For the first time in 20 years, the Federal Minister was not allowed to finish the report in the State Duma

For the first time in all recent years in the lower house of parliament, the minister of the federal government could not keep up the time limit on making a report. The speech of the head of the Ministry of Economic Development, Maxim Oreshkin, was interrupted while he read out a report on the issues of socio-economic priorities in the development of the country and the implementation of the national project of the Russian Federation on support for individual entrepreneurship.

Chairman of the State Duma Vyacheslav Volodin interrupted the speech of Minister Oreshkin, pointing out to him that the hall in fact refuses to listen to him.

Vladimir Zhirinovsky also voiced his comments on Oreshkin. The leader of the Liberal Democratic Party noted that the deputies did not hear specifics in the statements of the head of the Ministry of Economic Development, and “already five minutes after the speech, they began to go about their business.”

At this time, the speaker of the lower house advised the minister “to prepare better” and “generally learn public speaking”.

From Zhirinovsky's statement:

What should the deputies listen to? “Here we believe” and “here we have reached” ...

Zhirinovsky urged the minister to remove the parasitic words and “give specifics.”

As a result, the Duma postponed the speech of Maxim Oreshkin with a report at the end of March.

This is the first case for representatives of the government of Dmitry Medvedev, when the deputies made direct claims to the minister about his report, not allowing to finish the “speech”. Experts have already assessed the situation, noting that such an interruption of the Minister’s report was not in the 20 Duma for years.

Comments

[aszzz888]

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

[Separ DNR]

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

And someone said that he was being "promoted" almost to Putin's successors ...

[Stirbjorn]

Quote: Separ DNR

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

And someone said that he was being "promoted" almost to Putin's successors ...

So he dreamed about the presidency the other day, it was under Putin - they decided to put him in his place ... I think the real reason for the abstraction is this. For balabalism in the Duma, you have not surprised anyone for a long time

[Shurik70]

Zhirinovsky called on the minister to remove the parasite words and “give specifics”

Specifically, his mother pushed. In nature, Mlyn.

[Svetlana]

Quote: Separ DNR

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

And someone said that he was being "promoted" almost to Putin's successors ...

Not him, but the one who interrupted, and do not unwind, and cook. Therefore, such self-confidence. And Oreshkina was appointed to the post of prime minister as the Minister of the Republic of Estonia, as in 1998-m, to hold the largest economic frauds, then to dump all the alleged failures on an inexperienced young politician, everything goes according to plan. Soon Oreshkina, like Kiriyenko in 1998, will trample. Perhaps Volodin and appointed, then the prime minister, and then Putin.

[Thrall]

To hear the head of Oreshkin (DAM) in the afternoon of March 7!
The full composition of the Duma, except for women deputies and Zhirinovsky

[Separ DNR]

Quote: Thrall

The full composition of the Duma, except for women deputies and Zhirinovsky

There will be profanity, and Zhirinovsky, her (vocabulary) guru, will not be interested?

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

What is the bell? Such a report indicates complete unsuitability. Already leaving the state. Duma, he was supposed to be unemployed!

[Destiny]

I agree. Then what to demand from local officials, if the ministers so regard their work through their sleeves .. The fish rots from the head.

[icant007]

Again you are with your fish. Enough to offend already poor fish by comparison with officials)

[whole]

that's exactly. Putna's head has exactly the same tales: "it is necessary, I instruct, it will be", etc.

[taiga2018]

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

he had to be unemployed!

Do not tell, we don’t have such a culture of resignation, as in Europe, for example, our official will sit until the higher authorities give him a kick ...

[asar]

"will not give him a kick ..."
With a transfer to another, similar, place!

[askort154]

taiga2018 .....we don’t have that, I would say a culture of resignation, as for example in the same Europe,

In Europe, this "culture" is also being reborn. Sit until "blue in the face". Recent example: Macron, Merkel, May, etc.
Here in Japan, there they like to "retire" regularly, at the first "failure". And even the entire government. But it never threatened us, and never will. We can sleep well.

[Alexey RA]

Quote: askort154

In Europe, this "culture" is also being reborn. Sit until "blue in the face". Recent example: Macron, Merkel, May, etc.

So in Europe before sat until the end.
Helmut Kohl sat in his chair from 1982 to 1998.
Francois Mitterrand - from 1981 to 1995

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: taiga2018

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

he had to be unemployed!

Do not tell, we don’t have such a culture of resignation, as in Europe, for example, our official will sit until the higher authorities give him a kick ...

Oreshkin is already the second public puncture. Will he continue to be a minister?

