Military Review

Military film fan. Connoisseurs, this is for you!

73
Well, finally I waited! Finally, I do not have a gag reflex, I finally want to share the joy of seeing the film with a capital letter, shot just fine and tasteful!


Military film fan. Connoisseurs, this is for you!


Especially because of all these restrictions, I went to a small room for 12 people, there were four of us. In the afternoon, a VIP room (very comfortable chairs) - and four - that's great. And they left, as they say, without hiding their eyes.

So what I would like to say. The most important thing is backups or backups. They were, since I had watched a huge number of war films in my life, I had something to remember.

And - I remembered!

I don’t know how anyone, but for me the best actor in the film is Lyubov Konstantinova, who played the nurse. In fact, her playing frost on the skin, I immediately remembered "And the dawns here are quiet ...". The first one. 1972 year.



No, the others are also all just fine ... no, they didn't play. Perhaps, here I am not quite right. These people are remarkable in that they were able to live with their heroes. Show us that life and those lives that simply burned down in the fall of 1941 near Moscow.

The plot is simple ... Autumn 1941. The Germans are rushing to Moscow. The country has already understood that there is a war, but has not yet understood how terrible it is and for a long time. And these, young cadets, they heard the word, but the heart is still missing. Young…

And yes, here the Brest Fortress immediately pops up. And it's good that it pops up, great. This means that if the brain compares, it at least likes it.



In general, "Podolsk cadets" should be recognized as an exemplary canvas. And from the point of view of direction, and from the point of view of the operator's work (well, except perhaps with decelerations, too much, and even then, not fatal), and from the point of view of the acting. Everything is perfect.

Extras ... Here I have to say a huge "Thank you" to the entire reenactment party in Russia. Such great extras have not been in films for a long time. No blunders. Without owls stretched over the globe. No homemade products. The reenactors pulled this film to such a level of reliability that today it can be taken as a model.

In general, Ugolnikov came up with the idea to turn to reenactors.

Many thanks to private museums. Everything that traveled, everything is museum. From Vadim Zadorozhny (by the way, he is the producer of the film) there was a whole landing, mechanics and technicians, together with cars, other private museums and collections responded.

Five days ... Yes, nothing new. And thank God that there is nothing new in the picture. Young guys go to the front. They need to delay the advance of the Germans for five days. Some will survive, some will not. War. It is clear that there were few survivors in that meat grinder, but Moscow was at stake.

Everything is familiar. Killed or killed you. Managed to shoot, or did not have time. Very simple. There are no mediocre marshals, no drunken specials, there is nothing of those clichés that have been imposed on us for the past 20 years.

There is история... Rather, I would even more call the film a reconstruction; it is a very successful attempt to precisely reconstruct those events, rather than a detached display. Yes, there is a bit of such pathos, but it's not something that you can forgive - you need to.

When I watched and praised Shaliope's 28 Panfilovites, the sensations were completely different. Yes, the film was good, and at that time it was generally luxurious, against the background of general impotence from cinema, but, perhaps, "Cadets" is stronger.

Yes, someone may not like the love line crammed into the film, but firstly, and where without it, and secondly - well, it was!

In the end, whoever needs the dry story of the moment is Hot Snow, a film that will never be equal.



I was waiting for this film, I have already spoken about it. I am very glad I am not disappointed. Faces, acting, staging, script, technique. The spirit of the film. By the way, a very atmospheric film, somehow immersed me in "In August 44", I didn't even understand why, something like that was new, although many people consider "In August ..." unsuccessful, but I personally think. The atmosphere in it is conveyed just fine. Here is about the same thing.



I highly recommend going on weekends. Support creators, actors, extras. The movie is really good. For modern Russian cinema - more than. I never thought that in the ocean of squalor and lies of Russian cinema, an island of such light would suddenly flash. Probably because the Ministry of Culture gave only 60 million out of 450 and could not put pressure on the film crew.

I would like to say a big thank you to all those responsible for the appearance of this film. First of all - to Igor Ugolnikov, without whom nothing would have happened. Director Vadim Shmelev must be proud of this work. Actors, I have already spoken about them, Bezrukov does not know how to play badly and here it was only confirmed, Bardukov, Yudin, Gubin, Konstantinova, Dyatlov ...

