Abandoned "children" of Navalny

56


The last “All-Russian” action of Alexei Navalny can very much really be his last mass action. The idea went bankrupt, and everyone already understands this, even Lesch himself, who wants only one thing: so that all this ends as soon as possible and be left alone. His unhappiness colleague, ex-president of Georgia Mikhail Saakashvili also dreams of the same thing in Kiev.



If you look closely and analyze the Kiev Mikhomaydan and the social movement Navalny, we will see a lot of common details. Everything was clearly created for one training manual, initially had the same weaknesses, and therefore was doomed to defeat before birth. And this means that no one has ever considered either Navalny or Saakashvili as future political leaders. They appeared in politics to fulfill a completely different mission.

First, let's take a closer look at the features of both movements.



Both "opposition leaders", in Russia, in Ukraine, are the direct six of the US State Department, who do not have any real political base at home.

That the bulk of Navalny, that of Saakashvili, is pure impromptu, made on the knee. There are no real system specialists for building a party and promoting it in the political field. Most of them are creative “caring” people who are not accustomed to systematic and systematic work (and at the same time thinking). Therefore, whatever they created, all this is doomed to failure from the outset. And fast.

What is not immediately apparent to the inexperienced eye is obvious to a professional political technologist and a politician. Did you notice that neither real politicians supported Alexey or Miho? They are just fine figured out what's what. No, they wish their supporters all the best and victory, but at the same time do not provide them with any real help. Moreover, they demonstratively try to distance themselves and show with their whole appearance that they have nothing to do with this circus. And it is natural. Those who deal with politics professionally immediately realized that Navalny and Saakashvili are just highly paid hired clowns, and their social movements are political freaks.

With each of their new action, it became more and more obvious. In the early spring of 2017, Navalny looked like such a political heavyweight, with a claim to the role of the Russian opposition leader. But there were months, and each subsequent action became only a pathetic parody of the previous ones. The latter, held on January 28 in 46 subjects of the Russian Federation, has become a real disgrace.

1000 supporters of the “main anti-corruption activist” did not gather in Moscow, and in some other large cities of Russia, where several thousand people used to gather, 100-200 people came, who, judging by their faces, didn’t understand why did it.



We see the same thing in Kiev. In September, the 2017 th supporters of Nawal ..., that is, Saakashvili, were full of optimism. Already 17 of October, on the first official day of the protest, when Saakashvili was not supported by any significant Ukrainian politician, confusion appeared. And then Mihomaydan, as they began to be called among the people, very quickly degenerated into a open-air circus opposite the Verkhovna Rada building.



Well, you will agree, but why then all this was started? In fact, this is the point.

For example, you need to start a real political project. How to quickly unleash it? And while not to get dirty and do not get negative political "karma"? For this there are political torpedoes. Be it a person, be it a social movement. They do not make sense to throw good shots. These are peer projects that, after fulfilling their mission, are doomed to extinction.

They throw ideas into the society necessary for the customer, promote them in the information field, pump public opinion, set a vector of protest and quickly burn and disappear. All this is pretty cheap.

Let's remember the deceived children of Navalny and the “activists” of Saakashvili.

As we understand, in this scheme, the rapid accumulation of negativity against the leaders and combustion are inevitable. And there is absolutely no need for logic. On the contrary, it prevents such projects from developing. That is why we see no seemingly any logic in the protests of Navalny and Saakashvili. They do not have a comprehensive positive reform program for the country and far-reaching plans (and who needs them?). Everything is designed for simplicity, emotion and transience.

Leaders protest discredited, but it is not important for the customer. It is important that in the end there remains an angry and dissatisfied protest community that wants to recoup, which will be easy for them to pick up for themselves an already new political movement, the “pure” and the “pure”. At the same time there is no formal connection between the two projects. There is one customer and director, but they just remain out of sight of society.

Like this. And you say: meaningless. In fact, Americans rarely do meaningless things in this field. They are the best so far in the world experts on technology color revolutions. Yes, they do not all succeed, but in logic they can not refuse. That is why I would not laugh today at those who invested in Navalny and Saakashvili. I am confident that their ultimate goal does not lie in the plane of the current presidential elections in Russia or attempts to spin the early elections in Ukraine.
56 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. +4
    30 January 2018 06: 12
    enough can rub about the landslide? he is nobody, from the word "completely."
    1. +2
      30 January 2018 06: 27
      That's right. We only do PR and support something like that .. This also applies to the “news” from the ruin. Everything! The panel died!
      Quote: Dead Day
      enough can rub about the landslide? he is nobody, from the word "completely."
    2. +10
      30 January 2018 08: 06
      Quote: Dead Day
      enough can rub about the landslide?

