Military Review

The Kremlin list is lowered "from above". Are there Putin people in US ministries?

63
The list of personalities for the “Kremlin report” was lowered “from above,” indicates the well-known expert Anders Aslund. The substitution of the list for the Forbes rating was made in order to turn the list into a farce.




According to Art. Atlantic Council researcher Anders Aslund, the “Kremlin list” was replaced by a Forbes rating. The task of such a substitution is clear: someone wanted to put the idea as a mockery.

The list of Russian “oligarchs” and persons close to the Kremlin, who had been thought through for a long time in the American Ministry of Finance, was replaced at the last moment by “someone from above,” Aslund asserts. As a result, the long-awaited list became a “directory” containing a number of the names of Russian officials. With them for the company, the document was supplemented with the names of billionaires from the Forbes rating. This was done on purpose in order to laugh at the idea of ​​anti-Russian sanctions.

The “Law on Counteracting the Opponents of America through Sanctions” (CAATSA) is particularly interesting in the 241 section. This part of the document establishes the duty for the US Treasury Secretary, with the support of the Director of National Intelligence and the Secretary of State, to prepare a report with a list within 180 days. It was necessary to collect the names of the "most important" figures of Russia and the "oligarchs" who have connections with the "Russian regime".

This report was published on the night of January 30 2018. Several government departments did work on the list. "But at the last minute, someone at the top (it is not yet known who exactly) threw out the work of experts, and instead wrote the names of high-ranking officials of the presidential administration of Russia and the government, adding the names of 96 Russian billionaires from the Forbes list," Aslund quoted. "InoTV". “By doing so, this high-ranking official ridiculed government experts who prepared a completely different report, and presented CAATSA with an ineffective law, ridiculing the anti-Russian sanctions of the United States as a whole.” And by signing this list, the US Treasury Secretary took responsibility for the document.

According to Aslund, this is not a list, but some kind of "excerpt from the Kremlin's phone book." What is the effect of waiting for her? And the expert's answer: the published “Kremlin phone book” only ... will unite the Russian elite behind Putin!

But the authors of CAATSA, on the contrary, sought to split the Russian elite!

And the conclusion of the expert: the main beneficiary of the list is ... the president of Russia!

It turns out, we note that not only President Trump himself, but also his people in the government, starting with the Minister of Finance Mr. Mnuchin, are agents of the Kremlin.

The State Department also seems to serve Putin. Another one the news arrived: right on the day of the promulgation of the “Kremlin list”, the State Department was supposed to announce new sanctions against states and companies that had previously concluded deals with the defense and intelligence sector of Russia, as prescribed by the same CAATSA law. However, State Department officials suddenly refused these sanctions, explaining that, they say, CAATSA is already holding back trade in the defense sector of the Russian Federation.

Observed and commented on Oleg Chuvakin
- especially for topwar.ru
Photos used:
http://www.globallookpress.com/
63 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Alexander War
    Alexander War 1 February 2018 07: 47
    +4
    Video on the topic!
    1. vlad66
      vlad66 1 February 2018 07: 52
      12
      The task of such a substitution is clear: someone wanted to make the idea itself a laughing stock.

      I can send the state departments to the telephone directory of our city, let them practice. When a cat does nehren, he licks the dandies.
      1. volodya
        volodya 1 February 2018 07: 57
        18
        Putin is a polite person and therefore he has people around him!
        1. Gardamir
          Gardamir 1 February 2018 08: 02
          +8
          polite
          just a minus. no one who hates everything Soviet should be attached to the glory of those years.
          1. Andrey Yuryevich
            Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 08: 19
            10
            Quote: Gardamir
            just a minus. no one who hates everything Soviet should be attached to the glory of those years.
            Gardamir, but HE successfully imposed sanctions against hundreds of billionaires, to 140 million inhabitants of Russia. - and this is the whole broadcast. I hope everyone heard that? “These are sanctions against 140 million people!” - That was said. that is, the oligarchs and the people are a single monolithic force.
            1. You Vlad
              You Vlad 1 February 2018 08: 36
              +6
              Quote: Andrey Yurievich
              that is, the oligarchs and the people are a single monolithic force.

