Military Review

Serious violations. The Accounting Chamber checked the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation

48
Inspection of the activities of the Russian military in 2017 revealed an illegal use of various resources totaling more than 544 billion rubles, reports TASS.


Serious violations. The Accounting Chamber checked the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation


During the implementation of the external state audit (control) in 2017, violations were revealed, including the inefficient use of federal and other resources, for a total amount of 544,5 billion rubles, according to a report of the Accounts Chamber.

It is reported that "according to the results of the control measures, funds in the amount of 71,2 million rubles were returned to the federal budget."

Among the revealed violations, it is indicated, among other things, “provision of deliberately inaccurate budget reporting for the specified period (2017 year) to the Court of Accounts”.

In addition, "the procedure for the provision of medical care (including high-tech assistance) to servicemen and beneficiaries is not regulated by the normative legal acts of the Russian Federation." Also, the issues “related to making a decision on the source of inpatient medical care in the military medical institutions of the Russian Ministry of Defense with respect to non-beneficiaries” have not been resolved.
Photos used:
Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation
48 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The comment was deleted.
  2. PFT
    PFT 16 May 2018 13: 28
    +6
    So they got to the generalshey Shevtsova. Serdyukov and Vasilyeva haven’t been around for a long time, and their business (embezzlement of money) continues and flourishes.
    1. Hire
      Hire 16 May 2018 13: 37
      +30
      Do you understand the difference between inefficient use and theft? Apparently - no. I will explain it to you. If your wife sent you to the store to buy kefir, and you bought beer, this is an inefficient use. And if, having choked on beer, you climbed into the piggy bank of your children to “add”, this is theft. Is this clear? And do not gag. smile
      1. PFT
        PFT 16 May 2018 13: 45
        +5
        Quote: Hire
        use and theft understand

        "Non-legal use of various resources in the amount of 544 billion, including inefficient use," see the DIFFERENCE ???
        1. Nyrobsky
          Nyrobsky 16 May 2018 14: 23
          +6
          Quote: PFT
          "Non-legal use of various resources in the amount of 544 billion, including inefficient use," see the DIFFERENCE ???

          In my opinion, it’s too early to draw any hasty conclusions and appoint the perpetrators. Today, the Ministry of Defense is one of the most effective ministries, whose activities are like a bone in the throat of our "well-wishers" from Washington, the Pentagon and NATO. I do not affirm, but I cannot deny the presence of “their interest” in the conclusions of “our” Accounting Chamber, since they are delighted with any disruption in the work of the ministry. Dummies in any take a lot of time, effort and money. Something is confirmed, something is not ... The Accounts Chamber will remain on the sidelines. There, things can be mainly solved by transferring the allocated money from one expense item to another expense item, and here the “accountants with prosecutors” are already chasing the tsunami and preparing the bunks.
          1. Nikolai Grek
            Nikolai Grek 16 May 2018 23: 54
            +3
            Quote: Nyrobsky
            Quote: PFT
            "Non-legal use of various resources in the amount of 544 billion, including inefficient use," see the DIFFERENCE ???

            In my opinion, it’s too early to draw any hasty conclusions and appoint the perpetrators. Today, the Ministry of Defense is one of the most effective ministries, whose activities are like a bone in the throat of our "well-wishers" from Washington, the Pentagon and NATO. I do not affirm, but I cannot deny the presence of “their interest” in the conclusions of “our” Accounting Chamber, since they are delighted with any disruption in the work of the ministry. Dummies in any take a lot of time, effort and money. Something is confirmed, something is not ... The Accounts Chamber will remain on the sidelines. There, things can be mainly solved by transferring the allocated money from one expense item to another expense item, and here the “accountants with prosecutors” are already chasing the tsunami and preparing the bunks.

            yes there it is all in terms ... it is necessary to climb and delve into !!! wassat wassat laughing laughing laughing but in essence - "... the amount of budget funds" with signs of misuse or inefficient use "(corruption or theft can be part of such violations) amounted to about 40 billion rubles, or 2% of the total amount of financial violations, follows from the Accounts data the chambers ... "
            and that’s for general expenses ".. budget system expenses (federal budget plus the budgets of regions and extra-budgetary funds) in 2017 amounted to 32,4 trillion rubles, according to the Treasury. Thus, the amount equivalent to 5,8% of all was spent with violations government spending ... " request request

