Military Review

Bal-E coastal anti-ship complex

42



The coastal missile system (DBK) "Bal-E" is intended for: control of territorial waters and torrential zones; protection of naval bases, other coastal facilities and coastal infrastructure; protect the coast on landing-dangerous directions.

Combat use of the complex is provided in simple and complex weather conditions day and night with full autonomy of targeting after launching into enemy fire and electronic countermeasure conditions.

DB Bal-E is a mobile (based on the MAZ 7930 chassis) system, which consists of: self-propelled command and control and communications centers (SKPUS) - up to 2 units; self-propelled launchers (SPU) - up to 4 units, carrying anti-ship missiles (ASM) of type X-35E (3М-24E) in transport-launch containers (TPK). On the standard version of the SPU is 8 TPK. transport and handling machines (TPM), designed to form a repeated salvo - up to 4 units.

The command and control center provides target reconnaissance, target designation and optimal target distribution between launchers. The presence of active and passive high-precision radar target detection channels as part of a complex allows for a flexible strategy for detecting targets, including secretive ones. Launchers and TPM can be placed in hidden positions in the depth of the coastline. At the same time, the secrecy of combat positions and the presence of artificial and natural obstacles in the direction of firing do not limit the combat use of the complex.

Shooting can be conducted with single missiles or a volley from any launcher. It is possible to obtain operational information from other command posts and external means of reconnaissance and target designation. A volley complex can include up to 32 missiles. Such a volley is capable of disrupting the performance of the combat mission of a large shipboard attack group, airborne detachment, or enemy convoy. The presence of the TPM in the complex allows you to re-launch a volley in 30-40 minutes. The combat management system of the complex’s facilities is implemented using digital methods for transmitting all types of messages, using automated communication systems, processing messages, and classifying information with guaranteed durability.



The presence of night vision devices, navigation equipment, topographic referencing and orientation allows the complex to quickly change starting positions after completing a combat mission, as well as redeploy to a new combat area. The deployment time of the complex in a new position is 10 minutes. Formation of a coastal defense system based on the Bal-E ballistic missile system in combination with the use of the unified Kh-35E anti-ship missiles (3M-24E) on patrol ships in the near sea zone equipped with Uran-E missile systems and on aviation combat complexes, is able to ensure the solution of operational and tactical tasks with minimal economic costs by building a unified system for the operation and repair of anti-ship missiles.

The tasks of creating defensive systems for important coastal zones, port facilities, naval military bases, and other coastal territories were set and solved from time immemorial. We can recall examples from stories naval fleets of the past and the previous century, when such systems were created on the basis of developed fortifications and equipped with powerful artillery installations.

However, for modern means of destruction, which are based on high-precision weaponsuch systems are very vulnerable, and therefore they are a thing of the past. Today, they are being replaced by mobile defense systems, which, from an unexpected direction, can deliver an accurate and massive strike on enemy ships and, in a short time, having changed their position, be again ready to launch a striking strike. The coastal missile system "Bal-E", designed to control pouring zones and territorial waters, protect naval bases, coastal targets and coastal sections, belongs to such systems. It has high mobility, necessary power and accuracy of destruction. It consists of a self-propelled command and control and communications center (SKPUS), a self-propelled launcher (SPU), carrying anti-ship missiles in transport and launch containers, and a transport and reloading machine to form a re-salvo.

It is no secret that when changing the firing position most of the time is spent on referencing to the terrain, to determine their coordinates in a new place. Night vision devices, navigation equipment, topographic reference and orientation allow the complex to quickly prepare for the combat mission. The deployment time of the Bal-E in the new position is 10 minutes.

Bal-E coastal anti-ship complex


When operating on light-tonnage ships, firing can be done by single missiles. It is clear that during operations on large ships (such as a destroyer, etc.), launching a single missile against such an enemy will not make any special changes in its combat capabilities. The designers tried to make life as difficult as possible for the potential adversary. The fire salvo of the Bal-E complex can make up to 32 (!) Missiles with a launch interval of no more than 3 seconds, and given the maximum ammunition load, up to 64 rockets! In short, the adversary will need to think hard before entering into combat with such a complex.

In addition, the complex has a number of other advantages, allowing it to withstand a wide class of enemy maritime attack weapons. Centralized firing control, carried out by SKPS, provides target designation and optimal distribution of targets between SPU. At the same time, high-precision radar detection channels operating in active and passive modes make it possible to secretly find, classify, and accompany marine surface targets, including against the background of active and passive interference.