              Well, if you live in a vacuum, then of course you will not be affected by economic sanctions.
              Quote: Gardamir
              no one who hates everything Soviet should be attached to the glory of those years.

              An example can lead the hatred of GDP to everything Soviet?
              1. Andrey Yuryevich
                Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 08: 44
                +8
                Quote: You Vlad
                Well, if you live in a vacuum, then of course you will not be affected by economic sanctions.

                deep "castle" and there is almost a "vacuum". "Maskichs" do not even realize that There is Life.
                1. You Vlad
                  You Vlad 1 February 2018 08: 52
                  +7
                  Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                  deep "castle" and there is almost a "vacuum". "Maskichs" do not even realize that There is Life.

                  I lived in Moscow at that time for about ten years, I can say that Muscovites have no sugar! This crazy rhythm of life, constant traffic jams, noise background, there is absolutely no time left for life. hi
                  1. Andrey Yuryevich
                    Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 10: 13
                    +6
                    Quote: You Vlad
                    I lived in Moscow at that time for about ten years, I can say that Muscovites have no sugar! This crazy rhythm of life, constant traffic jams, noise background, there is absolutely no time left for life.

                    what a pity them .... but here we are, we also have to work for a penny. hi
                    1. AlexVas44
                      AlexVas44 1 February 2018 10: 29
                      +2
                      Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                      .and here we have to work for a penny.

                      And taxes collected in the region have to be sent to Moscow. am
                    2. You Vlad
                      You Vlad 1 February 2018 10: 55
                      +2
                      Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                      what a pity them ....

                      I really feel sorry for them, life passes by, and it is known to be finite! To live for the sake of later? Not what money is not worth it, because then, maybe not. I understand your Zamkady complex wink The very first time, when he was forced to return to his hometown, he was tormented the first time, it was not childish, how can I work for these pennies? crying
                      Now acclimatized, happiness is not in money, especially since they do not give life repeat
                      Briefly married and became a philosopher laughing
                  2. andrewkor
                    andrewkor 1 February 2018 13: 54
                    +2
                    I fully support you, I cut off for three years on ZiL. Then Tashkent seemed like a quiet backwater!
                2. just exp
                  just exp 1 February 2018 09: 10
                  +5
                  I live 3 thousand km from Moscow, tell me when I died?
                  1. Andrey Yuryevich
                    Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 10: 14
                    +3
                    Quote: just EXPL
                    I live 3 thousand km from Moscow, tell me when I died?

                    when were born outside the Moscow Ring Road. otherwise, the government would Know about you.
                    1. just exp
                      just exp 1 February 2018 11: 04
                      +1
                      Do you think it doesn’t know about me?
                3. andrewkor
                  andrewkor 1 February 2018 13: 55
                  +1
                  It used to be called the Tundra, the 80s.
            2. Gardamir
              Gardamir 1 February 2018 08: 41
              +4
              that is, the oligarchs and the people are a single monolithic force.
              When two years ago I could not find money for an operation for my wife, they were found simply by miracle. all that was needed was to approach Arkash Rottenberg ...
              1. Stas157
                Stas157 1 February 2018 09: 50
                +4
                Quote: Gardamir
                When two years ago I could not find money for an operation for my wife, they were found simply by miracle.

                Excuse me, did you treat your wife abroad? Simply, here on the forum they constantly write about what a wonderful and free medicine we have! I am at a loss ...
                1. Andrey Yuryevich
                  Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 10: 31
                  +4
                  Quote: Stas157
                  here on the forum they constantly write about what a wonderful and free medicine we have! I am at a loss ...
                  I, too ... literally a couple of hours from the Central City Hospital, I STARTED to do-Rights to change, because at the end of February-expire. total: turn to the "vampires" people 50-55 ... and this is at 7 30, blood intake from 8.30. all is piling up, swearing, tightness. you need to withstand this blood pressure, and ... yes ... another urine analysis in a jar to throw in another office (this is a trifle). my friend and I were in line for the 6th unhappy (not ... happy!), we went around 8.50 — the crowd was already murmuring ... —and that's all for a fee. for 1 thousand 165 rubles to you the Ministry of Health. (so that you ...) when they left the "blood zone" there were already 70 people ... offhand. the next step through .... TWO !!! WEEKS !!! by RECORD !!! "runner" with doctors, "grandmother at the cash desk" .... turn ... "X-ray" - "turn ...), am
                  a booster card in the registry (the line is natural) "(only after the" X-ray ") !!! - and the line is the line of the line ... to the optometrist, ENT,., etc. .... HELL .... we only have such a madhouse? I thought ... maybe well, nafig ... a car, a garden ... to sell all the fuck ... and ... but, children and grandchildren, who will support them then. recourse here again in battle.
                  1. marline
                    marline 1 February 2018 10: 55
                    +1
                    Quote: Andrew Y.
                    literally a couple of hours from the Central City Hospital reference ...

