Civilian casualties in 1941-1945: fakes and facts
Many articles have been written on this topic. But we decided to return to this story again for several reasons.
First, the 76th year since the Great Victory.
Secondly, one should never forget about such atrocities committed by Germany and the fascists against the civilians and children of Russia. So that something like this never happens again.
Thirdly, attempts in the West to rewrite our history... It is especially beneficial there that the new generation knows nothing about that our Patriotic War and the Great Victory, and even more so about the true face of Nazism and fascism. This revision of history must not be allowed, of course.
That is why telling the truth about that war is so necessary and so important now.
In the first part of our review "Aesopian language of loss: the pan-European empire VS Russia" we found out that Europe of those years longed for superiority and reprisals against the barbaric Slavs in the East. That is why practically all the countries of this continent easily and resignedly accepted Hitler's ideas and united against a common enemy - Russia.
In the second part of the cycle "Losses of Russia / USSR in the war against fascism: language of numbers" we began to study various versions of the losses of the armed forces of the USSR / Russia in the war against fascism.
In this third part of our review, we will analyze the versions of the general scale of the extermination of the civilian population of our country by the Nazis. And let us remind the reader how cynically, methodically and on a planned and scheduled basis the civilians of the USSR, who were recorded in advance and even before the start of the war in special registers of "unreliable", were destroyed.
It so happened that we rarely read very important documents, especially about an already distant war. And even less often we reread them.
Chronicle of the crimes of the Nazis
It seems to me not superfluous today, when a hotbed of nationalism and fascism in Ukraine is swelling near our borders by Western enthusiasts, to recall one most important document that reveals the consequences of the same kind of actions by the collective West, but only more than 75 years ago.
This was the unequivocal conclusion of the Extraordinary State Commission (hereinafter - the CHGK), which investigated the crimes of the fascists on Soviet / Russian soil immediately after the war (Collection of the ChGK 1946).
All the secret orders and instructions of the German military command and police cited by the ChGK speak convincingly of the system of mass extermination of Soviet people carefully developed by the Nazis in advance and ahead of time. For these monstrously criminal goals for the planned destruction of Soviet citizens, a special bureaucratic apparatus was organized.
It consisted of specially created all kinds of "operational teams", "Sonderkommando", special "filtrations", "executions", "liquidations", intended for the mass murder of Soviet prisoners of war and civilian Soviet citizens.
This commission collected and published genuine orders and specific pre-prepared instructions for organizing the killings of civilians in Russia / USSR. Real documents suggest that:
1) the German fascist invaders, already in the very first months of the war with the USSR, began mass extermination of both the civilian population of the USSR and the soldiers and commanders of the Red Army who were captured;
2) the mass extermination of the population and prisoners of war was ordered and carried out by agreement between the security police and SD and the high command of the German armed forces;
3) for the physical execution of "executions", "operational" and "special teams" (Sonderkommando) were drawn up, which had the right to independently decide on the use of executions;
4) the Germans tried to carry out the executions of prisoners of war and the civilian population in secret so that the rest of the prisoners of war and the civilian population would not know anything about it;
5) in some cases, it was ordered to specially bring Soviet prisoners of war for execution to the territory of the Soviet Union occupied by the Germans.
Published documents indicate that directives on the deliberate extermination of prisoners of war and civilian Soviet people came from Berlin, from the German government and the German High Command, from the Reich Minister of the Occupied Eastern Regions, the Chief of Security and SD and other members of the Hitlerite gang of criminals. (ChGK, pp. 181-182).
Only according to preliminary data (for 1946), registered by the Extraordinary State Commission, the Nazi occupiers about 2 million people were killed, poisoned in "gas chambers" and tortured in the occupied Soviet regions. Old people, women and children, peaceful Soviet citizens, as well as a huge number of prisoners of war - soldiers and officers of the Red Army.
For example, the Extraordinary State Commission received captured German documents found in a fireproof cabinet in a room where the Gestapo was located during the German occupation. These papers contained operational orders from the High Command of the German Army, the Reich Minister of the Occupied Eastern Regions, the Chief of the Security Police and SD and other documents, which set out a detailed and detailed procedure for "cleaning" camps for Soviet prisoners of war and places of residence of civilians from "suspicious persons."
It appears from these authentic German documents that as the only means of "cleaning" the German fascist authorities on a monstrous scale practiced the use of murders, which appear in the documents under the terms: "executions", "special regime", "liquidation", "special measures", "cleansing measures".
