Edward I Plantagenet. English crusader prince

91
Edward I Plantagenet. English crusader prince
Monument to Edward I at Brough-by-Sand

Edward (Edward, in Russian-language sources they often write Edward) I Plantagenet became one of the last high-ranking crusaders in Europe. However, his trip to the Holy Land traditionally remains in the shadow of his future activities. He is much better known as the king who for the first time united England, Wales and Scotland in one state (his other nickname, however, given to him after his death is Malleus Scotorum, “Hammer of the Scots”).


This is how the audience of the 1995 Hollywood film Braveheart saw King Edward I.


And this is what this king looks like in a portrait in Westminster Abbey

Scotland was conquered by Edward's great-grandfather, Henry II, who in 1174 defeated the army of this kingdom in the battle of Alnwick. But already in 1189, his son Richard the Lionheart sold it to the Scottish pretender William for 10 silver marks - the knight-king needed money to participate in the Third Crusade. But on April 000, 27, Edward I Plantagenet defeated the Scottish army at the Battle of Dunbar and captured the king of this country, John Balliol, who entered history as the first prisoner of the Tower of such rank. He was later exiled to France, where he died.




Captured John Balliol before Edward I

Another valuable trophy of Edward was the Coronation Stone of Scotland (Scottish Stone of Destiny, Skone Stone), which since 847 has been located in Skone (Skoon) Abbey and allegedly notified everyone with a cry when a true contender for the throne sat on it. He was forever silenced after he was placed under the foundation of the English throne in Westminster Abbey:


Skone stone. The Scots believed that it was the base of the famous "Jacob's ladder". According to another legend, the stone was brought from Ireland by the first king of the Scots Fergus, according to the third - by Saint Colombo (the baptist of Scotland)

Now this stone is in the Edinburgh Cathedral. Its origin, history, and incredible kidnapping in 1950 were described in the article "Stones of Destiny".

However, the appeasement of Scotland was still far away, and Edward I died during the next campaign against the rebellious northerners - July 7, 1307.


Memorial sign at the place of death of Edward I, Burgh by sands, Cumbria

With the Welsh, Edward I did better: it is thanks to him that all the heirs to the throne of Great Britain bear the title of Prince of Wales. They say that the leaders of Wales conquered by Edward for a long time did not want to take the vassal oath to the English king - until he promised them that he would be the Prince of Wales "a local native who does not know a word of either English or French". Such was his son, who was born the day before in the Welsh castle of Carnarvon: he, of course, did not yet know how to speak.


"First Prince of Wales". Illustration of the book Royal Children of English History

Among other things, Edward I became famous for issuing the Great Statutes, which formed the basis of English law.


Edward I in Parliament

And also the expulsion of the Jews from England in 1290 (and before that he ordered them to sew a yellow star on their clothes).

In addition, Edward I is sometimes called "the first English king of England" - before him, since the time of William the Conqueror, England for the monarchs of this country was a secondary outlying territory. The lands belonging to the English kings in the territory of present-day France were much more valued.


The possessions of the English Plantagenets in France

Edward's grandfather, John, brother and rival of Richard the Lionheart, was named Landless by his father because he did not get the mainland possessions already distributed among his eldest sons. At the same time, John received a large amount of land in England, and in 1177 also all of Ireland, but the title of English landowner and lord for a self-respecting Norman was then inexpensive. And it was Edward I who began to pay the most attention to his English possessions. Therefore, in the people's memory, this king remained a wise and just ruler.


Edward I

But today we will talk about Edward I as a crusader.

Early life of Edward I


Edward I Plantagenet was born on June 17, 1239 in the family of King Henry III of England (son of John Landless) and Eleanor of Provence. At the time of marriage, Henry's wife was 12 years old, she gave birth to her first child, Edward, the hero of our article, 5 years later, when she was 17. He received his name in honor of the Anglo-Saxon king of the Wessex dynasty, Edward the Confessor, who was revered by Henry III.

Edward's mother's sisters were Margarita, wife of the French crusader king Louis IX (Saint), Sancha, wife of Richard of Cornwall, who became king of Germany, and Beatrice, wife of Charles I of Anjou, future king of Sicily.

Edward's wife was also named Eleanor, she was the daughter of King Ferdinand III of Castile.