                    Why in the Central City Hospital? In a private one and a half out of turn.
                    1. Andrey Yuryevich
                      Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 11: 15
                      +1
                      Quote: merlin
                      Why in the Central City Hospital? In a private one and a half out of turn.

                      where to go ? we have "in paradise" one place where you can go ...
                      1. marline
                        marline 1 February 2018 11: 26
                        0
                        Quote: Andrew Y.
                        Quote: merlin
                        Why in the Central City Hospital? In a private one and a half out of turn.

                        where to go ?

                        Yandex will tell wink
                        No, seriously, look at private clinics. At least three years ago, they gave me a medical certificate in a couple of hours and not much more expensive than in a clinic. The year before, when a certificate was required for a job, it was there exactly how you killed two weeks and damned everything in the world.
                  2. Stas157
                    Stas157 1 February 2018 11: 31
                    +4
                    Quote: Andrey Yurievich
                    a booster card in the registry (the line is natural) "(only after the" X-ray ") !!! - and the line is the line of the line ... to the ophthalmologist, ENT,., etc. .... HELL .... we only have such a madhouse?

                    Yes, I drive my child to a paid clinic, having free for free near me! And this is not from the fact that I have nowhere to put money, but rather from hopelessness. The free procedures provided by the state still need to be achieved through the loss of time and nerves. So it turns out that we have free medicine only on paper, but in reality, you still have to pay.
                  3. Lieutenant
                    Lieutenant 2 February 2018 14: 33
                    +1
                    I don’t know how it is with you, but in Rostov near us, of all the inconveniences in the clinic, this is an electronic queue. But vampires and all other tests and procedures are free if not express. But about the queues, I agree with you.
                2. Gardamir
                  Gardamir 1 February 2018 14: 40
                  +2
                  treated?
                  she could die for free, but she wouldn’t have enough money to go abroad.
            3. Overlock
              Overlock 1 February 2018 10: 06
              0
              Quote: Andrey Yurievich
              that is, the oligarchs and the people are a single monolithic force.

              these are just words, just words. The essence has not changed
          2. Stas157
            Stas157 1 February 2018 09: 46
            +8
            Quote: Gardamir
            just a minus. no one who hates everything Soviet should be attached to the glory of those years.

            I am simply shocked by the fact that a parade is held on Red Square on November 7th, it is not called by its own name (military parade in honor of the 24th anniversary of the Great October Revolution), but simply: Parade of 41 years.
            What is the difference between the Kremlin and Bandera’s, if they retouch and rename historical names associated with the Soviet past. Mausoleum bashfully plywood shut! And, at the same time, imagine that none of the patriots ury feels at all humiliated.
            1. Overlock
              Overlock 1 February 2018 10: 08
              +3
              Quote: Stas157
              What is the difference between the Kremlin and Bandera’s, if they retouch and rename historical names associated with the Soviet past.

              tricky question! No ardent one will answer, because there is nothing to say.
      2. Stas157
        Stas157 1 February 2018 08: 52
        +7
        Quote: vlad66

        I can send the state departments to the telephone directory of our city, let them practice.

