Military Review

Sergey Glazyev: We have a terrible economic catastrophe

77
Sergey Glazyev: We have a terrible economic catastrophe



Shortly after the Russian Academy of Sciences (RAS) began to come up with a program to change the economic paradigm in the country, and Anatoly Chubais had to publicly defend the current model, we witnessed the so-called “reform” of the academy to further limit its powers. The latest incident was the disruption of the election of the president of the Russian Academy of Sciences and attempts to resubmit the election directly to the head of state. According to academician Sergei Glazyev, the reform of the RAS gives the opposite results of the officially announced, but scientists can still put the economy on the right track.

Sergei Yuryevich, please tell us about the latest developments in the Russian Academy of Sciences, what processes are going on and how do academics evaluate them?

The reform, which was imposed on the Academy of Sciences several years ago, did not actually achieve its results, but had the opposite effect. It was expected that the work of scientists would be freed from oversight, the economic and bureaucratic burden of management, but, in fact, there was a very serious bureaucratization of the work of academic institutions. The Federal Agency for Scientific Organizations (FANO) behaves as a higher structure and forces scientists to write endless reports that the officials of this organization are not able to even understand and understand them. Petty regulation, formalism and overbureaucratization very seriously interfere with the scientific process, complicating, and not simplifying the work of scientists.

What to do in this situation?

I think that it is necessary to return to the principles about which the president spoke when the reform was conceived, and to achieve correct subordination. There is the leadership of the Academy of Sciences, it defines the basic directions of basic research, and the FANO should be a service organization that works within the framework of the duties defined by the Presidium of the RAS.

Still, how do you assess the situation with the election of the President of the Russian Academy of Sciences - what is happening?

I do not appreciate. Elections we foiled.

Do you think the reform of the Russian Academy of Sciences is slowing down the modernization of the economy, the creation of 25 million high-tech jobs - something that the president has repeatedly called for?

Reform has nothing to do with this, because if we talk about the contribution of the Russian Academy of Sciences to economic development, here we are sorely lacking a mechanism for the commercialization of research and development. This mechanism should include venture funds, development banks, investment funds. If FANO was involved in creating a mechanism for introducing scientific achievements into practice, this would be very good. Instead, officials are engaged in petty regulation on the use of property. Here you can find out without officials how to effectively use property. But the task of organizing the promotion of scientific results in practice is just the function of government departments, which is stalled today. Therefore, the question of why the discoveries of our scientists are being introduced around the world, but not in our country, this is not a question of the Academy of Sciences, but a question for the work of the Government, the Central Bank, which form the economic policy and are responsible for creating conditions .

By the way, about the implementation of developments and attitudes towards scientists abroad. While the functionality of the Russian Academy of Sciences is being limited, China has begun to actively return its scientists from the United States, the Chinese press wrote about this the other day. Is it time for us to do the same?

China has been doing this for a long time and successfully, we are also trying. But the main thing here is not even the financing of scientific works, but for our foreign colleagues there is a system of grants, which stimulates their return to Russian educational and scientific organizations, the main thing is practical implementation, which I have already mentioned. It is very important for a scientist to see the result of his work in practice. Today, between fundamental and applied science in many branches of knowledge, the barrier has virtually been erased, and yesterday's scientific laboratories are becoming successful firms everywhere. In order for Russian minds not to be “exported”, but, on the contrary, returned to Russia, it is very important to create a favorable environment for innovative activity.

In recent months, various economic strategies are being discussed, the mainstream is apparently Kudrin's strategy, but there are others, including the one proposed by the Russian Academy of Sciences. Is it possible now to say that scientists are attracted to this work or, on the contrary, have been pushed aside from it?

Scientists of the RAS have always had and have a position based on scientific knowledge about the patterns of economic development. It, unfortunately, is not claimed by public authorities for 25 years. The recommendations that academic science has consistently defended have proven their practical effectiveness have manifested themselves in the economic miracle of China, in a number of other countries where sensible economic policies are pursued. Our economic policy is conducted in favor of the comprador oligarchy, speculators and Western capital. We follow the trajectory of the IMF, whose task is not economic growth, but the creation of favorable conditions for the movement of American capital throughout the world. Wherever the IMF works, we see economic disasters.

Our country is not an exception, but one of the typical examples of following the recommendations of the IMF, as a result of which investment activity decreases, production drops, but the economy is “successfully colonized” by Western capital. We already have more than half of the industry owned by non-residents.

If the goal is to make a colony for Western capital from Russia, then the policy pursued over the course of the 25 years with us can be said to be very successful. But it has nothing to do with national interests, nor with the tasks of economic development.

If the goal is economic development, what should be done?

It is necessary to implement not the recommendations of the IMF, but the recommendations of scientists of the RAS, which are based on an understanding of the laws of economic development, knowledge of international experience and have brilliantly recommended experimentally. We have a wonderful, unique economic stories experiment - at the same time we started reforms with China on the transition from a directive to a market economy. China has performed an economic miracle, today it already produces six times more products than we do, and we have the most monstrous economic catastrophe in the world history of peacetime. There are visual confirmations by which one can speak, which concept is correct and which is not.

Would you say that the failure of our concept has already been proven?

