Military Review

Bankrupt man. The loudest projects of Anatoly Chubais

118
Bankrupt man. The loudest projects of Anatoly Chubais



Mr. Chubais promised the Russians for each voucher two Volga, but he prudently traveled on an armored BMW. The new projects of Anatoly Chubais are even more sophisticated, although they lead to the former result. The focus is on the state-owned company Rosnano. The largest technology investor in Russia (annual investment of 100 billion rubles) with its permanent leader represented by Mr. Chubais.

Back in 2011, according to the results of the audit of the state corporation, the auditors of the Accounts Chamber issued a clear and convincing verdict to the mournful undertakings of Anatoly Chubais:

- allows transactions with interested companies;

- finances Russian and foreign companies in the framework of nanotechnology, pre-bankrupt;

- implements non-nanotechnology projects or having negative expert opinions.

Of course, Mr. Chubais got away with all this. Over the next five years, he and his legendary “RosBanano” have mastered half a trillion rubles, not getting anything but empty promises at the exit. A detailed acquaintance with the most enchanting and expensive “innovations” from Rosnano clearly convinces that a state-owned company is managed either by completely incompetent people, or by those who use the state-owned company as a screen for activities unrelated to science and technology.

Project “90 nanometers”

In the autumn of 2009, the country’s television screens flew around a report in which Mr. Chubais demonstrated new domestic chips made using the 90 nanometer technical process (manufactured by Micron, Zelenograd). It was reported that the new technology is designed to replace the previous product “Rosnano” - chips with a step 180 nanometers.

The creators of the report tactfully kept silent about the fact that even before the release of 90 nanometer chips by the head of Rosnano, the leading foreign manufacturers of microelectronics presented processors with 45 nm pitch (for example, Samsung ARM Cortex-A8).

As it turns out later, the “newest” 90-nm technology was acquired from the European corporation STMicroelectronics, which by that time had already mastered the production of chips with the 65 nm topology. Simply put, Mr. Chubais and his henchmen purchased from the STM a deliberately outdated product worth over $ 500 million.

The start of sales of Zelenograd chips with a step of 90 nm was solemnly announced only in ... 2012, when devices that had processors with a step in 32 nm were already offered on the world market. In this situation, you can only sympathize with the specialists of "Micron", who did everything possible on the purchased outdated equipment. But the “buyers” themselves felt great and didn’t regret about the purchase.

Nanoplanet, or Where are e-books for schoolchildren?

In 2011, at a meeting with Prime Minister Vladimir Putin, Mr. Chubais presented a promising Plastic Logic 100 tablet for Russian schools, which was supposed to replace all textbooks of the book sample. To the credit of innovators, with the name of the tablet did not become wise - left the same, from the British company Plastic Logic.



The training tablet was announced back in 2008, however, two years later, Plastic Logic refused to bring its development to the market. Obviously, the company correctly appreciated the commercial success of its new products and the possible risks and inconveniences in the introduction of such a tablet in schools.

However, Anatoly Chubais is not at all embarrassed.

Key issue throughout stories with a nanoplant: for what purpose was the technology acquired in the West that was already recognized as unsuccessful?

What happened to it later (six months later, Mr. Chubais announced the postponement of the project “training tablet” for an indefinite period) and where did the investments in Plastic Logic 150 million rubles go? Probably, searching for answers is meaningless.

Drawn to the sun

In 2007-2011 production and commercial company NITOL with the support of Rosnano (investment volume 4,5 billion) was engaged in the implementation of a program to create domestic solar panels. The original plans looked great:

- on the basis of chemical enterprises in the city of Usolye-Sibirskoe (Irkutsk Region), the creation of an integrated complex for the production of polycrystalline silicon, the main element of solar cells. Design capacity - 5000 tons per year;

- creation of an industrial complex (GK Hevel, Novocheboksarsk, Chuvashia) for the production of solar modules based on polysilicon supplies from the Irkutsk region;

- the final assembly of solar cells at the facilities of the Solar Wind LLC (Krasnodar).

The first samples of polysilicon “electronic” quality were successfully obtained in 2010 year. On this positive news are over.

Despite the efforts of innovators, the production of polysilicon, like the very existence of NITOL, was recognized as unprofitable. In 2012, it was announced the closure of production in Usolye-Siberian. According to Anatoly Chubais, he, as the head of Rosnano, does not have clear parameters for exiting the NITOL project. And where the invested funds were spent remains a mystery. On this note, “Rosnano” and completed its research in the field of solar power.

It is curious that even before the start of production, experts expressed doubts about the quality of the thin-film technology acquired by Rosnano from the Orelikon company. As it turns out later, the technology is really uncompetitive, despite all the loud statements of Rosnano managers.

It should be noted that the imminent NITOL bankruptcy occurred at a time of explosive growth in demand for solar batteries around the world. It was at that auspicious moment when this industry was becoming a new trend that any company dealing with solar energy issues could count on large profits.

It is simply surprising that the shareholders' lawsuit against Chubais and Rosnano (April 2015) states “intentional destruction of the chemical plant in Usolye-Sibirsky”.

