Makarevich - to the fans: Why were you yelling “Ukrykrymnash”?

300
The network continues to discuss the post on Facebook Andrei Makarevich, who actually insulted many people who are still fans of his work.

Makarevich - to the fans: Why were you yelling “Ukrykrymnash”?

Photo Makarevich, where he remembers the Holocaust




Before one of his concerts, Makarevich, as it turned out, was annoyed at the fact that people who supported the reunification of Crimea with Russia asked to be photographed with him. Some words “VO” have to be skipped due to possible complaints about their literary character.

From the post of a musician who continues to “rampage” about the will of the Crimeans:

“Oh, Andrey Vadimovich, can I take a picture with you? We have raised our songs! ”
Lord Yes you can, of course. Just what are you so ... in rose? What are you yelling "Urakrymnash"? Did you listen badly? You say beauty will save the world? Neither ... and she will not save him.


Further Makarevich left in the top to this post only those comments, in which Facebook users expressed, politically on the side of Makarevich.

But one of the users pretty much played musician with alternative views on the will of the people in his other post.

From a comment by Ivan Belov under a photograph of Makarevich a few minutes before a concert in Yekaterinburg:

18 March 2014, the Crimea officially became part of the Russian Federation. I congratulate you from the whole soul and sincerely !!!


Another user wondered who still goes to this person's concerts. Only instead of the word “man” a less euphonic word was used, but also with the letter “h”.

Recall that Makarevich initially spoke out against the reunification of the Crimea with Russia, and when millions of Russians after that expressed everything they think about Makarevich himself, the musician expressed something similar to an insult. At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from entering the public council of the State Duma on culture.
300 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The comment was deleted.
    1. +54
      18 March 2019 13: 57
      Hello Sergey hi
      These are, one might say, "shortfalls", since the 17th (descendants), well, I gave you power ... And in Sov.time I lived, normally. Better than many ... And after that, the loot is a river. And kind ...
      No. All offenses are old ... But my relatives ...
      And mine too, from the Volga region to Siberia. And then, three generations of "restrictions" ... And I had a lot of "such" friends in Kazakhstan, and Germans, and Poles, and Tatars, and Latvians, etc. I don’t know, there’s no shape-shifters. request
      Units.
      1. +72
        18 March 2019 13: 58
        Hello Stas hi I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...
        1. +91
          18 March 2019 14: 03
          Wisdom comes with age, but it happens that age comes alone. Under old age, Makar is also losing his mind. Regrettably !!!
          1. +21
            18 March 2019 14: 03
            As my grandmother used to say: "What is male, what is old!"
            1. +60
              18 March 2019 14: 29
              For me, Makarevich has long existed as a person!

              Makarevich has long been a liberal trash and nothing more!
              I am surprised that there are still people - from Soviet times - who do not understand this.
              1. +28
                18 March 2019 14: 38
                Quote: Tatiana
                For me, Makarevich has long existed as a person!


                What does he think of himself?

                I wrote some songs, thank you, was it in the company at the table or on the hike to sing, and what?

                Now he is nobody, he can’t squeeze anything out of himself, except for nasty things.

                We can forgive a lot of geniuses or talented people, but he is too far from a genius, and you cannot call him a great talent, so he got into the stream, he composed songs so-so, just for those whom he called "idiots"

                never considered him a "master of thoughts"
                1. +18
                  18 March 2019 15: 09
                  Quote: bulvas


                  Now he is nobody, he can’t squeeze anything out of himself, except for nasty things.
                  We can forgive a lot for this genius or talented people, but he is too far from a genius, and you can’t call him a great talent, he got into the stream, he composed songs so-so ...

                  Even if for someone Makar is a genius, this does not mean that he can offend our Motherland, which, perhaps, he once considered his own too. And to spit in the face of fans of their "creativity" - it's just meanness.
                  1. +10
                    18 March 2019 15: 30
                    Quote: DMB_95
                    Even if for someone Makar is a genius, this does not mean that he can offend our Motherland, which, perhaps, he once considered his own too. And to spit in the face of fans of their "creativity" - it's just meanness.

                    Yes, Makarevich had addicted his mind a long time ago, and his conscience was completely lost!

                    Makarevich has already become an old artistic junk on the stage. For a long time he has not even been quoted even for concerts, all for the same audience of his former fans, who also aged with him, is already dying. And for some of his former and politically advanced fans, for a long time he wasn’t even looking for a GIFT, but even his voice was disgusting to them!
                    1. +10
                      18 March 2019 16: 20
                      Quote: Tatiana
                      Quote: DMB_95
                      Even if for someone Makar is a genius, this does not mean that he can offend our Motherland, which, perhaps, he once considered his own too. And to spit in the face of fans of their "creativity" - it's just meanness.

                      Yes, Makarevich had addicted his mind a long time ago, and his conscience was completely lost!

                      Makarevich has already become an old artistic junk on the stage. For a long time he has not even been quoted even for concerts, all for the same audience of his former fans, who also aged with him, is already dying. And for some of his former and politically advanced fans, for a long time he wasn’t even looking for a GIFT, but even his voice was disgusting to them!


                      Tatyana, love
                      I will confirm. in his youth they listened and played his songs themselves, in the evenings after lights out. Now I want to spit in his direction and get!
                      rot does not immediately creep out.
                      1. +8
                        18 March 2019 20: 05
                        This unfortunately often happens .. They sing good songs, but the hypocrites themselves! "The whole world will bend under us" - but in fact he himself bowed under the striped ones with joy! Or maybe they bought it a long time ago for jeans .. Who knows.
                      2. +2
                        19 March 2019 13: 04
                        I remember him, in 1996 he came to Thessaloniki on Dmitry Shestakovich. then there were few Russian-speaking guides in Greece, and his group was given to my sister. in fact, we showed him the city, and although he willingly listened to us and even learned to cook in Greek, he made a lousy impression on me. Thank God he didn’t have enough time to stomp our city for more than a week, and our port rats were detained by the ship for non-payment ... even banned him from entering the port. but nevertheless he came several times later. unofficially of course, but this does not change the essence. I didn’t really listen and respect him there, but after his arrival in Greece I ceased to respect him at all. I’ve been saying this since 1996 ... when I saw him close. although he certainly tried not to talk about himself, but some notes in his voice began to annoy me from the very first minutes. he was lucky that the Greeks were not vicious, and even then they were more interested in establishing a tourist flow from the former USSR. Therefore, there was simply no one to complain about here. otherwise it would tempt him for those words about the first Chechen one, just to fall apart at the seams and daigonal ... let the Greek cops kiss their ass now, all the Greek police ... they saved his own ass from the separation of the hemispheres.
                2. +20
                  18 March 2019 16: 42
                  "... every fire
                  once burned out.
                  Wind ash
                  will scatter without a trace ... "
                  This is about your authority, Makar. Which you just flushed down the toilet.
                  1. 0
                    19 March 2019 13: 16
                    I agree completely!
                    Everything in his songs has long been written by him:

                    "... And he kept waiting,
                    that the time will come.
                    The appointed hour will break through.
                    And the world will be the opposite! "

                    "... In order not to become such a museum.
                    It's better to go to the bottom at the right moment ... "

                    It’s written by Makar about Makar himself ...
                    1. 0
                      19 March 2019 22: 15
                      Everything in his songs has long been written by him:

                      Or for example:
                      "... And you didn't choose the road,
                      and was always out of work.
                      And then I found, not what I was looking for,
                      And I was not looking for what I wanted .... "
                      Makar got confused by his old age ... I honestly thought that he would come to his senses - after all, he sang songs in defense of the world. And here the pro-fascist regime covers up. I was severely mistaken in it! ((( No.
                3. +7
                  18 March 2019 21: 00
                  Apparently we were listening and thinking about one thing. And he sang and meant something completely different. This is different now and is crawling out, so much so that this is, in my opinion, a clinical case.
              2. +28
                18 March 2019 14: 39
                Tatyana .. Makarevich, like the other Akhidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ... are associated with the Jewish diasporas and live their own separate lives, including political ones, for these diasporas .... Makarevich does not represent Russian self-consciousness, and therefore it relates as marginalized and what they do is their true face ...
                1. +6
                  18 March 2019 15: 32
                  Quote: Vladimir 5
                  Tatyana .. Makarevich, like the other Akhidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ... are associated with the Jewish diasporas and live their own separate lives, including political ones, for these diasporas .... Makarevich does not represent Russian self-consciousness, and therefore it relates as marginalized and what they do is their true face ...

                  I agree with you completely!
                  1. +1
                    18 March 2019 15: 43
                    Deceased Kobzon, or the authors of "Katyusha" and "Victory Day" + how many really folk songs? - what are the considerations of the "experts" about them?
                    1. +6
                      18 March 2019 18: 33
                      Quote: Carpenter 2329
                      Deceased Kobzon, or the authors of "Katyusha" and "Victory Day" + how many really folk songs? - what are the considerations of the "experts" about them?

                      The authors of "Katyusha" and "Victory Day" did not find fault with their country.
                      1. 0
                        18 March 2019 19: 21
                        Quote: olegyurjewitch
                        Quote: Carpenter 2329
                        Deceased Kobzon, or the authors of "Katyusha" and "Victory Day" + how many really folk songs? - what are the considerations of the "experts" about them?

                        The authors of "Katyusha" and "Victory Day" did not find fault with their country.

                        Yes, no, I’m just talking about the Jewish diaspora, I see - specialists, I’ve gone. Therefore, he asked.
                        And so - a good consideration.
                        Neither Zhukov, nor Konev, nor Pokryshkin also found fault with their Homeland.
                        Unlike Vlasov and at least two more millions who served for the benefit of the Reich.
                        So what is the matter in the nation, experts?
                2. -7
                  18 March 2019 17: 35
                  Quote: Vladimir 5
                  Makarevich, like the other Ahidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ... are associated with the Jewish diasporas and live their own separate lives, including political ones, for these diasporas .... Makarevich does not represent Russian identity

                  Well, where there is leavened patriotism, there is anti-Semitism. As grit, "beat the Jews, save Russia." To the wall of all these Makarevichs, Blanters, Sakharovs, Ginzburgs, Ioffe, Tammov, Dunaevskys ...
                  It seemed to me alone what stank of fascism? What are you doing, friends? How can you add such an abomination? Conscience has disappeared? You are rightly indignant about Ukrainian nationalism - but why don’t you see what you yourself have turned into?
                  1. 0
                    18 March 2019 18: 06
                    No, Alex, not one. And it didn’t seem. And, most interestingly, as always - not a single link. Someone splashed on the fan - and away we go. You begin to analyze the situation, but there was nothing of the sort. But, as they say, spoons were found, but the sediment remained.
                    1. -5
                      18 March 2019 22: 01
                      Quote: Dmitry Bolotsky
                      No, Alex, not one. And it didn’t seem. And, most interestingly, as always - not a single link. Someone splashed on the fan - and away we go. You begin to analyze the situation, but there was nothing of the sort. But, as they say, spoons were found, but the sediment remained.

                      Who splashed - they are all here.
                      I am surprised to moderators and administrators. For 282 tbsp. in relation to sites there has already been a recent conversation.
                3. +12
                  18 March 2019 17: 37
                  Quote: Vladimir 5
                  Makarevich, like other Akhidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ...

                  They didn’t love us, they don’t love us and they will never love us. We are not their people! This land is not their ancestors, and therefore they hate us! Feeding on our land, pretending to be us.
                  1. -1
                    18 March 2019 18: 18
                    Quote: 30 vis
                    They didn’t love us, they don’t love us and they will never love us. We are not their people! This land is not their ancestors, and therefore they hate us! Feeding on our land, pretending to be us.
                    Dear, how do you determine who is Russian and who is not? By last name? The shape of the nose and curly? Then you - at the dog show, there the exterior matters. And in the human community, the values ​​are different. Landau, Tamm and Sakharov have done immeasurably more for Russia than you and I do not determine their nationality. People like you, they probably didn’t love - but why love you? For Nazism? And of course they honestly earned their own piece of bread, but whether you can also brag about this is something unknown.
                    1. +13
                      18 March 2019 18: 30
                      Quote: astepanov
                      How do you determine who is Russian and who is not?