The failure of the libertarian concept of the Washington consensus received experimental confirmation in Russia, and the concept of an integral economic policy combining planning and market mechanisms yielded brilliant results. What else is needed for evidence, I do not understand.
Author:
Originator:
https://izborsk-club.ru/14743
77 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. Andrey Yuryevich
    Andrey Yuryevich 11 February 2018 06: 14
    +47
    to hell with economics ... the main thing is spirituality, braces! need more temples! in our city, "people in black," squeezed the building from the Rezhevsky diversified technical school ...! how is this possible? found some old pieces of paper, that "once" this building was theirs and that’s it! ROC behaves like a raider. why the hell education, sit pray and everything will be to you!
    1. Pereira
      Pereira 11 February 2018 09: 57
      +20
      The obscurantists take revenge for the Great October Socialist Revolution, although they themselves are descendants of the victorious people who betrayed the memory of their ancestors. Like svidomity. The analogy begs the most direct.
    2. Ber
      Ber 11 February 2018 10: 04
      +15
      Andrei Yurievich Today, 06:14 New
      to hell with economics ... the main thing is spirituality, braces! need more temples! in our city, "people in black," squeezed the building from the Rezhevsky diversified technical school ...! how is this possible? found some old pieces of paper, that "once" this building was theirs and that’s it! ROC behaves like a raider. fuck


      What do you write about? The Russian Orthodox Church has long turned into a demonic church. Feofan the Recluse wrote about this in the 19th century, that the devil will sit in the church and rule
      (the devil is the spirit of lies when everything turn over vice versa.)

      New Testament. Cathedral Epistle of St. James

      15If a brother or sister is naked and has no daily food, 16a one of you will tell them: “go in peace, warm yourself and eat,” but will not give them what is needed for the body: what is the use?

      17So faith, if it has no works, is dead in itself.

      18But someone will say: “you have faith, but I have works”: show me your faith without your works, and I will show you my faith from my works.

      19You believe that God is one: you do well; and demons believe, and tremble.

      20But do you want to know, an unreasonable person, that faith without works is dead?


      And this is the Orthodox Psalter.


      Here explain to me ??? how can one pray every day against the new testament of the gospel?

      Russian is written in white, FAITH WITHOUT MATTERS IS DEAD, and dead faith is demonic faith.
      1. Victor N
        Victor N 11 February 2018 11: 31
        +5
        How do your remarks relate to the topic of the article? Obscene clogging the field!
        1. Ber
          Ber 11 February 2018 12: 06
          +8
          victor n Today, 11:31 ↑ New
          How do your remarks relate to the topic of the article? Obscene clogging the field!


          There is no way with the topic of the article, I answered Andrei Yuryevich’s comment, but in the subject of the Russian Academy of Sciences and the interference of religious associations in power, it still correlates

          Andrei Yurievich Today, 06:14 New
          to hell with economics ... the main thing is spirituality, braces! need more temples! in our city, "people in black," squeezed the building from the Rezhevsky diversified technical school ...! how is this possible? found some old pieces of paper, that "once" this building was theirs and that’s it! ROC behaves like a raider. fuck


          Do you think it’s decent to intervene in a dialogue that doesn’t concern you personally?

          Dear Victor, for your information there are such scientific disciplines as, history, history of religions of the peoples of the world, a philosophy that originated as a religious philosophy.
          On the topic in the article, we are talking about the reform of the Russian Academy of Sciences, But if you decide to pull me for what I called the Russian Orthodox Church the demonic church, then you can watch two films on the topic.

          Sergey Glazyev: We have a terrible economic catastrophe
          Today, 06: 00

          In the film, the conversation is strictly on the topic of the article economics and science.

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-UocvV0hRSg

          At the 24th minute, it is mentioned that the reserves of Uranus 235 at which all nuclear power plants in the world are running out and will end even earlier than gas.

          In the next film, the rationale is what was said in the preceding 24 minute, the world's leading specialist with whom all RAS of the countries of NATO, China, India are considered ....

          https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x4rT0B0yhdM

          Enlighten Victor on the topic of the article.
    3. dSK
      dSK 11 February 2018 16: 01
      +1
      Quote: Andrey Yurievich
      to hell
      go there yourself, he has been waiting for you for a long time. The people built temples on their "blood" pennies, gentlemen, rrrevolutionaries.
      1. Pereira
        Pereira 11 February 2018 16: 31
        +7
        And MMM also bought up shares for hard-earned ones.
        1. Tatyana
          Tatyana 11 February 2018 19: 45
          +9
          dSK
          The people built temples on their "blood" pennies, gentlemen, rrrevolutionaries.
          Not all believers built their temples on their "hard-earned"!
          For example, St. Isaac's Cathedral, the historical pearl of tourist St. Petersburg, was not built on the donations of believers, but by the state from the state budget and never in history belonged to the Russian Orthodox Church, whose leadership has now “deprived” it of the people for its purely lucrative top-level religious and corporate enrichment.
          It is known that any religious denomination that has historically come down from the depths of centuries to our time is, from a materialistic and atheistic point of view, nothing more than an ancient business structure for managing society in the interests of the oligarchs, whose power it grows together, also turning into oligarchs from religion.
          Historically, these religious denominations survived only as a result of the fact that they had never paid any taxes to the state. In fact, these are commercial organizations selling to the population and the country's authorities all kinds of theological dogmas in the form of ideas. Indeed, in the world there is not only a market for the sale of material things, but also a market for the sale of religious ideas and ideas, historically divorced in time from their direct authors and distributed after their death by their apologists around the world in the form of corresponding ideologies.
          This is where all kinds of religious wars came from, are happening and will continue to happen.
          So the "gentlemen of the revolutionaries", as you put it, were right in separating religion from the state and recognizing it as a private affair of citizens of a secular state in a multinational and multiconfessional country.
          1. dSK
            dSK 11 February 2018 20: 57
            +1
            Hello Tatyana Fedorovna!
            Quote: Tatiana
            Saint Isaac's Cathedral

