US coalition responded to accusations of transforming Racca to Dresden 1945

The command of the US-led international anti-terrorist coalition does not agree with the statement of the Russian Defense Ministry that Syrian Raqqa was “wiped off the face of the earth” during the operation to liberate the city from militants of the Islamic State terrorist group (IG, banned in Russia). Dresden in 1945, said coalition spokesman Colonel Ryan Dillon.

We are making more efforts to prevent civilian casualties than anyone else. The damage that was caused Raqqah, lies entirely on the IG

- noted Dillon.

Of all the munitions that we dropped in three years, less than 1 percent, or more precisely 0,3 percent, resulted in civilian casualties

He pointed out.

The destruction of civilian infrastructure in the city of Dillon explained that for more than five years, Racca was the scene of armed conflict between several warring parties.

The Russian Ministry of Defense made accusations against the United States on October 22. The representative of the department, Major General Igor Konashenkov, stated that "Raqqah inherited the fate of Dresden 1945 of the year wiped off from the ground by the Anglo-American bombardments." He also pointed out that during the operation to liberate the city, many civilians were killed.

Comments

[Logall]

Isil for a long time demolished historical monuments, ruins! USA creates new! And the civilians that raised remained –– these are future mummies, Syrian Tutankhamuns ...

[The black]

And all these "human rights defenders", liberals and the UN got into their mouths ... silence. But how amicably and with rapture squealed about Aleppo. They got to the point that the average Euro-lover believed - and with open arms began to meet "refugees" ... and not only from Syria, but also from other countries .... Poor bearded "nephews were so moved that they dragged European girls into the cellars and the gates, where they “thanked” them with enthusiasm and the crowd. They are especially grateful to the Germans, whom they massively ennished on New Year's Eve ........ here you have democracy and international law and everything else ....

[NIKNN]

Of all the munitions that we dropped in three years, less than 1 percent, or more precisely 0,3 percent, resulted in civilian casualties

judging by the ruins of crayfish ...., 0.3% of these ruins are corpses These gentlemen are much more than what you were accused of ... It’s even scary to extrapolate something (and I don’t know how much ammunition was spent ..., well, take into account that one shell (bomb) is capable of realizing hundreds of corpses ..., Well, even 10-5 is already a serious admission in the lawlessness ...

[210ox]

The freelance tricksters are primarily guilty of organizing this mess with numerous victims and refugees in North Africa and the Middle East. They are the organizers of these killings. And often the perpetrators ..

[NIKNN]

Quote: 210ox

The freelance tricksters are primarily guilty of organizing this mess with numerous victims and refugees in North Africa and the Middle East. They are the organizers of these killings. And often the perpetrators ..

Chickpeas are without options, and there’s no point in discussing ...

[Warrior with machine gun]

but these earhooks don’t even understand this, half-fools ask, “why did you live in housing where people lived and destroyed the infrastructure?”

[Krasnodar]

Quote: 210ox

The freelance tricksters are primarily guilty of organizing this mess with numerous victims and refugees in North Africa and the Middle East. They are the organizers of these killings. And often the perpetrators ..

Both the organizers and the performers of all this are Sunnis with Shiites, Arabs and Jews, Christians and Druze. The fact that all third powers derive their own benefit from this (including the Russian Federation) is a third matter.

[Mikhail3]

Yeah. The vast majority of the ruins in the same Raqqa are the consequences of airstrikes. Who bombed her? Shiites? Christians are so accurate. Well, those who do not worship the pasta monster or do not profess Satanism are so fashionable (and recognized) in the USA. Are the Jews too? I mean, they also mix Racca with the earth? The local then no aviation ...

[Krasnodar]

Quote: Black

And all these "human rights defenders", liberals and the UN got into their mouths ... silence. But how amicably and with rapture squealed about Aleppo. They got to the point that the average Euro-lover believed - and with open arms began to meet "refugees" ... and not only from Syria, but also from other countries .... Poor bearded "nephews were so moved that they dragged European girls into the cellars and the gates, where they “thanked” them with enthusiasm and the crowd. They are especially grateful to the Germans, whom they massively ennished on New Year's Eve ........ here you have democracy and international law and everything else ....

And they went to Europe under this shop from peaceful Iran, Pakistan, from Africa ...

[newcomer]

Alexander, welcome. the masters of terror and slavery of the historical values ​​of our civilization will still answer before us in the Court: for Iraq and Syria, the list can be continued, but these are the most vivid examples of the destruction of our history. Yes, I forgot Libya.