Edward I and Eleanor of Castile. Miniature from a manuscript from the early XNUMXth century. Pay attention to Edward's right eyelid: this is congenital blepharoptosis, which he inherited from his father

Edward and Eleanor seemed to love each other, which is rare in royal families. After the death of his wife in 1290, Edward married only 9 years later - Princess Margaret of France, the youngest daughter of Philip III, son of Saint Louis, who died during the Eighth Crusade - in Tunisia.

Edward is described as a physically strong and at that time very tall (height 188 cm) man, as evidenced by his nickname - "Longshanks" ("Long-legged"). The right eye, as you remember, was half-covered due to congenital ptosis of the upper eyelid. Edward's character was quick-tempered, in the "Songs of Lewis" (1264) the king is compared to a leopard, which in those days was considered an example of an absolutely unpredictable predator. It was said that once, in a fit of anger, he tore a tuft of hair from the head of his son and heir, the future King Edward II. And the dean of the chapter of St. Paul's Cathedral in 1295 died during a conversation with this king.

The notorious curse of Merlin, according to which, in the Plantagenet family, the son had to rebel against his father, and the brother against his brother, still acted, but already weakly. In 1259, Edward participated in the uprising of the English barons, but later reconciled with his father and participated in the fighting on his side.

The situation in the Holy Land: the onslaught of the Mamluks


Things were not going well in the Christian states of Palestine. Jerusalem was lost back in 1244. The Seventh Crusade, led by the French King Louis IX, ended in complete failure. The main threat to the Christian lands of Palestine now came from Egypt, where in 1250 the Mamluks, former Kipchak slaves, came to power, from which the Sultan's guard was formed. In 1260, at the battle of Ain Jalut, the Mamluks even defeated the Mongols. Shortly thereafter, the ruling Sultan Kutuz was killed by his best commander, Baibars, who became famous during the battles with the Crusaders of the Seventh Campaign, when Saint Louis and his brother Alphonse were captured at El Mansur, another brother of the king, Robert d'Artois, died.

Christians still held Arsuf, Atlit, Haifa, Safed, Jaffa, Ascalon and Caesarea, but it was clear to everyone that the fall of these cities was only a matter of time. Nevertheless, another attempt was made to help fellow Palestinians. The French king Louis IX, who had already been captured by the Mamluks, announced on March 25, 1267 that he was again accepting the cross. Together with him, three of his sons gathered on the campaign - the heir Philip (the future father-in-law of the hero of our article), Jean Tristan (born in Damietta besieged by the Mamluks) and Peter, as well as the king's brothers - Alphonse (also a former prisoner of the Mamluks) and Charles I, King of Sicily . The intention to join the new (Eighth) Crusade was announced by King Thibaut II of Navarre and Prince Edward of England. But, as they say, “the fairy tale is soon told, but the deed is not soon done”: Louis IX was able to go on a campaign only in the summer of 1270. Meanwhile, Baybars in 1265 defeated the Armenians of Cilicia, who were allies of the Christian states of Palestine. In 1268, he captured Jaffa and Antioch, cities that the crusaders had owned for 170 years.

From Antioch Baibars sent the following letter to Bohemond VI, Prince of Antioch and Count of Tripoli:

“The count, the head of the Christians, who will now have to be content with the title of count – may God guide him on the right path, instructing him to follow good and entrusting him with the treasure of good advice – already knows how we moved against Tripoli and ruined the heart of his dominion ...

We took the city by storm at the fourth hour on Sunday, the 4th (number) of the highly revered Ramadan and terrified all whom you chose to protect and defend it ...

You should have seen your knights stretched out under the hooves of horses, your houses, into which marauders burst and devastated by robbers; your ladies, sold four at a time and bought at the price of one dinar of your own money! You should have seen your churches, with torn off crosses, sheets torn from the wrong Gospel, dug up graves of the patriarchs! You should have seen your enemy, a Muslim, trampling the place of worship with his feet, as monks, priests and deacons huddled on the altar; the patriarchs were struck by unexpected misfortune, and the princes of the blood were led into slavery. You should have seen how the fire spread through your palaces, how your dead burned in the fire of this world in front of the Fire of another world, how your palaces became unrecognizable, churches collapsed and destroyed ...

This letter contains good newsthat you are in good health and God has given you a long life, for at this moment you are not in Antioch, but are in another place. Otherwise, you would now be dead, captured, wounded, or mistreated.”


