Military Review

In the Council of Europe proposed to limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation

100
After the decision of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation on the impossibility of paying the former Yukos shareholders 1,866 billion dollars from the Russian budget, a certain alarm began in Europe. Recall that the decision to pay such a huge compensation was made by the European Court of Human Rights. After the decision was taken, the Constitutional Court of Russia in the ECHR said that in the Russian Federation "there are state abuses."


Council of Europe Commissioner Nils Muiznieks declares that "the actions of the Constitutional Court of Russia and state abuses threaten the system of enforcement of the European Convention on Human Rights."

In the Council of Europe proposed to limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation


After that, Mr. Muiznieks appealed to the Russian authorities for the adoption of a law that would effectively limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. According to Muiznieks, “Russia should at least change the law that gives the COP the right to prohibit the execution of court decisions in Strasbourg.”

Recall that on the eve of the chairman of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation Valery Zorkin called on European partners for equal dialogue. At the same time, according to Zorkin, the Constitutional Court of Russia will continue to guard Russian interests in terms of their compliance with the Constitution of the Russian Federation. Valery Zorkin noted that the decision of the ECtHR to compensate former Yukos shareholders from the budget of the Russian Federation is not constitutional, since the Yukos management has taken all steps to evade taxes.
Photos used:
The Irish Times
100 comments
Ad

Subscribe to our Telegram channel, regularly additional information about the special operation in Ukraine, a large amount of information, videos, something that does not fall on the site: https://t.me/topwar_official

Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. The black
    The black 20 January 2017 13: 48
    +15
    Brad. Then these clowns will have to limit the powers of both the American and Chinese courts ... but apparently the muizhnieks are not aware.)))
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich 20 January 2017 13: 52
      +23
      The Council of Europe proposed to limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
      megalomania or what?
      1. Reserve officer
        Reserve officer 20 January 2017 13: 56
        +33
        "Mr. Muiznieks asked the Russian authorities to adopt a law that would actually limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation."

        This is bold! And the next step is to appoint an external manager instead of the President of Russia? Nominations are being considered.
        1. WKS
          WKS 20 January 2017 14: 04
          +10
          What kind of goose is this "Nils Muiznieks"? Judging by the surname, the Latvian, and the American by the name. What kind of mixture is this? Moreover, the Constitutional Court of Russia is encroaching on.
          1. Thrall
            Thrall 20 January 2017 14: 34
            +14
            Dear Council of Europe Commissioner Nils Muiznieks, Violinist (ECHR) we don’t need, dear laughing
            1. cniza
              cniza 20 January 2017 15: 41
              +11
              If they walked through the forest, we have a sovereign state and we will figure it out ourselves, if you deal with your problems.
              1. Alena Frolovna
                Alena Frolovna 20 January 2017 17: 16
                +7
                How many of them, with a pointing finger in our direction, divorced. It is time to let out a cat in order to disperse these gray mice, who are tempted by someone else's cheese and not only: they already require sour cream. Oh well...
            2. kunstkammer
              kunstkammer 20 January 2017 17: 29
              +2
              it's high time to press the “mouthpiece” so that they all fly away ... :-)
          2. hrych
            hrych 20 January 2017 16: 11
            +2
            Quote: wks
            What kind of goose is this "Nils Muiznieks"? Judging by the surname, the Latvian, and the American by the name.

            No, the Swedish Niels, the Latvian-shaped stinks for almost a century, as the Swedish feudal lords tried to correct genetics, but apparently wasted time.
        2. Oldenburg
          Oldenburg 20 January 2017 14: 42
          +5
          Mr. Mui zhnikeksks, I pronounce his last name with pleasure, looks like an opera singer, went about his own business and as a young man carries a blizzard, which indicates to Russia. He seems to be out of his mind.
        3. Barbulator
          Barbulator 20 January 2017 14: 55
          +8
          Quote: Reserve officer
          the next step is to appoint an external manager instead of the President of Russia?

          In fact, Russia is a sovereign state! If the member states of the Council of Europe renounce it, and their constitutions allow interference in internal affairs, then this is their problem, be patient ...
        4. Lelek
          Lelek 20 January 2017 18: 28
          +1
          Quote: Reserve officer
          This is bold!