[siberalt]

Let the Syrians themselves say this, not the military.

[OFFICE-32]

Quote: siberalt

Let the Syrians themselves say this, not the military.

They say that only they do not believe in the "world media" .. like me on the site .. hehe

[newcomer]

MIKHAN, with the returnee!

[OFFICE-32]

Quote: newbie

MIKHAN, with the returnee!

And you don’t get sick! Yes, they’ll shoot .... They drove us into a corner already!
There is a cleansing of all sites of patriotic Russia ..

Hold on to the men who stayed .. Good luck in an unequal battle.!

[LSA57]

Quote: Logall

And civilians,

"and why reckon with them, you think only 0,3%" is the logic of these cannibals in tailcoat

[the villain]

Quote: LSA57

"such is the logic of these cannibals in tailcoat

Even in the earliest times, Soviet propaganda on this subject said, and the truth ...

[LSA57]

Quote: Villain

Even in the earliest times, Soviet propaganda on this subject said, and the truth ...

well, so are their students at the same level

[Mavrikiy]

US coalition responded to accusations of transforming Racca to Dresden 1945
Shaw, come up with it, uh? Oh well done!
Sparing ammunition and sniper arrows? Weakly. It’s necessary: ​​they threw cast iron, but it collapsed from vibration because the construction superintendents poured cement on the cement (they say they were to blame)

[volodya]

Quote: Mavrikiy

Shaw, come up with it, uh? Oh well done!
Sparing ammunition and sniper arrows? Weakly. It’s necessary: ​​they threw cast iron, but it collapsed from vibration because the construction superintendents poured cement on the cement (they say they were to blame)

C'mon, they’re not on purpose! First at the wedding, then at the funeral!

[just exp]

so ours could say that the Germans were to blame for the permission of Dresden, and they just bombed, and the one who is bombed is always to blame, and not the one who was bombed.
especially when the city that was bombed does not have military facilities.

[Logall]

No, better than the Yankees in Vietnam! Better yet, like in Japan ...

[LAWNER]

People were killed in Japan! And in Vietnam they were destroying NATURE ....
Better, worse, the story will answer.

[Lopatov]

Quote: LAWNER

People were killed in Japan! And in Vietnam they were destroying NATURE ....

In Vietnam, no less people were killed.
It is enough to recall the actions of the South Korean contingent, which "effectively fought" with the partisans on the recipes of the Nazis in Belarus

[Logall]

In Japan, is it only nature? Phosphorus cluster bombs, chemical weapons ... Was it all fought with nature?

[Incvizitor]

In Vietnam, people were burned out by villages and jungles with hectares, and the river was poisoned with “orange”, there are still no fish and people are still dying, yes, there is something to learn from the German fascists.

[Lopatov]

Quote: gml

Wimps, won the troops of Russia attacked Grozny, and what do you think? here and there a little dust, and so the houses did not fall, the schools did not collapse, the hospitals did not fire. Everyone act like Russia in Grozny.

Oops! You probably "accidentally forgot" about such small nuances as humanitarian corridors along which civilians were taken out of Grozny, about Ingush Ministry of Emergency Situations, who evacuated patients and medical personnel of the city, about repeatedly extended terms for the withdrawal of civilians ...

In short, your post-vivid example of the fact that you can put an equal sign between half-truths and lies.
As an example:
The village of Komsomolskoye was almost completely destroyed during the destruction of the Gelaev’s detachment, which for some reason captured him.
Fact? Reinforced concrete fact.
However, this is not the whole truth, is it? People like you tend to keep silent about the controversy that before the storming of this village the civilians were given time not just to exit, but to take out their property.
Despite the fact that the militants used this time to strengthen the defense, which led to more casualties from the group of forces.
But after all, people like you are not inclined to discover the whole truth for the reason that it is very inconvenient. It is so?

[tihon4uk]

I completely agree with you, but unfortunately you wrote in a void, such as gml will continue to cite the example of the first Chechen as a "brutal" attitude to the civilian population of the Russian Army in the war, these narrow-minded trolls will not translate when!

[Warrior with machine gun]

Assad drove, and you have nothing to do with the dandelion boys, world record holders for destruction, after Japan 1945 (the list is long besides this), silence you for a long time, gentlemen, "world benefactors for material reward." Over the past 50 years, after your "charity", a dozen countries they cannot come to their senses by tasting "American democracy", which is more reminiscent of something dangerous and not neat.

