Truth as a guarantee of victory

Increasingly, military correspondents, political scientists, experts at various levels say that it is impossible to defeat the enemy without the truth, without being sincere to ourselves. It is impossible to achieve success at the front, when in the largest media and in official reports everything is rosy, everything is victorious, smooth and so beautiful that real combatants are often turned inside out.

Everyone needs the truth: from the average layman to the largest military leader. This is the key to success. It is impossible to bury your head in a pillow or somewhere else - in the sand - to invent some kind of illusion for yourself and blindly believe in it, believe so much that when the illusion begins to disappear, it becomes unbearably painful.

At the same time, it is important not only and not so much to look for the guilty, but to answer directly and frankly the question: why did this happen? What needs to be done so that the errors are taken into account and the problem is solved? And if one responsible person is simply exchanged for another, will there be a result, or should “something be changed at the conservatory”, as the classic of Russian satire said.

Film director Nikita Mikhalkov reflects on the truth, revelation to ourselves, as well as other things that have become actual during our special military operation, on the air of the Besogon program.

Comments

[filibuster]

Besagon / Mikhalkov and the truth is not compatible things.

[flicker]

Besagon / Mikhalkov and the truth is not compatible things.

The question is: who knows the truth?

[antivirus]

Well done Nikita, he cuts the chip. For myself. Party committees and trade unions brought up with a clear goal *to build a country and socialism.
And Mikhalkov loves himself.
Under him or because of him, the birth rate has fallen and Russia and Russians are dying out?
Or is he not guilty on the side, and is not responsible for anything?
Questions without answer.
The refined and sensuous have become too refined in their search for truth.
And they forgot the prose of life, versifiers.

[sdtreew]

after the 53rd year, it was no longer necessary to build socialism and the country, the corresponding changes were made to the Constitution and the party switched to the construction of communism - later it will be declared voluntarism, but they will not turn off the path, all this will lead to a drop in the birth rate and other stagnant phenomena.

[tarkhil]

Disgusting demagogy. First of all, the truth is reliable reports on the situation of the troops and on the supply and training. Not bullshit.

[yuriy55]

Quote from: filibuster

Besogon / Mikhalkov and the truth is not compatible things.

The compatibility of things determines the time. There is nothing wrong with the fact that an actor of Soviet and Russian cinema in the right manner and in a competent language sets out his vision of various events, facts, situations. He does this not for self-interest, but for enlightenment, because some viewers and listeners are no longer capable of either independently analyzing today's life or presenting their own views in writing, because it is punishable to insert various interjections and swear words between words on the site.
Mikhalkov is not to be loved. You can watch or not watch. Who likes:

Quote: antivirus

But Mikhalkov loves himself.

In our country everyone loves himself, but not everyone is respected. The main thing in this business is not to overlove yourself!
I really liked one saying, where the hero (Ilya Semyonovich Melnikov) says:
“... Fifteen lines,” Melnikov repeated Kostya's words. - But it's a lot. Most people only have a dash between two dates...»

[runway-1]

He himself spread false information more than once, that is, "ducks" flew ...

[alekseykabanets]

Greetings!

Quote: WFP-1

He himself spread false information more than once, that is, "ducks" flew ...

Yes, he still can't.
Hero right! How can this animal be taken seriously, I do not understand!

[Lech from Android.]

Everyone needs the truth: from the average layman to the largest military leader.

It is doubtful somehow ... there is a law on military and state secrets ... there, for the truth, they will immediately determine 15 years.
It is beneficial for the military to drive misinformation about their operations to the enemy, the special forces also do not need to tell what is happening with them, the townsfolk and ordinary citizens find themselves in the role of dummy which both the enemy and the state use for their peace of mind.
You can’t talk, for example, about your losses, defeats, weaknesses in management, supply, and much more.
In general, in a war, talking about the truth is not serious, otherwise they can be mistaken for a spy or an accomplice of the enemy.