        In your city, that some oligarchs live and people close to Putin? I'm afraid that you are not interested in the State Department with your telephone directory at all ... But what’s what, and you won’t be denied self-conceit!
        I already wrote that the oligarchs and officials will now depict nominal sanctions as a blow to all of Russia, trying to add their personalities to the entire Russian people, so here you are doing the same thing. And this is not the first time that you have posted similar (not your own, alien) viral thoughts on the forum.
        1. Andrey Yuryevich
          Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 11: 25
          +3
          the fact that when the parade is held on Red Square on November 7, it is not called by its own name (military parade in honor of the 24th anniversary of the Great October Revolution), but simply: Parade 41 years.
          vmazat a point ...
      3. Lelek
        Lelek 1 February 2018 11: 51
        0
        Quote: vlad66
        I can send the state departments of the telephone directory of our city, let them practice

        Hey.
        Do you think that having eaten this reference book for breakfast, people from the Senate and Congress will be cured of their chronic Russophobia? I don’t think so - the process is irreversible. The only remedies are Kashchenko or the guillotine.
  2. Aristarkh Lyudvigovich
    Aristarkh Lyudvigovich 1 February 2018 07: 52
    0
    Of the 210 people in the "Kremlin" list of the USA, 5 are Tatarstan people. The Shaimiev brothers are Ayrat (general director of Tatavtodor OJSC) and Radik (member of the TAIF board of directors), TAIF general director Albert Shigabutdinov, TAIF chairman of the board of directors Rustem Sulteev and head of Tatneft Nail Maganov. The question is what interest the United States has in Tatarstan.
    1. Observer2014
      Observer2014 1 February 2018 08: 03
      11
      Aristarkh Lyudvigovich
      The question is what interest the United States has in Tatarstan.
      Probably because Tatarstan is Russia? No?
      1. Andrey Yuryevich
        Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 08: 33
        +2
        Quote: Observer2014
        Probably because Tatarstan is Russia? No?

        no, because Muslims, which means that you can send "emissaries" as it happens, and work from within.
      2. Gardamir
        Gardamir 1 February 2018 08: 45
        +4
        Tatarstan Russia?
        Ukraine is also Russia, but they have all explained to us that this is not so. Now you can take any region of Russia and say that they are horses.
        By the way, the real Ukraine in all: Lutsk, Rivne, Lviv, Ternopol, Ivanovo-Frankivsk, Uzhgorod and Chernivtsi regions, the rest are the same Ukrainians as Kuban and Stavropol.
        And Kharkov and Donetsk, and Odessa is also Russia, like Tatarstan, only to whom it is interesting, because only Crimea for some reason is ours.
        1. mikh-korsakov
          mikh-korsakov 1 February 2018 10: 44
          +1
          With what fright "Uzhgorod" Transcarpathian region actually is Ukraine. I haven’t met a single Ukrainian there, except the traffic police are Ukrainians in my heart, and so are all Hungarians, Slovaks, Romanians.
          1. Gardamir
            Gardamir 1 February 2018 14: 46
            0
            What a fright Hungarians, Slovaks, Romanians.
            You have inattentively read the east of Hungary, and Poland and Romania are Krajina. After 1945 they entered the USSR, and now it is customary to consider who, from Kharkov to Uzhgorod, this is all Ukraine. Only Ukraine is there in the west, and the rest is New Russia and Little Russia.
      3. uav80
        uav80 1 February 2018 09: 33
        +1
        You are not right smile , many still have Shaimiev’s separatism in their heads, they used to have their own flags on their license plates ... since the 90s, Tatarstan has been a state in a state. It was beneficial to the Republic and the Kremlin until a certain point. After Minnikhanov came to power, everything began to change, Moscow began to take the preferences of the region so that it did not stand out from its neighbors, increasing the tax burden and reducing federal data ...
    2. PalBor
      PalBor 1 February 2018 08: 48
      +3
      Quote: Aristarkh Lyudvigovich
      Of the 210 people in the "Kremlin" list of the USA, 5 are Tatarstan people. The Shaimiev brothers are Ayrat (general director of Tatavtodor OJSC) and Radik (member of the TAIF board of directors), TAIF general director Albert Shigabutdinov, TAIF chairman of the board of directors Rustem Sulteev and head of Tatneft Nail Maganov. The question is what interest the United States has in Tatarstan.

      Yes, it doesn’t matter. For example, three from the list of Ryazans. They sculpted, looking at posts, and not at geography.
    3. Overlock
      Overlock 1 February 2018 10: 10
      +1
      Quote: Aristarkh Ludwigovich
      The question is what interest the United States has in Tatarstan.

      no. Interest in personal condition. which is behind the cordon. Recently read. that the list includes those with more than 1 billion S. By the way, Luzhkov’s wife is on the list
      1. Paranoid50
        Paranoid50 1 February 2018 10: 54
        +1
        Quote: Overlock
        the list includes those with more than 1 billion S.