“I've been carrying pallets with some kind of junk all day” (from an interview with an employee of the Liotech plant)

In 2011, in the Novosibirsk region, in the territory of the warehouse and industrial park “Tolmachevo”, mass production of lithium-ion batteries was launched. The volume of joint investments of Rosnano and the Chinese Thunder Sky Grroup amounted to 14,8 billion rubles. The declared production capacity is over 1 GWh, or one million batteries per year, which could make Liotech a world-class player in the dynamically developing lithium-ion battery market.



Today, the most popular requests on the Internet, issued by the tag “Liotech”, are “salary” and “bankrupt”. The fact is that in January 2016, the arbitration court of the Novosibirsk region began the process of bankruptcy of the Chubais miracle plant.

Apparently, realizing the true goal of this enterprise, the Chinese partners fled with Liotech back in the 2013 year. Since then, according to the workers themselves, production has practically stopped there.

“Now nothing is produced there. Back in the days of cooperation with the Chinese, 1000 batteries were made, as they are there. Then they made some cases for different devices on the cheap, but nothing went for sale. I came in the morning, carrying pallets with some trash with other mechanics back and forth ... " (Andrey Kashnikov, former mechanic “Liotech”, from an interview with “Komsomolskaya Pravda”, 2016)

At the same time, few potential customers express displeasure at the pricing policy of the manufacturer of nanoaccumulators (cheaper to order in China), as well as inadequate work of the customer service department (the inability to look at the product “live”, referring to a certain “mode” and “ secrecy"). To see the battery is allowed only after registration and payment of the order.

The moral of the story with “Liotech” is by no means the next regular demise of the enterprise, to which Rosnano and A. Chubais put their hands. The main question is the purpose of creating a huge industrial complex and the injection of investments in the amount of 7,5 billion rubles. In the absence of clearly defined markets and any assessment of the demand for the products of the miracle factory.

A similar story happened with “Optogan” - another ward “Rosnano”. In St. Petersburg, the largest plant in Eastern Europe for the production of high-brightness LEDs was built, designed to produce 360 million LEDs per year. The volume of investments - 3,35 billion rubles.

2015 year. “Optogan” is a complete bankrupt. By the decision of Rosnano, Optogan is abandoned by its creators - physics scientists Maxim Odnoblyudov, Alexey Kovsh and Vladislav Bugrov.

Any enterprise is created based on the assessment of its profitability. A new high-tech production, not yet secured by sales markets, begins with a modest shop, which, with proper marketing policies, demand development and investment, gradually grows to a whole group of companies, with the advent of new production lines at different ends of the country.

Instead of all this, the largest amounts of funds were invested in new productions, and then everything was done to stall these enterprises. The purpose of such manipulations is too obvious: while there is an opportunity, withdraw funds from the budget and grab the largest jackpot on the construction site. How the company will function, as well as the entire high-tech industry as a whole, does not care about effective managers.

"I am a normal person. I understand that this is hard to believe, but believe it" (A. Chubais in an interview with Kommersant, 2013)

Tablet, NITOL, Liotech, Optogan, accusations of raider seizure of Hi-tec production (scandal with SUN, 2013), inquiries from deputies and the results of inspections of the Accounts Chamber, indicating activities related to a flagrant violation of the legislation of the Russian Federation. The list of actions of Anatoly Chubais as the head of Rosnano is drawing on numerous volumes of the criminal case. It's amazing how, after all the setbacks, Mr. Chubais manages to maintain political weight and remain in the post of one of the most important and capital-intensive Russian state corporations!
Author:
118 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. Uncle lee
    Uncle lee 29 September 2016 15: 07
    26
    Chubais can only do one thing well — pump money to your pocket!
    1. Vend
      Vend 29 September 2016 15: 16
      15
      The list of Anatoly Chubais’s acts as head of the Rusnano JSC draws on numerous volumes of the criminal case.
      Everything has its time. Chubais thinks that he has a life-long amnesty in his pocket, only it is bearer. It can be lost.
      1. Simple
        Simple 29 September 2016 16: 39
        10
        Quote: Wend
        It can be lost.

        When?
        1. pilot8878
          pilot8878 29 September 2016 17: 09
          13
          All this resembles the same circus almost a century ago - OSTEKHBYURO under the leadership of Bekauri. Also, "nanotechnology" pulled gigas from the budget of the already not rich then USSR. True, when they could not present anything at the exit ... In general, everything ended sadly. "Bloody Gebnya", damn it, shot. laughing
          1. captain
            captain 30 September 2016 06: 58
            +5
            Schubais’s father, a colonel in politics, headed the department of Marxism-Leninism. Apparently the son went in the footsteps of the pope. Promise and not fulfill the hobi ideologists of communism. For example :-) they promised land to the peasants in 1917 and gave it when they won, they took it away. They promised communism in 1981 / Khrushchev at the congress of the CPSU / and did not. They promised to raise a new Soviet man and raised :-) Gorbachev, Yeltsin, Shevardnadze, Yakovlev, Gaidr, Chubvis, Berezovsky, Khodorkovsky, Kozyrev, Medvedev, etc. They promised to destroy the old world to the ground and destroyed Russia, built a new world and a new man. There is also a wild brother Russophobe, the real descendants of the communist.
            1. Schultz
              Schultz 30 September 2016 08: 16
              +2
              The Russian land does not give rise to Ramon merkader. And, how would you now - Comrade Ramon would be in demand, in addition to your case, Andrei Yanuarevich Vyshinsky.
        2. Vend
          Vend 29 September 2016 17: 12
          +2
          Quote: Just
          Quote: Wend
          It can be lost.