[flicker]

It is doubtful somehow ... there is a law on military and state secrets ... there, for the truth, they will immediately determine 15 years.
It is beneficial for the military to drive misinformation about their operations to the enemy, the special forces also do not need to tell what is happening with them, the townsfolk and ordinary citizens find themselves in the role of dummy which both the enemy and the state use for their peace of mind.
You can’t talk, for example, about your losses, defeats, weaknesses in management, supply, and much more.
In general, in a war, talking about the truth is not serious, otherwise they may be mistaken for a spy or an accomplice of the enemy

Absolutely agree with you.
---
In addition, in the very thesis "it is necessary to tell the truth" a FALSE is hidden.
Suppose there are 100 events during the day, 90 positive and 10 negative.
Which of these events will be imposed on us?
Considering in whose hands the media, the Internet, etc., from morning to evening they will start telling us about 10 negative ones (and keep silent about 90 positive ones) - as a result (telling the truth !!!) we will get a completely DISTORTED (having nothing to do with the real) picture of what is happening.
---
So the truth about 10 negative events WITHOUT mentioning 90 positive events would give us a FALSE.

[Stas157]

Quote: flicker

So the truth about 10 negative events WITHOUT mentioning 90 positive events would give us a FALSE.

Let's look at the map. And no matter what anyone says, the whole score is on the scoreboard.

Here they gave Kherson and how can one cheat here? They gave it themselves or they took it from us - it doesn’t matter for history.

[flicker]

Let's look at the map. And no matter what anyone says, the whole score is on the scoreboard.

And what is the "scale" of the map, can you see everything there?
Can you see the state of the electric power industry in Ukraine?
And do you see on this map the financial (and not only) costs that the EU and the US are forced to bear to maintain the military-technical capabilities of Ukraine?
And how long can you fight without a rear?

And such questions are still a wagon and a small cart.

[sdtreew]

A lie is something that lies on the surface, that is, it is a superficial truth - foam that does not tell us anything about the essence, and, accordingly, misleads and deceives. That is, almost all daily journalism is clinging to bare facts from the surface, and some of them can be misleading and form a misconception about reality.
The task is to get to the bottom of the phenomenon - this will be true. Truth is a holistic view of reality.

[Battle Toads]

Do you want the truth?) Ok

1) The main goal of the Special Military Operation is the unification of the Slavic peoples into a single Russian state

2) since 2014, Russia has focused its efforts on the production of hypersonic weapons and supernova weapons, thanks to the presence of which the maximum that NATO is now capable of is sending mercenaries and weapons to Ukraine, but will not dare to conduct military operations against Russia.

3) The special military operation will end with the full achievement of all the goals declared by Russia, and the West knows this.

4) since the SVO is inherently an ANTI-TERRORISM operation and not a war, the leadership of the General Staff will often adopt non-traditional methods of maintaining a database.

5) no war will be declared to Ukraine

6) enough truth for now

[sergo1914]

Quote from BattleToads

Do you want the truth?) Ok

1) The main goal of the Special Military Operation is the unification of the Slavic peoples into a single Russian state

2) since 2014, Russia has focused its efforts on the production of hypersonic weapons and supernova weapons, thanks to the presence of which the maximum that NATO is now capable of is sending mercenaries and weapons to Ukraine, but will not dare to conduct military operations against Russia.

3) The special military operation will end with the full achievement of all the goals declared by Russia, and the West knows this.

4) since the SVO is inherently an ANTI-TERRORISM operation and not a war, the leadership of the General Staff will often adopt non-traditional methods of maintaining a database.

5) no war will be declared to Ukraine

6) enough truth for now

What did you want to say? And there seems to be a word, there are also punctuation marks, but there is no sense ...

[Lech from Android.]

send mercenaries and weapons to Ukraine, but will not dare to conduct military operations against Russia.

Why laugh then ... NATO strategists have already dealt a blow to our airfields by an unconventional method.

[Garik Gorkin]

The main goal of the Special Military Operation is the unification of the Slavic peoples into a single Russian state

To survive in the war with the Anglo-Saxons, it is necessary to unite all the Russian-speaking peoples (the former USSR), and not just the Slavic ones.
There are several definitions of the word Russian.

