"Besogon" Mikhalkov against the head of the Ministry of Emergencies. The Kremlin commented on the correspondence skirmish

Gaining momentum story with harsh criticism of the Minister Vladimir Puchkov and the entire Emergencies Ministry from the filmmaker Nikita Mikhalkov. The latter struck the work of the ministry in the next issue of the author's program "Besogon". According to Mikhalkov, today the staff of the department is simply not enough staff to extinguish fires. An illustrative fact here can be considered not only the tragedy in the SEC "Winter Cherry" in Kemerovo, but also a series of last year's fires in Rostov-on-Don.

From the program of Nikita Mikhalkov:

What is proposed to optimize costs - to save, right? How can I save? The fewer people, the less money you have to pay - right? Right. But they have to pay severance pay and wage arrears and as a result, the reduction leads to an increase. It's like gasoline to put out a fire. Something like this.
But the result. Just the facts. As of 2017, the average for the Ministry of Emergency Situations has been reduced to 30% of personnel, in sentries to 50%. Those. extinguish fires in 17 year, there was virtually no one. Very indicative story of the fire in Rostov-on-Don. It was a terrible August fire on 2017, when 150 houses burned down.

Mikhalkov:

First of all, the ministry’s flawed decisions should include the thoughtless and talentless approach of the so-called “optimization” of expenses for the current maintenance and increase of cost efficiency, which was reduced to a massive dismissal of employees of the Federal Fire Service in 2015-2016, as a result of which there was a gap in 60 Thousands of "bayonets" and battle calculations of reacting units were drained of blood. As a result of this - ineffective extinguishing fires.

Minister Puchkov disagreed with Mikhalkov’s opinion, to put it mildly. According to the head of the Ministry of Emergency Situations, the statement of the author and the presenter of "Bezogon" is "nonsense." At the same time, he added that the TV itself does not watch, but “regretted” all those who are viewers of “Besogon”.

Bundles:

I feel sorry for the people who watch these programs, sorry for those who believe this.

The press secretary of the president asked the journalists to comment on Mikhalkov’s correspondence squabble with the head of the Emergencies Ministry. Dmitry Peskov stated that he did not agree with Mikhalkov’s statements that “everything is ruined” at the Emergencies Ministry. At the same time, Peskov noted that all the problems of the ministry to the head of state are known. Speaking about the tragedy in the "Winter cherry", a spokesman for the president noted that the final conclusions should in any case make the result.

The same release of the program "Besogon":

Comments

[Russia]

They stand each other, clumsy some both.

[vorobey]

Quote: Rusland

They stand each other, clumsy some both.

there is such a thing ... I don’t look at both and don’t like both, but sometimes with firemen I thump
Yes, and there are clients from the fire control .. I know how they live .. Mikhalkov may have exaggerated, but there is some truth in his words .. and it’s significant ..

[Vadivak]

Quote: vorobey

and they don’t like both,

You do not know how to cook them

[vorobey]

Quote: Vadivak

Quote: vorobey

and they don’t like both,

You do not know how to cook them

Yes, I guys in general, in principle, as it is not very .. Hi..

[Vadivak]

Quote: vorobey

Hi..

Hi, Sasha, I’ve seen enough of this Ministry of Emergency Situations as you heard enough from the guys ... I don’t want to

[saltickov.]

I don’t want to overeat like fat cats that have succumbed, a man told the truth who else but the Mikhalkov is telling the truth.

[Baloo]

Quote: saltickov.

I don’t want to overeat like fat cats that have succumbed, a man told the truth who else but the Mikhalkov is telling the truth.

Here in our city, these same German firemen are cutting, so beautiful, with sparkles. And the chief Emergencies Ministry thought: where is the money for the service, spare parts? At the same time, there is one single staircase that is above the 11th floor to the whole republic, and there are more and more houses above 11. And what is worse than a fire truck based on KAMAZ or Zila? I would not refuse a fire at the ZIL base. The buildings are dense, in the yards between the cars you can’t squeeze through. What about respirators? And what did they find at the head of the Emergencies Ministry Kemerovo after the search, or is it a fake?
I support Mikhalkov, Puchkov-on a vacation to rest, those who, bypassing the government, allowed misuse of funds to investigators.

[the most important]

Quote: Balu

I support Mikhalkov, Puchkova-to rest on a pension,

And to appoint him a resting place in accordance with the merits - the sunny city of Magadan! 10 years.

[Ushly_bashkort]

There then, naturally, the 37th year will have to be arranged, half of the government to be sent to Magadan with families. As if the Magadans from such a contingent did not howl foolish =)

[Baloo]

Quote: Ushly_bashkort

send half of the government to Magadan with families. As if the Magadans from such a contingent did not howl foolish =)

There is a way: Magadans with things to Moscow.

[Lynx33]

It is high time, almost complete, along with the prime minister.

[just exp]

somehow it doesn’t mean that without much desire, but still there was a process.
since if it hadn’t existed, you would have written "yes, I’ve never been with peasants ...... (instead of the point of description that you never ......)."

[vorobey]

Quote: just EXPL

somehow it doesn’t mean that without much desire, but still there was a process.
since if it hadn’t existed, you would have written "yes, I’ve never been with peasants ...... (instead of the point of description that you never ......)."

who about what and you all dream of a man .. and we talked about gastronomy ..

[Logall]

Quote: vorobey

Mikhalkov may have exaggerated, but there is some truth in his words .. and significant ..

Then what could it mean?

At the same time, Peskov noted that all the problems of the ministry, the head of state is known

[vorobey]

Quote: Logall

Then what could it mean?
At the same time, Peskov noted that all the problems of the ministry, the head of state is known

Sanya, the problems of the Defense Ministry under Serdyukov were also known ..

maybe as an option to remove Medvedev from the next term .. this is so - thinkers ..

there are their summing up

[Russia]

Dissatisfaction with them is ripening, there are also firefighters acquaintances, scolding him for what the light stands on, attitude according to the residual principle

[Topotun]

Both are standing each other. And both of me do not cause any positive emotions. But the fact that in the Ministry of Emergencies the horsepower plows for itself and for a colleague who is not staffed is true. There is a familiar fireman. Plows like a horse. That's just his salary is not for two .....

[saltickov.]

This person is the only one among intellectuals who stands for the truth, the rest giggle.