            Read more at RBC:
            https://www.rbc.ru/economics/16/05/2018/5afb0aa29
            a79474409677396? from = newsfeed
          2. Skif83
            Skif83 17 May 2018 10: 58
            0
            Well, it’s not in vain that Kudrin was put on the Accounting Chamber. He will dissuade someone, and drown someone on the contrary. Probably, to dismiss those who misuse money, and to drown those who are trying to Russia, including and raise the Army, but how else? Someone believes in the government of DAM, Siluanova curls, which have a budget surplus of 4 trillion rubles. and salaries and pensions at some kind of Uganda?
            You need to put him in other public institutions, but ... you can see his plan is so ... happy laughing lol fool
        2. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek 16 May 2018 23: 45
          +3
          Quote: PFT
          "Non-legal use of various resources in the amount of 544 billion, including inefficient use," see the DIFFERENCE ???

          you do not get involved in amateur performances of local authors !!! wink laughing laughing laughing Further "illegality" in a strange way turns into inefficiency !!! wassat wassat see the difference ??? laughing laughing laughing but if it’s really interesting, then here is the link ... https: //www.rbc.ru/economics/16/05/2018/
          5afb0aa29a79474409677396? From = newsfeed .... I read it yesterday, it’s painted more or less normally !!! soldier Interestingly, the total inefficient costs are very small !! request request

          Well, explanations are given that "inefficiency" and other terms are not always something criminal or bad !!! request request

          "... However, the issue of inefficiency in spending funds does not necessarily mean the existence of a criminal offense, the expert clarifies. This may be an incorrect allocation of budget funds, technical violations that also entail responsibility on the part of those who committed them, but not so serious, he says ... "

          Member of the expert council of the collegium of the Military-Industrial Commission, Colonel Reserve Viktor Murakhovsky also notes that the violations identified are often formal.

          “... Most likely, we are talking about incorrect or untimely paperwork and incorrect conduct of some competitive procedures,” the military expert explained. According to him, with the existing pricing system, almost all funds can be considered inefficiently used ...

          Read more at RBC:
          https://www.rbc.ru/economics/16/05/2018/5afb0aa29
          a79474409677396? from = newsfeed
      2. MPN
        MPN 16 May 2018 13: 48
        +13
        Quote: Hire
        If your wife sent you to the store to buy kefir, and you bought beer

        And if you went for a beer and suddenly bought yogurt, and letting the change (anyway, there’s already not enough beer) put the children in a piggy bank .... laughing
        1. Hire
          Hire 16 May 2018 13: 52
          +10
          good afternoon hi
          Quote: MPN
          And if you went for a beer and suddenly bought yogurt, and letting the change (anyway, there’s already not enough beer) put the children in a piggy bank ....

          laughing If not the wife sent, then this is malicious “inefficient use."
          1. MPN
            MPN 16 May 2018 13: 54
            +10
            Quote: Hire
            If not the wife sent, then this is malicious “inefficient use."

            I thought so too ..., he clarified simply whether I think so alone ... laughing
          2. Alex-a832
            Alex-a832 16 May 2018 14: 57
            +3
            Quote: Hire
            If not the wife sent, then this is malicious “inefficient use."

            good laughing
            Now all this creation of auditors will be checked by other departments. And not the fact that at least 10% of this amount is confirmed as a significant violation. While you are hanging over the auditor’s soul and for every penny you argue with him, he considers it adequate, but give them freedom ... Once, the auditor somehow calculated the violations by three different methods and added up the result, receiving more than the sum of the contract. All this was introduced into the act and reported to the higher. We laughed and cursed on black. Bottom line: rechecking confirmed 0% of violations from the "identified". These are the results of the audit ...
        2. Nikolai Grek
          Nikolai Grek 16 May 2018 23: 21
          +2
          Quote: MPN
          Quote: Hire
          If your wife sent you to the store to buy kefir, and you bought beer

          And if you went for a beer and suddenly bought yogurt, and letting the change (anyway, there’s already not enough beer) put the children in a piggy bank .... laughing

          laughing laughing formally, it will also be considered inefficient use !!! request lol lol lol
      3. eugraphus
        eugraphus 16 May 2018 13: 52
        +7
        Instead of kefir, beer is not the intended use of funds. And not effective use - this is when it seems like he bought kefir, but he spilled some, did not put some in the refrigerator and he became moldy, that is, he transferred the product.
        1. Hire
          Hire 16 May 2018 13: 54
          +8
          Quote: eugraphus
          Instead of kefir, beer is not the intended use of funds. And not effective use - this is when it seems like he bought kefir, but he spilled some, did not put some in the refrigerator and he became moldy, that is, he transferred the product.

