Military Review

In the textbooks of Tatarstan, the republic is called "a separate state"

85
In the textbooks of Tatarstan, the republic is called "a separate state"



Schoolchildren of the Republic of Tatarstan often cannot unequivocally answer the question in which country they live: textbooks have been tangled. Separate textbooks on the Tatar language categorically declare a "sovereign independent state of Tatarstan" and put the region almost at the same level with the countries - France, Great Britain and ... Russia. Some of them, although they are distributed in schools, are excluded from the federal list of textbooks recommended by the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation, others are not even included. How the subject of the Russian Federation impersonates itself as a “country in the country” - read in the material on the eve of .RU.

“Report that Tatarstan is a sovereign state,” “Tatarstan has its own state symbolism,” “Tatarstan is an independent state, each state has its own symbols,” such tasks are offered to students in the Tatar language class. Parents of Russian-speaking children notice other, not so obvious alarming “bells”.



“By the way, did anyone pay attention to the main page of electronic diaries? Look carefully at which pile of books the boy with glasses leaned on. At the base — a fat book — Tatar's body, above — thin biology, chemistry, physics, for some reason almost everything There is no Russian language textbook at all, ”writes Olga in the group“ Committee of Russian-speaking parents of Tataria ”on the social network Vkontakte.



She is supported by other concerned parents. On the cover of one of the textbooks depicted the country and their capital. France, Great Britain, Turkey, Russia and Tatarstan stand in the same row, below are their sights: the Eiffel Tower, Big Ben, the Colosseum, the Kul Sharif Mosque, the Syuyumbike Tower.



“There was no place for the Moscow Kremlin there,” parents noted.



Is the same история with gift editions that children receive upon entering school. In the books, only the Republic of Tatarstan is mentioned as the Motherland, and Rustam Minnikhanov is mentioned as the President. Russian-speaking parents admit that they get rid of such literature without a twinge of conscience.


Local activists consider the policy of the authorities to impose Tatar identity on Russian-speaking children for separatism.

"It should be regarded as separatism. I generally think it is right to bring to justice those who allowed these textbooks, because this is the most despicable blow to children. This is on the verge of a foul: in regional schools the President of the Russian Federation, the flag of the Russian Federation and the anthem of the Russian Federation and the President of the Republic of Tatarstan, the flag of the Republic of Tatarstan and the anthem of the Republic of Tatarstan hang symmetrically. And then - even more “cooler”: the head of the municipal district, the flag of the municipal district, the anthem of the municipal district. ! Avnoznachnoe This "parochialism" must be stopped ", - shared his opinion with a member of the parent committee On the eve of Russian-speaking parents, the chairman of the Society of Russian Culture of Tatarstan Mikhail Shcheglov, adding that such phrases in the textbooks - is" mine "under the security of our country.



There is really cause for concern. Back in 2008, more than 80% of the surveyed schoolchildren of the republic were called Tatarstan as their home country. The study was conducted by the head of the center of ethnocultural education strategy of the Federal Institute for Educational Development Olga Artemenko.

"In the Republic of Tatarstan and in other republics, for example, both in Yakutia and Chuvashia, during 25 years, the formation of ethnic consciousness took place, the formation of republican citizenship consciousness among the speakers of these languages. As we can see, in some cases, it is one thing to write, and another to purposefully shape the consciousness, creating an environment not only in the educational system, but in general, an information environment aimed at the subconscious formation before minant sense of belonging to a particular ethnic group living in its small homeland. But you can not divide the homeland. For a child there can be no small or large homeland. She is alone, "Olga Artemenko told Nakanune.RU.

“Subversive” textbooks, as a rule, are no longer included in the list recommended by the Ministry of Education for use in schools. Some of them were excluded from it quite recently, others did not enter at all.

For example, the textbook of the Tatar language for elementary school in co-authorship: I.L. Litvinov, E.R. Sadyykova, L.I. Garipova left the register in 2015. Somewhere he still applies, as evidenced by the educational programs posted on the websites of schools.


From the educational program of the Kazan gymnasium

A textbook Khaidarova and Malafeeva "Tatar body 2" in the list and was not.

"I know about these textbooks. Of course, the use of such textbooks in the school educational process is unacceptable. We predicted that a situation when it is mandatory to impose learning of the Tatar language on everyone will only lead to interethnic tension. And that interethnic tension in the Republic of Tatarstan it is growing, it can be clearly seen by those who want to see it, "said Olga Artemenko.

The expert is confident that the use of such textbooks in schools is a serious violation of federal legislation by the authorities of the republic.

"With 2008, we sought to ensure that only those included in the federal list were used as basic textbooks in schools. Back in November, 2008, speaking at the State Council in the Republic of Tatarstan, I spoke about the need to include textbooks in native languages ​​from the number of languages ​​of the peoples of Russia in the federal list of textbooks. This position was enshrined in 2012 in the federal law on education in the Russian Federation, ”said the head of the center for ethno-cultural education strategy of the Federal Institute for Education Development,“ But We see that the Republic of Tatarstan allows itself to violate federal legislation both in the use of textbooks, and in the compulsory study of the state language of the republic, and in the number of hours allocated for its study, and we can also list the violations.

The prosecutor's office has already seriously taken up the situation in Tatarstan. Thousands of parents' appeals to the supervisory authorities regarding the forced study of Tatar in schools, often to the detriment of Russian, finally yielded a result. The prosecutor's office of the Vakhitovsky district of Kazan made a presentation of one of the schools where the curricula were in violation of the law. This was followed by a full inspection of schools by the Federal Service for Supervision in the Field of Education and Science.

"Rosobrnadzor is currently working in the Republic of Tatarstan, it is being checked. And I think that as soon as it completes its work, all changes will be communicated to you. They are working until October 27 from yesterday," the deputy minister of education and education told Interfax. science of Tatarstan Larisa Sulima last week.