[Lavrenti Pavlovich]

What is the truth? After the Shoigu, the Ministry of Emergencies only degrades, corruption, reductions ... If in the early 2000s there was a lack of equipment, now there is a lack of discipline, professionalism especially among the leadership, in short, the mess is growing.

[Rus2012]

Quote: Lavrenty Pavlovich

Ministry of Emergency Situations after Shoigu only degrades, corruption, reduction

... let's remember how it all began. And what was before ...
MOE arose not from scratch. There were shelves of civil defense and civilian services everywhere. Firefighters remember (such as when they were based). Recall who carried Chernobyl on his shoulders (and not only).
Yes! Then there were (steel) problems after the collapse of the Union. Shoigu - was in place.
Wait a minute, they probably want to return everything backwards: much of what is in the Emergencies Ministry is to transfer the Defense Ministry (including to revive the structures of civil defense), the firemen - the Ministry of Internal Affairs (or elsewhere).
Ministry of Emergency Situations - its function of the campaign performed ... it's time to translate / return to square one ...

[Igor V]

When the Ministry of Emergencies was created, engineering equipment was thrown out of the civil defense and fires were extinguished by bicycle pumps. There were fires in the USSR too, and when the explosives could not cope

[Igor V]

When the Ministry of Emergencies was created, the engineering component was thrown out of the civil defense and fires were put out by bicycle pumps. There were fires in the USSR, and when the explosives could not cope, they called GOs and then BATs, BTMs and MDKs localized the source of fire, the water supply companies pulled pipelines and drilled wells, the pyrotechnics extinguished the fires and created the oncoming fire, and the paratroopers extinguished them in hard-to-reach places. For doctors, too, work was found. And chemists probably rested. Like that.

[Vadivak]

Quote: Lavrenty Pavlovich

.MES after Shoigu only degrades

Of course with him, it flourished Porsche Cayenne MOE such a b .... nowhere in the world ....

[tol100v]

Quote: vorobey

Mikhalkov may have exaggerated, but there is some truth in his words .. and significant ..

Unfortunately, he did not even exaggerate! There has been a debate among firefighters for a long time: And how many fires should happen such as the Rossiya Hotel and the like, so that the situation with the Fire Department would not change, but at least return to a state of late "stagnation"!

[RUSS]

Quote: vorobey

Mikhalkov may have exaggerated, but there is some truth in his words .. and significant ..

Mikhalkov, "captain of evidence," said obvious things, but in general he is a specific flapper: Adaptation of businessman Boris Berezovsky in 1999, during the 1996 presidential election, Mikhalkov repeatedly spoke with words of support for Boris Yeltsin, and already in 2016 accused Mikhail Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin of criminal politics.
Also, this truth-seeker -In 2010, in an interview with REN-TV, Mikhalkov was asked whether it was true that he was driving with a flasher. Nikita Sergeyevich answered “yes,” “the flasher belongs to the Ministry of Defense,” thanks to the flasher, he “managed to shoot the film US-2.” He added that “it has always been like this and always will be like that!”

[Horst78]

Fire supervision Shoigu collapsed. I heard a lot of "flattering" words from them.

[konstantin68]

Mikhalkov does not lie: it is precisely the calculations that are being cut, that is, the "infantry". The bosses are all in the field.

[zloybond]

there is no truth, there are tons. The comrade fell under the same contraction in the Far East. duty officers and officers of the EMERCOM districts in Moscow will also confirm that the guards have been cut. constantly have to pull people and equipment from the side. And what about the regions? The fact that the purchases are not like trips, generally, as God puts the soul on the saw, only the lazy in the Ministry of Emergencies do not discuss. The fact that planes do not fly is a fact. Technique does not puff ... Much of what this minister did went awry.

[not main]

Quote: vorobey

Quote: Rusland

They stand each other, clumsy some both.

there is such a thing ... I don’t look at both and don’t like both, but sometimes with firemen I thump
Yes, and there are clients from the fire control .. I know how they live .. Mikhalkov may have exaggerated, but there is some truth in his words .. and it’s significant ..

So that's the point! The generals were bred, and ordinary firefighters leave for an emergency with a salary of 6 mp! But the generals! Yes, you count how many generals in the Ministry of Emergencies and how many in the Armed Forces! My father asked me yesterday, "you do not like generals?" I answered him: I do not like the Ministry of Emergency Situations! "At one time there was a civil defense system and did its job. And the Ministry of Emergencies is a feeding trough! You should have seen these pompous turkeys! I mean" generals "and not Fighters!

[Salavatsky Ministry of Emergency Situations]

Quote: non-primary

The generals spawn, and the emergency fire go ordinary firefighters

All right, only generals. And how many colonels ... There are about 7 colonels per fighter. You come to the Main Department - and there is a whole colonel's reserve.
In our city, the fire department is equipped with 60%, there are not enough ordinary extinguishers. There are vacancies, but no one is taken in their place - they were banned from the republic. There is a vacancy of the head of the unit - no one can be appointed, banned, save. And the Deputy Head has been fulfilling his duties and duties of the head for six months already.

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia! Repainted, calmed down the program "Besogon" created .. Quickly repainted hehe he barks! !
I know who he has on staff ....

[saltickov.]

The cutest on whose mill you pour water.

[saltickov.]

I have been watching the Mihan for a long time no, no, yes, some kind of muck will throw it away.

[Ross xnumx]

Quote: saltickov.

I have been watching the Mihan for a long time no, no, yes, some kind of muck will throw it away.

You do not watch him. All his comments can be expressed in several phrases:
Well, finally, men! It has long been necessary, heh heh ... Here they are not here ... Whether it was before ... It’s time to water them, it’s a pity to torture prostatitis ...
Mikhalkov, as an actor, is very successful and watchable. There are very good roles. Just do not need him to get involved in the game of autocracy and build a "Highness" from himself. Reveals sharply enough, only sense?

[Baloo]

Quote: saltickov.

I have been watching the Mihan for a long time no, no, yes, some kind of muck will throw it away.

not quite healthy old man. The word is ahead of thought.

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Quote: saltickov.

I have been watching the Mihan for a long time no, no, yes, some kind of muck will throw it away.

Mikhalkov is a good actor, but most often he played “how many personalities” He played himself!
He has any power on the crest of a wave .. And he kills many Russian directors and artists, everyone knows that .. Then I will not say anything, think for yourself if you have enough mind.