      Hehe hehe ...... covering your face with your hands, do not solve the problem!
      Quote: Dead Day
      he is nobody, from the word "completely."

      He may be "no one" but he fulfills his denyuzhka competently, the water sharpens a stone ..
      1. +2
        30 January 2018 08: 12
        Of the nine people in the foreground, two with cameras, one with video, two are taken to the phone. request
      2. +5
        30 January 2018 09: 50
        So the author writes about this. That such projects are being made precisely for the promotion of subsequent, real ones. Like a step. The goal at this stage is to increase the layer of people dissatisfied with the current government.
        Now, at the next stage, other settings will be used - not "friendship with the West", but "longing for the USSR."
      3. +5
        30 January 2018 12: 34
        Quote: Serg65
        He may be "no one" but he fulfills his denyuzhka competently, the water sharpens a stone ..
        The author says so, then, it will be easier for another wrestler. It is worth recalling that the work to destroy the USSR took place over the years, gradually. Also now, unconnected events can have common goals, and people as a result of this will be puppets, "and we are for shooo ?????"
        1. +6
          30 January 2018 12: 37
          Quote: Reptiloid
          it will be easier for another fighter. It is worth recalling that the work to destroy the USSR took place over many years, gradually

          And how it happened !!! Only in contrast to the modern Navalny under the USSR, the members of the ruling party were mostly engaged in this work, that’s painful!
    3. +6
      30 January 2018 08: 58
      enough can rub about the landslide? he is nobody, from the word "completely."

      Here, in 10 years, when a generation grows up without education under the current principles (to steal more) that a failure will always prove that our elite steals and lives on under the cover of power at the expense of population. And these young people without work or a salary are tears, then all your clever (as you think) conclusions, and most of those who comment, can be thrown into the furnace. ALL BODY MOVEMENTS ARE FAILED NOT FOR THESE ELECTIONS !!! And the fact that you are clever here what he is and where, yes to him and those who lead him.
      1. +2
        30 January 2018 14: 49
        Quote: passing
        which will fail all the time to prove that our elite is stealing and chewing under the guise of power at the expense of population.

        And this, of course, is not the case, Navalny is lying all the bastards, in fact, the Puten elite, including the most gentleman, are real patriots and silver-free people, and all educated and smart people know this!
    4. +1
      30 January 2018 11: 18
      I'm kind of trying to analyze in order to understand the situation. Me Navalny, like Saakashvili, are not interested. I am interested in the gain of the whole party, and for this I need to correctly understand the situation.
      1. +1
        30 January 2018 12: 37
        Quote: yurasumy
        I'm kind of trying to analyze in order to understand the situation. Me Navalny, like Saakashvili, are not interested. I am interested in the gain of the whole party, and for this I need to correctly understand the situation.

        And often remember, the USSR, the ruin, the Arab spring .......
      2. +4
        30 January 2018 12: 39
        Quote: yurasumy
        I am interested in the gain of the whole party, and for this I need to correctly understand the situation.

        Go back to 27 years ago and you will see the gain of the whole game and understand the situation ...
    5. 0
      30 January 2018 12: 51
      Quote: Dead Day
      enough can rub about the landslide


      And Lyokh and Ksenia give anathema! Let them boil in their own shit!
      1. 0
        30 January 2018 13: 15
        Yes to count them, and not to give anathema, to count recourse
        1. 0
          30 January 2018 20: 15
          Uh, no. The curators will jump for joy if Lesha something happens. After all, this will be the best PR and the best emotional effect. Better fight on a cold head.
    6. +2
      30 January 2018 14: 15
      Quote: Dead Day
      he is nobody, from the word "completely."