        And there is. yes Suppose, before entering the rotation, Durov had “not enough” 50 thousand poured money.
  3. Simon
    Simon 1 February 2018 07: 53
    +2
    It was necessary to collect the names of the “most important” figures of Russia and the “oligarchs” who have connections with the “Russian regime”. --- Apparently, they will look for “mishandled Cossacks” in themselves? Let the wool - wise guys! Trump, we chose our hackers! laughing
  4. tchoni
    tchoni 1 February 2018 08: 06
    +2
    Kaneshno, it’s not for nothing that our late Yezhov in the new reincarnation earned money by the American president))) Well, capital must be returned to Russia.
  5. Observer2014
    Observer2014 1 February 2018 08: 13
    +5
    Here I read all this and find myself wondering how I can drum all of these Kremlin lists. And all sorts of attempts there to split the Russian elites. However, as well as on these elites themselves laughingYes, let all accounts be arrested abroad. And they’ll make them non-entry. That’s generally purple to the bulb.
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich 1 February 2018 09: 19
      +2
      Quote: Observer2014
      So I read all this and catch myself thinking how can I get all these Kremlin lists on the drum.

      and I, I understand, that the hell is not a decent pension for me, and not the "indecent" pension, and the hell is it for me, not a decrease in the housing and communal services. And even more so gasoline ... everything is decided not from the wallet of the "oligarchs", but from the pockets of hard workers and retirees.
    2. Overlock
      Overlock 1 February 2018 10: 12
      0
      Quote: Observer2014
      Here I read all this and find myself wondering how I can drum all of these Kremlin lists. And all sorts of attempts there to split the Russian elites. However, as well as laughing on these elites themselves, let all accounts be arrested abroad. And they’ll make them not entry. to a light bulb. However, like these elites on ordinary Russians

      So the list of preferences "for moral damage" on the part of the state is organized. Rotenberg example!
      And again they will raise everything to us- prices, taxes
  6. aszzz888
    aszzz888 1 February 2018 08: 16
    +2
    It turns out that in the settlements of RUSSIA there is a Washington province, which is not absolutely necessary for us. Well, tolerate a little bit, and there - how they will behave! bully
  7. Knowing
    Knowing 1 February 2018 08: 20
    +2
    Exactly, it was: The Kremlin Report was replaced at the last moment. This statement was made by an economist specializing in Eastern Europe, an expert of the Atlantic Council, Anders Aslund.
    According to Oslund, in the original version the “Kremlin report” was to name entrepreneurs and “oligarchs” who made their fortunes illegally - through contacts with the Kremlin. However, at the last minute, some high-ranking person - who, now unknown, dropped the entire work of experts and instead wrote down the names of senior officials from the Russian presidential and government administrations and 96 Russian billionaires from the Forbes list.

    In favor of the fact that the “Kremlin” plan was insidiously laid out by PERSON PUTIN, Germany does not change its attitude towards Russia, and contrary to numerous wishes from the pan-cookers, who had already divided Russia in their dreams and divided land up to the Pacific Ocean, RUSSIA did not stand up on their knees and Sobchak with Navalny and Grudinin could not provoke a coup .... Although : Foreign Minister Klimkin expressed full confidence that Russia, after the “Kremlin list”, will be forced to return Crimea, Donetsk, Lugansk to Ukraine and pay “reparation” for the damage for centuries. The Minister of Justice Petrenko categorically said that everything, the Russian Federation is no more and it is only necessary to legitimize its division in accordance with international law. The guarantor of the nation significantly hinted that he expects the publication of such a list by the European Union. Wait, in his opinion, was not long. Few hours
    see: .http: //www.imperiyanews.ru/details/5da568f2-8
    806-e811-80ea-020c5d00406e


    http://www.imperiyanews.ru/details/23857ae8-b506-
    e811-80ea-020c5d00406e
    laughing
    1. aszzz888
      aszzz888 1 February 2018 09: 11
      +2
      Knowing Today, 08:20 Similarly, it was: the Kremlin Report was replaced at the last moment.

