Menzhinsky. The most intelligent security officer

45
December 20 in the Russian Federation celebrates the Day of the State Security Forces Officer. This date was not set by chance: in the 1917 year, 99 years ago, the All-Russian Emergency Commission on Counter-Revolution and Sabotage was established at the Council of People’s Commissars of the RSFSR - the first special service of the Soviet state. Quite quickly, the Cheka of the RSFSR turned into a powerful special service, which in its effectiveness surpassed even the famous “Tsarist secret police”. At the origins of the Cheka of the RSFSR stood a few party and state leaders, among whom the most famous, of course, Felix Dzerzhinsky. But in the first composition of the leaders of the Cheka there were other, no less remarkable people. So, one of the most influential figures at the early stage of the existence of the Soviet special services was Vyacheslav Rudolfovich Menzhinsky (1874-1934) - a professional revolutionary with a solid revolutionary "experience". Vyacheslav Menzhinsky set a kind of record for the duration of his tenure as the head of the special services of the Soviet Union in the Stalin era.

Unlike the later leaders of the security organs, Menzhinsky was of noble origin. His father, Rudolf Ignatievich, belonged to a Polish gentry family who converted to Orthodoxy. He had the rank of State Counselor (in the army - above the colonel, but below the major general) and taught history in the St. Petersburg cadet gymnasium, the Corps of Pages and several other higher educational institutions. Maternal grandfather on the maternal line, Alexander Shakeev served as an inspector of the School of Cavalry Sub-ensigns and Junkers. Thus, Vyacheslav Rudolfovich Menzhinsky had a noble origin, which, up to a certain point, determined his life path.



Menzhinsky. The most intelligent security officer


In 1898, Vyacheslav Menzhinsky graduated from the Law Faculty of St. Petersburg University. Like many young people of that time, he was seriously carried away by revolutionary ideas and, being an educated man, he began teaching in the evening and Sunday schools for the working class. In 1902, Menzhinsky joined the ranks of the Russian Social-Democratic Labor Party. Around the same time Menzhinsky tried to practice and literary activities. He published the novel “Roman Demidov” in “The Green Collection of Poetry and Prose,” published in 1905, and then the story “Jesus. From the book Barabbas ", which was published in the anthology" Protalina ". For life Menzhinsky earned advocacy.

In February 1903, Menzhinsky was temporarily sent by the party to Yaroslavl, where he was a member of the Yaroslavl Underground Committee of the RSDLP. As a cover, Menzhinsky worked as an assistant to the ruler of affairs in managing the construction of the Vologda-Vyatka railway. As part of the Yaroslavl Committee of the RSDLP, Menzhinsky was responsible for military matters. He collected information about the Russo-Japanese War, analyzed it, and also participated in the publication of the opposition newspaper "Northern Territory". After the 17 Manifesto of October 1905 was announced, the constitutional democrats who published this newspaper decided to remove the Bolsheviks from its editorial board. Soon before the start of the 1905 revolution, Menzhinsky returned to the capital. He joined the military organization of the RSDLP in St. Petersburg. That is, already then Menzhinsky chose for himself one of the most difficult and dangerous areas of party work - the military department.

Like many other members of the revolutionary underground, in 1906, Menzhinsky was arrested. However, he did not stay in prison for long. Unlike many other ordinary "fighters of the revolution", Menzhinsky was lucky to escape from prison. He left the Russian Empire and soon showed up in Belgium, then lived in Switzerland and France. Abroad, Menzhinsky even found a good job, settling into the bank "Lyon Credit" - both good education and comrades-revolutionaries played their part.

After the February 1917 revolution, Vyacheslav Rudolfovich Menzhinsky, like many other prominent revolutionaries, returned to Russia. Since Menzhinsky had been engaged in military issues in the RSDLP for more than a decade, he was appointed to edit the Soldat newspaper. When the October Revolution began, Menzhinsky, as a member of the Petrograd Military Revolutionary Committee, was commissioned to the State Bank. In fact, he became the head of the emerging finance system of Soviet Russia, taking the post of Deputy Commissar of Finance. December 8 1917 Menzhinsky year included in the Cheka. Here also played a role and experience Menzhinsky in military and financial matters, and, last but not least, personal qualities. Contemporaries spoke of Menzhinsky as a very polite, but silent and gloomy man.