      He is nobody. But who are his customers?
    7. +1
      30 January 2018 17: 54
      Navalny cannot even go to jail to pass for “a hero and a sufferer for the happiness of the people,” no matter how hard he tries. He was even denied this. laughing
    8. 0
      31 January 2018 10: 12
      Or maybe - according to the Law, it is high time to deal with him? He has convictions with real terms of imprisonment - yes, according to the Law he is obliged to serve his sentence - he is obliged, now - let him sit. good
  2. +4
    30 January 2018 06: 20
    Money has an account, invested ... received, based on what is happening from all this, the curators from the American side got more enriched ... remember not clinking glasses Ukraine ... like invested 5 (five) billion dollars ... for this money you could just have everyone to buy and do everything beautifully ... "democratically" ... Yushchenko’s experience was ... but we are witnessing an open slaughter, the curators turned on the scheme - the war will write everything off, the sponsors lost in the first place ... who invested, maybe the money was recaptured, but a pretty penny. Now curators need sacrificial rams, more precisely ... as in the case of Nemtsov ... and there are new sanctions. The USA cannot honestly trade, they are made according to their rules in their own field, and so they began to twist their hands around the world.
  3. +1
    30 January 2018 06: 27
    It’s a pity that the circus was closed and the clowns can leave as unnecessary in places not so remote.
    1. +1
      30 January 2018 07: 03
      Quote: Seraphimamur
      It’s a pity that the circus was closed and the clowns can leave as unnecessary in places not so remote.

      No need to worry about this, they will find other characters, have money, have goals, everything will continue as before, only with other people. hi bully
  4. +2
    30 January 2018 06: 37
    we will see many common details
    When bottling comes from one barrel this is not at all surprising.
    The last "all-Russian" action
    But the declarations were loud and should, in the opinion of the impudent one, at least frighten the authorities, and as a maximum the GDP should refuse to nominate its candidacy. The nonsense is certainly complete, but you need to somehow work out the money.
    1. 0
      30 January 2018 12: 42
      [quote = rotmistr60] [/ quote] But the declarations were loud and should, in the opinion of the impudent, at least frighten the authorities, and as a maximum, the GDP should refuse to nominate its candidacy. Nonsense is certainly complete, but you need to somehow work out the money. [/ Quote] Probably for these exaggerations and promises to overthrow he gets $$$$$ ..... Well, then --- SORRY, BROTHER, IT WASN'T RECEIVED! ..
  5. +2
    30 January 2018 07: 19
    Well, I would not so obviously “gloat” over the fact that Navalny came out to support such a small number of participants. The fact is that you still need to understand a little bit about modern methods of "protest movements." The state, by “tightening the screws”, made any meetings practically impossible, and even with the availability of the Internet there is no need for such “gatherings” —to attract too much attention, and therefore the “protest” movement has gone to the “Internet” - now those who are dissatisfied communicate and are “pumped up” by ideology their forums, networks, even on gaming sites, and prepare their actions for various elections - in order to “vote correctly” all at once or to officially authorized marches and demonstrations in order to “budge” in the right place and carry out what they need. In addition, carriers of "protest" are very active in schools, especially with "different biases", where the presence of "protest" sentiment becomes a fashion trend among students, the real persecution of students who are "patriot" or "for Putin" begins ... So that I wouldn’t be so happy about the alleged “reduction” of protest disorder, they are growing, they simply “went out of sight” deep so as not to “glow” in advance ...
    1. +3
      30 January 2018 12: 53
      I would not so obviously "gloat" over the fact that Navalny came out
      But is there any point in gloating (in your opinion) over those who in life do not fit into today's country, no matter how hard they try to work out Western money. Who provokes young people to a direct confrontation of power and at the same time modestly remains on the sidelines. Apparently and according to your comments, you are so "strongly" rooting for Russia on the American side, that you probably "can’t eat already."
  6. +2
    30 January 2018 07: 22
    Yuri! So far, bulk workers manage to brainwash youth, because no one works with these youth properly! Our youth is growing street! There is no like in the USSR there were clubs, circles, and sections where young people with pleasure went! And on the street, loitering to catch and make them brains is not a problem!
    1. +8
      30 January 2018 08: 16
      Which street"? What are the "circles"? Again, “Soviet” thinking does not allow us to see the obvious — in society now there is one “trend” - “make money”. And there is no other and will not be anymore. Young people no longer "stagger" through the streets, as in the late "scoop", but sits on the "Internet" and sometimes, with "short dashes", moves to places of "hanging out". And young people want only one thing - to make money, preferably a lot of money and move up the career and social ladders ... And what do they see? But they see that the country has built a system of "vertical power" at all levels where only relatives, friends and friends, but not anyone from the street can enter. They see that labor is the lot of losers, since those who work plow from dawn to dawn and remain poor .... money doesn’t work at all in the labor sphere, and you want to interest them with circles ... outdated This and nafig nobody needs.
      1. +2
        30 January 2018 09: 55
        Quote: Monster_Fat
        And young people want only one thing - to make money, preferably a lot of money and move up the career and social ladders ... And what do they see? But they see that the country has built a system of "vertical power" at all levels where only relatives, friends and friends, but not anyone from the street can enter.
        -in the days of Peter 1 there was also a “power vertical” at all levels where only relatives, close friends and friends could enter, “but for some reason Menshikov didn’t stop .... and there are such examples of the abyss ...
        In any state (absolutely any !!!) - there is always a "power vertical" at all levels where only relatives, friends and friends can enter, "where it is very difficult to break through.
        Nowhere do they meet pens under the whites and say they say - mister / comrade / pan / monsieur / others - there is a warm, moneyy place on which to sit easily and pleasantly, only YOU were waiting !!!!