          When?
          I hope that soon
          1. Simple
            Simple 29 September 2016 17: 24
            17
            Quote: Wend
            I hope that soon

            I hope that at least my children will be present in the frontal place when the verdict is brought into force.
            Although I doubt it

            for one RAO "UES" in a decent society, they would have gotten their face (at least), but in fact they would have been imprisoned for 25 years.
            Disintegration of the industry as a result of the reform led to increased accident rate. “The last 10 years of the Russian electric power industry is a continuous series of accidents similar to those in the Soviet electric power industry.”
            The miracle promised to us (once again) by Anatoly Chubais, the main ideologist and executor of this reform, did not happen. For example, the inflow of investments in the industry that was expected, although the business has moved forward, did not happen.

            According to the results of the reform, the quality indicators of the electricity industry in comparison with the Soviet period correspond to the level of 1946-1976. and are characterized by:
            - suboptimal operation of power plants;
            - high specific fuel consumption - 7% higher than in 1990;
            - growth of electric energy losses in electric networks up to 14% (according to standards - 8%); - increase in the number of operating personnel;
            - a sharp reduction in specialized repairs (8 GW capacities per year are not repaired, there is no readiness for emergency repairs);
            - low installed capacity utilization factor (KIUM) of TPPs and NPPs;
            - The efficiency of power units of Russian gas power plants is 1,5 times lower than that of modern combined cycle units, i.e. barbarous gas burning occurs;
            - state funding for research and development in the electric power industry compared to 1990 was reduced by 15 times - from 150 million to 10 million dollars; - the share of domestic equipment in new projects decreased by 3 times (from 99 to 35%);
            - the salary level of top managers exceeds the industry average by 70-100 times (in Soviet times - by 3-5 times).


            In a "normal" country, he would have been imprisoned long ago, or they would have been terminated in a quiet country (if not in court).
            Question: why is it still spoiling the air?
            Answer: someone (TAM) needs him
            The State Duma deputies who supported the reform (RAO "UES") received, according to sources in parliament, from 20 thousand (at the beginning of the process) to 580 thousand dollars (at the end, when each vote was critical) for passing laws on her. The total winnings of only top management of RAO from the growth of capitalization at the adoption of these laws exceeded the cost of bribery by more than five times (according to the minimum estimate).
            1. padded jacket
              padded jacket 29 September 2016 17: 47
              10
              Quote: Just
              Answer: someone (TAM) needs him

              Most likely in 2000, when Putin was desperately fighting for power with the oligarchs, Chubais was one of the "team" of Jewish moneybags close to former President Yeltsin who chose his side and "turned in" the rest of this "mighty handful" of his former friends like Berezovsky and Gusinsky Khodorkovsky. ...
              For this, Putin holds it, and even as a flag or symbol for the West - they say, look capitalists, Jews, oligarchs for me and even one of the main ideologues of the destruction of the USSR is also for me, so calm down gentlemen from Europe in Russia, "complete" capitalism and liberalism.
            2. poquello
              poquello 30 September 2016 01: 44
              +3
              Quote: Just


              for one RAO "UES" in a decent society - they would get a face

              cool photo
              You can see the battery only after placing and paying for the order.
              Count Cagliostro
      2. Donhapa
        Donhapa 30 September 2016 06: 03
        +3
        Quote: Wend
        The list of Anatoly Chubais’s acts as head of the Rusnano JSC draws on numerous volumes of the criminal case.
        Everything has its time. Chubais thinks that he has a life-long amnesty in his pocket, only it is bearer. It can be lost.


        The "Great Combinator" lied to the amnesty ...
        Even after he helped to privatize (destroy the industry of the country), he gets a position after position in the bread places under the patronage of SamogO
        1. AUL
          AUL 30 September 2016 16: 52
          +3
          Yes, because this one holds the Faberge tightly, it won’t squeak. Therefore, he walks gogol and looks like an eagle. And the fact that the whole country hates him - so even though he has pisses in his eyes, he does not hesitate.
    2. Sotskiy
      Sotskiy 1 October 2016 19: 14
      +3
      Quote: Uncle Lee
      Chubais can only do one thing well — pump money to your pocket!

      And who allows it to him? Can you recall who he is friends with? (drum roll and fanfare) President of the Russian Federation Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin!
      So all your complaints are not appropriate! laughing Until the time ... In the meantime, we enjoy the "stability" of the economic decline with the help of one more "friends" from the Government of the Russian Federation. But we chose it ourselves, didn't we? So we enjoy the "results" and do not whine!laughing
  2. De laert
    De laert 29 September 2016 15: 17
    31
    It is believed that Chubais in the hierarchy of the current government is more important than Putin. That Putin is his protege, then it is clear how stealing openly, being actually caught, Chubais remains at the helm of billions of projects. You can write a thousand of such articles, conduct a million checks of his activities, but this will not change anything. As he was at the helm since 91, it will be so.
    But what’s interesting is that if such people are in power, then what awaits Russia with ever-increasing attempts to drag us into the war ... In principle, I’m not a fan of everything, but how will we win the battle with the USA (let’s say) with such squandering of Russia?
    1. VECHESLAVIAN
      VECHESLAVIAN 29 September 2016 16: 04
      +2
      This video, albeit briefly, outlines the essence of what Chubais & Co is molding from Russia https://youtu.be/wUuYt8YmTus
    2. gladcu2
      gladcu2 29 September 2016 16: 36
      11
      De laert

      Do not worry your Chubais in the United States not measuredly. Minus minus, give a plus. These are products of the economic system.

