The conversation between Putin and Netanyahu in Paris did take place

166
It became known that in Paris on the sidelines of the celebration of the 100 anniversary of the end of the First World War, there was still a meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. For most journalists covering Paris events, this conversation was almost one of the most important events of 11 in November in the French capital.

Recall that earlier the French President Emmanuel Macron appealed to world leaders who were preparing to arrive in Paris, with a request to postpone the negotiations with each other on other dates. According to Macron, bilateral negotiations could divert attention from the reason that everyone was invited to the French capital. In particular, such an appeal was sent to the Kremlin and the White House. At least, the situation was described by the French media.





Reporters asked Netanyahu about how the meeting with Putin, and what the results of this meeting. The conversation itself on the sidelines was short-lived, and Netanyahu’s comment was therefore also more than concise:
The conversation went great and was very important.




Recall that Netanyahu several times sought the opportunity to hold a personal meeting with the Russian president, but Moscow did not consider that such a meeting was appropriate in this situation. After the tragedy with IL-20 off the coast of Syria, for which the Russian Defense Ministry placed the blame on Israel, the Air Force commander of this country arrived in Moscow and presented his version of what had happened. Apparently, the Israeli version of the Defense Ministry of the Russian Federation "did not like". Netanyahu himself, as the Israeli press wrote, called to Moscow and offered condolences over the death of Russian servicemen, but did not recognize responsibility for this death for Israel.

The fact that the conversation between Putin and Netanyahu in Paris did take place was received positively by Israeli journalists.

PS You can pay attention to the fact that among the invitees was the President of Kosovo, which was not recognized by Russia as an independent state, Hashim Tachi.



At that moment, the head of Serbia Alexander Vucic was in the group of guests standing opposite.
166 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +25
    11 November 2018 19: 09
    The conversation could be on the sidelines and so.
    -Shalom
    -Yes, you went ...
    1. -2
      11 November 2018 19: 15
      After all the glimpses of Putin’s meetings with Natanyahu, the Iranians were bombed in Syria. Let's see what happens this time ..
      1. +10
        11 November 2018 19: 40
        Quote: Krasnodar
        After all the glimpses of Putin’s meetings with Natanyahu, Iranians were bombed in Syria

        Well, friend Benya is no longer a friend, not a brother, but ... Pay attention to the protocol status of Poroshenko, in the next row after Israel, there are some Africans wassat
        1. 0
          11 November 2018 22: 13
          Why does Israel need this "personal meeting" at all?
          It is stupid to hope that Russia will remove the S-300 from Syria.
          Hoping that Israel will suddenly stop bombing its neighbors is also silly. Only the S-300 will no longer be able to use airplanes, which means there will be missiles and attack drones. Well, he will give more money to support various "useful" groups.
          To discuss every trifle - there are deputies for that.
          1. -5
            11 November 2018 22: 34
            Most likely, they wanted to solve something fundamental. And what exactly, in the next couple of decades, we most likely will not know.
          2. +11
            11 November 2018 22: 34
            Why does Israel need this "personal meeting" at all?
            Thank Putin for the S-300, they say, they had to be delivered for a long time.
            Now Israel has a reason to abandon air strikes against Syria, and thereby not endanger its pilots.
            In general, Israel has the opportunity to refuse to implement the aggressive US policy on BV and move to a new peaceful policy of its own: to negotiate with Iran and the Palestinians, return the Golan Heights to Syria, etc., and as a result, get the BV market for the implementation of its own economic projects. winked
          3. +16
            11 November 2018 22: 50
            Quote: Shurik70
            Why does Israel need this "personal meeting" at all?

            Ask Beny why he climbs to Putin laughing In addition to Syria, there may be a number of hidden issues, for example, the tasteless Israeli carrots and other agricultural products that Canada and the EU (and previously Jordan and Turkey) refused to take from Israel and the economic losses are very decent. And how can you not tell the Russian Federation, a permanent member of the Security Council and the Russian Federation can deliver something to Iran, transfer something to Hezbollah, transfer money to Khaled Moshal, etc. Also, Putin is very vengeful, but is not in a hurry. For example, after a plane shot down by the Turks, a bus with Turkish pilots took off, 22 of which were tight, and many remained disabled, and the Kurds got a few MANPADS (guess whose production) and a couple of Turkish helicopters completely scattered. Then they saved Erdogan a few minutes before the liquidation and simply destroyed the whole caste that ruled Turkey for the last hundred years. Benya is a southern man, hot, he will do business, and then he will rush about, and ours will surely wait a pause and ... badly hurt and that Benya shook his hand, Benya was delighted and calmed down, but this will not help.
      2. +2
        11 November 2018 22: 32
        You Rabinovich how to sleep yet in a dream you see your sick idea of ​​fixed bombing of Iranians ... even just bombing someone, if only unrequited ...
    2. +1
      11 November 2018 19: 18
      Quote: Fedorov
      The conversation could be on the sidelines and so.
      -Shalom
      -Yes, you went ...
      good
      Well, I think that everything is more polite, but the essence and result are quite consistent. winked
      1. +1
        11 November 2018 21: 29
        Polite it ...
        Netanyahu - Shalom!
        Putin - Yes, Yes, the exit door to your right!)))
      2. +7
        11 November 2018 22: 53
        Quote: KVU-NSVD
        Well, I think that everything is more polite

        Type:
        -Welcome
        -Bye
    3. 0
      11 November 2018 19: 21
      Quote: Fedorov
      The conversation could be on the sidelines and so.
      -Shalom
      -Yes, you went ...

      Probably.
      1. +4
        11 November 2018 19: 27
        But unlikely.
        Benya is very worried that the GDP would not bring anything to Syria.
        1. -6
          11 November 2018 19: 48
          Quote: Bearded
          But unlikely.
          Benya is very worried that the GDP would not bring anything to Syria.