Bust of Baybars at the Cairo War Museum

Now the Christian lands of Palestine were a narrow coastal strip from Gaza to northern Syria. In 1271 Baibars planned to expel the Crusaders from the county of Tripoli.

Prince Edward Cross


On June 24, 1268, Edward, his brother Edmund the Humpbacked, Earl of Lancaster (although some argue that the evidence of the deformity of this prince is a 17th-century falsification created on the orders of John of Gaunt), and cousin Henry of Aleman officially announced the decision to go to the Crusade hike. The question was in money, which was sorely lacking for fees. I had to borrow 500 pounds from the French king Louis IX and collect a tax from the British of 5% of their movable property, which they had not been subject to since 1237. For the approval of this tax, Henry III agreed to confirm the Magna Carta.

Some of the barons of still independent Scotland also joined Edward. Among them was Adam de Kilconquar, who would die at Acre, and his widow would marry Robert the Bruce, 6th Lord of Annandale. In this family, the future king of Scotland, also Robert, will be born, who will restore the independence of his country, conquered by Edward I - after the death of this king, during the reign of his son Edward II. But the Scottish barons acted at their own peril and risk, since King Alexander III prudently refused to participate in this campaign.

Edward gathered a small army - about a thousand people, including 225 knights. Edward's wife Eleanor went with Edward, who later gave birth to a daughter in Acre. At the place of birth, the girl received the name Joanna Akko (she is better known as Joan of England).

Edward sailed from Dover with his force on 20 August 1270. At the end of September, he arrived at Aigues-Maur (a French Mediterranean port), where he learned that the crusading army had already sailed for Tunisia (it landed in Carthage on July 17). Having reached the crusader camp, Edward learned that Louis IX and his son Jean Tristan had died of dysentery, and with them many other noblemen. Moreover, Charles I, who arrived in Tunisia on the day of the death of Louis, had already signed a peace treaty with the emir. The crusaders dreamed of only one thing - to quickly get out of Tunisia, and on November 1, the Christian army sailed from its shores. On the way home, about 4 thousand more people died, including King Thibaut II of Navarre, brother of Louis IX Alphonse de Poitiers and his wife Jeanne, wife of Philip III Queen Isabella.

And Edward decided to go to Acre to help Bohemond VI, oppressed by the Mamluks. This expedition of the English prince, which began as part of the Eighth Crusade, is sometimes singled out as a separate campaign, calling it the Ninth.

In the next article, we will continue our story and talk about the crusade of Prince Edward Plantagenet.
91 comment
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. 0
    29 May 2022 06: 03
    Quote: Author
    ... Louis IX and his son Jean
    Tristan died of dysentery.

    How many times have they said - wash your hands before eating, boil water, but no, European savages don't care.
    By the way, there is an opinion that this is how the Turks seized Tsargrad - because of the Greeks' non-compliance with the emergency regime (they did not have their own "Lord of the benches")
  2. +9
    29 May 2022 07: 16
    Along the way, somehow the curse of Merlin, according to which the son had to rebel against his father, and the brother against his brother, spread to the Ruryukoviches. smile
    1. +4
      29 May 2022 09: 56
      "It spread to the Rurikovichs", but at that time it could not be otherwise.
      Do you want to eat everyone? So the prince wanted to eat every day and preferably more satisfying
      1. +4
        29 May 2022 10: 08
        Katya-Katyusha, I'm not much, about something else, if Merlin cursed the English kings, then who cursed the Ruriks? smile
        1. +1
          29 May 2022 11: 24
          As an option, Rogvold?
          1. +3
            29 May 2022 11: 43
            As an option, Rogvold?
            And I don't want to guess. laughing
          2. +2
            29 May 2022 13: 27
            Quote: 3x3zsave
            As an option, Rogvold?