      The only remedy is Stalin's purges. True, they always forget that before this there was a revolution followed by a destructive civil war.

      And so it will be next. Some ancestors paid with their lives and created a country. Other ancestors came to sell the country, paying the same lives. Third ancestors lost their brains altogether, forgot history and turn into ruminants, gradually losing everything. Knowledge, science and technology.

      Life is not like a wheel. As it turns out. The reverse point of reference itself does not return. So it will take new lives. So get ready for the worst. To get better.
    3. NordUral
      NordUral 29 September 2016 17: 24
      14
      Take it wider. While in power all this Caudle, which is called the EP, which is one of the hypostases of the liberals, that the system that is not system (Navalny and K), the country will not have to wait for anything good.
    4. poquello
      poquello 30 September 2016 01: 48
      +4
      Quote: De Laert
      There is an opinion that Chubais in the hierarchy of the current government is more important than Putin .... if such people are in power, then what awaits Russia with ever-increasing attempts to drag us into the war ... I, in principle, are not a prowler, but how will we win the battle from the USA ...?

      there is an opinion that Chubais is more important than Obama
  3. dumpy15
    dumpy15 29 September 2016 15: 19
    10
    A.B. long been appointed overseer of Russia. Therefore, still untouchable.
    1. Baloo
      Baloo 29 September 2016 15: 28
      17
      Swamp mold intensified after the redhead's trip to the next meeting of the Belderbek club.
      I feel equally unpleasant and redhead and his bro-processor MGIMO (!!!), if I'm not mistaken. We need a mechanism for depriving citizenship of such freaks.
      1. Kerry
        Kerry 29 September 2016 18: 54
        +3
        Not citizenship, but goals.
  4. iouris
    iouris 29 September 2016 15: 30
    14
    Not Chubais bankrupt, but me. But Chubais is doing fine: he is building a great nano-power.
  5. LeftPers
    LeftPers 29 September 2016 15: 32
    17
    Let him do the only good thing for the country-hanged himself.
    1. DMoroz
      DMoroz 29 September 2016 15: 53
      +6
      I recall his phrase on the New Year's corporate bargain about moneyam
      it’s not in vain that all harmful red cats are called Chubais ...
      1. EvgNik
        EvgNik 4 October 2016 11: 13
        0
        Quote: DMoroz
        it’s not in vain that all harmful red cats are called Chubais ...

        They are therefore harmful because they are called so. Name it differently - there will be a good, affectionate cat. In my childhood I was Vaska - red, but affectionate.
        1. atalef
          atalef 4 October 2016 11: 23
          0
          Quote: EvgNik
          They are therefore harmful because they are called so. Name it differently - there will be a good, affectionate cat. In my childhood I was Vaska - red, but affectionate.

          Hi Zhen hi
    2. rasteer
      rasteer 30 September 2016 12: 19
      +1
      He would be glad, but somewhere nano rope and sowed soap. And on a simple hemp with laundry soap, nano religion does not allow him.
  6. Ru_N
    Ru_N 29 September 2016 15: 47
    15
    There is nothing surprising. Tolya is responsible for paying tribute to our overseas master by our country. Do not forget that we lost the Cold War and now must pay indemnity, because we are a colony. Here we pay. We can’t pay openly (we immediately recall our gold and currency reserves stored in hostile countries, sorry, with the owner), so we are building everything in a row, but it’s not so consummate so that more money is spent.
  7. Danil Laryon
    Danil Laryon 29 September 2016 15: 49
    10
    Rusty need to put on a stake.
  8. atakan
    atakan 29 September 2016 15: 59
    +4
    Let him do the only good thing for the country-hanged himself.

    There are many of you in Moscow, but there is no one to help.
  9. Air Force Colonel
    Air Force Colonel 29 September 2016 16: 01
    14
    Yes, he is watching Russia from the Rothschilds and Rockefellers.
  10. nik1321
    nik1321 29 September 2016 16: 04
    +8
    Chubais - was and is a symbol of the Russian economy and the authorities that are now at the helm of the country (until they put him in prison and if they put him at all) With which I can’t agree that he is a bankrupt person - it would be interesting to know what this person’s personal condition is assessed ..His annual income is also .. One thing is not clear - why did you write this article? The person is known and unsinkable no matter what and against all odds ............ As I understand it, if such a person is still at large, then he is either absolutely clean and innocent in terms of breaking the law ... or something is wrong in this state .. and to put it mildly not so.
  11. cheburator
    cheburator 29 September 2016 16: 05
    +3
    Red demon! It must be lustrated! negative
  12. Old Horseradish
    Old Horseradish 29 September 2016 16: 24
    +7
    Very interesting reference. It explains a lot, makes a lot clear, it becomes clear how the snake shed its skin!
    1. Horst78
      Horst78 29 September 2016 17: 33
      12
      The adult population of the USSR has been a member of the CPSU since 19xx. What is the news and, in fact, what is the release? Smart ass. Your "nickname" speaks a lot for you. "minus (-)"
      1. your1970
        your1970 29 September 2016 20: 21
        +6
        more precisely: to become a boss, it was necessary to become a member of the CPSU ... They WANTED to become bosses .....
        What's the news ???
        1. poquello
          poquello 30 September 2016 02: 06
          +2
          Quote: your1970
          more precisely: to become a boss, it was necessary to become a member of the CPSU ... They WANTED to become bosses .....