          Yes, perhaps you're right. It will be more accurate. smile hi
      4. PFT
        PFT 16 May 2018 13: 57
        +1
        Quote: Hire
        you climbed into your children’s piggy bank to “add”, this is theft. Is this clear? And do not gag.

        If you steal from your children, then it’s clear. Here the budget money, that is, MY (I pay taxes), so it is clear. drinks
      5. wellaut
        wellaut 16 May 2018 14: 15
        +4
        Dear zealot of legal subtleties, I will answer you this way: in my opinion, a simple layman says that one thing that is simply called the other is theft.
        And casuistry was invented to make it easier to otmazyvat managers who steal.
        Like the same Serdyukov, he is a hero, almost a relative of Medvedev, and they have found a loophole in the law.
        1. Tatanka Yotanka
          Tatanka Yotanka 16 May 2018 14: 37
          +1
          to make it clear 2 Crimean bridges stolen and another 100 lards for beer left to wash fellow
      6. Ross xnumx
        Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 14: 38
        +1
        Quote: Hire
        Do you understand the difference between inefficient use and theft?

        Do you understand the difference between buying yogurt and actions that qualify as undermining combat readiness? Something a lot of lawyers divorced. there is "The order of the commander (chief) - the law for the subordinate"and that’s it ... Round - to wear, square - to roll ...
        Correctly wrote about Shevtsova. A woman in the army can be neither a general nor a colonel ... No. Only lieutenant colonel (or sub major) lolForgive me the flight crew ... soldier
      7. Incomprehensible
        Incomprehensible 16 May 2018 14: 59
        +1
        Quote: Hire
        If your wife sent you to the store to buy kefir, and you bought beer, this is an inefficient use.

        In this particular example, this is called inappropriate use of allocated funds)
      8. Pulya
        Pulya 17 May 2018 05: 28
        0
        Do you understand the difference between inefficient use and theft? Apparently - no

        Well, yes - well, yes ... you explain this to your wife when you take beer instead of kefir :)
        Sweetheart, this is just not the intended use of our budget ... all in a bunch :)
        Your wife will quickly fix your brains where necessary :) :)
    2. siberalt
      siberalt 16 May 2018 13: 42
      +2
      He will come to the Audit Chamber Kudrin, recount in his own way, and everything will be cheeky - bunches. lol
    3. Anatole Klim
      Anatole Klim 16 May 2018 13: 44
      +1
      Quote: PFT
      So they got to the generalshey Shevtsova. Serdyukov and Vasilyeva haven’t been around for a long time, and their business (embezzlement of money) continues and flourishes.

      After the resignation of Serdyukov and his assistants, Shevtsova, one of the few from the team of Serdyukov, kept her post, although she submitted a report for dismissal back in 2012, but Shoigu rejected Shevtsova's report with the wording to perform duties until a new specialist is found. But how many years have passed already, but they have not found a replacement for her, maybe they didn’t want to, or maybe they’ll now look for it.
      1. Nasrat
        Nasrat 16 May 2018 14: 21
        +1
        Quote: Anatole Klim
        Quote: PFT
        So they got to the generalshey Shevtsova. Serdyukov and Vasilyeva haven’t been around for a long time, and their business (embezzlement of money) continues and flourishes.

        After the resignation of Serdyukov and his assistants, Shevtsova, one of the few from the team of Serdyukov, kept her post, although she submitted a report for dismissal back in 2012, but Shoigu rejected Shevtsova's report with the wording to perform duties until a new specialist is found. But how many years have passed already, but they have not found a replacement for her, maybe they didn’t want to, or maybe they’ll now look for it.

        Why replace it .... Shoigu is happy with "established" relations ... he also understood this from the Ministry of Emergencies .. wassat
    4. Alexey RA
      Alexey RA 16 May 2018 14: 49
      0
      Quote: PFT
      So they got to the generalshey Shevtsova. Serdyukov and Vasilyeva haven’t been around for a long time, and their business (embezzlement of money) continues and flourishes.

