Military Review

Duda: we have forgiven the Germans, but the question of the payment of reparations is not closed

63
Poland recounted its losses during the Second World War and considers the question of reparations from the FRG is still open. RIA News statement by the President of Poland Andrzej Duda.



I believe that the topic of reparation payments is not yet closed,
said duda.

According to him, in the Polish parliament this question was raised by a group of experts. The deputies agreed to discuss this topic and decide what to do next and what steps to take.

This is “a matter of truth and responsibility,” the president added.

Moreover, if humanly, the Polish people do not feel hatred for the Germans. The Poles are Catholics, they forgive each other, he noted.

Meanwhile, in the Polish Sejm, they cannot yet decide on the specific amount of reparations. The maximum demands that were raised there were $ 850 billion. More modest calculations speak of $ 48,8 billion. In October, Arkadiusz Mularczyk, head of the parliamentary committee on reparation payments, said that Warsaw would recalculate WWII losses and present the exact amount to Berlin.

The Sejm also stated that the new requirements for Germany will become a “reminder of justice, that belongs to Poland.”

But apart from a sense of justice, according to Oleg Nemensky, a senior researcher at the Russian Institute for Strategic Studies, the Polish side is driven by a purely pragmatic element: until the year 2020, Poland will continue to receive good money from the European Union, and then not. Therefore, flirting with Brussels and Germany, the reasons for Warsaw is becoming less and less.

The expert is not sure that the entire Polish political community hopes to receive reparations, nevertheless, there is a fairly large group of people in the power structures, which is very serious about this.

In Berlin, the question of war reparations Poland considered closed.

Recall that during the Potsdam Conference (1945 year) an agreement was reached, according to which the Poles received reparations from the share of the USSR coming from the eastern zone of Germany. Later, the USSR and Poland entered into an agreement, which ceased to collect reparations from the GDRs with 1954.
Photos used:
https://ru.depositphotos.com
63 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Benjamin Gnomes
    Benjamin Gnomes 28 October 2018 16: 30
    +18
    it’s known for lip whiskers than, rather than reparations) reparations are only for circumcised from the desert))
    1. ANCIENT
      ANCIENT 28 October 2018 16: 40
      +3
      Benjamin-Poland is not much less Jews than in Israel, hence the desire for freebies, but more, more, more ...
      1. Shurik70
        Shurik70 28 October 2018 17: 23
        +3
        How many Poles are trying to prove that they are not Slavs, but the Europeans themselves.
        But in love for the magic word "Хalyava "(with a capital letter) even surpassed the Russians.
        Russians love a freebie too, but all of them in childhood read the Russian fairy tale about the Golden Fish. Apparently, the Poles have no analogue of this tale.
        1. The black
          The black 28 October 2018 17: 37
          +6
          The thirst for freebies is ineradicable on the lands of the former Rzeczpospolita. "You sit, and dumplings themselves jump into your mouth" laughing.... They feel the parasites that the euro budget is waiting for contraction. And Madame Merkel I advise you to give them a reparation in the form of Arab migrants. wassat
          1. Arh
            Arh 28 October 2018 20: 22
            -1
            You can milk from the Germans as much as you want until you get tired and until I get enough of yours, I’m not talking about conscience, they are killers !!!
            1. Shurik70
              Shurik70 28 October 2018 21: 06
              0
              Do you believe yourself that "milking" can get bored?
              They ride whoever is lucky. And those who do not want to carry should regularly give such "riders" well in the teeth. And if there is a soft "not necessary", then they will try to put on a saddle. Until they put it on.
      2. Detective
        Detective 29 October 2018 09: 08
        0
        Sometimes there is a persistent feeling that the Poles are Slavic Jews!
      3. Dr.KonradMorgen
        Dr.KonradMorgen 29 October 2018 14: 47
        +1
        in Poland there are not much less Jews than in Israel