          or rather, far from the entire adult population, and not even all the bosses, but this ticket accelerated upward
    2. Sidel45
      Sidel45 29 September 2016 21: 55
      +7
      Well, and what is strange and even worse on this list? That was Soviet time, and in order to get comfortable enough in life, you had to be a member of the CPSU. The same thing now - if you want to prosper - be an edros. I know people who fussed in all parties of power, starting with the CPSU. Now it is United Russia. Another party will come to power and these people will trample on it, cursing the previous one. The Germans call such people not Parteigenossen, but Parteigeniessen, i.e. using the party for their personal purposes. There are also Karteigenossen, i.e. party members by the presence of a party ticket - there is a ticket - a communist, a ticket thrown out - an anti-communist. We also have enough of these.
  13. krops777
    krops777 29 September 2016 16: 50
    +4
    Who is behind Chubais the saboteur is the question that even the GDP is not able to do anything with it.
    1. Simple
      Simple 29 September 2016 17: 36
      +9
      Quote: krops777
      that even GDP is not able to do anything with it.

      What do you mean "unable to"?
      Maybe does not want? maybe he needs it?

      Such a bouquet according to the Chip Report of the Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation from 2013
      “Having signs of crime under the following articles of the Criminal Code of the Russian Federation:
      - Article 147 "Violation of inventive and patent rights";
      -Article 159 “Fraud”;
      - Article 159.1 "Credit fraud";
      -Article 174.1 “Legalization (laundering) of cash or other property acquired by a person as a result of his commission of a crime”;
      - Article 196 “Intentional Bankruptcy”;
      -Article 199 “Tax evasion and (or) organization fees”;
      -Article 285.1 “Misuse of budget funds”;
      - Article 201 “Abuse of authority”;
      - 185 article “Abuse in the issue of securities”


      the signature stamp “For official use” and, as it should be, was sent to law enforcement agencies (the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the FSB, the Prosecutor General, the Investigative Committee) for making procedural decisions.

      Shines for life (cumulatively)

      And Fonds Rusnano Capital in Luxembourg (3 people staff number), to manage it, Switzerland’s managing company Rusnano Capital AG has been established five peoplek (including Anatoly Chubais himself) = $ 440 million bytes of Russian money.
      well extended. Agreement on consulting services with Axioma Management, which paid $ 1,3 million for services

      And LLC “Usolye-Sibirsky Silicone” in 2011 year after investing in 4,5 billion rubles in the production itself, the corporation decided to appoint a new a design organization that became Sherigo Resources Limited, a company registered in the British Virgin Islands (BVI).
      DESIGN ORGANIZATION from the Virgin Islands crying
      Hkkk

      It took almost Sherigo Resources Limited to purchase 16 billion - of which Xnumx billion was spent by Rusnano, and Xnumx billion was co-invested in the Sberbank Capital project (as a result, Rusnano received 9,4% in the company; Sberbank Capital - Xnumx%). The new contractor spent almost all of the money received on another acquisition - for 6,6 billion rubles Sherigo Resources bought additional shares of Cyprus Insqu Production Limited

      According to the report of the Accounts Chamber, abroad, using various schemes, allegedly for joint projects 47 billion rubles were spent, less than half returned. At the same time, the report expressly noted that at least 1,2 billion rubles were transferred to one-day firms.
      1. Baloo
        Baloo 3 October 2016 22: 53
        0
        I'm not so much interested in losing money, but in another aspect of the red: How many nanotechnologies have Rusnano ruined? How many of them for some reason have flowed and sold across the river? winked
    2. stopkran
      stopkran 29 September 2016 17: 37
      +6
      The red-haired rat Nanotolik is a "beholder", he created "oligarchs" and for this zeal the owners appointed him a member of the board of directors of the largest bank of the Rockefeller group, J. P. Morgan-Chase ".
  14. prior
    prior 29 September 2016 16: 59
    +5
    Chubais knows how to cut better than many others.
    At the logging would be a foreman.
  15. esaul1950
    esaul1950 29 September 2016 16: 59
    +6
    Not everything is all right in our "der-moratic kingdom", glory to "United Russia" Urya!
  16. NordUral
    NordUral 29 September 2016 17: 10
    +4
    The list of the deeds of this bastard and before "Rusnano" has long been drawn to "nine grams".
  17. uskrabut
    uskrabut 29 September 2016 17: 27
    +4
    "It's amazing how, after all the failures, Mr. Chubais manages to maintain political weight and remain in the post of one of the most important and capital-intensive state corporations in Russia!"