The difference between the Russian nation and the Russian ethnic group. Is it dangerous to focus on one ethnic group, calling it Russian?
In a broad sense, Russians are not an ethnic group, but a CULTURAL AND HISTORICAL nation, consisting of more than a hundred ethnic groups, including Slavs.
Russian is a linguistic people. No, not an "adjective", but a linguistic people. The state was built on this for a thousand years.
This principle provided a single people for the vast territory of the Empire, the 6th part of the planet.
The Russian Empire is unique - it is an inclusive empire, defensive and defensive, the elites of the accepted peoples became the elites of the Empire, like Shamil, for example.
Western empires were built differently, the nations were there by blood and there was no mixing with the colonized territories, since these territories were intended for exploitation.

Stalin called himself a Russian Georgian.
At a reception in honor of the Victory, Stalin made a toast to the great Russian people and their patience. The moved marshal of the armored forces Pavel Rybalko approached him:
- As you, Comrade Stalin, remarkably said about the Russian people! How do you Georgians know the Russian people so deeply?
Stalin answered angrily:
- I am not Georgian - I am Russian of Georgian origin!

[alekseykabanets]

Quote: Garik Gorkin

To survive in the war with the Anglo-Saxons, it is necessary to unite all the Russian-speaking peoples (the former USSR), and not just the Slavic ones. ...

To begin with, let's start with the fact that we do not have any war with the Anglo-Saxons.)))) And in general, I'm very interested in who exactly you understand by the term "Anglo-Saxons". I would venture to suggest that by this term you mean Western European and American capital. Or do you have claims against the Spanish, Italian or English communists? And home-grown capital maintains close economic relations with Western European and American capital. Do you think it is possible to fight and trade at the same time? The war is sorted out.))) Now tell me please, why should I unite with anyone on national, and not on ideological grounds? After all, the USSR (especially the early one) was an association, first of all, on an ideological basis, namely, you set it as an example and the actor Frunzik Mushegovich Mkrtchyan clearly said to a slow-witted German that he was a Soviet person. Did it slip away from you? It’s just that at that time the words Russian and Soviet were synonymous. On a national basis, only separation is possible or the same regime as that of one underestimated Austrian artist, well, or look at Ukraine. And then tell me what is Chinese capital. in your opinion, is it better than Anglo-American?

[runway-1]

Greetings!
I remember that I once met in articles and books such, for example, the phrase: "Russian Soviet scientist."
To our great regret, the formation of a new historical community - the Soviet people, was not easy and, in fact, was forcibly interrupted ...

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Garik Gorkin

In a broad sense, Russians are not an ethnic group, but a CULTURAL AND HISTORICAL nation, consisting of more than a hundred ethnic groups, including Slavs.

Who drove this dangerous nonsense into your head? And you asked, for example, the Chechens - do they want to call themselves Russians? And the Buryats, and the Kalmyks, and the Dagestanis? But in Dagestan there are 33 nationalities. And what, will they all forget about their nationality and begin to call themselves Russians? I am sure that not a single Tatar would wish to betray his nationality and call himself Russian. Why do you impose on the peoples not their nationality? Russian is a nationality and nothing more, no need to invent and invent. Russia is a multinational country. What's bad about it? All nationalities in our country are equal in everything and in rights and duties. Have you ever thought that by imposing a "cultural-historical nation" you, intentionally or not, offend and humiliate other nationalities of the Russian Federation? Does the experience of the outskirts teach you nothing. After all, everyone there, the "president" himself, wrote down as Ukrainians. And forced to speak Move. But he is forgiven - he does not understand the difference between nationality and citizenship. And you?
= In a broad sense, Russians are not an ethnic group, =
Those. You, without hesitation, deprived me of my nationality? Who gave you such a right? Well, then go on and tell me - what ethnic group do I belong to?
Yes, the arrogant Saxons are dreaming of utterly destroying the Russians. Physically, it did not work out, we decided to go the other way - we will erase, disperse their nationality. And it began - Russian is not a nationality, but a state of mind, Russian is not a nationality, but a cultural and historical nation, etc. Well, try it.