[free]

Quote: MIKHAN

Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia! Repainted, calmed down the program "Besogon" created .. Quickly repainted hehe he barks! !
I know who he has on staff ....

Is Mikhalkov wrong? Yes or no?

[Vitaly Anisimov]

Quote: free

Quote: MIKHAN

Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia! Repainted, calmed down the program "Besogon" created .. Quickly repainted hehe he barks! !
I know who he has on staff ....

Is Mikhalkov wrong? Yes or no?

NO! This is not his dog business .. There is someone to figure it out! It would be better if I figured it out in my own cinematography, such chaos is happening there .. He takes into account the life of Russia, weather vane litter!

[free]

Quote: MIKHAN

Quote: free

Quote: MIKHAN

Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia! Repainted, calmed down the program "Besogon" created .. Quickly repainted hehe he barks! !
I know who he has on staff ....

Is Mikhalkov wrong? Yes or no?

NO! This is not his dog business .. There is someone to figure it out! It would be better if I figured it out in my own cinematography, such chaos is happening there .. He takes into account the life of Russia, weather vane litter!

Whose dog business is this?

[Tatanka Yotanka]

Quote: MIKHAN

Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia

and demons believe and tremble (James 2:19)

[didra]

Tatanka Yotanka (stas) Yesterday, 19:28 ↑
Quote: MIKHAN
Mikhalkov is the most demon in Russia
and demons believe and tremble (James 2:19)
Do you understand what you wrote? Just wondering.

[Black_Vatnik]

Mikhalkov is a typical weather vane, like his dad.
But in fairness, if at least half of what he said about the Ministry of Emergencies is true, and I think that there is more truth there, then this is a zvezdets.

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Black_Jacket

Mikhalkov is a typical weather vane, like his dad

It’s just not clear where the wind was going to blow. This optimization of everything and everything has already gotten overhaul. It would be better if the oligarchs were optimized. Well, yes, that’s what London will do. And for myself and for that guy, now many state employees are working hard, and not just in the Ministry of Emergencies.

[andrej-shironov]

Mikhalkov, like his dad for the homeland, has done many times more than you and many here taken together. With all my weak respect for Mikhalkov as a shifter.

Quote: Black_Jacket

Mikhalkov is a typical weather vane, like his dad.
But in fairness, if at least half of what he said about the Ministry of Emergencies is true, and I think that there is more truth there, then this is a zvezdets.

[Black_Vatnik]

And what did you mean by that? Rhetorical question.

[andrej-shironov]

Quote: Black_Jacket

And what did you mean by that? Rhetorical question.

And the fact that gluing labels is not the business of a thinking person.

[Black_Vatnik]

As if by the way, you yourself admit that he is a changeling ... that is, a weather vane is.

[andrej-shironov]

I admit, But dad then what does it have to do with it?

[Black_Vatnik]

So you already agree that in some cases labels can still be glued? Quickly convinced.
Among the literary intelligentsia of the USSR, Sergei Mikhalkov had the same reputation. To put it mildly, he was able to find an approach to any power.

[andrej-shironov]

It’s nice to hear about the literary intelligentsia, ahem, which you can safely call the majority of them prostitution, about the opinion of Mikhalkov as a, ahem piece of this intelligentsia.
Concerning labels of any persuasion. For me, Nikita and Sergey have done many times more for the Homeland than you and many here.

[Black_Vatnik]

For me, Nikita and Sergey have done many times more for the Homeland than you and many here

You can repeat this 15 more times. But this in no way cancels the fact that Mikhalkov is a weather vane.
And yet ... everything that he did, as for me, he crossed out himself when he started making "films" on the basis of terry anti-Soviet.

[andrej-shironov]

Does it make sense to me to repeat this to you? Regarding the anti-Soviet, I agree. The demon beguiled him, was subject to conjuncture. But for me, he is justified by one of his films - "Among the strangers ..."

[sogdy]

Quote: andrej-shironov

labeling is not a matter of a thinking person

The process of “thinking” primarily consists in systematization. Systematization, as we know, is a process of evaluation and labeling.
And what is the strength? And power is in joules. So no tantrums.

[andrej-shironov]

You directly remind me of labels with Karl Linnaeus, who also preferred labels. But Darwin saw further and wider and the labels were not the main thing. Think about it, thinking person.

[sogdy]

Quote: andrej-shironov

But Darwin saw farther and wider

Which of the three? Choose from: Charles, James, John.

[andrej-shironov]

In your case, any.

[sogdy]

John, an anthropologist, gave the scientific rationale that Tasmanians are animals. Tasmanian meat was sold at a whale price in Europe.
James, an anthropologist, author of The Origin of the Races. The consequences you need to know. The author of Darwinism.
Charles, an anatomist and surgeon, has developed a number of practical techniques for cardiac surgery. In his youth, he published diary entries "Journey to the Beagle", which gave arguments in favor of the theory of natural evolution _Pastera_. Scotland Yard is better known as a coroner.

Quote: andrej-shironov

But Darwin saw further and wider and the labels were not the main thing. lol Think about it, thinking person.

Your example is absurd. Both the peer and the two sirs were still those systematizers ("label stickers"!).

[andrej-shironov]

Your example is absurd. Both the peer and the two sirs were still those systematizers ("label stickers"!).

My example is normal. Apparently they didn’t attach much importance to the labels If you managed to surpass Linnaeus.

[Baloo]

Quote: andrej-shironov

Mikhalkov, like his dad for the homeland, has done many times more than you and many here taken together. With all my weak respect for Mikhalkov as a shifter.

With all the rulers, the Mikhalkov clan served primarily the people of Russia. You shouldn’t be so.
But the question is serious, there can be no two opinions. Puchkova on a pension.

[andrej-shironov]

Quote: Balu

Quote: andrej-shironov

Mikhalkov, like his dad for the homeland, has done many times more than you and many here taken together. With all my weak respect for Mikhalkov as a shifter.

With all the rulers, the Mikhalkov clan served primarily the people of Russia. You shouldn’t be so.
But the question is serious, there can be no two opinions. Puchkova on a pension.

You are not me, you are writing to a superior person.