    He probably managed to steal more money than the notorious "platinum colonel"
    1. rasteer
      rasteer 30 September 2016 12: 25
      0
      not stolen and redistributed and therefore does not sit.
  18. antivirus
    antivirus 29 September 2016 17: 29
    +1
    Does it right
  19. Horst78
    Horst78 29 September 2016 17: 30
    +3
    All. I am repainted in "red". Maybe then I'll get rich wassat
  20. Neputin
    Neputin 29 September 2016 17: 34
    12
    I do not think that the GDP can do nothing. Rather, he doesn't want to. And, note that he diligently distances himself from Chubais and the company on the one hand, and does not insult him and his entourage on the other. The phrase "now is not 37 years old" was the answer to the question of some journalist about Ryzhy's activities and how long ... I believe there is a connection between them, and since it is known that nothing binds people as tightly as money, the conclusions will follow not at all in favor of the guarantor. But Chubais still needs to be wary. While he finances the election campaigns, maybe something else and no one will touch him. If he becomes unnecessary, he will at the same time become a person "who knew too much." They will bang him someday on the sly, shoot him like a dog in his own villa in the Maldives and say that there was a robbery. Or maybe hang himself on a scarf. It is a pity that we will not wait for the public execution of the scoundrel.
  21. vfqjh
    vfqjh 29 September 2016 17: 44
    +2
    Humpbacked only to correct the grave, born to tyry - can not produce!
  22. terminator978
    terminator978 29 September 2016 18: 06
    +4
    Well, you are small children, Chubais is to blame, he will be imprisoned. Yes, no one will plant him, from a legal point of view he is white and fluffy, and all his deputies are crooks and bribes. Everything was agreed upon a long time ago, the government does not touch the redhead, and the redhead does not compromise the authorities, respectively, and the loot is poured into his company regularly and a lot, and for the sake of the appearance, they appoint someone from his entourage.
  23. Galleon
    Galleon 29 September 2016 18: 07
    +8
    Do you remember what Chubais did immediately after the assassination attempt on him? He rushed to Pu, and he urgently accepted him, talked in detail. And then the "show trial" of Colonel Kvachkov began.
  24. Gormenghast
    Gormenghast 29 September 2016 18: 48
    +3
    How much rope does not curl ...

    Now there is a crisis, so I look forward to when in the process of close study "petty transgressions"(to which they did not pay attention before) hands will reach nanotechnological innovations, thanks to which it is not the nano-sums of budgetary funds that evaporate.

    Thanks to Chubais personally, the term nanotechnology is assigned to the category of curses. Or nanorraging - to whom as. am
  25. Saratoga833
    Saratoga833 29 September 2016 19: 05
    +6
    Chubais is one of Putin’s best friends. This is where we should proceed from its immunity and unsinkability!
    1. vadsonen
      vadsonen 29 September 2016 19: 29
      +2
      Cooperative "Lake" does not rent its own.
  26. KRIG55
    KRIG55 29 September 2016 19: 19
    +2
    It is high time that this figure was identified in his deserved place and preferably forever.
  27. Signore Tomato
    Signore Tomato 29 September 2016 19: 27
    +2
    There is no money, but are you holding on?
    "At present, there are unfounded accusations against DAM."
    And soon: "At the moment there are unfounded accusations against the ABCh ..."?
  28. The comment was deleted.
  29. win
    win 29 September 2016 19: 32
    +6
    The list of Anatoly Chubais’s acts as head of the Rusnano JSC draws on numerous volumes of the criminal case.


    And GRU Colonel V. Kvachkov, who was charged with assassination attempt on Chubais, still sitting ...
  30. Tutin
    Tutin 29 September 2016 19: 50
    +2
    Sorry, but inspired ... If his antennae "fly" - the spitting image of Adolf.
  31. aud13
    aud13 29 September 2016 19: 55
    +3
    What is the Chubais in this photo similar to Hitler ...
  32. evge-malyshev
    evge-malyshev 29 September 2016 20: 10
    +2
    After reading the article, I realized that none of Chubais's "nano-beginnings" ended with a positive result. To squander such money and remain at the helm of such a company as RosNano is nonsense. This, it would seem, should not be. But, in fact, only for RAO UES he should answer to the maximum and is excommunicated from the trough of the head of the state company. However, it is still alive and well. Regrettable ...
  33. Fonmeg
    Fonmeg 29 September 2016 20: 28
    +8
    It would be cheaper for the state to nail this red shovel! The tremendous budget benefits are undeniable. This is our story, some create, others plunder destroy!
  34. Lelek
    Lelek 29 September 2016 20: 35
    +1
    (The list of Anatoly Chubais’s acts as head of the Rusnano JSC draws on numerous volumes of the criminal case.)

    Pyramids, pyramids, and I'm so small. The case will not reach the court (too many fat cats in this "enterprise" are tied up, and even if it does, it will be "as always"). I think there is no need to give examples.
  35. volodya
    volodya 29 September 2016 21: 21
    0
    It's time to plant! He knows nothing but his pocket!
  36. midashko
    midashko 29 September 2016 21: 55
    0
    Not bankrupt, but banknotes.
  37. encarcelado
    encarcelado 29 September 2016 22: 29
    +1
    It is difficult to judge objectively with reference to one material ... There is only fragmentary data ... But in my opinion a citizen has not achieved anything in his position. It could be safely sent to the scrap after idiotic reforms, but here the second chance is clearly a failure ... I am for the court.
  38. fzr1000
    fzr1000 29 September 2016 23: 59
    +1
    Regarding the production of microchips in Russia, here is an interview with the director of Mikron. There, and about Rusnano, and about the prospects there.
    http://imperiiia.com/2016/01/gendirektor-mikrona-
    gennadij-krasnikov-o-razvitii-mikroelektroniki-v-
    rossii.html

    And the data for 2015 on the production of microchips in the Russian Federation.