In general, this is a movie that definitely deserves to go to it. Our cinema did not give this out for a very long time, and it is not known whether there will be something like this in the future. Therefore, it's worth going and seeing. Recommend. The film is the same monument to those cadets like this one:



I didn’t purposely upload photos of frames from the film, at first, of course, I did it, then I decided that it would be better that way. Better you will see everything for yourself.
Author:
73 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Grandfather
    Grandfather 7 November 2020 04: 54
    17
    Better you will see everything for yourself.
    Author:
    Roman Skomorokhov
    intrigued ... I'll take a look, although I swore.
    1. Asad
      Asad 7 November 2020 05: 31
      +7
      I would gladly go, but something in Novosibirsk was raging in general! Maybe they will show it on TV early, although the TV certainly does not convey the entertainment of the cinema!
      1. Achilles
        Achilles 7 November 2020 18: 24
        +3
        Quote: ASAD
        I would love to go

        I went today, this film is not like those that were previously filmed about the war in Russia. The film is great, the acting, the special effects are all at a decent level
        1. svp67
          svp67 9 November 2020 11: 54
          +1
          Quote: Achilles
          The film is great

          This is your personal opinion. I didn't like the movie. The plot is very jerky. They say that at the same time they are preparing for the release of a television series, I think that it will be better in terms of the plot.
          Quote: Achilles
          acting,
          I didn't touch it, every time I wanted to say - I DO NOT BELIEVE, the film is VERY far from the Soviet, and even to the "28 Panfilovites"
          Quote: Achilles
          special effects are all at a decent level

          I didn’t notice any special effects. What I liked was the actions of the "Germans", I liked 90% of them, well done reenactors, compared to how the Soviet side acted, there are almost no complaints about the "Germans".
          There are many questions for historical, especially military consultants. Were they even there? And if they were, then they were not worth the money. To another regret
    2. Pilot
      Pilot 7 November 2020 05: 58
      53
      Quote: Dead Day
      Better you will see everything for yourself.
      Author:
      Roman Skomorokhov
      intrigued ... I'll take a look, although I swore.

      drinks Well, perhaps just a cursory glance, for informational purposes .. I myself only watch films of Soviet cinema, from the remakes it just stinks like a cesspool of bourgeois modernity. Recently, films about the revolutionary period of our country have been more popular. Yes, today is a great holiday, so I congratulate all members of the forum and say a short toast - God forbid, not the last! ... no, not a glass .. wink
      1. Grandfather
        Grandfather 7 November 2020 06: 02
        31
        Quote: Pilot
        today is a great holiday, so I congratulate all members of the forum and say a short toast - God forbid, not the last! ... no, not a glass ..

        Happy Holidays. today, as always, on the 7th of November, there will be a table, dumplings and some vodka. drinks
        1. Crowe
          Crowe 7 November 2020 06: 49
          52
          Happy Holidays, men!
          1. Crowe
            Crowe 7 November 2020 06: 50
            45
            You cannot strangle this song, you cannot kill!
            1. Crowe
              Crowe 7 November 2020 06: 53
              35
              The seventh day of November is the red day of the calendar!
              Look out your window, everything on the street is red
              Flags are hovering at the gates, blazing with flames,
              See, the music goes where the trams went!
              All people, old and young, celebrate freedom,
              And my red ball is flying, straight to the sky!
              1. Crowe
                Crowe 7 November 2020 06: 54
                37
                We see the city of Petrograd
                In the seventeenth year:
                A sailor is running, a soldier is running,
                Shoot on the go.

                Work drags a machine gun.
                Now he will join the battle.
                A poster hangs: “Down with the gentlemen!
                Down with the landowners! ”

                Carry units and regiments
                Cloths of Kumach,
                And ahead are the Bolsheviks,
                Guards Ilyich.

                October! Overthrown forever
                power
                Bourgeois and nobles.
                So in October the dream came true
                Workers and peasants.

                The victory was not easy
                But Lenin led the people,
                And Lenin saw far
                For many years to come.

                And the truth of their ideas -
                Great person -
                He is all working people
                United forever ..........
              2. Captain45
                Captain45 8 November 2020 00: 13
                +3
                Quote: Crowe
                The seventh day of November is the red day of the calendar!

                When I
                summarize
                what has lived
                and rummaging through the days -
                the brightest where,
                I remember
                same -
                Twenty fifth,
                first day.

