Kedmi explains the growing popularity of Stalin in Russia

Over the past 25 years in the public consciousness of Russian citizens there have been significant changes in the attitude to the "leader of nations" Joseph Stalin. In particular, today there is a growing popularity of Stalin’s personality, including among representatives of the Russian youth.

Many politicians, historians and public figures are trying to explain this phenomenon. However, they express completely different points of view. Someone thinks that in Stalin people see a “cleaner”, someone thinks that attention to Stalin is artificially heated by the media.

An interesting explanation for the rapidly growing popularity of Stalin was given on the talk show “Evening with Vladimir Solovyov” by the well-known Israeli expert Jacob Kedmi. He is convinced that those who are trying to denigrate and demonize the Soviet leader are the enemies of Russia and her stories.

In his opinion, those representatives of Russian society, for whom Stalin is the personification of state justice and who express their positive attitude towards him, are trying to protect themselves and all of Russia from enemies and enemies who use the image of Stalin for anti-Russian propaganda in the international community.

Far from all the guests of the program studio, which goes to the Russia 1 channel, agreed with Kedmi.

Comments

[MoJloT]

Kedmi explains the growing popularity of Stalin in Russia

Cedmi does not want to explain the actions of Israel in Syria?

[Bumblebee_3]

MoJloT (MoJloT)
But essentially Kedmi's statements about Stalin, nothing to say?

[MoJloT]

But essentially Kedmi's statements about Stalin, nothing to say?

There is something to say, Stalin is not on us!

[Bumblebee_3]

MoJloT (MoJloT)
Well, this is how to look. Maybe there is no Stalin on me, maybe on you

[Bumblebee_3]

MoJloT (MoJloT)
Sorry mate, beguiled! My answer is at 18:41, out of place!

[Nyrobsky]

Quote: MoJloT

Kedmi explains the growing popularity of Stalin in Russia

Cedmi does not want to explain the actions of Israel in Syria?

So he has already spoken out on this topic more than once, AND ........, which is typical, ........ not in favor of Israel and not even in favor of the United States. Mattresses from him sometimes get more than barmaley. In general, at times he gives out on the mountain such conclusions with which it is difficult to argue ... as a result, the question arises - where does such consciousness (without irony) come from in a person who is not the most friendly state in relation to Russia and at the same time has not yet been subjected to Jewish "anathema" - I do not know what the Jews call it. At least, I am very interested in his views on current events and the predictions that he makes for the future, based on the present day, without hesitating, to put it mildly, to call some of the Kremlin's actions, the actions of suckers, doing it in such a reasoned that can not argue. Neither for nor against - but objectively, unlike our liberal political scientists or Urkain experts present at our political talk shows, Kedmi is interesting.

[Mordor]

If there were now such a leader in Russia as Stalin, all the "grunting" and "grunting" would shut their snouts and behave calmly! And in Russia itself, all this ltberota would "mow" the forest and be engaged in construction projects of the national economy! And would not pour tons of slops on Russia. And with people like Chubais and other lovers of robbery, it would be what the people are dreaming of with a taxi!

[rocket757]

I suppose that, like Stalin, besides everything else necessary and good, we wouldn’t chat so freely and about everything .... however, there would be less criticism of the reasons, but they WOULD be anyway, and we couldn’t talk about them !!!
It's a choice, anyway! Difficult choice.

[Mr Credo]

Well, the same non-polite writer really tried to sit down. And choosing between the front and the prison for some reason I chose the prison. Why? So was the gulag a death factory or not? In the days of Stalin it was so scary that it was just scary !? Why then were there so many volunteers at the front if it was so scary? Under Stalin, they worked for a stew? And what did the workers buy tanks and planes for
and collective farmers? Today they began to live calmly and richly? How many tanks and planes did the free and wealthy Russians buy for the army today? Or today there are no rich?

[rocket757]

The Soviet state guaranteed almost EVERYTHING and FULFILLED! True, it also required a lot, but social justice is a huge incentive, more or less attractive than the "air of freedom" I will not say, did not decide.
I don’t want to talk about sales now, because the sales that are called "the air of freedom" we have with a fair smell!
That's right now and make a CHOICE! who will choose what, with a very high probability can be predicted!
The affairs of bygone days do not seem so terrible to very many of our citizens, and the prospects now are very vague, if not "sour" at all.

[Mr Credo]

And who or what interferes with guarantees today?

[rocket757]

Any problem, as a rule, has several causes.
This one, too, like everywhere else, has the greed of those who have grabbed almost everything, passivity, stupidity ....... those who have been ripped off and will be robbed further precisely for what they are now.
Everything is according to the textbook, if you want to have it, then you want to, fight or work for achieving it!
The capitalists, they are as they are, and our working class is what they need.