        Yeah. About 10 thousand bully
      4. Sergej1972
        Sergej1972 29 October 2018 15: 29
        +1
        No, now there are few Jews in Poland.
    2. ancestors from Don
      ancestors from Don 28 October 2018 17: 05
      +3
      the Poles are really cool, they live off EU subsidies in which the Germans are the main donors and they also need reparations))).
      1. Andrey Yuryevich
        Andrey Yuryevich 28 October 2018 17: 41
        +3
        Duda: we forgave the Germans
        dadu dadu ...
      2. Machito
        Machito 28 October 2018 18: 19
        +3
        The issue of reparations is closed. Late to drink Borjomi when the kidneys refused. In general, the Germans can also raise the issue of Silesia and Pomerania, the Poles drove the Germans out of there, in which the mother gave birth. I know one more country a beggar, Ukraine is called. So they send her there, where they will send Poland.
        1. Piramidon
          Piramidon 28 October 2018 19: 34
          +2
          Quote: Bearded
          The issue of reparations is closed. Late to drink Borjomi when the kidneys refused. In general, the Germans can also raise the issue of Silesia and Pomerania, the Poles drove the Germans out of there, in which the mother gave birth. I know one more country a beggar, Ukraine is called. So they send her there, where they will send Poland.

          We need to roll out the lawsuit to the Poles. Let them answer for Susanin. And the French for burned Moscow in 1812.
  2. Kent0001
    Kent0001 28 October 2018 16: 34
    +14
    Then let them return to the Germans the lands that had been cut from Germany to Poland after the war.
    1. plotnikov561956
      plotnikov561956 28 October 2018 16: 58
      +8
      The question of the German lands ... cut off to Poland remains open ... and the Poles will not think enough when the Germans will solve it ... and they will solve it ... definitely.
      1. Bull Terrier
        Bull Terrier 28 October 2018 17: 07
        +2
        The Germans will not do this for the next 100 years. Until the memory of the Second World War is erased in history. More precisely, the attitude to this war in the world will not be forgotten.
    2. Major Yurik
      Major Yurik 28 October 2018 17: 18
      +12
      Quote: Kent0001
      Then let them return to the Germans the lands that had been cut from Germany to Poland after the war.

      I just think that the Poles should show the capture and two years of residence in Moscow, in the "all inclusive" mode from 1610 to 1612! Plus for the arson of Moscow, also to collect at the highest rate. Then, together with Napoleon, these restless arsonists pressed on again and again burned Moscow! He can sue these arrogant people for a two-year freebie and robbery of the population, as well as violation of fire safety rules when visiting Moscow, when no one calls them there !!! am
      1. Machito
        Machito 28 October 2018 18: 23
        +2
        Poles can also show a lot of things. With this attitude towards neighbors, all neighboring countries have claims against Poland. And let's divide it, and deport the Poles to our beloved America. Not a bit of air poisoning here.
      2. LSA57
        LSA57 28 October 2018 19: 04
        +1
        Quote: Major Yurik
        I just think that the Poles should show the capture and two years of residence in Moscow, in the "all inclusive" mode from 1610 to 1612!

        Well, after all, the Sumerians brought a lawsuit to the Mongols.
        and these are worse
        1. Dr.KonradMorgen
          Dr.KonradMorgen 29 October 2018 12: 03
          -1
          Well, after all, the Sumerians brought a lawsuit to the Mongols.

          In fact, this is the purest fake that took place back in May 2015.
          The Ukrainian site Obozrevatel told its readers such a story, but indicated that it was a fake of the Zvezda television channel. By the way, material on the history of Mongolia was published on the website of this channel, but it was presented as a joke. Although “Zvezda” spread this news on its pages on social networks in such a way that readers took the “sensation” at face value.
    3. Bykov.
      Bykov. 28 October 2018 17: 21
      0
      Quote: Kent0001
      Then let them return to the Germans the lands that had been cut from Germany to Poland after the war.