          And this is such a chronic disease called - RUSSIA THEM SOMETHING NEEDED. So the bank of Comrade Rothschild advocates for a member of the Bilderbeg Club by the name of Chubais to assist him (Chubais):
        5. electrooleg
          electrooleg 23 January 2017 10: 06
          0
          Muiznieks


          In my opinion there should be another letter in front laughing
      2. 210ox
        210ox 20 January 2017 13: 58
        +10
        No, they just stopped in the 90s when Russia was under external control in politics ..
        Quote: Andrew Y.
        The Council of Europe proposed to limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation
        megalomania or what?
      3. Observer2014
        Observer2014 20 January 2017 14: 06
        +8
        Andrey Yuryevich
        megalomania or what?
        That, no. It’s just that you can wipe the decisions of European legal institutions in Russia. Good or bad is another and very serious question. For ordinary people who were looking for the truth in the Russian judicial system, this is a disaster. I do not mean Yukos. Europe itself is to blame for this situation . Well, the fact that they are asking to change the law. That fact itself suggests itself from Russia in three funny letters.
        1. Incomprehensible
          Incomprehensible 20 January 2017 14: 21
          +1
          Quote: Observer2014
          Andrey Yuryevich
          megalomania or what?
          That, no. It’s easy to wipe the decisions of European legal institutions in Russia. Good or bad, this is another and very serious issue.For ordinary people who were looking for the truth in the Russian judicial system, this is a disaster.I do not mean Yukos. Europe itself is to blame for this situation. Well, the fact that they are asking to change the law. That fact itself suggests itself from Russia in three funny letters.


          "Ordinary people" .. Who are these people?
          1. Observer2014
            Observer2014 20 January 2017 14: 35
            +5
            Incomprehensible
            "Ordinary people" .. Who are these people?
            Those who appealed to the European Court of Human Rights and won the case. Innocent convicts in the Russian Federation, in short. Or didn’t it happen with us?
            1. lis-ik
              lis-ik 20 January 2017 15: 31
              +1
              Quote: Observer2014
              Incomprehensible
              "Ordinary people" .. Who are these people?
              Those who appealed to the European Court of Human Rights and won the case. Innocent convicts in the Russian Federation, in short. Or didn’t it happen with us?

              There were, you are right. But still I do not understand what the hell we should be equal to their legal system. Thank God We are not in the EU.
              1. APASUS
                APASUS 20 January 2017 18: 33
                +3
                Quote: lis-ik
                But still I do not understand what the hell we should be equal to their legal system.

                And I am more interested in the question of an obviously economic dispute, which suddenly began to be considered by the court on "human rights." Here it does not reach me, the interweaving of such decisions.
                Maybe I have to knock on the ZhKO in Strasbourg or better on the traffic police ???
            2. The comment was deleted.
      4. Warrior with machine gun
        Warrior with machine gun 20 January 2017 14: 21
        +5
        so exactly, with schizoid bursts, this type is measured by the whole world with its Baltic ruler, and they are used to living on a leash, but resentment takes when someone wants to live without a leash and with their own heads, for the Baltics this is a disaster, the collapse of his worldview))
      5. svp67
        svp67 20 January 2017 14: 24
        +2
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        megalomania or what?

        Money, money and BIG money again and nothing personal ...
    2. SRC P-15
      SRC P-15 20 January 2017 13: 53
      +3
      According to Muizhnieks, "Russia should at least change the law that gives the Constitutional Court the right to prohibit the execution of court orders in Strasbourg."

      This Menzhenseks better try to change the law so that criminals are not protected in the Strasbourg court!
      1. Monos
        Monos 20 January 2017 13: 57
        +7
        According to Muizhnieks, "Russia should at least change the law that gives the Constitutional Court the right to prohibit the execution of court orders in Strasbourg."