          At your expense any whim.
        2. +1
          11 November 2018 20: 03
          Quote: Bearded
          unlikely

          The blonde on the foro in the third row who is interesting, such a young .... feel
          1. 0
            11 November 2018 20: 26
            Someone’s wife.
            1. 0
              11 November 2018 20: 41
              Quote: Krasnodar
              Someone’s wife.

              Right? laughing
              1. +2
                11 November 2018 20: 43
                I won’t say for sure, but I don’t know such prime ministers / presidents laughing
                1. +1
                  11 November 2018 21: 24
                  Tell me, is it true that everyone is happy, or is it for fun?
                  1. 0
                    11 November 2018 23: 43
                    Quote: cniza
                    Tell me, is it true that everyone is happy, or is it for fun?

                    If you're talking about a blonde, then more interesting than Hochma, it just stands out from the rest, as if it were in the wrong place ....
          2. +2
            11 November 2018 22: 14
            Quote: XXXIII
            Quote: Bearded
            unlikely

            The blonde on the foro in the third row who is interesting, such a young .... feel

            Yeah! Aunt is interesting, but against the background of Macron’s wife, she’s straight beauty. love
            1. 0
              12 November 2018 12: 39
              Quote: kapitan92
              Quote: XXXIII
              Quote: Bearded
              unlikely

              The blonde on the foro in the third row who is interesting, such a young .... feel

              Yeah! Aunt is interesting, but against the background of Macron’s wife, she’s straight beauty. love

              I am shocked that the bloody butcher of the Serbs Tachi was invited to this action! And Vučić with him in the ranks, a good defender of the Serbian people negative
      2. +1
        11 November 2018 19: 50
        Come on. Most likely, Putin is demanding the impossible from Netanyahu. Judging by the fact that Netanyahu is already breaking, he will sag. And what is the benefit for us? We are already going to Israel like that! Referendum ????? Again, build a bridge ????
      3. -5
        11 November 2018 19: 56
        Quote: Aaron Zawi
        Probably.

        Do you believe "in quite possible"? Find for Bibi more decent tackles to Pu hi
        1. 0
          11 November 2018 20: 14
          Quote: Tusv

          Do you believe "in quite possible"? Find for Bibi more decent tackles to Pu hi

          Not necessary.
          1. +4
            11 November 2018 20: 19
            Quote: Aaron Zawi
            Not necessary.

            Well, we will see how Israeli pilots versus Russia, Mothers will fight.
            Is that gut thick?
            1. -1
              11 November 2018 20: 33
              Quote: Tusv

              Well, we will see how Israeli pilots versus Russia, Mothers will fight.
              Is that gut thick?

              We teach history.
              1. +5
                11 November 2018 20: 41
                Quote: Aaron Zawi
                We teach history.

                Why not learn from the Khozar Kogaonat. The same Russia and the same stoned Jews. How did it end?
                Aron. Although I am a Jew, but of Guards nationality. Yours. May be. I saw in the cemetery hi
                1. -3
                  11 November 2018 20: 57
                  Quote: Tusv

                  Why not learn from the Khozar Kogaonat. The same Russia and the same stoned Jews. How did it end?
                  Aron. Although I am a Jew, but of Guards nationality. Yours. May be. I saw in the cemetery hi
                  Firstly, if it’s so deep, then we read Gumilyov.
                  Secondly, you are not a Jew, but a Russian with Jewish ancestors.
                  1. +8
                    11 November 2018 20: 59
                    Quote: Aron Zaavi
                    not a Jew, but a Russian with Jewish ancestors.

                    Does that change anything? I do not know pure Jews, to be honest, and were there any .... tongue
                  2. +4
                    11 November 2018 21: 07
                    Quote: Aaron Zawi
                    Firstly, if it’s so deep, then we read Gumilyov.

                    But did you read Him? There the biosphere of Russia in every sentence hi
                    Secondly, you are not a Jew, but a Russian with Jewish ancestors.

                    Es ah em Gumilev and the Guards badge raised hi
                  3. +3
                    11 November 2018 21: 30
                    Quote: Aaron Zawi
                    about the first, if so deep, then read Gumilyov.

                    When you master the three books of Gumilyov, I will give literature on Berdyaev hi
                  4. +3
                    11 November 2018 21: 57
                    Firstly, if it’s so deep, then we read Gumilyov.
                    Secondly, you are not a Jew, but a Russian with Jewish ancestors.

                    Gumilev, as a scientific authority, however indisputable, right))

                    Well, in the second paragraph you are just disgusting, by golly! Stained with terry chauvinism negative
                    Shut yours so that others are afraid?

                    Zionism and fascism, as I see it, are still twin brothers? wassat feel hi

                    Well, is Russophobia here, as without her?
                    Expected alas
      4. -1
        11 November 2018 21: 46
        Quote: Aaron Zawi
        Quote: Fedorov
        The conversation could be on the sidelines and so.
        -Shalom
        -Yes, you went ...

        Probably.

        Hmm, the whole question is who greeted the vis-a-vis and who answered ... recourse
    4. -1
      11 November 2018 20: 22
      Quote: Fedorov
      The conversation could be on the sidelines and so.
      -Shalom
      -Yes, you went ...

      Fedorov, and your president Poroshenko somehow thoughtfully looked into the back of the head Netanyahu. Why?
    5. 0
      11 November 2018 21: 56
      it you still correctly wrote, the last phrase.
    6. +2
      12 November 2018 00: 16
      after reading this comment .. out of laughter, I could not read further with a serious look. (laugh)
    7. Maz
      +3
      12 November 2018 07: 05
      I don't know how the journalists took it, but local citizens are throwing another tub of slops on Russia, they say, it's their own fault, your missiles, Syrian crews and your plane, and we have nothing to do with it, and on the President of Russia. So, Netanyahu will not be prime minister for a second term, not go to a fortune-teller. And Bibi at the same time heap in the comments no less than Putin. They say Israel itself is susam, and there is nothing to humiliate before GDP. Ghoul Sabbat. And most of all, it is Russian-speaking citizens who are "patriotic", oddly enough.
  2. 0
    11 November 2018 19: 12
    No wonder Netanyahu went, to look at him, he was bent or half-bent at the same time.
    1. -25
      11 November 2018 19: 19
      Quote: Rusland
      No wonder Netanyahu went, to look at him, he was bent or half-bent at the same time.