These documents refer to the first months of the invasion of the German invaders in the USSR, to the period July - December 1941.
The importance of the documents discovered by PMCs is characterized by the fact that all of them have a stamp: "Secret, of state importance" and "Secret, command document." (ChGK, p. 166).
In order to prevent the danger of the seizure of these documents by the Red Army, revealing the crimes of the German fascist executioners and their bloody plans for the physical destruction of the Russian population, operational order No. 14 of the chief of the German police said:
In the order of the headquarters of the high command of the German army No. 11, October 7, 41, it is emphasized:
(ChGK, p. 167)
German lists of unreliable Russians
We have already begun to forget that the Nazis were preparing this massacre in advance as the deliberate extermination of specific civilians, almost according to lists. And this is no exaggeration.
From the documents found, it is clear that Hitler's executioners, even before their attack on the USSR, compiled lists, search books and collected the necessary information about the leading Soviet workers who, according to their bloody plans, were subject to physical destruction. Thus, the "Special search book of the USSR", "German search book", "Lists for identifying whereabouts" and other similar "search books and lists" were prepared, which were supposed to facilitate the extermination of the advanced part of the population of the USSR / Russia for Hitler's murderers. (ChGK, p. 168)
For example, in a document called: "Appendix No. 2 to Operational Order No. 8 of the Chief of the Security Police and SD," dated "Berlin, July 17, 1941" and signed by Heydrich, who was then Himmler's deputy, states that you can't stop killing only on the payroll and only on those residents of Russia / USSR who were included in such lists (for physical destruction).
It turns out that in additional explanatory German orders, as the ChGK found out, it was specified that the prepared lists of names to be exterminated themselves were incomplete (that is, the lack of lists and search books was not hidden). Therefore, it was recommended not to restrain the "desires" of the punishers at all, and also indicated the need not suppress the initiative of the perpetrators... The punitive document says:
Along the way, it should also be reminded to the outraged Ukrainian nationalists today that they should not be under illusions about those owners who so generously fed them with buns on the Maidan. Their same Western puppeteers have already purposefully destroyed them once, of course, first using them against Russia. So it was in the Great Patriotic War in 1941, when the Bandera soldiers served the Wehrmacht. And this was done in secret.
The collection of the ChGK contains documents and genuine evidence that the bloody massacres were carried out by the Nazis and those Ukrainian nationalists whom Hitler initially used as companions in the fight against the Soviet Union. And then he dealt with them in the most vile and insidious way. Under the pretext that the Banderaites were "preparing an uprising." In the directive of the operational team C / 5 of the security police and SD No. 12/41 dated November 25, 1941 with a stamp of "secret, state importance" in relation to, for example, Ukrainian nationalists led by Bandera, it is said:
Planned extermination of the living
With German pedantry and punctuality, the Nazis approached the murders of the civilian population of our country. After all, there was an order from Berlin to maintain special registers of murdered Soviet citizens and regularly report on the implementation of plans for executions.
The head of the security police and SD in Appendix No. 2 to his operational order No. 8 demanded from the chiefs of the Sonderkommando:
The order further stated that
In development of this directive, the operational team C 5 of the Security Police and SD clarifies:
Weekly Annihilation Reports
The ruling Hitlerite clique systematically checked the fulfillment of its directives regarding the identification of the "suspicious." She demanded strict and complete accounting. Berlin demanded reports in urgent letters: where, how much, when and how they were killed. And that's all about the peaceful citizens of Russia / USSR.
In Appendix No. 2 to Operational Order No. 8, the Chief of the Security Police and SD strictly prescribed:
This report should contain: 1) a brief description of the activities over the past week; 2) the number of persons who should be finally considered suspicious (just indicate the number) ... "
It clearly follows from these documents that all these "executions" and reprisals were nothing more than the deliberate extermination of Soviet people, who were subjected to mass executions by the German fascist executioners. (ChGK, p. 174)
Extraordinary State Commission for the Establishment and Investigation of the Atrocities of the German Fascist Invaders in 1946 for the first time led the following publicly announced figures of the Nazi's deliberate destruction of the civilian population of the Soviet Union, broken down by republics (people):
RSFSR - 706,
Ukrainian SSR - 3 256 200,
Byelorussian SSR - 1,
Lithuanian SSR - 437,
Latvian SSR - 313 800,
Estonian SSR - 61,
Moldavian SSR - 61,
Karelo-Finnish SSR - 8 inhabitants.
In Lithuania and Latvia, there were special institutions for the extermination of people - concentration camps and death camps. That is why in these two republics the commission registers such a high number of killed citizens.
