Office Kudrin recorded a 10-year anti-record on the implementation of the federal budget

The Accounts Chamber published data on budget execution for 2019. The material says that the expenditure side of the budget was unevenly distributed.

In December, significantly more funds were spent than in previous months (18 percent). Experts attribute this to the fact that many reporting structures tried at the end of the year to spend financial resources allocated for particular programs. As a result, this approach often led to expenses that did not have the proper economic return for the country's financial system.

It turns out that in 2019 the federal budget was not implemented by 5,8%. This is a record level from 2008-2009.

The Accounts Chamber, headed by Alexei Kudrin, determined that the unfulfilled volumes of the federal budget last year amounted to about 1,1 trillion rubles, which is almost 1,4 times more than the same indicators for the year 2018.

According to the head of the Accounts Chamber, one has to admit low executive discipline in terms of working with the federal budget.

What specific non-performance are we talking about? First of all, these are funds that were not spent during the year on ongoing projects. In other words, funds from the federal treasury were allocated for certain projects, but in the end they remained on the accounts of structures that did not invest them in the implementation of plans and programs. In this regard, more than a trillion rubles have to be postponed to 2020 and to wait for the implementation of those very programs, the terms for which are automatically shifted due to the low executiveness mentioned by Kudrin.

Comments

[Hunter 2]

Damn ... Captain Evidence. who built this system? Could it be Kudrin?
The budget is not only not fulfilled - but also surplus! Where is the money in March ??? Yeah, they’ll do it in December! Then they lay the asphalt on the Snow ... and dig pipes.

[Krasnodar]

Hi!
There is an incomprehensible policy - for many projects that have proved their success, grandmas are cut off. For new projects - no one can come up with anything worthwhile even for cutting)).

[Hunter 2]

Hi ... it’s not a matter of projects ... but in What period - Money Allocate! And this “bad man” laid the foundations for such a budget allocation - being a Minister!

[novel66]

yeah, the whole year nobody needs anything, but at the end of the year everyone should give it all up! and the production is not rubber, but a particularly smart bosses do not want to do in reserve and as a result, they all get less! Hi, Lesh!

[Hunter 2]

Hi friend Look at what years it went .... and Who handed out the Signature of the Money ??? I will say without hiding - it was This Bortsun ...

[mat-vey]

Yes, this fighter has done a lot of things, and now big eyes - "and who did it?"

[Victor N]

Questions to those who should use the money - to the very bottom, right up to the road workers racing the asphalt into the water.

[tatarin_ru]

all year nobody needs anything

it’s not quite like that, the first quarter the budget is approved / adjusted (by articles), applications are submitted from the second quarter (prioritized), someone can submit only in July, while the application goes through all the committees and approvals end in October. , that is, two months remain for development (November and December), after December 15, payments are suspended (the year closes), but in order to pay, / you need to finish the work, submit the documents for payment, you have a month shorter, and if you do not have time, head off the shoulders.
So not everywhere, but often found and planted not childishly. Just a little - a deadline. They manage to cut themselves, because the circuits are debugged, but few people want to get down to business.

[bayard]

And why be surprised that there is no economic growth, if the Medvedev team hid precisely the funds that should stimulate this growth until the end of the year.
The question is why did these funds accumulate?
Is it just for the sake of wrecking the domestic economy?
Or were the goals more ambitious?
Is it to finance the notorious "transit of power" by force?
Now the FSB will take control of the spending of funds on national projects, but whether those who have already done everything possible to disrupt them will be asked ...

[vanavatny]

Yeah, here in one hospital came the loot by December, where to go? you give marble floors, and everything seems to be according to the law, but gives a little idiocy, and not from the head physician, the fish is blunt from the head ...

[Krasnodar]

Quote: vanavate

Yeah, here in one hospital came the loot by December, where to go? you give marble floors, and everything seems to be according to the law, but gives a little idiocy, and not from the head physician, the fish is blunt from the head ...

Well, yes, instead of sending doctors for an internship abroad, in order to learn how to use the equipment they have, they make floors. There are no brains, how to kick back from this. Unlike marble tiles.