[genisis]

What kind of professional suitability as Minister of Economic Development can be discussed if the main professional achievement of Oreshkin is that he was deputy Siluanov. The person who is entrusted with the task of economic, largely industrial, development, has never worked in life except in the financial sector. Therefore, Sberbank shows billions of profits for 2018 in our country, and it is unrealistic for a industrial enterprise to get a loan at a sane interest. So we live in the world of all-Russian prosperity drawn by various Rogozins and other Oreshkins.

[Vladimir 5]

Krasnoyarsk .. You listened to the report, you know it, judge only by external indicators. And most importantly, the deputies were not "booed", they were not removed from the rostrum, no one simply listened, this is also an indicator ... The problem is not in Minister Oreshkin, the problem is the whole cabinet of Medvedev, because the Oreshkin ministry is the main thing ... to demand to act on the orders of the President, this composition of the Duma is unlikely to be able to ... As if by string, both the government and the Duma completely change ...

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: Vladimir 5

Like a rope, and the government and the thought to change completely ...

Tell me more clearly. Some cannot develop laws so that they do not limit the parasitic existence of themselves and another two and a half million parasites. And others, with knowledge of the HSE of a certain party affiliation, cannot revive the economy under laws that do not allow the development of long-term lending to production.
They are even confused in the explanations ...

[Vadim237]

We have 30 million of these parasites - they don’t pay taxes, they use public goods for that.

[Alf]

Quote: Vadim237

We have 30 million of these parasites - they don’t pay taxes, they use public goods for that.

So why doesn't the state press them to the nail? In simple terms, this is called "the political impotence of the state."

[Reklastik]

So why shouldn't the state press them to the nail?

- And who is the state?))) Will they themselves squeeze themselves?

[Alf]

Quote: Reklastik

So why shouldn't the state press them to the nail?

- And who is the state?))) Will they themselves squeeze themselves?

Of course no. Just in VO there are those that represent the state as a spherical horse in a vacuum.

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Vladimir 5

Krasnoyarsk .. You listened to the report, you know it, judge only by external indicators. And most importantly, the deputies were not "booed", they were not removed from the rostrum, no one simply listened, this is also an indicator ... The problem is not in Minister Oreshkin, the problem is the whole cabinet of Medvedev, because the Oreshkin ministry is the main thing ... to demand to act on the orders of the President, this composition of the Duma is unlikely to be able to ... As if by string, both the government and the Duma completely change ...

Yes, Vladimir, I have not heard the report, have not read it. It is not necessary. It is enough that the deputies STOP listening to him. And they did not "boo" because this is not the kind of audience who whistles, stamp their feet, etc. in a "public place". DG is not a stadium.
= The problem is not with Minister Oreshkin, = I agree. But you will agree, a professional, a good worker, and with a bad boss, he is a professional and a good worker.
It was not Oreshkin’s boss who selected people for him to compose a report, but Oreshkin himself. And if he could not even do this, then ...
Moreover, he, in theory, had to read "his" report himself before being presented in the State Duma. So what? Have you read it? And didn't you find him worthless? Then - a worthless price for him, and not only as a minister.

[Vladimir 5]

Krasnoyarsk ... Remark: When pro-Israeli commentators defend the prime minister’s failure for all the decades by all efforts, this is another clear symptom not in favor of the prime minister of the Russian Federation ...

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Vladimir 5

Krasnoyarsk ... Remark: When pro-Israeli commentators defend the prime minister’s failure for all the decades by all efforts, this is another clear symptom not in favor of the prime minister of the Russian Federation ...

Vladimir, we are now discussing O-Resh-Ki-na! When we start discussing DAM, you will find out my opinion about him. And it is unlikely to be different from yours. In any case, I think so.

[Alf]

Quote: Vladimir 5

Like a rope, and the government and the thought to change completely ...

And the king is again in white .. Not tired?

[Svetlana]

Quote: Alf

Quote: Vladimir 5

Like a rope, and the government and the thought to change completely ...

And the king is again in white .. Not tired?

He is the king. He always has nothing to do with it. For that, he and the king, for that they revive the monarchy.

[Alf]

Quote: Svetlana

He is the king. He always has nothing to do with it.

Then the fig is needed? Show that the throne is not empty?

[Svetlana]

Quote: Alf

Quote: Svetlana

He is the king. He always has nothing to do with it.

Then the fig is needed? Show that the throne is not empty?

Yes, that's why he sits on our throne. But this, as Kanevsky says, is a completely different story. And about the created appearance of democracy and about the created appearance of purges, too, is a completely different story.

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Alf

And the king is again in white .. Not tired?

Have you ever led a team of people?
Yes, the leader is to blame for the poor work of the team. But he is not to blame for the fact that his subordinate is poorly performing his duties. That's right - replace! Is a replacement already at your reception? And are you sure it will work better?

