish population was forcibly evicted as an “unreliable element.”


    There must be a root cause for the negative attitude towards Jews among many peoples of the world. Most likely this is the persistent desire of the Jews to remake everyone for themselves.