[vanavatny]

they give you loot and under the terms of the game you have very little time to spend it, what kind of internship, what kind of sane repair, you spend anywhere, so you don’t get a hat off, by the way, even the guarantor complained about this system, so what? But one can’t spend it all time simply because there are only managers around, not pros

[Krasnodar]

So organize an internship - a week))

[vanavatny]

this is not a trip, besides, if the money was given for repairs, then repair, or what the hell next time you get

[Krasnodar]

I have experience in this
Organized several times
Beilinson Hospital Rabin Medical Center, Israel
Kazakhs - gastrointestinal laparoscopy in the surgical department
Russians - Resuscitation (ITU)

[vanavatny]

good to you, well done, not everyone is like that, that means the system should be filled with people like you until this is there, then the trouble is with the system

[Krasnodar]

So I'm Komers - I did everything through the administration of the clinic plus my own organization of living, etc.
Outside the system

[vanavatny]

so much the better, and the remaining 1,1 trillion rubles returned

[Krasnodar]

Not this year

[New Year day]

Quote: Krasnodar

There are no brains ...

just brains are, everything for yourself and the boss! Forge the iron without leaving the cash register

[Paul Siebert]

the fish is dull from the head.

For twenty years, our country has been ruled by the same people.
Years pass, nothing changes - the deck of managers is endlessly shuffled: bosses change jobs, officials change priorities, parliamentarians change their views, and sellers in stores - price tags.
The visibility of political life is in full swing - now they have taken up the Constitution ...
Apparently there was all misfortune in it, but nothing - put a tick on the referendum and then we will live!
As long as the country is ruled by an oligarch, one can forget about rational methods of governance, a social state, raising the birth rate ...
Want an example?
Please ...
Kisses suck with Erdogan. What was that? Visionary planning? Reasonable move?
No - these are clan interests of corporations, political groups, shadow managers close to the Untitled ...

[Victor N]

An important problem has been raised, one must think about how to establish systemic financing. A very complex system, so far it does not work. Any suggestions?

[Demon_is_ada]

Well, I have some kind of fabrications
1. The notorious "invisible organ of the market" is completely ineffective from the word in general, and especially in our climatic zone, do not listen to the Siysk advisers on the economy of the Florida coast
2. Or speed up the process of filing and accepting an application, if this is difficult due to the specifics, then postpone the reporting to the next year or postpone everything
3. All this leads to one thought, we do not have a billion free hands in China, and it’s practically impossible to do anything instantly within two months, since then winter until spring (winter came unexpectedly as always), an example with the flooding of the Irkutsk region , not only did the leadership besides drank and kickbacks perfectly mastered nothing more, so also the absence of an excess of building materials and working hands ... Introducing myself in their place, I would get out, but not everyone would get new housing in one year, alas but I know for sure how I acted ...

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: Victor N

A very complex system, so far it does not work. Any suggestions?

Why are you complicating things?
Kudrin - who is he? Apostle of economics? In a normal company, for a long time, his “face” was cleaned up for him ...
You just imagine - in two years 2 100 000 000 000 rubles !!! Maybe, let’s say, why is this happening?
The country's economy is built for one purpose - the unhindered receipt of currency in private hands. And budget expenditures are not spent just because local leaders do not know what can be done with money except for its misuse or outright misappropriation. But!!! Recently, we have been strict with this. Not only can people “spotlight” on YuoTube, so the Kremlin leadership can put in a less warm place. How much can you build a mall? And to build production in Russia is not profitable: loans at more than 10% and it is not clear what to produce - to whom it is then sold.
It is necessary to arrange the economy in such a way that one simply cannot do without raising tariffs. Survived! In Russia, where 22% of the world's fresh water reserves (practically not requiring treatment) are concentrated in Baikal alone, water in stores is sold at a price of 20 rubles a liter ...
Well, it’s not surprising to find the perpetrators ... It is a pity that prisons do not re-educate them, and there aren’t so many “spare ministerial chairs” and chairs of lesser importance ...
Vicious circle. If there is money, then it is money - who needs money. And whoever didn’t have them - that one can’t wait for intelligible answers to such questions forever.

[Alex Nevs]

And from the ass too.