[Alf]

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

Is a replacement already at your reception? And are you sure it will work better?

A search for a replacement is not fate? If the leader is not sure that he will not be able to pick up a team, then he should not even take up a leadership position.

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

And are you sure it will work better?

Did not manage, drive out, look for another. Your thoughts are very interesting. I’m not sure that I will find a good specialist, so let a bad worker work for me, let me ruin my work, and suddenly I won’t find anyone.

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Alf

Did not manage, drive out, look for another. Your thoughts are very interesting. I’m not sure that I will find a good specialist, so let a bad worker work for me, let me ruin my work, and suddenly I won’t find anyone.

Yes, you are right, of course. To us, from the outside, everything is so simple and easy. But how really? We don’t know.

[Alf]

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

Quote: Alf

Did not manage, drive out, look for another. Your thoughts are very interesting. I’m not sure that I will find a good specialist, so let a bad worker work for me, let me ruin my work, and suddenly I won’t find anyone.

Yes, you are right, of course. To us, from the outside, everything is so simple and easy. But how really? We don’t know.

And what, leaders other creatures with alternative thinking? Ask Vadim237, does he keep bad workers? He has his own office, personal, so he values ​​it, and our leaders regard their work as the next feeding trough, I’ll eat and go on, and even the grass doesn’t grow there. Like worms.

[AU Ivanov.]

We need to see this report. Perhaps everything is exactly the opposite: Oreshkin’s report was on the case, it’s just inconvenient for fat Dumaks.

[lukewarm]

Quote: AS Ivanov.

Oreshkin’s report was on the case

Prefer if criminal. In general, their affairs are not visible with the naked eye. In economics, complete ... yes. It. Or he. Therefore, respectively, cases and report.

[DimerVladimer]

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

What is the bell? Such a report indicates complete unsuitability. Already leaving the state. Duma, he was supposed to be unemployed!

Listen to Rogozin - he is a master of public speaking, only Roscosmos is losing more and more to the market of commercial launches, of one private company ...
Where is the Federation manned ship? Since 2019, Musk will begin manned flights to the ISS on its Dragons ...

[Lamatinets]

You can’t split a nut so easily))) Maybe this is Putin’s probe,

[Gardamir]

You can’t split a nut so easily

The hammer is not needed.

[RUS96]

..............

[hydrox]

Quote: Krasnoyarsk

Such a report speaks of complete incompetence. Already leaving the State. Duma he had to be unemployed!

With your speech, you lowered ALL the Russian ruling liberalism kagal below the baseboard !!

[Nikolay R]

I doubt that this report was somehow different from other reports. Just "if you took up a tug, then do not say that a lot." That is, if you started trying on the presidency, then you really should correspond, and not carry muck.

[Tank jacket]

And the entire economic bloc of government. Siluanov, too, runs the risk of going to Ulyukaev if he does not change his clothes. After the case of Arashukov and Michael Kalvi, the empty-headed Oreshkin and all of the HSE have to understand that they need to work for the good of the people, but there are still odious pro-American humanoids. Wangyu demonstration flogging Oreshkin in the coming months.

[taiga2018]

Quote: Tank jacket

And the entire economic bloc of government.

most likely to the entire government, although the president’s affection for the Medvedev government is very strange, it seems that for all the years that he has been in power he could not be suspected of shortsightedness, but then does he really not understand that this company is simply discrediting him ...

[Tank jacket]

I will say figuratively — these horses are made blinders and inheritances in order to make them work for the good of Russia. It turns out to train someone, someone for meat. A frequent change of leadership is loss of control for a long time, and our time is running out + personnel base is lame, the bench is small, they brought up the elite of the 90s ... So we have to put zealous horses in the stall.

[orionvitt]

Quote: taiga2018

this president’s strange attachment to the Medvedev government, it seems that for all the years that he has been in power he could not be suspected of shortsightedness

This once again suggests that the president is not omnipotent, although some have already written him down as "tsars." Here it is just worth remembering the "conspiracy theory", and understand that there is a third force against which even Putin is not quite a player.

[Lamatinets]

And where is the other company to take? He himself raised it. Vegetable grower

[Alf]

Quote: Lamatinets

And where is the other company to take? He himself raised it. Vegetable grower

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: Tank jacket

Wangyu demonstration flogging Oreshkin in the coming months.

Who will flog? The "executioner" has a day off ... Or is there another option?

[Tank jacket]

Option-Prosecutor General. From there and fly ...