            Consecrated in the name of St. Isaac of Dalmatia, revered St. Peter I, since the emperor was born on the day of his memory - May 30 according to the Julian calendar. The construction of the building and work on its design continued from 1818 to 1858. The construction was supervised by Nicholas I himself. The tsar built it so that the Orthodox pray for the salvation of their sinful souls and their own. The handsome temples were obtained from gratitude, therefore believers "in the unity of God the Father, the Almighty, the Creator to heaven and earth, visible to all and invisible," understand who He is and how he helps to live. There would be no real help - no one went then. On Sunday morning and especially on the next holiday, February 15, “The Present of the Lord,” go to the nearest church and see for yourself. And "staring" at the masterpieces is for you at the Hermitage, the Tretyakov Gallery.
            Not far from our house, within walking distance, the church was built in 2012 by parishioners of the district, for which our family is grateful to them, you do not need to ride a bus. From a pension of 11100 rubles - 500-600 rubles I leave in the church and still help children.
            1. Tatyana
              Tatyana 11 February 2018 22: 49
              +3
              Good evening, dear dsk!
              You are a good person! It is a pity that in this - religious - plan, I will never agree with you! But I accept you as you are, and I’m not going to rape you ideologically. As they say, free - will! To each his own!
              In addition, I understand that such believers as you are part of our people, and we have no other people. We are different, but, as they say, will be hardened - fall in love! After all, we have one homeland, and our destiny as a united nation is still common! hi
      2. dSK
        dSK 11 February 2018 16: 42
        0
        Quote: Andrew Y.
        pray and everything will be to you!
        It will only be that good for the soul. He prays correctly - "shed blood." Under the primitive communal system, the tribe could not feed “non-working” people and the “priest” was “three in one” - “priest”, doctor and “scientist”. All modern science was born in monasteries. "God is God - Caesar Caesarean." Now it’s specialization, but since those ancient times all the ruling bishops are well-educated, talented people, a diploma bought in the “transition” will not “work”.
        1. Sling cutter
          Sling cutter 11 February 2018 23: 23
          +8
          Quote: dsk
          All modern science was born in monasteries. "God is God - Caesar Caesarean." Now it’s specialization, but since those ancient times all the ruling bishops are well-educated, talented people, a diploma bought in the “transition” will not “work”.

          Do you mean believers or gundyaev?
          Explain why the leaders of the Russian Orthodox Church protection of the FSO? why armored limousines? Why does the Russian Orthodox Church go into politics? And why does the Far Eastern Priest go to the "rags", giving the Russian Orthodox Church anathema?
        2. BecmepH
          BecmepH 12 February 2018 06: 42
          0
          Quote: dsk
          There will be only that which is good for the soul. He prays correctly - "shed blood." Under the primitive communal system, the tribe could not feed “non-working” people and the “priest” was “three in one” - “priest”, doctor and “scientist”. All modern science was born in monasteries. "God is God - Caesar Caesarean." Now it’s specialization, but since those ancient times all the ruling bishops are well-educated, talented people, a diploma bought in the “transition” will not “work”.

          And I was warned for the flood ...
          1. dSK
            dSK 12 February 2018 07: 42
            0

            Sobchak earned over six years 403 million 855 thousand rubles. Such data published on the CEC website. Among the sources of these assets are the salary of the TV presenter on the Silver Rain radio station and the Dozhd TV channel, Dom-2, as well as in the Global Media Group publishing house.
            1. BecmepH
              BecmepH 12 February 2018 07: 49
              0
              Quote: dsk

              Sobchak earned over six years 403 million 855 thousand rubles. Such data published on the CEC website. Among the sources of these assets are the salary of the TV presenter on the Silver Rain radio station and the Dozhd TV channel, Dom-2, as well as in the Global Media Group publishing house.

              Are you one of those who "steers" the site and instills your opinion? For your comments on one topic ...
    4. gladcu2
      gladcu2 11 February 2018 16: 35
      +5
      A type of economy is a format of relationships between people.

      The capitalist economy is the economy of egoists. Lies, greed, fear, distrust, meanness. With this type of economy, there is no motivation for sharing information.

      As you say, "spiritual bonds." This is the format of the transmission, reception and storage of information.

      Therefore, in order to preserve spiritual bonds, one needs either religion or a systematic education leading to mutual understanding to a single opinion, or an ideology, or a technology for receiving, transmitting and STORING information.
      1. dSK
        dSK 11 February 2018 17: 02
        0
        Quote: gladcu2
        need either religion, or systematic education

        The old "trouble" from Lenin's grandfather does not interfere with one another, but helps. All the "Newtons", "Einsteins" were believers, because they understood that God wanted to reveal their secrets - they would. "God is God - Caesar Caesarean."
        1. gladcu2
          gladcu2 11 February 2018 17: 33
          0
          What are you speaking about?