The undoubted advantage of Menzhinsky was his exceptional education, especially in comparison with many other leaders of the Cheka, the OGPU and the NKVD. Menzhinsky was a man with a pre-revolutionary classical university education, owned sixteen (according to other sources - nineteen) foreign languages, wrote his own prose, brilliantly versed in classical and modern literature. Neither Berry, nor Ezhov, nor Beria possessed these qualities. By the way, it was Menzhinsky’s intelligence that later became the target of attacks by political opponents - he was accused of not interfering with political repression, but turning the security forces into an instrument of political terror.

However, shortly after his appointment to the Cheka, Menzhinsky was transferred to diplomatic work - by the Soviet consul in Berlin. Given the complexity of the then political situation, this was a very serious appointment. And it testified that Menzhinsky was one of the few political figures of Soviet Russia who could represent her interests in Germany. Menzhinsky returned to work in the Cheka organs at the end of 1919 of the year - after arriving from Germany. Two years, from July 20 1920 to July 20 1922, Mr. Menzhinsky headed the Special Department of the Cheka. In his subordination was the Foreign Department of the Cheka, the foreign intelligence of Soviet Russia. Naturally, being in these positions allowed Menzhinsky to gain significant political influence in Soviet Russia. It was under the leadership of Menzhinsky that the Soviet Special Section and the Foreign Department of the Cheka were doing their first steps. After the 14 of January 1921 of the year, the Secret-operational administration of the VChK of the RSFSR was formed, Vyacheslav Menzhinsky was also appointed its head. When in February 1922 the State Political Administration of the NKVD of the USSR was created on the basis of the Cheka, Menzhinsky headed the Secret Operational Directorate of the GPU, and then the OGPU - the United State Political Administration.

In 1923, Mr. Menzhinsky became the first deputy chairman of the OGPU. By this time, he actually concentrated in his hands the management of the Soviet secret services, since “Iron Felix” Dzerzhinsky was busy with other important party and state affairs. When in February 1924 Dzerzhinsky headed the Supreme Economic Council and engaged in the management of the economy of the USSR, the leadership of the OGPU is almost completely taken over Menzhinsky. 20 July 1926, Felix Dzerzhinsky died of a heart attack. After his death, Vyacheslav Menzhinsky was officially appointed chairman of the OGPU under the Council of People's Commissars of the USSR. Under the leadership of Menzhinsky there was a further strengthening of the Soviet special services. It was at that time, when Menzhinsky headed the state security organs, the most serious changes were taking place in the political and economic life of the Soviet Union - the departure from the course of the new economic policy, industrialization and collectivization began, Stalin began to gradually remove from power his political opponents - Trotskyists, Zinovievites, Kamenevists and representatives of other party opposition groups. Naturally, the main burden on the fight against the opposition, with the counter-revolutionary organizations, with the nationalists in the Soviet republics fell on the security organs.



Under the leadership of Menzhinsky, a system of corrective labor camps was created, the prisoners of which began to be involved in the construction of various objects of the national economy. Under Menzhinsky, construction began on the White Sea Canal and the Moscow-Volga Canal. However, since the beginning of the 1930-s, Menzhinsky's health has seriously deteriorated. First, he suffered from asthma, and constant smoking did not help alleviate the disease. Secondly, the consequences of a car accident, which Menzhinsky got into while he was living abroad, also made themselves felt. Well, of course, the peripetias of Menzhinsky's personal life played their part. This silent and gloomy man, however, was a success with women. In the life of Menzhinsky there were three marriages. In 1925, his second wife, Maria Rostovtseva, passed away. Although Menzhinsky then remarried - to Alla Adovaya, his experiences seriously undermined his health. Menzhinsky suffered a heart attack and after that he felt bad. He even had to hold meetings of the management staff of the OGPU at home — the deputies and heads of departments and departments listened to their chairman, who was lying on the bed.