      Your press deliberately inflates the image of your president, who fell below the baseboard after the pension reform. In fact, no one is running after him. In the West, he seems to be elusive John, everything is jumping from someone, but nobody really wants to communicate with him. And Natanyahu did not run after him, but simply once again diplomatically voiced the Israeli position on the Iranians in Syria. As the saying goes, he who has ears, let him hear. And your media, as always, cross-checked everything.
      1. +10
        11 November 2018 19: 22
        Quote: alexsipin
        And Natanyahu did not run after him, but simply once again diplomatically voiced the Israeli position on the Iranians in Syria.

        And it would be necessary to voice the Israeli position on the dead Russian military in Syria. And best of all, apologize!
        1. -1
          11 November 2018 20: 04
          Quote: SRC P-15
          And best of all, apologize!

          Late, Sasha the Israelites drink Borjomi. Wise fellows under Anger Russian
      2. +2
        11 November 2018 19: 22
        Well, let's not be nervous, buddy. Too many letters, you are excited as I look. smile
      3. 0
        11 November 2018 19: 30
        What are your media doing?
      4. +7
        11 November 2018 19: 38
        why are you sitting and writing on the site of our media. ?? if it is so wrong., trick. go to the cursor. sit there among your own.
      5. +11
        11 November 2018 19: 40
        Quote: alexsipin
        In fact, no one is running after him.
        tongue
        Did Benya tell you this? Well, ask him how much he made unsuccessful attempts to achieve an audience with V. Putin.
        Quote: alexsipin
        In the West, he's kind of elusive John
        request
        If the West needs him, then let him seek him in the East, where he lives.
        Quote: alexsipin
        everything is jumping from someone

        Israel "skips", and I even know from whom and from what .. wink .
        Quote: alexsipin
        nobody really wants to talk to him.
        This is especially noticeable in Ben ... YesAnd yes, the question is "no one" are those who are called "no way"?
      6. +6
        11 November 2018 19: 46
        Quote: alexsipin
        the floor

        the same Macron with his rating can only dream of Putin's rating "below the floor ..." and many leaders of other countries ...
        Quote: alexsipin
        nobody really wants to talk to him.

        as history shows, the welfare of the country and residents does not depend on whether the authorities of other countries want to communicate with the leader of any country or not, the same Poroshenko travels a lot, everyone meets him, pats him on the back, and life in Ukraine does not better ... but what is Poroshenko, our Yeltsin also traveled around the world (as long as he could), almost every leader was called his friend and addressed by name, and that ...
        Quote: alexsipin
        your media, as always, cross-checked.
        1. +5
          11 November 2018 20: 28
          Quote: taiga2018
          ... the same Poroshenko travels a lot, everyone meets with him, pat him on the back ...

          hi
          They clap when they need to drag the Ruin into the next adventure, and when not needed, they turn away and do not handle.

          Presumably, the race is having a "gloomy day" today. bully
          1. +6
            11 November 2018 21: 30
            Quote: Lelek
            Need to think

            In the photo, Trump most of all stretched out a smile, apparently glad to see an old friend of the KGB colonel, the major was scorched ... laughing
      7. +8
        11 November 2018 19: 57
        alexsipin well, you’re so funny as a shniperson from a shoe store. At once I mixed everything in a heap And dragged pension reform. Yes, no one wants to meet with the darkest, this is especially noticeable in the bin, which is like him after a dog! And by the way, what (garden plant) Jew came to the anniversary of the end of the 1st World War? Then there was no trace of Israel ... hi
        1. -6
          11 November 2018 20: 14
          Quote: Occupant
          And by the way, what (garden plant) Jew came to the anniversary of the end of the 1st World War? Then there was no trace of Israel ...

          And which garden plant, your country participated in the celebration of the anniversary of the uprising in the c / S Sobibor? They even shot a movie. The uprising that took place there has nothing to do with the titular nation in Russia, but it tells that Soviet Jews found a common language with Polish Jews and were thus able to plan a successful uprising. If you believe that modern Russia is the successor of the USSR and therefore has the right to participate in the celebration of the anniversary of the uprising in Sobibor, then modern Israel is also the legal successor of the Jews of the WWI and, on this basis, Bibi was invited.
          1. +4
            11 November 2018 23: 48
            Oh, you have beguiled everything in the world. On the grounds that the USSR (Russia) liberated, half of Europe, along with the camps. And even more I entered Berlin and hoisted the Banner of Victory over the 3rd Reich’s gray horse. Here on this link. But I wonder, on what basis, your bibi, came to celebrate the end of the 1st World War? What and where did the Judean troops fight? laughing hi
        2. +2
          11 November 2018 22: 40
          And what British-American clans kindled the war? Who was behind Wilson when that fire in Europe was fanning the United States from debtors to creditors? I think you can not guess, it is clear and so. Especially one family, the red shields.
          1. -2
            11 November 2018 23: 34
            The last war favorable to the Rothschilds was Napoleonic.
            1. +1
              12 November 2018 10: 21
              This is the first. Yes And how much later it was! Even the civil one in the USA, as a result of which the "paper" banks of the Rothschilds took control of the Dixie land with plantations of cane, tobacco, corn, and, most importantly, oil.
              1. 0
                12 November 2018 10: 45
                The basis of the capital of the Rothschilds were exchanges, stock markets, etc. That is, that from wars, as a rule, falls. Another thing is that they always tried to take advantage of any situation in their favor and most often they succeeded.
  3. -1
    11 November 2018 19: 13
    Personnel, how did Western leaders say hello to Putin - have you seen? )))
    1. +1
      11 November 2018 21: 43
      Not yet - but we will definitely see them.
  4. +6
    11 November 2018 19: 13
    And Putin is next to Macron’s wife ... I wonder how. And what is Ms. Merkel doing in the front row? But the English representative, I do not see something
    1. +1
      11 November 2018 19: 19
      Quote: svp67
      But the English representative, I do not see something

      Where Putin is, there is a "newbie" not far. They were very scared! laughing
      1. +4
        11 November 2018 19: 21
        Quote: Kurare
        Where Putin is, there is a "newbie" not far. They were very scared!