“Events are developing very interestingly and swiftly. Now prosecutors’ presentations are being sent to school principals, who find themselves alone with the problem. They don’t know what to answer to the mass requests of parents to cancel the Tatar language as a compulsory subject. his mink and pretends that nothing is happening, "- said Mikhail Shcheglov.

The excitement arose after the statement of Vladimir Putin about the inadmissibility of reducing the volume of learning the Russian language in schools. But the problem of "separatism in textbooks" is not concerned.

According to Shcheglov, the thing is that the regional elite lives according to its previous laws, in its order, uses its schemes, created at the beginning of 90's, Mintimer Shaimiev and his team.

The Republican Ministry of Defense as if ignores the public outcry. The only message - “clarification on the issue of teaching the Tatar language in general educational institutions of the Republic of Tatarstan” from September 7, where the legality of compulsory study of the Tatar language is said, went down the tape, making it positive news about the autumn holidays, the winners of competitions and contests.

At the time of publication, the Ministry of Education of Tatarstan could not explain why schoolchildren study according to the "forbidden" Tatar textbooks. On the eve.RU expects a response to the information request.

Tatarstan President Rustam Minnikhanov also remains silent. After his speech at the State Council at the end of September, he did not make new statements on this topic.

The almost paranoid desire of local authorities to instill Tatar culture in all residents of the republic, regardless of their nationality, is manifested not only in the educational system.

“Here, the local parliament is the State Council of the Republic of Tatarstan. Over the building on the steeple for many years, there was only one flag — the flag of the republic. Above the entrance doors below were two flags - Russia and Tataria, and at the top, a huge, prominent one from everywhere — the Tatar prosecutor wrote A remark on this, to which he received a quite humorous answer in the spirit: "The law says" ON state institutions ", and the expression" OVER state institution "is not in the law! And we really do have two flags at a state institution - both Russia and Tataria. "Now, however, the spire is empty, the only flag of Tataria has been removed, apparently, not to tease," said activist Mikhail Shcheglov.


Survey among the members of the "Committee of Russian-speaking parents of Tatarstan"

However, the Constitution of the Russian Federation gives the republics the right to determine their status. In 1992, the subject took advantage of this right and decided that "the Republic of Tatarstan is a democratic state of law, united with the Russian Federation by the Constitution of the Russian Federation, the Constitution of the Republic of Tatarstan and the treaty of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tatarstan" On the delimitation of subjects of knowledge ... ". in possession of the full state power (legislative, executive and judicial) outside the jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and the powers of the Russian Federation AI on issues under joint jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tatarstan and is an integral qualitative condition of the Republic of Tatarstan ".

According to the activist, the main law of the republic is outdated and behind the times.

“It’s necessary to change everything radically, starting with the legislation. Look, the Constitution of the Russian Federation says that, apart from the state language of Russia, the state languages ​​of the regions are allowed if local parliaments adopted them as such. But the Constitution was written in 1993 in a month after the shooting of the White House. Naturally, many things have changed since then, it is necessary to bring them into line with life, with realities. There are no regional states in Russia now, and we must remove all their signs from legislations of all levels ", says Mikhail Shcheglov .

In January, the 2016 of Vladimir Putin said that the founder of the Soviet state, Vladimir Lenin, "laid the atomic bomb" under the USSR, bearing in mind the principles of government. It is strange, moreover, that the federal government does not pay attention to much more real "mines" that have not been shared from Yeltsin's times.
Author:
Originator:
https://www.nakanune.ru/articles/113388/
85 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. A.V.S.
    A.V.S. 26 October 2017 15: 16 New
    +9
    The process is underway, we’ll soon hear: “... take sovereignty as much as you want.” And there is already independent Tatarstan and the independent Udmurtia ...
    1. St Petrov
      St Petrov 26 October 2017 15: 49 New
      17
      It is time to withdraw KAMAZ from there and other large enterprises. There should be a reaction to everything and a case in point. Reduce funding, increase funding in another region.

      And then they made economic zones in Tatarstan and they already think that the industry of the Tatars did everything.

      When someone begins to live better than other regions, a feeling of self-superiority appears. It is necessary to level. To land. Lower to the ground

      although it’s easier to close the local "elite" and put other people there. It worked out in Dagestan, and then it works out.

      1. Tatyana
        Tatyana 26 October 2017 15: 59 New
        22
        Local activists consider the policy of the authorities to impose Tatar identity on Russian-speaking children for separatism.
        Russians and Russian speakers in Tatarstan have been talking about this TATAR SEPARATISM for a long time! But things are still there!
        The ethno-Tatar leadership of R. Tatarstan act precisely as separatist provocateurs of the collapse of the Russian Federation according to the national religious principle!
      2. EvilLion
        EvilLion 26 October 2017 18: 46 New
        +4
        KAMAZ is 50 thousand only workers on it. Nizhnekamskneftekhim is the largest plant of this class in Europe. Where do you get them? And what will you do later, when the specialists leave Tatarstan from the republic with the number of local diluted to 50% or even less, turn into a territory where the vast majority will become local
        1. Mih1974
          Mih1974 28 October 2017 20: 44 New
          0
          As in WWII - for the Urals !! And other enterprises (especially important). Accompanied by the NKVD troops, letter echelons with deployment according to the laws of wartime !!
          1. Talgat
            Talgat 29 October 2017 20: 53 New
            +2
            wink in the vov all transported to kazakhstan

            I do not mind of course

            I wanted to note that actually the Tatars are the heart of Russia
            This is history. This is a relationship and kinship with the Kazakhs and Yakuts. with Altai and other Turkic peoples. These are Tu-160 White Swans and Kamazes and much much more
            Many Kazakh families have Tatar blood - and I, of course, too \ And many Russians have Tatar roots in Russian
            We can’t get away from each other
            Whatever they write there, we will always be together
      3. weksha50
        weksha50 26 October 2017 18: 51 New
        +3
        Quote: c-Petrov
        although it’s easier to close the local "elite" and put other people there. It worked out in Dagestan, and then it works out.