The scale of innocently killed local residents was even more impressive in areas adjacent to the front line. However, it is difficult and practically unrealistic to deduce completely accurate figures for such losses.
The smallest of the permissible values is the number of those who died in the Leningrad blockade. We are talking about 800 citizens. Leningrad, in general, it seems, then broke all records for deaths. Out of 000 babies born then 100 died. In other words, 75 showed a horrifying picture: the infant mortality rate in Leningrad jumped to 1942%.
Non-returners
Another important aspect. How many people (from those deported from the USSR to hard labor in Europe and other countries) chose not to return to their homeland when the war ended?
The Office of the Plenipotentiary of the USSR Council of Ministers for Repatriation (as of January 1, 1952) estimated the number of "second emigration" at 451 people.
Note. Under the second "emigration" in Soviet times, it was customary to mean hundreds of thousands of Soviet citizens who found themselves during the Great Patriotic War of 1941-1945. abroad and subsequently did not return to the USSR.
However, the Soviet historian Viktor Nikolaevich Zemskov considered this figure to be underestimated. In its work "The birth of the" second emigration "(1944-1952)" (1991), he argued that according to Soviet archival data, the number of the "second emigration" was 620 thousand people.
Some researchers cite the following data on the number of immigrants from the USSR (people) who remained after the war abroad from those driven to hard labor during the war:
Germans, Bessarabians and Bukovinians - 170,
Ukrainians - 150,
Latvians - 109,
Estonians and Lithuanians, etc. - 230,
Russians - 32.
(Total - 691).
Why didn't these people come back?
There are many versions. Here is one of them (quote from the historian V.N. Zemskov).
The Office of the Plenipotentiary of the USSR Council of Ministers for Repatriation of the contingent of Soviet displaced persons who settled in Argentina and did not return to the Union, in 1952 described as follows:
Some of the displaced persons joined anti-Soviet organizations operating in Argentina and has a negative impact on the rest of the displaced Soviet citizens, forcibly taken to Nazi Germany, and then fraudulently taken to the countries of South America.
A relatively small part of the displaced Soviet citizens has decayed and finds solace in drunkenness and debauchery, or is mired in a petty-bourgeois life, striving to find wealthy wives or husbands.
And, finally, a significant part of the displaced Soviet citizens are afraid of responsibility for the crimes committed before the Motherland, both during the war and after it, so they do not want to return to their Motherland under any circumstances. "
According to more recent studies, immediately after the war, more than 1 million people did not (or did not want) to return to the Union. And this means that from the previously recorded as irrecoverable losses of the inhabitants of the USSR, at least 300 thousand of those living who became a defector should be subtracted. Or, as they are now called more mildly and respectfully, emigrants.
Versions about the loss of civilians
Thus, with what numbers did the total demographic losses of Russia / USSR in the Great Patriotic War actually calculated? And how many of them were civilians? (We spoke about the irrecoverable losses of the Red Army in the previous article).
For almost two decades we were told from the high tribunes (NS Khrushchev) about the twenty million dead in the USSR taken from the ceiling. And by 1990 it turned out that this figure was underestimated. And at least up to a quarter of the real losses were hidden at that time.
The truth was revealed thanks to careful research by a specially created commission of the General Staff and the USSR State Statistics Committee. It turned out that this commission had documented that The victory over fascism cost Russia / USSR under 27 million lives. The exact figure was at that time - the death of 26,6 million inhabitants of our state at the hands of the enemy.
At the moment, this figure is the official one (26,6 million people).
Noteworthy is the fact that back in 1948, the Russian-American sociologist-emigrant Nikolai Sergeevich Timashev (Nicholas Timasheff) in his work "The Postwar Population of the Soviet Union" (1948) gave his assessment of the losses of the USSR in the war, which practically coincided with the opinion Commissions of the General Staff. Also with the data of the Commission G.F. Krivosheev's assessment of the Russian demographer-liberal Sergei Maksudov (pseudonym Alexander Petrovich Babenyshev), made by him in 1977, coincides. According to him, the losses were estimated at 24,5 million people.
Let's remind that before that (before the official conclusions of the commission of G.F.Krivosheev) the exact number of military losses of the USSR was the subject of political speculation and the figures varied in accordance with the political situation in society.
According to the commission of G.F.Krivosheev:
Let's summarize some results.
After the war, the losses of the Red Army were estimated at 7 million soldiers.