        Well, actually, this is all we need to know about a "friendly" Europe in relation to us.
      2. 210ox
        210ox 20 January 2017 14: 00
        +1
        Where should this Muizhnieks go? .... Exactly there .. And his passing ..
        Quote: SRC P-15
        According to Muizhnieks, "Russia should at least change the law that gives the Constitutional Court the right to prohibit the execution of court orders in Strasbourg."

        This Menzhenseks better try to change the law so that criminals are not protected in the Strasbourg court!
    3. Pirogov
      Pirogov 20 January 2017 13: 53
      0
      I agree ! And I would like to add, it’s time to start my opinion ,,,, work ,,,, with former compatriots!
      1. 210ox
        210ox 20 January 2017 14: 01
        0
        Work and work .... Berezovsky's scarves to help ..
        Quote: Pirogov
        I agree ! And I would like to add, it’s time to start my opinion ,,,, work ,,,, with former compatriots!
    4. maxim947
      maxim947 20 January 2017 14: 05
      +11
      The very definition that in certain cases international law is higher than Russian law should be considered as a threat to national security, and we have lived with "this" for almost a quarter of a century ... Something has been reaching us for a long time.
      And on the phrase "jeopardize the implementation system of the European Convention on Human Rights"[i] [/ i] the answer itself begs: And what does Russia have to do with ??? Well, follow your convention as you like, you should generally tick from there.
    5. INVESTOR
      INVESTOR 20 January 2017 15: 03
      0
      After that, Mr. Muizhnieks appealed to the Russian authorities
      Divorced advisers .. more precisely anti-advisers, teach your wife to cook borsch ...
    6. krops777
      krops777 20 January 2017 16: 19
      +1
      Brad. Then these clowns will have to limit the powers of both the American and Chinese courts ... but apparently the muizhnieks are not aware.)))


      It’s not nonsense the first time our constitution written by the Americans worked against themselves.
    7. neri73-r
      neri73-r 20 January 2017 16: 43
      0
      Quote: Black
      Brad. Then these clowns will have to limit the powers of both the American and Chinese courts ... but apparently the muizhnieks are not aware.)))



      Neither China nor the SGA is a member of the Council of Europe (as well as geographically in Europe) and, accordingly, should not obey the decisions of this moronic court! hi
  2. himRa
    himRa 20 January 2017 13: 48
    +3
    Well, please!
    the ECHR’s decision to compensate former Yukos shareholders from the budget of the Russian Federation is not constitutional, since the Yukos leadership took all steps to avoid tax payments.
  3. Smoked
    Smoked 20 January 2017 13: 53
    +1
    Oh, after the call of Great Britain to Russia to amend the constitution, so that someone from the citizens can be given to them, about nothing.
  4. evil partisan
    evil partisan 20 January 2017 13: 54
    +3
    To send him to ..., yes it’s clear that he is already there. yes
    1. Andrey Yuryevich
      Andrey Yuryevich 20 January 2017 13: 58
      +1
      Quote: wicked partisan
      To send him to ..., yes it’s clear that he is already there. yes

      Commissioner? send? Wow...! wink hi
      1. Odysseus
        Odysseus 20 January 2017 14: 47
        +2
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        Commissioner? send? Wow...!

        This is an imperialist commissar. God himself ordered him to be sent. And comrade Lenin approved smile
      2. evil partisan
        evil partisan 20 January 2017 19: 29
        +1
        Quote: Andrey Yurievich
        Commissioner? send?