        That’s the whole point ... It’s only annoying that they looked at these separatist attacks for too long ...

        Separatism ... I already somehow wrote in relation to Tatar separatism: let’s look at the map carefully, “separators”, Mlyn ... Enclave, the cleanest enclave ... Around - the border zone, the sky - airspace - blocked by air defense Russia ... How will you live? After all, even "guests" of investors will need to pass through the territory of Russia ... laughing
    2. The comment was deleted.
    3. Orel
      Orel 26 October 2017 18: 35 New
      +5
      Quote: A.W.S.
      The process is underway, we’ll soon hear: “... take sovereignty as much as you want.” And there is already independent Tatarstan and the independent Udmurtia ...


      The national question is very delicate. If we push too hard on the national republics, we will get Yugoslavia with all the ensuing consequences. If we are too soft, there will be a referendum similar to the Scottish one, but again not everywhere. I do not see any threats in this. Not everyone can live separately. To do this, you must have access to the sea or external borders. And Tatarstan, Bashkiria and many other republics have borders only with Russia. Their independence is impossible economically. With the introduction of the blockade by the Russian Federation, such "independent entities" they quickly become impoverished. Do not just make an elephant out of a fly. They want their flag, language and anthem. You are welcome. Do not be afraid of this, if you try to make everyone "Russian", then we get a war on a gigantic scale. I don’t see any problem here.
      1. Mih1974
        Mih1974 28 October 2017 20: 47 New
        +1
        In this regard, the experience of the United States is good - at least choose your governor, but the Laws, Courts, law enforcement agencies of the Country are the first than any local nonsense and local is not a confrontation with the Federal !! At the slightest retreat, the Rosguard is introduced according to the toughest program, with executions, mass landings (outside Magadan) and sweeps of the "elites" in full. good
    4. 210ox
      210ox 26 October 2017 19: 03 New
      +2
      And there are films .. "Stoker" for example, something else guano ..
      Quote: A.W.S.
      The process is underway, we’ll soon hear: “... take sovereignty as much as you want.” And there is already independent Tatarstan and the independent Udmurtia ...
      1. ver_
        ver_ 30 October 2017 14: 28 New
        0
        ..thank you Ulyanov = Blanca for the creation of Tatarstan and other national entities-the Jews knew what they were doing ..
    5. The comment was deleted.
    6. demo
      demo 27 October 2017 05: 50 New
      +2
      The independence of Kazan ended in 1552 with the last assault.
      Therefore, talking about the statehood of the Tatars is possible only conditionally.
      How about the statehood of the Udmurts, Yakuts, etc.
  2. garx
    garx 26 October 2017 15: 19 New
    +4
    On the carpet of authors
    1. Neputin
      Neputin 26 October 2017 15: 35 New
      +5
      No, not on the carpet. On stake! Only in this way is statehood created.
      1. Ronald Reagan
        Ronald Reagan 26 October 2017 17: 14 New
        +3
        I can already see how the Kremlin junta and peaceful Tatar "militias" are discussing through federal channels. Circus and only. laughing
  3. The comment was deleted.
    1. The comment was deleted.
  4. Mountain shooter
    Mountain shooter 26 October 2017 15: 55 New
    +6
    Tatarstan is the internal space of Russia, there are no exits to any borders. What are they counting on? After winning the election, Putin will roll them into a ram’s horn. With all their "sovereignty" ... and kind of smart people ...
    1. weksha50
      weksha50 26 October 2017 18: 55 New
      +9
      Quote: Mountain Shooter
      What are they counting on?


      These “THEY” are a bunch of the same well-fed white-blood-sucking Islamists-Judas, and you can somehow call them ... They are fed by the same owners who created the IS and various other organizations ... The task is to destroy the Russian Federation ...
      These are not the people of Tatarstan and not the Tatars living all over Russia among us ... THESE are not even politicians, but corrupt political Judas ... And the Constitutional Court of Russia and the FSB should work with them ...
      At the same time, it’s a blow to the heads of those who viewed these trends in Tatarstan ... And this is not only in Tatarstan, is it ???
      1. Doliva63
        Doliva63 26 October 2017 19: 38 New
        10
        These “they” are fed, first of all, by the first resident of the RSFSR, free of itself, and then fed by his successor. And all for the sake of power at all costs. Another thing is that it did not work out as I wanted. Because traitors are in no way valued by those for whom they betray.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  5. NIKNN
    NIKNN 26 October 2017 16: 01 New
    +1
    Kazan took Astrakhan took Revel took spak did not take ...