[vlad106]

Quote: Mister Creed

How many tanks and planes did the free and wealthy Russians buy for the army today? Or today there are no rich?

these "triggers" just in your pocket. until the confiscation of the illegally inhabited (plundered) and executions of the plunderers of state public property begins, by simple thieves, there will be no sense

[wax]

Chatting - Don't Build.

[rocket757]

People live, build, work .... back in the whistle, social networks, steam releases! A strange existence, given our past.
What is and another on the horizon is not observed.

[vvnab]

Be a leader like Stalin in Russia now ...

The leader does not arise from the void. What kind of people are such leaders. Individuals of the scale of Lenin and Stalin need to be "nurtured" for a long time, and for this it is necessary to unite the masses of the people around the Idea. And now, some in the forest, some for firewood ... There is not even a single view of one's own past.

[Mordor]

Quote: rocket757

I suppose that, like Stalin, besides everything else necessary and good, we wouldn’t chat so freely and about everything .... however, there would be less criticism of the reasons, but they WOULD be anyway, and we couldn’t talk about them !!!
It's a choice, anyway! Difficult choice.

Well, I lived in the late USSR, so I don't presume to judge the consequences for criticism. But getting acquainted with the memories of prominent people of that time, I can say that too much is exaggerated than it really was! What is actually trying to inspire us, so to speak, the "liberal community".

[rocket757]

I, too, am not the same age as the Stalin era, and I can judge from the stories of Parents, Grandfathers and eyewitnesses.
It was nice! It was difficult! It was different!
One grandfather sat, the other guarded ... not prisoners, but the borders of our country, and drove the hunkhuzes and pinched Bandera. They did not argue when they got together, but drank for their comrades, for all the good against all the bad!
Life is how we live!

[Mordor]

All right Victor it was different , as a matter of fact, at all times. This is our story! And our task is not to find fault, not to spit on the past. And live and take all the good!)))

[rocket757]

So there is the right Ivan!
As the Fathers and Grandfathers bequeathed - "Serve faithfully, to whom you swear, and remember the proverb: take care of your dress again, and honor when you are young."
I did not change my oath, I remain a fighter of the Soviet Army!
We will be faithful to our memory and see you in the ranks of the IMMORTAL REGION.

[Mordor]

Victor, I fully support. Let’s go through the IMMORTAL REGION, each in his own city!

[rocket757]

We have the city of STALINGRAD, I will lead the boys, let them REMEMBER!

[pepel]

Now many complain about the lack of a national idea. The growing popularity of Stalin is a public request for a deed for which Russia lives and works. The lack of ideology in the state forces society to formulate a national idea without the participation of the state. And it is entirely possible that the growing popularity of Stalin is the first touches of the future nat. ideas.

[rocket757]

Back to the PAST, this idea is not very .... forward to the FUTURE, taking from the past all the BEST!

[pepel]

The future is built on the foundation of the past. And what it will be called without a difference. To begin with, Stalin will do, and there, along the way, they may come up with something else.

[rocket757]

Stalin, too serious a symbol! Just hang the portrait on the wall, declare yourself followers, and act differently ..... disorder and fermentation will begin! And there, and to the collapse of the idea is not far !!!!
In my opinion, people can take a new path if they clearly weave ideas from the past into the idea, but combine it with new realities, so that all this can be seen and clearly understood !!!
In short, there is work to do and very carefully!

[Nikolaevich I]

I have not listened to Kedmi for quite a while ... There was a time when he used his arguments as arguments in disputes and discussions. But over time, for some reason, Kedmi began to remind me of Slavik Kovtun! (Seen by frequent speeches on any occasion ...) I do not know what and how Kedmi said this time about Stalin .... in the commentary I express my attitude not to Stalin, but to Kedmi ...

[Fevralsk. Morev]

Under Stalin, there was an ideology: a state for the people. Under Putin, ideology: people for the state.

[kukriniks]

It is strange that he constantly comes to Moscow to broadcast, interpret history and a new life path? Excuse me, I completely forgot about the occupation tool.

[Stalnov I.P.]

I personally agree, with Yakov, STALIN is a BUCK, which is recognized throughout the world and all the speeches of talkers and talkers from liberals and from power structures, speaks only about one thing that he did, they will never repeat and achieve. It is from this powerlessness that they are furious. A flag in their hands and a drum on their neck. NEVER REACH !!!

[Fevralsk. Morev]

Quote: I.P. Stalnov.

Stalin is a lump recognized throughout the world.

How are they trying to promote the cult of the personality of Nicholas II ?! The result is zero. Why? The result of his reign is zero. What can not be said about Stalin. The industrialization of Stalin, the results of which our cannibalistic authorities are still eating up.