[lukewarm]

Quote: Tank jacket

from HSE it’s time to already understand that we need to work for the good of the people

In principle, HSE and its pets are incapable of understanding this. Almost physically. For this school itself was born with opposite goals and raises its children in accordance with these goals. And in their "application" there is no tab "for the good of the people." There is a safety island of the fifth column, students and teachers keep a barely disguised fig in their pockets on the "patriotic" plans of the guarantor, practically openly and in agreement with the leadership they go to rally for bulk and many other things. Infa practically first-hand - a colleague's daughter is studying there, alas.

[Tank jacket]

So we will plant ...

[Lamatinets]

Why plant, on a collective farm, on the national economy, let them personally see how vegetables grow fruits. And at the same time learn to care for the garden in reality.

[Alf]

Quote: Tank jacket

Wangyu demonstration flogging Oreshkin in the coming months.

And Vaska listens, but eats ..

[Tank jacket]

Well, Michael Kalvi and Ulyukaev and Arashukov do not starve ...

[Lamatinets]

They have such a diet, but from which the senator forgets the language in which he must communicate in the Senate.

[den3080]

Mr. Oreshkin’s predecessor kept looking for the bottom of the financial abyss into which Russia falls, without making a single correct forecast from the point of view of Russia's economic development.
Zyuganov correctly noted once, on this occasion: the Minister did not guess even once ...
So the predecessor did find the bottom, for himself.
And what will be Mr. Oreshkin? Interesting.

[tomket]

Quote: den3080

Mr. Oreshkin’s predecessor kept looking for the bottom of the financial abyss into which Russia falls,

Ulyukaev was looking for the bottom, and this weirdo will begin to measure GDP in parrots to show growth, or to tell about unprecedented wage increases, I don’t even know which of these two causes less bitterness.

[Lamatinets]

36 parrots and one parrot wing? )))))

[Vladimir Postnikov]

What is the bell? That he, like Gref and Nabiulina, will go to "good feeding", or like Ulyukaev - to "bad feeding"? Most likely, he will leave for good feeding.
So what? Because Oreshkin will be better, will you personally like?
All my attitude to this episode has already been expressed in a joke:

The Mongols decided to establish the Ministry of the Navy. The Kremlin was surprised:
-- Why do you need? You don’t even have a sea!
“But you have the Ministry of Economic Development!” - answered the Mongols.

[Tank jacket]

Vladimir, everything is written below.

[tomket]

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

Yes, actually we are still engaged in the same chatter, That Rogozin, that Oreshkin, that Medvedev, that Putin. The only specifics from Putin’s mouth in the message to the federal assembly were about maternity capital and about the increase in benefits. Further solid water. What a king, such is the retinue.

[Sirius-2]

This is no longer a bell! This is a real slap in the face!

[Alf]

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

Then Putin. Does anyone else here believe that such large appointments are possible without the final decision of the king-father?

[Alf]

Quote: Alf

Quote: aszzz888

... this is a bell to Oreshkin! ...

Then Putin. Does anyone else here believe that such large appointments are possible without the final decision of the king-father?

An anecdote in the subject.
The first meeting of the new Duma, on the podium speaker.
If anyone does not know, I will introduce myself-I Volodin.
From the audience.
We are all here Volodya, you name your first name.

[Alexey-74]

Deputies were not satisfied with just the speech and the report of Oreshkin himself ??? Or the understanding that complete rubbish is voiced from the rostrum? Moved to the end of March, and that before the end of March, Russians will begin to live better?

[neri73-r]

Quote: Alexey-74

and that before the end of March, Russians will begin to live better?

No, they will not start, but they will already force me to write and read what specifically has been done and will be done, and not a transfusion from empty to empty masses of numbers and common phrases.

[Alexey-74]

Is it really something done? Report and facts are two different things .....

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Alexey-74

Deputies were not satisfied with just the speech and the report of Oreshkin himself ??? Or the understanding that complete rubbish is voiced from the rostrum? Moved to the end of March, and that before the end of March, Russians will begin to live better?

No, the Russians will not live better. It’s just that the State Duma gave Oreshkin time to dismiss those who wrote him the report, looking for new report writers and, well, for writing a new report convenient for the people's deputies.

[Lamatinets]

You might think new ones are better composed. Until the Pro-Putin camarilla is removed, all will remain.

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Lamatinets

You might think new ones are better composed. Until the Pro-Putin camarilla is removed, all will remain.

We will see. But, it seems to me, the people's deputies will listen to the new report of Oreshkin without interrupting.

[Vasiliev Yu]

Deputies were not satisfied with just the speech and the report of Oreshkin himself ??? Or the understanding that complete rubbish is voiced from the rostrum? Moved to the end of March, and that before the end of March, Russians will begin to live better?