          I am on the form of information transfer.

          Religion, system education, ideology, common sense, spiritual bonds. All this is a data transfer format.

          Faith or not faith in God, this is just a lack of knowledge.

          No one knows if there is a god or not, because they do not know.

          And faith and doubt are personal choices based on life experience. Because everyone had occasions of life that could be called fate. Predestination.
      2. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 50
        +2
        Quote: gladcu2
        either ideology, or technology for the reception, transmission and storage of information.

        as well as a mechanism for the development and implementation of knowledge products. Given the huge strata of different branches of science, IMHO I believe that individual science is becoming obsolete. The future lies only with the teams of scientists who carry out the task, with personal responsibility to each other and collective responsibility to the state.
        1. gladcu2
          gladcu2 11 February 2018 17: 58
          0
          Here. You picked up the idea correctly.

          RAS, this is a collective format of science.

          Applied science is already an individual form of application, including collective knowledge.

          And the criterion, the prerequisite of the organization is the format of knowledge transfer.

          Back to religion or technology.
          1. aybolyt678
            aybolyt678 11 February 2018 20: 14
            +1
            Quote: gladcu2
            Back to religion or technology.

            I consider the word religion inappropriate, but an ideology that has a legal (firing or financial) Strength, multiplied by technology, will inevitably produce results.
            I don’t even see the problem of what to take as the basis of Ideology. The basis of ideology should be the construction of state capitalism in our country for the benefit of society.
            1. gladcu2
              gladcu2 11 February 2018 21: 15
              0
              Well, I would not want to step on the old rake.
              The USSR was built ahead of time and with the help of ideology.
              Then there was a natural return to capitalism. Because there was no technological base.
              An ideology, together with the commissioners, must be launched in times of state crisis. If the question is not worth it then it is better to wait with ideology.

              Look.

              Presidents are being elected there. These promised you, as everywhere else, from three boxes, and then they will depict the famous figure from three fingers.

              What does this mean that information exchange and storage technologies are fraudulent.

              Conclusion. The company is not technologically ready to make the transition to a new technological structure.

              We do not sit idly by, but work. Forward to communism.
              1. aybolyt678
                aybolyt678 12 February 2018 05: 45
                0
                Quote: gladcu2
                Conclusion. The company is not technologically ready to make the transition to a new technological structure.

                We do not sit idly by, but work. Forward to communism.

                You inattentively read my comment, Dear! I write a lot about state capitalism, about the conditions created by the state for the development and accumulation of capital, about patriotism pragmatically aimed at the economic and technological components of economic growth.
                The concept of Communism is not formulated. Each according to the needs of each according to their ability, can be interpreted in different ways: provide proteins with fats and carbohydrates and tear off seven skins. Like in the zone. But social security, a progressive taxation scale, protection of the domestic market, taxation of exported money .... these are issues of survival and the real development of a country called Russia.
                1. gladcu2
                  gladcu2 12 February 2018 21: 19
                  +1
                  Communism is easy.

                  Take a large plant for clarity. Any worker or employee enters into a relationship without using the monetary system. He comes to the warehouse, takes tools materials. The team leader plans and distributes the work.
                  But they get paid, as a social allowance to counter an aggressive environment, outside the enterprise, which is called - capitalism.

                  We expand the enterprise to the level of the country and plan the future.

                  True, before this we must again have technological prerequisites.

                  And capitalism is a stone age. Outlived his.
                  1. aybolyt678
                    aybolyt678 12 February 2018 22: 20
                    0
                    Quote: gladcu2
                    Communism is easy.

                    Unfortunately no! the factory example is a special case of public ownership of the means of production, it works when workers work at the factory and live in a dormitory, eating exclusively in the dining room. And at work they produce goods in the name of the idea of ​​Victory over the enemy.
                    Even Stalin, in his work on the problems of building socialism, spoke about the difficulties of psychological motivation, the problems of ideology. His textbook on the Political Economy of Socialism was published after his death, during his lifetime the Leader considered it raw. Therefore, to date, there is no theoretically sound theory, not only of Communism but of Socialism. What I call state capitalism is the development of this very capitalism in our country. We do not have it! Capital is the value giving rise to new value, that is: means of production of consumer goods, energy, skilled workers, engineering personnel, raw materials, infrastructure, education capable of delivering world-class specialists .... we have none of this. We cannot offer the world a competitive product at a competitive price. Our state did not protect the domestic market, and turned the country into an infrastructure for the implementation of consumer goods with logistics of priority interests of transnational trading corporations. Capitalism enslaved us and we are its victim - a colony.
                    Quote: gladcu2
                    We expand the enterprise to the level of the country and plan the future.
                    In France they said - in palaces and squares they think differently. therefore, reconciling palaces with squares can only be ideology acceptable to all.
                    Quote: gladcu2
                    And capitalism is a stone age. Outlived his.