[ser6119]

Since the year 20 (the approximate end of the Civil War + Interventions of our "sworn partners" until 1941, the USSR became one of the industrial powers of the world. Many industrial enterprises were created! Now, during the whole period of reforms, apart from several screwdriver factories, nothing has been built, small enterprises (regional meanings) have become either trading floors or wastelands!

[Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock]

Quote: MoJloT

Kedmi explains the growing popularity of Stalin in Russia

Cedmi does not want to explain the actions of Israel in Syria?

***
Ask me questions: I will answer. And what is there something unclear?

[Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock]

Quote: Nyrobsky

Quote: MoJloT

Kedmi explains the growing popularity of Stalin in Russia

Cedmi does not want to explain the actions of Israel in Syria?

So he has already spoken out on this topic more than once, AND ........, which is typical, ........ not in favor of Israel and not even in favor of the United States. Mattresses from him sometimes get more than barmaley. In general, at times he gives out on the mountain such conclusions with which it is difficult to argue ... as a result, the question arises - where does such consciousness (without irony) come from in a person who is not the most friendly state in relation to Russia and at the same time has not yet been subjected to Jewish "anathema" - I do not know what the Jews call it. At least, I am very interested in his views on current events and the predictions that he makes for the future, based on the present day, without hesitating, to put it mildly, to call some of the Kremlin's actions, the actions of suckers, doing it in such a reasoned that can not argue. Neither for nor against - but objectively, unlike our liberal political scientists or Urkain experts present at our political talk shows, Kedmi is interesting.

***
The answer is:
1. Kedmi does not represent the state. He is neither a prime minister nor a president, not a foreign minister and not ... and not .. and not ...
2. Which country is not the friendliest towards Russia: the one that did not condemn the Chechen wars of Russia, the annexation of Crimea, actions in the Donbass, the history of the Skripals, did not impose any sanctions, despite US pressure?
And then what states are friendly to Russia? Waiting for a long list!
3. Kedmi pays tribute to Stalin as a statesman.
4. Kedmi’s remarks get mixed reviews in Russia, Ukraine, Israel ... maybe somewhere else.
5. About Stalin: dictator, the historical period in Europe and Asia is dictatorial, dictatorial methods.
It was such a time.

[Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock]

Quote: Mordor

If there were now such a leader in Russia as Stalin, all the "grunting" and "grunting" would shut their snouts and behave calmly! And in Russia itself, all this ltberota would "mow" the forest and be engaged in construction projects of the national economy! And would not pour tons of slops on Russia. And with people like Chubais and other lovers of robbery, it would be what the people are dreaming of with a taxi!

***
Are you sure you have not been accused of "grunting" and "grunting"? Well, look for an apartment, for a position ... or in the kitchen they expressed dissatisfaction with the next seal in the apartment ...
Read carefully "Victims of political terror in the USSR" http://lists.memo.ru/
You know, it’s great for the Stalinists to cleanse their brains when they see the masses of these people of different nationalities (about 80% of the Slavs (!) And only then Tatars, Uzbeks, Jews, Germans, and further to decrease). how many of these "enemies of the people" are simple, illiterate workers, peasants, and only then intelligentsia, priests) repressed in the most different years, right up to the death of Stalin ...

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve

how many of these "enemies of the people" are simple,

It is clear that you are literate. My grandfather was taken prisoner, then to the penal battalion, but ... he never scolded Stalin. But he was put into the "damn regime". To the mine of the Moscow region.

[Lieutenant Colonel of the USSR Air Force in stock]

Quote: mordvin xnumx

Quote: Lieutenant Colonel of the USSRF Air Force in reserve

how many of these "enemies of the people" are simple,

It is clear that you are literate. My grandfather was taken prisoner, then to the penal battalion, but ... he never scolded Stalin. But he was put into the "damn regime". To the mine of the Moscow region.

***
Well, on "you", so on "you" ...
1. I am literate.
2. You are not literate, sl-but?
3. Yes, I did not scold, I was afraid. Fear was driven into his skin.
4. And I knew repressed people who, after the 90s, just started talking about their "love" for Stalin.

[Fevralsk. Morev]

Stalin's popularity in a simple comparison. What was created during the years of industrialization in 12 years and what pr @ wr @ whether for the past 19 years (well, you know with whom). Stalin's popularity of 70% and Putin's rating of 30% -total 100%

[Stalnov I.P.]

This man, this BALK, set goals and solved them, and those who are talking now talk, promise, but they don’t solve and don’t do it. That’s why in the PEOPLE its popularity grows and I think the further, the bigger it will be.