                      I will answer you, "dear" ... I define it by love for the HOMELAND! To the people of Russian respect. By the curliness and color of the eyes you define "respected" .. hi
                      1. 0
                        18 March 2019 19: 28
                        Vis, Thrice Hero Social. Truda Zeldovich loved his homeland, or, as you say, pretended to be?
                        Or a fighter pilot, Hero of the Soviet Union Shapiro for the future Israel Hero received?
                        Who taught you to judge people like that in general? About whole nations?
                        Come on about us, about the Russians so judge?
                        Or do we have one solid heroes?
                      2. 0
                        18 March 2019 20: 02
                        Yes, he does not understand. It is impossible to convince the Nazis because for the most part they are from loser shopkeepers, with a poor education and an outlook of five degrees - usually beer houses.
                      3. -1
                        18 March 2019 20: 06
                        What fascists ...
                        Before the Nazis, the hollowers have no brains.
                        They themselves poorly know, or do not know at all, why such songs are howled.
                      4. 0
                        18 March 2019 21: 27
                        Are you Russian? So why soared? Will you repent now? Take a bite!
                      5. -3
                        18 March 2019 21: 47
                        Quote: Dart
                        Are you Russian? So why soared? Will you repent now? Take a bite!

                        I am Russian. Without something.
                        And never pop to call for such an action. )))
                        And take a bite and you yourself at home, if something is going to be picked up.
                      6. -1
                        18 March 2019 22: 00
                        they told the truth below ... and really, a brake.
                      7. +1
                        18 March 2019 21: 32
                        Quote: Carpenter 2329
                        Who taught you to judge people like that in general? About whole nations?
                        Come on about us, about the Russians so judge?
                        Or do we have one solid heroes?
                        --- We are gussian!
                        I didn’t shake hands with you, "respected", I didn’t drink at brotherhood .. And I have no desire. Therefore, on YOU. For people with tight thinking I will repeat ....-. I define it by love for my homeland! I define respect for the people of Russia !!! By the verbal diarrhea addressed to RUSSIA, I define people ... By the curliness of the hair and the color of the eyes, you define "respected".
                      8. -5
                        18 March 2019 21: 39
                        Vis!
                        We must carefully read the letters.
                        This is me about curly and color.
                        And you somehow left the question. As a famous character, from Mowgli.
                      9. +3
                        18 March 2019 21: 43
                        Because on YOU We are not in the army, I am not watered by a worker ... For people with tight thinking. With developmental delays .. I explain for the last time.-.-. I determine by love for my HOMELAND! To the people of Russian respect I define !!! By verbal diarrhea in the address of RUSSIA I define people.
                      10. 0
                        18 March 2019 21: 45
                        Vasya .... brake. Carpenter.
                      11. -4
                        18 March 2019 22: 07
                        Better a brake than Tobaccos.
                        But in general ...
                        It’s not peculiar to me to knit with dolboers.
                        So hi
                      12. 0
                        19 March 2019 09: 00
                        Quote: Carpenter 2329
                        It’s not peculiar to me to knit with dolboers.
                        So

                        And with an exclamation "- And we will go north! And we will go north!" trotted towards the owner ..
                    2. +1
                      19 March 2019 03: 43
                      Quote: astepanov
                      Dear, how do you determine who is Russian and who is not?

                      And why did you start talking about nationalities (Russian is not Russian)? Your opponent had: "They we were not loved, do not love and will never love ... "It seems to me, or are you stirring up?
                      1. -2
                        19 March 2019 11: 57
                        Quote: ctepx
                        And why did you start talking about nationalities (Russian is not Russian)? Your opponent had: "They did not love us, do not love and will never love us ..." It seems to me, or are you stirring up?

                        Maybe you forgot how to read? What was there in the original of your client about the Jewish diasporas? And how did he determine who is included in these diasporas and who is not? Huh? Tell me where the Natsik got so many defenders from. In appearance, this site is not a haven of skinheads, and there you’ve run up so much, it’s already rippling in your eyes. If this is the case, soon the assault troops will show up, will begin to thin out and uproot in the struggle for the purity of the race.
                      2. -1
                        19 March 2019 18: 49
                        And how did you determine that our client is specifically about diasporas, and even more so Jewish ones? So I personally do not divide people by nationality in principle. In relation to Russia, yes, I share. This was mentioned in the commentary)).
                4. 0
                  18 March 2019 22: 55
                  Quote: Vladimir 5
                  Tatyana .. Makarevich, like the other Akhidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ... are associated with the Jewish diasporas and live their own separate lives, including political ones, for these diasporas .... Makarevich does not represent Russian self-consciousness, and therefore it relates as marginalized and what they do is their true face ...

                  I totally agree! And if you recall the photo for the article, then what to talk about?
              3. +10
                18 March 2019 14: 57
                Quote: Tatiana
                For me, Makarevich has long existed as a person!

                Makarevich has long been a liberal trash and nothing more!
                I am surprised that there are still people - from Soviet times - who do not understand this.

                All the while I was rubbing near the powers that be, but what feats were awarded state awards, and what would not return. just do not agree. A traitor is a psychotype and fate.
                1. +3
                  18 March 2019 23: 01
                  Quote: Balu
                  awarded state awards, and what will not return. just do not agree

                  Here !!! good
                  Where GESTURE !!! You, artist ... Tear to the end ... What, with a bang! Like Serebryakov, he even emigrated ...

                  negative H man M orally launched.
                  1. +1
                    19 March 2019 06: 13
                    Quote: LiSiCyn
                    H man M orally launched.

                    The last jar of jam and a packet of cookies from the State Department is coming to an end, we must do something ...
              4. +14
                18 March 2019 15: 51
                Quote: Tatiana
                I am surprised that there are still people - from Soviet times - who do not understand this.

                No need for Soviet times. People at all times are different
                - solid, liquid, gaseous.

                The dawn of the group "Time Machine" came to my youth. Student hostel, portable cassette and ... almost the Beatles, only ours. This has never happened before. Everyone who could barely have a guitar knew ALL texts by heart. No matter that it was a primitive "square", it is important that the texts were in tune with time for us. Brezhnev's death was not so worried as the release of the new album, then they said - a concert ...

                So do not be in Soviet times.

                But with his perennial statements, Makarevich crossed out in me all the rainbow-youthful charm of the songs of the aforementioned group. Very sorry. It was like a betrayal. It's like dad kills mom before your eyes. I don’t want to sing his songs anymore, listen to me too. Sayings overshadow.
                1. +13
                  18 March 2019 16: 33
                  Quote: McAr
                  But with his many years of statements, Makarevich crossed out in me all that rosy and youthful charm of the songs of the aforementioned group. Very sorry. It was like a betrayal. It's like dad kills your mom before your eyes. I don’t feel like singing his songs anymore, listen too. Statements overshadow.

                  It is for the same reason that I do not watch "9th company", since the main role was played by the "shape-shifter". That is why I do not listen to Pugacheva, Kirkorov and Baskov ... that is why I do not watch anything with Zelensky, as well as with Akhidzhakova ... this whole story of recent years has clearly divided those who are with the West and their values, and those who are not wants to bend under the West.
                  But I see the mistakes of our helmsmen. Where is a clear foreign policy in the CIS? What are these partnership games with Western countries that are openly preparing to fight with us? Why is there no coherent ideology of the state? We are surprised that our schoolboy in the Bundestag justifies the Nazis ... and where is the intelligible education of young people? A trained person cannot be dusted with brains, but it is easy for a poorly educated person. It is easy to manage a herd of poorly educated. And here a lot of questions arise to our helmsmen.
                  1. +1
                    18 March 2019 17: 04
                    Quote: NEXUS
                    Where is a clear foreign policy in the CIS? What are these partnership games with Western countries that are openly preparing to fight with us? Why is there no coherent ideology of the state? We are surprised that our schoolboy in the Bundestag justifies the Nazis ... and where is the intelligible education of young people?

                    I agree!

                    There are so many questions to the steering that even briefly answering, they would have been too tired to answer. Will not answer. Because we, the peoples of Russia consider b_dlom. What is left? Either bend into the horn of sheep, or take power into your own hands through the socialist revolution. The first is easier, the second is harder. But the first is death, and the second is the chance to live.
                    1. +2
                      18 March 2019 17: 17
                      Quote: McAr
                      Either bend into the horn of sheep, or take power into your own hands through the socialist revolution.

                      No, revolution is a disastrous path. We have already passed it. The people died unreasonably and the death of so many citizens for the country will be fatal.
                      Maidans, revolutions, coups are methods that kill both the statehood of the country and destroy its development. After revolutions, civil wars often begin, which are just as deadly for the state.
                      And all this is well understood in the West. It is not for nothing that the United States is producing colorful revolutions around the world. Thus cutting off the head of the country ... well, and with the torso they can then do what they want.
                      1. -1
                        18 March 2019 17: 32
                        Quote: NEXUS
                        No, revolution is a disastrous path. We have already passed it. The people died unreasonably and the death of so many citizens for the country will be fatal.
                        Maidans, revolutions, coups are methods that kill both the statehood of the country and destroy its development. After revolutions, civil wars often begin, which are just as deadly for the state.
                        And all this is well understood in the West. It is not for nothing that the United States is producing colorful revolutions around the world. Thus cutting off the head of the country ... well, and with the torso they can then do what they want.

                        So boil like a frog. This is clearly better, right?

                        "Maidans, revolutions, coups" are different things. You don't confuse a crankshaft with a carburetor and an ear with a salad. So why mix chops with flies?

                        Yes, we once went this way. Those who like to use their own kind were dissatisfied. But is it worth paying attention to the opinion of scum? You just ALSO were unhappy with the opinion of Kolya from the Bundeswehr.

                        Just with the arrival of Capital in Russia, "a lot of people died." According to some estimates, more than for the Civil War and the Second World War combined. Silently. Like - I'm not me and the horse is not mine, but more people have perished than we can even imagine. And the last of the repressions - pension, will generally finish off Russia.
                      2. -1
                        18 March 2019 17: 46
                        Quote: McAr
                        "Maidans, revolutions, coups" are different things. You don't confuse a crankshaft with a carburetor and an ear with a salad. So why mix chops with flies?

                        And what are they different from the point of view of statehood of the country? I will give you an example. Until 17, the Russian empire developed, grew rich, strengthened state institutions, and by the way, the Russian ruble was the hardest currency in the world. Scientists, architects, writers came to us from all over the world, in general the color of any nation. It was prestigious.
                        The revolution came and who was nobody, he became everything. That is, illiteracy, poverty and the emergence of a new religion, in the form of a brighter future, plunged the country into chaos, with millions of victims. After the Civil War. And what did she give in strengthening the country? Again, the weakening of statehood is even greater. In the period from 17 to 41, the country, thrown back decades in development, only began to come to its senses, and then the Second World War. Losses again. Moreover, this war was mowed down again by the male half of the robust population, as well as the Civil, as well as repression, as well as the Red Terror. The question never came to mind: why in our country is the ratio of men to women quantitative, about one in nine in some regions, and in the country on average one in three in favor of women?
                        And Maidan is the same story, as well as the coup that is related to the revolution.
                      3. 0
                        18 March 2019 18: 04
                        Quote: NEXUS
                        And what are they different from the point of view of statehood of the country?

                        Dramatically different.

                        The state is a machine, a system of suppressing one class by another.
                        With this, I hope you will not argue?

                        If the bourgeois class dominates, then it suppresses the proletarian class.
                        If the proletarian class dominates, then it suppresses the bourgeois class.

                        Which class dominates, that owns the state. This is an axiom. I thought that you understand this, if indignant at SOME actions of our bourgeois state.

                        The bourgeois class is 1%, maxim 5%. And the proletarian is 80%. Consequently, the interests of the majority can be observed only if the state is in the hands of the proletariat. Hence the question: Are you for the interests of the majority, or the minority closer to you?
                      4. +1
                        18 March 2019 18: 30
                        Quote: McAr
                        Hence the question: Are you for the interests of the majority, or the minority closer to you?

                        You have not answered the question- Where is the positive moment for the statehood of the country in the power change of power? I have given you the negative aspects that, at best, discard the country decades ago in development, and at worst, destroy the state itself.
                        After all these revolutions, coups, warrior, our state still struggles with the consequences of the lack of men in the country, which these cataclysms gave rise to.
                        Hence the demography, comparable with the losses in the war, and the lack of specialized male hands, etc.
                        And here the majority or minority?
                      5. +1
                        18 March 2019 18: 40
                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Where is the positive moment for the statehood of the country in the power change of power?

                        The question is not correct.