It is possible to obtain operational information from other command posts, reconnaissance and target designation. In other words, "Bal-E" can act as an independent combat unit, as well as be part of a centralized defense system.

The complex uses the X-35E anti-ship missile (ASM) (3М-24E), which is a unified guided missile, which, in addition to the Bal-E mobile coastal missile systems, can be equipped with Uran-E missile systems, combat aircraft complexes tactical and naval aviation, as well as search and patrol aircraft and helicopters. RCC is designed to destroy surface warships with a displacement of up to 5.000 tons and sea transports.

Main tactical and technical characteristics
Range of destruction, km to 120
Remoteness of the starting position from the coastline, km to 10
The number of missiles on each SPU and SST to 8
Missile launch interval in salvo, s. no more than 3
Maximum speed of the movement, km / h:
- on the highway 60
- off road 20
Missile launch mass, kg ~ 620
Total complex ammunition, the number of missiles to 64
Power reserve (without refueling), km at least 850

The X-35E rocket (3М-24E) can be used in simple and complex meteorological conditions, day and night, under fire and electronic countermeasures of the enemy. Small dimensions, extremely low altitude of the flight path, as well as a special guidance algorithm that ensures maximum secrecy of the use of an active homing head by a rocket, cause a low level of visibility of the rocket.



In the Bal-E complex, the X-35E (3М-24E) missiles are housed in sealed transport and launch containers, which ensure high reliability of the complexes in difficult climatic conditions with a low level of labor costs for their maintenance.

Bal-E and X-35E (3М-24E) are export options. The Armed Forces of the Russian Federation will receive them not only without this index, but with several other possibilities, which are too early to talk about. According to Interfax-AVN, state testing of the complex was completed in 2004 year. As the head of the Directorate of orders and deliveries of ships, naval armaments and military equipment of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, Rear Admiral Anatoly Shlemov, explained, now the Ball complex is undergoing a corresponding clearance. The new equipment will go into service with the coastal forces of all four fleets.
Rocket bastion

In October, the 2004 of the year passed state tests and will soon enter into service the Russian Navy's newest mobile coastal missile system "Ball". It is based on the X-35 Uran missiles. Modern equipment and digital equipment allow you to deploy the complex in a new position in just 10 minutes. Several high-speed computers provide calculation for several solutions of a combat mission at once and recommend the most optimal one. With just one salvo from the 32-x missiles, the complex is capable of destroying the enemy carrier grouping or connecting enemy assault ships located at distances from 7 to 130 kilometers from the coast.

Within half an hour, having changed position, the Ball can launch a second missile strike. This complex is also unique in that its missiles can be used both from the shore, and from a fighter, and from a helicopter. "Ball" will replace those operated by navy more than 30 years of the Redut and Boundary systems. This film will tell about how the Coastal Missile Forces developed, starting from the second half of the 20th century. Viewers will recognize the names of the creators of the first stationary and mobile coastal systems from the ICB Raduga, NPO Mashinostroyeniya, as well as the current Tactical Missile Corporation.

42 comments
Information
Dear reader, to leave comments on the publication, you must to register.

I have an account? Sign in

  1. svp67
    svp67 31 August 2013 08: 55 New
    +3
    "Ball", but it would not be time for you to "tour" to Syria ... Especially since you with the letter "E" mean "export" ...
    1. 31231
      31231 31 August 2013 10: 45 New
      14
      The range is not enough. If only the Israeli utensils trivia shoot like that. It is relevant in the Caspian and in minor conflicts. Against serious opponents, the range is not enough. And so, of course, you need a thing.
    2. The comment was deleted.
  2. Nayhas
    Nayhas 31 August 2013 09: 04 New
    +1
    Uh ... I do not quite understand where in this complex the butterfly valve is?
    "Locking the barrel - with a traditional rotary bolt having 7 combat stops, behind the receiver insert. The bolt frame moves inside the receiver on two guide rods without touching the walls, the return spring is located in the middle between the rods and above them."
    1. ramsi
      ramsi 31 August 2013 09: 15 New
      +1
      yes yes it's a cool joke
  3. Pashhenko Nikolay
    Pashhenko Nikolay 31 August 2013 09: 10 New
    +3
    For the Strait of Hormuz, that’s it. And about locking the trunk, of course, it's cool, from another topic, like it probably stuck.
  4. Enot-poloskun
    Enot-poloskun 31 August 2013 09: 13 New
    +1
    Range of defeat - 120 km.