[Den717]

Quote: vanavate

Yeah, here in one hospital loot came by December

It must be understood that "loot to the hospital" is somewhat more complicated than crazy random money to the cashier of a private entrepreneur. Hospital "loot" can be spent in compliance with the procedures prescribed in the law on state. and mun. procurement, referred to in the common people as 44FZ. The procedure is cumbersome, difficult, with a bunch of all kinds of transparency and anti-corruption measures. Sometimes you can't even buy a simple pencil in a month, let alone something more complicated. And yes, by December 20, all contracts must be closed and the work must be paid, otherwise everything is completely unhealthy (for those who are involved in this contract). Someone can tell here that not all laws are followed. Maybe not everything, but if an error occurred in the terms of reference, for example, some amount of repair was not in the category that is required - the volume of major repairs was included in the current repair, then the least that threatens the guilty employee personally - a personal fine of 20000-50000 rubles. Who will risk their salary not to comply with the Federal Law? Of course, all this is reflected in the timing of the procurement organization at all stages. So no one will give money to the hospital in December, because any head physician understands that they cannot be mastered in principle. Do not think that people work in the budget are somehow worse or better than those who work for themselves or in a private organization. They, just like everyone else, care about the quality of their work, the fulfillment of the goals of their organizations, and, of course, about compliance with the law so that interesting bodies do not ask uncomfortable questions. Kudrin most likely does not have to 44FZ, the law was adopted without him. But the old one, 94FZ, was not much better ...

[for]

who built this system? Could it be Kudrin?

And who prevented her rebuild.

[Victor N]

And let's rebuild the whole world ?! And so that no one would be for it.

[private person]

Everything is simple there, so much dough that they did not even have time to pull apart and cash out.

[tatarin_ru]

who built this system? Could it be Kudrin?

On the one hand, YES, but on the other, who has prevented anyone from adjusting / changing this system over the past years.
Kudrin set the tone; the rest supported him. those. in fact, he can criticize this power in fairness, and his power is also fair. So that's the last 30 years.

[tatarin_ru]

So that's the last 30 years.

In the sense, we have been living for the last 30 years. All are right and all are to blame.

[helmi8]

Quote: Hunter 2

who built this system? Could it be Kudrin?

And with him everything was fulfilled? How many criminal cases were instituted, where he was only a witness for his cooperation with the investigation? And do not forget that he started on Sobchak’s team and worked with Chubais ... He would have been silent in a rag, benefactor ...

[Alex_59]

Quote: Hunter 2

Where is the money in March ??? Yeah, they’ll do it in December!

This is not the problem. I work in a large private company and is connected with this. It would seem that private business should be free from such vices. And no!
Money - it is there right away. But they must be spent correctly. That is, decide what, when and how to do it. And for this there is a competitive procedure. You start a competition - buy work, services or goods. The question arises - what specific goods or services? TTX to coordinate, estimates, approve projects. Ten times you cross out everything, at different levels and meetings. And you can’t say that this is wrecking - it’s not so, because you really need to spend the money correctly, wisely, so that every penny in the target. Well, we got to the auction, and this is March as a rule (in January the budget was not approved, in February the technical task was written and debugging was done). While the auction is already in April or May. Because contractors must also work on their tasks. Prepare documents. Make plans, estimates. And then there’s a rebidding, Well, let's say the auction is completed - already in May. If one of the participants was indignant and began to dispute the results, then June-July. But suppose no one even disputed. We sign the contract, it is checked by lawyers, financiers, accounting, security, back and forth - it’s already June in the yard. Further, the winner, the contractor begins to mobilize forces and means - if the service then concentrates materials and equipment on the objects of future work, and if the goods are given to production. So far it comes to the real deal - it’s already 100% autumn. And always pay with a deferment, and if the work was accepted in the fall, then the treasurers should prepare the money, often take loans in general, and bam - December.
And no wrecking.

[Misha Honest]

Quote: Hunter 2

who built this system?

Putin and co.

[Loess]

In other words, funds from the federal treasury were allocated for certain projects, but in the end they remained on the accounts of structures that did not invest them in the implementation of plans and programs.

I think this is mainly due to the fact that the money comes too late and it’s just not realistic to manage it as planned in the time remaining until the end of the year.

[bessmertniy]

In addition to the fact that money comes and is spent late, the entire competitive system is structured so that at the beginning of the year there is sheer idleness on budget orders, and then the commotion begins with order fulfillment, acceptance and settlement.

[pmkemcity]

due to the fact that the money comes too late and have no time to master it as planned in the time remaining until the end of the year is simply not realistic.

... turn on in the summer! Beer will be cold!

[Nyrobsky]

Quote: Less

In other words, funds from the federal treasury were allocated for certain projects, but in the end they remained on the accounts of structures that did not invest them in the implementation of plans and programs.

I think this is mainly due to the fact that the money comes too late and it’s just not realistic to manage it as planned in the time remaining until the end of the year.