By this time, in the leadership of the OGPU, Heinrich Yagoda became one of the most sinister and controversial figures in Soviet history. Heinrich Jagoda made a dizzying security career. In the past, a member of the Nizhny Novgorod group of communist anarchists, Yagoda (the real surname and name - Enoch Yehuda) joined the Bolsheviks only in 1917 year. In 1918, he settled in the Petrograd Cheka, and at the end of 1919, he became the head of the Administration of the Special Department of the Cheka, and in September, 1923 - deputy chairman of the OGPU. When the OGPU left Ivan Akulov, who occupied in 1931-1932. the post of first deputy chairman of the OGPU, in fact, Yagoda turned out to be the real head of the Soviet security agencies. By this time, Menzhinsky had practically retired, although formally he retained the post of Chairman of the OGPU under the SNK of the USSR.
10 May 1934, Vyacheslav Rudolfovich Menzhinsky died on the sixtieth year of life. One of the most prominent figures of the Soviet special services of the early stage of their existence, died of illness. Soon after his death, the OGPU was renamed the Main Directorate of State Security of the NKVD of the USSR, and he headed it, at the same time, having received the post of People's Commissar of Internal Affairs of the USSR, Genrikh Yagoda. Subsequently, the death of Menzhinsky was used to convict Yagoda himself - he was accused of ordering, at the direction of the Trotskyists, to organize the wrong treatment of the chairman of the OGPU.

Menzhinsky managed to stay on the post of the head of the state security organs for eight years. Still the same time before that, he was actually the second person in the Cheka, the GPU and the OGPU. Speaking about the figure of Menzhinsky, one cannot overlook the fact that in fact it was to him that the Soviet state was obliged to form an extensive and very effective system of political counterintelligence. It Menzhinsky became the initiator of the "purification" of the Soviet state from all kinds of opposition and politically unreliable elements. At the end of the 1920s, when Menzhinsky was at the helm of the OGPU, both the non-communist and the communist opposition were practically destroyed in the Soviet Union. “Shakhty affair”, “The Work of the Industrial Party”, “The Affair of the Labor Peasant Party” - all these high-profile processes took place exactly during the leadership of Vyacheslav Menzhinsky. In those years when Menzhinsky was in charge of the security forces, the Basmac movement in Central Asia was virtually destroyed. At the same time, the all-round strengthening of the OGPU troops was taking place, and the system of vocational education of the security organs developed. The outlines and methods of work of the security agencies that Menzhinsky laid down were subsequently used by his successors, who led the Soviet special services in the 1930s — 1950s.

Another colossal merit of Menzhinsky for domestic intelligence services is the creation of an extensive system of Soviet foreign intelligence. It was at the time when Menzhinsky was at the head of the OGPU that Soviet intelligence reached the international level. The activities of the Soviet agents developed in almost all countries of the world that had significance for Soviet politics and economics. Soviet intelligence agents acted in the midst of “white” emigration, infiltrated counter-revolutionary organizations, extracted military and technological secrets in Western countries. This entire system was also established and strengthened by Vyacheslav Menzhinsky, who had his own impressive experience in foreign work - both a representative of the Bolshevik Party and the consul in Berlin. Unlike the leaders of the Soviet secret services of a later time - Yagoda, Yezhov, Abakumov, Beria - the name Menzhinsky was not tabooed during the Soviet era - the streets of Soviet cities, military schools, military units were named after him.
45 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must sign in.
  1. SMS
    +10
    20 December 2016 07: 13
    One would think that until 20.12.1917/23/1918 in Russia there were no security agencies as well as until XNUMX February XNUMX the Russian army.
    1. +4
      20 December 2016 09: 57
      True, by the way. The prosecutor’s office has been counting since the time of Peter the Great and for a long time. Something about 270 or more years.
      1. +6
        20 December 2016 10: 27
        RomanRVV, you are absolutely right: we get some kind of paradox, the Ministry of Internal Affairs considers history from 1804, and the state security since 1917?
        1. +1
          20 December 2016 14: 57
          Right. In 2004, October seems to have been 200 years old. At the Main Entrance of the Ministry of Internal Affairs for the Rostov Region, at the main entrance to the foyer hung (now I don’t know, I haven’t been for a long time) a full-length portrait of the first Minister of Internal Affairs, Count Kochubei, it seems. And the badges were "200 years of the Interior Ministry". Identical in design, one large - for a uniform jacket, and a small one for a civilian jacket on the lapel.
          1. 0
            20 December 2016 15: 02
            In 2002)))
        2. avt
          +5
          20 December 2016 20: 31
          Quote: Monarchist
          RomanRVV, you are absolutely right: we get some kind of paradox, the Ministry of Internal Affairs considers history from 1804, and the state security since 1917?