        Yes, most likely they were scared that they would have to answer for all this BARDAK with "Novichok", so they didn't come
  5. +5
    11 November 2018 19: 24
    Volodya, let’s bomb it ...
    - Well, so contact the League of Sexual Reforms ... What do I have to do with it laughing
  6. +8
    11 November 2018 19: 28
    the leader of the "God's chosen" gang still hopes to bomb Syria with impunity, killing Palestinian children is not enough for him ...
    1. +3
      11 November 2018 19: 32
      They have a different god, not related to us. Who cares who "chose" whom
      1. The comment was deleted.
    2. -2
      11 November 2018 20: 01
      Quote: taiga2018
      the leader of the "God's chosen" gang still hopes to bomb Syria with impunity, killing Palestinian children is not enough for him ...

      Scolding Palestinian Women and Arab Auto-Duff laughing
  7. +7
    11 November 2018 19: 32
    To me, Natanyahu’s appearance reminds me of a shy cat when something is stage, and then it starts to rub on its legs.
    "in the group of guests, standing opposite, was the head of Serbia Aleksandr Vucic" he was "happy" to see Hashim Thaci. Once I casually looked at materials on diplomatic etiquette. Usually: the protocol department of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs takes into account such subtleties in advance to avoid possible scandals. If the French Foreign Ministry is interested in relations with the same Serbia or any other state, they can find 1001 ways so that they do not meet and even not stand opposite.
    In my opinion, it is evidence that the French have drum relations between Serbia and Kosovo.
    1. 0
      11 November 2018 20: 25
      Quote: vladcub
      In my opinion, it is evidence that the French have drum relations between Serbia and Kosovo.

      Or not on the drum and everything is done consciously. The cunning European politician.
  8. 0
    11 November 2018 19: 34
    An interesting moment ... the wife of pasta has a coat in the form of an imperial Romanov flag on a coat ...
  9. -12
    11 November 2018 19: 35
    Nothing will change .. Since there are no tomatoes in Russia. They made a lot of noise from 300 and shot down an IL. They knock one more down, then more and more .. This will all stop when the commander-in-chief of the Russian Federation appreciates the life of soldiers in the Russian Federation.
    1. +3
      11 November 2018 20: 13
      Quote: Andrson
      Nothing will change .. Since there are no tomatoes in Russia.

      Do not flatter our unconventional partners. Tomatoes, for Israel wazoo
      1. 0
        13 November 2018 07: 54
        I’m not flattering, but we have Chinese tomatoes (unfortunately). The point is that even if the A-50 is shot down, just do not quarrel with the "partner" Israel.
    2. +1
      11 November 2018 23: 40
      Quote: Andrson
      Nothing will change .. Since there are no tomatoes in Russia. They made a lot of noise from 300 and shot down an IL. They knock one more down, then more and more .. This will all stop when the commander-in-chief of the Russian Federation appreciates the life of soldiers in the Russian Federation.

      There are no tomatoes, but we plant on the very tomatoes.
      1. 0
        13 November 2018 07: 55
        But no, we are defeated on all fronts.
  10. +3
    11 November 2018 19: 41
    Well, I think now Bibi .. and the hand will not be washed, and grandchildren will talk about this case)
  11. +1
    11 November 2018 19: 44
    I feel sorry for the Piglet. it costs almost crying. no one patted on the shoulder and everyone strives to give a slap)
  12. 0
    11 November 2018 20: 00
    Is such a bunch of people celebrating a victory in 1mv? And did they actually take part there? They especially touch with a dot on their forehead!
    1. +4
      11 November 2018 20: 23
      Quote: dr.star75
      Especially touched with a dot on the forehead!

      Any Gurkhas. The British loved to push themselves like them forward.
      1. 0
        11 November 2018 20: 55
        Well, did they also participate in 1mv?
        1. +2
          11 November 2018 21: 11
          Quote: dr.star75
          Well, did they also participate in 1mv?


          Why force your ignorance? they hinted you and you again.
          Hindus fought and Australians fought and much more has happened in the history of mankind by you not even suspected.
          1. -1
            11 November 2018 21: 16
            Quote: Maki Avellievich
            and much more has happened in the history of mankind by you not even suspected.

            Well yes, well yes! I probably missed the moment when the Indians and, most importantly, attention! "AUSTRALIANS" - fought and lost their citizens! Well, yes. well yes. I probably didn’t follow !!!!!!
            1. +2
              11 November 2018 21: 22
              The Australians lost about 1 thousand people in 60mv, Germany declared war on August 4, 1914
              1. +2
                11 November 2018 21: 25
                strongly! especially the fact that Russia lost in 1mln about 10mln people. Australians with 60 thousand strongly. yes, take off my hat!
                1. -1
                  11 November 2018 21: 43
                  Quote: dr.star75
                  strongly! especially the fact that Russia lost in 1mln about 10mln people. Australians with 60 thousand strongly. yes, take off my hat!