    Why so little?

    It seemed to me that coastal missile systems should reach at least 300 km ...
    1. svp67
      svp67 31 August 2013 09: 24 New
      +4
      Quote: Enot-poloskun
      It seemed to me that coastal missile systems should reach at least 300 km ...
      Yes, because everyone has their own task - from what line to attack the enemy and who. There is an operational-tactical PKKK “Bastion”, with “Yakhants” with a range of about 600 km. There is a Club-M with a range of up to 300 km. Accordingly, they will be subordinate to the "front-line", "army", "divisional ...."
      1. Tu-214R
        Tu-214R 31 August 2013 13: 24 New
        -9
        And there is a tomahawk with a range of more than 1000 km., Which, as it were, hints that our coastal complexes are still able to repel only the invasion of poachers.
        1. beard999
          beard999 31 August 2013 15: 07 New
          +1
          Quote: Tu-214P
          tomahawk with a range of over 1000 km

          RCC, in addition to coastal SCRC, are placed on aircraft carriers, on NK and submarines. The line of defense can be from the coastline and beyond 1000 km. The range of Russian anti-ship missiles is 3M45 (550-600 km), 3M55 (over 400 km), 3M54 (375 km), X-59MK (285 km), 3M24M1 (260 km), X-31A (160 km), according to any allow the enemy’s AUG to come close to the territorial waters of the Russian Federation. In naval aviation, the combat radius of action is quite limited (for example, in F / A-18E, when working on the ground, only about 700 km).
        2. teleset
          teleset 31 August 2013 15: 22 New
          +2
          this is the catch that the tamahawk can fly both 2500km and up to 4000km. Now, if we had missiles at such a range DASTION WITH YACHANTS, then the United States would not have placed its destroyers near Syria. BUT, the problem here seems to be different: there is an agreement on not using medium-range missiles, we need to get out of it.
          1. The comment was deleted.
          2. The comment was deleted.
          3. yanus
            yanus 31 August 2013 20: 37 New
            +1
            Quote: teleset
            this is the catch that the tamahawk can fly both 2500km and up to 4000km. Now, if we had missiles at such a range DASTION WITH YACHANTS, then the United States would not have placed its destroyers near Syria. BUT, the problem here seems to be different: there is an agreement on not using medium-range missiles, we need to get out of it.

            There's actually about ballistic missiles ...
          4. beard999
            beard999 1 September 2013 14: 10 New
            +3
            Quote: teleset
            then a tamahawk can fly both 2500km and up to 4000km

            KR "Tomahawk", with a range of 4000 km, is not in service with the US Navy. The Americans had a Kyrgyz Republic with a range of 3000 km - AGM-129A. But, firstly, it is an air-based missile defense system, and secondly, the Americans destroyed the last of them in April 2012. The range of 2500 km was in the KR type “Tomahawk” modification RGM / UGM-109A with SBN, which were purchased back in the mid 80-ies. Most of them were converted by Americans into conventional RGM / UGM-109C / D modifications with launch ranges, depending on warhead type, from 870 to 1700 km. The rest of the U.S. KR, with MSS and a range of 2500 km, is decommissioned http://blogs.fas.org/security/2013/03/tomahawk/. In the 2000s For the Navy, the Americans purchased the RGM / UGM-109E Tactical Tomahawk, with a maximum range of 1600-1700 km and 340 kg OFBCH. They, at present, are the main type of SLCMs on American NK and submarines.
        3. Geisenberg
          Geisenberg 31 August 2013 18: 33 New
          +1
          Quote: Tu-214P
          And there is a tomahawk with a range of more than 1000 km., Which, as it were, hints that our coastal complexes are still able to repel only the invasion of poachers.