      There is not only theft, but also inefficient use. And under this, for example, you can summarize the work on hydroaerodromes for the beloved Shoigu Be-200.
      FSUE “Spetsstroyengineering at Spetsstroy of Russia” announced a tender for design and survey work on the object: “Construction of the Zavoyko hydroaerodrome in Zavoyko village, Kamchatka Territory” (object code P-34/13) ”in the amount of 79 (seventy nine million forty-six thousand eight hundred thirty-seven) rubles 046 kopecks, including 837,00% VAT on the procurement website.
      The sole executor of the order on November 28, 2014 was the Federal State Unitary Enterprise “Main Directorate of Special Construction on the Territory of the Southern Federal District under the Federal Agency for Special Construction” (short name - FSUE GUSST No. 4 under Special Construction of Russia).
      The deadline for the submission of documentation (urban planning documentation, surveys, engineering surveys, design documentation) is set 30.06.2015/XNUMX/XNUMX.
      © bmpd
      This hydroaerodrome is located at the exit of Avacha Bay into the open ocean. And it requires, in addition to the marine part, a concrete runway. Moreover, the Be-200 is an amphibious aircraft and is quietly based on conventional runways. By the way, besides this airdrome, it was planned to design another one - in the freezing bay.
      And most importantly, the Be-200 MO did not receive it. And this was already clear at the time of ordering the project - for the plant was already breaking all the deadlines for the previous Be-200 order for the Ministry of Emergencies.
      1. water
        water 16 May 2018 19: 55
        0
        Quote: Nyrobsky
        In my opinion, it’s too early to draw any hasty conclusions and appoint the perpetrators. Today, the Ministry of Defense is one of the most effective ministries, whose activities are like a bone in the throat of our "well-wishers" from Washington, the Pentagon and NATO. I do not affirm, but I cannot deny the presence of “their interest” in the conclusions of “our” Accounting Chamber, since they are delighted with any disruption in the work of the ministry. Dummies in any take a lot of time, effort and money. Something is confirmed, something is not ... The Accounts Chamber will remain on the sidelines. There, things can be mainly solved by transferring the allocated money from one expense item to another expense item, and here the “accountants with prosecutors” are already chasing the tsunami and preparing the bunks.
        - I am inclined to believe that this is the only "sober" assessment of the information given in the article. No, I do not want to say that they do not steal in the RF Armed Forces. Alas, they steal! They steal, as elsewhere. It is clear that in the course of the investigation, the amount of 544 billion will be "blown away" first by an order of magnitude, then further reduced by a multiple. Unfortunately, “inflating” the sum of shortcomings and misappropriations is a common practice of “provers” trying in this way to increase their significance. And the reason is simple - no one gives them ears for dishonest checks!
        Although, in principle, it can really be a “run over” to Shoigu by order of someone’s foreign “partners”.
  3. rocket757
    rocket757 16 May 2018 13: 29
    +2
    Now we let Kudrin into the “battle” and will we see?
    1. PFT
      PFT 16 May 2018 13: 48
      +2
      Quote: rocket757
      Now we let Kudrin into the “battle” and will we see?

      Looks like Golikova was therefore removed, KAPNULA deeply.
      1. rocket757
        rocket757 16 May 2018 14: 19
        +2
        I’m a skeptic in a cube; my life has flown to sharp, prickly corners! So I will put it this way - Nothing there, in the imperious ban-n-n community, does not happen without a team from the top ... though there are clearly a few tops!
        They dig only under the one who was allowed to bury.
        Nothing new, nothing unusual.
        1. Ross xnumx
          Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 14: 42
          +1
          Quote: rocket757
          Nothing there, in a powerful ban-n-th community, happens without a command from above.

          Dismissal, however, had a place to be, but paper reporting sometimes overlaps visibility ...
          1. rocket757
            rocket757 16 May 2018 15: 09
            +2
            In the words of W. Churchill, about the similar "Undercover bickering of bulldogs!" - they don’t invite us to look under the carpet, they’ll say, write it off, whatever.
            It wasn’t very interesting anyway, and after the appointment of a famous person as prime minister, it all became absolutely all right, I don’t expect anything good from that, in principle.
  4. Non liberoid Russian
    Non liberoid Russian 16 May 2018 13: 30
    +1
    SCA Kudrin Medvedev counts)))) while Putin does not slow down and will nightmare his checks
    1. Vadim237
      Vadim237 16 May 2018 13: 33
      +2
      Let them inspire everyone with nightmares - they can steal and spend in the wrong places, they will be less.
  5. Berkut24
    Berkut24 16 May 2018 13: 36
    0
    SchA Kudrin "come, order is in sight ..." He has in his subcortex a dislike for MO. Well, at least with some benefit, you can use this accountant. Away from the gold reserves of Russia, closer to the footcloths. Mutual education. Ingenious!
    1. DenZ
      DenZ 16 May 2018 14: 25
      0
      I do not think that this is ingenious (well, if only in the context of its separation from gold reserves). In addition to the footcloths, the army has a lot more. As if with his checks (and you can get to the bottom of the post) Kudrin did not torture those who at least try to do everything wisely and without theft in the Moscow Region. We will see in general.
  6. Dead duck
    Dead duck 16 May 2018 13: 38
    +4
    inefficient use of federal and other resources, totaling 544,5 billion rubles