    Going to this ... what
  6. Nemesis
    Nemesis 26 October 2017 16: 27 New
    17
    In Russia, it is time to begin real imprisonment under Article 280 of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation, and it’s time to demolish the monument to Yeltsin, his name can only be called a beer house, which sells bottling. Although, here it is already necessary to judge not only for separatism and activities leading to a violation of the territorial integrity of the Russian Federation, but also for treason. And the reason for this mess is the weakness of the central government in the Russian Federation and personally the GDP, which prefers to engage in empty populism, instead of taking specific measures.
  7. Rinat79
    Rinat79 26 October 2017 17: 23 New
    +5
    Yes, normally all Tatars remain in let countries and be part of Russia! Just here in the article, if you take it into account, it becomes clear about the superiority of the Russian nation, although among the Russian surnames more than 5000 thousand came from Tatar surnames, that is, they have Turkic roots and the very name Kremlin is a Tatar word! By the way, Putin’s mother has Tatar roots and they themselves have the right to consider the state the republic of which it is! And it has the right to both its own language and symbolism, this is rightfully the pride of Russia, and Russia is justly obliged to be glad that such noble and hardworking people as Tatars live in its composition.
    1. Voldemar07
      Voldemar07 26 October 2017 19: 00 New
      +9
      Well, in order.
      Who are the Tatars, no one knows. Even the Tatars. Who should be considered Tatars? Those who look like a Mongol or Turks, or Arabs, or Slavs? Well done, they decided for themselves that the Tatrtaria is Tataria, they themselves believed and are trying to convince others of it. With the same success, you can identify the Eskimos with the Eskimo.
      It’s not clear where they came from, where they went, but the fact is that you are only 3,5 percent now. Have you stopped breeding at all since the so-called Golden Horde ?. "Founders of the state" - but didn’t even have their own written language. From you, even the Mongols screwed. Joke. Yes, and throws you in the search for their roots, judging by the forums, not for children. Now to the Altaians, then to the Mayans, then to the Chinese or Turks. One Tatar “historian” proved that the Tatars are one of the lost tribes of Israel.
      Regarding the "5000 thousand million Tatar surname" ... And where did you get the roots of Turkic and not vice versa? Yes, and the Kremlin - "The word" Kremlin "is of old Russian origin, which also has the derivative word cream (b) nik - in the meaning" fortress inside the city "."
      Yes, and no one forbids you to language, learn health from your textbooks. Only do not force others to impose. Some representatives of the "noble people" generally propose to ban the Russian language in Tatarstan and switch to the Latin alphabet.
      1. protoss
        protoss 27 October 2017 16: 14 New
        0
        Quote: Voldemar 07
        But the fact is that you are only 3,5 percent at present. Have you stopped breeding at all since the so-called Golden Horde?

        finally, at the time of the capture of Kazan, the Kazan Khanate had about 450 people, of which about 000 were Tatar. Now Tatars like lyamy 250. i.e. it turns out growth over 7 centuries by 4,5 times.
        1. Mih1974
          Mih1974 28 October 2017 20: 51 New
          0
          laughing PAPER you give us a link to the tweeters of that time for the census, otherwise it’s not very funny. Most historical documents are more than 150 years old - you must definitely compare them with a dozen similar ones and analyze them in many ways. Not a single numerical statement of that time of the order of the "horde", "thousands" of the "multitude" is in any way unacceptable to be taken for granted, much less subsequently used as evidence !!
          1. protoss
            protoss 28 October 2017 22: 12 New
            0
            I’ll not give you a link; there is plenty of literature to evaluate the demographics of various regions of the world in various historical eras. I cited the numbers as a memory of both the population in the 16th century and now. I can be mistaken, but insignificantly. growth of 12 times or 17 in my opinion is not important. the fact is that "from the time of the Golden Horde" the Tatars multiplied.
    2. Aleksandr1981
      Aleksandr1981 26 October 2017 19: 05 New
      +9
      Kremlin Tatar word ????? Rave! Also tell us that the word money came from "tenge", and the Cossacks from Kazakhs!
      The word Kremlin is Old Russian, drill timber in Russia was called Kremlin, the root words are “cremnik” and “chrome”. Chrome was called the Pskov Kremlin, along with the word detinets, by the way the word "bins" came from it. These words are mentioned in our annals. The Kremlin tried to name the Türkic word only in the Soviet Union, in the eighties, moreover, natives of present Tatarstan. But the trouble is that the nomads who brought Igo to Russia did not really have their own cities, and simply could not give any urban terms to “Gardarika”!
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. kuznec
        kuznec 27 October 2017 06: 33 New
        +3
        In fact, most of the words in many languages ​​came from the oldest - Sanskrit. Both "money" and "tenge" - went from the Sanskrit "dog pes money" - to pay. Maidan in Sanskrit - square, Mata-Mama, Pata-Papa, and in general, there is such a case:
        The famous Indian scholar, professor of sanctology, Durga Prasad Shastri, at a 1964 scientific conference in India, noted that Russian and Sanskrit are two languages ​​in the world that are most similar to each other. “It is surprising, as he notes, that in two Our languages ​​have similar word structures, styles, and syntax. We add even greater similarity of the rules of grammar - this causes, in his words, deep curiosity among everyone who is familiar with linguistics ”[8].

        The most famous Russian word "satellite" consists of three parts: "c" - prefix, "put" - root and "nick" - suffix. The Russian word path is the same for many languages: path in English and path in Sanskrit. The Sanskrit word "pathik" means "one who follows the path, a traveler." The semantic meaning of these words in both languages ​​coincides: "one who follows the path with someone else." In Russian, a companion is also called a wife.

        “When I was in Moscow,” Shastri himself says, “at the hotel they gave me the keys to room 234 and said:“ two hundred and thirty-four. ” In perplexity, I could not understand if I was standing in front of a lovely girl in Moscow or in Benares or Ujjain in our classical period, about 2000 years ago. In Sanskrit 234 there will be “dwishata tridasha chatwari”. Is it possible somewhere more similarity? It is unlikely that there will be two more languages ​​that have preserved the ancient heritage - such a close pronunciation - to the present day "[9] About 4000 years have passed since the separation of the Slavic Aryans, and both languages ​​contain close and common words that arose in ancient times, but easily audible nowadays, even by lay people.

        During this visit, Shastri claimed: “you all here speak some ancient form of Sanskrit, and I understand a lot without translation” [10].

        Also, at one time he visited the village of Kachalovo about 25 kilometers from Moscow, where he was invited to dinner with a Russian peasant family. An elderly woman, apparently the mistress of the house, introduced him to a young couple, saying in Russian: "he is my son and she is my daughter-in-law." Shastri was terribly surprised that the phrase sounds quite understandable without translation. “How I wish,” Shastri writes later, “so that Panini, the great Indian grammar player who lived about 2600 years ago, could be here with me and hear the language of his time, so wonderfully preserved with all the smallest subtleties!” [eleven]

        The Russian word is "son" and in Sanskrit "suna". The Russian word is “mine,” and in Sanskrit is “madi,” and finally “daughter-in-law” is the Sanskrit “snusha”.