          For this reason, Tmogawk was called up so that the Papuans could shoot bullets from a thousand miles. This is a typical nasty weapon, so that with clean handles on the buttons and no answer in the face ... It rolls only against the Papuans, with serious guys it won't work. Even considering that the Syrians did not have very much half their air defense for sure.
          1. Windbreak
            Windbreak 31 August 2013 23: 30 New
            0
            That's only in Russia there is a similar subsonic missile ZM-14 with a range of 2000 km
            1. Geisenberg
              Geisenberg 1 September 2013 00: 26 New
              0
              Quote: Burel
              That's only in Russia there is a similar subsonic missile ZM-14 with a range of 2000 km


              And there is also ur100 and?
        4. The comment was deleted.
        5. The comment was deleted.
      2. Windbreak
        Windbreak 31 August 2013 17: 30 New
        0
        Quote: svp67
        There is an operational-tactical PKKK “Bastion”, with “Yakhanty” with a range of about 600 km.
        Its range is 300 km. And 600 km is not the missile range, but the length of the protected coast. Http://www.npomash.ru/activities/ru/missile2.htm? L = 0
    2. beard999
      beard999 31 August 2013 15: 06 New
      +4
      Quote: Enot-poloskun
      Why so little?

      RCC X-35 / 35E (3M24) began to be developed 30 years ago (since March 1983). For that time, a range of 120 km was absolutely satisfactory. Its more modern modification - X-35UE (3M24M1) http://www.ktrv.ru/production/68/673/899/ already has a range of 260 km. Among missiles weighing 400-700 kg (for coastal anti-aircraft missiles), the domestic X-35UE, in terms of maximum firing range, is superior to similar western missiles that are in service: NSM - 185 km, MM-40 block 3 - 180 km, SSM-1B - 150 km, RBS-15Mk.2 - 100 km.
    3. Nayhas
      Nayhas 31 August 2013 16: 46 New
      +3
      Quote: Enot-poloskun
      Why so little?

      Question with target detection. The missile itself does not see such a range, you must first fly up to the target and capture it, and to know where you need to fly you need to find the target. A self-propelled command and control command post is used for detection, its capabilities for detecting sea targets depend on how high it is from sea level, but in any case at a distance of 200 km. he will not see anything, so there is no sense in RCC of such a range.
      1. Asan Ata
        Asan Ata 31 August 2013 23: 14 New
        +2
        It would be nice for every salvo to have a pair of leading missiles with the ignorance of the group on target within the reach of the missiles.
    4. Geisenberg
      Geisenberg 31 August 2013 18: 29 New
      0
      The rocket is like that. This is an analogue of the American harpoon, only a little easier.
    5. Alex-z84
      Alex-z84 1 September 2013 12: 17 New
      -1
      300 is also nothing, the SCRC should calmly beat the distance from which the launch of the missile system is carried out, otherwise the meaning of these complexes is practically lost.
  5. saag
    saag 31 August 2013 09: 17 New
    +1
    Yes, it’s good to use something against the landing
  6. nikcris
    nikcris 31 August 2013 10: 05 New
    0
    Locking the barrel - a traditional rotary bolt, having 7 combat stops, for the receiver liner. The bolt frame moves inside the receiver on two guide rods, without touching the walls, the return spring is located in the middle between the rods and above them.

    What the hell is that? wassat
  7. Ascetic
    Ascetic 31 August 2013 10: 05 New
    +6
    For the defense of coastal areas in inland seas, for example, in the Caspian it is. We have one complex in Izberbash so far. There is an export version of the complex in Kamrani (Vietnam). Perhaps in addition to the Uran-E ship missiles from this complex that we already supply to many countries, the coastal Bal-E will go to Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan.

    "Bal-E" is a tactical defensive complex, which, in terms of aggregate performance characteristics, has no equal in the shooting zone from 7 to 120 km from the coastline. It is indispensable in solving problems such as disruption of landing operations, blocking of narrowness, destruction of violators of maritime borders, etc.
    The X-35E missile has significant advantages in a number of characteristics. It is hardly noticeable due to its small size. It flies at low altitudes (from 10-15 m), attacks the target at altitudes of 3 to 5 m, which makes it difficult to destroy the forces of missile defense of enemy ships. The missile is well protected from electronic countermeasures.
    In order for the costs of the complex and its ammunition to pay off, it is enough to complete only one effective salvo to destroy, for example, a naval strike group of three frigates. At the same time, the complex is capable of delivering a second thirty-two-missile salvo 30-40 minutes after the first volley due to the presence of four transport and loading vehicles carrying missiles of the second volley. The short deployment time, target designation, solving the tasks of target distribution, prelaunch preparation and launching the volley allow the complex in a matter of minutes turn around, strike and leave the starting position.
    The complex’s systems make it possible to obtain data on targets without turning on active radar stations when operating in the direction finding mode of radiation from enemy ships from two control vehicles (primary and backup). If the enemy is in the range of active radar systems, then when they are turned on, target designation data can be obtained in a few seconds, as they say, from one “smear” of the antenna.
    The communication facilities of the complex allow it to operate practically in radio silence mode, commands and data are transmitted by closed messages lasting from milliseconds to tenths of a second. The power of radio stations allows them to have an advantage in the signal-to-noise ratio during electronic countermeasures.