        even in absolutely open Soviet times, not everyone could become the head of a factory, for example, a master, please, the head of a workshop — you already had to prove yourself, and as a chief engineer — you had to make global efforts already ..
        Studying at a serious institute, and in Soviet times, not everyone could; at MGIMO, for example, there was a practically legalized quota for a province of 12 people (1987), “Kerosinka” named after Gubkin, they accepted only mathematical olympiads ...
        Relative to my parents in 1987 he said - to any military school! just submit documents and he’s considered enrolled! Besides Volsky, Ryazan, and Yaroslavsky. Why? said - after Volsky they often plant, Yaroslavsky he will not pull the level of ties, and Ryazan will fight in the next 10 years ...
        1. +1
          30 January 2018 15: 37
          ... with your comment you made my day! Thank you so much! To a relative - my deepest respect, and if alive - health and longevity!
    2. +2
      30 January 2018 09: 16
      Quote: Herkulesich
      There is no like in the USSR there were clubs, circles, and sections where young people with pleasure went!

      Why not? Out-of-school work centers are in every city. Schoolchildren under the age of 14 go there, and then they are not interested in this, as was generally the case in Soviet times. Most children see how their families live, and most live openly h.r.e.v.o. Therefore, they will easily go after those who will promise social justice. Everything is logical.
      1. +1
        30 January 2018 10: 01
        The funny thing is that they will still go for "social justice", no matter how good they are. Regardless of the wealth of the family, a teenager still wants to eat better, have the most expensive gadget or computer, and so on.
        Out-of-school work centers do exist, as they are, for example, at home of children's creativity.
        And children go there, and not a few - which of them are interested.
        As by the way it was in the USSR. Not all went to mugs and houses of pioneers. The mass was just hanging around the streets. Now hangs out on the Internet. in principle, no difference - the percentage of useless gouging remained approximately the same. As well as the percentage of talented and enthusiastic.
  7. +1
    30 January 2018 09: 26
    Both "opposition leaders", in Russia, in Ukraine, are the direct six of the US State Department, who do not have any real political base at home.
    That the party of Navalny, that the party of Saakashvili, is pure impromptu made on his knee. There are no real system specialists in building the party and promoting it on the political field.

    Strange, at first the author broadcasts about the direct hand of the State Department, and then about the “made on the knee”. The State Department, with his experience of color revolutions, can’t do it professionally ?! By the way, Navalny has no party, Saakashvili seems to have the same. Navalny just breaks into power, like Yeltsin at one time, so I doubt that he wants,
    to be left alone, too ambitious. Absolutely opportunistic character
    Did you notice that none of the real politicians supported either Alexey or Miho?
    And who is our real politician? Zhirinovsky, or is there Mironov ?! The political field is cleared, and therefore such Bulk crawl out
    What is not immediately visible to an inexperienced look is obvious to a professional political strategist and politician.
    The author is a professional polytechnologist or politician ?!
    In the early spring of 2017, Navalny looked like he was a political heavyweight, with a claim to the role of the Russian opposition leader.
    Navalny became isolated, exclusively on his beloved, and then there appeared an adequate Grudinin, who pulled upon himself the entire sane protest electorate, leaving Navalny with youngsters and very stubborn supporters
    1. +1
      30 January 2018 10: 07
      Finally.
      The author writes about this in the article that it is piled up so, a step, preparation of the soil. The next step is the Zagrudin residents.
    2. +2
      30 January 2018 11: 13
      Quote: Stirbjorn
      and then there appeared adequate Grudinin