                        There is no way and example when power from the bourgeois has been replaced by proletarian voluntarily. This has not happened in history yet. So, only through revolution.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        After all these revolutions, coups, warrior, our state still struggles with the consequences of the lack of men in the country, which these cataclysms gave rise to.

                        Do you think that the Second World War would not have taken place if Nikolai the Bloody continued to do his favorite thing - photography?

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        And here the majority or minority?

                        How?

                        Again. Either the interests of the bourgeoisie, or the interests of the proletariat. Both those and other interests are a division of the same pie. This means that either the lion's share belongs to the minority - the bourgeoisie, or the lion's share belongs to the majority - the proletariat.

                        So still, do you enjoy exploiting your own kind or not?
                      6. +1
                        18 March 2019 18: 53
                        Quote: McAr
                        There is no way and example when power from the bourgeois has been replaced by proletarian voluntarily.

                        Show me a country where the population is completely rulers. I am not a supporter of the change of power by force. It is clear that such methods are the most cardinal and capable of quickly, but very bloodyly, conducting surgery in the government. But surgical methods are not always the most correct.
                        Quote: McAr
                        Either the interests of the bourgeoisie, or the interests of the proletariat.

                        Any proletarian dreams of becoming a part of the bourgeoisie.
                        Quote: McAr
                        or the lion's share belongs to the majority - the proletariat.

                        Never and nothing did not belong to the proletariat and cannot belong. If a beggar robbed a rich man, this does not mean that he has become rich. It only means that at some point, he became illusory a little freer. And this epithet is stupid, that a cook can rule the state is fundamentally stupid and wrong. Without education, no proletariat is capable of a priori leading not only the state, but even a small enterprise.
                        I am a furniture maker with my own business. Take you, and let’s say give you a task, strip a couple of cubes of wood on a circular, you cut off your fingers, because you stupidly have neither the skills nor the education to do it. So with what hangover did you decide that the simple proletarian is able to lead the state? I recall the Sword-Combiner. Proletarian, idril him on a swing. And what did he instruct there not to remind?
                        Quote: McAr
                        Do you enjoy exploiting yourself or not?

                        Sorry, but where does the pleasure?
                      7. +5
                        18 March 2019 19: 27
                        I feel it will take a long time to work with you. )))

                        Well, for example, where did you get this: "And this epithet is stupid, that the cook can run the state is fundamentally stupid and incorrect."? I'll tell you where this nonsense comes from. The bourgeoisie inspired this to you. In whose face, I don’t presume to say - maybe a newspaper, maybe TV, maybe a neighbor. But for sure - the bourgeoisie. Because it is not profitable for her to show how the thesis about "the cook governing the state" actually sounded.

                        Original:
                        We are not utopians. We know that any laborer and any cook not capable immediately take control of the state. In this we agree with the Cadets, and with Breshkovskaya, and with Tsereteli. But we differ from these citizens in that we demand an immediate break with the prejudice that it is to run the state, to carry out the everyday, daily work of the administration, only rich or from wealthy families officials can take. We demand that training public administration was carried out by class-conscious workers and soldiers and that it should be started immediately, that is, to training this immediately began to attract all the working people, the whole poor. V.I. Lenin

                        Is it not true, this coincides with yours: "Without education, no proletarian is capable a priori of leading not only the state, but even a small enterprise."

                        We go further.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Show me a country where the population is completely rulers.

                        All socialist countries. There are no crises, no unemployment, no hungry.

                        And vice versa. In all capitalist countries, regular crises, unemployment, hungry. I am primarily talking about the Russian Federation - we have about 20 million starving people.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        I am not a supporter of the change of power by force.

                        And no one is a supporter. But it doesn’t work out otherwise. I would be the first FOR, if the capitalists voluntarily transferred their means of production to the proletariat. Any options to convince them of this voluntarily?

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Any proletarian dreams of becoming a part of the bourgeoisie.

                        This is still being bourgeois.

                        You know that social being determines social consciousness. Therefore, in bourgeois society, almost everyone wants to wear raspberry-colored pants and spit on everyone. It is enough to change social being in order to change social consciousness. First the basis, then the add-in.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Never and nothing did not belong to the proletariat and cannot belong.

                        You are mistaken. It belonged. And it should belong.

                        It was just like that in the USSR. True, from Khrushchev, the recapitalization of the system began. So the period when the state belonged to the proletariat was short-lived. But what prevents us from taking these errors into account and doing everything once and for all?

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        If a beggar robbed a rich man, this does not mean that he has become rich.

                        If someone robbed someone, then he is a criminal.

                        Another question is if by the word "robbed" you mean the expropriation of what was stolen by the bourgeoisie from the working people.

                        Who is worse - a thief / robber or an entrepreneur / businessman?

                        Do not rush to answer. A thief / burglar does his dirty work sometimes, occasionally - well, remember yourself when you were robbed or robbed for the last time. And an entrepreneur / businessman robs / robs the proletariat systematically, regularly, daily - he selects the surplus product created by the proletariat.

                        So who is more dangerous - who occasionally or who systematically rob?
                      8. +2
                        18 March 2019 19: 45
                        Quote: McAr
                        Is it not true, this coincides with yours: "Without education, no proletarian is capable a priori of leading not only the state, but even a small enterprise."

                        Dear, I know the original of this statement. But I told you about this phrase, which was very zealously inserted into the minds of the proletariat.
                        Quote: McAr
                        All socialist countries. There are no crises, no unemployment, no hungry.

                        Seriously? You really amused me. In the socialist countries there is no bourgeoisie or intelligentsia? That is, this layer of society in a socialist format is happy with everything?
                        Quote: McAr
                        It is enough to change social being in order to change social consciousness. First the basis, then the add-in.

                        Behind these very innocent words lie millions of people's lives. And your Marxism-Leninism is a failure, as history has proven.
                        Quote: McAr
                        It was just like that in the USSR.

                        Are you serious? What belonged to the proletariat in the USSR, except for an insignificant salary? Free education, medicine, free apartments are just a handout of the country's governing circles, so that people do not raise them to the forks. In the USSR, the proletariat was as poor as under the tsar. If this is not so, then tell us, what happened to the country's gold reserves during the 1917 -1991 years? Did any of this fall for you, are you wealthier?
                        Quote: McAr
                        Another question is if by the word "robbed" you mean the expropriation of what was stolen by the bourgeoisie from the working people.

                        Who is worse than a thief / robber or businessman / businessman?

                        Worse is the one who puts all this into an absolute, respected. That was Lenin, who, being part of the Russian aristocracy, dared this layer to zero.
                        If a person is not able to decide for himself what is better for him, to work for himself or work for someone, then this is not the problem of the country's leader. And robbery has nothing to do with it. There is freedom of choice by which the proletariat in the USSR was limited.
                        But if the proletarian picks up a pistol and takes away from the bourgeois his accumulated, then this is precisely robbery in its purest form.
                        Quote: McAr
                        regularly, daily - he selects the surplus product created by the proletariat.

                        And in our country is serfdom right now?
                        Quote: McAr
                        So who is more dangerous - who occasionally or who systematically rob?

                        Power structures in all countries without exception rob the population. So it was in the USSR, so it is in the United States and here now. And here the system, politics, does not matter at all. There were clandestine millionaires in the USSR, there are dollar billionaires in China in parliament, absolutely officially.
                      9. 0
                        18 March 2019 20: 02
                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Dear, I know the original of this statement. But I told you about this phrase, which was very zealously inserted into the minds of the proletariat.

                        There is no need to speak for the entire proletariat. Or are you not convinced in my case that "zealous instilling into the minds of the proletariat" was not crowned with success? So why repeat bad rhymes? Read better the good ones.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Seriously? You really amused me. In the socialist countries there is no bourgeoisie or intelligentsia? That is, this layer of society in a socialist format is happy with everything?

                        I did not say anything about the minorities - the barchat and the intellectuals. I said that there are no crises, unemployment and the hungry. What could cheer you up ... But you don’t laugh at the finger? I just know from childhood that you will show a fool a finger - he laughs.

                        Quote: NEXUS
                        Behind these very innocent words lie millions of people's lives. And your Marxism-Leninism is a failure, as history has proven.

                        But the victims of capitalism were not millions, but billions of people. You check the measure, otherwise it smells of cynicism.

                        As for Marxism-Leninism, it is not yet known what will triumph - the prosperity of mankind or armageddon. You like the lunar landscape on Earth - continue to vote further for capitalism. But if you do not care about your descendants, then you should think about it.
                  2. +4
                    18 March 2019 19: 20
                    Quote: NEXUS
                    I’m not looking at anything, as well as with Akhidzhakova ..

                    A good actor does not mean that a good person ... request
                  3. +2
                    19 March 2019 03: 53
                    Quote: NEXUS
                    where is the intelligible education of youth? ... dusting the brain ... easy for the uneducated.

                    I agree with you, but it is very annoying when education is confused with education. After all, if education - this ability to shootthen education determines which way you are shooting.
                  4. 0
                    19 March 2019 22: 19
                    maybe "Storm Gate?" or Bondarchuk also maydanulsya? I somehow "tortured" this dibilny company, that's garbage. ashamed of the real guys. with an Afghan break and this breed did not lie nearby. and how far is this main character from another BONDARCHUK - they fought for the Motherland
                2. 0
                  18 March 2019 17: 24
                  Quote: McAr
                  The dawn of the "Time Machine" group fell on my youth. A student dorm, a portable cassette player and ... almost the Beatles, just ours.

                  Of course, they don't argue about tastes, but I never understood what people find in Makarka and the Time Machine, it was interesting only to watch as a child how Makarka cooks in the kitchen in Smak, and then at some moments I wanted to disperse all this capitalist -bourgeois bacchanalia, especially when there was no food at home, and on the screen Makarka frowned his gulp from delicacies.
                  1. +3
                    18 March 2019 17: 50
                    Quote: tomket
                    Of course, they don't argue about tastes, but I never understood what people find in Makarka and "Time Machine", it was interesting only to watch as a child how Makarka cooks in the kitchen in "Smak"

                    Your childhood, therefore, is not the topic. Or how old were you in 1979?

                    And it's not about tastes. By the way, I could just get enough sleep on modern musical tastes. Reasonably.

                    If there was a topic about Vertinsky, Chaliapin or Sobinov as individuals, I would not open my mouth. Because this is not my era. But this is my upbringing. Not at all modern.
                  2. 0
                    18 March 2019 21: 06
                    We had a different childhood, in completely different years .....
                3. -4
                  18 March 2019 20: 11
                  Quote: McAr
                  Quote: Tatiana
                  I am surprised that there are still people - from Soviet times - who do not understand this.

                  No need for Soviet times. People at all times are different
                  - solid, liquid, gaseous.

                  The dawn of the group "Time Machine" came to my youth. Student hostel, portable cassette and ... almost the Beatles, only ours. This has never happened before. Everyone who could barely have a guitar knew ALL texts by heart. No matter that it was a primitive "square", it is important that the texts were in tune with time for us. Brezhnev's death was not so worried as the release of the new album, then they said - a concert ...

                  So do not be in Soviet times.

                  But with his perennial statements, Makarevich crossed out in me all the rainbow-youthful charm of the songs of the aforementioned group. Very sorry. It was like a betrayal. It's like dad kills mom before your eyes. I don’t want to sing his songs anymore, listen to me too. Sayings overshadow.

                  But he correctly educated many with his then creativity. Of these, in principle, people have turned out. Although this could not be.
                  Only these people did not go in his line, but began to think with their own heads.
                  And then he could not stand it!
                  And managed it ... Moreover - liquid.
                  laughing
                4. 0
                  19 March 2019 15: 44
                  Music is independent of anyone. Hitler Adored Wagner. And what, do not listen to Wagner?
                  1. 0
                    19 March 2019 15: 48
                    Quote: Alex Justice
                    Hitler Adored Wagner

                    Invalid comparison. Hitler did not write Wagner's music.
                5. 0
                  20 March 2019 00: 15
                  Well, I also lived in these times, and was an 30 summer guy, but I did not like Makarevich as much as ABP.
                  1. 0
                    20 March 2019 01: 16
                    Quote: tihonmarine
                    Well, I also lived in these times, and was a 30 year old guy, but I didn’t like Makarevich

                    You must have outgrown ...