[Yuyuka]

Quote: Black_Jacket

Mikhalkov is a typical weather vane, like his dad.
But in fairness, if at least half of what he said about the Ministry of Emergencies is true, and I think that there is more truth there, then this is a zvezdets.

communicated with a person - for more than 20 years in a fire - what Mikhalkov said is the tip of the iceberg ... there really is no one to work ...

[keeper03]

And what do you have against a weather vane? He perfectly performs its functionsshowing where the wind is blowing! And those forces that "blow" on Mikhalkov, and he himself - I have sympathy and respect !!!

[PalBor]

Quote: Rusland

They stand each other, clumsy some both.

One word - Romanians.
One, indeed, reduced the employees who work “in the field.” Another anti-Soviet-Russophobic films are made, a friend of Medinsky and Kolchak. Both are the greatest authorities, Mlyn.

[Lynx33]

That they clung to Mikhalkov, while he was engaged only in films, especially the last ones, I didn’t even watch them, I don’t like his approach to directing, but TV besogon is something. I began to respect Mikhalkov. A citizen of his country with a capital letter. In order to cut the truth of the uterus from the screen of the federal TV, it is necessary to have steel eggs, while he is trying to get to the bottom of things. I respect you.

[himRa]

Frankly, I do not really respect Mikhalkov as a person even less as a screenwriter and producer ... as a politician, he also did not take place.
In this case, too, gaining votes on the tragedy! Disgusting ...

[Astoria]

Regarding Mikhalkov, I agree, but there are conclusions from the Accounts Chamber (and the facts are stubborn), Puchkov needs a good bill along with the backs of execution (and this is still mild), not counting the total confiscations of the whole kin to the seventh generation.

[himRa]

Quote: Astoria

Regarding Mikhalkov I agree, but there are conclusions of the Accounts Chamber

Then, attention, why is the reputation of a person whose reputation is not high used for voicing problems?
I still think this is the initiative of Mikhalkov himself and whether there will be serious consequences for Puchkov, but he will definitely raise the rating of the program
Therefore, the reaction: abomination

[Astoria]

Voiced by a member of ONF on the channel Россия 24 but it's still not RenTV,

Therefore, the reaction: an abomination

- well, this is your business, true it is generally not always a pleasant thing.

Two ex-heads of the EMERCOM departments were under investigation - on the charge of misuse of more than 1,7 billion budget rubles, the former director of the EMERCOM development department Alexander Tomashov was placed in jail. Earlier, the ex-head of the financial and economic department of the Ministry of Emergencies, Rais Akhmadeev, was detained.

The Investigative Committee of the Investigative Committee of the Central District of Moscow incriminates 61-year-old Tomashov, part 2, art. 285.1 of the Criminal Code (misuse of budget funds committed on an especially large scale). As Kommersant’s sources in the power structures explained, an investigation into the criminal case was launched by the Investigative Committee in November 2017. The reason was the contracts of the Ministry of Emergencies for the supply of Be-200 amphibious aircraft to the Beran Taganrog Aviation NGO for the needs of the department. 1,74 billion rubles were allocated for these purposes, but new special equipment was never received. As a result, budget funds were spent on the purchase of other special equipment - cars, Mi-8 helicopters, etc. This circumstance became the reason for checking the FSB and initiating a criminal case.

Now Alexander Tomashov claims during interrogations that he had no relation to the ill-fated contracts. At the same time, he refers to the fact that the transfer of money from airplanes to helicopters was discussed at the board of the Ministry of Emergencies, held in February 2016, four months before his appointment (Tomashov was then deputy director of the department of international activity of the same ministry). Therefore, he simply could not influence “the process of procurement formation”.

According to interlocutors in law enforcement agencies, Alexander Tomashov knew about the interest of the FSB and the criminal case for at least three months, but did nothing. They also specified that the ex-official, who left the Ministry of Emergencies about a year ago, could not find any luxury items and luxury real estate - he was detained in an apartment that he received 15 years ago from the Ministry of Defense.

According to some reports, the arrest of Tomashov is related to the testimony of another person involved in this case - the former head of the financial and economic department of the Ministry of Emergencies, Rais Akhmadeev. He was detained shortly after the initiation of the criminal case, but after giving explanations he was transferred to house arrest.

Telegram channels claim that the head of the Ministry of Emergency Situations, Vladimir Puchkov, is also going on in the case, the testimony of which was given by Akhmadeev. And after the tragedy in the “Winter Cherry” shopping center, “provoked by the fictitious work of the fire department of the Ministry of Emergencies,” the minister may be arrested.
Read more: https://eadaily.com/en/news/2018/03/28/necelevoe-
ispolzovanie-vysshie-chiny-mchs-osvoili-17-mlrd-r
ubley

[himRa]

Quote: Astoria

Voiced by a member of the ONF on Russia 24 channel, but this is still not RenTV,

Colleague, such news only makes me happy! It makes me sad when I quickly get greased to the right cause
I didn’t understand your accent right away
Especially if they give the enchanting minister to the popular front!

[Victor N]

But there were tragedies. People are dying. Which Mikhalkov is the tenth matter. But he publicly blamed the minister, indirectly both the head of the cabin and the presidential administration. Responsible to respond! The accusations are very serious, stink of crime. You can’t be silenced! Write everywhere!

[himRa]

Quote: Victor N

Voiced by a member of ONF on Russia 24 channel, but this is still not RenTV

Quote: Victor N

Write everywhere!

Apparently, with “publicity”, everything is all right once they give their say on the channel, RUSSIA24, to the leaders of the public, popular front!
I am sure there will be consequences for the minister!
ps my comment is a sign of respect to your flag

[andrej-shironov]

Quote: Victor N

But there were tragedies. People are dying. Which Mikhalkov is the tenth matter. But he publicly blamed the minister, indirectly both the head of the cabin and the presidential administration. Responsible to respond! The accusations are very serious, stink of crime. You can’t be silenced! Write everywhere!

But as always, because of the slavish habit of the President, he could not blame!

[Andrey591]

"Forgot" about the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the traffic police, the police. Is everything okay there after the reduction?

[udincev]

Quote: Andrey591

everything is normal after the reduction?

Normal.
After a reduction in the security forces, the Russian Federation came out on the first place in the world in their number per thousand population.

[spirit]

It depends on what, if the people disperse those with batons, yes! There are many footprints of acquaintances there who are in a rush, people don’t sleep for days, no people.