                Bayonets
                pokes
                striking lightning,
                sailors
                into bombs
                play like balls.
                From the buzz
                shakes
                excited Smolny.
                In cartridge belts
                machine gunners below.
                - you
                causes
                comrade Stalin.
                Right
                third,
                he
                there. -
                - Comrades,
                do not stop!
                What have become?
                In armored cars
                and to the post office! -
                - By order
                Comrade Trotsky! -
                - There is! -
                turned
                and disappeared soon,
                and so on
                on tape
                at the naval
                under the lamp
                flashed -
                "Aurora".
                V.Mayakovsky
            2. Soveticos
              Soveticos 7 November 2020 08: 11
              23
              Thanks. Happy Holidays to all of you too. Pleasant memories of childhood and adolescence. One of the greatest holidays was, and still remains, despite all attempts to consign to oblivion and denigrate his achievements. Thanks to this very revolution in the West, ordinary people began to live more or less with dignity. Then the parasitic oligarchs were afraid that they would be overthrown.
          2. Lionnvrsk
            Lionnvrsk 7 November 2020 14: 22
            +9
            Quote: Crowe
            Happy Holidays, men!

            So yes, today is also World Men's Day! hi
        2. Van 16
          Van 16 7 November 2020 17: 37
          +4
          "there will be a table, dumplings and a little vodka"
          And we went into the forest, we smoked the fish, the autumn beauty is indescribable))
      2. Sotskiy
        Sotskiy 7 November 2020 07: 02
        22
        Quote: Pilot
        Yes, today is a great holiday, so I congratulate all members of the forum

        Mutually! good
        Happy day, without exaggeration, on a global scale, which took place in our country - on the day of the Great October Socialist Revolution!
        Time of the Great October
        It has not sunk into oblivion yet,
        And on this day in November
        March, as before, struck!
        Red kumach flies with banners, -
        And the past is not forgotten!
        It is not in vain that it was given to us
        It was - good!
        There is something to tell grandchildren
        There is something to be proud of sincerely
        We have not betrayed ideas,
        We survived the perestroika!
        So, you, friend, are not old yet,
        Forget about different sores!
        Happy holiday, comrades!
        Happy eternal great holiday!

        1. Van 16
          Van 16 7 November 2020 08: 37
          20
          All who celebrate - Happy October Day!
      3. Arlen
        Arlen 7 November 2020 10: 05
        27
        Quote: Pilot
        Well, perhaps just a quick glance, for informational purposes

        I will definitely watch this film.
        Quote: Pilot
        today is a great holiday,

        Happy October Great October everyone!
      4. raw174
        raw174 7 November 2020 23: 19
        0
        Quote: Pilot
        I myself only watch films of Soviet cinema, from the remakes it just stinks like a cesspool of bourgeois modernity.

        Cinema remains the most important of the arts, including in matters of propaganda. Of course, the leaders in this issue are the Americans, with Hollywood, but ours has been catching up in recent years, primarily in special effects and computer graphics. What are the Americans taking? Of course entertainment, dynamics and they are watched! You can at least shoot super believable and reliable films, but without dynamics, good graphics and effects, they will not go to them ... The viewer changes, young people have a request for action, it needs to be satisfied, then they will go to our films. Look at the New Year's costumes for children, now ... All the batmen, spider-men and other characters in American comics, because the Americans won the war for the minds of our children, through the screen. But in recent years, people have gone to our films, I think that the first successes began with the film "9th Company", then sports dramas: "Poddubny", "Legend 17", "Moving Up" ... Of the last: "Indestructible" , "T-34", "Outpost" ... These films are full of clichés, and actors do not always export them, but there is the main thing - entertainment, action and special effects. People go to these films. But of course we are far from Hollywood and this is bad ...
    3. Gardamir
      Gardamir 7 November 2020 07: 56
      13
      although he swore.
      everything is relative.

      and here

      well criticism
      1. Uncle Vanya Susanin
        Uncle Vanya Susanin 7 November 2020 13: 13
        +3
        This is a "waiting fork", if you expect the glass to be full, but it turns out to be half empty, then you will be disappointed, like Daniel in this video, the author, on the contrary, was ready for the glass to be empty, and he , surprisingly, turned out to be half full, from that Roman and such genuine joyful feelings from this film hi
        We must go and see, especially since I have already been ill, you can not be afraid!
    4. Hypertension
      Hypertension 7 November 2020 11: 30
      +6
      Quote: Dead Day
      I'll take a look, though I swore.