                    I, too, have had musical preferences over the years, with age. Agree, different interests in 15-18 years old, in 30-35 years old and 50-55 years old. Now I’m even surprised how I once could not like classical music.
              5. +2
                18 March 2019 17: 40
                Quote: Tatiana
                For me, Makarevich has long existed as a person!

                Makarevich has long been a liberal dump
                and nothing more!
                I am surprised that there are still people - from Soviet times - who do not understand this.

                "Makarevich has long been a liberal dump ..."
                Liberal trash - everyone who traded their homeland for personal success and personal income, and there are a lot of such people, this is not the only nasty type.
            2. 0
              18 March 2019 17: 15
              Quote: Sith Lord
              As my grandmother used to say: "What is male, what is old!

              =====
              Here it is "ne male and ne old" .... Here it is: "debilné"!!! Well, or very much" dravne God's chosen"!
              1. +1
                18 March 2019 19: 02
                Eh, brothers! Anyway, you can't say better than Kozma: “a specialist is like a flux — he is one-sided.” Andrey is a good musician, BUT and nothing more.
          2. +7
            18 March 2019 14: 18
            Quote: Egorovich
            Under old age, Makar is also losing his mind. Regrettably !!!

            it is possible that he was not
          3. +4
            18 March 2019 14: 55
            Quote: Egorovich
            ... Under old age, Makar is also losing his mind. Regrettably !!!

            ... Dimentia + SPICE wassat - A hell of a mixture ........ am
            1. +1
              18 March 2019 14: 59
              diving!!! hi Sanya!
          4. 0
            18 March 2019 16: 44
            He has a mind only for himself beloved, he initially did not root for Russia, the goal was to blacken it. There is a film I do not know what mohay years. There he almost plays himself a similar character, an oppositionist. You can search the network for mine "start over." I never had respect for him.
          5. +1
            18 March 2019 17: 04
            Quote: Egorovich
            Wisdom comes with age

            Insanity too.
          6. +2
            18 March 2019 18: 08
            He lost it much earlier, when he betrayed his group, receiving all the prizes and laureates alone!
          7. 0
            19 March 2019 11: 39
            And those who dragged him to the committee on culture? They have something crazy.
            Judging by myself. He is right, right that this miracle is worth only oblivion. After what he did and said out of sight out of mind. And he still goes to Russia, gives concerts and gives the country poop.
            DO NOT.
          8. 0
            19 March 2019 12: 03
            There is a rephrased dictum on this subject: a punch with age does not become a sage, he becomes an old pit
          9. 0
            20 March 2019 00: 11
            I’m not sure that Makar is devoid of reason; rather, resentment for the ancestors with which the Soviet regime did a little incorrectly. Resentment at all Russian.
        2. +6
          18 March 2019 14: 06
          Quote: Sith Lord
          cultural committee ..

          Comets ... And the order? Ranks?
          By the way, I wanted to ask you, was his boat built in Sevastopol?
          A year ago, stood at the wall in the South. the bay. And in November I was, like I didn’t see ... what
          1. +5
            18 March 2019 14: 19
            I have no idea; I haven’t been in Crimea for a long time.
        3. +11
          18 March 2019 14: 17
          Quote: Sith Lord
          I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...
          what kind of culture and advice
          1. +7
            18 March 2019 14: 26
            Quote: Barmaleyka
            what kind of culture and advice

            the key phrase in the article is At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture it says - what kind of power is this and advice
            1. +12
              18 March 2019 14: 49
              Quote: Tiksi-3
              what kind of power and advice

              culture is not better
              1. 0
                18 March 2019 14: 59
                Quote: Barmaleyka
                culture is not better

                Duc she is Ukrainian ..... and radical ....))))) (I'm talking about the photo)
                1. +2
                  18 March 2019 15: 02
                  so then our citizenship, by the way, they didn’t let her into dill, she sobbed somehow on this subject
                  1. 0
                    18 March 2019 19: 37
                    Say she did not cry, she was offended that her Ukrainian was not allowed to go home, but she didn’t mess with Russia.
                    Quote: Barmaleyka
                    so then our citizenship, by the way, they didn’t let her into dill, she sobbed somehow on this subject
              2. +3
                18 March 2019 15: 35
                Damn, I like these.)
                1. 0
                  18 March 2019 19: 21
                  Without interest laughing good
          2. +3
            18 March 2019 15: 26
            It's a pity, I would put a lot of advantages to you, you need to ask administrators about it.
            1. +1
              18 March 2019 15: 46
              Quote: Ravil_Asnafovich
              It's a pity, I would put a lot of advantages to you, you need to ask administrators about it.

              I have already set. One really is not enough!
              negative
        4. jjj
          +2
          18 March 2019 14: 57
          Quote: Sith Lord
          Hello, Stas. I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...

          He, in his time, with whom he had to drink beer
        5. +1
          18 March 2019 15: 30
          Quote: Lord of the Sith
          Hello Stas hi I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...

          As one wise man said: "Keep your friends close, and your enemies even closer." - Sun Tzu
          1. -3
            18 March 2019 16: 31
            Quote: major147
            Keep your friends close and your enemies even closer

            This is probably why the friends of Russia are outside the Moscow Ring Road, and the enemies are in the Kremlin?
            1. The comment was deleted.
        6. 0
          18 March 2019 18: 31
          Quote: Sith Lord
          I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...

          hi , Sergei.
          Not only that, why write and discuss this creature (and it is not the only one in the vastness of Russia)? Well, they don’t like our system, our laws and orders, so let them pass their passports and bring them to sunset. So no, they spoil the air and crap, crap, crap scoundrels. negative
        7. +1
          18 March 2019 21: 04
          I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...
          They took him there for a simple reason, I remember very well how they showed DAM meeting with rock musicians on a box, which this organism shoved and I remember very well what crazy shine he had in his eyes from the realization of where he had leaked!
        8. -2
          19 March 2019 06: 50
          I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...


          Because it is a committee on culture, and not on frostbitten cheers-patriotism laughing
        9. 0
          19 March 2019 14: 07
          keep your friends close and your enemies even closer ..
        10. 0
          20 March 2019 10: 13
          in my opinion it’s quite understandable why such freaks are taken to all kinds of public organizations. each creature in a pair. so do not worry quite logical move.
        11. 0
          23 March 2019 16: 32
          So maybe they took him there, because only one name remained from the culture. How can they raise what they themselves have lowered below the plinth ?! No way, only the loot is washed there on "culture".
      2. +12
        18 March 2019 14: 53
        Yes, and here his ancestors. He does not remember them. An attempt to hypanut + one wants to remain in power as poor as he is. This old man tired me. Maybe I’m wrong, but I can’t go to concerts and watch movies of creatures that crap in my country. And about their ancestors, how much blood of our ancestors was shed during the defense of Crimea! So they do not consider themselves to be with us, so the road to them is oblivion. And who sincerely rejoices at the accession of Crimea and brings them their money, I want to say: think about how they laugh at you, don’t laugh, but laugh.
        1. +10
          18 March 2019 15: 28
          Maybe I’m wrong, but I can’t go to concerts and watch movies of creatures that crap in my country.


          Support!
          Are you pouring dirt home? If you don’t express your opinion, you don’t justify, but you pour dirt and insult the Motherland and its people - for me such a person does not exist. He is a jerk.

          And I don’t intend to go to his concerts and listen to his songs performed by him. He died for me.
      3. The comment was deleted.
      4. +3
        18 March 2019 15: 26
        Is Makarevich from the "offended" 1917?
        Perhaps I'm wrong, but this is a freak from the breed of money lovers: under the Union he was "fed" and he admired the Soviet power, there is no Union, but the "good uncles" gave money and went. If V.V. had paid more, Makarevich would have forced everyone to recognize the reunification of Crimea, otherwise V.V. did not pay the result.
        PS. I guess it was included there for security reasons, otherwise it will run and bite everyone
        1. +1
          18 March 2019 15: 38
          Quote: vladcub
          Is Makarevich from the "offended" 1917?

          I remembered whether it was either the grandfather or the great-grandfather of the re-priest priest in Zap. Belarus.
          Quote: vladcub
          V. V. did not pay the result either.

          Why does V.V. have to pay him? No, not so ... It is not enough for him that he already has (from power) and that he is allowed to "have" ???
      5. +1
        18 March 2019 15: 38
        I tried to find the word for the letter "h", so as not to "man."
        Only one thing came up - Chmardiai, and even by the number of letters it matched.
        Was that the word? winked smile
        1. 0
          19 March 2019 07: 55
          I tried to find the word for the letter "h", so as not to "man."
          Only one thing came up - Chmardiai, and even by the number of letters it matched.
          Was that the word?
          Is there a more modern and shorter one? H o laughing
      6. +3
        18 March 2019 15: 43
        Under the USSR, Makarevich was against power, under Yeltsin Makarevich was against power, under Putin Makarevich was against power. So maybe something is wrong with Makarevich, and not with the authorities?
        1. 0
          18 March 2019 16: 40
          Quote: Wend
          under Putin, Makarevich was against power

          In 1996, Makarevich and Time Machine took part in the “Vote or lose” propaganda campaign.
          Especially at the beginning of 2000: "Among us there is such a wonderful person as Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin."
          For many of the negative aspects of Russia's life, it’s not the government that is responsible, but society, which has too firmly adopted many stereotypes of the Soviet period
          As part of the “Time Machine”, Makarevich also participated in a concert in honor of the completion of the presidential election of Russia 2008 of the year. And then, and later Makarevich said more than once that he was not ashamed of this speech and he completely consciously supported the coming to power of Dmitry Medvedev.
          1. +1
            18 March 2019 17: 50
            Quote: naidas
            Quote: Wend
            under Putin, Makarevich was against power

            In 1996, Makarevich and Time Machine took part in the “Vote or lose” propaganda campaign.
            Especially at the beginning of 2000: "Among us there is such a wonderful person as Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin."
            For many of the negative aspects of Russia's life, it’s not the government that is responsible, but society, which has too firmly adopted many stereotypes of the Soviet period
            As part of the “Time Machine”, Makarevich also participated in a concert in honor of the completion of the presidential election of Russia 2008 of the year. And then, and later Makarevich said more than once that he was not ashamed of this speech and he completely consciously supported the coming to power of Dmitry Medvedev.

            Making money does not mean maintaining power.
      7. 0
        19 March 2019 11: 40
        I never liked his songs and as a person he is ..
  2. +13
    18 March 2019 13: 38
    Makarevich, judging by the "quirks" just a sick person fool
    1. +13
      18 March 2019 13: 44
      Yes, just getting old, insanity makes its way. Well, always seeing with rottenness was
      1. SOF
        +3
        18 March 2019 13: 58
        Quote: Hagalaz
        Well, always seeing with rottenness was

        .... who knows .... maybe in the next tour of the Western countries some blacksmith "coded" it and filmed this action ...
      2. +3
        18 March 2019 13: 59
        Quote: Hagalaz
        insanity makes its way.

        Stupidity breaks through, old, at the end of his life a person should already think about the eternal, and not make evil statements.
      3. +2
        18 March 2019 14: 57
        Quote: Hagalaz
        Yes, just getting old, insanity makes its way. Well, always seeing with rottenness was

        How correctly noticed
      4. +5
        18 March 2019 15: 35
        Quote: Hagalaz
        Yes, just getting old, insanity makes its way. Well, always seeing with rottenness was

        As far as I remember, he propagandized freedom in his songs, but as soon as the Crimeans decided to use freedom and make a decision, he was immediately against it. There was infa that he was doing business with some kind of authorities in the Crimea, well, as Crimea returned home, the business covered itself accordingly.
        1. +1
          18 March 2019 17: 54
          Quote: major147
          Quote: Hagalaz
          Yes, just getting old, insanity makes its way. Well, always seeing with rottenness was

          As far as I remember, he propagandized freedom in his songs, but as soon as the Crimeans decided to use freedom and make a decision, he was immediately against it. There was infa that he was doing business with some kind of authorities in the Crimea, well, as Crimea returned home, the business covered itself accordingly.

          For me, as long as I remember, his "freedom" always smelled rotten, never respected "Time Machine" and this type - and I'm glad that I was not mistaken.
    2. +18
      18 March 2019 13: 45
      Quote: Qwertyarion
      Makarevich, judging by the "quirks" just a sick person fool

      Nope, he’s healthy. It’s just that when something is good for the Russian people, it’s already upset! angry
      1. +8
        18 March 2019 13: 52
        Not one mankind, there are many of them in this environment, as they call themselves "bohemians".
        1. +13
          18 March 2019 15: 37
          Quote: GKS 2111
          Not one mankind, there are many of them in this environment, as they call themselves "bohemians".