        This is not a real commissioner stop . It is possible. It’s even necessary. yes
        Hi, amateur from fishing! drinks
    2. Viktor.N.Aleksandrov.
      Viktor.N.Aleksandrov. 20 January 2017 14: 00
      +2
      So he was sent ... along with the Council of Europe and their court! laughing
  5. arane
    arane 20 January 2017 13: 57
    +4
    We are under sanctions and in general the citadel of evil!
    We can do everything now tongue
    We wanted it ourselves!
  6. Proton
    Proton 20 January 2017 14: 04
    +3
    Bay Kommisarov laughing save Russia laughing
  7. Portuguese boat
    Portuguese boat 20 January 2017 14: 05
    +12
    Russia is not part of the EU, and after the EU gave political asylum to people on the territory of the Russian Federation in criminal search, including for terrorism, the EU needs to be silent and not to open its mouth, because they themselves did not give a damn about good neighborly relations with the Russian Federation.
  8. yahont
    yahont 20 January 2017 14: 09
    +13
    It is time to convene a constitutional assembly and amend the constitution, namely, to exclude those articles that were included in the constitution in 1993, in particular those articles in which international law is recognized over state law.
    1. ibu355yandex.ru
      ibu355yandex.ru 20 January 2017 14: 18
      +4
      I agree completely! The constitution must be changed. You need to live in Russia according to Russian Laws! And no supremacy of international law. You can only listen to him and take into account that it is.
    2. kunstkammer
      kunstkammer 20 January 2017 17: 40
      +3
      one wouldn’t forget about the native Central Bank ... that’s where the bunch of obscurantists and followers of the global dollar dominance.
      We all remember the overseas black Obama with Clintonsha, and at our side, their fosterlings are sitting.
      Not good, sir!
      1. Cat man null
        Cat man null 21 January 2017 01: 32
        +1
        Quote: kunstkammer
        Not good, sir!

        - I agree. Too, too thick ... negative
    3. Ayratelinsion
      Ayratelinsion 21 January 2017 13: 48
      0
      Yes, have you worked on this issue already? About six months ago, rumors circulated about the abolition of these articles, sort of like ..
  9. Oleg Monarchist
    Oleg Monarchist 20 January 2017 14: 16
    +2
    Serious they have ganjubas there in this Brussels laughing
  10. Zaval
    Zaval 20 January 2017 14: 17
    0
    Yes, he would not go ...
  11. bratchanin3
    bratchanin3 20 January 2017 14: 17
    +2
    It is urgent to leave the Council of Europe. This is an impudent violation of the sovereignty of Russia. What is Russia - the region of the European Union? How long will Russia be insulted by its spine ??
  12. Atlant-1164
    Atlant-1164 20 January 2017 14: 19
    +2
    in the world there are only 2 sovereign states .. which do not obey international law .. Russia is not included in this deuce.
    1. Atlant-1164
      Atlant-1164 20 January 2017 14: 21
      +2
      Contract No. 410940-4 and this is an appendix to sovereignty.
  13. rotmistr60
    rotmistr60 20 January 2017 14: 22
    0
    a certain commotion has begun in Europe

    Even over the past year, they have shown that (no one) they are and what they eat. And will this European, supposedly legal construction, dictate our rights to us?
  14. izya top
    izya top 20 January 2017 14: 22
    +10
    After that, Mr. Muiznieks appealed to the Russian authorities for the adoption of a law that would effectively limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. According to Muiznieks, “Russia should at least change the law that gives the COP the right to prohibit the execution of court decisions in Strasbourg.”

    1. andj61
      andj61 20 January 2017 15: 41
      +2
      Quote: iza top
      After that, Mr. Muiznieks appealed to the Russian authorities for the adoption of a law that would effectively limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation. According to Muiznieks, “Russia should at least change the law that gives the COP the right to prohibit the execution of court decisions in Strasbourg.”


      Or maybe it's better here? repeat
  15. Berkut24
    Berkut24 20 January 2017 14: 27
    +1
    What does he achieve? So that Russia once again sophisticatedly, publicly and with the use of a leather whip lowers the CE?
  16. Banishing liberoids
    Banishing liberoids 20 January 2017 14: 28
    +1
    It is necessary to immediately amend the Constitution by establishing the precedence of our laws over international ones, and send all those who disagree away.
  17. vvp2412
    vvp2412 20 January 2017 14: 29
    0
    Let their wives teach Borsch to cook! :)
  18. Stinger
    Stinger 20 January 2017 14: 38
    +1
    And such dolbaki work in the Council of Europe?
  19. jetfors_84
    jetfors_84 20 January 2017 14: 39
    0
    Mr. Muiznieks