      In vain they swore. At least in theory, there should be decent films. After all, there are people who are not indifferent to the theme of the Second World War, and who are well versed in it and understand the spirit of that time.
    5. vlad.baryatinsky
      vlad.baryatinsky 7 November 2020 13: 31
      +1
      Quote: Dead Day
      intrigued ... I'll take a look, although I swore

      Hello!
      I also really want to see!
      I will wait!
      True, now all the cinema clubs are closed. Lockdown.
      Can they show on TV? !!
      1. Alf
        Alf 7 November 2020 16: 44
        +2
        Quote: vlad.baryatinsky
        Can they show on TV? !!

        Torrents canceled ???
        1. vlad.baryatinsky
          vlad.baryatinsky 7 November 2020 17: 11
          +1
          No concepts.
          Quote: Alf
          Can they show on TV? !!
          1. Alf
            Alf 7 November 2020 17: 23
            +2
            Quote: vlad.baryatinsky
            No concepts.
            Quote: Alf
            Can they show on TV? !!

            Wangyu, that in a couple of months he will appear in a heavy figure on Rutrekker.
  2. sergo1914
    sergo1914 7 November 2020 05: 03
    20
    Eh ... I worked for five years in the building of the former Podolsk infantry school. One of the colleagues is the grandson of one of the surviving cadets. In the course of the filming process. I haven't watched the film yet. Still on sick leave.
    Well, I also wanted to add one material here. Eternal memory to Heroes.





    1. Asad
      Asad 7 November 2020 05: 26
      +7
      Get well!
      1. sergo1914
        sergo1914 7 November 2020 05: 38
        +6
        Quote: ASAD
        Get well!


        17.11 will be kicked out to work.
  3. sergo1914
    sergo1914 7 November 2020 05: 04
    14
    Damn, only 5 photos fit. The remaining.


    1. Alexey RA
      Alexey RA 9 November 2020 10: 41
      +1
      The results of the battle on October 16, 1941:


      And a description of the battle from uv. Y. Pasholoka:
      ... from the north, 3 guns looked to Varshavskoe highway, which perfectly fired through the terrain, plus a 76-mm anti-aircraft gun. From the south, there were several more 76-mm guns, plus an anti-aircraft gun.
      The tanks of the 37th tank company of the 5th tank regiment of the 27th tank division (commander - Oberleutenant Peter-Paul Plinzner) went directly to the raid on the position of the 19th SD, to which the infantry from the 3rd company of the 73rd was attached motorized regiment (commander - Oberleutenant Heinrich Westhoffen). The column consisted of 13 Pz.Kpfw. 38 (t), 2 Pz.Kpfw.IV (one Ausf.C and one Ausf.F), with a group of 8 tanks going first, followed by the materiel of motorized infantry (part on armored personnel carriers ), and then 7 more tanks.
      (...)
      The first part of the convoy of 6 Pz.Kpfw. 38 (t) and 2 Pz.Kpfw.IV, which broke off ahead, was almost completely able to slip through the dangerous section and freely enter Ilyinskoye. But the motorized infantry and the second part of the column were not lucky. The first who understood that "these are not ours!" Was Shapovalov's calculation. He opened fire on the two trailing tanks of the head column, which almost reached the turn to Lukyanovo. Next, the order to open fire was given by Museridze, then Dobrynin's gun "spoke", anti-aircraft guns and 85-mm) and Prokopov's battery opened fire. The attempt to maneuver was unsuccessful: the Pz.Kpfw.38 (t) with tower number 512, which went last, was incapacitated when it tried to turn around. It seems that the anti-aircraft gun was not noticed at all: at least those tanks that fired were clearly trying to shoot in the direction of Museridze's guns. The vehicle with tower number 533 at the time of its death was trying to target Dobrynin's gun. The "canon" version of the destruction of 14 out of 15 tanks belongs to this episode. In fact, 9 tanks were destroyed, and it took about four minutes.
      In fact, the battle was still ongoing. The tanks that jumped forward started a battle in Ilyinskoye, but later some of them (according to German data, 6 pieces) returned. But not all: a battle also began in Ilyinskoye, in which Lieutenant A.I. Aleshkin. They could not fire directly from the bunker, so the gun rolled out to the reserve position and fired at the tanks from it (this is shown in the film). Among the destroyed tanks, one turned out to be serviceable, which was used by the cadets, driving it into position and turning it into a firing point.
      (...)
      In total, the battle lasted about 40 minutes, according to the results, the number of destroyed German tanks corresponds to Soviet data.
      © Yuri Pasholok. Tank pogrom on the Ilyinsky frontier: Podolsk cadets against the 19th Panzer Division.
      http://alternathistory.com/yurij-pasholok-tankovyj-pogrom-na-ilinskih-rubezhah-podolskie-kursanty-protiv-19-j-tankovoj-divizii/
      1. sergo1914
        sergo1914 9 November 2020 11: 10
        +1
        Quote: Alexey RA
        The results of the battle on October 16, 1941:


        And a description of the battle from uv. Y. Pasholoka:
        ... from the north, 3 guns looked to Varshavskoe highway, which perfectly fired through the terrain, plus a 76-mm anti-aircraft gun. From the south, there were several more 76-mm guns, plus an anti-aircraft gun.
        The tanks of the 37th tank company of the 5th tank regiment of the 27th tank division (commander - Oberleutenant Peter-Paul Plinzner) went directly to the raid on the position of the 19th SD, to which the infantry from the 3rd company of the 73rd was attached motorized regiment (commander - Oberleutenant Heinrich Westhoffen). The column consisted of 13 Pz.Kpfw. 38 (t), 2 Pz.Kpfw.IV (one Ausf.C and one Ausf.F), with a group of 8 tanks going first, followed by the materiel of motorized infantry (part on armored personnel carriers ), and then 7 more tanks.
        (...)
        The first part of the convoy of 6 Pz.Kpfw. 38 (t) and 2 Pz.Kpfw.IV, which broke off ahead, was almost completely able to slip through the dangerous section and freely enter Ilyinskoye. But the motorized infantry and the second part of the column were not lucky. The first who understood that "these are not ours!" Was Shapovalov's calculation. He opened fire on the two trailing tanks of the head column, which almost reached the turn to Lukyanovo. Next, the order to open fire was given by Museridze, then Dobrynin's gun "spoke", anti-aircraft guns and 85-mm) and Prokopov's battery opened fire. The attempt to maneuver was unsuccessful: the Pz.Kpfw.38 (t) with tower number 512, which went last, was incapacitated when it tried to turn around. It seems that the anti-aircraft gun was not noticed at all: at least those tanks that fired were clearly trying to shoot in the direction of Museridze's guns. The vehicle with tower number 533 at the time of its death was trying to target Dobrynin's gun. The "canon" version of the destruction of 14 out of 15 tanks belongs to this episode. In fact, 9 tanks were destroyed, and it took about four minutes.
        In fact, the battle was still ongoing. The tanks that jumped forward started a battle in Ilyinskoye, but later some of them (according to German data, 6 pieces) returned. But not all: a battle also began in Ilyinskoye, in which Lieutenant A.I. Aleshkin. They could not fire directly from the bunker, so the gun rolled out to the reserve position and fired at the tanks from it (this is shown in the film). Among the destroyed tanks, one turned out to be serviceable, which was used by the cadets, driving it into position and turning it into a firing point.
        (...)
        In total, the battle lasted about 40 minutes, according to the results, the number of destroyed German tanks corresponds to Soviet data.
        © Yuri Pasholok. Tank pogrom on the Ilyinsky frontier: Podolsk cadets against the 19th Panzer Division.
        http://alternathistory.com/yurij-pasholok-tankovyj-pogrom-na-ilinskih-rubezhah-podolskie-kursanty-protiv-19-j-tankovoj-divizii/


        I have German materials on those battles somewhere. Translated trophy war logs. And the bunker of Aleshkin is going to be restored. In the summer, it seems, completely dug up and cleared.
  4. Crowe
    Crowe 7 November 2020 05: 10
    28
    "And the dawns here are quiet ...". The first one. 1972 year.