                    In modern conditions of limited spaces and resources, Capitalism, with its competition, will kill humanity.
    5. Aviator_
      Aviator_ 11 February 2018 18: 23
      +6
      If you choose between the ruins of churches and the ruins of factories and scientific centers, then I prefer the ruins of churches.
      1. dSK
        dSK 11 February 2018 22: 53
        0
        Quote: Aviator_
        choose

        "A body without a soul is a corpse," "a soul without a body is a ghost."
        1. Aviator_
          Aviator_ 11 February 2018 23: 36
          +5
          And what does LLC Gundyaev & Co. have to do with the soul?
          1. dSK
            dSK 12 February 2018 08: 03
            0
            "Residents of the village of Argunovo, near which the plane crashed, help rescuers, and pray for the blessed memory of those who died in a terrible plane crash."
            “So how do you get inside? It has been closed for so many years,” Anastasia, a resident of the village of Argunovo, rising from her knees from the snow. Here, An-148 crashed a few hours ago.
            Next to the old church, several more men and women stand and are baptized, heavy snow falls on their covered heads, the wind freezes cheeks. They stand for a long time, read a prayer. Prior to this, local residents helped to drive off looters and warmed the frozen employees of the Ministry of Emergencies with tea. "And what else will we help. Not to help them already. 71 people have died. Do you understand? We’ll at least pray for them," says the stern Alexander, brushing off the annoying journalists. The church, according to local residents, they were promised to restore for a long time. But for now, everything was limited to promises alone. (Channel "Tsargrad" 12.02.18/XNUMX/XNUMX)
            1. Aviator_
              Aviator_ 12 February 2018 13: 37
              +3
              I understood the aspirations of the Tsargrad television channel - if the church had been repaired (for which Gundyaev & Co. LLC had no money), then there would be no disaster. For some reason, I remembered the struggle against epidemics with the help of religious processions and by falling for miraculous icons.
              1. dSK
                dSK 12 February 2018 23: 26
                0
                "A cross of 71 lamps: The Muscovites mourning for the An-148 crash prayed for the dead." At the Cathedral of Christ the Savior in Moscow, an action was held in memory of the victims of the plane crash of the An-128 plane that crashed on February 11 in the Moscow region. The grieving Muscovites laid out a cross of 71 lamps in memory of the victims. In addition, participants prayed for the victims of the tragedy, as well as their relatives. For three days, volunteers will be on duty at the temple, maintaining fire in the candlesticks.
                He prays correctly - "shed blood", whoever tried, he will understand. The Holy Fathers say, "Give blood - receive the spirit."
  2. Vard
    Vard 11 February 2018 07: 19
    +2
    The Academy of Sciences has completely obsolete education ... The feeder for the army of bureaucrats from science ...
    1. AnpeL
      AnpeL 11 February 2018 08: 51
      +9
      The Academy of Sciences has completely obsolete education ... The feeder for the army of bureaucrats from science ...

      Yes, of course. That’s why FANO was created and works flawlessly. Only one "benefit" fan of such a fan.
    2. Pereira
      Pereira 11 February 2018 09: 58
      +2
      Rent an Academy to Rusty. And prosperity will come.
    3. Victor N
      Victor N 11 February 2018 11: 34
      +1
      Do you have rich experience? One grandmother said ..... So it looks. Do not be funny. The question is painfully serious, for specialists.
  3. kipage
    kipage 11 February 2018 07: 42
    +30
    We have a monstrous economic disaster

    You can’t say better
    And with activity outside dust is let into people's eyes and money is washed
  4. The Siberian barber
    The Siberian barber 11 February 2018 08: 09
    +18
    A completely objective thesis, which, in its own way, is felt by a simple layman.
    Due to my professional activity, I have to communicate with people of different social status (marginals do not count).
    Almost everyone is unhappy with the situation. But, the most interesting thing is that, unlike the 90s, when there was complete o ... pa, people looked ahead, with some kind of hope, now, the vast majority thinks that it will be even worse)
    Here, business, and state employees, and even officials
    I express my observations, no more ..
    1. Victor N
      Victor N 11 February 2018 11: 41
      +1
      On the contrary, the prospects are very favorable; there are opportunities for correcting the situation. The main thing is not to miss them. There is and will be resistance to the measures proposed by Glazyev - there is a serious struggle. So win! But fewer empty words!
      1. Sergeant71
        Sergeant71 11 February 2018 13: 37
        +12
        And in what place are they favorable? What is it even expressed in? Who bothered to "fix" before? And who will do the “correction”? The same from one deck of cards released 18 years ago?
    2. avt
      avt 11 February 2018 13: 02
      +2
      Quote: The Siberian Barber
      Due to my professional activity, I have to communicate with people of different social status (marginals do not count).
      Almost everyone is unhappy with the situation. But, the most interesting thing is that, unlike the 90s, when there was complete o ... pa, people looked ahead, with some kind of hope, now, the vast majority thinks that it will be even worse)
      Well then you go there
      The prospects for life are very bleak, - I will solve the urgent question: I will die under the cottage train, Smiling between the wheels.
      bully Glazyev balabol, the same nestling of Chubais’s nest, but repainted and attached to the RAS at the time of the wings. Trotskyist like Tolik, but maybe with a less globalist bias. And all this
      Quote: The Siberian Barber
      Almost everyone is unhappy with the situation.

      From banal illiteracy, since Lenin’s
      “Politics is the most concentrated expression of the economy,”
      they understand from their ignorance, in view of the conceit of congeniality, as primacy of the economy over politics, completely discarding the Leninist continuation of HIS expression
      Politics is a concentrated expression of economics, I repeated in my speech, because I had already heard this unacceptable, in the mouth of a Marxist, absolutely unacceptable rebuke for my “political” approach.
      Politics cannot but have primacy over the economy.
      To argue otherwise is to forget the ABC of Marxism.
      So to demand from ,, Economy "something such-and-such is primary stupidity. ,, Economy" is a means to solve political problems in a "peaceful" way.
      Quote: Victor N
      On the contrary, the prospects are very favorable; there are opportunities for correcting the situation.