          laughing Well, the "monarchists" we have blushed sharply bully Straight according to the covenant - beat whites until they turn red bully You cannot build a cause-and-effect relationship on a campaign. The Cheka was created to fight the COUNTER-REVOLUTION AND SABOTAGE against the Great October Revolution, which the Bolsheviks spoke of the need for. "And what does the tsarist Security Department have to do with it? Put on your panties, or remove the cross. GPU-OGPU POLITICAL MANAGEMENT!
          Quote: Monarchist
          Ministry of Internal Affairs considers history from 1804

          What does the Ministry of Internal Affairs have to do with it !? Even in the NKVD, it was a separate service - the NKGB, which was transformed into the KGB -, the vanguard of the party, selflessly devoted to the cause of the CPSU "That died in 1991 along with the USSR and its political system. For reasons quite predicted by Atz.
          “... It is necessary to smash and cast aside the rotten theory that with each advance we make, the class struggle should fade more and more, that as our successes the class enemy becomes more and more tame.
          This is not only a rotten theory, but also a dangerous theory, because it puts our people to sleep, leads them into a trap, and gives the class enemy the opportunity to recover in the struggle against Soviet power.
          On the contrary, the more we move forward, the more success we have, the more the remnants of the defeated exploiting classes will become embittered, the sooner they will go to more acute forms of struggle, the more they will harm the Soviet state, the more they will clutch at the most desperate the means of struggle as the last means of the doomed ... "(I. Stalin" On the shortcomings of party work and measures to eliminate the Trotskyist and other double-dealing people "//" A word to Comrade Stalin. "M., 1995, p. 121-122).
      2. Cat
        0
        20 December 2016 21: 19
        With the advent of the position of "chief prosecutor", it will be 300 years old in the 18th year.
    2. avt
      +3
      20 December 2016 20: 20
      Quote: SMS
      You might think that until December 20.12.1917, XNUMX, there were no security agencies in Russia.

      There were, but the funniest thing they ended up with the same thing as the KGB under the Council of Ministers of the USSR. After 1991, there was neither the USSR, nor its Council of Ministers, and the KGB providing security, just like the Security Department did not protect Nicky No. 2, and in the end the Empire was shamed.
      Quote: RomanRVV
      True, by the way. The prosecutor’s office has been counting since the time of Peter the Great and for a long time.

      laughing fool There is absolutely no way to understand what is what and what is the difference between the prosecutor's office and the secret political intelligence service! ??
  2. +3
    20 December 2016 07: 25
    ..... Henry Yagoda - one of the most sinister and controversial figures in Soviet history ...., the author reports.
    Menzhinsky is the same sinister figure in Soviet history as Yagoda, even more disgusting. And why the streets of Soviet cities (Menzhinsky) were named after one, and the name of the other (Yagoda) was shy to mention - the author did not inform.
    1. +4
      20 December 2016 10: 22
      Quote: bober1982
      Menzhinsky is as sinister in Soviet history as Yagoda

      You should start denouncing right from Lukich!
      1. 0
        20 December 2016 10: 30
        Who is Lukic?
        1. +2
          20 December 2016 14: 15
          Quote: bober1982
          Who is Lukic?

          This is another pseudonym for "forever alive". Didn't they listen to anecdotes about him, Nadenka and Inessa under developed socialism? Even Trotsky was sometimes present in them ...
    2. MrK
      +1
      20 December 2016 13: 48
      Quote: bober1982
      Henry Yagoda is one of the most sinister and controversial figures in Soviet history ..