    MASTERPIECE
  5. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 7 November 2020 05: 44
    18
    although many consider "In August ..." unsuccessful
    Still, probably not many people think, tk. the film is successful and the acting is good. In addition, the plot of Bogomolov's book "The Moment of Truth" is fully preserved.
    1. carstorm 11
      carstorm 11 7 November 2020 06: 08
      12
      it is too succinct compared to the book. just very much. I noticed one thing, everyone who read the book understood everything, and those who did not have time had a bunch of questions about the plot and perceived the film in a completely different way. not to disclose the topic of wolfhound cleaners and just its elite representative Tamantsev, for me the main mistake. if you remember, the whole book was based mainly on him and he was the main character. why he was so pushed into the background to me is not very clear. a cold strategist who calculates everything for many moves some kind of simple dude in the film. almost an ordinary country guy) but from the book it is just immediately obvious that the author considers him the main character. everything rests on him.
      1. rotmistr60
        rotmistr60 7 November 2020 06: 20
        +4
        You are a little wrong about the plot of the book, which was supposedly built on Tamantsev as the main character. Indeed, the book pays much attention to the fact that he (Tamantsev) is a true wolfhound cleaner, a hard worker of war, but the main characters are still the whole trinity of SMERSH employees. But the "cold strategist calculating everything for many moves" is Alekhine.
        1. carstorm 11
          carstorm 11 7 November 2020 06: 26
          +6
          Alekhine is an intellectual and a tactician) he always seems to be above the situation. By the way, the movie is too simple. As for Tamantsev, remember that only passages of the book dedicated to him are in the first person. This is what the author distinguishes him from among all. I liked the film by the atmosphere, but after the book I felt that I had watched one episode from the series.
      2. infantryman2020
        infantryman2020 7 November 2020 06: 55
        0
        Moreover, it is unfortunately not digitized. Watching at home is uncomfortable.
        (as well as many other Soviet war films)
        1. Alf
          Alf 7 November 2020 16: 49
          +1
          Quote: infantryman2020
          Moreover, it is unfortunately not digitized. Watching at home is uncomfortable.
          (as well as many other Soviet war films)

          Why not digitized? There is a 6 gig version.
  6. HaByxoDaBHocep
    HaByxoDaBHocep 7 November 2020 06: 07
    22
    Thanks to the "great" actor of modern Russia Alexander Petrov, who saved the film by his absence)
    1. Grandfather
      Grandfather 7 November 2020 06: 30
      14
      Quote: HaByxoDaBHocep
      Thanks to the "great" actor of modern Russia Alexander Petrov, who saved the film by his absence)

      if there is no Petrov and Kozlovsky, then you definitely need to look! yes
  7. lwxx
    lwxx 7 November 2020 06: 26
    +7
    I will not say that it is a direct masterpiece, but I watched it with pleasure. Finally, there is no stupid destructive pathos about Soviet people and that time. True, Ugolnikov invited Bezrukov here too, but he does not spoil the picture.
  8. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
      1. The comment was deleted.
        1. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
  9. Train
    Train 7 November 2020 07: 55
    +9
    Ugolnikov never ceases to amaze. There are still people in our country who can "shoulder" the burden of responsibility for real cinema!
    1. Jager
      Jager 7 November 2020 18: 51
      +3
      He also filmed "Brest Fortress".
  10. Vadim Golubkov
    Vadim Golubkov 7 November 2020 08: 00
    15
    I have one of my favorite films "Torpedo Bombers", which shows the oppressive, oppressive and difficult atmosphere of war, at some moments to the point of creeping, to tears ... and in this atmosphere of war ... people, pilots who do their job , duty, defend the country .... This is my feeling, I love this film. I will definitely look at the Podolsk cadets. Thanks.
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 7 November 2020 09: 36
      +7
      Quote: Vadim Golubkov
      I have one of my favorite films "Torpedo bombers"

      "The Living and the Dead", "They were imprisoned for their Motherland" ... Perhaps not so relevant and without battle scenes, but - "Wait for me" ... And also (in terms of patriotic education) "Liberation", "Battle for Moscow" ...
      Interestingly. In 1941, all the people (the majority) went to defend the capital - the heart of our Motherland. Is he ready to defend the capital today (in case of danger) and in the name of what?
    2. Bez 310
      Bez 310 7 November 2020 09: 37
      +7
      Quote: Vadim Golubkov
      one of my favorite films "Torpedo bombers"

      Yes, this movie is the best movie about aviation in war.
      I had to live in Severomorsk, where the film was shot,
      I also had to serve in the Naval Aviation, I have a special
      attitude towards this film.
      Defense of the Motherland is hard work ...
      1. ZEMCH
        ZEMCH 7 November 2020 14: 18
        +2
        Quote: Bez 310
        I had to live in Severomorsk, where the film was shot,
        I also had to serve in the Naval Aviation, I have a special
        attitude towards this film.