On top of that, you were already voiced about Oreshkin’s presidential ambitions:

Maxim Oreshkin just now allowed himself to embarrassingly say while talking with students of the Academy of Journalism that he would be interested in working as president of Russia. And then it started: media, publics, jokes, "onalitega" in Telegram. Of course, then he bombed on his Facebook: they say, the press likes to misinterpret the words spoken - and all for the sake of hype. Of course, the embarrassing about “it would be interesting” spread everywhere - not every day the ministers show, albeit very carefully, their presidential ambitions. But Oreshkin’s statement should be taken in exactly this way: the easy and unobtrusive desire to become “Roissy’s president”, which was also stated at the not-so-large event, speaks for itself.

And on this occasion what they say in telegrams:

State Duma Speaker Vyacheslav Volodin interrupted the speech in front of the House of the Minister of Economic Development Maxim Oreshkin, saying that "the implementation of the President's message requires a more responsible approach and a more specific conversation." - RBK

"Government hour" with Oreshkin's participation has been postponed to the end of March or the beginning of April.

V.V. Zhirinovsky has already noted that this was the first time in the State Duma. Well, everything in the world once happens for the first time.

Deputy Rashkin (Communist Party) tweeted that there is no specificity in Oreshkin’s words, it’s impossible to get answers to questions. In essence, this is Volodin’s support. Interestingly, the Secretary of the Moscow City Committee of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, Rashkin, in 1972-2010. He lived in Saratov, in 1994-1996. Volodin and Rashkin were deputy chairmen of the Saratov Regional Duma.

There is no doubt that Volodin’s actions are not an impromptu, but a homework. Naturally, commentators have already linked the incident with the presidential ambitions of Volodin and Oreshkin: they say, 2 candidates for successors collided.

More realistic is the version of other commentators about Volodin’s conscious escalation of the conflict with the government.

However, one doesn’t interfere with the other: Volodin could have figured out which Prime Minister Medvedev would be the most reluctant to stand up for.

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: Alexey-74

Moved to the end of March, and that before the end of March, Russians will begin to live better?

Since March, only deputies will be able to live better ... Maybe in the report they just did not indicate about this "deputy improvement"?

[neri73-r]

It’s necessary to drive these ministers together with Mr. Medvedev, and not to listen. But at least somehow the ice started to break.

[Separ DNR]

Quote: neri73-r

But at least somehow the ice started to break.

WHERE and WHAT "ice"?

SWAMP.

[neri73-r]

Quote: Separ DNR

SWAMP

In general, yes! So far! But, over 20 years of the first young puppy (I still did not understand he was a well-born or talented), such as an effective progressive manager, they stopped him, poked his nose into unsuitability and sent him to the second year (in March). You can say that he started.

[edeligor]

Quote: neri73-r

progressive manager

MANAGER is more true. Spirited, overfilled bureaucrats. After the retirement sequestration, everything in the government and the Edrosovsky Duma is ALL anti-people! People spit on the TV screen, one word in words, but in reality .... !!!

[LiSiCyn]

Seryoga, don't tear your soul ... I understand, you are offended. Not only do we not really help you, but we are also busy with "talking shop" and not with business. A push is needed. Maidan-Crimea. Gas pipeline from Qatar - Syria.
What will be next, I do not know

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: LiSiCyn

Tolchek needed.

They will "visit" Ulyukaev - they will have everything: pasta for dinner, and one "push" for the whole camera ...

[asar]

Simpatish ... .. frogs!
And in the case, that's right!

[tomket]

Quote: asar

Simpatish ... .. frogs!
And in the case, that's right!

By the way, what has Putin sorted out with the "whale prison"? Or now even he cannot beat the "shifting of papers"? Are they waiting for a final rest?

[dvina71]

To begin with, in the upcoming elections, the State Duma needs to give the EP a full ride .. Medvedev’s creature .. And in general, the election system must be changed .. vote not for parties, but for people and the work of the State Duma .. two months in the district, a month in Moscow .. otherwise they are sitting in the capital and they don’t know what the people have problems with.

[neri73-r]

Quote: dvina71

To begin with, in the upcoming elections, the State Duma needs to be completely driven by EP.

So no one has voted for them for a long time, but ......... elections (and not only in our country) are a wonderful thing! A great way of manipulation and the ability to speak on behalf of the people without responsibility to the latter.

[dvina71]

Quote: neri73-r

So for a long time nobody votes for them, but ..

Well, as it were in the last elections to the local OD .. the result for the EP was nothing. And they vote for them ..

[neri73-r]

Quote: dvina71

Quote: neri73-r

So for a long time nobody votes for them, but ..

Well, as it were in the last elections to the local OD .. the result for the EP was nothing. And they vote for them ..