        “Here is another Russian expression:“ That is your house, this is our house. ” In Sanskrit: "I will give your tat, I will give our etat."
        I learn Hindi, a language that is very similar to Sanskrit, and at times I am amazed how these languages ​​have a lot in common with Russian, and certainly, a lot in common with Turkic and Arabic groups of languages. And of course, the Slavic languages ​​are uniquely more ancient, so to speak, “more primary”. Archaeologists know that India, for example, was settled by immigrants from Siberia, as it was called then, "Tartaria." This is the oldest Slavic state, which has nothing in common with the present Tatars and the Tatars.
        1. protoss
          protoss 27 October 2017 16: 12 New
          0
          Quote: kuznec
          I learn Hindi, a language that is very similar to Sanskrit, and at times I am amazed how these languages ​​have a lot in common with Russian, and certainly, a lot in common with Turkic and Arabic groups of languages.

          so you are not Hindi, but Urdu must be taught - that’s where the Persian-Arab-Turkic influence is strongest.
          1. kuznec
            kuznec 27 October 2017 16: 30 New
            +2
            I teach Hindi to communicate with my friends. Hindi and English are the two main languages ​​in India. In general, there are also more than a hundred peoples in India, and different dominant languages ​​in different states. And, for example, in Karnataka, you will not be understood in Hindi and English, but in Goa the locals speak or Konkani, and only visiting Hindus know Hindi. In the northwest, in Mumbai, Rajasthan - yes, they know Urdu.
            But I didn’t talk about this, but that we are all from the same fraternity (in Sanskrit-Bharat)!
            1. protoss
              protoss 28 October 2017 01: 33 New
              0
              You have not discovered America in the question of the relatedness of languages, that Russian and Hindi in the same Indo-European language family are no secret. you just don’t have to overestimate the degree of kinship, these are still different language groups that dispersed about 5 thousand years ago.
              South Dravidian India is a separate story altogether, they are probably the only religion that unites them with central and northern India, anthropologically, linguistically and historically, Tamils, etc. Telugu is an absolutely separate ethnos.
      3. qwertysav
        qwertysav 30 October 2017 09: 29 New
        0
        The Tatars (Volga Bulgars) who inhabited the present territory of the Republic of Tatarstan were not nomads at all. The Golden Horde is not only nomadic tribes.
    3. ALEA IACTA EST
      ALEA IACTA EST 26 October 2017 20: 47 New
      +1
      The issue is not ethnic, but national: there can be only one nation in a state, and therefore only one sovereignty.
  8. Rinat79
    Rinat79 26 October 2017 17: 29 New
    +4
    By the way, what about Chechens you won’t write about?
    1. Aleksandr1981
      Aleksandr1981 26 October 2017 19: 14 New
      +2
      And why do you even translate the topic on a national basis ?????? Here the conversation is not about the Tatars, like the people, but about the government of the Republic of Tajikistan, that is, specific people.
  9. Yak28
    Yak28 26 October 2017 17: 51 New
    +5
    This is the fault of the president, who gave a lot of authority to the heads of various regions and it started apparently from Chechnya. Chechnya is a kind of state in the state with its leader who is more authoritative for Chechens than the president of Russia in particular Putin. And these are the initiatives that lead to the collapse of Russia should be stopped by the president immediately. Our ancestors created a Russian empire with a vast territory, after the tsar, by his stupidity and shortsightedness, spoiled the country, the communists came to power and created the Soviet Union which became a huge superpower.
  10. LAWNER
    LAWNER 26 October 2017 18: 02 New
    +4
    Calm down already ....
    From January 1, 2018, the volume of Russian language learning will be brought to the level established by the Ministry of Education and Science of the Russian Federation for all types of educational institutions.
    In grades 10-11, the study of the Tatar language is only on a voluntary basis, according to the appropriate profile of training ...
    In general, the smell of fried in RT))) All politicians sing praises of the Constitution of the Russian Federation and President Putin .... And they shrug their hands- "and who did it? Wai-wai what a bad person wants to quarrel us with Vladimir Vladimirovich)))
  11. alex116rus
    alex116rus 26 October 2017 18: 10 New
    +9
    Good day.
    Please explain to me what the article is about? As I understand it, people have nothing to do, they start to whip up anything ... but under the guise of indignation, there are textbooks that nobody studies, whose flag is not there, some incredible aunt with a poll of 300 people (three hundred Karl, three hundred respondents). A serious cut, 300 people ... Let's look sensibly at the situation, and what we will see is a region with excellent roads, min. % unemployment in the Russian Federation. Someone is not too lazy to rock the boat, and periodic emissions on the topic which Tatars are cranks with the letter "m". How bad, that’s all ... Friends, let’s live together, and we won’t “be fooled” by stuffing.
    PS. Russian was born and live in Kazan.
  12. Moore
    Moore 26 October 2017 18: 22 New
    +1
    It is high time that this self-styled viper called "the government of Tatarstan" slam.
    This is about the issue of education:
    http://www.evening-kazan.ru/articles/otkazatsya-o
    t-tatarskogo-roditeli-atakuyut-shkoly-i-upovayut-
    na-genprokuraturu.html
  13. igorra
    igorra 26 October 2017 18: 24 New
    0
    Crush the nationals without pity.
    1. EvilLion
      EvilLion 26 October 2017 18: 49 New
      +3
      The vast majority of nationalities in Tajikistan are indistinguishable from Russians, the problem will disappear by itself in a couple of generations.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  14. weksha50
    weksha50 26 October 2017 18: 46 New
    +6
    "There really is cause for concern. Back in 2008, more than 80% of the schoolchildren surveyed in the republic named Tatarstan their native country.".

    Well, so they were born in it ... And there is such a republic within the Russian Federation ...

    "the founder of the Soviet state Vladimir Lenin" laid the atomic bomb "under the USSR, bearing in mind the principles of state structure. It is strange at the same time that the federal government does not pay attention to much more real" mines "that have not disappeared from Yeltsin’s time"...