                  It was necessary to protect the soldiers, not shells.
                  1. +3
                    11 November 2018 21: 50
                    Jews succeeded greatly in this. The Jewish army suffered the smallest losses!
                    1. -2
                      11 November 2018 22: 09
                      Quote: dr.star75
                      Jews succeeded greatly in this. The Jewish army suffered the smallest losses!

                      Judging by the fact that at least half a million Jews fought in the Russian Army by 1916, their losses were hardly less than the Australian ones. In the British army, 10 thousand Jews were killed, 8 thousand in the French, 15 thousand killed and wounded in the US Army, 12 thousand killed in the German army, 30 thousand in the Austro-Hungarian and many in the armies of Turkey, Bulgaria and Romania. For a people without a state, this is a rather big loss.
                      1. +2
                        11 November 2018 22: 14
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        fishing for the fact that by 1916 at least half a million Jews fought in the Russian army,

                        This is based on what happened ??????
                      2. -3
                        11 November 2018 22: 18
                        Based on statistics. Google it.
                      3. +2
                        11 November 2018 22: 26
                        you want to say. what during 1mv more Jews died than Russians? Did I understand your post correctly?
                      4. -3
                        11 November 2018 22: 29
                        No. In the Russian army during the 1mv, 2016 thousand Jews fought for 500. Losses among them probably corresponded to the average for the tsarist army
                      5. +3
                        11 November 2018 22: 30
                        500 thousand Jews? WHERE did you get this from?
                      6. -1
                        11 November 2018 22: 35
                        Quote: dr.star75
                        500 thousand Jews? WHERE did you get this from?

                        Internet to help you.
                      7. +1
                        11 November 2018 22: 39
                        Quote: Aron Zaavi
                        Internet to help you.

                        Well then Jerusolim is Istanbul.
                      8. +1
                        11 November 2018 23: 44
                        Quote: Aaron Zawi
                        Quote: dr.star75
                        500 thousand Jews? WHERE did you get this from?

                        Internet to help you.

                        Have you read it on wikipedia?
                      9. +1
                        11 November 2018 23: 29
                        Quote: dr.star75
                        500 thousand Jews? WHERE did you get this from?

                        In the years 1914-1917 About 600 thousand Jews served in the Russian army, at least 100 thousand of them died at the front. The repressions against the Jewish population of the front line and the suppression of the facts of heroism provoked a public response. Jewish charitable organizations have been active in the field of assistance to refugees, evicts and victims of war

                        https://www.jewish-museum.ru/exhibitions/evrei-rossii-i-pervaya-mirovaya-voyna/
                      10. +1
                        11 November 2018 23: 43
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        No. In the Russian army during the 1mv, 2016 thousand Jews fought for 500. Losses among them probably corresponded to the average for the tsarist army

                        "for sure" - well, this is the argument of course laughing
                      11. 0
                        12 November 2018 08: 30
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        No. In the Russian army during the 1mv, 2016 thousand Jews fought for 500.

                        A couple of million Jews lived in Russia at that time. Of these, men of draft age are about 500 thousand. And all as one rushed into the trenches ?? Do not make me laugh!
                      12. 0
                        12 November 2018 10: 46
                        About 4 million Jews lived in the Russian Empire.
                      13. 0
                        12 November 2018 11: 45
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        About 4 million Jews lived in the Russian Empire.

                        Well, suppose 4 million. Of these, men of military age are about a million. Including oblique, lame and wretched. Of these, half fought ??? Do not make me laugh.
                      14. 0
                        12 November 2018 12: 21
                        From 1914 to 1917? It is possible)) Half - 2 million
                        Every 4 men fought - 500 thousand
                        What's wrong?
                      15. 0
                        12 November 2018 12: 33
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        From 1914 to 1917? It is possible)) Half - 2 million
                        Every 4 men fought - 500 thousand
                        What's wrong?

                        The calculations are wrong. 4 million people, this is all, men, women, children and the elderly. Of these, about 2 million men (probably less), including children and the elderly. Of these, about 1 million are of draft age, including all patients who are not subject to draft for various reasons and others who have slanted. There remains something about 500 thousand, which theoretically could be called up. And yet they called everyone ?? The USSR was straining harder, and not everyone was called upon.
                      16. 0
                        12 November 2018 12: 46
                        They called on everyone, about 100 thousand died. 468 thousand Jews participated in the Second World War (according to other estimates, taking into account the “Tashkent” Polish Jews - 490 thousand) with 3 million 210 thousand of the Jewish population of the Union.
                      17. 0
                        12 November 2018 13: 10
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        with 3 million 210 thousand of the Jewish population of the Union.

                        What are you jumping to the Union? If for the Second World War the figures stated by you are quite plausible, then for 1 MV there is no.
                      18. 0
                        12 November 2018 13: 24
                        I do not jump to the Union laughing
                        Quote: Sergey Medvedev
                        The USSR was straining harder, and not everyone was called upon.

                        Quote: Sergey Medvedev
                        If for the Second World War the figures stated by you are quite plausible, then for 1 MV there is no.

                        You do not take into account the "geographical" factor. During the 1st mv, the bulk of the Jewish population of the Republic of Ingushetia lived in the Western regions of the countries, close to hostilities, respectively, the first and largest calls were from there. As in the Second World War, with the difference that Poland, where many Jews lived, became an independent state, and a significant part of the Jewish population moved to Moscow and Leningrad
                      19. 0
                        12 November 2018 13: 43
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        During the 1st mv, the bulk of the Jewish population of the Republic of Ingushetia lived in the Western regions of the countries, close to hostilities, respectively, the first and largest calls were from there.

                        Not this way. The Serbian crisis did not develop for three hours. Mobilization began long before the outbreak of hostilities and not only in our country. And there was no sudden attack that could justify your claim that they called those who are closer. As far as I remember, these two armies, led by Samsonov and Rannenkampf, invaded Prussia to save the French.
                      20. 0
                        12 November 2018 12: 56
                        Quote: Krasnodar
                        Quote: dr.star75
                        Jews succeeded greatly in this. The Jewish army suffered the smallest losses!