I'm talking about how they count, and not about how they vote!

[dvina71]

Quote: neri73-r

I'm talking about how they count, and not about how they vote!

Well .. this time they counted correctly ..

[hydrox]

Only someone who comes to the CEC with machine guns can correctly calculate ...

[Separ DNR]

Quote: dvina71

they are sitting in the capital and they don’t know what the people have problems.

[asar]

In the morning I smear a sandwich -
Immediately thought: what about the people?
And the caviar does not climb into the throat,
And compote does not pour into your mouth!

[Destiny]

At this time, the speaker of the lower house advised the minister “better prepare”
This can be advised by many ministers in the government and their subordinates on the ground ... It is better to prepare for the performance of their duties. Work, not kick the air. They don’t even want to listen to them in the Duma, what can I talk about here?

[neri73-r]

Quote: Destiny

This can be advised by many ministers in the government and their subordinates on the ground ...

The overwhelming majority of federal ministers should be advised to dry crackers, to be honest.

[Mouse]

the speaker of the lower house advised the minister to "get better prepared" and "learn to speak publicly in general."

sit down ... two!

[Russia]

Oreshkin, going to the Duma, thought he had come to the parasites, and the parasites thought that he was a parasite.

[Russia]

Quote: Mouse

sit down ... two!

Somewhere I heard this expression recently, but obviously not at school.

[plotnikov561956]

Maxim ... he is also in Africa Maxim ... I remember his report to Putin in Vladik ... which has become a parable ... It is ridiculous to imagine such cases under IV Stalin ...

[Geosun]

The deputies do not understand the ministers, the people do not understand the deputies, an interesting carousel.

[Antokha]

Does the people understand themselves?

[Geosun]

And people for self-awareness need at least to be well-fed, healthy and in their home, it is desirable to have some kind of plans for the future. Then you can philosophize.

[Antokha]

In a well-fed state, he is not very philosophical. A hungry person is much more likely to ask himself why is this so? It is depressing that too many answer stereotypically "the tsar is to blame", and I am in nothing.

[Geosun]

I do not agree with the first part, and philosophy itself arose when people had free time.
But at the expense of the tsar, you are right, but after all, the Soviet generation was brought up in such a way that the state cares about people, and the initiative is punishable. So they got used to blaming the "king" for everything

[Antokha]

As for the first part, it is more an observation from life. However, in the spiritual sphere, where "philosophizing" is one of the main occupations, this is an axiom. Even asceticism is specially invented (hello, coming Great Lent). On the second part - I completely agree with you - we were brought up that way. But we have not been in the USSR for 30 years, more than one generation has grown up that did not see that level of care, and this mentality is passed from father to son, from mother to daughter. And the enemies around us will not spare. We have to act ourselves.

[ODERVIT]

Shame on the minister (kindergarten) and it doesn’t matter if there is an experience in public speaking. First exit? It's time, time.

[Prisoner]

In vain, that was not. Accustomed in general to break out. Words on chervonets, but not everyone’s for a penny.

[Zomanus]

That's right. Now you can already talk about real affairs without scoring time with an empty talker.

[Sotskiy]

Zhirinovsky urged the minister to remove the parasitic words and “give specifics.”

Here they are victims of the exam, already at the highest level, as Zhores Alferov spoke about.

[Botanik Medveddev]

The kingdom of heaven to him, Alferov, and eternal memory ...

[Vadim237]

This education is still an old model - to see the same there were a lot of similar exams here, absolutely nothing to do with.

[Sotskiy]

Quote: Vadim237

and the exam here, absolutely nothing to do with.

Unified State Exam is absolutely and the coolest thing that is everywhere. My mother-in-law, who is 69 years old, taught English at the local university - they were stuck with tests, reports and obligatory scientific papers on the websites of scientific communities (without them you are not a teacher), even with a diploma, experience, experience and merit. Moreover, all these "dopas" are not reflected in the salary. There was simply no time left to prepare for classes. She sat until "deep after midnight" every day, until she came down with pressure. We persuaded her to leave, but since she is an old school workaholic by nature, she is now preparing cadets in English at a military school. He says it's easier there. It can be seen there the exam has not yet reached.

[eleronn]

It is a pity that they could not hear the head of the transport department!

[Alf]

Quote: eleronn

It is a pity that they could not hear the head of the transport department!

He usually speaks only before the Federal Assembly.

[Fevralsk. Morev]

Even the deputies of the State Duma are fed up with fairy tales about the albino bull. This is the finish bro.

[GRIGORIY76]

I thought they were already accustomed to dilettante speeches, well, there in the State Duma, the government, on different messages. Everywhere, "we must," "we have no time to swing," and so on.
Window dressing is next.