Probably someone stupidly scrolls these funds on accounts, withdraws their interest and then throws it under the implementation of "how it goes". If it does not work out, then the money is returned to the budget, and the resulting percentage warms the soul. With a trillion, probably not sickly runs, and it seems like there is no crime - budget babos are not lost. Maybe this is not so, but some kind of selfish "interest" is visible in this.

[Loess]

Quote: Nyrobsky

Probably someone stupidly scrolls

I don’t know who scrolls what and where, but I think that this system needs to be changed. And the tender system also needs to be somehow brought to mind. At tenders, too, a lot of time is lost.

[Lamata]

Why is Kudrin not happy as a financier? Money is not spent, returned to the bins, he advocated eclnomy. A low discipline, so who studied.

[Sergey Olegovich]

Well, he is a liberal - not spent badly, spent even worse. He is like that, he is a European liberal.

[Lamata]

And I have the same opinion.

[Livonetc]

Strange as it may seem, this is a real indicator of the fight against corruption.
Officials finally began to be afraid to take bribes.
As a result, some projects did not start.
Officials do not want to take responsibility without being financially involved in the scheme (salary does not count).
And the other side is the complicated preparation and budgeting of individual ministries of departments and unitary enterprises.
Budget financing is sometimes approved only by the middle of the year.
And only after that the preparation of competitive procedures starts.
As a result, often only by the fall project executives are determined.
Well, for several months to implement a project that should last a good year is unlikely or poor quality.

[Ravil_Asnafovich]

Of course they stopped, because now the siloviki began to take billions .

[Gene84]

Quote: Livonetc

Strange as it may seem, this is a real indicator of the fight against corruption.

this is not an indicator. when laws are enforced locally, then it will be possible to talk about reducing corruption.

[Lamata]

that matter is not a matter of corruption, but a big desire to bind to projects and be responsible for their implementation

[Livonetc]

And the desire to contact the wound was largely due to the involvement of officials in the kickback scheme.
Now the risk has become unacceptable for many.

[Lamata]

Now in search of how and what to take.

[Pashhenko Nikolay]

It’s just that the bureaucracy is stopping bureaucrats from assimilating money on time and nothing more.

[prior]

Kudrin’s office formally confirmed the antipopular nature of the party and government.

[Ratmir_Ryazan]

If Russia had an anti-people government, you would not know anything about it.

[prior]

The government loves its people. It is ready to strangle him in his arms - but loving.

[Tank jacket]

There is money. The past government purposely pretended not to exist. Fired.

[askort154]

In December, much more money was spent than in previous months (18 percent).

What is incomprehensible - for New Year's corporate parties. Actually, you can't understand "helmsmen". One called - "there is no money, but you are holding on." Another says - a lot of money, why don't you spend it.

[Sergei 23]

No money, bad. We have money, we can’t spend it? !! Through the looking glass ...

[Gene84]

Quote: Sergey 23

Through the looking glass ...

not a professional financial management. more precisely

[georggy]

Accounts Chamber, headed by Alexey Kudrin

Well, so much attention to this VALENKO ................... it does not know who he is and why he lives in this world

[Vasily Ponomarev]

"Every people deserves its government" -Count of Montesquieu

[g1washntwn]

Considering that before that we were told that there were violations in the millions and almost billions, but here they also "didn’t fix" it. And you can ask: from the fact that all the same was spent to target projects, how many percent of a penny did it come then?
If only we could agree on departments there, otherwise we get some kind of information dissonance instead of lullabies.

[Ratmir_Ryazan]

They survived, they allocate so much money that they do not have time to spend.

At the same time, there are not enough medicines in hospitals, and roads in cities are in a disgusting state.

It is necessary to change something in the budget system of the country. It is necessary that the money should not be debited, but should bring results.

[g1washntwn]

And this is all from the series "Do not go to the store - it means they do not want to eat - it means that they are well-fed - so you can not feed it."
The result is true, but the trouble is that a considerable amount of time passes from the moment when they reported that the money was allocated (budget approval) to the report on the fact of their development. And here, in order to please the reporting, either go to postscript or tyap-blunder implementation, both options are jurisdictional. It is safer for health not to take this money at all (see the beginning of this comment). Then there is no need to report and the palms under the ultraviolet lamp do not shine.

[Anatole Klim]

Quote: Ratmir_Ryazan

It is necessary to change something in the budget system of the country.