American Nikolai Timashev called the following figures for the losses of Russia / USSR:
Red Army - 12,2 million soldiers,
civilian population - 14,2 million citizens,
direct human losses - 26,4 million people,
general demographic - 37,3 million Soviet people.
President of the German Society for Documentation Helmut Arntz and Chairman of the Council of Ministers of the USSR Nikita Sergeevich Khrushchev determined the scale of the country's losses as 20 million people.
French physician and demographer Jean-Noel Biraben in Population (1976) and Alexander Solzhenitsyn gave other significantly overestimated figures:
Red Army - 20 million soldiers,
civilian population - 22,6 million citizens,
direct human - 42,6 million people,
total demographic 62,9 million Soviet residents.
Liberal with the pseudonym Sergei Maksudov (A.P. Babenyshev from Harvard University in the USA) issued his version:
Red Army - 11,8 million soldiers,
civilian population - 12,7 million citizens,
direct human losses - 24,5 million Soviet people.
At the same time, the same S. Maksudov in his writings calculated the purely combat losses of the Red Army as 8,8 million.
Whereas the Russian demographer Leonid Leonidovich Rybakovsky in the book "Population of the USSR for 70 years" (1988) mentioned that direct human losses of the USSR amounted to almost three tens of millions of Soviet citizens (27-28 million).
It is curious that L.L. Rybakovsky in 2011 (to the 70th anniversary of the beginning of the war) also publishes a summary table of different versions (put forward from 1946 to 2004) about the total human losses by year. It contains figures that have been voiced by all kinds of politicians and specialists in the past years. And sometimes the same personalities in different periods presented to the people various versions of the truth.
For the sake of historical justice, we present this set of figures in the form of a table in full.
Source: cyberleninka.ru
Please note that this table shows only the total losses of our country in different copyright variations.
And we will continue to consider the versions of those who, among other things, presented the figures for the losses of the civilian population of Russia / USSR.
EAT. Andreev, L.E. Darsky, T.L. Kharkov in their joint work "The Population of the Soviet Union, 1922-1991" (1993) (as some authors represent them - the General Staff, the Krivosheev Commission) set out their version as follows:
Direct combat losses of the Red Army - 8,
and including prisoners of war - 11.
Civilians (including prisoners of war) - 17.
Direct human losses - 26 million.
As he is called in the professional environment "the most indefatigable professional forger", publicist of the opposition avant-garde B.V. Sokolov entered the annals of historiography as calculating the losses of the Soviet Army (military personnel) alone at 26 million soldiers and officers.
Well, what about without Great Britain?
English expert on economics and Russian defense Mark Harrison from Warwick estimated the total losses of the USSR at 23,9-25,8 million people.
Subtotals
So, if you make a kind of squeeze out of the above versions, then what will happen if you apply elementary logic?
The 7 million casualties of the Red Army, as published in 1947, were based on unfinished research and calculations. And, of course, they were preliminary in those years.
Khrushchev's opinion was not criticized in his time, but it cannot be accepted today one hundred percent, since it has not been specifically confirmed.
Solzhenitsyn's 20 million (or even 44 million) human losses are also somewhat dubious. Here, in order not to offend the hyped political writer, we will simply quote one opinion, quite fair, in our opinion, about such inflated figures:
The strategic mouthpiece of the liberal community B. Sokolov claims that the losses of the armed forces of the USSR alone amounted to 26 million fighters. It proceeds from the fairly well-known losses of the officers of the Red Army, which amounted to 784 thousand people (for 1941-1944).
This gentleman, as usual with liberals, refers to the logic of purely Western statistics. Namely, the Wehrmacht. The point is that this researcher does not seem to make any (statistical) distinction between us and the opponents. Therefore, he proceeds from German realities, which he transfers without amendments to us.
From his point of view, since the average losses of Wehrmacht officers on the Eastern Front in the same years (1941-1944) amounted to 62 people, and using the data of Mueller-Gillebrant, the ratio of losses of the German officer corps to the rank and file was deduced as 500: 1 (25%). This means that in Russia / USSR the ratio of losses should be exactly the same.
So he gets from German logic our 26 million irrecoverable losses of the Red Army. Mathematics, nothing personal. However, some have revealed that this approach is false. Let's analyze briefly the version of the oppositionist.
Russian experts point out that in some campaigns the same Wehrmacht lost much more officers than the aforementioned 4 percent. For example, in the Polish campaign. There, the ratio of losses of officers to the total losses of the German armed forces was 12 percent.