      Not to the Germans, but to us. Stalin gave - Putin took.
      1. The comment was deleted.
  3. ANCIENT
    ANCIENT 28 October 2018 16: 38
    +3
    we need Pshekia to bring a lawsuit only for the shot Red Army soldiers of the Tukhachevsky trillion five euros, and for the fact that they received the whole hundred trillion euros from the USSR, we need to squeeze them out - or take away the land received after the war as part of the amount of debt from our lawsuit.
  4. A good one
    A good one 28 October 2018 16: 38
    +9
    "Duda: we have forgiven the Germans, but the issue of paying reparations has not been closed."

    How much generosity and borrowed American arrogance. smile
  5. Non liberoid Russian
    Non liberoid Russian 28 October 2018 16: 40
    +4
    Psheks have been used since 1945 to handouts-grants-help to live ... in short to a freebie from the USSR-EU ... and the faucet will soon close ... here they are looking for ways to replenish the budget
  6. Jerk
    Jerk 28 October 2018 16: 45
    +6
    Hospada ... Idiocy spreads around the planet ... No, everything is clear, this crustacean (see the slave pose in Trump's office) is trying hard to lick the master - and the example of neighboring Ukraine does not teach him anything.
    * Ukraine fed from trade with the Russian Federation. She chopped it off herself, the USA threw them.
    * Poland is fed by the EU, and Germany is its head. He begins to teach Germany how to live - and this despite the fact that the Germans have already opaque declared Europe 2 speeds. The US will not give up when the EU ceases to feed?
    laughing However, 2 circuses in one region will not survive - competition. And soon, both will die. And Duda - not only did the unreasonable reparations that they ALREADY received, also managed to ultimatively say - we, POLAND, ORDER you to chop off the Nord Stream. Poland - Germany? Orders?
    It’s just like in Holopia. The result will be the same
    1. Rurikovich
      Rurikovich 28 October 2018 17: 24
      +3
      Quote: Jerk
      Poland - Germany? Orders?

      The Poles think that if their uncle Sam uses as he wants and also gives candy for the moaning, then you can kick with your foot at the same roommate in bed wassat But uncle Sam can play enough and leave, then anarchy will come in the harem, and the hair will survive in the strongest, who is also the caretaker of the harem. Will Poland be stronger than the strongest? what ...
  7. HAM
    HAM 28 October 2018 16: 49
    +6
    But did the Germans forgive! ??
    Nobody forgives or loves beating ....
    They will demand from us for release, wretched ....
    1. Jerk
      Jerk 28 October 2018 16: 58
      +10
      There you can still recall that WWII count began with the Shot of Sudeten Germans, and it ended with it. And if in the first case it’s still possible to write off propaganda somehow, then the second case, after the war, when the Poles in Sudeten civilians, civilians, were shot on camera — these were their own, Polish, photocores and they shot ...

      1. Machito
        Machito 28 October 2018 18: 26
        +4
        A section of Czechoslovakia with Hitler?
      2. Dr.KonradMorgen
        Dr.KonradMorgen 29 October 2018 14: 41
        0
        In fact - the Sudeten Germans lived, were until October 1938 in Czechoslovakia. And by the beginning of World War II, they had been in the Reich for almost a year now.
      3. Sergej1972
        Sergej1972 29 October 2018 15: 30
        0
        The Sudetenland is Czechoslovakia.
  8. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 28 October 2018 16: 53
    +2
    They won’t get ANYTHING. Relations with Germany will be ruined. And where will the Poles be put to, who will be driven out of Britain after Brexit? Here is a headache, not these miserable Wishlist. They won’t get anything anyway. Even if the entire Anglo-Saxon army will fit in for them ... laughing
    1. Bull Terrier
      Bull Terrier 28 October 2018 17: 10
      +3
      Yes, they do not count on money. Hype is important to them about this. Stab Germans, put pressure on them. The Poles seriously believe that their role in the European Union is small and so they want to raise it. It’s like with your Baltic friends. They will always demand from us. It’s just profitable.
  9. Lara Croft
    Lara Croft 28 October 2018 16: 59
    +3
    Poland recounted its losses during World War II and considers the issue of reparations by the FRG still open, RIA Novosti reports the statement of the President of Poland Andrzej Duda.