      2. +4
        18 March 2019 13: 57
        Yes, he is healthy! PR is all of them. Everyone has already forgotten for him, but here is such an opportunity to compete with Ginger! He blurted out, and the people dragged to the masses ... We ourselves support this PR by telling what he is ...
      3. +3
        18 March 2019 15: 06
        Does anyone remember one old story associated with Makarevich? Once upon a time, a long time ago ... (back in Soviet times ...) in the Soviet press of that time, criticism of some songs of the Time Machine ... in particular, the Blue Bird! Criticized for some phrases, the meaning of which can be sublimated in the form .... "It's stupidity (or ..." only fools believe .. ") to believe in the Blue Bird! This creature is gone! ... well," like so "! Well, not much time has passed ..." perestroika "burst out ... and Makarevich's" lawyers "poured out on the pages of the media, recalling this story! Well, the" style "was usual ...: "The Soviet press, obeying the dogmatic instructions of the party bosses of the CPSU, did not justly spread rot on Makarevich's sweetheart ...
        PS Just in case, I would like to note that it seems that the Time Machine was correcting the song after criticism ... So a corrected version may come across ... request
        1. -1
          18 March 2019 15: 52
          Quote: Nikolaevich I
          Does anyone remember one old story associated with Makarevich? Once upon a time, a long time ago ... (back in Soviet times ...) in the Soviet press of that time, criticism of some songs of the Time Machine ... in particular, the Blue Bird! Criticized for some phrases, the meaning of which can be sublimated in the form .... "It's stupidity (or ..." only fools believe .. ") to believe in the Blue Bird! This creature is gone! ... well," like so "! Well, not much time has passed ..." perestroika "burst out ... and Makarevich's" lawyers "poured out on the pages of the media, recalling this story! Well, the" style "was usual ...: "The Soviet press, obeying the dogmatic instructions of the party bosses of the CPSU, did not justly spread rot on Makarevich's sweetheart ...
          PS Just in case, I would like to note that it seems that the Time Machine was correcting the song after criticism ... So a corrected version may come across ... request

          Article V. Astafiev "Stew from a blue bird", newspaper "Izvestia" from 11.03.1982.
    3. +6
      18 March 2019 13: 49
      He's not sick at all! With a bad mind, he could not be treated kindly both under the USSR and under the EBN. Especially "touches" his attempts to cling to the fighters against the "system")) And the whining about the Crimea, from the oppressed business interests
      1. +4
        18 March 2019 14: 29
        This action (admission to the council) speaks only of the STRONGEST 5 COLUMN in power, but there is also a "good moment" in this, shouting "Hurray", thinking about defense without putting a halo on your head.
    4. +9
      18 March 2019 13: 51
      Why did you yell “Ukrykrymnash”? Did you listen badly?

      When the country fell apart and shrank, it was good for him, and now he has goose bumps, the whole business of his life is down the drain.
    5. +4
      18 March 2019 13: 59
      He is not sick, he treats the sick, and psychos are forcibly sent to ward number 6, and if he is sane in court.
      1. -8
        18 March 2019 14: 21
        Quote: Ravil_Asnafovich
        and if he is sane in court.

        And what exactly are you accusing him of? What article? Stab Mr. Procurator fellow
        1. +2
          18 March 2019 14: 42
          Well, I’m not a prosecutor, what was he doing when he hung up his neck with enthusiasm? Didn’t he shout about injustice on every corner? nobody will throw a lifebuoy overboard, etc., etc. ..., nothing personal, with respect !!!
          1. -8
            18 March 2019 15: 09
            What are you spinning, as in a frying pan! What article are you going to plant? Or "Guided by revolutionary consciousness"? It was already.
            1. 0
              18 March 2019 15: 49
              [quote = astepanov] Why are you spinning like in a frying pan! What article are you going to plant? Or "Guided by revolutionary consciousness"? It was already. [/ Quote A respected court may be not only criminal, but also administrative exactly a year ago, this type offend all residents of Russia, while being in Moscow, I spoke to you politely, and you are spinning in the pan, in Soviet times he even no one touched a finger, and so from such liberals you can always get a knife in the back, that's all.
        2. +3
          18 March 2019 14: 51
          Quote: astepanov
          What article?

          Article 280.1. Public calls for the implementation of actions aimed at violating the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation
          1. -8
            18 March 2019 15: 03
            Quote: Barmaleyka
            Article 280.1. Public calls for the implementation of actions aimed at violating the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation

            Do not lie. Nowhere and never did Makar call for any action, including the transfer of Russian Crimea to Ukraine. He only talked about what he personally did not like. Does the difference come? Not?
            1. -1
              18 March 2019 15: 08
              there would be a desire and this article could be adapted,
              "Russia could just buy the peninsula, and not take it away illegally" from which it can be concluded that the Makarka considers the Crimea occupied and not Russian
              as they used to say there would be a person - there is an article
              besides
              and certainly it can be fined for a mat
              1. -4
                18 March 2019 18: 22
                Quote: Barmaleyka
                there would be a desire and this article could be adapted,

                Here you are all in the palm of your hand - you propose to act according to the principle "If there were a man, but there is an article. Aren't you afraid that one day you will be rolled around the same way - without an article?
                1. 0
                  18 March 2019 18: 40
                  Quote: astepanov
                  Aren't you afraid that one day they will also roll you up - without an article?

                  On Makarevich, there’s just an article - they have 58th in bold on their forehead
            2. -2
              18 March 2019 15: 09
              Quote: astepanov
              Does the difference come? Not?

              Shoo, are you so excited? !!!!
        3. +4
          18 March 2019 15: 01
          Quote: astepanov
          And what exactly are you accusing him of? What article? Stab Mr. Procurator


          Art. 228 CC RF
          1. -3
            18 March 2019 15: 28
            Are you kidding?
          2. 0
            18 March 2019 19: 23
            In the Union was 229)))
      2. +2
        18 March 2019 14: 26
        Just one more - "citizen of the world" nowhere and no one else, not needed
    6. +4
      18 March 2019 14: 10
      Quote: Qwertyarion
      Makarevich, judging by the "quirks" just a sick person fool

      And who is not sick at all, Svanidze? Obscurantists writhes, they feel something is not coming out of them.
      We live, we solve our everyday problems. And they "remember, we will not forgive!" So God is cleaning up.
    7. +5
      18 March 2019 14: 20
      Quote: Qwertyarion
      Makarevich, judging by the "quirks" just a sick person fool

      Not really. They are called agents of influence. During his career as a musician, how many fans did he get? And now he doesn’t listen to his songs to his fans, but he looks from an alternative reality, that is, Russia is Evil, West is good. And people hawala both here and in Ukraine. Not all of course, but enough.
      1. +1
        18 March 2019 14: 25
        At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.

        Quote: NEXUS
        Russia is Evil, the West is good. And people hawala

        Quote: NEXUS
        These are called agents of influence.

        What then does this person do in the public council of the State Duma, why was he invited there?
        1. +3
          18 March 2019 14: 31
          Quote: Qwertyarion
          What then does this person do in the public council of the State Duma, why was he invited there?

          And our Looking Glass behind, too, with its wild excesses, such as this, or Chubais at RUSNANO's post, or Serdyukov, instead of landing, occupies the second position in Russian helicopters.
          Maybe this question is not for me, but for the FSB?
          1. +2
            18 March 2019 15: 10
            Quote: NEXUS
            And our Through the Looking Glass, too, with its wild excesses

            Yes uzhzhzh, that is, that is!
    8. +2
      18 March 2019 14: 30
      Quote: Qwertyarion

      Makarevich, judging by the "quirks" just a sick person

      no, it’s a common practice when a freebie was taken away, he had vineyards there and plans to produce wine, but after the 14th everything collapsed .....
  3. +20
    18 March 2019 13: 39
    We also remember. And songs and words ... For the first - THANKS, but for the second - negative
    The worst thing is that he still does not understand how much he has become DUPLICATE. He remembers the Holocaust, but what about the fans of those who arranged it for your people? Is there any desire to answer this, but not to me, but to those who died then?
    1. +6
      18 March 2019 13: 56
      Continues to "drown" for freedom of the Crimea? Well, let yourself ... Bortsun, you know ... Will we somehow change our minds from this? No.
    2. +5
      18 March 2019 13: 56
      He probably does not even think of anyone else but himself. Only that which he wants should be. Everything is only for his own benefit.
      Quote: svp67
      We also remember. And songs and words ... For the first - THANKS, but for the second - negative
      The worst thing is that he still does not understand how much he has become DUPLICATE. He remembers the Holocaust, but what about the fans of those who arranged it for your people? Is there any desire to answer this, but not to me, but to those who died then?
    3. +3
      18 March 2019 14: 30
      Two-faced anus. Just wrinkles him, lost a lot in the Crimea.
  4. +11
    18 March 2019 13: 40
    And what the hell, this chaldon goes on tour around the country, the population of which for the most part supported the reunion with the Crimea! Monster loves money.
    1. +6
      18 March 2019 13: 54
      Quote: Hagalaz
      And what the hell, this chaldon goes on tour around the country, the population of which for the most part supported the reunion with. Yakrym! Monster loves money.

      Why are the chaldons (people from the Don) insulting? Who is Makarevich? Why does VO palm off on us this nature error for discussion? With the same success, we could discuss the words of Comrade Moti from the market, no matter which. Do we need it? Poor Russian culture, once in its public council there are such exhibits as Makarevich.
      And, the question is, how did it happen that he is a member of this very council? It is interesting to look at the one who adapted it there. I'm sure this type is also from the "chosen of God"
      1. +2
        18 March 2019 14: 07
        "Poor Russian culture, since its public council contains such exhibits as Makarevich."
        We make the same mistake as with Bandera - we are afraid to seem intolerant of traitors. Or is it not a mistake, but the duplicity of our bohemian "elite"?
      2. +1
        18 March 2019 15: 06
        If so, I'm sorry hi Did not know. In youth, this word was considered dismissive in our country.
  5. +4
    18 March 2019 13: 40
    At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.
    Login ... Invited! Oh, I would call these invitations ... But it's worthless to be like Makarevich.
    1. +5
      18 March 2019 13: 45
      Sometimes things need to be called by their proper names, but moderation will not miss hi
    2. -8
      18 March 2019 13: 51
      on the contrary, everything is correct. let them sit next to them to be under control. Yes, and they need to give places, otherwise you know how with children. if they are not occupied with something, something will necessarily be broken)
    3. +4
      18 March 2019 13: 52
      Quote: BecmepH
      At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.
      Login ... Invited! Oh, I would call these invitations ... But it's worthless to be like Makarevich.

      There is something else incomprehensible --- how was it invited if the Russian authorities and this character had different positions? If he was against the actions of the authorities then and now he continues to speak out.
      1. +1
        18 March 2019 21: 33
        Quote: Reptiloid

        There is something else incomprehensible --- how was it invited if the Russian authorities and this character had different positions? If he was against the actions of the authorities then and now he continues to speak out.

        And who told you that the Ministry of Culture shares our position on the Crimea? This is not even a fact.
      2. 0
        19 March 2019 08: 07
        Quote: Reptiloid
        Quote: BecmepH
        At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.
        Login ... Invited! Oh, I would call these invitations ... But it's worthless to be like Makarevich.

        There is something else incomprehensible --- how was it invited if the Russian authorities and this character had different positions? If he was against the actions of the authorities then and now he continues to speak out.

        In your opinion, is entry to the State Duma free? Makarevich decided and entered the State Duma without invitation))
    4. +4
      18 March 2019 13: 56
      Quote: BecmepH
      At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.
      Login ... Invited! Oh, I would call these invitations ... But it's worthless to be like Makarevich.

      For the people, patriotism, but for them it’s darling.
  6. maw
    +5
    18 March 2019 13: 41
    And when was Andryusha happy? As far as I can remember, he is always buzzing about a new turn and what he brings to him.
    1. +6
      18 March 2019 13: 47
      It just logs in periodically. You need to remind yourself, hype or something
      That pushes
      By and large it’s a weather vane (to put it mildly)
      But who and for what merits it put in the public council on culture at the State Duma, I don’t understand
      Yes, and I do not want to understand
      What culture will he carry? The one that he is voicing now?
      1. -7
        18 March 2019 14: 49
        Quote: kot28.ru
        What culture will he carry?