[Vladimir M]

Or maybe you just need to start. And then all our actions are half-hearted.

[Tagan]

Quote from: filibuster

Besagon / Mikhalkov and the truth is not compatible things.

Navalny too. Nevertheless, you refer to it (in earlier comments). And no contradictions, right? ))

[filibuster]

Navalny exploits quite a real field for his activities: Russian corruption, he (his foundation) has repeatedly announced corruption in the military-industrial complex, there have been investigations against Chemezov, but now we ourselves have seen how close Navalny is to the truth.
Mikhalkov, on the other hand, is simply working out the agenda that the Kremlin needs, he removed frankly discrediting / belittling the victory of the USSR in the Second World War, Burnt by the Sun 2/3, relatively speaking, if Mikhalkov were in opposition, then for these films he could well have been attracted under the article: Rehabilitation of Nazism.

[alexoff]

Every second person can tell about corruption in the military-industrial complex and in the Russian Federation in general, in order not to see it you have to be blind. But building your policy on phrases like "the sun rises at sunrise, ladies of easy virtue work in a brothel" is rather strange, especially when your former boss is caught getting a suitcase of money, and you say that this is all untrue and he is good.

[filibuster]

Every second person can tell about corruption in the military-industrial complex and in the Russian Federation in general, in order not to see it you have to be blind

Here Navalny traveled far and wide on this topic, without inventing anything by and large.

But building your policy on phrases like "the sun rises at sunrise, ladies of easy virtue work in a brothel" is rather strange, especially when your former boss is caught getting a suitcase of money, and you say that this is all untrue and he is good.

I don’t know why for you large-scale and destructive corruption is like "the sun rises at sunrise."
I repeat, Navalny worked precisely on an existing problem in the country, Mikhalkov has long become a propagandist, and has long lost its relevance for the younger generation (up to 35), but he can scare us “old people” with the fact that Americans “hack” our brains through 5G, but young people don’t even always knows about the existence of Mikhalkov.

[alexoff]

We have corruption fighters every second journalist. Since you know him so well, can you tell us what kind of eye surgery he had in Spain in 2016, which could not be done in the Russian Federation, after which he went to the beach, where the legendary pictures were taken? And then at about the same time I repaired my own eyes and was quite surprised by such a story - only three and a half types can do eye operations, and beaches are contraindicated there for many weeks and even months. Now I’m asking all the Navalnists, no one can answer, and moreover, no one even thinks to find out this question. All answers - but Mikhalkov, but Putin. Well then why Navalny? Vote for me, I've never taken bribes in my life, I didn't arrange firms in Montenegro and I didn't ruin any kirovlesov.

[gromit]

You will be burned for casting the "Navalny" spell.
This is the mark of a heretic - a traitor, a gay European, a liberal.

If you voice Navalny's theses without mentioning his name and the name of the FBK, then the public will be much more favorable, especially the National Socialist-minded.

[Battle Toads]

Quote: Vladimir M

Or maybe you just need to start. And then all our actions are half-hearted.

Get to the front line and your actions will be integral!

[Lech from Android.]

Quote from BattleToads

Get to the front line and your actions will be integral!

Yeah, you'll get there ... Strelkov tried ... one desire is not enough here.

[Raccoon Raccoon]

Kleptocracy is true - like a cockroach dust. From these "Besogons" the elderly already have physical heartburn, like after an expired beer.

[Andrei from Chelyabinsk]

It is impossible to bury your head in a pillow or somewhere else - in the sand - to invent some kind of illusion for yourself and blindly believe in it

Why not? Our President proves by personal example that it is very possible...

[Lech from Android.]

Our president is in a difficult position...
frankly, I wouldn't want to be a rower in his galley.
It seems that there is power, and at the same time, he is burdened with thousands of obligations, which he himself has loaded ... where voluntarily, and where involuntarily.