            Then the ancients. smile
            Under Rogvolod, strife was already in full swing.
            I propose as a curser Prince Mala - a person as legendary as Merlin. smile
            1. +1
              29 May 2022 13: 30
              Let's dig even deeper!
              Askold and Dir.
              1. +1
                29 May 2022 13: 35
                But no ... the curse should have been in the time of Svyatoslav - it all started with his offspring. smile
                1. +2
                  29 May 2022 13: 47
                  Well, this scumbag had enough cursers, from the Greeks to the Khazars.
        2. +4
          29 May 2022 13: 22
          Lesh, welcome. I have an assumption that Faina did it.
          Do you remember, Ruslan and Lyudmila: "Oh, the hero, that was Faina."
          Just the right time
          1. +3
            29 May 2022 17: 02
            Glory, brilliant, as always .. laughing
        3. +2
          29 May 2022 16: 53
          By analogy with the Rurikovichs, I remembered: "Marinko's curse of the Romanovs"
          I don’t know about you, but I feel a little sorry for Marina Mnishek: a toy in big politics.
          And Ksenia Godunova is an unfortunate victim
  3. +6
    29 May 2022 07: 40
    Good morning everyone! smile

    Richard the Lionheart sold it to the Scottish pretender William for 10 silver marks.


    "To sell something unnecessary, you must first buy something unnecessary" (S. Kot Matroskin)
    The image of the Cat, by chance, was not written from Richard? laughing



    And also the expulsion of the Jews from England in 1290 (and before that he ordered them to sew a yellow star on their clothes).

    So, then, the primacy is not at all with Adolf ... belay
    1. +3
      29 May 2022 08: 09
      Good morning, Constantine!

      And there are a lot of cats, and Richards. Try to get to the source.

      They say that Uspensky's friend was the prototype of Cat Matroskin.
    2. +6
      29 May 2022 10: 01
      So, then, the primacy is not at all with Adolf ...
      It's a tradition and it's being kept. Back in 474 BC. - the courtier of Artaxerxes I, Haman, tried to expel the Jews from the Achaemenid Empire (Persia). Aman felt such personal dislike for them that he could not eat. It ended with his execution and the coming to power of the Jews, while Artaxerxes I formally retained power.
      1. +1
        29 May 2022 10: 10
        Of course, Hitler did not appear out of nowhere: they say that everything in Europe was fine before him, the Jews were loved and cherished, and suddenly - the Fuhrer personally developed such hostility. Intolerance is a generic feature of the Western European peoples - even on national grounds, even on religious grounds, identified gays were burned for a sweet soul. Too smart, too beautiful or, on the contrary, too ugly were destroyed out of harm's way, suspecting of having links with the devil. The current liberalism and tolerance is already a sign of old age, it is simply not enough strength to hate everyone in a row, you have to focus on Russophobia.
        1. +6
          29 May 2022 10: 27
          Intolerance - a generic trait of Western European peoples
          In 50 - expulsion from Rome by Emperor Claudius, in 414 - under Patriarch Cyril, the Jews were expelled from Alexandria. VII century - from Arabia by Mohammed. Modern Islam still outlives the Jews wherever it has sufficient influence. In 613 - all Spanish Jews who refused to be baptized were forced to leave the country by order of the king of the Visigoths. They were returned in the 620s, expelled again in 638, once again refused to be baptized. accept them, and if they secretly enter, then freely kill and rob them. This happened after a major Jewish pogrom. the population rebelled against the hated salt monopoly established by Svyatopolk.
        2. +5
          29 May 2022 10: 33
          The current liberalism and tolerance is already a sign of old age,

          The current liberalism is Jewish machinations and revenge on European anti-Semites! (joke) laughing
      2. +4
        29 May 2022 10: 31
        Tradition is a good thing, but not always useful. laughing Adolf himself deprived himself of an atomic bomb, well, thank God.
    3. +2
      29 May 2022 10: 42
      A few years later, Philip the Handsome expelled the Jews from France, though not only them.
      1. +3
        29 May 2022 10: 52
        And who else has received such an honor? laughing
        1. +2
          29 May 2022 11: 25
          Lombards.
          1. +4
            29 May 2022 11: 33
            And what are these for? Pawned? laughing