[sogdy]

Quote: udincev

After a reduction in the security forces, the Russian Federation came out on the first place in the world in their number per thousand population.

Confirm the data, please. It is advisable, from official sources, not from an ugly training manual.

[udincev]

Quote: sogdy

It is advisable, from official sources, not from an ugly training manual.

If officially, then the Decree
http://publication.pravo.gov.ru/Document/View/000
1201712310010
This is the Ministry of Internal Affairs. + Rosguard, + FSIN + ...

[Fox]

Quote: udincev

F after the reduction in the security forces came out on the 1st place in the world in their number per one thousand population.

og ... in the slaughter for 12 operas throughout the state, two in stock ...

[udincev]

Quote: Fox

og ... in the slaughter for 12 operas throughout the state, two in stock ...

Perhaps these are the fruits of the new system of remuneration (SSOT) in the public sector, introduced in 2008. Briefly: salary money is allocated to the entire state; funds "saved" in staff units are divided, as he wants, by management. Everyone is happy: some earn from the heart for three (og ...), others for three receive a salary, legally, by the way, and no "fraud".

[Baloo]

Quote: Andrey591

"Forgot" about the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the traffic police, the police. Is everything okay there after the reduction?

No, not everyone catches minnows.

[Aroma77]

Although I do not like Mikhalkov, I can’t disagree with him. Corruption in the Ministry of Emergencies, as well as in other bodies, blooms and smells. About the checks that they do and what they ask for it all heard. Not so long ago, before the sad incident, the Ministry of Emergencies began to run around the buildings and check. safety in public buildings, before this check was only a fictitious fraud.

[Beby]

A very revealing story of a fire in Rostov-on-Don. It was a terrifying fire in August 2017, when 150 houses burned down.

A muddy story with this Rostov fire was - for the local population is inclined to the version of arson, to "clean up" the commercially attractive territory.
Not a good example of problems in the Ministry of Emergencies, which, of course, are, as in any other large department.

[kvarfax]

arson, businesses will not do on Saturday, at the height of the working day. Simply quieter in the night. Less attention - easier to cover your tracks. We then with you may be the true culprits and will not be called. But to find, they will certainly find.

[Sergey ippon]

normal guy Mikhalkov, and his programs are correct.

[igor67]

Quote: Sergey Ippon

normal guy Mikhalkov, and his programs are correct.

maybe this hunger strike by firefighters. impressed Mikhalkov

[semenoffdima]

As far as I remember, “besogon” is one who “drives the demon”, i.e. - lies, deceives, tells fables.

[saltickov.]

Exorcising demons, do not distort.

[didra]

Nikita Besogon is an early Christian saint. It can be assumed that he is the heavenly patron of Nikita Mikhalkov.

[Sirocco]

Minister Puchkov, to put it mildly, did not agree with Mikhalkov’s opinion. According to the head of the Ministry of Emergency Situations, the statements of the author and the host of Besogon are "nonsense."

Mikhalkov did not lie, unlike Puchkov, in Ulan Ude there is a fire department near the Spirtzavod highway, so there is one person in the fire brigade, he is essentially a guard of what remains, there is a fire-fighting complex, there are fire engines in the form of old man Kraz and ZIL, which are about to fall apart, and the Ministry of Emergencies of the village was renamed the fire brigade of 5 or 6 cripples. A friend burned several years ago in an apartment building, they waited for them to arrive from the city (Ulan Ude) with IDASh, they could not enter the basement. That's the truth.

[Dormidont]

N.S. Mikhalkov alone stands a beam beam

[saltickov.]

This is not nonsense; it is the realities of our life, optimization of her mother, people were tested, deprived of legal payments and benefits, for ten thousand no one gets into the fire. By and large, he is right, our whole life is nonsense.

[sogdy]

Quote: saltickov.

for ten thousand no one climbs into the fire

I am wildly sorry, but this is the rate of the clerk in the council. In fire calculation, drove 35tr. The fighters have more + epaulets, length of service, special uniforms, rations.

[free]

Quote: sogdy

Quote: saltickov.

for ten thousand no one climbs into the fire

I am wildly sorry, but this is the rate of the clerk in the council. In fire calculation, drove 35tr. The fighters have more + epaulets, length of service, special uniforms, rations.

This is for those who have epaulets, only here they are fewer. And soon they will be removed from all the others. The fighters have less than the wages they drove.

[faterdom]

The point is not the Minister of Emergencies, or the same Ministry of Internal Affairs, which over the past 8 years has been consolidated. Who is not in the know - and the FSB has reduced it. And at the heart of everything is "optimizing government spending," while all sorts of deputies, senators, ministers do not forget to regularly index everything, help oligophrenics who are sanctioned ... I think everyone can see and hear everything about schools and hospitals using their own cities and towns . Well, really, it’s not for Rusnano to save, or there is a HSE (for what kind of shisha these men are kept - can anyone know?). Should Gozman grumble somewhere?

[Victor N]

Government spending must be optimized, but very carefully.
But to avoid filling the budget is ugly, if not to say - mean! Moreover, it is obscene to demand something from the authorities. In Russia, tens of millions do not pay taxes or the Pension Fund. And it is not audible that someone refused a pension - they say, I did not pay .....

[andrej-shironov]

Andrey, what do you think, the tsar is to blame for this? Or just the boyars?

[faterdom]

And you do not know exactly who signs the decrees on the number of law enforcement agencies? It’s not the ministers themselves, that's for sure. Then later who exactly to reduce sometimes - their creativity. Sometimes, as in the case of the traffic police, or with the same Organized Crime Control Department (10 years already this year), this is also decided from above.

[andrej-shironov]

I then know, I would like to know your opinion.

[_Sergei_]

It is necessary to reduce it, but not the infantry, but the authorities. But the authorities will not cut back on their loved ones

[andrej-shironov]

Sergey, do not think flat. It's not about reductions, it's about the approach! If the principle of economic efficiency is central, then no doubt needs to be reduced, and if the principle of caring for society is applied, a different approach is needed, not in the current paradigm of development of the socio-economic situation in Russia.

[The Siberian barber]

I don’t know how in the Ministry of Emergencies, but in many structures (FCS, police, for example) there are reductions, to a greater or lesser extent .. Moreover, as Mikhalkov correctly noted, the reductions relate, for the most part, to those working “on the ground”. It is a fact (
Optimizers .... Damn ....