    Meanwhile, in the Polish Sejm they still cannot decide on the specific amount of reparations. The maximum requirements that rose there are $ 850 billion. More conservative estimates indicate $ 48,8 billion.

    And the territory of East Prussia, Poland does not want to return Germany.
    Yes, and Danzig did not interfere with the return of the status of a free city.
    In 1945, 126 German citizens of Danzig were expelled, and 472 Poles from central Poland and 101 immigrants from eastern Polish territories who, after the war, became part of the USSR, arrived in their place. As of 873, about 26 thousand former citizens of the Free City lived in Germany, 629 1950 were “checked” and received Polish citizenship
  10. Bykov.
    Bykov. 28 October 2018 17: 16
    +6
    The "hyena of Europe" was drooling.
  11. bald
    bald 28 October 2018 17: 44
    0
    I wonder what this money will be started up for, or shoved into - let it keep on blowing.
    1. helmi8
      helmi8 28 October 2018 19: 10
      +2
      Quote: bald
      I wonder what this money will be started up or shoved

      No matter what. They (money) where they were will remain there. Well, the Poles, right, will do the trick themselves, you know what tune ... laughing
  12. Proton
    Proton 28 October 2018 17: 44
    +3
    Very bad when gdaza exceed the size of the stomach laughing , reach out to the alternate pans.
  13. Masya masya
    Masya masya 28 October 2018 17: 44
    +9
    Duda thinks thinking .... thought of ... lol
    1. Jolly oldster sailor
      Jolly oldster sailor 28 October 2018 18: 28
      +3

      Sea-to you ...
      1. Masya masya
        Masya masya 28 October 2018 18: 39
        +8
        So there it is, the sea! .. Burns with turquoise,
        It sparkles with pearl foam!
        On a wet sandbank wave after wave
        Runs up anxiously and hard ...
        Take a look, he lives, this shaky crystal,
        He groans, threatens, resents ...
        And what a distance! .. Oh, how this distance
        Tired eyes enchant!
        Son of the edge of blizzards, mists and blizzards,
        Son of gloomy and pale nature,
        How ardently, how eagerly I rushed south
        To you, measuredly noisy waters! ..
        1. Jolly oldster sailor
          Jolly oldster sailor 28 October 2018 18: 46
          +5
          Son of the edge of blizzards, mists and blizzards,
          Son of gloomy and pale nature,

          Thanks youSun...... love love love love love love
    2. atesterev
      atesterev 29 October 2018 00: 27
      +3
      ... but in fact it will be.
  14. The comment was deleted.
  15. Terenin
    Terenin 28 October 2018 18: 11
    +5
    Duda, your mother ... let's count the reparations with the FRG faster, otherwise these Germans will already count you, Poland, for sure yes .
  16. tihonmarine
    tihonmarine 28 October 2018 18: 12
    +3
    After the war, the Poles received reparations in the amount of a third of modern Poland, which had departed from Germany. But human greed has no limit.
  17. Ross xnumx
    Ross xnumx 28 October 2018 18: 13
    +2
    Duda: we have forgiven the Germans, but the question of the payment of reparations is not closed