        There is something to remember, but you can't tell children! We ended up at the Brigantine and then moved to the pilots! drinks
  11. Van 16
    Van 16 7 November 2020 08: 52
    +7
    I am very cautious about modern "film masterpieces", I prefer Soviet films, you can watch them endlessly. But since Roman advises .. let's see.
  12. Ross xnumx
    Ross xnumx 7 November 2020 09: 28
    +7
    Roman Skomorokhov's commentary is worth a lot. yes I'll see it as soon as possible.
    Quote: Pilot
    Yes, today is a great holiday, so I congratulate all members of the forum

    And this is the main point! It was at this time that you begin to realize what we have lost thanks to Yeltsin's criminal coup ...
  13. lucul
    lucul 7 November 2020 10: 15
    +2
    In general, "Podolsk cadets" should be recognized as an exemplary canvas. And from the point of view of direction, and from the point of view of the operator's work (well, except perhaps with decelerations, too much, and even then, not fatal), and from the point of view of the acting. Everything is perfect.

    Did the Russians make a film for the Russians?
    I have been saying for a long time - it's time to move "foreigners" away from our culture.
    Tired of listening and watching that Russians have to forever "pay and repent" for 1937, and indeed, for the fact that we are Russians.
  14. Andrei from Chelyabinsk
    Andrei from Chelyabinsk 7 November 2020 10: 19
    +2
    That's awesome!
    I run to the cinema, losing my toilet items along the way ...
    1. Pilot
      Pilot 7 November 2020 11: 11
      +6
      They will be allowed to go without underwear, but don't lose your mask. laughing
  15. dgonni
    dgonni 7 November 2020 10: 42
    0
    I'll have to look. I looked at the trailer. Seems not bad.
    1. Snail N9
      Snail N9 7 November 2020 11: 14
      +4
      Well ... Here, in one review, you correctly noticed, you can watch, but the film looks like some kind of glue from episodes ... "Horses mixed together, people" ...
  16. steelmaker
    steelmaker 7 November 2020 11: 52
    -1
    Now, before watching a historical film, I am interested in the history of the event. I watched the thriller and was not satisfied with the historical truth of the film. At least I won't go to the cinema to watch a movie. Then I'll look on the Internet. A film like "Rzhev, Stalingrad, Shtrafbat."
    1. Andrey VOV
      Andrey VOV 7 November 2020 22: 41
      0
      And what is not true? I would not put it on a par with the penal battalion, this is generally the bottom of the bottom
  17. La Peruse
    La Peruse 7 November 2020 12: 08
    -1
    Not an interesting film, nor any content, a lot of sloom mo ... The plot is not revealed, the constant appearance of secondary characters. Storylines are not forks! Compared to the films of the past, Hot Snow or the Battalions ask for a fire full of slag! Even the Panfilovites are better. And why the author admires a very mediocre film is not clear.
    1. Jager
      Jager 7 November 2020 18: 49
      +7
      "Hot Snow" or "They Fought for the Motherland" and many more films, in principle, it is impossible to "jump over".
      In "They Fought for the Motherland" were filmed front-line actors.
      Sometimes it is scary to look at Nikulin in the frame - such longing and pain in the eyes that no actor will ever convey SUCH energy to the viewer again ...
  18. parusnik
    parusnik 7 November 2020 12: 12
    +3
    A good film, without anti-Sovietism, the actors' play is generally not bad, the technique, battle shooting, everything is somehow at an excellent level, but it does not pull up to Soviet masterpieces ..
  19. panzerfaust
    panzerfaust 7 November 2020 12: 13
    +1
    The latest "masterpieces" - "Rzhev" and "Kalashnikov" are clearly depressing. Especially scenes with special officers. Let's look at the "cadets" and compare.
  20. ZIS
    ZIS 7 November 2020 12: 19
    +3
    It is imperative to go to the cinema in order to support the creators with money, otherwise we will "slurp" about the staff battalions and the lesson of patriotic defenders.
  21. Igoresha
    Igoresha 7 November 2020 12: 22
    -3
    strange that they did not remember the film "Star" dir. Nikolai Lebedev, 2002, three heads taller than the original with Kryuchkov in 1949 (not a movie but a booth) and even better than the original story
  22. Barkun
    Barkun 7 November 2020 14: 09
    0
    I accept it as a recommendation. And in truth, yes, nothing was praised so much ...
  23. ZEMCH
    ZEMCH 7 November 2020 14: 11
    +3
    I watched the film, thanks to the author for the article, the film is worth watching! good
    Happy Holidays to all members of the forum!