[Lelek]

Quote: Warrior with machine gun

Assad drove

Hey. Speaking of the actions of the Assad government. It proclaimed a focus on the pacification of all groups ready for constructive cooperation with the central government, for which the latter is ready to go to amend the constitution, and to grant the Kurds wide autonomy, and to re-elect the country's government. Assad’s good move in spite of the Turks, and the Americans, and the Saudis.

[Shura Sailors]

There is no war without sacrifices and destruction. It is only one thing to demolish a house as an enemy firing point and it is quite another thing to destroy a city in order to intimidate or because of its assiduousness and inability to fight properly

[Reserve officer]

Alexander, quite rightly, there is no war without destruction. And all sorts of “experts” can be said that the craving for total destruction, in fact, does not speak of general talents. You noted this with brighter speech turns.
There is Dresden, and there is Krakow. Both the one and the other cities did not bomb the whole war. But fate in the last year of the war turned out to be different. The official travel guide for Krakow 1967 of the year said:
“Krakow was liberated 18 January 1945 year after five years of Nazi occupation. The lightning attack of the Red Army prevented the Germans from completely destroying the city before their flight. The famous maneuver of Marshal Konev - to encircle the city and attack from the northeast, and not from the east - took the German command by surprise. This decision was so unexpected for them that the Germans, fearing that the path to the retreat would be cut off, hastily fled from the city and did not have time to blow up all the key historical buildings, although they mined them long before the Red Army approached. Only the railway bridge and several minor buildings were destroyed. Krakow, unlike other Polish cities, survived. In gratitude, the residents of Krakow awarded Marshal Konev the title of honorary resident of the city. ”
Military art provides, inter alia, to minimize destruction and casualties among the civilian population. And Krakow is a brilliant example. True, somehow the descendants of the rescued Poles have all "forgotten" this. And the monument to Konev is no longer there.

[Shura Sailors]

Extreme paragraph - the quintessence of the whole topic
It is MILITARY ART that determines the level of training of the armed forces. Russian military art (Russian, Soviet ...) is known all over the world. About the military art of Americans, only talk and legends ...
With regards to "forgotten" - the story develops in a spiral. There will also be snot "Russia save and help." For some reason I’m sure of this (although I am not an adherent of the sect of “Russian lovers”)

[sabakina]

Quote: Shura sailors

There will also be snot "Russia save and help." For some reason I’m sure of this (although I am not an adherent of the sect of “Russian lovers”)

You are an interesting person, Shura. On the one hand, you are not an adherent of the sect of "lovers of Russia," on the other, you are sure that they will ask her to save and help .... The paradox ...

[Shura Sailors]

Yes, there is nothing interesting in me. I am a citizen of my country. And I love my country simply because it is my homeland. Yes, I don’t like a lot of things here, there are points in the politics of my country against which I categorically. But, again, this is my homeland. And I do not accept some statements about Ukraine. What's so strange about that?
Regarding my attitude to Russia - I love history (as a science) and appreciate it. And history knows that brotherly and "brotherly" peoples turned to Russia for help more than once, and Russia helped. I am sure and will help more than once. Such is the fate of Russia to help those who ask. Wide soul.

[Krasnodar]

Quote: Stock Officer

Alexander, quite rightly, there is no war without destruction. And all sorts of “experts” can be said that the craving for total destruction, in fact, does not speak of general talents. You noted this with brighter speech turns.
There is Dresden, and there is Krakow. Both the one and the other cities did not bomb the whole war. But fate in the last year of the war turned out to be different. The official travel guide for Krakow 1967 of the year said:
“Krakow was liberated 18 January 1945 year after five years of Nazi occupation. The lightning attack of the Red Army prevented the Germans from completely destroying the city before their flight. The famous maneuver of Marshal Konev - to encircle the city and attack from the northeast, and not from the east - took the German command by surprise. This decision was so unexpected for them that the Germans, fearing that the path to the retreat would be cut off, hastily fled from the city and did not have time to blow up all the key historical buildings, although they mined them long before the Red Army approached. Only the railway bridge and several minor buildings were destroyed. Krakow, unlike other Polish cities, survived. In gratitude, the residents of Krakow awarded Marshal Konev the title of honorary resident of the city. ”
Military art provides, inter alia, to minimize destruction and casualties among the civilian population. And Krakow is a brilliant example. True, somehow the descendants of the rescued Poles have all "forgotten" this. And the monument to Konev is no longer there.

Americans pity their people (electorate) but do not pity their bombs.

[Lopatov]

Quote: Krasnodar

Americans pity their people (electorate) but do not pity their bombs.