      From the book of Alexander Kurlandchik “Damned” Soviet power ... on Prose. RU.
      ... And no one, by the way, “knocked out” the testimony from the widow of Tomsky, who was so entangled in his relations with all sorts of oppositionists that he preferred once to put a bullet in his forehead while others did not take care of it.
      Before the suicide, Tomsky asked his wife to go to Stalin and tell him that the People's Commissar Yagoda was an ideological supporter of the Trotskyists, which helps them in every way in their illegal activities, covering and covering. They did not arrest Tomsk, did not interrogate - she came to Stalin, and she told him everything that her late husband was punishing.
      And here, finally, they finally took up Enoch Gershevich, comrade Yagoda, thoroughly and seriously, with all the befittingness and meticulousness befitting the occasion! Well, they tied it, of course. I didn’t even squeak. It turned out, incidentally, that it was Comrade Yagoda that very likely belongs to the honor of the first in the state workers and peasants user of a dildo - since, among other things, a male rubber penis was removed from his table, which were then not made or sold in the USSR, and it was possible to get them only in the corrupt West.
      With whom Yagoda spoiled this thing, with Tymosha or someone else, the story remained unknown, and it’s not interesting, in general. Much more interesting is what then began.
      Shots Berries, carefully selected and loyal associates, began to shoot, as on a conveyor! Themselves. With all zeal...
  3. +3
    20 December 2016 07: 32
    Well, let Poland compensate for the activities of this and other Poles on the genocide of the Russian people.
    1. MrK
      +4
      20 December 2016 13: 46
      Quote: Kostya Andreev
      Well, let Poland compensate for the activities of this and other Poles on the genocide of the Russian people.


      And for Marshal Rokosovsky too?
      1. +2
        20 December 2016 16: 49
        To be cynical, it depends on the political situation. (joke)
        The next time you try to show off your knowledge, turn on your head. No need to compare Menzhinsky and Rokosovsogo !!!
        1. +1
          20 December 2016 20: 42
          ..Next time when you try to show off your knowledge turn on your head. No need to compare Menzhinsky and Rokosovsogo !!!

          That's right - Rokossovsky !!!
  4. +10
    20 December 2016 07: 36
    Objective article, thank you Ilya ...
  5. +3
    20 December 2016 10: 32
    Berry (real last name and first name is Enoch Yehuda)
    it's five...!!!! uzhos .. !!! I didn’t know ... some Jews .. yo-may ....
    1. +5
      20 December 2016 13: 45
      Quote: bug_1
      some Jews .. yo-may ....

      Moreover, he was married to - the niece of Yankel Sverdlov ..
      And the "Slavs" argued over whom to rule angry in Russia ....
    2. The comment was deleted.
      1. +4
        20 December 2016 16: 20
        As N.V. writes. Old men in one of his books that Stalin did not tolerate this chantrop and "... in time he shot commissars in dusty helmets .."
  6. +1
    20 December 2016 10: 46
    V.R. Of course, not an angel, but his affairs can not be compared with Berry, Yezhov. For some reason, we had mainly foreigners at the head of state security: Jews, Poles, some Swiss (Artuzov), and there were fewer Russians. By the way, and by bloodthirstiness, Yezhov is an exception, they are also ahead
  7. +4
    20 December 2016 11: 12
    One of the biggest criminals of the Stalin era.
    It is not surprising that they began to praise him after Beria
    and the rest. Neo-Stalinism is gaining momentum.
    However, the trend, as the Chukchi say ... recourse
    I am waiting for laudatory articles about Yezhov, Berry, Merkulov and others.
    1. +7
      20 December 2016 11: 29
      You greatly exaggerate, both about neostalinism, and about laudatory articles about Yezhov, Yagoda, Merkulov.
      Yagoda is Trotsky’s best friend + nationality, who in Russia will write laudatory articles about him will not understand. Yezhov, the St. Petersburg proletarian, degenerate, even went too far by Stalin’s standards, also no one will say a good word. Merkulov - shot as a friend of Beria, for the company.
      What time it was, such and the people's commissars, someone prettier, someone more disgusting.
      1. 0
        20 December 2016 11: 50
        I would be glad if you are right.
        1. +4
          20 December 2016 12: 02
          Menzhinsky managed to die quietly, they did not manage to declare him a Polish (English) spy, hence honor and respect, others were not lucky, that’s the whole difference between him and Yagoda, or Yezhov, etc.
    2. The comment was deleted.
      1. +3
        20 December 2016 13: 00
        "thanks to their managerial talents and efforts ..." ///