        And you put sweet Yuri Nikolaev, Boris Moiseyev, Petrosyan - and other entertainers with genital humor in that council. You can also stick the organizers of Dom-2 there, as well as the authors of endless and ridiculous serials, and other equally "successful" ones that define the face of our culture. And people like Gergiev, Piotrovsky, Tsiskaridze, Arkhipovsky have long been a dusty dress coat, and not the face of our culture. Our culture has long ago rotted away: if earlier the artist raised the viewer to himself, now he sinks to the "masses", because the breadth of the audience determines the amount of dough. And, judging by the multitude of comments that I read here every day, people simply do not understand what kind of swamp they fell into long ago. To place commas - and they do not know how.
        And by the way, gentlemen, answer a simple question: do you want mass approval again? To all, as one, in the foot, and the rest - in the camps? Shoot, perhaps, Makarevich and Bykov? If you have no other answer, it is only because you have no arguments either, but there are signs of a rally of hysteria. Ah, are there any arguments? Then why are you rallying and agitating each other? They would have laughed, spat, and parted, than wasting nerves.
        And now, gentlemen, comrades, we line up and minus. You can also blurt out something about "liberast". Forward!
        1. 0
          18 March 2019 14: 55
          What does the Moses and other rabble from home 2?
          Buzov forgot!
          There is no place for a Russophobic type of bull and Makarevich in such posts!
          Shevchuk is much more worthy!
          1. -1
            18 March 2019 15: 26
            Quote: kot28.ru
            Shevchuk is much more worthy!

            That's it, the voting begins. But, I assure you, if the committee on culture will be elected by public vote, then it will become even softer than it is now. Much weaker. Because our culture and education are in the complete corral. The committee selected by voting will instantly prove that of all the arts, advertising and pop are the most important for us. As already proven, the most important and only sport is football.
        2. -2
          18 March 2019 18: 25
          You want to save a dried-up well. In vain, do not pour water there with buckets, you’ll get tired, but your efforts will not save, since the well should initially have water, but it has not been there for a long time .. (
  7. The comment was deleted.
  8. +6
    18 March 2019 13: 42
    Insanity seems to have already knocked ...
    1. +4
      18 March 2019 14: 01
      Quote: Azazelo
      Insanity seems to have already knocked ...

      Along the way, not only insanity was knocking on, there his foulness shabby not childishly, because of which he had a crisis of the genre because lately, he has been singing only about what he is of himself - about Nazmo and worms.
  9. +9
    18 March 2019 13: 47
    Question to Makarevich:
    Which countries voted against the resolution in the Russian edition on the ban on the glorification of Nazism in the UN?
  10. +4
    18 March 2019 13: 50
    Again Makarevich wondered ... it smelled. Why about him here?
  11. +5
    18 March 2019 13: 50
    Quote: Hagalaz
    what the hell, this chaldon goes on tour around the country, whose population for the most part supported the reunion with. Yakrym! Monster loves money.

    He called 80% of the population d ... mi, that’s what he uses to make money. The best response of society for him is a boycott of his concerts, but they go ...
    1. -1
      18 March 2019 18: 19
      A reference, if not difficult. I can’t find such statements anywhere. Everywhere there are only toads, fakes and sayings like yours. And for some reason there is no original ...
    2. 0
      19 March 2019 23: 03
      The best response of society for him is a boycott of his concerts, but they go ...

      Here it is interesting, although it was said a long time ago by the culprit of the article: http://www.rock-book.ru/rus/mv/publication/html/1987-02-1.html

      ".... If I see that everything has already been sung, that they do not go to our concert, that the songs are drowning in the indifference of the audience, then I have enough courage hang your guitar on a nail. "
      - No, Andrey Vadimych, it’s not enough ...... that you definitely don’t have enough ... hi
  12. wow
    +5
    18 March 2019 13: 51
    There are enough such "bohemian" people of age and with quirks - Akhedzhakova, Ada Rogovtseva, Basilashvili, Makarevich and a hedgehog with them .... Old age + not dusty work all life make itself felt.
  13. +4
    18 March 2019 13: 51
    Makarevich became somehow dreadful, like some kind of bogeyman.
    Quote from the famous musician ........ Say, beauty will save the world?
    Dear comrade, read Dostoevsky, novel III diot, this phrase was uttered by one of the malacholny characters of this book. Uneducation! everything strummed on the guitar.
  14. +3
    18 March 2019 13: 51
    Holocaust and 9/11 events in the United States made one piece. For yourself, for your own sake.
    In both cases there is a gesheft of organizers.
  15. -4
    18 March 2019 13: 52
    I don’t agree with his position, I condemn him for many words, but at least it’s hard to call him political political ... God, the girl. Consistency in views is a worthy thing. And his songs are good.
  16. +1
    18 March 2019 13: 53
    word in letter "H"
    "claims to their literary nature"
    admins that you are shy as girls, here is a male adult audience.
  17. +5
    18 March 2019 13: 57
    Wisdom comes to some with old age, insanity comes to macarque.
  18. +5
    18 March 2019 13: 57
    Do not be surprised at the inspiration. when writing new songs, he went to the us embassy. And on account of the Crimeans, adequate people live there, and in the choice: - there was no doubt about the war as a part of Ukraine, or the world, as part of Russia!
  19. -6
    18 March 2019 13: 58
    Leo Tolstoy was further defamed in the press and in society at the time.
    He also castigated the authorities "neodestski". Even excommunicated from the church, which was then a terrible punishment.
    Nothing ... And Leo Tolstoy today is the world symbol of Russia. And Emperor Alexander the Third, whom Leo Tolstoy poured mud, is also respected. History - after 200 years - puts everything in its place.
    1. +6
      18 March 2019 14: 40
      hi You, Voyaka uh, so, megacomplementary "conjured by 200-year history", compare the empty hypocrite-opportunist as much as Leo Tolstoy and Alexander III, is this petty equal to them ??! smile
      Is it you who joked about Andrushka's exorbitant ambitions for "classicism" ?! smile
      Yes, if not for his scandalous "howl and groaning" - this "released in circulation", "pop.artist" would have already been forgotten, as well as other similar "stage horses" that were once heard too! smile
      1. +1
        18 March 2019 20: 58
        Yes Voyaka, (someone's) brother, probably didn’t read Leo Tolstoy in Russian. And about Alexanderlll. So, he’s clumsy about the training manual, Russian is not his language, everything doesn’t matter ---- Shaw Makar, Shaw Tolstoy. ..... everything is one.
        Quote: pishchak
        hi You, Voyaka uh, so, megacomplementary "conjured by 200-year history", compare the empty hypocrite-opportunist as much as Leo Tolstoy and Alexander III, is this petty equal to them ??! smile
        Is it you who joked about Andrushka's exorbitant ambitions for "classicism" ?! smile
        Yes, if not for his scandalous "howl and groaning" - this "released in circulation", "pop.artist" would have already been forgotten, as well as other similar "stage horses" that were once heard too! smile
  20. +2
    18 March 2019 13: 59
    I used to love the songs of "cars", but now I don't want to listen to them, although I grew up on them.
  21. +6
    18 March 2019 14: 02
    Makarevich himself once sang `` You shouldn't bend under a changeable world, '' and eventually he caved in.
  22. +2
    18 March 2019 14: 02
    Good technology to reduce the number of fans. So bright to live, and so sour to finish ...
  23. +5
    18 March 2019 14: 03
    he is ordinary, like everyone else in this liberal get-together, it’s enough to talk to them: they don’t know history, they don’t understand realities, as if they live in the world of elves, with an infantile worldview that violates the law at any opportunity
  24. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 04
    It is impossible to convince a person, so do not waste your nerves on this, but simply educate your children properly.
  25. +2
    18 March 2019 14: 06
    Andryukha somehow imperceptibly faltered ... and after all, a matey friend ... everything that he could listen to was written before 1975 ... but the people still remember, and he spits this people ... right, with pleasure, in the face ... but for what? for the fact that someone with him with the "prophet" does not agree? voluntarist is shorter)
    1. +1
      18 March 2019 14: 51
      Quote: KilleMall
      somehow imperceptibly curled Andryukha ...

      _________________________
      People do not hover, the cache is not rushing ... It is necessary to attract attention with something. And here is such a moment to declare itself. fellow laughing laughing
  26. +11
    18 March 2019 14: 06



    briefly ...
    1. +8
      18 March 2019 14: 44

      The essence ...
      1. 0
        18 March 2019 16: 30
        Quote: MoJloT

        The essence ...

        So now there are hundreds of thousands who are not satisfied with the Soviet regime and today.
        1. 0
          18 March 2019 19: 44
          You are minus ....
  27. +4
    18 March 2019 14: 09
    In the photo he looks like a cruel hangover. And judging by the statements, Makarevich does not come out of hard drinking.
  28. +5
    18 March 2019 14: 12
    He remembers the Holocaust, but not the millions of victims of Nazi aggression?
    1. 0
      18 March 2019 20: 07
      Quote: DeusExMachina
      He remembers the Holocaust

      Yeah, I grew up in a concentration camp. Everything is simpler than a steamed turnip, under the USSR, something did not remember that he was a Jew, but how they began to pay for Jewishness, so he learned the word "Holocaust". Creativity is not compatible with politics, although its salivation
      has nothing to do with politics.
  29. +5
    18 March 2019 14: 12
    The eternally dissatisfied Zionist creature. Now, if the former USSR would become additional states in the United States, according to the number of republics, I hope I would be pleased. Although who will understand this two-faced "creative personality". He sang the correct songs, and also tapped where necessary, so that the proven correct songs would multiply, sell and the money would drip ...
  30. +2
    18 March 2019 14: 15
    Yes, it is no longer necessary to mention him. Like him, any mention is to the vein. And since he’s not capable of more, it’s at least that way, even in shit, but on the lips of everyone.
    Grind and forget. Also pour "Whiteness" on top.
  31. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 24
    Andrushka Bleevich (he never liked the "songs" - the bleating of this "cloven-hoofed"), probably, he got so angry because of the loss, as they say, of his Balaklava "investments", what is "cunning tax evasion" after "Crimea is our" came out sideways ??! winked
    How does he "remember the Holocaust" ????! Why did he hang around so closely and support Bandera's descendants and ideological followers of the murderers of the Jewish people ?! request
  32. +3
    18 March 2019 14: 25
    Ah Andryusha, now just as your creativity sounds on the radio, you will automatically have to switch the radio.
  33. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 28
    Here, like Kasparov, I respect the world chess champion, and as a person and, especially a politician, I think m. The songs were good.
  34. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 29
    Geek! Send him to Israel, there is his homeland!
  35. +2
    18 March 2019 14: 32
    The authorities love Makarevich; they introduced him to the public council under the State Duma Committee on Culture
    1. +1
      18 March 2019 20: 09
      Quote: Million
      They introduced him to the public council under the State Duma Committee on Culture

      It would be interesting to look at the fruits of his labor.
  36. +4
    18 March 2019 14: 40
    Fifth column
  37. +2
    18 March 2019 14: 43
    Makarevich is against the reunification of the Russian people, that is, the unification of the Crimea with Russia, so he is against Russia, so if he lived in the states, he would already be back and forth from something, apparently they didn’t understand him there either. And in general, who helped him enter the State Duma’s public council on culture. What can he give cultural for our people in Russia ?! request
  38. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 49
    Hmm, here's the news so news. More hype, more. Advertising advisor ... sorry, culture. How well he picked up the time for the remark, immediately attracted so much attention. I even remembered his song for this occasion about a starling, who did not know where and why to fly away, why he was called somewhere. So, you, Andrey Vadimovich, somehow steer in the wrong direction with your "turns". We sang about one thing, but do it differently. That "it is not necessary to cave in under the changing world", but themselves as "a wolf and a hare, tigers in a cage, they are all puppets."
  39. -2
    18 March 2019 14: 50
    I understand and share the indignation of many about the position of Makarevich, but let's not judge him strictly by rumors he has a serious illness and needs money for treatment so he earns on his authority. Do not judge, do not be judged.
    1. +1
      18 March 2019 20: 15
      Quote: MONTEVIDEO01
      strictly rumored that he has a serious illness and needs money for treatment

      Nehai will send a letter to the TV channel, will cry, will show his sore, maybe someone will be dumped that way for the merciful.
  40. +1
    18 March 2019 14: 51
    Moderators, and what does this rotten creature have to do with the "Military Review" ???
  41. +2
    18 March 2019 15: 00
    Eh, Makarevich ... Is it all because of your vineyards in the Crimea? Well, alas, now you have to pay taxes ...
  42. -5
    18 March 2019 15: 00
    Not a single sensible comment, everything is the same, one water ....
  43. +2
    18 March 2019 15: 02
    Quote: astepanov
    Quote: Ravil_Asnafovich
    and if he is sane in court.