    Here, once again, someone is trying to drive discord and mistrust between nations ...
    I will not be unfounded, here I give an example of distorting the facts from this article:
    1) “There was no place for the Moscow Kremlin,” said the parents. ”
    This is about the cover of the textbook ... Look, guys, for the cover in the article ... Baaaa, yes, at the top, exactly in the middle, the Moscow River with the Kremlin ...
    2) It is played out that they force us to say that Tatarstan is a sovereign country ...
    Look at the picture - there, as in the EGE test, you have to answer the correct question, and among them is just the one mentioned by the author ...

    Yes, many of the questions raised by the author are unpleasant, and these are the machinations of politicians, not the Tatar people ... I have had (and have) many acquaintances and comrades from the Tatars in my whole life, we lived and live normally, and never any national nuances did not interfere with our communication ...
    Rђ RІRѕS, The Duma and the Constitutional Court, coupled with the FSK-FSB, instead of doing bad things it was necessary for a long time to intervene in the unconstitutional activities of individual politicians of individual republics in the Russian Federation... hi soldier
    1. bald
      bald 27 October 2017 03: 47 New
      +1
      That's right, especially the last sentence. The same, commented below, and then your reasonable koment saw it.
    2. CONTROL
      CONTROL 27 October 2017 08: 26 New
      +2
      Quote: weksha50
      Rђ RІRѕS, The Duma and the Constitutional Court, coupled with the FSK-FSB, instead of doing bad things it was necessary for a long time to intervene in the unconstitutional activities of individual politicians of individual republics in the Russian Federation...

      By the way: the FSB and the FSK react so well to manifestations of separatism and propaganda such as IG * (forbidden everywhere ...) - In Kazan, twice in the last year, I witnessed shmonons like "mask shows" in a self-opening mosque and in some kind of suspicious " Islamic "house of worship; they even fed there like homeless people (well, they gave them books to read ... at leisure - so as not to get bored; printed in Russian, by the way) - of any faith! any fighters will fit jihad ... But I rarely visit Kazan - a couple of times a year ...
  15. ruff
    ruff 26 October 2017 19: 02 New
    0
    We urgently introduce troops, ship bombs with fabs
  16. Sige
    Sige 26 October 2017 19: 28 New
    0
    The longer Moscow does not notice the nationalist Tatar problems, the greater will be the losses under the CTO in Tatarstan.
    1. Grumant
      Grumant 26 October 2017 21: 19 New
      +5
      It is immediately clear that the person is not in the subject of the situation.
      1. There are no special nationalist problems in Tatarstan (so right in Russian). There are groups of marginals, very small, but don’t mess around with the local FSB.
      2. In order for there to be no problems with Tataria, Moscow does not need to notice anything especially here (although it is of course necessary to control). We need to pay more attention to Kirov, Ulyanovsk, Samara, Orenburg. The development of the republic is the result of the work not only of the Tatars.
      3. WHO in Tatarstan is very unlikely at all. Firstly, the nature of the theater of war does not at all favor the long-term resistance of the regular army (well, not Chechnya at all). Secondly, the extremely low armament of the population (also not the Caucasus), and especially nowhere to take weapons (the almost complete absence of military units).
      Bottom line: Russian, I live in Kazan, while calm.
      1. CONTROL
        CONTROL 27 October 2017 08: 42 New
        +1
        Quote: Grumant
        1. There are no special nationalist problems in Tatarstan (so right in Russian). There are marginalized groups, very small,.

        In the 90s, Naberezhnye Chelny conducted road works on one such street; so, small things, repair ...
        And now I look: there is such a solid administrative building about several entrances, on one there are signs (standard breech-type ...) ... On the right (oshu ...) is a sign of the then very famous nationalist organization TOTs (Tatar Public Center) either they had a committee there or something leading ... And on the right is a sign of the Russian nationalist organization RNU (Barkashovites, that is ...) ... They live, it means, in one entrance ... go to feed in one cafe (the guys and I dined there); everything is quiet and peaceful, communicate with each other - friendly and welcoming! No disagreement is visible ...
        ---------------------------------------
        It’s a pity, then there were still no cameras in cell phones (well, in affordable ones - which they could afford) ...
        So the question is - who are these "nationalists", what is "national policy" and who and how do we - "simple non-writers" - NPC - make a fool of their heads? ...
  17. Doliva63
    Doliva63 26 October 2017 19: 47 New
    +9
    Somewhere in the manuscripts I read - The Tsar with his Tatars. Nationality came up with this later. But there remained "real" ones - my acquaintance, according to the Tatar passport, says - everybody came along with me! laughing
  18. Yugra
    Yugra 26 October 2017 21: 56 New
    +2
    All the turbidity in Tatarstan is from Turkey. They softly lay, invest a lot, and the situation is not childish for the trouble ...
    1. antivirus
      antivirus 26 October 2017 23: 18 New
      0
      cute scolding - only amuse (about all)
  19. Alexander S.
    Alexander S. 27 October 2017 02: 38 New
    0
    No matter how the committee of Russian parents was declared separatists. For Russians it is customary to crush Russians.
  20. bald
    bald 27 October 2017 03: 39 New
    +2
    A smart little step for the Islamists, in general, this is a question for the FSB - this is their direct responsibility and their oversight. Otherwise, how? That's why she and the security service. But I need to find the sources of this and will not be difficult for the office. Russia is a multinational state and on this basis, it is easy to undermine it, which is what is happening.
    1. Svidetel 45
      Svidetel 45 30 October 2017 00: 11 New
      +1
      The problem with the separatists is not the FSB’s problem (I’m sure they report to whom it is necessary and how it should be), it’s a problem and a flaw in Russia's top political leadership, it’s necessary to show political will, otherwise you can really play up to the WHO with its liberalism.
  21. Fedor1
    Fedor1 27 October 2017 05: 34 New
    +1
    It’s not good for the first person of the state to poke him in yogurt. Russia is positioning itself in the international arena.
  22. Shurale
    Shurale 27 October 2017 06: 52 New
    +6
    In the textbooks of Tatarstan, the republic is called "a separate state"