      Grudilin was nominated by 4 parties with different interests. Grudilin stands for the weakening of presidential power. Grudilin, having come to power, dreams of giving Russia control to these parties, which will undoubtedly lead to the seven-boyars of the 90's. So, inadequate follow the Grudilin and the marginal not reporting on the consequences of their actions.
      Quote: Stirbjorn
      leaving Navalny with youngsters and very stubborn supporters

      Tomorrow these youngsters will determine whether or not to be Russia. The lights of Navalny are Kolya from Urengoy and student pilots who advertise pidaring.
      For the moderator - This is a literary word and is found in all known dictionaries. The substitution of the word leads to the loss of the image. Loss of image leads to the loss of an adequate response. Thus, we are imposed on behaviors alien to our culture. I ask you not to take part in this and to remove this word from auto renaming. Thanks.
      1. +2
        30 January 2018 11: 21
        Yes, it’s just that all secret plans were revealed. Apparently, they read a lot of articles, analyzed a bunch of materials. Only you would first learn the name of the presidential candidate correctly. Grudinin he. And not Grudilin.
        1. +2
          30 January 2018 11: 32
          Quote: Reserve officer
          Only you would first learn the name of the presidential candidate correctly

          I don’t need to remember the name of the fleeting past. About youngsters:
      2. 0
        30 January 2018 16: 56
        Quote: Boris55
        The lights of Navalny are Kolya from Urengoy and student pilots who advertise pidaring.

        these kids sat on pots for another 10 years and studied and taught history according to Fursenko’s method, the bulk only uses the fruits of state education and upbringing of teenagers, he probably personally instructed Kolya and was a choreographer for the pilots, so who promotes the Bologna system and who houses 2 sponsors? Who brings up an effective consumer out of children and weaning them from thinking? the state itself has withdrawn from education, or rather, is doing everything to dull the masses
        and refrain from writing me down as a proponent of bulk
  8. 0
    30 January 2018 09: 53
    Quote: Monster_Fat
    And young people want only one thing - to make money, preferably a lot of money and move up the career and social ladders ... And what do they see? But they see that the country has built a system of "vertical power" at all levels where only relatives, friends and friends, but not anyone from the street can enter.

    But isn’t it in the USA? Can any teenager from the street go into power? Or is it still necessary to finish the correct educational institution, to belong to the "right family", etc.?
    1. 0
      30 January 2018 10: 26
      Absolutely anyone would be a "mosk" in the head. Than Reagan and Schwartz, but Obama are not examples? No, of course there are "closed" areas where the entrance is for "thoroughbred" and with "special" -education, but there they are constantly looking for "on the side" those who are smarter and not connected with any families or clans, for "strengthening" their ranks and avoiding "stagnation". What I like about the United States is that people here are valued everywhere who, with their own hands and "head", generate income, company profits, or even who do not really appreciate "family" and other ties. But in Russia it is the other way round — everywhere in leading positions relatives, friends, acquaintances, etc., are not distinguished by either intelligence or other “talents,” and the rest, like slaves, are forced to “look into their mouths”.
      1. -1
        30 January 2018 15: 05
        Well, what did Putin not please you then? Also not from the oligarch's family.
        And of course, I meant the highest echelons of power. There you will agree, there are very few random people.
      2. 0
        30 January 2018 15: 49
        ... Schwartz say, heh, you don’t even know which clan his squaw belongs to ... in my opinion, your opinions, to put it mildly, are false, Potemkin villages in the American way. Ronald is a man of authority who did not have power (like nothing behind his soul), and you make such bold statements ... I also managed to read Pioneer Truth, but even in a happy childhood, in a socialist country, I did not truly believe everything.
      3. 0
        30 January 2018 16: 05
        Quote: Monster_Fat
        constantly looking for "on the side" of those who are smarter
        Obama is the head! Don’t put a finger in his mouth ... Only Clinton is probably smarter.
      4. 0
        31 January 2018 06: 58
        Exactly. That's why they can have Ilon Mask, and in Russia only Rogozin, who is only about a trampoline and can tryndet and put his son on a bread place. Therefore, no matter what, the states are moving forward, and the Russian Federation is increasingly slipping into stagnation.
  9. 0
    30 January 2018 10: 02
    Quote: Stirbjorn
    Navalny became isolated, exclusively on his beloved, and then there appeared an adequate Grudinin, who pulled upon himself the entire sane protest electorate, leaving Navalny with youngsters and very stubborn supporters