      Well, from the same author
      A true “business executive”, comrades (let me do a little “production propaganda”!), Knows that the capitalists and organizers of the trusts, even in the most advanced countries for many years, sometimes ten years or more, have been studying and checking their (and alien) practical experience, correcting, redoing what was started, going back, correcting many times in order to achieve a management system that is quite suitable for the case, the selection of top and lower administrators, etc.
      The question is again ... in the POLITICAL will of the ruling class! To decay, or to set a goal and achieve it. But the adherents of the sect ,, Gaydarov’s Witnesses ", who are waiting for the coming of the" Holy Investment ", have this fight. bully
      1. The Siberian barber
        The Siberian barber 11 February 2018 14: 36
        +7
        SW avt, you read my post, once again, please) Have you seen somewhere that I wrote that "everything is lost!" ???))
        I shared my observations, just that ...) from someone’s conclusions, their perception is unlikely to change) Regarding “literacy”, mine, or people with whom I have the honor to communicate, if not me, then many of them, can read you the full course of Political Economics))
        Py.sy.
        Personally, I am not an adept, neither Gaidar and co., Nor have a great respect for the Guarantor and co.)
        Another thing is important to me: what will we leave for our children and grandchildren?) Neither more nor less. Common experiences for the Country, and the people living in it, like many visitors to VO)
        From SW. hi
        1. passing
          passing 11 February 2018 16: 08
          +5
          The Siberian barber
          do not pay attention to avt,
          There is no more knowledge than yours, and the situation does not interest him. He is just a fan of mocking! hi
      2. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 39
        +1
        Quote: avt
        So to demand from ,, Economy "something that kind of - stupidity is paramount

        You are wrong here! if you remember that we opened up to the global economy, and took an appropriate place in it. It is enough just to tax the transnational corporations operating in our country, and to control customs with the border, and the situation will immediately change for the better. The business will immediately have fewer competitors. There will be an incentive to produce their own.
    3. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 44
      +2
      Quote: The Siberian Barber

      12
      Siberian Barber Today, 08:09 New
      A completely objective thesis, which, in its own way, is felt by a simple layman.
      Due to my professional activity, I have to communicate with people of different social status (marginals do not count).
      Almost everyone is unhappy with the situation. But, the most interesting thing is that, unlike the 90s, when there was complete o ... pa, people looked ahead, with some kind of hope, now, the vast majority thinks that it will be even worse)

      In the 90th the situation was as follows:
      The crest knows, the Georgian knows
      need to have your own store
      the Jew knows, the Uzbek knows
      Your store -Happiness forever !!!
      Now there’s simply nothing to do, the service market is full, production is unprofitable, it’s more profitable to buy abroad, only a shift, security, a seller for three rubles
  5. parusnik
    parusnik 11 February 2018 08: 42
    +12
    Yes, what a disaster, smile in our county town there are more shopping centers than enterprises ... But enterprises are decreasing ..
  6. prior
    prior 11 February 2018 09: 42
    +11
    Even if you want to change something, where to get people: engineers, turners, cleaners ???????
    Who will stand up for these high-tech machines? Yesterday's Yegeshniki? These will work.
    Young scientists? Those who stayed are the gray-haired remnants of the Soviet school.
    The process has gone so far as to find a problem for a worthy leader at any level. No, it is easy to appoint a "defective manager" who knows how to cut costs by reducing the number of workers and reducing the wage bill. But to raise production!? in a country where the most popular professions are a salesman, driver and security guard? For some reason I strongly doubt it. Although in words everything is possible. Promise and marry, as they say ...
    1. basmach
      basmach 11 February 2018 10: 05
      +15
      And what, paws overhang and sadly whine. I recall 30, the years of the first five-year plans. There were many literate and qualified (just do not need tales about the massive Gulag and the free labor of convicts.) ?. But they built, and learned, and raised the science. You can whine, or you can do it with gritted teeth. The question is different. What to do with the current regime and system is basically impossible.
      1. Victor N
        Victor N 11 February 2018 11: 49
        +1
        You are right in the need to act - in the interests of yours, your family. And to use all available legal possibilities of influence on the power - everyone has them. Just do not be fooled that the truth is with you and all of you will obey.
      2. passing
        passing 11 February 2018 16: 14
        +4
        What to do with the current regime and system is basically impossible.