    And what exactly are you accusing him of? What article? Stab Mr. Procurator fellow


    Art. 228 CC RF
  44. +4
    18 March 2019 15: 03
    Damn ... just like alive!
  45. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 05
    I also grew up on these songs. But then Crimea was ours. Khokhlyatina with her show off, appeared in the 90s.
  46. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 11
    Surely many remember how he led the meeting of rock musicians with the Great and the Terrible. Yes, the very one on which some bad person turned out to be unfamiliar with Yuri Shevchuk !!! Interesting ...
  47. +2
    18 March 2019 15: 12
    Makarevich had vineyards and stuff there. and now oops.
    and I don’t understand something. Does he have any fans? If there are any popular songs, he did not write them.
    And what kind of Holocaust does he remember? where does Russia come from?
  48. -1
    18 March 2019 15: 19
    Let the balabolit what he wants. Freedom of speech. You shouldn't take someone else's opinion so aggressively, just everyone has his own opinion. Even if his position is that of a minority. Dobitok or not dobitok .... what difference does it make to you. Do not go to his concerts, do not listen to his songs, do not visit his facebook. I will refrain from evaluations, but most of the commentators have forgotten or perhaps do not know at all that wisdom lies in the fact that to respect not only your position but also the opinion of others. And this way you are no better than Makarevich. Of course, he is still a type, he is promoting himself on this topic, and you are behaving like children. They also carried it in the comments about Jews, worldwide conspiracies, and so on ... but do not envy anyone, live your life. Everyone is spinning as they can. Himself the blacksmith of his own happiness. This "our" aggressive manner "who is not with us is against us" is really annoying, just read the comments. Patriotism should not dazzle. My acquaintance in UFOs believes at work. Why kill him for that? but the fact that he joined the council ... so he does not decide anything there, so he will not be able to harm. After all, even the presidents who won the race often take the leaders of the opposition blocs as their comrades-in-arms. I wonder if you react to him that way. not to break this law:
    Article 280.1 of the Criminal Code: “Public calls for the implementation of actions aimed at violating the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation”. The article is divided into two parts: in fact, “public appeals”, and the same actions, but committed on the Internet or in the media.

    everything else, please, how much will fit.
    1. +3
      18 March 2019 16: 13
      It's not that he has his own opinion, but the way he expresses it.
      Insulting the WHOLE people, insulting the country, expressing itself not in the literary language, but in boorish dialect
      Do you agree that he calls all Russians cattle and slaves?
      Me not.
      You agree with his right to express his opinion on behalf of all Russians when he declares that:
      “I am ashamed to be called Russian, we are a nation of mediocre drunks”?
      Me not.

      He can speak about its mediocrity, about youralcoholism, and the right to judge whole nation no one gave him.
      Do not judge and you will not be judged. He is trying to judge, so here is his retaliatory condemnation on behalf of the Russian people.

      Personally, I love his old songs, but I will not go to his concert out of principle. Let those who are ready to be considered cattle and his slaves go ...
    2. +2
      18 March 2019 17: 22
      Quote: Examenatornick
      Do not be so aggressive in taking someone else's opinion.
      ?????
      what about this ?!

      because the same other people's opinion
      1. 0
        19 March 2019 11: 09
        because the same other people's opinion
        In general, this is a crime.
        1. -1
          19 March 2019 11: 24
          but this is their inertia
          1. -1
            20 March 2019 20: 13
            But Chikatila also had an opinion, but essentially the same crime.
            1. 0
              20 March 2019 20: 34
              I have a request to you, before answering, read what the dispute is about
  49. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 21
    [quote = Sith Lord] why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ... [
    What advice is such a culture
  50. +4
    18 March 2019 15: 31
    Quote: GKS 2111
    Not one mankind, there are many of them in this environment, as they call themselves "bohemians".

    Unfortunately, this "bohemia" had been "fed" with rottenness for a long time before 1917
  51. +3
    18 March 2019 15: 35
    Makar, if you are so disgusted by all this living in Russia, no one is forcing you! Go where you feel most comfortable! But why do you continue to do chess in Russia? Didn't like 404 in the country? Just think, your wallet was stolen on the train! So this is from freedom! You see, democracy! Or don’t you like it when democracy punches you in the face?
  52. 0
    18 March 2019 15: 35
    Makar has brain liquefaction due to old age/stupidity. And don’t confuse the songs, which are really good, with the person singing them. I like the songs, but I won’t sit in the same field with him, I’ll disdain him.
  53. The comment was deleted.
  54. +2
    18 March 2019 15: 42
    Has always been a two-faced abomination to me. And what always amazed me was how he criticized the Soviet regime, and he himself was released on tunes, acted in films, and even traveled around the country with concerts and in the countries of the social bloc too. A typical two-faced rogue and opportunist. hi
  55. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 43
    In any normal country that respects itself and its dignity, such individuals would simply “disappear” from all the media, price lists and any mention anywhere and ever, but in our country, it seems, starting from our corrupt tops, they are accustomed to wiping away the grub from the cheeks and then smile obsequiously. And, in general, it is not clear why suddenly representatives from the trash heap of the elite decided that they could open their mouths without any consequences, humiliating and insulting a people with a millennia-old culture and age-old values ​​of which they are part and which are so they despise him, without knowing anything about him and his history. And yet, what kind of world-class masterpieces did they all create in order to rake in millions, build castles for themselves and buy villas in Miami and California, etc., how and how do they acquire such opportunities, if the overwhelming majority of these creatures do not have any talents, although some significant intelligence at least larger than a cat, which would allow them to at least coherently express their thoughts or communicate in their native language, and even more so, without possessing at least some rudiments of morality and principles. And this is all with the complete indifference of the authorities and the public, so why do we need them, what is their use, other than a parasitic existence at the expense of the people they hate and despise so much.
  56. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 45
    He just has a business there. I think it's related to the restaurant business.
  57. +1
    18 March 2019 15: 45
    Utyrok...They should all call their people cattle and harness them to someone else's yoke. I can’t call them either an elite or an intelligentsia. I don't know who he is. The songs are sound... But what I meant meant something else and I didn’t understand. Or he was just lying to me...
  58. +3
    18 March 2019 15: 46
    I remember an old interview with Pyotr Podgorodetsky, in which he said that Makar does not love or respect anyone except himself and money. So, what kind of homeland? He doesn't even know the word.
  59. 0
    18 March 2019 15: 52
    The talent has passed, the ambition remains... He bet on the wrong “horse” to promote himself... For me, he has long since died as an artist and a person.... Here he is, a representative of the fifth column...
  60. -2
    18 March 2019 15: 53
    I don’t understand why this site (supposedly patriotic) is promoting Makarevich? “Wonderful are your works, O Lord!”
    1. +2
      18 March 2019 16: 17
      Quote: Vladimir Postnikov
      I don’t understand why this site (supposedly patriotic) is promoting Makarevich? “Wonderful are your works, O Lord!”


      the site enlightens how rotten a person can become.
      shame on him on behalf of those whom he called cattle and other words
      1. -2
        18 March 2019 16: 27
        Quote: Old bulka
        the site enlightens how rotten a person can become.
        shame on him on behalf of those whom he called cattle and other words

        Then you don’t know much about what PR is and what PR people do. The editors of this resource make “candy” out of “rottenness” without meaning to. And you, by disgracing this “rottenness,” personally participate in this too. Competent propaganda work requires intelligence, not the amount of slop poured out.
    2. -1
      18 March 2019 17: 19
      well only if it's black
      1. -1
        18 March 2019 19: 17
        Quote: Barmaleyka
        well only if it's black

        PR people don’t care what kind of PR they use.
        To understand this, try to understand the following information: “In Russian-language YouTube, on average, they pay 1000 dollar for 1 views.” They pay for views, not for the content of the material posted.
        I am an engineer, and I realize that man is the most complex “mechanism” on the planet. Knowing psychology well means knowing the program of this “mechanism” well. So respect good psychologists.
  61. Cry
    +1
    18 March 2019 15: 56
    The mere fact that under the communists his “Time Machine” flourished, and this is possible in the USSR if you are a very good son of the CPSU, already says that he will sell his homeland for a buck.
    1. +1
      18 March 2019 16: 54
      No, it wasn't like that there. In 1949, the Soviet cartoon “Alien Voice” was filmed by director I. Ivanov-Vano based on the poems of S. Mikhalkov. And these words sounded in it: "Today he plays jazz, and tomorrow he will sell his homeland!"
      1. Cry
        +1
        18 March 2019 17: 12
        I mean that he faithfully served the CPSU, and now for bucks - dollars.
  62. +2
    18 March 2019 16: 49
    A quote from Jules Verne's novel suggests itself:
    “The sea is not subject to despots. On its surface they can still fight and kill each other, but at a depth of ten feet their power ends... Ah, professor, live in the depths of the seas! Only here is a person truly free! Only here no one can oppress him! "
    Jules Verne. Twenty thousand leagues under the sea
    (I remember I read this novel when I was 12 or 13, I don’t remember more precisely. It’s a classic, of course. One gets the impression that some people got into the image of Captain Nemo so much that they don’t leave it even in old age.)
    1. 0
      19 March 2019 00: 54
      “It seems that some people have become so ingrained in the image of Captain Nemo that they never leave it even in old age.” ////
      ------
      There is such a thing ...
  63. 0
    18 March 2019 16: 50
    The most interesting thing now will be the position of the State Duma, which in advance co-opted him as a “mirror” of morality.
  64. +1
    18 March 2019 16: 53
    Yes, public figures, sometimes the cover is beautiful, but inside is rotten.
    How many of these!
    Makarevich, Akhidzhakova, Panin, Serebryakov, Efremov....
    They presented them to us from the screen in movies or at concerts, they were good....
    And as soon as they opened their mouths, they smelled rotten meat!
    1. 0
      19 March 2019 10: 50
      I wonder whether we should rejoice or cry that the centuries-old Russian tradition of denouncing the existing “regime” by cultural figures is supported and alive (the terminology is taken from numerous publications in the media)? After all, A.S. Pushkin, and V.S. Belinsky, F.I. Shalyapin, A.D. Sakharov and Solzhenitsyn (In the XNUMXth century), not to mention F.M. Dostoevsky, and L.N. Tolstoy, who was even excommunicated from the Orthodox Church in his time, in different ways, but in general, everyone said something similar about the government existing in their times, and about their own people. It is known that poets, writers, musicians see more sharply and think differently. And there is nothing like that.
      It is no coincidence, therefore, that V.I. Ulyanov (Lenin), the founder of the USSR, wrote the article “Leo Tolstoy as a Mirror of the Russian Revolution” in 1908. An interesting article that is still relevant today. And some of its provisions seem to have been taken from some modern blog or political science site.
      1. 0
        19 March 2019 11: 05
        Alexander Sergeevich, of course, criticized the government and the country. But somehow I didn’t descend into criticism. And he certainly didn’t sing along with outspoken enemies. And yes, he once said, in his heart, that he despises his fatherland from head to toe, but he immediately added: - but it annoys me when my opinion is shared by foreigners!
        And Pushkin also wrote “To the Slanderers of Russia”!
        1. 0
          19 March 2019 11: 46
          I agree with you! But one thing needs to be taken into account. In the XNUMXth and most of the XNUMXth centuries there was no Internet. People treated the written or printed word differently than today, more seriously, perhaps, remembering the Russian proverb: “the word is not a sparrow; if it flies out, you won’t catch it.” In addition, only a few relative to the bulk of the population could speak, engage in elegant verbiage, and publish. And today, with the general decline in the level of people’s culture, everyone can afford boorish expressions. We must fight this and boycott the boor! But, in my opinion, no one is going to erect monuments to these comrades. Although, who knows, history sometimes plays cruel jokes on those who strive to enter it by hook or by crook and respect those who simply do it.
  65. -1
    18 March 2019 16: 57
    Will the "Fog" mod ban Makarevich?
  66. 0
    18 March 2019 17: 04
    At the same time, the position of the Russian authorities in the same Crimea did not prevent Makarevich from joining the public council of the State Duma on culture.