[Samara_63]

Well Mikhalkov is so right!

[kakvastam]

Freud's reservation: "all problems of the ministry are the head of state."

And you can’t argue - you can delegate authority, but not responsibility, and if his subordinates engage in sabotage with impunity, then this is his fault.

And if anyone hopes for radical changes in the composition of the government, then you can only sympathize with his imminent imminent disappointment. Well, they can donate Medinsky, or dismiss the Minister of Education, or even Shoigu with Lavrov - but they certainly will not encroach on the sacred, on the "economic bloc".

[andrej-shironov]

So the king cannot cut his own hand! It gets off with another scapegoat.

[Azazelo]

Well, yes, how much more govnofilm need to be removed so that Nikita will be kicked in the neck with shame.

[Semen1972]

Put the director against the wall and shoot, there are such slime dishes with each formation. They are worse than the enemy.

[hhhhhhh]

Mikhalkov advertising lures into cinema halls, and the Ministry of Emergencies is to blame. Suppose that on posters advertising cinema like on packs of cigarettes 30% should be occupied by photos of those burned in the cinema.
Film distributors must ensure the safety of watching movies. There are not so many requirements and they are standard for cinema halls. Let Mikhalkov travel around the country and close poorly-tested Emergencies Ministry halls.

[fa2998]

Quote: The Siberian Barber

Moreover, as Mikhalkov correctly noted, the reductions relate, for the most part, to those working "on the ground." It is a fact (

If there is no one to extinguish fires, the outgrowth of people from the fire inspection! The states there are cool, we are probably the leaders in the number of inspectors. There is no one to put out, and to collect the money is full.

[The Siberian barber]

Well, Duc ... !! You forgot to mention the structures inspecting inspectors!
We have enough of something, well, this "good" ((
They don’t take care of themselves, they absolutely “improve” everything ..
I think everyone watched the picture: one digs, and two or three people are nearby, they control and advise)))

[Tatanka Yotanka]

Quote: fa2998

If there is no one to extinguish fires, the outgrowth of people from the fire inspectorate

Yes, you sho, there are some officers and a tower there, half of them were dummies, another category for health in the IHC, and those who were not allowed to work at the GDZS, who didn’t give up carcasses to hand-commanders, interfere with work)))

[citlstar]

Quote: udincev

Normal.
After a reduction in the security forces, the Russian Federation came out on the first place in the world in their number per thousand population.

Sorry, I don’t think so. When traveling a distance of approximately 100 km. I meet at least 5 traffic police crews on the road.

[taiga2018]

Mikhalkov well done! A man has achieved so much that we all together would achieve at least half of this, but at the same time he does not calm down, in this program we get from our "liberals" and officials ...

[The Siberian barber]

Of course well done!
With any form of power, always in favor))) Talent ..!)

[dgonni]

Internal showdown for cutting cake. Nothing personal just business . In fact, they cover Keizhutovich. For under him the general plan of the building was made and the money came directly to him. Just a business. And the fact that they urinate the new head of the Ministry of Emergencies? Yes, I beg you. Keizhutovich clearly understood where the stone was flying and what life could be after that, connected Mikhalkov as heavy artillery.

[andrej-shironov]

So the cover goes not only to Kuzhugetovich, but you yourself know who! They will throw the next people a bone and voila!

[Terenin]

I agree, it is important who says. For example, after Makarevich’s "filthy stance" in Ukraine, he makes me sick from his songs. But, the facts in the "besogon" Mikhalkov, about the Ministry of Emergency Situations, "the fool is understandable" were given by specialists from this department (both the acting and those who "left"). I personally spoke with those who replaced specialists there. No, not that level of fire knowledge to say the least. I can’t understand how they can demand the observance of fire rules from "scorched", experienced (having passed more than one lawsuit) entrepreneurs. , to which, incidentally, after retirement, firefighters will ask for work.

[andrej-shironov]

Nikita Mikhalkov, as always, lowers the level of the problem. The problem is at the top of power, Putin and the Government. Everyone else plays by the rules that they write to them! It is time for Mikhalkov and many here to admit the obvious facts! However, something tells me that they will not understand. My aspirations for parts of the people will be lost in vain.

[Doliva63]

The problem is not at the top of power, but at its source - a society deprived of ownership of the means of production cannot influence power. Affected by the current owners. Or didn’t you study at school?

[andrej-shironov]

Or didn’t you study at school?

At school? No, I didn’t study.

[Doliva63]

Home education? Damn, I’m so unlucky - the excess of knowledge tires

[free]

It may be differently related to Mikhalkov, but he pointed out the problems of the Ministry of Emergencies accurately and truthfully!

[Alexander War]

In general, we will look at the new government! If Putin leaves everything as is, then we will slowly slide into the abyss!

[free]

Quote: Alexander War

In general, we will look at the new government! If Putin leaves everything as is, then we will slowly slide into the abyss!

Any doubts? No illusions!

[Micfoster]

Have you seen how the Minister of Emergencies responded to the president at a meeting in Kemerovo? I got the impression that this was not the Minister of Emergencies, but the Minister of something else! His president asked about the fire safety audit, and he bleated about the tax holidays. Ministers snickered in! They began to think a lot about their own well-being! And Mikhalkov is also not a gift, but he is the only one who started to pull out this problem. I have a fireman next door from above, sometimes also divided. All this seems a trifle while it does not concern you!

[faterdom]

His (Puchkova) fault is only in stupidity. He applied the term "tax holidays", launched with a light hand by the prime minister, and it was out of place. In fact, the holidays are “verification”, that is, no one can check, then the company is re-registered - and voila - again, three years can’t be!
This fact now shows the ongoing investigation: the interrogated head of the regional department of the Ministry of Emergencies shows: the prosecutor’s office explicitly forbade checking! The regional prosecutor reports: on top of him! so ordered! And who could order the regional prosecutor, so independent and on guard of the Law, from above? Only those who proposed these laws and shoved through the printer. After all, no one denies the existence of these "holidays"?
Only no one wants to be responsible for the consequences either. Well, except for the chief of the fire brigade, who, it turns out, sent the brigade of fighters not in the optimal way.