    link
    1. Apollo
      Apollo 31 August 2013 10: 34 New
      +4
      greetings to all! hi
      video footage in the topic

  8. tlauicol
    tlauicol 31 August 2013 10: 53 New
    -2
    for a long time he is in position. in modern Aviation will not allow conflicts. the Swedes won in 5min RBS15 time to deploy-shoot-roll. and in general, there is something wrong with this complex - the MO is not in a hurry to buy it, probably the rocket is not like it: weak and stupid against the background of analogues
    1. Sirocco
      Sirocco 31 August 2013 16: 36 New
      +4
      Quote: Tlauicol
      for a long time he is in position. in modern Aviation will not allow conflicts.

      Do you think this complex will cover the air defense system? I think yes. Most likely the shell.
      Quote: Tlauicol
      Moscow region is not in a hurry to buy it, probably the rocket does not like: weak and stupid against the background of analogues

      Well, on this "silly" topic, I offer you a video of state tests of the BAL complex.
      1. tlauicol
        tlauicol 31 August 2013 17: 49 New
        -7
        The rocket came out really stupid in comparison with its “classmates.” It’s not universal in terms of media (you won’t let the submarines go), it doesn’t hit the shore, 140 kg warheads — it turns out that for 30 years we designed the rocket worse than the ancient Harpoon! It is not programmed to re-attack in the event of a miss or a failure to capture the target, nor to retarget it, there is no data exchange between missiles in flight. It does not hold more than one target in the brain. not Stells. Who are you selling this in the 21st century?
        1. Htuek
          Htuek 31 August 2013 19: 30 New
          +4
          Do you know anything about her what to write? This rocket has 3 modifications. One of which hangs out on the MiG-29.
      2. Nayhas
        Nayhas 31 August 2013 17: 55 New
        0
        Quote: Sirocco
        Well, on this "silly" topic, I offer you a video of state tests of the BAL complex.

        Impressive, but why shot at a distance of less than 2 km?
      3. tlauicol
        tlauicol 31 August 2013 18: 23 New
        -7
        it's 2013 now. even now, Uranus cannot even half what Harpoon could 40 years ago
        1. Geisenberg
          Geisenberg 31 August 2013 18: 37 New
          +8
          Quote: Tlauicol
          it's 2013 now. even now, Uranus cannot even half what Harpoon could 40 years ago


          A harpoon, in turn, cannot do what the P500 can do, which was created as an answer to the harpoon.
        2. Tektor
          Tektor 31 August 2013 22: 38 New
          0
          "even now, Uranus cannot even half what Harpoon could 40 years ago“Well, if you think so, then everything is correct. Not a joke.
  9. chunga-changa
    chunga-changa 31 August 2013 11: 16 New
    0
    In the case of target designation from Russian ships, it will be quite secretive and effective, but with such a radius of action, the AUG will not even scare you. They would have a couple of Warsaw.
    1. Sirocco
      Sirocco 31 August 2013 16: 50 New
      0
      Quote: chunga-changa
      . They would have a couple of Warsaw.

      Boats for this were created. In our case with BAL, if suggest that the AUG approached the distance of the missile launch, then all 32 missiles will be launched, then the AUG will turn around like a devil in a pan, how many missiles will the AUG intercept? And if you hit at least one missile on an Aircraft Carrier, this is enough to undermine the "fighting spirit" of the soldiers of the US Army.
      1. Geisenberg
        Geisenberg 31 August 2013 18: 39 New
        +2
        Quote: Sirocco
        And if you hit at least one missile on an Aircraft Carrier, this is enough to undermine the "fighting spirit" of the soldiers of the US Army.