Not a fact.
Often the opposite is true, it’s enough to remember Monte Cassino. Excessive damage leads to the opposite - an increase in losses.
The battles in the ruins are still a problem ...

[Krasnodar]

Quote: Spade

Quote: Krasnodar

Americans pity their people (electorate) but do not pity their bombs.

Not a fact.
Often the opposite is true, it’s enough to remember Monte Cassino. Excessive damage leads to the opposite - an increase in losses.
The battles in the ruins are still a problem ...

Like the Germans in Stalingrad ... well, yes, it happens

[Mikhail3]

Quote: Krasnodar

Americans pity their people (electorate) but do not pity their bombs.

Is it possible to call people creatures that thus “pity themselves”? In my opinion, this is already illegal.

[Alex Justice]

There are wars without destruction.
In his memoirs, in the town of Yugoslavia, a German shot a street from a house. They wanted, as always, from the gun, but it was impossible to receive the order from the gun, the house would suffer. They called a sniper. He killed a German, but the offensive was delayed for several hours while they were waiting for him.
Another case. Ours Liberated the city with many large warehouses, including clothing. The Yugoslav partisans immediately set guard at the warehouses and forbade the use of warehouses. Our soldiers wore out and wanted to take warm clothes from the warehouse for themselves and friends. It is impossible. The only thing they could do was change into a brand new one at the warehouse.
So Europe fought the Germans. Fight as you like, they say, but do not touch ours.

[Warrior with machine gun]

no better than the American clowns with their jackals Montecassino stormed

[Herculesic]

In short, the United States and mongrel said, like we didn’t bomb, it was always like that, like where we just won’t fly, then for some reason there are ruins under our planes!

[Gormenghast]

Mattresses are used to dividing the WAR into a democratic and totalitarian.

Here in Aleppo - there is Oslo and gloom. Totalitarianism.

And in Raqqa, 90% of the buildings are decently destroyed there. Democracy!

[sabakina]

Quote: Gormengast

And in Raqqa, 90% of the buildings are decently destroyed there. Democracy!

[Settlement Oparyshev]

And what about Dresden? Dresden didn’t bomb the whole War and gradually all the deviators, mother-in-law, sissy, henpecked, old ladies merged there. Therefore, Stalin asked Churchill to work with the town. Well, let’s bombard Churchill and connected the Yankers and the town like that. gradually descended to Victory.

[Lopatov]

Quote: p-k Oparyshev

Therefore, Stalin asked

And without knowing about such a request?

[Settlement Oparyshev]

don’t worry about Stalin, you’re a shaman, maybe 2-3 levels. And not a single person on Earth has reached the Stalin level yet. Stalin is the only highly developed shaman.

[self-propelled]

Quote: p-k Oparyshev

And not a single person has reached the Stalin level

few people will reach such a troll level as you. here supporters of Navalny and his liberal team are negligible. You to another site

[Settlement Oparyshev]

You obviously use regularly in two cases, on holidays and between them. You’re frank .. Why are you asking? Provoke me to checkmate? This is not noble, you are clearly from the lower class.

[the villain]

Quote: p-k Oparyshev

.After this, the War gradually came to Victory.

It’s like it, but I thought that events such as the defense of Moscow, Stalingrad, the Kursk Bulge, the heroism of the besieged Leningrad and the soldiers of the garrison of the Brest Fortress, the courage and dedication of our grandfathers and great-grandfathers brought the war to victory.

[Settlement Oparyshev]

Here the topic is different. It’s one thing when your mother-in-law and wife survive you in the war, that you would have a salary and a kindred one with you. And another thing, when you are free like a bird and Life looms before your eyes, not clouded by your mother-in-law.

[sabakina]

Quote: pp to Oparyshev

Here the topic is different. It's one thing when the mother-in-law and wife survive you in the war, that would have a salary from you

Then I see, you write from the trench ... P.S. I am without malice.

[Settlement Oparyshev]

I am writing on the back of a murdered comrade, after I repulse another attack of the enemy. The forces are no longer what would rise in a counterattack.

[Krasnodar]

Quote: pp to Oparyshev

And what about Dresden? Dresden didn’t bomb the whole War and gradually all the deviators, mother-in-law, sissy, henpecked, old ladies merged there. Therefore, Stalin asked Churchill to work with the town. Well, let’s bombard Churchill and connected the Yankers and the town like that. gradually descended to Victory.

This is a historical myth. Stalin did not ask Churchill on the bombing of German cities; on the contrary, his policy was: The Nazis would leave, but the German people would remain.