    It’s not for you to forgive today's Germans, who are mostly not to blame before you. And then we remember 1612. Return the land to Germany and pull the tail, brave fighters. Poles are your profession.
  18. anjey
    anjey 28 October 2018 18: 35
    +1
    Duda: we forgave the Germans
    No need to summarize, you can’t forgive the Nazis for crimes, but the German people themselves are the victor, the USSR forgave and gave a new historical milestone in life with the subsequent unification, divided by the people's war, so who are Psheks to mumble something against this background ???
  19. swyatoslav
    swyatoslav 28 October 2018 19: 08
    +3
    "Poland is the hyenas of Europe" - W. Churchill.
    As they say, not in the eyebrow, but in the eye!
    1. atesterev
      atesterev 28 October 2018 21: 22
      +1
      And it would be necessary in the crotch
    2. Dr.KonradMorgen
      Dr.KonradMorgen 29 October 2018 14: 55
      0
      It was literally said by Sir Winston:
      "England, leading France, proposes to guarantee the integrity of Poland - the very Poland that just six months ago (the quote refers to March 1939) hyena greedy took part in the robbery and destruction of the Czechoslovak state. "

      And in the Reich Foreign Ministry, Poland was called only "the hyena of the battlefield".
  20. Andrei Nikolaevich
    Andrei Nikolaevich 28 October 2018 19: 12
    +2
    This Poland should still Germany! For the fact that not all psheks were exhausted ..
  21. varakin_54
    varakin_54 28 October 2018 19: 28
    +2
    Duda, it's time to return Pomerania and Selizia to Germany, and then talk about reparation.
  22. APASUS
    APASUS 28 October 2018 19: 37
    +3
    Poland, having lost the war, covered by the Soviet Union and thanks to the Russian soldiers, was preserved on the map, does it require reparations from Germany? Even now, EU-dependent Poland is not aware of its inferiority.
  23. Sands Careers General
    Sands Careers General 28 October 2018 19: 52
    +3
    The Poles were completely stunned when you consider that it was because of their greyhound that the Second World War began.
    Pretentious and inadequate people with a claim to the state "from sea to sea", but not having the slightest opportunity for this, due to their pretentiousness and inadequacy.
    They also drove to Germany with reparations. Mind, no.
  24. atesterev
    atesterev 28 October 2018 21: 13
    0
    Let the Germans do business with the Poles as reparations, they will give hohland to them, but only Western.
  25. SASHA OLD
    SASHA OLD 29 October 2018 01: 27
    0
    pshek need a new sponsor that's all
  26. aszzz888
    aszzz888 29 October 2018 01: 59
    0
    In October, the head of the parliamentary committee on reparations, Arkadiusz Mulyarchik, said that Warsaw would recount the losses from World War II and show Berlin the exact amount.

    ...want is not harmful... laughing
  27. Retvizan 8
    Retvizan 8 29 October 2018 05: 58
    0
    Oh, and Poland’s authorities!
  28. Dr.KonradMorgen
    Dr.KonradMorgen 29 October 2018 11: 51
    0
    Poland recounted its losses during World War II and considers the issue of reparations by the FRG still open

    Ghm ... As far as I know - Germany officially closed this issue in the days of the NDP ...
  29. Detnix
    Detnix 29 October 2018 12: 00
    0
    As this Polish whining got, I hope history will make one more round, and we with the Germans will share these whiners.))
  30. 23424636
    23424636 29 October 2018 19: 05
    0
    it’s time to file a presentation with Ivan Pshekowski for Ivan Susanin and the Russian genocide during the Time of Troubles, including the rape of the novice of the Novodevichy Convent. The venerable Deonis Abbot of the Trinity Monastery went into the ass of these creatures and saved Great Russia, let the GDP not be modest but wish them amero liquefied natural gas for competitive development
  31. little way
    little way 29 October 2018 20: 08
    0
    Jackal psheks must first remember at whose expense these by whom and the creatures were freed. Or does Duda think that Pshekiah itself saved the Germans? A few Poles nemchura burned.
  32. Metallurg_2
    Metallurg_2 29 October 2018 20: 09
    0
    new requirements for Germany will become a “reminder of justice, that belongs to Poland”

    Do not forget to return Slesian to the Germans ...