        This is the main trouble in the country! How to defeat devastation, hunger, etc., we know. How to bring out those who interfere with this?
  7. To be or not to be
    To be or not to be 11 February 2018 10: 00
    +2
    prior
    Everything is pretty objective!
    A critical mass of quantitative changes has accumulated. There will inevitably be a new quality. Dialectic.
    And again, dialectics - the law of negation by negation will work.
    But Glazyev-for the smoke screen .. they say everything is bad in the Russian economy. It's like under Serdyukov in the sun, everything is bad. But then suddenly a modern army appeared
    1. vanavatny
      vanavatny 11 February 2018 10: 37
      +2
      yeah, but for now it’s a scooter: they pushed themselves off and moved into the unknown, and no one really answers for anything, and yes, we’ll come for anyone somewhere ...
    2. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 32
      +6
      Quote: To be or not to be
      It’s like when Serdyukov’s in the Armed Forces, everything’s bad. But then suddenly a modern army appeared

      our army is not for the people, but for the oligarchs, so that the West does not offend them.
      1. Ayratelinsion
        Ayratelinsion 12 February 2018 12: 03
        0
        Oh how. And where is the army for the people, and when was it?
  8. Sverdlov
    Sverdlov 11 February 2018 10: 21
    +12
    Everything is not simple, but very simple. "Reform", "FANO" behaves in relation to the Academy of Sciences as a superior organization. "Who pays the money is the master. No wonder.
    Only with science this does not work. Science is based on the fundamental laws of the universe, which cannot be violated. The reform of the Russian Academy of Sciences on the official model ruins science and this is obvious to everyone except the country's leadership.
    A similar reform of the judicial system has led to its complete degradation and the loss of its main function - to protect citizens of the state through compliance with laws. Only judicial officials decided that the law obeyed them. And there is.
    Compared to physics. If you throw a stone, it will fly along the trajectory in accordance with the laws of physics along a completely predicted trajectory. If a lawyer throws a stone where he will fly no one will predict.
    The fundamental law of nature, which allows organisms to survive, including the state and each person individually, the feedback law is violated.
    Put your hand in the fire - burn yourself. And our government is sitting assholes on a hot stove, smoke is around, and they broadcast from the box as everything around is beautiful.
    Happy new time, comrades!
  9. vlad007
    vlad007 11 February 2018 11: 01
    +8
    We need to invest in our economy (science, space, manufacturing, infrastructure), and not in US debt obligations.
    1. sds87
      sds87 11 February 2018 13: 00
      +6
      Quote: vlad007
      We need to invest in our economy

      Apparently, our state is not interested in this. American bonds are our everything. Does anyone else believe in the “independence of the Russian Federation” and the “right” path chosen by the government and the president? Or is it also a “cunning plan” and a “multi-way” to destroy its production and pump money out of the economy?
    2. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 28
      +1
      Quote: vlad007
      We need to invest in our economy (science, space, production, infrastructure)

      It is necessary to create conditions so that the invested money does not go for foreign cars, consumer goods and building materials.
    3. Alber
      Alber 11 February 2018 20: 28
      +2
      Quote: vlad007
      We need to invest in our economy (science, space, manufacturing, infrastructure), and not in US debt obligations.

      Yes, and without the World Cup in football could do ...
      will still sabotage
      1. Victor N
        Victor N 11 February 2018 22: 00
        +1
        You should work out with a different audience.
  10. Victor N
    Victor N 11 February 2018 11: 54
    +2
    This is not a discussion, nothing close to the topic. Grunts of old grandmothers.
    1. Sverdlov
      Sverdlov 11 February 2018 13: 15
      +9
      This is because the people are isolated from power. According to the constitution, one thing, and officials fenced themselves from "ties with the people." A referendum - imposing, rallies, demonstrations - low, constitutional assembly - low, publishing in the press criticism of the authorities - low, getting the court to comply with the law - it is impossible ...
      1. Sling cutter
        Sling cutter 11 February 2018 15: 23
        +6
        Quote: Sverdlov
        This is because the people are isolated from power. According to the constitution, one thing, and officials fenced themselves from "ties with the people." A referendum - imposing, rallies, demonstrations - low, constitutional assembly - low, publishing in the press criticism of the authorities - low, getting the court to comply with the law - it is impossible ...

        The main thing is scrapie, Comrade! hi
    2. Sverdlov
      Sverdlov 11 February 2018 13: 28
      +4
      Therefore, it remains to bay and fart bad gases ...
    3. populist
      populist 11 February 2018 15: 13
      +6
      Victor N
      This is not a discussion, nothing close to the topic. Grunts of old grandmothers.

      And what is there to discuss, dear Victor?
      Glazyev is right in everything. Mechanisms to finance the development of the economy have not been created. The RAS a few years ago came forward with criticism and suggestions. Since then, the RAS has been destroyed. The guarantor is satisfied with the incompetent government. To all thinking people, everything is clear, like "God's" day. Read at Sverdlov
      And our government is sitting assholes on a hot stove, smoke is around, and they broadcast from the box as everything around is beautiful.
      Happy new time, comrades!
      crying
  11. Lexus
    Lexus 11 February 2018 13: 56
    +13
    Sergey Glazyev: We have a terrible economic catastrophe

    As long as the government is “run,” it will only get worse. Zomboyaschik better not watch
    1. Svetlana
      Svetlana 11 February 2018 18: 16
      +2
      Quote: lexus
      As long as the government is “run,” it will only get worse. Zomboyaschik better not watch

      good
  12. APASUS
    APASUS 11 February 2018 15: 04
    +3
    I almost mastered the text, already in the first words I understand that Glazyev too simply sees a solution to the problems of the RAS.
    The reform has no relation to this, because if we talk about the contribution of the Russian Academy of Sciences to economic development, here we are sorely lacking in the mechanism of commercialization of research and development. This mechanism should include venture funds, development banks, investment funds.