            1. +2
              29 May 2022 11: 50
              No, it's not about money, but about the confrontation between Philip and the Vatican. Although the Handsome King was sorely lacking money. Poverty and snobbery.
          2. +4
            29 May 2022 11: 38
            More Moors from Spain. Gypsies were driven periodically - more often on the "initiative from below" ..
            1. +1
              29 May 2022 11: 54
              1. The tragedy of the Moriscos and Sefarads is a completely different story.
              2. The first documented appearance of gypsies in Europe dates back to the beginning of the XNUMXth century.
              1. VLR
                +5
                29 May 2022 16: 34
                In the memoirs of Catherine II and Dashkova, Peter III tells how, as a boy, at the head of a squadron of hussars, he drove the "Bohemians" out of his duchy. They cite this story as an invention of a drunken "Petrushka". However, in the documents of the archives of the ducal house of Holstein-Gottorp, confirmation of this story was found. Young Karl Peter Ulrich fulfilled his father's order to expel the gypsy camp from the duchy, whose members caused general popular indignation, engaging in all sorts of fraud, theft and deceiving simpletons with their "witchcraft". "Bohemians" is the generally recognized name of the gypsies in Europe in those years. And the word "bohemia" then meant "gypsy", had a sharply negative meaning.
                1. 0
                  29 May 2022 16: 42
                  I cited information gleaned from the "Diary of a Parisian Citizen". The entry about gypsies dates back to 1410, if I'm not mistaken.
                  1. VLR
                    +4
                    29 May 2022 16: 44
                    Well, the time of Peter III is the 18th century.
  4. +5
    29 May 2022 07: 43
    Thank you, Valery!
    Baybars' letter is just an example of triumph, and an inexorable one at that.
    1. +3
      29 May 2022 08: 34
      I imagine how this Baybars swelled and puffed up with complacency when he wrote (or dictated) this letter.
      And they say that "the East is a delicate matter." laughing

      Hello Sergey. smile
      1. +4
        29 May 2022 08: 39
        Glad to see Constantine!

        Quite an "oriental" version of the presentation.
        1. +4
          29 May 2022 09: 42
          Yeah, these guys are tough... request Yes, and the ladies too. laughing

          1. +3
            29 May 2022 09: 45
            This is before they loosened up.
            1. +3
              29 May 2022 10: 34
              Did they loosen up? Did they need it?
              1. +3
                29 May 2022 11: 36
                As elsewhere, people are different. But Comrade Sukhov will find a way out of difficult situations.
                1. +4
                  29 May 2022 11: 50
                  But Comrade Sukhov will find a way out of difficult situations.


                  "E-t-that's EXACTLY!!!" (c)

                  1. +4
                    29 May 2022 13: 12
                    “We will get it from the future. Not the first time "(c).
                    1. +4
                      29 May 2022 13: 32
                      "It would be fun in the company of such
                      And until the future is within reach "(c)
  5. +3
    29 May 2022 08: 16
    The good statesman Edward was torn between the romantic ravings of the overseas crusades and the prosaic need to equip his own kingdom. Lucky for the British, made the right choice
  6. 0
    29 May 2022 10: 09
    Quote: Sea Cat
    Good morning everyone! smile

    Richard the Lionheart sold it to the Scottish pretender William for 10 silver marks.


    "To sell something unnecessary, you must first buy something unnecessary" (S. Kot Matroskin)
    The image of the Cat, by chance, was not written from Richard? laughing



    And also the expulsion of the Jews from England in 1290 (and before that he ordered them to sew a yellow star on their clothes).

    So, then, the primacy is not at all with Adolf ... belay


    Although I like Walter Scott, show me a person who is indifferent to Ivanhoe, but Richard is far from Matroskin.
    In my opinion, Richard the Lionheart is closer to Balls, and Matroskin is Ivan Kapitan
    PS. Does anyone know, though, that a nuclear submarine and some ship are named after him
    Somewhere on the radio I heard a piece of information, but now I remembered
    1. +2
      29 May 2022 10: 37
      Does anyone know if the Premier League is named after him?


      In the name of Cat Matroskin? smile
      1. +1
        29 May 2022 15: 26
        No iminem Ivan Kalita
        1. +2
          29 May 2022 15: 31
          Yes? It's a pity! It would be much more interesting to serve on a boat named after the Cat, only the team needs to be selected with a sense of humor. wink
          1. +2
            29 May 2022 16: 18
            Then you will be the captain!
            1. +2
              29 May 2022 16: 45
              God forbid, in my opinion there is no worse job than working with people in the world. I, at one time, had enough "pleasure" to command a bunch of seventeen-year-old slobs, I couldn't eat enough. So let someone else be in charge there. laughing
              1. +3
                30 May 2022 06: 00
                "Worse work" agrees to work with people is difficult, but someone needs to. Here, I work, but I'm not a leader
                1. +1
                  30 May 2022 21: 12
                  but i'm not the boss


                  Luckily, you don't have to answer for anyone. smile
            2. ANB
              0
              31 May 2022 08: 50
              . captain

              Commander. On ships, positions are called "commander" and "chief". A captain is part of a naval rank.
    2. +1
      29 May 2022 16: 23
      Why do I think that Kalita is closer to Matroskin? Remember how he said: "I will save money"?
      1. +2
        29 May 2022 16: 30
        By the way, Matroskin is very popular with Finns.
        1. +2
          29 May 2022 16: 50
          Interesting, why? Why is it popular with the Turmalai?