[den3080]

By the way. I would not say that high-netted intellectuals / professionals / specialists are sitting in the State Duma. Maybe a dozen or so, but no more.
The rest are the same as you and me. Only with a material situation they have much better.

[Vladimir 5]

Grigoi ... You listened to the report, you know it, we judge only by external indicators. And most importantly, the deputies did not "boo", they did not remove the deputies from the rostrum, no one simply listened, this is also an indicator ... The problem is not in Minister Oreshkin, the problem is the whole cabinet of Medvedev, because the Oreshkin ministry is the main thing ... to demand to act on the orders of the president, this composition of the Duma is unlikely to be able to ... As if by string, change the government and the Duma completely ... This symptom is similar from the song: Everything is fine, beautiful marquis, everything else is good ...

[GRIGORIY76]

I agree with you, the failures of the government should be appreciated and such episodes should be with every minister and even with the president.
And who will be asking them in the State Duma? Any actor or athlete? Or maybe a former security official who does not understand nicherta in the economy?

[Dimy4]

And at the end of March, he will have to say a short phrase on behalf of the government: WE began to live better! And that will be true.

[ROBIN-SON]

Don’t get so excited ... This is their business upstairs ..

[silverwolf88]

The ministers are used to the fact that blah blah blah is passing ... and there is nothing more to say to them ... and moreover, an understandable program on the Ministry of Economic Development ... how we reach and where we are going - the minister has no ...

[asiat_61]

Under the USSR, in order to become a minister of something, it was necessary to go the way from the bottom, from the machine tool. Now they have beaten some pasan, and he is the minister !!!!!

[senima56]

Nobody "catches the pasans" ... They nominate "their own pasans" (sons, brothers, nephews, etc.) For example, the son of D.O. Rogozin "Pasan" runs ILom!

[Botanik Medveddev]

According to Oreshkin's physiognomy, a selection criterion is visible: intelligence should not be higher than a certain level. Like the journalists.

[Simferopol]

So can give a kick in the ass and assign a normal?

[Homer_J_Simpson]

I would not be surprised if he saw his report only this morning.

[mag nit]

From Putin, too, it has been heard for 20 years - "stop swinging."

[afrikanez]

And it is not surprising why he was interrupted: him about Thomas, and he about Jerome.

[senima56]

Where did this gentleman come from ?!

[Tank jacket]

From the Chubais rotten nest of the HSE ..

[Fedor Kostrov]

The first bell. The buttonholes have clearly not an iron point. Only all this and vanity of vanities are useless. They "feel intuitively" that they have long worked out the highest measure of social protection. They need to run right now, then it will be too late ...
Here is a comment from me.

[APASUS]

Such a serious indicator for our country! If Oreshkin, while occupying the position of the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation, cannot really put everything on the shelves, then what should be expected from officials at a level lower? That’s why they don’t take our roads, dumps around, constant scandals with bribes.
Complete incompetence!

[Antokha]

I worked with a person similar to Volodin according to the working method. This is a strong assistant to the leader who does not seek to jump above his head, sets tasks clearly, understands the topic quite well, has huge connections, but does not trump them. It is useless to lie to him. Even if he doesn’t figure it out right away, then he’ll check it. And at the same time extremely polite, so you are even surprised that such a person speaks on equal terms with you. The impression is that the education and experience of such a person are special services. Doesn't like to chat. Volodin in its place. He fulfills the tasks set by the President, and you can rely on him.
Essentially, he told efficient managers that they did not know anything, and this is known above and causes irritation there. On the other hand, it’s hard to lead anything. And the ministry and even more so. Everything is huge there, billions are around, go and see if everything is correct. One percent to steal, already hundreds of millions. Why there are no results is also often difficult to understand. They kind of gave money ... I know, because worked in this environment.

[The Siberian barber]

. I worked with a person similar to Volodin according to the method of work

Do you have any idea about Volodin’s work?)) Why are you so zealously defending him?)
Much was written about his "methodology" when he was still in Saratov. For me - an ordinary "product, in the spirit of the times"

[Stroi76]

But this Oreshkin tried in his own way. He strained someone to make a report, memorized him sleepless nights. And here, bam, and they don’t want to listen, you’re tired of talking. There’s nothing to do with the report of a respected person. Here we have everything to do in Rada, some jokes poison, he indulges in coke, he watches the other porn on the phone, and they fight in the name of the welfare of Ukraine .

[Gardamir]

Something like this


sorry no full video.

[vadimtt]

In the first frame, the oil painting is straight - "Deuce again!"

[Krasnoyarsk]

Quote: Gardamir

comments

In the photo, Oreshkin, just like a schoolboy by the blackboard who has not learned homework.