In addition, the military reminds that in the German regiment (nominally), for example, the infantry - 3049 people, and the officer corps there are 75 people. That the ratio is not 4, but 2,5 percent. If you look at the Soviet infantry regiment, then it is 1582 people. And there are 159 officers there. The percentage is ten. And not at all "German" 4.
And finally, the last. The military especially remind that the higher the experience, the less losses from the officer corps. And they give examples. The Germans lost their officers (percentage):
in the Polish campaign - 12%,
in the French campaign - 7%,
on the Eastern Front - 4%.
It turns out that this ratio is a quantity, as they say, a variable.
As for the Red Army, according to statistics, at the beginning of the same (Great Patriotic) war, losses among officers could be as high as 24%, and by the end of the war they could have already dropped to 8-9%.
So, as always with the liberals: everything is logical. Only the logic is not the same. And the denominators are not the same.
Why, in general, analyze the version and theories of this Sokolov? So he also most often replicates his views in the opposition media.
Thus, if we discard too underestimated and very overestimated versions, then only three remain:
1948: Timashev - 12.
1977-1993: Maksudov - 11.
2001: Official (Krivosheev Commission) - 8 (with prisoners of war 700).
By the way, the British M. Harrison's losses of our army are also close to the above mentioned values.
Different researchers have used peculiar and dissimilar methods of calculus. Some of the abovementioned (Timashev and Maksudov) could not use the archives of the Ministry of Defense and Russia, according to some experts.
We believe that the actual losses of the Armed Forces of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics in the Great Patriotic War are close to the figures named by these three mentioned researchers. Recall that 2,6-3,2 million Soviet prisoners of war killed by the Nazis are also included in these figures.
As a result, you can also accept the point of view of Maksudov, who proposed deducting the defectors from the losses. There were 1,3 million of them. What initially did not begin in the General Staff commission.
So, if you reduce the losses of the USSR by this amount, then the distribution of losses (in%) looks like this:
Losses of the Armed Forces (including prisoners of war) - 41%, and direct combat (without prisoners of war) - 35%.
The loss of the population of the occupied territories and the front line - 39%, and with prisoners of war - 45%.
These two categories of losses in total accounted for 80% of all.
The remaining 20% of our losses included:
rear population - 8%,
GULAG - 6%,
emigration outflow - 6%.
Official results from 2020
Well, in conclusion, you need to provide the official data of Rosstat, updated for 2020, on the losses of Russia / USSR among the civilian population.
For the 75th anniversary of the Victory over fascism, a jubilee collection, which contains the following updated and verified figures on the number of civilian casualties of the USSR during the occupation.
In total, the civilian population of the USSR died during the occupation of 13 684 692 people.
Of these, 7 420 379 people were deliberately exterminated. Including 216 431 children.
Killed in forced labor in Germany 2 people.
4 people died from the harsh conditions of the occupation regime (hunger, infectious diseases, lack of medical care, etc.).
The total number of citizens of the USSR taken to Germany for hard labor reached 5 people.
In addition to those killed in forced labor in Germany, 451,1 thousand people who did not return to their homeland and became emigrants (defectors) were attributed to the total civilian casualties.
Who will answer?
And here is another quote from the conclusions of the ChGK in 1946, an excerpt from the chapter "Directives and orders of the Hitlerite government and the German military command on the extermination of Soviet prisoners of war and civilians" (p. 182 of the Collection of messages of the Extraordinary State Commission on the atrocities of the German fascist invaders):
1) The direct organizers and leaders of the mass destruction of Soviet prisoners of war and civilian Soviet people are: the head of the prisoner of war camps of the 1st Military District of East Prussia, Major General von Hindenburg, the head of the prisoner of war camps of the "general-governorship", Lieutenant-General Herrgott, liaison officers, Criminalrat Schifferrat Crime Commissioner Rushwitz.
2) The direct executors of this monstrous extermination of Soviet people are the personnel of the Sonderkommandos, operational teams, commandants and staff of the camp commandant's offices, as well as their accomplices. All of them must suffer severe punishment for their crimes against the Soviet people.
Published in the newspaper "Izvestia" No. 60 of March 11, 1944 on the basis of the Resolution of the Extraordinary State Commission of March 10, 1944, Protocol No. 27. Page 182
Note. The acts and reports of the ChGK became one of the most important evidence of the prosecution at the Nuremberg trials against Nazi criminals.
In the next part we will talk about different studies of the scale of Wehrmacht losses in the Great Patriotic War.
To be continued ...
Information