[Andrei from Chelyabinsk]

Quote: Lech from Android.

Our president is in a difficult position...

It could be greatly simplified... by pulling out the head. Alas, it looks like the age is not the same. Brezhnevism in its purest form

[Beringovsky]

Age has nothing to do with it, it was like that before. He always does such a feint, chik chirp I'm in the house! Since the "gas war" in 2005, when he fell out of the public field for a couple of weeks. Then he behaved in the same way in 2008, when oil collapsed, followed by the ruble. Then he did the same at the end of 2014. Well, how he climbed into the bunker in covid, leaving everything, this is generally a song. So everything is as usual and I'm not even surprised at all by his behavior. This is not a rambu with a chinganchguk to portray.

[alexoff]

Is the truth needed? Well, so that Shoigu would come out and say - we left Kupyansk and Balakleya to lift sanctions against Abramovich and promises to unblock the ammonia pipeline? Or did Surovikin immediately say that difficult decisions would be made so that the price ceiling for oil would be $60, not $20? Well, they told us the truth earlier - they scored on drones, failed import substitution, stole winter uniforms, and then what?

[Lech from Android.]

Ek where did you go ... dreams, dreams.

[rocket757]

Truth as a guarantee of victory

. The topic was discussed more than once ... at least something, at least somewhere, have there been any changes?
Tops, bottoms, live, as it were, their own lives, although the interdependence is direct, and can become critical, especially when the paths of the path diverge in different directions.

[for]

Truth as a guarantee of victory

Everyone has their own truth and everyone believes what they want.

[Battle Toads]

Quote: Garik Gorkin

The main goal of the Special Military Operation is the unification of the Slavic peoples into a single Russian state

To survive in the war with the Anglo-Saxons, it is necessary to unite all the Russian-speaking peoples (the former USSR), and not just the Slavic ones.
There are several definitions of the word Russian.

The difference between the Russian nation and the Russian ethnic group. Is it dangerous to focus on one ethnic group, calling it Russian?
In a broad sense, Russians are not an ethnic group, but a CULTURAL AND HISTORICAL nation, consisting of more than a hundred ethnic groups, including Slavs.
Russian is a linguistic people. No, not an "adjective", but a linguistic people. The state was built on this for a thousand years.
This principle provided a single people for the vast territory of the Empire, the 6th part of the planet.
The Russian Empire is unique - it is an inclusive empire, defensive and defensive, the elites of the accepted peoples became the elites of the Empire, like Shamil, for example.
Western empires were built differently, the nations were there by blood and there was no mixing with the colonized territories, since these territories were intended for exploitation.

Stalin called himself a Russian Georgian.
At a reception in honor of the Victory, Stalin made a toast to the great Russian people and their patience. The moved marshal of the armored forces Pavel Rybalko approached him:
- As you, Comrade Stalin, remarkably said about the Russian people! How do you Georgians know the Russian people so deeply?
Stalin answered angrily:
- I am not Georgian - I am Russian of Georgian origin!

Support!

[parusnik]

"If you're drinking with thieves, Watch out for your wallet. If you're walking on a muddy road, You can't help but get your feet dirty. If you pull out your hair, You won't put it back. And your head is always responsible for where your ass sits. The truth is always the same "(c)

[Tagan]

Quote from: filibuster

Navalny exploits quite a real field for his activities: Russian corruption, he (his foundation) has repeatedly announced corruption in the military-industrial complex, there have been investigations against Chemezov, but now we ourselves have seen how close Navalny is to the truth.
Mikhalkov, on the other hand, is simply working out the agenda that the Kremlin needs, he removed frankly discrediting / belittling the victory of the USSR in the Second World War, Burnt by the Sun 2/3, relatively speaking, if Mikhalkov were in opposition, then for these films he could well have been attracted under the article: Rehabilitation of Nazism.