[Alexander War]

Mikhalkov correctly said add video

[Vkd dvk]

I am surprised and indignant at Putin’s “tolerance”. After the answer that "the tax holidays have not yet ended, therefore ....", this "minister" had to be taken out of the office in handcuffs and without shoulder straps.

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: Vkd dvk

After the answer that "the tax holidays are not over yet, therefore ....",

He messed up with a supervised vacation, most likely.

[Archikah]

Jokes are not funny comrades. Mikhalkov told the truth, this can be understood by the reaction of Puchkov. Remember how the official layer reacts when they are stepped on their tail - they are not trying to justify themselves or try to explain their position. No. Immediately there are direct insults, defamation and contemptuously "delirium". Not any clear and correct explanations on their part. But about Mr. (it’s not Mr.) Peskov himself said the GDP very well. "He sometimes carries such a blizzard." Sands is not a diplomat, but everyone is trying to like it. And again he carried the "snowstorm."

[Boyar]

Mikhalkov told the truth clean, the Ministry of Emergency Situations is corrupt through and through. Puchkov is simply an unscrupulous reptile.

[Doliva63]

Really only the Ministry of Emergencies?
Was in Jobburg deputy mayor for housing and communal services, the surname does not matter, he once told me - if you approach the law, you need to put us all

[Sergey ippon]

and it's time!
otherwise there is no road and development, only the development of everything into pockets and ... beyond the hill!

[turbris]

The fact that everything is not normal in the Puchkov’s department is a fact, so many people who died in fires indicate that the service is not working effectively. The fact that there were gross violations of fire safety, we learn only after the mass deaths of people in boarding schools, nightclubs and shopping centers, and where before were our brave Ministry of Emergencies, which are required to identify these violations and monitor their elimination? Yes, and with the training of firefighters, not everything is in order, otherwise they could have saved more people in Kemerovo, because they were notified on time, arrived on time, then why so many victims?

[Hiller]

I have a classmate in the Ministry of Emergencies at the level of the regional leadership of this structure .... not a single kind word addressed to Puchkov and his entourage ..

[Awaz]

there, not only are there not enough people, they simply don’t know how to put out fires. I kind of respect the work of the firemen’s boys, but the system itself has completely degraded, so that it wouldn’t show on TV.
A few years ago, I witnessed how the floor of the region was extinguished by fires on huge peat bogs in my small homeland ... It was some kind of bastard. They pulled a bunch of equipment, but it was completely useless in those conditions, and stood in a camp near the nearest river, which they stupidly could not force. For a whole month they crumpled there, and fires only intensified. Heaps of bosses, with and without shoulder straps, constantly came to this river and took pictures against the backdrop of technology, bravorously telling magazines about successes, although the situation was only getting worse. There was even a case that a helicopter did a water discharge on this entire gang (either by a specialist or by mistake), but it was mistaken and merged wherever it was often. (guys volunteers told)
And in general, they would have waited for the rains and hung up medals and prizes, but there was no rain and these colonels had to attract the old workers of the destroyed peat enterprise, on the territory of which the fire broke out. And only when these peasants were allowed to supervise and advise “professionals” in a week they stopped all the foci and things got better and finally put out, but without cool and modern kamazes stuffed with fire extinguishing systems and ordinary marsh tractors and PTM vehicles and human skills .
When I lived there, fires there were commonplace, sometimes they took on enormous proportions, but they were always eliminated by the local forces of workers, without involving any services from the outside, they attracted a maximum of Vshnikov for spilling the soil. Each employee knew his maneuver in case of fire, just as everyone knew what to do so that there would be no fire. I myself shabbat one summer at PTM as this same fireman. THERE, even the slightest smoke, immediately stopped, if the wind slightly exceeded the permissible force, all the equipment stopped working (so as not to provoke the appearance of sparks) Everything was tough and adequate.
PTM is Dt 75 swamp tracts with a huge barrel, which was in the form of an asphalt paver rink and rolled behind it with a supply of water ...
Although I don’t really like Mikhalkov, in this story I completely agree with him ... The Ministry of Emergencies has degraded and needs to be completely shaken up, as well as all other services

[mitchhunter]

It is necessary for Mikhalkov to throw an idea on a new video about medicine, especially the one behind the Moscow Ring Road. They also optimize well and look at the words of the Minister of Health. There will be the same answer. Bayonets, oh sorry, there are enough nurses and doctors. That’s why people just die like flies.

[Baloo]

Quote: mitchhunter

It is necessary for Mikhalkov to throw an idea on a new video about medicine, especially the one behind the Moscow Ring Road. They also optimize crying well and look at the words of the Minister of Health. There will be the same answer

Alas, it’s worse than you imagine. Our talented young people for the most part have poor basic training, lack of clinical thinking. They see a sore in a patient, but they don’t see a patient with all the other sores: This is not mine and move on ....

[sogdy]

andrej-shironov,
Racism?! - and surpassed Linnaeus?
Or did Pasteur surpass Linnaeus?
And yes, in practice, the theory of mutations is used - still our Karl ....

[Drlivsi]

Fire, a week ago, Simferopol. The 6th floor of 9 floors is on. From the facade - people from the 7th floor are going to jump. Major-chief (responsible or who he is) in the crowd inside the courtyard. The calculation is somewhere inside, the staircase is also inside the courtyard, the staircase driver refuses to take pictures of people because of the lack of an order, the major thinks, thinks, thinks ... until they openly promise him: "Give pi ... s". After that, everyone is removed from the 7th floor. In general, there are no victims. PS: The driver of the ladder does not have a radio station, it was taken by the calculation (according to the driver). Ministry of Emergency Situations of Russia rules.

[Drlivsi]

Quote: mitchhunter

It is necessary for Mikhalkov to throw an idea on a new video about medicine, especially the one behind the Moscow Ring Road. They also optimize well and look at the words of the Minister of Health. There will be the same answer. Bayonets, oh sorry, there are enough nurses and doctors. That’s why people just die like flies.

Where is enough? Who is missing? Who is enough? Why do qualified personnel go to private structures? Because they are ready to serve, to serve - not-ee-ee ...., it is expensive, but everyone wants a "hal ... you."

[A.]

What else could a well-fed and smooth Ministry of Emergencies say. His salary is certainly more than that of the driver of a fire truck.

[shirkoled]

Let Puchkov regret himself !!! Can’t lead,
then you need to drive such a boss in three necks !!!