    Unclear who and for what services included him in this council and isn't it too much honor this undistinguished figure in every sense, but with high self-esteem and political ambitions! And why is he at VO again - who, in general, is interested in his opinion?
  67. +1
    18 March 2019 17: 15
    Something in Makaronych’s head went completely off the rails. Brings a blizzard.

    How did he sing? Not to bend to a changing world? So why is this gray-haired Cheburashka sagging?
  68. +1
    18 March 2019 18: 07
    If, suddenly, I meet this freak on the street, I will go to the opposite side.
  69. 0
    18 March 2019 18: 46
    An aspen stake in his transom
  70. 0
    18 March 2019 19: 04
    Who is Makarevich?
  71. +3
    18 March 2019 19: 05
    Makakarevich has long become a brainless monkey. Now going to his concerts means admitting your stupidity and hatred of Russia. Although this clown was always “kind of against it,” he was never banned or limited. The Cossack was sent)))
  72. 0
    18 March 2019 19: 09
    Quote: den3080
    I tried to find the word for the letter "h", so as not to "man."
    Only one thing came up - Chmardiai, and even by the number of letters it matched.
    Was that the word? winked smile
    1. 0
      18 March 2019 19: 10
      It wasn’t, so it will be
  73. +2
    18 March 2019 19: 10
    Well, it’s clear that he’s earning money, who will support him? - it’s clear who also surrendered their homeland. Don’t pay attention or attract attention with articles at all.
  74. +2
    18 March 2019 19: 38
    What, only Makarevich? Here is a link to a “resource” that shows some famous personalities who either supported the annexation of Crimea to Russia or did not support it, all with interesting comments. By the way, Basilashvili and Yursky are on the technical list. who did not support the annexation of Crimea to Russia. request
    [media =http://2queens.ru/Articles/Teatr-Artisty/Artisty-i-drugie-deyateli-kultury-kto-podderzhal-politiku-Putina-v-Ukraine-i-Krymu-i-kto-ne-podderzhal-spisok.aspx?ID=1977]
  75. +1
    18 March 2019 19: 42
    Consign it to the dust of oblivion. This is not worthy of mention. It’s a pity that he’s going to Belarus again to sing with his mouth...
  76. Jan
    +1
    18 March 2019 19: 52
    I don’t understand what the “bazaar” is about, sorry for the vulgarism, but it’s true! Who is this man? Singer!=buffoon! and so what if he once sang songs that we liked? Who is he for us to bother with his opinion? I really don't care what this musician thinks about the annexation of Crimea! He was never ours - not a worker/peasant, not an intelligentsia! So a stratum! That sometimes with his songs he fell in time with our thoughts!
  77. 0
    18 March 2019 20: 00
    It was easy and pleasant to powder the brains of teenagers in the 70s, but as time goes on, the powder blew away for some, but for others it was blown away, it was necessary to protect themselves...., you still rush like a bull to the color red...
  78. +1
    18 March 2019 20: 04
    The murky story with wines and shops in Crimea knocked Makarka out of the saddle...............
    1. 0
      18 March 2019 20: 41
      Yes, there also seem to be some vineyards.....
  79. 0
    18 March 2019 20: 24
    Why be surprised, Makarevich is the power in Russia, what he openly talks about Crimea, the power silently does in Donbass...
  80. 0
    18 March 2019 20: 30
    Should I throw it in the trash? What do you think? Maybe then it will dawn on people that they shouldn’t raise their voices against breadwinners. After all, they will forget, and in Ukraine they don’t particularly expect him.
  81. 0
    18 March 2019 20: 46
    He said correctly - who will respect such “fans”? - I thought he had been singing in the trash for a long time - but here he still gives concerts - and someone comes?
  82. 0
    18 March 2019 20: 53
    In the 70s we sang "Shizgares" at school dances. The guitars were crazy, I didn’t know the lyrics, I was screaming like a beast, but our girls were screaming and it was fun, believe me. Makarevich was nowhere near the Beatles, Queen or Slades. I was at the Time Machine concert in 80 in Novosibirsk. The audience greeted them rather coldly and accompanied the “New Turn” with rather thin applause. Now Makar is completely “driven”. I don't understand this insanity. Perhaps there is some kind of mercantile interest here.
  83. 0
    18 March 2019 21: 39
    Such people should be deprived of citizenship and expelled from the country, let them hang out in Ukraine
  84. Quote: Vladimir 5
    Tatyana .. Makarevich, like the other Akhidzhakovs, Pugachevs with Galkins ... are associated with the Jewish diasporas and live their own separate lives, including political ones, for these diasporas .... Makarevich does not represent Russian self-consciousness, and therefore it relates as marginalized and what they do is their true face ...

    You also do not represent Russian self-awareness, because you are short-sighted and repeat nonsense. Do you think everyone should be the same and scream OKAY?
    I don’t share Makarevich’s point of view on Crimea, but I also don’t agree with the idea that everyone should think the same.
    Well, share your deep knowledge and its sources about diasporas and their isolated life, I’m interested to know...
  85. +1
    18 March 2019 23: 19
    Lord, here is also a figure - Makarevich. "Homer, Milton and Panikovsky..." (C). In Soviet times, she was a court-bred chansonette, but now there is simply no one to call. There would be someone to discuss.
  86. 0
    19 March 2019 05: 18
    I wonder how much Makar pays for such advertising. Well, who is it that regularly sparks a wave of interest in this type?
  87. 0
    19 March 2019 06: 01
    Evict him to Ukraine and let him sing his songs there.
  88. The comment was deleted.
  89. 0
    19 March 2019 08: 58
    Makarevich was a pop kitchen KSPshnik (amateur song club - author), and remains so.
    Makarevich would spend his entire life as a sort of 1960s-style dissident. Despite the fact that his group was called “Time Machine,” this machine has long been broken. He remained in the past, thinking that the CPSU still reigns in the country, against which any creative person should protest.

    He did not notice that the 21st century had arrived, the situation had changed long ago, and now being a kitchen grouch, covered in cigarette ash and dandruff, a dissident, is not only pointless, but also not even fashionable. And he still thinks that he is some kind of guru of the generation, a teacher, but he himself looks, rather, like a teacher who responds to every living action of the children in the class with need.
  90. -2
    19 March 2019 10: 13
    I’m not particularly a fan of Makarevich... he personally supported Crimea more often than not...
    But.. a person’s opinion is worthy of respect..
    The fact that he is “alone” against the crowd.. makes one wonder whether we are sheep..
    It’s clear that a person doesn’t defend his position for money.. it’s just that maybe he really doesn’t need either Crimea or half of the world.. After all, that’s not the main thing in life.. You can live simply!!
    1. 0
      19 March 2019 11: 47
      It is clear that a person does not defend his position for money..


      Makarevich uses this moment for self-PR, so that people remember him, go to a concert, buy a record. Purely for the money. Otherwise, what would he live on? Plus, there is such liberal masochism, since Makarevich belongs to the type of relict liberals, and for them any word or action against Russia is sacred.
      1. 0
        19 March 2019 12: 05
        “so that they remember him, go to a concert, buy a record” If you, for example, spit at him for his position.. like the majority.. Then damn you will remember him with a good word.. and you’ll rather refuse the concert, even if I was going to go.. Why would anyone give in to such PR?

        “Otherwise, how would he live?” I think he somehow lived before Crimea... coped...

        I don’t know anything about liberals.. I can rather say the opposite.. it’s strange that as soon as someone starts speaking against the herd.. they immediately write him down somewhere.. You’d think that all of them must be relic Putinoids.. And what’s more? here it’s generally “against Russia”.. Even a normal, adequate husband sometimes scolds his beloved wife.. when it’s on business.. But Russia, if you listen to it, is completely devoid of shortcomings..
        Like, patriotism means frantically shouting and shouting or something...
  91. -2
    19 March 2019 10: 25
    Makarevich had enough integrity to remain committed to his opinion and not change his views; he would have a stronger character than others
    1. +1
      19 March 2019 16: 52
      You are right, a worthy opponent does not cheat, he says what he thinks without hiding a stone in his bosom.
  92. 0
    19 March 2019 11: 08
    I don’t know who the author of these poems is, but

    One weirdo with a fake-sad face
    “Huddling” in the cabin of his “Porsche”,
    Said, "I am ashamed to be called Russian.
    We are a nation of mediocre drunks. "
    A solid look, behavior -
    All devil thought out cunningly.
    But the merciless degeneration virus
    Dismissed ingloriously all his gut.
    His soul is not worth a half
    Like a yellow leaf from broken branches.
    But the descendant of the Ethiopians Pushkin
    He was not burdened by his Russianness.
    They considered themselves Russian rightfully
    And they lifted the Motherland from their knees
    The creators of Russian seafaring glory
    Both Bellingshausen and Kruzenshtern.
    And not reconciling with a narrow worldview,
    Trying to look beyond the horizon
    It was considered an honor to be called Russian
    Scots - Greig, de Tolly and Lermont.
    Any of them are admirable,
    After all, to sing homeland is the law for them!
    So he gave his life without regret
    For Russia, Georgian Prince Bagration.
    Our language is multifaceted, accurate, faithful -
    He heals the soul, then smothers like steel.
    Are we able to value him immensely
    And to know him, as the Dane Dahl knew?
    What the hell is it! And in our time a lot of
    Speaking Great Language
    No worse than crest Mykola Gogol,
    What was once familiar with Pushkin?
    Do not bang your head on the wall
    And in a rage saliva sprinkle in vain!
    "We are Russians!" - so said Shevchenko.
    Read the kobzar carefully.
    In the soul love is filial cherished,
    All my life I worked up to seven sweats
    Suvorov, Ushakov and Mendeleev,
    Kulibin, Lomonosov and Popov.
    Their names remained on the tablets
    Like a true story of the basics.
    And among them, like a pillar, an old Derzhavin,
    In whose veins the blood of the Tatar Murza.
    They go — servants or messiahs —
    Carrying your cross on bent shoulders
    How he carried it in the name of all of Russia
    Descendant of the Turk Admiral Kolchak.
    They instilled and nurtured love
    From centuries-old origins and roots.
    He is a Russian whose soul lives in Russia,
    Whose thoughts are about mother, about her.
    Patriotism does not sell to the load
    To berets, boots or coats.
    And since you are ashamed to be called Russian,
    You, my friend, are not Russian. You are nobody.
  93. 0
    19 March 2019 12: 41
    I grew up listening to the songs of Vladimir Semenovich, but what Makarevich thinks is his personal opinion.
    Crimea was, is, and will be Russian. Whether someone likes it or not. hi
  94. ZVS
    0
    19 March 2019 12: 45
    Makarevich doesn’t remember anything. He does not remember that Russia fed him; doesn’t remember that he earned his millions in Russia. This is a representative of a nation with genetic unconsciousness. They don’t remember that 30 million Soviet people died in that war. And as many Belarusians died as Jews, not to mention Russians and Ukrainians. The Makarevichs don’t remember this, so the Holocaust is nothing more than an attempt by the Jews to elevate themselves to other nations.
  95. 0
    19 March 2019 13: 55
    Quote: Lord of the Sith
    Hello Stas hi I also did not understand why he was taken to the council by the committee on culture ...

    Because the management company of the Russian Federation is against the Russians and Makarevich too
  96. 0
    19 March 2019 19: 00
    Well, what advisors are like, so is the culture of their work.
  97. 0
    19 March 2019 23: 54
    In the 70s, I enjoyed listening to “Machina” and was able to see the concert on tape recorders and even “live” in the St. Petersburg Korabelka. But in his declining years, somehow his position became completely opposite to mine. winked
    Maybe he wants to shock people, because with new songs he can’t wassat
  98. 0
    20 March 2019 01: 29
    Quote: Barmaleyka
    Quote: astepanov
    What article?

    Article 280.1. Public calls for the implementation of actions aimed at violating the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation

    In the West, and even in the East, he would actually receive a real sentence for such statements. But Russians are too kind. In the rest of the world, such kindness is perceived as weakness!
  99. 0
    20 March 2019 01: 39
    If the majority is in favor, then one musician does not count.
  100. The comment was deleted.