      Verily, your deeds are wonderful, Lord!
    2. Sanichsan
      Sanichsan 1 February 2018 16: 09
      0
      So. Stop! if the one that was published is the wrong list, then where is the correct one? maybe Oslund’s correct list is so secret that its publication, as an alternative to the wrong one, is impossible?
      or maybe the fighter with Russia Oslund just drank up the budget money allocated for the project and is now trying to save his ass from the righteous anger of the employer? laughing
  8. mikh-korsakov
    mikh-korsakov 1 February 2018 08: 47
    +2
    I quote: "Indeed, several government departments worked on the list. “But at the last minute, someone at the top (it is still unknown who exactly) threw out the experts' work, and in return wrote the names of senior officials of the presidential administration of Russia and the government". In short, several government departments WORKED. As an option, deprive everyone and warn of incomplete official compliance. It turns out that they do not have the White House, but the entrance yard, if someone managed to replace the document that they worked on for six months. As an option, fire everyone security guards and cleaners. Finally, to him Aslund, I would now call him Osland it is not known who exactly replaced the document - Nui is stupid! Is it really not clear that Putin’s long arm reached out to the white house.
    1. jjj
      jjj 1 February 2018 10: 27
      +3
      Quote: mikh-korsakov
      Is it really not clear that Putin’s long arm reached the white house.

      Sergei Evgenievich Naryshkin, our chief intelligence officer, just returned from the United States just before
  9. Alex-a832
    Alex-a832 1 February 2018 08: 52
    +3
    To explain their own stupidity by Kremlin conspiracies for the state elites has become the norm of things. Apparently, degradation has a large inertia. It seems that against the background of the activity of such geopolitical opponents of the United States as Russia and China, the Americans should have cheered up and stopped being stupid, but no, they are still stupid in the dark, put themselves on display for being ... satchels, which they are.
  10. CAT BAIYUN
    CAT BAIYUN 1 February 2018 08: 54
    +1
    the main beneficiary of the compiled list is ... the president of Russia!

    That is, as usual - the Darkest is to blame .... Well, it's not news - we are an absolute evil in the American sense. Absolute evil must be destroyed. That is, this is what is coming ... I mean, they will try.
  11. cniza
    cniza 1 February 2018 08: 55
    +2
    The State Department also seems to be serving Putin.


    All US people serve Putin.
    1. Lelek
      Lelek 1 February 2018 11: 58
      0
      Quote: cniza
      All US people serve Putin.

      hi
      That is how the people of China join this company. bully
  12. Monster_Fat
    Monster_Fat 1 February 2018 08: 57
    0
    But "this" did not "enter", like "that" ....

    https://marketsignal.ru/2018/01/31/chubajs-obyasn
    il-pochemu-ego-net-v-kremlevskom-doklade /? utm_sou
    rce = finobzor.ru wink
  13. mihey
    mihey 1 February 2018 09: 13
    0
    Conspirologists attack America !!! (while Russian hackers are resting) laughing
    1. Lelek
      Lelek 1 February 2018 12: 01
      0
      Quote: mihey
      Conspirologists attack America

      hi
      Well, not only that. There are heads in this world stuffed with brains:
  14. bald
    bald 1 February 2018 09: 15
    0
    Absolutely fools are confused, from through dimensional enthusiasm for Russophobia.
  15. Laksamana besar
    Laksamana besar 1 February 2018 10: 09
    +1
    In Davos, Dvorkovich said that we do not have oligarchs, but there are successful managers who earn 200 thousand bucks a day by releasing gas, oil and Rolls-Vaz. At 2017 on the Forbes list, the number of our billionaires has grown by 25% to 96. And we should be grateful to all these people, because only thanks to them the average salary in the country is growing steadily and continuously, otherwise we would live poorly even according to statistics. anekdotov.net
  16. iouris
    iouris 1 February 2018 11: 31
    0
    I think that in the American ministries there are people of the conditional Rothschilds and conditional Rockefellers. And our ministries?
  17. Fkjydjckfrgh
    Fkjydjckfrgh 1 February 2018 13: 21
    +1
    marline,
    "No bread? Let them eat cakes." (with)