[kotik77713]

The Duma does not want to hear anything except preferences in its address, and the rustle of money ... The question is of course, the necessary laws will never be adopted, only insignificant. Before the next vybaromi throw a bone, and on the thumb .....

[moscowp]

The State Duma decided to recall its existence by choosing the safest minister. It is not surprising that Oreshkin did not listen, who will listen about economic policy, Khorkhin, Valuev, Shipulin, or who is there at all today?

[Million]

Putin picked up every ..... (any word can be inserted)

[lukewarm]

I read all this about the impunity of bureaucrats. And paradoxically I remembered the "blessed 90s". Of course, even then none of the prime ministers left to cut the woods, and the reasons for the resignations were far from "popular", but still ... With what ease the "forever young, forever drunk" Yeltsin kicked out such people ... "They sat down wrong." .. This would be a decisive successor ...

[georggy]

State Duma Chairman Vyacheslav Volodin interrupted the speech of Minister Oreshkin, indicating to him that the hall actually refuses to listen to him

And this body (Oreshkin) is still aiming for the presidency of the country. "Try yourself". Whip ................

[Gardamir]

And this one (Oreshkin) marks the presidency of the country

They will choose it and it will be inconvenient for you.

[georggy]

And with this you think it’s convenient? Horseradish radish, not sweeter.

[georggy]

And in general ................... Isn't it time for the entire "accounting block" of the Government to go out! ??? There is no benefit from them!

[Andrey Shch]

Quote: Anton

Volodin in its place. He fulfills the tasks set by the President, and you can rely on him.

What a cunning "squiggle"! And maybe all the same the prime minister should deal with the would-be minister, well, or Himself? These are their duties. Can't figure it out without Volodin?

Quote: Anton

Essentially, he told efficient managers that they did not know anything, and this is known above and causes irritation there.

Same. They (i.e. WCT and GDP) cannot do this themselves? Why? Well, this is their business first of all!

Quote: Anton

On the other hand, it’s hard to lead anything. And the ministry and even more so. Everything is huge there, billions are around, go and see if everything is correct.

So do not go with a pork snout in a Kalash row. It's hard for them, you see, to figure it out. They deal with their personal affairs and the affairs of their relatives (especially their wives) very effectively. Why then was Ulyukayev imprisoned? After all, "go figure it out if everything is right."

Quote: Anton

Why there are no results is also often difficult to understand. Money, like they gave ...

"It's Chubais to blame for everything!" (Boris N. Yeltsin)

[Panting]

Ta da da da dam, there ta tam. A crucian has arrived.

[MegaPups]

Who are the judges? Zhirik tongue scratch on the topic and without it the same. Only he takes clowning. And such that conversations to talk for an hour and a half without specifics there is a large part of the Duma.

[Campanella]

It’s funny to tell a person better prepared if he has no idea about the topic. He can remove the words of the parasite, but he is definitely not capable of engaging in theory.
Putin did well, drew plans, and all sorts of nuts there should give real things? Not a thankful post, and even with such a government structure.

[Kaw]

In my opinion, this suggests that dissatisfaction with Putin is ripening among our political elite. We recouped in this case on the minister. This is fraught with serious problems for the whole country.
As for the report, for some reason it seems to me that he does not interest anyone at all and has never been interested. Most of those who sit in the State Duma understand the state economy, no more than plumbers from a water utility.

[Campanella]

What nonsense, Volodin against Putin?))) Do not tell!

[Lexa-149]

And here he is still receiving a "beggarly" salary from our taxes for this ?! Yes, drive him in the neck, this demagogue!

[hydrox]

Quote: Svetlana

Perhaps Volodin will be appointed, then Prime Minister, and then Putin.

After all that Volodin carried in the summer about the pension robbery, his place was not in the premieres, but in the janitors!

[Vadim237]

He correctly carried everything about pension reform - quick retirement is the lot of loafers, and even though people will live longer, because work is an incentive to life.

[faterdom]

That rare case when the deputies are right ... But it is necessary to consolidate: the same Volodin, too, should go to the same place where he sent Oreshkin - to leave and close the door from that side. As, however, for the whole EP: I will scrupulously find everyone who was or is in this party and cross out in all types of elections. They deserve it.
But Volodin does not become poor - a palm-oil baron.

[Stalnov I.P.]

This mediocre performance only emphasizes which non-professional cadres work there at the top. But this is the staff of the president. It turns out that the president is not fully engaged in personnel. And from the decisions made by these underprofessionals, the simple PEOPLE first of all suffers. Probably it is necessary to ask the Supreme who he appoints and how they work. Smiles are not appropriate here.