[voyaka uh]

Stalin asked in Yalta to bomb the Dresden railway junction - the largest in East Germany. Through it, all logistics of deliveries to the Eastern Front were carried out. Indeed, the first raid was on the station of Dresden and its environs.
And then the British decided to bang and the whole city at the same time. Where, by the way, all the institutions of the SS, the Nazi Party and other Nazi civilian authorities were transferred from all over Germany. All covered with civilians.

[Krasnodar]

Quote: voyaka uh

Stalin asked in Yalta to bomb the Dresden railway junction - the largest in East Germany. Through it, all logistics of deliveries to the Eastern Front were carried out. Indeed, the first raid was on the station of Dresden and its environs.
And then the British decided to bang and the whole city at the same time. Where, by the way, all the institutions of the SS, the Nazi Party and other Nazi civilian authorities were transferred from all over Germany. All covered with civilians.

I haven’t read such a thing, and it’s unlikely that Stalin’s level should be asked to bomb something ... this is the level of the chief of staff or something like that

[Settlement Oparyshev]

The first raid? It is known that the raid was one, but passed in several waves.

[Eurodav]

Quote: Spade

Quote: gml

Wimps, won the troops of Russia attacked Grozny, and what do you think? here and there a little dust, and so the houses did not fall, the schools did not collapse, the hospitals did not fire. Everyone act like Russia in Grozny.

Oops! You probably "accidentally forgot" about such small nuances as humanitarian corridors along which civilians were taken out of Grozny, about Ingush Ministry of Emergency Situations, who evacuated patients and medical personnel of the city, about repeatedly extended terms for the withdrawal of civilians ...

In short, your post-vivid example of the fact that you can put an equal sign between half-truths and lies.
As an example:
The village of Komsomolskoye was almost completely destroyed during the destruction of the Gelaev’s detachment, which for some reason captured him.
Fact? Reinforced concrete fact.
However, this is not the whole truth, is it? People like you tend to keep silent about the controversy that before the storming of this village the civilians were given time not just to exit, but to take out their property.
Despite the fact that the militants used this time to strengthen the defense, which led to more casualties from the group of forces.
But after all, people like you are not inclined to discover the whole truth for the reason that it is very inconvenient. It is so?

Are you not a doctor for an hour? Show such patience for the sick! Well to hell with it!

[askort154]

"Of all the ammunition that we dropped in three years, less than 1 percent, or rather, 0,3 percent, resulted in civilian casualties."

Here it is, the humane know-how of the "exceptional" in the 21st century. Consider the deceased civilian population as a percentage of the amount of ammunition dropped on the head of this population so that this population accepts "an exceptional democracy."

[Alex Justice]

It is clear what they wanted to say. Why twist the phrase and look for another meaning?

[Fkjydjckfrgh]

of all the ammunition that we dropped in three years, less than 1 percent, or rather, 0,3 percent, resulted in civilian casualties
Well, if you dance from the ratio of the mass of ammunition to the mass of the "striking element", then you won’t dig into merikos

[OFFICE-32]

The United States, as they were the killers of peaceful Indians and Africans, so they remained ...
Now Russia has been chosen as the target to pit us again and then they want to bomb, bomb and bomb .. Fortunately, technology now allows ..
But we are against the Russians. as usual...

[Andryukha G]

If NATO bombes and kills civilians from other countries (in particular, in Syria and we do not forget Yugoslavia) - this is the establishment of "democracy", if the Russian air forces bomb terrorists - this is support for the Assad’s bloody regime. But all countries are silent, and indeed the bloody regime of the US empire, because of which peaceful people die every day around the world.

[Wolka]

Yankees woe-warriors, wimps and barbarians, even to recognize the obvious courage is not enough ...

[Ural resident]

It is necessary to remind about Dresden more often, especially to the Germans. And in general, be more active in foreign policy, and not just defend. Hiroshima and Nagasaki should also be remembered at every opportunity, because something is delicately ours are silent, while we are accused of all the horrors of the 20th century almost daily

[Steve57]

Do not deny

[VALERIK_097]

Quote: OFFICE-32

The United States, as they were the killers of peaceful Indians and Africans, so they remained ...
Now Russia has been chosen as the target to pit us again and then they want to bomb, bomb and bomb .. Fortunately, technology now allows ..
But we are against the Russians. as usual...

Mikhan, You do not cut phrases, negotiate, or drink it do not go to the site.

[bronnco]

These didn’t even understand anything!

[dvb]

"Raqqa inherited the fate of 1945 Dresden, wiped off the earth by the Anglo-American bombing"