    Based on the results of the control measures, funds in the amount of 71,2 million rubles were returned to the federal budget

    I feel not what we are doing ... what
  7. Munchhausen
    Munchhausen 16 May 2018 13: 53
    +1
    I do not say to make money, even they can’t spend normally.
    1. naidas
      naidas 16 May 2018 14: 01
      +2
      You cannot earn it normally, but people earned 544,5 billion rubles, funds returned in the amount of 71,2 million rubles, the difference is good earnings.
      1. Munchhausen
        Munchhausen 16 May 2018 14: 10
        +1
        Yeah, Mystechny bises)
        And the profit is 544,5bn. - 71,2 million will be taken to the bank, where they will also be thrown))
  8. Andrey NM
    Andrey NM 16 May 2018 14: 29
    0
    Trying to merge Kuzhugetych? If the army goes in the right direction, then you need to decapitate it ...
    1. Ross xnumx
      Ross xnumx 16 May 2018 14: 46
      0
      Quote: Andrey NM
      Trying to merge Kuzhugetych?

      Kuzhugetovich has long had to retire. After 60 in the army there is nothing to do, because one thing to believe in words, and to see with your own eyes and make decisions based on your own opinion (knowledge of military science) is a completely different matter. We must give way to the young ...
      1. Andrey NM
        Andrey NM 17 May 2018 13: 19
        0
        Quote: ROSS 42
        After 60 in the army there is nothing to do

        Suvorov and after 70 gave the enemy about .... smiling ...
  9. alex3075
    alex3075 16 May 2018 15: 13
    +1
    Quote: eugraphus
    Instead of kefir, beer is not the intended use of funds. And not effective use - this is when it seems like he bought kefir, but he spilled some, did not put some in the refrigerator and he became moldy, that is, he transferred the product.

    Ineffective use is when I bought kefir, bought beer, and did not take vodka. Vodka without beer or beer without vodka.
  10. The comment was deleted.
  11. Sinbad
    Sinbad 16 May 2018 17: 42
    0
    The question is who heads the accounting chamber and "whose mill is pouring water." Today, the Russian armed forces are the most effective structure, in the sense of development and influence on world politics. Casting a shadow on the army, and if it works out, at least somehow weakening it, is the dream of many of our “partners”, and the agents of their influence, alas, are more than enough.
    1. Nikolai Grek
      Nikolai Grek 17 May 2018 00: 04
      +2
      Quote: Sinbad
      The question is who heads the accounting chamber and "whose mill is pouring water." Today, the Russian armed forces are the most effective structure, in the sense of development and influence on world politics. Casting a shadow on the army, and if it works out, at least somehow weakening it, is the dream of many of our “partners”, and the agents of their influence, alas, are more than enough.

      Yes, no one ... this is precisely the work of the Accounts Chamber ... there was a general check ... they wrote here only about the Defense Ministry !!! request request request
  12. ochakow703
    ochakow703 16 May 2018 17: 46
    0
    Of course, I can be mistaken, and not all angels are in the Ministry of Defense, but at least kill me, I believe the Accounting Chamber even less. Well, like that ...
  13. shirkoled
    shirkoled 16 May 2018 19: 47
    +1
    Well, this question will resolve the darkest !!!
  14. Hiller
    Hiller 16 May 2018 21: 13
    0
    Who is there in the heads of the military medical department ??? "Submit Lyapkina-Tyapkina here"
  15. migys
    migys 23 May 2018 09: 52
    0
    Report of the Accounts Chamber - an official document and the facts of violations speak for themselves. And what types of violations - theft, ineffective, inappropriate, illegal, etc. - the second question. Radish horseradish is not sweeter.

    The main thing is that in the finances of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation there are more violations in the 2017 year than all the other main managers of budget funds; not counting only the space sphere. Almost a third (!) Of all identified joint ventures of violations accounted for by the Ministry of Defense.
    Moreover, these violations amounting to 544,5 billion rubles in the field of defense, security and law enforcement are just the visible part of the iceberg. The JV report states that a number of documents contain information constituting state secrets, and they are not published. Therefore, the full amount of violations in the MO is, quite possibly, even more. The last time this was in the days of Serdyukov.
    Read more here http://vfeu.ucoz.ru