                        Judging by the fact that at least half a million Jews fought in the Russian Army by 1916, their losses were hardly less than the Australian ones. In the British army, 10 thousand Jews were killed, 8 thousand in the French, 15 thousand killed and wounded in the US Army, 12 thousand killed in the German army, 30 thousand in the Austro-Hungarian and many in the armies of Turkey, Bulgaria and Romania. For a people without a state, this is a rather big loss.

                        The valiant French army, without the help of the Russian expeditionary force, was going to surrender its capital! Obviously this is a sign of great military art by the French generals? negative
                    2. -3
                      11 November 2018 22: 09
                      Quote: dr.star75
                      Jews succeeded greatly in this. The Jewish army suffered the smallest losses!

                      Too big for me. And for the interests of others.
                      1. +2
                        11 November 2018 22: 16
                        Quote: Aron Zaavi
                        Too big for me. And for the interests of others

                        Well, do not go into all the holes, there are plenty of stingers. understand without you.
                    3. 0
                      12 November 2018 09: 14
                      Quote: dr.star75
                      Jews succeeded greatly in this. The Jewish army suffered the smallest losses!

                      My great-grandfather died in 1914. He was a soldier of the imperial army.
                      And grandfather during the Second World War went to the same places ...

                      But you keep stigmatizing. Raise self-esteem.
                2. +4
                  11 November 2018 21: 44
                  dr.star75:Well yes, well yes! I probably missed the moment when the Indians and most importantly, attention! "AUSTRALIANS" - fought and lost their citizens

                  Michael, what about Galipoli, have you heard anything?
                  1. 0
                    11 November 2018 21: 51
                    Dmitry, have you heard anything about the attack of the dead?
                    1. +3
                      11 November 2018 22: 06
                      why bite? You yourself write:
                      I probably missed the moment when the Indians and most importantly, attention! "AUSTRALIANS" - fought and lost their citizens

                      to which I gave you a link to Galipoli
                    2. -2
                      11 November 2018 22: 10
                      Russian corps in France.
                3. +3
                  11 November 2018 22: 48
                  10 million is the irretrievable loss of all participants. According to various sources, Russia lost from 1,7 to 2 million, about the same number of Germans, smaller, but comparable Austro-Hungarians and French.
    2. 0
      12 November 2018 17: 14
      Quote: dr.star75
      ? Especially touching with a dot on the forehead!

      Uh, these, with dots, bloodsheds were shed in the WWII a lot. Like the New Zealanders. Yes, and all the British colonies.
  13. +2
    11 November 2018 20: 07
    And who next to Putin put Panin in makeup? laughing
  14. +4
    11 November 2018 20: 08
    One thing I don’t understand, on whose side was Israel in World War I ....
    1. maw
      +2
      11 November 2018 20: 14
      And everyone needs marketitants.
    2. +3
      11 November 2018 20: 19
      Quote: Humpty
      One thing I don’t understand, on whose side was Israel in World War I ....

      1.5mln Jews fought during WWII. A separate Jewish unit was part of the British Army.
      1. +3
        11 November 2018 20: 41
        So the Jews fought. And it's about Israel.
      2. +3
        11 November 2018 20: 43
        Wait, 1MV, a lot of people are chopped, after 100 years they have gathered, calmed down. What does Israel have to do with it?
        1. -3
          11 November 2018 20: 58
          Quote: dr.star75
          Wait, 1MV, a lot of people are chopped, after 100 years they have gathered, calmed down. What does Israel have to do with it?

          Israel is a state representing the Jewish people at the ceremony.
          1. +2
            11 November 2018 21: 19
            Quote: Aron Zaavi
            Israel is a state representing the Jewish people at the ceremony.

            And on which side did he participate? laughing laughing
            1. -2
              11 November 2018 21: 26
              Quote: dr.star75

              And on which side did he participate? laughing laughing

              And on which side did the Russian Federation participate?
              1. +3
                11 November 2018 21: 28
                From the Entente! And Israel?
                1. -2
                  11 November 2018 21: 45
                  Quote: dr.star75
                  From the Entente! And Israel?

                  And we had a fratricidal war. Jews killed Jews for the interests of other nations.
                  1. +2
                    11 November 2018 21: 56
                    Quote: Aron Zaavi
                    And we had a fratricidal war.

                    Well, we also cut down for the fatherland.
                    The question remains: Israel was fighting for which side? I understand the Jewish question to answer the question with a question! But not with me! So for whom did Israel fight in 1mv? Whom did Netanyahu represent?
            2. +1
              11 November 2018 21: 33
              From all sides
              On the fields of the First World War, more than one and a half million Jewish soldiers fought in the ranks of the opposing armies - Russian and German, British and Austrian, French and American ... More than 200 thousand of them fell on the battlefields.

              British Field Marshal Sir John Monash and Austrian Field Marshal Samuel von Halazi, dozens of Austrian, French, Italian generals and admirals, thousands of German officers and hundreds of thousands of Russian soldiers were Jews and fought in the armies of their countries, voluntarily or involuntarily fulfilling the ancient Halachic law from Babylon: “The law of the country is the law for the Jew”, which requires Jews to be absolutely loyal to the states of which they are citizens.
              1. +1
                11 November 2018 21: 36
                Quote: brigadir
                From all sides

                so Israel noted: victory or surrender?
                1. -2
                  11 November 2018 21: 46
                  Quote: dr.star75
                  Quote: brigadir
                  From all sides

                  so Israel noted: victory or surrender?

                  The end of fratricide
                  1. +2
                    11 November 2018 22: 05
                    Quote: Aron Zaavi
                    The end of fratricide

                    Thanks to Comrade Stalin for our happy childhood! laughing
                    1. +1
                      12 November 2018 04: 51
                      Quote: dr.star75
                      Thanks to Comrade Stalin for our happy childhood!