    one wants to put X instead of M
  20. V.ic
    V.ic 20 January 2017 14: 41
    0
    Well, who else wants to try the commissar body?
  21. nord62
    nord62 20 January 2017 14: 42
    +3
    Well, really - they are sick all head! Limit the rights of a sovereign state - chickens to laugh. Did they mess up rams there? My heart feels that this Geyropa and all their pseudo-organizations will not live long. But Russia needs to defend its interests even harder! angry
  22. Odysseus
    Odysseus 20 January 2017 14: 44
    +2
    Well, this is already super impudent. In fact, we are voluntarily invited to limit our own sovereignty. Moreover, it is proposed not even the United States, but only their European puppets.
    On the other hand, it was we ourselves who "strove to Europe" so there is no one to blame.
    PS A worthy response to this would be the proposal of the EU to adopt a law that would oblige European courts to comply with the decision of the Constitutional Court of Russia and would make it impossible to challenge them.
  23. LVMI1980
    LVMI1980 20 January 2017 14: 45
    0
    .... so the European Union goes into the distance ...
  24. PValery53
    PValery53 20 January 2017 14: 52
    +2
    The Russian Constitutional Court could impose sanctions on the Council of Europe for $ 1,866 billion for attempts to violate Russia's sovereignty. And to forcefully squeeze out this fine from the participants of the European gang.
  25. PBF
    PBF 20 January 2017 14: 55
    0
    If it weren’t for the news, I would never have known who Nils Muizhnieks is. belay
  26. sgazeev
    sgazeev 20 January 2017 14: 58
    0
    . Turn to the next world to Eltsin or Hunchback.
  27. russmensch
    russmensch 20 January 2017 15: 08
    0
    It would be wrong to start ... Mr. Muizhnieks first needed to urgently appeal to Brussels to immediately introduce the Russian Federation to the EU with all rights and privileges, and only then modestly ask Russia to consider the ECHR's priority.
  28. K-50
    K-50 20 January 2017 15: 24
    +2
    Do these Geyropeytsy face with their exclusivity will not crack? belay
    They will agree to the point that they want to ban Russia itself! But who will save them from the next "Napoleon" once again?
    Even if Russia moved to another planet, these "consciences of nations" would still want to get to us.
  29. DPN
    DPN 20 January 2017 15: 25
    0
    While RUSSIA owns 1/6 of the globe, not a single Sharashkin office dares to stutter about it. I hope there will be no more scoundrels in the kind of labeled humpback.
  30. parafoiler
    parafoiler 20 January 2017 15: 27
    0
    Damn them bald!
  31. surovts.valery
    surovts.valery 20 January 2017 16: 07
    0
    Council of Europe Commissioner Nils Muiznieks

    With such a surname (I would explain to him whoever the thread is next to the Russian-speaking) towards Russia it is better not to speak at all.
    Here are already options on our website:
    Mui jnikesksks

    Male sex

    It’s still here we are all culturally educated and tolerant and moderator admins, and in other places they have long called him the appropriate word, close to reading his last name in Russian transcription.
  32. Corsair
    Corsair 20 January 2017 16: 26
    0
    Somehow the phrase creeps into my head:
    Do you not like something, are you not happy with us?
    Well of that - go to x .. in small steps ...

    Well, or, as an option, abbreviated more tolerant of Europeans - DPTNHP.
  33. samarin1969
    samarin1969 20 January 2017 17: 23
    0
    Nilssss! Wgo ahead ... you have full nsdapss in Latvia
    1. notingem
      notingem 22 January 2017 19: 58
      +1
      The parade of the homeless. Cool
  34. Disorder
    Disorder 20 January 2017 17: 30
    +1
    Russia is not a member of the EU, so they go through the forest.
  35. japs
    japs 20 January 2017 17: 52
    +4
    Muzyeykis, digging his nose, looking at the ceiling, may still advise the Russian government and President Putin. Gentlemen do not see the edges.
    I would advise a foot erotic journey of both the ECHR and all the gentlemen from the geyparliament and the council of geyropa.
  36. Kibl
    Kibl 20 January 2017 18: 24
    0
    This same Muizhnieks is an American Latvian, at one time he was an ombudsman in Latvia with us.
  37. ZVS
    ZVS 20 January 2017 18: 45
    0
    Complete idiocy! How do the gay people imagine this? ))))))))))
  38. Wolka
    Wolka 20 January 2017 19: 02
    0
    whom to whom, but not Europe to teach us how to live ...
  39. esaul1950
    esaul1950 20 January 2017 19: 02
    0
    Quote: Lelek
    Quote: Reserve officer
    This is bold!