A resident of Chelyabinsk Elena Karpenya sent her January increase to her pension to the Kremlin, which amounted to 1 ruble and 10 kopecks.
According to Elena Karpeni, she worked as an English teacher for 33 years.
“In January there was an indexation of 6,6%, it was supposed to go for the entire amount of the pension, but they did it, like last year, for a minimum. I am a teacher, I already have a small pension, the lowest, I received 1 ruble and 10 kopecks, this is simply insulting! " - she stressed.
Elena Karpenya clarified that her pension is 9225 rubles and she paid 81 rubles to send a letter to the Kremlin. Further: https://news.rambler.ru/community/43715988/?utm_content=news_media&utm_medium=read_more&utm_source=copylink

[rocket757]

They are frankly afraid to slam while the noise goes on ... but cleverly they were NOT taught! in short, these "hard workers" do not know how to use it wisely for their intended purpose, or slamz! In business !!!

[Krasnodar]

Yeah, do not guard, do not slam

[rocket757]

Understates, always and in everything ... and where did they get them like that? Are the victims of the exam and already nestled there?

[Krasnodar]

That not
Graduates of perestroika Soviet Universities, accustomed to working according to the skid-rollback-cut scheme, are lost here
And how to ask for a skid, Schaub not to be scorched?
And how are we going to cut it?
And what about new rollback schemes without a pale?
What if it’s fake?
Shorter, in short

[rocket757]

Quote: Krasnodar

Graduates of perestroika Soviet universities,

It could be ... nothing was left of those Soviet universities. A game of survival at the expense of ... and anyone and whatever. So they released under-graduates, imperfections.

[lukewarm]

Kudrin is still a shot, but not in the eyebrow, but in the eye. It is significant that the diagnosis of "organism" is made by one of its parents.

[DMB 75]

In other words, funds from the federal treasury were allocated for certain projects, but in the end they remained on the accounts of structures that did not invest them in the implementation of plans and programs.

In addition, the money should not be attached anyhow to anyone, but to their trusted people. Only now to monitor the kickbacks have now become stricter, so everyone is afraid. Many do not want to work with state contracts, because if you are not your own, people will come to you in uniform and open a criminal case. And then they will be imprisoned for large-scale fraud.

[Dmitry Potapov]

I work at a construction site. One and the same picture, the building is not ready and landscape work is already underway (the money is being mastered), in a week instead of the landscape a mess of curbs and chernozem, they don’t give a damn again.

[sagitch]

1st quarter - in January they finish what they did not have time for in December. In February-March there is complete unemployment, even if you put your teeth on the shelf. At least fire the workers.
2nd quarter - butting at auctions for a row, at times reducing the cost, and scratching their "turnips" how to fulfill what they won for ridiculous little money. Everyone is in search of brigades.
3rd quarter - all at once they break down to buy building materials, etc., demand exceeds supply. There are not enough working hands.
4th quarter - autumn, rains, but it is necessary to work, they do not have time to use the funds, but they hope to sign at the end of December that which has not yet been completed. On New Year's holidays, while everyone is walking, they are in a hurry to complete the work already handed over according to the documents.
And so every year ...

[Russian_man]

It began to rumble darkly, that’s the whole answer. It’s more profitable to portray an activity than to really promise.

[VLADIMIR VLADIVOSTOK]

Kudrin can only set anti-records!

[Ros 56]

Are the names of the heroes of the events known? And what will Mr. President say? And what are the consequences for the heroes, if not any, then what is the bazaar, the air about?

[tomket]

I read it like "A 10-year-old joke was recorded in Kudrin's department" ...

[faterdom]

Uh, here they are sprouts of bipartisanship! Soon you can Kudrin to the Ministry of Finance, and Siluanova - to the Accounts Chamber, so that he could already talk about the viciousness of their common brainchild ....
And the people will rejoice: now they’ve removed! Here - appointed!
Hurray, reforms have begun, so you see, pensions will soon be raised through the Constitution (by the way, we must also add them to the Bible and the Koran, to be convincing).
Yes, you can still change Golikov, for example, with Nabiulina - also a mover for the people, otherwise he, sickly, got bored ... they say nothing changes!
And Sberbank after the sale by the Central Bank to the government can be resold to the Ministry of Finance, for example. And if these trillions are also included in the GDP for it, then it (the GDP) will grow significantly! Ingenious! And to sell twice - in general! Hooray!
In historical time we live!

[Po-tzan]

Office Kudrin recorded a 10-year anti-record on the implementation of the federal budget

There are questions to Kudrin, but since Putin keeps him with him, then he is an intelligent man, necessary to get Russia off its knees and make a technological breakthrough.