    Common sense in your words. Did it all happen by chance?
  10. 0
    30 January 2018 10: 05
    Quote: Stirbjorn
    And who is our real politician? Zhirinovsky, or is there Mironov ?! The political field is cleared, and therefore such Bulk crawl out

    Zhirinovsky leads the far from the smallest faction in the State Duma and the party for almost 27 years.
    A real politician, nowhere is more real.
    1. +1
      30 January 2018 11: 45
      Quote: Mestny
      A real politician, nowhere is more real.

      Interestingly, why did he do such real things in 27 years? laughing
      1. -1
        30 January 2018 15: 07
        All these years he managed to be re-elected to the State Duma with not the worst result. That for a politician is an achievement
        1. 0
          30 January 2018 15: 12
          Quote: Mestny
          All these years he managed to be re-elected to the State Duma ...

          Is this his only goal? But I naively thought that they would fight for my happiness. laughing But no. They would only break into the Duma, and there even though the grass does not grow.
        2. 0
          30 January 2018 15: 55
          ... moreover, preserving the electorate, which for various reasons swayed, from choices harmful to the authorities. He did not aspire to the head physician, but neurology and psychiatry always pulled excellently, GOOD Fellow!
  11. +17
    30 January 2018 13: 32
    Is it like the children of Lieutenant Schmidt?
    enough can rub about the landslide

    Not enough - this is Putin's project. To keep Misha in check
  12. 0
    30 January 2018 14: 52
    Bulk fellow, at least someone is not afraid of thieves to say it in person! As president, I don’t know how politician he is. Those in the government are needed, otherwise they have developed some friends and tandems of the silent. Time to cleanse the government of dirt.
    1. -1
      30 January 2018 15: 08
      You do not confuse. One thing in politics, another thing in government.
      In politics - yes, it is needed. so he is. Nobody has hidden it yet.
      And in the government, what should he do?
    2. +3
      30 January 2018 16: 03
      I watched his failed election video, I advise you to do it ... still I can’t decide who the biggest demagogue is, or Ksenia Anatolyevna ... it reminds me of a prostitute joke and those who were not invited to the sauna ... as always IMHO of course. .. and yet, for me, well done - a person who works for the good of my Motherland and our People, and this, if well done, is American.
  13. 0
    30 January 2018 18: 25
    Well, straight to the ridiculous. A man with a criminal record walks and barks against the authorities, but they cannot close him in prison. Why do you really believe that it is just so possible in our country? And what is all the State Department? Yes, the states need Putin in the Kremlin and stagnation more than Navalny and at least some kind of shake-up. Well, how does the oligarchy really feed the lure? Indeed, in the history of Russia it was already so when they gave money to the fiery revolutionary V.I. Lenin. Navalny is the same systemic opposition as Zhirinovsky.
  14. +2
    30 January 2018 21: 20
    Quote: Mestny
    The goal at this stage is to increase the layer of people dissatisfied with the current government.

    To this end, the government itself is coping! Unsure, crooked measures, anti-people's laws, growing poverty - like this power we were abandoned as saboteurs, pests. angry hi
    1. +1
      30 January 2018 22: 52
      The authorities and truth have successfully “trampled on” their people and not by the fact that she really needs it, but it’s just that it’s not popular and it doesn’t even reach the “civilized” capitalist !!!
      However, in the recent speeches of the “great and terrible”, and of the other “chosen ones”, care and compassion for the “kindred” ELECTOR are right off scale!
      Honestly, I can’t believe it at all and it’s completely disgusting to realize that this is all a lie ... statistics probably show something wrong, that's all "care"!