That is, the codpiece-fuhrer can be justified and taken for granted only because he worked out the agenda NOT of the Kremlin.
Here it is ...))) This is different. Understand.
We will modestly omit the fact that there is nowhere to put samples on it.

[filibuster]

We will modestly omit the fact that there is nowhere to put samples on it.

Quite, as well as on anyone who participates in politics, but compared to Mikhalkov, Navalny is an innocent child.

[alexoff]

No one will lift a finger for Migalkov, and Biden threatened more for Navalny than for the whole of Ukraine. Why so much honor? Well, under this sauce, I suppose Yeltsin in 1991 was an innocent child near Gorbachev

[flicker]

and Biden threatened more for Navalny than for the whole of Ukraine. Why so much honor?

Read between the lines. If the Anglo-Saxon threatens someone, then he will do it himself.
If Assad uses chemical weapons, then ... Skripal was poisoned by the Anglo-Saxons - Russia received sanctions, Russia allegedly interfered in the US elections - sanctions, if Russia uses nuclear weapons - then Ukraine is preparing a provocation with a dirty bomb.

So it is with Navalny - if Biden threatened, then they themselves were preparing to remove him. They tried to poison him (even the girl from London was discharged), we were forced to send him to Germany.

[alexoff]

So I know this, I'm still trying to find at least one Navalny lover who is ready to answer such questions. While I could not find, all at once in the bushes

[petrol cutter]

What kind of truth is that?
Are all children small?
Anyone who is over forty years old and worked in the same production knows perfectly well that there is truth, that there is window dressing.
Everyone knows perfectly well that there is nothing, but let's give a five-year plan in three years. I think the same way on the fronts.
However, we are trying.
That’s the whole truth.

[Vsevolod Z]

But Nikita does not want to return 1%, our martyr. The ghoul sits on 1% of all potentially recording and storing and teaches the poor lackeys. There were people and everything has become.

[Woodman]

Everyone needs the truth: from the average layman to the largest military leader. This is the key to success.

You just need to understand that for success, the "ordinary layman" is supposed to know the "truth" much less than the "largest military leader." Plus, you need to understand that part of what they say from the stands is intended for opponents and "partners", i.e. is deliberate disinformation and it is not necessary to arrange "Yaroslavna's lament" after such statements. So the higher a person's "tolerance", the more "truth" he knows. And that's okay.

[Barberry25]

what is needed is not truth, but responsibility, everyone must do what they must. and not imitate activity .. but the truth should be in the reports for those who make decisions .. and not for everyone .. sorry, but these are military operations, not a wedding

[katarsafebox.com]

But Nikishka the besogon himself is a well-known liar ...

[certero]

Completely agree with the message of this post.
But I do not agree with the illustration of the video of the liar.

[Nikolay Malyugin]

"If the devil is playing with me, if God is in charge." The keepers of truth have always been in power. With relative justice, something fell into the hands of the people.

[tarkhil]

Mikhalkov, talking about the truth - it's like a castrato, talking about love.
The handle from a shovel is in his ... ... ... hands.

[tarkhil]

And if you want GOOD examples of truth from a GOOD person and professional, read Svechin.

[Bogalex]

He has already shown everyone in "Burnt by the Sun" what truth he cares for. Thanks, we don't need that. Eat your own slops.

[flyer]

There is no truth, on both sides .... If it were, then it would be right for the leadership to go out to the people and explain why we have no partners, the CSTO circle is assembled from such leaders who are afraid to entrust their rear, the legacy of the USSR military-industrial complex still plays a key factor, and why the officials and oligarchs grew rich not together with the people, but separately.

[Maks1995]

There was a joke, remember?
"There is no truth, Russia is sold, only Labor remains"
IMHO, and now it’s somehow relevant, in the analysis of the statements of the Ministry of Defense and officials on the VO that they have already ground everyone one and a half times, there will be a tribunal just about, Ukraine itself will not suffer, only the Nazis, there will be no mobilization, etc.

[Ivanov IV]

"- Everyone has his own truth, only the Truth is one ....."
I would like the Truth to be closer (nearer) to the Truth.