    Can we read our textbooks first? Have you seen ours? I have two sons. I often read our textbooks, sometimes it’s funny sometimes scary, I won’t even talk about history anymore. It’s hard to read lies, but for example, literature, do you know which author is the first to study foreign literature? Guess the hell - Edgar Poe !!! Of course I respect this writer, his contribution to world literature is invaluable, but not in the sixth grade to read such things to a child? Are there really no other writers?
  23. Lganhi
    Lganhi 27 October 2017 07: 43 New
    +2
    Article Ukrainian stuffing. Pans dream of pitting different nationalities in Russia for the collapse of the country. Russia is a federal country, and the regions have some independence, in contrast to unitary Ukraine. If you open the Constitution of Tatarstan, then it says this:
    SECTION I. BASES OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL SYSTEM

    Article 1

    1. The Republic of Tatarstan is a democratic state of law, United with the Russian Federation The Constitution of the Russian Federation, the Constitution of the Republic of Tatarstan and the Treaty of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tatarstan "On the delimitation of subjects of reference and mutual delegation of authority between the state authorities of the Russian Federation and the state authorities of the Republic of Tatarstan" and being a subject of the Russian Federation. The sovereignty of the Republic of Tatarstan is expressed in the possession of the fullness of state power (legislative, executive and judicial) outside the jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and the powers of the Russian Federation on the subjects of joint jurisdiction of the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tatarstan and is an integral qualitative state of the Republic of Tatarstan.
    2. The names of the Republic of Tatarstan and Tatarstan are equivalent.
    3. The status of the Republic of Tatarstan cannot be changed without the mutual consent of the Republic of Tatarstan and the Russian Federation. The boundaries of the territory of the Republic of Tatarstan may not be changed without its consent.
    4. Within the limits of its authority, the Republic of Tatarstan independently participates in international and foreign economic relations.

    Article 8

    1. The state languages ​​in the Republic of Tatarstan are equal Tatar and Russian languages.
    2. In state authorities, local governments, state institutions of the Republic of Tatarstan, the state languages ​​of the Republic of Tatarstan are used on an equal footing.
    That is, in the Constitution of Tatarstan, the republic is a subject of Russia, and its status cannot be changed without mutual consent between the Russian Federation and the Republic of Tatarstan. Russian and Tatar languages ​​are equal.
    1. V. Ushakov
      V. Ushakov 27 October 2017 08: 01 New
      +2
      Only for some reason, in the leadership of the "Republic of Tatarstan" Russians - the cat cried.
      Russian ministers, for example, 5 out of 30 ministerial posts ...
      Doesn't it seem strange?
      Or, - Everything is good, beautiful marquise, everything is good, everything is good !?
      1. Lganhi
        Lganhi 27 October 2017 08: 08 New
        +1
        Are you a tolera and sexist? Maybe still suggest quotas for ministers to do? Of the 30 ministers, 15 are men and 15 are women, and two of them must be LGBT? Actually, according to the 2010 census, the share of Tatars in the population of Tatarstan is 53%, the share of Russians is 40%, the Chuvashs are 3%, and the rest of the nationalities share a percent.
        And by the way, where does the information about 5 ministers of Russian nationality and 25 ministers of non-Russian nationality come from? Maybe among these ministers Jews, Chuvashs, or Ukrainians made a mess of themselves.
        1. V. Ushakov
          V. Ushakov 27 October 2017 12: 41 New
          0
          There is an article in Yandex - "The Tatarstan leadership."
          Fingers, sir, you need to move your fingers, but first of all your fingers - you need to move the convolutions of the cerebral cortex.
          I never give links to elementary things - a little bit, you have to work independently.
          And quotas are a good thing, on nationality in the leadership of the regions, on women, in the same place, but LGBT people have nothing to do with it - we live in Russia, thank God, they don’t really "pamper" them ...
          1. Lganhi
            Lganhi 27 October 2017 19: 08 New
            0
            Well, that's merged, Mr. provocateur from Ukraine am
            1. V. Ushakov
              V. Ushakov 27 October 2017 20: 53 New
              0
              I am a Siberian, I live in the city of Tomsk.
              You missed, mr.
              1. Lganhi
                Lganhi 27 October 2017 21: 13 New
                0
                You are the same Siberian as I am from Kiev. For some reason, dill love to disguise themselves as Siberians, and for some reason they choose Tomsk.
                1. V. Ushakov
                  V. Ushakov 27 October 2017 23: 02 New
                  0
                  You must have been hanging around here for a long time (captain's shoulder straps).
                  It's time to get at least elementary insight.
                  You believe that if you are a Tatar, then for this reason, you can fence (with impunity) any garden in this topic.
                  On another resource, I would have brought you alive from a nationalist armored car, however, you are far from my level - you are much lower.
                  Khush sau bulygyz, dear.
                  1. Lganhi
                    Lganhi 28 October 2017 03: 13 New
                    0
                    What language do you speak at home: in Russian or Ukrainian? What mother was spoken to in childhood? I know a lot of Ukrainians who were recorded during the course of forced Ukrainization during the USSR by Ukrainians only because they live in Ukraine, although they were Russian and did not know the Ukrainian language. And now they and their children got it into their heads that they are Ukrainians, and their native language should be Ukrainian. Therefore, in Ukraine there are a lot of Russian Ukrainians who speak Russian at home and speak Russian with their parents, but count them.that their native language is Ukrainian. Although I believe that a person’s native language is the one in which he spoke with his parents in childhood.
                    1. V. Ushakov
                      V. Ushakov 28 October 2017 06: 25 New
                      0
                      You are a fool.
                      1. Lganhi
                        Lganhi 28 October 2017 08: 14 New
                        0
                        And you are dill wassat hi . Remove the saucepan from the head.
  24. sergo1914
    sergo1914 27 October 2017 09: 01 New
    +2
    Actually, I found photos of the Moscow Kremlin on the cover of the textbook (didn’t anyone really notice?). The author distorts, it seems. No one has canceled the article for inciting. Hence the question, why is this shit splashed here?
    1. Lganhi
      Lganhi 27 October 2017 21: 13 New
      +1
      This is Ukrainian stuffing. Pans are trying to drive a wedge between the Russians and the Tatars and foment the international.
      1. faiver
        faiver 28 October 2017 04: 51 New
        +1
        Before talking about stuffing, live in any national republic of the Russian Federation, clanism and veiled nationalism are flourishing in all national republics, for example, they take only the minimum necessary amount of work to the bodies of the republican government of Russia so that they will not be accused of national recruitment ...
        so I advise you to remove the saucepan from your head - it can help .. hi
        1. Lganhi
          Lganhi 28 October 2017 08: 13 New
          0
          I myself have been living in the national republic since childhood. And I did not notice any discrimination on the basis of nationality.
          1. faiver
            faiver 28 October 2017 09: 45 New
            +1
            there are not many options - either lucky, or pink glasses, or tell me the truth ... hi
            1. Lganhi
              Lganhi 28 October 2017 09: 51 New
              +1
              And I have only one option: you are a Ukrainian troll, hired to incite internationalism in Russia. All citizens of the Russian Federation are fluent in Russian, and nothing prevents them from speaking and writing in Russian. This is you, Bendera, turning inside out, like a devil from holy water, the use of the Russian language.
              1. faiver
                faiver 29 October 2017 08: 22 New
                +1
                Well, what could I tell you - no mind, consider a cripple, it's about you hi
              2. CT-55_11-9009
                CT-55_11-9009 30 October 2017 16: 13 New
                0
                In general, I agree with you, BUT:
                Quote: Lgankhi
                All citizens of the Russian Federation are fluent in Russian, and nothing prevents them from speaking and writing in Russian.