        You know how many Hitler had such ... with the talents of managers ...
        and through their efforts, the Nazis ironed Europe from the Atlantic to the Caucasus.
        Nuremberg for a long time versed in their talents. Someone hanged, someone
        planted, someone was acquitted.
        1. MrK
          +6
          20 December 2016 13: 34
          Quote: voyaka uh
          Nuremberg for a long time versed in their talents. Someone was hanged, someone was imprisoned, someone was acquitted.


          Where did you see from Israel the Nuremberg trial of communist leaders: Lenin and Stalin
          1. +1
            20 December 2016 15: 23
            At one time it would be nice. But now it’s too late and unnecessary.
            "the son is not responsible for the father." Today's generation for
            their deeds are not responsible.
            1. +3
              20 December 2016 20: 57
              Quote: voyaka uh
              At one time it would be nice ...


              It is strange that it was you who wrote this.
              If the Nazis had won "in due time" ...
              Only the Soviet Union was able to destroy fascist Germany in the form in which it existed precisely in that historical period.
        2. +3
          20 December 2016 14: 19
          Quote: voyaka uh
          Nuremberg for a long time versed in their talents. Someone hanged, someone
          planted, someone was acquitted.

          This is because the Red Army took Berlin.
        3. The comment was deleted.
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. +2
            20 December 2016 15: 45
            That's how they came up with fairy tales about Lohokost.
        4. +2
          20 December 2016 15: 27
          This is how many Jews in Nuremberg were hanged, how many were imprisoned, how many were acquitted? Hitler, like a semi-Jew himself shot himself if the Jewish press is not lying
    3. +7
      20 December 2016 12: 54
      Quote: voyaka uh
      It is not surprising that they began to praise him after Beria

      Strange logic. If they wrote a bunch of nasty things about Beria that he did not do, and then they dared to dare this bunch - is this praise? Those. if a person has stolen, can he be accused of murder, bribery and rape at the same time? Like, he still has nothing to lose. And we pass it off as "freedom of speech" and justice. Hmm, nothing to say ...
      1. The comment was deleted.
    4. MrK
      +2
      20 December 2016 13: 31
      Quote: voyaka uh
      I am waiting for laudatory articles about Yezhov, Berry, Merkulov and others.


      And why not about Yankel Gamarnik?
    5. The comment was deleted.
  8. +3
    20 December 2016 12: 14
    Apparently very fond of the Russian people, apparently Dzerzhinsky put forward his half-blood Pole. He contributed to the destruction of the Russian people. Poles took revenge on the Russians.
    1. +7
      20 December 2016 13: 01
      Quote: captain
      Apparently very fond of the Russian people, apparently Dzerzhinsky put forward his half-blood Pole. He contributed to the destruction of the Russian people. Poles took revenge on the Russians.


      Another Pole in the service of Stalin forgot Rokossovsky.
      1. +3
        20 December 2016 14: 33
        Plus it was set, but who, besides the Russians, remembers Rokossovsky? The gentry hates him ...
        1. +1
          20 December 2016 20: 27
          ..but who, besides Russians, remembers Rokossovsky? The gentry hates him ...

          If he hates, then he remembers.
  9. The comment was deleted.
  10. +4
    20 December 2016 17: 12
    Quote: Kostya Andreev
    The next time you try to show off your knowledge, turn on your head. No need to compare Menzhinsky and Rokosovsogo !!!

    And who needs to be compared? Menzhinsky and Dzerzhinsky? And why only the Poles. And not Georgians and Mengrels? Or have nothing to do with it, as you say in the genocide of the Russian people? Then let's go through the list, everyone. And including the Russians guilty of the genocide of the Russian people.