    And this is such a chronic disease called - RUSSIA THEM SOMETHING NEEDED. So the bank of Comrade Rothschild advocates for a member of the Bilderbeg Club by the name of Chubais to assist him (Chubais):

    Isn't it time to disperse this thieves' ball called "RosNUNU" and send the redhead away, and send money to real science.
    1. scaramaks27
      scaramaks27 21 January 2017 14: 30
      0
      Will not work! red she is everywhere red 1
  40. Fagelov
    Fagelov 20 January 2017 19: 53
    0
    A cry of helplessness. A cry of exhaustion. ECHR, come on, boldly head on the oak. hi
  41. olimpiada15
    olimpiada15 20 January 2017 19: 55
    0
    We have no legal reason to puke about the statement of the Council of Europe because THIS OUR CONSTITUTION ACKNOWLEDGES THE SUPREME OF OTHER LAWS, and the CE merely poked the RF into the current constitution.
    In the Soviet "non-democratic times" the constitution was changed several times, the day of the Constitution was December 5, then in October.
    In modern "democratic" times, according to the constitution of the Russian Federation, it is subject to international laws, and the Central Bank of the Russian Federation is not subject to the state. And the majority in the State Duma of the Russian Federation considers this state of affairs to be the norm and sees no reason for revision.
  42. oldzek
    oldzek 20 January 2017 20: 18
    0
    Lord, how many comments on this nonsense. Do not give a damn and forget IMHO
  43. Sergey F
    Sergey F 20 January 2017 20: 55
    0
    This is the real interference in the affairs of Russia!
    Violation of sovereignty in the full sense of the word!
    They will not wait!
  44. rfv0304
    rfv0304 20 January 2017 21: 28
    0
    Honestly, I am surprised. What, they all moved there? Do they really think that the words and decisions of the Council of Geyropa mean something to us. For me, our Constitutional Court and any district court in Russia are much more important and more important than all European courts combined. And judging by the name of this Muizhnieks - Lithuanian (I had to serve there). And in Lithuania, a huge bacchanalia is happening now, after the Leningrad cleaning lady came to power.
  45. Sidel45
    Sidel45 20 January 2017 21: 38
    0
    The Council of Europe proposed to limit the powers of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation

    On such statements I can only shrug and twist my finger at my temple. Our European "partners" have finally gone crazy.
  46. VDV1985
    VDV1985 20 January 2017 21: 46
    0
    These homosexuals from Europe have already completely mixed up the shores ?!
  47. Sergey S.
    Sergey S. 21 January 2017 00: 09
    0
    According to Muizhnieks, "Russia should at least change the law that gives the Constitutional Court the right to prohibit the execution of court orders in Strasbourg."

    The title of the article is too caricatured.
    The question is deeper.
    United Europe as it were.
    And in it, indeed, there should be uniform laws, or at least a mechanism to single out laws of a higher level.
    But this is their business ...
    Russia has not entered this same united Europe. They didn’t accept ... They imposed ... Sanctions ...

    Nevertheless, they make demands on Russia. as a full member of the European Union.
    Absurd.
    And, most importantly, it is now necessary in the territory of Russia to legally prohibit campaigning for joining the European Union, the European Parliament ... I would even leave UEFA. Still does not shine ...
    Everything is extremely bare.
    European officials are looking for dough and boys for sadistic pleasures.
  48. Umnichka
    Umnichka 21 January 2017 01: 21
    0
    Already breathtaking from such impudence ... Just no words. Greyhound is an art! There are no words, just in the face ...
  49. Warchild_83
    Warchild_83 21 January 2017 01: 38
    0
    Something this "commissar" with reduced social responsibility, beguiled the coast, from the word at all.
  50. tolmachiev51
    tolmachiev51 21 January 2017 04: 28
    0
    "Shore beguiled" Gayrope !!!