        Unfortunately, the aircraft carriers went to another sea, apparently just in case ... On the whole, yes, it will be so. God forbid which vessel of the aggressors approach the strike distance. One rocket is enough to immediately end the war for economic reasons laughing
      2. chunga-changa
        chunga-changa 31 August 2013 19: 38 New
        +2
        Of course, you can assume anything. But, AUG is standardly placed to work on the ground 200-250 miles from the coast (10 minutes of flight), this is more than 400 km. If the AOG approaches the launch distance, its aircraft will gain altitude already above the shore. American generals are certainly all as one, but not to the same extent. Nothing shines in the standard. Only landing gear.
  10. Dimka off
    Dimka off 31 August 2013 12: 41 New
    +2
    if you use the Kh-35U missile, then the range increases up to 260 km.
  11. sergey158-29
    sergey158-29 31 August 2013 16: 42 New
    +2
    The necessary complex! 120 km is a type for export, well, Iran will have enough to block the spillway !! lol
    1. teleset
      teleset 31 August 2013 16: 46 New
      +1
      here the battle order of the carrier will be very difficult for Pts to approach him for otaki.
      1. The comment was deleted.
      2. Dimka off
        Dimka off 8 September 2013 11: 17 New
        0
        why immediately to the aircraft carrier?
        the first wave of missiles clears the guard. The second - takes out an aircraft carrier.
  12. saag
    saag 31 August 2013 19: 04 New
    +5
    And where on the plan is a submarine in the wake of an aircraft carrier, with torpedoes pointing along the wake? :-)
  13. Alex-z84
    Alex-z84 1 September 2013 12: 12 New
    0
    Quote: svp67
    "Ball", but it would not be time for you to "tour" to Syria ... Especially since you with the letter "E" mean "export" ...

    The range is small, and the tomahawks launch from a distance of 1000 km, so there is no point in the usual target.
  14. Ivanovich47
    Ivanovich47 1 September 2013 12: 21 New
    0
    Complex "Ball" is designed to combat naval targets in the near zone. It is simply economically inexpedient to use the "Yakhont" (300 range of km., 200-300 kg charge mass. Kg) at short distances. The X-35E rocket occupies its niche and fully complies with customer specifications. Among the promising anti-ship missiles, one can note the joint Russian-Indian missile BrahMos, whose parameters are close to Yakhont
    PJ-10 BrahMos is a supersonic cruise missile that can be launched from submarines, surface ships, aircraft or land. It is a joint development of the Organization for Defense Research and Development of India (DRDO) and the Russian "NPO Mashinostroyeniya", which in 1998 formed Brahmos Aerospace LLC (Ltd.). The fastest, in service, cruise missile in the world.
    The designation "BraMos" comes from the name of the two rivers Brahmaputra in India and Moscow in Russia. The missile is capable of speeds 2,8-3,0 max, which is 3,5 times the speed of the American harpoon cruise missile. Currently, the possibility of installing and launching BrahMos from airplanes is being tested, and it can be expected that by 2012, India will become a country with a supersonic cruise missile in all military branches. Moreover, they are testing an advanced model for delivering quick air strikes, capable of accelerating 6M. Completion is expected by 2016 year.
    Although the Indian side expected the BraMos missile to be built on the basis of the P-700 Granite medium-range cruise missile, Russian experts, given the norms of the Missile Technology Control Regime, preferred the P-800 Onyx short-range model (but non-export version of "Yakhont"), the flight design work on which was completed in full at the beginning of the 90's.
    It is estimated that the total development cost will be 13 billion.
  15. xomaNN
    xomaNN 1 September 2013 17: 50 New
    +1
    In the early 80s, I had to participate in typical factory tests of the launcher of the previous Rubezh complex. The topic is in demand, it pleases. I agree with the previous comments, in battle I would try a new kompless !. True to 100 km. unless a landing command approaches the shore, but the battleship "Iowa" :))
  16. Zomanus
    Zomanus 2 September 2013 00: 03 New
    0
    Without cover, the air defense will be defeated as they approach the launch line. And as I understand it, the system is designed to work in layered defense. That is, there is “Yakhont” and after it comes “Ball”. We cover it all with Vityaz and Shell.
    1. svp67
      svp67 2 September 2013 02: 55 New
      0
      Quote: Zomanus
      Without cover, the air defense will be defeated as they approach the launch line.
      And if they are ALREADY located in well-defended, technologically equipped and, most importantly, still not opened, enemy reconnaissance positions? In this case, they have a chance to inflict at least one blow on the troops of the ships. And in this situation this may well be enough for the Americans to "calm down"
  17. Alex_dnepr
    Alex_dnepr 2 September 2013 02: 47 New
    0
    I'd love to believe that the Syrian people have such weapons!
  18. Brave
    Brave 3 September 2013 21: 54 New
    0
    Good technique!