    PS Today is also World Men's Day! drinks
  24. bionik
    bionik 7 November 2020 16: 00
    +3
    Alexey Isaev about the film Podolsk cadets.
  25. Aleksey Aleksandrovich
    Aleksey Aleksandrovich 7 November 2020 16: 18
    0
    I will watch.
  26. nznz
    nznz 7 November 2020 16: 39
    +3
    I saw from the trailer that it was again a varnished and bronzed spectacle. It was not people who were walking, but monuments.
    Today there are no directors who saw the war, there are almost no those whose fathers fought, there are few of those left who, at least somehow, communicated with the real participants. They shoot it as a business project. They gave me money, a business plan, and drove it. I do not mind, though in this form of youth rasskat. The form is obvious - as is always the Hollywood cliché. Doesn't hurt or touch me. I am a patriot, I am with all my heart for the propaganda of our soldiers, there is something to show and tell .. not so but without pathos. I will not forget my commander, he served as a conscript in 41700, the commander of a separate radio relay battalion. Vatutinki. Lieutenant Colonel Podyachev Alexander Ivanovich, dad .. He raised us as probably the fathers of sons. We go from the exercises, no matter where, from the Moscow ring (71-73), always, in any weather, he stopped a column of fifty cars, the personnel were taken out of the KUNGs, built -departure Dubosekovo, feat of 28 Panfilovites. A short speech, a minute of silence. It knocked through to the heels. We conscripts gave honor and respect to the same soldiers, but heroes. They stood at attention without hats in the snow or rain .. and there was unity with the commanders, they are professional, with us goldfinches and the fallen.
  27. RAS-159
    RAS-159 7 November 2020 18: 09
    0
    The author forgot to mention the incomparable film "Star" by Shakhnazarov.
  28. Jager
    Jager 7 November 2020 18: 42
    0
    Tomorrow I'll go, I was waiting for this film.
  29. BAI
    BAI 7 November 2020 19: 20
    +3
    1. The technique is shown very reliably.
    2. Finally, it was recognized that the cadets were not thrown into an open field with shovel cuttings, but into positions prepared in advance.




    3.
    Yes, someone may not like the love line crammed into the film, but firstly, and where without it, and secondly - well, it was!

    Well, there were no women among the cadets, not.
    Between "As it was" and "Nice" we chose "Nice".
  30. Sergey Z.
    Sergey Z. 7 November 2020 22: 32
    0
    Thanks for the information. You can see at least something. And then some are filming about the war - girls on the front line with painted lips, eyelashes, in zero tunics and chrome boots ... how to watch it?
  31. Victor Tsenin
    Victor Tsenin 8 November 2020 00: 58
    +1
    Thanks for the review, one of these days I will go with friends, I will join)
  32. Comrade Kim
    Comrade Kim 9 November 2020 00: 57
    0
    Quote: raw174
    These films are full of cliches, and the actors do not always export them, but there is the main thing - entertainment, action and special effects. People go to these films.

    Right.
    I listened to F. Bondarchuk on the radio as he spoke about focus groups.
    Before the film, the target audience is asked: what do you want to see on the screen?
    Can you imagine what answers they give.
    Focus group of young people (17-30 years old): "We want a lot of boobs, shootings and humor" (like the degenerates from the Armenians of TNT). The Bondarchuk received a report and made a movie. The main thing is to collect more dough.

    Never mind, soon in Russia they will be filming with an eye on tolerasts, as in the USA.
    There at Snow White (filmed by a good director. N. Shyam. But with an eye on tolerasts) all seven dwarfs personify a rampant democracy.
    One negro, another Mexican, third sodomite, fourth generally middle sex, fifth Arab, etc.)

    PS The film "Rzhev" and "Panfilov's 28" are very good.
    In both films, the actors and extras are at a high level.
    Reconstructors mododtsy. There is nothing to complain about.