    In the field of electronic documents, which include smart cards, electronic passports, etc., Russia can create chips for biometric passports, for electronic citizen identification, etc. In the transport system, only the Moscow metro receives 235 million tickets a year, plus 80 million tickets - Mosgortrans, regional transport systems are also launched. All of them are created on domestic chips.

    Another section is industrial electronics. Russia produces voltage converters and rectifiers for batteries and chargers, as well as power management and controllers for LED lighting. Russia exports these products to Asia, mainly to China, which, using the Russian element base, produces the final product - charging and LED lamps. Mikron, for example, exports 50 million microchips every month to China for this purpose.
  39. Freelancer7
    Freelancer7 30 September 2016 01: 49
    0
    padded jacket,
    Yeah, and Chubais also goes to the meetings of the Bilderberg Club. The question arises - for whom then does Putin hold him and how what symbol ?!
  40. Phosgene
    Phosgene 30 September 2016 02: 50
    0
    It’s high time to send this red-headed scammer to a logging site, under a good escort.
  41. Timmer
    Timmer 30 September 2016 03: 52
    0
    We must wait for the results of elections in the USA, Clinton will win - Chubais will remain on the horse, Trump will win - he will have a year or two, after which he will either have to fell to Argentina or to forest.
    1. rasteer
      rasteer 30 September 2016 12: 40
      +2
      Clarify why?
      Two years later, the United States, led by Trump, will occupy Russia or Chubais is Trump's personal enemy and he will pay for his arrest?
      HOW is one connected with durgim?
  42. Vovan 73
    Vovan 73 30 September 2016 05: 29
    +2
    "It's amazing how, after all the failures, Mr. Chubais manages to maintain political weight and remain in the post of one of the most important and capital-intensive state corporations in Russia!" - Good question for another direct line with the president
    1. kotvov
      kotvov 5 October 2016 12: 19
      0
      it was told to you, we don’t give our own.
  43. All-seeing
    All-seeing 30 September 2016 05: 40
    0
    Yeah, amazing inefficiency! The last of the Mohicans ... how he manages to stay afloat, I do not understand.
  44. Volzhanin
    Volzhanin 30 September 2016 08: 07
    +1
    With great pleasure I would shoot this red cattle.
  45. guzik007
    guzik007 30 September 2016 08: 28
    0
    And we were amazed at the lards of Zakharchenko. Compared with the red demon, Zakharchenko is simply a primitive piece of cake. Here's how to work! Sleight of hand and no fraud.
  46. Enoch
    Enoch 30 September 2016 09: 29
    +3
    With such a roof, Ryzhem does not care. Question to the roof with whom you are.
  47. vladimirvn
    vladimirvn 30 September 2016 12: 32
    +1
    Yesterday in the news: "70% of the power grids are completely worn out ...." I remind you that in the course of the RAO UES reform, carried out by the genius reformer of all times and peoples, the unsinkable comrade Chubais, they were handed over to private owners for operation. Question? At whose expense will they be restored now? Right! For ours with you!
  48. sokudo
    sokudo 30 September 2016 14: 41
    0
    Thanks to privatization, Chubais owns so much that it’s easy to remove it, remove it, etc. - it doesn’t work out.
  49. Buffet
    Buffet 30 September 2016 16: 53
    0
    They don’t give up their friends ...
  50. Kaiten
    Kaiten 30 September 2016 21: 46
    +1
    Under Soviet rule, the Jews all sat in warm places. And there was a great cry in Russia, against the dominance of the nationalities. Academics wrote your smart books, such as "Russophobia", which scientifically proved the need for pogroms of the "Small People". After the Jewish scientists left you, there were only Jewish moneybags. Now in science all the warm places belong to the indigenous nationality. And it turned out that the cries about the dominance of the Jews and science are two big differences. Progress then left with the Jews, look how science flourished in Israel after the 90th year and in what degradation it is in Russia. Say thanks to Shafarevich and other guardians for Russian science without Jews.
    1. Bloodsucker
      Bloodsucker 30 September 2016 21: 54
      0
      From creating an image of imaginary greatness, does not heal?
      Of course, E. Satanovsky, a Jew, said that if a Jew is smart, then this is Einstein, but if a Jew ......., then to everyone ....... ........
      The exact presentation of his words, forward in the program of V. Solovyov, the same way by the Jew, is precisely said about you.
      To avoid complaints, https: //topwar.ru/101421-neprikasaemye-i-na
      rushiteli.html
      1. Kaiten
        Kaiten 30 September 2016 22: 34
        +2
        Quote: The Bloodthirster
        From creating an image of imaginary greatness, do not hesitate?