                      They must erect a monument to Stalin for:
                      the only Jewish administrative-territorial formation in the world, besides Israel, with official legal status
                      1. 0
                        12 November 2018 10: 24
                        Quote: ROSS 42
                        Quote: dr.star75
                        Thanks to Comrade Stalin for our happy childhood!

                        They must erect a monument to Stalin for:
                        the only Jewish administrative-territorial formation in the world, besides Israel, with official legal status

                        And how many Jews live there?
                        Okay, let’s make it easier. And what is the maximum percentage of Jews in the population of the EAO in the entire history of its existence?
                        From wikipedia:
                        the number of Jews in the EAO never exceeded two percent of the population and with great difficulty managed to find a person with a Jewish surname for the post of first secretary of the regional committee

                        But you still need to erect a monument!
    3. +4
      11 November 2018 21: 09
      Quote: Humpty
      One thing I don’t understand, on whose side was Israel in World War I ....

      On the side of the arms barons and money-lenders ... However, as in 2 MB ...
    4. +1
      11 November 2018 23: 45
      Quote: Humpty
      One thing I don’t understand, on whose side was Israel in World War I ....

      From all sides, of course wink
      1. +1
        12 November 2018 05: 01
        Quote: Humpty
        One thing I don’t understand, on whose side was Israel in World War I ....

        There is such data:
        In addition, the law of December 6, 1915 provided additional deferrals to persons of military service of all categories who worked for defense. Among them:
        • new recruits - 99850;
        • militia warriors younger than 26 years old - 175650;
        • those who worked on the construction of railways - 72000;
        • employees of freelancers in the Ministry of Railways - 173498;
        • employees in zemstvo and city unions - 5352;
        • employees of institutions of military-industrial committees - 976312;
        • employees in private credit institutions - 3700 people.
        The total number of deferred workers working for the defense was 1506362.

        There they served ... We plowed ... I don’t believe something in this massive heroism taken from Wikipedia.
  15. 0
    11 November 2018 20: 20
    "It became known that in Paris, on the sidelines of the celebration of the 100th anniversary of the end of the First World War, a meeting between Russian President Vladimir Putin and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu took place." Was it rubbed behind the curtains? Or, on the run, they caught ours behind the floor, and while the guards ripped them off, he managed to complain about life?
    "Lobby (from French couloir - corridor) - utility rooms, corridors and side halls in the building of parliament, institutions, theaters, concert halls."
    1. -1
      11 November 2018 20: 42
      utility rooms

      Caught in the toilet, or what? ...
  16. ZVS
    0
    11 November 2018 20: 22
    If Netanyahu said "excellent", then he got carte blanche
    for further bombing of Syria.
    1. -2
      11 November 2018 20: 29
      Yes, not Syria, but Hezbollah with the Iranians.
    2. +1
      11 November 2018 20: 29
      Wait and see, but for now you can guess as many
      1. -2
        11 November 2018 20: 44
        but for now you can guess as much


        Yes, no .., most likely I heard: "... okay, live for now ..."
  17. -4
    11 November 2018 20: 29
    Wow, before flying to France, Netanyahu answered the journalist’s question that his plans did not include a meeting with Putin, apparently, this meeting was important to the president.
    The leaders of the security agencies said that the S-300 in Syria does not threaten military aviation, but threatens with a civilian plane. If there is a threat to military aircraft, the installation will be destroyed.
    Alas, the destruction of the S-300 could undermine its sales, Russia fears this ...
    1. +3
      11 November 2018 21: 15
      Quote: alta
      The leaders of the security agencies said that the S-300 in Syria does not threaten military aviation, but threatens with a civilian plane. If there is a threat to military aircraft, the installation will be destroyed.

      Well what kind of nonsense, you seem to have slept badly the other day belay
  18. +3
    11 November 2018 20: 30
    Vladimir, what is Israel ?! Benya, Israel - everything! Very soon everything.
    1. +1
      11 November 2018 20: 39
      Quote: Good
      +1
      Vladimir, what is Israel ?! Benya, Israel - everything! Very soon everything.

      !+ good Subtly ... Odessa steers .. laughing
  19. +2
    11 November 2018 20: 31
    Oh, hospyda. Bibi’s police affairs are one after another - that person will be removed for corruption or for mischievous women (he likes to eat delicious food at public expense). With Gaza, it is not clear what - the money in Hamas’s suitcases is transferred, in millions !!!!! It is necessary to somehow translate the attention. You can say Israel - the main participant in the First World War - but at least on TV appeared among the world leaders. And then bread - and then a solid negative in life.
    But I talked with Putin / did not talk-who cares? what's the use ... the main thing is that everyone is healthy and the children study well.
    1. 0
      11 November 2018 22: 01
      I don’t understand how clever times chose such an idiot as Bibi ?! It doesn’t fit in my head!
      1. +1
        11 November 2018 23: 41
        Why an idiot? The two countries that did not suffer losses from the financial crisis of 2008 were Germany and Israel. Everything is OK with the economy, he just healed very much and too much believed in his own star.
      2. +1
        12 November 2018 09: 26
        Quote: Andrey Nikolaevich
        I don’t understand how clever times chose such an idiot as Bibi ?! It doesn’t fit in my head!