[Mordvin 3]

Quote: shirkoled

Let Puchkov regret himself !!! Can’t lead,
then you need to drive such a boss in three necks !!!

And how it all began.

[Ivan Tucha]

It’s hard not to believe Mikhalkov. It’s even more difficult to kill his materials - as a rule, opponents do not have the evidence base to the contrary.

[tolmachiev51]

I would like to believe that this is nonsense! , BUT, look, we have about 70 percent of firefighters working on another car. ZIL sample 70-80 years! and where the denyuzhki from optimization !!! ???

[Berkut154]

The situation in the Ministry of Emergencies is difficult. Goacquaspas centers destroyed. Near the Baltic crashed Ka-29 searched for two weeks. Until the age of 16, there was this center with all the search equipment. Now he is gone. The military in the Ministry of Emergencies and internal service were dispersed to the maximum. Gone are the pros. Instead of repair, 76 purchased unnecessary superjets-100. People leave because there are no prospects and low salaries. Have you ever seen a beam in uniform? He shows with all appearance his attitude to the service !!!! All that Mikhalkov said is true! A small part of the truth.

[annodomene]

In order to fart in a puddle a big mind is not necessary (this is me about Mikhalkov). That not everything is in order in the "kingdom of the Ministry of Emergencies" it is visible. But what does Comrade offer? Mikhalkov? The answer is nothing. Only the air shakes ... Where is at least one, maaaaalenkoe, proposal to improve the situation in the Ministry of Emergencies? So there is no him. Moreover, comrade Mikhalkov, in my opinion, is not only an expert, but even a specialist in this field ...

[Vkd dvk]

Quote: annodomene

In order to fart in a puddle a big mind is not necessary (this is me about Mikhalkov). That not everything is in order in the "kingdom of the Ministry of Emergencies" it is visible. But what does Comrade offer? Mikhalkov? The answer is nothing. Only the air shakes ... Where is at least one, maaaaalenkoe, proposal to improve the situation in the Ministry of Emergencies? So there is no him. Moreover, comrade Mikhalkov, in my opinion, is not only an expert, but even a specialist in this field ...

It looks like you are stuck in the USSR, like your flag. It was then proposed not to criticize, but to offer to do it yourself. A good idea is for the filmmaker to propose and improve the Ministry of Emergencies. Like Krylov, Ivan Andreyevich wrote about the cake man who began to stitch his boots? Read, better late than never.
Please fragment:

"PIKE AND CAT
The trouble is, if the cobbler starts the cakes,
And the boots stitch the pastry,
And things won’t work out.
Yes, and a hundredfold
What who loves to take someone else’s craft,
He forever others stubborn and foolish:
It’s better to ruin everything,
And glad soon
The laughing stock of becoming light
Than honest and knowledgeable people
Ask il to listen to reasonable advice ..... "

[annodomene]

And you, apparently, belong to the “Pepsikol” generation, which only knows how to wag the tongue well, without producing anything. What is happening around us without Mikhalkov is visible. If I need your advice, I’ll definitely ask. Although what can you advise based on your statements? Yes, and you do not need to touch the USSR, if you do not have a clue about it.

[Vkd dvk]

Quote: annodomene

And you, apparently, belong to the “Pepsikol” generation, which only knows how to wag the tongue well, without producing anything. What is happening around us without Mikhalkov is visible. If I need your advice, I’ll definitely ask. Although what can you advise based on your statements? Yes, and you do not need to touch the USSR, if you do not have a clue about it.

I am 71 years old and Pepsi passed without my drink. He worked half of his life in the design bureau, and the second as an instrumentation and automation engineer.
Not going to compete with your achievements with you. Incompatible does not compare. Judging by your suggestion, you are not even Pepsi. An even shorter generation.

[Alex66]

What difference is good or bad Mikhalkov, he gives facts that can be verified, but if the answer sounds I feel sorry for the people who watch these shows, sorry for those who believe this I am sorry that we have such a minister who is engaged in chatter, instead of attracting Mikhalkov for defamation, and if he cannot attract, he himself must be involved.

[Vard]

Ministry of Emergency Situations ... this is a completely anti-Soviet organization ... To create the appearance of their need, they hit the tail ... Agree if you prevent one hundred fires or put out one ... by PR, of course, one extinguished fire will block everything ...

[lazy]

if the plane crashes, military helicopters of the search and rescue service will fly first (at any time of the day), the Ministry of Emergencies does not have such helicopters ready for 10-15 minutes, so until the crew finds it ready to prepare the helicopter ... to extinguish the fires arrive when the villages are already burn, or smoke such that arriving aircraft can not fly out because visibility at the airport does not correspond to the minimum crew. generally not a very operational department. in my opinion. while it’s not around to save people, but to take out corpses

[serg.shishkov2015]

when I see Mikhalkov for some reason I always remember the phrase from 12 chairs, Barin! From Paris!

[keeper03]

I watched the program - Mikhalkov opened his eyes to the blind! It seems that Puchkov is harming deliberately, because it is not by chance that "tidbits" burn down throughout Russia! This is corruption and sabotage in its purest form. - it's time to drive the minister in the neck, along with his hangers-on !!!

[gorgo]

Quote: ROSS 42

Mikhalkov, as an actor, is very successful and watchable. There are very good roles. Just do not need him to get involved in the game of autocracy and build a "Highness" from himself. Reveals sharply enough, only sense?

Mikhalkov is a hereditary nobleman. There are very few of them left, they must be protected. And personally, I think that he is quite worthy of estates, and flashing lights, and "high esteem" ...

[rotfuks]

I watched the transfer of Mikhalkov with interest. It seems that after the departure of Shoigu, the Ministry of Emergencies just falls apart. I was especially touched by the purchase of fire tankers based on a German truck, in the presence of cheap analogues on the basis of KAMAZ and the massive purchase of drones flying no more than 15 minutes on a single charge. For example, in some countries, fire protection is maintained at the expense of urban municipalities.

[mss001]

Strange, but Putin looked through his fingers and looks not only at the outrages of Puchkov, but also at the subversive actions of Serdyukov, Chubais and others, especially in the financial bloc of the government.

[vladimirasha]

What nonsense is this? If you have nothing to put out fires with, then you need to throw in the snickering head of the Ministry of Emergency Situations. So that the next one knows how to answer.