        Greatness is with you, in the homeland of elephants. For the last 30 years of the Soviet regime, the Jews of the USSR were poked into shit, explaining to them that they are parasites in their own country, of non-indigenous nationality, and in general "take them to your Zhidrail." And when they got together and left, it turned out that science and medicine left with them, there were only crooks. With your next victory over common sense.
        1. Bloodsucker
          Bloodsucker 30 September 2016 22: 50
          +3
          Quote: Kaiten
          The last 30 years of Soviet power, Soviet Jews were poked in the shit, explaining to them that they are parasites in their own country,

          Bullshit, that's what your speech is called.
          Quote: Kaiten
          And when they gathered and left, it turned out that science and medicine left with them, there were only crooks.

          Now those who left, like you, from uselessness and worthlessness, whine in the Internet all nonsense.
          Like Moishe Belfand, from Kiev, who rushed to Israel in 89 and achieved nothing because of uselessness in KIEV-taiga, he did not find there, after the Forestry Academy, and in Israel, they did not give him an increased pension, although he so shouted that they say I’m a fighter with the Soviet regime.
          So what about GREATNESS of Russia, not for you to argue.
          Our Jews are with us, and you, ballast, we do not need. Ballast, completely devoid of common sense.
          1. Kaiten
            Kaiten 30 September 2016 23: 13
            +1
            Quote: The Bloodthirster
            Bullshit, that's what your speech is called.

            Bullshit is your modern science with Petrik on one side and Chubais on the other.
            Quote: The Bloodthirster
            Our Jews are with us.

            Rather, you are with the remaining Jewish oligarchs, and not they with you. Normal scientists, physicians, engineers have long been dumped from you.
            Quote: The Bloodthirster
            you ballast we don't need

            Yeah, ballast. that is why you buy from us technologies that were produced by the same Jews who left you. Treated with their sores, you also go to the ballast. My cousin recently had back surgery in a hospital in Israel. 2/3 of the department - patients from Russia, Ukraine, Kazakhstan. A lot of money comes and pays for a surgeon who comes from the hSSSR to do the surgery. The question is, did the science people need to poke shit at one time, what would then come to him to pay homage and pay a lot of money? Say thanks to your anti-Semites, your Shafarevichs and Vasilievs. Let them treat you.
            1. Bloodsucker
              Bloodsucker 30 September 2016 23: 26
              +2
              You are a ballast.
              Not necessary, vicious and worthless.
              What attracts you to sites about Russia?
              Who needs your poisonous passion for lies, myths and gossip?
              You are ridiculous in your eagerness to be something significant, essentially not being anything and nobody.
              Where to you to Russia.
              Heal. Multiply, but do anything at home there, it makes me neither cold nor hot.
              To blame people who are going to be treated, this is the level of caveman hatred, the doctor does not have the nationality of the patient, you have a debt, it is true, it is associated with exorbitant money.
              So don’t be sad for us, somehow, but without you.
              And the last, the only force in the world to which people like you, run praying for help, so that they wouldn’t cut it out again, there was, is and will be so RUSSIA hated by you.
              The conversation is over, you are abominable in your hatred.
          2. Kaiten
            Kaiten 30 September 2016 23: 27
            +1
            Quote: The Bloodthirster
            Now those who left, like you, from uselessness and worthlessness, whine in the Internet all nonsense.

            For reference, My worthlessness and uselessness is well paid + state benefits. an employee + a car from the state with free gas + early retirement. This is my worthlessness and uselessness. a little of course, but enough for me.
            1. rasteer
              rasteer 30 September 2016 23: 54
              0
              Sorry, but the worthlessness of a person is not determined by the RFP and social. guarantees. So yes you are well settled there in Israel, believe here there are many people in Russia without indicating their nationality (well, they removed this column from the passport) who lives no worse than you. But this does not mean their significance for society.
              As uncle Arakcheev said to flatterers about his nephew, "Sho is smart and dumb, but sho was so lucky."
            2. Was mammoth
              Was mammoth 1 October 2016 00: 24
              +4
              Quote: Kaiten
              For reference, My worthlessness and uselessness is well paid + state benefits. an employee + a car from the state with free gas + early retirement. This is my worthlessness and uselessness. a little of course, but enough for me.

              And this is all just for the comments on "VO"? The rich country of Israel! wink
              So, I don’t understand, is Chubais yours or ours? If yours, please take it! wink lol
          3. rasteer
            rasteer 30 September 2016 23: 44
            +2
            We can say that, like the Jews, they clamped all Russia in their paws. We can say that all the same, there was no benefit from the Jews, and thank God. Maybe so, but you ask yourself who, besides the Russians, built this country, and if your answer does not include these same Jews. then you have to ride on the Maidan. your life was a success, and I congratulate you on this.
            1. Kaiten
              Kaiten 1 October 2016 00: 17
              +2
              Quote: rasteer
              We can say that, like the Jews, they clamped all Russia in their paws. We can say that all the same, there was no benefit from the Jews, and thank God. Maybe so, but you ask yourself who, besides the Russians, built this country, and if your answer does not include these same Jews. then you have to ride on the Maidan. your life was a success, and I congratulate you on this.

              Yes, the matter is not in the Jews themselves or in Russians or in any other nationality. And the thing is the processes that led your science to such a sad state of things. And one of the processes that undoubtedly influenced this was the short-sighted actions of some academics, who, on the pretext of freeing up seats for representatives of indigenous nationality, forced promising scientists to leave. A scientist should not be evaluated by the name of his father or mother, but by his scientific contribution.