    Quote: Monarchist
    V.R. Of course, not an angel, but his affairs can not be compared with Berry, Yezhov. For some reason, we had mainly foreigners at the head of state security: Jews, Poles, some Swiss (Artuzov), and there were fewer Russians. By the way, and by bloodthirstiness, Yezhov is an exception, they are also ahead

    And it’s hard to be an angel, standing at the head of a special service. Especially in those years. Why were the foreigners at the head of the special services? And HZ, maybe because of his personal qualities, to some extent of his mind. Agree, not every head of the special services knew 16 languages, plus 3 more he learned while being at this post.
    1. 0
      20 December 2016 17: 50
      .... not every intelligence officer knew 16 languages ​​.....
      What do you want - you received a brilliant education under the tsar, then lived for 10 (ten) years in exile. Life in exile was vibrant, including working in a bank. It would be interesting to know who he was talking to (in exile). He returned to his homeland in 1917. - and energetically began to destroy the same polyglot (and not only them), and this is not an illiterate and stupid Yezhov.
  11. +3
    20 December 2016 17: 45
    "When in February 1922, on the basis of the Cheka, the State Political Administration under the NKVD of the USSR was created,"
    funny, but the USSR was created on December 30, 1922 ...: The NKVD of the USSR was already February ... crying
    the author should be more careful ... bully
  12. +3
    20 December 2016 18: 37
    It was not pleasant to read the laudatory article about this security officer. From his biography it follows that he was originally a secret destroyer of the Russian state. In my face - he is a hostile of the Russian people, but he was involved in the executioner's craft. The state security organs of the USSR had a not very clean in terms of morality, the history of its occurrence. Bloody she was. And there were a lot of security officers devoted to their homeland - Russia. This one was betrayed only by the Bolshevik Party.
    1. The comment was deleted.
  13. +4
    20 December 2016 20: 47
    Quote: ser56
    "When in February 1922, on the basis of the Cheka, the State Political Administration under the NKVD of the USSR was created,"
    funny, but the USSR was created on December 30, 1922 ...: The NKVD of the USSR was already February ... crying
    the author should be more careful ... bully

    Yes, the GPU was under the NKVD of the RSFSR

    Quote: bober1982
    What do you want - you received a brilliant education under the tsar, then lived for 10 (ten) years in exile. Life in exile was vibrant, including working in a bank. It would be interesting to know who he was talking to (in exile). He returned to his homeland in 1917. - and energetically began to destroy the same polyglot (and not only them), and this is not an illiterate and stupid Yezhov.

    How energetic it is difficult for us to judge. In addition, he initially headed the People's Commissariat of Finance. In any case, the number of victims under him was less than in the era of the "Great Terror"

    Quote: Evgenijus
    It was not pleasant to read the laudatory article about this security officer. From his biography it follows that he was originally a secret destroyer of the Russian state. In my face - he is a hostile of the Russian people, but he was involved in the executioner's craft. The state security organs of the USSR had a not very clean in terms of morality, the history of its occurrence. Bloody she was. And there were a lot of security officers devoted to their homeland - Russia. This one was betrayed only by the Bolshevik Party.

    The bulk of the members of the RSDLP (b), and the Chekists, especially at that time, did not separate the party and the state. He was betrayed by the Bolshevik party - which means he was betrayed to Russia (the Soviet Union). It is impossible to say how far he was, as you say, the secret destroyer of the Russian state. There are no facts of this kind, and conspiracy theological versions are only conspiracy theories. As for the executioner's craft in his person - I do not think that he personally took part in the executions. Well, the signature on the verdict or a similar document is not part of the executioner's craft. In his assessments, we differ. I don’t consider him an enemy.
  14. 0
    21 December 2016 00: 44
    "Old Bolsheviks" are a very interesting company. The main thing for them was to destroy the "prison of peoples" (to give freedom to Poland and abolish the Pale of Settlement). And what will happen next, they did not think. By the way, their descendants, as a rule, are in the "non-systemic opposition". That is why Stalin was forced to shoot them: he is the "red Genghis Khan". And the Cheka is a real governing body (in contrast to the party, in which, for the time being, discussions were not only allowed, but also considered a necessary element of intraparty democracy).