        Bibi is a top manager. Super. How he holds his motley coalition is to learn and study for everyone. Graduated from MIT. From a professorial family. He was an officer of the special forces of the General Staff, participated in the liberation of Saben's aircraft from terrorists. Was injured.
        Everyone is simply "looking for" him: the press, the opposition. The people do not love his wife, and it costs a lot.
        The main problem of him and his coalition - as for me - is no strategy. As if the situation, as it is now, could go on forever. And his party is a rotten apple. They’re even close to me in ideology, but I can’t vote for them - that’s Mr. parliamentarians from Likud (as the Bibi party is called).
        Bibi is far from dee, she is simply pursuing a policy based on the specific situation for today, and not strategically .... Although in Israel, the one who strategically takes action will not last longer than a year in power. Here is such a vicious circle.
        1. 0
          12 November 2018 17: 13
          Hello. Thanks for the answer. Everything is brief and clear.
          If the conversation has already begun, then answer me, how did the idiot Petya Poroshknko be allowed into the Knessit? Or did the Jews forget that they were doing OUN sheep with Jews? Jews, I am ashamed of you! A shame!
          1. 0
            12 November 2018 18: 18
            Quote: Andrey Nikolaevich
            Hello. Thanks for the answer. Everything is brief and clear.
            If the conversation has already begun, then answer me, how did the idiot Petya Poroshknko be allowed into the Knessit? Or did the Jews forget that they were doing OUN sheep with Jews? Jews, I am ashamed of you! A shame!

            My deceased grandmother told me what the policemen did to the Jews - she managed to escape from the ghetto and to nip to the partisans, and the partisans "parachuted" from the mainland were lucky - a detachment named after Chapaev. Local, even "Soviet" partisans - Jews were simply killed. I myself find the current names of streets in Ukrainian cities disgusting: Petliura, Bender, Shukhevych. But.
            Poroshenko - the legitimate / elected head of Ukraine, adopted around the world - this must be reckoned with. In addition, Jews still live in Ukraine. It’s not enough, but they are there and this must be taken into account - even Prime Minister Groisman - why should they complicate their lives. And do not try the intra-Russian anti-Ukrainian hysteria with the state. TV channels projected to the whole world. This is for domestic use. And in Germany there are neo-Nazis in Russia. What happened during the Second World War - was. I have more than half of the family destroyed the Germans with the cops. A new relationship needs to be built. In America, a neo-Nazi went into the synagogue and shot a bunch of Jews there. So now what, quarrels and breaks off relations with the USA?
            1. 0
              13 November 2018 10: 13
              Dear, do not go too far — the neo-Nazi in the synagogue and Poroshenko with the glorification of the underbelly of Bandera. I understand that Jews are smart people and diplomatic .. but it’s necessary to be a “hell” that you cannot cross. Otherwise, under the general silence of the Jews, they will again begin to be pushed into the gas chambers.
              And then, I am Russian and grew up among the Jews. Therefore, I respect this people.
              PS By the way, and I swear in your language, great. :-)
  20. +1
    11 November 2018 20: 36
    Will the S-300 be launched again? Or change to S-400?
  21. 0
    11 November 2018 20: 57
    Quote: Occupant
    what (garden plant) did the Jew come to the anniversary of the end of the 1st World War? Then there was no trace of Israel ... hi

    Apparently, on the one hand, this is a tribute to the Jews who gave the Christian world Jesus Christ, the Virgin Mary. Yes, and John the Baptist, who performed the first holy baptism, was a Jew.
    And all four Gospel writers were Jews. And all twelve apostles.

    On the other hand, I looked at Google: in World War I, more than 1 million Jews fought in the fields of World War I, often fought against each other, by the way, about 500 thousand Jews in the Russian army took part in World War I ....
    1. -1
      11 November 2018 21: 14
      1) John did Atbala (rite of purification before the end of the world and the coming of the Messiah) was called baptism later
      2) Luke was a non-Jew
      3) It would be better instead of giving respect, they gave money. For the participation of 1,5 million potential Israeli citizens laughing
  22. -1
    11 November 2018 21: 08
    Double disrespect: to the fallen in the First World War, and to the crew of the aircraft. It looks like a demonstration of power on the one hand and dependence on the other.
  23. -1
    11 November 2018 21: 13
    Quote: Tusv
    Well, we will see how Israeli pilots versus Russia, Mothers will fight.
    Is that gut thick?

    History needed to know ....
    In Egypt, at the request of President Gamal Abdel Nasser, the Soviet 135th Fighter Aviation Regiment was stationed .... Five Soviet MiG-21 fighters were shot down over Sinai.
    It happened in 1970 .... Theoretically, the Soviet Union could respond to this attack, but it could lead to a direct clash with the United States, so the Soviet pilots no longer took part in the air war with Israel.
  24. +1
    11 November 2018 21: 15
    Leaked all the same. No one does it better than them.
  25. -1
    11 November 2018 21: 46
    All this is disgusting, reminds me of dancing on the bones of our dead children ...
  26. 0
    11 November 2018 21: 59
    And Poroshenko there? .. Ukraine is also a state ?!
  27. +3
    11 November 2018 22: 11
    I remember that President Abama also complained that Netanyahu is annoying and penetrates everywhere and is similar in style of communication to a bed bug.
  28. +1
    11 November 2018 22: 43
    US Ambassador to Syria James Jeffrey said Washington hopes that Russia will allow the Israeli army to bomb "Iranian targets" after the delivery of Russian S-300 systems to the SAR.

    “Russia must be condescending and allow Israel to strike at Iranian targets in Syria. We hope that this will happen soon, ”Business Insider quoted the ambassador as saying.
  29. -1
    12 November 2018 01: 34
    and who is next to the guarantor in such fashionable polt? New wife? Clearly Bibi is Putin's favorite. While daddy is pouting, but is ready to forgive. The photo shows his kind eyes.
  30. 0
    12 November 2018 08: 23
    BB: - Let's talk?
    GDP: - Your special forces in the golan were handed out lule ...
    BB: - I have to go.
  31. +1
    12 November 2018 08: 34
    The meeting between Putin and Netanyahu is a meeting of serious politicians and leaders of states.
  32. +1
    12 November 2018 13: 20
    And what did Zhidanyahu do on the anniversary of the victory in World War I? Israel, as it were, did not participate. Or will history be rewritten now?