    Has anyone seen a poor academician? Yes, all of them have long been with funds and banks, squeeze other people's research, manage offices. In their actions there is not a drop of transparency, the whole structure is bureaucratized to the point of horror.
    Just give an example from my life.
    There are two poultry farms under Peter in Sinyavino. Many probably saw "good" heaps around such complexes accumulated over many years of operation. So this is the basis for developing a very good fertilizer complex. So an American company (I will not name) appeared in St. Petersburg with a proposal to build a factory in this area processing bird droppings into fertilizer, they had only one condition. The Americans want to work with private owners, they will not tolerate any public servants in the shareholders, the result is a factory built in China.
    A curtain!
  13. gladcu2
    gladcu2 11 February 2018 16: 17
    +2
    Sergei Glazyev

    Keep criticism. Criticism is an information transfer format.

    Reporting in science should be. But specialists should be engaged in reporting, (control). To free scientists to direct activities.

    Fundamental science is the fruit of social organization. This is the property of society. Therefore, property value, as public, should be publicly available. In addition to consumption by foreign countries. I hope it is clear why?

    Therefore, your thesis on the commercialization of the Russian Academy of Sciences contradicts the principles of the foundations of fundamental science. RAS, should not be responsible for the application of their developments.

    But you wouldn’t try to figure out a known organ to your nose. It will work out for you analytically.

    Under capitalism, a system based on the primitive instincts of man, lies, greed, theft, mistrust, fear. Fundamental science will remain formal. There will be no development, as there will be no recognition. In such a macrosystem, fundamental knowledge cannot be claimed by society. Since society consists of egoists, which means there is no exchange of information.

    Under capitalism, we can only talk about applied science based on a system of grants.

    He promised with three boxes, received funding. Passed, rectally brought. The result is a muzzle with poppy seeds. He sent all three letters. This is a science under capitalism.

    Please do not confuse science inside corporations. Communist principles work within corporations. There is no monetary system inside corporations. There is a different type of power.

    You are already respected Sergey Glazyev, determine the laws of the organization. And then rushing between capitalism and socialism.
  14. aybolyt678
    aybolyt678 11 February 2018 17: 14
    +2
    SHARE INTERCONTINENTAL TRADE CORPORATIONS !!! SHARE FOREIGN TRADE NETWORKS AND SUPERMARKETS !!!! angry
    1. gladcu2
      gladcu2 11 February 2018 21: 32
      +1
      Is there something to offer in return?

      And then wagging his tongue, not carrying bags.
      1. aybolyt678
        aybolyt678 12 February 2018 05: 48
        0
        nothing to offer, but there is something to strive for .. laughing
  15. To be or not to be
    To be or not to be 11 February 2018 19: 31
    +1
    Quote: aybolyt678
    Quote: To be or not to be
    It’s like when Serdyukov’s in the Armed Forces, everything’s bad. But then suddenly a modern army appeared

    our army is not for the people, but for the oligarchs, so that the West does not offend them.

    Everyone has their own vision!
    But, with any, there is a Homeland, Fatherland .. And "there is such a profession, to protect the Homeland!"
    1. gladcu2
      gladcu2 11 February 2018 21: 39
      +3
      It is good when there is confidence in the fatherland. You give your life for the fatherland, and the fatherland will take care of your loved ones.

      And if in your country liberal capitalism. Authorized gopot is in power. Legalized crime. An economic system that involves the exploitation of primitive moral principles. All the same lies, cowardice, greed, meanness, fear, ignorance - illiteracy and so on. Characterized in one word by selfishness.

      So what? And How?

      And who is the patriot here?
  16. orehovalexandr2017
    orehovalexandr2017 13 February 2018 12: 30
    0
    Alexander Orekhov I deeply sympathize with the respected Sergey Yuryevich Glazyev in his attempt to reason the government and, above all, our guarantor of the protection of state interests - V.V. Putin, to whom he is an unrequited adviser. Surprising and not understanding of the cold indifference of the president to the cries of academician S.Yu. Glazyev on the catastrophic situation in the economy, the hostile actions of the Central Bank, led by E. Nabiulina, as well as a number of other persons who have imposed on the citizens of the country, their destructive activities against Russia, taking into account the president’s attitude to the comments of our country's scientists and patriots, his absolute disregard for them opinion, there is doubt_ whether the president is the guarantor of the country, and if the guarantor, then whom and why. Send, reply
    1. aybolyt678
      aybolyt678 13 February 2018 21: 21
      0
      Quote: orehovalexandr2017
      hostile actions of the Central Bank led by E. Nabiulina

      I would say differently, the actions of a hostile Central Bank. The fact is that not all actions of a hostile Central Bank are harmful to us. For example, licenses from many banks have been revoked. I can’t explain it, but it feels like something is preparing
    2. VladGashek
      VladGashek 18 February 2018 23: 49
      0
      I deeply agree with your comments. But I wanted to invest my "three pennies." Unfortunately, Our Supremes are an excellent politician, but not a bad economist. The dizziness from the success of politics leads him to an unrighteous perception of modern economic realities in the Russian Federation. As a result, he easily perceives the judgment of the Kudrin-Chubais Krasnobaev and is unable to understand the critical analysis of Academician Glazyev.
  17. wax
    wax 13 February 2018 18: 22
    +1
    I wonder how much more to wait for the President to listen to the opinion of his adviser. The last parade is coming.