          1. +1
            29 May 2022 16: 55
            His image is very suitable for the Finnish mentality.
            There is also an opposite example. In Sweden, Carlson does not have such popularity as in Russia. Pippi and Emil are much more respected there.
            1. +2
              29 May 2022 17: 32
              Who is Emil? Why dont know!?
              1. +1
                29 May 2022 17: 34
                "Emil from Lennenberg"
                1. +2
                  29 May 2022 17: 43
                  I didn't read it, I didn't watch it, I don't know. request smile
                  1. +1
                    29 May 2022 17: 46
                    I can't do anything about it...
                    1. +2
                      29 May 2022 17: 49
                      This is understandable, and these heroes are not of my childhood, although I heard something about Pippi.
                      1. +1
                        29 May 2022 18: 19
                        They can't be your childhood heroes. Lindgren's first publication in Swedish was only 2 years before you were born.
                        By the way, it was Pippi.
                        As for Emil, there is much more humor than in the Carlson trilogy.
                      2. VLR
                        +5
                        29 May 2022 18: 26
                        Lindgren wrote in her diary:
                        "I'd rather scream 'Heil Hitler!' for the rest of my life than have Russians here in Sweden. I can't imagine anything more disgusting."

                        The modern Russophobia of the Swedes is becoming more understandable, isn't it?
                      3. +1
                        29 May 2022 18: 42
                        Tove Jansson didn't have much love for us either. The first story, Little Trolls and a Big Flood, was written in 1938 and published in 1945.
                      4. +2
                        29 May 2022 19: 33
                        Dear woman, do not say anything. request
                        Thank God, not all Swedes are like that, in the early seventies I spoke closely with one Swede, his name was Sten - a doctor and a yachtsman, after the second bottle of Agdam we communicated without an interpreter, although my English was much worse than his. Bullshit question, perfectly understood each other. They stole the communal Martel and blew it for two in the kitchen from faceted glasses, standing by the refrigerator. Our wives found us there, having a fascinating conversation, from which the girls didn’t understand a damn thing. But then it turned out that I infected Sten with diving and he got carried away with it.
                        Yes, his wife studied at the University of Medicine at the Faculty of Medicine and was my then friend.
                      5. +3
                        30 May 2022 09: 38
                        I noticed long ago that a single Pole, Estonian, even a Westerner from near Lvov can be normal, even pleasant people in communication. But, as soon as they gather in one mass, it turns out something zombified and homogeneous, stupidly voting for Russophobes and supporting the demolition of monuments, renaming and so on with both hands.
        2. +1
          30 May 2022 06: 04
          Didn't know this.
          Do they know our cartoons?!
          1. 0
            30 May 2022 06: 08
            Well, why not? The Japanese, for example, generally bought the rights to the image of Cheburashka from Uspensky.
  7. +2
    29 May 2022 11: 17
    for 10 silver marks
    It is worth noting here that the silver mark was not a coin or a counting unit, but only a measure of the weight of a precious metal, like the current troy ounce. If we translate this number into the French counting system of that time, which most likely took place, we will get about 3 tons of silver.
    Thank you, Valery!
    1. +1
      29 May 2022 16: 00
      “About 3 tons of silver*, and then they didn’t know checks and payments were only in cash.
      I can imagine how many peasants were ruined in order to collect such a figure. And then delivering is also a troublesome task.
      Lomonosov's ambition was brought on 2 carts, and there were much less.
      Option: pay with pearls
      1. +1
        29 May 2022 16: 08
        Hello Katya!
        My series of articles on medieval monetary systems will soon begin to be published, if it interests you, I will answer questions.
        And pearls in medieval Europe were predominantly river.
        1. +1
          29 May 2022 16: 15
          Thank you. It will be interesting
  8. +5
    29 May 2022 11: 30