                this is not the case, to say the least. Go deep into Chuvashia, say, somewhere in Batyrevo or Ibresi - and there is no free command of the Russian language. The vast majority communicates on wild surzhik. Fluency in Russian - except in Cheboksary, Novocheboksarsk and in the south - in Russian regions (Poretskoye, Alatyr to some extent), and not everyone has it.
                1. Lganhi
                  Lganhi 31 October 2017 03: 01 New
                  0
                  Come on. Even Tuvans know Russian.
                  1. CT-55_11-9009
                    CT-55_11-9009 3 November 2017 09: 01 New
                    0
                    Quote: Lgankhi
                    Even Tuvans know Russian.

                    They know. The Chuvash people also know, but it is difficult to understand their surzhik: they chatter very quickly, a feature of the language.
      2. Svidetel 45
        Svidetel 45 30 October 2017 00: 14 New
        +2
        Maybe Ukrainian, but only the customer. probably overseas.
    2. Snakebyte
      Snakebyte 30 October 2017 19: 11 New
      0
      This is not the first such article.
      It is noteworthy that in the previous one all the comments that disproved its contents ("forcefully impose the Tatar language") were deleted.
      It seems that the journalists have a large order to prepare public opinion in line with the need to "dispossess" of the Tatars.
  25. Vokalist78
    Vokalist78 28 October 2017 12: 21 New
    0
    Those. as in the Donbas, it’s so normal, but in Tatarstan - the separatists.
    Typical doublethinking in the head, how do people get along with this?
    1. Svidetel 45
      Svidetel 45 30 October 2017 00: 19 New
      +1
      Donbass against the Kiev junta. which illegally seized power, and what separatists in Tatarstan are opposed to? Well, if you are such a big supporter of the self-determination of each village from the center. then do not forget to give independence to Corsica, there are also people who want to separate from you, I’ll see. how do you sing then.
  26. Nitarius
    Nitarius 28 October 2017 19: 33 New
    0
    guys with the president of Tatarstan is closed and that’s it!
  27. Vicon
    Vicon 28 October 2017 22: 30 New
    0
    And you say Catalonia, Spain ... What is going on with us? The next "sovereignty parade" is brewing. The government has relied on regional economic development. The problems of the regions are your problems, your money is our money. Tatarstan, Chechnya, Siberian Republic - who is next?
  28. Mars
    Mars 29 October 2017 09: 45 New
    0
    I want to see how Russia will release Tatarstan with a referendum. Occupy do not give)
  29. kalabaha
    kalabaha 29 October 2017 10: 56 New
    0
    Quote: c-Petrov
    It is time to withdraw KAMAZ from there and other large enterprises. There should be a reaction to everything and a case in point. Reduce funding, increase funding in another region.

    And then they made economic zones in Tatarstan and they already think that the industry of the Tatars did everything.

    When someone begins to live better than other regions, a feeling of self-superiority appears. It is necessary to level. To land. Lower to the ground

    although it’s easier to close the local "elite" and put other people there. It worked out in Dagestan, and then it works out.


    Roll up your lip - "ground electrode of the Tatar people."
    Will you transfer oil wells in Tatarstan outside the republic?
  30. qwertysav
    qwertysav 30 October 2017 09: 45 New
    +1
    Nothing to do again? Are Tatars so bad and bad again? This boat is rocking again. It is envious to someone that people in Tajikistan live a little better than in most other regions of the Russian Federation.
    What kind of polls are there still with 390 respondents among members of the Committee of Russian-speaking Parents of Tatarstan? It is clear that in such a separate group, where there are no Tatars, the survey will have such “results”.
    In the daughter's class, half of the children are Russian-speaking. All parents were asked to write statements about the Tatar language lessons - 100% decided to leave the number of hours at the same level. Nowhere in the Republic of Tajikistan there are no pickets, rallies, etc. with indignant about the curriculum of the Tatar language. All the hype is only in the media and the Internet.