    The sons of this Edward were born after his return from the campaign. If this crusader had died in Palestine from a wound or from an illness - you see, Wales could retain independence for some more time. On the other hand, the miserable homosexual Edward 2, who was overthrown by his own wife, Isabella, the "French Wolf" (together with her lover Mortimer), would not have been born and become king. Which then, allegedly, ordered to introduce a red-hot poker into the anus of the son of Edward the Crusader - because it’s not good to use this very passage for other purposes. And Edward 3, whose mother was a "wolf", would not have started the Hundred Years War. Still, the role of the individual in history is great, no matter what anyone says.
    1. +1
      29 May 2022 12: 06
      Still, the role of the individual in history is great, no matter what anyone says.
      If we consider macrohistorical processes - negligible. With the same success, one can talk about the role of the heron in history.
      1. +4
        29 May 2022 12: 39
        Well, we just don't consider "macrohistorical processes". Macrohistorical processes are a look from the 16th floor at a bush of some hawthorn growing at the entrance: can you see a bee on it, or a single flower? Can you smell this flower? People are interesting, their relationships and affairs, not "processes". And the role of individuals is still huge. For example, in the event of Trotsky's victory over Stalin, the USSR would probably have been defeated in 1941 or even earlier. You can say: anyway, the USSR collapsed. But somehow we don't care.
        1. +3
          29 May 2022 13: 09
          Interesting people, their relationships and affairs
          My debut article, which deals with such issues, should be published soon. I look forward to your participation in the discussion.
          1. +3
            29 May 2022 13: 17
            And what will it be called? To pay attention
            1. +1
              29 May 2022 13: 22
              "King's ransom". It echoes the previous "medieval" cycle of Valery. It will be published from under Shpakovsky's account.
          2. +1
            29 May 2022 13: 42
            Anton, greetings. Already waiting. I will definitely read it and give my opinion.
            Anton, I warn you right away: if there is a reason for criticism ... So don't be angry
            1. 0
              29 May 2022 13: 44
              Anton, I warn you right away: if there is a reason for criticism ... So don't be angry
              Necessarily will!
              Hello, Glory!
        2. 0
          29 May 2022 13: 36
          "look at it bee" you can use a spyglass or binoculars. And if you don’t see the floor, you can go down
          1. +2
            29 May 2022 14: 21
            But then we move from macro processes to "ordinary" history
            1. 0
              29 May 2022 14: 42
              I am a proponent of ordinary history
      2. +1
        29 May 2022 13: 44
        Disagree: history is made by individuals
    2. +1
      29 May 2022 16: 06
      "hot poker" - savagery. Roofing felts drown the matter in wine
  9. 0
    29 May 2022 13: 31
    "to help Bohemond, oppressed by the Mamluks, 6" once came to fight with the Mamluks - you have to fight.
    Edward also brought benefits: he helped Bohemond.
    Valery, how much help was needed and with what result?
    1. VLR
      +3
      29 May 2022 13: 59
      Of course, Bohemond needed help, and the result will be discussed in the next article.
      1. +1
        29 May 2022 14: 37
        Liked:
        the Prince of Wales will be "a local native who does not know a word of either English or French." Such was his son, who was born the day before in the Welsh castle of Caernarvon: he, of course, did not yet know how to speak.

        And about the yellow star.
        Here they are, the origins!
        It is clear where to look for all the buried dogs.
      2. 0
        29 May 2022 14: 40
        Very good
  10. +3
    29 May 2022 15: 01
    Quote: 3x3zsave
    in opposition to Philip and the Vatican

    At that heroic time, the Vatican did not yet exist ...
    1. +1
      29 May 2022 15: 06
      I agree, I just "broke" it was longer to write.
  11. 0
    29 May 2022 15: 40
    Quote: Sea Cat
    And who else has received such an honor? laughing

    A large percentage was removed.
    This morning I went into the red and could not jump out for a long time to put it down. Usually I paid online with a card, but today I missed putting it in.
    I had to put in cash. The percentage was ripped off by a decent 12 r from 100!
  12. 0
    29 May 2022 16: 11
    Quote: vladcub
    I am a proponent of ordinary history

    Me too, but I don't forget fantasy either